20200673 Ver 1_Pictures_20200608 (2)

Strickland, Bev
From: Kim Jordan <[e-mail]>
Sent: Monday, June 8, 2020 4:05 PM
To: Perez, Douglas J
Subject: Re: [External] Re: 3726 Lake Shore Rd. (20-0673)
Attachments: Jamie Baker Catawba Riparian form.pdf, Jamie Baker tree photo 1 (1)jpg; Jamie Baker
tree photo 2jpg; Jamie Baker tree photo 3jpg; Jamie Baker tree photo 4jpg
• 1 External email. Do not click links or open attachments unless you verify. Send all suspicious email as an attachment to
[e-mail]
Hey Doug,
I'm attaching 4 photos of the tree, in addition to the Catawba Riparian form.
Please let me know if you need anything else.
Have a great night,
Kim
On Mon, Jun 8, 2020 at 10:56 AM Kim Jordan <kitnklyfemarine.com> wrote:
Thank you!
Will get Jamie Baker's tree photos to you as soon as we have them.
On Mon, Jun 8, 2020 at 10:44 AM Perez, Douglas J <doug_perezkncdenr.gov> wrote:
Hey Kim,
Ok, that makes more sense. I suppose since she's the main person I've been in contact with I don't need the form. I'll
kick out the application for Sommer and it should go out this week.
All the best,
Doug
From: Kim Jordan [mailto:[e-mail]]
Sent: Monday, June 8, 2020 10:41 AM
To: Perez, Douglas J <[e-mail]>
Subject: Re: [External] Re: 3726 Lake Shore Rd. (20-0673)

• xternal email. Do not click links or open attachments unless you verify. Send all suspicious email as an attachment to
[e-mail]
To clarify, we are doing the shoreline work for Sommer, but she opted to do her own forms
On Mon, Jun 8, 2020 at 10:40 AM Kim Jordan <kim o,lyfemarine.com> wrote:
Yes, we charge a fee for processing permits and she wanted to do it on her own.
We are doing the work for her, but she wants to be the contact for her applications.
Do you still need the authorization in this type of situation?
For Jamie Baker, Randy is going to go to his property later today and get better photos of the tree for you.
On Mon, Jun 8, 2020 at 10:03 AM Perez, Douglas J <doug_perez o,ncdenr.gov> wrote:
One other thing I didn't see with Sommer's application, however, was an Agent Authorization Form. If you could get
that to me, I could keep working on the application.
Doug
From: Kim Jordan [mailto:[e-mail]]
Sent: Monday, June 8, 2020 9:38 AM
To: Perez, Douglas J <[e-mail]>
Cc: Johnson, Alan <[e-mail]>; Randy Jordan <[e-mail]>
Subject: Re: [External] Re: 3726 Lake Shore Rd. (20-0673)
r—
External email. Do not click links or open attachments unless you verify. Send all suspicious email as an attachment

Good morning,
Yes, the online submission is new to us, so I figured it would entail a learning curve. I will have Randy
circle the tree for Jamie Baker and give any details as needed. He has signed the form and I will submit that
to you as well as soon as Randy signs for the Contractor.
We have another client with this same issue. She chose to submit the forms with our guidance and was not
aware of the 2 trees to be removed on her property. They are both in photos that were submitted, I believe
and are leaning over the lake. Her name is Sommer Eperthener and you have been in contact with her. Do
we need to address this as well? I believe you have her signed form.
Thanks for your help,
Kim
On Mon, Jun 8, 2020 at 8:39 AM Perez, Douglas J <doug_perezkncdenr.gov> wrote:
Hello,
On your application, on page 12 which is the drawing of the shoreline, there is a tree (shown in red) for
removal. Can you send me pictures of said tree? None of the pictures in your application showed this tree. Once I
see these pictures, we can decide if anything needs to be included in the approval. Typically, when trees that
aren't severely undermined or diseased, are requested to be removed, we ask for a tree to be re -planted in its
place. Please get me those pictures if at all possible.
Doug
From: Kim Jordan [mailto:[e-mail]]
Sent: Saturday, June 6, 2020 10:19 AM
To: Perez, Douglas J <[e-mail]>
Cc: Johnson, Alan <[e-mail]>; Randy Jordan <[e-mail]>
Subject: [External] Re: 3726 Lake Shore Rd. (20-0673)
External email. Do not click links or open attachments unless you verify. Send all suspicious email as an attachment
Lo [e-mail]

