HomeMy WebLinkAboutUnk Ver 1_Staff Comments_20121101,*,-e*lr) �3vksre \l
o
1�
w l II V1nK
6ddlkk �"Ttn71 ✓ h! IG14 L ✓cJ L 04 t -i-►'I!y -C Aifcmrrd
() I
�W J-►rnc ✓� �ro SS Vtxlc < — L
VICG �� filSIr-w 1 trke
-its
okr i= Chi
Sn ►-)�
�a•.l
r
-c.Y lt.✓
V, C
V
VICG �� filSIr-w 1 trke
yus
-�
�a•.l
VOM --
,t r, lorc �cc
ow
Cc �w 1 tvv- �S ?
1
h t W Wt,-
s
Lz r ► 3
Av �Z
0
nt%..Jl
��f� -� '� OU
mJ �t G��4►�-.a $'a�cr
VSei 11 Kf- a�lf-'f-t L-4-
ar*-j
�Qlrly�� �r "rC' � —
�,..�
V)CAV e
-OW
r
-c.Y lt.✓
V, C
V
q �
C1' cc c T /U F 1 L Lc
��� �-C � �•! iPGr�i --tn ytr � �� er- ...P -1 T--- i �
Ync- l c SE'S
V L SUS tC�— 1 Ors pn ��.,cc t
1 4
4 ri 5 'e-
,p e• -r►-� -� ss cr
Kpzyt ►'` QY1 Durk — art r L r q
o o. r - -1 1/aAxc•�` Vr •e cn r ►Q-S 1n..s�L�.r- ,.1 -a h,, 0 21Q
itrVO�r 5�{S'�►'Y� , �cY. (J�0.�
.5 �o � �omlcn� � Smcrl� 1�0+ -x� S `D,= S.`► r��.«\ lr.- ,,�'iC,.�Ld �jti ��"�
U. -L f or; r?'o r� m� m.A Sms' -I knc— 1 3 ,1 4 �— �v S � d ei-s' A
01x'1
c> S c c j L u r- rrro
ODI
�/ t,YYlCt 1 i M 4 li Fnr c
tyc v NYY-\ c.lc-ss;-J;CL-4-
w os a- v
fns S- W 1 1 ` <4-:% L J •
be �f e� � f->,►� r c�l '�^- �� 2Z v � �.�r,.,� �.r- ��t�, -,� �
D
I'' 1 17, �� { n j C�v►'
1W S
4.4 c s \t4 Pte — AV If
d
!Q1 CA
P4 aL\
c ct' r ZZ O -ty-
n h i �-
�,A`__ a at, , I , k` -C-v --A r.% z w AS i knell V�CAU
L �, r'� S
'�� l7 rates �'v� -r 0.C►�vt'i Yhb.t D(� (KJG� -� �X �I
•
OF
SrP2��IrF (��io
S n
IV
1 cam+ -�-►. �•-� � 1;-1 -.
S —
3 n-(w W-c- h.ct-)d—s' � ( c !?"� 6 4ri":2 e
C 1 ✓S c t. /ilrr� s � 5 �►-YIS -t c.� i� � or, t � �,— o"' '1� S � i c C.si
�'�trG. `'+ �_y��r+ �.- ►�la.,�.,5 CCY't��.) IJ►itTIG -4
1
-t�cj/ P.
C^tiJS R-nro:4
WAZ�Ac"A-., ti
4y T>cs
V n i k '4- -2
M ter; r�-o► -�► -cr-'� o �
? �w 'ICY' -1-cl
c�rt ✓+ -►•c -� ►mot
OA-5 V i� . (''-cS c r ✓a �s-
►rc r-t /h d G�YiC
�1J\ �� 0`��tG1 �.f -2�� a►'�,� .�-.! � m � 1 •�'�- i'1� G� i /�'cvt�inC L -' _ .
