Loading...
HomeMy WebLinkAbout19920039 Ver 1_Monitoring Report_20100910M Y2-oaf PotashCorp Helping Nature Provide Federal Express September 9, 2010 Mr. Larry Eaton Mr. Eric Kulz NC DENR - Division of Water Quality Surface Water Protection Division 2321 Crabtree Blvd., Suite 250 Raleigh, North Carolina 27604 RE: Whitehurst Creek Summary Data Report Dear Mr. Eaton and Mr. Kulz: As both of you are aware, PCS Phosphate has requested to cease monitoring of the Whitehurst Creek mitigation channel. Separately, each of you requested a summarization/compilation of the monitoring data collected by CZR over the years since monitoring began, to assist you in making a decision whether or not to cease monitoring. Enclosed is a report by CZR entitled "Whitehurst Creek West Prong Aquatic Macroinvertebrate and Fish Survey and Water Quality Analysis: Summary Report. Whitehurst Creek before impact was an incised, channelized, and confined stream channel, that provided little aquatic habitat. After reclamation, it is a wide, slow-moving, permanent stream that provides aquatic habitat for a wide variety of species. If you have any questions, please call me at (252) 322-8249, or e-mail me at ifumesskpcsphoMhate.com, or Sam Cooper/Julia Berger of CZR at (910) 392-9253, or e-mail scooper czr-inc.com orjberger@czr-inc.com. Sincerely, 1 frey C. Furness Senior Scientist Enclosure pc: 23-01-004-26 w/encl. R.M. Smith w/encl. S. Cooper-CZR w/encl. J.Hudgens-CZR w/encl. ko? ? ?LL 0 SEPI0Z010 DENR - WATER QUALITY 1NEWDSAND STORMWATER BRANCH 1530 NC Hwy 306 South, Aurora, NC USA 27806 T (252) 322-4111 KS Phosphate I www.potashcorp.com g2- b()39 i WHITEHURST CREEK WEST PRONG AQUATIC MACROINVERTEBRATE AND FISH SURVEY AND WATER QUALITY ANALYSES: SUMMARY REPORT • Prepared for: NORTH CAROLINA DIVISION OF WATER QUALITY Raleigh, North Carolina Prepared by: PCS PHOSPHATE COMPANY, INC. Environmental Affairs Department Aurora, North Carolina CZR INCORPORATED 4709 College Acres Drive, Suite 2 Wilmington, North Carolina 0 August 2010 • The purpose of this report is to provide the North Carolina Division of Water Quality (NCDWQ) summary results of the baseline and mitigation monitoring in the West Prong of Whitehurst Creek in Beaufort County, North Carolina as they determine whether future monitoring may cease. The baseline data are derived from macroinvertebrate and fish surveys conducted during the winter and summer of 1992. The mitigation channel data are derived from macroinvertebrate and fish surveys conducted during the winters and summers of 2003-2009 as well as water quality data that was collected on a monthly basis from 2003-2009 by PCS personnel. The reader is directed to the Whitehurst Creek West Prong Aquatic Macroinvertebrate and Fish Survey and Water Quality Analysis: 2009 Annual Mitigation Channel Report (CZR, Incorporated, 2010) for details regarding the background of the study and methodology for the data presented in this report. Appendices A and B from the 2009 annual report are included with this report. Aquatic Macroinvertebrate Surveys (Figures 1-9; Appendix A from the 2009 Annual Report) Sixteen groups of macroinvertebrates were identified during the eight years of this study (including the 1992 surveys). Coleoptera, Diptera, Hemiptera, and Odonata were the most commonly identified groups during both the baseline and mitigation channel surveys. Two groups, Megaloptera and Orthoptera (which is actually a terrestrial group), were identified in low numbers during the baseline survey and were not identified during the mitigation channel surveys. Conversely, five groups, Hirudinea, Mollusca, Nematoda, Nemertea, and Platyhelminthes (also identified at low numbers), were identified during mitigation channel monitoring and not during baseline monitoring. • Thirty-four (34) percent of the taxa identified during baseline monitoring were also identified during mitigation channel monitoring. There has also been an increase in the percent tolerant taxa (TV >7) in the mitigation channel over the baseline channel. It is probable that habitat differences between the original channel and the mitigation channel account for the absence of some baseline species and the identification of several other new taxa. The baseline channel was narrow, relatively shallow, and ditch-like. Conversely, the mitigation channel is wide, relatively deep, and pond-like (as a result of persistent downstream beaver activity). Although the macroinvertebrate assemblages have changed from the baseline channel to the mitigation channel as indicated by the low Jaccard index, Biotic and EPT indices are similar, indicating similar water quality in the baseline and mitigation channels. Fish Surveys (Figures 10-15; Appendix B from the 2009 Annual Report) Of the nine fish species captured during baseline monitoring, seven were also captured during mitigation channel monitoring. The two species that were not recaptured