Loading...
HomeMy WebLinkAbout20111127 Ver 1_CAMA Application_20111223December 22 2011 MEMORANDUM ® @ L-#J OU 9� TO Cyndi Karoly Supervisor DEC 401 Oversight & Express Permits Unit 2011 Division of Water Quality Surface Water Protection TLAND.AyCSTOR,1WA ERSFANCH FROM Doug Huggett NC DENR DCM Mayor Permits Coordinator 400 Commerce Ave Morehead City, NC 28557 (Courier 11- 12 -09) SUBJECT CAMA/Dredge & Fill Major Permit Application Review Applicant Corbett Shirley (c /o G L Gurganus Agent) Project Location 111 Burlington Street adjacent to a man made canal in Holden Beach NC Brunswick Co Proposed Project Applicant proposes to install approximately 50 linear feet of bulkhead, and fill approximately 362 square feet of coastal wetlands Please indicate below your agency s position or viewpoint on the proposed project and return this form by January 14, 2012 If you have any questions regarding the proposed project contact Holley Snider (910)796 -7270 when appropriate in depth comments with supporting data is requested REPLY This agency has no objection to the project as proposed This agency has no comment on the proposed project This agency approves of the project only if the recommended changes are incorporated See attached This agency objects to the project for reasons described in the attached comments SIGNED DA 400 Commerce Ave Morehead City NC 28557 3421 Phone, 252 808 2808 \ FAX 252 247 3330 Internet www nccoastal management net An Equal Opportunity \ Affirmative Action Employer NorthCarohna Naturally DIVISION OF COASTAL MANAGEMENT FIELD INVESTIGATION REPORT APPLICANT S NAME Shirley Corbett c/o Gary Gurganus 2 LOCATION OF PROJECT SITE 111 Burlington Street Holden Beach Brunswick County Photo Index 2006 2000 1995 State Plane Coordinates X 2213473 Y 59908 GPS File P121510A Lat 33 53 45 06034 N Long 78 17 47 45067 W 3 INVESTIGATION TYPE CAMA /D &F 4 INVESTIGATIVE PROCEDURE Dates of Site Visit — 8/18/11 12/15/11 Was Applicant Present — No 5 PROCESSING PROCEDURE Application Received — 11/28/11 Office Wilmington 6 SITE DESCRIPTION (A) Local land Use Plan — Town of Holden Beach Land Classification From LUP — Residential (B) AEC(s) Involved EW PT ES CW (C) Water Dependent Yes (D) Intended Use Private (E) Wastewater Treatment Existing—None Planned None (F) Type of Structures Existing — None Planned 50 linear feet of bulkhead (G) Estimated Annual Rate of Erosion N/A Source — N/A 7 HABITAT DESCRIPTION [AREA] DREDGED FILLED OTHER (A) Vegetated Wetlands (Coastal) High Marsh 62 sq ft Low marsh 300 sq ft (B) Non Vegetated Wetlands Open Water (C) Other 2 000 sq ft uplands (D) Total Area Disturbed 2 362 sq ft ( 0 05 acres) (E) Primary Nursery Area No (F) Water Classification SA Open No 8 PROJECT SUMMARY The applicant proposes to install approximately 50 linear feet of bulkhead and fill approximately 362 sq ft area of coastal wetlands Shirley Corbett c/o Gary Gurganus Page Two 9 PROJECT DESCRIPTION The project site consists of a canal front lot located at 111 Burlington Street in the Town of Holden Beach Brunswick County To find the project site from US Highway 17 in Shallotte travel south on Holden Beach Road (NC 130) Travel approximately 7 5 