Loading...
HomeMy WebLinkAbout20110896 Ver 1_More Info Received_20120322Strickland, Bev From: Mcmillan, Ian Sent: Thursday, March 22, 2012 9:06 AM To: Strickland, Bev; Dennison, Laurie Subject: FW: Orton 2 Attachments: Orton - Project Purpose Supplement.pdf �] � i t [ �7 ► G� �i Q � F � I� E -mail correspondence to and from this address may be subject to the North Carolina Public Records Lai and may he disclosed to third parties. From: Steve Morrison [mailto:smorrison(a)lm roup.net] Sent: Monday, March 19, 2012 5:21 PM To: Frye, Jennifer S SAW Subject: FW: Orton 2 Jennifer, 2nd of three emails for revised Orton Materials. Thanks. Steve From: Jenny Johnson Sent: Wednesday, March 14, 2012 3:08 PM To: Steve Morrison Subject: Orton 2 Jenny Johnson I Environmental Scientist Direct: 452- 0011 x 1937" 1 Fax: 91 {x.452.{ 060 Email: Ilohnson(@Irngroup.net Land Management Group, Inc I En ironnie real C0r)sr11tZMtS P.O. Box 2522 1 VVilmingto r. IBC 28402 1 www.lmgroup.net Project Purpose Supplement Orton Plantation Historic Rice Field Protection and Restoration Project As stated in the original permit application, the purpose of the proposed project is "to protect and restore the various elements of the historic rice field system at Orton Plantation ". The Applicant's preferred alternative, as presented in the Public Notice, has been selected subsequent to careful consideration of a range of alternatives as detailed in the project Alternatives Analysis and is believed to be the least environmentally damaging, practicable alternative (LEDPA) that satisfies the stated purpose. The purpose of the project is not the commercial production of rice. Rather, the above - stated purpose involves the reestablishment of historic rice cultivation and revitalization of this historic resource as a defining landscape element of the Plantation. In doing so, agricultural practices related to rice cultivation will be employed within only the five rice fields within the functioning, intact, hydrologic management system. In the fall of 2010, Orton Plantation was purchased by Orton Plantation Holdings LLC. The principal of the parent company of Orton Plantation Holdings LLC is a direct lineal descendant of Roger Moore, the person who succeeded to the original crown grant and established the plantation in 1725. As such, Orton Plantation Holdings LLC has an interest and a purpose to reestablish the plantation for the cultivation of rice consistent with the rehabilitation of the historic plantation buildings, gardens and cemeteries. Rehabilitation of these historic resources is being performed in close coordination with the North Carolina State Historic Preservation Office (SHPO). In addition, the owner recently submitted a formal application and nomination to the National Park Service for consideration of Orton Plantation as a National Historic Landmark (refer to attached correspondence). As the last remaining intact rice system of the 35 documented plantations in operation during the Colonial and Antebellum periods in North Carolina, Orton Plantation is believed to be of both regional and national historical significance. Orton's rice fields have the potential to be a primary source from which researchers can gain understanding about historic rice production and its contribution to the culture and economy of the Cape Fear Region and North Carolina during the Colonial and Antebellum periods. The historic significance of the plantation and rice fields makes the effort to restore the property to rice cultivation one of significant public interest. SHPO concurs in this assessment. Tangible public benefits are anticipated as a result of the proposed project. For instance, the rehabilitation of rice fields and re- establishment of cultivation of heirloom rice varieties can provide unique educational opportunities in a manner similar to the recent longleaf pine restoration workshop held on the Orton property.' The proposed rehabilitation of the rice fields is consistent with the overall conservation effort of the owner, and the revitalization of these areas as an historic and educational resource benefits the public interest. The project purpose calls for rehabilitation and protection of the historic rice fields. The rice fields included in the project represent the surviving remnant of the much larger operation which once flourished at Orton Plantation. These remaining rice fields have been continuously served by a constricted fresh water reserve (Orton Pond) that was initially formed in the 18th century. The overall water management system has been continuously maintained for over 280 years. The fields have been protected by dikes continuously maintained for the same time period. Other rice fields of the Kendall system, north of the subject rice fields within the Orton property (totaling approximately 180 acres of former fields and over 600 acres of dammed freshwater reserve) have reverted to coastal marsh as their protective dikes and the water management system deteriorated to the point of becoming nonfunctional. The system of rice fields for which the project is proposed remains intact and functioning and as such, is the sole remaining viable rice plantation in North Carolina out of the 5,000 plus acres of rice that were grown in the state at the time of the Civil War. (See the attached map of "Plantations on the Lower Cape Fear 1725 to 1760 ".) Agricultural practices related to rice cultivation will be employed within only those areas functioning as a part of the present day, intact, hydrologic management system. The alternative of restoring all the historic rice fields, including the Kendall system, was considered by the applicant. However, this alternative was eliminated from further consideration due to permit feasibility (the prior owners had applied for and been denied permits for similar activity), the extent of disturbance to coastal wetlands that would result from the project, and the cost and effort required to re- establish the water management system. As a result, the applicant does not seek to reestablish fields which have been lost over time due to the destruction of their dikes or water management systems, but only to reestablish rice cultivation on fields that remain intact and have been maintained as managed freshwater areas. The project purpose remains unchanged and is consistent with the overall historic Plantation restoration currently underway. The attached correspondence and supporting information submitted to the National Park Service provides more detailed information regarding the historical significance of Orton Plantation including the surrounding rice fields which represent the last remaining intact system in North Carolina. Rehabilitation of this system is an integral component of the historic restoration efforts being undertaken by Orton Plantation Holdings, LLC and represents a unique opportunity to maintain and protect a regionally significant resource. I Over 50 people (iricludirtg members of the C Coastal Larid Trust, the l -C ii'ildli fe Resources