Loading...
HomeMy WebLinkAboutNC0026611_Meeting Notes_20040607NPDES DOCIMENT SCANNING COVER SHEET NC0026611 Morehead City WWTP NPDES Permit: Document Type: Permit Issuance Wasteload Allocation Authorization to Construct (AtC) Permit Modification Complete File - Historical Engineering Alternatives (EAA) Meeting Notes Instream Assessment (67b) Speculative Limits Environmental Assessment (EA) Document Date: June 7, 2004 Whims document in printed on reuse paper - ignore any content on the reirerae Decide 411c4 NCUG..74040 4 &ert 6e( elk ? 2. 51 /21e.) /-<, er,(>17,,7/fr .......----/- v ' xr_af,6, 4, /._-5,4//67-4) 4r/ r.40,76 . i: 6// Cily IkPr. I (`'-- • A .,) .7(, f. _ (di". ) i C_ ".e W az A GP'. 2 4t.6-,C. r 1 , • . ; ri . ir " 6? //411.-/ 4 e' 1 el, free ire14-4Y 4 t°,-)1 0?#15/ 11(1t/l/ .1"e7leveffhcH/7, a 6 ;:, , ,.., . , )6 - - f:_'-,--r • y r /2(4/ie 04 ' Irie. - o o4 c r cr — 1 1 erl 0 /yr. /4/),1 kill -,,,' 0 , /cc /4 t'eto 1 11;.z._,(,, i..efitiCaten k. (I r• ;-/et(1:261 .54 f.::_c 4,,,ee i : , : tea. 1Ork Cils,4 ality re : a 1 ( 7 . 6? -4/ • • .1(,)-1 (c( '..,:i. ‹,,n;ita( r/ 74":.'44.4-1 ..1,. v -(1- - n ,r... •-l- -- t-- -TC . 0 VIel'e' 1417/& MOREHEAD CITY FLOYD M. CHADWICK, JR. Council PAUL W. CORDOVA ROBERT B. HOWARD, JR. - JOHN F. NELSON DEMUS L THOMPSON TO: FROM: DATE: I. Mayor Pro-Tem NORTH CAROLINA 706 ARENDELL ST P.O. DRAWER M MOREHEAD CITY, NC 28557-4234 TEL (252) 726-6848 FAX (252) 726-2267 EMAIL townotmc@nternet.net Division of Water Quality Town of Morehead City June 7, 2004 GERALD A. JONES, JR., Mayor R. RANDY MARTIN City Manager The Town of Morehead City respectfully requests that the State's Division of Water Quality remove the City from the moratorium list which currently prohibits sewer line extension permit issuance. Morehead City has taken steps to support the requested action as follows: • The City has requested and received approximately $2.8 million state grant and loan assistance to address inflow and infiltration (i&i) problems. The recently completed project has resulted in a significant reduction in i&i which, combined with the impacts of major weather related events, was the reason that Morehead City was placed and has remained on the moratorium list. [NOTE: To support Morehead City's contention that the i&i project has been successful, the services of ECU's Decision Science Department were engaged to study the impact of the project. Enclosed is the executive summary of their findings] . • In addition to this major project, Morehead City has for the past eight (8) years recognized the significance of i&i problems by committing a dedicated crew with equipment and material resources that has worked exclusively to address i&i problems. An estimated additional $1.0 million has been expended by the City during the period for this purpose. The City is committed to continuing this successful ongoing effort. • The City is operating its existing Wastewater Treatment Plant (WWTP) very efficiently as documented by a 2002 Performance Evaluation of the WWTP performed through services of the State's Municipal Compliance Initiatives Program conducted by Mr. Gene Johnson, MCI Coordinator, Division of Water Quality. In fact, other than flow violations, the City has, with only very minor exceptions, operated within its NPDES permit and has avoided bypasses of untreated wastewater during the past decade despite extremely high flows during major storm events [e.g. numerous hurricanes, El Nino, record rainfall in 2003]. • The City is committed to a long term goal of reducing and hopefully finding an alternative to discharging into Calico Creek. To this end, the City pursued, received and will soon complete a grant -funded project for a ADA/EOE/P Equal Opportunity Employer Provider 5 acre demonstration reuse irrigation sod growing site on City land. The City undertook this project to gain experience while completing the upgrade of the existing WWTP to produce 100% reuse quality effluent. The City also recently completed a new park in close proximity to the WWTP that has a reuse irrigation system already installed that is ready to accept effluent from the new plant. The City only last week received approval of another grant to expand the new park and add additional acreage and reuse irrigation opportunities with that project also being completed prior to the new WWTP going online. The park sites will total 25 — 30 acres. The City has also begun dialogue with the Clean Water Management Trust Fund about a major, primarily grant -funded project to develop a first phase of a larger scale reuse project to construct an elevated tank and distribution system to expand reuse irrigation opportunities to a nearby golf course, county park and two school sites. The Coastal Federation has indicated a willingness to support the City in this effort, as well as, efforts to pursue other projects to mitigate potential stormwater impacts from the City's upgrade of its WWTP and inherent increased flow [NOTE: The City and Coastal Federation were co -applicants in a successful project last year to acquire Sugarloaf Island off the Morehead City waterfront for conservation purposes preventing the property from being developed by commercial interests] . • The City has completed its 201 Facilities Plan and is awaiting final issuance of the required FONSI to construct a reuse quality WWTP. The City Engineer is under contract and well on his way to completing plans and specifications for the new 2.5 mgd facility by the end of 2004 at which time the City will apply for permits to proceed with immediate construction of the facility. Based upon these and other efforts, Morehead City believes relief from the moratorium to allow additional line extensions is fair and justifiable. The City obviously needs to expand its customer base to help spread the fixed costs associated with debt already incurred to make improvements to the system and to address the $8 T 9 million conservatively estimated for the new WWTP. Morehead City officials thank you in advance for your prompt consideration of this request. Sincerely, • AOi /'4I ayor Ger ENCLOSURES A. Jones, Jr. Executive Summary Morehead City Sewer Improvement Project Purpose: The Town of Morehead City utilized the services of Scott Delana and David West, Associate Professors of Decision Science, College of Business at East Carolina Universty, to project the effectiveness of sewer improvements on reducing infiltratibn/inflow of extraneous water into the City's sewer system under varying rainfall and groundwater conditions. Backgr 4p und: As of June, 2003, Morehead City's sewer collection system consisted of approxithately 60.4 miles of sanitary sewer lines, 1,100 manholes and 24 pumping Pp Y stations. During the past year, the City completed the following work to reduce infiltration/inflow into the sewer system. • Installed HDPE liners in 504 LF of 6" sewers and 25,389 LF of 8" sewers • installed cured -in -place liners in 1,394 LF of 8" sewers and 976 LF of 10" sewers • Replaced 214 manholes [190 (0-6 ft) and 24 (6-8ft)] • Installed fiberglass liners in 40 manholes. The high majority of sewers treated with the above improvements were vitrified clay pipes without water tight joints. The bulk of the construction work was completed in stages between October 2003 and April 24, 2004. [NOTE: Although improvements were phased (throughout the project, full impact of the reductions of the infiltration/inflow was not achieved until late April, 2004] . As of April 1, 2004, an updated breakdown of the material types of sewer lines in the City's system is as follows: approximately 25% are vitrified clay, 32% PVC, 19% PVC Truss, 9% ductile iron and 14% polyethylene. [NOTE: Prior to the project, the system consist d of approximately 32% vitrified clay, 32% PVC, 19% PVC Truss, 9% ductile iron an 7% polyethylene]. Findings: An ARIMA intervention model was used to estimate the effectiveness of sewer improvements made by the Morehead City municipality from June 2003 to April, 2004. The estimate of the impact of the sewer improvements is a reduction of inflow and infiltration of 201,000 gallons per day during an average year. Wastewater treatment flow rates were predicted for the improved system under the following three scenarios, a wet year comparable to 2003, a perfectly average rainfall year, and a drought year 1 comparable to 2001. The average daily flow rates through the improved sewer system .,...and discharged from the wastewater treatment plant aregivenin the following_tab_ Sc nano Average Annual Rainfall Groundwater level Wastewater flow (inches/year) (centimeters) (mgpd) Extremely wet year 92 44 1.67 Average Drought year year 61 35 96 1.28 153 1.02 Model and Variables: The primary purpose of the model developed for this study is to accurately predict the discharge flow of wastewater from the treatment plant. Daily measures of flow rates through the wastewater treatment plant (WTF) were provided by Morehead City personnel. The explanatory variables selected for the model were those suggested by the Morehead City project team and supported by prior publications in the research) literature. We found that the WTF had a first order autoregressive behavior which simply means that today's flows are correlated with yesterday's flows. The inflow and infiltration rates are known to be highly dependent on rainfall rates and groundwater levels. Daily rainfall (RF) rates were measured at the treatment plant and used in the study. Actual groundwater levels (GWL) were not available but estimates were constructed by interpolation from a major field research study conducted in Carteret County under the direction of Professor Amatya of North Carolina State University. The most of ective explanatory variables were found to be GWL and a dynamic interaction term be een RF and GWL with an exponential decay of approximately 5 days. An intervention term (I) was used to model the fact that the system was changing during the study. This intervention term is a ramp function that defines a continuous rate of improvement in the sewer system beginning June 1, 2003 and ending March 31, 2004. For completeness, the functional form of the model is given below. (1 9/3)WTFt = aGWL +rl RF * GWL + wIt (1 bB) Validity of model: The parameters of the model were estimated from 1,552 daily observations beginning in January 2000, and ending March 31, 2004. The model is highly significant with an R2 of 0.856 and a mean absolute percent error of 5.99 /o. Each of the variables in the model is also highly significant withp values generally less than 0.0001. The small p values suggest that all variables are necessary to explain the wastewater treatment flow. Investigators: Scott Dellana, East Carolina University David West, East Carolina University 2 --- Office East Carolina University College of Business Administration Department of Decision Sciences Greenville, NC 27585 (252) 328-6370 email: westd@mail.ecu.edu EDUCATION VITA DAVID A. WEST Home 1404 Doris Circle Greenville, NC 27858 (252) 321-8390 UNIVERSITY OF RHODE ISLAND, Kingston, RI. Doctor of Philosophy, May 1996 Concentration in Operations Management and Management of Information Systems Dissertation Topic, Applications of Neural Networks to Decision Science Problems UNIVERSITY OF CHICAGO, Chicago, IL. Masters of Business Administration, May 1974 Member Beta Gamma Sigma, national business honorary Selected for International Business Program CLARKSON UNIVERSITY, Potsdam, NY. Bachelor of Science in Chemical Engineering, June 1967 Awarded National Science Foundation Fellowship PUBLICATIONS Neural Network Ensemble Strategies for Financial Decision Applications'; forthcoming in Computers & Operations Research, with S. Dellana. Ensemble Strategies for a Medical Diagnostic Decision Support System: A Breast Cancer Diagnosis Application", forthcoming in European Journal of Operational Research, with P. Mangiameli, R. Rampal, and V. West. "Model Selection for Medical Diagnosis Decision Support System", Decision Support Systems (36) 247-259 2004 with P. Mangiameli and R. Rampal. "Predicting Wastewater BOD Levels with Neural Network Time Series Models" in Neural Networks in Business Forecasting , Idea Group Publishing, with S. Dellana. "Transfer Function Modeling of Processes with Dynamic Inputs", Journal of Quality Technology, (3) 315-326, with S. Dellana and J. Jarrett. "Credit Scoring using Supervised and Unsupervised Neural Networks", in Neural Networks in Business Techniques and Applications~ Idea Group Publishing, 2002 with C. Muchineuta. "On -Line Education in a Management Science Course — Effectiveness and Success Factors"; Journal of Education for Business, Vol. 76(1) with S. Dellana, and W. Collins. - "Model Selection for a Medical Diagnostic .Decision Support System. BreastFer. -�.