HomeMy WebLinkAboutWQCSD0561_Regional Office Historical File Pre 2018 (2)AVA
NCDENR
North Carolina Department of Environment and Natural Resources
Division of Water Resources
Water Quality Programs
Pat McCrory Thomas A. Reeder
Governor Director
November 27, 2013
James Davis — (ry''' m n $
Pharr Yarns Inc.
100 Main St.
McAdenville, NC 28101
John E. Skvarla, Ill
Secretary
Subject: Compliance Evaluation Inspection
< ih7Tfi " Er Decmed "Collection= System
WQGSD0,564.=
Spencer Mountain WQCSD0049 •
Gaston County
Dear Mr. Davis:
Ms. Barbara Sifford of the Mooresville Regional Office of the Division of Water
Resources (DWR) conducted a compliance evaluation inspection for the Pharr Yarns wastewater
Collection system (WQCSD0561) and the Spencer Mountain (WQCSD0049) on August 20,
2013. Your assistance was greatly appreciated. An inspection checklist is attached for your
records and inspection findings are summarized in this letter.
Owners of deemed permitted collection systems must comply with all rules listed under
NCAC 15A NCAC 02T.0400, a copy of these rules is included with this letter. Documentation
of the inspections for both pump stations is required. Overflows are to be reported to the
Regional Office within 24 hours of occurring and 5-day reports are to follow for completed
information. A copy of this report is also included with this letter.
Right-of-ways and easements are to be maintained for accessibility of equipment needed
to maintain the collection system.
All documentation for all activities to comply with the requirements should be kept for a
minimum of three years, and the map should be maintained for the life of the system. If you
have any questions concerning the required documentation for this system please call Ms.
Barbara Sifford at 704-235-2196 or by email at Barbara.sifford@ncdenr.gov.
Mooresville Regional Office, 610 East Center Avenue , Suite 301
Mooresville, NC 28115
Phone: 704-663-1699 l Fax:704-663-6040
Internet: www.ncwateroualitv.orq
An Equal OpportunitytAffirmative Action Employer
Davis„Pharr Yarns
November 27, 2013
Page 2 of 2
The Spencer Mountain permit number will be listed as inactive for future reference this entire
system has been eliminated and only septic systems remain for residential and business.
Sincerely,
Barbara Sifford
Technical Consultant
Mooresville Regional Office
Division of Water Resources
Attachments:
Inspection Report
2T 403 Regulations
CERTIFIED MAIL #: 7015 1520 0002 8376 2654
RETURN RECEIPT REQUESTED
April 27, 2016
George Altice, Corporate Director of Engineering
Pharr Yarns Inc
PO Box 1939
Mc Adenville, NC 28101-1939
SUBJECT: NOTICE OF VIOLATION
Tracking Number: NOV-2016-DV-0163
Sanitary Sewer Overflows - March 2016
Collection System Permit No. WQCSD0561
Pharr Yarns Inc
Gaston County
Dear Mr. Altice:
The self -reported Sanitary Sewer Overflow (SSO) 5-Day Report submitted by Pharr Yarns Inc indicates violations
of permit conditions stipulated in the subject permit and North Carolina G.S. 143-215.1. Violations include failing to
effectively manage, maintain, and operate the subject collection system so that there is no SSO to the land or
surface waters and making an outlet to waters of the State for purposes of G.S. 143-215.1(a)(1), for which a
permit is required.
Specific incident(s) cited in the subject report include the following:
Total Vol
Total Surface
Incident Start Duration Vol Water
Number Date (Mins) Location Cause (Gals) (Gals) DWR Action
201600774 3/29/2016 60 100 Saxony Drive Other, Pump station 2,000 500 Notice of Violation
equipment failure
Remedial actions, if not already implemented, should be taken to correct the above noncompliance.
State of North Carolina I Environmental Quality Water Resources
610 East Center Avenue, Suite 301, Mooresville, NC 28115
704-663-1699
If you have any questions, please do not hesitate to contact Barry Love with the Water Quality Section in the
Mooresville Regional Office at 704-663-1699 or via email at barry.love@ncdenr.gov.
