Loading...
HomeMy WebLinkAboutNC0036277_Permit Issuance_20090713NPDES DOCUWENT SCANNINS COVER :iMEET NPDES Permit: NC0036277 McDowell Creek WWTP Document Type: Permit Issuance Wasteload Allocation Authorization to Construct (AtC) Permit Modification Complete File - Historical Engineering Alternatives (EAA) Correspondence Instream Assessment (67b) Speculative Limits Environmental Assessment (EA) Document Date: July 13, 2009 This document i6 printed on reuse paper -ignore any content on the reverse Bide r NCDENR North Carolina Department of Environment and Natural Resources Division of Water Quality Beverly Eaves Perdue Coleen H. Sullins Governor Director July 13; 2009 Ms. Jacqueline A. Jarrell, P.E. Environmental Management Division Charlotte -Mecklenburg Utilities 4222 Westmont Drive Charlotte, North Carolina 28217 Dee Freeman Secretary Subject: Issuance of NPDES Permit NCO036277 McDowell Creek WWTP Mecklenburg County Dear Ms. Jarrell: Division personnel have reviewed and approved your application for renewal of the subject permit. Accordingly, we are forwarding the attached NPDES discharge permit. This permit is issued pursuant to the requirements of North Carolina General Statute 143-215.1 and the Memorandum of Agreement between North Carolina and the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency dated October 17, 2007 (or as subsequently amended.) This final permit includes the following modification compared to the draft permit sent to you on May 20, 2009. • The reuse clause under the Supplement to Permit Cover Sheet and in Section A. (4.) was removed. Based on discussions with the Aquifer Protection Section and the use and volume of reclaimed water needed at the McDowell facility the Division recommends that Charlotte Mecklenburg Utilities pursue a non -discharge permit. • A statement recognizing McDowell WWTP's Class IV facility rating was added on the Supplement to Permit Cover Sheet. Please note that the receiving stream is listed as an impaired waterbody on the North Carolina 303(d) Impaired Waters List. Addressing .impaired waters is a high priority with the Division, and iristream data will continue to be evaluated. If there is noncompliance with permitted effluent limits and stream impairment can be attributed to your facility, then mitigative measures may be required. 1617 Mail Service Center, Raleigh, North Carolina 27699-1617 NonrthCarolina Location: 512 N. Salisbury St. Raleigh, North Carolina 27604 y Phone: 919-807-63001 FAX: 919.807-64921 Customer Service:1-877.623-6748 Internet www.ncwaterqual4.org An Equal Opportunity % Affirmative Action Employer If any parts, measurement frequencies or sampling requirements contained in this permit are unacceptable to you, you have the right to an adjudicatory hearing upon written request within thirty (30) days following receipt of this letter. This request must be in the form of a written petition, conforming to Chapter 150B of the North Carolina General Statutes, and filed with the office of Administrative Hearings, 6714 Mail Service Center, Raleigh, North Carolina 27699-6714. Unless such a demand is made, this permit shall be final and binding. Please take notice that this permit is not transferable. The Division may require modification revocation and reissuance of the permit. This permit does not affect the legal requirements to obtain other permits which may be required by the Division of Water Quality or permits required by the Division of Land Resources, Coastal Area Management Act, or any other Federal or Local governmental permits may be required. If you have questions concerning this permit, please contact Julie Grzyb by e-mail Oulie.grzyb@ncmail.net) or phone at (919) 807-6389. jc relly�, YV ln H. Sullins r / Enclosures: NPDES Permit NCO036277 cc: EPA/Region Mooresville Regional Office / Surface Water Protection Section (ecopy) PERCS (ecopy) Ecosystems Unit/Attn. Jenny Atkins (ecopy) Aquatic Toxicology Unit (ecopy) Steve Reid, TACU (ecopy) NPDES File Central Files Mecklenburg County DEH, Groundwater & Wastewater Services, 700 N. Tryon St., Suite 211, Charlotte, NC 28202 1617 Mail Service Center, Raleigh, North Carolina 27699-1617 One Location: 512 N. Salisbury St. Raleigh, North Carolina 27604 NorthCarohna Phone: 919-807-63001FAX: 919-807-64921Customer Service: 1-877-623-6748 �Q'tu `!J/ Internet wvv:.nmaterquality.org y An Equal Opportunity 1 AFmnain Action Employer t • Permit No. NCO036277 STATE OF NORTH CAROLINA DEPARTMENT OF ENVIRONMENT AND NATURAL RESOURCES DIVISION OF WATER QUALITY PERMIT TO DISCHARGE WASTEWATER UNDER THE NATIONAL POLLUTANT DISCHARGE ELIMINATION SYSTEM In compliance with the provision of North Carolina General Statute 143-215.1, other lawful standards and,regulations promulgated and adopted by the North Carolina Environmental Management Commission, and the Federal Water Pollution Control Act, as amended, City of Charlotte (Charlotte -Mecklenburg Utilities) is hereby authorized to discharge wastewater from a facility located at the McDowell Creek Wastewater Treatment Plant NCSR 2074 Huntersville Mecklenburg County to receiving waters designated as McDowell Creek in the Catawba River Basin in accordance with effluent limitations, monitoring requirements, and other conditions set forth in Parts I, II, III and IV hereof. This permit shall become effective August 1, 2009. This permit and authorization to discharge shall expire at midnight on December 31, 2013. Signed this day July 13, 2009. en H. Sullins, Director Division of Water Quality By Authority of the Environmental Management Commission c Permit No. NC0036277 SUPPLEMENT TO PERMIT COVER SHEET The exclusive authority to operate this facility arises under this NPDES permit. The conditions, requirements, terms and provisions of this NPDES permit governs surface water discharges from this facility. All previous NPDES Permits issued to this facility bearing this permit number, whether for operation or discharge, are hereby revoked. City of Charlotte (Charlotte -Mecklenburg Utilities) is hereby authorized to: 1. Continue to operate the existing 12.0 MGD wastewater treatment facility consisting of: • Two 6 million gallon storm flow equalization tanks • Mechanical bar screens • grit removal • odor control • one 1.3 million gallon flow equalization day tank • five primary clarifiers • two trains in parallel of activated sludge treatment utilizing three stage Biological Nutrient Removal (BNR) and two trains in parallel of activated sludge treatment utilizing five stage Biological Nutrient Removal • four final clarifiers • effluent denitrifying filters • anaerobic sludge digestion • Mechanical sludge thickening and dewatering equipment • sand drying beds • UV disinfection • Membrane filtration and reuse distribution This facility is located at McDowell Creek Wastewater Treatment Plant, on SR 2074, 4901 Neck Road, near the Town of Huntersville in Mecklenburg County. McDowell WWTP is currently rated a Class IV facility. 2. After receiving a Non -Discharge permit for reclaimed water use, operate facilities to distribute up to 3 MGD of reclaimed wastewater in accordance with the applicable Non - Discharge permit. 3. Discharge from said treatment works at the location specified on the attached map into McDowell Creek, which is classified WS-IV water in the Catawba River Basin. NC00036277 - CMU McDowell Creek Facility Latitude: 3e22'54" Sub -Basin: 03-08-33 Location Longitude, W56'20" County: Mecklenburg a #: F15NWILake Norman South Stream Class: Receiving Stream: WS-Iv McDowell Creek ^ ,O/_ Charlotte Mecklenburg Utilities NC0036277 I\VI 1/I7 CMU - McDowell Creek W WTP Permit No. NCO036277 A. (1.) EFFLUENT LIMITATIONS AND MONITORING REQUIREMENTS During the period beginning on the effective date of the permit and lasting until expiration, the Permittee is authorized to discharge up to 12 MGD of municipal wastewater from outfall 001. Such discharges shall be limited and monitored by the Permittee as specified below: EFFLUENT <� , _ ' CHARACTERISTICS, ` t : = EFFLUENT LIMITS; MONITORING REQUIREMENTS ; Monthly Average Weekly Avers e:` Daily Maximum Measurement Fre uen Sample Type Sample Location Flow 12.0 MGD Continuous Recording I or E CBODS 200C 2 Summer 4.2 m /L 6.3 m /L Daily Composite E, I CBODs 20°C 2 inter 8.3 m L 12.4 m /L Daily Composite E, I Total Suspended So1ids2 9.0 m /L 13.5 m L Daily Composite E, I NH3 as N 1.0 m /L 3.0 m fl Daily Composite E Dissolved OxygeO Daily Grab E Fecal Coliform eometric mean 100 / 100 ml 200 / 100 ml Daily Grab E Total Residual Chlorine4 19 /L Daily Grab E Temperature °C Daily Grab E Total Nitrogen Summer 450 lbs/day Monthly Composite E Total Nitrogen PMinter 500 lbs/day Monthly Composite E Total Phosphorus Summer 27 lbs/day Monthly Composite E Total Phosphorus inter 32 lbs/day Monthly Composite E Chronic Toxicity5 Quarterly Composite E Conductivity Daily Grab E Total Copper 2/Month Composite E Total Zinc 2/Month Composite E Total Mercury 2/Month Grab E H Between 6.0 to 9.0 standard units 'Daily Grab E Dissolved Oxygen Weekly Grab U, D Temperature °C Weekly Grab U, D Conductivity Weekly Grab U, D Chloro h ll-a Summer Monthly Grab D Total Phosphorus Summer Monthly Grab D NH3-N Summer Monthly Grab D TKN Summer Monthly Grab D NO2 + NO3 as N Summer Monthly Grab D Footnotes: i Sample Locations: E — Effluent, I — Influent, U — Upstream at Beatties Ford Road, D- Downstream at Neck Rd. 2 The monthly average effluent CBODs and total suspended solids concentrations shall not exceed 15% of the respective influent value (85% removal). 3 The daily average dissolved oxygen effluent concentrations shall not be less than 5.0 mg/L. 4 Monitoring only if effluent is chlorinated. 8 Chronic Toxicity (Ceriodaphnia) P/ F at 90 % effluent concentration shall be conducted quarterly (January, April, July and October). Refer to Part A. (2). [Summer] = April 1- October 31 [Winter] = November 1- March 31 Total Nitrogen = NO2 + NO3 + TKN Lbs/day= Pounds/Day There shall be no discharge of floating solids or visible foam in other than trace amounts. Permit No. NC0036277 A. (2.) CHRONIC TOXICITY PERMIT LIMIT WRTRIM The effluent discharge shall at no time exhibit observable inhibition of reproduction or significant mortality to Ceriodaphnia dubia at an effluent concentration of 90 %. The permit holder shall perform at a minimum, auarterlu monitoring using test procedures outlined in the "North Carolina Ceriodaphnia Chronic Effluent Bioassay Procedure," Revised February 1998, or subsequent versions or "North Carolina Phase II Chronic Whole Effluent Toxicity Test Procedure" (Revised -February 1998) or subsequent versions. The tests will be performed during the months of January, April, JuIJ. and October. Effluent sampling for this testing shall be performed at the NPDES permitted final effluent discharge below all treatment processes. If the test procedure performed as the rust test of any single quarter results in a failure or ChV below the permit limit, then multiple -concentration testing shall be performed at a minimum, in each of the two following months as described in "North Carolina Phase II Chronic Whole Effluent Toxicity Test Procedure" (Revised -February 1998) or subsequent versions. The chronic value for multiple concentration tests will be determined using the geometric mean of the highest concentration having no detectable impairment of reproduction or survival and the lowest concentration that does have a detectable impairment of reproduction or survival. The definition of "detectable impairment," collection methods, exposure regimes, and further statistical methods are specified in the "North Carolina Phase II Chronic Whole Effluent Toxicity Test Procedure" (Revised -February 1998) or subsequent versions. All toxicity testing results required as part of this permit condition will be entered on the Effluent Discharge Monitoring Form (MR-1) for the months in which tests were performed. If reporting pass/fail results using the parameter code TGP3B, DWQ Form AT-1 (original) is sent to the below address. If reporting Chronic Value results using the parameter code THP311, DWQ Form AT-3 (original) is to be sent to the following address: Attention: NC DENR / Division of Water Quality Environmental Sciences