20010384 Ver 1_COMPLETE FILE_20010314

?F Vv A MFR
r-
O ?
Michael F. Easley
Governor
William G. Ross, Jr.Secreta ry
Department of Environment and Natural Resources
Kerr T. Stevens
Division of Water 01inllt,,
Division of Water Quality
Department of Environmental and Natural Resources
Wetlands/401 Unit
Location: 2321 Crabtree Boulevard, Suite 250 Raleigh, NC 27604-2260
Mailing Address: 1650 Mail Service Center Raleigh, NC 27699-1650
Contact Information: General 919-733-1786 Fax: [phone]
Fax To: ??--
Comp
From:an i
Fax Number:
Date:
Phone:
No. Of ages including cover sheet:
Notes or special instructions:
Y`P- 'Ps
AAA
NCDENR
Division of Water Quality 2321 Crabtree Blvd, Ste 250 Raleigh, NC 27604-2260
Wetlands/401 Unit: [phone]
Fax: [phone]
W AT FRIG
r
o` ?
Michael F. Easley
Governor
William G. Ross, Jr., Secretary
Department of Environment and Natural Resources
Kerr T. Stevens
Division of Water Quality
March 16, 2001
Hyde County Project
DWQ Project No. 01-0384
CERTIFIED MAIL-RETURN RECEIPT REQUESTED
Harvey & Taffy Marron
174 Lynn Street
Peabody, MA 19600
Cc: Larry Ihle; 252-928-7002 (fax)
RE: Lot No. 3, Blocka-Brugh-Price Subdivision, Pamlico Shores Road, Ocracoke, NC
UT to Pamlico Sound [03-03-07, 29-(40.5), SA]
REQUEST FOR MORE INFORMATION for the use of the MAJOR VARIANCE; From the Tar-Pamlico
Riparian Buffer Rules for the Construction of Residential Structures on Existing Lots on Barrier Islands
[15A NCAC 2B .0259(9)(b)]
Dear Mr. and Ms. Marron,
The NC Division of Water Quality (DWQ) has reviewed your plans to impact 576 ft2 of protected riparian
buffers on the subject property for the expansion of an existing deck as described in your application received by
this office on 3/14/01. Insufficient evidence is present in our files to conclude that your project must be built as
planned in protected riparian buffers in accordance with 15A NCAC 213 .0259. Therefore, unless modifications of
the proposal are made as described below, we will have to move toward denial of your Major Variance Approval
as required by 15A NCAC 2B .0259 and will place this project on hold as incomplete until we receive this
additional information.
Please provide us with information supporting your position that states your project must be constructed as
planned and that you have no practicable alternative to impacting these protected riparian buffers. Specifically
can you;
? Provide additional information as to why the proposed deck needs to be expanded. This office believes that
it would be possible to plant additional woody and herbaceous vegetation or to use other methods to stabilize
the subject area. The DWQ can provide you with additional guidance in this matter at your request. The
DWQ is required to ensure that all impacts to Zone 1 are minimized to the maximum extent practical per
Condition No. 4 of the "Major Variance from the Tar-Pamlico Riparian Buffer Rules for the Construction of
Residential Structures on Existing Lots on Barrier Islands" approved by the Environmental Management.
Commission on 4/13/00.
Any documentation such as maps, construction plans and narrative that you can supply to address alternative
designs for your project may be helpful in our review of the variance request.
Please respond within three weeks of the date of this letter by sending a copy of this information to me and
to Ms. Deborah Sawyer, DWQ Washington Regional Office (252-946-6481). If we do not hear from you in three
North Carolina Division of Water Quality, 401 Wetlands Certification Unit,
1650 Mail Service Center, Raleigh, NC 27699-1650 (Mailing Address)
2321 Crabtree Blvd., Raleigh, NC 27604-2260 (Location)
919-733-1786 (phone), 919-733-6893 (fax), http://h2o.enr.state.nc.us/ncwetlands/
Page 2 of 2
weeks, we will assume that you no longer want to pursue this project and we will consider the project as
withdrawn. I can be reached at 919-733-9646 if you have any questions.
Sincerely,
pDorney
' cation Uni
t
Cc: Deborah Sawyer, DWQ Washington Regional Office
Terry Moore; DCM Washington Regional Office
File Copy
Central Files
010384
o?0?wAT499
r
> .?
O `C
Michael F. Easley
Governor
William G. Ross, Jr., Secretary
Department of Environment and Natural Resources
Kerr T. Stevens
Division of Water Quality
MEMORANDUM
March 12, 2001
To: Bob Zarzecki
From: Deborah Sawyer
Subject: Request for Major Variance for Barrier Islands
Tar - Pamlico Buffer Rules
Harvey Marron
Hyde County - Ocracoke
Ft.s+ r:n'
The above subject variance request was reviewed by the WaRO. A site visit was made on
2/21/01. The applicant proposes to construct a ground-level deck between the existing house and
the existing bulkhead. All impacts are in Zone 1.
The WaRO has concerns as to the "hardship" on this project. A deck and screened porch already
exists on the site. Most of the site is already built upon area. It is the opinion of the WaRO that
this proposed construction is unnecessary. It is recommended that the applicant supply the DWQ
with a reason for the construction stating what the hardship will be if the ground deck is not built.
If the applicant cannot show a hardship reason for the construction, them the Wa.RO recommends
denial of the proposal.
10334
943 Washington Square Mall Washington, NC 27889 252-946-6481 (Telephone) 252-946-9215 (Fax)
02/05/2001 17J36 2529287002 IHLE CONSTRUCTION PAGE 01

