20100063 Ver 1_Mitigation Information_20100806

1111111111 Jill Jill FAST LANE
27949 - ?..._ _. _.
SAME DAY)
mm" mw r am mw 'Awft
` NEXT DAY
FROM S & EC
11010 RAVEN RIDGE ROAD
RALEIGH, NC 27614
846-5900
.s
PICKUP DATE ?a / PICKUP TIME
DRIVER # OF PIECES__LWEIGHT _
BILL TO : ?5HIPPER RECEIVER 3RD PARTY
CAR VAN ROUND TRIP CHARGES
PROJECTL);-1140+."a 11mo. YAII. ? ??
828-0303

TO #
COMPANY NAME d jd.}
STREET ADDRESSr ?`Jv.>ty `fc?`?d :i.
CITY .'-1?'?t STAd ZIPd'7 0`i
CONTACT NAME AGI I'}
PHONE # ri f. _

SIGNATURE S rk.? ?CyY? ?.tJ tv , fl .' ` (c 'I L? a
PRINT 4- DATE TIME
Soil & Environmental Consultants, PA
11010 Raven Ridge Road - Raleigh, North Carolina 27614 - Phone: [phone] - Fax: [phone]
www.SandEC.com
August 6, 2010
S&EC Project # 11404.P2
USACE
Raleigh Regulatory Field Office
Attn: James Lastinger
3331 Heritage Trade Drive, Ste. 105
Wake Forest, NC 27587
Raleigh, NC 27609
Re: Compensatory Mitigation Plan
Franklin County HUB Site
DWQ Project #10-0063
Youngsville, Franklin County, NC
NCDENR
Division of Water Quality
Attn: Ian McMillan/Eric Kulz
401 Oversight/Express Review Permitting Unit
2321 Crabtree Boulevard, Suite 250
Raleigh, NC 27604
i?Et
u
AUG 0 6 201.0
DENR-11h1 OR QUALITY
L11ETW1rDSANQ3TQR;rlYw'?TER BRANCH
To Mr. Lastinger and Mr. McMillan:
The Kerr-Tar Regional Economic Development Corporation originally proposed payment into the NC
Ecosystem Enhancement Program (NCEEP) to meet their compensatory mitigation requirements for the
Franklin County HUB Site. Recently however, we have been working with your offices on a mitigation plan
proposing preservation to offset some of these compensatory mitigation fees. James Lastinger of the US
Army Corps of Engineers (USACE) and Eric Kulz of the NC Division of Water Quality (NCDWQ) have
visited the site and concur with our proposed methodology. As such, I have summarized below the revised
compensatory mitigation plan for your review and anticipated approvals. In addition, we have provided a
sketch map that shows the approximate locations and length/areas of the perennial and intermittent
stream and wetland preservation. The property owner is currently surveying all streams and wetland
features on the site and at a later date we will provide the final survey and recordation of deed restrictions
for your files. As discussed, we anticipate that you will make receipt of the survey and recording of the
deed restriction a condition of you approval.
The Franklin County HUB project is proposing permanent impacts to 238 linear feet of
important/perennial stream, 120 linear feet of unimportant/intermittent stream and 0.167
acres of jurisdictional wetlands (permanent + temporary). The USACE is requiring
compensatory mitigation at a 2:1 ratio for 238 linear feet of important stream and 0.167
acres of wetlands. The NCDWQ is requiring compensatory mitigation at a 1:1 ratio for
120 linear feet of intermittent stream.
In order to meet the above compensatory mitigation requirements, the applicant is
proposing an In-Lieu Fee payment to the NCEEP for 238 linear feet of stream, the
applicant has a valid NCEEP Acceptance letter for this In-Lieu fee (see attached). In
addition, the applicant is proposing preservation of approximately 1,905 linear feet of
important/perennial stream, 1.67acres of wetlands and the adjacent riparian areas to the
extent of the eastern and western property boundaries to meet the additional mitigation
requirements. Based on site visits with James Lastinger and Eric Kulz, they have both
agreed to a 5:1 preservation ratio for the streams due to the quality of the system and the
owners willingness to place a deed restriction on the entire property not just the first 50
feet adjacent to the streams. The 1,905 linear feet of importanbperennial stream
preservation equates to 1,190 linear feet of stream preservation for the USA CE at a 5:1
Charlotte Office: Greensboro Office:
Phone: [phone] Phone: [phone]
Fax: [phone] Page 1 of 2 Fax: [phone]
ratio and 715 linear feet of stream preservation for the NCDWQ at a 6:1 ratio. The only
exception would be a 40 foot wide corridor as approximately shown on the attached
exhibit, this corridor will be shown on the future preservation survey. It is unknown if a
greenway will ever be built and unlikely that a utility line will ever be installed within the
easement but all involved believed it was better to indicate this possibility now rather than
to possibly have to modify the restrictions in the future. The approximately shown
easemenbcorridor would be a 25 foot wide permanent easement with 15 foot of additional
width to be used only for a temporary construction easement. This preservation area will
be protected by a recorded Declaration of Restrictions. The owner's intention is that the
remainder of the streams and wetlands shown on the exhibit will be used for similar
preservation mitigation at some time in the future and has no objection to that
understanding being documented in your approval letters.
