Loading...
HomeMy WebLinkAbout20120170 Ver 1_401 Application_20120212Environmental Corp of America Phone 828 505 0755 1340 Patton Avenue, Suite K .`� Fax No 828 505 0959 Asheville, NC 28806 Z From Ben Salter AAIFR�C 2® 1 2 0 1 7 0 To Mr Ian McMillan Phone 919 807 6364 NC Division of Water Quality 4011Wetlands Unit 1650 Mail Service Center Raleigh, NC 27699 1650 C U` U RI E 1 3""Y TRANSMITTAL COVER SHEET COPY Date February 14, 2012 Subject Pre Construction Notification American Towers, LLC — 273409 (Murraysville NC) Mabee Way Wilmington, New Hanover County, North Carolina ECA Project # M 382 USACE # SAW 2011 01367 Notes Mr McMillan D FEB 1 5 2012 DENR WATER QUALITY WE DSAND STQRMWATER BRANCH Please find the attached courtesy copy of the Pre Construction Notification for your review Documentation will be forwarded to you upon execution of the proposed mitigation Please contact me if you have any questions or need additional information Thank you Sincerely C'. 4-0— Ben Salter Environmental Corporation of America 1340 Patton Avenue Suite K Asheville NC 28806 1- ENVIRONMENTAL CORPORATION OF AMERICA February 14 2012 U S Army Corps of Engineers Wilmington Regulatory Field Office 69 Darlington Avenue Wilmington North Carolina 28403 Attention Ms Christy Wicker Subject Pre Construction Notification American Towers, LLC — 273409 (Murraysvdle NC) Mabee Way Wilmington, New Hanover County, North Carolina ECA Project # M 382 USACE # SAW 2011 01367 Dear Ms Wicker 2 6�`PIIRUWRY FEB 1 5 2012 DENR WATER WETLANDS AND STORMWATER BRANCH Environmental Corporation of America (ECA) is assisting our client American Towers LLC with environmental due diligence for the proposed project American Towers LLC plans to construct a 90 foot monopole telecommunications structure (overall height with appurtenances) and a 50 foot by 50 foot fenced compound within a 100 foot by 100 foot lease area The area of disturbance associated with the fenced compound will measure 57 feet by 57 feet and will include mechanized clearing outside the proposed 50 foot by 50 foot equipment compound The proposed compound would be accessed by a proposed approximate 2 534 foot by 25 foot access /utility easement which is shown on the Site Plans in Appendix A and most of which is occupied by an existing paved or gravel drive (Mabee Way) A new gravel covered access drive would be constructed over approximately 879 feet of the easement from Mabee Way to the proposed lease area The access drive would include a 12 foot wide running surface a total 18 foot wide area of fill to include side slopes and buried utilities and a 21 foot wide limit of mechanized disturbance Background The portions of the project site which will require development are located within an area of densely wooded land occupied by planted pines hardwoods and a dense woody understory Wetlands were determined by ECA and USACE to be present within portions of the proposed access /utility easement and lease area ECA met with USACE on September 29 2011 to review wetland boundaries established by ECA USACE requested several edits to the information submitted with the Jurisdictional Determination (JD) Request Revised information was 1375 Umon Hill Industrial Court State A Alpharetta Georgia 30004 (770) 667 2040 fax (770) 667 2041 www eca usa com Page 2 submitted to USACE on September 30 2011 and February 1 2012 As of the date of this Pre Construction Notification the Jurisdictional Determination is pending Documentation of Jurisdictional Determination consultation is included in Appendix C Proposed Impacts Based on the proposed project design and the wetlands boundaries verbally confirmed by USACE American Towers LLC plans to impact 6 622 square feet (0 15 acres) of the identified Jurisdictional wetlands Construction of the proposed equipment compound would result in 0 07 acres of forested wetland impacts The proposed equipment compound would be 50 feet by 50 feet The proposed limits of mechanized disturbance associated with the compound would be 57 feet by 57 feet Any clearing required beyond the 57 foot by 57 foot area would be done by hand The 50 foot by 50 foot compound would be constructed by compacting the sub grade and covering with gravel over geotextile In addition a fence would be placed around the compound and concrete foundations for the proposed tower and an equipment shelter would be placed within the proposed compound Construction of the access drive would result in 0 08 acres of forested wetland impacts The proposed access drive would include a 12 foot running surface with an 18 foot total fill width (to include 50% side slopes) Utilities would be buried beneath the access drive side slopes The limits of mechanized clearing would measure 21 feet in width Any additional clearing outside this corridor would be done by hand A 15 inch by 20 foot culvert would be placed beneath the access drive within the wetland in order to maintain hydrologic connectivity between wetlands remaining on either side of the access The access would be constructed by compacting the sub grade and covering with gravel over geotextile Site layout drawings including wetland boundaries areas of impact cross sections of easement and compound areas and proposed volumes of fill /cut materials are provided in Appendix A It appears that the proposed project would meet the criteria for authorization under Nationwide Permit (NWP) 39 NWP 39 requires that a Pre Construction Notification be prepared Therefore ECA has prepared this document along with attachments on behalf of American Towers LLC (Applicant) A Pre Construction Notification form has been completed and is included in Appendix B Site Selection, Avoidance, and Minimization The selection of wireless telecommunications facilities is based primarily on the established grid within a specific service area Within the service area antenna structures have been previously constructed at specific nodes As such there is limited flexibility when selecting the exact F PROJECT /2011 Prof /Regulatory/Wetlands /M 382/M382_PCN Letter doc Page 3 locations of new facilities to allow for factors such as acceptable coverage available sites and sites which are environmentally sensitive Factors considered in choosing the site location included RF coverage objectives existing land use considerations environmentally sensitive sites and the willingness of individual land owners to enter into a contract for sale or lease of a suitable parcel of real estate for construction of the subject facility Based on these considerations the subject property was selected as the preferred alternative The primary carrier to be located on the proposed tower is AT &T The 90 foot monopole tower is required by AT &T to improve weak coverage to motorists along Murrayville Road and to residences in neighborhoods along and off of Murrayville Road As shown the selection of the proposed site location is based in part on availability of required space and willingness of the property owner to enter into a lease for the development of the land as a communications tower site Only two parcels large enough to meet tower height setback requirements were identified within the specific coverage objective search area The original site was across Mabee Way from the currently proposed site and on land owned by the New Hanover Department of Education This site was not feasible due to disagreement between New Hanover County and the nearby elementary school s PTA The specific tower location on the parent tract was chosen based on the willing land owner s wishes The property owner would only allow the facility to be placed in its currently proposed location to minimize effects on future tract development The proposed facility would sit along the southern most property boundary reserving the remainder of the tract to the north for potential future development without such development being hampered by the physical presence or visual intrusion of the proposed tower facility In addition the proposed tower site cannot be moved closer to Mabee Way due to surrounding Single Family Residential uses along the southern tract boundary and airspace issues associated with the nearby Wilmington International Airport Current proposed tower height is 90 feet due to the location within the primary and secondary approach zones for Runway 24 at the Wilmington International Airport Moving the facility further to the north would require a taller tower to meet the coverage objectives for residences and traffic along Murrayville Road A taller tower would not be allowed due to airspace issues American Towers LLC has limited the proposed equipment compound size to 50 feet by 50 feet from the standard 100 feet by 100 feet The total area of wetland disturbance associated with the compound will measure 57 feet by 57 feet A total of 7 605 square feet of wetlands are located within the 100 foot by 100 foot lease area By reducing the area of disturbance associated with the compound from 100 feet by 100 feet to 57 feet by 57 feet wetland impacts have been minimized by 4 538 square feet F PROJECT /2011 Proj/Regulatory/Wetlands /M 382/M382_PCN Letter doc Page 4 The running surface of the access drive has been limited to 12 feet of the proposed 25 foot wide access /utility easement The total width of fill would be approximately 18 feet due to needed side slopes (50% or 2 1) The total width of mechanized disturbance would be 21 feet which is the minimal amount necessary to ensure continued clearance for construction and facility maintenance vehicles with minimal vegetation maintenance American Towers LLC proposes to install silt fencing around the entire area of disturbance (uplands and wetlands) to prevent indirect impacts to surrounding wetlands as a result of sediment runoff After completion of construction activities American Towers LLC would remove the silt fencing and any sediment deposits bring the area to grade and properly stablize the site per the sediment and erosion control plan which will be reviewed by NCDENR as part of the Coastal Stormwater Management Permit process Based on the information provided above constraints associated with siting of the proposed facility would result in unavoidable wetland impacts However American Towers LLC has demonstrated both avoidance and minimization in the proposed project design to the extent possible Mitigation Based on the area of proposed impacts (0 15 acres of forested wetland) it appears that compensatory mitigation would be required ECA assumes that a 2 1 mitigation ratio will be applied Therefore a total of 0 30 acres of mitigation would be required No mitigation banks with current approval are located within the project watershed (03030007 — Northeast Cape Fear) Therefore American Towers LLC proposes to purchase 0 5 non riparian freshwater wetland in lieu fee credits from the North Carolina Ecosystem Enhancement Program (NC EEP) We understand that in lieu fee credits are sold in 0 25 acre /credit increments A credit request statement submitted by ECA to NC EEP on behalf of American Towers LLC is included in Appendix D A response from NC EEP will be forwarded upon receipt Additional Information The Pre Construction Notification Form has been completed and is included in Appendix B An Agent Authorization Form is also included in Appendix B The Lease Agreement between American Towers LLC and the parent parcel land owner is included in Appendix E Per the lease agreement American Towers LLC has been granted the authority to obtain the necessary permits in order to construct the project A list of adjoining property owners and addresses are provided in Appendix H A survey showing the locations of these adjacent parcels is also included in Appendix H F PROJECT /2011 Proj/Regulatory/Wetlands/M 382/M382_PCN Letter doc Page 5 The Raleigh Field Office of the US Fish and Wildlife Service has specifically requested that they not be consulted for proposed telecommunications tower projects unless the applicant/consultant has determined that suitable habitat for threatened or endangered species is present within the project area This guidance is included in Appendix F ECA has performed an Informal Biological Assessment at the project site to evaluate for potential impact to federal and state protected species ECA found that no suitable habitat for federal or state threatened or endangered species is present within the project impact area The Informal Biological Assessment is provided in Appendix F ECA evaluated the proposed project for effects on Historic Resources per the Federal Communications Commission and North Carolina State Historic Preservation Office (NC SHPO) guidelines Based on research performed and consultation with NC SHPO ECA has concluded that the proposed project will have no effect on Historic Resources listed in or eligible for listing in the National Register of Historic Places including archaeological resources The NC SHPO finding with regard to impacts of the proposed project on Historic Resources is included in Appendix G Conclusions and Recommendations Based on the information collected during this project the resources reviewed and our site inspections ECA has determined that portions of the proposed equipment compound and access drive are located within jurisdictional wetlands Construction of the facility would result in 6 622 square feet (0 15 acres) of impacts to wetlands Impacts would result from the placement of gravel and soil fill material associated with access road turnaround and compound construction and concrete associated with equipment and tower foundations A culvert would also be placed within the wetland and beneath the access drive to maintain hydrologic connectivity ECA has prepared the documentation contained in this report in order to receive US Army Corps of Engineers authorization for these proposed wetland impacts Based on the nature of the proposed project ECA believes that the project would meet the criteria for authorization under Nationwide Permit 39 The proposed impacts would be less than '/2 acre and are unavoidable due the willingness of the parent tract landowner and his/her stipulations for project construction and constraints related to nearby residential setbacks and airspace issues In order to mitigate for the proposed wetland impacts American Towers LLC proposes to purchase 0 5 non riparian wetland in lieu fee credits from the NC EEP A credit request has been made and is included in Appendix D A response from NC EEP will be forwarded upon receipt Regarding Section 401 Water Quality Certification projects that are authorized under Nationwide Permit 39 do not require written certification from the North Carolina Division of Water Quality (NCDWQ) assuming that the project meets the criteria of General Certification 3821 (See Appendix I) Based on the specifications of the proposed project no written Section F PROJECT /2011 Proj/Regulatory /Wetlands/M 382/M382_PCN Letter doc Page 6 401 Water Quality Certification would be required ECA will however provide a courtesy copy of this PCN to NCDWQ and will provide documentation of completed mitigation once received Closure If you have any questions about the contents of this report please contact Ben Salter of ECA at (828) 505 0755 Sincerely Environmental Corporation of America Itch Clark Project Scientist Attachments Appendix A — Figures Ben Salter REP Principal Wetlands Scientist Appendix B — Pre Construction Notification Form and Agent Authorization Appendix C — Jurisdictional Determination Appendix D — NC EEP In Lieu Fee Credit Request Appendix E — Lease Agreement Appendix F — Informal Biological Assessment Appendix G — Historic Resource Consultation Appendix H — Adjoining Property Owners Appendix I — NC DWQ General Certification 3821 F PROJECT /2011 Proj/Regulatory/Wetlands/M 382/M382_PCN Letter doc APPENDIX A FIGURES '' �`.,. S 3 ,•. 1. � [ l �'r_i. -r -+.,, -v' } � 4 S C. i A l .i � � � � . L•.. � 1000 0 1000 Feet Source: USGS Topographic Quadrangle Map, 7.5 Minute Series, Scotts Hill, NC (1970) ATC - 273409 (Murraysville NC) �_G1ITALC��� it Maybee Way w z N Wilmington, New Hanover County, North Carolina �A'AKER�P Figure 1: Site Location ECA Proj. #: M -382 , —ion — r6uo 3 U IDUVLL6 — dllnnujmy4/OlN/OLOZ — SbUMDJO/,k 2L994L OIAHO ZL -0L —ZO ' �c7 a W ��\ / �0 N a af ¢ ro P gN�� o Z g o�� as ��a�°W Z U >~ ..a� N J = ........ O m w I I I I I � Z w w �J QN -�; o Wz r7o N \\ iji II - o 0 o =d�' o -� � y _ Q � �o G s J w m $ °Co�i�o�rr Wi O�F �U dF�H H° NUSIUM18MR1 w q W= 0 �/ 9 _ O a O(� \ r. 0- 34 Z >- Y Qp N Z , —ion — r6uo 3 U IDUVLL6 — dllnnujmy4/OlN/OLOZ — SbUMDJO/,k 2L994L OIAHO ZL -0L —ZO ' ������ °n��3�i�H uS$� o_ p s s s a ♦ ♦ ♦ \ \�� O�y��� �a o Z Of i> mI�I�I Of �Z JN'- V CL `Yy� � o w M V C CO U N = W t= ~ Ld m O a= N y� � a � � z L2 ° i Ct" �i z -- .�i �d¢�go oo ~z wig gin oc�r;F ��Ho�Sc�HH� ZF Hin F3 ISHr� -az U .au k' id Ci 2 U �i N ut rFci o 4 Z Q N < N � Z O tai Q W 'y O Q t� 0 d �'v� V ♦�� I Gj ♦ F �� O//�/" 0.� \♦ N I� "� �` \\ C. m Z 3 9 p m p Y v x U ¢ p a O z 0 y Sri m N �y (� K x V1 j I Z F V LJ Ld x N Z V V I N =>O S O O V �._, CD Z I-/-1 W w U d d K CL R�5 Q �d =O - (/� S LJ = f O ago V)WdH N I I a V) WI I I ws =�1 ON C> I I Ilrr ✓ ✓/ W (7 � Z V I N= I I I ° I I I I I o a Ir U o � I U kb � yF LLJ v ryk.II d Ow V '�^^ W Z I I I II 0l i a vi I I I i Z co p 00 00 0o V)O)ZO a��Qrmww = O W oz° m Q m 2z MW ~ V) N N N N N S? W ZOS ° }Fs W ~pZOZUN0Q(9w OQ W W L71--- Q -mod' Z °N° ChM nM -c0 jl }ZOQFUj HAW ° Oa�J Z I ZUm U°w Q OwZ=Z�O� cr � ¢z- O ° U ZO�p�W FF VW Z W II II N I a M,- x� E-2°3 �a W II wa I U W O W Zw M V) U� l°- Uw2 ~wWOF"(n Q w~ N O C H V) V) W V) V) W SU �Z Q1� J W W mod' Q W U (/i U¢ �d U¢ �a Z° Zq N O O W U noon_ °ate =w0 °�3c� W Z Z � O °_ ¢ � ao a0Q LCJ 3 •--• I � c� z V) E> - z 3?cr Z SOJ W O W <W>� FJOFof O Z Z in Z a 3 °N V ce Z _j WaVQW�HWm?�wZO OF Q O o w� w OU I I I o g V�o wzaQfm°wxV)Q = W° N Z d O g W Q33 m33 °oN °oW 3a Ilan wrn O° �< dr I I °o ° F Lil UCH HQ�3 aoa000�ui w U o CL O CL r mr� N N w F 33ri 3 a 00 � � oQ0 a a I — — O O V) o gy= o O C C. o < o dd C� =a =E O = O Z W V U ° a m O I z J w i �"m ° I O (r� v CD w J O w3o 0 OS Z Z W INYllnO Q Z¢ o r z W -J JZ� � °€ Z3 �W AW 1V OOl 0 L9 \ U o cn w z W , , o U W zm N wZm O J O m d � �' W O z x ~ U W W O Y Z Cf) �uOO N Wpm I Q O Lj w W U O U V- C.D w o o d7 0° ° C> p w Q oz ��VO W �° ` �°n O ¢ ` m 4 F- N W W N � z °N oS x �g 3 Q X Q X n- n Lil Z W (l'I W Z W Q W I I \ � O 5mP OO /SZ- LO -Z LOZ S(10-/60t,2/-Z - all n Djjnw /OlV /O LOZ - S6u moJO/ A C L cz il I nlnwn 71-f)1-7A 5u� °a v rr m ZI �I I I I I }� w w Q N +�Z Z� �pp \ %fi O C��� I tn ZQ '^ V of !.7 �0 w ~ 03200 IY O �g G9 C Q gZ I~i (/) JOiO �' _ w m r O p F �oWOO�Z~L Ig ��HH a: SAM U �. p ed v Z ci C i0O N ¢ N �Z 3 N N % S o`J = a O O'{/ O CL d' \ \� �i O \% �\ > m 3 a5 m W = K a _z N m= r ''^^ r V z = v _ �d F E c o _ 8a h 6. s g \ �� S titz Qf U� ��osb{�� v s$ o � m �I �I I I I I W W 3 _� � � �Z \�P �z � � o o -d,,> o s C7 ossb Lu _ J Q' W N 0�j 8W ,t' gcx N NO O O Q m z N F t V Z I W 2 Ul ■ � e� 6 §a § §§ & §§ �§® % &s,§ ■ §�B & _ � ® m■ u - _ § \ . ■ � � �k� ��� �¥ � % r � � ; ; � ± N � 77�, w)) mom.■ m! § ub ■,�77, § &!¥E e.s�u .w a§ , ak2 © ■7E` q m � 6 = kkllll m � e ■ § I § b : x + : � � � ,o C. o, o o - ° f �� a &- & a _§ =7J _ ��_= 6 2 2 § § ( § 2 z / § ° / o z Lu = v � - m g� �H §�,�aa,�2§BB§[ »!■8 /».se«�gE§ ■ \�W! $ § 3 § ■ 2 o_ « N k ® z �_ - s S 2 2 0 k ��� ƒ ��� , i % k 8 \ ! § § m D , � ® § ) ( \ w _J L.� 0 Of a- w J _J Of Q Of Q 0 U Q C O (n ° Z _ O d 0 O L w w Z w J Q U N C a C L� v v L1 (_ C- a LL C n 0 U W N J Z C7 Z OO 0 0 r7 0 0 N O O O OLO C I CD p m K a0 a0� � � � ���_- ♦O 53 �OOm 0 04 X � /�� a W w 3 �P bo '.� . \ � i / o $ i � zo o � 4 a g o o - C Z V• N Z o wI z w M o= ♦/ I o N - o CJ J d Q vo z N o V/ v w V J W (n cn W tzi aid' N c� �' LU � U N = C) C m v IA T <G M U z � '�rcW ' Pi`�3 biaw�c�& pa� RRVcoi v�F3 K�Za3 Ur Siz V �� � " C ld 61 Ul Te o O ���� Z VVV�IV�I A�' Lo a `� Q N �Z � C) x 'y �Y OQt� o a ���� V `.` `� Q '� o \� ♦` r I /� ♦ VI I� {' �� �♦ m Z 'i a� O 0 Y U _ U ¢ �° ¢ O U vii m N V) CL Q �' 0 W L� N Z 'I^ �j v w N w _J L.� 0 Of a- w J _J Of Q Of Q 0 U Q C O (n ° Z _ O d 0 O L w w Z w J Q U N C a C L� v v L1 (_ C- a LL C n 0 U W N J Z C7 Z OO 0 0 r7 0 0 N O O O OLO C I CD R w w Z w J Q U (J7 N W W J J U Z tzi Z 0 cn W U Q C> W z O U w cn o cn O U 0 Ln C:, A I O 7 ' LC b L ninvn 71 —n 1 —70 / tzi Z OO Y p> rnppV IA T <G M U Y N U Z N Y p MpU N� CO N T 3 / ONiU c0 'D M U N U IC=J O Q V O= O V O= O V O= OU m V O= OU Z � Q m � °� V N c";'5 pww W O W U M O w NQw W N ° N O O V O U Q m Z Q Z W li�w 3 N o � C. No In o 'F °d x a o o CD w c� � era = O � m I cD v) �vvim' ov aZ- I I O °W w U J ?N m c>� �� w a� / \� i 0 3z aa° U�F3 UY� O w C� mmg N m C, � � w C W =ZQQ � o U � U Z V Q N J O� N Z W N Q W O m m �i P*0 /8Z— LO —ZLOZ SOO— /604£LZ — all ADJ nW /Old /OLOZ — s6 MDJQ/,k C3 CL 0 m C LL N M M w3 mCC3 0 a w3 o � w z W ° N U W U p = Vl d Z ppN Q O = N C) W O z z W Z „ �3 °wm Oz m3 �° CL ° m o_ ° w 3 Z j W o Z O cm CL oU R w w Z w J Q U (J7 N W W J J U Z tzi Z 0 cn W U Q C> W z O U w cn o cn O U 0 Ln C:, A I O 7 ' LC b L ninvn 71 —n 1 —70 / N 3 / vOaa I aim I I w \\ O I I cD v) �vvim' I I Nw C. z oO / /�� °os �2 � O = I c>� �� w a� / \� i 0 3z aa° /� /A P*0 /8Z— LO —ZLOZ SOO— /604£LZ — all ADJ nW /Old /OLOZ — s6 MDJQ/,k R w w Z w J Q U (J7 N W W J J U Z tzi Z 0 cn W U Q C> W z O U w cn o cn O U 0 Ln C:, A I O 7 ' LC b L ninvn 71 —n 1 —70 M N r` J M U Q J LL- O ° pQ O r� U) W U U O Q O N o � N II e 0 W J U Q W J LA- O Of r2 D Q o O cD � Cn W U Q O w w Li Z w J Q U (/) O N O 0 N II o� �o ¢3N W �ZC-) N p �xw Q W N O O p C d � 6 p Z oa 0 U m 3 z % or w O N O �o a > d Y N O / d / cr a. U ? ? p nrn � 1E a a �i �00� F� 0as $ �'" � 0� � fi �+ y r M >�� ~ � o >N_ } r W m Zlof I I I I �3JL, Z Z` p WZ M N % p 114 N_d' p I O O Jam— �y m Q e}. Q Z W / O Q W J ILL. Q U Q 4 �/1 m U w O�° o mrz + gg �'2ozs`¢ cf1 SC�1Z oci c�4a bo'�oo g88 IYw��z&`WSIn = GgHU� id d1 a v=i vUi ! p Z U C < N a N �Z U N _ y O� = a t �� \` } U 3 p zo vi N C Q f� `� f2 N �+ / z S (n M N r` J M U Q J LL- O ° pQ O r� U) W U U O Q O N o � N II e 0 W J U Q W J LA- O Of r2 D Q o O cD � Cn W U Q O w w Li Z w J Q U (/) O N O 0 N II o� �o ¢3N W �ZC-) N p �xw Q W N O O p C d � 6 p Z oa 0 U m 3 z % or w O N O �o a LL +o vis 00 +0 vis - LO -Z LOZ S O)- /60*£LZ - all N � > d Y N O / d / cr a. U ? ? w SL t +9 d1S / CL w / J N J U U w 7 J Q U O p N Z O w O N a a & O N JW O M 0 z LL +o vis 00 +0 vis - LO -Z LOZ S O)- /60*£LZ - all N � d Y O / d / cr a. U ? ? w SL t +9 d1S / LL / r ti n Djjnyy /OlV /O LOZ - s6u MDJQ/ A U) w U Q CD Z Q S 1i Q U Q 0 cD W J l.� O 0- O w w LL Z w J Q U (/ ) O N O O N II O M 0 z O CL M O U o I a co m c Q U O w Ui Q Z W w J J � O N O CL O O N II 0 L£ LO l Z OIAVO 7 L - 90 -70 CV Cn Z O w U o w _ W awe W O 3� ,OL °o LL - C) o rte= w�W °vwioo= U -W LLJ CL 030 °zvwio``' N JJ U� }W N O ~ S oo =D Z ¢~ w N 2 2 w m Q> d \ ��a ��zozo =o O22 oo�o�QO _Z LLJ O H Z ~ W U U m Z N~ Jpp m Oz N U J° 1. 1 ° ¢ ° W ¢ ¢NF LLJ w om O °zoo 'a "'m QaQ omo.� -,wm Cn w m.li ? ZOZ w~ °°Z ¢ �O� ¢ d'M J �m O W= M8? Y m la] Q U ¢ J W S a 2 W J� O O =w w w=U w3 2� w a_ mj4¢f03<n �U' aCC, 0:: ��ad �aoWw�°w °o w 30 vw ° ¢_ w z 2 m N ° d MM M W W m m W D W N O d�Q SU 2d 2\ Y Z Z 3d' Z JNZ N� V1 NQ � NWT �.j ¢ C> w U ri U mp Zd¢U ZNZ O OU¢ O ° N OU OU ° N w U W VI m W U W J_ p ���� w �� Z w V � ¢ y O� CL o r JJ ¢ W m w N w w w w ¢ d w tj Z N a J J U W J 00 W W x Q ZOw a o_ 0 ON V —¢ �3m z w� a ap °ww w� °w �ZZZ �o �� �w ~� w wCl D and °a CL r2-0 N odds °oo ¢max 3�idF a:�C �00wZ (n N MCL �d U� N N U� O OU¢ W 2 ¢ 0 - d r S b O z 3� N w p7 a w Z O i Z o U x pp a w W � w ¢ T S Z 0 ° W H O } Q D N 30 U �' Y Q -i° 2 y v 2 i J 3 W U x a c~n J U z v Aw 0 � � � a NZ H�lld J j Q w o LLJ Olga � aw tz �44'� i g �$ Z Z zz if N A N 0 F- M O U Z LLJ W q NE` Cn w _ �7 <<� \\� U d NA1uDEFINE� �NANNE� $3 Q W� \� m a o OR UN O ~o �\� \ \ \ S ¢ s O J a 7s P N w m W \; F- < co CL \ \ �F ww g 3�> v w ?F O� LU i ow qG 3� Z O LL M � RIM J y�e Z��! m� \ \ \ nit O m� Z 6MP99 /82- LO -ZIOZ SO7- /60bS /7 - all XDLnW /nIH /nln7 - s6uMOin/ i o�rr� a moj���= °� AM �+ s> e.o Z o m'T� Oj Of z WW3v z Z ° W Z _� a• O J O^ y► N O U Q Ld OWi�JQ ��Td. OZ/ FNQ z�+ i< 1. m�bbF�88Y oW�j$j$E his 93 ZF �iibHv� �3 HMlMul UU �� �` ed v = U N N o z vv�vCN Q A� Q N 1A "I 3 U N W O� w� S �Y OQ - Q ����d' O 5� ��� � �/ O \ �. N II �� \� m 3 a 0 m p v = U 3 a Z m N W Z 0 J W W = W N m m Z I r = N CV Cn Z O w U o w _ W awe W O 3� ,OL °o LL - C) o rte= w�W °vwioo= U -W LLJ CL 030 °zvwio``' N JJ U� }W N O ~ S oo =D Z ¢~ w N 2 2 w m Q> d \ ��a ��zozo =o O22 oo�o�QO _Z LLJ O H Z ~ W U U m Z N~ Jpp m Oz N U J° 1. 1 ° ¢ ° W ¢ ¢NF LLJ w om O °zoo 'a "'m QaQ omo.