during mitigation sampling were the pirate perch and swamp darter. Twelve (12) additional species to those captured during baseline monitoring were captured during mitigation channel monitoring. The total number of individuals captured has been slightly variable, yet comparable, to the baseline surveys in the mitigation channel with the exception of 2009 (the number of individuals captured during the summer of 2009 was low compared to all other years). However, the eastern mosquitofish comprised the majority of the baseline total (288 of 316 individuals) while bluegill and pumpkinseed have made up the majority of the totals during mitigation channel monitoring. There is an increasing trend in the percent of piscivorous fish taxa during mitigation channel monitoring which suggests trophic complexity has increased in the mitigation channel. • During the 1992 baseline surveys, Whitehurst Creek was confined to the channel and only a backpack electroshocker and block nets (if needed) were utilized. Conductance measured by CZR during these surveys ranged from 116 pS to 520 pS. However, specific conductance measured during mitigation channel monitoring has ranged from 562 pS to 3,974 pS and averaged 2,418 pS. The effective conductivity range for the electroshocker is 10 pS to 600 pS. Thus, fish capture via the electroshocker during mitigation channel monitoring was almost certainly lower than baseline fish capture due to the operation of the electroshocker outside its limits. In addition, beginning in 2003, paired fyke nets (one facing upstream and one facing downstream) were set in the channel at the downstream end of both sampling stations. The fyke nets were employed to more thoroughly sample fish populations in the flooded conditions that existed in the mitigation channel from the ongoing beaver activity (PCS has the beavers removed on a regular basis, but they have become a chronic problem immediately downstream of the mitigation channel). Surface Water Quality (Figures 16-23) Overall water quality in the mitigation channel was typical of blackwater swamp streams in the region and hypoxic conditions were rare. The only observable trend was a slight increase in specific conductivity over the duration of mitigation channel monitoring. Two phosphorous peaks were observed in the spring and winter of 2008. These peaks were associated with elevated turbidity, indicative of runoff events prior to sampling. • 9 L E 7 0 a) c 0 U N () C L o Y U) co Y Y C (n O O N 3 QE o L L a) > co a) W -0 a) 0 C) N O 0O N O N <n C;) ?o N O Q) cnL s a) c L Q) - U o ? c o c Y U O C ? O L L a) mo ?-0 c; _ L N O M am a) 10 a) 0 L =3 CN tn CD U ? c c a) Y Q Y a7 N O Qz Y L a) CU (D a) U >' () cn a 1 E -r- N U Tj co a) Q) ? C O Y ?C L N a) a) C y= C E a) U, -_0 CU c c? yr L a) a) () a) >E E o o 4-- C-) (6 cu x E 2 ' 0 L a) o a) C ? a) Z c 0 L) ?E U- 0 u o eaaldoyaial N 00 O sauluiwlauAleld O N o eialdoulj0 N 13 co o e?aeu?o?il0 N N eleuop0 ? ,It C) ea:PauaaN M O o epojeWE)N N CA eosnlloW Im eaaldole6aW eauipnaiH eaaIdIWGH eaajdoaauaaydEj eaaldia eaoelsna:D eaaldooloo epiuyoeay Oo C0 N O 00 CO N O exel jo aagwnN 0 0 co U • • Figure 2. Macroi nverte b rate taxa by season for the Whitehurst Creek mitigation channel monitoring (2003-2009) compared with the baseline monitoring (1992). Note that the 1992 data are derived from three stations while the 2003-2009 data are derived from two stations. The 1992 baseline data are depicted across all monitoring years for reference. Reference lines for baseline winter and baseline summer represent the same value. 70 60 x 50 / w 40 -- 0 ID 30 ? ? ` f p s Z' 20- 10-1 0 1992 2003 2004 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 Sample Year 1992 Baseline Winter 1992 Baseline Summer 1992 Baseline Total - - Mitigation Winter - - Mitigation Summer - - Mitigation Total Figure 3. Number of macroi nverteb rate taxa by station during the 1992 Whitehurst Creek baseline monitoring (1992) and mitigation channel monitoring (2003-2009). The number of macroinvertebrate taxa displayed represents the combined total number of taxa identified during the winter and summer surveys. The 1992 baseline data are depicted across all monitoring years for reference. 50- 45- 40- 'X0 35- 30- 0 f- w 25- . . . . . . . --- - - - --------------------- 20- z 15- z 10 5 0 1992 2003 2004 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 Sample Year - - 1992 Baseline Station 1 - - -1992 Baseline Station 2 - - - -1992 Baseline Station 3 Mitigation Station 1 Mitigation Station 2 4 • • • Figure 4. Number of macroinvertebrate taxa identified in common with Whitehurst Creek baseline monitoring (1992) during mitigation channel monitoring (2003-2009) and cumulative annual total taxa identified from sampling the Whitehurst Creek mitigation channel (2003-2009). Note that the 1992 data are derived from three stations while the 2003-2009 data are derived from two stations. The 1992 baseline data are depicted across all monitoring years for reference. 