HomeMy WebLinkAbout20031554 Ver 2_More Info Received_20100505 (2)Chapman, Amy
From: Bob Zarzecki [bzarzecki@sandec.com]
Sent: Wednesday, May 05, 2010 1:19 PM
To: Chapman, Amy; Homewood, Sue; Ventaloro, Julie; jpayne@ncdoj.gov
Cc: Dawson, Amos
Subject: FW: Write up - Attorney Work Product - CONFIDENTIAL
Attachments: EPA Drinking Water Contaminant List.pdf; EPA-1,4 Dioxane.pdf
_ u .._ . _ . _ .. ... 0-1, _ .,. _ _..v
_ _
.:F. ;? ?. .a .. _ ,. ..._."?' _.i_ 1K
_.__? .. .. i.l .....
-es S US n
G(
"D 2 TO
S r a', S.
-a`E - c a' -
Bob Zarzecki
Wetlands Department Manager
Soil & Environmental Consultants, PA
This electronic communication, including all attachments, is intended only for the named addressee (s) and may contain confidential information. This electronic
communication may not have passed through our standard review/quality control process. Design data and recommendations included herein are provided as a
matter of convenience and should not be used for final design. Rely only on final, hardcopy materials bearing the consultant's original signature and seal. If you
are not the named addressee (s), any use, dissemination, distribution or copying of this communication is prohibited. If you have received this electronic
communication in error, please notify the sender by return e-mail and delete the original communication from your system. Thank you.
From: Chapman, Amy [mailto:amy.chapman@ncdenr.gov]
Sent: Wednesday, May 05, 2010 9:21 AM
To: Bob Zarzecki; Homewood, Sue; Ventaloro, Julie; jpayne@ncdoj.gov
Cc: Dawson, Amos
Subject: RE: Write up - Attorney Work Prod uct_CONFIDENTIAL
Thanks for the document Bob.
What are some of the health concerns with these compounds?
From: Bob Zarzecki [mailto:bzarzecki@sandec.com]
Sent: Wednesday, May 05, 2010 8:56 AM
To: Chapman, Amy; Homewood, Sue; Ventaloro, Julie; jpayne@ncdoj.gov
Cc: Dawson, Amos
Subject: FW: Write up - Attorney Work Prod uct_CONFIDENTIAL
Importance: High
_?? .:..
1.1 0 E- 'D
Bob Zarzecki
Wetlands Department Manager
Soil & Environmental Consultants, PA
11010 Raven Ridge Road
Raleigh, NC 27614
(919) 846-5900 Office Phone
(919) 256-4517 Direct Line
(919) 846-9467 Fax
(919) 270-2068 Mobile
bzarzecki(d)sandec.com
www,SandEC.com
This electronic communication, including all attachments, is intended only for the named addressee (s) and may contain confidential information. This electronic
communication may not have passed through our standard review/quality control process. Design data and recommendations included herein are provided as a
matter of convenience and should not be used for final design. Rely only on final, hardcopy materials bearing the consultant's original signature and seal. If you
are not the named addressee (s), any use, dissemination, distribution or copying of this communication is prohibited. If you have received this electronic
communication in error, please notify the sender by return e-mail and delete the original communication from your system. Thank you.
2
National Drimary DOW' '1?,
!ater Regulations
Contaminant i1 or Potential health effects from Common sources of contaminant Public Health
"T P }' long-Wrins exposure above the MCL in drinlung water Goal (mglLy
s: Au'.lon cle Nn'.om, system of Mood piobl ms. lidded to water dunug i cv*j;G •.:..
