Loading...
HomeMy WebLinkAbout20060268 Ver 1_Year 2 Monitoring Report_200905210b-OJA ANNUAL MONITORING REPORT BOLD RUN STREAM AND BUFFER RESTORATION WAKE COUNTY, NORTH CAROLINA (EEP Project Number 439) Monitoring Year 2 of 5 (2008) EP?J i."W 'b': D t L jty D%NR - r"w,i cr: uw'U I 7 %NU hNDS AND STORUMATER BRANCH FILIE Submitted to: North Carolina Department of Environment and Natural Resources Ecosystem Enhancement Program Raleigh, North Carolina ??.Cf)SVSt?'Ill mm E V w= P% DEL 2 1 7Uud f!C ECOSYSTEM! WANCEMENT PROGRAM December 2008 ANNUAL MONITORING REPORT BOLD RUN STREAM AND BUFFER RESTORATION WAKE COUNTY, NORTH CAROLINA (EEP Project Number 439) Monitoring Year 2 of 5 (2008) Submitted to: North Carolina Department of Environment and Natural Resources Ecosystem Enhancement Program Raleigh, North Carolina Prepared by: Axiom Environmental, Inc. 2126 Rowland Pond Drive Willow Spring, North Carolina 27592 Design Firm: KCI Associates of North Carolina, PA 4601 Six Forks Road Raleigh, NC 27609 Axiom Environmental, Inc. f December 2008 EXECUTIVE SUMMARY The Bold Run Stream and Buffer Restoration Site (Site) is located five miles northwest of the Town of Wake Forest on Bold Hill Road, approximately 1.5 miles east of the intersection with Mangum Dairy Road in Wake County. The Site is located within United States Geological Survey Hydrologic Unit 03020201065010 (North Carolina Division of Water Quality Subbasin 03-04-08) of the Neuse River Basin. The Site was identified to assist the North Carolina Ecosystem Enhancement Program in meeting stream and buffer restoration goals. This report summarizes data for year 2 (2008) monitoring. Primary activities at the Site included stream restoration and riparian buffer restoration by stabilizing stream banks, installing in-stream structures, adjusting stream planform, and replanting riparian areas with native vegetation. Project restoration efforts provided 1629 Stream Mitigation Units and 27.1 Buffer Mitigation Units. Fifteen vegetation plots (10-meters square) were established and permanently monumented following Site construction with five plots established in the streamside riparian buffer planting zone and ten plots within the remaining buffer area. Plots were surveyed in August and September 2008 for the year 2 (2008) monitoring season. Based on the number of stems counted, average densities were measured at 456 planted stems per acre surviving in year 2 (2008). The dominant species identified at the Site were planted stems of green ash (Fraxinus pennsylvanica), cherrybark oak (Quercus pagoda), and willow oak (Quercus phellos). In addition, each individual plot met success criteria and no vegetation problem areas were noted during the year 2 (2008) monitoring season. Five permanent cross-sections were established after construction was completed. Measurements of each cross-section include points at all breaks in slope including top of bank, bankfull, and thalweg. Riffle cross-sections are classified using the Applied Fluvial Morphology (Rosgen) stream classification system. Longitudinal profile measurements of the entire Site restoration reaches include thalweg, water surface, and bankfull; with each measurement taken at the head of facets (i.e. riffle, run, pool, and glide) in addition to the maximum pool depth. Visual assessments of in-stream structures were conducted to determine if failure has occurred. Failure of a structure may be indicated by collapse of the structure, undermining of the structure, abandonment of the channel around the structure, and/or stream flow beneath the structure. Success criteria for stream restoration reaches should show little to no change from the as-built channel over the five-year monitoring period. Year 2 (2008) monitoring measurements indicate that there have been minimal changes in both the longitudinal profile and cross-sections as compared to as-built data. Stream problem areas documented within the Site during the year 2 (2008) monitoring year consisted of a large beaver dam at the downstream extent of the Site near the confluence with New Light Creek and an area of stream widening and bank erosion near cross-section 5. Beaver activity has resulted in backwater effects from the beaver dam. Proactive maintenance measures including the removal of existing beaver dams and beaver is recommended, as necessary. In summary, the Site achieved success criteria for vegetation and stream attributes in the Second Monitoring Year (2008). Bold Run (final) Axiom Environmental, Inc. Monitoring Year 2 of 5 (2008) EEP Project Number 439 December 2008 Wake County, North Carolina page i Table of Contents EXECUTIVE SUMMARY ...................................................................................................................... i 1.0 PROJECT BACKGROUND .............................................................................................................1 1.1 Location and Setting ..................................................................................................................... l 1.2 Project Objectives .........................................................................................................................1 1.3 Project Structure, Restoration Type, and Approach ........................................................................ l 1.4 Project History and Background ....................................................................................................3 1.5 Monitoring Plan View ................................................................................................................... 5 2.0 PROJECT CONDITION AND MONITORING RESULTS .............................................................. 5 2.1 Vegetation Assessment ................................................................................................................. 5 2.2 Stream Assessment ....................................................................................................................... 5 2.2.1 Bankfull Events ........................................................................................................ 5 2.2.3 Stream Problem Areas ............................................................................................... 6 2.2.4 Categorical Stream Feature Visual Stability Assessment ............................................6 2.2.5 Quantitative Stream Measurements ........................................................................... 