HomeMy WebLinkAboutNC0044725_Lab Results_20070913LMAC Aquatic Toxicity failure for month of May
Subject: LMAC Aquatic Toxicity failure for month of May
From: "Dale.Lopez" <Dale.Lopez@ncmail.net>
Date: Thu, 17 May 2007 08:59:31 -0400
To: Dale Lopez <Dale.Lopez@ncmail.net>, Belinda Henson <Belinda.Henson@ncmail.net>, Hughie
White <Hughie.White@ncmail.net>, Don Register <Don:Register@ncmail.net>, Chad Turlington
<Chad.Turlington@ncmail.net>, Mike Lawyer <Mike.Lawyer@ncmail.net>, Mark Brantley
<Mark.Brantley@ncmail.net>, trent.allen@ncmail.net
Charles Vandenburg "phoned in" a non -compliant Multiple DilutionWET result for
May. 'LMAC's NPDES limit is 2.6%, and the test failed at 0.92%. Because a
Priority Pollutant Analysis was performed during'the same week as the WET for May,
Charles will have moreinformation in the near future about the possibilities that'
can be eliminated as the cause. The WWTP effluent sulfide result that was sampled
during theweek of May's WET sampling was below detection level. Charles will
collect a sample for a sulfide analysis from the digester supernatant today. LMAC.
will begin a quarter in June with a Pass/Fail.WET.
Dale Lopez
Environmental Specialist II
Surface Water Protection Section
Fayetteville Regional Office
Phone: (910) 433-3312
Fax: (910) 4'86-0707
1 of 1 5/17/2007 8:59 AM
LMAC June verbal "Pass" for the Aquatic Toxicity
Subject: LMAC June verbal "Pass" for the Aquatic Toxicity
From: "Dale.Lopez" <Dale.Lopez@ncmail.net>
Date: Wed, 13 Jun 2007 15:40:42 -0400
To: Dale Lopez<Dale.Lopez@ncmail.net>, Belinda Henson <Belinda.Henson@ncmail.net>, Hughie
White <Hughie.White@ncmail.net>, Don Register <Don.Register@ncmail.net>, Chad Turlington
<Chad.Turlington@ncmail.net>, Mike Lawyer <Mike.Lawyer@ncmail.net>, Mark Brantley
<Mark.Brantley@ncmail.net>, trent.allen@ncmail.net
Good news from LMAC, they received a verbal report that the aquatic toxicity was a
"Pass" for June (the beginning of a new quarter) So, they won't have to sample
again until September (the beginning of their next quarter). The problem is that
the cause for the previous three months of aquatic toxicity "Fail" results was not
determined, and it might occur again. . -
Dale Lopez
Environmental Specialist- II
Surface Water Protection Section
Fayetteville Regional Office
Phone: (910) 433-3312
Fax:.(910) 486-0707
1 of 1 6/13/2007 3:40 PM
LMAC risk assessment of data concerning aquatic toxicity
Subject: LMAC risk assessment of data concerning aquatic toxicity
From: "Dale.Lopez" <Dale.Lopez@ncmail.net>
Date: Fri, 22 Jun 2007 16:08:24 -0400
To: Dale Lopez <Dale.Lopez@ncmail.net>, Belinda Henson <Belinda.Henson@ncmail.net>, Hughie
White <Hughie.White@ncmail.net>, Don Register <Don.Register@ncmail.net>, Chad Turlington
<Chad.Turlington@ncmail.net>, Mike Lawyer <Mike.Lawyer@ncmail.net>, Mark Brantley
<Mark.Brantley@ncmail.net>, trent.allen@ncmail.net
CC: Sandy Mort <Sandy.Mort@ncmail.net>
Sandy Mort.(ESB) evaluated several reports of laboratory data that Charles
Vanderberg sent to her this week. Her general findings were that there were
potential toxicants: Copper, Zinc, and Cobalt, and a possibility that there was
another toxicant(s) present that was not analyzed. The Conductivity was high
(sub -lethal toxicity begins showing up at around 1,600 microMHOS). The high
values of each toxicant, when combined, could have increased the toxic effect
during the Ceriodaphnia analysis ("Fail" for March, April, and May 2007). In
June, LMAC "Passed" it's quarterly Cerio analysis. (During the collection period
of the recent "Pass" composite sampling events, it appears that the toxicant
level(s) subsided.)