miles and follow NC 130 to the right and continue south approximately 10 mile to the base of the Holden Beach Bridge Turn Left onto Ocean Boulevard W and travel approximately 15 miles to Burlington Street Turn right onto Burlington Street and travel approximately 0 4 miles The project site will be located on the left The project site is a canal front lot that measures approximately 50 feet in width by approximately 90 feet in depth The elevation of the high ground area of the lots averages approximately 2 5 feet above normal high water (NHW) High ground vegetation consists primarily of lawn grasses and transitions to marsh adjacent to the shoreline The shoreline of the property is unstabilized irregular and recessed where erosion is occurring from stormwater runoff from Burlington Street Erosion feet along the NHW has been observed and is evident from the elevation change of approximately Y boundary These areas are irregularly vegetated with wetlands and inundated with debris from flood tides Coastal wetlands have volunteered in the areas where stormwater run off has created changes to elevation erosion and natural drainage paths A fringe of coastal wetlands including Spike Grass (D►st►chhs sp►cata) and Salt Meadow Hay (Spart►na patens) intermixed with Sea Ox eye (Borr►ch►a Sea frutescens) are present landward of NHW Smooth (Spartina are, alterniflora) along average 20 feet in w dth Lavendar (L►monium spp ) exist waterward of the NHW boundary as measured from the NHW boundary The project site is currently undeveloped and not serviced by any utilities The adjacent shorelines have been stabilized with bulkheads and are aligned approximately 8 12 feet waterward of the existing NHW boundary of the project 10 feet of boundary on the d grass adjacent properties is located along the bulkheads with approximately waterward of the bulkhead The Holden Beach Land Use Plan classifies the adjacent AIWW a ►roe classif the adjacent ied ed SA by the high ground portion of the project area as Residential The waters Division of Water Quality and are NOT designated as a Primary Nursery Area (PNA) by the N C Division of Marine Fisheries They are CLOSED to the harvest of shellfish PROPOSED PROTECT The applicant proposes to install approximately 50 linear fill lkhead would be installed on average 6 81f feet sq ft area of coastal wetlands As proposed the bu waterward of the NHW boundary The bulkhead would t mates that approximately 300 squarely 10 5 feet waterward of the NHW boundary The app licant es feet of backfill material would be placed below t� area mentioned above which would consist primarily alignment would incorporate the coastal wetland of Smooth Cord Grass (Spart►na altern►flora) As proposed the bulkhead alignment would connect to Shirley Corbett c/o Gary Gurganus Page Three the two (2) existing bulkheads on the adjacent riparian properties and would measure approximately 50 feet in length The applicant states this alignment is requested to minimize erosion by eliminating offsets and sharp angles of the bulkhead once completed The limits of disturbance would be located approximately 40 feet landward of the proposed bulkhead alignment 10 