Section 1621 Mail Service Center Raleigh, North Carolina 27699-1621 Completed Aquatic Toxicity Test Forms shall be filed with the Environmental Sciences Section no later than 30 days after the end of the reporting period for which the report is made. Test data shall be complete, accurate, include all supporting chemical/physical measurements and all concentration/response data, and be certified by laboratory supervisor and ORC or approved designate signature. Total residual chlorine of the effluent toxicity sample must be measured and reported if chlorine is employed for disinfection of the waste stream. Should there be no discharge of flow from the facility during a month in which toxicity monitoring is required, the permittee will complete the information located at the top of the aquatic toxicity (AT) test form indicating the facility name, permit number, pipe number, county, and the month/year of the report with the notation of "No Flow" in the comment area of the form. The report shall be submitted to the Environmental Sciences Section at the address cited above. Should the permittee fail to monitor during a month in which toxicity monitoring is required, monitoring will be required during the following month. Should any test data from this monitoring requirement or tests performed by the North Carolina Division of Water Quality indicate potential impacts to the receiving stream, this permit may be re -opened and modified to include alternate monitoring requirements or limits. If the Permittee monitors any pollutant more frequently then required by this permit, the results of such monitoring shall be included in the calculation and reporting of the data submitted on the DMR and all AT Forms submitted. NOTE: Failure to achieve test conditions as specified in the cited document, such as minimum control organism survival, minimum control organism reproduction, and appropriate environmental controls, shall constitute an invalid test and will require immediate follow-up testing to be completed no later than the last day of the month following the month of the initial monitoring. Permit No. NCO036277 A. (3) EFFLUENT POLLUTANT SCAN -The Permittee shall perform an annual Effluent Pollutant Scan for all parameters listed imthe attached table. The analytical methods shall be in accordance with 40 CFR Part 136 and shall be sufficiently sensitive to determine whether parameters are present in concentrations greater than applicable standards and criteria. Samples shall represent seasonal variations. Unless otherwise indicated, metals shall be analyzed as total recoverable." Ammonia (as N) Trans-1,24chloroethylene Bis (2-chloroethyl) ether Chlorine (total residual, TRC) 1,1-dichloroethylene Bis (2-chloroisopropyl) ether Dissolved oxygen 1,2-dichloropropane Bis (2-ethylhe)yl) phthalate Nitrate/Nitrite 1,34chloropropylene 4-bromophenyl phenyl ether Kjeldahl nitrogen Ethylbenzene Butyl benzyl phthalate Oil and grease Methyl bromide 2-chloronaphthalene Phosphorus Methyl chloride 4-chlomphenyl phenyl ether Total dissolved solids Methylene chloride Chrysene Hardness 1,1,2,2-tetrachloroethane Dk-butyl phthalate Antimony Tetrachloroethylene Dan-oc to phthalate Arsenic Toluene Dibenzo(a,h)anthracens Beryllium 1,1,1-trichloroethane 1,2-dichlorobenzene Cadmium 1,1,2-tdchloroethane 1,3-dichbrobenzene Chromium Tdchloroethylene IA-dichbrobenzene Copper Vinyl chloride 3,3-dichlorobenzidine Lead Acid -extractable compounds. Diethyl phthalate Mercury P-chloro-m-cresol DimethI phthalate Nickel 2-chlorophenol 2,44nitrotoluene Selenium 2,4-dichlorophenol 2,6-dinitrotoluene Silver 2,4-dimethylphenol 1,2-diphenylhydrazine Thallium 4,6-dlnitro cresol Fluoranthene Zinc 2,4-dinitrophenol Fluorene Cyanide 2-nitrophenol Hexachlorobenzene Total phenolic compounds 4-nitrophenol Hexachlorobutadiene Volatile organic compounds: Pentachlorophenol Hexachlorocyclo-pentadlene Acrolein Phenol Hexachloroethane Acrylonitrile 2,4,6-tdchlorophenol Indeno(1,2,3-cd)pyrene Benzene Base -neutral compounds: Isophorone Bromoform Acenaphthene Naphthalene Carbon tetrachloride Acenaphthylene N'ftrobenzene Chlorobenzene Anthracene N-nitrosodi-n-propylamine Chlorodibromomethane Benzidine N-nitrowdimethylamine Chloroethane Benzo(a)anthracene N-nitrosodiphenylamine 2-c hloroethylvinyl ether Benzo(a)pyrene Phenanthrene Chloroform 3,4 benzofluoranthene Pyrene Dichlorobromomethane Benzo(ghi)perylene 12,4-trichlorobenzene 1,1-dichloroethane Benzo(k)fluorenthene 1,2-dichloroethane Bis (2-chloroethoxy) methane Test results shall be reported to the Division in DWQ Form- A MR-PPA1 or in a form approved by the Director within 90 days of sampling. The report shall be submitted to the following address: NC DENR / DWQ / Central Files 1617 Mail Service Center Raleigh, NC 27699-1617. CMU - McDowell Creek NPDES No. NCO036277 NC DENR/DWQ FACT SHEET FOR NPDES PERMIT DEVELOPMENT CMU - McDowell Creek W WTP NPDES No. NCO036277 (Draft) Facility Information Applicant/Facility Name: Charlotte -Mecklenburg Utilities - McDowell Creek WWTP Applicant Address: 5100 Brookshire Blvd.; Charlotte, NC 28216 Facility Address: NCSR 2074, near the Town of Huntersville Permitted Flow 12.0 MGD Type of Waste: 85%Domestic 15010 Industrial Pretreatment Program: No SIU's, maintains Long Term Monitoring Program as part of CMU Facility/Permit Status: Class IV/Active; Major Renewal County: Mecklenburg Count Miscellaneous Receiving Stream: McDowell Creek Regional Office: Mooresville Stream Classification: WS-IV State Grid / USGS Quad: F15NW/Lake Norman 303(d) Listed? Yes Permit Writer: Julie Grz b Subbasin: 03-08-33 Date: May 15, 2009 Drainage Area (mi): 28.3 .'AdW Lat. 350 22 54" N Long. 800 56' 20" W Summer 7Q10 (cfs) 1.8 Winter 7Q10 (cfs): 4.2 30Q2 (cfs) Average Flow (cfs): 31 IWC (%): 91 % SUMMARY This plant was constructed in 1980 as a 3.0 MGD activated sludge facility serving the Charlotte metropolitan area. A facility expansion to 6.0 MGD in 1999 incorporated a 3- stage biological nutrient removal (BNR) process. During the previous permit cycle the permittee requested a major permit modification to provide for interim phased flow limits at 6.6 MGD (based on a facility re -rating of current treatment system), with phased construction to 9.0 MGD and 12.0 MGD. The facility completed its expansion in one construction project and began meeting the requirements for the 12 MGD permit on December 1, 2007. The expanded facility has four trains of activated sludge treatment utilizing three and five stage biological nutrient removal. Treated effluent from the plant is discharged into McDowell Creek approximately 0.5 miles upstream of Mountain Island Lake on the Catawba River. McDowell Creek is classified as a WS-IV stream (no longer CA) and on the NC 2006 303(d) list as impaired based on biological data for the last 11.6 miles prior to discharge into Mountain Island Lake. The source of impairment is identified as land development which results in an increased discharge of pollutants carried in stormwater runoff from rapidly increasing impervious:. cover (parking lots, roads, houses, etc.) and construction activities in the McDowell Creek watershed. The lake serves as a drinking water supply for Charlotte and the 12 MGD permit limits were developed using extensive water quality modeling to evaluate future conditions in McDowell Creek and Mountain Island Lake, where nutrient enrichment is of primary concern. Using Page 1 of 4 Version: 5/15/-009 CMU - McDowell Creek NPDES No. NCO036277 the Bathtub model of Mountain Island Lake and McDowell Creek Cove developed by CMU's consultant, the Division ran several model scenarios to develop phased expansion limits for TN and TP. The modeling endpoint was to have less than 10% of the model predictions exceed the chlorophyll -a water quality standard of 40 ug/1. CMU has a full pretreatment program through the Division of Water Quality's PERCS Unit for all five municipalities it operates including the McDowell Creek facility. There are no categorical industries or significant industrial users in the McDowell Creek service area. CMU McDowell Creek voluntarily administers its Long Term Monitoring Program under PERC's analyzing 12 different metals and Oil & Grease on a monthly basis in addition to its NPDES permit monitoring. Class B solids are land applied in accordance with land application permit number WQ0000057 in North Carolina and SCDHES Permit #ND0080900 in South Carolina. Biosolids that do not meet the Class B requirements are disposed at local landfills. Currently this facility does not have a Non - Discharge permit to reuse wastewater; however, discussions with potential customers are being held. The facility does have membrane filtration and reuse distribution equipment to reclaim wastewater if desired. DMR DATA Effluent Chemistry: In reviewing effluent data from 2007 and 2008; CBOD and TSS concentrations average less than 2 mg/1 and 1 mg/L respectively, with annual removal rates exceeding 99%; TN effluent averaged 212 lbs/day with an removal rate > 88%; TP effluent has averaged less than 0.23 nig/l with a removal rate > 96%. Effluent Pollutant Scalars The application contained data from five annual Effluent Pollutant Scans on volatile organic compounds and six scans "on Acid-Extractables and Base -Neutral compounds. The scans did not find these contaminants to be present in the facility's effluent. An annual priority pollutant scan requirement will remain in the permit to ensure that the permittee complies with the requirement in the municipal permit applications. Toxicity Testing Effluent Toxicity: The facility has passed all 18 toxicity tests for Ceriodaphnia and 4 tests for fat head minnow taken during the last four and one-half years. Effluent toxicity has not been a water quality issue. DWQ recommends that the quarterly chronic toxicity tests at 90% be continued in the renewed permit. Reasonable Potential Analysis (RPA) Results Effluent data for toxicants were reviewed for the period January 2007 through December 2008. All effluent data for arsenic, cadmium, chromium, lead, molybdenum, selenium, and cyanide requiring analyses under the pretreatment program were reported in less than detectable amounts. Cadmium had one measurement at 2.0 ug/L. As part of its Pretreatment Long Term Monitoring Plan, CMU will continue to monitor these parameters but no effluent limits or monitoring will be required in the NPDES permit. A review of the past three years (2006, 2007, 2008) of effluent sampling data for silver showed all results were less than detectable levels of 5 ug/L and several at less than a detectable level of 1 ug/L. Silver monitoring was originally put in the permitee's NPDES permit issued -in 2001 based upon a finding of reasonable potential for the effluent to violate the allowable Water Supply in -stream concentration of 10 ug.L. The 2001 RPA was based on sampling that primarily measured silver at a detection level of <30 Page 2 of 4 V asion: 5/1 5r-009 CMU - McDowell, Creek NPDES No. NCO036277 ug/L. Since samples measured at the facility during the past five years were below detectable levels of 5 and 1 ug/L, it is recommended that silver monitoring be removed from the permit renewal. Silver will continue to be monitored on a monthly basis as part of CMU's Pretreatment Long Term Monitoring Plan. The following metals were found in detectable levels in the facilities effluent so a reasonable potential analysis was conducted for copper, zinc, nickel, and mercury (attached). The results of these analyses are summarized in the table. below. s S�,Fi'..».s�•.' `�..fa9�N�r.., s..:.w..:iHtu�..t... ...i;,-.�!". •..Ysa �.; Copper (ug/L) AL 7 8 10 Zinc (ug/L) AL 67 55 . 