r l
�,S•c.Z � o.�ls..." a�.S rt-t-
n FW n o+ ACS b vs-r.r z
Qk�,t.,r \.t c.n I LS O s
t �vG a�r-rr t Aia;
r ovr � � �� � a < <- C �rr�. -ill- W•t.( -� c,,,- �.. S �.. -r�.,� -
3 J O - �
IL
ho
3 J O - �
Ii J, / r z
C�S
o GQ O t f 71 U v (,-6 hr-\ t s ch't ✓),
w.. cc�r-,
V V off- o-�e YQV4 � v-w
Scm -y-\ < Maw
LTcrN. --
-p Iati
n C;,-Cas t- hoppro
C f ✓rarJ o Sw,�nrT-
' S
;)0 SohK T s /�►- ���YrY. —
TJ V �1 f CJ OH S< {y1 A r, 6 r n
ck
rl
VA V v,V-t ► 1. r Lnr -V 1 /`C - Clr I 1 n T - k 1 G V.W lk (A0 . N c- Ilk At,
rat v�- � r� wc<►Y•
r1�4SC/'�77�,C19�r t ,� hn
v
J I�l�;kt V►) c. s FI�IJ
E's I _
c_v-`
t ,
fim w— �1►� �o�.l �C
.�s t(movaj
M
_W/—C-
Expanded Harris Reservoir
Wetlands Mitigation Planning
ENVIRONMENTAL
SERVICES, INC.
r—
Outline for Discussion
• Evaluation of existing wetlands
• Wetlands distribution modeling
• Reference reservoir system
• Develop wetlands mitigation concept plan
Evaluation of existing wetlands
• NCWAM classification of wetlands covered by
approved JD
• Functional evaluation on representative
wetlands
• Quantified HAR impacts per NCWAM
(2012
1
Representative He
Reservoir Wetland Types
9oaomWW Hardwood Forest In
Utley Creek wrtemW
• 2w older or greater streams, •1•
InterMltendyto seasonally J
Inundated 1
• NCWAM gating- Medium
• Extended bwndadon affects
Nnctlonel ra"M BlH
• Nutrient removal
• Export organic material
•
Surface and wDsurfacewater
SUMP
10/31/2012
2
Representable Harris
Reservoir Wedand Types
Headwater Forest
• less than 2"• order streams or
topographic aenulatlons,
seasonally to semF
permanently saturated and a
only Intennittemly inundated
NCWAM Retina -High
• Typically higher in landscape
position
• Intercept runoff
•
Filter pollutants before
reaching streams
1WY
Y'
Representative Harris �t
Reservoir Wedand Types
RhroriM Swamp Forest In
Norris aranoh watershed
• Associated with airy stream
order, feasoMliyto semi-
permanentlyinundsted
• NCWAM Raang -High
• Flooderaterstorege
• Groundwaterredurge
• Nutrient removal
• Organic material export
• Wildlife habitat
Representable Harris
Reservoir Wetiend Types
Nor W dal Freshwater Marsh
• At kart semi-permanently
inundated or saturated
Includes kcustrineand
riparian hhrge
NCWAM Rsting -High
• Hydriila and primrose slightly
reducas habitat wtMmctlon
rating, but not enough to
affect Overall rating
• Shoreline ftabRitallon
Nutrient uptake
Fish nursery
• Wateriowl and wading bird
habitat
k�
t
10/31/2012
3
Representative Harris
Reservoir Wetland Types
Non-Wal freshwater Momh
• NCWAMRa Igh
Harris Lacustrine Wetland Community
Characterization
• Soils
• Species composition
• Zonation patterns
• Hydrologic influence
Harris Lacustrine Wetland Community
Characterization
Soils
• Primarily Triassic Basin parent materials
• 2/3 of the soils in wetland areas evaluated
have failed to develop hydric indicators
10/31/2012
4
Wetlands Affected by HAIR Project per NCWAM type
47593 052 081
75.29 361 -
3019
10.78 060 012
316 - -
9.76 099 -
60&67 972 093
Wetlands Distribution Modeling
• Purpose: predict wetland formation around future reservoir
(24(' MSL) based on current conditions (220' MSL)
• Approach: linked wetland JO for current lake level to
environmental features in a GIS as basis for predicting suitable
wetlands habitat at future lake level
• Assumption: similar hydrologic conditions at future normal
pool
r r
LA.