Sincerely,
SOIL & ENVIRONMENTAL CONSULTANTS, PA
'I LL
Kevin Martin
Environmental Specialist
Attachments:
1) NCEEP Acceptance Letter-dated April 8, 2010
2) S&EC Sketch Preservation Map
Page 2 of 2
1-
f osPtem ggg
Y _ 7 ( . s. , . $ Tc . i I F.
PROGRAM
April 8, 2010
Ronnie Goswick
Franklin County Economic Development Commission
112-D Wheaton Derive
Youngsville, NC 27596
Project: Franklin County HUB Site
Expiration of Acceptance: January 8, 2011
County: Franklin
This is a revised acceptance letter that replaces ones issued January 14, 2010 and April 6, 2010. The purpose of this letter is to notify
you that the North Carolina Ecosystem Enhancement Program (NCEEP) is willing to accept payment for impacts associated with the
above referenced project. Please note that this decision does not assure that the payment will be approved by the permit issuing
agencies as mitigation for project impacts. It is the responsibility of the applicant to contact these agencies to determine if payment to
the NCEEP will be approved. You must also comWy with all other state, federal or local government permits regulations or
This acceptance is valid for nine months from the date of this letter and is not transferable. If we have not received a copy of the
issued 404 Permit/401 Certification/CAMA permit within this time frame, this acceptance will expire. It is the applicant's
responsibility to send copies of the permits to NCEEP. Once NCEEP receives a copy of the permit(s) an invoice will be issued based
on the required mitigation in that permit and payment must be made prior to conducting the authorized work. The amount of the In
Lieu Fee to be paid to NCEEP by an applicant is calculated based upon the Fee Schedule and policies listed at www.nceep.net.
Based on the information supplied by you the impacts that may require compensatory mitigation are summarized in the following
table.
River
Basin CU
Location Stream (feet) Wetlands (acres) Buffer I
(Sq. Ft.) Buffer II
(Sq. Ft.)
Cold Cool Warm Riparian Non-Riparian Coastal Marsh
Impact Tar-Pamlico 03020101 0 0 379 0.166 0 0 11,481 5,516
Credits Tar-Pamlico 03020101 0 0 758 0.332 0 0 34,443 8,274
Upon receipt of payment, EEP will take responsibility for providing the compensatory mitigation. If the regulatory agencies require
mitigation credits greater than indicated above, and the applicant wants NCEEP to be responsible for the additional mitigation, the
applicant will need to submit a mitigation request to NCEEP for approval prior to permit issuance. The mitigation will be performed
in accordance with the Memorandum of Understanding between the N.C. Department of Environment and Natural Resources and the
U.S. Army Corps of Engineers dated November 4, 1998.
If you have any questions or need additional information, please contact Kelly Williams at [phone].
Sincerely,
William D. Gilmore, PE
Director
cc: Cyndi Karoly, NCDWQ Wetlands/401 Unit
James Lastinger, USACE-Raleigh
Martin Richmond, NCDWQ-Raleigh
Debbie Edwards, agent
File
kutDYG;,?J... 'E ... Prot" 0" Sta&
? L,
RUM
North Carolina Ecosystem Enhancement Program, 1652 Mail Service Center, Raleigh, NC 27699-1652 / 919-715-0476 / www.nceep.net
• ?- - LL
a i a¢
rM'pg???rw a) U
IIQ x cu
ni er-_ + II U O cu
yire ti a? W' = 11 t II L r
.Tip a . A ,.y U U Q
co 0
* X .,n r>!!` ", } "! dY f ' I"'t }}"" y +14?' j 'rt .A?' fF 5 Q m •L ?? i,,,? Q
a) LL V " Rr
'r r
to J C
Y'?` 'E}? a .e ?''eel?i?,',}?a` 4h °„+4 r S co 0
"i q, LO
,?:;?'-+` tae tlo,. `? i 'a'li+` a?`,y sa, k -„ * •_ X
?4 cm
CL Z!