mc.ea>ed trak of cane sate: aaier uesim"t
alachloy ? ? j$ Evt, h.w hdn y m plem ptobterna; Runoff htan herbicide zeto
amcmu in, rdaKd ?s}- of cancer u-vd on row cops
r ntpwphoton ,. > tt<r.:• Inn?a'dW ofLvx*r PaoomofmMatdeposit of :.edan zero
°. mtmah thm are tadioacd-a and
ma Ludt a form of tadrapmt Imoan
Z ttrtootrv ^
t r :
LtrEaat in blood cholesterol, decEasc u stphi t•d37tho11
DtschargE fkom petrolaun r?iaetta
0006
. m blood st.par fnE rEtaldat114. GEItrmtr`:.. tlee0omcv
,
. . solder
........_._........_........._ __._?
e. •tleentc '" 4 ry tq, %hn damage or problems with i-mmIdLort Erostoe of nanil d"its, im off 0
vxtem.a+d,nw,have tctowed ltomoishrds,ruofrfrom do--jA.
'tak of getting cinon eleetromr s plodueuon.--rote-,
a : hestof (fiber, ; s `v '*mjtkk+
. Inwcaa-ed rul of dnrlopmgbentm
t
Da a, of asbesros cement it. Hate
? MET_
nucrorntiet") 1 (Yi mtesrnal polyps tutus, Most= ofraunal deports
s:
Wdiosavul9:systemoiie
p[oductrvc
Runoff from hetbladc mat on rosy
0001
ptobl?ms ,.tops
_ Bimm? tS I11uras.: m bloodptesa.ne Nklimtgt of rhdlmg .-Aste%. dticbarge ..
fora meul+ehnestei, erosion
..', of naft d dtpossm
s tjt A Anemia; deu:aac in blood letelm.
P Dtac
barge from fa.tont;.lrachtng
zero
t.tueased oak of eanoet from qas atmaec tanks and haadhils
-----
a' t3rn^,o(e)p?nenc
?r?', `q3r,? -,;
RPpmductm difficulties. increased nsk
Ltachmg horn lu mgt of water storaltt
A"
(PAHs) of-ncet tmh and dionbuhon ffitcs
w +' Betvlhum Y': tr tai- '? inttsunal lesions rimbaW. from metal t finite. and 0 004
???'i'; , ? i roal-b?u:4 !asto,tes dtachalge
.- = homdrf-'O l aat>,Psc. aitd
defense IDdaatntia
Beta photon Em ,? at?S})I+Q??.
"
'
f
? Incicmdmi ofcam' Decay ofnewal and man-midi r.El0
t
Fes
-
S
- ??11ee??cc?? of Ltnwn utnath thai set
d
h
- ta
iua
ttne.indmaS-soator;o+of
#
? Wiatton knowa sa pnototn ind Wo
-,-` radiator
Man Sibalaft !? ?lls Inma, ed ttsk of cancer Svptoduct of d m*W vacs dnintachon Zero
Cadmium 31dti Kldne} damage (0110.0011 of 52hatuzedpipes.00MOB 0OW,
of natural depnsrbt dtst?a ggee
f
l
i
iom:neta
tef
aertca,lttnoft heat
vast,. btareucs and patuh
C
arbofwan ___A_....?..
Prohlwm with blood, ner,oua s?strm in
Ieacbmgof wil fumtgantusalon ttst .._.. ........._.....
0?'
... .
s C alban tetrachlt.... z
..
, 17,ptoducare •;vsttu
._._-___ .
Lr a piobeau utawed task of cancer and shalfa
............... .. _._.._ .....__.._.-.__.
e hom chennul
Dulun
lain
d
f
V
I p
s an
gg
th
d
t
l
t
M Zero
< ?
J
- o
ain
us
ra
ac
t
tes
Q Chluramrves l+ I dY` Eyt: nose imiAbon, stomach discomfort Whet addinir used to coatiol M12DLG=4,
daitinw auctobes
l - ?hlwfiiue .... .......__..
Lain in m,sous ,rystem problems.