6 3.0 REFERENCES ............................................................................................................................... 10 List of Figures Figure 1. Site Location ...........................................................................................................................2 Figure C 1. Monitoring Plan View .......................................................................................... Appendix C List of Tables Table 1. Site Restoration Structures and Objectives ................................................................................3 Table 2. Project Activity and Reporting History ......................................................................................3 Table 3. Project Contacts Table ..............................................................................................................4 Table 4. Project Background Table .........................................................................................................4 Table 5. Verification of Bankfull Events ................................................................................................. 6 Table 6. Categorical Stream Feature Visual Stability Assessment ............................................................6 Table 7. Baseline Morphology and Hydraulic Summary ......................................................................... 8 Table 8. Morphology and Hydraulic Monitoring Summary ..................................................................... 9 ---- --------- Bold Run (final) Axiom Environmental, Inc. Monitoring Year 2 of 5 (2008) EEP Project Number 439 December 2008 Wake County, North Carolina page ii Appendices APPENDIX A. VEGETATION DATA 1. Vegetation Survey Data Tables 2. Vegetation Monitoring Plot Photos APPENDIX B. GEOMORPHOLOGIC DATA 1. Table B 1. Stream Problem Areas and Photographs 2. Fixed-Station Photos 3. Tables 132. Qualitative Visual Stability Assessment 4. Cross-section Plots and Tables 5. Longitudinal Profile Plots 6. Pebble Count Plots APPENDIX C. PLAN VIEWS 1. Figure C1. Monitoring Plan View Bold Run (final) Axiom Environmental, Inc. Monitoring Year 2 of 5 (2008) EEP Project Number 439 December 2008 Wake County, North Carolina page iii 1.0 PROJECT BACKGROUND 1.1 Location and Setting The Bold Run Stream and Buffer Restoration Site (Site) is located five miles northwest of the Town of Wake Forest on Bold Hill Road, approximately 1.5 miles east of the intersection with Mangum Dairy Road in Wake County (Figure 1). The Site is located within United States Geological Survey (USGS) Hydrologic Unit 03020201065010 (North Carolina Division of Water Quality [NCDWQ] Subbasin 03- 04-08) of the Neuse River Basin. The Site was identified to assist the North Carolina Ecosystem Enhancement Program (NCEEP) in meeting stream and buffer restoration goals. Directions to the Site from Raleigh, North Carolina, are as follows: ? From Interstate 440 take the Six Forks Road exit, travel north for approximately 8 miles ? Turn left to stay on Six Forks Road, travel approximately 3 miles ? Turn right on Highway 98, travel approximately 2.7 miles ? Turn left on Stony Hill Road, travel approximately 2.4 miles ? Turn left on Purnell Road, travel approximately 0.1 mile ? Turn right on Mangum Dairy Road, travel approximately 1.8 miles ? Turn right on Bold Hill Road, travel approximately 1.5 miles ? The Site is on the right 1.2 Project Objectives The primary components of the restoration project included the following. • Construction of a stable, riffle-pool stream channel capable of moving sediments supplied by the watershed so that the channel neither aggrades nor degrades. • Stabilize stream banks, install in-stream structures, adjust stream planform, and replant 27.1 acres of riparian areas with native vegetation. • Improve water quality and reduce lateral erosion and bed degradation of stream channels by establishment of riparian vegetation. • Enhance aquatic and terrestrial wildlife habitat through improvements to stream water quality including improved oxygen levels, reduced sediments and nutrients, and varied stream bed features. • Assess project success by measuring stream dimension, pattern, and profile; taking Site photographs; and sampling vegetation. o Stream measurements should show little to no change from the as-built channel over the five-year monitoring period. o Riparian vegetation should meet minimum survival standards for riparian buffers of 320 stems per acre surviving after five years. 1.3 Project Structure, Restoration Type, and Approach The Site is encompassed within a 31-acre easement owned by NCEEP. Prior to restoration activities, the Site was utilized for livestock pasture. Land use modifications including the removal of riparian vegetation and hoof shear to stream banks resulted in degraded water quality and unstable channel characteristics (stream entrenchment, erosion, and bank collapse). Primary activities at the Site included stream restoration and riparian buffer restoration by stabilizing stream banks, installing in-stream structures, adjusting stream planform, and replanting riparian areas with native vegetation. Project restoration efforts provided 1629 Stream Mitigation Units and 27.1 Buffer Mitigation Units as outlined in Table 1. Bold Run (final) Axiom Environmental, Inc. Monitoring Year 2 of 5 (2008) EEP Project Number 439 December 2008 Wake County, North Carolina page 1 ` -i "° ' Directions to the Site: From Raleigh, North Carolina r From hiterstate 440 take the Six Forks Road exit, travel north for l? approximately 8 miles Turn left to stay on Six Forks Road, travel approximately 3 miles Turn right on Highway 98, travel approximately 2.7 miles Turn left on Stony Hill Road, travel approximately 2.4 miles " n Turn left on Purnell Road, travel approximately 0.1 mile Turn right on Mangum Dairy Road, travel approximately 1.8 miles Turn right on Bold Hill Road, travel approximately 1.5 miles . t i The Site is on the right s .'fP ,d PM1d )? ,2 3 +rt? F: A v?tT N%1. e ^ . .1? t ?? .g3y.. y • IN, Aeoav?'! ? ? ru?<? l •r ,?? t =arty. n . ` _ `,) ? O ' 4 ? ?, l ne , faSA18Kpt! mes ray AV + ,• pan ?. ,.. , : g v J suP?t a tl4tr+ x (° { $ a+ s ` Wake ?Forest 3 . e a ! , ,"}? L F t S Y L: x 4? , =.F tc N° AM fiLf APPROX. . v SITE w o Al Y LOCATION • #,. , ?? A ?f 4 ? ? ,?.?