16 X ea 0 d E 3 Z 180 160 140 120 100 80 60 40 20 0 ? .00 I 1992 2003 2004 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 Sample Year 1992 Baseline - - - Cumulative Baseline - - Cumulative Annual Mitigation Figure 5. Jaccard index of similarity for the Whitehurst Creek baseline monitoring (1992) and the mitigation channel monitoring (2003-2009). Note that the 1992 data are derived from three stations while the 2003-2009 data are derived from two stations. 0.160- 0.140- 0.120- > a 0.100- X GI 0.080- 0.060- OM v 0.040- 0.020- 0.000- 2003 2004 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 Sample Year - Index Value 5 • • 17J Figure 6. Percent of taxa with tolerance values (TV) <5 and >7 for the Whitehurst Creek baseline monitoring (1992) and mitigation channel monitoring (2003-2009). Only taxa with an assigned TV from the winter sampling events were used for analysis. The 1992 baseline TVs are depicted across all monitoring years for reference. 100 90 80 ca X 70 ~ 60 0 c 50 m L 40 m a 30 20 10 0 1992 2003 2004 - __2 1992 Baseline TV <5 Mitigation TV <5 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 Sample Year 1992 Baseline TV >7 - Mitigation TV>7 6 Figure 7. Biotic index values (winter values only) for the Whitehurst Creek baseline monitoring (1992) and mitigation channel monitoring (2003-2009). Values were calculated by averaging the calculated biotic index value of all three stations during the baseline monitoring and both stations during the mitigation channel monitoring. The 1992 hacf?lina hinfir- inrilrrac orc Hanirforl nrrncc nil mnni4nrinrr -,- f- -f- -- ,., Figure 8. EPT index values by station for the Whitehurst Creek baseline monitoring (1992) and mitigation channel monitoring (2003-2009). The number of macroinvertebrate taxa displayed represents the combined total number of taxa identified during the winter and summer surveys. The 1992 baseline EPT index is depicted across all monitoring years for reference. • • 4- 3- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - ?a X 2 C H w 1 - - - - - -------------------- 0 1992 2003 2004 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 Sample Year - - 1992 Baseline Station 1 - - -1992 Baseline Station 2 - - - -1992 Baseline Station 3 -- Mitigation Station 1 Mitigation Station 2 - - - - - - --- - - - - - - - - 7 Figure 9. EPT index values for the Whitehurst Creek baseline monitoring (1992) and mitigation channel monitoring (2003-2009). Reported EPT values represent the combined total of EPT taxa across all stations (three stations during the 1992 survey and two stations during the 2003-2009 surveys). The 1992 baseline EPT index value is depicted across all monitorina vears for reference. Y m c a? LL L - cu C ?o CU (n cn o U ?E ?o O L z ? ?_0 E ca E c6 cncu cn_0 c O cu o N M - O O CD N Y ,c v? C - a) -C U)3 CL cn o ?_ L L Y c6 .0 cn L CD U a) m w o m s cn CD L O ON cu cu M ? O N O O N O N a) cs C Y CU Y .C (6 U L Y C ? oY o ca z v? v? > c c L N rn 3 ?a m ? c CU CD a) N cl) ?E Y o (D - U c Y C cn CU : L ? U a) > C > 4 L OU Y c W ?o -o C M a) o N t in C: O O .? L c ? c E? z? () ? .N m ? L CD L m 0 co N N LO O slenpinipul ;o aagwnN O O goaad al!gM aiddeao el!gM q}nowieM aapep dweMS paesui? dwnd goaad aleJld bogoiwwnn aeb asoubuo-l sseq glnowebie-l gsijuns uaaa!D aaulgs uaploE) pegs piezziE) aall_? gsijolinbsow uaalse3 daeo peagllnq uMoig u l jMo 8 gsijuns pallodsenl8 ll!banl8 laa ueoiaauay uepequaua olluelIv 0 0 co • • • Figure 11. Number of fish taxa by season during the Whitehurst Creek baseline monitoring (1992) and mitigation channel monitoring (2003-2009). The number of fish taxa displayed represents totals from two monitoring stations for each season during mitigation channel monitoring and three monitoring stations for baseline monitoring. Fyke nets were utilized beginning in 2003 due to an unconfined channel from elevated water levels. The 1992 baseline data are depicted across all monitoring years for reference. Reference lines for baseline total and baseline summer represent the same value. 14- 12- 10- 8- p ® ® ® '? \\ / \ N. \\ ?/ 6 Z ? \ 2 - - - ? 0 1992 2003 2004 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 Sample Year 1992 Baseline Winter 1992 Baseline Summer 1992 Baseline Total - - Mitigation Winter -- Mitigation Summer - - Mitigation Total Figure 12. Number of fish taxa by sampling station during the Whitehurst Creek baseline monitoring (1992) and mitigation channel monitoring (2003-2009). Note that baseline monitoring included three stations and mitigation monitoring included two stations. Fyke nets were utilized beginning in 2003 due to an unconfined channel from elevated water levels. The 1992 baseline data are depicted across all monitoring years for reference. 