Dale Lopez
Environmental Specialist II
Surface Water Protection Section
Fayetteville Regional Office
Phone: (910) 433-3312
Fax: (910) 486-0707
1 of 1 6/22/2007 4:10 PM
[Fwc!: fax [Fwd: LMAC Lab Results]]
Subject: Re: [Fwd: fax [Fwd: LMAC Lab Results]]
From: Dana Folley <Dana.Folley@ncmail.net>
Date: Thu, 13 Sep 2007 12:27:51 -0400
To: Dale Lopez <Dale.Lopez@ncmail.net>
CC: Deborah Gore <Deborah.Gore@nemail.net>
Dale, I looked at the sampling data, and wow, that's alot of metals! But then again, it's sludge, so it's
supposed to have high metals. What I think they need to do is look at the pounds of each pollutant
(metals and conventionals and nutrients) in X number of gallons of the sludge and compare this to
their MAHL remaining on their AT to find out how much the WWTP can take. Whichever pollutant
is the most restrictive, then that's the max flow they should put into the WWTP. And generally in any
case, they should start off with really low flows and watch the WWTP closely to see how it likes the
sludge.
Using zinc as an example, 9.13 mg/1 zinc times 0.5 mgd times 8.34 equals 38 pounds of zinc! Their
AT shows they only have 3.5456 lbs/day of zinc left after SIUs plus uncontrollable (their entire
MAHL is only 7.9814 lbs/day). But 0.025 mgd at 9.13 mg/1 is 1.9 lbs....and 0.005 mgd is only 0.38
lbs...much more do -able. Even so, maybe they want to start off even lower to let the WWTP
acclimate slowly.
Don't know exactly how they would figure out the oxygen demand, with such high CODs, BODs, and
Nitrogen, but I'm sure they can figure something out.
-Dana
Deborah Gore wrote:
Subject:
fax [Fwd: LMAC Lab Results]
From: "Dale.Lopez" <Da1e.Lopez@ncmail.net>
Date: Wed, 12 Sep 2007 17:11:11 -0400
To: Deborah Gore <deborah.gore@ncmail.net>, Sandy Mort <Sandy.Mortancmail.net>
To: Deborah Gore <deborah.gore@ncmail.net>, Sandy Mort <Sandy.Mort@ncmail.net>
Hi Deborah and Sandy,
A few minutes ago I faxed laboratory results for the sludge that was recovered from the spill that
went into the swamp at LMAC near Laurinburg. It looks like the POTW will pump this sludge
into the new WWTP from the old Basins #1 & #2 (that were not in use). *The volume in each
basin -is approximately 500,000 gallons*.
Thanks,
Dale
1 of 2 9/13/2007 3:39 PM
Re: [Fwd4 fax [Fwd: LMAC Lab Results]]
Subject:
LMAC Lab Results
From: Belinda Henson <Belinda.Henson@ncmail.net>
Date: Wed, 12 Sep 2007 14:40:51 -0400
To: "Dale.Lopez" <Dale.LopezAncmail.net>, don register <don.register cr,ncmail.net>, Mark
Brantley <Mark.Brantley(a,ncmail.net>
To: "Dale.Lopez" <Dale.Lopeznancmail.net>, don register <don.register ancmail.net>, Mark
Brantley <Mark.Brantley@ncmail.net>
Staff,
Comment back to me on the lab results you have received from the sludge (collected from the
abandoned WWTP) that is located in the two basins. Charles Vandeburgh is asking for our
assistance before it is fed back into the WWTP.