# ,, r4 ?.. ? ? t ?• ?..? _ t -? q A 1 w= - -? 71-1 7. ` • 3 . f <- ?aa F Mk Y} x Y oMa!" a. _ o 4 mi. ` MF y? Ga-BJ 1:158,400 z It Source: 2003 North Carolina Atlas and Gazetteer, p.40. r 2 8d s Dwn. by: 2126 Rowland Pond Dr SITE LOCATION CLF FIGURE Willow Spring, NC vs92 BOLD RUN RESTORATION SITE Ckdby: (919) 2155-11693 WGL ,...,.._... (919) 341-3839 fax Project Number 439 Date: Wake County, North Carolina Oct 2008 - Project: 08-001 Table 1. Site Restoration Structures and Objectives Bold Run Restoration Site (EEP Proiect Number 439) = u ? ? L C ? a U NeyR W G Restoration Segment/ a b ° 0 Reach ID ? 0 Stationing Comment o a , ?, •?0 ° ec°n e`?io Wes' F Afs ? ? Reach 1 175 Restoration/P4 175 1 175 10+00 - 11+75 -- Reach 2 1296 Restoration/P2 1454 1 1454 11+75 - 26+29 Riparian Buffer 27.1 Restoration 27.1 1 27.1 -- -- Miti ation Unit Summations Stream Riparian Wetland Nonri arian Wetland Total Wetland Riparian Buffer Comment 1629 0 0 0 27.1 -- P2=Priority 2, P4=Priority 4 1.4 Project History and Background Completed project activities, reporting history, completion dates, project contacts, and background information are summarized in Tables 2-4. Table 2. Project Activity and Reporting History Bold Run Restoration Site (EEP Project Number 439) Activity or Report Data Collection Completion Actual Completion or Delivery Restoration Plan November 2005 February 2006 Final Design - Construction Plans NA Jul 2006 Construction NA February 2007 Term orar Seed Mix Applied to Entire Project Area NA February 2007 Permanent Seed Mix Applied to Entire Project Area NA February 2007 Tree Planting NA February 2007 Mitigation Plan/As-builts (Year 0 Monitoring-Baseline) March 2007 March 2007 Year 1 Monitoring (2007) October 2007 January 2008 Year 2 Monitoring (2008) Se tember 2008 October 2008 Bold Run (final) Axiom Environmental, Inc. Monitoring Year 2 of 5 (2008) EEP Project Number 439 December 2008 Wake County, North Carolina page 3 Table 3. Project Contacts Table Bold Run Restoration Site EEP Project Number 439 Designer, Monitoring Year 0 Performer, KCI Associates of NC Monitoring Year 1 (2007) Performer Landmark Center II, Suite 220 4601 Six Forks Road Raleigh, North Carolina 27609 April Davis and Adam S filler (919) 783-9214 Construction and Seeding Contractor Vaughn Contracting, Inc. PO Box 796 Wadesboro, North Carolina 28170 Don Vaughn (704) 694-6450 Planting Contractor and Nursery Stock Bruton Nurseries and Landscapes Supplier PO Box 1197 Freemont, North Carolina 27830 Kelly Bruton (919) 524-5304 Seed Mix Source Evergreen Seed Company (919)567-1333 Year 2 (2008) Monitoring Performer Axiom Environmental, Inc. 2126 Rowland Pond Dr. Willow Spring, NC 27592 Grant Lewis (919) 215-1693 Table 4. Project Background Table Bold Run Restoration Site (EEP Project Number 439) Project County Wake County, North Carolina Drainage Area 1.6 square miles Drainage impervious cover estimate (%) < I percent Stream Order Second Physiogra hic Region Piedmont Ecoregion Northern Outer Piedmont Ros en Classification of As-built C4-type Dominant Soil Types Chewacla, Chewacla variant, Chewacla-Riverview Reference Site ID Richland Creek USGS HUC Site-03020201065010 Reference-03020201070060 NCDWQ Subbasin Site-03-04-08 Reference-03-04-02 NCDWQ Classification for Project WS-IV, NSW, CA (Stream Index # 27-13-(0.1)) An portion of any project segment 303d listed? No Any portion of any project segment upstream of a 303d listed segment? No Reasons for 303d listing or stressor Not Applicable % of project easement fenced 100 percent Bold Run (final) Axiom Environmental, Inc. Monitoring Year 2 of 5 (2008) EEP Project Number 439 December 2008 Wake County, North Carolina page 4 1.5 Monitoring Plan View Monitoring activities for the Site, including relevant structures and utilities, project features, specific project structures, and monitoring features are detailed in Figure C l in Appendix C. Site features including vegetation, stream dimension (cross-sections), stream profile and pattern, wetland hydrology, and photographic documentation were monitored in year 2 (2008). 2.0 PROJECT CONDITION AND MONITORING RESULTS 2.1 Vegetation Assessment Following Site construction fifteen plots (10-meters square) were established and monumented with metal fence posts at all plot corners and PVC at each plot origin. Five plots are located in the streamside riparian buffer planting zone and ten plots are located within the remaining buffer area. Plots were surveyed in August and September 2008 for the year 2 (2008) monitoring season. Sampling was conducted as outlined in the CVS-EEP Protocol for Recording Vegetation, Version 4.0 (Lee et al. 2006) (http://cvs.bio.unc.edu/i-nethods.htm); results are included in Appendix A. The taxonomic standard for vegetation used for this document was Flora of the Carolinas, Virginia, Georgia, and Surrounding Areas (Weakley 2007). The locations of vegetation monitoring plots are depicted on Figure C 1 in Appendix C. Success criteria dictate that an average density of 320 stems per acre must be surviving after five monitoring years in accordance with North Carolina Division of Water Quality Administrative Code 15A NCAC 0213.0242 (Meuse River Basin, Mitigation Program for Protection and Maintenance of Existing Riparian Buffers) (NCDWQ 2007). Based on the number of stems counted, average densities were measured at 456 planted stems per acre surviving in year 2 (2008). The dominant species identified at the Site were planted stems of green ash (Fraxinus pennsylvanica), cherrybark oak (Quercus pagoda), and willow oak (Quercus phellos). In addition, each individual plot met success criteria and no vegetation problem areas were noted during the year 2 (2008) monitoring season. 