ANTICIPATED IMPACTS The proposed new bulkhead construction with associated backfill and tie back /anchor system would result in the incorporation of approximately 362 square feet of coastal wetlands and estuarine waters The proposed bulkhead construction would result in the disturbance of approximately 2 000 square feet of high ground The bulkhead backfill would also result in the filling of approximately 300 square feet of coastal wetlands primarily Smooth Cord Grass (Spartina alterniflora) Estuarine Waters and Public Trust Area Minor increases in turbidity should be expected during construction Submitted by Holley Snider Date December 19 2011 Office Wilmington October 4 2011 N C Dept of Environment Health and Natural Resources 127 Cardinal Drive Extension Wilmington NC 28405 -3845 Att Holly Snider Ref Major CAMA Permit for Shirley Corbett 113 Burlington Street Holden Beach NC The enclosed Major CAMA Permit application is for the proposed construction of a bulkhead to facilitate shoreline stabilization The proposed alignment will utilize existing bulkheads located on each side of the property This alignment will help to minimize erosion by eliminating any offsets and sharp angles of the finished construction Sincerely L201 L6*.tAT4vj---:� Gary L Gurganus PL5 GAR OLD �F,SS'0N,y ti9 e' e � s v 4 gEAL a L'3414 a Cr GI;&� `• fIrT II 2011a r4 d — October S 2011 I hereby authorize Gary L Gmpmis, PIS to act as agent on by behalf to obtam a Major CAMA pennit to construct a bulkhead on Lot 173 (111 Burlington Stre4 at Holden Beach, North Carolina. tT 2 s -8 Busyness Name t u me (# ) Applicant 1 First Name MI Last Name S I RLl C Og&T Apocant 2 First Name 0 Last fry M Ham! Wpffcanft pie aMuh an, ,11 w fps ) a-M names tatad M.fin9 A State P o (3ox tit CRY �c FAX z,P LOUUHUY 784 66 C-0 W n Alt S 9 to 656140 ea Street Address (fdrfl%m# from above) C8y State ZIP Email &isrness Narne GAY GOaGAa "S L•A,JD SKAvEYIAG Agent/ ContracW 1 Fast Name M! Last Name GAKY L GwRGA0Ks Agentf Carft cW Z First Name t1A1 last Name Malfing Stage aw 1108 5wo ST2f.�`T Sw PO an S�,elpOr ti►G ZIP Phone No 1 Phone No. 2 7, 62 �q,o 233 7605 tea- °� FAX No cwuacw# StredAd*em ffeffaraW frmnabm* CRY Stale aP Email GAP-YaLAP, e Cyr �� 4�r j GFOrm connffflm Off 2011 252 808 2808 1 888 4RCOAST www a eccoastalmanagemgQtyrnet � r Form DCM MP i (Page 2 of 4) APPLICATION for oevdqxTmd Pe and a. Total kino of sho erne an the tract (k) 49.88 C. Sao of mfiv ivai lol (s) 4 *4187 Sa Fr (/f marry bt sms please i I r fr aWffbrWpWwMa &Q e. Vegelabon on tact b. Shoe of enfus tract (sd-R) Lie 96? d Appnoomnate dean of tract above NHW (normsat high waW or IAVL Omnnw USAVIevaq Z 7-d• or CIe Z TAEES 4 COASTAL G-)ETLA#305 L Man-made feabum and uses now an tract J.lo0JE g Ideaftanddmcnibette ii Imrd hem to lha pf - sam S i ra6xc.E FAM r 1-Y R eS I o E,JCE h, nowt does local govenunent zone rie tract? IQESMEaT1A L F' 1 C (-ea,.1 b6f6l ty) L is the proposed propaconsaMord with Me applicable mnmp (Attach numM cranp6eree certificate if aW;csble) j6es Elft Elm 1 Is Me proposed aclift W of an defhan waterfront mdmekpmeM PmPosa!? Dyes mb I,. Has a professional wdmeotoWcal assessmerd been done for the