20001102 Ver 1_COMPLETE FILE_20000822

Attachment
cc: Corps of Engineers Wilmington Field Office
Wilmington DWQ Regional Office
Central Files
File Copy
Doug Huggett
Rick Civelli, 139 Stokley Road. Wilmington, NC, 28403
001102
..
State of North Carolina
Department of Environment
and Natural Resources
Division of Water Quality
Michael F. Easley, Governor
William G. Ross, Jr., Secretary
Kerr T. Stevens, Director
099NA
D E N R
January 31, 2001
DWQ# 00-1102
New Hanover County
David and Ruth Ann Phillips
1035 Ocean Ridge Drive
Wilmington, NC, 28405
APPROVAL of 401 Water Quality Certification
Dear Mr. and Mrs. Phillips:
You have our approval, in accordance with the attached conditions, to fill 0.02 acre of wetlands in order to
construct a freestanding storm wall on your property in New Hanover County, as described in your application
received by the Division of Water Quality on August 22, 2000, and in additional correspondence received January
24. 2001. After reviewing your application, we have determined that this fill is covered by General Water Quality
Certification Number 3274. This Certification allows you to use your CAMA Permit when it is issued by the NC
Division of Coastal Management. In addition, you should get any other federal, state or local permits before you
go ahead with your project including (but not limited to) Sediment and Erosion Control, Non-Discharge and Water
Supply Watershed regulations. Also this approval will expire when the accompanying CAMA Permit expires
unless otherwise specified in the General Certification.
This approval is only valid for the purpose and design that you described in your application. If you
change your project, you must notify us and you may be required to send us a new application for a new
certification. If the property is sold, the new owner must be given a copy of the Certification and approval letter
and is thereby responsible for complying with all conditions. If total wetland fills for this project (now or in the
future) exceed one acre, compensatory mitigation may be required as described in 15A NCAC 2H .0506 (h). For
this approval to be valid, you must follow the conditions listed in the attached certification.
If you do not accept any of the conditions of this certification, you may ask for an adjudicatory hearing.
You must act within 60 days of the date that you receive this letter. To ask for a hearing, send a written petition
conforming to Chapter 150B of the North Carolina General Statutes to the Office of Administrative Hearings. P.O.
Box 27447, Raleigh, N.C. 276 1 1-7447. This certification and its conditions are final and binding unless you ask
for a hearing.
This letter completes the review of the Division of Water Quality under Section 401 of the Clean Water
Act. If you have any questions, please telephone John Dorney at 919-733-9646.
Non-Discharge Branch 1621 Mail Service
Telephone [phone]
Sincerely,
_Q+
:evdnS
Raleigh, or h Carolina 27699-1621
FAX # [phone]
An Equal Opportunity Affirmative Action Employer 50% recycled/ 10% post consumer paper
4A01 I
JAN 2 4 2001
ESTUARINE RESOURCES
P.O. Box 199 • Wrightsville Beach, NC 28480 • Tel [phone] • Fax [phone]
January 19, 2001
Ms. Cyndi Karoly
Division of Water Quality
401 /Wetlands Unit
1621 Mail Service Center
Raleigh, NC 27699
Re: DWQ Project No. 001102, Phillips wetland mitigation plan
Dear Ms. Karoly,
On August 22, 2000, the North Carolina Division of Water Quality received an
application for a 401 Water Quality Certification to impact 0.02 acres of wetlands in
order to construct a storm wall at 1035 Ocean Ridge Drive. Since the cumulative wetland
impacts associated with the Landfall Subdivision exceed one acre, compensatory
mitigation is being required in accordance with 15A NCAN 2H .0506(h). To satisfy this
requirement the Phillips' propose to create 515 square feet of wetlands to offset the loss
of 330 square feet of impacted wetlands.
Since DWQ received the application, Angie Pennock with the U.S. Army Corps
of Engineers visited the site, and flagged the effected jurisdictional wetlands. Due to the
limitation of allowable construction activities within New Hanover County's COD
setback, this area had never been delineated. The previous delineation required for the
construction of the Phillips' home, started 75' landward from the edge of significant
conservation resources.
After Ms. Pennock flagged this area, the wetland line was then surveyed, and
signed off by Scott McLendon. Upon inspection of the survey, we moved the placement
of the structure landward to further reduce the impacts to 0.008 acres.
The enclosed plan depicts a proposed area that Joanne Steenhuis suggested for
onsite mitigation. The Phillip's landscape contractor will grade the area to support the
proper hydric soil conditions required to propagate "404" vegetation. The proposed
plantings are a combination of the following:
Common Name Scientific Name
Arrowhead Sagittaria lancefolia
Native Cattail Typha latifolia
Golden Club Orontium aquaticum
Blue Flag Iris Iris versicolor
Japanese Iris
Yellow Flag Iris
Pickard Weed
Sweet Flag
Umbrella Palm
Sedum `Autumn joy'
Traveling Elephant Ear
Bog Sage
Clump Bamboo
Moudry Fountain Grass
Iris kaempferi
Iris pseudacorus
Pontederia cordata
Acorus calamagrostis
Cyprus alternarifolias
Sedum x Autumn Joy
Colocasia esculenta
Salvia uliginosa
Bambusa multiplex
Pennisetum alopecuroides Moudry
To ensure proper functionality, the mitigation site will be monitored for a year. If you
have any questions or need any additional information, please call. Thank you for your
time.
Sincerely,
y
I R ?-
Richard V. Civelli CEI, CES
Environmental Consultant
CC: Dave & Ruth Ann Phillips
Joanne Steenhuis, DWQ
Angie Pennock, USACE
Enclosure: Wetland Mitigation plan
Approved wetland survey
O - N09'tL() (O 1- 00 O) O
N CO) I?tU7(Oi*-00 Q) N N CN
U
c
3
v
3
L
c
ca
r
C\l
C ?
d I
r/ '
O /
V '
\ I