.__.Residue ofbamtra te[mtuctdt
reto .........
muoased risk of :anted
D chlmmc (ds cl) at1f1(xyLe{F?A Equttux natation, stomach discomfort -Ater KW,ti.o used to conWI MRDLG-4'
tmcloba
0 r.hlodmc dtoxtdc
?asC7O
1
t
?' a, 1ma, Infant+ young elnidrm, and tetusrb of
•
- Wad., addrtn: used to onuol MRDI (i°0 S'
t
_._._ r
'k' Ptegnam
vornm ncrsou SumEffi
R Imcanbes
a
(himtte ` +ya Anemia, infants, V W'% duldran. and letua v :,f .............
He rodutt of dnnkmg »met ... 0_f.
a thlerobenzene . ++w.
"' '-".- paegnant woma) . ncrsom system effects dtsinfanoo
. Lt.uutktdnrpeublema Ducbardti:ansfi-.mtedand agucultwai 01
t'bmmui.,,total
...
f}, I'
431ci
u didrnattns ctenucal facatttles
0tschtt
t from heel and
ul
milk
01
_.._ g g
p
p
,
erosion of mural depostts
LonP0i
?a YfiFK1tt -_: Shout-term eaposure Gashntntc Amal Corrosion of bou,ehold plunbmg 13
d,--nes+ Long-teirnwjim re incroi a.aems erouonof osnaaldeposits
s ]odfwv damast People •vah Wilson a
D
e
sh
ld
l
3 n
w
ou
consu
t ineu imsmtal
doctor Lf the amount of cappce m then
l
d
th
t
]
wa
e excee
s
e action
est
.............. _..._............._ _. ...... ._.. __....................... .....
!? rplu;.pa.dnon . __...... - _ ....... ............. _.
4hort-tam etposuc. GashomtevthW Aim. Hu mm and -u sl fecal zeste zero
• ,:....y. (e g,drurhes.soautmg.camps)
RN0 Bi?nfectarft + Inorganic Chemical Organic Chemical
® Disinfection Byproduct Microorganism a' Radionuclides
Contaminant
`
e c; erode
sa%7>'t'P. C}•87IldR ? ' rte-"
?`tT F
i
s. Dnlapon
'
m 12-Dlbiomo-j
1
1 +f .'h
?
s
61tr?opaue
1
1
(DHCP) M1
+f?
;
............
s' p-Dichlmowwi, i
............. ..___
s' 7,7-Drchta.odh n: s
?...?
nz3,r?•
s crs-i 2-Uxhlme? s
, ,, ,,,,,,,,,,,,,,__............._..... _
ttana-l2-
Dich10rodby1H:..
•' Dichlwomed=,
??
a? t3-Ihchlaa?ul? ?
a D7(2-uhvYtec••l
13142-cthvlhe*,1
phthalau
s' Dsn(mb
rTQ .. ......... ..
Doran (4 7 8- Ft
..................
•' Diquat
Endothail
• Endrib ; ..
._..__
s Ethytfxnreae
s' Fth.lene3tlua?a..',:
Fecal cohlimm sa
E cot,
Flaade`. _ _ ? -__ ? _
-.- - ......-.....
Giamm 1,1111bba
Beak drheasc (pam and teodarm of
the bontsi: children msy gat molded
Toth
Short-4crm exposure Gastrointestinal illness
(e.g msrtbta, vomiting. pumps)
W#tra afttive which promotes 4.0
stru.g teeth aaaon of natural
dcrovh. diachargc. from fahhm
and aluminum }attains
Human ad abimai fecal waste
ran
a Olvpl-t. i K>dner ptoblems repraductiot R.rmofffrom herbicide me 07
drffiwhta
H 5)1e aadr Increased mk ofsamer B)promit t ofdrtnkuig meta na'
diamfe-hon
s Heprocbla 4,uj4Qi ? na damage introtbed nak of cenvu Restdtx ofbanned terauhadt %ero
s Hephlblor epow +- f3 i Lr-,T dam igt, increased tul of cancel Hurakdown of beiaaehla
zoo
Hetaubaphtc pia:,:
cowd
( ) HPr has no hearth effeln, it is an
HPC' masers a rang, of bacteria Wit
? rkb .,., analytic method used to maastrcc the
mat ate naturalb pmem to the
' .