12 10 8 x - - - - - - - - - - - - - - 0 L 6 d - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - E 4- :I Z 2 ------------------------------------- 0 1992 2003 2004 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 Sample Year - 1992 Baseline Station 1 - - -1992 Baseline Station 2 - - - -1992 Baseline Station 3 ?-Mitigation Station 1 Mitigation Station 2 9 • Figure 13. Cumulative number of fish taxa for baseline monitoring (1992), mitigation channel monitoring taxa in common with baseline per year, and total taxa collected during mitigation monitoring (2003-2009) per year. Note that baseline monitoring included three stations and mitigation monitoring included two stations. Fyke nets were utilized beginning in 2003 due to an unconfined channel from elevated water levels. The 1992 baseline data are depicted across all monitoring years for reference. 25 20 M x 15 w 0 a? 10 0 Z r i i 5 E • 0 1992 2003 2004 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 Sample Year 1992 Baseline - - - Cumulathe Baseline - - Cumulative Annual Mitigation Figure 14. Number of fish captured by season and annual totals for Whitehurst baseline monitoring (1992) and mitigation channel monitoring (2003-2009). Note that baseline monitoring included three stations and mitigation monitoring included two stations. Fyke nets were utilized beginning in 2003 due to an unconfined channel from elevated water levels. 400- 350- .T 300- Z 250- 200- 0 d 150 a 3 100 Z 50- 0 1992 2003 2004 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 Sample Year ¦ Winter ¦ Summer ¦ Total 10 • Figure 15. Annual percent of total tolerant fish taxa and piscivorous fish taxa captured during the Whitehurst Creek baseline monitoring (1992) and Whitehurst Creek mitigation channel monitoring (2003-2009). Note that baseline monitoring included three stations and mitigation monitoring included two stations. Fyke nets were utilized beginning in 2003 due to an unconfined channel from elevated water levels. The 1992 baseline data are depicted across all monitoring years for reference. 60 - M x 40 t v 30- 20- 10- 0- 1992 2003 2004 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 Sample Year - - 1992 Baseline Tolerant Species 1992 Baseline Pischerous Fish 500 Total Tolerant Species Total Pisci\orous Fish 11 Figure 16. Monthly water temperature in the Whitehurst mitigation channel from 2003- 2009. Data provided by the PCS Phosphate environmental department. The gap indicates missing data. • • 35- 30- 25- 20- B 2 w 15 a E 10 H 5 0 M O M O M O ?t cr O O ?h 4 O O (O (O (D 4 O O O ti O O ? CO O O CO O ao O O O O) O O f4 (C N ? N N c f0 N N fT0 N W N N ? f?6 N (0 N N Date Figure 17. Monthly dissolved oxygen concentrations in the Whitehurst mitigation channel from 2003-2009. Data provided by the PCS Phosphate environmental department. 16 14 - CO E 12- 10 10 a? x 8- 0 6 0 4 N N 2 O 0 CO O CO O CO ?F 4 O 4 v LO 4 O LO U) CO t0 CO ?? O O 4 O 4 O h 4 t? 4 o0 00 O O 00 rn O O O O O O c co ?, ca a c ? m >, m a c m to >, a c >. n c m a> ca m a> ca >, m a m c >, m m a c ?, a m ? m a> ? ? cn ? g vi ? g u? ? g cn ? ? cn ? g vi ? g cn Date 12 Figure 18. Monthly specific conductance in the Whitehurst mitigation channel from 2003- 2009. Data provided by the PCS Phosphate environmental department. Note that specific conductance measured by CZR during the 1992 benthic and fish surveys were below 520 NS. 4500 • 0 4000 M 3500 v 3000 2500 c 2000 1500 1000 d 500 0 C''> M M ' I t ? O LO MW 0 W ? I- ? W W W m m m o 0 0 0 0 0 o Q o 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 >, a c >, a c >. n c ?, n c ?, a c >, a c >, a m co a> m co a> m m? m tv m co ca m co m a? m m a> ? g cn ? ? cq ? ? vi ? g cn ? ? cn ? g cn ? g cn Date Figure 19. Monthly pH in the Whitehurst mitigation channel from 2003-2009. Data provided by the PCS Phosphate environmental department. 8.5 8 2 7.5 x 7 CL 6.5 6 M M M "*' 8 q In 0 0 CO fO (O ti ti h 00 00 01 01 0 0 9 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 m aci M m m m c>a m m m 0 M? aai m o 0 M m m Date • 13 • • • 6 E 5 A N 4- 2 L 3 CL U) O L 2 a ea 0 1 H 0 M M M ? ? ? ? ? ? (D (O (O ? h h 00 00 OD O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O Date Figure 20. Monthly total phosphorus concentrations in the Whitehurst mitigation channel from 2003-2009. Data provided by the PCS Phosphate environmental department. Figure 21. Monthly flouride concentrations in the Whitehurst mitigation channel from 2003-2009. Data provided by the PCS Phosphate environmental department. Inaccurate data was omitted from analysis. 2.5- 2- 1.5- m 0 1 0.5 0 M O M O M O O LO 4 O 4 LO LO (O Q O O co co I- Q 4 O co O O O co 4 co O O O O O O O N m N m m N m m N N m Q C M N N m 0 m M N ? U 2 Cn W g (A Date 14 • Figure 22. Turbidity (NTU) depicted monthly in the Whitehurst mitigation channel from 2003-2009. Data provided the PCS Phosphate environmental department. Turbidity data collection began in late 2004. Gaps indicate missing data. 0 • 100- 90- 80- 70- 60- 50- 40- 30- 20- 10- 0 M O M O M v O O v 10 O O to O tO O (fl O (O O O O O r- O ? O O O 00 O CO O O O O O rn O T gy ? ? ?' L (0 ? N N f p ? fC fp ? p ? fD (0 ( ( 6 f0 N N f6 ( 0 Date Figure 23. Salinity measured at fish and benthos sampling stations 1 and 2 biannually in the Whitehurst mitigation channel from 2003-2009. Data collected by CZR during fish and benthic surveys. 