114 Nickel (ug/L) 261 97 5.2 Mercury (n ). N/A 13 5.8 • Nickel continues to be a parameter showing no reasonable potential for an in -stream violation so it will not be monitored in the permit but remain as part of the Pretreatment LTMP. • Mercury does not show a reasonable potential for an in -stream violation. No limitation is necessary; however, monitoring should be maintained due to the effluent concentration levels of the contaminant and the high IWC. It is recommended that the permit be renewed without the mercury limitation and the monitoring changed from weekly to 2/Month. • The copper and zinc maximum predicted concentrations exceed the allowable acute and chronic standards exhibiting some reasonable potential for a violation. For these parameters, the standards are Action Level standards and should be reviewed in conjunction with toxicity testing. It is recommended that monitoring be continued for both parameters as part of its NPDES permit at a frequency of 2/Month. Should the presence of copper and zinc in the effluent be identified as causative factors of whole effluent toxicity, limitations will be determined. Water Quality Based Effluent Limits McDowell Creek, the receiving stream segment is subject to water quality standards applicable to the classification Water Supply, class IV, for freshwater streams. The previous permit included water - quality based effluent limits for TRC, TN, TP, and Mercury. Ammonia nitrogen and BOD were based on both water quality modeling and best available technology. TN and TP were determined based on the 2003 modeling endpoint which was to have less than 10% of the model predictions exceed the chlorophyll -a water quality standard of 40 ug/L. Current limitations for BOD/CBOD, NH3-N, TN, and TP will remain in the permit. The facility no longer uses chlorine for disinfection, however; the TRC limit will remain in the permit should the effluent be chlorinated for any reason. ADDITIONAL DATA The inspection reports reveal a well maintained and properly operated facility. Records show the facility had only one violation in 2008. resulting from a Priority'Pollutant Scan. which analyzed TRC at 90 ug/L. The. permit limitation is 19 uglL. CMU personnel are unable to conclude how the TRC was in the discharge since UV is used for disinfection. CMU personnel have re-evaluated all possibilities and no possible cause was ever found. Page 3 of 4 Vcrsion: 5/15/2009 i CMU — McDowell Creek NPDES No. NCO036277 PROPOSED PERMIT CHANGES Remove monitoring for total silver from the permit. Remove the mercury limitation and reduce monitoring to 2/Month. PROPOSED SCHEDULE FOR PERMIT ISSUANCE Draft Permit to Public Notice: 05/20/09 Permit Scheduled to Issue: 07/13/09 (estimate) NPDES DIVISION CONTACT If you have questions regarding any of the above information or on the attached permit, please contact Julie Grzyb at (919) 807-6389 or by email atjulie.grzyb@ncmail.net. NAME: DATE: REGIONAL OFFICE COMMENTS NAME: DATE: SUPERVISOR: DATE: Page 4 of 4 Vcrsion: 5115P-009 REASONABLE POTENTIAL ANALYSIS 4 1 4 5 9 11 1t CMU - McDowell Creek WWTP NCO036277 Time Period January 2007 - December 2008 Ow (MGD) 12 . WWTP Class IV 7Q10S (cfs) 1.8 1WC (%) 0 7010S 91.176 701OW (cfs) 4.2 ® 701OW 81.579 3002 (cfs) 0 30Q2 N/A Avg. Stream Flow, QA (cfs) 31 ® QA 37.5 Reeving Stream McDowell Creek Stream Class WS-IV Ouffall 001 Qw^12MGD STANDARDS & PARAMETER TYPE CRITERIA (2) POL Units REASONABLE POTENTIAL RESULTS RECOMMENDED ACTION (1) NC Wos/ fi FAV/ a F pa Max Pred CW Aftwabte CW Chron/c Acute Acute: WA WaterSapply;standard - ug/L Arsenic C 10 ug/L 77 0 2.9 No reasonable potentialfor a_n;tn-stream viOtatiot _ _ - _ _ _ _ Chronic: 27 Ad stunples less lh8n deieclatite Remains in CMU's Long Term:Pretreatinent Moriitofgig Ptan Acute: 1,022 Chromium NC 50 1,022 ug/L 77 1 2.9 No re_asonaW potential for an Wstrearri violation _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ Chronic 55 _ Remains to CMU s Long Term Pretreafinent Monitoring Plan Acute: 7 Copper NC 7 AL 7.3 uglL 77 37 10.1 _ _ -8 Reasonable potential to exceed stds _ _ Chronic: No timtt as this Is an'actbri Level parameter Mairifam monitoring:: S: Acute: WA Mercury NC 12 2.0000 ng/L 73 26 5.7810 Noo reasonable potential for a_n irrstre_am violation _ _ - _ _ _ _ Chronic: 13 1lemove permit Fimitatton'and reduce monito ft to 2MMorith Acute: 261 WaterSupply standard - 25_ugfL Nickel NC 25 261 ug/L 77 61 5.2 Noreasonablekor:tialfor'a_nWStream _vlolation _ _ _-_ Chronic: 27 Remains In GMU's Long Terrrr Pretreatment Mgrib jng Plan Acute: 67 Zinc NC 50 AL 67 ug/L 77 77 114.0 Reasonable potential to exceed stds _ _ _ _ _ _ Chronic: 55 No [imd�as this is an action level aarameter Maintain rt�orrtioring.. •Legend: C = Carcinogenic NC = Non-cardnogenic A = Aesthetic •' Freshwater Discharge McDowell rpa 2009 extra.xis, rpa 5/15/2009 1 REASONABLIt POTENTIAL ANALYSIS Arsenic Chromium Date Data BDL=I2DL Results Dale Data BDL=I2DL Results 1 1/2/2007 < 5 2.5 Std Dev. 0.6795 1 1/2/2007 < 5 2.5 Std Dev. 0.4489 2 1/32007 Mean 2.4026 2 1/3/2007 Mean 2.3896 3 1/412007 < 5 2.5 C.V. 0.2412 3 1/42007 <: 5 2.5 C.V. 0.1878 4 1/8/2007 n 77 4 1/8/2007 n 77 5 1/10/2007 5 1/10/2007 6 1/16/2007 < 5 2.5 Mult Factor = 1.2000 6 1/16/2007 <1 5 2.5 Mult Factor = 1.1500 7 1/17/2007 < 5 2.5 Max. Value 5.0 ug/L 7 1/17/2007 <°. 5 2.5 Max. Value 2.5 ug/L 8 1/182007 Max. Pred Cw 6.0 ug4 8 1/18/2007 1 Max. Pred Cw 2.9 ug4 9 1/2212007 <. 5 2.5 9 1/22t2007 <4 5 25 10 12412007 10 1/24/2007 11 1/2912007 < 5 2.5 11 1/29/2007 < 5 25 12 1/31/2007 12 1/31/2007 13 2/2/2007 < 5 2.5 13 2/2/2007 < 5 2.5 14 2/6/2007 14 2/6/2007 15 2/82007 < 5 2.5 15 2/8/2007 <. 5 2.5 16 2/12/2007 16 211212007 -' 17 2114/2007 < 5 2.5 17 2/14/2007 < 5 2.5 18 2/19/2007 18 2119/2007 19 2/20/2007 < 5 2.5 19 2/20/2007 < 5 2.5 20 221/2007 20 221/2007 21 2/26/2007 < 5 2.5 21 2/26/2007 <1 5 2.5 22 228/2007 22 2/28/2007 23 3/2/2007 < 5 2.5 23 3/2/2007 <-- 5 2.5 24 315/2007. 24 315/2007- 25 302007 < 5 25 25 3/9/2007 < 5 2.5 26 3/12/2007 26 3/12/2007 27 3/13/2007 27 3/13/2007 28 3/14/2007 28 3/14/2007 29 3/20/2007 < 5 2.5 29 3/20/2007 < 5 2.5 30 3/21/2007 30 3/21/2007 31 3/22/2007 < 5 2.5 31 3/22/2007 <1 5 25 32 3/2612007 < 5 2.5 32 3/26/2007 < 5 2.5 33 3/27/2007 33 3/27/2007 34 4122007 34 4/2/2007 35 4I412007 < 5 2.5 35 4/4/2007 < 5 2.5 36 4/812007 36 4/9/2007 37 4/10/2007 37 4110M07 38 4/11/2007 < 5 2.5 38 4/11/2007 < 5 2.5 39 4/132007 39 4/13/2007 40 4/14/2007 < 5 2.5 40 4/14/2007 < 5 2.5 j 41 4/16/2007 41 4/16/2007 42 4/172007 < 5 2.5 42 4/17/2007 < 5 2.5 43 4/232007 43 423/2007 _ 44 4/25/2007 44 4125/2007 45 4/30/2007 < 5 2.5 45 4130/2007 < 5 2.5 46 5/1/2007 < 5 25 46 5/1/2007 < 5 2.5 47 5/3/2007 _ 47 5WO07 48 5/6/2007 < 5 2.5 48 5/6/2007 <9 5 2.5 49 5r712007 49 6/7/2007 50 5/14/2007 60 5114/2007 51 5/16/2007 < 5 2.5 51 5/16/2007 < 5 2.5 52 5/21/2007 52 5/21/2007 53 512PJ2007 53 5/222007 54 5/23/2007 < 5 2.5 54 5/2312007 < 5 2.5 55 5/29/2007 < 5 2.5 55 5/29/2007 <'. 5 2.5 56 5/30/2007 56 5/30/2007 57 6/4/2007 < 5 2.5 57 6/4/2007 < 5 2.5 58 6/11/2007 58 6/11/2007 59 6/1212007 59 6/12/2007 60 6/1312007 60 6/13/2007 61 6/15/2007 61 6/15/2007 62 6118/2007 < 5 2.5 62 6118/2007 <1 5 25 63 620/2007 63 6/20/2007 ^; 64 62112007 64 621/2007 65 6/25/2007 < 5 2.5 65 6/26/2007 <`' 5 2.5 66 6/2712007 < 5 2.5 66 6/27/2007 < 5 2.5 67 628/2007 < 5 2.5 67 6/28/2007 c: 5 2.5 68 7/2/2007 68 7/2/2007 69 7/9/2007 69 7/9/2007 70 7/11/2007 < 5 2.5 70 7/11/2007 <' 5 2.5 71 7/16/2007 71 7116/2007 72 7/17/2007 72 7/17/2007 73 7/18/2007 < 5 2.5 73 7/18/2007 <' 5 2.5 74 7/23/2007 < 1 0.5 74 7/23t2007 <, 1 0.5 75 7/26/2007 75 7/25/2007 76 7/30/2007 < 5 2.5 76 7/30/2007 <.: 5 2.5 77 8/1/2007 77 8/1/2007 ', 78 8/2/2007 < 1 0.5 78 8/2/2007 <,; 1 0.5 79 8/6/2007 79 802007 . 80 8/8/2007 < 1 0.5 80 8/8/2007 1 2 2.0 81 8/132007 81 8/13/2007 82 8/14/2007 82 8/14/2007 McDowell rpa 2009 extra, 83 8/15/2007 < 1 0.6 83 -1 B/15/2007 <. 1 0.5 4, s. data 84 8/2012007 as slzv2oo7 e REASONABLE. �TejgT 7' . ANALYSIS 86 8/27/2007 < 1 0.5 87 8/29/2007 88 e/3012007 < 5 2.5 89 9/4/2007 90 9/512007 < 5 2.5 91 0/10/2007 92 9/13/2007 < 5 2.5 93 9/14/2007 94 9/17/2007 95 9/20/2007 ! 5 5.0 96 9/24/2007 97 9/26/2007 < 5 2.5 98 10/l/2007 < 5 25 99 10/5/2007 < 5 Z5 100 10/8/2007 101 10/10/2007 < 5 2.5 102 10/15/2007 103 10/16/2007 104 10/1712007 < 5 2.5 105 10/22/2007 106 10/29/2007 < 5 2.5 107 10/31/2007< 5 25 108 ll/l/2007 109 111512007. 110 1116/2007 < 5 2.5 111 11/9/2007 112 11/10/2007 < 5 2.5 113 11/12/2007 114 11/13/2007 115 11/14/2007 < 5 2.5 116 11119/2007'< 5 2.5 117 11/2112007 118 11/2812007 < 5 2.5 119 ll/27/2007 120 12/2/2007 < 5 2.5 121 12/3/2007 < 5 2.5 122 12/5/2007 123 12110/2007 124 12/12/2007 < 5 2.5 125 12/17/2007 126 12/18/2007 < 5 2.5 127 12/19/2007 128 12126/2007 < 5 2.5 129 12/31/2007 < 5 2.5 130 1/212008 < 5 2.5 131 117/2008. 132 1/14/2008< 5 2.5 133 1/16/2008 134 1/22/2008 135 1/23/2008 <, 5 2.5 136 1/28/2008 137 1/30/2008< 5 2.5 138 2/4/2008 139 215/2008, < 5 2.5 140 2/6/2008 141 2/11/2008 142 2114/2008 < 5 25 143 211812008' < 5 2.5 1" 2/20/2008 < 5 2.5 145 2/27/2008 < 5 2.5 146 3/5/2008 147 3110/2008 < 5 2.5 148 3/12/2008, 149 3/18/2008 < 5 2.5 150 3/1912008 < 5 2.5 151 312612008. < 5 2.5 152 April < 5 2.5 153 < 5 2.5 154 < 5 9 5 polate to find Mult. Factor n = 77 1 Hits) cv = 0.241 which truncates to 0.2 row in M.F. Table - 77 column in M.F. Table- 2 upper & lower Mult. Factors and interpolate: value 1 address ='mf table'!$C$79 value 1 = 1.1610489 value 2 address = 'mf table'!$D$79 value 2 = 1.24775324 Interpolated MF value = 1.19675703 Round to 2 dec. places to get MF: 1.20 86 8/27/2007 < 1 0.5 87 8/29/2007 88 8/30/2007 < 5 2.5 89 9/4/2007 90 9/5/2007 < 5 2.5 91 9/10/2007 92 9/13/2007 < 5 2.5 93 9/14/2007 94 9117/2G07 95 9/20/2007 < 5 2.5 96 9/24/2007 97 9/26/2007 < 5 2.5 98 1011/2007 < 5 2.5 99 10/5/2007 < 5 2.5 100 10/8/2007 101 10/10/2007 < 5 2.5 102 10/15/2007 103 10/16/2007 104 10117/2007 <. 5 25 105 10/2212007 108 10/29/2007 < 5 25 107 1110112007 < 5 2.5 108 1111/2007 109 1115/2007 110 11/6/2007 < 5 2.5 111 11/9/2007 112 11/1012007 < 5 - 25 113 11/12/2007 114 11/13/2007 115 11/14/2007 < 5 2.5 116 11/19/2007 < 5 2.5 117 11/21/2007 118 11/26/2007 < 5 2.5 119 11/27/2007 120 12/2/2007 < 5 25 121 12/3/2007. < 5 2.5 122 121512007 123 12/10/2007 124 12112(2007 < 5 2.5 125 12/17/2007 126 12/18/2007 < 5 2.5 127 12/19/2007 128 12/26/2007 < 5 2.5 129 12/3112007 < 5 2.5 130 1/2/2008 < 5 2.5 131 1/712008 132 1/14/2008 < 5 2.5 133 1/16/2008 134 1/22/2008 135 1/23/2008 < 5 25 136 1/28/2008 137 1/30/2008 < 5 2.5 138 2/4/2008 139 2/5/2008 < 5 2.5 140 2/6/2008 141 2/11/2008 142 2/14/2008 < 5 2.5 143 2/18/2008 < 5 25 144 2/20/2008 < 5 2.5 145 2/27/2008 < 5 2.5 146 3/5/2008 147 3/10/2008 < 5 2.5 148 3/12/2008 149 3118/20DB < 5 2.5 150 3119120D8 < 5 2.5 151 3/26/2008 < 5 2.5 152 April < 5 2.5 153 < 5 2.5 154 < 5 2.5 nterpolate to find Mult. Factor n = 77 1 Hits) cv = 0.188 which truncates to 0.1 =ind row in M.F. Table - 77 =ind column in M.F. Table - 1 'ick upper & lower Mult. Factors and interpolate: value 1 address = 'mf table'!$B$79 value 1 = 1.07811324 value 2 address ='mf table'!$C$79 value2= 1.1610489 Interpolated MF value = 1.15096018 Round to 2 dec. places to get MF: 1.15 rpa 2009 xtra.xls, data 4/22/2OD 5 REASONABLE POTENTIAL ANALYSIS Copper Mercury Date Data BDL=1/2DL Results Date Data BDL=I2DL Results 1 1/2/2007. 2.4 2.4 Std Dev. 1.1081 1 1/2/2007 < 1 1.0 Std Dev. 0.5146 2 1/3/2007 Mean 1.9221 2 1/3/2007 Mean 1.1041 3 1/4/2007 < 2 1.0 C.V. 0.5765 3 11/4/2007 C.V. 0.4661 4 118/2007 n 77 4 118/2007 < 1 1.0 n 73 5 1/10/2007 5 1/10/2007 6 1/16/2007 < 2 1.0 Mull Factor = 1.5000 6 1/16/2007 1.2 1.0 Mult Factor = 1.41 7 1/17/2007 < 2 1.0 Max. Value 6.7 ug1L 7 1/17/2007 Max. Value 4.1 ng/L 8 1118/2007 Max. Prad Cw 10.1 ug/L 8 1/18/2007 Max. Pred Cw 5.8 ng/L 9 1122/2007 < 2 1.0 9 1122/2007 < 1 1.0 10 112412007 10 1/24/2007 11 1/2912007 < 2 1.0 11 1/29/2007 1.2 1.0 12 1/31/2007 12 1/31/2007 13 202007 < 2 1.0 13 22/2007 '. 14 2/612007 14 2I8/2007 <, 1 1.0 15 2/8/2007 < 2 1.0 15 2/8I2007 16 2112/2007 16 2/12/2007 3 3.0 17 2/14/2007 < 2 1.0 17 2/14/2007 18 2/19/2007 18 2119/2007 19 2/20/2007 < 2 1.0 19 220/2007 4.1 4.1 20 2/21/2007 20 2/21/2007 21 2IM2007 < 2 1.0 21 2/26/2007 1.4 1.0 22 2/28/2007 22 2/28/2007 23 3/2/2007 < 2 1.0 23 3/2/2007 1.4 1.0 24 3/5/2007 24 3/5/2007 1.1 1.0 25 3/9/2007 < 2 1.0 25 3/9/2007 25 3/1212007 26 3/12/2007 27 3/13/2007 27 3/13/2007 1.1 1.0 28 3/14/2007 28 W1412007 29 3/20/2007 2.4 2.4 29 3/20/2007 1.1 1.0 30 321/2007 30 3/21/2007 31 3/22/2007 2.3 2.3 31 3/2212007 1.1 1.0 32 3/26/2007 2.2 22 32 3/26/2007 33 3/27/2007 33 3/27/2007 34 4/2/2007 34 4/2/2007 < 1 1.0 35 414/2007 2 20 35 4/4/2007 36 4/9/2007 36 4/9/2007 ' 37 4/10/2007 37 4/10/2007 1.3 1.0 38 4/11/2007 < 2 1.0 38 4111/2007 < 1 1.0 39 4113/2007 39 4/13/2007 40 4/14/2007 < 2 '' 1.0 40 4/14/2007 1.7 1.0 41 4/16/2007 41 4/16/2007 42 4/17/2007 2.1 2.1 42 4/17/2007 43 4/23/2007 43 4/23/2007 1.9 1.0 44 4/25/2007 - 44 4/25/2007 45 4/30/2007 <. 