2.2 Stream Assessment Five permanent cross-sections were established after construction was completed. Measurements of each cross-section include points at all breaks in slope including top of bank, bankf ill, and thalweg. Riffle cross-sections are classified using the Applied Fluvial Morphology (Rosgen) stream classification system. Longitudinal profile measurements of the entire Site restoration reaches include thalweg, water surface, and bankfull; with each measurement taken at the head of facets (i.e. riffle, run, pool, and glide) in addition to the maximum pool depth. Visual assessment of in-stream structures was conducted to determine if failure has occurred. Failure of a structure may be indicated by collapse of the structure, undermining of the structure, abandonment of the channel around the structure, and/or stream flow beneath the structure. Success criteria for stream restoration reaches should show little to no change from the as-built channel over the five-year monitoring period. Year 2 (2008) monitoring measurements indicate that there have been minimal changes in both the longitudinal profile and cross-sections as compared to as-built data. 2.2.1 Bankfull Events Documented bankfull events are included in the table below. One bankfull event was documented during the year 2 (2008) monitoring period. Bold Run (final) Axiom Environmental, Inc. Monitoring Year 2 of 5 (2008) EEP Project Number 439 December 2008 Wake County, North Carolina page 5 Table 5. Verification of Bankfull Events Bold Run Restoration Site (EEP Project Number 439) Date of Data Collection Date of Occurrence Method Photo (if available November 19, Between 8/31/2007 Crest Gauge -- 2007 and 11/19/2007 Total of 3.48 inches* of rain reported to fall over 2 days October 8, 2008 August 28, 2008 (August 27 - 28, 2008) as well as crest gauge readings at the Site * Reported at KNCWAKEFI Weather Station on Welcome Drive in Wake Forest. 2.2.3 Stream Problem Areas Stream problem areas documented within the Site during the year 2 (2008) monitoring year consisted of a large beaver dam at the downstream extent of the Site near the confluence with New Light Creek and an area of stream widening and bank erosion near cross-section 5. Beaver activity has resulted in backwater effects from the beaver dam. Proactive maintenance measures including the removal of existing beaver dams and beaver is recommended, as necessary. Stream problem areas are summarized in Table B1 and documented in photographs in Appendix B and are depicted in Figure C 1 in Appendix C. 2.2.4 Categorical Stream Feature Visual Stability Assessment The stream was visually inspected during the year 2 (2008) monitoring period using eight feature categories and various metrics within each category. Assessment features included riffles, pools, thalweg, meanders, channel bed, banks, structures, and root wads/boulders. Semi-quantitative assessements for the stream are included in Appendix B (Table B2). The mean percentage of performance for features is summarized in the tables below. Table 6. Categorical Stream Feature Visual Stability Assessment Bold Run Restoration Site (EEP Project Number 439) Feature Year 0 2006 Year 1 2007 Year 2 2008 Year 3 2009 Year 4 2011 Year 5 2012 A. Riffles 100% 100% 100% B. Pools 100% 100% 95.6% C. Thalweg 100% 100% 100% D. Meanders 100% 100% 100% E. Bed General 100% 98% 99.5% F. Banks 100% 99% 98% G. Vanes / J. Hooks, Etc. 100% 94% 100% H. Wads and Boulders 100% 100% 100% 2.2.5 Quantitative Stream Measurements During the year 2 (2008) monitoring period 5 cross-sections and longitudinal profiles on the entire stream reach were measured; plots for year 2 (2008) monitoring overlain on baseline and previous monitoring years data are included in Appendix B. As a whole, monitoring measurements indicate that there have been minimal changes in both the longitudinal profile and cross-sections as compared to as-built data. The as-built channel geometry compares favorably with the emulated, stable E/C type stream reach as set forth in the detailed mitigation plan and construction plans. Current monitoring has demonstrated Bold Run (final) Axiom Environmental, Inc. Monitoring Year 2 of 5 (2008) EEP Project Number 439 December 2008 Wake County, North Carolina page 6 dimension, pattern, and profile were stable over the course of the monitoring period. Tables for quantitative assessements are included below; these tables include data from previous years. Bold Run (final) Axiom Environmental, Inc. Monitoring Year 2 of 5 (2008) EEP Project Number 439 December 2008 Wake County, North Carolina page 7 R ? O d I ? O ?z p u x° ba ?W o W o? a y RS F M O M kn 00 O N M ,--. N O • 'U 6 r- 00 O C M 00 M M O 00 00 N --? O O ti M ,? N M ,--? ?O N 00 d• 10 U ¢ p O O _ kn M pp ? 0M0 O DD ° ° 'It o o U 00 00 ?O N N (V N O n O p O 00 00 M v'i O O n O _ O U O U U y O1 N 00 M 'n N 00 M O '-' N .--? M 000 .-• ? O O O O ?t ,,. U U U O O a N O N N [? M 00 00 l? C? .-+ ,--? O O M O M kn N m 'n 41 O O O C,3 p l? M l? ?O in p M O M O r n F, 7 O ?' ? p U O U M 00 ?n O M M l? 0 U CA It Cj m U ? ?" 7 00 M D, DD .r l? O O 00 0. O U ? ? o a`?si ? C?s .Q oy?n %7 r C ? ' y • y+ LY, O O ? C U -• C> 'T U k 73 y r o ca w 3 a"i O °? r v 3 U o ? 3 W - w ? ? x a a m > ? v i a rx ? ? ? -. x 3 [ a a A a a V] Q r a r M O u r H i l l y C N vi C n '? N O S D R O L L U c G C ? n N ? N O A ? ? ? ^ M .ter ~ C. G a, O cs N p N xx 2 °o A M ^ N A ^ M O C 00 M N O M G O c G O O p r O r G d ° a' N O a y O L P vi M N h - ? N Q z' Q Z. Q Z ? 1O V - ?p ?O V •-- L U ?+ 2 O? M O A - .p N M C Q 'Z Q Z Q Z ? ° ? N l? ?p r N 1 o cC/ G U O ? v'1 f'? v? '? ^. M ?! N a\ O O\ ul M ? v1 •-- tr ?_ O /? ? N N m M N N O ^ Ni? .--. N O pp N p ? W /? N /? M O r r+' M W ? M N K O ^ O .-. O ? W M o .-. N O ? C C , C. O? ? OM N M' O N 0 ? ? /? ? N M' N M N O O L ?. r d oo ? ? ?p n O p P ? 0- 1 O r O C r G N N rn N oo O u y? N N O _ r m ? O ?. ?D 7 f? y C ? v? O O ? N O - O O N m M .p d G ^. OO - d p ^ ` L n rn - - U - O o U r ^ O O W `O. O in . r N M O 7 O ._. O O ?O ^ o0 ^ t? ?., ?+ N `D n O D\ •- D\ N r o0 M. O ,_, ` ?p .__, o0 •-- 7 .... O W 'e' T N v'i vi N ? ? ?O ? Op O M N Q` N ^, o O O U c C .- N G C O O O .--' O ?O .p ?p ^ V O M, ? O O r ? O ? r D\ ? ? O cV ? 7 O ? C' M O ?D ? ? O W ? ` `' 'O 'O W ? y ? s Q cW' ? C ? s N 'D E O E 7 s 9 = 'D W s N i d rG L CG ^ ? •= O 7 F E O E W s ": F ? ? a b ? Y " s d ? W h ?' Y N y N ? fn O ? o c W c ? ? b ?_ A CO c y V1 w •O C N E c O '0 C L. V C ?n 7 (Y1 O 7 w Y W N 3 .x O O `? O Y K W ? L c A 0 (Cd ? R N G-' o c ? u, o ? '° W U cC °? y CG ? i U f? ? U p7 W G ? ? 3 y 7 w d d p ? W ? O L d O ? E C G W t ? ? ? r w C 7 i ? Ee ? co L ?, a D W ° o ? ? E 00 d C 1 ? E e Z 5O ? L .: O L 0 G 7 ! ? u W ` ? •i o ? o ? DD ? d a E= c 3.0 REFERENCES Lee, Michael T., R.K. Peet, S.D. Roberts, and T.R. Wentworth. 2006. CVS-EEP Protocol for Recording Vegetation, Version 4.0. (online). Available: http://cvs.bio.unc.edu/methods.htm North Carolina Division of Water Quality (NCDWQ). 