Hello Doug. There are two items in your requirements that are new requirements to us.
1. Re -planting trees has not been a prior requirement in other Shoreline Certification Approvals that we've
done over the years.
2. We've been able to show Alan or your office photos of undermined trees to propose removal. There has
never been an additional step of hiring a licensed arborist.
Will you please confirm, as this will be a costly, additional process for all of our Clients now and in
the future.
Thank you,
Kim
On Thu, Jun 4, 2020 at 12:22 PM Perez, Douglas J <doug_perezkncdenr.gov> wrote:
Hello,
I am emailing you today about your shoreline stabilization application. There are two things I wanted to
note. The first, is that you will need to fill out, sign, and return to me a Catawba Riparian Buffer form. I
have attached it here. The second relates to the first. In the form, you will note that trees of 3" diameter
or greater at shoulder height are NOT to be removed. Unless the trees are severely diseased or critically
undermined. If said trees are, then they must be replaced by trees of 3" diameter at shoulder height and
6'-8' tall and placed somewhere within the 30' buffer. Similarly, if said trees are diseased or undermined,
photographic documentation must be presented to this office along with documentation from a licensed
arborist stating as such. If you could clarify these issues, I can continue working on your application.
Sincerely,
Doug Perez

DWR--'--F
�Iian a# Or Resources
Doug Perez — Environmental Specialist
NC Dept. of Environment & Natural Resources (NCDENR)
Division of Water Resources - Water Quality Regional Operations
610 East Center Ave., Suite 301, Mooresville, NC 28115
Phone: [phone] Fax: [phone]
E-mail correspondence to and from this address may be subject to the North Carolina Public Records Law and may
be disclosed to third parties unless the content is exempt by statute or other regulation.

Pm].d Nm ma.ddr..:3�\ \- 9-�iy'@Aa.,�q rbm : ; A r n n
The approval is for Oro purpom and &Wigs lambed in yore sppficetioo. Imp, not indintcd in the
ePpli'don is a v]olatim of the Buffer RWe. Site speWfre work should be povidcd in the app0m0om 115A
NCAC 02H .0506 eat 15ANCAC 02B .0243(S)]
T1 am Isol allowed to be removed fiom Zone I of the Buffo (within 30 fl ofthe fWl pond ekvwim), Imka
approve& Exception, those pee, that . so,mly Imdcrminod long the Wmediate shomlbm m be removed.
Minim" ahepmg nod sloping WooS the immediate shoreline i. Wlo.M [I SA NCAC 02B .0243(6)]
Benching end gadWg in tk buffet iv not 0110wed £x«ssive disnpbmoe of pound cover. [15A NCAC
.0243(6)]
Beschm imPervlom Petim, bmPWAOm walkways, do. me not slowed in the buds unless
Wmved by We Dnvioo. There me li dt-6m m sis for dxk.115ANCAC 02B .0243(4) and (6)]
Work W be conducted from Imd mum indimte m .aom end indlak my Irea that arc to be removal The
work corridor should be dmaibed. The approved mesa corridor shell be stored. Staging, spoil, omnpuefm
materiel marl be oubide the bn(ra. [15ANCAC 02H .0502 and 15ANCAC 02B .0243 (4).(6), (8)]
Stontt r am,ot be piped m channeled fro dh t disenmge W me lake. AB commMpd mamwaa
discharge, mart be a we na W ekvadm and d(ad,mged Prior m rntering the bufla diroct d ar diffuse or
sheet now at no 3ive velocities to the lake. [15ANCAC 02B .0243(5), (6)]
4eknos/dgr,rtenr ofNaafiemon
ti Jnmlo �akt� lt=bymmewmfh.,ebminfo. .fro Cm. ea
RIPQIap BW7a Rule. Apyw kWn&wtcd in the lmffa, not speClfimBy slated inthe.ppllemmnend.pp.
by the Division ofWata Rm (DWR), is a violation and subject to eeforemeot Due dfligi will be
mkm such thm the comtructim will be built within sadtntla compflma.nd Went ofthe 401 Was Qlrlay
Cerdfloatiou and Buda Rule, the approved plm(s) and specifioetionis), and other aupportlag maaisla.
Signature (0w ): fhbe: G y 20 av