trod:7 it yes, atladh a patsy Qlfes ]]No ViA If yes, by w horn? I Is the proposed project located m a N lional Rego Koh= Dish or does: undw a ElYes ❑No IA Nabors! Rehr fisted or efigble, prqpW „ <Fonn continues on Rod P896> �- j MT 12 2011 252 808 2808 1 888 4RC ®AST www nccoastalmanagement net Cohudy (can be mWWe) Sheet Address State R L # BRL4,j.StJIC -K III JOURLIA61 d STREET Subdfi isen Name (�iOLOEP► $64CH H69" Ho�6 -► H slate �G Zip 7.841,7— Phorhe No w t (s) (� Y aJ paw wr�h fstl a J did a In w>wh NC met bam s the papled:localeP h PlemeelbodyalmdeirmareatopmPOsMF L um 4E R A1* LA Will C Op4TRACo ` (JgIEP -SJAY c is the water body ddenww m (b) above, nahuat or am miade? d Name ride dosed mapr water body to the Proposed Protest sde A*TLA#JTI C OCEAIJ e Is proposed wwk wllm dly ftft or plamNV pub? f K appficeift W rite O m M jurad'aldon or cdy ftft the prolmsed )&es ❑No work falls wllmh. Not.sEol BfJ9CH a. Total kino of sho erne an the tract (k) 49.88 C. Sao of mfiv ivai lol (s) 4 *4187 Sa Fr (/f marry bt sms please i I r fr aWffbrWpWwMa &Q e. Vegelabon on tact b. Shoe of enfus tract (sd-R) Lie 96? d Appnoomnate dean of tract above NHW (normsat high waW or IAVL Omnnw USAVIevaq Z 7-d• or CIe Z TAEES 4 COASTAL G-)ETLA#305 L Man-made feabum and uses now an tract J.lo0JE g Ideaftanddmcnibette ii Imrd hem to lha pf - sam S i ra6xc.E FAM r 1-Y R eS I o E,JCE h, nowt does local govenunent zone rie tract? IQESMEaT1A L F' 1 C (-ea,.1 b6f6l ty) L is the proposed propaconsaMord with Me applicable mnmp (Attach numM cranp6eree certificate if aW;csble) j6es Elft Elm 1 Is Me proposed aclift W of an defhan waterfront mdmekpmeM PmPosa!? Dyes mb I,. Has a professional wdmeotoWcal assessmerd been done for the trod:7 it yes, atladh a patsy Qlfes ]]No ViA If yes, by w horn? I Is the proposed project located m a N lional Rego Koh= Dish or does: undw a ElYes ❑No IA Nabors! Rehr fisted or efigble, prqpW „ <Fonn continues on Rod P896> �- j MT 12 2011 252 808 2808 1 888 4RC ®AST www nccoastalmanagement net R Form DCM MP 1 (Page 3 of 4) I m n Are gore wedands on the site? (7 Are there coastal vAMmids on the sit? (m) If yes to eIN>er (j or no above has a debeefian been cmKkckW d=A,, ff) $q•�t'��4RY SCOW SYSTEM"! o. Describe emsev dtrs" wad Mpply sMUM New ty (,.M.M9 SYSTE-P, PL Descift 9 st - WAdW U=lagMeldlff I s 000..36 APPLICATION for Major DevaWment Pemld 13No Aq I— Q''°° )Wes ElNo Hs 0f-) 9 —i -11 a_ VVe Nee propct be for cammercmt, pu bf r, or pnraie use? L j mnmerum Ur Pp. I %)A-rE X�rev"Carrememity b- (�nve a i� die of peevpose, eesei, ats! da�i � �>� p wieeie C*.SSTRMCTIOtJ Of iSUWn� '% f'WE� E�af:a� p(.A,WMC ,.1T ofr FILL t A--r6AjAL, To LEVEL. TRAC' Q Desadee the proposed cmWucbm mell types of cwgruchm mpjpnerd to lbp- used dernng consbeacfime the nuernber of eadi type of egwpment and where d is b be sore& tltrjl CU -Aviv K H A Ab _r0 .S d. Ust all develop and acbwdm your popwm e' a t'rE rl ( 6) h Describe bcabore and type of eQeg and poposed eSsdearges to wa hem of the sffie- r'I o,3c Wig WaSIOWStOr or stotmrMW be disdM9W Ludo a nerd' If yes, will do c5schargad watm be of Nee same saft* as No nx=v g WWB& DYes EIM )TNA 1. Is # me any mftabm p