3 2.5 w a 2 a 1.5 c 0.5 0 M O M O O tt O to LO (O CO O O O O ? 1? CO O O O CO O O O O O L L L C L I_ L L L L C C C I_ L L L CD C C L I_ L L a) a) C I_ > > > > ) CO U) CO U) U) ^ Season Salinity Station1 Salinity Station2 15 r ? LJ APPENDIX A • AQUATIC MAC ROI NVERTEB RATE TAXA DOCUMENTED IN UPPER WHITEHURST CREEK DURING THE 1992 BASELINE AND IN THE WHITEHURST CREEK WEST PRONG MITIGATION CHANNEL DURING 2003 THROUGH 2009 SURVEYS 0 >+ co E m x m H O O 0 N L rn O O L M O O N E 7 N c m c a c c c0 L U c O c0 rn E m c O a N m Y U L N L O L c N c0 L N O O a) E 7 rA c ca 4) c Y U 3 L O L a a O E O c am E D U O 70 w U N a m ui (`0 O C > c 0 0 U D ro r - E c0 o d - c0 c0 Z 7 Q O Q c0 x a O c -p N a? CL L> <.E c0 N ' I x, ' I I i I i ! I i i xl IX I I i I ! I i ( ? I I xix I ? ' .I I i I ? I ? i j xI x? I X ( iX ? 7 I! i I I I I I j I i I I i I I I I t I ! O ! t j ! N l > V y l j : I ?? I I I I IXI ? I I I XI I X I X?X I I f ! I I I I I IXI X I N ? l i ! j I , I j I ' I ? i i i I I i ! I I ' j I I I I i I ! , ! I ? ' ? I I I t i ' L ' D 1 I I' X ! i l l i ' I I I Ixj ! f ' I I I ; ! ! I x Ix. Ixl I xix I I x j I I! I i I i I I i i I ! ' I I ( I i i ; I ' I i ix; XI I ; a x O I I j 1 I I I N K j l l i I i ?. C X _ IXI IXi ? x' ( xix xI I I IXi x; X I I ! i ! I I i j I f I I ! I I ' I ?' ' i i I i 1 I I i I i ? >L. ! 'X I I I I I 'X; ! j ' ! ? j XI iX I XIX j I j I ;! ' i i i I I 1 I ' j t Xj I IXI jX;X X j IXi XjXlx c 0 O E : ! ! ! O L ! I ! 1 : i ! t i N I I ; I ! LL y c ? . XlX' i, i I I Xj !X IXI ! i I XIXI 'XI IX ' X X I I i j I I I l j?! I l i Ix' IX; XjX ! (X i ? ? i. l i I j i( I I I'! i l l l I I I >` ? ; I x' ! I! I I I i l i i i I l i? l i l ! I l i i I I l I I I I ( I I I I j l I i I I I! I i I I I ', l i l j I XI ! I IX '+ (D o 3 N ; I I I 1 I I i i i I I i i I i j I! I i I I ; N r. I j l l I I I I j o y X; Ix l I i ?x ? l XI 1Xi I ix l j l : L XI iX ? X' ! I i l I I I xl 'xl i I !I ! I IX I ? C >% ? cn i! i l l I l l ! l , I I II I I? l j II!? I l i N ~ C jxl I l l x X' X! 1 I j 1 i I I I I I 1 I ix I I I I j IXI x ix, x I j Ix t I j I I 4 i i I I I I '' j I I I I i j i :. i! ! I I I I I I I! I w I I Il i a ? j I I ! I j i I ; I: ' ! ! I l ?xI I I, I i Ij I I I j l l ; i ? I I I I I I i I, ix I I !, i I I' I I ? ? I j i ! I I ; I I I I ix Ix! ' j ix xl -a N I ' o o? ! ! ! ; I i I i I I i I ; I ; N Q ? ,? I I I i I l I I ! ? ? I i 1( i l t N ? C ;XI I l IXi xj I l i ?xj ( X i l I I I IXi I I X ? i I i ' s i I I I I I I I i i 1 i I I ! I i 1 i, j ? I ! I i i I I i i' j l l I i i! I I I cG d '' i I I I I I I I I Xi iXIX I j I ; I I i i I I ? X I I iX I i ' i ? i I I ! i i i I? I j! j I ? I I I I IXI I Ixi xi i IXI iXi IXIX N ! I ! f I I j j C-4 L I ! I ! l ix ! xi ;xix I i j I x I XI 1 jx ?X? ?x;Xl X 1 ; ? I x(x! xlxl I l i j l: I 1 i ? I I , ? I i i 1 xl I ! I xj i I ? I i i l l l l ' ? I I I I i i Xj I xl Ixl iX N C O 7 y ' i I j l ! j i I I j ! I I I I i j I I I U) j 00 ?, C X!X Xi i i l l i l l I I I I XjX I (' IX I I I I ' j I j i l I I i I I I I XIXiXI I I jXl I 'X I i I I j l i j i i I I I I i r l I i i I I i I I I i ? 1 a i l ' I I O a! ! c0 1 i I I I I I I ! i I ' I ? i ! I I I i { 1 I ! i i OI j I j ! j Co I j I Q i?' iro i i ! I N ' I I a O ?I AI , `I OI NI 1 0 N ? i I t I? I ? I? I I I i ? l I i I i I I ? jam' O? i I OI ! i I i I c I ( !? O! 4 o ° ? I I O I U ? ?ci'? io,m ' I ?_ I? m o U Lj C m i a I 101 ro ?' 1 N I'S ro c I dal o ; a- Cl aj cn q) co ro CO .i co c n., j c 9 j I I p E 14I p a m L I L O I m c ml I Imo! c co m I -OQ U ca m E o l a ? l O>' I d E ?n lro?laira ?I? ) o ? 0 CL ci m t ) m 3'3 a rn o _ oma alcnlE_I p x x k A I 0 c ' ' c M l m I 0 L m -0 al l kid s O cn U wl om co co ci ° C) 4.' co ml y .? -0 O O '?I m m fl ;2 .c k c o y m m m p U a (D co a CO ? o' 0) k roiC? ti .4 ro a a Q cn 3 cn ? -co C ?' p a! a a o I U U ° co .m .m , m CO p a ? i o a a ° CAi L O p o p co p -a -0 l a- c U U to ro Co .ro cu C E G a g a m ro m a c l a> E 3 i i i n+ a ° o o z p ro m . n ro U ")I ciII U p E Q) ro! ro `y 2 ro ro ° m y O m m ti z co O o N al E °I D = co ?I? c Q m m U , p ? k c Q NI ?t.c .c •cn t c cl c c_ ° m U C ` ?'