2007. Redbook, Surface Waters and Wetlands Standards. North Carolina Department of Environment and Natural Resources, Division of Water Quality. Raleigh, North Carolina. Rosgen, D. 1996. Applied River Morphology. Wildland Hydrology (Publisher). Pagosa Springs, Colorado. Weakley, Alan S. 2007. Flora of the Carolinas, Virginia, Georgia, and Surrounding Areas (online). Available: http://www.herbarium.unc.edu/WeakleysFIora.pdf [February 1, 2008]. University of North Carolina Herbarium, North Carolina Botanical Garden, University of North Carolina, Chapel Hill, North Carolina. Bold Run (final) Axiom Environmental, Inc. Monitoring Year 2 of 5 (2008) EEP Project Number 439 December 2008 Wake County. North Carolina page 10 APPENDIX A VEGETATION DATA 1. Vegetation Survey Data Tables 2. Vegetation Monitoring Plot Photos Bold Run (final) Axiom Environmental, Inc. Monitoring Year 2 of 5 (2008) EEP Project Number 439 December 2008 Wake County, North Carolina Appendices o m r-i O 00 00 00 r- 0 Ch r aJ 00 ri m N lD m ri N m o N < C 06 ri O- O O Ln O Q O m N i c c 0 i Q co 0 *R <7 x U Q U Q m = 0 ar Q I- u m . m = O c a v L VI VI ? }, t' d m 0 m Q O N . CL O . 4. . 4? a) m m m Q c Q V1 U ? r E v c o v ? a) VI 0 a) cu Q c m E = V; C E U ,C m Ln E O vi u O L n Y a 4- Vl i a) ; m 4? VI bZ c -Fa 4- U7 > .7 VI 4- Q c m O ._ -0 E O Qj 4- X ? VI v v_ _ O E 0) 2 3 O L U L C +, V1 L . O -c -m Q 4- O _0 t L m ~ _0 m m m a) i V; V) C E U >• 4-1 U 4 i Q v1 m a) L m a) > Q U 4- v v a U V1 a) m L 0 - V) 4 m -0 L O ? a 0 L Q vi a) m a) L . v - U L a) M CL L C C 0 V) n VI a) E cu 4.1 - -0 7 1 (U 4- D 41 -0 Ln O LU n V) a -C -C ai p Q Z J m 0 v ) of ,n U m U m 0 0 0 +?+ a U O O a) aJ a) _ V1 u> + +? O ? ? dA CL CL > > m CL ++ T +1 O U Q vi ± O p a-+ X ) N 3 '3 E 3 c c M -c o v O "a a) O O .r- 41 c N N +C m m - a) a) v _ cu n n ai ? Y ° O E o - a) 'L 'L V1 p aJ N O CA +1 v v 41 (A -Fo > > O O Q \ O Q c c O E () a) X CL CL M , a) a1 tw • an c: H 'L, N E E O N N O O W W c J U- U- J Q m o E a o a v -W a a m m a m ao on eo w a, Q m a) O L O ` O ao tw C a a a > > a a Q m ? 0 O p U C'I r O i 'n CL E 0 U ? Q O C. 0 G ti O O m > W ? O Q 4! w Ln N N rq r-I 7 Ln co N C m m i v i n Ln ? 7 7 Ln i Ln O cr O O a) i i co m co z i ? V a 3 m v' O m o •? m {yL o f a ?z 0 Q U Q co V M Q v W ' W O a i i a N d tw 0) m O Q. U a OC a ? a a 0 > E: c ?? A i m y u v+ n p x m0w 3 00 00 n E L 0) 'C +' O N N Ln m = 14- O p y O L C Ili 4 :03 E ? > 'Ln O L0 Opp O ,n L Z 3 v m C = m O = _ (0 u V 01 3 tw w E OC .E- m 'a Y Z O 7 am a m V H C OJ Ln - E tw G1 C V QJ a co U p c O GJ +' U 'O Lo v L •? a %m CL 41 V N c Y O 41 IZ ? dJ > M u •? X L H E E +? 3 aC LO N Q > m? C MO _ 00 > w J Z m 75 Lo 0. m c GJ L_ t V m v L CA Ln Ch m Zi- m m N -* m r, Iq IZI- M It CL N In r, O Ln ? -4 m r-1 n Ln d' -t N Ln -t ID 00 N r-I m O m N Lo 00 Ln O Ln O r- O N 1 LD Q1 Q1 M It -Zt O 00 Ln C l0 J Ln 0 U E i of Q - a M ++ J H > 0 x d J r-I Ln r-I .--1 Ln q* Ln ? 4cl, N lD l0 m Ln r? (A LJ m rh M r\ -t N Zt w r- Ln N 00 00 O O rn 4 am am 4 m -4 Ln r-i o Ln q R*, 1D O > O LN U a Q N M O Ln r-I O O O N n M O O O O O p? W It ? ICT w O t w It f0 41 a W L N d N w N H U 3 E N Q Z > N a 00 v Ln m o Ln I ct Ln ' m -t m w m Ln :i, r- > C J= w M O d' w t m oo q q N m d 4 w N w m N Ln o0 w O w m m m J a W 1 N U ? (A r0 U of a x w W ' oo Ln w c) Ln t Ln -t w rn LD tD m -t r- 4! 0p H a 00 O 00 0) Iq N Iq W N LD 00 00 00 LD ILO E v lD [h 00 't m '* m Ln r' rr m Ln c v Q M J {% N a a 0o (7 Ln 0, O N N r-I 00 "1 r, o, M N N O m 'cl, C Z 01 r1 ri N I I e i -I i -I r-I c I •? H Y J E ? Ln M 4+ J N u 0) > J 0 W M .-I m y ri oo r-I v m w M N N O Ln m E ' N r1 N N ri r I r-I N N r-I r-1 ri r-1 r-I > 01 O -? N L lD r I ci N O O O m w r- -4 O O r-I ri - y r-I ri L ? +O+ r O O m ++ Z O N 0 to 0 0 0 0 0 0 a 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 m N N N N Q1 O N N r-I 00 r-I r, (n M N N O M -?t Z r-I r-I N r-1 r-I -1 r-I T-4 -1 ri Y G1 w M O y H O U 0) a x > J I J W IA r, O N N r-I 00 r-i 0) M 01 N N N 0) KT Q) E -4 -4 r-I N r-I ci r-I ri r-I r-1 r-I ri ? 10 • i+ J H D. L LO N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N Iv ` N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N O > a ? J r-I O r-I N m v Ln N cn It Ln W n m rn O r-i r-I r-I r-i r-1 r-1 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 r O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O p O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O p, w w w w w w w w w w w w w w w x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x a a a a a a a a a a a a a a a m cc W m m m w rY Ir C m CL o- m m m m m m m m m m m m m m m C O m E O c O a 0 00 O U N O ? C ? ? SZ O. ? U Q N N ? Q bA c O C O r ti fi ou 0 w O .k Q O a, ?v L ?z G z ;, 0. ? O C. a r??3 'u a1 Q H T L O 40 C O C Y C M dA C N H C G 0 ri ci r-1 r-I c-I ? N N l0 ri Ln N r- m m c I r i -4 N M rl N N O N r N M r-i c-1 M r, 0 Ol N Kl- -1 0 0 d -4 M rn ? ra U Vf m _ C vi ? .- ra c ? N x CL fu M 7 Ln m -0 O f0 7 Cl) m U aJ 10 OD O C ,. U dA a) m u " 6 L O. tia > E Q to % E a a m u v1 -0 L -a O aJ E N M M N to to N N L aA •L U L C O m - 'n c o v v o ` 3 m a m U U LL C7 U V U n ( (n ) a O o o p v oNv 'n ..O f1 O E N Q N U ? Q bq C O Q O c? ti obi W 0 Q a.. aJ Ln ri N N Ln O N N ? N a C c ? rn ? u S o o r1 N M O 4- O w C E i N Ol LLnn N m N Ln l0 N Ln O l.n O Ln O Ln O ar a i+ c 7 O u `I w w 0 0 r-I n N N -1 -•1 -4 -1 1II E c Q OO to E Vl i o CL ra C +-+ O Y N L £ -O O v 0 v Y v E a, -C L v t N v > co in = of o p co m m 0 C ? O ? U ? o c •o 0 c°ow3 ?0 O ? U CA L C O ? Q Q N U u Q umouiun N ri Ln Aaa ool a;!s N sluapoa jewiud umoulun/aay;p spasul r-I Ln r4 o poldweal uewnH r1 ?, paseasia ,i iaaa k.0 N r-I m 00 rn N aanea8 (asewep ou) m N N N u1 lD ri Ul O ri 00 L n r-I 00 00 r-I r I r4 ri sai.iosa;ej agewea IIV M w V1 Ln M 00 k.0 00 r?I Ln N 00 N Ql 00 r-I r-I .-I ri N M `i u _ a, - . m y CU E 3 ) Ln a ?, •+ + • X = f0 co -0 CA O cu C co o C OJ ? s= U CO 4-1 -C U_ 0 GO = N ) a u •L 0 C C - u L u u •tw v u M N + i X a O ? N 4J N N X X c C CD U U f0 LL 00 .L J (D d 7 U 7 U r7 .I V r7-! V m N f0 Ln m un I? ei H O Uf N sa. an OA m E m 0 bq G O G O Q ti a d 0 a W 0 Q C 01 ? vU i Y Z Z C y O 0. U a?w3 -00 ? O 0 U ? N ^p U Q N U U U Q bq A O umouiun r-1 rV Ln Aao ool al!S r-I N s;uapoa lewiud umoulun/aaylp spasul v KT r, paldweaj uewnH paseasla Jaap a-I N N v1 O N 't r- M lD N Ln aanea8 r, r.1 (a4euaep ou) 00 m N m ri N r- r- m r14 r -I N r4 ri soposa;ej asewe r- r-I 0) .m -I r-o) I r4 r -I c,4 -1 r4 14 0) ??