20200670 Ver 1_More Info Requested_20200722

Strickland, Bev
From: Annino, Amy M
Sent: Wednesday, July 22, 2020 10:35 AM
To: [e-mail]
Subject: DWR 20200670 - Bingham, 2294 Lighthouse Lane
Attachments: 20200670 Ver 1-Shoreline Stabilization_20200521.pdf
Susan,
The application fee has not been submitted for this project. The project can't be reviewed until this happens. I did make
a cursory review, but there is not enough project information to proceed with processing the application. For payment
questions, please contact Sheri Montalvo at [e-mail].
On May 20, 2020, the Division of Water Resources (Division) received your application requesting a 401 Water Quality
Certification from the Division for the subject project. The appropriate fee has not been received. The Division cannot
review your application until the fee has been received. After a cursory review of the application, the Division has
determined that your application is incomplete. The application will remain on hold (after the fee is received) until the
following items are addressed:
1. Please clarify whether you are proposing to construct a wood retaining wall or use rip rap to stabilize the
shoreline. A wooden retaining wall can only be used if bank erosion is 3 vertical feet or greater.
a. Please provide dimensions of the proposed stabilization project. Include all disturbed areas both above
and below the full pond level. Provide a sketch of the proposed plan as required in the application.
2. Please clarify whether any trees are proposed for removal along the shoreline.
3. Please clarify whether any trees are proposed for removal from the proposed 8' wide access path. Please
indicate the total length of the access path through zone 1 of the buffer (First 30 feet from full pond level) and
zone 2 of the buffer (last 20' of the 50' buffer). Provide information as to how disturbed areas will be stabilized
after construction is complete.
Pursuant to Title 15A NCAC 02H .0502(c), the applicant shall furnish the required fee and all of the above requested
information for the proper consideration of the application. If all of the requested information is not received by August
22, 2020, the Division will be unable to approve the application and it will be returned.
Amy Annino
Environmental Specialist -Asheville Regional Office
Water Quality Regional Operations Section
NCDEQ - Division of Water Resources
2090 U.S. Hwy. 70
Swannanoa, N.C. 28711
828 296 4656 office
984 232 1222 mobile
amy.annino(cancdenr.gov
Email correspondence to and from this address is subject to the

North Carolina Public Records Law and may be disclosed to third parties
Based on the current guidance to minimize the spread of COVID-19, the Department of Environmental Quality has
adjusted operations to protect the health and safety of the staff and public. Many employees are working remotely or are
on staggered shifts. To accommodate these staffing changes, all DEQ office locations are limiting public access to
appointments only. Please check with the appropriate staff before visiting our offices, as we may be able to handle your
requests by phone or email. We appreciate your patience as we continue to serve the public during this challenging time.

Action History (UTC-05:00) Eastern Time (US & Canada)
Submit by Anonymous User 5/20/2020 3:19:29 PM (Submittal)
Approve by Montalvo, Sheri A 5/21/2020 2:43:50 PM (Non -DOT - Approver)
• The task was assigned to Montalvo, Sheri A 5/20/2020 3:19 PM

Shoreline Stabilization Application Form
15ANCAC 02H .0500 —Water Quality Certification, Shoreline Stabilization
FORM SSGP 10-2013
DRAFT -NOT FOR USE AT THIS TINE 7
Submission Form
I. Applicant Information [15A NCAC 02H .0502(a)]
Please note: fields marked with a red asterisk below are required. You will not be able to submit the form until all
mandatory questions are answered.
Owner Information:
Name:*
Susan Bingham
Email:*
[e-mail]
Phone Number:*
[phone]
(xxx)xxx-xxxx
Mailing Address:*
Street Address
2294 Lighthouse Lane
Address Line 2
City
Connelly Springs
Fbstal / Zip Code
28612
Is there an agent working on the f Yes
project?* f• No
Project Information [15A NCAC 02H .0502(a) & (b)]
Project Name:* Bingham
State / Frovince / Pegion
NC
Country
US
If your project has a formal name please use this. If your project does not hake a formal name, please identify your project by
the owner name and proposed acti\ity (Jones Property Access Road, Smith Guest House, etc.) List in parentheses any
other names that ha\e been used to identify the project in the past.
1. Provide a vicinity map (i.e. street map) clearly showing the location of the property with respect
to local landmarks such as towns, rivers, and roads.*
r Upload File
r Lookup address