i
7L
,mss ,
tl-t?
AkVLL- i
g^,d,A)
L?orwC ?iw yw

ft " 7Z?
I aAl" 7-* *wpm V/m
6-4
02/05/2001 171
00, 36 2529207002 IHLE CONSTRUCTION

PN04E NO.
- a,crs txrwa? '?
v"
d 1?
,' t
?• I
Wor 1
N Q w~
sma
Ra0%Q«
tT2 1
LOT .1
:.:
As
CAN
5 .• ? ?? Era ?? 1
SEAi.

,1.y

LOT 3
. f +
r

PAGE 02
"o WM, 42f
Sep
W
i
y •
LOT 4
1
I
i
00

N\
N1t yNL
MA APO
02/05/2001 17 36. 2529287002 IHLE CONSTRUCTION PAGE 03
Raw" 9
OFFlCE ONLY, thaw PAQ61wed
maw a N. CWdkW
boeftle of Eff*mrwnent Wo W WW R"Wlow
of aft OWN*
. •
>ecL
Var nee Request Form - Mjor variance fror the Gp? Ctipq of RAi&ntial Structures va?Neelv?i? ?3 Left Q?ooqOn' B?a?rri4411=005; 1slso08; Lots
(M 1d b!?1hs EnvbortnteTttri MOB Caft r : .
miait be prioca+a ??T)?2o00)
Tar-Pv maim River Basin: Nutrient Sens dlve Waterfs Aga Rule ent NGAG
Strata y Protection and Maintenance of Riparian
A258) . .. -
NOTE his (brm msy by photaq3bQ rbr usr as an ortplnel.
Part General Information
(Pleas lncJude ettechments X the room provided is insuf'fklent.)
1. Ap n nt' n .. l the 1 iv awn the Pr9Pd•.
2. Pd s 00M/narl8l nin Oftl 1 {pe? I09WIY r!Mnr-Tb1e for ft arty . nd I!? cpmplWmoe)
t 4iddresz:
slaw, zip,
3. N ntact person who oa zn Rnew Wg 81111is.?ab?o_ ut tin proposed project;
E pail:
4. P J*ot Name (subdMslon, facility, or eatabNshrnamt npme - aansistent with ptoject narne on
p ns, s 601 icab AS, left . o n and maln*anaa apreem ts, etG.):
- j*L yI
fj 11 "1 s. Jett Looat?on?
address:
strait, Zip:
MY
deAonpitude: ---
g. lrections to site from nearest rnaJor intorsebtlon (Also, sltach an a x 1 i oopy of the U806
t wgraphic map ind1q1jiWt1e lo?lon of the dte} ?J?1 it l/ ?.ErT'.
Y,
1: February 3000
02f05/2001. 17 36 2529287002 IHLE CONSTRUCTION PAGE 04
. . . ...., .. -.
St"n
PMPONWW" ?? T` to the roared Ilaned strum)'
nart a Impu f0
s 15A NC:AC .015
dass? [? w ri thtf Er Mad ClWfliCMlon
kW*l
(N ) Of .03i't (Tar-P?rth{loo}): , .. . .
Jc ?d lha fcMowlns p epQrovau wit bi mqufisd or haw 6wri t Mved sfriady for
a. rhis,.. Man,
irrd: jtwWvsd: DIAS t6b*Mu : Permit TYge.
R CAMA MMiw
_? - CAMA Minor