� -,wm Cn w m.li ? ZOZ w~ °°Z ¢ �O� ¢ d'M J �m O W= M8? Y m la] Q U ¢ J W S a 2 W J� O O =w w w=U w3 2� w a_ mj4¢f03<n �U' aCC, 0:: ��ad �aoWw�°w °o w 30 vw ° ¢_ w z 2 m N ° d MM M W W m m W D W N O d�Q SU 2d 2\ Y Z Z 3d' Z JNZ N� V1 NQ � NWT �.j ¢ C> w U ri U mp Zd¢U ZNZ O OU¢ O ° N OU OU ° N w U W VI m W U W J_ p ���� w �� Z w V � ¢ y O� CL o r JJ ¢ W m w N w w w w ¢ d w tj Z N a J J U W J 00 W W x Q ZOw a o_ 0 ON V —¢ �3m z w� a ap °ww w� °w �ZZZ �o �� �w ~� w wCl D and °a CL r2-0 N odds °oo ¢max 3�idF a:�C �00wZ (n N MCL �d U� N N U� O OU¢ W 2 ¢ 0 - d r S b O z 3� N w p7 a w Z O i Z o U x pp a w W � w ¢ T S Z 0 ° W H O } Q D N 30 U �' Y Q -i° 2 y v 2 i J 3 W U x a c~n J U z v Aw 0 � � � a NZ H�lld J j Q w o LLJ Olga � aw tz �44'� i g �$ Z Z zz if N A N 0 F- M O U Z LLJ W q NE` Cn w _ �7 <<� \\� U d NA1uDEFINE� �NANNE� $3 Q W� \� m a o OR UN O ~o �\� \ \ \ S ¢ s O J a 7s P N w m W \; F- < co CL \ \ �F ww g 3�> v w ?F O� LU i ow qG 3� Z O LL M � RIM J y�e Z��! m� \ \ \ nit O m� Z 6MP99 /82- LO -ZIOZ SO7- /60bS /7 - all XDLnW /nIH /nln7 - s6uMOin/ i o�rr� APPENDIX B PRE CONSTRUCTION NOTIFICATION FORM AND AGENT AUTHORIZATION AGENT AUTHORIZATION FORM PROPERTY LEGAL DESCRIPTION LOT NO PLAN NO STREET ADDRESS Mabee Wilmington New Hanover County NC Please print Property Owner TF Holdings Limited Partnership MVrraAsu 16 ` N(- PARCEL ID R02700-001 -003 000 Property Owner. American Towers LLC (lessee has authority to obtain necessary permits per lease agreement) The undersigned, registered property owners of the above noted property, do hereby authorize Ben Salter , of Environmental Corp of America (Contractor / Agent) (Name of consulting flrm) to act on my behalf and take all actions necessary for the processing, issuance and acceptance of this permit or certification and any and all standard and special conditions attached Property Owner's Address (if different than property above) 10 Presidential Way Woburn MAO 1801 (Lessee) Telephone 781926-4916 We hereby certify the above information submitted in this application is true and accurate to the best of our knowledge Signature Authorized Signature vZ—i3 —)- - Date RICHARD ROSSI 'Ice President ContractManagemerd \O2ot W A TF9 - r > 1 O .c 20120170 Office Use Only Corps action ID no DWQ project no Form Version 13 Dec 10 2008 Page 1 of 11 PCN Form — Version 1 3 December 10 2008 Version Pre - Construction Notification PCN Form A Applicant Information R 1 Processing 1 a Type(s) of approval sought from the Corps ®Section 404 Permit El Section 10 Permit 1b Specify Nationwide Permit (NWP) number 39 or General Permit (GP) number 1 c Has the NWP or GP number been verified by the Corps? ® Yes ❑ No 1 d Type(s) of approval sought from the DWQ (check all that apply) ® 401 Water Quality Certification — Regular ❑ Non -404 Jurisdictional General Permit ❑ 401 Water Quality Certification — Express ❑ Riparian Buffer Authorization le Is this notification solely for the record because written approval is not required? For the record only for DWQ 401 Certification ® Yes ❑ No For the record only for Corps Permit ❑ Yes ® No 1f Is payment into a mitigation bank or in lieu fee program proposed for mitigation of impacts? If so attach the acceptance letter from mitigation bank or in lieu fee program ® Yes ❑ No 1 g Is the project located in any of NC s twenty coastal counties If yes answer 1 h below N Yes ❑ No 1h Is the project located within a NC DCM Area of Environmental Concern (AEC)? ❑ Yes ® No 2 Project Information 2a Name of project American Towers LLC 273409 (Murraysv lle NC) 2b County New Hanover 2c Nearest municipality / town Murraysvdle 2d Subdivision name 2e NCDOT only T I P or state project no U \y g m 3 Owner Information FER 3a Name(s) on Recorded Deed TF Holdings Limited Partnership pro 3b Deed Book and Page No 1783/1251 6NE ps ALITY 3c Responsible Party (for LLC if applicable) 3d Street address 1202 Eastwood Road 3e City state zip Wilmington NC 28403 3f Telephone no 910 799 8755 3g Fax no 3h Email address Page 1 of 11 PCN Form — Version 1 3 December 10 2008 Version 4 Applicant Information (if different from owner) 4a Applicant is ❑ Agent ® Other specify Proposed Lessee 4b Name Elyssa Bailey 4c Business name (if applicable) American Towers LLC 4d Street address 10 Presidential Way 4e City state zip Woburn MA 01801 4f Telephone no 781 9264916 4g Fax no 781 9267011 4h Email address enviro services @amencantower com 5 Agent/Consultant Information (if applicable) 5a Name Ben Salter 5b Business name (if applicable) Environmental Corporation of America 5c Street address 1340 Patton Avenue Suite K 5d City state zip Asheville NC 28806 5e Telephone no 828 505 0755 5f Fax no 828 505 0959 5g Email address ben salter @eca usa com Page 2 of 11 PCN Form — Version 1 3 December 10 2008 Version B Project Information and Prior Project History 1 Property Identification 1a Property identification no (tax PIN or parcel ID) R02700 001 003 000 Latitude 34 300745 Longitude lb Site coordinates (in decimal degrees) 77 846557 (DD DDDDDD) ( DD DDDDDD) 1 c Property size 280 63 acres 2 Surface Waters 2a Name of nearest body of water (stream river etc) to Smith Creek proposed project 2b Water Quality Classification of nearest receiving water C Sw 2c River basin 03030007 3 Project Description 3a Describe the existing conditions on the site and the general land use in the vicinity of the project at the time of this application Site is timberland Surrounding area is timberland residential development and an elementary school development 3b List the total estimated acreage of all existing wetlands on the property Unknown on entire parent tract Proposed lease area and easements = 0 27 acres of wetlands 3c List the total estimated linear feet of all existing streams (intermittent and perennial) on the property No streams on property 3d Explain the purpose of the proposed project To provide wireless telecommunications service to surrounding residences elementary school and traffic along Murraysville Road 3e Describe the overall project in detail including the type of equipment to be used American Towers LLC would construct a 50 foot by 50 foot gravel covered fenced telecommunications equipment compound within a 100 foot by 100 foot lease area The limits of mechanized disturbance associated with the compound would measure 57 feet by 57 feet Any clearing required beyond the 57 foot by 57 foot area would be done by hand The compound would be occupied by a 90 foot monopole tower and associated ground level equipment An 879 foot portion of the proposed access /utility easement would be improved with a gravel covered access drive and buried utilities The access drive would measure approximately 18 feet wide (including 50% side slopes) with a 21 foot wide area of mechanized disturbance Utilities would be buried beneath the access drive Construction of the compound would result in 0 07 acres of forested wetland impacts Construction of the access drive would result in 0 08 acres of forested wetland impacts A culvert would be installed beneath the a/u easement and within the wetland to maintain hydrologic connectivity between remaining wetlands Construction equipment to be used would be typical for such work and would include dozers graders and trucks 4 Jurisdictional Determinations 4a Have jurisdictional wetland or stream determinations by the Corps or State been requested or obtained for this property / ®Yes ❑ No El Unknown project (including all prior phases) in the pasty Comments Yes awaiting approved final JD 4b If the Corps made the jurisdictional determination what type ❑ Preliminary ® Final of determination was made? 4c If yes who delineated the jurisdictional areas? Agency /Consultant Company ECA Name (if known) Ben Salter ECA Other 4d If yes list the dates of the Corps jurisdictional determinations or State determinations and attach documentation USACE JD pending Chris Coburn of NCDWQ visited the site and determined that there were no state regulated streams Page 3 of 11 PCN Form — Version 1 3 December 10 2008 Version 5 Project History 5a Have permits or certifications been requested or obtained for this project (including all prior phases) in the past? ❑ Yes ® No ❑ Unknown 5b If yes explain in detail according to help file instructions 6 Future Project Plans 6a Is this a phased project? ❑ Yes ® No 6b If yes explain Page 4 of 11 PCN Form — Version 1 3 December 10 2008 Version C Proposed Impacts Inventory 1 Impacts Summary la Which sections were completed below for your project (check all that apply) ® Wetlands ❑ Streams tributaries ❑ Buffers ❑ Open Waters ❑ Pond Construction 2 Wetland Impacts If there are wetland impacts proposed on the site then complete this question for each wetland area impacted 2a 2b 2c 2d 2e 2f Wetland impact Type of jurisdiction number — Type of impact Type of wetland Forested (Corps 404 10 Area of impact Permanent (P) or (if known) DWQ — non 404 other) (acres) Temporary W1 ®P ❑ T Permanent Fill and clearing forested ® Yes ❑ No ® Corps [:1 DWQ 0 08 W2 ®P ❑ T Permanent Fill forested ® Yes ❑ No ® Corps ❑ DWQ 007 W3 ❑ P ❑ T ❑ Yes ❑ Corps ❑ No ❑ DWQ W4 ❑ P ❑ T ❑ Yes ❑ Corps ❑ No ❑ DWQ W5 ❑ P ❑ T ❑ Yes ❑ Corps ❑ No ❑ DWQ W6 ❑ P ❑ T ❑ Yes ❑ Corps ❑ No ❑ DWQ 2g Total wetland impacts 015 2h Comments W1 impacts would include an 18 foot wide access road (including side slopes) with buried utilities and clearing on either side of the proposed road Total width of impact would be 21 feet W2 would result from construction of a gravel covered fenced equipment compound and adjacent clearing The compound would be 50 feet by 50 feet and the limits of clearing 57 feet by 57 feet Any additional clearing outside this area would be done by hand 3 Stream Impacts If there are perennial or intermittent stream impacts (including temporary impacts) proposed on the site then complete this question for all stream sites impacted 3a 3b 3c 3d 3e 3f 3g Stream impact Type of impact Stream name Perennial Type of jurisdiction Average Impact number (PER) or (Corps 404 10 stream length Permanent (P) or intermittent DWQ — non 404 width (linear Temporary (T) (INT)7 other) (feet) feet) S1 ❑ P ❑ T ❑ PER ❑ Corps ❑ INT ❑ DWQ S2 ❑ P ❑ T ❑ PER ❑ Corps ❑ INT ❑ DWQ S3 ❑ P ❑ T ❑ PER ❑ Corps ❑ INT ❑ DWQ S4 ❑ P ❑ T ❑ PER ❑ Corps ❑ INT ❑ DWQ S5 ❑ P ❑ T ❑ PER ❑ Corps ❑ INT ❑ DWQ S6 ❑ P ❑ T ❑ PER ❑ Corps [:11 NT ❑ DWQ 3h Total stream and tributary impacts 31 Comments Page 5 of 11 PCN Form —Version 1 3 December 10 2008 Version 4 Open Water Impacts If there are proposed impacts to lakes ponds estuaries tributaries sounds the Atlantic Ocean or any other open water of the U S then individually list all open water impacts below 4a 4b 4c 4d 4e Open water Name of waterbody impact number — (if applicable) Type of impact Waterbody type Area of impact (acres) Permanent (P) or Temporary 01 ❑P ❑T 02 ❑P ❑T 03 ❑P ❑T 04 ❑P ❑T 4f Total open water impacts 4g Comments 5 Pond or Lake Construction If pond or lake construction proposed then complete the chart below 5a 5b 5c 5d 5e Wetland Impacts (acres) Stream Impacts (feet) Upland Pond ID Proposed use or purpose (acres) number of pond Flooded Filled Excavated Flooded Filled Excavated Flooded P1 P2 517 Total 5g Comments 5h Is a dam high hazard permit required ❑ Yes ❑ No If yes permit ID no 51 Expected pond surface area (acres) 51 Size of pond watershed (acres) 5k Method of construction 6 Buffer Impacts (for DWQ) If project will impact a protected riparian buffer then complete the chart below If yes then individually list all buffer impacts below If any impacts require mitigation then you MUST fill out Section D of this form 6a ❑ Neuse ❑ Tar Pamlico ❑ Other Project is in which protected basin? ❑ Catawba ❑ Randleman 6b 6c 6d 6e 6f 6g Buffer impact number — Reason Buffer Zone 1 impact Zone 2 impact Permanent (P) or for Stream name mitigation (square feet) (square feet) Temporary impact required? B1 ❑P ❑T ❑Yes ❑ No B2 ❑ P ❑ T ❑ Yes ❑ No B3 ❑ P ❑ T El Yes ❑ No 6h Total buffer impacts 61 Comments Page 6 of 11 PCN Form — Version 1 3 December 10 2008 Version D Impact Justification and Mitigation 1 Avoidance and Minimization 1a Specifically describe measures taken to avoid or minimize the proposed impacts in designing project The proposed equipment compound was reduced to 50 x50 from a standard 100 x100 to reduce impacts The proposed access drive was designed with a minimal running surface of 12 feet to reduce impacts to wetlands A culvert is proposed beneath and within W1 to maintain hydrologic conductivity between remaining wetlands 1 b Specifically describe measures taken to avoid or minimize the proposed impacts through construction techniques A coastal stormwater permit is being obtained and a sediment and erosion control plan prepared Stringent erosion and sediment control measures will be implemented during and after construction to prevent impacts to adjacent wetlands from sediment runoff Mechanized clearing will be limited only to the proposed impact areas Any additional clearing outside proposed areas of disturbance will be conducted by hand 2 Compensatory Mitigation for Impacts to Waters of the U S or Waters of the State 2a Does the project require Compensatory Mitigation for impacts to Waters of the U S or Waters of the State? ® Yes ❑ No 2b If yes mitigation is required by (check all that apply) ❑ DWQ ® Corps 2c If yes which mitigation option will be used for this projects ❑ Mitigation bank ®Payment to in lieu fee program ❑ Permittee Responsible Mitigation 3 Complete if Using a Mitigation Bank 3a Name of Mitigation Bank 3b Credits Purchased (attach receipt and letter) Type Quantity 3c Comments 4 Complete if Making a Payment to In lieu Fee Program 4a Approval letter from in lieu fee program is attached ® Yes 4b Stream mitigation requested linear feet 4c If using stream mitigation stream temperature ❑ warm ❑ cool ❑cold 4d Buffer mitigation requested (DWQ only) square feet 4e Riparian wetland mitigation requested acres 4f Non riparian wetland mitigation requested 0 5 acres 4g Coastal (tidal) wetland mitigation requested acres 4h Comments 2 1 mitigation ratio = 0 30 acres EEP only sells credits in 0 25 acre increments therefore 0 5 credits have been requested 5 Complete if Using a Permittee Responsible Mitigation Plan 5a If using a permittee responsible mitigation plan provide a description of the proposed mitigation plan Page 7 of 11 PCN Form — Version 1 3 December 10 2008 Version 6 Buffer Mitigation (State Regulated Riparian Buffer Rules) — required by DWQ 6a Will the project result in an impact within a protected riparian buffer that requires buffer mitigation? ❑ Yes ® No 6b If yes then identify the square feet of impact to each zone of the riparian buffer that requires mitigation Calculate the amount of mitigation required Zone 6c Reason for impact 6d Total impact (square feet) Multiplier 6e Required mitigation (square feet) Zone 1 3 (2 for Catawba) Zone 2 15 6f Total buffer mitigation required 6g If buffer mitigation is required discuss what type of mitigation is proposed (e g payment to private mitigation bank permittee responsible riparian buffer restoration payment into an approved in lieu fee fund) 6h Comments Page 8 of 11 PCN Form — Version 1 3 December 10 2008 Version E Stormwater Management and Diffuse Flow Plan (required by DWQ) 1 Diffuse Flow Plan la Does the project include or is it adjacent to protected riparian buffers identified ❑ Yes ® No within one of the NC Riparian Buffer Protection Rules? 1 b If yes then is a diffuse flow plan included? If no explain why ❑ Yes 0 N Comments 2 Stormwater Management Plan 2a What is the overall percent imperviousness of this protect? 1 1 % 2b Does this project require a Stormwater Management Plan? ® Yes ❑ No 2c If this project DOES NOT require a Stormwater Management Plan explain why 2d If this project DOES require a Stormwater Management Plan then provide a brief narrative description of the plan Based on impervious surface area no structural BMPs are required Silt fencing is proposed around entire area of disturbance and immediate stabilization of soils will be implemented ❑ Certified Local Government 2e Who will be responsible for the review of the Stormwater Management Plan? ® DWQ Stormwater Program ❑ DWQ 401 Unit 3 Certified Local Government Stormwater Review 3a In which local government s jurisdiction is this project? New Hanover County ❑ Phase II 3b Which of the following locally implemented stormwater management programs ❑ NSW ❑ USMP apply (check all that apply) ❑ Water Supply Watershed ❑ Other 3c Has the approved Stormwater Management Plan with proof of approval been ❑ Yes ® No attached? 4 DWQ Stormwater Program Review ® Coastal counties ❑ HQW 4a Which of the following state implemented stormwater management programs apply ❑ ORW (check all that apply) ❑ Session Law 2006 246 ❑ Other 4b Has the approved Stormwater Management Plan with proof of approval been attached? ❑ Yes ® No 5 DWQ 401 Unit Stormwater Review 5a Does the Stormwater Management Plan meet the appropriate requirements? ❑ Yes ❑ No 5b Have all of the 401 Unit submittal requirements been met? ❑ Yes ❑ No Page 9 of 11 PCN Form — Version 1 3 December 10 2008 Version F Supplementary Information 1 Environmental Documentation (DWQ Requirement) la Does the project involve an expenditure of public (federal /state /local) funds or the ❑ Yes ® No use of public (federal /state) land? lb If you answered yes to the above does the project require preparation of an environmental document pursuant to the requirements of the National or State ❑ Yes ❑ No (North Carolina) Environmental Policy Act (NEPA/SEPA)? 1c If you answered yes to the above has the document review been finalized by the State Clearing House? (If so attach a copy of the NEPA or SEPA final approval ❑ Yes ❑ No letter) Comments 2 Violations (DWQ Requirement) 2a Is the site in violation of DWQ Wetland Rules (15A NCAC 2H 0500) Isolated Wetland Rules (15A NCAC 2H 1300) DWQ Surface Water or Wetland Standards ❑ Yes ® No or Riparian Buffer Rules (15A NCAC 2B 0200)? 2b Is this an after the fact permit application? ❑ Yes ® No 2c If you answered yes to one or both of the above questions provide an explanation of the violation(s) 3 Cumulative Impacts (DWQ Requirement) 3a Will this project (based on past and reasonably anticipated future impacts) result in ❑ Yes ® No additional development which could impact nearby downstream water quality? 3b If you answered yes to the above submit a qualitative or quantitative cumulative impact analysis in accordance with the most recent DWQ policy If you answered no provide a short narrative description 4 Sewage Disposal (DWQ Requirement) 4a Clearly detail the ultimate treatment methods and disposition (non discharge or discharge) of wastewater generated from the proposed project or available capacity of the subject facility Not applicable unmanned facility Page 10 of 11 PCN Form — Version 1 3 December 10 2008 Version 5 Endangered Species and Designated Critical Habitat (Corps Requirement) 5a Will this project occur in or near an area with federally protected species or ❑ Yes ® No habitat? 5b Have you checked with the USFWS concerning Endangered Species Act ® Yes ❑ No impacts? ® Raleigh 5c If yes indicate the USFWS Field Office you have contacted ❑ Asheville 5d What data sources did you use to determine whether your site would impact Endangered Species or Designated Critical Habitat? Raleigh field office does not want to consult on communications tower projects where the consultant has determined that there will be no effect on T &E species See attached letter from USFWS and Informal Biological Assessment 6 Essential Fish Habitat (Corps Requirement) 6a Will this project occur in or near an area designated as essential fish habitat? ❑ Yes ® No 6b What data sources did you use to determine whether your site would impact Essential Fish Habitat? Online Essential Fish Habitat Mapper 7 Historic or Prehistoric Cultural Resources (Corps Requirement) 7a Will this project occur in or near an area that the state federal or tribal governments have designated as having historic or cultural preservation ❑ Yes ® No status (e g National Historic Trust designation or properties significant in North Carolina history and archaeology)? 7b What data sources did you use to determine whether your site would impact historic or archeological resources? Consultation with NC SHPO See attached consultation 8 Flood Zone Designation (Corps Requirement) 8a Will this project occur in a FEMA designated 100 year floodplain? ❑ Yes ® No 8b If yes explain how project meets FEMA requirements 8c What source(s) did you use to make the floodplain determination? Online FEMA Flood Mapper Ben Salter Agent � h i• Applicant/Agent s Printed Name Ap icant/Age t Signature D e (Agents signature is valid only if an authorization letter from the applicant is provided Page 11 of 11 PCN Form — Version 1 3 December 10 2008 Version APPENDIX C JURISDICTIONAL DETERMINATION From Ben Salter To Wicker. Christine W SAW Subject RE American Tower Murraysvllle NC Telecommunications Site (UNCLASSIFIED) Date Wednesday February 01 2012 2 0100 PM Attachments JDform Wetland A.odf JDform Wetland Bmclf Murrawille FCD s Rev 2 G 0 2012 01 30 #4.odf Murrayville Final Survey (Rey 5) C 4 2012 01 30.odf HI Christy we finally have the needed Items for the Murraysvllle JD I ve attached a JD form for each of the wetland areas Identified I ve also attached the site survey and the grading plan (shows a little more detail) both with the certification statement and signature blocks I have hard copies of these If you need them It looks like we would have about 35 linear feet (0 01 acre) of RPW ditch Impacts Would you suggest that we Include this in our wetland mitigation proposal with general wetland credits from EEP? Let me know of any questions or comments Thanks' Ben Ben Salter REP Environmental Corp of America (ECA) 1340 Patton Avenue Suite K Asheville NC 28806 Office (828) 505 0755 Fax (828) 505 0959 Mobile (828) 226 0056 ben salter @eca usa com www eca usa com Alpharetta GA / Asheville NC / Chicago IL / Nashville TN / West Palm Beach FL Original Message From Wicker Christine W SAW [mallto. Christi ne .W.Wlcker(&usace.army.mlI] Sent Monday October 17 20112 37 PM To Ben Salter Subject RE American Tower Murraysvllle NC Telecommunications Site (UNCLASSIFIED) Ben I was able to stop by on my way home last Thursday The line looked good and you can go ahead and get it surveyed Once I receive the survey I will send out the JD Also can you send me an electronic copy of the rapanos forms? I looked through my email and couldn t find one if you already sent it to me Thanks Christy Christy Wicker Regulatory Specialist U S Army Corps of Engineers 69 Darlington Ave Wilmington NC 28403 (910) 251 4637 (Ph) (910) 251 4025 (Fax) II 1 I II _ lilll�l I I� I �6 I � I I 1 I s �g� � � g ts _ —T— T II 11 II 11 II 111 I- - -- -�m 1 11 1 11 II II 1 11 I �1 I � I I 1 1 I I O I I I I 1 I I 1 I I II I � I I I I 1 I 1 1 I c9 I 1 �$ 1 I 1 1 g I �a 1 I � I 1 � I tW SW I voi 0 3 3 m ¢ °o az w y� °w> U CE n O z voi Q I I O G ZOUWu S f cr H O W Z U M OJ�O w � UO � � p¢K o O y M = LZo w o 5: co z = mw °- °W WoinaFm Z K K Q H W Z WHZ OQ 00 tjOZ Hd'wmKO Z<I, oz Ny O U U U U ¢ W F W QH <Z W O O O W °Q Ooo °�� za°ad -p NU�w� QZ Sm N Z OF �'L"I a Z W p� ° w -010 � �U O o ° o O zw ¢ ¢ m m m x ?