2 of 2 9/13/2007 3:39 PM
Re: fax [Fwd: LMAC Lab Results]
Subject: Re: fax [Fwd: LMAC Lab Results]
From: Sandy Mort <sandy.mort@ncmail.net>
Date: Thu, 13 Sep 2007 15:06:43 -0400
To: "Dale.Lopez" <Dale.Lopez@ncmail.net>
Dale, attached are the spreadsheets' of analytical data for the 2 basins and the
calculations of "hazard quotients" (HQ). 'There are numerous individual metals +
cyanide that result in HQs >1.0, as well as the sum of all HQs >1.0. HQs >1.0
indicate that the chemicals concentration in the samples exceed concentrations that
have been shown to cause toxicity. The concentrations were compared to toxicity
screening values routinely used for risk assessment investigations. Diluting the basin
contents so that the summed HQs are -<1 would presumably reduce the chemical
concentrations to levels where toxicity impacts would not be anticipated. (example:
Basin #1 the summed acute HQ = 482, so dilute basin#1 contents —500x to reduce.
potential acute toxicity to <1, or dilute 11,000x to reduce potential chronictoxicity to
<1).
Call me if you have questions.
Sandy
Dale.Lopez wrote:
Hi Deborah and Sandy,
A few minutes ago I faxed laboratory results for the sludge that was recovered from the spill that
went into the swamp at LMAC near Laurinburg. It looks like the POTW will pump this sludge
into the new WWTP from the old Basins #1 & #2 (that were not in use). *The volume in each
basin is approximately 500,000 gallons*.
Thanks,
Dale
Subject:
LMAC Lab Results
From: Belinda Henson <Belinda.Henson ancmail.net>
Date:. Wed, 12 Sep 2007 14:40:51 -0400
To: "Dale.Lopez" <Dale.Lopez@ncmail.net>, don register <don.register@ncmail.net>, Mark
Brantley <Mark.Brantley@ncmail.net>
To: "Dale.Lopez" <Dale.Lopez@ncmail.net>, don register <don.register@ncmail.net>, Mark
Brantley <Mark.Brantley@ncmail.net>
Staff,
1 of 2 9/13/2007 3:18 PM
k`oLiM MQIAyj
a w►
`Jl ► �av\ �u
u► (-"\-k- QA
' Su; sb u a_`o),"-Q
5-v1 S2.,) b1 w,---&s 2�a
c-71,ricif v b-C.,8 c:\u,a(\
gar9 u00.1\ kA-D
cia
• ua
..1. o Q 0�
d.b:TO LO 2T daS
Sep 12 07 01:43p
p.2
'B L�
Environmental Laboratory
2401 W. 5ih St.
Lumberton, NC 28358
Phone: 910-738-6190
PO Box 589
Lumberton, NC 28359
FAX: 910-671-8837
Email:tbIlab@ncrrbiz.com
LAURINBURG'MAXTON AIRPORT
16701 AIRPORT ROAD
MAXTON, NC 28364-
SAMPLE NUMBER- 42640
DATE SAMPLED- 08/01/07
DATE RECEIVED- 08/01/07.
TIME RECEIVED- 1215
Page 1 of 1
ANALYSIS
CHEMICAL OXYGEN DEMAND
TOTAL SUSPENDED SOLIDS
FINAL REPORT OF ANALYSES
PROJECT NAME: TBL-18356
REPORT DATE: 08/16/07
SAMPLE ID- AERATION BASIN 1
SAMPLER- CHARLES VANDENEBRG
DELIVERED BY- JOHNNY HESTER
ANALYSIS
METHOD DATE BY
8000 08/05/07 TC
SM2540D 08/01/07 TC
LABORATORY DIRECTOR
SAMPLE MATRIX- WW
TIME SAMPLED- 0915
RECEIVED BY- PSH
RESULT UNITS
10,770 MG/L
5,900 MG/L
QUAL DET.