-i -1 "1 N r-I 00 r, r-i N cn a !!d r4 c-I 0 N 0 m 0 ? 0 Vl 0 to 0 r- 0 co 0 m 0 o -4 "i ri N r-1 m ri it r-I Ln ri 0 O 0 O 0 O 0 O 0 O 0 O 0 O 0 O 0 O 0 O 0 O 0 O 0 O 0 O 0 O Q, w X w X w X w X w X w X w X w X w X w X w X w X w X w X w X a a a a a a a a a a a a a a a CL m CL m CL m CL m CL m Q? m C? m CL m CL m Q? m CL m CL m CL m CL m CL m Ln 0 O a v tw m E m 0 C O Ci ti v v r 0 W 0 .k Q xa bay w°w3 Z:aeaA `^ W rl -ST -3Xd-219 ;old Z:aeaA Ln N oo' - oo-3 -21a 3o d Z:aeaA m - -3 -218 3o d Z:aeaA N oo N -Z -3 -218 ;old Z:aeaA N m - -21a;o d Z:aeaA m .i m m - -3 -21a;o d Z:.ieaA N m m - - -218 ;old Z:aeaA ri N M - -3 -21a;o d Z:JeaA N oo - -3 - a Old Z:aeaA N m - -218 ;old Z:.IeaA ^' v Icz3l N -S -3 -21a;o d Z:aeaA 0) r-I r-4 Ln ri cri - -3 -21 ;old Z:aeaA m w - -3 -21a;o d Z:aeaA c-i Ln N r-i M - -3 -21 ;old Z:aeaA rI m N -1000-3XV-119 ;old SUla;S #SAe Un N N ? m N N w w r, -;T m rl ci ci ei -i .-i in m N m Slo1d # N m oo ri cf Ln M M r*- N N ri ci ri r+ r-I Sala; alue elO SP IdI l m ?n u, ? m oo ? r-I oo -4 m r-I "' N 00 N rn oo .? ci .? .? rn co U_ c L- 41 Ln - vi Ln ? 0 E 7 fu of Q ? o X to M -O CA O C: N -0 ? f6 C: f6 _ 'U O > E E C c N ? + C _ U O a m ? t u O to _ ai u = N U L. v m . H w •C Q) f0 a N • C vl N N a v1 s vI cv uo s.. U fo i N :3 C 0 -p = :3 L L L L •C x V1 x N CO N U O U L LL OL J f0 d 7 U ?7./ V ??./ V ? V 7./ _ • (n _ fn E In E D E m E D ei O H h v u v Q H m O a E N a? m a ??? O ? U N b N u ? Q 0 0 r o, i W 0 Q C Q1 ? U L ? ? o Ix ° U o. bay c wQ Z:JeBA Ln F.D ri -STO -3 -218 rl Z:JeaA ri Ln r4 00 - 00-3 -218 Z:JeaA M ,-, ri - 0-3 -218 Z:JeaA N 00 ri ri N - -3 - 8 Z:aeaA ? N r? M N - -3 -218 Z:JeaA ri m m m ri - -3 -218 Z.JeaA N m Lo m ri Ln - -3 - 8 Z:JeaA r, N - -3 - Z:JeaA N 00 N -L -3 - 8 Z:JeaA fo ri m N N - -a Z:JeaA m r4 -s -a Z:JeaA M ri 0) .? Ln r-4 -4 M r-r %o N - -3 -218 Z:JeaA m ri M '.D N CA N - - -ae Z:JeaA r1 -4 Ln Ln ? - -3 -218 Z:JeaA ri ri N r-r m n+ N - -3 -218 # SUIaIS RAe ri m M N N r14 N M r1 l0 u1 ri ri n M l0 ri ri M M r r N c-I ko N m d' ri ri slold # ri m m -t m ri M M Ln r? n N N r-I r-I w M Ln r-I M M r r r4 N slUal$ le;ol ri n V1 M M v-1 N N Ol 00 ri ri 0 Ol ri M "ZI, ri qcT N U co VI fu f6 > U m x C (J) Q m N co c o 3 O fa ? m N N bD > 6- E a a (O u VI OL p OL N L c a Vi - c: E Vf 0 In VI a0 • U 'L- U i Vl N 3 bA ff0 U ++ N + ? L . X C C -o n u w u w u a u a x c Ln X -a O VI 7 4? C i 7 D D 7 co co u u LL cn m V) J d a a Q N O F- G1 u GJ Q. .a C m 40 O a H aEi H a -00 0 00 ? C, 0 0.9 O N b ?d N U ?Q •o 0 ci ti Q obi 0 Y w 0 a, ?U O z z >; r4 u ww3 ? }F??? =tY r .h. 4 i 41- ' A, 4, j # r . I t ?t ? ( - A I XI Axiom Environmental, hie. Monitoring Year 2 of 5 (2008) December 2008 Appendices Bold Run (final) EEP Project Number 439 Wake County. North Carolina 111pcndices Bold Run Restoration Site Year 2 (2008) Annual Monitoring Vegetation Plot Photos (taken late July to early September 2008, continued) j? . 1. < ,? w t , s Bold Run (final) Axiom Environmental, Lne. Monitoring Year 2 of 5 (2008) EEP Project Number 439 December 2008 Wake County. North Carolina Appendices Appendices APPENDIX B GEOMORPHOLOGIC DATA 1. Table 131. Stream Problem Areas and Photographs 2. Fixed-Station Photos 3. Tables 132. Qualitative Visual Stability Assessment 4. Cross-section Plots and Tables 5. Longitudinal Profile Plots 6. Pebble Count Plots Bold Run (final) Axiom Environmental, Ine. Monitoring Year 2 of 5 (2008) EEP Project Number 439 December 2008 Wake County. North Carolina Appendices Appendices -qq Table 131. Stream Problem Areas Bold Run Restoration Site (EEP Proiect Number 439) Feature Issue Station Numbers Suspected Cause Photo Outer bend bank Lack of deep-rooted vegetation, Problem Area Photos erosion/channel widening 24+00 downstream beaver activity 1-2 Large beaver dam causing Immediately Problem Area Photo backwater effects downstream of Site on Beaver activity 3 Bold Run Creek Problem Area Photos Taken August 15, 2008 4 Problem Area Photo I - Channel widening at outerbend f ._ q r s, r ' A -4 ? a 4 y x Problem Area Photo 2- Bank erosion Bold Run (final) Axiom Environmental, Inc. Monitoring Year 2 of 5 (2008) EEP Project Number 439 December 2008 Wake County, North Carolina Appendices Appendices Bold Run Restoration Site Fixed-Station Photographs taken August 15, 2008 g fth Rd g 8 k i " F? 4 ` k Bold Run (final) Aiionr Environmental, Inc. EEP Project Number 439 Wake County. North Carolina Appendices pNd@ Monitoring Year 2 of 5 (2008) December 2008 Appendices FN@h Rd N Bold Run Restoration Site Fixed-Station Photographs taken August 15, 2008 (continued) Ilk .z PN9@ Rd ?9 , Ph& Rd go Bold Run (final') Axiom Environmental, Inc. Monitoring Year 2 of 5 (2008) EEP Project Number 439 December 2008 Wake County, North Carolina Appendices Appendices Bold Run Restoration Site Fixed-Station Photographs taken August 15, 2008 (continued) M& Rd IN V ?t 'v k t' M - - --- - ------- - --- ----- ---- - -- Bold Run (final) Axiom Environmental, Inc. Monitoring Year 2 of 5 (2008) EEP Project Number 439 December 2008 Wake County. North Carolina Appendices Appendices C Cj Y t? I.?.1 e? ?r a N H o ° o ° ro a 4 O s.. a? F, o O vj o O o O ? 00 0 O 0 O ? N O S- :E o 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 "o b 0 0 0 0 ° ° 0 0 0 0 0 0 s. N V1 p 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 `p 0 O 0 O 0 O 0 O O 0 O 0 O 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 O O ? 0 ?. p p ?.•p Q ¢ ¢ Q ¢ ¢ ¢ ¢ ¢ Q Q Q Q Q O O Q Q ca; -0 z z z z z z z z z z z _ z z z ? ,\-• z z z z z z O p Y z Q N N N N N v ?t O ¢ z ¢ z ¢ z C* 00 00 00 ?° 11° o? _N ?. by ^C3 • ? N N N N N n ?-- M n Q Q F Q 00 00 00 00 lp \p - O ? 'O Q N +°. bb .? V Cl. aj -0 y C Cl. U 0 bA ? Cl • In U bA ? a i c4; :. y ? b^A i. c p y O cc O E p tj) U -0 u U C '5 "O ro ?h O o U 'U N p cC .? ro y0., ro i, O cC ?, -S p o w °' a OJ 4. 3 4k ° ? ro ' 'C,3 c 3 ' i c o a? CL cC O m E a? D ? ? v «t ? '" a, ? O o ai CL u - ca. p ? ' L o OJ - ° v b b _ 3 L1 a ° c a v bA ti C,3 o a o m b O b c o CL bA 0 C. ? U ? bpD w bpA ? ? ? a. cd bA ; • N bA ? O N y N a Q w ? .? N a ? O O ¢ y.. ? ? Q r? x Q c? LT 0 c° N M d' kn .- N M •- N N M v -? }., N U -- .. -•• N M . r- N cd 0 n bA N 3 'O c N y v L v Y C13 -0 3 w U ¢ w U L ua C7 x M L z v •i a W W W Q Vl C 0 it O a, a O' 7 0 oo N 0 o v O ? N ^d O N N v N y Q b-0 C O O Ci ti r r 0 .r W O Q c rn o U y^, ? o ?z 7 O ° cL v c. ro m?3 _O O u a? V? O U 3 6fi I t" 00 yy ?' 4'? .st'x 1 ' Q O [? O 1 r ,?