I
/ c
n3
/ o
I
ed

0 •1?
?
O a .
.,? m
Lr)
c
M

,?

mi

ry

?

i
v

I 1
I '
I?
I I
it
I
I?
I `
I
I
I
I
I
I ,
I
I
c?
N Ch
co .-
E+
o?
o
L9
rn
Y
3 a)
U ?
R!
(a
U) a
c c
_O O
m .C
Y_
ca
3
m
(>n
rn
c
X
W
M a LO
N N N
----------- __

c
H d 7
I

Y
- - w.0
_ xv
rn LLJ .n
\----------- - /
00
?/ n 0
? O
c
cu
U C c
.co
I ?
a)
' C
Y
1
? J
c
8?
' '0O
0+
a>
H
a>
Z m i
o °' CL 'A
N 3 .'
Y J T
00 '
U r I-
a> L
H a(Di
3J
?,U)
cm
°v
Eo
o
a>
HN
' co C
? O
M 3
r:: /
::•i:'r: r- co
(n co
? o
ny I
_rn
3J% E I
0 I
L- --
3 co
1 v E? `
m +
a> 0 - - t- - - - - - - - - - --
a) a> i \
C9 U') co rl \
co i \ O ON. N c) to co r, co
r 3 ? O O
• \ \ MS /Lb,?? \\
co \ S°?7(??? O0 f?i?ixO \ \
°o
N

?3Vs
3a? ? ? ? C
IWO
m w V a
d'
-0 C EQ?O?N
co s
°Jz
zz 4xzzz
`? A w " R N
I " n
K r`R- Q.
g ° d
R
R R
a + .Nr
Q " ` " a + Ux
H -R
t R l
N?
1 _L.Q
LLJ
v /
O ?
I
w w w w w w w w w w w w w w w 3 3 3 w w w w w w w 3 w w w 3 w 3 3 3

m _ OD t0 t0
M t(]
LA
ED O ^
4 a
N h
r)
'n

N

N

? t ^ t0 (0 fT N p a a a

-
C'

Q
'co

p

N

p

Ul

M

a

1?

d
(D
O

T-

' !

t0

N

U

'J
O

N

O

f1
M

?
.t N

Ql ,.
j

f? r'1 M

O)

? O

N
v

M
N N

O <

O

I M

Ln O

t

0 ?(1

O O N M a

M

r

U/

Z
oo

O

7
to

at
f0

tp
h

0
O

00

O
N

M
h

N
t0

O>
t0

h
I?