CODE LIMIT
NCDENR DWQ # 37, NCDENR DW #37781
10.0
0.1
Sep 12 07 01:44p
p.3
Environmental Laboratory
2401 W. 5th St.
Lumberton, NC 28358'
Phone: 910-738-6190
PO Box 589
Lumberton, NC 28359
FAX: 910-671-8837
Email: tbllab@ncrrbiz.com
LAURINBURG MAXTON AIRPORT
16701 AIRPORT ROAD
MAXTON, NC 28364-
SAMPLE NUMBER- 42641
DATE SAMPLED- 08/01/07
DATE RECEIVED- 08/01/07
TIME RECEIVED- 1215
Page 1 of 1
ANALYSIS
CHEMICAL OXYGEN DEMAND
TOTAL • SUSPENDED SOLIDS
FINAL REPORT OF ANALYSES
PROJECT NAME: TBL-18356'
REPORT DATE: 08/.16/07.
SAMPLE ID- AERATION BASIN 2.
SAMPLER- CIPRLES VANDENEBRG
DELIVERED BY- JOHNNY HESTER
•
SAMPLE!MATRIX- WW
TIME SAMPLED- 0930
RECEIVED BY- PSH
ANALYSIS •
METHOD DATE' BY RESULT"UNITS
8000 08/05/07 TC 13,080 MG/L
SM2540D 08/01/07 TC 32,200 MG/L
LABORATORY DIRECTOR
QUAL DET.
CODE LIMIT
NCDENR DWQ # 37, NCDENR DW #377B1
.10 . 0
0.1
ro
Re n ulshed by: (Signature)
Company Name/Address:
TI3LLabotatory ,
.
P.O. Box 589
Lumberton,NC 28359
Alternate billing information:
.
Ana
vsls/QuIajurfPreseivat1 e
Chain of Custody
of
Page- -
Prepared by:
•
' * ENVIIZONMENTAL
. ,
SCIENCE CORP. i
12065 Lebanon Road
Mt. Juliet, TN 37122
. "
Phone (615) 758-5858
Phone (800) 767-5859 •
FAX (615) 758-5859
T•r.1:„Y.
,, ...
a,
1
S
lig
.,..
,
'
-',
!:
1;+-.r:i
,..,
0 :•:•t;
•,•
•Z ,
—
,
•i!: '
.,,L,,
C
tsi
C..)
.3
—c
Oi..::t
••14,..-.):-...
VI
:":Wz.
•
-
' 7,..
:.,
41
70
`\ • ,,
':C
:t.r:!••S
•
:',T;'.4i
.
,,. .
•• i.
..".
.
.:t . : :
. .
:l
Report to:
(n ail to: .
Project
Descriptlerl:
City/sole
Collectri
Phorie: (9101738-6190
FAX: (9101 671-8837
Client Project #:
___.
I BL.,- \S 35 uz
ESC Key:
-
Colinbi
Vein
Site/Facility IN:
P.D. ft;
,•. • .::
' 7COCode: TB LAB (lab use onlY)
Terhplaie/f?relOgIn
;;.:.Shippaci.V12:.'...".„.:::::
,— &Aar
Collected by (signature);
‘4/0 Lab MUST Be Notified
)
Date Results Needed:
Same Day 200%
A5AP
No.
Next Day, 100%
Email? No_Yes
Two Day 50%
0
Packed on Ice N
FAX? Noyes
Sample ID
Comp/Grab
-
Matrix
Depth
Date
Time
Crilrs
Fiemarks/Contamlnanl
Sample d (lab only)
• t;
n
G
Wv/
c-i-en
c4.15
iQq::;:-
„. f
.•,-:4
'... ':'.
eArcel•ieNc-1 1345‘;-,,S2-
G
1
el
=lawn
tii_
•.;. ':!
