Loading...
HomeMy WebLinkAbout20120270 Ver 2_401 Application_20121012DIAL CORDY AND ASSOCIATES INC. 14x- ID �'� ° U2, Environmental Consultants 490 Osceola Avenue LETTER OF TRANSMITTAL Jacksonville Beach, FL 32250 904 - 241- 882'Fax 904 - 241 -8885 TO: NC DWQ, 40IMetlands Unit Attn* Ian McMillan 1650 Mail Service Center Raleigh, NC 27699 -1650 WE ARE SENDING YOU X]Attached via FedEx THE FOLLOWING ITEMS: Shop drawings Prints Copy of correspondence 11 Change order DATE 1019/2012 1PROJ. NO J12 -1210 ATTENTION SUBJECT under separate cover via OTracings Samples Contract documents other: 12 @ [2 9 W [2 1 DST 1 1 2012. COPIES DATE DWG NC DESCRIPTION 5 Permit modification request for SAW- 2010 -01797 / DWQ Project #2012 0271 DWQ Project #2012 02701 Onslow County THESE ARE TRANSMITTED as checked below - For review and concurrence E] For review and comment ❑ Resubmit copies for review For your information Returned for corrections Submit copies for distribution As requested _ Prints returned after loan to us Return corrected prints No exception taken may be used as submitted 1:1 Exceptions as noted may be used subject to comments REMARKS: If enclosures are not as noted, please advise us at once. Signed: Jason Evert 1. DIAL CORDY AND ASSOCIATES INC Enuironmental Consultants 4 October 2012 Mr. Brad Shaver Project Manager USACE Wilmington District CESAW- RG(1145 -b) 69 Darlington Ave Wilmington, NC 28403 I a -va ?o u a- LNn T 1 1 2012 ob ..... AT� _ RE: Modification Request for Action ID No. SAW- 2010 - 01797/ Department of the Army Permit New River Marine Corps Air Station, Camp Lejeune, NC 28542 -0004 Dear Mr. Shaver, Dial Cordy and Associates is in receipt of document 2012- 08 -08- 130225 dated 15 August 2012 and your email (request for additional information) sent Monday, 10 September 2012 at 12:36 PM pertaining to the above project. We sincerely appreciate your efforts on both counts, and have made revisions and additions to our submittal to clarify our request. Overview of Modifications. At this time, we have secured the necessary topographic data and engineering plans to provide additional details regarding Phases II and III of the project, and are also able to update Phase I. Phase I changes include the identification of a previously unanticipated, small, wetland impact where an ephemeral ditch empties to Wetland 5 (W5) and some additional, necessary grading near Wetland 4 (W4). Previously anticipated impacts to wetlands in Phases II and III have been minimized to the maximum extent practicable; in fact, one impact of 0.24 -acre has been completely avoided. With - project- condition cross - sections of wetland impacts areas are shown in attached Figure 9, and the positions of these cross - sections are shown in planview in Figure 10. In addition, the applicant's engineer has provided planview sheets (in electronic format) showing construction details, from which the various frames in Figure 10 were transcribed. Avoidance and Minimization. Also, due to avoidance and minimization efforts, project engineers have been able to achieve an overall decrease of 1.09 acres of wetland impacts throughout the project area. Below is a summary of proposed changes for each phase of the project (acreages are not necessarily impacts that will require mitigation). Summary of Changes in Wetland Impact Both Temporary and Permanent Areas Phase Initial (ac) Modified (ac) Difference (ac) 1 0.80 0.82 1'2 +0.02 I I 0.56 0.14 -0.42 III 1.20 0.51 -0.69 Project Total 1 2.56 1.47 -1.09 '207 linear feet of permanent impact to Wetland 4 intermittent stream is anticipated for this phase 234 linear feet of permanent impact to Wetland 5 intermittent stream is anticipated for this phase �1) For the Phase I portion of the project, it has of late been determined that the proposed and necessary alignment of north - south - oriented Longstaff Road (see revised Figure 4, road feature outlined in red) will, in fact, result in permanent impacts to Wetland 5 of up to 487 square feet. This is due to the close configuration of the southeast comer of the proposed hangar and its south