Property Address Lookup..*
Latitude:* 35.778619
Street Address
2294 Lighthouse Lane
Address Line 2
City
Connelly Springs
Rbstal / Zip Code
28612
State / R•ovince / Region
NC
Country
us
Longitude:*-81.494839
2. Provide a detailed site plan showing property boundaries and proposed locations of vegetation clearing,
structures (buildings, retaining walls, docks, impervious surfaces, etc.), rip rap, excavation or dredging
below Full Pond/ Normal Water Level elevations, and construction access corridors. You may use the
diagram under section 12.normal pool lake level/normal water level*
BinghamDravang.pdf 474.78KB
Please use the diagram at the link below:
https://edocs.deq.nc.gov/WaterResources/0/edoc/616616/Shoreline%20Layout.docx
3. Attach a photograph of the shoreline/ buffer proposed to be stabilized. (Include a scale of some sort- a
yard stick, shovel handle, etc.)*
Binghamphoto1.jpg 5.95MB
Binghamphoto2.jpg 3.18MB
BinghamPlat.pdf 476.37KB
4. Location of the property (where work is to be conducted)
Nearest Town:* Connelly Springs
County:* Burke
Lake/ river/ ocean adjacent to Rhodhiss
property:
Subdivisions name or site address:* Paradise Harbour
Include phase/lot nun ber
Directions to site:*
From Ashville
Interstate 40 to Exit 116, Turn Rt. on Old NC 10, turn Ift on Hwy 70,
Rt on Shady Grove Rd, Shady Grove becomes Tomlinson Loop,
Rt on W Paradise Harbour Dr, Lft (still W Paradise Harbour Dr), Lft
on Sunset Point Dr, Rt on Lighthouse Ln, Property is at end of rd
on rt
Rease include road narres and numbers, landmarks etc.
5. Describe the existing land use or condition of the site at the time of this application:*
Residential
Residential, undeveloped, etc.
6. Pro pertySize 4 5'
Acre
7. Describe proposed work (include discussion as to how hardening of shoreline has been
avoided, or why it is necessary):
Stabilize bank on backside of boat dock from eroding any more
approx. 100' with a wooden wall

8. How will the work be done?* 17 From Land
F From Water
9. Total amount of disturbance below the normal pool lake level/ normal water level:*
(including all clearing, back fill, excavation, rip rap, retaining walls, etc.)
300 sq ft
square feet
10. Total amount of disturbance above the normal pool lake level/ normal water level and 50 feet
land -ward:*
(including all clearing, back fill, excavation, rip rap, retaining walls, etc.)
100 sq ft
square feet
11. Please describe the vegetation above the normal pool lake level/ normal water level and 50 feet
landward to be impacted:*
(nunber of trees, for instance)
none
All disturbed grass disturbed will be mulched
Sketch: BinghamSketch.pdf 1.26MB
Application Fee:
Once the application has been accepted. You will need to send a corresponding fee in with the appropriate DWR#. The
application fee is as follows (pursuant to G.S. 143-215.3D):
o $240.00 for impacts to lake (below normal water level) of less than 1 acre
o $570.00 for impacts to lake (below normal water level) of greater or equal to 1 acre
By digitally signing below, I certify that:
o I have given true, accurate, and complete information on this form;
o I agree that submission of this form is a "transaction" subject to Chapter 66, Article 40 of the NC General Statutes (the
"Uniform Electronic Transactions Act")
o I agree to conduct this transaction by electronic means pursuant to Chapter 66, Article 40 of the NC General Statutes
(the "Uniform Electronic Transactions Act');
o I understand that an electronic signature has the same legal effect and can be enforced in the same way as a written
signature; AND
o I intend to electronically sign and submit this form.
Full Name:* Susan Bingham
Signature:
7 �
rrc�rz.� r. �ujf�r�°r

Initial Review
Is this accepted into the review
process?*
Project Number:* 20200670
Select Reviewer:*
Select Reviewing Office
Has payment been received?*
What amount is owed?*
r Yes r No
Version:* 1
Amy Annino:eads\amannino
Asheville Regional Office - [phone]
f No Payment Needed
f Fee Received
r Need Fee - send electronic notification
* $240.00
f $570.00