ElYes ElNo if yes. a" I amagoonproposel <Fonn continues on c, t Orr 204 252 808 2808 1 888 4RCOAST WWW ueccoastairna`nvs, d omen t net Form DCM MP 1 (Page 4 of 4) a A project narrative APPLICATION for Major Developrniw Permit A fist of the names and complete addresses of the a4went waterfront (npanan) landomiers and signed return ram as juoet go such oawaers gave recerued a copy of the and plats by cerlffied butt. Such landionum nuist be adwsed that fleet' low 30 days m wtWA ID subin8 COMMents an Me pmposed pi>W to the umsion of Cwt Akanagenaa& Address 12Sao Gu djELL RD Cr1A4tcaiT'r4r, rK- 2821_R 597 -1146 g. A fist of previous state or federal permits issued for work on the project trail include permit numbem perni f e, and suing dates ti 0pE i h. S%"3d cm I I or agent audioruaffion farm. 8 applicable, l L Wellanddellrieation d necessary I j A signed AEC hazard notice for pinjecls in ocerationt and inlet areas (Must be signed try pmpedty o r A smment et comprranoe wffi the N Q EnviioreiieiM P+ta€uyAct (MC G_& 113A 1 10) if necessary ff 8re F*d ewa>Kq3S of public founds or use of pttft bnds aWich a statement documenting compere, with the North CamIna E nwonmentai Policy Aar: I understand that any permit issued in response to this application will allow only the developrimad descrbed in the The project will be subject to the conditions and resbTCbons contained in the permit I certify that t am autlwnzed to grant. and do in fad grant pemussion to representatives of slake and federal review agencies iD enter on the aforementioned lands m car with evaluating mforirralicm rem to Bas ptrnid aeon and follmv -up monitoring of the project_ I further certify that the information provided m this application is truthful to the best of my knowkxfge Date Ab os a Print name L G� &jvs S%nature G Please tridicate awn aftactumft perhamM to ymff proposed pmjea ODt m MP 2 Excavation and Fig Information ❑DCM MP-5 Midges and Culverts ODCM MP-3 Upland DeveMpnent a a f DDCM MP-4 fires kdommom �4 f4 Yid 262 808 2808 1 388 AIRCOA$T WWw nccoastalmanagement net IZ DEPOSAL OFMCAVaTEDMATEMat JKMwaedrmntlfsAlft3W i a Locefimofdespoesdam& b. omtenmons arm C- Q) [b j ckmm fffeb anm& []Yes Ebft Elm i) ff no, aa3ch a f pemee� inn f3am bee aeeenea 8. Q) Donne dspmd mm kmkdmmw cosadwagoubmamb (C, a*mft vq ebdm rAVI *AB Iboftm M er dher (WW ff any b®ae sw cbeekeR pnev11 to mobw ofisWebdaffned ErAV EISB Elw E3Naw QQ Desmbe Bee p opcea of desposa! M&mamw d 0i Uma mwbeaLm6W%hfwfi I e nvbs [Ift 0A Qi)ffymafKm6? i ¢�Doesas mdat wWamamfheaelw? Elwbs Cgo EW (i) ffge3ee, hmenaehado ow W. aft? ZaZ.808 26ug Form DCVA RIP-2 and FP11, Page 2 of 2 I Siff STABRMTM EITM seen not appftabb (lfdevokpme is a wood Qmn use MP-4— ) a. Twe arswel.e b- LM& T c. Average de�oa +d of 1�9iYY ar b� 6 8 FEET a TWeaf WOOD +g. oafsm�fee#afUfDbepacedbeker bvmL Ekddmw bay US F.,Fm BmsIwmftmM_ ()OW- L Soiroe a(ift mabma� LOCAL BEACM COeIPATtALE SA-ib vvw . ?S FT d Mmmwm aaemrmd of Id Mvr NWL to 5 FIECT t 0) Mal I , beesb � 18 eem® &fixgPeCmfffMt2 OYes, Ob EPA & Tnea mmamd GtEAa Ftt.L .SAaD 14. t)T I R FILL ACS pTft sew not appb s. n vm IN maw be brain b goals? Wen EDb OM b. (O M SE male Bi be pbmed m