2 1.0 45 4/30/2007 0'. 1 1.0 46 5/1/2007 2.9 2.9 46 5/l/2007 47 5/3/2007. 47 5/312007 48 SB2007 3.1 3.1 48 5/6/2007 < 1 1.0 49 5A/2007 49 5/7/2007 50 5/14/2007 50 5114/2007 1.3 1.0 51 5/16/2007 3.1 3A 51 6/16/2007 52 521/2007 52 5/21/2007 63 5/22/2007 53 522/2007 <; 1 1.0 64 523/2007 3.2 3.2 54 5/23/2007 55 5/29/2007 3.4 3.4 55 5/29/2007 <. 1 1A 56 5MI2007 56 5/30/2007 < 1 1.0 57 6/4/2007 3.7 3.7 57 614/2007 58 6/11/2007 58 6/11/2007 59 6/12/2007 59 6/12/2007 _ 1 10 60 6/13/2007 - 60 6/13/2007 61 6/15/2007 61 6/15/2007 62 6118/2007 - 3.3 3.3 62 6/18/2007 1.1 1.0 63 6120/2007 63 6/20/2007 64 6/21/2007 64 6/21/2007 65 625/2007 3.6 3.6 65 6/25/2007 < 1 1.0 66 6/27/2007 2.6 2.6 66 6/27/2007 67 6/28/2007 2.4 2A 67 628/2007 _ 1 1.0 68 71212G07 68 702007 69 7/9/2007 .. 69 7/9/2007 <, 1 1.0 70 7111/2007 2.6 Z6 70 7/11/2007 71 7/16/2007 71 7/16/2007 72 711712G07 72 7/1712007 < 1 1.0 73 7/18/2007 4.1 4.1 73 7118/2007 1 74 723/2007 3.2 3.2 74 723/2007 1 1.0 75 7/25/2007 75 7/25/2007 ' 76 7/30/2007 3.4 3.4 '76 7/30/2007 <, 1 1.0 77 8/1/2007 77 8/1/2007 78 8/2t2007 - 2.8 2.8 78 802007 ' 79 816/2007 79 8/6/2007 c' 1 1.0 80 8/8/2007 3 3.0 80 8/8/2007 81 e/l3/2007 81 8113r2007 82 8/14/2007 82 8/14/2007 1.3 1.0 McDowell rpa 2009 extra 83 8/15/2007 3.3 13 83 _ 1 8/15/2007 _ q 84 8/20/2007 85 e/2212007 86 8/27/2007 87 8/29/2007 88 8/30/2007 89 9/4/2007 90 915/2007 91 9/10/2007 92 9/13/2007 93 9/14/2007 94 9/17/2007 95 9/20/2007 96 9124/2007 97 9/26/2007 98 10/1/2007 99 10/5/2007 100 10/8/2007 101 10110/2007 102 10/15/2007 103 10/16/2007 104 10/17/2007 105 10/2212007 106 10/29/2007 107 10/31/2007 108 11/l/2007 109 11/5/2007 110 11/6/2007 111 11/9/2007 112 11/10/2007 113 11/12/2007 114 11/13/2007 115 11/14/2007 116 11/19/2007 117 11/21/2007 118 11/26/2007 119 11/27/2007 120 12/2/2007 121 12/3/2007 122 12/5/2007 123 12/10/2007 124 12(12/2007 125 12/17/2007 125 12/18/2007 127 1211912D07 128 12/26/2007 129 12/31/2007 130 1/2/2008 131 1/7/2008 132 1/14/2008 133 1/16/2008 134 1/22/2008 135 1/23/2008 136 1/28/2008 137 1/30/2008 138 2/4/2008 139 2/5/2008 140 2/6/2008 141 2/11/2008 142 2/14/2008 143 2/18/2008 144 2(20/2008 145 2/27/2008 146 3/5/2008 147 3/10/2008 148 3/12/2008 149 3/18/2008 150 3/19/2008 151 3/26/2008 152 April 153 154 3.3 3.2 28 2.6 3.3 3.2 2.8 2.6 3.2 3.2 2 1.0 2.4 2.4 2 1.0 2.1 21 2 1.0 2 1.0 2 2.0 2 1.0 2 1.0 2 1.0 2.2 2.2 2 1.0 2 1.0 2 1.0 2 2.2 2 2 2.7 2 2 2 2.2 6.7 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2,3 1.0 2.2 1.0 20 2.7 1.0 1.0 1.0 22 6.7 1.0 1.0 1.0 1.0 1.0 1.0 1.0 1.0 1.0 2.3 REASONABLE polate to find Mull. Factor n = 77 37 Hills) cv = 0.576 which truncates to 0.5 row in M.F. Table - 77 column in M.F. Table- 5 upper 8 lower Mull. Factors and interpolate: value 1 address = 'mf table'I$F$79 value 1 = 1,4278575 value 2 address = 'mf table'I$G$79 value 2= 1.51907636 Interpolated MF value= 1.49763152 Round to 2 dec. places to get MF: 1.50 F8q)TeX%V ANALYSIS 86 8/27/2007 < 1 1.0 87 8/29/2007 88 8/30/2007 89 9/4/2007 < 1 1.0 90 9/512007. 91 9/10/2007 92 9/13/2007 <- 1 1.0 93 9/14/2007 :, 94 9/17/2007 <:' 1 1.0 95 9/20/2007 < 1 1.0 96 9/24/2007 . 97 9/26/2007 <I 1 1.0 98 10/1/2007 3.5 3.5 99 10/5/2007 100 10/8/2007 1.7 1.0 101 1CV1012007 102 10/15/2007 103 10/16/2007 < 1 1.0 104 10/17/2007 105 10/22/2007 108 1012912007. <'. 1 1.0 107 10/31/2007 ' 108 11/1/2007 109 11/5/2007 1.4 1.0 110 111WO07 < 1 1.0 111 11/9/2007 112 11/10/2007 113 11/12/2007 114 11/13/2007 1.3 1.0 115 1111412007- 116 11/19/2007 1.1 1.0 117 11/21/2007 118 11/26/2007 <, 1 1.0 119 11/27/2007 120 12/2/2007 <' 1 1.0 121 12/3/2007 122 12/5/2007 123 12/10/2007 <: 1 1.0 124 l2/lX2007 125 12/17/2007 126 12/18/2007 < 1 1.0 127 12/19/2007 < 1 1.0 128 12/26/2007 129 12/31/2007 < 1 1.0 130 1/2/2008 < 1 1.0 131 1O12008 132 1/14/2008 < 1 1.0 133 1/16/2008 134 1/22/2008 <. 1 1.0 135 1/23/2008 136 1/28/2008 < 1 1.0 137 1130/2008 138 2/4/2008- 139 2/5/2008 1.1 1.0 140 21612008- 141 2/11/2008 < 1 1.0 142 2114/2006- 143 2/18/2008 < 1 1.0 144 2/20/2008 < 1 1.0 145 2J27/2008< 1 1.0 146 3/5/2008 147 3/10/2008 < 1 1.0 148 3112/2008 149 3/18(2008 < 1 1.0 150 3/19/2008 < 1 1.0 151 3/26/2008 1 1.0 162 April < 1 1.0 153 < 1 1.0 154 < 1 1.0 155 < 1 1.0 Interpolate to find Mult Factor Mercury n= 73 26 Hills) cv = 0.466 which truncates to 0.4 Find row in M.F. Table - 73 Find column in M.F. Table - 4 Fick upper 8 lower Mull. Factors and interpolate: value 1 address = 'mf table'!$E$75 value i = 1.3500103 value 2 address = 'mf table'!$F$75 value 2= 1.44481977 Interpolated MF value= 1.4126832 Round to 2 dec. places to get MR McDo ell rpal$009 xtm.xls, data -2- 4/22/2009 ++ REASONABL POTENTIAL ANALYSIS Nickel I Zinc Date Data L4pL=1/2DL Results Dale Data BDL-1/2DL Results 1 1/2/2007 2.4 2.4 Std Dev, 0.7865 1 1/212D07 40 40.0 Std Dev. 8.1511 2 1/3/2007 Mean 2.2870 2 11312D07 Mean 47.8571 3 1/4Y2007 2 1.0 C.V. 0.3439 3 1/412D07 33 33.0 C.V. 0.1703 4 118/2D07 n 77 4 1/8/2D07 n 77 5 1/10/2007 5 1/10/2007 6 1/16/2007 2.2 2.2 Mull Factor = 1.2900 6 -11161=7 37 37.0 Mull Factor = 1.1400 7 1117/2007 2.1 2.1 Max. Value 4.0 ug/L 7 1/17/2007 39 39.0 Max. Value 100.0 ug/L 8 1/18/2007 Max. Pred Cw 5.2 uglL 8 1/18/2007 Max. Pred Cw 114.0 uglL 9 1/22/2007 2.4 2.4 9 1/22/2007 42 42.0 10 1/24/2007 10 1/2412D07 11 1129=7 2 1.0 11 1/2912D07 44 44.0 12 1/3112D07 12 1/31/2007 13 2/212007 2.3 2.3 13 2/2/2007 51 51.0 14 2/812007 14 2/6/2D07 15 2M/2007 2 1.0 15 2/8/2007 43 43.0 16 2/12/2007 16 2/1212007 17 2/14/2007 2 1.0 17 2l14/2007 46 40.0 18 2119/2007 18 2/19/2007 19 2/20/2007 2.1 2.1 19 2/20/2007 46 46.0 20 2/21/2007 20 2121/2007 21 2/26/2007 2.3 2.3 21 2/26/2007 40 40.0 22 2/2812007 22 2/28/2007 23 312/2007 2.6 2.6 23 3/2/2007 47 47.0 24 3/5/2007 24 3/5/2007 25 3/912007 9 a 9.1 25 39/2007 49 49.0 26 3/12/2007 27 3/13/2007 28 3/1412007 29 3/20/2007 2 1.0 30 3/21/2007 31 3/2212007 2.3 2.3 32 3/26/2007 2.4 24 33 3/27/2007 34 4/2/2007 35 4/4/2007 2.3 2.3 36 4/9/2007 37 411012D07 38 4/11/2007 2.3 2.3 39 4/13/2007 40 4M4/2007 2 1.0 41 4/1612D07 42 4117/2007 2 1.0 43 4/23/2007 44 4/25/2007 45 4/30/2007 2.2 2.2 46 511/2D07 2.4 2.4 47 SW2007 48 5/6/2007 2 2.0 49 5/7/2007 50 5/14/2007 51 5/1612D07 2.6 2.6 52 5/21/2007 53 - 5/2212007 54 5/23/2007 2.6 2.6 55 5/29/2007 2.6 2.6 56 -sW12D07 57 614/2D07 3.2 3.2 58 6/1112007 59 6/1212007 60 6/13/2007 61 6/15/2D07 62 6/18/2007 2.5 2.5 63 6/20/2007 64 6/21/2007 65 6/25/2007 2.5 2.5 66 6/27/2007 2.2 2.2 67 6/28/2007 2.6 2.6 68 7/2/2007 ' 69 7/9/2007 70 7/11/2007 2.8 2.8 71 7/16/2007 72 7/17/2007 73 7/18/2007 2.8 28 74 7/23/2007 3.8 3.8 75 7/25/2007 76 7/30/2007 3 3.0 77 8/i/2007 78 8/2/2007 2 1.0 79 8/6/2007 80 8/8/2007 2.7 2.7 81 8/13/2007 82 8/14/2007 83 8/15/2007 2 2.0 26 3/12/2007 27 3/13r2007 28 3114/2007 29 3/20/2007 30 3/21/2007 31 3/22/2007 32 3/2612007 33 3127/2007 34 4/21M07 35 4l4/2007 36 4l9/2007 37 4/1012007 38 4/11/2007 39 4/13/2007 40 V14/2007 41 4/16/2007 42 4/17/2007 43 4/23/2007 44 4/2512007 45 4/30/2007 46 5/112007 47 5/312007 48 5/612007' 49 6f7J2D07 50 5/14/2007 51 5116I2007 52 5/21/2007 53 5/22/2007 54 5/23/2007 55 5/29/2007 56 5/30/2007 57 6/4/2007 68 6/11/2007 59 6112I2007 60 6/13/2007 61 6/15/2007 62 6/18/2007 63 6/20/2007 64 6121/2007 65 6125/2D07 66 6/27/2007 67 6/28/2007 08 712/2007 69 7/9/2007 70 7/11=7 71 7/1612007 72 7/17/2007 73 7/18/2007 74 7/23/2007 75 7/25/2007 76 7/30/2007 77 811/2007 78 8/2J2D07 79 8B/2007 80 e1812007 81 8/13/2007 82 8/14/2007 83 -1 8/15/2007 53 49 56 44 43 43 43 48 51 53 45 44 57 53 +T 45 40 55 47 54 53 52 100 44 i 53.0 49.0 56.0 44.0 43.0 43.0 43.0 48.0 51.0 53.0 45.0 44.0 57.0 53.0 52.0 45.0 40.0 55.0 47.0 54.0 53.0 52.0 100.0 44.0 52.0 McDowell rpa 2009 exl ds. data 84 8/20/2007 85 8/22/2007 86 8/27/2007 87 8/29/2007 88 8/30/2D07 89 9/4/2007 90 915/2D07 91 9/10/2007 92 9/13/2007 93 9/14/2007 94 9/17/2007 95 9/20/20D7 96 9/24/2007 97 9/2612007 98 10/1/2007 99 10/5/2007 100 10/8/2007 101 10/10/2007 102 10/15/2007 103 10/16/2007 104 10/17/2007 105 10/22/2007 106 10/29/2007 107 10/31/2007 108 11/1/2007 109 11/5/20D7 110 11/6/2007 111 1119/2D07 112 11/10/2007 113 11/1212007 114 11/13/2007 115 11/14/2007 116 11/1912D07 117 11/21/2007 118 11/26/2007 119 11/2712007 120 12/2/2007 121 121312D07 122 12/5/2007 123 12/1012007 124 12/12(2007 125 12/17/2007 126 12/18/2007 127 12/1912007 128 12/2B/2D07 129 12/31/2007 130 1/2/2008 131 117/2008 132 1/14/2008 133 1/16/2008 134 1/22/2008 135 1/23/2008 136 1/28/2008 137 1/3012008 138 21412008t 139 215/2008t 140 2/6/20081 141 211112D08 `. 2 22 2.2 2 10 2.2 2.2 1.0 2.9 2.9 2.7 2.7 2.6 2.6 2.6 2.6 2.8 2.8 2.4 2.4 2.1 2.1 2 1.0 2 1.0 2 1.0 3.3 3.3 2.1 2.1 2 1.0 2.1 2.1 2.2 2.2 2.4 2 2 2 2.9 2.6 3.3 2.7 2.7 2A 1.0 1.0 2.0 2.9 2.6 3.3 2.7 2.7 REAS 142 2/14/2D08 2.6 2.6 143 2118/2008 2.6 2.6 144 2120/2008' 3.5 3.5 145 2/27/2008 22 22 146 3/5/2008' 147 3/10/2008'. 3 3.0 148 3/12/2008 149 3/18/2008 3.4 3.4 150 3/19/2008 3.4 3.4 151 3/26120081- 3.3 3.3 152 April 3.2 3.2 153 3.6 3.6 154 4 4.0 nterpolate to find Mult. Factor n = 77 61 Hits) cv= 0.344 which truncates to 0.3 Ind row in M.F. Table - 77 'Ind column in M.F. Table- 3 'ick upper & lower Mult. Factors and interpolate: value 1 address = 'mf table!$D$79 value 1 = 1.24775324 value 2 address = 'mf table'I$E$79 value 2 = 1.33707032 Interpolated MF value = 1.28694485 Round to 2 dec. places to get MF: 1. 9� 41�� 86 8/27/2007. 87 8129/2007 88 8/30/2007 89 9/4/2007 90 9/5/2007 91 9/10/2007 92 9113/2007 93 9/14/2007 94 9117/2007 95 9/20/2007 96 9/24/2007 97 9/26/2007 98 10/1/2007 99 10/5/2007 10D 10IW2007 101 10/10/2007 102 10/1512007 103 10/16/2007 104 10/17/2007 105 10/22/2007 106 10/29/2007 107 10/31/2007 108 l l/l/2007 109 11/5/2007 110 11/6/2007 111 11/912007 112 11/10/2007 113 11/12/2007 114 11/13/2007 115 11M412007 116 11/1912007 117 11/21/2007 118 11/26/2007 119 11/27/2007 120 12/2/2007 121 12/312007 122 12/5/2007 123 12/10/2007 124 12/12/2007 125 1211712007 126 12118/2007 127 12/19/2007 128 12/26/2007 129 12/31/2007 130 1/2/2008 131 1/7/2008 132 1/14/2008 133 l/16/2008 134 1IM2008 135 1/23/2008 136 1/28/2008 137 1/30/2008 138 2/4/2008 139 2/5/2008 140 2/6/2008 141 2/11/2008 ANALYSIS 48 48.0 53 53.0 55 55.0 48 48.0 46 46.0 37 37.0 36 36.0 41 41.0 42 42.0 42 42.0 35 35.0 52 52.0 43 43.0 47 47.0 44 44.0 52 52.0 53 53.0 44 44.0 55 55.0 46 46.0 55 55.0 51 51.0 44 44.0 53 53.0 51 51.0 44 44.0 42 42.0 51 51.0 142 2/14/2008 46 46.0 143 2/18/2008 51 51.0 144 2/2012008 54 54.0 145 2/27/2008 51 51.0 146 3/5/2008 147 3/10/2008 47 47.0 148 3/12/2008 149 3/18/2008 46 46.0 150 3H9/2008 52 52.0 151 3126/2008.. 