- Detection Case'; Artificial Intelligence in Medicine, Vol. 20 2000 with =V:4West "Neural Network Credit Scoring Models"; Computers and Operations Research, Vol. 27, 2000. "Improving Diagnostic Accuracy Using a Hierarchical Neural Network to Model Decision Subtasks", International Journal of Medical Informatics, Vol. 57 with V. West. "Identifying Process Conditions in an Urban Wastewater Treatment Plant", International Journal of Operations and Production Management, Vol. 20(5-6) 2000 with P. Mangiameli. "Control of Complex Manufacturing Processes: A comparison of SPC Methods with a Radial Basis Function Neural Network", OMEGA: The International Journal of Management Science, Vol. 27,1999 with S. Chen and P. Mangiameli. "An Improved Neural Classification Network for the Two -Group Problem", Computers and Operations Research, Vol. 26,1999 with P. Mangiameli. "A Comparison of SOM Neural Networks and Hierarchical Clustering Methods", European Journal of Operational Research, Vol. 23 1996, with P. Mangiameli and S. Chen. "Improving Product Design Effectiveness With Associative Memory Neural Networks", in Engineering Applications in Management Science, JAI Press, Vol. 9, 1996, with S. Narasimhan. "The Comparative Ability of Self -Organizing Map Neural Networks to Recover Cluster Structure"; OMEGA: The International Journal of Management Science, Vol. 23 No 4, with S. Chen and P. Mangiameli. PROCEEDINGS "Issues in Scheduling Dynamic Demand Service Operations", Proceedings of the Production and Operations Management Society, New York, October, 1992, with P. Mangiameli and S. Narasimhan. "A Heuristic Scheduling Algorithm for Dynamic Demand Service Operations", Proceedings of the Northeast Decision Sciences Institute, Boston, April 1992, with P. Mangiameli and S. Narasimhan. "Scheduling Service Operations With Dynamic Demand: A Heuristic Algorithm", Proceedings of the Decision Sciences Institute, San Francisco, November 1992, with P. Mangiameli and S. Narasimhan. "A Benchmark Study of the Ability of Neural Networks to Recover Cluster Structure", Proceedings of the Decision Sciences Institute, Washington, November 1993 with S. Chen. "Improving Product Design Effectiveness With Associative Memory Neural Networks", Proceedings of the Production and Operations Management Society, Boston, October 1993, with S. Narasimhan. "Improving the Design Retrieval Process With Associative Memory Neural Networks", Proceedings of the Northeast Decision Sciences Institute, Portsmouth, April 1994, with S. Narasimhan. "Increasing the Effectiveness of Research Literature Retrieval", Proceedings of the Decision Sciences Institute, Honolulu, November 1994, with P. Mangiameli and S. Westin. "The Impact of First Order Positive Autocorrelation on Process -Control", -Proceedings othe Northeast Decision Sciences Institute, Providence, March :1995",::vrR- h=J: Jarrett. Winner -of -The Robert W. Pearson Award for best application of theory. "Statistical Process Control of Complex Manufacturing Processes", Proceedings of the Decision Sciences Institute, Boston, November 1995, with P. Mangiameli and S. Chen. "The Accuracy of Neural Network Classification Models", Proceedings of the Decision Sciences Institute, Orlando, November 1996, with P. Mangiameli and S. Chen. • "An Improved Neural Classification Network for the Two Group Problem"; Proceedings of the Decision Sciences Institute, Annapolis, April 1997, with P. Mangiameli. "Employing Statistical Learning Networks to Improve Classification Decision Accuracy"; Proceedings of the Decision Sciences Institute, San Diego, November 1997, with P. Mangiameli. "Neural Network Applications of Quality Control: A Case Analysis"; Proceedings of the Decision Sciences Institute, Boston, March 1998, with P. Mangiameli and C. Roethlein. "An Investigation of The Bias/Variance Dilemma for Neural Network Classification Models", Invited paper for Joint Conference on Information Systems, Research Triangle Park, North Carolina, October 1998. "Identification of Process Faults in an Urban Waste Water Treatment Plant"; Proceedings of the Decision Sciences Institute, Las Vegas, November 1998, with P. Mangiameli. "Improving Health Care Diagnosis"; Proceedings of the Northeast Decision Sciences Institute, Newport, RI, March 1999 with P. Mangiameli. "Detecting Process Disturbances with ARIMA Intervention Models"; Proceedings of the Decision Sciences Institute, New Orleans, November 1999, with S. Dellana and J. Jarrett. "Model Selection for a Medical Diagnostic Decision Support System", Proceedings of the Northeast Decision Sciences Institute, Atlantic City NJ, March 2000. Winner of The Mrs. Ulker Alasyali Best Paper Award for Health Care Services. "Using Intervention Analysis to Develop Control Charts for Autoregressive and Moving Average Data Structures", Proceedings of the Decision Sciences Institute, Orlando Florida, November 2000, with S. Dellana and J. Jarrett. "Bagging Predictors for a Decision Support System: A Credit Scoring Application", Proceedings of the Decision Sciences Institute, Orlando Florida, November 2000. "Modeling Process with Dynamic Inputs", Proceedings of the Northeast Decision Sciences Institute, Pittsburgh Pa., March 2001 with S. Dellana and J. Jarrett. "Model Selection for Improving Diagnosis", Proceedings of the Northeast Decision Sciences Institute, Pittsburgh Pa., March 2001 with P. Mangiameli and R. Rampal. Winner of The Mrs. Ulker Alasyali Best Paper Award for Health Care Services. "A Comparison of Student Performance in On-line vs. Traditional Instruction", Proceedings of the Northeast Decision Sciences Institute, Pittsburgh Pa., March 2001 with S. Dellana & W. Collins. BUSINESS EXPERIENCE WESTGREN ASSOCIATES, Barrington, RI. President, 1982-1990 Developed $3 million small business focused on retail products for. children~ Implemented distributed information system for inventory management and purchasing control. -- UNIROYAL INC., Middlebury, CT. Manager of Business Planning, 1979-1981 Responsible for annual operating and strategic plans for the 5 business units of the Plastic Products Division with annual sales of $200,000,000. CF INDUSTRIES, Long Grove, IL. Senior Planner, 1975-1979 Responsible for business, production, and logistic plans for a $1 billion agricultural business. ATLANTIC RICHFIELD, Chicago, IL. Project Manager, 1967-1974 Responsible for the planning, design, and construction of major chemical manufacturing facilities. TEACHING EXPERIENCE East Carolina University, Greenville, NC Assistant Professor of Decision Sciences. 1996-2001 Responsible for teaching graduate and undergraduate courses in Operations Management Courses taught, 1996-1999 DSCI 3023, Management Science DSCI 3123, Operations Management DSCI 4383 Management of Operations Technology DSCI 6123, Graduate Level Operations Management SERVICE Bryant College, Smithfield, RI. Lecturer in Management, 1990-1994 Nominated for Excellence in Teaching, May, 1994 Faculty advisor for Student APICS Chapter Reviewer for European`Journal of Operational Research Reviewer for Computers & Operations Research Reviewer for IEEE Transactions on Neural Networks Reviewer for Decision Support Systems Reviewer for Journal of Environmental Engineering and Science Reviewer for Northeast Decision Science Proceedings, 1994-2003 Operations Management Track Chair for Northeast Decision Science Institute, 1998 & 1999 Board of Directors, Northeast Decision Science Institute, 1999-2001 Board of Directors ASQ, Section 1126 MBA Case Competition Advisor PROFESSIONAL AFFILIATIONS The Institute of Management Sciences The Decision Sciences Institute American Society for Quality Control, ASQC I. - IV SCOTT A. DELLANA t 301 Fault Circle Greenville NC 27858 East Carolina University Department of Decision Sciences 3410 Bate Classroom Bldg Greenville NC 27858 (252) 328-4893 Present Rank: i.ssociate Professor, Tenured (1999) Education: University of Missouri -Rolla, Ph.D. in Engineering