�° ow K?C70W� wWmzz�� =° -w�° JV1My> W 0X N N YJ zii O O U O N OZ SQ°>N \w n9mI 090 H QO- WQ zao owzm Mzmmm d 0 izw irw�� -=o Q�d��V° =O¢ w =K =3¢ ° Z O ¢a f >�N3Z �a3 �� �w_¢ W ~N o� Ow mw O S Z O Z Z Q W W p W Z yH O W ¢aOX U�Q amZZ o >NQO 1- a,XJOw _ZOO Q Z~ N w¢ o�O�W= �ti�p] w VI I� O O U W �� LLJ ~ a ~ aFy �p¢J°N z03ua a ZNw°p� ry��W ZO N Z w�U��z //�/���7^ (,0 0 a ° w 3 W¢W i O z N O Z U U� N O Y¢ OO VI d'WOZN W< 0¢ z y QO Qm Y Z W N m 0 0 NO W Q Q N� � Q� N z N M ^�^ O N ~N(n d'ZOOd�.00W¢K mW�w J> ¢ ¢ Oy�NVI� y �w0 FK(Z' w WWS J¢zJ W U U OM <0 Z o m m m � Q W ¢w0 maw> �F"�\ W �w //—�// W ~I/n� z w O m n \\ 0 O¢ MONY J�J X� w W Jz O �m QOM 7y� Zf/IO y ZQO mQ- w UN UO Z� U W O o v y in �z¢z J¢J a¢� F¢z ¢wa¢c�a�ma�d¢ v� N �N�mNOw moo �QOo�¢ II 3m �N o0er a c M N N z N M< V1 t0 OSO WWX�= Z�N3WwF- =W Jay NZ -wwOY_ Q can O ----------- I a +O� {} b � ❑ ❑❑ m QNUwn �wwWw O W K d �,y C OrP 1a �ZS j 0 U w ozw- af W, 0, Uw 00 x0 < w0ao z °o¢�oaam �w d �aw3 3 'O moa�w N C� �n z aw ° o N zo F- N Q p z 0 0 (r (r oaaa�mw�?owa o ��w000 w z w'•' a ^m w CW7 ILLI M ®0 00® will, / -W.W n O<N �P ON Uw hp° >�NO�w �ZN Q 3 Za W z wzw zwrr >w U OUm wWZZ ¢ >mO O� z(X 2 x Sow z¢ J m J w x rr ww, m CERT out wac'1 If<< w V, °O =3o0w0 Uma. 3:3t -N En II 1 I II _ lilll�l I I� I �6 I � I I 1 I s �g� � � g ts _ —T— T II 11 II 11 II 111 I- - -- -�m 1 11 1 11 II II 1 11 I �1 I � I I 1 1 I I O I I I I 1 I I 1 I I II I � I I I I 1 I 1 1 I c9 I 1 �$ 1 I 1 1 g I �a 1 I � I 1 � I tW SW I W O I I I I I I MABEE WAY PRIVATE) O cl� Lu CE CD D- 1� 110 � Q I I �C C W O I I I I I I 3 �1� G � s s s a #$ e Er vial I I Iz f n CD In 3 Rl Of I m A I I I I I I I w I I IJ_I J � Q � � z J V O p d 3 2 N Z Z CL CL uj (N G.9 Z V' Q 0 3 0 °o N W W Z_ W Q N p p 0 0 n ' 1 Ob — — —_ 04 l4 I I &tv, I I ee a I / I I I YY YY YY I I I I I zg� I I a e 3� �6 �� I �I Bgg8 Bel I I Y I I I I II l L s s 2R �s Ek y CL CL uj (N G.9 Z V' Q 0 3 0 °o N W W Z_ W Q N p p 0 0 n DEPARTMENT OF THE ARMY WILMINGTON DISTRICT CORPS OF ENGINEERS 69 DARLINGTON AVENUE WILMINGTON NORTH CAROLINA 28403 1343 August 9 2011 Regulatory Division Action ID No SAW 2011 01367 American Tower Inc Attn American Tower Corporation 10 Presidents Way Woburn Massachusetts 01810 Dear American Tower Corporation This letter is in reference to the submitted verification of Junsdictional determination for the project area American Cell Tower (273409) at the end of Mabee Way in Wilmington New Hanover County North Carolina On July 20 2011 Mrs Christy Wicker of the U S Army Corps of Engineers Wilmington Regulatory Field office made a site visit to verify the line flagged by Ben Salter of Environmental Corporation of America and found some areas of question On July 26 2011 Mrs Christy Wicker and Mrs Emily Hughes did a second site visit specifically after a rainfall to look at the areas in questions and determined that the site needs to be re delineated The Corps recommend revisiting the site for delineation in late fall /early winter due to weak hydrology indicators on data forms DP 4 and DP 5 The Corps recognizes that both site visits both took place during times of drought but hydric soil indicators were not detected in some areas Three (3) pink wetland delineation flags were hung in separate locations along the cutline where hydric soils were identified Also the 25 foot easement and the 100 x 100 foot project area needs to be clearly identified in order to properly verify the delineation Should you have any questions please contact me at (910) 251 4637 Sincerely IJ Christine Wicker Wilmington Regulatory Field Office Copy Furmshed Environmental Corporation of America Attn Ben Salter 1340 Patton Avenue Suite K Asheville North Carolina 28806 APPENDIX D NC EEP IN LIEU FEE CREDIT REQUEST Statement of Compliance with Session Law 2009 -337 An Act to Promote the Use of Compensatory Mitigation Banks and SL 2011 -343 (link to SL 2009 337) (fink to SL 2011 343) Prior to accessing the Ecosystem Enhancement Program (EEP) In Lieu Fee Mitigation Program all applicants requesting wetlands, stream and /or riparian buffer mitigation are now required by law to comply with Session Law 2009 337 An Act to Promote the Use of Compensatory Mitigation Banks as well as Session Law 2011 343 which made changes to the operation of the NCEEP All new requests submitted on or after June 27 2011 MUST include this form signed and dated by the permit applicant or an authorized agent Please refer to DENR s Implementation Policy for more detailed guidance Compliance Statement I have read and understand SL 2009 337 and SL 2011 343 and have, to the best of my knowledge, complied with their requirements I understand that participation in the NCEEP is voluntary Please check all that apply Applicant is a Federal or State Government Entity or a unit of local government meeting the requirements set forth in G S 143 214 11 (as amended by SL 2011 343) and is not required to purchase credits from a mitigation bank X There are no known mitigation banks with the requested credit type located in the hydrologic unit where this impact will take place (link to DWQ list) (see approved mitigation bank link under Options for compensatory mitigation heading) I have contacted the mitigation bank(s) in the hydrologic unit where the impacts will occur and credits are not available The DWQ or the Corps of Engineers did not approve of the use of a mitigation bank for the required compensatory mitigation for this project Note It is the applicant's responsibility to document any inquiries made to private mitigation banks regarding credit availability CA� I have read and understand EEP's refund policies (attached) initial here 0�� C itt-ey **&As�t[6�A14A Signature o App scant or Agent Printed Name Its 6 Date American Towers LLC 273409 (Murraysvdle NC) Project Name Wilmington New Hanover County NC Location NORTH CAROLINA ECOSYSTEM ENHANCEMENT PROGRAM, NCEEP IN -LIEU FEE REQUEST FORM Revised 8/11/2011 Print this form fill in requested Information sign and date and either mad to NCEEP 1652 Mad Service Center Raleigh NC 27699 1652 fax to 919 715 2219 or email to kelly williams ()ncdenr oov Attachments are acceptable for clarification purposes (location map or lat long is required) Review meetings are held on Tuesday afternoons Information submitted is subject to INC Public Records Law and may be requested by third parties CONTACT INFORMATION APPLICANTS AGENT (optional) APPLICANT 1 Business or Individual Name Environmental Corp of America American Towers LLC 2 Street Address or P O Box 1340 Patton Ave Suite K 10 Presidential Way 3 City State Zip Asheville NC 28806 Woburn MA 01801 P 4 Contact Person I Ben Salter i Elyssa Bailey I 5 Telephone Number 828 505 0755 781 926 -4916 6 Fax Number 828 505 0959 781 9267011 7 E Mad Address (optional) ( ben salter @eca usa com enviro services @amencantower cpm i PROJECT INFORMATION I I 8 Project Name 9 Project Location (nearest town city) ATTACH MAP SHOWING IMPACT LOCATI 10 Lat Long Coordinates (optional) 11 Project County American Towers LLC 273409 (Murraysville NC) Mabee Way Wilmington NC 34 300745 N 77 846557 W New Hanover 12 River Basin & Cataloging Unit (8 digit) (see Note 1) 03030007 ' 13 Project Type * *specify owner type and E Government X Private write in project type (e g school church retail residential SD apartments road utilities military etc ) I 14 Riparian Wetland Impact (ac) (e g 0 13) 15 Non Riparian Wetland Impact (ac) j0 15 acres of forested wetland impact (non riparian) 17 Stream Impact (ft ) (e g 1 234) �mm�Warm � Cool _ Cold t II 18 Riparian Buffer Impact (sq ft ) Zone 1 Zone 2 _ (where applicable) _ 19 Regulatory Agency Staff Contacts i i USACE Chris Wicker DWQ NA (Indicate names if known) Christy I 20 Other Regulatory ID Information (e g USACE Action ID If known) IMPORTANT Check (�) below If this request Is a _ revision to a current acceptance or _ re submission of an expired acceptance —extension of unexpired acceptance USACE SAW 2011 01367 By signing below the applicant is confirming they have read and understand EEP s refund Ihorized icy posted at I nceep net s Sig natu�Appli0n or A Agent Z. Note 1 For help in determining the Cataloging Unit visit www nceeo net or contact EEP Direct questions to Kelly Williams at 919 716 1921 or kelly williamsCa7ncdear gov or to EEP s front desk at 919 715 0476 Refund Policy for Fees Paid to EEP s In Lieu Fee Programs (9/21/2009) Purpose The purpose of this policy is to make clear the circumstances and process under which a permttee can obtain a refund while simultaneously balancing customer service and responsible business practices This policy applies to all refund requests made on or after the publication date of this policy 1 All refund requests must be made in writing to EEP s In Lieu Fee Program Coordinator at kelly williamsCa)_ncdenr gov 2 All refund requests are subject to fund availability EEP does not guarantee fund availability for any request 3 The request must either come from the entity that made the payment or from an authorized agent Third parties requesting refunds must provide written authorization from the entity that made the payment specifying the name and address of the authorized refund recipient 4 Refund requests related to unintended overpayments typographical errors or incorrect invoices should be brought the attention of the In Lieu Fee Program Coordinator as soon as possible Such requests are typically approved without delay 5 Payments made under EEP s incremental payment procedure are not eligible for refunds 6 Refund requests made within nine months of payment to EEP will only be considered for requests associated with projects that have been terminated or modified where the permttee s mitigation requirements have been reduced Such requests must be accompanied by written verification from the permitting agency that the project has been cancelled the permits have been rescinded or have been modified or the mitigation requirements have been reduced 7 Refund requests made more than nine months from the payment date will only be considered for permits that were terminated or modified to not require any mitigation Such requests must be accompanied by written verification from the permitting agency that the project has been cancelled the permits have been rescinded and /or mitigation is no longer required 8 Refund requests not meeting the criteria specified above are not eligible for a refund 9 Refund requests that meet the criteria above will be elevated to EEP Senior Management for review The following considerations apply to all refund requests a availability of funds after consideration of all existing project and regulatory obligations b the date the payment was made c the likelihood EEP can use the mitigation procured using the payment to meet other mitigation requirements 10 Once a refund has been approved the refund recipient must provide a completed W 9 form to EEP s In Lieu fee Program Coordinator within two weeks in order to process the refund though the State Controllers Office 1 I All decisions shall be final APPENDIX E LEASE AGREEMENT Site Name Murraysville Site Number 273409 OPTION AND LEASE AGREEMENT THIS OPTION AND LEASE AGREEMENT ( "Agreement") is made effective as of the date of the latter signature hereof (the "Execution Date') and is by and between Optionee/Tenant and Optionor/Landlord RECITALS A WHEREAS, Optionor is the owner of that certain parcel of land (the "Property ") located in the County of New Hanover State of North Carolina as more particularly described on Exhibit A and B WHEREAS Optionor desires to giant to Optionee an option to lease from Optionor a portion of the Property (the Premises) together with easements for ingress and egress and the installation and maintenance of utilities (the Easement) both being approximately located as shown on Exhibit B (the Premises and the Easement will collectively be referred to herein as the Site ) NOW THEREFORE in consideration of the sum of $10 00 the mutual covenants and agreements herein contained, and other good and valuable consideration, the receipt adequacy and sufficiency of all of which are hereby acknowledged the parties hereto hereby agree as follows Business Terms For the purposes of this Agreement the following capitalized terms have the meanings set forth in this paragraph 1 (a) Optionee/Tenant American Towers Inc a Delaware corporation (b) Optionee s/Tenant's Notice Address American Towers Inc c/o American Towei Corporation 10 President Way Woburn MA 01810 Attn Land Management with a copy to Amei scan Towers Inc c/o American Tower Corporation 116 Huntington Ave Boston MA 02116 Attn Law Department (c) Optionor/Landlord TF Holdings Limited Partnership (d) Optionor s/Landlord's Address 1202 Eastwood Road Wilmington NC 28403 With a copy to each of the following Raiford Trask III Brian Eckel David G Martin 1202 Eastwood Road 1051 Military Cutoff Road Smith Moore Leatherwood Wilmington, NC 28409 Wilmington NC 28405 300 North Yd Stieet Suite 301 Wilmington, NC 28401 Site Name Munaysville Site Number 273409 (e) Option Commencement Date The Execution Date (f) Option Consideration (Initial Option Term) $1400 00 (g) Option Extension Consideration (Renewal Option Term) $1,400 00 (h) Initial Option Term Six (6) months (i) Renewal Option Term(s) One (1) period of Six (6) months 0) Commencement Date The date specified in the written notice by Optionee to Optionor exercising the Option constitutes the Commencement Date of the Lease (k) Rent The monthly amount of $1400 00 increased as further provided for in paragraph 14(b) and 1(n) hereof (1) Initial Base Rent Rent due to Landlord fi om Tenant first Lease Yeai (m) Lease Year The fast Lease Year will be the period commencing on the Commencement Date and ending on the date immediately preceding the one year anniversary of the Commencement Date Each Lease Year thereafter will be a 12 successive calendar month period (n) Rent Increase Rent will increase at the commencement of each Renewal Term by an amount equal to 15% of Rent for the previous 5 year period as further described in paragraph 14 below (o) Initial Term 5 years commencing on the Commencement Date (as defined in paragraph 10) hereof) and continuing until midnight of the day immediately prior to the 5'" anniversary of the Commencement Date (p) Renewal Terms Subject to paragraph 13(b) hereof, each of the five (5) successive periods of five (5) years each with the first Renewal Term commencing upon the expiration of the Initial Term and each subsequent Renewal Term commencing upon the expiration of the immediately preceding Renewal Term I OPTION 2 Grant of Option Optionor hereby gives and grants unto Optionee and its assigns an exclusive and irrevocable option to lease the Premises and use the Easement pursuant to the terms of this Agreement (the Option ) Optionoi agrees and acknowledges that Optionee may at Optionee s sole cost have a metes and bounds survey of the Site survey prepared and that the legal description of the Site as shown on such survey will thereafter become the legal desci iption of the Site 3 Initial Option Term The Initial Option Term is as set forth in paragraph 1(h) 4 Extension of Option This Option will automatically be extended for each Renewal Option Term unless Optionee provides Optionor written notice of its intent not to extend the Option Optionee will pay Optionor the Option Extension Consideration within thirty (30) days of the commencement of the Renewal Option Term 5 Consideration for Option Option Consideration is due and payable in full within thirty (30) days of the Option Commencement Date Payment of the Option Consideration by Optionee to Optionor will be credited in full to the first year s Rent due Optionor if this Option is exercised by Optionee Site Name Murraysville Site Number 273409 6 Optionor's Representations and Warranties As an inducement for Optionee to enter into and be bound by the terms of this Option Optionor represents and warrants to Optionee and Optionee's successor s and assigns that (a) Optionor has good and marketable title to the Property free and clear of all liens and encumbrances other than those of record in New Hanover County Optionee may at Optionee's sole cost and expense procure an abstract of title or a commitment to issue a policy of title insurance (collectively 7711e ) on the Property In the event that Optionee objects to any defect or cloud on Title Optionee will notify Optionor in writing of the defect of cloud and Optionor will have 15 days to clear the defect or cloud to Optionee s satisfaction If the title is not cleared to Optionee s satisfaction within such 15 day poi rod then Optionee may declare this Option to be void and of no further force or effect whereupon this Option will terminate and there will be no further liability of the parties accruing hereunder however if within the 15 day period Optionor is diligently pursuing a cure Optionor shall have up to 34 days to cure the defect or cloud on Title (b) Optionor has the authority to enter into and be bound by the terms of this Option (c) To the best of Ophonor's knowledge there are no pending or threatened administrative actions including bankruptcy or insolvency proceedings under state or fedetal law, suits claims or causes of action against Optionor or which may otherwise affect the Property and (d) The Property is not presently subject to an option lease or other contract which may adversely affect Optionor s ability to fulfill its obligations under this Option and Optionor covenants that it will not grant an option or enter into any contract which will affect the Property or the Site until this Option expires or is terminated by Optionee These repiesentations and warranties of Optionor survive the exercise of the Option and the termination of expiration of the term of this Agreement 7 Taxes Optionor will pay any ad valorem taxes or othei special assessment taxes attributable to the Property and the Easement during the Initial Option Term and any Renewal Option Term of this Option 8 Liquidated Damages American Towei is not obligated to exercise this Option In the event the Option is not exercised Optionor's sole compensation and damages will be fixed and liquidated to the sums paid by Optionee to Optionor as consideration for this Option Furthermore, Optionor hereby expressly waives any other remedies it may have for a breach of this Option by Optionee including specific performance and damages for breach of contiact 9 Inspections and Investigations Ophonor hereby grants to Optionee its officers agents employees and independent contractors the right and piivilege to entei upon the Property at any time after the date of this Option to perform or cause to be performed test borings of the soil environmental audits engineering studies and to conduct a survey of the Property and /or the Site (collectively the `Environmental Tests') Optionor will provide Optionee with any necessary keys or access codes to the Property if needed for ingress and egress, and Optionee will not unreasonably interfere with Optionot's use of the Property in conducting these activities Optionee agrees to give Optionor 24 hours advance notice before entering the Property during the Option Term In the event of any invasive testing Optionor reserves the right to have a representative present during the testing Optionee agrees to keep the results of the Environmental Tests confidential unless disclosure is legally required or required for Optionee to be able to use the site for its Intended Use Notwithstanding the foregoing Optionee may disclose the results of the Environmental Tests to potential or actual licensee(s) or sublessee(s) Site Name Murraysville Site Number 273409 10 Furthgr Acts Optionor will cooperate with Optionce in executing any documents necessary to protect Optionee s rights under this Option or Optionee's use of the Site, including the execution and delivery of a Memorandum of Option and Lease in a form acceptable to Optionee, and to take such action as Optionee may reasonably require to effect the intent of this Option Optionor hereby irrevocably appoints Optionee or Optionee s agent as Ophonor s agent to file applications on behalf of Optionor with federal state and local governmental authoi ities which applications relate to Optionee s Intended Use (as defined in paragraph 12 of this Agreement) of the Site including but not limited to land use and zoning applications Any necessary applications or permits will be obtained at Optionee s sole cost and expense 11 Exercise of Option Upon the tender of written notice of Optionee s intent to exercise the Option, the terms and conditions of the Agreement applying to the leasing of the Premises and use of the Easement governs the relationship of the parties and this Agreement will thereaftei be referred to as the Lease' Optionor will thereafter be referred to as Landlord' and Optionee will thereafter be referred to as Tenant H GROUND LEASE 12 Use (a) Tenant shall be permitted to use the Site foi the purpose of constructing, maintaining, securing and operating a communications facility including but not limited to the construction or installation and maintenance of towers structural tower base(s) communications equipment one or more buildings or equipment cabinets, radio transmitting and receiving antennas and ielated facilities on the Premises (collectively, the "Tower Facilities') to facilitate the use of the Site as a site for the tiansmission and ieceipt of wireless communication signals including but not limited to voice, data and internet transmissions and foi any other uses which are incidental thereto (the "Intended Use') Tenant may at its sole expense use any and all appropriate means of restricting access to the Premises or the Tower Facilities including without limitation construction of a fence Tenant may at Tenant's sole expense construct Tenant s Tower Facilities on the Site to meet Tenant's needs and Tenant shall maintain the Premises in aacommercially reasonable condition throughout the Initial Term and any Renewal Terms reasonable wear and tear and damage from casualty and condemnation excepted Landlord shall reasonably cooperate with Tenant in executing any documents necessary to protect Tenant s rights undei this Lease or facilitate Tenant s and Tenant s sublessee s and licensee s use of the Site and will take such further reasonable action as Tenant may reasonably require to effect the intent of this Lease but all without cost to Landlord It is understood however that Tenant will not pay Landlord s attorneys fees (b) Tenants obligations heieunder are expressly conditioned upon Tenants ability to obtain maintain renew and reinstate all of the certificates permits licenses zoning, variances and other approvals which may be required from any federal state or local authority as well as any necessary easements (collectively the "Approvals' Landlord shall cooperate with Tenant at no out of pocket expense to Landlord in its efforts to obtain the Approvals, and Landlord shall take no action which would adversely affect the status of the Site with respect to Tenants Intended Use thereof If (i) any application by Tenant for any one of the Approvals is finally denied or rejected or is otherwise withdrawn or terminated or (n) if any matters exist affecting Landlord's title to the Site which prevent Tenant from using the Site for Tenant's Intended Use (unless such title item can be cured by Landlord to Tenant's satisfaction within 15 days, or 30 days so long as Landlord is diligently pursuing a cure within the initial 15 day period), then Tenant shall have the right to terminate this Lease upon written notice to Landlord and Landlord, within 30 days of such termination shall refund to Tenant any Rent paid by Tenant applicable to the period subsequent to such termination Site Name Murraysville Site Number 273409 (c) Landlord agrees without cost to Landlord to execute within 15 days after receipt of a written request from Tenant any and all documents necessary in Tenant's commercially reasonable judgment to protect Tenant's rights or the rights of Tenant's sublessees or licensees under this Lease to facilitate Tenant s use of the Site as contemplated under this Lease or to allow Tenant to obtain maintain, renew or reinstate the Approvals Tenant will provide all documents for execution on Tenant s standard forms or in the case of zoning applications or other situations regulated by governmental bodies, on forms specified by such governmental body Documents provided for execution may include without limitation affidavits relating to title curative measures non disturbance agreements memorandums of lease memorandums of amendment and zoning applications and other related documents required to obtain zoning approval Landlord further irrevocably appoints Tenant as attorney in fact coupled with an interest to execute any document pertaining to the initial installation of the Towet Facilities which Landlord fails to execute within 15 days after Landlord s receipt of a request for execution In addition the parties agree that Tenant shall be entitled to liquidated damages for the revenue lost as documented by Tenant as a result of any delay caused by Landlord s unwillingness to execute a document or to take any other action deemed necessary by Tenant to protect Tenant s leasehold rights or to facilitate the Intended Use As the actual amount of such lost revenue is difficult to determine the parties agree that Tenant may deduct the amount of One Hundred and No /100 Dollars ($100 00) per day from future installments of Rent for any delay to Tenant caused by Landlords failure to act, such amount being an estimate of Tenant s lost revenue Tenant s right to collect such liquidated damages will in no way affect Tenant s right to pursue any and all other legal and equitable rights and remedies permitted under applicable laws 13 Term (a) Initial Term The Initial Term of this Lease is set forth in paragraph I (o) (b) Renewal Terms Tenant shall have the right to extend this Lease for each of the Renewal Terms Each Renewal Term will be on the same terms and conditions set forth in this Lease except that Rent will escalate as provided in paragraph 14(b) This Lease will automatically be renewed for each successive Renewal Term unless Tenant notifies Landlord in writing of Tenants intention not to renew the Lease at any time prior to the expiration of the Initial Term or the Renewal Term which is then