OD
?'

a

N

O ?I

trn, p

M p

0

0

?o N

M O

M V- tV M

N ;n

O

M O P

w

p P

'n n
Z Z Z to Z Z Z V, Z Z Z m U) V) Ln W (n (n N Z Z Z Z. Z Z Z Z Z Z W Z N Z N

3
jr-
N a M N
O h
O ^ N
O1 N
a V'
N op
O l0 !?
,f1 00
N N
a) 00
to O
w l0
st O
O O)
M h
m
h
O Ot
M tp
O t0
l0
?"? '
t0 M
('n N
m O
O
h
2 J M N
t0
?
:Z
N
10
O/
O
h
V
q-
00
M
M
m
M
M
r.
?
`t
W
O)
N
N
O)
m
h
a0
tTl

w
W
Z

J
N
I
M
I

I
N
I
(0
I
(?
I
W
I
O
I
O
_?
I
N
M
a
to
t0
h
OD
lT
O
N

N
N
N
rr)
N
sY
N

N
tD

N
h

N

op

N

N
(31

O

M

M

M

M

'
M
J J J J J J J J J I
J -J I
J I
J I
J I
J I
J I
J I
J I
J J J ,J J J J J J J J J J J J II

F
$
o ?
3
O ?
Z W J
Q ¢ i
W O
a
e
J o 0

ZZ
O
ry
II
K ? ?
C U
U U
z U
?
V/ F z R
in ? N u? a

J a

I m
a
o
R

rl)
T
o a+ \
o as ?
W ?a (N )
N
u m
0
_ ,00'91 ,£ l'OZ S9'LL t
ov + + 101 ,9L'i7LZ M„b0,Zl,.6bN
3. 1 + + m$
o
ro
iry
S ari M
?I
rn0?
r?
i
A
w
`\
+"\ ?
MO
? Y Z
Q h

r.F
IA z

?
O }
N
r .Cr
v
r ^
MO
I
l+ ?4'
' C`v?
`-?y
N
?n m
O
10
+
aa rv?

F }
F
+ IT
R.. .N ya0
Of A
- t - - - ?r LO'617
j +
N + n fd„bO,Z..GbN
c
V
M cOF + ry ,'r ?
> CC