Management, May 1993 Major Manufacturing Systems Engineering. Minor Field: Quality Dissertation title: Application of Total Quality Management to a Research and Development Environment. Universiy of Missouri -Rolla, Master of Science in Engineering Management, May 1991. Minor Field: Engineering Mechanics University of Pittsburgh, Bachelor of Science in Civil Engineering, December 1983 Majo : Soil Mechanics and Foundation Engineering: Magna Cum Laude Professional Certifications. EIT (Engineer in Training) Administration and Teaching Experience: EAST CAROLINA UNIVERSITY, Greenville, NC. 8/93-Present Administration: Chair of Decision Sciences Department, College of Business 8/01-present. Duties involve managing the daily operations of the department and setting future direction for a faculty of about 27 people. Typical activities include: developing class schedules, managing operating budgets, evaluating faculty performance and determining faculty compensation, hiring of new faculty, leading departmental meetings, managing faculty and student problems, assigning of graduate assistants, and setting of annual departmental goals. Teaching: Courses taught include: Operations Management (Graduate and Undergraduate and online), Management Science, Materials Management, Project Management, Management and Analysis of Quality, and Production Planning & Control. Overall student evaluations: 4.3 out of 5 (1993-97) and 5.9 out of 7 (1997-present). Advis!ng: have advised approximately 30 students (majors and non -majors). DRURY COLLEGE, Fort Leonard Wood, MO. 9/92-12/92 (School of Business). Courses taught: Operations Management Other Experience: UNIVERSITY OF MISSOURI-ROLLA CENTER FOR TECHNOLOGY TRANSFER AND ECONOMIC DEVELOPMENT, Rolla, MO. 9/91-5/93 Quality Assurance Specialist - Coordinated Quality Assurance program for DemMaTec Foundation, Inc., teaching of training courses, consulting and seminar speaking engagements. MCDONNELL DOUGLAS CORPORATION, St. Louis, MO. 10/86-9/91 Lead Engineer — Responsible for supervision of aircraft structural engineers in production of various aircraft including: Harrier II+, A-12 Advanced Tactical Aircraft, ATF-23 Advanced Tactical Fighter, and F15-Eagle. ROCKWELL INTERNATIONAL CORPORATION, Columbus, Ohio. 2/84-10/86 Aerospace Structural Engineer - Supported B-IB Strategic Bomber production as structural analyst. STONECRAFT COMPANY, INC., Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania, USA and Carrara, Italy. Youth (My father, Leno J. Dellana, was the President of Stonecraft — a stone and marble fabrication company). I lived iin Italy from the ages of 9 to 13 as a result of my father's international joint venture with Menchini & Dellana, Incorporated. Attended Italian schools, where I mastered fluency of the language and culture). Original Works/Research: Published Journal Articles West, David; Dellana, Scott.; Qian, Jingxia. (2004). Neural Network Ensemble Strategies for Financial Decision Applications. Computers in Operations Research. In Press. Dellana, Scott A.; Snyder, David. (2004). Student Future Outlook and Counseling Quality in a Rural Minority High Sch ol. High School Journal. Forthcoming. Dellana, Scott A.; David West. (2002). Transfer Function Modeling of Processes With Dynamic Inputs. Journal (Quality Technology. 34:315-326. Dellana, S. and Glascoff, D. (2001). The Impact of Health Plan Profit Status on Consumer Satisfaction With Health Care. Journal of Nonprofit & Public Sector Marketing. 9 (3):1-19. Dellana, S. and Glascoff, D. (2001). The Impact of Health Insurance Plan Type on Satisfaction With Health Care. Health Care Management Review, 26(2): 33-46. Dellana, S., Collins, W. and West, D. (2000). On -Line Education in a Management Science Course: A Study of Effectiveness and Performance Factors. Journal of Education for Business, 76(1): 43-47. Dellana, S. and Hauser, R. (2000). Corporate Culture's Impact on a Strategic Approach to Quality. Mid -American Journal of Business, 15(1): 9-20. Killingsvforth, B., Hayden, M. and Dellana S. (1999). Total Quality Involvement in the Classroom: Integrating TQM into a Systems Analysis and Design Course. College Student Journal, 33(3): 465-476. Dellana, S. and Hauser, R. (1999). Toward Defming the Quality Culture. Engineering Management Journal, 11(2): 11-15. Dellana, S. A., Bass, K. E., and Hebert, F. J. (1998). Industry Managers' Reactions to Total Quality Management in U.S. Business Schools. Mid -American Journal of Business, 13(1): 73-82. Dellana, S. A. and McLeod, M. E. (1997). Relationships of Instructors' Personalities With Total Quality Management Practice in the University Classroom. Psychological Reports, 81: 99-118. Collins, W. H. and Dellana, S. A. (1997). Process Analysis Using Automated Regrouping. Quality Engineering, 10(1): 185-193. Dellana, S. A. and Radahkrishnan, S. (1996). A Statistical Approach to Inspection System Selection. Quality Engineering, 9(1): 135-141. Bass, K. E., Dellana, S. A., and Hebert, F. J. (1996). Assessing the Use of Total Quality Management in the Business School Classroom. Journal of Education for Business, 71(6): 339-343. Dellana,?. A. and Coffin, M. A. (1996). Quality Management Tactics in U.S. Manufacturing: Do They Rival thapanese? Engineering Management Journal, 8(2): 27-34. Hebert, F. J., Dellana, S. A., and Bass, K. E. (1995). Total Quality Management in the Business School: The Fac lty Viewpoint. SAMAdvanced Management Journal, 60(4): 20-31. Dellana, S. A. and Wiebe, H. A. (1995). An Exploration of Total Quality Management Practices in U.S. R&D Organizations. Engineering Management Journal, 7(2): 23-29. Conference Papers in Published Proceedings Dellana, Scott; West, David. March 2004. A Comparison of Linear and Non -linear Models for Process Quality Control. Proceedings of the Northeast Decision Sciences Institute. Pgs. 287-289, Atlantic City, NJ. West, David; Dellana, Scott; & Qian, Jingxia. March 2004. Ensemble Strategies for Financial Decision Support. Proceedings of the Northeast Decision Sciences Institute. Pgs. 180-182, Atlantic City, NJ. Killingsworth, Brenda; Schellenberger, Robert; & Dellana, Scott. March 2004. The Use of Geographic Information System to Track and Forecast Health Care Needs for a Regional Hospital. Proceedings of the Northeast Decision Sciences Institute. Pgs. 315-317, Atlantic City, NJ. West, David; Dellana, Scott. November 2003. Nonlinear Forecasting Models for Predicting Wastewater Effluent Loads. Best Paper Award. Proceedings of the Decision Sciences Institute. Washington D.C. West, David A.; Dellana, Scott. March 2003.Monitoring Process Quality With Neural Network Time Series Models. Proceedings of the Northeast Decision Sciences Institute. Page(s) 277-9. Providence, RI. Dellana, Scott A.; Prichard, Jan, Hayden, Michael & Killingsworth, Brenda. March 2003. Role -Based Access Cntrol Techniques for Sharing Medical Information Across Integrated Delivery