in effect (c) The Initial Term and Renewal Terms are collectively lefened to herein as the Term 14 Consideration (a) Tenant shall pay its first installment of Rent within fifteen (15) business days of the Commencement Date Thereafter Rent is due and payable in advance on the first day of each calendar month to Landlord at Landlords Address Rent will be prorated foi any partial months including, without limitation the month in which the Commencement Date occurs (b) Rent will be increased at the commencement of each Renewal Term (the Increase Date ) by an amount equal to 1 S% of Rent for the previous 5 year period At Tenant s electron Tenant may confirm to Landlord in writing the amount of the Rent increase ( Increase Notice ) Unless Landlord notifies Tenant in writing within 30 days of the date of the Increase Notice that it disagrees with the amount of the Rent increase stated therein such amount will be conclusively presumed to be the correct calculation of the Rent increase (c) If this Lease is terminated at a time other than on the day immediately preceding the anniversary of the Commencement Date Rent will be prorated as of the effective date of such termination (the "Termination Date ") If this Lease is terminated for any reason provided herein other than Site Name Murraysville Site Number 273409 nonpayment of Rent all Rent paid in advance for the period after the Termination Date will be refunded to Tenant by Landloid within 30 days of the Termination Date (d) In the event Tenant makes an overpayment of Rent of any other fees or charges to Landlord during the Term of this Lease, Tenant may but shall not be requited, to treat any such overpayment amount as prepaid Rent and apply such amount as a credit against future Rent due to Landlord (e) In no event will Tenant be tequired to remit the payment of Rent to more than two recipients at any given time 15 Landlord's Representations and Warranties Landlord represents and warrants that (1) Tenants Intended Use of the Site is not prohibited by any covenants restrictions reciprocal easements servitudes or subdivision rules or regulations (n) there are no easements licenses rights of use or other encumbrances on the Site or the Property which will interfere with or constructively prohibit Tenants Intended Use of the Site and (m) the execution of this Lease by Landlord will not cause a breach or an event of default of any other agreement to which Landlord is a party If there are any restrictive title items that Tenant believes may prohibit or inhibit Tenant's Intended Use then Landloid shall have 15 days after receipt of written notice from Tenant to cure any such title items to Tenant s satisfaction This time period may be extended to 30 days so long as Tenant is diligently pursuing a cure within the 15 day period 16 Conditions Subsequent If Tenant's Intended Use of the Site is actually or consttuctively prohibited through no fault of Tenant then without limiting any othet remedy in law or equityJor Landlords breach or negligent or intentional acts or omissions including any breach or negligent or intentional acts or omissions caused by Landlord s employees contiactois or agents Tenant shall have the option to terminate this Lease upon written notice to Landloid after any applicable default cure periods have expired 17 Interference Landlord shall not use, not shall Landlord permit its tenants, licensees, invitees of agents to use any portion of the Property in any way which interferes with Tenant s Intended Use of the Site Such interference will be deemed a material breach of this Lease by Landlord and Landlord shall have the responsibility to terminate said interference immediately upon written notice from Tenant Anything to the contrary in this Lease notwithstanding the cure periods provided for in paragraph 19 hereof will not be applicable to failure by Landloid to fulfill its obligations under this paragraph 17 If any such interference does not cease or is not rectified as soon as possible but in no event longer than 24 hours after Tenant s written notice to Landlord Landlord acknowledges that continuing interference will cause irreparable injury to Tenant and Tenant shall have the right, in addition to any other rights that it may have at law or in equity to bring action to enjoin such interference or to terminate this Lease immediately upon notice to Landlord If within the above mentioned 24 hour cure period Landloid has begun to diligently pursue a cure to any interference Landlord will be provided a reasonable period of time to complete such cure 18 Improvements, Utilities, and Access (a) Tenant shall have the right, at Tenant s sole cost and expense to erect and maintain on the Site improvements personal property and facilities including without limitation the Tower Facilities and other related facilities The Towei Facilities are the exclusive property of the Tenant throughout the term as well as upon the expiration or termination of this Lease Tenant shall remove all of the above- ground portions of the Tower Facilities within ninety (90) days following the expiration or termination of this Lease Landlord grants Tenant the right to clear all trees undergrowth or other obstructions and to trim cut and keep trimmed all tree limbs which may interfere with or fall upon the Tower Facilities or Site Name Murraysville Site Number 273409 the Site Landlord grants Tenant a non exclusive easement in over across and through the Property as shown on the preliminary survey in Exhibit B attached hereto and incorporated by reference, and the temporary use of the portion of the Property immediately adjacent to the Site as shown on Exhibit B as may be reasonably required for construction and installation -of the Tower Facilities (b) Tenant shall have the right to install utilities at Tenant's expense and to improve present utilities on the Property and the Site Tenant shall have the right to permanently place utilities on (or to bring utilities across or under) the Site to service the Site and the Tower Facilities Tenant and Tenant s licensee(s) or sublessee(s) have the light to install backup generator(s) on the Site If utilities necessary to serve the equipment of Tenant or the equipment of Tenant s licensee(s) of sublessee(s) cannot be located within the Site Landlord agrees to cooperate with Tenant and to act reasonably in allowing the location of utilities on the Property or other real pioperty owned by Landloid without requiring additional compensation from Tenant of Tenant s licensee(s) or sublessee(s) Landlord shall, upon Tenant's request, execute a separate recordable written easement or lease to the utility company providing such service evidencing this right (c) Landlord represents and warrants to Tenant that Tenant shall at all times during this Lease enjoy ingress egress, and access fiom the Site 24 hours a day 7 days a week to an open and improved public road which are adequate to service the Site and the Towel Facilities If no such public road exists or ceases to exist in the future Landlord will grant an appropriate easement to Tenant Tenant's licensee(s) sublessee(s) and assigns so that Tenant may at its own expense construct a suitable private access drive to the Site and the Towel Facilities To the degree such access is across other property owned by Landlord Landlord shall execute an easement evidencing this right without requiring additional compensation from Tenant Landlord shall maintain access to such easement and the Easement in a free and open condition so that no interference is caused to Tenant by other Tenants licensees invitees or agents of Landlord which may utilize the easement To the extent damage (including wear and tear caused by normal usage) to the Easement of any other route contemplated hereunder intended to provide Tenant with access to the Site and the Tower Facilities is caused by Landlord or Landlord's Tenants, licensees invites or agents Landloid shall repair same at its own expense In the event Landlord its employees or agents impede or deny Tenant s access (excluding acts of God) of that of Tenant s agent(s) licensee(s) or sublessee(s) to the Site Tenant shall without waiving any other rights that it may have at law of in equity deduct fiom Rent due under this Lease an amount equal to Fifty and No /100 Dollars ($50 00) per day for each day that such access is impeded or denied If Landlord desires to re locate the Easement for access and/or utilities during the Term, Landlord will provide Tenant with 180 days prior written notice of the desired relocation Landloid and Tenant will then identify a mutually agreeable alternate easement location each party acting reasonably Landlord will pay all costs and fees associated with the Easement relocation and will ensure that at all times Tenant has 24 hour per day 7 day per week access to the Premises and that utility service is uninterrupted If the Easement relocation includes a relocation of utilities serving the Towel Facilities, then Landlord will obtain all necessary approvals from the applicable utility companies and will pay all costs and fees associated with relocating the utilities If the alternate easement location is across pioperty owned by third parties Landloid will obtain all necessary easements and will make use of the third party easements available to Tenant (d) Landlord grants Tenant (including, without limitation, Tenant s sublessees and licensees) a license to use such portions of the Landlord s property contiguous to the Site as shown on Exhibit B on a temporary basis as are reasonably required from time to time during the Term of this Lease for the construction installation and maintenance of the Towel Facilities including (i) access to the Site for construction machinery and equipment (n) storage of construction materials and equipment during construction of the Tower Facilities and (iii) use of a staging area for construction installation and removal of equipment Site Name Murraysville Site Number 273409 (e) Tenant shall have the right to install and maintain during the Term of the Lease identifying signs or other signs required by any governmental authority on or about the Site including any access road to the Site (f) Tenant will install a shared lock system on the existing gate to the access road and will provide Landlord with any necessary keys or codes to open the gate Landlord will not be given access to the Premises 19 Termination This Lease may be teimmated without any penalty or further liability upon written notice as follows (a) By either party upon a default of any covenant or term hereof by the other party which default is not cured within 60 days (30 days if a monetary default but such monetary default shall not occur more than twice in a Lease Year) of receipt of written notice of default (without however limiting any other rights available to the parties in law or equity) provided that if the defaulting party commences efforts to cure the default within such period and diligently pursues such cure the non defaulting party shall no longer be entitled to declare a default (b) Upon 30 days written notice by Tenant to Landlord if Tenant is unable to obtain maintain renew or reinstate any agreement permit of other Approvals necessary to the construction and operation of the Tower Facilities or to Tenant s Intended Use of (c) Upon 30 days written notice from Tenant to Landlord if the Site is of becomes unsuitable, in Tenant s sole, but reasonable judgment=foi use as a wireless communications facility by Tenant or by Tenant s Iicensee(s) or sublessee(s) 20 Licenses, Subleases Tenant at its sole discretion shall have the right, without prior notice or the consent of Landlord to license or sublease all or a portion of the Site or the Tower Facilities to other parties Tenants licensee(s) and sublessee(s) shall be entitled to modify the Tower Facilities and to erect additional improvements on the Site including but not limited to antennas dishes cabling, additional storage buildings of equipment shelters as are reasonably required for the operation and maintenance of the communications equipment to be installed on the Site by said licensee(s) and sublessee(s) Tenant s licensee(s) and sublessee(s) shall be entitled to all rights of ingress and egress to the Site and the right to install utilities on the Site as if said licensee(s) or sublessee(s) were Tenant under this Lease 21 Taxes Tenant shall pay when due any personal property taxes assessed on or attributable to the Tower Facilities Landlord shall pay when due all teal property taxes and all other fees and assessments attributable to the Property Premises and Easement provided that Tenant will be responsible for any increases to the real property taxes due on the Property that are directly attributable to Tenant s use of the Site (but not however taxes attributable to periods pnoi to the Commencement Date such as roll back or greenbelt assessments) Tenant will issue payment for any increase amount within 15 business days of receipt of a tax bill from Landlord provided that Tenant reserves the right to legally challenge any such increase Landlord must submit all such tax bills to Tenant within three months of the assessment If Landlord fails to pay when due any taxes affecting the Property or the Site Tenant shall have the right but not the obligation to pay such taxes and (i) deduct the full amount of the taxes paid by Tenant on Landlord s behalf from future installments of Rent or (u) collect such taxes by any lawful means 22 Damage or Destruction If the Premises the Easement or the Tower Facilities ate destroyed or damaged so as to hinder the Intended Use of the Tower Facilities in Tenant's sole and reasonable ,judgment and using industry standards, Tenant may elect to terminate this Lease as of the date of the damage or destruction by written notice to Landlord In such event all obligations of Tenant to Landlord shall cease to accrue as of the date of the damage or destruction and Tenant shall be entitled to the Site Name Murraysville Site Number 273409 reimbursement of any Rent paid by Tenant applicable to the period subsequent to such damage or destruction 23 Condemnation If a condemning authority takes all of the Site, or a portion sufficient in Tenant's sole judgment, to render the Site unsuitable for Tenant's Intended Use in Tenant s reasonable discretion this Lease will terminate as of the date the title vests in the condemning authority Landlord and Tenant shall share in the condemnation proceeds in proportion to the values of their respective interests in the Site (which for Tenant includes where applicable the value of the Tower Facilities, moving expenses prepaid rent and business dislocation expenses)_but the award to Tenant shall not diminish the condemnation proceeds payable to Landlord for the Property excluding the Premises If a condemning authority takes less than all of the Site such that the Site remains suitable foi Tenant s Intended Use the Rent payable under this Lease will be reduced automatically by such percentage as the aiea so condemned beans to the Site as of the date the title vests in the condemning authority A sale of all or part of the Site to a purchaser with the power of eminent domain in the face of the exercise of eminent domain power will be treated as a taking by condemnation for the purposes of this paragraph 24 Insurance Tenant shall purchase and maintain in full force and effect throughout the Initial Term and any Renewal Term such general liability and property damage policies as Tenant may deem necessary Said policy of general liability insurance will at a minimum piovide a combined single limit of $2 000 000 23 Environmental Compliance Landlord represents, warrants and covenants that to the best of Landlords knowledge = without independent investigation (i) that neither Landlord nor to Landlord's knowledge any third party has used, generated stored or disposed of or permitted the use generation, storage or disposal of any contaminants oils asbestos, PCB's hazardous substances of wastes as defined by federal, state or local environmental laws regulations or administrative orders or other materials the removal of which is required or the maintenance of which is prohibited regulated or penalized by any federal, state or local government authority having jurisdiction over the Property ( "Hazardous Materials' on under about or within the Property in violation of any applicable law or regulation and (ii) that Landlord will not and will not permit any third party to use generate store or dispose of any Hazardous Materials on under about or within the Property in violation of any applicable laws regulations or administrative orders Tenant agrees that it will not use generate store or dispose of any Hazardous Material on under about or within the Site in violation of any applicable laws regulations or administrative orders This Lease will at the option of Tenant terminate upon written notice by Tenant to Landlord if Hazardous Materials are discovered to exist on the Property after Tenant takes possession of the Premises and Tenant shall be entitled to a refund of all the consideration paid in advance to Landlord under this Lease 25 Indemnification (a) General Landlord its heirs grantees successors and assigns shall exonerate hold harmless indemnify and defend Tenant fiom any claims obligations liabilities, costs demands damages, expenses suits or causes of action including costs and reasonable attorney s fees which may arise out of (i) any injury to or death of any person, of (ii) any damage to property, if such injury, death or damage - arises out of or is attributable to or results from the negligent of intentional acts or omissions of Landloid, or Landlord s principals employees, invitees agents or independent contractors Tenant its grantees - successors and assigns shall exonerate hold harmless indemnify and defend Landlord from any claims, obligations liabilities costs demands, damages expenses suits or causes of action including costs and reasonable attorney s fees which may arise out of (i) any injury to or death of any person or (ii) any damage to property if such injury death or damage arises out of or is attributable to or results Site Name Murraysville Site Number 273409 from the negligent or intentional acts or omissions of Tenant or Tenant s employees agents or independent contractors (b) Environmental Matters Landlord its heirs grantees, successors, and assigns shall indemnify defend reimburse and hold harmless Tenant from and against any and all damages arising from the presence of Hazardous Materials upon about or beneath the Property or migrating to and from the Property or arising in any manner whatsoever out of the violation of any applicable laws regulations or administrative orders pertaining to the Property and any activities thereon which conditions exist or existed prior to or at the time of the execution of this Lease or which may occur at any time in the future through no fault of Tenant Tenant, its grantees,— successors and assigns shall indemnify defend reimburse and hold harmless Landlord from and against environmental damages caused by the presence of Hazardous Materials on the Site in violation of any applicable laws regulations or administrative orders and arising solely as the result of Tenant s activities after the execution of this Lease Notwithstanding the obligation of Landlord to mdemnify Tenant pursuant to this Lease, Landlord shall upon demand of Tenant and at Landlord s sole cost and expense promptly take all actions to remediate the Property which are required by any federal, state or local governmental agency or political subdivision or which are reasonably necessary to mitigate environmental damages or to allow full economic use of the Site which remediation is necessitated fiom the presence upon about of beneath the Property of a Hazardous Material Such actions include but not be limited to the investigation of the environmental condition of the Property the preparation of any feasibility studies reports or remedial plans and the performance of any cleanup remediation containment, operation maintenance, monitoring or actions necessary to restore the Property to the condition existing prior to the introduction of such Hazardous Material upon about or beneath the Property notwithstanding any lessee standard of remediation allowable under applicable law or governmental policies 27 Sale of Premises During the Initial Term and any Renewal Terms of this Lease Landlord may sell the Site or any real property of which the Site is a part to a third party as long as (i) such sale is made subject to the terms of this Lease and (it) if such sale does not include the assignment of Landlord s full interest in this Lease such purchaser covenants, without requiring compensation from Tenant or Tenant s licensee(s) or sublessee(s) to be paid to such purchaser to perform any obligation of the Landlord under this Lease, including Landlords obligation to cooperate with Tenant as provided hereunder which obligation Landlord would no longer have the legal right or ability to perform following such conveyance 28 Notices All notices or demands by or fiom Tenant to Landlord or Landlord to Tenant, required under this Lease will be in writing and sent (United States mail postage pre paid certified with return receipt requested or by reputable national overnight carrier service transmit prepaid) to the other party at the addresses set forth in paragraphs 1(b) and 1(d) hereof as applicable or to such other addresses as the parties hereto may from time to time designate consistent with this paragraph 28 with such new notice address being effective 30 days after receipt by the other party Notices will be deemed to have been given upon either receipt or rejection —Landlord also requests that copies of Notices to Landlord be sent to the following Raiford Trask, III Brian Eckel 1202 Eastwood Road 1051 Military Cutoff Road Wilmington NC 28409 Wilmington NC 28405 David G Martin Smith Moore Leatherwood 300 North 3'd Street, Suite 301 Wilmington, NC 28401 29 Title and Quiet Enjoyment Landlord warrants and represents that (i) it has the full right power and authority to execute this Lease and (it) it has good and marketable fee simple title to the Site Site Name Murraysville Site Number 273409 and any other real property across which Landlord may grant Tenant, its sublessees and /or licensees an easement, free and clear of any liens and encumbrances or mortgages other than those of record in New Hanover County Landlord covenants that Tenant shall have the quiet enjoyment of the Premises during the term of this Lease Landlord shall indemnify Tenant from and against any loss cost expense or damage including attorney s fees associated with a breach of the foregoing covenant of quiet enjoyment as long as Tenant is not in default under this Agreement If Landlord fails to keep the Site free and clear of any liens and encumbrances Tenant shall have the right, but not the obligation, to satisfy any such lien or encumbrance and to deduct the full amount paid by Tenant on Landlord's behalf from future installments of Rent If the Site is encumbered by a mortgage or deed of trust, within 30 days of receipt of a written request from Tenant Landlord agrees to execute and obtain the execution by its lender of a non disturbance and attornment agreement in a mutually agieeable form to the effect that Tenant and Tenant s sublessees and licensees will not be disturbed in their occupancy and use of the Site by any foreclosure Howevei so long as Landlord commences its efforts to obtain the non disturbance and attomment agreement within said 30 day period and is diligently pursuing such efforts to completion Landlord will be afforded a reasonable time to complete such efforts Should a subordination non disturbance and attornment agreement be requested by Landlord or a lender working with Landlord on a loan to be secured by the Property and entered into subsequent to the Execution Date Tenant will use good faith efforts to piovide Landlord of Landlords lender with Tenants foim subordination non disturbance and attornment agreement executed by Tenant within 30 days of such request 30 Assi ng ment Any sublease license or assignment of this Lease that is entered into by Landlord or Tenant is subject to the provisions of this Lease Landlord may assign this Lease in its entirety to any third party in conjunction with a sale of the Property in accordance with paragiaph 27 hereof Landlord shall not otherwise assign less than Landlord s full interest in this Lease without the prior wiitten consent of Tenant which consent shall not be unreasonably withheld conditioned or delayed Tenant may assign this Lease without prior