46 46.0 152 April 45 45.0 153 50 50.0 154 54 54.0 interpolate to find Mult. Factor n = 77 77 Hits) cv= 0.170 which truncates to 0.1 =ind row in M.F. Table - 77 =ind column in M.F. Table - 1 Dick upper & lower Mult. Factors and interpolate: value 1 address = 'mf tablel$B$79 value i = 1.07811324 value 2 address = 'mf table) $C$79 value2= 1.1610489 Interpolated MF value = 1.13643421 Round to 2 dec. places to get MF: xtra.xls, data 2 4/2212009 Grzyb, Julie Subject: FW: Reuse at McDowell WWTP Jackie Jarrell of CMUD was notified on the Divisions decision to remove the reuse clause from the final permit for the McDowell WWTP and to pursue a non -discharge permit from Aquifer Protection on 6-26-09 at 4:50 PM. Julie Grzyb From: Risgaard, Jon Sent: Friday, June 26, 2009 12:54 PM To: Grzyb, Julie Cc: Belnick, Tom Subject: RE: Reuse at McDowell WWTP Julie, Thanks for getting the'proposed language and alternatives together. I feel strongly that for any facility desiring to use the effluent as reclaimed water, they must be made aware of the appropriate limits and be able to demonstrate that they are in fact meeting all of the reclaimed water standards. While I believe that McDowell facility is capable of meeting all of the standards, if we can't figure out a way of including all of the limits in the NPDES permit, than I feel we need to direct CMUD to pursue a minor permit from the Aquifer Protection Section (APS) for the generation and use of reclaimed water. I understand Tom's concerns with properly monitoring and enforcement of the system. While I doubt that CMUD would abuse the system and cause a problem, for the sake of consistency it may be best to continue to require permits from both sections. Please advise them that they may wish to seek a permit for either a bulk fill station or for a permit specifying the fields where the which to irrigate. They can contact me for information on how to seek the permit. Thanks again for brainstorming ideas to try to make this work, and for taking the time to meet with me and talk with CMUD staff. I am interested in finding ways to facilitate the use of reclaimed water and there may be cases in the future where it can be more seamlessly be added to an NPDES permit. Jon From: Grzyb, Julie Sent: Friday, June 26, 2009 10:20 AM To: Risgaard, Jon Subject: Reuse at McDowell WWTP Jon, After further discussion, Tom is concerned about the enforcement and tracking of any additional limitations not put on the Effluent and Limitations page which will not make it to a DMR. The turbidity limit we discussed is fine because they will have an instantaneous reading. Additional Fecal and TSS limits would not be tracked. I suggest the following: 1) Go with the permit as stated below, trusting that McDowell's tertiary treatment is sufficient for this use 2) Require that the effluent be treated using membrane filtration (this treatment is what they installed for their reclaimed water use facility and would be additional treatment to their existing effluent.. According to our discussion on the phone it sounded like they were going to use this treatment on the reclaimed effluent anyway, this would assure TSS and fecal coliform limits are being met. 3) Have them get a non -discharge permit. I was hoping to come up with a standard clause that could be used if a facility had a real need for several thousand gallons of reclaimed tertiary treated effluent (i.e. option number 1). However, if they come back requesting to reuse a significant amount of wastewater that should be tracked and monitored more closely, I am thinking they should simply apply for a non -discharge permit. Let me know what you think, Julie Revised NPDES permit clause on Reuse: SUPPLEMENT TO PERMIT COVER SHEET 1. Reuse less than XXX gallons per day of non -potable treated effluent for watering rain gardens on the property of the McDowell Creek Wastewater. Treatment Plant in accordance with condition A. (4.) of the permit. A. (4.) Reuse of Tertiary Treated Effluent Mallard Creek WRF is authorized to use less than XXXX gpd of tertiary treated effluent for watering the rain gardens within the perimeter of the existing wastewater treatment plant provided the following conditions are met: a) Use of tertiary treated effluent will supplement rainfall during dry periods of the year only; b) No runoff or ponding shall occur from the irrigated areas; c) Trucks or areas around the hoses carrying the effluent for watering shall identify the source as non - potable water not to be used for drinking water. d) All irrigation shall occur within the fenced perimeter of the wastewater treatment plant with controlled public access. Such controls may include the posting of signs showing the activities being conducted at each site. e) Permission to use the tertiary treated effluent for watering shall not relieve the Permittee of the responsibility for damages to ground or surface waters resulting from the distribution of tertiary treated effluent on the rain gardens. fl Tertiary treated effluent shall not be applied within 100 feet of a drinking water well. g) The quality of the effluent used for watering shall not exceed the limitations specified in Section A. (1.) of your NPDES Permit. In addition, the reclaimed effluent shall not exceed a turbidity limit of 10 NTU's. Turbidity shall be monitored using a continuous recorder. h) The Permittee shall maintain records at the facility tracking the amount of reclaimed effluent used for watering the rain gardens. These records shall include the following information: i. Date of distribution ii. Daily estimated volume of reclaimed effluent iii. Weather conditions iv. Turbidity i) An education program shall be developed and implemented to inform employees of the proper use of reclaimed water. These materials shall be maintained consistent with the reclaimed water uses. All educational materials shall be made available to the Division upon request. Julie A. Grzyb, Environmental Engineer NC DENR / Division of Water Quality / Surface Water Protection Section NPDES West, Point Source Branch Julie Grzyb NPDES Unit, Western Program NC-DENR 1617 Mail Service Center Raleigh, NC 27699-1617 Re: Dear Ms. Grzyb, • AM CHARLOTTE:M Draft Permit McDowell Creek WWTP NPDES #NC0036277 Mecklenburg Co. RECEIVED JUN 2 4 2009 DENR - WATER QUALITY POINT SOURCE BRANCH Thank you for submittal of the Draft Permit for McDowell Creek WWTP for our review. For the most part we agree with the terms of this permit and find them acceptable. However, we do object to Part A. (4) Reuse of Treatment Plant Effluent. This part of the permit was intended to be used at McDowell to water the rain gardens that were installed at the plant as bio-filters for storm water. During drought conditions these plant may die without watering. The objectionable parts of this permit condition require metering of the treated effluent used for irrigation and restricts the volume of water that may be applied. There are 23 rain gardens on this site that were installed to meet the highest possible Best Management Practices (BMP's) to keep silt out of the surface waters. With the current requirements we may have to install as many as 23 meters. The limits on the volume of water may not allow us to soak the plants enough to keep them alive during drought conditions. We are willing to accept other restrictions on this, such as: • The effluent may only be used for watering on the rain gardens; • Watering may only occur during low rainfall periods_ etc. _ If we could arrange a meeting with us and State personnel to discuss how this may be resolved that would be very helpful. I believe we could meet via a phone conference if that is alright with all of the parties. Thank you for your assistance with this issue, 7acqu'ellel Jarrell, P.E. Superintendent Environmental Management Div. Charlotte Mecklenburg Utilities CHARLOTTE-MECKLENBURG UTILITIES Environmental Management Division 4222 Westmont Drive Charlotte, NC 28217 Phone: 704/336-4407 t Grzyb, Julie From: Grzyb, Julie Sent: Tuesday, June 02, 2009 4:23 PM To: Belnick, Tom Subject: FW: NCO036277 McDowell Creek WWTP From: Hyatt.Marshall@epamail.epa.gov [Hyatt.Marshall@epamail.epa.gov] Sent: Tuesday, June 02, 2009 10:05 AM To: julie.grzyb@ncmail.net Subject: NCO036277 McDowell Creek WWTP EPA has reviewed this permit and has no comments. 1 Beverly Eaves Perdue Governor NCDENR North Carolina Department of Environment and Division of Water Quality Coleen H. Sullins Director May 20, 2009 MEMORANDUM To: Britt Setzer NCDENR / DEH / Regional Engineer Mooresville Regional Office From: Julie Grzyb NPDES Unit Subject: Review of Draft NPDES Permit NCO036277 Natural Resources RECEI'VED MAY DENR - WATER QUALITY POINT SOU . E BRANCH McDowell Creek WWTP Mecklenburg County Please indicate below your agency's position or viewpoint on the draft permit and return this form by June 26, 2009. If you have any questions on the draft permit, please contact me at (919) 807-6389 or e-mail Julie.grzyb@ncmail.net. RESPONSE: (Check one) Concur with the issuance of this permit provided the facility is operated and maintained properly, the stated effluent limits are met prior to discharge, and the discharge does not contravene the designated water quality standards. ❑ Concurs with issuance of the above permit, provided the following conditions are met: Opposes the issuance of the above permit, based on reasons stated below, or attached: 1617 Mall Service Center, Raleigh, North Carolina 27699.1617 Location: 512 N. Salisbury St. Raleigh, North Carolina 27604 Phone: 919.807-M \ FAX: 919-807-6492 \ Customer Service:1-877-623-6748 Internet: www.ncwaterqualit .org An Equal Opportunity \ Affirmative Action Empoyer No e hCarolina Natura!!r, The CharLotte Observer PubLishing Co. Charlotte, NC North Carolina } as Affidavit of Publication Mecklenburg County} THE CHARLOTTE OBSERVER DINA SPRINKLE NCDENR/DWO/POINT SOURCE BRANCH 1617 MAIL SERVICE CENTER RALEIGH NC 27699 REFERENCE: 30063432 6346732 Wastewater Permit Before the undersigned, a Notary Public of said County and State, du Ly authorized to administer oaths affirmations, etc., personally appeared, being duly sworn or affirmed according to Law, doth depose and say that he/she is a representative of The Charlotte Observer Publishing Company, a corporation organized and doing business under the laws of the State of Delaware, and publishing a newspaper known as The Charlotte Observer in the city of Charlotte, County of Mecklenburg, and State of North Caro Linal and that as such he/she is familiar with the books, records, files, and business of said Corporation and by reference to the files of said publication, the attached advertisement was inserted. The following is correct Ly copied from the books and files of the aforesaid Corporation and Publication. PUBLISHED ON: 05/22 AD SPACE: 74 LINE FILED ON: 05/29/09 NAME: O.CIrI'if `U.l (J��YL= TITLE: , yMr( ��� DATE: In Testimony Whereof I have hereunto set my hand an of e day and yefir aforesaid;,_ _ q Notar / I l -fly Ofnmission Expires Public Notice None Carolina ErNlmnnuum.1 Management Comme sloe NPOES Unit 1617 Meil SBNice Carney Baleigb. NC 27699-1617 Notice of Intent to Issue a NPOES Wastewater Permit The North. Carolina Erimmrnemel Management Commission Proposes to issue a NPDES waWawater discharge permit to Rye ssteel Written umilt 3e days stra, Bob the pub ah posed late of thabases. ll be Bable raof athe NO DMuch of Water Oualiry (OWO) m2y hold e — .. n .., w,... in three as a significant occurs of public on or Rowan Associates & Mercantile requestaa renewal of NCOO6t034 for b, Rower jimecades & Mercantile WV1fP In Rowan County. unnamed t buaq W ranitted Town Creeksto Me Yadlon Pea Oeearred wastewater t River Benin. Weslslde Swim & Racquet Club requested renewal of permit NCBo4243 in Rowan County This permuted discharge is formed tlomastic wastswetef to Braes Branch in the )(ionnoPea Dee Rrvar Basin. my seal, the My Commission Expires May 27, 2011 SOC Priority Project: No To: Western NPDES Program Unit (� Water Quality Section f Attention: Dina Sprinkle ; I AUG - 7 2008' Date: August 4, 2008 (__ ` DE'-R RATER :' LI { NPDES STAFF REPORT AND RECOMMENDATION--- County: Mecklenburg Permit No. NCO036277 PART I - GENERAL INFORMATION Facility and Address: Charlotte Mecklenburg Utilities McDowell Creek WWTP 5100 Brookshire Boulevard Charlotte, North Carolina 28216 2. Date of Investigation: 8-01-2008 3. Report Prepared by: Samar Bou-Ghazale, Env. Engineer II 4. Persons Contacted and Telephone Number: Mr. Pete Goins Jr., (704) 875-6443 Directions to Site: From the intersection of SR 2128 (Beatties Ford Road) and SR 2074 (Neck Road), travel west on SR 2074 approximately 1.9 miles. The W WTP is located on the right side of SR 2074 after crossing McDowell Creek. 6. Discharge Point(s), List for all discharge points: Latitude: 350 22' 54" Longitude: 80° 56' 20" Attach a USGS map extract and indicate treatment facility site and discharge point on map. U.S.G.S. Quad No.: F15NW U.S.G.S. Quad Name: Lake Norman South, NC Site size and expansion area consistent with application? Yes. 8. Topography (relationship to flood plain included): Slopes range from 2 to 4%, the W WTP is not in a flood plain. 