#.; �` j # • • wwF
M!
p(r
RLj
.jIro_ -
LVLe
h4
,4je 4
iV
PWrI
4�rA
.mj IMmd
qrS
imi
45
JRJ!—
SOvL
PAIL
MW
ir
MWL
qr
NA
k R' I IN '.i '+' �. s -r + L { y+'' ` tY#t� 5li h - , L "1- -e F .;•J,y . .t` �� '-
L�
i 1 �"� r rr Y►r�/, ? i. S Z �'! r" '� �. #- ~ f , 4"'r� + k ••" { ate'�F
* f _ i L '# " 'ti'� f # ; it
r t
F
A l * •r i i .41,+ '�" +ii , LY i T•Fr_ . �• ; i i 'L T +r f + • +. #
,' * t ` r r -A
i r ... r ,�"# '
i +t _ r
i f t W.1 i 'ti 4, _ F • +` T 5 _ Rtr �.r J — � � ' • � F ~ r - _
T+ ` +r-"A''!167_- Z7 x y T'. .FF 'r 'ram�1 T t , 1 • ; x
bA
� I!��+ •• 4 - M1�-�;� " � ��f + iR �3Y�4 r� #�! �iL�F � r�� � �� R5 � �rJ� � � � � �� � 'ti•
7r'],i ','' w
-tXA
r *r J + F # 4 r y rr } +
�L. f ti ��• iF ;�� _ ]� �, '�#� ` ,1� ■h� A' * �• r 1'
'r r�` F t'' k ' 1 `4�i �* i �,, 1�" 1•r 'r 4
- _ i .ter
S l i ,r 1 I yyy I
,• .. ` _ � - � y r *� � �r ti 1 � �1E, � �� � G r � � � � �j .� � } � �� t: *�1 `,� � � R �•
1 1 k i ` t % F
r a L ti 1. M• �f a 4 #; 1 j
+*it y r l .� i '.� hl 11 I/i i 1'�.# '
t per`
kIM, LW
-. � ' i�
Ar
�'� 'y+� i.� '•7i•'F 1 ' "�� sr � _ - ��* j �!ice+"-• ,� � y i•,1 � �'
� y � � a r, � # •� - i � � f � O � � -�•,- �`�- '� �� #.€-� �• � _ + ,�,� � �' •.{ ••lsJ, �
All
rp
1 r ! MYi � ► � }` J r!r � y �' - � JI T � ! V J � S � - _ F { �� � f`,� r / � .+ 4 ".,.Filmy- . �- �. _ _ --• T r , . _ \a a� 4 T �+ ,. ' � ` - `# -
• M
.1 r �. �` ! - f �, �Y r '�. y2� }+ -r,•. ' ~'� 4i - l r S i
��� � ,ems..+��1
•. • L I , _- ,5,., . - a+t.JX F .Y~#'_ wr M {�'^.
71._ * } - f f;* `V* C ' _ _ '.r -+*fF~� �Y { d S •+T •i5 - +L I y -"4 # •# +1 .� ,
� _ _ '. ,wf. Y � � r r • - �� ..ram � iiF r� � # - � - �' ��'. ~� • 1� � ,. ti.. - - 3 :fir 1 Y '� � - � - � � `4'��� � +�• '� ~ k� i' •� • �J� �` � { � '. ` �`-
� J�� . R r� � � � ` _ _ � 7 / r. - � �� ' # `w • • � � � � •`/ � ~4 � � _ .� �' � { * - � r '� � f _ �' � lam+ � . � t - ,� * � � 5 � � y,
- _
+rt ��i.I..d *#�
..# r i 1 �#} x '". '• ,� _ � F# r+t3 A ' R� r` - • ` a+ �� _ * `yy� -' L
~
',I -!\ �`!*� - ��x �
Fr ti. •' - 40
�•L � '� y �'
. - , Y.�+• *'' ;,ham`# '.} r< i ' •����i, # r 7 \
L, VL1
ice' _.L.
" �" _ ' 1 v� •'1 ± 4 ��• Y' '4 1' 4 F ~ - ti -li 4k r,
49
lit
' �•_ tom, 1+JIL-
_
~� -fir• ,. i - i i w
M
_ ALA,
a
l
�3
r
•
qF
Mold
or
#• . + .AIL
■� # , - L - _
I S i F rAr i' 7
' k i
* `'fir .M FrAl
at + S {
AWN x
_ IL rV d it . I>f 1 if F #
. 4 # 1
s r f A 33 a f
t T f.
' . 2 or
it
41
r
Ah
0
AN
}}
Af AF
_11 f r r
ip
49 * 1 # ,
kl
at 90,
!!
+ '� • '
I
Rp
'Ity ■
OrL� rial w AL. r
J it
49 d14 14. #1 / . f . I i.
Rp-,Om or
j f # :� �. o . ( - " 9
i do
67'
+a up r
kip
1Rnr
~ _ '� i ' rim ' �+� • •* ` 1b Y i 'W41 ■
* !. wR ■
' •"
M.
qr
AL
• * r •!+
e 3
aIL
�
r .~ t + '1 - * - , f .Ira •� — ;
tp
d, p
IV OL
#ti ! ' y ► _
* # '! + \ `