ColnInissiol, the V'S Fish acid TFildlye Service, acid the Cape Fear River match) attended this workshop. Belvedere Property Martagement LLC Peter J Taltv Vice Pre.vident March 1, 2012 Alexandra M. Lord, PhD Branch Chief National Historic Landmarks Program National Park Service 1201 Eye Street, NW Washington, DC 20240 Re: Orton Plantation, Winnabow, North Carolina Dear Ms Lord: Further to our various communications and on behalf of the new owner of Orton Plantation, I am now pleased to summit a formal inquiry request for potential listing of Orton Plantation as a National Historic Landmark. Built in 1735 by Roger Moore, co- founder of the adjacent historic Brunswick Town, the original Orton Plantation house is one of the oldest structures in Brunswick County and has evolved into what is now considered to be a near-perfect example of Southern antebellum architecture. In 1773, Moore created the first and largest rice plantation on the Lower Cape Fear River, and as one of 35 inter-coastal plantations, Orton is now the last remaining intact rice system in North Carolina. In 1973, the Orton Plantation house and 12 acres of gardens were nominated on the National Register of Historic Places (a copy of the original nomination is included with this inquiry). Orton Plantation Holdings, LLC, purchased the property in 2010. Louis Moore Bacon, a direct descendant of Roger Moore, is the owner of Orton Plantation Holdings, LLC, and it has become his mantra to rehabilitate and where possible restore the property to a semblance of its antebellum grandeur. During its history, Orton Plantation has been attacked by Native Americans, used as a military hospital, and was a home to lawyers, physicians, military leaders, and a Colonial governor. As part of this process of rehabilitation and restoration, an application has recently been submitted to North Carolina State Historic Preservation Office to extend the existing nomination to include Orton's historic rice fields. A copy of this application is also included together with supporting infon-nation. 1251 Avenue of the Americas, 17 "' Floor New York, NY 10020 Rehabilitation work is almost complete on the original Orton Plantation house and gardens, and the proposed rehabilitation and restoration of the rice fields are currently pending subject to permit approval by the U.S. Army Corps of Engineers. A Cultural Landscape Report is being compiled to establish Orton's historic context within a wider landscape and highlight Orton's cultural importance in the development of the Lower Cape Fear Region. From its settlement in 1725, the region became the most prosperous in North Carolina by 1775. At this time, no other region developed as rapidly as Lower Cape Fear and the Moore's proved to be pivotal in shaping the regions political and economic importance within North Carolina. The rice grown and produced at Orton was of a high quality, fine grain, which was highly prized and sought after as seed rice by the larger South Carolina plantations. The annual production of seed rice was critical in order to maintain the vast economies and rapid growth of rice plantations in the southern states. Orton and other Lower Cape Fear plantations were a key factor in maintaining the development and success of the Southern based rice economy. Orton's rice fields have the potential to be a primary source from which researchers can gain understanding about Colonial and Antebellum periods of North Carolina and the Cape Fear Region. The above is but a brief overview of Orton Plantation's complex social and cultural historic importance. A more detailed history is included with the attached National Register nomination and application. On behalf of the owner, I would hope that in recognition of Orton Plantation's historic importance, much of which we are still uncovering, Orton Plantation house, gardens and the surrounding rice fields would qualify for nomination as a Historic National Landmark. STATE HISTORIC PRESERVATION OFFICE NORTH CAROLINA DEPARTMENT OF CULTURAL RESOURCES OFFICE OF ARCHIVES AND HISTORY SURVEY AND PLANNING BRANCH STUDY LIST APPLICATION Please type or print 1. HISTORIC PROPERTY NAME: Orton Plantation Rice Fields (adjacent and part of National Register Nominated, Orton Plantation House & Gardens — 12 acres) Other names n/a (if historic name is not known, use current name or address) 2. LOCATION (give street address in urban areas; give both street address and physical location in rural areas, for example, N side of SR 1234, 0.5 mi. S of SR 1965, [1123 Jones Farm Road]) Street /Secondary Road (SR) /Highway Junction of S.R1530 and S.R. 1529. 0.8 mile drive on private road Town or vicinity: Smithville Township County: Brunswick County 3, GENERAL INFORMATION A. Is this an individual property or a historic district ?: Individual Property (If this is a district, please consult with the National Register Coordinator at the State Historic Preservation Office for guidance in completing this application.) B. ', Property use and construction date(s): Individual Properties Primary building /resource: provide historic and current use, original construction date, and if appropriate, dates of additions. If exact date is unknown, give approximate date. As an integral part of Orton Plantation the rice fields where constructed between 1726 and the late 1750's by Roger Moore. The rice fields remain intact in their original layout and configuration. Historic earthen dikes, facing ditches and quarter drains are fully evident, together with associated and functioning canal, ditch and trunk gate flood system. Upon his death in 1750 Roger Moore left his Orton & neighboring Kendal Plantations with 250 slaves. Brunswick 1850 census shows Orton having a profitable. Sawmill, Corn mill and Rice Threshing machine producing 15000 bushels of rough rice (annual production of 325,000 pounds of Rice) together with 77 slaves. Ri';WlQrLor SII110 /8iC< Field Arum. 21')9,- 012 Rice production expanded and flourished until end of the Civil War. Brunswick 1860 census lists Orton as having 144 slaves in 40 houses. A public auction of Orton in 1872 advertised 9,026 acres with 300 acres of superior rice land of which 225 acres produced 16,300 bushels of rice with houses detached for 200 hands. 