O x E ?rnp t?
co
:lz
a p! ??Y• ?' t y p _ ff•ff LLJ
00
0 < CL CU
c Z Z-, C:
, ,. , ^- Y.K A' ,?.. y. , _ • ,'x, 1? k y, w,•,v""?"?" ?, '?• .ice ` , -,yrO- C: L .id "d
R Y" it • A a %. 'R,?,'+ 33
tt "`*+iwi r t fi? ? a s 1a r: y ?i r, • CD Co (U Z) L2 U
ai.A+ ?,{'- ' M74+ .? CO
a) C:
L- 0 U)
Lm C/) Co CU
i+Ir??/; . y, k,5• srtv'ys x- F Q. z V Q? '7 O) ?}
tA?},?b" k p ; '.*J.? £.J. ^`«P a :? ?i O C L Q c •L ??" p
cu cn
cu cu
4 j. U)
a) c: a) cn
s r ?}?y : a? y y « tee { Cp
O
e- O /L?' N N V?
cn CD
? }FK '3F ?R 11 ¦i •F'•?
;k 70
w 4-
??< ? •? c: r ;.i ?y? „F$ k i .,?,..,? ° 'f J:'?gtr `V c O ^ O
.." ? P l f .1rir,!i *"?°'? . ''_ r', x _? ? i ??9 ` ??, ??' '` . f j ?`;,?°R:,` •? = Q CQ (J LL, co • ?r
0) 0 (D
r.fp s a
x?' '.haw y F ? x * fit, ?ys??•i ' { r prs 1?,: .? _ }?? 0- J a. ?t J
'd-ft- J
:jk
v; CT"
10 .1w
f `" €' • t+
ltwh i.
.t- JaA i
• ? fi
r r. ? tik c
YY
XMI,
-, b? f # ? t??• ,?'?iy. ?+r. ;`i'e?'? '??? ??- +'?. +e"i ?'lky?v`R. '+6 ?v?W`? f' j. A..? .? ????
qyyr?? T'?q'1 ..33„ p }? n:?r? 't p .tt py? N
at - +e`'ya".,µ, e°?t?w ..Fp \I' ;?"t`';?y i • `v3',?t.?` ?y.:?si'I'`;"?,. '? •fri'"3i!•'??*,&6*?!y'tk? 1«aF'''r?' 'sue.
f ?,. t*,k' ?,YF?,er. "A' yf `? <v:. ?.. a ,3t" ^•?M1 '°a. aq _:? --bY 'BI.w•', ?? 4 ,`-M1Rf kRr. ..{?..t y,..
. ,? f,€a.?,w.! ,? .. .. r, tv '?'?v .t+r "4'f 11' lk, *5`'"`?' =«, b y yr`' • { .; 4'?';:
7;! ,.4 Wt
c 'eRR`,?'#" ,.r n „a,"? ',.sr - _. N
>` ,° - _:?„ FPS. •w;. .vn.?, t,.416 2p fb +? •+B?'z,.. '# r n
-? fi a+a i .
a'?R?' ? '%?'tT•1r'b J?t,?y`.ri )??` .,` ,y-. ? i? ;ip,Y '! .6 .aS+.?: " hy? '?,'M' ?O ?, ?" .. ?if?I A ? /'''''
...gia w? t•9 0 2 ;yp i. ,?'4-.??''6"` t #- '9? -inn
rot i
m
ri.
::? f?, ? •rs.t -^' . ?.? ° _ "` ' ? i. ?'? a ? .??+ , off -
OWN
v i 4 ='. w c? °' r 'mac "'
? r s ?: ?' Y ??'" iH... ??? •` ? *w '1x '7` .P, ,}.? f di?:? r• F
a., ,'' Yr
4? IF
4
,k, .: rn 'y_ • _ ? ? ... Y ? ?, ?:: fin.
g Ey CN4g x o f `} • F s #+'S J C
o t °t W I (?