A� if
,at `• �.\ .'�� WSJ 0� Irrci :x 7 rr j r }. TY,IIfr� �rl lea '+q9'AS
.:nTj� x
IRS
fly
It I
to
.�Z er.. ,S Se. , , .� s We
Cd 1�: 4 � { l.' IM �y +' 1,,' ' 11 Iµ�Cd•., 0W.0
a / t JrvS
iJ le III
IR
�i o .1 � its r4 '
It f (((
s
W .v > km
,it> ry j; r f F
It
� ..'♦ 4 f n' 0 ��:) ' S"1��� 1 �- .;ice- 1 ( .6, ° " r ��''f S 5=21a� j .rA<
SO 4
RS
1 IV
tI
tI
II
T i �' / s A t 3 .. a, f
IT p Y J
r\, \, %4 :10,`S ,tJ ,'. �f i `•�. '- L ,i ` l "'';1. 1 "f �. � ," k. '/>,, ,' �i; �e.� ` M �,. w.- � rat �
•n� >.y- k,}• - '(, �a •'I 11a •¢ ��. , N{>leY ..1 icy. en'..M
tl
II
�{t'.�_r,•. 1•ti` i ~�'• :I• I'. r`r d / Tay
nl.j` i a �1:� • 7'I'��j•�!'�
CY
- �• S P7'��1 %S '�+ ;? f�i - aiA - Y" #
!c'iv
,4(5 �i / c''l�EA E i FI•;sw31 -a a •A
Ii
Fete
ISF
pv
If
fi `4 i yQ`,`•1, E` `.e`w ,4 Ij s Psi
It I r FvIle
i' r`'" > Y I:
Wet
!.� IV
-
y-. f1 t It
- !" if t'r �`.; ` i l sIt `wt i t13V e y�r'.
.i, �i.J.> ,.li' i , (�ir ` 1/' fir .`y. .x 9 r:�el 0 :of 41 PI
A, I „ 9 Vy S, -wAtt
- .1'�
A f�
II
y�y� �' N1 \ n t . I _ 6S,VI
. c
it
'>Awpm It
'I ekl 444Ila
Idwj rr
`i �44R.(t V sty, �[t1fre. 'I b MR IV'
I to
teN tell
Sir
SIR
— f i'�y� '
`� \ y
PIRO/
\♦�IS
°° ♦♦ °s°♦♦♦°♦°�° ♦ ♦ ♦ ♦ �, y Y
� • +° °�� ` � �r „� � * - ` d%♦4♦°o♦o°osli°o°s®soo,�°♦°®°`°m♦oo♦O�♦♦° Oi ♦♦
1 - < - � ♦ ♦ y l ♦ ♦N+ 9 �A��*4.A�.A�A®SO�•?A♦F1♦HdAA°®®4,'�6 ♦ . `-�
c_.
1vAL`'IA'•���3A•h�1.�Q0 +YES t,�W�;s,,��o5>'i4^c'epP®L�t•6A'V"�'PA•9A :� " ..
c '9'1 00 ♦`�D�. O •A •r9eb'ca?ej y.'�
o* s° Y 1 ♦ �I�*r®wvm�zt 'x�s dN4..D �IIr �0♦ r,�",'
•.�_'. :1"' i+ "-' `'s'. fir+. P '+l \'s� h4'^,aA4+S6AOrB dt@•IRS
v r`'��"i;.tn9 @A®i+0°♦AQ, �L
�' C,�' '�" .+•' €5 MP
,.-'\'`'�`a. , `.«.�'s" °^• F 4 fiaQ'o H•1.♦+,J,c VC�hY' �$��♦ , v .n.e ('
WIWI
�? .f N SW
y1 egsas i . aYM►lok
OIL
It
ell v AL
_ - -c
.VP
SO
It AS,
zwRld
_Rr
OVI
- =�SIR
-IS IOF ,�>
p'1
1 I'.' — �S.g31
"en. .� 11 1 z/ - i �_ 1€,A,1�y� Y` C -
w SO
A� ? ; i J J.; '�� 1*y��� iIS
a,'0AIS:II
a - r' \ c°y�
• `� c .1� ' -F" i- _ off, "K ,>..� %+ o• ,
„> ,yam '����- _ "_
—� j y +fE� N� /y?? e _ •d 'a. - - .., .fi" "` ', ,.Xy,'!11��`?`I' ♦'
r. = �-t ewvp
c �W ,
It AD
!1�IRS0 It
arISO
It RL
-
1.i K
;o q ('
y
s 1 J ',.•�
lid
` 1,: APB..