'Orton Plantation is the last remaining, fully intact, rice field system in North Carolina and last remaining plantation on the Cape Fear River of 60 plus plantations which provided high quality and highly prized seed rice to the larger southern plantations. Reference materials suggest that rice was last commercially produced` at Orton during the early 1930's. As part of restoration proposals by the current owner the Rice Fields are currently subject to a USACE permit review process: Subsidiary buildings (if present): provide same as above for each building Slave quarters, water powered mill, ancillary structures and lighthouse are evident from plans and brick remains on site and are currently being researched to establish extent and purpose. Historic Districts: provide historic and current use, and give range of dates for the entire district, not for individual buildings Orton Plantation` is adjacent to Old Brunswick Historic District, Orton being built by one of the founding settlers of Brunswick Town C. Approximate acreage: Approximately 465 acres (Includes Rice Fields at 320 acres and existing Nat. Reg. House and Gardens Nomination at 12 acres) D. Have any buildings on the property been moved? Yes ❑ No V (If yes, explain the reason for the move, and provide further details and the date of the move. Use an additional sheet if necessary.) E. Architect and /or builder (if known): 4. APPLICANT OR CONTACT PERSON INFORMATION (If other than owner) Name: Orton Plantation Holdings LLC 9149 Orton Road SE Winnabow, NC 28479 Attn: Mr Peter Talty Address 17th Floor, 1251 Avenue of Americas City /State: New York, NY Zip Code 10020 Daytime Tel.: 212 782 7078 E -mail address: peter.taIty @bIlc.com Signature Date ' ` 'TI I ffPll,'Ortc�rr 4HPf)Rr t f rcld lrrrn�,? '9/?l)1 5. This application is submitted [check one of the following]: V by the owner ❑ with the owner's knowledge but not at his or her request ❑ at the request of the owner ❑ without the owner's knowledge I 6. REASON FOR REQUEST (Please be brief. Use a separate sheet of paper if you desire to provide a longer response) In 2025 Orton Plantation rice fields will be 300 years old. The principal shareholder of the owner's parent company is a direct lineal descendant of Roger Moore, the founder of the plantation and therefore has a keen interest in its history. Moore created the first and largest rice plantation on the Lower Cape Fear and as one of 35 inter coastal plantations, Orton is now the last remaining intact rice system in North Carolina. The principal of Orton Plantation Holdings LLC`wishes to ensure that the Plantation, House 'Gardens, Rice fields are understood and preserved as a legacy of an important facet of North Carolina history. 7. Does the owner plan to seek rehabilitation tax credits? Yes ❑ ; No ; V If "yes" checked, answer question 12. Is the property income - producing ❑ or nonincome producing ❑? 8. Has the property ever been surveyed by the State Historic Preservation Office or by a locally- sponsored historic preservation project? If yes, please give the name and date of the survey project, if known: The Rice Fields have been surveyed' and researched as part of current Restoration/ Rehabilitation Permit proposals and a shore line archaeology survey will be conducted during Spring 2012. No other surveys have been carried out at this time.- 9. LEGAL OWNER OF PROPERTY (For individual property only; give mayor's name /address for districts) Orton Plantation Holdings LLC 10. SUPPORTING INFORMATION Please attach all of the requested supporting information. Incomplete applications cannot be considered. All materials' submitted become the property of the State Historic Preservation Office and cannot be returned.' A. Description (Include as an attachment on a'separate sheet of paper) 1), For individual properties, briefly describe the original and current appearance of the building(s), both exterior and interior. Include information on any historic features that have been, or will be removed or altered, and describe all current and proposed additions. 2) Briefly describe the setting for both individual properties and historic districts. For example, ' is it in a' commercial area, residential neighborhood, or a rural landscape? B. History (Include as an attachment on a separate sheet of paper) Briefly outline the history of the property and give a short explanation of why the property or district is historically or architecturally important. Be sure to include information on any significant local, statewide, or national historical events associated with the property, historical Y,f'!ll,'Oi-torr /.SITYO,'Rice Fall Vorn,. 229,'?Q1Z individuals related to it, and /or any historical trends with which it is associated. A detailed essay is not necessary, however, the information should clearly explain why the property meets the National Register criteria. Please refer to the enclosed National Register Fact Sheet 2 for information on the evaluation criteria. C. Map /Site Plan (Include as an attachment on a separate sheet of paper) Provide a street or road map with the location of the property marked on it. A hand -drawn sketch' map with the street and /or route numbers and a north arrow is acceptable for properties located in unmapped city or county jurisdictions. If there are several buildings on property (such as a farmstead, school campus, or industrial complex), please provide a sketch site plan showing the location of all of the buildings. D. Photographs Photographs may be digital images submitted on `a CD (preferred) or color prints or color slides. If you submit digital photographs, please include proofs of the images on paper. To save paper and ink, as many as nine images may be placed on a single 8 x 10 sheet of paper, though images should be at least 31/4 " x 21/2 Black and white proofs on plain paper are acceptable. You do not need to use expensive inks or papers for proofs. Proofs provide a quick reference for the property file to show us what is on the CD. Please use a CD -R and not a CD -RW to burn your photographs. CD -RW disks often will not read in computers other than the one in which they were created. We cannot accept photographs as attachments to email except when only two or three are being submitted to supplement an application for which most photos have been already submitted on a' CD. Call or email us before sending photos as attachments. We prefer digital images in jpeg format of no more than 500 Kb per image. However, if you do not have an image editor to manipulate image size or format, we will accept the images as they are created by your camera. If you submit prints, or slides, HPO staff will scan them at no cost to you. Study List applications are presented to the North Carolina National Register Advisory Committee (NRAC) in a PowerPoint presentation assembled by staff. We prefer that you not submit your photographs in your own PowerPoint presentation. If your application is for a large district or an unusually complex property, we may consider using a PowerPoint presentation that you have assembled, though we reserve the right to edit the presentation to meet the needs of the NRAC and to be of acceptable length, for the agenda. For individual properties, please provide a set of photographs showing all sides of the building(s), representative interior views; outbuildings (if any) and views of the setting. Prints, slides, CDs, and proofs of digital photos should be labeled with the name of the property, location, county, view, and date. If 'a site plan is included in the application (see C above), please key the views to the plan. 11. ADDITIONAL INFORMATION REQUIRED FOR HISTORIC DISTRICTS Note: Before completing a Study List application fora historic district, please contact the National Register Coordinator at the State Historic Preservation