access road, the proposed squadron warehouse, and the large swale that runs east -west between the hangar and warehouse positions. Essentially, the intersection cannot be moved farther to the west due to the previously existing swale /ditch (not readily visible in revised Figure 5), which will continue to serve a significant water management function post- construction. The resulting impact, including 34 linear feet of intermittent stream, has been minimized as much as possible. Finally, additional topographic data indicate the need for further grading at the impact site in Wetland 4, resulting in 0.01 ac additional permanent impacts and 0.01 ac temporary impacts. For the Phase II portion of the project (see attached Figure 7; Figure 6 from the initial submittal has not changed, and is not referenced in this request), impacts were minimized primarily by keeping the position of the perimeter road (actually named "Perimeter Road ") as far from the large, contiguous wetland to the south (W7) as possible. However, the roadway must be far enough from the proposed runway /over -run extension to comply with UFC (Unified Facilities Criteria) 3- 260 -01, which dictates that a roadway cannot be placed within 500 feet (parallel, i.e., next to) of the active runway or its "over- run." Furthermore, if a fence is placed at the perimeter, it must be placed seven feet farther away from the runway /over -run for each foot of the fence's vertical height. Hence, roadways (which must be placed outside the perimeter fence) cannot be moved any farther from the wetlands and still be in compliance with the UFC. Variances to the UFC are not available to decrease the resulting 570 -foot minimum distance in this case (see below for a case where a variance was approved). Due to revised roadway position and minimizing fill for grading, impacts to wetlands W9 (not under federal jurisdiction) and W7 (impact formerly designated as W7 -1, now simply designated as W7) were minimized by a combined 0.42 acre compared to the applicant's original proposal. The remaining necessary impacts are due to fill for road grading, which has been reduced in lateral coverage to the maximum extent practicable. For the Phase III portion of the project, previously proposed impact W7 -2 (of 0.24 acre) has been completely avoided (this was near the "fire circle," a circular, paved feature visible in Figure 4's aerial photography), due to a repositioning of the Perimeter Road slightly to the east. Perimeter Road near Wetland I (i.e., "i ") is proposed for realignment in accordance with UFC 3- 260 -01 (i.e., 500 feet clear distance +7:1 -foot allowance for a perimeter fence), which results in impacts to Wetland I. Because a future project phase (to be completed between approximately 2014 and 2016) will extend the western runway /over -run to the southwest (to address the airfield operational design considerations in the NATOPS Flight Manual for MV -22s and also to fulfill UFC 3- 260 -01 requirement for 1,000 -ft over -runs on all Navy and Marine Corps runways), the proposed Perimeter Road will need to be realigned again in a few years to run parallel to the future runway /over -run, heading farther to the southwest before turning to the northwest around the end of the over -run (a graphic of this will be submitted under separate cover). In the interim, the roadway will be temporarily configured to balance aviation safety and wetland protection; the UFC clear distance is observed for as much of the roadway as possible, but the corner of Perimeter Road near impacts Wi -1 and Wi -2 (see Figure 8) will not involve a 90- degree turn, but instead a graded turn. The sharper - angle -turn alternative would have had approximately 100% more impacts to wetlands due to installing the necessary grading along two road segments that together are longer (and closer to the wetland) than the proposed single reach. To achieve this reduction of impacts, a temporary exemption from the UFC was allowed, but just for the turn /corner area. This will allow for at least a temporary preservation of approximately 0.75 