ooasW viefiendshmish (CM Ny. ODAmMItaf RmfsBdtDIm~imVw O P) affmam AV& 5nje $' m Rupowctfm L e%) EL L oT a MKV0 arm I Ibeh*taa9ieandeca�, LA W htFhD C. (OvannsaftmMadsw I ssa s efthepmpmp Ce) g`WI6 eeI II IdW*WW and iwwftyv abe lb- !; ti Dom 6 VA %waf eq vig be umd oLg, b-UK- Qd-djpn I" Mt,it &cAVATaR SRO? OYss W tom► $r yeas g, dgsgimvmbebdemioavader . �� Ma 6 KEMP, 4 1 1 , ) 2n� SHIRLEY CORBETT 111 BURLINGTON STREET HOLDEN BEACH, NC PROPOSED BULKHEAD ELEV AT TOP 4 3 PROPOSED FILL cl Fv It n CAR0'��i� L SEA e a 4 7 e a e O O EXISi1NG GRADE nus wm- fB� WATER UNE ELEV 189 CROSS SECTION SCALE. 1 ° = 5 MAL CAMA Wr-ILPND UNE ELEV 2 10 RECEIVED DCM WILMINGTON NC NOV 2 8 2011 i Ht3IEBY A CHED PLAT OF SURVEY TIE LINE. LS A 1RU ATM Of LAND COMMENCING AT MONUMENT -GRIF- (NC. GRID COORDINATES- N = 59 4202519 at VT AND E = 2-2116318070) THENCE N 86451171E 82404 FEET TO A1Q1 ARDS OF 118 12' (N-C- GRID COOImBrNES. N = 59 4WLW45 AND E = 2,212,4545233} CAR0L9iA THENCE N 81106 097E 1 107 95 FEET 70 A MAC MAR. 7HENCE N 08'42 11'W 296-30 FEET TO A THENCE S OV6'297E 49-86 FEET TO EIP 'a ALL RINGS ARE EIP 11 KC GRID 1 PA NORnt NAD 19M ALL DISTANCES Z'�' I ARE HORLUINTAL GROUND DISTANCE& GMZL L-,-44 DATE suvt O ///1111111` t 1 I � 1 I t I I i -- I-- - J LOT 172 t -- i HOLDEN BEACH t HARBOR t I MAP BOOK 7 PAGE 24 I I EXISTING I I BULKHEAD V-4 3 1 I t --- - - - - -- 4— _ WME%A" t I 1 I 77 18 +4 3 EIP I L2 L EIP +46 N 85 54 16 E i 1 1 1 I PROPOSED BULKHEAD 1 t t 1 1 � 1 ip i OD NORMAL LOW j WATER LINE BY ELEVATION I I t EDGE OF 1 MARSH 1 LOCATED 09 -29 -11 t 1 t 1 I t 0 A Z D r 1W COASTAL CAMA X18 WETLAND LINE FLAGGED BY DENR LOCATED 09- 06-11 LOT 173 1 LIMITS +42 (VACANT LOT 1 I OF FILL 4 987 SQ FT Z i +3 8�-_ _ 1 � I +41 o ' 4-, I 4 - - -- W X24+ � A3 4 3 9 + - - �• j 3 i W 70 02 I4 2 \ 1 I I I i I I I NRB S 8553 � NORMAL HIGH +4 9 WATER LINE LIMITS OF FLAGGED BY DENR DISTURBACE LOCATED 09 -06 -11 EXISTING BUI KHEAD LOT 174 HOLDEN BEACH HARBOR MAP BOOK 7 PAGE 24 NOTES *LOT 173 IS IN FLOOD HAZARD ZONE °VE FASE ELEVATION 18 FEET BASED ON DFIRM 37202016001 PANEL DAT- 06 -02 -06 *REVISED 10 -11 -11 TO CORRECT PROPERI} ADDRESS 2011 20 0 20 40 �. SCALE 1 = 20 VIMTY MAP NOT TO SCALE AL W 7FRWAY I I mil 1� OCENNd VIEW SITE HIGH POINT BLVD WEST ATLANTIC ST OCEAN LEGEND - EIP O DISTING IRON PIPE (FOLM) NRS c NEW RE-BAR (SET) Em O EXISTING RE-BAR 0101M) A CONCRETE MONUMENT Pr O O ! PK NAIL T O CLEAN OUT II O FIRE HYDRANT A'V O WATER VALVE vim 0 WATER METER ERRM FILL Al EA 9 v O -P rn O rn � N to � x m r v 0o rn 3 'B. EIP CP 7 m Zo 00 00 0 to x m -p- o 01 La z m m I 1 t l 6 C m Z -L3Q C)..46 mo 4 oZ D� �;0 LINE BEARING DISTANCE L7 I S 85-53 37° W 23 98 L2 N 8554 16° E 1 22 82 M U Z 0 O Go 0 O c$ Z _ I nT O Q�1,- O V Z j 1Q Li W :row OOU Z J to O I.-- O OOK Nin omm 00 Z x U GARY GURGANUS LAND SURVEYING GARY L. GURGANUS P LS �rtx 3369 HOLDEN BEACH RD SW Supply North Carolina 28462 (910) 233 -7605 r� FOR T-a , i �+� �SU�RVVEY .7HIM � COMM MADE FROM LOT 173 (111 STREET) HOIDEN BEACH HARBOR SUB13MSION MAP BOOK 7 PACE 24 HOLDEN BEACH NORTH CAROLINA AND EXISTING PHYSICAL EVIDENCE LOCKWOOD FOLLY TOWNSHIP BRUNSWICK COUNTY NC 1 9/6/11 FIELD 800K FILE NO 11126 SOB NO 11126