Office (HPO). HPO staff usually` make a site visit before evaluating a Study List application for a district. T.,V'0r tw?, SHPUmmRic Field \ fml , 2 '9 '012 A. Map The map should show the proposed historic district with the tentative boundaries clearly delineated. Proposed boundaries are usually defined during the HPO staff site visit. B. Photographs (See item 10 -D for information about formats for photographs) Photographs should illustrate the character of the proposed historic district with exterior views of significant buildings, a selection of typical buildings, distinctive landscape features, and a few representative views of streetscapes. Please key the photographs to the district map. 12. ADDITIONAL INFORMATION REQUIRED FOR PROPERTIES WITH PLANNED REHABILITATION TAX CREDIT PROJECTS Provide specific' information about the building's period of significance and additions and alterations that have acquired historic significance in their own right. If exterior alterations,' new additions or adjacent or related new construction are planned, describe how they impact the significant historic features of the building or its setting. Also, please contact the Restoration Branch at 919- 807 -6590, if you have not done so already. Please remember' that the HPO staff is available to assist you with general information about the required supporting items for the Study List application. If you are unsure about any of the requirements, please contact the HPO: Return to: Ann V. Swallow HPO website: www.h o.ncdcr. ov_ National Register Coordinator APPLICATION CHECKLIST Survey and Planning Branch, HPO Do you have the following items in your 4617 Mail Service Center application packet? Raleigh, NC 27699 -4617 0 Completed two -page form (questions 1 -9) E] Physical description (question l0A) O ace Location: Archives /State Library 0 History /Significance (question 1013) Building F Historic district map (for district only) 109 East Jones Street E] Map marked with property location Raleigh, NC 27601 F' Site plan (multiple buildings /resources only) E Rehabilitation information (question 12) Telephone: 919/807 -6587 Photographs or CD and image proofs — Fax: 919/807 -6599 labeled E -mail. ann.swallow(?ncdcr.gov -„ P,P;1,G'Ortoir %SHPo i'Ricct i ld Norm.. 2129 ,:?012 ORTON PLANTATION HISTORIC RICE FILEDS - STUDY LIST APPLICATION (Section 10) SUPPORTING INFORMATION A Description Orton Rice fields remain intact (see attached Rice Field layout and configuration). This diagram shows the rice fields in relation to Orton plantation house and gardens together with an overlay of the historic canals, facing ditches and quarter drains. The current owner has an enforceable agreement with respect to the withdrawal of water form the historic 8 mile long Orton Pond, which was built to supply Orton's rice fields and water powered mills, constructed circa 1725 by the damming of Orton Creek. The original rice field dike system is fully intact, notwithstanding occasional breaches which have always been promptly repaired, or are part of 'a current restoration proposal within a USACE permit application review process. The demise of other historic Cape Fear Plantations due to hurricanes and economic downturns has resulted in Orton being the last remaining functioning rice plantation. The 'Front' rice fields are dominated by invasive Phragmites with the 'Back' rice fields being colonized by volunteer shrub/scrub wetland species. Aerial images reveal a complex network of intact historic facing ditches, quarter ditches and dikes which are in need of rehabilitation. Historic trunk gates and water control valves have been replaced and renewed over time and the rice fields can still be flooded as originally intended. 19th & 20th century repairs are evident to both Trunk Gates and the dike revetments facing the Cape Fear River. Orton Plantation rice fields together with Orton pond have a significant geomorphology which has dominated the surrounding landscape for nearly 300 years. Historic plans and images show that what was once a barren landscape stripped of its timber for ship building and construction has over time been softened by regeneration of wetland fringes by Cypress trees together with human intervention by the planting of what are now majestic Live Oak avenues 88, 'Orlon'SUPO/Rice Pic Id Nom. 2,29,2012 ORTON PLANTATION HISTORIC RICE FILEDS - STUDY LIST APPLICATION (Section 10) SUPPORTING INFORMATION B. History Between 1700 and 1775 no colony in British America experienced more impressive growth than North Carolina, and no region within the colony developed as rapidly as the Lower Cape Fear. Totally uninhabited by Europeans in 1700, this isolated corner of North Carolina's southern coast is particularly noteworthy for its relatively late colonization and its rapid rise to economic prominence. First settled in 1725, the region grew to be the most prosperous in North Carolina by 1775. The study of the eighteenth-century settlement of the Lower Cape Fear is a prime example for understanding North Carolina and the entirety of colonial America as a patchwork of regional cultures (Bradford, J Wood, 2004). One family, the Moore's, proved to be pivotal in the development of the Lower Cape Fear. During early 1700's they shaped the regions political and economic importance within North Carolina. The Moore's provide an instructive if exceptional example. As the most powerful family in the region, they articulated an elite model of behavior many other families no doubt emulated. The Moore's like many other settlers clearly developed impressive and complex kinship ties to the Lower Cape Fear. Maurice and Roger Moore were powerful men, coming from one of South Carolina's most prominent families. Maurice's father, James Moore, came to South Carolina from Barbados in the 1670's and served as Governor of South Carolina between 1700 and 1703. These connections insured that two of the 10 siblings, Maurice and Roger, would become wealthy and influential plantation owners. Orton and Kendal plantations were created on lands granted by the Lords Proprietors in 1725 to Maurice Moore, who along with brothers Roger, Nathaniel and a group of settlers founded Brunswick Town (now within Historic Brunswick Town District). Maurice established lands further up river and passed ownership of the land to Roger. Although the Moore's had originally emigrated from Ireland via Barbados, Orton and Kendal were named after the Moore's ancestral homes in the Lake district of North of England. Roger Moore was among the first settlers to build a distinctive plantation system along the Cape Fear River. Some fragmentary business accounts reveal that by 1735 Moore already exported lumber, turpentine and wood shingles from Lower Cape Fear. At this time Moore also traded with connections in both South Carolina and Barbados. These accounts probably provide only a small glimpse of the range of activities on Moore's Orton & Kendall plantations. Fifteen years later, Moore's will revealed that his resources included "Twenty Odd Thousand