Cc:
Ln
.33
ru
.A
m
co
Sincerely,
W. Corey Basinger, Regional Supervisor
Water Quality Regional Operations Section
Mooresville Regional Office
Vater Resources, NCDEQ
'xo RECEIVED/NCDENRIDV R
a
Y MAY — " 1.E
+ WQROS --
I OR j SVILLE REGIONAL OFFICE
v
c
co
-iLlc i I�i N .
—
•o 1
co i < v —
ai 1 cC Z —
E ' to H
Z
- d w
'5 Now
wmwo1aoo Om ,0 D
o. •
U.S. Postal Service"'
C,RTIFIED MAIL® RECEIPT
Domestic Mail Only
For delivery information, visit our website at www.usps.com®.
Certified Mail Fee o
`l-t�
$
Extra Services & Fees (check bar, add fee as appropriate)
❑ Retum Receipt (hardcop1 $
Retum Receipt (electronic) $
Certified Mall Restricted Delivery $
Adult Signature Required $
El Adult Signature Restricted Delivery $
Postage
PHARR YARNS, INC.
PO BOX 1939
McADENVILLE NC 28101-1939
ATTN: GEORGE ALTICE
Dwr/bl 4/27/16
PS Form 3800, April 2015 PSN 7530-02-000-9047 See Reverse for Instructions
State of North Carolina i Environmental Quality I Water Resources
610 East Center Avenue, Suite 301, Mooresville, NC 28115
704-663-1699
•
02T .0403 PERMITTING BY REGULATION /2
A(215A•NCAC
I h �( . C�n $
Tracking #: WQCSDO v ..5.-a%
Date: - 3/4 y
6Permittee:
POC:
.POC Phone: 70 4i3 3 �f ?-
111
(a) Collection systems having an actual, permitted or
Division approved average daily flow less than 200,000
gallons per day are deemed permitted pursuant to Rule .0113
of this Subchapter provided the system meets the criteria in
Rule .0113 of this Subchapter and all specific criteria
required in this Rule:
YES
NO
'
REMARKS
•
(1) The sewer system is effectively maintained and operated
at all times to prevent discharge to land or surface waters,
and to prevent any contravention of groundwater standards
or surface water standards.
Y
N 5� ,� " 2 ��
(2) A map of the sewer system has been developed and is
actively maintained:
.
(3) An operation and maintenance plan including pump
station inspection frequency, preventative maintenance
schedule, spare parts inventory and overflow response has
been developed and implemented.
(4) Pump stations that are not connected to a telemetry
system (i.e., remote alarm system) are inspected by the
permittee or its representative every day (Le., 365 days per
year). Pump stations that are connected to a telemetry
system are inspected at least once per week.
f ��
3. p�� y
(5) High -priority sewers are inspected by the permittee or its
representative at least once every six-months.and
inspections are documented.
0////4---
�w
(6) A general observation by the permittee or its
representative of the entire sewer system is conducted at
least once per year.
-7/.-Ai f ems. y �/ g •
S
knot' /2� .
(7) Overflows and bypasses are reported tu•the appropriate
Division regional office in accordance with 15A NCAC 026
.0506(a), and public notice is provided as required by G.S.
143-215.1 C. .
. A/ �Y� S� �. 0/
(8) A Grease Control Program is in place as follows:
/ V !
if ,,,,'h. sf c ti'„i {o of j,^^��'
(A) For publicly owned collection systems, the Grease
Control Program shall include at least bi-annual distribution of
educational materials for both commercial and residential
users and the legal means to require grease interceptors for
new construction and retrofit, if necessary, of grease
interceptors at existing establishments. The plan shall also
include legal means for inspections of the grease
interceptors, enforcement for violators and the legal means to
control grease entering the system from other public and
private satellite sewer systems. .
4-
/ / /1-
- -
.
.
(B) For privately owned collection systems, the Grease
Control Program shall include at least bi-annual distribution of
grease education materials to users of the collection system
by the permittee or its representative.
y
S �t L
0 0.51, i s n r t n S t ie
*Li r , 2 d .
5
(C) Grease education materials shall be. distributed more
often than required in Parts (A) and (B) of this Subparagraph
if necessary to prevent grease -related sanitary sewer
overflows. .
.
// �D . .S r�ES /S1
///
J
(9) Right-of-ways and easements are maintained in the full
easement width for personnel and equipment accessibility.