+ +
+ +
W
C
+ 4-

3P$?9
+
V +

CO -1 +

+ + 0br 3

-}- + { 3
+ r? 90 N
Q .
+ + Y + + Z } z
U'L£Z

4- 4bp.^.
+ t }
i
i
I
00
?Q
I ?
i
i
?I
I
9rs r 5,,?'? 1? i
11
/ U I

to 2
W
OC)
I

N N
a z?
C N
W
I
U Ql

5

%
: k
°

o `y ?o .o Ji 8
O v U
?? ?\

o
U ob??i.
-\
F: j
Z
E
SS
o
° a<
vl -
0
U ?$$c?io ???Er ?? 8
L•7
I
s
wl
i
ol?
i
I
w
10
? O
OIL .? 2
I I
WrnI
V
I Q
W ! u I
w 0,
h `f
olo i
z
t :State of North Carolina
Department of Environment
and Natural Resources
Wilmington Regional Office
Division of Coastal Management
James B. Hunt, Jr., Governor
Bill Holman, Secretary
Donna D. Moffitt, Director
August 17, 2000
MEMORANDUM:
TO: Mr. John R. Dorney, NCDENR
Division of Water Quality
4401 Reedy Creek Road
Raleigh, NC 27611-7687
FROM: Doug Huggett
Major Permits Processing Coordinator
A kTC5WJ
461a
"Wo
NCDENR
NORTH CAROLINA DEPARTMENT OF
ENVIRONMENT AND NATURAL RESOURCES
001102
AUG 2 2nn,?
ANDS r,
,QIG, lry .
SUBJECT: CAMA/DREDGE & FILL Permit Application Review
Applicant: David & Ruth Ann Phillips
Project Location: 1035 Ocean Ridge Drive, Adj. to AIWW, Landfall Subdivision, New Hanover Co.
Proposed Project: Proposal to construct a freestanding storm wall to protect his residence and
property during tropical storm events
Please indicate below your agency's position or viewpoint on the proposed project and return this form
by September 9, 2000. If you have any questions regarding the proposed project, please contact
E.F. Brooks at extension 247. When appropriate, in-depth comments with supporting data is requested.
REPLY: This agency has no objection to the project as proposed.
This agency has no comment on the proposed project.
This agency approves of the project only if the recommended changes are
incorporated. See attached.
This agency objects to the project for reasons described in the attached comments.
SIGNED DATE
127 Cardinal Dr. Ext., Wilmington, North Carolina 28405 Telephone [phone] FAX [phone]
DIVISION OF COASTAL MANAGEMENT 0 0 1 1 0 2
FIELD INVESTIGATION REPORT
1. APPLICANT'S NAME: David & Ruth Ann Phillips
2. LOCATION OF PROJECT SITE: at 1035 Ocean Ridge Drive, adjacent to the AIWW, Landfall
Subdivision, in New Hanover Co.
Photo Index - IM:174-9 S,T - 8 1225:22-257J-8
State Plane Coordinates - X: 2364549 Y: 181135
3. INVESTIGATION TYPE: CAMA/D&F
4. INVESTIGATIVE PROCEDURE: Dates of Site Visit - 7/18/00
Was Applicant Present - Yes - Agent
5. PROCESSING PROCEDURE: Application Received - 7/27/00
Office - Wilmington
6. SITE DESCRIPTION:
(A) Local Land Use Plan - Wilmington/New Hanover County
Land Classification From LUP - Conservation/Resource Protection
(B) AEC(s) Involved: ES
(C) Water Dependent: Yes
(D) Intended Use: Private
(E) Wastewater Treatment: Existing - New Hanover County Sewer
Planned -None
(F) Type of Structures: Existing - Single-family residence
Planned - Storm wall
(G) Estimated Annual Rate of Erosion: N/A
Source- N/A
7. HABITAT DESCRIPTION: [AREA]
nDVnr'sun =T T L'Tl /ITrTT}Tb
A Vegetated Wetlands - "404 type" 750 s ft.
Non-Vegetated Wetlands
(C) Other - Highground disturbance 1635 sqft.
(D) Total Area Disturbed: 2385 sqft.
(E) Primary Nursery Area: No
(1) Water Classification: SA Open: No
8. PROJECT SUMMARY: The applicant proposes to construct a freestanding storm wall to protect
his residence and property during tropical storm events.
David & Ruth Ann Phillips
Page 2
9. PROTECT DESCR_TP M
The project area is located within the existing development known as Landfall. Landfall is an ongoing
large-scale project, which includes golf courses, both single-family and multi-family residential, and
commercial development. Landfall is located on the mainland side of the Atlantic Intracoastal Waterway
(AIWW), near Wrightsville Beach, north of Eastwood Road and east of Military Cutoff, in New Hanover
County. The applicant's property is located at 1035 Ocean Ridge Drive (Lots 26R & 27R), as well as,
joint ownership of Lot 28. The 1.15 acre tract is approximately 217 feet wide along the Atlantic
Intracoastal Waterway (AIWW), and 220 feet in depth from Ocean Ridge Drive. The site includes a
drainage easement through a natural drainage feature that runs through the property and functions as a
stormwater outfall for an existing culvert at the street. Prior to constructing their residence in 1994, the
applicants obtained a federal Nationwide Permit and 401 Water Quality Certification to fill a portion of
this wetland drain to allow construction. The applicants have utilized the drainage feature in the house
design and landscaping and have supplemented the vegetation with both native and ornamental wetland
plant species. The residential design includes three structures; the main house, guest house, and a garage.
All are inter-connected by walkways along the side-slopes and elevated over wetland areas. The wooded
lot includes mature Live Oaks and Hickory trees. Adjacent to the AIWW shoreline there is a border of
coastal wetlands and mud flats, approximately 700 feet wide. This marsh vegetation is predominantly
Smooth Cordgrass (Spartina 1 P iflora). Other high coastal marsh plants intermix into the vegetation on
the landward side of the marsh border. Species observed include: Black Needle Rush (Juncos