R \ F
`` •. `'yl
` Is le
.
b
'
t41
n�.r
A
�.'
i
All
•AI
IN
Tom, to
�• Y - f
Ire,
` M,,
III I
- •14
1V
10040E ,
r.Y' �..
' y ♦t ` 1
p •\ I
1p
�a
Ilk
IN
!-lam• •1 a� r7 `
Wit!
a 'as G� �1 [ll � i � - i •tea. A: 1 , nl
'ate _ - I � •. a. i:, ry t `
Fa. 77
3 ,
-. 1 �-���-_•a�"�i....email'1.a1w��13�\I�!�p"�'d."a.-.�� - -.. - �1
' 1. //� ' 1 -. 1. Tti ''•.
J 1
/ t
1
.ls.ia+ .2 +ply .Z. _a.'�e.-•. raar-J.
f
T'32, i6

....4 • .,k .. ie k
A t.. �., •L y�[C` y' N �.� _ gj It .-/�+ �:�t'•`.�y L- 'Qi.' i 1 _y 'i,.j _,1_
..i '•21"�' \ 'q'.� ♦'i M'• J - •. ,�yS'�i'�, Wit' -. ` dRo `YT fL air'? f.�`�.'. \"'�^ •�5/"�`
` [ 4 •
�fjtl � �l i - h - X r ✓ , .. t. ^ Il. '.1 � � '� 3 ,. f. 6�
pal
r r rS"�' mr .i `ti � � Al�• �i ,� `, �f_ f.,daRj.
t At. ��. VA r q fY +t - �aM Y rr F .AP• f ','Siff
.tie
I air
A" ri Y �V � "' � ---ttk�v.y�{f �. � : L , ' ._ � r }.� f � 1 �_ •/ I' �}.! ref
,7 'f �` a /,', 1 r �. .�� '• r I. !' fi„ /rA'C•`f yr
y `\ ' j �. ''f � � .� C�•�'~ 'fir J'f//htr %'Io Y 'A�J/,r , /piy r`r, r� /1 't u. ,.: � ' llpp�
\i�yyj•+
/t-4^y r�p w,f`'�.a\ •3 'i '7A. ' [%
i�.. . �. / 1/ � • �` r A'• �i F., A hr. � � A' J i I `.-6'. SIB �,..• F !`-
(�E R rtit l': j..
far r" ' ;,`'{: .1 + 1. �.i `,'jb1R� R �M�.�`�+1p l ..i% �! �A; ` /,� ! i. T�•� / .:ice �1'�_ _ •.i �t�
♦ ^� , • ( 1 'r 1 i?rd4. • r• i` . I J,-S`�L.r ,y,. I.vim.
•s AN,, -•L.'n .., ,r:� 1 f „ I: N�'�'� /. �' 3 ' `, -T'c:.
\�1` Jar�f..�h r •Li• + \ �1'J.i � •rf,�'Lr � r. r Cli'.1�,� ',ir.. r` � �.�' L/ �•. �I ♦ (//\�.
pp( r
141
Warr
1 /i '�C� .1• . V
_ �77 .,v jr t� •. ,b J a
�11. `�-- ;�;�.�✓'' L ,.+ff�jj+/jfvflf ` .�_• 7�G * � �j ''rTA`" h�-►.�%';•., �+P �Qly '� �-
2'r ht[1.F7$ "7 ,PPP"' 1 , / , i'r yv " •w/ % 1 -
- - � _ _ 'r �///��`j1{�' T x� {{,, 1�„� '' f'. �` �.' \t• �. ,�-✓., qr
:1°, r 1�r•_ �_�x/ ..' • a ' `
'�{r_., �< �. Y •:`}: .titr+'Ny .a r\t�.'i`.4, /��.•.r�/.,� .Q r N rj.i .(r''�rk:�. •♦ r i "y i.
1 �.+ti.. �,..`a....a. �� .a. %� •�v i �ye �,1� / '�. ,..� +. .''•FG :F4,, •} �7. .aF%' ! 'a
t � � <� � : \, L;: /: r `, \ I . 'as a /I ✓�. � �.'r • > ,r%' �1 ' � ti�'r. f �.; � .'1W ��. �,�+•. ff(, �•.� � •y. ,i". \ : lr
— � '�--y-, a� yak_ •. �' ,(� � , ;�. " [�,� • � ,� �,� � , % � . ��. /, i` �, i !! " � '� �
1,. �. I'• `� r. { .o +tV L►
- _ < \'i', y ' '�+/II'
-``I/• ---+ Jl�F. • I+ -,� �A/ .l ��L .1 ..�... . s,s,,-
i I1.b� ''U'a io* ." �•.
i
• I /E+
��• / : -.�- - •� ' =t t ' i./�fi A'�\ r .. f RI i� j1 1 +'(9
-
-NAr .✓ - " / Asa.'+ r, '+- r/,Ih', '
Rai
,
�' NARROW
•\
�.��
I
if
Of
-
IY
L
%fo /`!' 7N • 1 � ` . . 9.h`I ` • �, '� � h r 'tip. � .�- _ i. _ 1'
fit
OF
of
OR
ir
J ..
r„ r
OF
a
/ ! /' ;/r'
•♦