acre of wetland functions for the habitat area that would have been impacted by a 90- degree corner positioned 570 feet from the existing over -run. The combined wetland impacts for Phase III have been minimized from the original plan by 0.69 acres and further reductions are not practicable or possible given engineering and aviation /transportation safety concerns. Page 2 of 4 Request for Modification of SAW- 2010 - 01797/ 4 October 2012 As can be seen on the following page, Tables C.2 and C.3 from the initial application package (which were previously revised 16 July 2012 and submitted to regulatory staff) have been revised again, as of 27 August 2012, to include the modified impact acreages for Phases II and II (and Phase 1). Mitigation. Mitigation for unavoidable impacts to wetland and stream habitats will be provided. In accordance with "the Mitigation Rule," which states that private or public mitigation banks are preferred over programs such as NCEEP, the applicant proposes to utilize Bachelor's Delight mitigation bank for mitigation purposes. We are in correspondence with the manager of the property to determine availability and suitability of mitigation. To date, the applicant has mitigated for 0.62 acre of wetland impacts and 207 linear feet of stream impacts. In addition to providing mitigation for those impacts, the applicant will provide funds to these banks in order to offset an additional 0.58 acre of permanent wetland impacts and 34 linear feet of permanent stream impacts. We understand that use of off -site banks (Bachelor's Delight) would result in the application of a mitigation ratio of 2:1. We are currently exploring whether the impacts at Wetlands 7 and 9 could be mitigated at a ratio less than 2:1 due to having been previously impacted. Related information will be provided under separate cover. We appreciate your efforts on behalf of federal regulatory compliance for this important project. Should you have any questions regarding the above, please contact me at (904) 476 -9571 or jevert@dialcordy.com at your earliest convenience. Best Regards, Jason Evert Senior Ecologist ENCL: 4 figures, color, 11x17" 2 figures, b &w, 11 x17" Engineering drawings (pdf) Page 3 of 4 Request for Modification of SAW- 2010 - 01797/ 4 October 2012 Tables C.2 and C.3 REVISED 4 October 2012 Table C.2. *Isolated wetland; not under federal jurisdiction Table C.3. Z V u u M a E: E: dA o (6 Q. G1 N f0 N cc E (0 C Qi (6 E CL U t0 "6 0 E: V — „ �' o C. _ E 2v LL 3 o CL •E +•+ c -O C 3 o o ° v L af°i Ec o N Z U y w ro �- +�. ro a Q) Y �i`n Q H Q W L H yr u O �4 V1 L �v� Qi L Q I W4P Permanent Forested No 0 0.63 ac I W4T Temporary Forested No 0 0.19 ac I W5P Permanent Forested No 0 487 sf I W5T Temporary Forested No 0 351 sf II W7P Permanent Forested No 180 0.11 ac II W7T Temporary Forested No 180 237 sf II W9* Permanent Forested No 540 625 sf II W9* Temporary Forested No 540 500 sf III MAP Permanent Forested No 100 0.43 ac III Wi -1T Temporary Forested No 100 0.05 ac III Wi -2P Permanent Forested No 15 0.02 ac III Wi -2T Temporary Forested No 15 515 sf Permanent Wetland Impact Subtotal 1.2155 ac Temporary Wetland Impact Subtotal 0.2768 ac Total Wetland Impact (acres) 1.4923 ac *Isolated wetland; not under federal jurisdiction Table C.3. Page 4 of 4 Request for Modification of SAW- 2010 - 01797/ 4 October 2012 u u M a E: a� E: u Q.. L r.. a+ C cc E (0 C Qi u CU L E c Z E: _0 '° — „ �' °' 2 C. _ E f0 s u O E E: a� E w •E +•+ c a) 4- J L .. @ `J `� U CL M a o Z u co v a) M m M - M `° N C V) Q H d C N L d 'Yp Q 1 R12(IS) n/a Permanent Intermittent 3' 207 0.0143 1 R12(ED) n/a Permanent Ephemeral n/a n/a n/a I R13(IS) n/a Permanent Intermittent 3' 34 0.0023 Total Stream Impact (by length and acreage) 241 0.0166 Page 4 of 4 Request for Modification of SAW- 2010 - 01797/ 4 October 2012 >1 Parallel Taxiway FOR OFFICIAL USE ONL imlEphemeral Ditch Ephemeral Ditch Apron NN 7 FOR OFFICIAL USE ONLY Legend PHASE ID PHASE I PHASE 11 PHASE III Surface Water Course Centerline Wetland Area 0 750 1,500 2,250 FOR OFFICIAL USE ON FOR OFFICIAL USE ONLY W4T, 0.18 