Acres of Land & Near Two Hundred and Fifty Slaves", making him almost certainly the wealthiest plantation owner in North Carolina. Some time between 1726 and 1730 Roger Moore established a modest house on the 10,000 acre site to be called Orton. The house was burned down by Cree Indians and his next home was established on neighboring land which subsequently became Kendal Plantation. However, by 1735 he had moved his family to a more suitable brick mansion situated on the original Orton house site. Over time and subsequent ownerships the original brick structure was enveloped and extended to create a Greek Revival Antebellum house that is one of the most recognized in North Carolina today. Neld.Alotn, 2'29/2012 Orton Plantation's rice fields as seen today were constructed some time between 1726 and 1750 together with the damming and construction of Orton pond, which was essential as a reserve to supply the rice fields with water. The pond and rice field layout is recorded on many early historic navigation plans of the Cape Fear River. Research is ongoing and current ! thinking suggests that the `back' rice fields contiguous to Orton pond, protected by higher ground and most easily fortified against the brackish Cape Fear River, were developed first as a beta test site to experiment with rice cultivation. Due to their success, a large dike impoundment was built out into <a shallow portion of the Cape Fear River. This was equipped with extensive` irrigation and water control structures to modulate water levels. At the same time sluices drained the fresh water of Orton pond through a series of paddies and canals within the original "Back" rice fields to the 200+ acres of rice fields that provide the magnificent foreground view from the front of the plantation house. Although cultivation of rice and other crops has been intermittent in the last few decades, the original system of water controls, sluices, canals and embankments are largely in place and functional. Orton was the first rice plantation in the Lower Cape Fear Region and one of the largest in North Carolina and because of his vast land holdings, Roger Moore was referred to as `King' Roger. The amount of slave labor that was needed to build the original pond and back rice fields was significant but with commercial success even more slaves were imported to build out and cultivate the massive front rice fields. This horrendous and cruel labor system gave way after the civil war to large agrarian employment and eventually more mechanized cultivation. Upon his death in 1750, Moore left his Orton and Kendal estates and 250 slaves to his sons, half brothers George and William. William died seven years later and passed Orton to wife Mary and son Roger (the younger). Orton was thereafter passed through various ownerships: • Richard Quince:. 1770 -1796. • Benjamin Smith: 1796 -1826, grandson of Roger Moore and Governor of North Carolina (1810 - 11) . 1800, Brunswick census lists 199 slaves • Dr Fredrick Jones Hill 1826 -1854. 1830 Brunswick census lists 55 slaves. 1850 census shows profitable Sawmill, Corn mill and Rice Threshing` Machine producing 15000 bushels of rough rice (annual production of 325,000 pounds of Rice) with 77 slaves • Thomas Calezance Miller: 1854 -1872. Rice plantation flourishes until end of Civil War. 1860 Brunswick census lists 144 slaves in 40 houses. • Isaac B Grainger: 1874 -1876 Currer Richardson Roundell: Feb 1876- July 1876 Co[. Kenneth McKenzie Murchison: 1884 -1909 • Luola Murchison Sprunt and James Sprunt: 1909 -1924 James Laurance Sprunt: '1924 -1973 • James Laurance Sprunt Jr., Laurance Gray Sprunt, Kenneth Murchison: Sprunt, Samuel Nash Sprunt • 1978 -2010 Louis Moore Bacon (descendant of Roger Moore), as principal of parent company to Orton Plantation Holdings LLC. Current rehabilitation of National Register nominated Orton Plantation house and gardens together with the proposed rehabilitation and restoration of the rice fields highlighted the need to connect the plantation house, gardens and rice fields as one historic entity, hence the desire and importance of including the rice fields on the National Register. In order to understand the rice field systems as agricultural features, the fields should be considered in context of the plantation, plantation house, slave villages, kitchens, outbuildings and burial grounds. As cultural landscapes, rice fields consist of interconnected systems of land, water, vegetation and wildlife that differentiate them from other cultural' resources. The rice grown and produced at Orton was of a high quality, fine grain' which' was highly prized and sought after as seed rice by the larger` southern plantations. The annual production of seed rice was critical in order to maintain the vast economies and rapid growth of rice plantations in the southern states. Orton and other Lower Cape Fear plantations were a key factor in the maintaining the development and success of the Southern based rice economy. Orton Rice fields have the potential to be primary sources from which researchers can gain understanding about Colonial and Antebellum periods of North Carolina` and the Cape Fear Region.' Extensive slave labor made the economic development of the Lower Cape Fear possible and the circumstances' surrounding slavery did' as much to differentiate the Lower Cape Fear form other regions as anything else.' Contemporaries acknowledged that there were many more slaves in the region than could be found on inland territories. Although fiercely independent of South Carolina, Governance and Tax: structure, Lower Cape Fear rice plantations, represented the most northerly position of the Carolina Low Country and is known as the upper most limit of the "Deep South ". Orton's' rice fields are the last of the many rice plantation's of North Carolina. They stand as tangible record of the skill and labor exerted by enslaved laborers. Although the noted Civil War battlefields of Fort Fisher and Fort Anderson flank the southern boundary of Orton, the reason for the war itself was the demands of the slave labor practice that built and cultivated the plantation's' rice fields that will hopefully be restored as its own 'battleground' testimony. I l3Pl6'0rton1SHP0 Rice Field- ,Vom�2 29'2712 Orton Plantation Location Location: Smithville Township North Carolina United States 34 °3'38 "N Coordinates: 77 °56'47 "W34.06056 °N 77.94639''W Coordinates:. 