LL ir:
?IV 1 -°,... SN-_ Z
.r ' v'; 'D 3 J :w•[?'??'?l Tsn1 i¢.,i ?#°Ru '
•i
41,
4 1 `
•Y
e
LL-
44
+ddY b ; ' ' J? j .,,'!}t 'ra`n! ?' • ;k' My4 ? ?, tom.,. ?'? W.ML
y 1 Flt
P?A
rj ' yr ,.,b s;. ,+? ° '?'';, g •?'4 ate` fV- "?'
ey? 1 F-
?.,
t r
Alt,
'.A +' k C '1`iJ+&t••V4.'•. +?M'Y'
ry SF.• j(.'?IM?????n;? ? ?` ? h R ?;? 4i ? ? ++?????????.M i?? h?? R /f .. ? O
C? C\1
I- ?jl
y(?/ yes ?;., }xtwly S'4"_"x a>t
j -``? r T x }' is - o °
'All

A
t y
N
.W
> 1-14- -41-- X, -?-
ilk-
t-K
Oak Ride Y-
11843;!W V<Q' i ??lA* P ¢v* k a -cI? °?
SO,
M R ? ?G . ?, p y?'?a?, fi?.,.,i?r,....•:,;iC:rwa? .,.i'dlf? k'?' =r-,? ?
Gm= e43 --y ??+:'+% '?'?'` ~„' ?? ,?' ?J.?.S"r..f"'?°°j?''a,ar..`d p? *y`, `??: „?f:.,? -•.S
? tJ?l -?? ?Kw E-;? E'i.. - ° °???•`?°?LTZ? ? „-?t+?'!?'?_..?? ea' ?"."?'' '`4?':,
J' H4 5
4\ r C ?" '? ? ,. - ?$ ° ? 4._ ??i ?',; ls` ?'"fi.; ''114. r r .:? "•5r , ° "'1 ?
r 3 i' ST *? r-'sfr<tTMC
•
8\.+s}%' '' •pwr'??' _$µ?i -
? YM1 x #y,' - Rr'y is F+?,B'.:. 4?.. .E]7 g•fN ?P'Sf.ss- x '. .^a'?
7, 11-f?i 11
ii -'a .. ?i ?•r
t 4! ie t _ Y# e`5 Al h,4} Y F yc _ A "{ T 1
` '??. ? ? ?tH? ..t *r??, fG ?;,,°9' s "?'74.• ry ?•y;. 7•i "?. x#^??v' ?"??a '47r3 ? +R. ?`" ,? ?„. ':? +? '?'`; ??,'u -Y?' 'r??s?
4 4
1Ak:`.?
-fir .?^?i. V'" 7?'l?`,??,!? is m°` f et 'lK'gJ??';:'i d'}? •` DER ?'?•'Ck ???.r,
5 y
.? .!.' ?'? ?'?'SIIE'? •-,??' i,"d'?' ?'? ??«k tis#•t}?a?rC? `???"';??' yk'N??a?h'?'??'??c ,??? " ?.? `? ;?.?
r7N,? ? ?qti??, 14'?r*' .? r`t .Y ? ? ? w - ? r y?"?•. -' ?rF ??,?. ??7^?°?.% 'r '+rvtv`i..+s ?. 5.i r ? T ' ? ?;
:•? a z. fir' . ?+ ?,y *E -?'* ?q??vlt ,p??a+' t ,yl! ? y? '?y ? ,r a!. . • •••`I? w?' >?` ?? NA;II 6
?` ,wR < x t¢Es ` 1s 4 yT ''tr'.d" ?+q r", a f , 3 za. {•=r '+t"° t ..s ,? ` r ?, "" yyt r?y?.F,e
v ¢ ?"'?,?,? w x+4-6^"?r a?` iE. p ? y,? ,?1?k -r ! - ! • ? Fr€-s=
.? ... s. ' ? ?y?__. qd`?"'4,` ' ?? "..?° ? o ". ` 11' . ? ?.k?? ?r`?xi? +?y : •?'a k ys, ar <, .al? 3 - o s c ? y? ?+1 ?'s' r i
" ?„?,' g ?.?iF,? °3''?i+?,Y?",j?ii'yw a`'??TjF }``r ?1y?z&&""??`rr, ?„7Ta•/k•"e? +k' `'?`?°r',?`-?•'??#'"" ;k'° f,f _ ?`?,g E •?','?
e .?""? ` ',? r$ _ C # °? , A r •,{ _ E $[ ` , is vrf,"Its ?am i , vt? • `< '4. *+a `V.° J` ?".?° , Y44J
F,. :.? r?.. -.. ?°ti}'ae°'<?? ,,???t :.,r?? =?M????. •f ., .'a ,.;??x.' r' r?7r'"?+I?? ?+?.. . '?s?t?.??.CS °,-'?„?.. ,Z' - 4 .-?,+ ,€:.
F 4 s , i? f 5 ry .` a r.