wresr.�.�r..r IIO��+rr.r.s.ro�w
10/31/2012
5
Wetlands Distribution Modeling - Methodology
• Built three separate models— emergent, fringe, and terrestrial
• Used CH21VIHi1I elevation zones to constrain potential habitat
• Derived potential predictor variables from DEM and soils
• Predictors represent terrain shape, landscape position, and
soils characteristics
• Used logistic regression since JD data is presence/absence
• Correlated variables eliminated before models were built
Wetlands Distribution Modeling - Results
• Overall predictions were about 77% accurate
• Emergent = 76 %, Fringe = 65 %, Terrestrial = 91%
• For emergent and fringe models, relative elevation and
horizontal distance from normal pool were most influential
predictors
• For terrestrial model, slope, relative elevation, and hydnc soils
were most Influential predictor variables
10/31/2012
0
Harris Observed and Future Modeled Lake Levels
IfE
_
irr m��YVUr�roaur�a�r•i:a
rrr�rra�r!
Sim
t><�
i011i[l1110110141m1!
n
HEM
\
0ii0WHINt
IV
rY \r
/ /r�rrbJi•fYZ.r��rir��a,�l
►`f111f
Reference reservoir review
• Initial screening
• Hydrology evaluation
• Selection for on -site evaluation
IfE
_
irr m��YVUr�roaur�a�r•i:a
rrr�rra�r!
rars�zaurisrwsr•�i�rssa
t><�
Reference reservoir review
• Initial screening
• Hydrology evaluation
• Selection for on -site evaluation
10/31/2012
7
rars�zaurisrwsr•�i�rssa
t><�
i011i[l1110110141m1!
n
HEM
\
0ii0WHINt
IV
rY \r
/ /r�rrbJi•fYZ.r��rir��a,�l
►`f111f
Comm(
iW
\O7FAUA
11i
im
E.milla,
Up,
p0I011
irr��,w:�rr�ra�ar►ar.�J�n�
�,Jrr-- —
10/31/2012
7
Jordan preliminary wetlands screening
,or&n LWo ftwmenr n..
w.wna.
N—IMW ft shy .Mash
MCWMPAft-KO t
Danb Wh7 —.da Wf
ygeYbn �,lnashm wYa aNOa)
lean tpda & —ft,hM Nast
—M..b
Kry Ma rw d mYYI Iloa6r
hand w(YYI011
Ib IIOI�IIYIw %DYb(Le IrydMa)
db—d
10/31/2012
10/31/2012
Jordan Lake
Examples of Shoreline Scarping
Jordan lacustrine wetland community
characterization
• Soils
• Species composition
• Zonation patterns
• Hydrologic influence
Jordan Lacustrine Wetland Community
Characterization
Soils
• Primarily Triassic Basin parent materials
• 1/3 of the soils in wetland areas evaluated
have failed to develop hydric indicators
lype�mYOm 0.OSSbJamslb laasar lRasllWmsmplorTtltlArLatabW
10/31/2012
10
0
Vegetation Summary
• Non -tidal freshwater marsh and lacustrine fringe
18(17%) 18(32%)
38J37%) 16(29%)
•. 48(46%) 22(39%)
104 56
ac.r� s
Wetlands mitigation concept plan
considerations
• Existing and future wetlands function
• Wetlands distribution modeling
• Reference reservoir
• Land use
• Watershed approach
10/31/2012
11
Harris Stream and Wetland Mitigation Planning
IRT Site Visits 2011 -2012
Date
Site
Stream System ID
(See figure)
March 17, 2011
White Oak Creek and Big Branch (White Oak Creek)
17 and 18
Utley Creek
22
April 14, 2011
Utley Creek
22
Future inundation area in White Oak Creek
(conceptual wetlands discussion)
NA
(adj. to 16)
June 16, 2011
Lower Buckhorn Creek
1
July 13, 2011
Thomas Creek
7
September 16, 2011
Utley Creek
22
October 20, 2011
White Oak Creek and Big Branch (White Oak Creek)
17 and 18
March 8, 2012
Beaver Creek
31
April 19, 2012
Norris Branch (upper section) and Cary Branch
25
May 17, 2012
Jim Branch
28
Norris Branch (limited part of lower section)
25
June 21, 2012
Norris Branch (lower section)
25
Upper Buckhorn Creek
29
August 29, 2012
Little White Oak Creek
14
Big Branch (Little White Oak Creek)
11
September 20, 2012
Lower Buckhorn Creek
1
\,