acres W4 ,Constructed Bulkhead I FOR OFFICIAL USE ONLY \ " v V" W5P, 0.01 acres Proposed Feature Line PHASE I Type of Wetland Impact Permanent Temporary Phase I Stream Impact Area Wetland Area 0 150 300 450 600 Feet FOR OFFICIAL USE ONL FOR OFFICIAL USE ONLY W7 PROPO; RUNWA FOR OFFICIAL USE ONLY Legend Proposed Feature Line PHASE ID PHASE II PHASE III Type of Wetland Impact Permanent Temporary Wetland Area LL 150 300 450 600 Feet W9T, 0.01 acres FOR OFFICIAL USE ONLI FOR OFFI Mr, OR OFFICIAL USE ONLY R WI -2P, 0.02 acres FUTURE PHASE _. OVER -RUN EXPANSION AREA WI -2T, 0.01 acre Wit. tLf y SR OFFICIAL USE ONLY Legend OVER -RUN Proposed Feature Line PHASE ID — PHASE III Type of Wetland Impact Permanent ® Temporary Wetland Area 0 150 300 450 600 Feet FOR OFFICIAL US ,.- _�.;,� s: i � Cam. ^-n •`�:A R WI �� OR OFFICIAL ON g - a �. �x r, F O USE k' . - I I I I t.. m� RS Phase III Proposed Structure Impacts PRE- CONSTRUCTION NOTIFICATION APPLICATION MCAS NEW RIVER, CAMP LEJEUNE, NORTH CAROLINA Scale: 1 inch = 150 feet Drawn By: MR Date: August 2012 Approved By: JE DIAL CORDY ANSI ASS0CI ATE. s IN C. Fl llvir(nvne) licit r'r,r>_cuNcnuv J10-1210 FIGURE8 C/L LONGSTAFF SEEDED SIDE BANK STREET I 2' PAVED 12' SEEDED SHOULDER SHOULDER (TYP) 16' 11' TRAVEL I SEEDED 6' SEEDED HUD SHOULDER DTH 12' TRAVEL (TYP.) VARIES LANE TYP. MATCH EXISTING GRADE ASPHALT PAVEMENT STRUCTURE 16" WATER DBL 36" RCP RIPRAP PAD �- EXISTING WETLAND LINE NEW WETLAND LINE TEMPORARY WETLAND IMPACT LINE 467 SF 351 SF AN 7 TEMPORARY VETLAND I WETLAND IMPACT IMPACT TO ,BE RESTORED MATCH EXISTING GRADE WETLAW S CROSS SECTION EXISTING WETLAND LINE C/L PERIMETER NEW WETLAND UNE ROAD TEMPORARY WETLAND IMPACT LINE SWA WIDTH VARIES; 6' SE D S B TTOM AN 2' SHOULDER UP EACH SIDE BANK 11' TRAVEL (TYPO (TYPO; U1NE TYp SEED REMAINDER OF SIDE BANKS (TYP.) .0% , I MATCH [XISTING ASPHALT PAVEMENT S00 (TYP 2' GRADE STRUCTURE TYP. 625 SF 500 SF _TEMPORARY WETLAND WETLAND IMPACT IMPACT TO BE RESTORED SWALE WIDTH VARI SOD BOTTOM AND UP EACH SIDE BA (TYP.); SEED REMAINDER SIDE BANKS (TYF MATCH EXISTING GRADE SOD PERIMETER SECURITY FENCE SEEDED SIDE BANK C/L PERIMETER I ROAD 12' SEEDED SHOULDER 6' SEEDED 22 RDnowAr SHOULDER (TYP) 16' 11' TRAVEL I 11' TRAVEL - (TYP.) WETLAND 7 CROSS SECTION EXISTING WETLAND LINE 0.43 AC. PERMANENT WE PERIMETER SECURITY FENCE SWALE WIDTH VARIES; 12' SEEDED SOD BOTTOM AND 2' MATCH UP EACH SIDE BANK (TYP.) EX (TYP.); 10 ISTING ' SEED REMAINDER OF GRADE ISIDE BANKS (TYP.) D7� 2' TYP. SOD (TYP.) ASPHALT PAVEMENT STRUCTURE EXISTING WETLAND LINE NEW WETLAND LINE /— TEMPORARY WETLAND / IMPACT UNE 0.11 AC. 237 SF 7RMANENT TEMP RARY NETLAND WETLAND IMPACT IMPACT TO BE RESTORED NEW WETLAND LINE C/L PERIMETER ROAD EXISTING 0.05 AC TEMPORARY WETLAND IMPACT TO TEMPORARY BE RESTORED WETLAND IMPACT UNE SHOULDER SEEDED SIDE BANK 11' TRAVEL (TYPO I LANE (TYP.) Approved By: JE .0% 4.05 J12-1210 FIGURE 9 ASPHALT PAVEMENT STRUCTURE MATCH EXISTING GRADE WE LAND 9 CROSS SECTION (N.T.S.) W WETLAND 1 -1 CROSS SECTION (N. T. S.) `Ta EXISTING WETLAND LINE r— C/L LONGSTAFF STREET NEW WETLAND LINE 2' PAVED SHOULDER TEMPORARY WETLAND 1 SEEDED IMPACT LINE 6' SEEDED HL SHOULDER 9DTH 12' TRAVEL (TYP.) VARIES LANE TYP. 0.01 AC. 2.O X D.02 AC PERMANENT TEMPORARY' WETLAND IMPACT TLANDS R IMPACT TO IBE RESTORED I ASPHALT PAVEMENT STRUCTURE ❑BL 36" RCP MATCH EXISTING RIPRAP PAD GRADE WETLAND I —Z CROSS SECTION (N.T.S.) X WITH- PROJECT CROSS - SECTIONS AT AFFECTED WETLAND AREAS PROPOSED MODIFICATION TO SAW- 2010 -01797 DWQ Project #2012 0270, MICAS NEW RIVER NC Not To Scale Drawn By: TL (Haskell) Date: October 2012 Approved By: JE DIAL CORDY 1 n r.n - dnuu. J12-1210 FIGURE 9 G 16 1 ST 7T \ O �l } I 5I r.. 1 \ + �� I o 524+5361 j i I j KEY DIAGRAM FOR WITH- PROJECT CROSS - SECTIONS AT AFFECTED WETLAND AREAS PROPOSED MODIFICATION TO SAW- 2010 -01797 DWQ Project #2012 0270, MCAS NEW RIVER NC Not To Scale Drawn By: TL (Haskell) Date: October 2012 Approved By: JE ANI) VSS o (:I. -V ES INC —m DILL_ CORDY I , J12 -1210 FIGURE 10 ui (D' 1 k 00 J O 71 O i -- - PERIMETER ROAD -- -�-- -- - 63 00- 635+00 634 +00