rcm rianu?), Cat-tail (lypba =), and Bulrush (=), Saw Grass ( ldi m j m i nce), Spike Grass
(,12istichlis Xicata), Sea Oxeye (Borric is fruescens), Salt Meadow Grass (S an rtina patens), and shrubs,
Wax Myrtle (Myrica cPjkm), Marsh Elder (Iva frutescens), and Grounsel-Bush (Baccharus h imifo ia),
along the side-slopes of the transition to highground.
The AIWW is approximately 600 feet wide in the project area. It is classified as SA by the NC Division
of Water Quality, and is CLOSED to the harvest of shellfish. The area is not a designated Primary
Nursery Area (PNA) by the NC Division of Marine Fisheries.
The applicant proposes to construct two (2) walls along the southeast (waterward) side of his property.
A retaining wall is proposed along the southern-most side of the property to raise that section of the lot
to the 100-year storm elevation (+12 ft. MSL). This wall would be 121 feet long and 3 -4 feet above
existing grade. Its design would be typical marine construction consisting of pilings, whalers, and vertical
V-groove sheathing. The retaining wall is proposed landward of all wetlands and would require
approximately 190 cubic yards of backfill material. The second wall is depicted as a free-standing
masonry storm wall to help protect the property from hurricane storm surge. A concrete foundation, 5
feet wide, 12 inches thick, and approximately 2 feet below grade would poured to support the wall. Two
masonry walls, 4'8" apart, would be constructed on the foundation. The outer wall (south) would be
constructed to elevation 13'4" MSL and the inner wall (north) would be constructed to elevation 10'4"
MSL. Earthen fill material would be brought in to fill the void between the walls and capped with a
concrete cap at the elevation of the lower wall. Wall design includes two (2) 24" outlet pipes, equipped
with flapper gates that would allow the existing stormwater outfall to function while preventing in-flow
from any storm surge. The top of the wall would be accessed by a concrete steps on the inside of the
structure. The applicants also propose a third masonry wall to create a pool over a portion of the natural
wetland substrate. The inside area of the pool would be planted with wetland plant species. The proposed
alignment of the wall is well landward of the mean high water contour (MHW) and landward of all
David& Ruth Ann Phillips
Page 3
coastal wetlands. Approximately 150 ft. of the 235 ft. long wall would be located within the previously
delineated non-tidal wetland drain. The wetland fill area would 150 feet in length and 5 feet in wide.
10. ANTICIPATED IMPACT
The proposed wetland fill would incorporate 750 square feet of "404 type" wetlands. The installation of
the wetland pool would create additional temporary disturbance and possibly alter the existing wetland
function. There would be 1635 square feet of additional highground disturbance associated would the
construction of two walls. The project would provide some degree of protection to the applicant's
residence during hurricanes.
Submitted by: E.F. Brooks Date: 8/16/00 Office: Wilmington
001102
ESTUARINE RESOURCES
P.O. Box 199 • Wrightsville Beach. NC 28480 • Tel [phone] . F 0 1156-9686
7Z
Project Narrative: JUN f 0 2000
-? V
CO ,,SSq1 CF
Enclosed are plans for upland site improvemerits at 1035 Ocean Ridge ISriv f ?+N?yUEI?_NT
Wilmington. The proposed is consistent with T15A:07H.0209, development standards
for Estuarine Shorelines.
This project entails the construction of a masonry wall designed to protect the applicant's
property from tropical storm events. The width of the structure has been minimized to
limit fill in "404" wetlands, but will also provide structural integrity according to North
Carolina building codes. The height of the structure will serve to protect from storm
surges associated with a 100 year event (per FEMA standards BFE +2'). The base flood
elevation for this lot is I I'MSL.
The site has two natural drainage swales that handle storm water from the lot and
adjacent street/parcels. To manage this flow, Keith P. Bulla, P.E. from Catlin EnLyineers
and Scientists calculated flow volumes, and designed a culvert system with flap gates.
This system will allow the site to drain, but will also protect the upland area from scour
and debris.
A timber constructed retaining wall approximately 3'- 4' in height is also proposed to
bring a section of the lot to 100 year flood level elevation. This design was used because
all associated back fill for this part of the project will not be placed in any wetland areas.
The area of disturbance is located in a Conservation Overlay District. This local
ordinance restricts impervious surfaces within the setback, minimizing associated
degradational impacts to important natural resources. The project lies within the
jurisdictional limits of the City of Wilmington. The City has recently adopted this
ordinance and is currently relying on the interpretation of County officials.
An onsite meeting was held with Debra Wilson, a New Hanover County Zoning
Enforcement Officer and John W. Fullerton, a City of Wilmington's Zoning Inspector. A
follow up meeting was also held with Ann Hines, Chief Zoning Enforcement Officer for