9. Location of nearest dwelling: None within 1000 feet. 10. Receiving stream or affected surface waters: McDowell Creek t Page Two l a. Classification: WS-IV b. River Basin and Subbasin No.: Catawba 030833 C. Describe receiving stream features and pertinent downstream uses: Receiving stream is approximately 50 feet wide x 3-5 feet deep. A CMU water intake is located a few miles downstream on Mountain Island Lake. The lake is used for primary and secondary recreation as well as water supply source. PART II - DESCRIPTION OF DISCHARGE AND TREATMENT WORKS 1. a. Volume of wastewater to be permitted: 12.0 MGD (ultimate design capacity) b. Current permitted capacity of the wastewater treatment facility: 12.0 MGD C. Actual treatment capacity of the current facility (current design capacity): 12.0 MGD d. Date(s) and construction activities allowed by previous Authorizations to Construct issued in the previous two years: NIA e. Please provide a description of existing or substantially constructed wastewater treatment facilities: The existing WWT facilities consist of influent pump station with influent screening and Vortex grit removal, one 1.3 million gallon flow equalization day tank, two 6 million gallon storm flow equalization basins for a total of 12 million gallon, five clarifiers, 4 trains biological treatment, four final clarifiers, sludge pump station,15 MGD RAS/WAS pumping station, five anaerobic digesters (four primary and one secondary). The secondary digester is a gas scrubbing system, a blower building, a lime storage and feed facility, a chemical storage and feed facility, a chlorine contact tank for membrane feed, two distinct effluent filter with UV disinfection, cascade post aeration and stand-by power supply. f. Please provide a description of proposed wastewater treatment facilities: N/A g. Possible toxic impacts to surface waters: This facility has a good compliance history with toxicity testing results. h. Pretreatment Program (POTWs only): CMU has an approved pretreatment program. There are no significant industrial users permitted to discharge process wastewater to the WWTP. 2. Residuals handling and utilization/disposal scheme: a. Residuals are land applied. DWQ Permit No. WQ0000057. Page Three Residuals Contractor: Synagro, Inc. b. Residuals stabilization: PSRP C. Landfill: Waste from the grit chamber and bar screen is taken to Mecklenburg County. landfill. 3. Treatment plant classification: Class IV 4. SIC Code(s): 4952 Wastewater Code(s) 01 Main Treatment Unit Code: 11113 PART III - OTHER PERTINENT INFORMATION 1. Is this facility being constructed with Construction Grant Funds or are any public monies involved (municipals only)? Public monies 2. Special monitoring or limitations (including toxicity) requests: None at this time. 3. Important SOC, JOC or Compliance Schedule dates (Please indicate): N/A 4. Alternative Analysis Evaluation: N/A 5. Air quality and/or groundwater concerns or hazardous materials utilized at this facility that may impact water quality, air quality, or groundwater: No AQ or GW concerns nor are hazardous materials utilized at this facility. PART IV - EVALUATION AND RECOMMENDATIONS The permittee, Charlotte -Mecklenburg Utilities, has applied for Permit renewal for the subject facility. The WWTP appeared in good operational condition at the time of the investigation. This facility was expanded in 2004 from 6 to 6.6 MGD. Also, in 2004 this facility requested an A to C to expand from 6.6 to 9 MGD and later from 9 to 12 MGD. The expansion was completed in 2007. It should be noted that the new discharge point is approximately 100 feet up -stream of the old discharge point. Pending review and approval by the Western NPDES Program Unit, it is recommended that the permit be renewed as requested. Signature of report rep Date Water Quality Regional Supervisor D e 13be6 �5 I V14 RIO& 491900 1 1 IU M. - NPDES/A uifer Protection Permitting Unit Pretreatment Information Request Form PERMIT WRITER COMPLETES THIS PART: PERMIT WRITERS - AFTER you get this form Date of Requestl 2/26/2009 Facility Name CMU McDowell Creek Permit Number NCO036277 Region MRO Basin Catawba check applicable PERCS staff: Check all that apply aacK rrom rtrtUs - Notify PERCS if LTMP/STMP data we said should be on DMRs is not really there, so we can get it for you (or NOV POTW). - Notify PERCS if you want us to keep a specific POC in LTMP/STMP so you will have data for next permit renewal. - Email PERCS draft permit, fact sheet, RPA. - Send PERCS paper copy of permit (w/o NPDES boilerplate), cover letter, final fact sheet. Email RPA if changes. municipal renewal x new industries WWTP expansion Speculative limits stream reclass. stream relocation 7010 change otherl ✓ jCTB, CHO. LUM, NEW, ROA - Dana Folle 523 HIW, LTN, NEU, YAD - Monti Hassan 371 BRD, CPF, FRB, TAR - Sarah Morrison (208) Listed as having a pretreatment program but zero non -categorical SIU's and zero CIU's PERCS PRETREATMENT STAFF COMPLETES THIS PART: G y� ! . P�'�o a� GCiF7j"N�Status of Pretreatment Program (check all that apply)'r`V1, 1) facility has no SIU's, does have Division approved Pretreatment Program that is INACTIVE 2) facility has no SIU's, does not have Division approved Pretreatment Program 3) facility has SIUs and DWQ approved Pretreatment Program (list "DEV" if program still under development) C ttAA, 3a) Full Program with LTMP 3b) Modified Program with STMP 4) additional conditions regarding Pretreatment attached or listed below TMP time ost re t: Flow, MGD Pe i ed Actual Time period for Actual Next cle: - da Indust al Uncontrollable n/a G POC due to C✓ l V I POC In Parameter of NPDES/ Non- Required POTw POC 4Fq LTMP LTMP/ Concern (POC) Disch Permit Required by 603 POC due (Explain Ent Effluent Ob S P Check List Limit b EPA' Slud e * to SIU1 below "" Fr 4Q M Q = Quarterly M = Monthly all data on DM YES NO attach data) data ins readshi YES email to writer NO 4 1 UM 4 1 QM 4 1 Q M vays`in the LIMP/STI�IIP ;_ " Only in LTMP/STMP If sludge land app or composte (dif POCs for incinerators) Only in LTMP/STMP while SIU still discharges to POTW "" Only In LTMP/STMP when pollutant is still of concern to POTW :omments to Permit Writer (ex., explanation of any POCs: info you have on IU related investigations into NPDES problems): lq5 McDowell Creek NPDES_Pretreatmentrequestfortn.feb20a8-1 Revised July 24, 2007 RE: spray it igation Subject: RE: spray irrigation From: "Padgett, Dawn" <DPadgett@ci.charlotte.nc.us> Date: Fri, 20 Mar 200915:37:04 -0400 To: "'Julie Grzyb"' <Tulie.Grzyb@ncmail.net> CC: "Jarrell, Jackie" <Jaarrell@ci.charlotte.nc.us> Thanks Julie - I think this would be a good idea, the only thing we don't have is a quantified meter, I think we can get something for this. Thanks for thinking about us. Also, did you get my voice message asking about the McDowell NOV for TRC? I asked Jackie about this and she had not seen it. I would object to the NOV based on the footnote in the existing permit - Footnote #4 for Total Residual Chlorine "Limit and monitoring only apply is effluent is chlorinated". Since we do not chlorinate the effluent (I think the result was from an interference), this limit does not apply. If you could let us know when this was sent and who received it, I would appreciate it. Thanks, Dawn -----Original Message ----- From: Julie Grzyb [mailto:Julie.Grzyb@ncmail.net] Sent: Friday, March 20, 2009 3:08 PM To: Padgett, Dawn; Jarrell, Jackie Subject: spray irrigation Dawn, There is a standard clause that can be put into a NPDES permit for reuse of non -potable ,'treated effluent for irrigation and dust control on the property of the permitted facility in accordance with the following conditions: A.(1.) SPRAY IRRIGATION CONDITION The spray irrigation of tertiary treated effluent around the existing wastewater treatment facilities is authorized by the Division under the following conditions: * The irrigation water will supplement rainfall during dry periods of the year only; * The effluent applied will be quantified by a meter; * The maximum application rate shall not exceed 0.25-inch/hour or 1.0-inch/day; * No runoff shall occur from the irrigated areas; * Appropriate notice shall be supplied at the entrance of the facility indicating that the area is being irrigated with reclaimed water that should not be used for drinking; and * Irrigation shall occur within the fenced perimeter of the wastewater treatment plantl,with controlled public access. Would you be interested in having this put in the McDowell Creek permit? It is also possible to allow for additional internal uses (i.e. restrooms, HVAC system, and vehicle wash down) along with the conditions above and: * The reuse water will be used by plant personnel who are trained and knowledgeable about water reuse. * An RPZ device will be required onsite to protect the potable water 1 of 2 3/20/2009 4:42 PM RE: spray irrigation f r supply. * No runoff shall occur from the vehicle wash down or irrigated areas. If you are interested in using treated water for irrigation at McDowell during dry periods please let me know because a clause like this should be put in the permit. Also, I know Mallard Creek has a permit for water reclamation but if it does not specify that you can use it around the facility for irrigation I can put it in Mallard's permit as well - if wanted. Julie Julie Grzyb Environmental Engineer NPDES West/ DWQ N.C. Dept. of Environment and Natural Resources 1617 Mail Service Center, Raleigh, NC 27699-1617 (919) 807-6389; fax (919) 807-6495 E-mail correspondence to and from this address may be subject to the North Carolina Public Records Law and may be disclosed to third parties. 2 of 2 3/20/2009 4:42 PM Mi hu-11 U LVCy va- 1 WiUleaa G Russ JF . " NOM Catolasl Lk] uuwnf of Fnrarnnneut 41dN=94d Hetawt CUIctu }1 ..^.nllml, I hlCtt T Augusl B. 2008 S, r.r.� doe °r%' gERTIFIED MAIL 700 14SU 0004 4510 0202 RETURN RECEIPT RiQUESTED Ms. Jacqueline a. Jai lell C',hnrlotte Mecklenburg UlililieS 42V Westmont Drtve Charlotte, Wirth Caroll a 28217 Subjecd. Notice of Violation - Effluent Limitations Tracking #. NOV-2008-uV-0383 McDowell Creek VVW I I' NPDES Permit No. M6cklernburg County Dear Ms. Jarrell* A iaview ul the April 111113 somiIf-mnniforing report for the hubjw;1 facility revealed a violation of the following pdIameter. Pipe Parim ctcr Repotted valuc Permit Limit 001 TR 9U ugn (daily mAylmum) 18 uyll (daily maxlntum) Remedial acliul eS, if tut already Implr►me►nled. should be taken to cui1u l any problem The Division of Water uallly 1pay pursue enfnrr ment actions for this and any uddiliunal vininfinns If the violations are Ur A t~ulduluinq nature, not related to operation and/w mnlntPnAnrn prnbtem-arld yuu anticipate remedial constnirtinn ar:tivities. then you may wise to consider Applying R; a Spbt;lal Order by Consent. You may rnntn& Mr. John Lesley of the Ciffice for addirinnal in rmation. If you have hie etinn, conceritirty lhib lildtter. please do not hesitate to enntnr:t Mr. Lesley or me at 70Al43,'I BOO. Robert B. K1 tlUb Surface Watei PiuteCtwn ' Regional Supervisui M Pu1111 Suutc.d ranch MeukleitLuiy uuoty Water Uuality Protection MOPE Aadrtss rkw•• (144) rd..1.1699 r,Ocacian l,> � �u•,1 •• 610 MCI l.CQW1 Avinur, Sulu l 1 btu hart IC.elntet AWDUC, SURC S01 ;UAltdi 1 fdooftsv7b, NC J8115 DdaOreevilic.WonhCa waso FOR+ncr vvw acxrten • ■1.1 In, CactamerS#mcr IJI17-67.' VAB j gnF�pul�flly ■l�.tdriAliuntil eeAClrontmobYer—> KCCt'ClCdflO'riPOLIC01IN11 fP4W' A 0 # L "t L' 0 W 5 L `oZ IVII18ON LOOSH Ot L6 @ION jjnsa8 aged awil IaejS apoW .lagwnN 8uogd/x8J 9V:SL 60OZ OZ aeW L'd 4CAC :I— —A 0CIa8 -=�uai:3 :�. i W S U e A 1 AK*C 56V9t086 L6 :xed aa.lnoS Iu i od 08a Qatd Flow Eff As Cd Cr Cu Pb Hg Mo Ni Se Ad Zry CN ug/l ug/I ug/l /l u I ng/l ug/l ug/I ug/l g/l /l ug/I 1 /1 /2007 5.6 5.6 1/2/2007 5.4 5.4 1 <10.00 1 /3/2007 5.21 5.2 <1.00 1 /4/2007 5.31 5.3 <5.00 <1.00 <5.00 2.4 <5.00 <5.00 2.4 <5.00 <5.00 40 1 /5/2007 5.3 5.3 1 /6/2007 6 6 1 /7/2007 6.5 6.5 1 /8/2007 7.8 7.81 1 <10.00 1 /9/2007 5.8 5.8 1/10/2007 5.4 5.4 <5.00 <1.00 <5.00 <2.00 <5.00 <1.00 <5.00 1 <2.00 <5.00 <5.00 33 <10.00 1 /11 /2007 5.4 5.4 1 /12/2007 5.4 5.4 1 /13/2007 5.4 5.4 1 /14/2007 5.41 5.4 1 /15/2007 5.21 5.2 1 /16/2007 4.9 4.91 <10.00 1 /17/2007 4.9 4.9 1.2 1 /18/2007 5.1 5.1 <5.00 <1.00 <5.00 <2.00 <5.00 <5.00 2.2 <5.00 <5.00 37 1 /19/2007 5.1 5.1 1 /20/2007 5.4 5.4 1 /21 /2007 5.51 5.5 i 1 /22/2007 5.8 5.8 <5.00 <1.00 <5.00 <2.00 <5.00 <5.00 2.1 <5.00 <5.00 39 <10.00 1 /23/2007 5.21 5.2 1 /24/2007 5.1 5.1 <1.00 1 /25/2007 5.2 5.2 1 /26/2007 5.1 5.1 1 /27/2007 5.3 5.3 1 /28/2007 5.41 5.41 1/29/2007 5 51 <5.00 <1.00 <5.00 <2.00 <5.00 <5.00 2.4 <5.00 <5.00 42 <10.00 1 /30/2007 5 5 1 /31 /2007 2/1 /2007 _ 4.9 5.51_5.5 4.9 1 1__ 1.2 2/2/2007 5.11 5.1 <5.00 <1.00 <5.00 <2.00 <5.00 5.8 <2.00 <5.00 <5.00 44 2/3/2007 5.31 �5.4 5 5.3 5.4 J_ 5 I _ 2/4/2007 2/5/2007 i i 