A� if
,at `• �.\ .'�� WSJ 0� Irrci :x 7 rr j r }. TY,IIfr� �rl lea '+q9'AS
.:nTj� x
IRS
fly
It I
to
.�Z er.. ,S Se. , , .� s We
Cd 1�: 4 � { l.' IM �y +' 1,,' ' 11 Iµ�Cd•., 0W.0
a / t JrvS
iJ le III
IR
�i o .1 � its r4 '
It f (((
s
W .v > km
,it> ry j; r f F
It
� ..'♦ 4 f n' 0 ��:) ' S"1��� 1 �- .;ice- 1 ( .6, ° " r ��''f S 5=21a� j .rA<
SO 4
RS
1 IV
tI
tI
II
T i �' / s A t 3 .. a, f
IT p Y J
r\, \, %4 :10,`S ,tJ ,'. �f i `•�. '- L ,i ` l "'';1. 1 "f �. � ," k. '/>,, ,' �i; �e.� ` M �,. w.- � rat �
•n� >.y- k,}• - '(, �a •'I 11a •¢ ��. , N{>leY ..1 icy. en'..M
tl
II
�{t'.�_r,•. 1•ti` i ~�'• :I• I'. r`r d / Tay
nl.j` i a �1:� • 7'I'��j•�!'�
CY
- �• S P7'��1 %S '�+ ;? f�i - aiA - Y" #
!c'iv
,4(5 �i / c''l�EA E i FI•;sw31 -a a •A
Ii
Fete
ISF
pv
If
fi `4 i yQ`,`•1, E` `.e`w ,4 Ij s Psi
It I r FvIle
i' r`'" > Y I:
Wet
!.� IV
-
y-. f1 t It
- !" if t'r �`.; ` i l sIt `wt i t13V e y�r'.
.i, �i.J.> ,.li' i , (�ir ` 1/' fir .`y. .x 9 r:�el 0 :of 41 PI
A, I „ 9 Vy S, -wAtt
- .1'�
A f�
II
y�y� �' N1 \ n t . I _ 6S,VI
. c
it
'>Awpm It
'I ekl 444Ila
Idwj rr
`i �44R.(t V sty, �[t1fre. 'I b MR IV'
I to
teN tell
Sir
SIR
— f i'�y� '
`� \ y
PIRO/
\♦�IS
°° ♦♦ °s°♦♦♦°♦°�° ♦ ♦ ♦ ♦ �, y Y
� • +° °�� ` � �r „� � * - ` d%♦4♦°o♦o°osli°o°s®soo,�°♦°®°`°m♦oo♦O�♦♦° Oi ♦♦
1 - < - � ♦ ♦ y l ♦ ♦N+ 9 �A��*4.A�.A�A®SO�•?A♦F1♦HdAA°®®4,'�6 ♦ . `-�
c_.
1vAL`'IA'•���3A•h�1.�Q0 +YES t,�W�;s,,��o5>'i4^c'epP®L�t•6A'V"�'PA•9A :� " ..
c '9'1 00 ♦`�D�. O •A •r9eb'ca?ej y.'�
o* s° Y 1 ♦ �I�*r®wvm�zt 'x�s dN4..D �IIr �0♦ r,�",'
•.�_'. :1"' i+ "-' `'s'. fir+. P '+l \'s� h4'^,aA4+S6AOrB dt@•IRS
v r`'��"i;.tn9 @A®i+0°♦AQ, �L
�' C,�' '�" .+•' €5 MP
,.-'\'`'�`a. , `.«.�'s" °^• F 4 fiaQ'o H•1.♦+,J,c VC�hY' �$��♦ , v .n.e ('
WIWI
�? .f N SW
y1 egsas i . aYM►lok
OIL
It
ell v AL
_ - -c
.VP
SO
It AS,
zwRld
_Rr
OVI
- =�SIR
-IS IOF ,�>
p'1
1 I'.' — �S.g31
"en. .� 11 1 z/ - i �_ 1€,A,1�y� Y` C -
w SO
A� ? ; i J J.; '�� 1*y��� iIS
a,'0AIS:II
a - r' \ c°y�
• `� c .1� ' -F" i- _ off, "K ,>..� %+ o• ,
„> ,yam '����- _ "_
—� j y +fE� N� /y?? e _ •d 'a. - - .., .fi" "` ', ,.Xy,'!11��`?`I' ♦'
r. = �-t ewvp
c �W ,
It AD
!1�IRS0 It
arISO
It RL
-
1.i K
;o q ('
y
s 1 J ',.•�
lid
` 1,: APB..