New Hanover County. All officials concurred that the project was designed to minimize
impacts to natural resources. The project as presented meets the standard described under
the COD ordinance and is therefore consistent with local government standards.
The disturbance is less then 1 acre in size, therefore the proposed development does not
require a sedimentation and erosion control permit, nor a stormwater permit.
ESTUARINE RESOURCES
?!? ;11 ?''P. 1 • Wrightsville Beach, NC 28480 • Tel [phone]. Far [phone]
June 14, 2000
DIVISION OF
COASTAL Mr. Doug HugEettT
Major Permits Processing Coordinator
Division of Coastal Management
1638 Mail Service Center
Raleigh, NC 27699-1638
Re: Major CAMA/Dredge & Fill Permit
Gentlemen,
Mr. E. F. Brooks
Senior Field Representative
Division of Coastal Management
127 Cardinal Drive Extension
Wilmington, NC 28405
Enclosed are plans for upland site improvements at 1035 Ocean Ridge Drive,
Wilmington. The proposed is consistent with T15A:07H.0209, development standards
for Estuarine Shorelines.
This project entails the construction of a masonry wall designed to protect the applicant's
property from tropical storm events. The width of the structure has been minimized to
limit fill in "404" wetlands, but will also provide structural integrity according to North
Carolina building codes. The height of the structure will serve to protect from storm
surges associated with a 100 year event (per FEMA standards BFE +2'). The base flood
elevation for this lot is I VMSL.
The site has two natural. drainage swales that handle storm water from the lot and
adjacent street/parcels. To manage this flow, Keith P. Bulla, P.E. from Catlin Engineers
and Scientists calculated flow volumes, and designed a culvert system with flap gates.
This system will allow the site to drain, but will also protect the upland area from scour
and debris.
A timber constructed retaining wall approximately 3'- 4' in height is also proposed to
bring a section of the lot to 100 year flood level elevation. This design was used because
all associated back fill for this part of the project will not be placed in any wetland areas.
The area of disturbance is located in a Conservation Overlay District. This local
ordinance restricts impervious surfaces within the setback, minimizing associated
degradational impacts to important natural resources. The project lies within the
jurisdictional limits of the City of Wilmington. The City has recently adopted this
ordinance and is currently relying on the interpretation of County officials.
An onsite meeting was held with Debra Wilson, a New Hanover County Zoning
Enforcement Officer and John W. Fullerton, a City of Wilmington's Zoning Inspector. A
follow up meeting was also held with Ann Hines, Chief Zoning Enforcement Officer for
New Hanover County. All officials concurred that the project was designed to minimize
impacts to natural resources. The project as presented meets the standard described under
the COD ordinance and is therefore consistent with local government standards.
The disturbance is less then I acre in size, therefore the proposed development does not
require a sedimentation and erosion control permit, nor a stormwater permit. If you have
any questions please call. Thank you for your time.
Sin
?'-? cerely, /
V C?
Richard V. Civelli CEI, CES
Environmental Consultant
rll? -777
I
JUN 19 2000 i
DIViSION OF
COASTAL MANAGEMENT
CC: Dave & RuthAnn Phillips
John W Fullerton, City of Wilmington, Development Services
Ann Hines, New Hanover County, Chief Zoning Enforcement Officer, LPO
Debra Wilson, New Hanover County, Zoning Enforcement Officer, LPO
Form DC.N1-N1P-7_
7
J U I'll
" C 200 PPLICATION 001102
E
D I V; S I O N OF (To be completed by all applicants)
COASTAL MANAGEMENT
b. City, town mum or landmark
1. APPLICANT ?i I FDM i N q -on/
a. Landowner:
Name I Ay'%A 4?A Aiv, r ? ? II 1 aS
-
Address 10 3 0 C??ni I? ? ? C' rive
City i I Al ia/v State IV C
Zip 8 10S Day Phone
Fax / YA
b. Authorized Agent: I I / I
Name C ? C"'r V.
e? C .1 ve- 1 1
Address_1? 1 STUk ley 1 GC,?
City Vi I Mi N q TG N State
Zip a ?'i ?C) 3 Day Phone 910. a S?. 9 3 i5
Fax 910. %66
c. Project name (if any) S-bfM WA I
N07Z Pernur vviU be i::ue in name ?iQ- ?ser(sJ, cry/or
p-je= name.
2. LOCATION OF PROPOSED
c. Street address or secondary road number
- 103S C)scan. I i89C _b 6v<2
d. Is proposed work within city limits or planning
jurisdiction? Yes No
e. Name of body of water nearest project (e.g. river,
creek, sound, bay) 1 C \.?6/
3. DESCRIMON AND PLAIh'NED USE
OF PROPOSED PROJECT
a. List all development activities you propose (e.g.
building a home, motel, marina, bulkhead, pier, and
excavation and/or filling activities
CCWr4(UC?1anr Jf A (??AiN1N ??q?4
a rce a,v I t V0 Q -S
G N r wa I.
b. Is the proposed activity maintenance of an existing
project, new work, or both? New war
c. Will the project be for public, private or commercial
use? rlva`Ae-
d. Give a brief des iption of purpose, use, methods of
constru pion and daily operations of proposed
project. If more space is needed, please attach
additional pages.
S 0 ' e
PROJECT
z. Countv N &-w &-w NrA A/ov(-2 r
Rersed 03/596S