µ ^ r ?tl ?y 1 1 O? o0 ! ?`" 'x m r g?? ?`4,: o CC CC 3" 1 ?#s 9 i, t 1 1 ? C1. Q G G 3" !< i 1 1 a * ? JP? ? ?? ? 1 1 1 1 $ a .7 1 1 y? ` 1 1 1 S`? k N 1 1 J i z y+ ', m i Yd? 1 1 t ig !I m 1 1 1 1 O rl 'r ce 1 1 00 A m , L ? 1 1 ? I 1 1 1 1 ? 1 1 N Q? 1 1 z , 1 1 1 1 1 1 O i 1 1 ? 1 1 ?, 1 1 l N N + C ? } - = 1 1 ;v C O 7 N O 00 c o- 7 oo x r- r O N N N N N r a ?? (Taaj) UOIjVAel ? x z X Q c N o0 00 - ,-• •• r ,? ?n ^r 7 ?D N-? r C M N? ??', 7 ?G c R o?oooox o ?, o oo xo o a x oc r r r r r r Ir r r r- r r r r v N N N N rJ N N N 11 rl N N N rJ N N Y L: 3' 00 ?O oG a - cS M x r ?C O` 'p Q 3 ... R L L O - ?L V', O` r ?G x x N r? ?G r V M C V', N tl0 vl - N r x ?C M rl cal oC p L R ?/ O OC L y C C R ?t"i O` O M '? M. 1'^, - x ?, 7 ? `+? V y "C ? ^ OC ? r x 00 7 70 CT O ?. N N N x 3 iC D C Gz. a` - N N M, M v -s -r ?n ?c r x N - N - L C ce ° ? ? 5 x x Q V i t i V V R L ' V L ?. ~ ',?' .! ' ? ?_ = L a. L a o v c R x t ? G V -? t ? . ? Y ? '7 C Q i 1 I L, = C O C % R R V ` C _ i 1 1 ? a 1 y? , I C m n 1 , Y C1. -p 0, 00 ,., N O O Cq w Q o 1 - V1 kr) ?+ w N co N O 1 m , CL CD 0 L a 1 0 1 Cq , 0 1 N L O N > N W d h 7 v z CD o C u ?+ s .Y C c I o N N Q I L CC Q C ?i 1 - d W yy V ... ? u y 'y s ` C v 8 s , ? ^ ? CG c ? of A o w L s ` S O = p c , Y o c c G i ? oc oc v N t- N O ? ! ?- = R - = O CC V C N N N N N N o ? d i 0.1 CO CO 7 zr 3 w GC (paaj) uoi 7nnal? z ? oc •• 0 7 M ? O? O O 'n 1? M ^ DD Vl O? N OC C>. 10 v1 00 DD 't I? 10 O ? ? r r u 00 ?O \O ? lp r V rq M N m M V r \O rq r, ? 00 rA 00 rA ? V _ w N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N L L L. R L O - N o N 00 '- \D V O M R f? 1D O, V 00 00 m 7 V O 0 M ?O L 7? v +. (, C ? 'C y `7 m W M 00 ^ N N V N t- N 00 N N m V7 m v 7 0 ?n 7 vi N ?O 7 z R 3 c c y ?; a. L ?? •: rF ? h ? t?, ? 1 1 1 .'.v 1 1 C C " ??' 1 1 1 1 ? C I s? ? °aE h 1 1 1 1 ? ?O 40 3'?' 1 1 1 1 1 1 I ? ? i 00 1 'n y., CJlIIW ?`.? JL ?? ? 1 1 a+ t ? m 1 1 ^ ? r.' 1 1 'N ,MtR 1 1 W L 1 6J ? ' y E C ?J z ' 1 ! 1 1 f 1 - 1 ? 1 1 1 ,C 1 1 ? N N } i 1 G _J S w i. C x C 4 ? r r v-, cn - r r r r ? ? 4 N N N N N x z?x_¢ r C M r r (n O V` C t"'1 r `7 ? JO E n C ^ R K V 7 4 N N- C-4 7 V r r r r r r r r r r r r r l? N N N N N N N N N N N N N N v •• L $ O R L ? L L R - r N `7 C m 0c 0, --- 7 M O C x y ,? ? N f+l - ?G C? O M M rl .? J 1 1 z3y= r N ? N ? r N /? r N r •-• v, C N n c - R L R C 7 ? ? ? 6c: t 1 C ? %, ?+ L '? v ? '? L 6J L L:i L ? ^ O C L - E CL Yr a a H 8 R L N C? N ? w w ? o N ? 7 c N C z m n ? a ¢ C .. ? M ?n M Q? r Q? ? M N -- o? r oo x C R V'? Vl Vl M M -- O O O N M M Yn Vl W N N N N N N N N N N N N N N d L C 3 R t L C ,? O A v- N 7 0 N N \O ' V 00 O^ M o, `7 M P N ^ 6J C i n :J ^ N N M M M M ?' V1 Vl r L iL[L a3iAA?. ? N O Pn - ?? N p Yn ? O ^ M O R L ? C CC C R _ F C a R Y R c¢ ,C A ? o ? r 3 `? ? o rs ?^ CG Y W L v ? ^ o CJ o `? s L ? W E yn tt i w w ` L 0. L o, ? ? A R x L" `a 'y te _ ? ca R R o o R ? y ? ? U. 0.1 R7 0.1 k. L- L i W 0.1 0 ' ' Q o r o 1 1 ^ 1\ ° Vl 'p C O O 1 1 p7 w Q ? ? •°o ' e ' 1 1 1 1 1 1 O N ? 1 61 IP.n 9 P 1 P 1 4 X 1 i 1 1 ? O " ' v 7 1 P 1 1 Q U j 'C , 1 m f 1 ? '? Y 1 1 1 M? W e L ? ' 1 P ' 1 N W d N 1 ? t ? z ' P ?1 Y r P I , 1 , O P * f 1 ? 1 1 , 1 0 N N N r r N N (?aa? uoilnn a?? r r oo ? °:.1'• M ' ? ? t 1 (]? LL Q G C-D f < 3' 1 1 , f t ? ?l 1 1 ;' 3Y 1 O ti a 116, 1 C 1 F m 1 1 d ? 1 N h N 3 ' z 1 I 1 1 O i t i N + O ? ? o C r r r r C? O N N N N N N (100j) uou naal,g ZMX?o ¢ C ?/'M Mi r- N O OC 7 O M c G R N - ^ O` 00 00 r 00 00 - - M M > r r c? .c ? ?c ?o ?c .c r r r r Y N N N N N N N N N N N N N R L R ?./ L L Y r Ci C ? 9 - r O ?L x r x `7 ?t c" O ?O o eR+ - N N N M. M? '7 Vl ?D ?O r > R U. i ce .? r N ? ? ? -S N R Ci L Q C R G > ? 7 I c i.? = Y C O , r ? i ? Y Y R S O Y L L Y R v u Y ? ? ? 7 C C Y .t L ,? C ,? - - R C O R ?! R Y ? L C R O CC N O i ? o ? •o o ? 'o W a ? a W W 0 0 x 0 0 r C_ 0 0 s 0 G? m d w L L d 3 00 0 N 0 0 'uL z o O o F H 0 w m 0 ¦ 0 ¦ r 0 a 0 0 N O O E r O r M m Q O O _ O a0 a0 a0 r °r° r r r ° r ? N N N N N N N N N N N (;j) UOIIUAal:4 O O N V CL O C4 GL S m N O 1 ? M eC V '? O •? O v O O ? ?I W W 0 0 N 0 N O O M N z 0 o Q 0 N O O_ N CJ u w L L V CC 3 V V C cC t C W u w z v L h C O O_ In -. 00 N O w CO e O I O L r' hkl. r 0 0 'r 0 0 0 f r 0 M H Q i N M N N N N N N N N N N N (j3) UOIIPAal:4 a f?l ri R R M 0) U Ca M CL a I 0 7 0 Q W M 00 0 0 N i, (Q 6l CF 7 ^O O number of particles N CO 00 (D v N O O O O O U 3 3 ] ) nlnnloonnnnnn? ? _ I I I I I I ) I I I I ? I I I o I I I I l ? I I O O O O O E E N_ 0 V) N U CU O O_ r O O 0 a o 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 o a O M 000 1- (00 M IT M N O O ueyt jaul; tuawed o 0 ° 0 N V N O C N O H T 'O N U U CO M O U O N Q C O N_ 0 N_ U) CO O Lr) d' M N O M O M E n C C 3 Q N N_ Y O M - IT 00 M r O) M V E O E 05 0 - CO LO (D OD 0) 0 0 0 0 0 O O O E cN LO O O N? 00 O (D N N N V 01 O O Ci i f 0 O 0 N MNNto V' V' (D 00 N M V' M O? OO(n O N (0 O M (p N O 0 U U C CO U O g N LO LO LO e- N N N 'It 0 M r O N N U ' ? V' O OD O @ @ ° (0 N N V' 00 s < O N O 0 N M V (D O N 00 LO (0 N V' p a _ 0 (V M ( O O (6 (n 1 0 0 N Q r T M U 'D "O -O 'O N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N f0 Y C 'p C f0 U C C C C C > > > > > > > > > N M M M M M M M M Q Q Q Q N N N -0 'O -0 -0 'O ++ U O . O O a O M M M M M m Q) a) a) M O O M M O M M U O U U 0 0 0 0 0 3 f M E c M y N 6) N E E a) m a) m n Q Q Q Q Q L M (a 6 ;C - 7C C C C 2 M` M = 7 N E N N O - - 6) 6) w ?' O O ?•_ ?_ m 0) N N E 2 O f0 7 O M , ,7) E E > a) a) > Z J > > > C D 0 U a? a i a number of particles _U r m a LO O LO O N N LO O O O O O I O 0 > ° o00C'40 0 o n 7 H T a N m CO U C > CU B O u J O 7 . O U O N ? O O E E a) O .? CO O m O N O U _ CU in CL .0 a) C: E N 3 N ? N Y Ch -0 (n X .=. O 0 N 17 N o 0) a) CO W LO ? E N to ap - - N E U ) I I v N o LO Otov((> M LO (0 CO a) _ 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 o O m O O O O O O O O O O O ueyj jau4 jueoaad O U - t E N (0 (0 ;N (n 00 ? N C 3 C 3 O O ;,- N U aOOO M N N 0 V O N M 0 NN_ V O O O O U U C O ?;OOO?N V 0M NMIt W M N MI Nv _ 0 N M M M (O N N N (0 00 O N N M V O OD O N CO (O 0) N 00 W N N IT 00 LO (D N U E 0 d i 0 O M (n O f6 N N N In o o a # >. CO a a a a a c c c c c E m m a? m m m `m m `m _ Y c g CE U CO m m m m m > > > > > > > > > -0 -0 -0 -0 m m m m m m m m m 0 0 0 v-0 n _o 'o o o a o N a? m E m a) E - - - rnrnrnrnrnrnrnrnrn 0 0 0 0 U U?? 0 0 0 0 o ?? y ?i min a m C C y N w a) a) E E 0 0 0 a) ? :3 :3 'n CO E (D Q) O U U E O m m - E E O O m r E 0 0 0 0 U U v U ?i cn ?n m m U a a? ' E > E U ) > m m i > > >4 m > Z N a 7 0 o o ° o 0 a) Q Q O U N I I I I I I T I i I I I I I I a I I I I ? Ch I I I I I I I I I I ? I I ?