2/6/2007 5 5 5 - 5 I <10.00 2/7/2007 2/8/2007 5 <5.00 <1.00 <5.00 <2.00 <5.00 "<1.00 <5.00 2.3 <5.00 <5.00 51 <10.00 2/9/2007 _5 4.9 4.9 2/10/2007 5.3 5.3 2/11 /2007 5.4 5.4 2/12/2007 5 5 <10.00 2/13/2007 5.2 5.2 2/14/2007 6.4 6.4 <5.00 <1.00 <5.00 <2.00 <5.00 3 <5.00 <2.00 <5.00 <5.00 43 2/15/2007 5.4 5.4 2/16/2007 5.2 5.2 2/17/2007 5.3 5.3 2/18/2007 5.4 5.4 2/19/2007 5.2 5.2 <10.00 2/20/2007 5.11 5.1 <5.00 <1.00 <5.00 <2.00 <5.00 <5.00 <2.00 <5.00 <5.00 46 2/21 /2007 5.1 5.1 4.1 2/22/2007 5.5 5.5 2/23/2007 5 5 2/24/2007 5.2 5.2 2/25/2007 6.31 6.3 2/26/2007 5.5 5.5 <5.00 <1.00 <5.00 <2.00 <5.00 <5.00 2.1 <5.00 <5.00 46 <10.00 2/27/2007 5.3 5.3 1 1_ 2/28/2007 5.1 5.11 1 1 _ 1 1 1 1.4 Clow JL Date Flow Eff As Cd Cr Cu Pb Hg Mo Ni Se Ag Zn CN ug/l ug/l ug/l ug/l ug/l ng/I ug/l ug/l ug/l ug/I ug/l ugll 3/1 /2007 6.3 6.3 3/2/2007 6.6 6.6 <5.00 <1.00 <5.00 <2.00 <5.00 <5.00 2.3 <5.00 <5.00 40 3/3/2007 11.4 11.4 3/4/2007 6.2 6.2 3/5/2007 61 6 1.4 <10.00 3/6/2007 5.31 5.3 3/7/2007 5.31 5.3 3/8/2007 5.3 5.3 3/9/2007 5.1 5.1 <5.00 <1.00 <5.00 <2.00 <5.00 1.1 <5.00 2.6 <5.00 <5.00 47 <10.00 3/10/2007 5.5 5.5 3/11 /2007 5.6 5.6 3/12/2007 5.41 5.4 1 <10.00 3/13/2007 5.41 5.4 <5.00 <1.00 <5.00 1 <2.00 <5.00 <5.00 2.3 <5.00 <5.00 1 49 <10.00 3/14/2007 5.41 5.4 3/15/2007 5.41 5.4 3/16/2007 6.11 6.1 3/17/2007 5.81 5.8 _ 3/18/2007 5.71 5.7 3/19/2007 5.31 5.3 _ 3/20/2007 5.1 5.1 , <10.00 3/21 /2007 5.2 5.2 1.1 3/22/2007 5 5 <5.00 <1.00 <5.00 2.4 <5.00 <5.00 <2.00 <5.00 <5.00 53 <10.00 3/23/2007 5.11 5.1 3/24/2007 5.41 5.4 3/25/2007 5.61 5.6 3/26/2007 5.31 5.3 1.1 _ <10.00 3/27/2007 5.11 5.1 <5.00 <1.00 <5.00 2.3 <6.00 <5.00 2.3 <5.00 <5.00 49 3/28/2007 5.11 5.1 3/29/2007 5.1 5.1 3/30/2007 5.3 5.3 3/31 /2007 5.3 5.3 -� 4/1 /2007 5.3 5.3 4/2/2007 4.9 4.9 <5.00 <1.00 <5.00 2.2 <5.00 <5.00 2.4 <5.00 <5.00 56 <10.00 4/3/2007 5 5 i <1.00 - i 4/4/2007 4.9 4.9 4/5/2007 4.9 4.9 - 4/6/2007 5 5 4/7/2007 5.2 5.2 4/8/2007 5.2 5.2 4/9/2007 5.21 5.2 <10.00 4/10/2007 5.11 5.1 <5.00 <1.00 <5.00 2 <5.00 <5.00 2.3 <5.00 <5.00 44 4111 /2007 5 5 1.3 4/12/2007 5 5 4/13/2007 4.6 4.6 <1.00 4/14/2007 51 5 <5.00 <1.00 <5.00 <2.00 <5.00 <5.00 2.3 <5.00 <5.00 43 <10.00 4/15/2007 7.31 7.3 4/16/2007 5.31 5.3 1.7 <10.00 4/17/2007 51 5 <5.00 <1.00 <5.00 <2.00 <5.00 <5.00 <2.00 <5.00 <5.00 43 4/18/2007 5.11 5.1 4/19/2007 5.21 5.2 4/20/2007 5.41 5.4 4/21 /2007 5.41 5.4 4/22/2007 5.51 5.5 4/23/2007 5.11 5.1 <10.00 4/24/2007 5.11 5.1 4/25/2007 5.11 5.1 <5.00 <1.00 <5.00 2.1 <5.00 1.9 <5.00 <2.00 <5.00 <5.00 43 4/26/2007 51 5 4/27/2007 5.3 5.3 4/28/2007 5.2 5.2 Qatd , low Eff As Cd Cr Cu Pb Hg Mo Ni Se Ag Zn CN ug/I ug/l ug/l ug/l ug/l ng/l ug/l ug/l ug/l ug/l ug/l ug/l 4/29/2007 5.4 5.4 4/30/2007 5.11 5.1 <10.00 5/l /2007 51 5 1 <1.00 5/2/2007 51 5 5/3/2007 5.11 5.1 <5.00 <1.00 <5.00 <2.00 <5.00 <5.00 2.2 <5.00 <5.00 48 5/4/2007 5.11 5.1 5/5/2007 5.4 5.4 5/6/2007 5.5 5.5 <5.00 <1.00 <5.00 2.9 <5.00 <5.00 2.4 <5.00 <5.00 51 <10.00 5/7/2007 5.1 5.1 1 1 <1.00 <10.00 5/8/2007 5.2 5.2 5/9/2007 5.21 5.2 5/10/2007 5.21 5.2 5/11 /2007 4.91 4.9 5/12/2007 5.3 5.3 5/13/2007 5.3 5.3 5/14/2007 5.2 5.2 <5.00 <1.00 <5.00 3.1 <5.00 <5.00 2 <5.00 <5.00 53 <10.00 5/15/2007 5.1 5.1 5/16/2007 5.11 5.1 1 1.3 5/17/2007 5.11 5.1 _ 5/18/2007 5.11 5.1 5/19/2007 5.1 5.1 5/20/2007 5.1 5.1 5/21 /2007 5.2 5.2 <10.00 5/22/2007 51 5 <5.00 <1.00 <5.00 3.1 <5.00 <5.00 _ 2.6 <5.00 <5.00 45 5/23/2007 5.1 5.1 <1.00 5/24/2007 5.7 5.7 5/25/2007 5.6 5.6 5/26/2007 5.2 5.2 5/27/2007 5.1 5.1 5/28/2007 5.4 5.4 5/29/2007 5.41 5.4 i <10.00 5/30/2007 5.3 5.3 <5.00 <1.00 15.00 3.2 <5.00 <1.00 <5.00 _ 2.6 <5.00 <5.00 44 <10.00 5/31 /2007 5.3 5.3 6/l /2007 5 5 6/2/2007 5.2 5.2 _ 6/3/2007 5.4 5.4 �6/4/2007 5.6 5.6 <5.00 <1.00 <5.00 3.4 <5.00 <1.00 <5.00 2.6 <5.00 <5.00 57 <10.00 6/5/2007 5.71 5.7 6/6/2007 4.91 4.9 6/7/2007 51 5 _ 6/8/2007 51 5 6/9/2007 5.21 5.2 6/10/2007 5.11 5.1 6/11 /2007 51 5 <10.00 6/12/2007 4.8 4.8 <5.00 <1.00 <5.00 3.7 <5.00 1 <5.00 3.2 <5.00 <5.00 53 6/13/2007 4.8 4.8 1 6/14/2007 5 5 6/15/2007 5 5 <10.00 6/16/2007 5 5 6/17/2007 5.21 5.2 6/18/2007 5.11 5.1 <10.00 6/19/2007 5 5 6/20/2007 5 5 1.1 6/21/2007 5 5 <5.00 <1.00 <5.00 3.3 <5.00 <5.00 2.5 <5.00 <5.00 52 6/22/2007 4.91 4.9 6/23/2007 5 5 6/24/2007 5.2 5.2 6/25/2007 5.2 5.2 <10.00 6/26/2007 4.91 4.9 ' Cd Cr Cu : 11 11Ciro1 11 mom, 11 11 ® 11 11 EWA 11 11 ©© 11owl1 11 11 11 ® 11 li �1 1 11 mug1 1 NMI ' ' Will1 1 11 MIA • 11 -® 11 it 11 ® i 11 1 1 m 1 1 mom, 11 ' • 110 T11 2ff 11 1 11 oil 1 11 WE 11 my,1 amommi1 ® 1 11 11 �� 11 11 11 11 11 11 11 of it � 11 11 11 � 11 11 ® 11 11 11 11 1 11 KIN I.-TO-791 MI 1:161 1 MI FamwiTellomom 1 1 1 1 1 1 ® 1 1®- - • i i ®®_ • 1 i '' • li ' • m 11 axiom VOTAMmIn. mr,/ 11 ® 11 11 ® 1 11 . 11 LONm7r,1 . 11 • . Layi1 1 • • • 1 1 1 V. 11 PUZ,1 1 •• ! 1 ___ 1 1 1 FMT.Wet 11 1 1 11 11 11 it 11 11 ® 11 ® 11 11 ® ! 11 1 • 11 Em, Em,�___________ �� 11CRITIN 1 m- MEN ® ® • SEFL, IMo 1 MW of its off ... 1 pffiffiRifffffim— E ® ® _ ............... so ® sworlumn l w _ Mfg m, 0 MI �� i UY 11ORITIN M MIMMITIN . !1 11 !! © 1! !! 11 © 11 11 m 1 !1 Sri SHE IS UBUR11: 11 11 !! 11 11 !! 1 11 MFA11: 1 1 : 1 1 :wn.Evil., Sri ! ! 1 : 1 ! : mom 11 11 11 11 11 11 1 !1 1 11:�� 11 11 11 11 11 11 11 ® 11 11 �� _ ffirgi MKITIN1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 ® 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 : • �____-__-_-_- a !1 1 1 : �' No 1 1 : Date Flow Eff As Cd Cr Cu Pb Hg Mo Ni Se Ag Zn CN ug/l ug/I ug/l ugll ug/l ng/I ug/I ug/I ug/I ug/I ug/l ug/l 2/18/2008 4.6 4.4 <10.00 2/19/2008 5.2 4.5 2/20/2008 4 4.2 <5.00 <1.00 <5.00 6.7 <5.00 <1.00 <5.00 2.6 <5.00 <5.00 46 2/21 /2008 4.1 4.1 2/22/2008 4.11 4.3 2/23/2008 4.41 4.4 2/24/2008 4.41 4.4 2/25/2008 4.21 4.3 2/26/2008 4.51 4.4 2/27/2008 4.41 4.6 <5.00 <1.00 <5.00 <2.00 <5.00 <1.00 <5.00 2.6 <5.00 <5.00 51 2/28/2008 4.3 4.4 2/29/2008 4.2 4.3 3/1 /2008 4.5 4.3 3/2/2008 4.6 4.4 3/3/2008 4.3 4.5 3/4/2008 5 4.6 3/5/2008 5.3 5.2 <5.00 <1.00 <5.00 <2.00 <5.00 <1.00 <5.00 3.5 <5.00 <5.00 54 <10.00 3/6/2008 4.5 4.8 3/7/2008 5.3 4.7' _ 3/8/2008 5.3 5.1 3/9/2008 4.6 4.61 ) I 3/10/2008 4.6 4.7 <5.00 <1.00 <5.00 <2.00 <5.00 <5.00 2.2 <5.00 I <5.00 51 3/11 /2008 4.3 4.5 3/12/2008 4.3 _4.51 <1.00 ----i- 3/13/2008 4.3 4.4 3/14/2008 4.2 1 3/15/2008 5 _4.4 4.7 i- 3/16/2008 5.1 4.91 ) 3/17/2008 4.51 5.11 ) 3/18/2008 3/19/2008 4.51 4.7 4.8 <5.00 4.8 <1.00 <5.00 <2.00 <5.00 <1.00 <5.00 3 <5.00_ <5.00 47 -� <10.00 3/20/2008 , 4.71 _ 5.1 _ ! ) 3/21 /2008 ; 4.61 51 3/22/2008 3/23/2008 3/24/200_81 , 4.61 j_4.3 4.2 4.71 4.6�_ 4.4 3/25/2008 4.2 4.5 46 3/26/2008 4.3 4.5 _ 15.00 <1.00 <5.00 <2.00 <5.00 <1.00 <5.00 3.4 __� _ <5.00 T <5.00 ; 3/27/2008 4.3 _4.2 3/28/2008 4.41 4.41 3/29/2008 4.7 4.3 ! 3/30/20081 3/31 /2008 4.6 4.6 4.5 4.7� April <5.00 <1.00 <5.00 <2.00 <5.00 1 <5.00 3.4 <5.00 <5.00 52 <10.0 <5.00 <1.00 <5.00 <2.00 <5.00 <1 <5.00 3.3 <5.00 <5.00 46 <5.00 <1.00 <5.00 <2.00 <5.00 <1 <5.00 3.2 <5.00 I <5.00 45 <5.00 <1.00 <5.00 <2.00 <5.00 <1 <5.00 3.6 <5.00 <5.00 50 <5.00 <1.00 <5.00 2.3 <5.00 <1 <5.00 4 <5.00 <5.00 54 all non -detect all < 5 RPA all<5.0 RPA all<10 RPA all<5 all<5 RPA all<10 one 2.0 "A- 6,, C tA- 14-a /V/� zn CW RE: NPDES permit renewals for Mallard and McDowell Subject: RE: NPDES permit renewals for Mallard and McDowell From: "Padgett, Dawn" <DPadgett@ci.charlotte.nc.us> Date: Wed, 18 Mar 2009 18:19:40 -0400 To: "'Julie Grzyb"' <Tulie.Grzyb@ncmail.net> Hi Julie - the attached letter - residuals mgmt letter.doc should address the sludge management questions. Please let me know if you need anything else with this. McDowell does not have a re -use permit. The facility is set up to have a re -use program, but since there are no customers this has not been pursued. Also, McDowell does not have any SIU's that discharge to this facility. Though there are a number of commercial facilities in this basin the wastewater is predominately residential. I do not have any firm numbers for the percent residential. I can give you a guess of 95% residential and 5% commercial, but this is a guess. Do you need a specific number? Dawn -----Original Message ----- From: Julie Grzyb [mailto:Julie.Grzyb@ncmail.net] Sent: Wednesday, March 18, 2009 5:48 PM To: Padgett, Dawn; Jarrell, Jackie Subject: NPDES',permit renewals for Mallard and McDowell Dawn, To complete the renewal applications for NCO030210 and NCO036277 the following is needed: Sludge management Plans for Mallard and McDowell Creek. These were`not requested as part of the NPDES 2A Form but on the initial permit renewal letter from NCDENR sent on June 8, 2007. Simply identifying that you have one, the Class type of biosolids, and that they are land applied in accordance with Permit Number is sufficient along with a narrative description. McDowell Creek - identify any non -discharge permits (for reclaimed water), include amount allowed for reuse and permit number. Also, for McDowell what percent of wastewater is considered residential? If you believe this information has already been sent in as part of CMU's renewal for Mallard and McDowell, please contact me. Thanks, Julie Julie Grzyb Environmental Engineer NPDES West/ DWQ N.C. Dept. of Environment and Natural Resources 1617 Mail Service Center, Raleigh, NC 27699-1617 (919) 807-6389; fax (919) 807-6495 E-mail correspondence to and from this address may be subject to the North Carolina Public Records Law and may be disclosed to third parties. Content -Description: Residuals Mgmt letter.doc Residuals Mgmt letter.docContent-Type: application/msword Content -Encoding: base64 1 of 1 3/20/2009 9:54 AM permit renewal, Mallard and McDowell Subject: permit renewal, Mallard and McDowell From: Julie Grzyb <Tulie.Grzyb@ncmail.net> Date: Wed, 18 Mar 2009 15:53:12 -0400 To: "Padgett, Dawn" <DPadgett@ci.charlotte.nc.us> Dawn, Thanks to you and all the CMU staff who came out and helped explain and answer questions on Mallard and McDowell Creek WWTP's. I can see why you all are so proud to show the plants off. Again, thanks for all your time and effort showing me around. I am trying to finish up both draft permits and have a few items requiring your help. Mallard Creek - the correspondence file in the Central office contains no copy of the letter CMU wrote in response to the NOV issued 3-7-08. If you can email that to me (or send it) I will try to incorporate your response into the fact sheet if appropriate. The NOV is for a discharge of wastewater without adequate disinfection and not a failed operating procedure so. IlL think your letter may be appropriate. G,. reef r�.,d e,1c4t- A;;lc / igVl McDowell Creek,- The permit renewal applicationgives_process design _removal rates in Attachment #3 A.11.b. Can you give me actual removal rates for these parameters over the past two years (1/07 - 12/08)? Primarily interested in TN and TP but if you have the others it would be helpful. Please call if�you want to discuss, a - k Julie �' ��^ O .- Julie Grzyb Environmental Engineer NPDES West/ DWQ N.C. Dept. of Environment and Natural Resources 1617 Mail Service Center, Raleigh, NC 27699-1617 (919) 807-6389;.�fax (919) 807-6495 E-mail correspondence to and from this address may be subject to the North Carolina Public Records Law and may be disclosed to third parties. 