? vin set) of bacierta that are common to arztoitment
s»:'k>'
. roster. the "o the wwomtraaai of
-- baaena in •hukmg norm tht better
mamtamcd the nat% aymm is
Olsinfsctaw inorganic chemical ® Organic Chemical
® Disitifection Byproduct Microorganism Radionuclides
Potential health effects from
long-terms exposure above the MCL
Common sources of contaminant Public Health
in drinking wafer Goal (mg/L)t
Nets. a damage in thyroid piabltms Dlschatge from steelh"l ta?tunts 02
dtblhatp. from plasut. W katttlraet
factorie•
Kidnei, hvo, of a4 =&I gland problems. Runoff from habitude nand on rot 007
............. ......
.
..
.... crops
.
.
...
..
htinur kidne, • changes Runoffnom htrbicid, aced 9nn is
of way
Reproductive dffbculttes mateaStil ,ak Itn4off u.1mig ftom soil hmugaw
of UWAT used on smbearr- Comm lie ce"It •
.......... .................. and achdlds
Lava Iodoer; a W CWMW system DuchmRc from mdusn,al ch?mieal 06
problem tactmles
'moms, hs er, kidney or spleen dsmagc, Dvi hsige from indottial ehumaal 0 075
charges m blood
............_......_....... . ...___..... _.................... _.... faeto:leb
..... _...
Increased risk of tanca Entrharge from rndusmrl cl&imasl Z%O
factones
tier pi oblwnr Dtscha re.. from mduicirl chemical 0 007
fa,,twtes
Laca;tnilkms Dmchatge Bum mdusnlal chemical 0.07
factmte ,
._..__...._..._........._.._..._...._..--.._... .....
Liver problem, .. _. -
Lihchame f opi mdustnal • t anal
01
fxtoms
Lvet p obiens, mueased r;sk of-wixta ......._..............._......
Dlschargt from din and themlcal __.._.._..........._..._.._.......__..._.-..-.._.
Toro
factories
"zased,tbk of"acti Dibchatgl fluor mduirufal chemical a^.o
factor--$
.................... ..11.11-111111 ............... ----------------- .-..._...
Wakht i n itvn rroblerw.. m possible ........................... _ _- __..__
Dmiusfe from thomtr.ai twont r
04
repnahlcuse difnwines
ft wdu?uvedtfficulhtx,liverpmblvais, Dtcchmgcfiomntbb"and chemical zero
m .tAV d 13k of "W= tactmteb
R.eproducbscdifficulties Runoff from herbicide vied onrovheans 0007
?_._.- .__ .........._. .. ...
..
.
.
.. and , cgeubks
. .
...
_ ._.._.,......
.
.
Reprodame di ficulties, mpeasad tr.4 __......._.._._ ....._-- _ ... ._.._.?__._.......__.
Fmusiom from ,ask tmmetahon
Mo
of cancer and other u,mbusnou d1wharge
flow cheolrs.4 ibuouw
Cawracts Rumoft Fran hcrbipde use 0.02
Stomach and mtestuirl problem
._._._ ... _ ... _..". ___ Runoff from herb.wdn ust 01
laser;nublems
.............. .. ........ _... _ .._.._........._... ._ __ __ _ _._.._..._ ......
Rendae of bamta• rmecbt-ade
............................................ .. ......
0.002
Increased cancer nsk stomach problems Lnrhsrac from mdushtsf cb=c l zoo
factories, m mmpums of tome %ate•
tttatme u chemicals
1 [ IAvu in kxh.,! lnoblcm a chamgr. hom peboleum rchuus- 07
..... -_._---------- --
Problems,,sith liver, Stomach, t oduchvc Ihscbmgc from peuvleum tetmelles zoo
{ system, a kidneys lac Eased rok of antic
y Fecal cohforvra• and E of. are bacteria whose Humtan and amoral fall waste zoo
F?,
?=.:
' pTRaaL'e mtI1CYC1 that Ute Rater rfY'-' 11E t.OntamnfdtCd
9 r with human oi mmul Nasws Microbes in dw., viastas
¢ coati lauac bburl term effects, incur dh dtarrhu, taampr
munwi beadarhes M od•w s mptoms i'f•Ey mid •'po-,e d
?.. ,:..