?-=-- - ?r 401 G fson/404 Pw Mft t
r h oft wMiw1sw Permit
NPDEB Pem tt (ncfuding strocrrrwater).
mw"fied,sr o PsOMS
wow $up* w N
y---- ou+Ks (spoor
Port pm, A COW
(Pie !nolude ettechmertt5 K the r"m pro vided 1s insuftlont.)
pf a atbsch s map of rinklemd dowi (such as at OW
1. ?Ol.prapol?ed ?` the bouedaffsi ottlr! I"
a? b be utilizftd in CarMnp
ar sir plan) b aocwatelY dM?e elrburbanw In 1ha NO" Duffers
il?rfty+fale toaslior+ suid to ?t Of my rian bus on the fend, incladf !h?? am
WW to d r! Me.ln
mpljs
rMia+? why a* pion for the propoW 9*OvttY cannot ba practically acco??ed.
i
2.
r
sd or raoon(ftitrn1d to WW_TSnrm?e °_r i °e s ? ? ? 13
I d anyr Des! Marrpamer?t practlc?ss m bs used fb Control lmpaats auxfatad with
propbMq actlvity (i.e., o? runoff fromi..I?mp?st1vi_a_rsYwr?'hy?s to pravfde dif[ust flow,
imom ?1?1nn r?n??tlY1 Of RH41MCa''r1?11 V I eK1?+ 91 ?,?i?? `l ?`.'') ? . .a r? w w t A E'
T10 M
JA0 G
4. ibiq providt Mh "nation of the following:
? ) The pratftoai diffiadties or hardships V& would result from the strut eppiicstian Of {his
uie. Ala D JJARM 4 f P W LLD I A A ed t
Asqued Fcm..PW 2
I: fbnra y soot
02/05/2001 171

36 2520297002
Wit
IHLE CONSTRUCTION

121 He* row do cumm or hs*to moll, "f" oeWgar to to PRO"
I A%
I"

Wt i. Did its
,y yew ? ti rat ? d M+b ne.??n, ?? ? r? Wr?aualurai??
ilr wiMnor Od M WNW
e4ow
?r?iw;4 MAN V06 m !wd. wMet !e .m
% 046
Mllyd M Ma 1hM? and 1 to w wil ba raid ! 11
WL~0lbf7W .
pan Al"t A?1 oA
mu w%h M 48@WeaW ruEtnhw W&WpW M WMOW kldl 4WI ?r 14M M vA 1wy Pn,? PrrAde
inb?+?1?M 1/t ?qyr Ml?• P?? ?? ? ??
.'lr?1MM y111'? ;Iilriv ?: ?I>1 ?r _???.,•-r-
Vd'.tw
TIL*! --
PIIK
BMW,
iiRR i:- APPHOGIM11 CbVM VQP
n i1Md
a M r?'b
Maw MI I n fwTh O!lli01,
M ?' I?lertt?llolt and tat ri r
dal #W P wf d In ,aewllh b+M
mmouoti w stoat nr?. wr* ?R? tti? brm aM d w*"t gvrgd w-nl
"mus
Rliw
TIM,
vanm isetumly lam
PAGE 05

ants^,
`>
11 "BMW,

r

? J.Y? Sf c{ YET rx,r rY Its ? r5 itf ,.
S tt ? ? 22 ?? ? i ?1 I S X3±4 ?';??4}??as {ft
rt
f h. t t 3f h Stj )f ?? 1`tF it Fih s;t Y t ti fs f