Systems. Proceedings of the Northeast Decision Sciences Institute. Page(s) 300-2. Providence, RI. West, Da id A.; Dellana, S. & Jarrett, J.. March 2001. Modeling Processes With Dynamic Inputs. Proceedi gs of the Northeast Decision Sciences Institute. Page(s) 316-8. Dellana, Scott A.; Collins, W. & West, D.. March 2001. A Comparison of Student Performance in On-line Versus Traditional Instruction.. Proceedings of the Northeast Decision Sciences Institute. Page(s) 4-6. West, D. and Dellana, S., and Jarrett, J. (November 2000). Using Intervention Analysis to Develop Control Charts for Autoregressive and Moving Average Data Structures. Manuscript accepted for presentation at the 2000 Decision Sciences Meeting in Orlando, FL. West, D., Dellana, S. and Jarrett, J. (March 2000). Using ARIMA Intervention Modeling to Detect Special Causes in Autoregressive Control Charts. Proceedings of the 29`h Annual Meeting of the Northeast Decision Sciences Institute (pp. 271-273). Atlantic City, NJ. Collins, ., Dellana, S., West, D. and Collins, C. (March 2000). Achieving Interactivity in an On -Line Course. Proceedings of the Annual CITE Conference (http://www.cite.ecollege.com/index.learn). Denver, CO. West, D. Dellana, S. and Jarrett, J. (November 1999). Detecting Process Disturbances With ARIMA Intervention Models. Proceedings of the 306 Annual Meeting of the Decision Sciences Institute (pp. 1421-1423). New Orleans, LA. Dellana, LS. and Glascoff, D. (October 1999). The Impact of Rural Versus Urban Location on Consumer Satisfactfion with Healthcare. Proceedings of the 1999 Atlantic Marketing Association Conference (pp. 523;532). Annapolis, MD. Dellana, S. and Glascoff, D. (July 1999). A Study of Satisfaction With Health Care Options in the United tates. Proceedings of the 5th International Conference of the Decision' Sciences Institute (pp. 689 691). Athens, Greece. Dellana, S. and Glascoff, D. (March 1999). The Impact of Plan Choice and Plan Changing on Satisfaction With Health Care. Proceedings of the 1999 Northeast Decision Sciences Institute (pp. 245-247). Newport, RI. Dellana, S., and Hauser, R. (November 1998). An Empirical Examination of the Impact of Corporate Culture on Total Quality Management. Proceedings of the 29th Annual Meeting of the Decision ScienceS Institute (pp. 1690-1692). Las Vegas, NV. Dellana, S , and Glascoff, D. (March 1998). Variables Affecting Consumers' Satisfaction With Health Care. Proceedings of the 1998 Northeast Decision Sciences Institute (pp. 326-328). Boston, MA. Dellana, S , and Glascoff, D. (November 1997). Assessing the Quality of Health Care Service Plans. Proceedings of the 28th Annual Meeting of the Decision Sciences Institute (pp. 1632-1634). San Diego CA. Dellana, S , Hauser, R. and Nicholson, J. (March 1997). Toward a Relationship of TQM and Organizational Culture: Case Studies. Proceedings of the 1997 Northeast Decision Sciences Institute (pp. 302-304). Annapolis, MD. Dellana, S,, Bass, K., and Hebert, F. (1997). TQM Practice in the Business School: Industry Views and Expectations. Proceedings of the 1997 Southeast Decision Sciences Institute (pp. 248-250). Atlanta, GA. Dellana, S , Hauser, R. (November 1996). TQM and Corporate Culture: An Empirical Examination. Proceedin s of the 27th Annual Meeting of the Decision Sciences Institute (pp. 1736-1738). Orlando, FL. Dellana, S., Bass, K., and Hebert, F. (1996). University Professors Translate the TQM Movement into Higher Education. Proceedings of the 1996 Southeast Decision Sciences Institute (pp. 306-308). Charleston, SC. Bass, K., Dellana, S. and Hebert, F. (1995). Total Quality Management in the University Classroom: Current Practices to Business Schools. Proceedings of the 1995 Southern Management Association (pp. 468-470). Orlando, L. Dellana, S., Hebert, F., and Bass, K. (March 1995). The Attitudes of U.S. Business School Faculty Toward TQM and its Use in the Classroom. Proceedings of the 1995 Northeast Decision Sciences Institute (pp. 452-454). Providence, RI. Dellana, S. and McLeod, M. (1995). Instructor Personality Type and Total Quality Management in the Classroom: A Pilot Study. Proceedings of the 1995 Southeast Decision Sciences Institute (pp. 93-95). Wilmingtn, NC. Dellana, S. and Wiebe, H. (October 1994). An Exploration of Total Quality Management Practices in US R&D Organizations. Proceedings of the 1994 International Conference of the American Society for Engineering Management (pp. 46-51). Washington, DC. Dellana, . and Wiebe, H. (1994). The Use of Student Teams to Identify CQI Opportunities. Proceedings of the 1994 International Conference of the American Association for Engineering Education (pp. 1285-1290). Edmonton, Alberta,Canada. Dellana, S. and McLeod, M. (March 1994). The Myers -Briggs Type Indicator as a Tool for Implementing Total Quality Management in Higher Education: A Preliminary Study. Proceedings of the 1994 Northeast Decision Sciences Institute (pp. 313-315). Portsmouth, NH. Dellana, S. and Wiebe, H. (October 1992). Application of Total Quality Management to Research and Development: An Historical Perspective. Proceedings of the 1992 International Conference of the American Society for Engineering Management (pp. 327-331). Hoboken, New Jersey. Academic Papers Presented (not published in Proceedings) Dellana, . and Hauser, R. (1996). A Theoretical Basis for the Quality Culture. Presented at the POMS 6 International Conference in Indianapolis, Indiana. Other Publications West, D. and Dellana, S. Predicting Wastewater BOD Levels with Neural Network Time Series Models. Neural etworks in Business Forecasting, Chapter V, pp 102-120: IRM Press, 2004. Dellana,; S., Hebert, F., and Bass, K. (1995). TQM in U.S. Business Schools: A Faculty Perspective. the career forum, 14(2), 20-24. ($'14\ Presentations: Managing Business Projects. Seminar presentation to a group of MDs for the Research Department of Internal Medicine at the Brody School of Medicine, East Carolina University, December 12, 2001. Purchasing and Supply Management: Partnering Industry and Business Education. Meeting of the National ssociation of Purchasing Managers, Eastern Carolina Section, November 11, 1997. Purchasing and Supply Management in the Business School Curriculum. Meeting of the National Association of Purchasing Managers, Eastern Carolina Section, January 14, 1997. An Introduction to the Principles and Elements of Total Quality Management. Seminar presentation for the ECU Graduate Dean's Office and the ECU Office of Sponsored Programs, September 1994. Manufacturing Assessment Program - Quality Module. Symposium for the SBA, sponsored by the University of Missouri -Rolla Center for Technology Transfer, 1993. Textbook Reviews: Burns, James R. Information Technology Management (Prentice Hall, 2001). Reviewed entire draft uscript. Finch, B on. OperationsNow.Com: Processes, Value. and Profitability (McGraw Hill/Irwin, 2001). Reviewed entire