/'o 00 / £/W Y i S 7,e
, •
r 661 fir ,, 4�
�S
Li
(10) Documentation shall be kept for Subparagraphs (a)(1)
through (a)(9) of this Rule for a minimum of three years with
,, exception of the map, which shall be maintained for the life of
•
\ Pump Station Inspection Checklist
/0
Name:
Address:
# Pumps - Z
1
2
Working - 2-
1
2
Ca M1x (-7/6,
Zoo ,$a-X0ny Dr•
Me- 11.1vVlc-
Run Time -
YES
NO
Weather: .
Signage:
i%�
'
Housekeeping:
�.
-J
Secure:
e
Wet Well Floats:
Debris:
./
Working High Water Float:
/
Telemetry: / y M c ro /..4 , Z;) ;r/ /c4.,� / C • »/ .
,4.44.4(
SCADA:
AudioNisual:
/! %'., •'
Is alarm system tested, How often: %Nee-r/
✓
/
Inspection Logs: -
,,//
Emergency Power: !v 1-
Type: Portable Onsite Fuel - ScheduleNender -
Ouick Connect:
Testing Schedule:
Backflow: A /! ' )
Pi in / , j / •// '
Overflow g�
p
7 i
Bypass Pumping: / (
Inspection Schedule:
Comments/ Observations:
�tr MpS
Pump Station Inspection Checklist
Name:
Address:
# Pumps -
16,
Working _
\✓
2 •
Q/S
o S Lc..pC ny
. 0 s,--,1,,-(oil)
RunTime-
YES
NO
Weather: .
Signage:
• Housekeeping:
Secure:
Wet Well Floats:
c/
Debris:
Working High Water Float:
Telemetry: -
SCADA: •
NM-
Audio/Visual:
Is alarm system tested, How often: ---. `7� '
7/
Inspection Logs:
Emergency Power:
Type: Portable Onsite Fuel - ScheduleNendef -
Ouick Connect: -
.
Testing Schedule: •
/''.
Backflow:
Overflow Piping:
i
Bypass Pumping: .
Inspection Schedule:
Comments/ Observations:
movk 2e,v/ &pi,/
•
Pump Station Inspection Checklist
Name:
Address:
# Pumps -
1
67-
Working -
1
P.
I () °r-
5c-'- C))'"/
Run Time -
YES
NO
Weather: .
Signage: ll(
. Housekeeping:
Secure:•
Wet Well Floats:
..------
Debris:
Working High Water Float
Telemetry: - •
SCADA:•
AudioNisual:
Is alarm system tested, How often: .Pi/GI �✓
Inspection Logs:
Emergency Power: • /
Type: Portable Onsite Fuel - Schedul- ender -
Ouick Connect:
•
Testing Schedule: \
,
Backflow:
Overflow Piping: (
, i
Bypass Pumping:
Inspection Schedule:
Comments/ Observations:
pipt-A-o- /4:r
45.1.c
;-0 e/5-
//
r
fry
Collection System SSO 24-HcarNblificaiio rT .
C___V/ Q c_5D 056 f
Collection System: Number and Name.WQOS#11G0 ®d S/
Incident Number from BIMS 20160 c) ? .7
Incident Reviewed (Date):
Incident Action Taken: BPJ
NOV-2016-DV
DV-2016-
Spill Date -34 ,6 Time 'S',)° am/
Reported Date
Time r0 2 re pm
Reported To RO WQ Staff or EM Staff JI- 0 /,-,--
dam` p,,,,, Phone 79 2, Ao_c13L('
Reported By'
Address of Spill r O O--5`A.K0 nay py- r
County a—ct5 vl City A4,/lcp , ✓-, 11,-
Cause of Spill NI -e-6114111 ,c-u ).0— 1 �j 1 r ► c— ct / —LT., ;1. ,
Total Estimate Gallons 2-t O 0 . Est. Gal to Stream ,2 00 0
Stream . G h Fo `" k- Stream Classification
Fish Kill: Yes Number Species
Non Required Initial Information and other comments relating to SSO incident:
Response time minutes Zone Manhole #
Duration of SSO
� (I 11 - -- 5�; ,ti c✓
d ;
.5 y — D c7 ( ji
YaS
North Carolina Department of Environmental Quality
Division of Water Resources w Q C 5 0 056 I
2-0I600??1-1-
WWTP Upset , Spill, or Bypass 5-Day Reporting Form
(Please Print or Type Use Attachments if Needed)
Permittee: _Pharr Yarns, LLC Permit Number: NC0004812_
Facility Name: _Pharr Yarns Collection System County: _Gaston
Incident Started: Date: 3/29/16
Incident Ended: Date: 3/29/16
Level of Treatment:
Time: 1700
Time: 1800
_X_None Primary Treatment Secondary Treatment Chlorination/Disinfection/Only
-'\`aood) KI! •.f ccL0 �n ti/c<•K�
Estimated Volume of Spill/Bypass: _20cPgals. (must be given even if it is a rou'i estimate)
Did the Spill/Bypass reach the Surface Waters? _X_Yes No
If yes, please list the following:
Volume Reaching Surface Waters: _500 gals._ Surface Water Name: U.N. Tributary of S. Fork_
Did the Spill/Bypass result in a Fish Kill? Yes _X_No
Was WWTP compliant with permit requirements? X Yes No
Were samples taken during event? Yes _X No
Source of the Upset/Spill/Bypass (Location or Treatment Unit):
Pump Station at 100 Saxony Dr. McAdenvill.
