HomeMy WebLinkAbout20190262 Ver 2_PCN Supplemental Information_202007271
Timmons Group Burgess Court
Supplemental Information, PCN Application
PCN Supplemental Information
SECTION A – APPLICANT INFORMATION
PART 3. OWNER INFORMATION
SECTION B –
PROJECT
INFORMATION
AND PRIOR
PROJECT HISTORY
PART 1.
PROPERTY
IDENTIFICATION
3a. Names on
Recorded Deed
3b. Deed Book
and Page Number
3d. Street
Address 3e. City, State, Zip
1a. Property
Identification
Number (PIN)
HUNTERS CREEK
TOWNHOUSE
HOMEOWNERS
ASSOCIATION, INC
DB 3506
PG 174
C/O SENTRY
MANAGEMENT,
INC. 2180 W.
STATE ROAD 434,
STE 5000
LONGWOOD, FL
32779 0793176867
HUNTERS CREEK
TOWNHOUSE
HOMEOWNERS
ASSOCIATION, INC
DB 3646
PG 391
C/O SENTRY
MANAGEMENT,
INC. 2180 W.
STATE ROAD 434,
STE 5000
LONGWOOD, FL
32779 0793172961
NEERAJ KUMAR DB 11891
PG 1101
1713 KAYLA
COURT
RALEIGH, NC
27606 0793175856
GLENN AND KIM
MILLER
DB 17315
PG 462
5308 BURNING
OAK COURT
RALEIGH, NC
27606 0793175859
JON DAVID
JIVIDEN, EMILY
ANN NANCE
DB 13872
PG 220
1709 KAYLA
COURT
RALEIGH, NC
27606 0793175960
JEREMIAH
CORKERY, FIONA
FARRELL
DB 13277
PG 437
4709 TWINWOOD
COURT
RALEIGH, NC
27613 0793175943
MARY G PARKER DB 3875
PG 136
1705 KAYLA
COURT
RALEIGH, NC
27606 0793175945
RONALD HAL
JOHNSON
DB 08-E
PG 3050
1703 KAYLA
COURT
RALEIGH, NC
27606 0793175927
JACKIE JOHNSON,
BRANDON GIBBS
HAWKINS
DB 15283
PG 1937
1701 KAYLA
COURT
RALEIGH, NC
27606 0793175939
2
Timmons Group Burgess Court
Supplemental Information, PCN Application
SECTION B – PROJECT INFORMATION AND PRIOR PROJECT HISTORY
PART 3. PROJECT DESCRIPTION
3a. Project Description:
This PCN Application is for an amendment to existing 404 and 401 permits. The permits are listed as
follows:
USACE 404 No: SAW-2019-00471 Approval Date: 4/18/2019
DWR 401 and Buffer Authorization: DWR NO 19-0262 Approval Date 3/3/2019
These documents have been included in Appendix B. The PCN Application was originally sent in by Kris
Bass Engineering as the Applicant. The HOA requested assistance through the City of Raleigh Drainage
Assistance Program. Due to the culvert failure at Burgess Court the project was accepted into that
program. The project prepared by Kris Bass Engineering was designed with two reaches. Reach one
consisted of a stream restoration on approximately 150 linear feet of stream. Reach two consisted of bank
repairs along 75 linear feet of stream adjacent to the Burgess Street Culverts. The PCN application was
approved for this work in 2019 as listed above.
The Burgess Street Culvert flared end sections were dislodged during a storm event which caused blockage
and severe erosion on the banks and adjacent to the dual 84-inch CMP’s. A stress fracture in the street
was also found indicating potential street failure in the future. A part of the City’s Drainage Assistance
program addresses failing city infrastructure and therefore Reach 2 previously permitted with the original
401 and 404 permits was re-designed by the Timmons Group to permanently stabilize the Pipe entrance
and protect the street downstream infrastructure. The new design for Reach 2 includes the replacement
of the dual 84-inch flared end sections with a head wall structure. The headwall structure has been
designed to be within the footprint of the existing flared end sections so that no additional stream impacts
to the overall stream length will occur with the placement of the headwall. The stream had migrated
severely to the west and a large point bar had established restricting flow to the eastern culvert. With the
re-design of Reach 2, the stream configuration has been improved to provide a better alignment to the
dual culverts through an improved radius of curvature. The stream banks will be stabilized with a rock toe
along a short section in the approach to the culverts. The existing riffle just downstream of the existing
sanitary sewer crossing will be extended, pool improvements made, and an embedded stone apron has
been designed just upstream of the proposed headwall. Reach 2 has been completely re-designed as
shown in the attached construction plans.
The original design of Reach 1 proposed by Kriss Bass Engineering remains as originally intended with
slight modifications to the placement of some of the rock structures to move them further out of the
existing sanitary sewer easement required by the City’s utility department. The original application by
Kriss Bass Engineering did not include the temporary impacts to zone 2 for the buffers due to the
construction access. Therefore this is the primary change to the overall impacts for Reach 1 included
herein.