+Fn.- a neabh ink fa mfants. ?o
pecta] ung children, and people
'
h
t
d
? wit
tre
m
y compromise
immmme wi tent
Contaminant _ Act or
Hesachlarbcn > 44-
...._.........
Lead
g ? tIs
mr:.
Mecur• (rnorg
.j
a' Memncycbka --
Ndrate (iotasun? .:> ""' {uy"">
- Nthog?n
Nitntc (meastuc . s c !--
Nttogea) q?
?Nb
a' Dcamvlt?ydea: -- ?-
a' Pwrtachhmgihcr
s' lhclotam
aPplychtminated D;p?^. ?-.._ ,
{PCBs}
Radium 226 and
Radrum'2& (cow _-Jf
?''• ", Selenium
Mae
r Srytene
s ?
i . Tttrachlor.....
lballtutn +
a'Toluent
Total Colifmm-,
Sam Iota] Inhalorai
(TTHMsr
To*aphenc
s
s' ; I-l,2-Tnahturoct? :ate ?° ??i 'Itichloroc"enc fi
a ? •r'
Potential health effects from Common sources of contaminant Public Health
loWterml exposure above the MCL in drinking water Goal (mg/W
_---- _...... ._..__.. ................... .._ ...
1s w or kidne•,• problem;. i.xroduchre Dw-hatae firm metal r d'inerie, and zM
dithoudtx:: mur:asednakof,anctr ag olturatchcmtcalf lo=
Kidney or stomach problems Dachmto firm unerr," fr•nurws 0 0
Infants red tfultkm Ikisys m physical m (erosion of hovwhold pltunbmq zstp
a mcmal dr-elopmtnt, cMUhtn could s=Mts., womon of natural deposes
bh.,s, slight defies ,r attention ,pad
and 1?stmng abilities, Adults Kidiw,
pioblum nigh bloud pmc urt
..... ... ...... _
I.alpon attc's Disease, a rpt of Found naturally in water, mmtiplses ar zwp
pnemnoo.a heating s?Mtms
Ia• ci m kidney. problem- Runott'leaching from inseeficide u wd 00002
on taUk hnnber. Rardem
Kidney dsmage Finamn of nsmtal d"ints• discharge q W2
from nfineaen and faciones
runoff fiver lendfiilt aid eaoplaads
Repmduontduftivuluc% Rrmoffleachmgfiommsecacaueused 009
on fruits. ~ cget*bltb rhfahia, hr: ; asmk
Infants lAlow tbr, age of a, months wno Rmmf, from fertduae. use, lea,,hnge 10
drink •s atis cm mu ms rotate in txcess &:rot aepnc V01%. sewage, uostoe of
of the MCL could begot: termmh in natus depou%
ami if unheatcx .na•• die Svmptpens
include ;botne s oflacath rsidbinc-bob;
s,ndrome
Infants below iht agt of sit mnntns who RunroFtiom fwtilrr:i use itachmg
drink •satu ,omammg mtnte to crccaa from sep+ic tanks rage,'=WoP of
of the MCL Lentil be.:mue settously to notmal deposit,
and, if umtrtattd, mss die Svmptoms
ihciode shortntsa of biesth ind blue-bab•,
s•,ruKrome
3hght nf; . M Sntero effects Runutr•kerbmg hta im -tictde imd 4
on apples potatoes, Ind tomatoes
Inaoilidm:;ptoblerm mcreaard Dsch-rtgcfiomwoad-pmessmg :ao
cancw ink fattort"
Lr•crproblems Herbicide ..moll 0
Ok= changer dismus gland problems Ranotr from landillis, dibehaigt of zip
immune dahcim, ies mpraductr.e at •-asst ehemuzKr
nenot% *,Wa dtthcultme mttwsed
risk of t mtt
Ineteised risk of rancei Erosion of natmal deposits ? ? ,sxo
Hatt o fmgeinsih toss. numbness in fingers Knscbage firm pchokum and meiat teBnares. 0 tK
of toe:. cucuta.as • prob]tms tiosum ofnapaai d%vsrb.: diwtvirc
Iron, mine-
Problenu with blood Hebicia,unoff 0 004
laver krdnr,: of cm..ulaton system problem.; Dtschetue from rubber and plastic 01
facton",' leaching fivm kndnns
U n problems mcrea.,ed cnk of uancer Discharge hum fatrums and m, cleans zeuo
.._._.... .._.... .? .._-_ ................_....__......._........._......._....._.......