1 of 1 3/18/2009 5:48 PM • CHAHIATTE- i! JUN 2 6 2008 LI! June 24, 2008 NCDENR/DWQ ---- Attn: NPDES Unit 1617 Mail Service Center Raleigh, NC 27699-1617 RE: NPDES Permit Application for McDowell Creek W WTP NPDES Permit #NC0036277 Dear Point Source Unit: Please find enclosed the original and two copies of the NPDES Permit Application for McDowell Creek W WTP, NPDES Permit #NC0036277. This application is for the renewal of the current NPDES Permit that expires on December 31, 2008. Please note that the expanded effluent testing data is a summary of the data gathered from January 1, 2005 — March 31, 2008. There are four attachments with this application. Attachment #1 shows the facility and a one mile radius as required by Section B.2. Attachment #2 is the process flow diagram required by Section B.3. Attachment #3 completes the treatment description required in Section A.I La. and includes a summary of the attachment required in Section B.3. Attachment #4 includes copies of ail of the toxicity results (both daphnia and fat head minnow) for the past 4 % years. Please let me know is there are any issues with the permit application, or if you have any questions. If there are any questions, please give me a call at 704/336-4460. If I am not available, please call Dawn Padgett at 704/336-4448 or Pete Goins at 704/875-6443. Thank you for your assistance, acquene A Jarrell, P.E. uperintendent Environmental Management Division Charlotte Mecklenburg Utilities 4222 Westmont Dr. Charlotte, NC 28217 CHARLOTTE-MECKLENBURG UTILITIES Environmental Management Division 4222 Westmont Drive Charlotte, NC 28217 Phone: 704/336-4407 K I Streets Wells / Drinking Water — Streams = ForceMain Gravity LowPressure Sludge QMcDowellParcel .t Neck Rd a'J One Mile Radius Around McDowell Creek WWTP WAitlNq p-bSOIiA PAIL RAAAiyj JJ 0 0.125 0.25 0.5 0.75 1 Miles 2 OSMf GN C.amNoOaVm rm"W Ar Charlotte -Mecklenburg Utilities McDowell Creek WWTP NPDES # NC0036277 Process Flow Schematics Attachment #3 — Additional Information OUTFALL NUMBER: 001 A.1 La Description of Treatment Treatment consists of coarse and fine mechanical bar screens; grit removal; odor control in the headworks; five primary clarifiers; two trains in parallel of activated sludge treatment utilizing three stage biological nutrient removal and two trains of activated sludge treatment utilizing five stage biological nutrient removal; four final clarifiers; effluent denitrifying filters; membrane filtration and reuse distribution; ultraviolet disinfection; sludge thickening; anaerobic digesters; and sludge dewatering. A.1 Lb Design Removal Rates Process Design Percentages of Removal Parameter 12.0 mgd Winter 12.0 mgd Summer CBOD (%) 97 98 SS (%) 97 97 P (%) 95 96 N (%) 87 88 B.3. Process Flow Diagram or Schematic McDowell Creek WWTP is currently designed to treat 12.0 million gallons per day (mgd) of wastewater. The attached schematics (SC-1, -2, -3) show the process flow through the facility. A full summary of the process flow is included on the following page. Charlotte -Mecklenburg Utilities McDowell Creek WWTP NPDES # NCO036277 Process Flow Schematics 12-mgd treatment description Preliminary treatment: Wastewater enters the plant through a 36-inch gravity sewer line and splits between two manholes. Flow then enters the headworks and influent pumping station through two 48-inch gravity sewer lines. Flow entering the head works separates into three screening channels each sized for 30.0 mgd capacity and passes through mechanical bar screens. Screenings are compacted and conveyed to a dumpster loading area common with the grit dumpsters. Primary treatment: Following preliminary treatment, the wastewater splits between distribution boxes (DB), DB-1 and DB-16 and is distributed to the five primary clarifiers (PC-1 through PC- 5). After primary treatment in the clarifiers, a part of the wastewater from PC-1 and PC-2 is directed through DB-4. It continues through DB-4a to combine with wastewater from PC-3, 4 and 5 in DB-4a and further to DB-5 where it is combined with' Return Activated Sludge (RAS). Secondary treatment: The combined flow from PC-1, 2 and 3 through DB-10 is split equally between biological treatment trains 1 and 2 where it goes through an anaerobic zone, anoxic/oxic zone and aeration zone with internal recycle. Flow from PC-4 and PC-5 go through a rate control structure before entering the newly constructed 5-stage BNR basins (BTB-3 and 4) designed for nitrogen and phosphors removal. Following the aeration basin, flow from anoxic/oxic basins 1 and 2 is combined in DB-9 and split to final clarifiers (FC) FC-1 and FC-2. Flow from BTB-3 is sent to FC-3 and from BTB-4 is sent to FC-4. Tertiary treatment: Combined secondary effluent from all the final clarifiers is sent to effluent filter structure (EF) EF-1 and EF-2 for filtration and UV disinfection or 3.0 mgd is sent to microfiltration units. Filtered effluent from the microfiltration system and the effluent filter structures will be combined and sent to the cascade aeration structure where aeration takes place. The cascade aeration structure will discharge through a 48" line into McDowell Creek. ----------------------------------- ( ,�JJHH++..,,II -------ZONE S_-(r---------------ZONE-r------�E-`_-----`+------7--'-T--r-------------�------------------�-�-------- - r1• 1 (3.D.6.0)-4 (-----Tr, ',,ti_S_6 ' ZONE 5-9 ;-�- Lj'�' �_ I `RFD M f z\ �__________LT ______� , IIY"''"' O -, MJ ________ _ ___}R'b-li Y\�{ i 14" rEi i ml ' ZONE �`<' [='S , F__________ _____ i_____________'_-c1}--� ZONE: ' /� Y �� L a _ ________>._____( ZONE 5-2 ZONE 5-5( 1 5 13;RPD/ `f.' I ZONE 1 ZONE 5-7 ' PR MAR �--.• I ! ,'•) 5-10 CLRRIFIER --' '( T ." �•. RATE CONTROL`-fc1}--'----'--____--+---'---------E�'3'>•'---1 F-------"---, --ft''}--- ZONEr:, STRUCTURE NO, ( . L-------, ; ZONE 5-14FINAL RL RFD I DO NO.16 'S° �'Q' }` •�"---_ --' ' ' ( ; 5-11 `�'_Y_: CLRRIFIER I I I -- l - I i :; ZONE S-3 ZONE S-4� ,LO}�1, I ZONE 5-8 ' PRIMARY SLUDGE , RRTE CONTROL J , , ___ __________________J___��3_�________a________________________1___________________ ` i __ _____________ _________ I - AND SCUM i STRUCTURE BYPRSS } ' ' , 1 ' / RFD I oi, FFtt 9.0,18.E -4 ' [______________________�,�_.t_ ____ _______________________ FROM IPs ( ) I TYP. ( }----' <, / -------------'I + I SHEET SC-1(1.5,3.0)-4 �., / .__.L.1._ l - - - - -- ------------- LE�'�3-r- E---------------- I wfls rD _____________________________________ __-__- S-__--_----___________ I I RFD I �,P�♦ ' _________ ______ L- ]Ni ___�� 3--'a r=1__� I OLD ING \ 1 I I .os\29 3 -I 7-- d----ON + I 1 1 BflSIN [_S f---ZUWE--------- r- a LT /' �M, �. fz\' ZONE a-lr rZONE �---�-----T--- ri----ice of I 1„ �i �� { y �Er 1 r- I q g� ZONE 4-9 �I j 1 �}1L I I �hJ 1 I Y' ZONE I of nl / I 24"J 12" 14 „k,d.. ,4,. 29„ 4.imzl I �I bF�Do-- Fo-�1 4-12 I I r--------------- 1+ o I I I )_ I _/__ I I I I ZONE I I RF I vi --- -� a61 -} ---'4, ,_I I E i 11----- ZONE 4-2, ZONE 4-5T r-------'�-1 I 4-131 m' *j I "I I c T ti I LJ 1 1 I ----= I � r I I I 4 PRIMRRY I ZONE 4-7 -1 ZONE 1---- E�z}---LI }- J I + RFD wm - PI �\ CLRRIFIER �- 3 \� RAT E CONTROL I !j + 1 LJ Ir 4-10 1 ,, ` 1 :o) ' { N0.5 2 I I STRUCTURE N0.3 I I I - I"'I "'I I /- P I I L '7 --------I------ E,3 FI-----�- [�J ZONE,J, �'---'----24J I I� I I , I I L - - - I ZONE 4-141� of I I I J-�j I I l l 4-11 1 '' m1 I RATE CONTROL J I r I I 1 I I IJ T 1 1 / \ 1 ! I BTB 5 w m STRUCTURE BYPRSS I �- I I ZONE 4-8 1 I I I Iy I r--_}= t- 1 SCU FORM Q I I I i L_ _ ZONE T f ZONE�a_a�---------- e I! i j %�J 5 IBTB 4 -- J----------J--------L----1-J� 1 / mz I PC FF EFFLUENT 20 I__________ I��I� _i_ �r_J 4 mIm I I \\ F Ai / I i e SCU IFOBM r--________ _ 4 i L—--------------- 4 BTB NO.4 (1.5,3.0)-3/4 �� J ` PI' o SCUM TO 4 I FORM wr 1 1 \ CLRR, TIER .� I , IBTB 3 __________________i_______-_ J J „ /a I�1 .4 m'R a' DIGESTERS CU 0oI ------- -------------------------- r-------1 amt. 4 m�z II 3.0,6.0'-2 3'4 � \ 3 M 2 L 14 . RRS/WRS PUMPING STRT ION I Y 24 12 14' 14 24 CY ' ' I ______ _ -y ZONE 3-1 ZONE 1 j Jj� 4 24- PRIMARY Ws E 3-6 ZONE ZONE 3-9 ZONE =1 I I J CLARIFIER RATE CONTROL 3 12 ZONE ND•4 STRUCTURE NO.1 ZONE 3-2 ZONE 3-5 3-13 I t DB N0.171 I 24" ZONE 3-7 1 ti ZONE M 1 lay �M RATE CONTROL - ZONE I I STRUCTURE BYPASS - - - I I (9.0,12.0)-4 QB NO. 2 (3 ?./ ZONE 3-14 ___J �sOJs6)�/ 3-11 (6.0,12.0)-3 BNR SYSTEM 2 2�J `— ZONE 3-B 30" 42" (3.0,6.0)-2 EFFLUENT I ZONE 3-3 ZONE 3-4 /4 E SHEET SC-3 PRIMARY CLRRIFIER I FROM 1 2 PRELIMINARY 36" TRERT MENT A STRUCTURE 6.6,13.2)-1 SHEET SC-1 (9.0,18.D)-2 (6. 0,12-0)-2/ DB NO.1 BLOWER BUILDING N0.1 3 J a m z kx- LJ \�1 LJ I \ m z LJ PRIMPRI SLUDGE TYP. i i ri o BYPASS PRIMRRY • - SCUM QB NO, IDB�ND.ID e n IMI I PRIMRRY CLRRIFIER 0 I I 9 PRIMARY CLRRIFIER NOal � N . s SJJ MH 4 OJ �/ (6.0,12 2 .0) -1 HJI 12 4 36" 24" , NO \ 1p o \y DB No 13 ry OPTIONAL RAS ROUTING v" DB NO.4A -j i I o� a OB NO, BTB N0.3 PLANT DRAIN I w OB NO.11 R NREROBIC � �- BRSIN NO .2.1 i !� MM� MH 17 30" MH IB DB ND_14 TO PLANT DRAIN =l ANAEROBIC BASIN N0.1.1 (1.65,3.0)-1 MH 13 (1.65,3.0)-i 16" RRS (1.5,3.0)-2/ EFFLUENT 24" F[NRC WEIR ITYP1 (1.5,3.0)-2/3/4 CLARIFIER 36- FLOW DEPENDS ON REUSE DEMAND IMI 4 (6.0.12.D)-2/3/4 36" �BNR SYSTEM 1 (4.95,9.fi)-1 — EFFLUENT (� (4.5,9.0)-2/3/4 N SHEET SC-3 1 48 f ANOXIC/DXIC BASIN NO.2.] 24" DXIC I 4 ANoxlc/oxlc BASIN NQJ, 1 VS RERRTIDN l MH 11 m _ BASIN OB NO.12 VS N0,2.2 e o MH 12 BYPASS ! 11 > T �wm 4 RE RRTIO\mN E.R us 1 B SIN I i A � 'D1 08 NO, 3 Lti' ryh' DR NO, "Ds MHH� m n ,yps7,944 ;.. Q ` � AERATION VS BRSI.. NO. 1. v "I i R FINALS ^'INAL ' CLARIF] lj3 NO.2 WAS/SCUM TO_ DIGESTER WAS TO _ PLANT DRAIN WAS TO WAS HOLDING BASIN AND BLDG 300B ' r' RATE CONTROL STRUCTURE NO, v19 f Lend 6.6 MGD RE -FATED FACILITY (1) 9.0 MGD EXPANSION (2) -- 12.0 MGD EXPANSION (3) --------- FUTURE 15.0 MGD EXPANSION (4) (9.0,18.0)-2 —LEGEND REFERENCE NO. \PEAK DAY FLOW (MGD) w AVG DAY FLOW MGD) PLRNTjDRRIN �— TD RFD RFD (1.5,3.0)-2/3/4 RFO ( RFO •. RFD 2M' ­ RRS/WRS PUMPING STATION IN EFFLUENT FILTER BUILDING (3.3,6.6)-1 FINRL CLRRIFIER U 1 y, ti ti ti 0 p LL LL LL 4 H F� N ti ~ � O U O � E7 Lu j '-L _ Z W y W O J W co Y co g W o ti � a J CC 3 Q O U g DESIGNED: PROJECT NO. 97057 SC-2 SHEET 2 OF 3 97057-330-WWTUP-PR-HOOODDISV 12/01/2000 15:22:09 AGO. PIOLLed : 211101 6:42:56 PM INFLUENT PUMPING STATION (NOTE 1) DRY WELL I I - j- I j- (6.6,13.2)-1 (9.0,18.0)-2 GRIT A SCREENINGS 1 OUMPSTER BELT AIR FROM CONVEYOR BLOWERS BC-2 �ti i EllEWS GRIT BASIN BELT d CONVEYDR - BC-2 , 41L TO PRIMARY SCUM PIPELINE WET WELL ✓P T 36" (6.6,13.2)-1� BYPASS (66,78.0)-2 . 901 ' I / EXISTING I I - - 1-1/2" BAR I SCREENMECHANICAL I , T BAR SCREEN BS-1 I I — SCUM TO S PRIMARY I 1 , --- �BOX PCUM IPELINE I I , I I L__-_-- (0.0,0.0)-2 24" OVERFLOW PRELIMINARY TREATMENT EXISTING FLU - - PRRSHALL FLUME INSERT I I , 1 (NOTE 11 I I ® I L------------------------ --------------- ---------------------- HEADWORKS 30" FM (12.0,247 3 , o5.0.30.0)-4 ' (12.0,24.0)-3 r---------- Q5.0,30.0)_4 (NOTE 11 , I OWG NOTES: 1. EXISTING HEADWORKS. INFLUENT PUMPING STATION. I 1T♦ -� r - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - I I - - - - , SC-2 I- - TO FUTURE - TOE TRERTMENT F INFLUINFLUENT AND PRELIMINARY TREATMENT STRUCTURE TO BE ENT 11 ABANDONED AFTER NEW HEADWORKS FINE) INFLUENT PUMPING STATION IS IN SERVICE DURING 12 MGD EXPANSION. I , _____________- - - - - - - I _ -p'i! I i TRAINS I , I ------------- I I r� I I ♦, 1 I I , , r--------------'7 r------------------T-------------------------------------+ ----------- I I r-1 I I I H I 1 I 1 1 I --------------- 1 r7I 1 I 1 1 nw 1 , /- � I -#F� r� H II ♦-/ I I 1Iy I 1 I--"-------1 I 1 i -T I I J I I I I I I I I I I I MECHRNICRL I I ,-, ,r., u II�'�--I , , rH1 , , , i I 1 DRY TANK BAR SCREENS ��� I I rF�}1+ I ♦-� I I - I I I I I NO. 2 I I I I, ♦-' 1 I i ����i/ �__-----------0�"a'� DT-1 1 I I IVORTEX GRIT __i _- _-_--_ 1 r�HREMOVA � I1jII INFLUENT LL.( ---1......I� --------T-___T-11-------- ----__= 1III ��ti,�b11y -------------0 I o-o-yJ�aIjI 1L1I7 L �wrr1hhLr1 wrt,rT4I� , ♦ --L - , t��'`� J_,, 2piIII r jwrt,r�1l STORM FLOW EOURLIZRTIONN FUTUR ----(-_--___---_- _. - - - - - - - - y --------Lc-J------- -- -------� 1r, -0� H- --/� rh rh ,II11II BASINJ INFLUENT L /♦ jJj'PLANT �IC-UUI1III `iy`i'�L-1Yjj- r ,/♦♦---�', YY`Hrr -Tr-------------0 Ii 1 / I DRY TANK I I I - �, 1 I ♦_, I I I I -________-__-0*-o-4 NO. 1 I I DT-2 I 1 417j-I I L1_ I L I-----------��--o-J I I 1 ''----------J I I I , IL-------r-------------------- I- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - j ' ' I r 1 p1 '- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - �C�i _______-------0*-o-11 I 1 I I I Y\ I I ' ' ♦-' I I .`, _ I ����♦_i --0J I L - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - L_�l-m''F� j 1 i FIRST STAGE I I I j}qI L-------------------------------11LL------------------------------- PUMPS I I I I Legend 1� 5 i 1[ DESIGNED: DETAILED: CHECKED: APPROVED: DATE: PROJECT NO. �V�4�+1 SECOND STAGE 6.6 MGD RE -RATED FACILITY (1) I 97057 I I I I PUMPS I 9.0 MGD EXPANSION (2) I I L - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - _______________-_-_____________________J ----_ 12.0 MGD EXPANSION (3) HEADWORKS AND INFLUENT PUMPING STATION --------- FUTURE 15.0 MGD EXPANSION (4) (9.0,18.C)-2fLECEND REFERENCE NO. PEAK DAY FLOW (MGD) AVG DAY FLOW (MGD) SC-1 SHEET Y OF 3