notice to or the consent of Landlord Additionally, Tenant may mortgage or grant a security interest in this Lease and the Tower Facilities and may assign this Lease and the Tower Facilities to any such mortgagees or holders of security interests including their successors and assigns (hereinafter collectively referred to as "Secured Parties ") If requested by Tenant but without cost to Landlord Landlord shall execute such consent to such financing as may reasonably be required by Secured Parties In addition if requested by Tenant Landlord agrees to notify Tenant and Tenant's Secured Parties simultaneously of any default by Tenant and to give Secured Parties the same right to cure any default as Tenant If a termination disaffrrmance of rejection of the Lease by Tenant pursuant to any laws (including any bankruptcy or insolvency laws) occurs, or if Landlord shall terminate this Lease for any reason Landlord will give to Secured Parties prompt notice thereof and Secured Parties shall have the right to enter upon the Premises during a 30 day period commencing upon Secured Parties receipt of such notice for the purpose of removing any Tower Facilities Landlord acknowledges that Secured Parties are third party beneficiaries of this Lease 31 Successors and Assigns This Lease runs with the Property and is binding upon and will mure to the benefit of the parties, their respective heirs successors personal representatives and assigns 32 Waiver of Landlord's Lien Landlord hereby waives any and all lien rights it may have statutory or otherwise, in and to the Tower Facilities or any portion thereof regardless of whether or not same is deemed real or personal property under applicable laws 33 Waiver of Damages Neither Landlord nor Tenant shall be responsible or liable to the other party for any loss or damage arising from any claim to the extent attributable to any acts of omissions of other licensees or tower users occupying the Tower Facilities or vandalism or for any structural of power failures or destruction or damage to the Tower Facilities except to the extent caused by the negligence or willful misconduct of such party EXCEPT AS SPECIFICALLY PROVIDED IN THIS AGREEMENT Site Name Murraysville Site Number 273409 IN NO EVENT SHALL LANDLORD OR TENANT BE LIABLE TO THE OTHER FOR, AND TENANT AND LANDLORD EACH HEREBY WAIVE THE RIGHT TO RECOVER INCIDENTAL, CONSEQUENTIAL (INCLUDING BUT NOT LIMITED TO LOST PROFITS LOSS OF USE OR LOSS OF BUSINESS OPPORTUNITY) PUNITIVE, EXEMPLARY AND SIMILAR DAMAGES 34 Abscellaneous The following provisions apply to the Option and providing Optionee exercises such Option to the Lease (a) The substantially prevailing party in any litigation arising hereunder is entitled to its reasonable attorney's fees and court costs including appeals, if any (b) Each party agrees to furnish to the othei within 30 days after request such estoppel information as the other may reasonably request (c) This Agreement constitutes the entire agreement and understanding of Landlord and Tenant with respect to the subject matter of this Agieement and supersedes all offers negotiations and other agreements There are no representations of understandings of any kind not set forth herein Any amendments to said Agreement must be in writing and executed and delivered by Landlord and Tenant (d) If either Landloid or Tenant is represented by a real estate broker in this transaction that party is fully responsible for any fees due such broker and will hold the other party harmless from any claims for commission by such broker (e) Landlord agrees — without cost to Landlord to reasonably cooperate with Tenant in executing any documents necessary to protect Tenant s rights under this Agreement of Tenant s Intended Use of the Premises including but not limited to affidavits relating to title curative measures and non disturbance agreements and to take any further action which Tenant may reasonably iequire to effect the intent of the Agreement (f) The Agreement will be construed in accordance with the laws of the state in which the Site is situated (g) If any term of the Agreement is found to be void or invalid, such invalidity will not affect the remaining terms of the Agreement which will continue in full force and effect (h) Upon request by Tenant Landlord shall execute and deliver to Tenant a Memorandum of Option and Lease which Tenant may record in the county in which the Property is located If the information included in the Memorandum of Option and Lease should change or if it becomes clear that such information is incorrect or incomplete of if the Option or Lease is amended Landlord agrees to execute and return to Tenant a recordable Amended Memorandum of Option and Lease in form supplied by Tenant (i) Tenant may obtain title insurance on its interest in the Site, and Landlord shall coopeiate by executing any reasonable documentation required by the title insuiance company 0) Unless otherwise provided in this Agreement Landlord hereby irrevocably appoints Tenant or Tenant s agent as Landlord s agent to file applications on behalf of Landlord with federal state and local governmental authorities which applications relate to Tenant s Intended Use of the Site including but not limited to land use and zoning applications Site Name Murraysville Site Number 273409 (k) This Agreement may be executed in two or more counterparts all of which are considered one and the same agreement and become effective when one or more counterparts have been signed by each of the parties, it being understood that all parties need not sign the same counterpart (1) Landlord will not during the term of this Option and Lease together with any extensions thereof enter into any other lease license or other agreement for a similar purpose as set forth herein, on or adjacent to the Property (m) Failure or delay on the part of either party to exercise any right power or privilege hereunder will not operate as a waiver thereof and waiver of breach of any provision hereof under any circumstances will not constitute a waives of any subsequent breach (n) The parties agree that irreparable damage would occur if any of the provisions of this Agreement were not performed in accordance with their specified terms or were otherwise breached Therefore the parties agree the parties will be entitled to an injunction(s) in any court in the state in which the Site is located to prevent breaches of the provisions of this Agreement and to enforce specifically the terms and provisions of the Agreement this being in addition to any other remedy to which the parties at entitled at law or in equity (o) Each party executing this Agreement acknowledges that it has full power and authority to do so and that the person executing on its behalf has the authority to bind the party (p) This Agreement is valid and binding only upon Tenant s execution by its duly authorized representative (q) Tenant reserves the right to survey the Property and /or the Site and the suivey of the Property Premises and/or Easement will then become Exhibit B I which will be attached hereto and made a part hereof and will control in the event of discrepancies between Exhibit B 1 and Exhibit A and/or Exhibit B Landlord agrees to execute an Amended Memorandum of Option and Lease in iecordable form containing the new legal descriptions of the Premises and the Easement if so requested by Tenant (r) The parties agree that a scanned or electronically reproduced copy or image of this Agreement will be deemed an original and may be introduced or submitted in any action or proceeding as competent evidence of the execution terms and existence hereof notwithstanding the failure or inability to produce or tender an original executed counterpart of this Agreement and without the requirement that the unavailability of such original executed counterpart of this Agreement first be proven (s) Tenant will not pay of reimburse any of Landlord s attorneys fees unless specifically provided to the contrary herein 35 Confidentlality Landlord shall not disclose to any third party the Rent payable by Tenant under this Lease and shall treat such information as confidential except that Landlord may disclose such information to prospective buyers, prospective or existing lenders Landlord's affiliates and attorneys or as may be required by law or as may be necessary for the enforcement of Landlord's rights under the Lease Landlord acknowledges that the disclosure of such information to any other parties may cause Tenant irreparable harm and in the event of such disclosure Tenant shall be entitled to pursue all remedies in law or in equity for the violation including but not limited to, injunctive relief [SIGNATURES APPEAR ON NEXT PAGE] Site Name Murraysville Site Number 273409 IN WITNESS WHEREOF Landlord and Tenant have each executed this Lease as of the respective dates written below LANDLORD TF Holdings Limited Partnership Print Name f%tr %ldf)-- Date 23Z/0 1°Za // Title row Print Name R U S�r Tr Date .3 z / -// Title 4 Pin Px-a.I 1262r -t h Pa^ J� Print Name Lo amt G�, Date Title 9 'Pm yv / ear} t ed- ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS TO FOLLOW Site Name Murraysville Site Number 273409 STATE OF Not^4R 044021i'h a COUNTY OF PPrLkoPer� Before me & 162 2 -r/t the undersigned a Notary Public for the State personally appeared 8 � who is the "era pie4— of TF Holdings Limited Partnership a ML _ limited partners personally known to me (or proved to me on the basis of satisfactory evidence) to be the person whose name is subscribed to the within instrument and acknowledged to me that _he executed the same in his/her authorized capacity and that by his/her signature on the instrument the entity upon behalf of which the person acted executed the instrument ,p `st�i� gtr %S� day of doy,y'C.k �A,;;,��� �� � 1 �e,�r WITNESS my hand and official stamp or seal this � y to Ity 0 00 ivi, 1P ��� t�Yti, � &FIX NOTARY SEAL] STATE OF IVoi^ A Cwrd rna COUNTY OF 72."der MoAry Public My commission expires 7-'L6 / 2--- Before me rri t Ca the undersigned a Notary Public for the State personally appeared . �'r . , who is the a of TF Holdings Limited Partnership a _(C limited partners*,personally known to me (or proved to me on the basis of satisfactory evidence) to be the person whose name is subscribed to the within instrument and acknowledged to me that he executed the same in his/her authorized capacity and that by his /her signature on the instrument the entity upon behalf of which the person acted executed the instrument WITNESS my hand and official stamp or seal this �-` _ day of MarCj , t [AFFIX NOTARY SEAL] t t 01 lie a� N ary Public My commission expires 7-2-6 - / 2— Site Name Murraysville Site Number 273409 STATE OF j , r* �1in a COUNTY OF P!P�vqoiP!^ Before me, r J, c -a ir ep the undersigned a Notai Public for the State personally appeared �e _, who is the iv of TF Holdings Limited Partnership a ALC-1 limited partnersffio personal y known to me (or proved to me on the basis of satisfactory evidence) to be the person whose name is subscribed to the within instrument and acknowledged to me that She executed the same in his/her authorized capacity and that by his /her signature on the instrument the entity upon behalf of which the person acted executed the instrument WITNESS my hand and official stamp or seal ON& 0"ry Public My commission expires % - 24 '—/ 2- JAfFIX NOTARY SEAL] t �7� t AI 1 bS; n- �1 N r 0 this &LL day of Ara— , Site Name Murraysville Site Number 273409 TENANT American Towers, a Delaware corporation Jason Hirsch Vice President Corporate Development 11 Date US Tower � `4 I o � COMMONWEALTH OF MASSACHUSETTS) ) ss COUNTY OF MIDDLESEX } Then on the �- day of �k 20 personally appeared the said ah&At 41M.14 of American Towers Inc as aforesaid signer and sealer of the foregoing instrument and acknowledged the same to be his/hei free act and deed as Vf C9 -r p ()e, v US To ivc r of American Towers Inc and the free act and deed of said corporation, before me Nr, mmission ~ Public M Expires 4q)iopi Site Name Murraysville Site Number 273409 The following exhibits are attached hereto and incorporated herein Exhibit A Description or Depiction of Property Exhibit B Description or Depiction of Site Site Name Murraysville Site Number 273409 EXHIBIT A DESCRIPTION OR DEPICTION OF PROPERTY The Property is described and /or depicted as follows Located in New Hanover County NC Being Parcel R02700 001 003 000 a 280 63 acre tract being a portion of the pioperty conveyed in Deed Book 1783 Page 1251 With a non exclusive access and utility easement across the property located in New Hanover County, NC and described as R03506 005 001 000 being a portion of the property conveyed in Deed Book 1783 Page 1251 Site Name Murraysville Site Number 273409 10:4.1101a1.1 DESCRIPTION OR DEPICTION OF SITE Preliminary description of Siteg LQAL IIEWIPTIOV OF LEAR AREA d INNING AT 1W NORTHEA919INVOST RIGHT OF WAY OF FIVE AORE ROAD, UEINO A 1 OMEN TOP MON FOUND MI-11 A NORTNINO M 9012x10902 AND AN EAVTINO M 2MIM 2069 PAID POINT BEING 1W INITIAL MINT OF bECINNINCI THFJ:ICE A 0MANGE OF 1042 60' NO7101 P7 W ALONO A TIE UNE TO A #6 REDAR FOUND THENCE A DISTANCE OF 64 08 ND71a 30 W 10 A POINT' 1HENCE A 014TANCE OF 7111 410 NO? 1N 10 W TO A POINT THEME A DISTANCE OF 87901 N8104 488E 10 A POINT THENCE A OIRtANLE OF 25 OO 6011190 E TO A POINT (90 POINT DONO THE ME POINT OF MiNINO FOR THE LEASE OITE}1 THENCE A 01RANCE OF 100 00 N0141 G8"W TO A POINT THENCE A DISTANCE OF 100 00 NO2 48 02 E TO A POINT THENCE A OWANOE OF 100 00 S07 III 11W E TO A POINT THENCE A DiRTANCE OF 100 00 SOP 400W TO A POINT SAID PQNt REMO THE TRUE POINT OF 0EMNOM OF THE LEAR NIfE 50 TRACT COVTAININO 10,009 00 8 F /0 230 ACRES LOCAL 1=9111TIO4 OF, 2b AIAINTEVANCL 1111LItY h ACCESS MEMENT "D DONNING AT THE NORTH ASTERNMW NIGHT OF WAY OF IV[ AGILE ROA9, 00110 A I" OPEN TOP IRON FCUN) WIT-1 A NORMINO (IF'' 20 2210962 AND AN EAqTMO 0 x3479[%7066 SAID POINT OEINO THE INITIAL POINT OF MMINNINO, THENCE A 611TANCE OF 1042 3C' N07DI 27V ALONG A TIE UNIE TO A $3 REDAN FOUND THENCE A DISTANCE OF M08 N0710 30V TO A POINT, (RAID MINT OEIAO THE TRUE POINT OF UEONNINO OF THE A' MAINTENAN, E 11111-ITY k AI LL19 EA it MENTI, 1001! A 11 RANCE OF 2b 60 401 1636 "W TO A PINT THENCE A DISTANCE Or 810 D1 NM OWE TO A POINT, 100I A DSTANCE OF 26 30 0011169 E TO A POINT THING A DISTAKE OF 070 00 S83VI 48 -W 10 A POINT (SAID POIN MIND 1HE Mt POINT OF REMNING OF 1HE 16 MAINTENANCE, UTLIV & A6CE63 EAMMENT) Wt) VAT CONTAIVIN4 91010 Or / 0 00 AG Landlord grants Tenant the light to use Landlord s existing Access and Utility Easement to Murrayville Road, such easement described as follows LEGAL tlESCtO001 Or 75 MAINTENANCE, UTILITY & ALMS EAWMT _A 1190INNIND AT THE NONVEAlIMNMO;1T I11UHT OF WAY OF FIVE WE ROAD, IIEINO A 1" MN TOP IRI6N P00% WITH A N0141HINO OF 2012216062 AND AN EAOTINO 0'I MOW 2060 LAID POINT HEING -HE INITIAL POINT OF IlEOINN1N01 THENCE A MAKE OF 3000' IV 309 "6 TO A POINT THMIDE A DISTANCE OF 26 Ulf' 98)4P7'W TO A POINT (SAID POINT 091NO TEE TIM POINT OE HEOINNINJ OF THE 70 MAIAIMANPE UtIuTY k ACCEM EASEMENT) THEKE A O19TANU OF 1900 407117719 TO A POINT THENCE A DISTANCE OF 616 46 90110'40'E TO A POINT THENCE A DISTANCE Or 20 16 NOW 40 E TO A POINT, THENCE A DIUTANOIi OF OM 40' NO/46'40 W TO A POINT 6AID PONT IMNO THE TRUE POINT OF IIEOINNING OF THE 4 MAINTENANCE UTILITY k ACCE09 EAREWNT SAID TRACT GONTAININO 14 4911 % / O 11 AC 1.0h 11E, M13114N OF 18 MAINTENANCE. 1111LITY & AME4,9 EASEMENT 13" DEOINNINO AT THE NORTHEARERNM09T RIGHT OF WAY OF FIVE ACRE ROAD BEINO A 1 OPEN TOP IRCN FOUND WH A NORTHNd OP 7011719907 AND AN EAIRNO 0- 71 A U AM SAID POINT A©NG -HE INITIAL POINT OF AEGINNING THENC E A MSTANI E OF 20 91 902 2322 % T9 A POINT, SAID POINT MINO THE TNVE P0141 OF OEOINNINO OF 1HI1 24 MAINTI3'IANCE, UTILITY & 401196 MEME" THENCE A OII ;TANGE OF A 00 661 IS AI"W TO A PONT THENCE A MOTANCIE OP 105 08 N0148 191 TO A POINT THENCE A DISTANiE OF Wi O NO61O'38 "W T1 A POINT THENCE A DISTANCE OF 2800 N0741'16'E 10 A POINT THENCE A Rum or 33141 SOO IC A E 10 A POINT, THENCE 4 DISTANCE OF 103 31) 007 9 30 E TO A POINT SAID POINT BEING THE TRUE PONT OF IIEOINNINO OF THE 10 MAINTENANCE, UTILITY & AC1,t314 EA'IEMENT `SAID TRACT CONTAINING 46,010 3 F / 0 80 AG p{Qn $ a w S mho o~ of z Z _ z 5� q q 11MIML z � w r z,� 5 ry�p GSa0.g �taQN� ?m O �3 qq Q a0 S z z aiQS a o��"R�io'sl - �7 qqgg �NN V) o o rctn w� FtkA ~ n � a Fg 0�{{{f�pqoZ� C� F 3 gOZnpy UySy1f°�w = =pp E Z <Wx§ U%t6r�� riGl 1,v7C700 � 961!0:96 t 0�6�Qm �y U O Q al Z np�t i�u` O Z Ld m Syri= <pap la�ZtS3 �Q1!&.96 Q� o��� K t _4 � GZ Q 21 p gtg�i z �UZ7� < n. w O�� � �mZQ�� IC31 �k W Z` F a�om{{a11JJ� �' gzi'^a Q�'qq ' w (n v Q N o`O y"�Fi' o I)- d aG og°d�z,(L oy 4�nQ�„f Z zJ� R 14,TG n ZiER 8. 1i Zh _ �iPXmZ o* ,$ !Y BEE \ \\unnnuln�� yl d W IL yG@ z K 'S 'm C a 005 �'i-O VCzS p- Psa�i G zpp 33i ttyV���111 �aaa mm_U wfl H�71f11111411 IOr� ~gg3 0 i l I I pP p4 \4I Ib2% m a 1 1 1 1 Ua $ m ° W , ap Z w LLJ le a w Q� o� 1 IIII414ifK} U a� vi � 33w�in o s�g �pSpBpSpS �aa$8 °oS �°o8mv18�: �o8MN�8!99 8is8wv� -Its 0000 �NN� N x (q +jN n 9 ". A � NN V, t3�� ¢..`�" R P MO '} °°Owx ?m �a Ss sM ;��� 4 < r r r r a r P zww pNp zmo F Zm �p qp W� F W ppp pp pF papF 3� ���$�j 41 Z 2N SZ N Jm ZTZ � N VIN IfI .LZ 181 _1`21V 7oa000 wrlulic�c�S�i �mmm °m�mm �sa"�aaa d IRA 2 Ig it 1 4 S Ig 1 I} Itl o7.01 W W I .� `A4 III 19 i 93 CIO 3 U W Q s I C) a- 0 1�� "g nf I I } I B I I M 1� 4 APPENDIX F INFORMAL BIOLOGICAL ASSESSMENT r United States Department of the Inte>i for FISH AND WILDLIFE SERVICE s Raleigh Field Office Post Office Box 33726 4R 'gyp Raleigh North Carolina 27636 3726 June 21 2006 Susan Keller Environmental Corporation of America 1375 Uinon Hill Industrial Court Suite A Alphatetta, GA 30004 Dear Ms Keller Due to numerous mqunies conceining the potential impact of communication tower projects on federally listed threatened and endangered species, migratory birds and wildlife habitat the Raleigh Field Office of the U S Fish and Wildlife Service (Service) is no longer able to review and respond to each individual tower site proposed for construction within our area of responsibility (see attached county list) Instead, we are providing information to assist the action agency, or then designated representative (tower owner or their consultant), in meeting their requirements under the Endangered §pecies Act, as amended (16 US C 1531 et seq , ESA) and the Migratory Bird Treaty Act (16 U S C 103 et seq , MBTA) Thig information is intended to aid the applicant in determir ng when communication tower projects would and would not require concurrence from this office regarding potential impacts to federally listed species Generally, projects which involve the following actions are not likely to affect any federally listed threatened or endangered species, wetlands, or other resources undei .jurisdiction of the U S Fish and Wildlife Service • Projects that do not involve new construction activities, • Construction of new toweis or placement of antennae assemblies which are co located with an existing structure (tower, building, water tank, smokestack, etc ) • Construction of new towels in areas that are currently used for agricultural practices (farms) of in areas previously disturbed by commercial development • Routine maintenance of existing tower sites such as painting, antenna or panel replacement, upgrading of existing equipment etc , • Repair or replacement of existing towels and/or equipment, provided such activities do not significantly increase the existing tower mass and height require the addifion of gay wnes or increase the siz6 or location of the existingpad site or equipment shelter, and/or • Projects that receive a "no effect!' determination as described below It is not necessary to contact the Raleigh Field Office about the actions hsted above For those proposed projects that do not meet these criteria (e g new tower sites on undeveloped land), we offer the following information with regards to threatened and endangered species migratory birds and wetlands Threatened and Endanger ed Species Section 7 of the Endangered Species Act requires that all federal agencies (or their designated non federal representative), in consultation with the Service insure that any action federally authorized funded or carried out by such agencies is not likely to jeopardize the continued existence of any federally listed endangered or threatened species A biological assessment or evaluation may be prepared to fulfill that requirement and in determining whether additional consultation with the Service is necessary A county hstm.g of all federally protected endangered and threatened species with known occurrences in North Carolina is now available on our web page at h / /nc es fws gov /es /countyfr html In addition to the federally protected species list, information on the species' life histories and habitats and information on completing a biological assessment or evaluation and can be found on our web page at httn / /nc es fws gov /es /es htrni. Please check the web site often for updated information or changes If your project contains suitable habitat for any of the federally listed species known to be present within the county where your project occurs, the proposed action has the potential to adversely affect those species As such, we recommend that a qualified biologist conduct surveys to determine the species' presence or absence within the project area The use of North Carolina Natural Heritage progiam data should not be substituted for actual field surveys Please note that surveys for red cockaded woodpecker cavity trees should be conducted within a one half mile radius of the proposed project site and that surveys for bald eagle nests should be conducted within a one nule radius of the proposed project site Adjacent property owners within the survey area should be contacted before surveys are performed Surveys for federally listed plant species should be conducted during the appropriate survey window as identified on our web site http / /nc es fws gov /plant/optinal survey windows for plants html If you determine that the pr oposed action will have no effect (i e no beneficial or adverse dal ect or andu ect effect) on feder ally lasted species then you are not required to contact our office for concurrence However, you should maintain a complete record of the site assessment including steps leading to your determination of effect, the qualifications of personnel conducting the assessment, habitat conditions site photographs and any other related articles If you deter mane that the proposed action may affect (i e likely to adversely affect or not likely to adversely affect) a feder ally protected species you should note this office with your determination the r esults of your surveys survey methodologies and an analysis of the effects of the action on lasted species including consideration of du ect indirect and cumulative effects befor e conducting any activities that might affect the species The Service will either concur that your project is not likely to adversely affect federally protected species or recommend the initiation of the formal consultation process 2 Mratory Birds All native migratory birds (e g, waterfowl, shorebnds, passerines hawks owls vultures, falcons) are afforded protection under the Migratory Bird Treaty Act (40 Stat 755, 16 U S C 703 712) Communication towers and antennas may pose a hazaid to migratory birds in flight and may pose a threat to nesting birds attracted to the site, depending on tower height, physical design, lighting, and site location The Service has adopted draft guidehnes for the siting construction, and operation of communication towers that would minimise the potential for avian collisions These draft guidelines are included with this letter and are also available on our web site at htti) / /nc es fws goy/es/Tower guidelines udf We recorrunend that they be implemented on all future communication tower projects Wetlands and Wildlife Habitat Wetlands and riparian corridors are high priority fish and wildlife habitat and a resource of national concern They serve as unportant sources of food, cover, and habitat for numerous species of resident and migratory fish and wildlife Waterfowl and other migratory birds use wetlands and riparian corridors as stopover feeding, and nesting areas In addition sustaining the integrity of wetland systems is an important mechanism for maintaining water quality conditions for aquatic resources For these reasons we strongly recommend that the sites selected for communications towers and other projects not impact wetlands and riparian areas and be located as far as possible from these areas Migratory birds tend to concentrate in or near wetlands and riparian areas and use these areas as migratory flyways and dispersal corridors, which could exacerbate the documented problein of birds being killed by flying into and strAmg the towers If you anticipate unavoidable impacts to wetlands, you should contact the appropriate U S Army Corps of Engineers office to determine if a permit is required by that agency prior to commencement of construction activities Again due to our existing pioject workload the Raleigh Field Office is no longer able to respond to each request for concurrence that we receive on communication tower projects If you do not receive a response from our office within 35 days of your letter being mailed to our office, you can assume that we concur with your findings We hope that the information provided in this letter clarifies the consultation process while continuing to protect our trust resources If you have any questions or comments, please contact Mr Dale Suiter of this office at (919) 856 -4520 extension 18 Enclosures Sincerely, ti P Benjamin Ecological Services Supervisor 3 List of Counties in the U S Fish and Wildlife Service's Raleigh Field Office Area of Responsibility Alamance Lee Beaufort Lenoir Berke Martm Braden Montgomery Brunswick Moore Camden Nash Carteret New Hanover Caswell Northampton Chatham Onslow Chowan Oiange Columbus Pamlico Craven Pasquotank Cumberland Pender Cuirituck Peiqunmans Dare Person Duplm Pitt Durham Randolph Edgecombe Richmond Franklin Robeson Gates Rockingham Granville Sampson Greene Scotland Guilford Tyrrell Halifax Vance Harnett Wake Hertford Warren Hoke Washington Hyde Wayne Johnston Wilson Jones 4 Service Interim Guidelines For Recommendations On Communications Tower Siting, Construction, Operation, and Decommissioning 1 Any company /applicantlhcensee proposing to construct a new communications tower is strongly encouraged to co locate the communications equipment on an existing communication tower or other structure (e g billboard water tower, or building mount) Depending on tower load factors from 6 to 10 providers may collocate on an existing tower 2 if collocation is not feasible and anew tower or towels are to be constructed communications service providers are strongly encouraged to construct towers no more than 199 feet above ground level (AGL) using construction techniques which do not require guy wires (e g use a lattice structure monopole etc ) Such towers should be unlighted if Federal Aviation Administration regulations permit. 