34 °3'38 "N ��56'47"W34.06056 °N 77.94639 °W Built: 1735 Architect: Unknown Architectural style: Classical Revival Greek Revival Governing body: Private NRHP Reference #: 73001294u Added to NRHP: i April 11, 1973 nw (Gheak one) ' Excellent ❑ Good Fair DcPiad ❑ ❑ erorte El Ruins ❑ Unexposed CONDITION (Check One) (Check One) FXj Altered ❑ Unaltered ❑ Moved Original Site DESCRI13E THE PRESENT AND ORIGINAL (if known) PHYSICAL APPEARANCE Orton is a, large, imposing Classical Revival mansion set amid great magnolias and live oaks 'draped with Spanish moss.' The present house com- bines elements from three 'centuries. The earliest`' elements ('the first' -story front and side brick walls) were built about '1735`as part of a: one- and -one- half story dwelling. In the 1840s` the house was enlarged into a two -story Greek Revival temple -form structure. Evidence in the attic suggests a possible intermediate stage of development, with the front part of the house being raised to two stories (a center hall plan one room 'deep) earlier, and the portico and rear section following in the 1840s. Neoclassical` Revival wings were added in 1910, and other work was done in the main house, blendi g with what was built in the 1840s. To the rear is an expansion done in the early 1960s. The temple form main block of Orton retains much of its original character. It is a two -story stuccoed brick 'structure and has a gable roof ' covered with slate. The main (east) facade features a massive` tetrastyle N I -Doric portico.' The entablature carries around the sides of the building. 9 rn The elliptical ° lunette in the center of the pediment is apparently a 1910 m elaboration of an earlier louvered lunette. The facade has at both levels a central doorway, which is flanked at z the first level by single wide- three -part windows and at the second by pair of normal size windows; this arrangement' existed at least as early as 1890. The first -level entrance consists of a single` door flanked by fluted Ionic columns and sidelights. An entablature with pulvinated frieze breaks out over the columns; above it is a wide transom with tracery. These` elements, n within paneled soffit and reveals, are framed by a symmetrically molded architrave with roundel corner blocks and base blocks featuring a Greek fre". The first -floor facade windows have nine- over -nine sash in-the center secti n (replacing the original six- over --six) and three -over -three in the sidelight s They are framed; and divided by symmetrically molded` architraves' with rounde Z corner blocks. At the second level`, the 'doorway, of twentieth century de- LA sign, consists of a`double door beneath a transom; the upper part of each leaf is glazed'. The 'symmetrically molded architrave has 'corner blocks and base blocks featuring a Greek. fret. This doorway serves a balcony which, though it had an earlier precedent, was elaborated in 1910. It is 'supporte by large, carved scroll brackets and enclosed by - turned balusters and ' paneled pedestals that carry a molded rail. The four windows at this level contain six- over -six sash and are framed by symmetrically molded architrave with roundel corner blocks like those below._ Louvered shutters appear on i all windows of the main block and wings, except at the rear. 1 The addition of ` the wings about 1910 altered the side elevations. As 1 seen in a circa 1890 photograph, the widely spaced two front bays` of the south side of the main block were identical at both levels, with windows containing six -over -six sash 'flanking an interior end chimney. Behind these ( but within the block of the house) was a porch with a 'two -bay olliptical- archod open arcade; four closely placed windows appeared above. Today the wing covers the second bay and the rear porch is enclosed; the second -floor fenestration is undisturbed. No early picture of the north elevation has been found; the present scheme with six bays and two interio i Form 10.300a UNITED STATES DEPARTMENT OF THE INTERIOR STATE (July 1969) NATIONAL PARK SERVICE North Carolina NATIONAL REGISTER. OF HISTORIC PLACES COUNTY INVENTORY - NOMINATiON FORM Brunswick FOR NPS USE ONLY ENTRY NUMOER DATE (Continuation Sheet) E - .n.�, '+ (Numbor all entries) 7. A The one -story side wings echo many of the features of the Greek Revival main block; the wall, cornice, and window treatments are identical. The °south wing is a single room. Three 'arched openings occur in the 'south wall, that in the center containing a French door. The northern wing is much larger and 'contains three`; bedrooms and several baths. The flat roofs of the wings are enclosed with balustrades identical to that of the gallery on the temple form section. The plan of Orton would seem to have developed, as follows: a center- hall plan, one room deep, ca. 1735; perhaps then raised from a`story- and -a- half to two full stories with the 'same plan; in the 1840s a transverse stair hall and rear rooms added. This plan probably was maintained until the 1910 renovation. An 1872 notice of the auction of Orton, states that "The ,Improvements consist; of a TWO STORY DWELLING HOUSE, 'containing, 10 Rooms, Brick Basement. . . " Ten rooms can be accounted for in the pre 1910, portion of the house. .Besides' adding the wings; Kenneth` Murchison, architect for the 1910 additions, altered the floor plan and some of the interior trim of the house -- mainly at the first" level. On the first- floor, the walls which formed the center hall were removed, creating a large parlor, extending the width of the main block. The windows to the rear of the fireplaces were enlarged as entrances to the wings. The rear porch was enclosed and some alterations made to the rear. The two stylistic eras (1840s Greek Revival and`1910Neoclassical Revival) present in the interior features are so compatible that identifying all of them is impossible. In addition, it appears that some of the Greek Revival molding was either reused or reproduced. In the parlor, all the windows are framed with symmetrically molded architraves with roundel corner blocks. The reveals are flat - paneled with alternating square and vertical panels. A panel also occurs beneath each window. The doors are framed with a modified version of the front entrance, each employing a pair of Ionic columns and an entablature with ,a pulvinated frieze. The fireplace at each end of the room features a gray -black marble mantel with engaged Ionic columns which support a frieze of serpentine with faceted panels in the center tablet and end blocks. Elaborate plaster work of classical motifs dating from 1910 forms the cornice and adorns the ceiling. The stair located in a transverse hall behind the parlor rises in two flights with a landing in between. The newel is turned and covered with acanthus leaves. Turned balusters carry a handrail oval in section. Behind the stair hall is the bit -. liard room which has a tall neo- Federal style mantel, a molded chair rail, and a deeply molded baseboard. In the dining room, a shallow dome forms the central portion of the ceiling. The woodwork consists of a, high flat- paneled wainscot, symn-iatrically molded architraves with paneled corner blocks', and a neo- Federal style mantel. The `south end of the 'dining room is '`treated as a solarium. Its terrazzo floor is raised one stop, and the room is visually divided by 'a pair of Tuscan columns which 'occur at each end of the step. ` A handsome art nouveau copper chandelier is the focal point.. The central spherical globe is encircled by a filigree ring from which hang eight smaller GP 921.724 Form 10 -000a UNITED STATES DEPARTMENT OF, T HE INTERIOR STATE (July 969) NATIONAL pPARK SERVICE C North Carolina ' 1`IAIIU'NQL.1 \'..YIJi L�.i�OFiCiSiORiPLA(r. L`.J COUNTY,...,,..m....N. Brunswick N INVENTORY - OMHNIA T ION FORM � v FOR NPS USE ONLY ENTRY NUMBER DATE (Continuation Sheet) (Numbor all on(rlee) 7• B bulbs, each with a foliated cup.