rough draft manuscript. T.D. Klastorin. Project Management: Techniques and Trade-offs (Prentice Hall, 2000). Reviewed prospectus submission for future manuscript. Thomas oster. Managing Quality: An Integrative Approach (Prentice Hall, 1998). Reviewed first half of r ugh draft manuscript. James A. Fitzsimmons and Mona J. Fitzsimmons (1998). Service Management: Operations, Strategy and Information Technology (Irwin McGraw-Hill, NY, 1998). Reviewed entire textbook. Roberta S. Russell and Bernard W. Taylor, III (1998). Operations Management: Focusing on Quality and Competitiveness (Prentice Hall, Englewood Cliffs, NJ, 1998). Reviewed entire textbook. Papers SubmittJd and Under Review: West, D Manusc and Dellana, S. Advanced Forecasting Models for Predicting Wastewater Effluent Loads. ipt under second review at the International Journal of Forecasting. Grants Received: Grant Proposal for ECU School of Business Summer 2000 Research Stipend in the amount of $8,000. Research topic: Using ARIMA Intervention Modeling to Detect Special Causes in Autoregressive Control Chart Data. Award made by East Carolina University School of Business. Grant Proposal for ECU School of Business Summer 1997 Research Stipend in the amount of $7,500. Research topic: Assessing Health Care Service Gaps Using SERVQUAL: HMO Organizations versus Private Physician Care." Award made by East Carolina University School of Business. Grant $oposal for ECU School of Business Summer 1996 Research Stipend in the amount of $7,500. Researchtopic: Theory and Empirical Assessment of the Quality Management Culture Concept. Award made by East Carolina University School of Business. Awarded Post -Doctoral Fellow in the amount of $10,000. Research Topic: Application of Total Quality Management to Higher Education. Part of the University of Missouri -Rolla TQM implementation effort - 5/93-8/93 Course and Curriculum Development: Developing an online course in Project Management. Developing a course in Supply Chain Management. Restructured the Operations Management concentration. Restructu ed the Materials Management course to include emphasis on Purchasing and Supply Chain Management (1996). Developed a new course in Project Management. Developed a new course in Quality Management. Work -in -Progress: West, D. nd Dellana, S. Currently performing analysis of data for forecasting business failure. Dellana, S. and West, D. Currently writing manuscript for journal submission of nonlinear models in process quality control. Target Journal: Journal of Quality Technology. Dellana, S. and West, D. Currently writing manuscript for journal submission of wastewater case study for Morehead City, NC. Target Journal: Interfaces. Kros, J., West, D. and Dellana, S. Research in work on overbooking in a student health center. Rosenthal , D., Dellana, S. Kros, J, and Seeman, E. Currently performing data collection of Computerized Physician Order Entry System pilot implementation program at Pitt County Memorial Hospital. Public and Professional Service Activities: Reviewefor the European Journal of Operational Research, 2004. Reviewer for the 2004 Northeast Decision Sciences Institute conference. Reviewe and discussant for the 2003 Northeast Decision Sciences Institute conference. Elected t Board of Directors for the Northeast Decision Sciences Institute, 2000-2003. Track Chair for the 2000 Northeast Decision Sciences Institute conference. Reviewer for the 2000 Northeast Decision Sciences Institute conference. Discussant for the 2000 Northeast Decision Sciences Institute conference. Campus Representative for the 2000 Northeast Decision Sciences Institute conference. Manuscript reviewer for the journal, Integrated Manufacturing Systems (1999). Session Chair for the 1999 International Decision Sciences Institute conference. Track Chair for the 1999 Northeast Decision Sciences Institute conference. Reviewe and best paper judge for the 1998 American Society for Engineering Management conference. Session C hair for the 1998 Northeast Decision Sciences Institute conference. Paper reviewer and best paper judge for the 1997 American Society for Engineering Management conference. Paper reviewer for 1997 Decision Sciences Institute national conference. Paper discussant at the 1997 Northeast Decision Sciences Institute conference. Paper reviewer and best paper judge for the 1996 American Society for Engineering Management conference. Paper reviewer for 1996 Northeast Decision Sciences Institute Proceedings. American Society for Quality — East Carolina Section 1126 Chair 1997-98 and Treasurer1995-97 Alpha Iota Delta Honorary of the Decision Sciences - East Carolina University Chapter President 1996-97 and Vice President 1997-99. National Association of Purchasing Managers — Scholarship Chair 1996-97. Professional Consulting Experience: NACO Materials Handling Group, Inc. for Demand Flow Technology implementation, 1997-1999. ASMO, Inc., Quality Control Training Course for ISO 9000 Certification, May 1996. f Committee Assignments: University: College of Business: Department: Research & Teaching Grants Committee — Term length 1999-2002. Career Education Committee —1998-99 Vice Chair. Term length 1996-1999. Academic Libraries Committee — term length 1998-1999. Graduate Committee — term length 1997-1999. Cooperative Education representative - 1997-present Outreach Committee —1997-98. Operations Management Curriculum Committee — 1996-present. Professional Affiliations: American Society for Quality — member since 1993. National i ssociation of Purchasing Managers — member since 1996. Decision Sciences Institute — member 1992 — 2001. American Society for Engineering Management — member 1992 —1998. Production and Operations Management Society — member 1996 -1998. Society of Manufacturing Engineers — member 1992-1994. Awards and Honors: Alpha Iota Delta Honorary of the Decision Sciences — November 1992 University of Missouri -Rolla Chancellor's Fellowship - September 1991 Tau Beta Pi National Engineering Honorary Society — March 1983 William Radcliffe Smith Memorial Award in Civil Engineering — April 1984 Chi Epsilon National Civil Engineering Honorary Society — December 1982 Who's VYho Among Students In American Junior Colleges - May 1979 Personal: Born July 6, 1958. U.S. Citizen. Have held a variety of government security clearances. Married; four children ages 7, 11, 15, and 17 years. Fluent it Italian. Conversational in Spanish. References: Available upon request. 