? U UI I? m c! 1j F- Q IUIU UIO Q. co U- U- U' U' U' a . UIDJ I IJ Z I-II- U U c Q i Q c c 4 0 QI00 U W i?WIWIW W E W I ? I0 J JIJ Zla ' ' I ? ' ' I ? ! I ! Nj i ! ! ? I I ? ! I ' I I cc I CL! I I cc ?j I ? I I ! N m; Ot a>I c a j j 3 m j I I Lt p' ? C ' ' 7 i L I j O ? I I I 1 I I ?I I i OI I LI CL WI O O _ O fl = I I I I I I ? I ! I Q 0 0 0 N 7 C C U Q X c O 0- a Q L d I ! I i ? ! ! I i ; i ! I t I ! I I ', I I ,' ! i ' I i d 'x' XI ' I I I X I xl I , j I I I! I ' I I I I ! I O i L ? N ? i ' I i l i I{ i;! j i j I I I I ! I I I C N ! ! I I l l ! I I 1 j i i 1 X : i I i i ; I I XI lx ? ?, Xi I I ' l i t I! I , i >C1 jXl i l l 1 I i I I I ?XI 1 I I ! ' ; i I I ;Xi i I I 14 I i i? I !I I I IXI IX' o°' ? j j I I I I I j i l ' l j ' N ?' ? ? I ', I I I { ? i I I I! ( ! ? I ! ! I ! I I I 1 I I I I I I ? I ? I 9 I ` ? I 'I' j I I I ? I I ( I I I ; I i ( I I f i I N xiX. •. I ? X•?! !X{ ! i I I I I ! i !Xi ( i I I •',. I ' i I I. I IxXlx, !X I I I I I ; I ! ' I i XI , I ! ',, I ! x ixl j I i I I I I ? I I i O°' y i II I ! I III l i? I? i N , I I I i I i f I C XI Xi I i , ' i IXI ! I ! (x, I I I iXi ! j j I i I I i ! ! I I ! I I I I co iXi I 'xixi Ix; ! 1 I! I j l i! d 7 i ! i I ! I i i I O' er ' I I i I I i i I I I { ' I I I I l l (? ; I I I I I I l i I j LL C xl • I iX! ', XIX X I i I t , j f i I . 1 I i I I i II I I i I ! I i! , i i I ' I I I i I I I ' t I, I 3 I ? I ! i j I i i { I ixl I i i ? I{ IxX; I I ( I I { I j! I ! I I I i I X' I I I d ? I I i I I I I ! i I I I { O? I ! i I I f I I I O? N ? , I i? I ! i l! i l I i l 1 l i l ? I I I I I i, i 1 1 L ?- d C ? 1 ! I I i i i I I { ; i I ! i x i I i '.XI I '' i i I i x' I , I XI I I x I ? I I i ' 'I j ' { 1 I I ! I' I I I I I I i ? • I ; ' i I l i i I i i I! i ' ! 1 I I I ! i I • N L N G ? ' ' I I I X I I ? i i I I I I I ! { i ' ! I I' { I i I I ' I , I I 1 i I ! i I i! I I X x l ? I ! i I I ! I I I I t 1 j I I 1 I ' ! i , '? I . I I I X{ ? ! I I . I I I ? ' I. I I I i I I{ I I I I I X ! X j ? C o { I I I ! , I I I I i I I? 1 i i I l i I f I { i I l i! I I I I I I I i ! ? ! i I , I ? i O ' i i I I I l i ! i! I I I N I f I V y C ! I I! I i IXI ; l ! I I I I i i I ! I ? ; I j I ! i j lxf i I I I I i I I ; i i I i{ i I i i ! I I l i t ? ! ca ? 1 1' I x!x) I i l i l' I IX , i I l i XX! l l I i 11 1 x i! i 1 I xi Mp I l i I ! I ' i ( I i ( I { i I I N +r I i I I I ! ' I f 1 ? ' I i I I i I i I I I f ? ! ? I I I I I I ? l l l I i L 41 ; I i , i , ( x i ! i ! x x; I j ! i I I i I I' I I l i I L ? I I I t I ? 1 ! I { i i ;xixlxi I ! I I ? j I 1Xj i f I I I i ix I ' I I Ix ? i I i I i I I? I lll i! o, N i ? I m ? j I I I !ii I I!! ! (I illl I I i li,j l i c I Ix' 1 1 1 ; 1 1 I ! I ?? I , ; x i { 1 1 I I I I i ! i l i i i l l i i i! I I i ! Oi I ; i I ( j I Ol ? ? ! C a> y ?) ! 3 U N col w a c ml ! C o Ei Oj c ?- al 1 WI ; i N c 1 I I _ I C I <a O co a I_i• a MISI NI U) 'Z k w I U { ?I ICI I ?i y co v o OI Q p? ` i al . OI O U, ') O o! Q . i cn n aD ca O a . d j i I a l _ o o C ?I UI m m cO I .- o o o ° cO ail ?;I W 0) I ; 3 t I I mi U cli Z C j•O I o o w a. I C ?? a>. U) ca m N I E CO CO r F (O NI c m ,co »r E N m . ? a QI vai; CO) - := ca V N Q .m aril k xl a 0 L L (n ?I aI a rn is i =? I d Q w E a y I ?.: N Cl) l U) ? i L L L N N! EI N N ca N N ca 0 O a I z : 0? 0 N cu O N N 70 > N > L) , z i m m O O Q) > co I V V Q (n y y O y v) CO O O j :? w .0. L I a I O m ( CO U N ca K w I O Q QII Q C 'iI p ?) ?I E i v1 > O I CO v1 O O i •X 0 0 •c ca 0 y U i U ca ca I 0 0 . + L O O C c CO cu O? O O t o m O D = a) Q) :3 p p p cn I c O co ro c y ti 1 0 O O C a O O y N N O I c 1 CO m F- L N l i >„ >,I >, O aja1? cnicnicnl?- Q G> Q Qlm N N lm m N O O N N m o cD N co ! N O Z O z O ca co a a!? C U 'L '` i N tile- i-I> a O co O) N a ":K! Q m O N N I N m mU Q Q Q Q O O O >, > U U UIU?U N I .? o'0 ' i; yy 1 ! I I i i i l 1 1 I { I I I ' i i i I 1 I ? i i 1 f I t i ! I I I i I ! rO I , I; 1 ? i ? a. •?, . I i ! I I I ' j I I ; ' ' i i I 1 i I I ! i - al I OI i i ' I ; i I = I 1 I 1 ? I I I I N Q C C 0 Q X C Q CL Q j I ?. l I I ! 1 1 I i I i i ,I ! I I I i I I 1 1 ! I t l I I I ! I i ce. E I I ! x i i ix ?X i i I Q d ! ! I I ? co i ! I ( I i I I ? I I i ! ° c ! ,' I C I I ! ! , I ? I ! I I I I! I l i l I G>1 CD C l 'xlx! . I IX! I I i j ! I ? I XI t ! I ? i ? I I •I I I ? ? j ? li ? I I ? I I I ! ? i I ! d I IX' X1iXi XI ! ! iXII ( I I ! I I I i IxlxixIx' l I I I X v l I 1 N co l i I i j i ! i ( I j CD . I i ° r N x ? I I ( I ! I I ? i ! I ! 1 I i I I I I j ? i ? I I I ! `. ! X X' ? I l I 1 X I I !' I ! I ( I X I x I , i I X i " I 1 I i i i ! I I? I I I i I I d i I I ! ? i i I i I i I i I I ? i x I I!X I I . 1 1 i X !i ! i I i i XI xi I N E ( i I I o ? I " I I I ? ? 1 1 t I i N I I ! i t I LL r I I ! I I I jX j I I X ! i I C i i I i '' I l ! I ! ' ? I ' i I I! ! a L y ! I , I I I I I I I i i xX'X I I I ! I I I I ( I I {x; I x ! ! ( I . i i i I I I I I? I I I I 1 xl IXi I I i I ? ? i ' x x xl l i l i ? E ; i i I o in i.! I ; i l i i i ! 04 ? I I ' i I I ' N ?+ j I j I 1 ! , ! i i ! I i I I I X ! I I I ! I I I I i ' f i' I I j I I% I I I 1 I i I I i ! I. i i I I! 1 I i L , !'! l i l ! ' i I !! I ' I i Ixi I I I ? I 1 I i I I I I x? i I IX! l; I I i 4) cn j I !; j i I , I I ° N I I ! ! l I I I I ! ! I I I I I i I IX I I i I I ! I I l ? ? l i i I I I I ! I! I? I I i ? I I I I! I!" I I l l i j L I I I ?1 j I I ,II I I ? ? '? ! I ' ; I I ! I II i ! I ? I i ? I I il Ijl ' I i ! (40) E I X! I I I ! ; j X I ! I X I I I X i? I X I ' I v I X; I ! ' V p V U) ( 1 1 I I I I I ! I ! I I , I I I 1 I 1 I I ca 4) y 4) c I I ! I; + i I x I I i i ! ? i j ' I l ? l? l! l ?!; 1 ? ? 