` The second floor, although partitioned to create dressing rooms, bath- rooms, and closets, retains much of its simple Greek Revival finish. - The hall is unusually narrow and has a heavily molded transverse elliptical arch carried on paneled pilasters. The architraves in the `hall` and those in the southeast bedchamber are symmetrically molded and have faceted 'corner blocks. Plaster cornices also occur in those' two areas. Mantels remain only in the two front bedchambers. They are wood and follow simple straight lines. Molded chair rails also occur in those rooms; however, 'their era is'undetermin able. The Orton Plantation gardens, open to the public, are among the best- { kknown in the southeast. The gardens were developed in the early twentieth' century, and "many of its important parts were designed by the . . . landscape architect,: Robert Swann Sturtevant." Live oaks shade extensive plantings of azaleas, and other flowering trees and shrubs abound. A formal "scroll garden;" a "white circle garden" and a "sun garden" are individually treated. A 1915 Memorial Chapel and a curious tomb said to be that of the first owner of Orton,, "King" Roger Moore are on the grounds as well. The vast rice fields have been leased to the North Carolina Wildlife Resources Commission as a waterfowl sanctuary. Still; visible are many of the old ditches and drains, part of the elaborate irrigation system for the rice fields; some are still used to;flood the fields' for the autumn migration of the birds. GPO 9 21.7 24 PERIOD. (Check One or More as Appropriate) ❑ Prc- Columbian i ❑ 161h Century P_q 181h Century 201h Century ❑ 151h Century ❑ 171h Century PC] 19th Century , I SPECIFIC DATE(S) ((tApplicablo andl(norvn) AREAS OF SIGNIFICANCE (Chock Ono or More as Appropriate) Aboriginal ❑ Education Political ❑ Urban Planning: ❑ Prehistoric' Engineering ❑ Other (3pocily) ❑ 9� 9 ❑ Religion/Phi. Historic ❑ Industry losophy Agriculture' ❑ Invention ❑ Science Architecture ® Landscape ❑ Sculpture ❑ Art Architecture ❑ Social /Human. ❑ Comaorce ❑ Literature itarian ❑ Communications ❑ Military ❑ Theater ❑ Conservation ❑ Music ❑ Transportation _ STATEMENT OF SIGNIFICANCE Orton Plantation is an impressive and intriguing composite of three centuries of remarkably eventful history.' It was a vast and fertile plan- tation yielding great wealth first from naval stores, then from rice pro -` duction. The house began as the relatively small circa 1735 home of the z colorful and powerful early settler, "Ding" Roger Moore; saw the rising and falling fortunes of a series of notable owners including Governor Benjamin ' Smith; grew to a sophisticated and imposing Greek Revival temple -form ` structure in the 1840s; suffered the vicissitudes of the Civil War and Reconstruction; was reclaimed in the 1880s as a luxurious winter hunting u retreat; and in the twentieth century has been lavishly expanded and renovated, so that today, with its superb gardens it is perhaps the best- known antebellum showplace in North Carolina, typifying the romanticized ideal of the Southern mansion. <, z Among the first settlers along the lower Cape Fear River were the — Moores, sons of James Moore, a governor of the province of South Carolina. They became acquainted with the area while on a military expedition to w relieve North Carolinians embattled by fierce Tuscarora Indians. By 1728, W Maurice Moore had patents' amounting to 9,210 acres and his brother Roger, ? ` 12,780 acres. Roger Moore built on this land probably about 1725. His house was located on the west bank of the Cape Fear River between present cities of Wilmington and Southport. Known as Orton,,probably after an t English place name associated with the Moore family; it was burned by Indians whose encampment was across the river from it. The imperious and opulent Moore is supposed not long 'after to have armed his many slaves and entirely eradicated the Cree band responsible. Sometime before. 1734 "King" Roger Moore, as he was called, built the house whose walls form the core of I j the present Orton. A traveler's letter dated 1734 relates , I Mr. Roger Moore, hearing we had come,' was so kind as to send fresh horses for us to come up to his house, which we 'did and were kindly i received by him, he being the chief gentleman in all Cape Fear. His house is built of brick and exceedingly pleasantly situated about f two miles from the town and about half a mile from the river, though, there is a creak that comes up close to the door between two beautiful meadows about three miles in length. `` He has a prospect of the town of Brunswick, and of another beautiful brick house, a building about half a mile from him belonging to Eleazer "Allen, Esq., late speaker to the Commons House of Assembly in the province of South Carolina. Form 10 -3000 UNITED STATES DEPARTMENT OF THE INTERIOR STATE (July 1969) NATIONAL PARK SERVICE North Carolina NATIONAL REGISTER OF HISTORIC PLACES cou TY � _. INVENTORY - NOMINATION FORM Brunswick FOR NPS USE ONLY s ENTRY NUMBER DATE (Continuation Sheet). -- -- } (Number all entries). 8. A Still; another nearby house, Russellborough, was owned by the Moores and `served as the residences of royal governors Arthur Dobbs and William Tryon. The only ` lucrative trade of the Cape Fear area at this time was in naval stores purchas d by England for hpr ships. Orton with its rich pine forests no doubt contribu ' d much - lumber, turpentine, tar, and pitch to this trade. ISing Roger Moore died in 1750 leaving a vast estate including 250 slaves. A few years later Orton was bought by a. wealthy local' merchant, Richard Quince. A lady diarist writing about 1775 mentions Quince and includes a_ reference to the pre- Revolutionary; tenor of the times. We got safe on shore and tho' quite dark landed from the boat with little trouble, and proceeded thro' rows of tar and pitch to the house of a mercht'to whom we had been recommended. . . These [houses] are inhabited: by merchants of whom Mr. Quence, our host,; is first 'in' con sequence. He is deeply engaged in the new system of politicks, in which they are all more or less, tho' Mr. Dry the Collector of Customs, is the most zealous and talks treason by the hour. A year after these words were penned, Brutish soldiers burned William Dry's home,' Russellborough, the former governor's residence. Its ruins are 'one- half mile from the entrance to Orton. In 1796, Richard Quince, Jr., sold Orton to Benjamin Smith, an aide to General George Washington in the Revolution and a grandson of King Roger Moore. Smith was one of the first trustees of the University of North Carolina and became its first` benefactor when in 1789 he gave it land 'warrants for 20,000 acres. Smith Hall, built in 1850 as hall for literary societies and now serving as