3 If constructing multiple towers providers should consider the cumulative impacts of all of those towers to migratory birds and threatened and endangered species as well as the impacts of each individual tower 4 If at all possible new towers should be sited within existing 'antenna farms (clusters of towers) Towers should not be sited in or near wetlands, other known bird concentration areas (e g state or Federal refuges staging areas rookeries) in known migratory or daily movement flyways or m habitat of threatened or endangered species Towers should not be sited in areas with a high incidence of fog mist and low ceilings 5 If taller ( >199 feet AGL) towers requiring lights for aviation safety must be constructed, the minimum amount of pilot warning and obstruction avoidance hghtrng required by the FAA should be used Unless otherwise required by the FAA only white (preferable) or red strobe fights should be used at right, and these should be the minimum number minimum intensity and minimum number of flashes per minute (longest duration between flashes) allowable by the FAA The use of solid red or pulsating red warning lights at night should be avoided Current research indicates that solid or pulsating (beacon) red lights attract night migrating birds at a much higher rate than white strobe lights Red strobe lights have not yet been studied 6 Tower designs using guy wines for support which are proposed to be located in known raptor or waterbnrd concentration areas or daily movement routes, or in major diurnal migratory bird movement routes or stopover sites, should have daytime visual markers on the wires to prevent collisions by these diurnally moving species (For guidance on markers see Avian Powei Lane Interaction Committee (APLIC) 1994 Mitigating Bird Collisions with Power Lanes The State of the Art in 1994 Edison Electric Institute Washington, D C 78 pp, and Avian Power Line Intet action Committee (APLIC) 1996 Suggested Practices for Raptor Protection on Power Lines Edison Flectr ac IristitutelRaptor Research Foundation, Washington D C,128 pp Copies can be obtained via the Internet at http / /www eel org/resources /pubcat/enviro/ or by calling 1 800/334 5453) 7 Towers and appendant facilities should be sited designed and constructed so as to avoid or minimize habitat loss within and adjacent to the tower `footprint However, a larger tower footprint is preferable to the use of gay wires in construction Road access and fencing should be minimized to reduce or prevent habitat fragmentation and disturbance and to reduce above ground obstacles to birds in flight 8 If significant numbers of breeding feeding or roosting birds are known to habitually use the proposed tower construction area relocation to an alternate site is recommended If this is not an option seasonal restrictions on construction may be advisable in order to avoid disturbance during periods of high bird activity 9 In order to reduce the number of towers needed in the future, providers are encouraged to design new towers structurally and electrically to accommodate the applicant/licensee s antennas and comparable antennas for at least two additional users (minimum of three users for each tower structure) unless this design would require the addition of lights or guy wires to an otherwise unlighted and/or unguyed tower 10 Security hghtmg for on ground facilities and equipment should be down shielded to keep fight within the boundaries of the site 11 If a tower is constructed or proposed for construction Service personnel or researchers from the Communication Tower Working Group should be allowed access to the site to evaluate bird use conduct dead bird searches to place net catchments below the towers but above the ground, and to place radar Global Positioning System, infrared thermal imagery and acoustical monitoring equipment as necessary to assess and verify bird movements and to gain information on the impacts of various tower sizes, configurations and lighting systems 12 Towers no longer in use or determined to be obsolete should be removed within 12 months of cessation of use February 14 2012 Erik Carlson American Tower Corporation 10 Presidential Way Woburn MA 01801 Subject Murraysville NC Mabee Way Wilmington NC Project No M 382 2 Environmental Corporation of America (ECA) is assisting American Tower Corporation with environmental due diligence at the subject site In conjunction with the FCC NEPA Environmental Checklist the purpose of this letter is to provide American Tower Corporation with documentation of our investigations and findings relative to federally or state protected species and /or critical habitat migratory birds and wetlands indicators at the subject site In accordance with 47 CFR 1 1307 (a) 3 ECA conducted an Informal Biological Assessment (IBA) to identify whether any Federal or State listed species will be affected by the proposed project Project Description The federal undertaking includes construction of a telecommunications facility including a fenced compound within a 100 foot by 100 foot lease area and an 87 foot (90 foot overall height) monopole tower structure The lease area will be accessed via an approximate 2 534 foot by 25 foot proposed access /utility easement approximately 1 655 feet of which is existing As part of this review ECA also assessed approximately 30 feet in all directions outside of the proposed lease area and evaluated the assessment area for federally and state protected species Project Location The lease area additional assessment area and portions of the access /utility easement are occupied by undeveloped wooded land The 2 534 foot by 25 foot proposed access /utility easement would traverse Mabee Way an existing paved road in a northerly direction from Murrayville Road and then turn eastward through an area of wooded land toward the lease area as shown on the Site Plan in Appendix D Photographs of the project area are included in Appendix A Descriptions of the photographs are provided underneath each photograph and photograph locations are graphically depicted on the Site Plan in Appendix D The address listed in this report and throughout the attachments is the best approximation of this projects address at the time environmental services were ordered It should be noted that the address may change once the E 911 address is established by the local municipality Regardless of any change of address that may occur in the future the position location and description of the site assessed during this project are as described herein Wetland Discussion According to the USDA New Hanover County Web Soil Survey soils found within the project area and access /utility easement are Seagate fine sand and Murville fine sand Seagate soils are moderately well drained soils typically found on flats on marine terraces Murville soils are very poorly drained soils typically found on depressions and flats on marine terraces These soils are listed as hydric In New Hanover County North Carolina Environmental Corp of America Page 1 0:7121 ECA has conducted a formal wetland delineation of the proposed project area The findings of the delineation indicate that portions of the lease area additional assessment area and access /utility easement are occupied by apparent jurisdictional forested wetlands Further based on National Wetlands Inventory data the lease area additional assessment area and non existing portion of the access /utility easement are mapped as a wetland area ECA recommends that identified wetland boundaries be confirmed by the Wilmington District U S Army Corp of Engineers and if impacts to Jurisdictional wetlands or waters are proposed that the proper authorizations be obtained prior to commencement of any site development activities Threatened and Endangered Species Discussion ECA has reviewed the most current US Fish and Wildlife Service ( USFWS) Endangered or Threatened Species by County List for New Hanover County North Carolina and the North Carolina Natural Heritage Program Database Locations of Rare Species Element Occurrences by 7 5 Minute USGS Quadrangle ECA has also reviewed information from various sources pertaining to the habitat requirements of the listed species The USFWS has developed interim guidelines providing recommendations on location and construction of communications towers in an effort to minimize impacts to migratory birds ECA has reviewed these guidelines (included in Appendix E) Habitat at the site was evaluated during our February 16 2011 site visit which was conducted by Ben Salter of ECA Species with a state or federal threatened or endangered or proposed threatened or endangered status that are recognized as inhabiting the Scotts Hill North Carolina 7 5 minute Quadrangle or New Hanover County North Carolina are listed below as well as in Table 1 Descriptions of these species are provided in Appendix E Because the proposed undertaking would not impact any open waters aquatic species are not a concern for this undertaking The American alligator (Alligator mississippfensis) is listed as a federally threatened species in New Hanover County North Carolina This species is found primarily in freshwater swamps and marshes but also in rivers lakes and smaller bodies of water Due to the lack of any significant bodies of water near the project area ECA believes that no suitable habitat for the American alligator is present The piping plover (Charadrius melodus) is listed as a federally threatened species in New Hanover County North Carolina The piping plover generally nests along the sandy beaches of the Atlantic Coast and the gravelly shorelines of lakes Piping plover breeding territories include feeding areas such as a dune pond or a slough or near a lake shore or ocean edge No suitable habitat for the piping plover is present within the project area Furthermore this species is not listed as being present within the Scotts Hill USGS 7 5 minute Quadrangle Map The red cockaded woodpecker (Pfcofdes borealis) is listed as a federally and state endangered species in New Hanover County North Carolina and within the Scotts Hill USGS 7 5 minute Quadrangle Map The red cockaded woodpecker generally nests in mature pine with low understory vegetation and forage in large pine and pine hardwood stands greater than 30 years in age and preferably greater than 10 inches in diameter No pine observed near the proposed project area were mature enough to provide a suitable habitat for the red cockaded woodpecker and the understory in the project area is composed of dense shrubs and hardwoods Cooley s meadowrue (Thahctrum cooleyi) is listed as a federally and state endangered species in New Hanover County North Carolina and within the Scotts Hill USGS 7 5 minute Quadrangle Map Cooley s meadowrue occurs on circumneutral soils in grass sedge bogs and wet pine savannas It may also grow along fire plow lines in roadside ditches and woodland clearings No suitable habitat for Cooley s meadowrue is present within the project area Golden sedge (Carex lutea) is listed as a federally endangered species in New Hanover County North Carolina Golden sedge grows in sandy soils underlain by coquina limestone deposits where the soil is calcareous Soils supporting the species are very wet to periodically shallowly inundated The species prefers the ecotone (narrow transition zone between two diverse ecological communities) between the pine savanna and adjacent wet hardwood or hardwood /conifer forest Most plants occur in the partially shaded savanna /swamp where occasional to frequent fires favor an herbaceous ground layer and suppress shrub dominance The wetland areas within the project impact area are vegetated with a thick woody shrub understory Therefore no suitable habitat for golden sedge is present within the project area Furthermore this species is not listed as being present within the Scotts Hill USGS 7 5 minute Quadrangle Map Rough leaf loosestnfe (Lysfmachfa asperulifolia) is listed as a federally and state endangered species in New Hanover County North Carolina and within the Scotts Hill USGS 7 5 minute Quadrangle Map Rough leaf Environmental Corp of America Page 2 0:71A] loosestrfe generally occurs In the ecotones or edges between open stands of mature longleaf pine /oak and areas of dense shrub and vine growth usually on a wet peaty poorly drained soils The subject site consists of a densely forested area with a dense woody understory No ecotones between this habitat and mature longleaf pine /oak habitat were present In the project Impact area No suitable habitat for rough leaf loosestnfe is present within the project area Seabeach amaranth (Amaranthus pumdus) Is listed as a federally and state threatened species in New Hanover County North Carolina and within the Scotts HIII USGS 7 5 minute Quadrangle Map Seabeach amaranth occurs on barrier Island beaches where Its primary habitat consists of overwash flats at accreting ends of Islands and lower foredunes and upper strands of non eroding beaches No suitable habitat for seabeach amaranth is present within the project area Big three awn grass (Anstida condensata) Is listed as a state threatened species within the Scotts HIII USGS 7 5 minute Quadrangle Map This species is generally found along Carolina bay rims and prefers areas of xeric pine /oak scrub habitat The subject site is a dense forested wetland No suitable habitat for big three awn grass is present within the project area Snowy orchid (Plantanthera n►vea) is listed as a state threatened species within the Scotts HIII USGS 7 5 minute Quadrangle Map This species is generally found in moist open pinelands and wet prairies The subject site consists of a densely forested area with a dense woody understory No suitable habitat for the snowy orchid is present within the project area Tracy s beaksedge (Rhynchospora tracyi) Is listed as a state threatened species within the Scotts HIII USGS 7 5 minute Quadrangle Map This species is generally found In clay based depressions In open coastal marshland No suitable habitat for Tracy s beaksedge Is present within the project area Drooping bulrush (Sc►rpus 1►neatus) is listed as a state threatened species within the Scotts HIII USGS 7 5 minute Quadrangle Map This species is generally found In open wetland prairies and open hardwood forested wetlands The subject site Is a densely forested wetland with a generally dense shrub understory No suitable habitat for drooping bulrush is present within the project area The eastern diamondback rattlesnake (Crotalus adamanteus) is listed as a state endangered species within the Scotts HIII USGS 7 5 minute Quadrangle Map This species generally inhabits dry sandy areas palmetto or wiregrass flatwoods pinewoods coastal dune habitats or hardwood hammocks They generally avoid wet areas No suitable habitat for the eastern diamondback rattlesnake Is present within the project area The eastern woodrat (Neotoma flondana) is listed as a state threatened species within the Scotts Hill USGS 7 5 minute Quadrangle Map The eastern woodrat is a habitat generalist This species can be found in habitats ranging from swamplands along the lower Mississippi River through forested uplands to the and plains of eastern Colorado Therefore ECA does not believe that the proposed undertaking would reduce the availability of eastern woodrat habitat In the area and would have no effect on this species Migratory Bird Discussion The 90 foot monopole telecommunications tower will be built on anew 100 foot by 100 foot lease area and will Include a 2 534 foot by 25 foot access easement/utility easement The project area and tower structure does appear to be located near a principal migration route of the Atlantic Flyway Upon our site Investigation It was determined that the project area is not located in a mapped waterway wildlife refuge national wilderness area native grassland or forest area ridge line mountain top coastline or area commonly known to have high incidences of fog or low clouds where migratory birds may be found The nearest significant body of water is Smith Creek located approximately 2 500 feet south of the subject site Although wetlands are located within and surrounding the project area these areas would not act as migratory bird attractants The proposed tower will be 90 feet (overall height) According to the current available studies such as the Michigan State Police Tower Study towers above 500 appear to have more of an effect on migratory birds than towers that are shorter than 500 While a more comprehensive and /or a long term study may provide different results based on the efforts undertaken during this IBA as well as the current data made available from studies being conducted we have concluded that there is minimal potential for the proposed project to have a significant effect on migratory bird species Furthermore this tower will be constructed to accept future collocations thus reducing the need to build additional towers within the Immediate project area In addition as recommended in the USFWS Service Interim Guidelines for Recommendations on Communications Tower Siting Construction Operation and Decommissioning the tower will be less than 200 feet tall no guy wires will be used and the tower will not be lit minimizing the chance for migratory bird strikes Environmental Corp of America Page 3 I The findings In the above paragraphs suggest that measures for minimizing Impacts to migratory birds have been Incorporated Into this proposed undertaking and suggest that there will be no overall Increased risk to migratory birds based upon the specifications of this project Conclusions Based on the Information reviewed and our site Inspection ECA has found no evidence suggesting that state or federally protected species Inhabit the site or the Immediate site area (Impact zone) It Is our opinion that the proposed project will not Impact state or federally protected species or designated critical habitat Based on the proposed tower design and location no adverse Impacts to migratory birds are anticipated We have Included a Tower Site Evaluation Form in Appendix E Based on a wetlands delineation conducted by ECA within the project area portions of the lease area additional assessment area and access /utility easement are occupied by apparent jurisdictional forested wetlands ECA recommends that identified wetland boundaries be confirmed by the Wilmington District U S Army Corp of Engineers and if impacts to jurisdictional wetlands or waters are proposed that the proper authorizations be obtained prior to commencement of any site development activities Ben Salter of ECA conducted the site visit and area Inspection Mitch Clark collected the applicable information and compiled this report Mr Salter reviewed this report Mr Salter Is a degreed Biologist His resume is included In Appendix F Site Assessor O�Aa4 Mitch Clark Project Scientist Environmental Corp of America Page 4 Senior Reviewer Ben Salter Principal Scientist Table 1 Species List ATC Action Area Habitat Species Assessment Species Name Federal Species State Species Species Habitat Requirement Species Rationale Status Status Effect American alligator Federal Threatened Freshwater swamps and marshes 1 No Effect No suitable habitat present (Alligator but also in rivers lakes and smaller mississippiensis) bodies of water Piping plover Federal Threatened Generally nests along the sandy 1 No Effect No suitable habitat present (Charadnus beaches of the Atlantic Coast and melodus) the gravelly shorelines of lakes Piping plover breeding territories include feeding areas such as a dune pond or a slough or near a lake shore or ocean edge Red cockaded Federal Endangered State Endangered Nests in mature pine with low 1 No Effect No suitable habitat present woodpecker understory vegetation and forage in (Picoides borealis) large pine and pine hardwood stands greater than 30 years in age and preferably greater than 10 inches in diameter Cooley s meadowrue Federal Endangered State Endangered Occurs on circumneutral sods in 1 No Effect No suitable habitat present (Thalictrum cooleyi) grass sedge bogs and wet pine savannas It may also grow along fire plow lines in roadside ditches and woodland clearings Golden sedge Federal Endangered Sandy sods underlain by coquina 1 No Effect No suitable habitat present (Carex lutea) limestone deposits where the sod is calcareous Sods supporting the species are very wet to periodically shallowly inundated The species prefers the ecotone (narrow transition zone between two diverse ecological communities) between the pine savanna and adjacent wet hardwood or hardwood /conifer forest Most plants occur in the partially shaded savanna/swamp where occasional to frequent fires favor an herbaceous ground layer and suppress shrub dominance Rough leaf Federal Endangered State Endangered Occurs in the ecotones or edges 1 No Effect No suitable habitat present loosestnfe between open stands of mature (Lysimachia longleaf pine /oak and areas of asperulifolia) dense shrub and vine growth usually on a wet peaty poorly drained sods Seabeach amaranth Federal Threatened State Threatened Occurs on barrier island beaches 1 No Effect No suitable habitat present (Amaranthus where its primary habitat consists of pumdus) overwash flats at accreting ends of islands and lower foredunes and upper strands of non eroding beaches Big three awn grass State Threatened Carolina bay rims and prefers areas 1 No Effect No suitable habitat present (Anstida of xenc pine /oak scrub habitat condensata) Snowy orchid State Threatened Moist open pmelands and wet 1 No Effect No suitable habitat present (Plantanthera nivea) prairies Environmental Corp of America Page 5 1 . Species Name Federal Species State Species Species Habitat Requirement Species Rationale Status Status Effect Tracy s beaksedge State Threatened Clay based depressions in open 1 No Effect No suitable habitat present (Rhynchospora coastal marshland tracyi) Drooping bulrush State Threatened Open wetland prairies and open 1 No Effect No suitable habitat present (Scirpus (meatus) hardwood forested wetlands Eastern State Endangered Dry sandy areas palmetto or 1 No Effect No suitable habitat present diamondback wiregrass flatwoods pinewoods rattlesnake (Crotalus coastal dune habitats or hardwood adamanteus) hammocks Eastern woodrat State Threatened Swamplands along the lower 1 No Effect Species is a habitat (Neotoma flondana) Mississippi River through forested generalist undertaking uplands to the and plains of would not reduce habitat eastern Colorado availability No evidence of species was observed Environmental Corp of America Page 6 Appendix A: Photos A: Northerly View From Near the Center of Proposed Lease Area B: Easterly View From Near the Center of Proposed Lease Area Environmental Corp of America C: Southerly View From Near the Center of Proposed Lease Area D: Westerly View From Near the Center of Proposed Lease Area Environmental Corp of America 16 =-- . - Ami& r, W**'4 - r�� e r i Appendix B: NWI Maps 2 aai t O N U) a) E o o LL W LL C t d m` }� m M m rm LL LL W W LL J (� Z Z u E o Z mc v ; E 3a -a3 �m �t i..