Cause or Reason for the Upset/Spill/Bypass:
Electrical Malfunction and pump blockage.
Describe the Repairs Made or Actions Taken:
Electrical repaired, pump unstopped.
Spill/Bypass Reporting Form (August 1997)
WWTP Upset , Spill, or Bypass 5-Day Reporting Form
Page 2
Action Taken to Contain Spill, Clean Up and Remediate the Site (if applicable):
All contaminated dirt was removed and place on plastic for disposal at landfill.
Site was limed and covered in straw to prevent erosion.
Action Taken or Proposed to be Taken to Prevent Occurrences:
Plans are being made to upgrade electrical systems.
Additional Comments About the Event:
Pictures are provided.
24-Hour Report Made To: Division of Water Resources _X Emergency Management
Contact Name: Barry Love
Date: 5/30/16 Time: 0802
Other Agencies Notified (Health Dept, etc):
Person Reporting Event: _James Davis Phone Number: _704-813-9342
Did DWR Request an Additional Written Report? _Yes _X_No
If Yes, What Additional Information is Needed:
Spill/Bypass Reporting Form (August 1997)
Love, Barry F
From: James Davis <jldavis012@gmail.com>
Sent: Monday, April 04, 2016 11:35 AM
To: Love, Barry F
Subject: Pharr Yarns Sewer spill
Attachments: HP Spill Response 4-4-16.doc; Sewer Spill HP.JPG; Sewer Spill HP.JPG 2.JPG; Sewer Spill
HP.JPG 2.JPG 3.JPG; Sewer Spill HP.JPG 4.JPG
Barry, enclosed is the sewer response form and pictures of the
incident we had on 3/29/16. If anymore information is need please
feel free to call me at 704-813-9342 or jldavis012@gmail.com
Jamey
i
State of North Carolina
Department of Environment and Natural Resources
Division of Water Resources
Collection System Sanitary Sewer Overflow Reporting Form
Division of Water Resources Form CS-SSO
PART I:
This form shall be submitted to the appropriate DWR Regional Office within five business days of the first knowledge of the
sanitary sewer overflow (SSO).
Permit Number: NC0004812 (WQCS# if active, otherwise use WQCSD#)
Facility: Pharr Yarns, LLC
Region:
Incident #: 1 Owner: Pharr Yarns
City: McAdenville County: Gaston
Source of SSO (check applicable): ❑ Sanitary Sewer ® Pump Station / Lift Station
SPECIFIC location of the SSO (be consistent in description from past reports or documentation - i.e. Pump
Station 6, Manhole at Westall & Bragg Street, etc.): 100 Saxony Dr.
Manhole #:
Latitude (degrees/minute/second): Longitude (degrees/minute/second):
Incident Started Dt: 3/29/16 Time: 5:O0pm Incident End Dt: 3/29/16 Time: 6:00pm
(mm-dd-yyyy) (hh:mm) AM/PM (mm-dd-yyyy) (hh:mm) AM/PM
Estimated volume of the SSO: 2000 gallons Estimated Duration (round to nearest hour): 1 hour(s)
Describe how the volume was determined: Missing flow from avg. at WWTP
Weather conditions during the SSO event: Clear
Did the SSO reach surface waters? ® Yes ❑ No ❑ Unknown
Volume reaching surface waters: 500 gallons Surface water name: U,N. Tributary of South Fork
Did the SSO result in a fish kill? ❑ Yes ® No El Unknown
If Yes, what is the estimated number of fish killed?