IF III++
1
oe
"� A J
�e : 40
N-IW
de
!`� ` _ • ,� f ► era � i r .' _ � ►� s �y � _ �NY
'
41
000
IV do
pp qu
qp
4400
dp
gel JML
tA - 0.. p
Oak do �—.•�/+ 1�is .:T � �;F�'�+ �� t� �.T
dr
dt
AL
dr
mw
me._�.,► . '.00
' ,ems.. �
�N4L 4w
L AN
4 4; 40WO
�+ � Via' ?J+• � � .All
40 Ar-
d4pp
AT GOP
PdMP-
4d AL
W!"o %.6
AL
Aire
me
dip
4411,
k9a; ram•.
4
r
4
00*
ap -v
OF
op
dr lop do
Y
IP op
dr
opo of ipp,
00
01 •�+,, t��,�; y.' (fir'
let
i L-L
Wf.
-A
U
it
lop 01
' rJ
WA
l
r qwc
A
—•IRA
1plw
Ap 0

a
ownenivuu��`*
qm=
Imo.
�tq
o
R3T
a
_
zC
x
u
�
_
o
hGiM - ,5`lJ d3�"
a
<Foe n
a
'R4
Sry�a �o
�=34
a
•t �i}eL h
8 Q�IN
n
x
ITS
%U
O
O
C$•iOL{O•
�»N 9"n3 vv
T.
m
2
Q
a
In
in
¢°33°ryv�

State of North Carolina
- Department of Environment and Natural Resources
Division of Water Resources
15A NCAC 02H .0500 — Water Quality Certification, Shoreline Stabilization
FORM: SSGP 02-2017
Please approximately sketch the following information on this plan and provide dimensions for
each item:
a. All proposed vegetation clearing
b_ Location of rip rap or fill to be placed above the Full Pond/ Normal Water Level elevation
C. Location of rip rap or fill to be placed below the Full Pond/ Normal Water Level elevation
d. Location of any proposed structures such as buildings, retaining walls, docks, etc.
e. Location of any excavation or dredeing hPln%ni th¢ FI III Dnnd/ Normal IA c _1__._..
La ke
(At Full pond/ Normal Water Level)
Full Pond/ Norma[ Water Level
Shoreline
FORM: SSGP O2-2017
Page 1 of 3

f L,
Lake
(At Full Pond/ Normal Wab
Side View
U-
Lake
{A% Full ao4 Normal wafer level)
Existing hack
. 3ortx 7ft l
jh� t
f
3 ft
xL h
Fufl Pond/ Normal Water Level . selawiu�l po ae NWL
� Shoreline
I
Rlprap r, atrx 15o ft
P6
I 2ft.x150 ft. — M p-al NAIL
add'V-1
tleannr, { ��
� "nett -scary S.
.'A
I n
Plan View I
! l
FORM: 55GP 02-2017
Page 2 of 3

vi

0
■
g
s
�
0
ODE 2
$Mm»a 2 r.L n
WO)OWkMm-0
o (a-
a - x
/CDXCD(D Z
\ER®
CG%
2&/
moo
co
N�/
\
\
\
�
co
C-
�
CD
C)
0
�
�
�
z
0
CD