1 1 ? i j l l l I I o f i I i l i I j x! l i l I I ! i j I I i ; ? ; I ? I X; i i i I I I i I ( i I! I I V I !X? Ix ! I ?? I ;XIX x! ! C"! d C5 7 U) ! I I ! ; CV U) l I _ LL C x ix! ! ! x I I X' I !xl x i l i i ! i ? ? X 1 1 1 1 1 a) E xl IxI jx ! xl (x j Ix!x!xl I x) Ix; x 4) I j i I I i I l l I l i i m , ?? ? i i ! ? ; I ; ? I i ? ; ? I i I t • ? ; , m ? I I I I I II X I ! X I I ! ! X I ! ` ! ? ti II X I X 3 ; ? i I ' I ! ! j l ? I I I ? i ' ' I I ? I I ! I j i i ( ! I I ! l I '! I i ? ' ??, . I I I ' I I I , i ! ! I I! I ? I ! I I ? I I I ! i I I.! ? i ! j ' ! I ? I i I I ! ! 1 ! ! ? I 1 1I I I! I I f I? I I I I I l I I I? I I I I ! h '? ! I I ' i ! ( I I i . I I I! I I i I ! I fn i I C 1 ! ! i co l co . O +-• I co co O ti ! c?0 0 ::3 1 ? ? ? I I= +. i t I i I z co Z 0 0 CO I ? ? ( I ! O t?Bl I ?l ?i I j y +•.. Q?? I '' ? O O co .? L c0 i 1 ?„ t c QI ? y .?? i 1 w ?( m y Q Q .w N ' ( co of p +0 co i U 1 O O C l o U m j ? U y O I E( I a 1. co o, oIE -! y co -Q l a U) ( N o I (o a !s al ?-,? EI °•' '? Q; I m' E co U) 0) I o al a, m 0 Q of ? .M- u°iI a CU Q) (0 I= 0 c ' Co °'?- Q J-- a? olal? a"i affi a o 0 0) ? I CO U co co ?I 051 z 03 co c ?- N ( N L 0- lq ti+ N a (0 O' co co w CO) :,3 ? z L O 3 o o m o Co ? h I I A I L- v. O ` l co z I = M U co O C, 0 0 "? y'o I n U L N N NI N N N ; U O O C L L ? O U' I d E iI L N r O ? 3 i? o •o .? w"', I z - O moooC co c a !?. `? cc .U 8. U Q a a a °> m I Q! 0-1 O co o 0 0 0 0 o a o 0 0! c z ti E U S, ?, ! S S,1 U: O 42 a a a ala a 0 •. E ' o I E ? y ?? yN .y CO W o y L a m x ,? 'n cu U U ,4, .4..4 -z o oc a,a c m m l 'm o ?, ? I L o m aaaaaa-a ° a m a U U >, ] O ?, , 10 N O I" 0 o O 0l0'o c cs _ o o 0 O === .. .. 1. I.° o m Q? a? O N N N N( N 'i I C I C O m C , Q 4 o : o i L Q L a a o c? m o co L 3 L p F- 0j01W W ={=i= =±=I =I=,=I=I= ! J J =i=I=I= ? Z Z ??ala a v ? ?- ?- ??-I?I? c? I I! •; ! • i I i I IiI ' '' I i ! i i j; 1! I i! ! I I I I I ?I ! I I 1 I I I I I ! I ! !! ! I i? I i" ? i ! I i !! I I I'?, ! c0 3 I I I i CD N I '' ' i i I ' . 1 I I! I l I I I I D 0 0 d c 0 Q X c N a a Q y ! I? !i I i I I I ? I ??( j ', I i I j 1 i I m 1x IXI i ' I j 1 I XIXIX X, fX? j C ;X! ? I d j i I 'I I 1 I 1! I I ? I ? ! ! 01 O -? ?' I i I ' I' i I I I I 1 I i i ! I I I I i j I I O ' N C I ! ! i t I I 1 I ? I I I ' l ! j y C ! l i l i XI ?X? I I I I; I i; ! I I ? I I I I ! i I 1 1 ! ! ! i, XI t ? I! I I! I I I i I L N I I I I ' t ix IXI I I ', '' I! i j IXI IXI i I?! I I I I! I I?! _i !! I i Xi IXI I I IXI ! ! I' ! IXI i( I? '. I? I i I! O co l l j I l I ! I t i O Z N K I I I i ! I I I 1 1 i I ' N ?, I I! I Ixl x'Ixl ix' ? ? I !! j ! ? ? IX ! ? ! I i! fix, Ixi I 1 ; I j i ? I ? I I ! I i i I I I I L (, x xl , IX; Ixi 1x? x! xl x x N 3 I I I 1 N $ ' ' i I I ' I LL L d i ? ?I I I I i ' I ? i I i ! I I ; ! I I I ! ! I I I i ? r+ C ? I X ' ! i I 1 I j : I I ! i j I I I I I I i 1 i! I I I L ! l i t 'Xi X I I i ': ;I I I ? ! !' I Xt C I I j j X! i I ' ! I I ? I I j i i I ! I O Z ? I I i I I I i I ? I I i ? ! j I I f I I I ? N t ! I ! i ! I I ? i LL C IXI IXI i I j X i! I j I I i ;xl I I I I 1 i IX! X I i I I I. I , I I ? j I i ? j i I I I ? I I ? I L d I I I I I xlXi I ? i I I I I I I I I I ? : I i t ? ! I I iXl I ? d > o = CO) ??I!I I l i III l Ali i l ! I I I l I , I I N? L ! 'I j I I ? I I I i? I I i i I I '? I I! 1 I' a+ C ! I ! I X 1 I I ! I X X I X I I X i ! i I I I I I I 1 j l i , l I I 1 ? 1? i I I' I I I I I I ' ' `a d L y E i ! I ?, I ;X XIXiXIX I I ! I I I i 1 I I i I ! I ? 1 ! 1' i l i ! I ! I I X ' I I I I I I ' I I : i ! I I i i ? i I I ;XI I ?? ? N ?!' ' j I I I! ? I I i! ! I! I i I ! i I I I j ' i I I I I ?! I ! I I i o c j i ! I I I i I i ! N v (n L c l IXI X I j I xi xI IX I I X! I , iX I I xl xl I I I I I I I ! I I I I I xl I I I j I I I I Ix lC M d p ? ? ? I I j i ' I ??• I? I? ? i I ! I I I 1 l i ! I j! i? l I I r i I ! I l i I i i i j l ! I ! V I I N L I i I I I ! i I I I t I ' i i i 1 I I LL L r+ ?. ? ? I i x x x i Ixi , I 'I I I XI i I i ? I ?XX I I I I i I ! i j I I ! ! I I ! i ! i I i i I I i j x ! ?x?. I II ' ! I I I t I I I I I ' I i I I ? I i ' ! I d y 1! I I I I I I I XI ' I ! I I I I! ' ?X' I I I I i I I, I 11 i I ? j 1, i I XI I 1I i ? i I I I I j ? I I I XI IXI N c - I ! I I ! ' rn o? N i l! I I I i? i l i I I I I '; i I r I i i ! ! 1 1' ? I I I m L r+ c I j x X! iXl I I ;xi X 1 1 I I I IXI ' 1 ! I! I ! I I iXIX! 1 ?' I I I xIX?X X ? I I l i I ' I! I; I I I j i! I I I I ! I I I i I, I ?! ' I ? I i I l i I I i I i I !? -•. ? i ! : y i t I ?; i I I I ? I ! I I l ? ? I I i ? i I I l ? i I I I? ? I I t ! I ? ? I i c 0 I I i I 1 ; 1 I ? j j I I j I j !?I , ! ' I I j; Q y UI f j I t I h I (CO ( I t I I I 41 ?_ I 0 ! i vim. ! 