Han loss -:banes in blood kidaev, imesont, I .achmg from ore-ptocessing :rite:, 0 0005
m It, w inoblcma discharec from elechoruca, glast.
da drug kdones
..Nei otu • tem. Iridney, m s. a pn.biws mach age. from petroheum facbne,
ColAmns ire bacteria that mdudte that other, xaturall, present in them. u0nment
potrntanv harmfrl hsctcua maa be preacm
See focal wirforme and E colt
Lr a. ludon' m caitnl nef.ow. system problems:. Bypro,hrct of drmkmg water disuifecdon n'r'
tneredsed -l' of eaneet
kidney, lr<ei of thyroid problem-, Rumfl:•teacnmg from msectresderued svp
in,reastd risk of Aacei on cuttun and cable
L ,er probtems Rrudue of liamtel berbr.idt 0 05
Changes in ad,enai glaods Dischatge fium te,mlt tint hmk 0 rvl
factniik.
Itver ncr-ous oi cm;ulatory Micharge from metal degtea,mg 02
problems sets and other factories
Li- er, kidney. m immure q,4= Ihschsrge from mdo ti tal chemresi 0.003
hnoblems fa..tantt
Lien problems, mcitased risk of cancer Disdiarw from metal degeuin zero
sites and other botones g
Dismilectant inorganic Chemical ® Organic Chemical
® Disinfection Byproduct Microorganism
WAS' Radionuclides
Contaminant : iir °°" Potential health affects from Common sources of contaminant Public Health
# long-term' exposure above the MCL in drinking water Goal (mg(LF
-- T ................. ._ :; . __._...
...
......._.._....
.........................,..
1labidity -IucLnlu: is a measmp. of the -:lmidmess of v atu Sod tudofi rya
It to used to mduate water quaht• and filtat w
Aothe, rheas, avurtg oigmiscm
.nc }nesem) Highet tuibedit, k? oh dM 011eo aesecwted
with bight.ovals of dixease austng mtcroorgm sm>.
such as -.iruaa, pacaotes and som bsetum fheac
r ;r
L..
' ayanumds can emm shm, tnnn s-mtptnms inch a.?
i nausea-cramps.dmtrim,andassociatedhcadaclt.
??oY?. Pramuro
•`Y
l?d
y Inc eased n•k of camel. kidne; toxtmt- 1 mnoe of nauual dW$11- .ao
my
andc !tl _ Tnmeasednokofcama LeecLmg!Tom PVC, ptpe, diN.hatgc 2VM
firm plastid f*-.tonts
\truses (entenc r 1t'" Shoot-term &,.pwme Gastromtesunal tllnms
(e
d
h
t Human and anal fecal waste Mo
• }(vteft; (tutai) .g ,
tvr
ea, vomi
ing. camps)
ltimvuus rysteQ• datoagc
Dtacharge from ysermlatm factonta
t9
dhsebatgt from hemical faetorK*
Disinfectant inorganic chemical Organic Chemical
® Disinfection Byproduct Mkroorganism WU'Radlonuclides