� v E �m35 a Z e e r L tsY ry L d N Appendix C: Site Location Map Image Provided by Environmental Data Resources, Inc. Source: USGS Scale: 1" = 909' SITE LOCATION MAP .1ri.co� Murraysville NC ATC Site #: 273409 Mabee Way Wilmington, NC DATE: 02/24/2011 CONSULTANT PROJ. #: M -382 -2 Image Provided by Environmental Data Resources, Inc. AERIAL PHOTOGRAPH Murraysville NC ATC Site #: 273409 Mabee Way Wilmington, NC DATE: 02/24/2011 CONSULTANT PROJ. #: M -382 -2 Imaae Provided by ESRI N,y wA"4tlon Rd SITE o ?D Oop w", a +r b° � tQ�O` R1fh Gnck °r CL � �f "^xn °r Gr RA J A Spn ^p °� U f MNI Ga • � � OrMh C � � 8 y Y = 4 Acre Rd ♦ O° Rfce Gel° i a A � a. d u M—yr n° Rd m m 0 fer ^dale °i o < S MaadownN Aw r V p pine Knoll Rd i Raw Hawn DT d o n 6 %r 40 VJ Sherman Oaks °r n°rO Rlr° Ri60° Pd yl NaQ°rd «n Or In Ni °jh164T SMIa Cr B undaries of the Property are Approximate. STREET MAP Murraysville NC 4° ray ATC Site #: 273409 a } Mabee Way Wilmington, NC °r: DATE: 02/24/2011 CONSULTANT PROJ. #: M -382 -2 Appendix D: Site Plan v a N N 00 m ION M 3 a xZ a °— e z ww a z�� VI J OF LLI 0 W N w OW N a ~ a0 �„ U m EL I °cm v I CD o w oa p 0 m I a (-) I 0 j �� to to v m N < Q -v v m m h Q o IL — •o N I j N I � W O co M m I Z ° m w ___ �C� ; _ •� IL Z Z I o O V) 3 mo I m _ ° N j w N N _ a Q I -- - -- --- a� ° r -- -- - - - - -- -- Z 0 — -- _ — — — -- U T � m V) 0 U 7 Q V 0-2 cv U O r— M -v .20 m -t c) 0 a c s m rnE —°o W W N J W cn O H O Z Appendix E Resources New Hanover County Endangered Species, Threatened Species,Federal Sp Pagel of 4 Endangered Species, Threatened Species,Federal Species of Concern, and Candidate Species, New Hanover County, North Carolina Updated 09 -22 -2010 Critical Habitat Designations Piping plover - Charadrius melodus - See the Federal Register for a description of the primary constituent elements essential for the conservation of wintering piping plovers within the designated units This document also contains a map and a description of each designated unit Federal Register Reference July10, 2001, Federal Register, 66 36038936136 TR VALIGN =TOP> Common Name Vertebrate American alli ag_tor American eel Carolina crawfish frog Eastern painted bunting Green sea turtle Loggerhead sea turtle Mimic glass lizard Northern pine snake Scientific name Alligator mississippiensis Anguilla rostrata Rana capito capito Passerina ciris ciris Chelonia mydas Caretta caretta Ophisaurus mimicus Pituophis melanoleucus melanoleucus Federal Record Status Status T (S /A) Current FSC Current FSC Current FSC Current T Current T Current FSC Historic FSC Current http / /www fws gov /nc- es /es /cntylist /new_hanover html 2/15/2011 New Hanover County Endangered Species, Threatened Species,Federal Sp Page 2 of 4 Piping plover Charadrius melodus T Current Rafinesque's big -eared bat Corynorhinus rafinesquii FSC Current Red - cockaded woodpecker Picoides borealis E Current Shortnose sturgeon Acipenser brevirostrum E Current Southeastern myotis Myotns austroriparius FSC Current Southern hognose snake Heterodon simus FSC Current West Indian manatee Trichechus manatus E Current Invertebrate Buchholz's dart moth Agrotis buchholzi FSC Current Cape Fear threetooth Triodopsis soelneri FSC Current Eastern beard grass skipper Atrytone arogos arogos FSC Obscure Greenfield rams -horn Helisoma eucosmium FSC Historic Loammi skipper Atrytonopsis loammi FSC Obscure Magnificent rams -horn Planorbella magnifica FSC Historic Rare skipper Problema bulenta FSC Current Vascular Plant Bog St John's -wort Hypericum adpressum FSC Historic Carolina bishopweed Ptilamnium ahlesn FSC Current Carolina lead -plant Amorpha georgiana var FSC Historic confusa Coastal beaksedge Rhynchospora pleiantha FSC Current Coastal goldenrod Solidago villosicarpa FSC Historic Cooley's meadowrue Thalictrum cooleyi E Current Dune blue curls Trichostema sp 1 FSC Current False coco Pteroglossaspis ecristata FSC Historic Golden sedge Carex lutea E Probable /Potential Grassleaf arrowhead Sagittaria weatherbiana FSC Current Pickering's dawnflower Stylisma pickeringn var FSC Current pickeringn Pondspice Litsea aestivalis FSC Current Raven's boxseed Ludwigia ravenn FSC Historic Rough- leaved loosestrife Lysimachia asperulaefoha E Current Sandhills milk -vetch Astragalus mcchauxra FSC Historic Seabeach amaranth Amaranthus pumilus T Current Small- leaved meadow -rue Thalictrum macrostylum FSC Current Spring - flowering goldenrod Solidago verna FSC Current Tough bumelia Sideroxylon tenax FSC Historic http / /www fws gov /nc- es /es /cntylist/new_hanover html 2/15/2011 New Hanover County Endangered Species, Threatened Species,Federal Sp Page 3 of 4 Venus' fly -trap Nonvascular Plant Lichen Dionaea muscipula FSC Current Definitions of Federal Status Codes E = endangered A taxon "in danger of extinction throughout all or a significant portion of its range " T = threatened A taxon "likely to become endangered within the foreseeable future throughout all or a significant portion of its range " C = candidate A taxon under consideration for official listing for which there is sufficient information to support listing (Formerly "C1" candidate species ) BGPA =Bald and Golden Eagle Protection Act See below FSC = federal species of concern A species under consideration for listing, for which there is insufficient information to support listing at this time These species may or may not be listed in the future, and many of these species were formerly recognized as "C2" candidate species T(S /A) = threatened due to similarity of appearance A taxon that is threatened due to similarity of appearance with another listed species and is listed for its protection Taxa listed as T(S /A) are not biologically endangered or threatened and are not subject to Section 7 consultation See below EXP = experimental population A taxon listed as experimental (either essential or nonessential) Experimental, nonessential populations of endangered species (e g , red wolf) are treated as threatened species on public land, for consultation purposes, and as species proposed for listing on private land P = proposed Taxa proposed for official listing as endangered or threatened will be noted as "PE" or "PT ", respectively Bald and Golden Eagle Protection Act (BGPA) In the July 9 2007 Federal Register( 72 37346 - 37372), the bald eagle was declared recovered, and removed (de listed) from the Federal List of Threatened and Endangered wildlife This delistmg took effect August 8,2007 After delistmg, the Bald and Golden Eagle Protection Act (Eagle Act) (16 U S C 668 -668d) becomes the primary law protecting bald eagles The Eagle Act prohibits take of bald and golden eagles and provides a statutory definition of "take" that includes "disturb" The USFWS has developed National Bald Eagle Management Guidelines to provide guidance to land managers, landowners, and others as to how to avoid disturbing bald eagles For mor information, visit http / /www fws ov /mi rg atorybirds/baldeagle htm Threatened due to similari , of appearance(T(S /A)) In the November 4, 1997 Federal Register (55822 - 55825), the northern population of the bog turtle (from New York south to Maryland) was listed as T (threatened), and the http / /www fws gov /nc- es /es /cntylist/new_hanover html 2/15/2011 New Hanover County Endangered Species, Threatened Species,Federal Sp Page 4 of 4 southern population (from Virginia south to Georgia) was listed as T(S /A) (threatened due to similarity of appearance) The T(S /A) designation bans the collection and interstate and international commercial trade of bog turtles from the southern population The T(S /A) designation has no effect on land management activities by private landowners in North Carolina, part of the southern population of the species In addition to its official status as T(S /A), the U S Fish and Wildlife Service considers the southern population of the bog turtle as a Federal species of concern due to habitat loss Definitions of Record Status Current - the species has been observed in the county within the last 50 years Historic - the species was last observed in the county more than 50 years ago Obscure - the date and/or location of observation is uncertain Incidental /migrant - the species was observed outside of its normal range or habitat Probable /potential - the species is considered likely to occur in this county based on the proximity of known records (in adjacent counties), the presence of potentially suitable habitat, or both http / /www fws gov /nc es /es /cntylist/new_hanover html 2/15/2011 Topo Map Record Search Results Pagel of 2 TOPOGRAPHIC MAP RECORD SEARCH RESULTS Search Criteria [Topo Map Name is like Scotts Hill] [Any Scientific Name] [Any Common Name] [Any State Rank] [Any Global Rank] [Any Name Category] [Any Protection Status] Records Returned [Animal Assemblage 1] [Invertebrate Animal 2] [Natural Community 3] [Vascular Plant 16] [Vertebrate Animal 9] [Total 31] Name Scientific State Federal State Global Topo Topo Category Name (click for Common Name Status Status Rank Rank Map Map map] Status Animal Gull Tern Colonial Scotts Assemblage Skimmer Waterbirds S3 GNR Hill Historical Colony Nesting Site Invertebrate Calephelis Little Metalmark SR S2 G4 Scotts Current Animal virginiensiS Hill Invertebrate Elliptio Cape Fear Spike SC S3 G3Q Scotts Current Animal marsumobesa Hill Natural pine savanna S2S3 G3 Scotts Current Community Hill Natural Pond pine S4 G4G5 Scotts Current Community woodland Hill Natural Salt marsh S5 G5 Scotts Current Community Hill Vascular Amaranthus Seabeach T T S2 G2 Scotts Current Plant u p milus Amaranth Hill Vascular Aristida Big Three awn T S2 G4� Scotts Historical Plant condensata Grass Hill Vascular Asclegias Savanna SC V S3 G4 Scotts Historical Plant pedicellata Milkweed Hill Vascular Dichanthelium A Witch Grass SR L S2 G2G3 Scotts Historical Plant sp 9 Hill Vascular Dionaea Venus Flytrap SC V FSC S3 G3 Scotts Current Plant muscipula Hill Vascular Gelsemium Swamp SC V S1S2 G5 Scotts Current Plant rankinii Jessamine Hill Vascular Lysimachia Rough leaf E E S3 G3 Scotts Current Plant asperulifolia Loosestrife Hill Vascular Oenothera Riverbank Scotts Plant riparia Evening SR L S2S3 G2G3 Hill Current primrose Vascular Pinguicula Yellow SR P S2 G4G5 Scotts Current Plant lutea Butterwort Hill Vascular Platanthera Snowy Orchid T S1 G5 Scotts Historical Plant nivea Hill Vascular Polvgala Hookers SC V S2S3 G3 Scotts Current Plant hooken Milkwort Hill Vascular Rhynchospora Tracy s T S2 G4 Scotts Historical Plant tra Beaksedge Hill http / /nhpweb enr state nc us /search/findTopo php ?mapsheetSearch= Scotts+ 2/15/2011 Topo Map Record Search Results Vascular Plant Vascular Plant Vascular Plant Vascular Plant Scirpus Drooping Bulrush T S2 lineatus Solidago verna Spring flowering SRO FSC S3 Goldenrod Thalictrum Cooley s E E S2 coolevi Meadowrue G4 G3 G2 Yucca glonosa Moundlily Yucca SR P S2? G4? Page 2 of 2 Scotts Current Hill Scotts Current Hill Scotts Current Hill Scotts Current Hill Vertebrate Ambvstoma Mabee s SR S3 G4 Scotts Historical Animal mabeei Salamander Hill Vertebrate Caretta caretta Loggerhead T T S3B S3N G3 Scotts Current Animal Seaturtle Hill Corynorhinus Rafinesque s Vertebrate rafinesguii Big eared Bat SC FSC S3 G3G4TNR Scotts Obscure Animal macrotis Coastal Plain Hill subspecies Vertebrate Crotalus Eastern Scotts Animal adamanteus Diamondback E S1 G4 Hill Current Rattlesnake Vertebrate Haematogus American SC S36 S4N G5 Scotts Current Animal alliatus Oystercatcher Hill Vertebrate Malaclemvs Diamondback SC FSC in S3 G4 Scotts Current Animal terrapin Terrapin part Hill Vertebrate Neotoma Eastern Woodrat Scotts Animal flondana Coastal Plain T S1 G5T5 Current Hill flondana population Vertebrate Passenna cans Eastern Painted SC FSC S3B G5T3T4 Scotts Current Animal cans Bunting Hill Vertebrate Picoides Red cockaded E E S2 G3 Scotts Current Animal borealis Woodpecker Hill Explanation of codes NC Topographic Map Index Results current as of Tuesday 15 February 2011 @ 17 16 13 EST NORTH CAROLINA NATURAL HERITAGE PROGRAM DIVISION OF NATURAL RESOURCES PLANNING AND CONSERVATION DEPARTMENT OF ENVIRONMENT AND NATURAL RESOURCES 1601 MSC RALEIGH NC 27699 1601 http //nhpweb enr state nc us /search/findTopo php9mapsheetSearch= Scotts+ 2/15/2011 Page 1 of 1 LEE http: / /alaska.usgs.gov/ science / biology/ avian_ influenza limages /NA_migration_flyways.gif 8/26/2010 TOWER SITE EVALUATION FORM 1 Location (Provide maps if possible) State NC County New Hanover Latitude/Longitude /GPS Grid N 34'18 2 7 W 77 050 47 6 Ci , and Highway Directions From Wilmington, NC take US 17 north to I 140 east, take NC Route 133 south, take a left on Bavarian Lane, which becomes Murraysville Road Mabee Way will be on the left Subject site is off of Mabee Way on the right 2 Elevation above mean sea level 40 7 feet 3 Will the equipment be co located on an existing FCC licensed tower or other existing structure (building billboard etc )? (y /n) n If yes type of structure If yes, no further information is required 4 If no provide proposed specifications for new tower Height 90 Construction type (lattice monopole etc ) Monopole_ Guy wired9 (y /n) N No Bands NA Total No Wires NA Lighting (Security & Aviation) N If tower will be lighted or guy wired, complete items 5 20 If not, complete only items 19 and 20 5 Area of tower footprint in acres or square feet 6 Length and width of access road in feet 7 General description of terrain — 8 Meteorological conditions (incidence of fog low ceilings etc ) 9 Soil type(s) 10 Habitat types and land use on and adjacent to the site by acreage and percentage of total 90% grassed land and 10% stream 11 Dominant vegetative species in each habitat 12 Average diameter breast height of dominant tree species in forested areas 13 Will construction at this site cause fragmentation of a larger block of habitat into two or more smaller blocks9 (y /n) If yes describe 14 Is evidence of birds roosts or rookeries present9 (y /n) If yes describe 15 Distance to nearest wetland area (forested swamp march riparian marine etc ) and coastline if applicable 16 Distance to nearest telecommunications tower 17 Potential for co location of antennas on existing towers or other structures 18 Have measures been incorporated to minimizing impacts to migratory birds9 (y /n) 19 Has an evaluation been made to determine if proposed facility may affect listed or proposed endangered or threatened species or their habitat as required by FCC regulation at 47 CFR 1 1307(a)(3)? (y /n) y If yes present findings See Report 20 Additional information required Appendix F: Qualifications Ben Salter, REP EDUCATION M S Biology August 2004 Western Carolina University Cullowhee North Carolina B S Biology Chemistry Minor — December 1998 Georgia College & State University Milledgeville Georgia PROFESSIONAL EXPERIENCE November 2007 Principal Scientist/Office Manager Present Environmental Corporation of America Asheville NC April 2006 Principal Environmental Scientist / Partner November 2007 Blue Ridge Ecological Waynesville North Carolina January 2005 Project Environmental Scientist November 2007 Malcolm Pirme Inc Newport News Virginia August 2002 Research Assistant/Teaching Assistant December 2004 Western Carolina University Cullowhee North Carolina May 2003 Biological Science Technician September 2003 United States Forest Service (USFS) Asheville North Carolina January 1999 Project Scientist / Project Manager May 2002 Environmental Corporation of America Alpharetta Georgia TRAINING AND CERTIFICATION • GA DOT Coastal Wetland Plant Identification w/ Dr Bob Mohlenbrock (Sept 2010) • Airports Council International — North America NEPA Workshop (Dec 2009) • NC State Stream Restoration Design Principles (Oct 2007) • Southeastern Watershed Roundtable (2006) • Rosgen Level 1 — Applied Fluvial Geomorphology (2006) • VDEQ Stream Impact and Compensation Assessment Manual (SICAM) Workshop (2006) • VIMS Perennial Stream Workshop (2005) • VA Association of Wetlands Professionals Regulatory Update (2005) JOURNAL PUBLICATIONS Miller JR EB Salter JB Anderson PJ Lechler SL Kondrad PF Galbreath 2005 Influence of Temporal Variations in Water Chemistry on the Pb Isotopic Compositions of Rainbow Trout (Oncorhynchus mykiss) Science of the Total Environment 350 p 204 224 1 REPRESENTATIVE PROJECTS Environmental Impact Statement / Feasibility Study for Flood Damage Reduction and Ecosystem Restoration James River South Dakota Evaluation of Ecosystem Restoration and Flood Damage Reduction Measures on the Federally Endangered Topeka Shiner in the James River Basin South Dakota Environmental Assessments Proposed Soco Creek and Old #4 Sewer Line Replacements Cherokee North Carolina US Forest Service Biological Evaluation Proposed Eastern Band of Cherokee Indians Snowbird Community Center Nantahala National Forest Robbinsville North Carolina US Forest Service Environmental Assessment Proposed Eastern Band of Cherokee Indians Snowbird Community Center Nantahala National Forest Robbinsville North Carolina USACE and FDEP Wetlands Individual Permit and Mitigation Freeport Walton County Florida Multi Day Active Osprey Nest Monitoring During Telecommunications Tower Activities Wilmington Island GA USACE and St Johns River Water Management District Nationwide and Environmental Resource Permit and Mitigation Fellsmere FL USACE and St Johns River Water Management District Nationwide and Environmental Resource Permit and Mitigation Jacksonville FL National Environmental Policy Act (NEPA) Investigations including Section 106 Review and Environmental Assessments — Over 500 Projects Nationwide Protected Species Evaluations/ FWS Consultations over 500 Sites Nationwide Multiple Intensive Surveys for the Federally Threatened Dwarf Flowered Heartleaf Western North Carolina USACE Wetland /Stream Delineations and USACE /State Permitting Alabama Delaware Georgia Florida Illinois Louisiana Mississippi North Carolina New York Ohio South Carolina South Dakota Virginia and West Virginia Wetland Delineation and Mapping of entire Eastern Band of Cherokee Indians Reservation Cherokee North Carolina Telecommunications Tower Osprey Nesting Survey Greensboro North Carolina Phase I Environmental Site Assessments — Over 500 Projects Nationwide OA Phase II Environmental Assessments UST Removals Groundwater Monitoring Events and Petroleum and Chlorinated Solvent Remediation System Installations — Multiple Projects in Southeastern US Chestatee Chattahoochee RC &D Mud and Little Mud Creek EPA 319 Watershed Management Plan Habersham County Georgia US Army Corps of Engineers and Virginia Port Authority Environmental Impact Statement Craney Island Dredged Material Disposal Area Expansion and Subsequent Virginia Port Authority Craney Island Terminal Construction Portsmouth Virginia Wetlands Delineation of over 2000 acres City of Jacksonville Land Treatment System Expansion Onslow County North Carolina Preparation of Individual Permit Application and State Environmental Policy Act Documentation City of Jacksonville Land Treatment System Expansion Onslow County North Carolina Water Quality Testing and Benthic and Fish Assessment Hiawassee Georgia Ecological Risk Assessment Brown s Lake Fort Eustis Newport News Virginia Benthic Geomorphology and Water Quality Evaluation Bull Run Manassas Virginia Fisheries Assessment and Management Plan Development Lake Lure North Carolina Fisheries Assessment and Management Plan Development Lake Ravenel Highlands North Carolina Brook Trout Genetic Typing Population Estimate Habitat Survey and Restoration Multiple Projects throughout Western North Carolina Brook Trout Tissue Collection and Genetic Typing Headwater Streams Throughout Western North Carolina VA Environmental Impact Reports — Multiple Projects for Virginia Port Authority and Virginia Department of Juvenile Justice Evaluation of Lead Isotopic Composition of Freshwater Snails of Richland Creek Basin Waynesville North Carolina Asbestos and Lead Based Paint Inspections Abatement Monitoring and Preparation of Abatement Specifications — Multiple Projects throughout Georgia Geotechnical Investigations and Construction Material Testing for Cell Tower and Fiber Optic Communications Infrastructure — Multiple Projects Nationwide 3 APPENDIX G HISTORIC RESOURCE CONSULTATION Communications Tower Review Form I Applicant Information Preparer /Company Environmental Corporation of Amenca Address Phone /Fax/E mall 65 Hill Street Suite A Asheville NC 28801 P 828 505 0755 F 828 505 0959 kira mazzi@eca usa com 1j1j it For North Carolina HPO Use Only GT II II Tower Information (Attach copy of USGS map or photocopy of quad on reverse include 1 and 2 mile radius around site) x Raw Land (New) Co-Location Applicants Identification # Address Mabee Way, trJ lVmtrAL fo j County New Hanover County North Carolina FCC Registration No Tower type and height Monopole 90 ft overall height Quad Name Scotts Hill and Castle Hayne 111 Identification of Historic Properties List sites by site number and status NR = National Register listed SL = Study List DOE = Determination of Eligibility LD = Local Designation UA = Unassessed Archaeology - # of recorded sites in immediate area of tower 4 IV Additional Information /investigation Needed Survey Testing of sites Recommended by /on (Office of State Archaeology) Architecture �1// # of recorded sites within /Lmile radius Photo Reconnaissance Balloon Test Recommended by /on (Survey & Planning Branch) V Recommendations /Final Determination Recommendations for additional work are shown above The proposed communication tower will a7 affect historic properties in the area of potential effect 0,0,u &" — &-,� d - Is- - Renee Gledhill Earley Environmental Revie C ordinator Date cc FCC Februar} 2001 FEB10Z" APPENDIX H ADJOINING PROPERTY OWNERS y d C O CL 0 IL C O a Q CV) CV) M� N CV) O 000 � 000 CL ItIt It It 11 ICTIT N N N N N N N N O UUUU UUU to ZZZZ ZZZ t U cc () m c c c c c r- 0 O O O 0 0 c_ c_ c c _c c E E_ E E E E V a) Cc -C c L 1.1. co LL CD Q m LJ 'O v > Q L O� "O c o 00 N (C m O A Lo O co L WZ020 WO m O 0 Q N, � M 0 0 CO 4 (p N o a "2 J C C O O «+ O "c m CD c_ 'O O c E a) cn 7 ° — E c �cu U U J m cn cL°E O `n c —a)"> a) 0 c0 N a) 'l ca m c '. O w O 2 cU 0 3 O u.Uo�aa)-0aa)ccn F— z�mZw3:O c O �r � c m 0w JdI - Z(n(n (n U) nn a 15 is � Igo 9SP H l� �d8 13 it it 9�� 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 b � O O O O O O O O � s z1b; pan g ZR ORA N gig R Rog W °o N Z_ W QJ V N Op f� O 6 W/ /60 / / L 6 / f 9 a V0 Rig Zi �'bb' •q S �!�! 