1 WWTP FLOW RAINFALL TREND DATA [NOTE: WWTP flow and rainfall data result from actual readings at the WWTP. Morehead City's WWTP is a certified NOAA facility for documenting rainfall data]. TABLE 2.3 COMPARISON OF WATER SUPPLY WELL PUMPAGE VERSUS WATER SALES VERSUS WWTP FLOWS TOWN OF MOREHEAD CITY 1975 - 2002 Year Well Pumpage Avg. (GPD) Metered Sales Avg. (MGD) WWTP Flow Avg. (GPD) Water Loss Well vs Sales (%) Water Gain Sales vs WWTP (%) Annual Rainfall (IN) 1975 619,995 506,622 1,150,000 18.29 55.95 1976 666,247 507,000 1,200,000 23.90 57.75 1977 716,164 558,173 920,000 22.06 39.33 1978 729,000 585,277 800,000 19.72 26.84 1979 704,000 604,120 830,000 14.19 27.21 1980 780,000 579,000 773,000 25.77 25.10 1981 755,000 572,000 1,257,000 _ 24.24 54.49 48.95 1982 766,000 645,000 1,162,000 15.80 44.49 58.89 1983 858,000 662,000 1,523,000 22.84 56.53 66.37 1984 906,000 711,000 1,250,000 21.52 43.12 63.89 1985 1,009,000 847,000 1,201,000 16.06 - 29.48 65.35 1986 975,000 892,000 1,050,000 8.51 15.05 48.48 1987 904,581 r 882,901 1,032,263 2.40 14.47 53.68 1988 931,613 848,167 1,251,068 8.96 32.20 52.67 1989 950,726 852,334 1,310,142 10.35 34.94 71.28 1990 974,156 900,638 995,025 7.55 9.49 37.86 1991 993,345 907,545 1,151,789 8.64 21.21 62.47 1992 977,898 890,142 1,133,880 8.97 21.50 . 56.38 1993 986,306 913,167 1,130,568 7.42 21.36 54.99 1994 1,040,907 905,816 1,195,549 _ 12.98 24.60 55.07 1995 1,072,000 938,469 1,236,202 12.46 22.54 51.84 1996 1,207,686 1,040,535 , 1,386,839 , 13.84 25.97 72.56 1997 1,184,127 1,032,735 1,252,528 12.79 17.62 51.85 1998 1,218,008 _ 1,013,258 1,560,700 16.81 35.35 70.68 1999 1,187,496 1,055,672 1,348,410 _ 11.10 21.80 54.70 2000 1,196,003 992,184 1,504,378 , 17.04 33.86 67.00 2001 1,151,879 956,705 1,117,114 16.94 14.36 35.04 2002 1.142.898 971.763 1.280.183 14.97 31.73 60.34 11G-PC 11D8051FTL120041141H201 PR2.TXT MH-C CT 1-201-PLAN-R02.TXT 27 040223 [2004: Completed Sewer Rehab Project] [2003: 90 + inches of rain - a record for this region; excessive high wlter table throughout year; sewer rehab. Project begun; exceeded flow permit for yearly average; 3 montli DWQ flow violations]. [2001: Drought ear; extremely low rainfall] [1998: Winter 1 Nino event; storm events; 90 + % flow for year triggers official line extension moratorium] [1996: Inflated ainfall; Hurricane storm events during summer months] N @co hLLII • Do5-`CD N IV W •P :1%► .p 0) C C\ NI co O -s le, J••IC ON .. ` . O -Ls :.)..1\1-a i J.3..S- "'%1 In CO Q0 In N CO -COJ1 COCDN031CO 03 - 0 C) 0) Q) n) IV W 41 O-.i�l O-1CD cJ1rn CA0 O 00 c) 000 Jh no 00 N 0 �1 CJ1 GO "co IV o 0 4 0) ) '4 p1 — CO O) oo0000000 000000000 COCO-•1jNN COWIN) IA* -� CO 0 C31 01 COC O CO 0 CO CO -0► _0 O OOO00000000 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 CO O N 0 0 --� .i ce. -s N - - - -a. -s - - -s O O IV -co no Co -.l 1,) = n) ~00 �ICDCOCOOCONcoCJ1-IN•ts NOor�J aOW000NNo 0 0 - • co O O O O O O O O O O O O ▪ 0 0 0 P7 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 -L1.3i1 W 4I N IV N - -% IV -co y4:k•CO.s-a►-I►1%3'4041031•3 Ca) W CO 01 N CO 571 O CD CO O ..,,, O co -co O -aO O -a co O O CO 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 CO O 00000000000 Co Cr O IV co CJ1 N IV b-0► cm •CM 0:1 �.93GOON--I.ODCOD�COO 0) t%) 0o0.000000 000�000000 1 -a. 3 3 - -a .3 - -a. IV IV W �► s ► •j V .13 OC3)O N CO)7:4a,8o) coo CO -coO O O O -cob-cob O O O CO 000000000000 - ..a..a.s'f`1. --a-a.-a.-a.- -s A •[OfV:•s CA �► CA . at --s GO CO CO 0) CO d OCOtJ1'NI 000_1CO 01 000 ..s 00 0000oo0oo co coo t00000000o co 00 000000o c) - -i ...a. s - --1...a. -i O-no NC03.4-a. -N "01 -CJIC000100tl1C3)0 O-1.0 �c1 00000000000 0 00000000000 CO CD 0 CO 0 COJ1 OT1 0 y•4mNOCOoii1mN0CCOC) -. CO 03 SO .91 SO ** 1 o Ca o 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 o Co w o0000000000o CO w 000000000000 .A• MONTHLY RAINFALL M. C. WWTP 1997 1998 1999 2000 2001 2002 2003 JAN.3.57 LL,213. 3.39 4.06 1.42 4.32 2.84 FEB. 2.77 12.36 2.23 2.40 2.47 3.29 3.86 MAR. 3.81 2.42 2.56 1.98 3.85 5.53 llr APR. 3.94 4.85 2.93 7.51 2.29 1.39 232 MAY. 2.35 6.78 3.50 4.39 1.96 5.56 13.41 JUN. 2.75 1.22 4.37 8.188 5.83 4.16 6.46 JUL. 5.25 5.87 2.47 1122 7.35 8;04 8.8 AUG. 3.04 15.49 13.22 242 4.26 10.26 6.0 SEPT. 8.57 6.31 11.21 10. 1.49 .5, 2 11.1 OCT. 2.46 0.98 4.13 0.54 0.44 4.02 ,6 NOV. 6 1.82 3.11 5.79 1.53 5.14 3.90 DEC. Is_la 5.15 1.58 3.24 2.15 2.81 7.36 TOTAL 50.46 70.68 54.70 67.44 35.04 60.34 91.52 C [EXCERPT] Municipal Compliance Initiatives Program PERFORMANCE EVALUATION TOWN OF MOREHEAD CITY WASTEWATER TREATMENT PLANT PREPARED BY CONSTRUCTION GRANTS AND LOAN SECTION DIVISION OF WATER QUALITY AUGUST 2002 CONCLUSIONS AND RECOMMENDATIONS-------,--,- --- OPERATION AND MAINTENANCE A Mu �cipal Compliance Initiative (MCI) audit was performed for the town of MoreheadtY system. City to evaluate its wastewater s stem. The evaluation included (1) a determination bf the status of the wastewater treatment plant's current NPDES permit requirements. A comparison, expressed as percent of limit, was made for Flow, Biological Oxygen Demand (BOD5,), and Total Suspended Solids (TSS); (2) a table top Inflow/Infiltra 'on (I/I) analysis. The analysis was based on available records rather than conducting field work; (3) an evaluation of both the physical condition and equipment to determine the plant's ability to meet the requirements of the NPDES permit; (4) a review of the sewer budget and the town's user charge; (5) an analysis of the performance of the treatment facility at current and design conditions, and (6) staffing requirements for the facility. Based on these analyses the following conclusions and recommendations are made: 1. The ton of Morehead City had one (1) notice of violation and one (1) notice of deficie�c duringthe eighteen(18) month review period, those being for toxicity. Y � (Thougi not related to the four (4) parameters the MCI monitors (BOD5, TSS, Ammonia, and. Flows,_ 2. The Inflow/Infiltration (111) analysis indicated that the town has both an inflow and wet weather infiltration problem. During dry periods when the groundwater table is low J approximately five(5)percent of the design capacity flow enters the plant , PP Y g P as infi}tration. As the groundwater rises above the level of most of the collection system, extraneous water leaks into the pipes and an additional 78 percent flow enters the plant in excess of the expected Average Daily Flow (ADF). Inflow presets even a greater problem. During one five (5) day period in which 2.21 inches of rain fell, an increase of flow attributed to inflow into the plant was over three end one-half million gallons. These values indicate that under certain conditions, each inch of rainfall produces an additional flow of approximately 1.65 million gallons at the plant. Of course under these conditions, solids can more readir be washed out of the plant 3. The t?wn of Morehead City has approximately 71 miles of interceptor and cone tion sewers ranging from 6 to 20 inches in diameter. This equates to over 639 ' ch miles of pipe. An old EPA criterion used to determine excessive infil tion is a rate which exceeds 3,000 gallons per day per inch -mile (gpdim) of pipe. At this rate approximately 2,000,000 gpd in additional flow above the exile ted average daily flow would be expected at the plant. Of course if flows at - 19 - (4111 this magnitude were to enter the plant, the