SPECIFIC cause(s) of the SSO:
[]Severe Natural Conditions ❑ Grease ❑Roots ❑Inflow & Infiltration
ZPump Station Equipment Failure ❑ Power Outage ['Vandalism El Debris in line ❑Pipe Failure (Break)
❑Other (Please explain in Part II)
24-hour verbal notification (name of person contacted): Barry Love
®DWR • DEmergency Management Date (mm-dd-yyy): 3/30/16 Time: (hh:mm AM/PM): 8:02am
Per G.S. 143-215.1 C(b), the owner or operator of any wastewater collection system shall:
In the event of a discharge of 1,000 gallons or more of untreated wastewater to the surface waters of the State, issue
a press release to all print and electronic news media that provide general coverage in the county where the
discharge occurred setting out the details of the discharge. The press release shall be issued within 24 hours after
the owner or operator has determined that the discharge has reached surface waters of the State.
In the event of a discharge of 15,000 gallons or more of untreated wastewater to the surface waters of the State,
publish a notice of the discharge in a newspaper having general circulation in the county in which the discharge
occurs and in each county downstream from the point of discharge that is significantly affected by the discharge. The
Regional Office shall determine which counties are significantly affected by the discharge and shall approve the form
and content of the notice and the newspapers in which the notice is published.
WHETHER OF NOT PART II IS COMPLETED, A SIGNATURE IS REQUIRED SEf PAGE 13
Form CS-SSO Page 1
Pump Station Equipment Failure (Documentation of testing records, etc should be provided upon request)
What kind of notification/alarm systems are present?
Auto-dialer/telemetry (one-way communication) ® Yes
Audible ❑ Yes
Visual ❑ Yes
SCADA (two-way communication) ❑ Yes
Emergency Contact Signage ® Yes
Other ❑ Yes
If Yes, explain:
Describe the equipment that failed: Electrical Component Failure
What kind of situations trigger an alarm condition at this station (i.e. pump failure, power failure, high water, etc.)?
Were notification/alarm systems operable? ® Yes ❑ No DNA ❑ NE
In no, explain:
If a pump failed, when was the last maintenance and/or inspection performed? 3/29/16
What specifically was checked/maintained? Pumps Run
If a valve failed, when was it last exercised?
Were all pumps set to alternate? ❑ Yes ® No DNA ❑ NE
Did any pump show above normal run times prior to and during the SSO event? ❑ Yes ® No DNA 0 NE
Were adequate spare parts on hand to fix the equipment
® Yes ❑ No ❑NA ❑ NE
Was a spare or portable pump immediately available? ❑ Yes ® No DNA ❑ NE
If a float problem, when were the floats last tested? How?
If an auto -dialer or SCADA, when was the system last tested? How?
Comments:
Form CS-SSO Page 7
Other (Pictures and police report, as applicable, must be available upon request.)
Describe:
Were adequate equipment and resources available to fix the problem? ® Yes ❑ No ❑NA ❑ NE
If Yes, explain: Personnel can be pulled from serperate locations if needed. Spare electrical parts can be attained from
different Pharr facilities.
If the problem could not be immediately repaired, what actions ❑ Yes ❑ No DNA ❑ NE
were taken to lessen the impact of the SSO?
Comments:
Form CS-SSO Page 11
System Visitation
ORC
Backup
Name: James Davis
Certification Number: 15248
Date visited: 3/29/16
Time visited:
How was the SSO remediated (i./e. Stopped and cleaned up)?
® Yes
® Yes
I Pump was run manually until electrical could be fixed. Spill coverede soil was removed, placed onto plastic and covered.
This will be disposed in the landfill.
As a representative for the responsible party, I certify that the information contained in this report is true and accurate to the
best of my knowledge.
Person submitting cl
Signature:
James L. Davis Date: 4/5/16
Telephone Number: 704-813-9342
Title:
Any additional information desired to be submitted should be sent to the appropriate Division Regional Office within five
business days of first knowledge of the SSO with reference to the incident number (the incident number is only generated
when electronic entry of this form is completed, if used).