3Yz O �� No ^CSC pi CL �� • 4�E®® 6 � �i y P� S� a a nn a 15 is � Igo 9SP H l� �d8 13 it it 9�� 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 b � O O O O O O O O � s z1b; pan g ZR ORA N gig R Rog W °o N Z_ W QJ V N Op f� O 6 W/ /60 / / L 6 / f 9 a V0 APPENDIX I NC DWQ GENERAL CERTIFICATION 3821 Water Quality Certification No 3821 44 (MINING ACTIVITIES). AND 46 (DISCHARGES IN DITCHES), AND RIPARIAN AREA PROTECTION RULES (BUFFER RULES) Water Quality Certification Number 3821 is issued in conformity with the requirements of Section 401 Public Laws 92 500 and 95 217 of the United States and subject to the North Carolina Division of Water Quality (DWQ) Regulations in 15A NCAC 2H Section 0500 and 15A NCAC 213 0200 for the discharge of fill material to waters and adjacent wetland areas or to wetland areas that are not a part of the surface tributary system to Interstate waters or navigable waters of the United States () as described in 33 CFR 330 Appendix A (B) (18 29 39 41 42 43 44 and 46) of the Corps of Engineers regulations (i a Nationwide Permit No 39) and for the Riparian Area Protection Rules (Buffer Rules) in 15A NCAC 2B 0200 The State of North Carolina certifies that the specified category of activity will not violate applicable portions of Sections 301 302 303 306 and 307 of the Public Laws 92 500 and 95 217 if conducted in accordance with the conditions hereinafter set forth Activities meeting any one (1) of the following criteria require written approval from the Division of Water Quality (the Division') I Stream and/or buffer impacts a Any impacts to perennial waters (as depicted on the most recent USGS 124000 topographic map or as otherwise determined by the local government) and their associated riparian buffers in Water Supply (WS) High Quality Water (HQW) or Outstanding Resource Water (ORW) watersheds Only water dependent activities public protects and structures with de minimus increases in impervious surfaces will be allowed as outlined in those rules [15A NCAC 2B 0212 through 0215] All other activities require a variance from the delegated local government and /or the NC Environmental Management Commission before the application for the 401 Water Quality Certification can be processed b Any impacts to streams and buffers in the Neuse Tar Pamlico Randleman Catawba and Jordan basins (or any other basins with Riparian Area Protection Rules [Buffer Rules] in effect at the time of application [in accordance with 15A NCAC 2B 0200]) unless the activities are listed as EXEMPT from these Rules c Any impacts to streams involving excavation or dredging d Total stream impacts equal to or greater than 150 linear feet of intermittent and /or perennial stream to be filled culverted rip rapped or relocated including temporary and/or permanent impacts II Impacts (temporary and /or permanent) to waters a Equal to or greater than one third (1/3) of an acre East of Interstate 95 (1 95) b Equal to or greater than one tenth (1/10) acre West of Interstate 95 (195) III Wetland impacts (temporary and /or permanent) a Equal to or greater than one third (1/3) acre East of Interstate 95 b Equal to or greater than one tenth (1/10) acre West of Interstate -95 c Any impacts to wetlands adjacent to waters designated as ORW SA WS I WS II or Trout or wetlands contiguous to waters designated as a North Carolina or National Wild and Scenic River d Any impacts to coastal wetlands [15A NCAC 7H 0205)) or Unique Wetlands (UWL) [15A NCAC 2H 05061 Water Quality Certification No 3821 Water Quality Certification No 3821 IV If the activity is associated with or in response to a Notice of Violation or an enforcement action initiated by the Division and/or the Division of Land Resources In accordance with North Carolina General Statute Section 143 215 3D(e) written approval for a 401 Water Quality General Certification must include the appropriate fee If a project also requires a CAMA Permit then one payment to both agencies shall be submitted and will be the higher of the two fees Activities that are below the thresholds or otherwise do not meet the criteria listed above In this General Certification do not require written approval from the Division of Water Quality as long as they comply with the Conditions of Certification listed below Including the Stormwater Management Plan condition If the project requires a Stormwater Management Plan but is otherwise below the written approval thresholds the applicant may provide a courtesy copy of the Pre Construction Notification along with a copy of the Stormwater Management Plan (and approval letter from the appropriate locally delegated state program where applicable) If any of these Conditions cannot be met then written approval from the Division is required Conditions of Certification 1 No Impacts Beyond those Authorized in the Written Approval or Beyond the Threshold of Use of this Certification No waste spoil solids or fill of any kind shall occur in wetlands waters or riparian areas beyond the footprint of the impacts depicted in the Pre Construction Notification and authorized in the written approval from the Division including incidental impacts All construction activities including the design installation operation and maintenance of sediment and erosion control Best Management Practices shall be performed so that no violations of state water quality standards statutes or rules occur 2 Standard Erosion and Sediment Control Practices Erosion and sediment control practices must be in full compliance with all specifications governing the proper design installation operation and maintenance of such Best Management Practices a Design installation operation and maintenance of the sediment and erosion control measures must be such that they equal or exceed the requirements specified in the most recent version of the North Carolina Sediment and Erosion Control Manual The devices shall be maintained on all construction sites borrow sites and waste pile (spoil) projects including contractor -owned or leased borrow pits associated with the project b For borrow pit sites the erosion and sediment control measures must be designed installed operated and maintained in accordance with the most recent version of the North Carolina Surface Mining Manual c Reclamation measures and implementation must comply with the reclamation in accordance with the requirements of the Sedimentation Pollution Control Act and the Mining Act of 1971 d Sufficient materials required for stabilization and /or repair of erosion control measures and stormwater routing and treatment shall be on site at all times e If the project occurs in waters or watersheds classified as Primary Nursery Areas (PNAs) Trout (Tr) SA WS I WS II High Quality (HQW) or Outstanding Resource (ORW) waters then the sediment and erosion control requirements contained within Design Standards in Sensitive Watersheds (15A NCAC 04B 0124) supercede all other sediment and erosion control requirements ' Water Quality Certification No 3821 Water Quality Certification No 3821 3 No Sediment and Erosion Control Measures in Wetlands or Waters Sediment and erosion control measures should not be placed in wetlands or waters without prior approval by the Division If placement of sediment and erosion control devices in wetlands and waters is unavoidable then design and placement of temporary erosion control measures shall not be conducted in a manner that may result in dis equilibrium of wetlands or stream beds or banks adjacent to or upstream and down stream of the above structures All sediment and erosion control devices shall be removed and the natural grade restored within two (2) months of the date that the Division of Land Resources or locally delegated program has released the project 4 Construction Stormwater Permit NCG010000 Upon the approval of an Erosion and Sedimentation Control Plan issued by the Division of Land Resources (DLR) or a DLR delegated local erosion and sedimentation control program an NPDES General stormwater permit (NCG010000) administered by the Division is automatically issued to the project This General Permit allows stormwater to be discharged during land disturbing construction activities as stipulated by conditions in the permit If your project is covered by this permit [applicable to construction projects that disturb one (1) or more acres] full compliance with permit conditions including the sedimentation control plan self monitoring record keeping and reporting requirements are required A copy of this permit and monitoring report forms may be found at http 11h2o enr state nc us/su /Forms Documents him 5 Construction Moratoriums and Coordination If activities must occur during periods of high biological activity (i a sea turtle or bird nesting) then biological monitoring may be required at the request of other state or federal agencies and coordinated with these activities This condition can be waived through written concurrence on a case by case basis upon reasonable justification All moratoriums on construction activities established by the NC Wildlife Resources Commission (WRC) US Fish and Wildlife Service ( USFWS) NC Division of Marine Fisheries (DMF) or National Marine Fisheries Service (NMFS) to lessen Impacts on trout anadromous fish larval /post larval fishes and crustaceans or other aquatic species of concern shall be implemented This condition can be waived through written concurrence on a case by case basis upon reasonable justification Work within the twenty five (25) designated trout counties or identified state or federal endangered or threatened species habitat shall be coordinated with the appropriate WRC USFWS NMFS and /or DMF personnel 6 Work in the Dry All work in or adjacent to stream waters shall be conducted in a dry work area Approved best management practices from the most current version of the NC Sediment and Erosion Control Manual or the NC DOT Construction and Maintenance Activities Manual such as sandbags rock berms cofferdams and other diversion structures shall be used to minimize excavation in flowing water Exceptions to this condition require submittal to and approval by the Division of Water Quality Water Quality Certification No 3821 Water Quality Certification No 3821 7 Riparian Area Protection (Buffer) Rules Activities located in the protected 50 foot wide riparian areas (whether jurisdictional wetlands or not) within the Neuse Tar Pamlico Catawba Randleman and Jordan (or any other basin with buffer rules) shall be limited to uses identified within and constructed in accordance with 15A NCAC 213 0233 0259 0250 0243 and 0267 and shall be located designed constructed and maintained to have minimal disturbance to protect water quality to the maximum extent practicable through the use of best management practices All buffer rule requirements Including diffuse flow requirements must be met 8 Water Supply Watershed Buffers The 30 foot wide vegetative buffer (low density development) or the 100 foot wide vegetative buffer (high density development) shall be maintained adjacent to all perennial waters except for allowances as provided in the Water Supply Watershed Protection Rules [15A NCAC 2B 0212 through 0215) 9 If concrete is used during the construction then a dry work area should be maintained to prevent direct contact between curing concrete and stream water Water that inadvertently contacts uncured concrete should not be discharged to surface waters due to the potential for elevated pH and possible aquatic life /fish kills 10 Compensatory Mitigation In accordance with 15A NCAC 2H 0506 (h) compensatory mitigation may be required for losses of 150 linear feet or more of streams (intermittent and perennial) and/or one (1) acre or more of wetlands For linear public transportation projects impacts equal to or exceeding 150 linear feet per stream shall require mitigation Buffer mitigation may be required for any project with Buffer Rules in effect at the time of application for buffer impacts resulting from activities classified as Allowable with Mitigation within the Table of Uses section of the Buffer Rules or require a variance under the Buffer Rules A determination of buffer wetland and stream mitigation requirements shall be made for any General Water Quality Certification for this Nationwide Permit Design and monitoring protocols shall follow the US Army Corps of Engineers Wilmington District Stream Mitigation Gu►de/►nes (April 2003) or its subsequent updates Compensatory mitigation plans shall be submitted for written Division approval as required in those protocols Alternatively the Division will accept payment into an in lieu fee program or credit purchase from a mitigation bank Finally the mitigation plan must be implemented and /or constructed before any permanent building or structure on site is occupied In the case of public road projects the mitigation plan must be implemented before the road is opened to the public Proof of payment to an in lieu fee program or mitigation bank must be provided to the Division to satisfy this requirement 11 For all activities requiring re alignment of streams a stream relocation plan must be included for written Division approval Relocated stream designs should include the same dimensions patterns and profiles as the existing channel (or a stable reference reach if the existing channel is unstable) to the maximum extent practical The new channel should be constructed in the dry and water shall not be turned into the new channel until the banks are stabilized Vegetation used for bank stabilization shall be limited to native woody species and should include establishment of a 30 foot wide wooded and an adjacent 20 foot wide vegetated buffer on both sides of the relocated channel to the maximum extent practical A Water Quality Certification No 3821 Water Quality Certification No 3821 transitional phase incorporating appropriate erosion control matting materials and seedling establishment is allowable Rip rap A -Jacks concrete gabions or other hard structures may be allowed if it is necessary to maintain the physical Integrity of the stream however the applicant must provide written justification and any calculations used to determine the extent of rip rap coverage Please note that if the stream relocation is conducted as a stream restoration as defined in the US Army Corps of Engineers Wilmington District April 2003 Stream Mitigation Guldelines (or its subsequent updates) the restored length can be used as compensatory mitigation for the impacts resulting from the relocation 12 Stormwater Management Plan Requirements A Linear public transportation projects will be required to treat stormwater runoff to the Maximum Extent Practicable in accordance with the practices described in the NCDOT Best Management Practices (BMP) Manual B All other projects shall comply with the requirements set forth below In addition the applicants shall follow the procedures explained in the version of Protocol for Stormwater Management Plan (SMP) Approval and Implementation that is in place on the date of the submittal of the SMP i Project Density Projects with SMPs that require 401 Oversight/ Express Unit approval shall be classified as either Low or High Density according to the criteria described below a Low Density A development shall be considered Low Density d ALL of the following criteria are shown to have been met The overall site plan excluding ponds lakes rivers (as specified in North Carolina s Schedule of Classifications) and saltwater wetlands (SWL) must contain less than 24% impervious surface area considering both current and future development All stormwater from the entire site must be transported primarily via vegetated conveyances designed in accordance with the most recent version of the NC DWQ Stormwater BMP Manual 3 The project must not include a stormwater collection system (such as piped conveyances) as defined in 15A NCAC 2B 0202(60) 4 If a portion of project has a density equal to or greater than 24% then the higher density area must be located in an upland area and away from surface waters and drainageways to the maximum extent practicable b High Density Projects that do not meet all of the Low Density criteria described above are considered to be High Density requiring the installation of appropriate BMPs as described below 1 All stormwater runoff from the site must be treated by BMPs that are designed at a minimum to remove 85 percent of Total Suspended Solids (TSS) Projects located in watersheds that drain directly to waters containing the following supplemental classifications shall meet these additional requirements Water Quality Certification No 3821 Water Quality Certification No 3821 Water Quality Stormwater BMP Requirement Supplemental Classification §303(d) Project specific conditions may be added by the Division to target the cause of the water q lity impairment NSW A minimum of 30 percent total phosphorus and 30 percent total nitrogen removal or other applicable nutrient reduction goal for the watershed as codified in the15A NCAC 2B 0200 rules Trout (Tr) A minimum of 30 percent total phosphorus and 30 percent total nitrogen removal BMPs should also be designed to minimize thermal pollution All BMPs must be designed in accordance with the version of the NC Division of Water Quality Stormwater Best Management Practices Manual that is in place on the date of the submittal of the SMP Use of stormwater BMPs other than those listed in the Manual may be approved on a case by case basis if the applicant can demonstrate that these BMPs provide equivalent or higher pollutant removal and water quality protection u Vegetated Setback In areas that are not subject to a state Riparian Area Protection Rule a 30 foot wide vegetated setback must be maintained adjacent to streams rivers and tidal waters as specified below a The width of the setback shall be measured horizontally from 1 The normal pool elevation of impounded structures 2 The streambank of streams and rivers and 3 The mean high waterline of tidal waters perpendicular to shoreline b The vegetated setback may be cleared or graded but must be planted with and maintained in grass or other appropriate plant cover c The DWQ may on a case by -case basis grant a minor variance from the vegetated setback requirements pursuant to the procedures set forth in 15A NCAC 02B 0233(9)(b) d Vegetated setbacks and filters required by state rules or local governments may be met concurrently with this requirement and may contain coastal isolated or 404 jurisdictional wetlands ui Stormwater Flowing to Streams and Wetlands Stormwater conveyances that discharge to streams and wetlands must discharge at a non erosive velocity prior to entering the stream or wetland during the peak flow from the ten year storm iv Projects Below Written Authorization Thresholds Projects that are below written authorization thresholds must comply with the version of Protocol for Water Quality Certification No 3821 Water Quality Certification No 3821 Stormwater Management Plan (SMP) Review and Approval that is in place on the date of the certification for the project v Phased Projects The DWQ will allow SMPs to be phased on a case by case basis with a final SMP required for the current phase and a conceptual SMP for the future phase(s) If the current phase meets the Low Density criteria but future phase(s) do not meet the Low Density criteria then the entire project shall be considered to be High Density 13 Placement of Culverts and Other Structures in Waters and Wetlands Culverts required for this project shall be designed and Installed in such a manner that the original stream profiles are not altered and allow for aquatic life movement during low flows Existing stream dimensions (including the cross section dimensions pattern and longitudinal profile) must be maintained above and below locations of each culvert Placement of culverts and other structures in waters and streams must be placed below the elevation of the streambed by one foot for all culverts with a diameter greater than 48 inches and 20 percent of the culvert diameter for culverts having a diameter less than or equal to 48 inches to allow low flow passage of water and aquatic life Installation of culverts in wetlands must ensure continuity of water movement and be designed to adequately accommodate high water or flood conditions Additionally when roadways causeways or other fill projects are constructed across FEMA designated floodways or wetlands openings such as culverts or bridges must be provided to maintain the natural hydrology of the system as well as prevent constriction of the floodway that may result in destabilization of streams or wetlands If site specific topographic constraints preclude the ability to bury the culverts as described above and /or the applicant can demonstrate that burying the culvert would result in destabilization of the channel and head cutting upstream the Division will consider alternative design proposals Any nprap required for normal pipe burial and stabilization shall be buried such that the original stream elevation is restored and maintained The establishment of native woody vegetation and other soft stream bank stabilization 3 techniques must be used where practicable instead of nprap or other bank hardening methods 14 Additional site specific conditions may be added to the written approval letter for projects proposed under this Water Quality Certification in order to ensure compliance with all applicable water quality and effluent standards 15 If an environmental document is required under the National or State Environmental Policy Act (NEPA or SEPA) then this General Certification is not valid until a Finding of No Significant Impact (FONSI) or Record of Decision (ROD) is issued by the State Clearinghouse 16 If this Water Quality Certification is used to access budding sites then all lots owned by the applicant must be buildable without additional impacts to streams or wetlands The applicant Is required to provide evidence that the lots are buildable without requiring additional Impacts to wetlands waters or buffers if required to do so In writing by the Division For road construction purposes this Certification shall only be utilized from natural high ground to natural high ground Water Quality Certification No 3821 7 Water Quality Certification No 3821 17 Deed notifications or similar mechanisms shall be placed on all retained jurisdictional wetlands waters and protective buffers in order to assure compliance for future wetland water and buffer impact These mechanisms shall be put in place at the time of recording of the property or of individual lots whichever is appropriate A sample deed notification can be downloaded from the 401Mletiands Unit web site at http !/aortal ncdenr oro/ web /wa /swpMrs/ 401 /certsandpermitslappiylforms The text of the sample deed notification may be modified as appropriate to suit to a specific project 18 When written authorization is required for use of this certification upon completion of all permitted impacts included within the approval and any subsequent modifications the applicant shall be required to return the certificate of completion attached to the approval One copy of the certificate shall be sent to the DWQ Central Office in Raleigh at 1650 Mail Service Center Raleigh NC 27699 1650 19 This General Certification shall expire three (3) years from the date of issuance of the written letter from the Division or on the same day as the expiration date of the corresponding Nationwide Permit The conditions in effect on the date of issuance of Certification for a specific project shall remain in effect for the life of the project regardless of the expiration date of this Certification If the construction process for approved activities will overlap the expiration and renewal date of the corresponding 404 Permit and the Corps allows for continued use of the 404 Permit then the General Certification shall also remain in effect without requiring re- application and re approval to use this Certification for the specific impacts already approved 20 The applicant/permittee and their authorized agents shall conduct all activities in a manner consistent with State water quality standards (including any requirements resulting from compliance with §303(d) of the Clean Water Act) and any other appropriate requirements of State and Federal Law If the Division determines that such standards or laws are not being met including failure to sustain a designated or achieved use or that State or Federal law is being violated or that further conditions are necessary to assure compliance then the Division may reevaluate and modify this General Water Quality Certification Non compliance with or violation of the conditions herein set forth by a specific fill protect may result in revocation of this General Certification for the project and may also result in criminal and/or civil penalties The Director of the North Carolina Division of Water Quality may require submission of a formal application for Individual Certification for any project in this category of activity if it is determined that the project is likely to have a significant adverse effect upon water quality including state or federally listed endangered or threatened aquatic species or degrade the waters so that existing uses of the wetland or downstream waters are precluded Public hearings may be held for specific applications or group of applications prior to a Certification decision if deemed in the public s best interest by the Director of the North Carolina Division of Water Quality Water Quality Certification No 3821 Water Quality Certification No 3821 Effective date April 6 2010 DIVISION OF WATER QUALITY By Coleen H ullins Director History Note Water Quality Certification (WQC) Number 3821 issued April 6 2010 replaces WQC Number 3705 issued November 1 2007 WQC Number 3631 issued March 19 2007 WQC Number 3402 issued March 2003 WQC Number 3362 issued March 18 2002 WQC Number 3287 issued June 1 2000 and WQC Numbers 3106 and 3108 issued on February 11 1997 This Water Quality Certification is rescinded when the Corps of Engineers re authorizes Nationwide Permits 18 29 39 41 42 43 or 44 or when deemed appropriate by the Director of the Division of Water Quality Water Quality Certification No 3821