The project site is located within the Hunters Creek townhouse development in Raleigh, North Carolina.
An unnamed tributary (UT) to Bushy Creek runs through the Homeowners Association property area
behind the townhouses along Kayla Court and Ithaca Lane. The watershed contributing stormwater to the
3
Timmons Group Burgess Court
Supplemental Information, PCN Application
project site was evaluated using USGS StreamStats online application. The contributing watershed has an
area of approximately 0.37 square miles.
3b. List total estimated acreage of all existing wetlands of the property:
The project will be completed in a limited area of the project. No wetlands were iden tified within the
project area. The repair area along the stream is the same length covered in the original permit.
3d. Explain the Purpose of the Project:
The primary objective for the project is to repair failing Dual 84-inch pipes at Burgess Court. Burgess court
is the only entrance to a multifamily development and therefore permanent stabilization of the pipe
infrastructure is paramount. Because both repairs to Reach 1 and Reach 2 was approved through the City
of Raleigh Drainage Assistance Program the work in Reach 1 is proposed to be constructed with the much-
needed repairs to the culverts in Reach 2.
3e. Describe the Overall Project in Detail, Including the Type of Equipment to be Used:
Reach 1: The improvement of the stream at this location is a full stream restoration, involving the
construction of grade control structures, the excavation of a new channel that reconnects the stream to
a floodplain, backfilling of the old channel, and thorough planting of native species that will strengthen
the streambanks and provide wildlife habitat. The stream thalweg will be repositioned slightly to move
the stream further away from nearby townhomes, but the stream length will remain unchanged. To
accomplish this, the left bank, as looking downstream, will be cut back, while the right bank will be
backfilled. In-stream grade control structures in this reach include: 2 Boulder Drop Pools, 1 Double Cross
Vane, 2 Constructed Reinforced Riffles, and 2 Boulder Steps. Additional buffer impacts will occur
temporarily along the construction access and staging area. These areas will be stabilized with proper
riparian vegetation at the conclusion of construction. All side slopes are 3:1 or greater, except for the last
25 LF of the reach on the right bank, where the steepest side slope is approximately 1.5:1. All stream and
buffer impacts are detailed in the tables below.
Reach 2: The proposed headwall and culvert improvements will be installed where the old pipes were
previously located so that there are no impacts to the stream associated with pipe installation. The
improvements to the stream at this location include channel and bank grading and stabilization, culvert
improvements, and headwall installation. The stream position will be adjusted slightly at the culvert
entrance to provide a more appropriate radius of curvature. The left bank, as looking downstream, will be
cut back while the right bank will be filled to shift the stream east by approximately 15 feet. The channel
will be transitioned in width as to accommodate the existing dual 84-inch culverts. Stream stabilization
will be provided on the banks through reconstruction to a side slope of 2H:1V with rock toe reinforcement,
installation of constructed riffle that ties into the existing rock, and planting of permanent woody
vegetation. The existing sanitary sewer manhole on the east side of the stream will be stabilized using a
rock toe. The existing flared end sections will be removed. (The City completed the emergency removal
of the dislodged obstructions in January 2020). A 10-foot section of pipe and headwall will replace the
flared end section within the existing culvert impact length. It was determined through soils investigations
that the fill soil behind the culverts was less than optimal, therefore structural fill will be brought in for
placement behind the new headwall structures (Falcon Engineering soils reports are available upon
request). The fill slope from the road to the headwall will be established at a maximum slope of 3H:1V.
4
Timmons Group Burgess Court
Supplemental Information, PCN Application
Existing scour has occurred along the length of the pipe to distances as great as 10 feet. These scour areas
will be filled with grout.
The stream bank corridor within the repair area will be re-vegetated along both sides of the stream along
with the bankfull bench. The re-introduction of vegetation to the graded channel banks will aid in
providing long term bank stability. The vegetation will be a combination of native herbaceous and woody
plant species. The stabilized banks and re-vegetated corridor will additionally provide stormwater quality
benefits.
The equipment to be used in the project is earth moving equipment and various othe r support
apparatuses. The stream normal flow will be pumped around the project site. Stabilization will occur daily
within the work area. Heavy equipment may include hydraulic excavator, compactors, bulldozers,
skidsteer loaders, and dump trucks to load and unload materials. The construction equipment will enter
Reach 1 from the parking area on Sterlingworth Drive. The construction equipment will enter Reach 2
from Burgess Court. All construction will be performed within a defined limit of disturbance.