the Playmakers Theater, was named for him. He was fifteen times a state; senator and was serving as such when he was elected governor of North r Carolina in 1810. Though an able man, Smith suffered financial reverses that forced the sale of Orton. In 1824 it was advertised as the late residence of Governor Benjamin Smith containing 1 � , g x.,975 acres,:: more or less. Of this track between; 100 and 500' acres is swamp land of a, strong; and 'fertile soil, which, it is believed will produce at least 1,000 lbs.'of cotton or four times of rice to the acre. . . Included in the premise's is "a very superior and never failing mill stream with an excellent dam, wanting only flood gates. The rice' machine mill and gin having been recently destroyed by fire. The pond may be used at all times as a reservoir of water to 'flow the how lands, thus rendering Orton one of the most valuable rice plantations in the country. In 1826, Dr. Frederick Jones' Hill bought Orton. Hill was a state- senator' in 1835, and 'a representative the succeeding three legislative sessions; it was his education bill, passed in 1839, that put into operation a public school system for the state. During Hill's ownership Orton house was enlarged and GPO 921.724 > } Form 10.3000 UNITED STATES DEPARTMENT OF THE INTERIOR STATE (July 1969) NATIONAL PARK SERVICE North Carolina NATIONAL REGISTER OF HISTORIC PLACES COUNT`/ INVENTORY NOMINATION r'"©RM Brunswick FOR NPS USE ONLY I ENTRY NUMBER DATE (Continuation Sheet) ---°s -~ (Number all enlrlos) 8. B the central block took on its present rather typical antebellum appearance with a full Doric portico. Thomas Cale�ance'Miller bought Orton in 1854. According to the census of 1860 he had 417 acres in cultivation and 8,276 unimproved or fallow. There were 561,000 pounds of rice on the plantation, indicating it was still the chief crop. The estate contained 144 slaves and was valued at $42,500. The Cavil War apparently caused the abandonment of Orton. It is said to have been used around that time as a hospital for smallpox victims. An auctioneer's handbill of 1872 advertised Orton and "Lands adjacent thereto, 9,026 acres by actual survey." Among other particulars listed are its two -mile front on the river, water power from a pond seven miles in length, ' ten -room dwelling house, and houses for 200 hands. About 1880 Orton became the property of Colonel K. M. Murchison, a former Confederate officer who after the war had built a successful cotton and naval stores trade in New York. Murchison built the first hotel of any note in Wilmington and called it "The Orton ". He restored the decayed Orton Plantatio I, and spent his winters there, where hunting on its vast acreage was his frequen pastime.' When Colonel Murchison died in 1904, his son -in -law James Sprunt bought the estate. Like most of Orton's owners, James Sprunt was a noted figure, During the Civil' War, when a youth of seventeen,' he went to sea as purser on ships running the Federal blockade of Wilmington. While so employed he was captured and imprisoned for some months.` After the war, he was -a member of his father's cotton export firm and become a well - established civic leader and philanthropist. His interest in history led him to become a knowledgeable writer on historical events and to endow the publication of historical studies by the University of North Carolina. Mr. Sprunt lavished care on Orton and undertook the addition of wings to the main structure in 1910. Orton remains in the Sprunt family., In the mid- twentieth century Orton has come to be the state's most widely recognized example of "Southern" architecture; its romanti facade 'amid lush; gardens is widely pictured on travel posters, wallpaper, and most recently, represents the South on boxes of Scotties Tissues in the "Rediscover America" series (see enclosure) GPO 921.724 .\ _ - _ 9• MAJOR BIBLIOGRAPHICAL REFERENCES Research by Charles. Blume, survey specialist; architectural description by Janet Seapker, survey specialist. New Hanover. County Records, New Hanover County Courthouse, Wilmington, North Carolina, Office of the Register of Deeds '(Subgroups: Deeds, Wills). New Hanover; County Records, State Department of Archives and History, Raleigh, North Carolina (Subgroups: Deeds, Wills). Brunswick County Records, Brunswick County Courthouse, Wilmington, North Carolina, Office of the Register of Deeds' (Subgroups: Deeds, Wills). 10. GEOGRAPHICAL DATA:, �_...W LATITUDE AND LONGITUDE COORDINATES LATITUDE AND LONGITUDE COORDINATES DEFINING �. D EFININGA RECTANGLE LOCATING THE PROPERTY Q DEFINING THE CENTER POINT OF A PROPERTY OF LESS THAN TEN AC_RES__ C ORN ER LATITUDE LONGITUDE .` LATITUDE LONGITUDEM ,..,....,,. ...._.,_. Degrees Minutes Seconds Degrees Minutes Seconds Degrees Minutes Seconds Degrees Minutes Seconds NW 34 e 03 , 54 ° 77e 57' 02• 0 O N E 34 e 03 ' 54 `" 77° 56' 25,. S E 34 e 03 , 09 " 7 7e 56, 25,. Sw 3 e 03 ' 09 77o _ 57, 02w APPROXI MATE ACREAGE OFNOMINATED PROPERTY: 12 acres ILI STALL, STATES AND COUNTIES FOR PROPERTIES OVERLAPPING STATE OR COUNTY BOUNDARIES .STATE: CODE COUNTY CODE I, STATE: CODE.. COUNTY: CODE STATE: CODE. COUNTY:. CODE I. .STATE: CODE COUNTY:- CODE. u1 _: :F ORM f.RCPARCD.BY 4 NAME AND TITLE: __2, r c Plaranin Unit Staff ORGANIZATION DATE te Deiartment of Archives, and ,Hstor 13 December 1 STREET AND NUMBER: Q9 s 0k1 e CITY OR TOWN: STATE CODE ry IEEE North Carolina 12 STATE Ll;AISON QFFICER: GERTIFICAI IOf! IiAi "I C3lA, RF'&yl:� i (R`11EPl1ATIGN? — As the designated' State Liaison Officer for the No— tional Historic Preservation Act of 1966 (Public Law I hereby certify that this property is included in the 89 -665), L hereby nominate this property for inclusion National Register. in the National Register and certify that it has been evaluated according to the criteria and procedures set forth by the National Park Service, The recommended Chief, Office of Archeology and Historic Preservation level of significance of this nomination is National E] State M Local' r-1 p Date Name {/i" i`!� H. G. Jones - ATTEST: I I 'rifle State His torian/Administrato:r Keeper of The lational Register �: c� 13 December,' 1972 I7nte Orton Plantation Junction of S.R. 1530 and S.R. 15291-.8 mile drive to office on private road it Smithville Township, North Carolina USGS Map, Wilmington Quadrangle Scale: .1: 62,500 ' !rove Date: 1948 -N- Latitude Longitude -' degrees minutes seconds degrees minutes seconds - NW 34 03 54 77 57. 02 1 : ` k, NE 34 03 54 77 56 25 SE 34 03 09 77 56 25 { - SW 34 03 09 �7 57 02 KEG �t - t t•. 1 1 t. �•�: � k��1i l I v li j�l r Itt �' 1 4• , B 11 11 't I , w - r. aM FEDERAL' POINT rr' TOWNSHII 26 II 06• � .' 7 r . -� al, `• 'i , I I Ij; 9 �at,,'�� ,Lr1 1 -��'�. FEAR RIVER y� CHANNEL LIGHT C i,R.C.L. Seabreeie;. r'ORTONCHUjI H,7 CUPO INLAND' n y -�`7J• 'U`_ HVILLE - T HIP AUINS VERSON 'VC Y CAROLINA BE N " y._ — •3.�g° �' ' -•711! i °AI ! �. t__y / /..,� °" ='iZ` iy... 'A / N YPRESA - ( _=,u r Wilmington Beach `' Kure Beach J4'W e� 79-W n n.wrs.. ri SCALE 1:62 ..ury•rowr 1. w. 1