_ I I i a number of particles U_ CO CO O L O LO O N N LO O O O O O _O 0 N o o ° o o > O 0 0 71 C O O 0 O a T 7 ? - 7 0 T N C N .D - 5 CU CU 1T m U O y ` O O 1 O E E C U I ----------- -- --- O N _ LO (O OD N N 00 LO N O U 3 _ (6 O_ Vl 0 N 'O N N E d N 3 Y N n N X CO O O N L NLO(D' N (O co N E C 7 N O M LO (D 00 0) o U) 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 o 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 00 0 0 0 0 0 0 00 o O 0 O m O rn OOD C) COO O V O N O O ueyj jaug juawed N 'L7 7 N Q O U I I I I I I 1 I ? I I ? I I ? I 1 I I I 1 i [ I I I I ? I I ? I I U FBI 1 M aD v number of particles CU CU Q Co (O v N O ?-- e- 00 0 V N O O 0 I O O 0 0 0 0 0 0 N 3 O U 1 T -0 N 75 T N O T -0 75 N 1 O) U O .N ? O O E E O N (D N 0 N 0 N .- Ui O O U y N 0 .O w O O N E N C N V? U) CL U) Y 00 C U 0 0 N N i 0 4, Ce) LO 00 IT r LO r- °D (CC) O E C n O N N U W 00 M v LO - CO LO (D OD O) 0 D O ) ? 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 O O O O O O O O O O O O) O r M LO IT M N O O - ueyj jaui; juaoaad ?c .. _. __..?.__ ?'?I?.?`9'E, ..._. ,... _ _ ... .. ..?SdY3iTS?4'i?k?f>3?51 •... .: •:d.q:?'?fi?. I® I? E C'4 LO (D 04 N V 0) C O C 3 N 917 N (f) (D N N 0 V Co O (D O N M 0 N N O O O O U U O? 0 0 O - N It (D CO C IN V, (D O N jj M U) r N r C CO i . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . € . . . . . 0 3 N LO LO U N V (D CO .- (O (V N LO 0 (D N N D N M IT V O 00 0 (D m N CO (D N N V CO U) (O N v O LD O 0 U +. r M O - N a0 7 O - N C fn O O Q- I n T'O 'O "O 'O •D N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N M Y C ?p m c c c c c>>>>>>>>> U M M M Co Co m M f6 m m M Co M M .n .n M .Q O O-0.0? 0 0 a 0 ' = ` to w v) w to ?_ 00 0o rnrnrnrnrnrnrnrn E ou ccou c ou( ou 7 7 7 7 7 o o o o o v . I m 3r N C C fq fq N 23 N N E E N O) O) N N(D .0 -0 -0 -0 ?Q t 7 f6 w ?.= 'O CM M m U U ? N N f6 f0 (? ? U) N f6 f0 'p 'U U U U U U > E j E E j E - O N O V7 L (D > 4) E a) Z > > { I > ? 3 N U 7 O 00 N O N 00 000 O N O U I I I I ca I I I I I I I I I I I I ? I I I I ? I I I I I I I I N I I I I ?_ I I I I ,.??.yy1 ?I 0 V F'?I i YE .r number of particles U_ C U" LO O LO O LO O LO O V CO CO N N LO O O O O I O O 0 O CL T a a? a) U U ? ? ? U 1i V) U O 1 y O - - - -- - - - - - - - - - - - - E O N .? C O U M N M 15 Lo C? U n C C 0 .O 0 O N C: N E d 3 U) CL LC) n Y X 00 (n O N v N (0 1- LO N (p V o E O O . . _ . (O ?O?v(O N MLO CO 00 CF) o o 0 0 C) 0 0 0 0 \0 \0 \o 0 0 0 0 0 0 \o 0 \ \ 0 0 O 0 m 0 0) 000 r- COD (0c') IT CO N 0 O O uey; aaull luaojad 0 O O E s ? .. E N 2? C C O 117 N N LO M O M N N N CO M 0 O 0 ;0 0 0 .- N ?- (O N N (n V 'V (O CO ? N M I (O O O t[> a) N O 0 0 0 M (n N? ? ; " F U cc I R i (6 O N (n LO (f) 0 CN 0 N (0 CO (O N N (n .- N M I T O c0 O M O N M (O N N CO 0 M N? U "r w -E i i O N U O 1 0 6 O (V M LO O O N (6 Q r >+ f6 " O 'O -O 'O - O C C C C C N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N (O Y C 'g f6 U `6) IU 10i u`6) ? to >>>>>>>>> co CO m m m (o (o (o m n o a o 0 0 0 o a o ? L O N I C rnrnrnrnrnrnrnrnrn o 0 0 0 U U M n D M M 0 0 0 0 0 v '9 M 3 ? + `u C_ 'n e N N N E E N N N a) C C C N i O 0 (6 E -0 M.n-0 a) 4 t j N (6 (0 7 m_ ' UJ D E N U U Ei >+ O M E ' O U N N U U U U y N (6 f0 E N U E > > > m I I N 7 O 0 m 0( 300 N O O U N I m I I t I I t 1 ? I I ? I I I I I I ? I ? I I ? I I APPENDIX C FIGURE C 1. MONITORING PLAN VIEW Bold Run (final) Axiom Environmental, Inc. Monitoring Year 2 of 5 (2008) EEP Project Number 439 December 2008 Wake County, North Carolina Appendices Appendices U) z ,O vJ w w F- O z ee??RRrn ?M W M W W rn InNI W 0W " W Mr ?rn ,[J W r r?nrrn ooC , NI" NN W O "' rOrn(O `f 1O^ N OOrr rOrN ,p W W ? [p M ?O W yy??0? W rn W rnOr,n NNNN W UlM d W WN ?c0 [00 cp Wy rnrn rM ?? N,IJ rnN d ? V ONN ??? ?[J (O ,C1 N M M N N NNNN o . . W r o r W r fp t0 l0 t0 M M M M N N N o O O O 0 0 0 0 NNNN O O O O 0 0 0 0 NNNN NNNN . . 0 0 0 N N N O O O O NNNN 0 0 0 0 NNNN O O O O NNNN 0 0 N0N0N N N .- N N N N N N N N N N NNN N N N N N N N N N N N N -NN N N N N N N N N OO I r CR n o .,P<' O a m ?n N NN r 'R q mO cq W ON OM . . W r(OmO Q QQ d r,ll (D QCJm m V W NONO cc cc ? tD MOi ?N O mN Om N Or(p i 6 O i .-m Wry QOrnN .- tAQ r•pNQ m N W m? O W .- mIW wN M M m ?? M M M co M M M M W M M M M rnrnmrn M M M M MMNM I M M m M M M M W W M M M M MMM M W W W W W W W W W W W W W W W W W W W W W W W W W W W W W W W W W W W v. o it # M a ° n # LL I tt O a a d a a 0 a a Z a z Z p O O O O z p O O a a a a ? ? ~ a ~ ¢ g w w w w w w w U' C7 C7 (D w w 0 O 0 Q > > > > j w > > > o > M 0 a Z ov?'i Ncn'o `r°m mCW ady w O Qt W (o f0 N In Q (7 Q J N N N N N N N ry N N a W a O . O ? M W io nN ,n ? co N o ? v, vM roM'rm N ? 0 0 rr W r-1o ? M Q W hMM W, w ro cW ^ r r ?1 m4 o o M mN II Z W OP1m r MN N . M f0rQm m^ rn r N N O WWrn O W r y d N N N 0 0 r 0 0 !ON 0 0 O N N N A O O rn oO O O O O -IN lD o O N 0 Q M M 0 0 0 2 W W W W -.11 ^ N N N N N N N NNN N NNN N 92N N N NN N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N NNNN NNNN NNNN NNNN N ry N N n. IN Q M?w Q W OWl N Q' Wrn N M N N N ?'? QI r N m M N W m N M,n rnQ rn N Q W rn O (O W W OQ Q O rn Q J (O 1 u O r r inQQr r d M W MM W W d rn N Qd?.- N rn Ol W W rn N r r rn WO I o? o? 00 0° oo O ?oo? 0000 0000 W ornrno W d S N Q M MM I m In In ro w w ro m m m m m m m m m m ooo ro m m m m m m m m m m m? mw mo m e mcr +? ? k 0 0 0 0 0 z O O O O a a a a a a u w U U U Z O Z O Z O O W w N N w O w w O O ¢ ¢ ¢ O < O G U 0 a 0) U) w v i i U) w w w w w w cr w w of x w w w w w > u U U U U > > > > > O N W Q U U_ 2 o a o 0 f N 1 1 \ 1\ 0 -1 / l if 1/ 0 1 /1 1 \.(?1J a / / a N , \0 o z (\ill; i Ui F w?-`\\`l 1\\\ ?.Q ?...\'I1\\\1111 I'V I F- _ / \ \\\ L) co \ ?, C' 1 \ - --- ?4 - \ -ttj > EL CL A r 0, CL CL v 1z \ \\?\? / \ \ _ , / 2 p0 LLI -ir LLI I 11#101 ?V W LLI J y ?. 0 } z w z a Er ¢m Of Lu w 3: O 0 U w Z O O Z = O S W M U Z w ~ Z W > w O O w J W w O W a U If m m ~ a 0 w o LL O O 0 O w o 0 Q Q K a a U O 0 N CL U C: co O Q Q O 0 - CO Z 0U c? } 2 U CL 0 0 -C m O C:) Z ° 0 N N VJ . L ? W- gi _O > C O (U :2 a- O z w V ? U C 0 0 s ° 00 Q L) O 0? O O z O (9 U Qj (z U N 0 U) 0 tZ s" . / f?r? \ r/ a /i / ( I I 11\1%/ to II ' I IM// Z o Q/ I/ 1 I M ^ • // /$//// ?Y\/Il/l/lll?/ 1I(1/lljl C) \ I III0. p?o ? I\I?111 / U '? I IIIj41111 I (Hill it I?III! ?I 1111\\ \ \I 11\ \1 1 ris&.