'Q al i ; 1 m o OI ?I ?? y a' OI O; ? o c, I , OI co ° 0 O ti a I 0 Q! U OI N a cla U) l = i c c0i :?I CO 'er I O ! C ' _• c z 0 I?I alY' caI 1 r a t °' U ?I c rn' CL, a ? { 1 a l U) c E Z31 a ?J? ti ? c 0 O ! a ?I'a101 'L'a Q 0 ( ° w• o. I 01 cn 0 c: ?I c 1 i ?iN;0i o ?I _ 0 ` a co ? C) ' v?l.m U) co a ajc C)i0 Q 0 N W 0 ° 0 h h 0 010 0 (0 co E E E E 0 0 0l0 0 o I a 4 c c c Ixl !U) 0' a a ?' o ?ajc?°lo Ala I C/) c i EIE c =1 a, 01 v, N' o o U L N '? L a co a ?; c 0 (n cn rn v 0 co ?i ?' alE E Q 10' ' ° y w l n, . ?, 0 Q- ?•QI c 0 ' c ai .Q a a a a a c a o 0 0 d o •: ?, L c c I c c c ca y U a 0 j,) c c .o m :3 c) 1 fp I Si cn a 0 o c ° ?I ? UI a a a a a? 0 E er o O ?? c 0 c Q0 cI c c'c c , 0 ca ?; o? a a a ?I ° `? ,; , c l v E w ?I aai a o! ca o = R k m 0 1 0 Q 4 N -ca 0 ?I?I° °I? N ?' -0 ?I?I c c c c O Z 0 0 O O U O c c c .UI? I- O O C O 0 0 1 0 0L L L' I L U UI.U U 0 0 1 •'"' "" a Q Q, N 0 0 a ? c 0 0 0 ca ca 0 1 O k L 1 1 U 0 0 c i c I 4' Q =° I U 1 0 3 0I ca Lca (a Lcal ?, U L L O I OI 0 a ca fa m N O O s F- U U UIU;Q1 Q! Q; U?U!U Q U ?U U U UIU Q?QiO 0 LW CD (D (D (D (D =IYI?I? L. 0 IOIa Ala Ala alai cn p L i I I I ' ? ' 1 I ! II l l j ' I! i I I I i I I I I V i 1 I ? I I ! I I ' I i I• I I j I I ! I I ! I? I I j I ? ( !! I ; I ? I I ' i I I I I I j 1! ? I ' ! i I ? i i I i i ! I I I ? I I I !! 0 • Q 0 M U c 0 Q x c N CL CL a m i X! xi Ix x I xl ?x x x N o p E M 00 ~ O N C d ? ? 'I I I I O i lx? I I , I 3 ! I i '' ! ' I ' ` X ; I ! X; XI Ix d co ' ! 0) o ° o t!1 +d+ c X IX X, I ! I j ! I ?X O M ? i l i I I ! I ?' ' ? I ? I x x; X? ! i ? II I , I ix x ° N j N 0 ° o t (0 N ?+ O X x M N 1 I i j I I i M X X, i ! N N ca O Z co i i ! I I M (0 U') O O (0 N 3 ? I I O U. C XI XjXI XI N I i I o I ? t C) x U') co t6 d U) CN O ? ' I i i I I I I i ? ? O i N i 1 i I I i O L F- ? C 1 i X? l x! i ! X N I I ' I? ? I I I ? d i I I I j 1' ? i l I I I O N I I I co C M N O ? to c x;xl xi j rn i ! m x !xl i I I I x Cl) CV) M d ? ? i I i I I ! co O +' I I ce) oo O N I O LL ? ' i ? I I .. ? C I li I I i I i I ! I j I x ? N j L I I ' I I I I I ! I d jX Xj x x M O y N j O Q Q O co Z Z ? I M L X X IXI IX j i x M I i I I j i j j I I Cl) ! C) N ? ? t I ? I I U C y C ; I i I 1 m c ? Q! c I •U ' CO ' i a r4 r4 0 C cp I O O N p y ) I C V OI O; U, UI U I C I QI C, N U •y O 2 U I O •? C C C CL cn U ?i ?I d dl U (13 U (u co- dl C n o 0 i, C. O' N (b ?3 j y U i y l CI Q C O U d Q' U) U) (0 co Q N Q t? N L c C N O U ? j i I C QI O O O C! d O U (D ? h ca C •C i I C (U o7 ti E v> co x co co I h i (? h ?i 3 Ci C! C L f0 N L L !A N f0 .? ,y O m O C f0 N ? d rz O U C o -0 co O C Q' QI QI Q CU O +: a) Q) to ?I N =? co U Q I ti (?U c " L rL_ a) X lC c0 Q? CI C C' C C C : I N o7 I N N (0 tp c0 ? C C ns I N Q N C C U O O U N O L I N O N N C 2 L 2 c co 1- ! 1_ . I_ I ti ` a E- 1= U O O a I- _ = cn a Z CL O o w I i ( I cn cc N (0 >, E L N N c m d 0 d 0 C X p 0) - m y (D d m co m x x x c x w j I I d, o 1 c I L c o f0 w N o ..- (O a p a> L m ' w " w ' c0 cog m D j j V I I (Up I j 0) m E m m L f?0 Fu Fu V i f a Z Z 0 0 - 0 F- 0 1- -? o F- z 0 0 U) am 0 z LO a 0 • APPENDIX B FISH SPECIES DOCUMENTED IN UPPER WHITEHURST CREEK DURING THE 1992 BASELINE AND IN THE WHITEHURST CREEK WEST PRONG MITIGATION CHANNEL DURING 2003 THROUGH 2009 SURVEYS 0 M O O N L aT 7 O M O O N rT C '0 C C f0 L U c O N rn Y_ E rn c ^O LL N >O a> U L m >L 0 w C c co a in a? C .0 U co L N O O 0 L 0) c a N U N 7 L 0 >L o) a CL 7 c N C 0 7 U 0 '0 rn w N Z (n d N cn C L ? w U- 3 m a X ? .0 co m rn CL .N Q m E X X X X X X m E oM r CO) o0 N O N ? > fn ?% X X X X ? C 01 X X X X X X X X X X r co N 3 co r r ? N rs-. 5 ` _ N :: X X X X c `m E X X X X X X X X X X r Q :t, CO r O t LL X X X X X X 3 d L m E X X X X X a ) W >- E y 0) = (fl O N 7 ` U. X X N £ X X X X X X X d in :r' ' = co O LO O C N t ? c X X X X X X N X X X X X X X X X rl- m T ^ V CO rn Ln N 0 N X X m E X X X X X X X X X M N ? Q O co r r ti N N i7L N X X X `m £ X X X X X X X X X 0) _ (D .N 3 co O Z 0) W m ` ? X X X X X cn to 7 O > Z } Z Z } Z Z Z Z Z Z Z > } Z Z Z Z Z } } N CL d O E E E E E F- F E O Q E E E E E ce) ° 0 - F F F- F- F- F- Z O N ? U C ? ? c a _ in fB n Q) O cz y O O O U ca N 0 c O (0 O y co Q) 3 :14 C cri in O y L U) 0 N h Q co Q : :3 N CL U co N c h vj 0 N C0 co lw_- c c 3 c U 0) O U C , a? O U O = O 0 c7 O O 3 15 co o O 0 >; U 0 L O E Q O O c0 Q E gz U S2 Q y " a co co to O c0 c6 O N C IM -M W ?. O O Q L u O c E E O Z O E co O z c)) O N L L U N c O v? L cn Q N t i? , o o O Q - Q J a N O Q O c 42 E O O N a N a c cn m two Q co C CD O ? J U) J Q Q) W O O a) a) N N =3 N m Z3 (D cu LL -5 'Z3 -5 N 0) O 0 Q a 0 U) O m c w L p? CA L 0 C a L Q Q d d c v 0 0 Q 7 Q ? ? to c 0 :3 O s ` cn O -0 L p ` cn cn v1 to a- 0 d rU-- U _ . 0 C co c L C . V 0 U C G O E U C U 0 c - 0 2 U 0 Q L w L w L w L ? N d `m ? (D m° 3 a a) 2) D ) E ° m m m 5 'Fu E C Q E Q 0 m 3 O m O co 2 co m U c0 W . =(D CD O 0 0 CD N o CO 7 a j a ? co c0 3r L 3: L O O O O 0 F- F- F- F- Z rn c L U tr_ O U N c m CA (D c O L Y U 7 U 0 C E Q N ° a ° o N C U C C O ._ D =3 c cn <0 U CD 7 ? "O O 0 -o II 2 C o 0 -0- O 0 7 O C 0) U ? fn 'C OD E L 0 c U 0 o-.S w E II C co E U U) Z -00 r m