Form CS-SSO Page 13
PRESS RELEASE
ATTN: NEWS DESK
WASTEWATER SPILL IN GASTON COUNTY
This news release was issued on 4/4/16 in compliance with North Carolina
General Statute 143-215.1 C (a portion of the Clean Water Act of 1999). For
further information, contact Christy Gliddon, at 704/823-2333.
Pharr Yarns, LLC has cleaned up a sewer spill/overflow, which occurred [March
29, 2016 at approximately 5:00p.m. at 100 Saxony Dr. McAdenville N.C. due to
an electrical malfunction. The electrical components were fixed to prevent further
discharge.
Approximately 2000 gallons were discharged, with about 500 gallons entering an
unnamed tributary (in the form of a storm ditch) of the South Fork River of the
Catawba River Basin. No discharge reached the river. This spill has been
cleaned up and reported to the N.C. Division of Water Resources.
Pr
S"riti
NCDENR
North Carolina Department of Environment and Natural Resources L,S
Division of Water Quality
Beverly Eaves Perdue Coleen H. Sullins Dee Freeman
Governor Director Secretary
August 23, 2011
Mr. George Altice, Director of Corporate Engineering
Pharr Yarns, LLC
Post Office Box 1939
McAdenville, North Carolina 28101
Subject: Notice of Violation
Tracking No. NOV-2011-DV-0211
Collection System Permit
Number WQCSD0561
Pharr Yarns, LLC
Gaston County
Dear Mr. Altice:
FILE,
A review has been conducted of the Pharr Yarns self reported Sanitary Sewer Overflows
(SSOs) 5-Day Report(s) for July 2011. This review has shown Pharr Yarns to be in violation of
the requirements found in Collection System Permit WQCSD0561 and/or G.S. 143-215.1(a)(1).
The violations that occurred during July 2011 are summarized in Attachment A.
Remedial and corrective actions, if not already implemented, should be taken to prevent
further SSOs. As of December 1, 2007, any reportable SSO may be issued a Notice of Violation
(NOV) and some may be assessed a civil penalty. Civil penalties will be issued for SSOs based
on volume, volume reaching surface waters, duration and gravity, impacts to public health, fish
kills, and recreational area closures. Other factors considered in determining the amount of the
civil penalty are the violator's history of spills, the cost of rectifying the damage, whether the
spill was intentional, and whether money was saved by non-compliance.
Mooresville Regional Office
Location: 610 East Center Ave., Suite 301 Mooresville, NC 28115
Phone: (704) 663-1699 \ Fax: (704) 663-6040 \ Customer Service: 1-877-623-6748
Internet: www.ncwaterquality.org
An Equal Opportunity \ Affirmative Action Employer — 50% Recycled/10% Post Consumer paper
NorthCarolina
Naturally
Mr. George Altice
PTO\-201;1-4V-0211
Paget
tz
Be advised that G.S. 143-215.6A provides for a civil penalty assessment of not more than
twenty-five thousand dollars ($25,000), or twenty-five thousand dollars ($25,000) per day when the
violation is of a continuing nature, against any person who is required but fails to apply for or to
secure a permit required by G.S. 143-215.1. Penalties may also be assessed for any damage to the
surface waters of the State that may result from the unpermitted discharge.
The SSOs noted in Attachment A under violation action as "Proceed to Enforcement" are
the overflows that the regional office has determined, after review of the CS-SSO 5-day report,
that may result in a civil penalty assessment. You have 20 days from receiving this Notice of
Violation letter to provide any additional justification for the identified SSOs as to why
these spills do not meet the criteria listed in this letter for civil penalty assessment.
If you have any questions regarding this policy please do not hesitate to contact Mr. Lon
Snider 704-663-1699.
Sincerely,
Robert B. Krebs
Surface Water Protection Section Supervisor
Division of Water Quality
Mooresville Regional Office
Attachment — A
Deemed Permitted Rules & Regulations
Cc: PERCS Files
Attachment A
Pharr Yarns Collection System
July 2011
24 Hour 5 Day Vol.
Permit # Location Incident # Start Date Gallons Reaching Surface NOV Case Violation Action
Water
WQCSD0561 200 Saxony Drive 201101507 07/27/11 6000 0
NOV-2011-DV-0211
Cause: Pump Station
Equipment Failure
Proceed to NOV Yes