5b. Project History
USACE 404 No: SAW-2019-00471; Application Date: 2/25/2019; Approval Date: 4/18/2019
DWR 401 and Buffer Authorization: DWR NO 19-0262; Application Date: 2/25/2019 Approval Date
3/3/2019
SECTION C – PROPOSED IMPACTS INVENTORY
3i. Stream Impacts:
S1: The permanent impact with no functional loss are associated with stabilization of the stream include
bank grading, boulder steps, rock vane, a constructed riffle, and installation of permanent woody
vegetation for approximately 150 LF of stream in Reach 1.
S2: The permanent impacts associated with rock toe include undercutting the bank to provide room to
place the rock toe for approximately 58 LF of stream in Reach 2.
S3: The permanent impacts associated embedded apron upstream of culvert inlet is 12 LF in reach 2.
S4: The permanent impacts associated with culvert extension and headwall is 10 LF in reach 2.
5
Timmons Group Burgess Court
Supplemental Information, PCN Application
Table 1 – Stream Impacts Chart
Impact Permanent /
Temporary Type of Impact
From PCN by KB
Engineering 2019 PCN Amendment 2020
Reach 1 Reach 2 Reach 1 Reach 2
S1 Permanent Stabilization 150 75 150 0
S2 Permanent Rock Toe 0 0 0 58
S3 Permanent Riprap Apron 0 0 0 12
S4 Permanent Pipe Extension
and headwall 0 0 0 10
Total Length Permitted in 2019 225
Total Length Impacted in 2020 230
Total Change in Impacted Length 2020 5
6i. Buffer Impacts:
B1: The buffer impacts associated with stabilization of the stream include grading to provide a floodplain
bench along the stream for approximately 3743 square feet for Reach 1 and to improve the overbank side
slopes for approximately 1147 square feet for Reach 2. All of B1 impacts occur in Buffer Zone 1. The total
4890 square feet of impacts have been previously permitted.
B2: The buffer impacts associated with the construction access include clearing to provide sufficient room
for construction activities to occur. Approximately 833 square feet of Buffer Zone 1 and 615 square feet
of Buffer Zone 2 for Reach 1 are included in the impacts. Approximately 2763 square feet of Buffer Zone
1 and 2780 square feet of Buffer Zone 2 for Reach 2 are included in the impacts. The total 3596 square
feet of Buffer Zone 1 and 3395 square feet of Buffer Zone 2 are additional impacts for which this
amendment required.
Table 2 – Buffer Impacts Chart
Impact Permanent /
Temporary
Type of
Impact
From PCN by KB Engineering
2019 PCN Amendment 2020
Reach 1 Reach 2 Reach 1 Reach 2
Z1 Z2 Z1 Z2 Z1 Z2 Z1 Z2
B1 Temporary Stabilization 3743 0 1147 0 3743 0 1147 0
B2 Temporary Construction
Access N/A N/A N/A N/A 833 615 2763 2780
Total Area Permitted in 2019 3743 0 1147 0
Total Area Impacted in 2020 4576 615 3910 2780
Total Change in Impacted Area 2020 833 615 2763 2780
SECTION D – IMPACT JUSTIFICATION AND MITIGATION
6
Timmons Group Burgess Court
Supplemental Information, PCN Application
1a. Specifically describe measures taken to avoid or minimize the proposed impacts in designing
project.
This project is necessary due to the active bank erosion that is encroaching dangerously on the residential
structures at in the Hunters Creek townhouse development as well as to repair the damaged culvert
entrance at Burgess Court. The project will stabilize the stream channel and to eliminate active erosion of
the stream channel bank. The stabilization of the banks will reduce sediment import into the stream that
is currently occurring. The minimization of the project includes working with the existing stream pattern
with limited pattern changes and raising the channel for better floodplain connection to reduce the stress
on the stream banks during large storm events. The limits of disturbance have been minimized to only the
area needed to construct the repairs. Impacts to the stream buffer will be minimized by accessing the site
through a narrow corridor and protection of as much existing vegetation as possible.
1b. Specifically describe measures taken to avoid or minimize the proposed impacts through
construction techniques.
Pumping of normal stream flow be maintained and pumped around the site during construction activities.
Bank stabilization, covering the slope with riparian seed and coir matting, will occur daily upon completion
of bank grading. Permanent woody vegetation will be installed on all stream banks above rock toes limited
to bankfull elevations.
SECTION F – SUPPLEMENTARY INFORMATION
5d. What data sources did you use to determine whether your site would impact Endangered Species
or Designated Critical Habitat?
The site is an existing urban residential area that has been previously impacted by development. Open
areas are currently being mowed and maintained. Habitat is not present for Wake County listed vertebrate
and invertebrate endangered species with the exception of Northern Long Eared Bats. It is not anticipated
that this tree removal would be an impact to critical habitat for the Northern Long Eared Bat in Wake
County. Therefore, it is not anticipated that there will be any adverse impacts associated with T/E species.