facility would not be able to:handle them. Wet weather infiltration has been calculated to be approximately 500,000 gpd at the treatment plant. With the length and size of sewer lines, based the EPA criteria, innfiltration is not considered excessive. However, these flows equate to almost orke-third the permitted flow and would have a marked impact on the facility. Large increases in flow, due to inflow, at Morehead City's treatment facility follow rain fall events. Recorded flows of increases above the expected average daily flow of 500,000 to 700,000 gpd were not uncommon several days following rainfall events. A general EPA guide line for excessive inflow is that if inflow is i greater than 275 gallons inflow per resident it is considered excessive. With 4,333 customers, and assuming three (3) persons per residence, an inflow in excess of 3,500,000 would have to occur to be considered excessive. Guide lines are just that and are not always applicable to every case. In the case of Morehead's treatment facility, should flows of 3,500,000 enter the plant, the facility could not function. Morehead City has an aggressive inflow/infiltration program and should be commended on the work that they have accomplished. It is suggested that they continue or increase the level of rehabilation they are now performing. 4. Based on reported Daily Maintenance Reports (DMRs), the treatment plant at Morehead City is performing exceptionably well for a secondary treatment plant. During the eighteen (18) months under review, January 2001 through June 2002, the tricking filter plant averaged 95% BOD5 removal and 93% TSS removal. efficiencies maybe the physical design of the plant. A contributing factor to these efficie p y g This doe not necessaillf mean the actual type of facility but rather the size of some of the conponents on the site when compared to the flow into the plant. The Primary deeper the dee er of the secondary clarifiers, as well as the combined size of the chlorine contact chambers are much larger than required for the average influent flow. The additional storage (size) of the basins provide quiescent zones that allows the solids in the wastewater additional settling time. Another factor that could aid in better effluent quality is the weir length of both the primary and secondary clarifiers. With the longer lengths, less liquid passes over each linear foot of 7 eir, thus reducing the hydraulic velocities. With slower velocities, solids are less susceptible to beingdrawn over them. P 5. There is one problem that could be associated with one (1) of the two (2) secondary clarifiers. Even though both clarifiers meet or exceed design criteria, there is a problem with at least one of them, that being its depth. While one is eleven (11) feet deep, one that could present a problem is only seven (7)feet deep. Today's clarifiers are typically designed to be twelve (12) feet deep or deeper. The inc eased depths aid in preventing an upset in the solids that have settled to the bottom associated with high flows that enters the plant from time to time. -20- 6. The two i2) trickling filters have the design capacities to handle a much higher influent tlow, as much as a third more, than is typically experienced today. However, as tighter restrictions are probably going to be imposed in future NPDES permits, the filters may not be able to meet those requirements. As mentioned earlier, the plant is operating above exceptions and to get higher performance may be unobtainable. Morehead City has initiated plans for a new tertiary treatment plant and they are to be commended for this inititative. 7. The average residual chlorine discharge from the treatment facility over the eighteen 18) month review period was 1.3 mgfl. Even though Morehead City does not have a NPDES chlorinelimi discharging chlorine at this level in the effluent could cause toxicity problems as a 'deuced with a notice of violation and a notice f deficiency issued by NCDENR It is suggested that the chlorine feed rate be reduced or a su ur io de -or -other chlorine neutralizing system be installed. 8. The chlorine contact basins had considerable amounts of settled solids at their bottoms. In some areas, they were accumulated to a depth of sixteen (16) inches. Settled s lids in chlorine contact basins can easily be placed into suspension by hydraulic flows. If suspended, the solids can be discharged with the final y ' ipermit limits. It is suggested jeopardizing the NPDES that the solids not be allowed to build up in these basins, but rather they be cleaned of them periodically. 9. Under current conditions, the two aerobic digesters have sufficient detention times for the solids produced at the plant. At design parameters they are not. Each of the digester's aerator is sized sufficiently to successively reduce the volatile solids introduced into them, and mathematically the horsepower supplied for mixing is sufficient. However, as deep as the digesters are, even with the use of a draft tube on the aerators, some of the solids near the bottom of the structure may not be completely mixed. Another possible problem with the digesters are that they are self decanting. Some solids are constantly being passed through the overflow back into the treatment train. This means that there is a possibility that some solids may pass through the treatment train several times. As the particles are digested they are red9ced in size and could eventually become ash. Small particles and ash are mel difficult to settle and easilypass into the final effluent. As the digesters extremely y have f ed platform aerators, the surface of the digesters must remain constant, negatin the use of a swivel arm decanting device. If in the future the aerators requirereplacement it is suggested that floating aerators and a swivel arm decanting device be considered. -21- 10. The calculated sludge production indicates that the number of sludge drying beds are insufficient. Design criteria suggests that each of the beds be used eight (8) times per year. The calculations indicate that the beds must be used twelve (12) times per year under current conditions. This suggests that the sludge would be removed prior to being completely dry. The town has an excellent storage facility for the solids from the beds. A 50 foot x100 foot metal storage building is on site that provides storage for up to one year. The extended period of time provided by this stora a facility aids the town in meeting its class B sludge requirements. 11. EPA guidelines indicate that slightly approximately 4 man years (8,000 hours) are required to operate the plants at Morehead. Presently about 3 Y2 man years are being dedicated and only account for time spent on the physical facility. Any time spent on a collection system or pump stations outside the physical plant site is not inclu l ed. The town may wish to consider an additional employee. - 22 -