1.d* 4r:?Ca?aEjie?-fib 74 4 :? '?4 > ??,s<+41,1? '=r/ f, °Fas? C y
Z^`m':" .X 'Y .r`.. l e `? v-.:-. ,.a ?}w o': X?^"'':'{il",&:. ?.??; ?lr',? E• ''? '"gyp j1•'?•,Ar?; s'?. V,aJl`l?a<.'
v' ._f'$ z'? E'? 'F.*v!
y
' ` s Je•' "gr ?':3't":,q f ? ? 1?IE'? ''?4 'i:-`. R' ? yy?C ?? ? 4 d1 . k q i? ?#'_ ? °' •3 R=? :t' ° z° in ? _ rN
r . }° . ,. s, t k 'G"x, H?,,;r,i ..,.? ?? `? .. '?.-:r+?,?"tR=" < f•,R?„ m q? ? ...r j , j d F ? « 5 ` .?bf 1.
w,R'4?r??+?y ?.1° `;? ? ???" ?q 7F ;• ,t;?, .'F` ±? . y ? ? ;'??.* R? ,ya ? a ?? b?_ <: ., _ ?, r °rn ??` a ? c ? j
,+p er o* -R -. a°tgk r, :... ,sue ry".pyF
t
?
a ?•'...t r P4.,`?_ fir, a:`,bFs'J .r\?'` "r r .;'+,. ss K?q:,s:}?- r7 a:_t.r?""'r4h ?t`?"ar , /';"'.: in r ''';`e ?F"":.
d ?1k+lr LL'3?
'? $' y?.'?. ` r "''v .: ? 's?. t ??• ?; 4 ?m , ,?4a'Y°"? '" ?• ,+ ?„;"? ?".?y?i a.°? d ,?-? E E *^ R?
? A <6" +?,? 1? r #? ? 's.nL' v ?q? P o? ?? 5 iy? ^? ? v ? •ev?' v .
rv,
? ??_? .?` rmta u m9''1 ?? E? '4?y? T?' 94t' ?t c?iml ,'? P• '??. i.,Y
5 JA
?"??/. `+1? .. O `^? a •' ? a rrT?-tz-<-t-.._ ? w ? ?,'?i. ?. ??s." .a E ??,."., e. Y? ,T ??? r
? T V
4At
?A'- ,?y}??? ?` t ?y? '•! r1 c0 : Ia I k ?1 l?MP 1[Y '?{? i???a??'?. .¢? 'fir '?' ? ?,
oz'111? SW
mxQ; ? - 11, 1 ?,i, ? t r far! •i-,'+. ?{ Y _ « I i ? ? ? .? ? s?: T -`?°'?" M??•?Fya: ?3 ' :??'.?t ?X ;?? :{ ` E ? 'o`+ ?,??-' ?, ??#""'%m*¢? = ' ?e5 ill+ii ?F,d"?•?+?[?
? 'O+Ir
W?F
E
.?'
14
mot fS
,wr
Ap,
Mitchell -i /?` • a? ' P+r ..?` T 1
^,` ; - _?1„ ?? ark .r"P,?1" ,r $-`e :,+• ri K ,< w`,:N " s° %
.,. ? !? ? 1 _.. ., { ?;?„? (r. . ??a?'; -y.. ? ?A... x?.•`rTe? :. .fr4?'?t ???+t°awarl'?' P?'i>? ?,-'. ??'
?, .? '? i* ,,8 :aa .. ??? '-?. ... ???nq t??t '1 ,f j? st.,.,'?? l?? , ??, -4'•?A' '.? s'... -rrx?`•`,Ky ?, "??'r°??? ?qp ,';
71
.r' ` * ? ,fir ', &S ? •, € ?- '?'
71
* # F* f R ?"w e
„Y .ti"
A r T
!Q b 7 v pA b IIV y ..•b `ti ?',v ''? +?' r., j +,- M'1.?,«r;_:? r? 4 t`` t a?'?"?• °
-'fglU
t' ?71G a-,.
A-e
Fa?
41
::. (Q ? ro ? e? o ? ? ? sF ? _N+` . P \\? / e , a I,s?.p' ,?•rs'??R ??•- £ ? y : '? w .`?tY l
w 4 a i nn? tf r • ,. y. Y sat.y
03
... to 1?'?`' ,?. ?.,:,-= r?? P ?.i"?zY.r? ?`7®."?.: .'. ? .° ?.C Rt•'''- s 4y.._?aj ?:< i6^.? L- -? - -