..,:„.
,
•
.. -
,
:-...,
•
..,,.
.:.
„ ..
. .
• • 11
'Matrix: SS - soli/solid GW - Groundwater WW - WasteWater OW - Drink ng Water OT - Other
Remarksple424). ifv.t 5 04 NA On ikitval
Nists 2—
PH
Flow
Temp
Other
Date:
a le:
Date:
_A
The: Recel ed b re)
Time:
Ic2ls
Time:
Samples returned via: 0 ups
FedEx LCouIer 1:1
Sep 12 07 01:44p
p.5
One
Pam Hester
TBL Laboratory
P.O. Box 589
Lumberton, NC 28359
Sample #
Sample Matrix
Date Sampled
Delivered by
Parameter
Sodium
Chromium
Cobalt
Nickel
Copper
Zinc
Germanium
Arsenic
Selenium
Molybdenum
Silver
Cadmium
•Barium
Lead
Mercury
WW
08/01/2007
Picked Up
en Smith, Laboratory Director
FINAL REPORT OF ANALYSES
August 3, 2007
Client Project Name LMAC
Client Project Number TBL-18356
PO Number
El Project Number e9503
Sample ID
Sample Type
Time Sampled
Sampler
El Sample #
Aeration Basin #1
Grab
0915
C. Vandenburg
9503-1
Date Received 08/01/2007
Time Received 1315
Received by . MFD
Result Unit Dilution DL Method Date
101 mg/L 250 0.02 EPA 200.8 08/02/2007
0.224 mg/L 10 0.05 EPA 200.8 08/02/2007
9.81 mg/L 250 0.05 EPA 200.8 08/02/2007
0.298 mg/L 10 0.05 EPA 200.8 08/02/2007
2.99 mg/L 10 0.02 EPA 200.8 08/02/2007
9.13 mg/L 250 0.05 EPA 200.8 08/02/2007
0.013 mg/L 1 0.05 EPA 200.8 08/02/2007
0.041 mg/L 1 0.05 EPA 200.8 08/02/2007
0.018 mg/L 1 0.05 EPA 200.8 08/02/2007
0.661 mg/L 10 0.05 EPA 200.8 08/02/2007
0.057 mg/L 1 0.02 EPA 200.8 08/02/2007
0.026 mg/L 1 0.02 EPA 200.8 08/02/2007
5.31 mg/L 250 0.05 EPA 200.8 08/02/2007
0.924 mg/L 10 0.03 EPA 200.8 08/02/2007
0.035 mg/L 10 0.0002 EPA 245.1 08/02/2007
9503 TBL-18356 LMAC Report Compiled by -Dv,/
NC Certifications: DW 37788 and DWQ DENR 604
Sep 12 07 01:44p
p.6
1
One
Pam Hester
TBL Laboratory
P.O. Box 589
Lumberton. NC 28359
Sample #
Sample Matrix
Date Sampled
Delivered by
WW
08/01/2007
Picked Up
Parameter
Cyanide
Total Phosphorus
Total Nitrogen-N
Kjeldahl Nitrogen, TKN
Nitrate+Nitrite
Ken Smith,
ri72>a
aboratory Director
FINAL REPORT OF ANALYSES
August 9, 2007
Client Project Name LMAC
Client Project Number TBL-18356
PO Number
El Project Number e9503
Sample ID
Sample Type
Time Sampled
Sampler
El Sample #
Aeration Basin#1
Grab
0915
C. Vandenburg
9503-1
Date Received
Time Received
Received by
08/01/2007
1315
MFD
Result Unit Dilution DL Method Date
0.852 pg/L 1 0.005 SM4500CN C&E 08/02/2007
54.3 mg/L 1 0.1 4500-P B,5 & E 08/03/2007
226 mg/L 1 0.5 EPA 300.0+351.4 08/06/2007
206 mg/L 1 0.5 EPA351.4 08/06/2007
20.1 rng/L 50 0.05 EPA 300.0 08/02/2007
9503 TBL-18356 LMAC CN TN TP Report Compiled by TIvJ
NC Certifications: DW 37788 and DWQ DENR 604
Sep 12 07 01:45p
p.7
One
Pam Hester
TBL Laboratory
P.O. Box 589
Lumberton, NC 28359
Sample #
Sample Matrix
Date Sampled
Delivered by
Parameter
Sodium
Chromium
Cobalt
Nickel
Copper
Zinc
Germanium
Arsenic
Selenium
Molybdenum
Silver
Cadmium
Barium
Lead
Mercury
WW
08/01/2007
Picked Up
FINAL REPORT OF ANALYSES
August 3, 2007
Client Project Name LMAC
Client Project Number TBL-18356
PO Number
El Project Number e9503
Sample ID
Sample Type
Time Sampled
Sampler
El Sample #
Aeration Basin #2
Grab
0930
C. Vandenburg
9503-2
Date Received
Time Received
Received by
08/01/2007
1315
MFD
Result Unit Dilution DL Method Date
91.3 mg/L 250 0.02 EPA 200.8 08/02/2007
0.745 mg/L 10, 0.05 EPA 200.8 08/02/2007
27.1 mg/L 250 0.05 EPA 200.8 08/02/2007
1.04 mg/L 10 0.05 EPA 200.8 08/02/2007
10.0 mg/L 250 0.02 EPA 200.8 08/02/2007
61.6 mg/L 250 0.05 EPA 200.8 08/02/2007
0.032 mg/L 1 0.05 EPA 200.8 08/02/2007
0.154 mg/L . 10 0.05 EPA 200.8 08/02/2007
0.055 rng/L 1 0.05 EPA 200.8 08/02/2007
0.767 mg/L 10 0.05 EPA 200.8 08/02/2007
0.512 mg/L 10 0.02 EPA 200.8 08/02/2007
0.250 mg/L 10 0.02 EPA 200.8 08/02/2007
8.85 mg/L 250 0.05 EPA 200.8 08/02/2007
6.07 mg/L 250 0.03 EPA 200.8 08/02/2007
0.010 mg/L 40 0.0002 EPA 245.1 08/03/2007
en Smi , Laboratory Director
9503 TBL-18356 LMAC Report Compiled by 'INN)
NC Certifications: DW 37788 and DWQ DENR 604
Sep 12 07 01:45p
p.0
One
Pam Hester
TBL Laboratory
P.O. Box 589
Lumberton, NC 28359
Sample #
Sample Matrix
Date Sampled
Delivered by
WW
08/0,1 /2007
Picked Up
Parameter
Cyanide
Total Phosphorus
Total Nitrogen-N
Kjaldahl Nitrogen, TKN
Nitrate+Nitrite
FINAL REPORT OF ANALYSES
August 9, 2007
Client Project Name LMAC
Client Project Number TBL-18356
PO Number
El Project Number e9503
Sample ID
Sample Type
Time Sampled
Sampler
El Sample #
Aeration Basin #2
Grab
0930
C. Vandenburg
9503-2
Date Received
Time Received
Received by
08/01/2007
1315
MFD
Result Unit Dilution DL Method Date
1.15 pg/L 1 0.005 SM4500CN C&E 08/02/2007
73.8 mg/L 1 0.1•4500-P B,5 & E 08/03/2007
392 mg/L 1 0.5 EPA 300.0+351 .4 08/03/2007
368 mg/L 1 0.5 EPA351.4 08/06/2007
24.3 mg/L 50 0.05 EPA 300.0 08/02/2007
—Ken Smith, Laboratory Director
9503 TBL-18356 LMAC CN TN TP Report Compiled by_'r.l
NG Certifications: DW 37788 and DWQ DENR 604
V
0
CTv CI,
cJ a
O%
kon
G