Form DCh1-MP-1 I
JUN 1
20
0
l
.
4
00

4. LAND AND WATEJOASTAL MA1?AGE' M,ENTm. Describe exist' Wastewater treatment facilities.
c
oonN ? scw?r
CHARACTERISTICS
a. Size of entire tract 5 u?reS n. Describe location and type of discharges to waters

b
Size of individ
l l
Nf A of the state. (For example, surface runoff, sanitary
.
ua
ot(s) wastewater, industrial/commercial effluent, "wash
., down- and residential discharges.) A.-r^4vrA 1
c. Approximate elevation of tract above MHW or %" a e `I ik c 0U
NWL=qe ia' ov-tle-? ?. flq a{e- valve
d. Soil type(s) and texture(s) of tract
8
Sa
L o. Describe existing drinking water supply source.
4'
y
' 'V
c,:?, AA G1`? G
wiIMlN, TGN
?'

e. Vegetation on tract Cs rAsS c? ?a o ba S
s eM
wiiIn LaA, scc,pini9
f. Man-made features now on tract
?`F=S ?QeA'CC'
?
_
G-e s-f gc,us' C?4TA q e
r. ADDITIONAL INFORNLATION
a What is the CAMA Land Use Plan land
an
classification of the site? (corzruir ru local land,uc pl In addition to the completed application form, the
following items must be submitted:
Conservation 'T'ransitional
Developed Community A Copy of the deed (with state application only) or
Rural Other other instrument under which the applicant claims title

h. How is the tract. °nd blocal government? to the affected properties. If the appIicant is not
claiming to be the owner of said property
then
K - a0 ,
forward a copy of the deed or other i
nstrument under
which the owner claims title, plus written permission
i. Is the proposed proje.^t consistent with the applicable from the owner to carry out the project

zoning? ? Yes No .
(Attach zoning taniptiaacr crrincaze, if ©pli•bk) An accurate, dated wort; plat (including plan view

j. Has a professional archaeological assessment be and cross-sectional drawings) drawn to scale in black
°
en
done for the tract? Yes No
If ink on an 8 I2" b 11
white dope tAr
Coastal Resources Commission Rupaper.
7J
Q203 f
t

yes, by whom? .
or
o
detailed description.)
k. Is the project located in a National Registered
Historic District or does it involve a National
Register listed or eligible property?
Yes ? No
1. Are were wetlands on the site? ? Yes Nc
Coastal (marsh) ? Other
If yes, has a delineation been conducted?
(Aram do='r n ' ' nor., if ...=iz pie)
Please note that original drawings are preferred and
only high quality copies will be accepted. Blue-line
prints or other larger plats are actable only if an
adequate number of quality, copies are provided by
aDDiicant. (Contact the U.S. Amy Coms or-
E nsineers regarding that agency's use of larger
drawings.) A site or location map is a part of plat
reouirements and it must be sufficiently detailed to
guide agency personnel unfau--iiliar w•iw we area to we
R!! i-d 03ML-
Form DChi-NIP-1 -r '7
?
D
L?v J U N 1 9 2000 site. Include highway or secondary road (SR)
numbers, landmarks, and the like. DIVIIATION AND PERMISSION
COASTAL IVIAti MGng?
ormwater Certif ti ' f TO ENTER ON LAND
• A St
ica ion, i one is necessary.
• A list of the names and complete addresses of the
adjacent waterfront (riparian) landowners and
signed return receipts as proof that such owners
have rived a copy of the application and plats
by certified mail. Such landowners must be advised
that they have 30 days in which to submit comments
on the proposed project to the Division of Coastal
Management. Upon signing this form, the applicant
further certifies that such notice has been provided.
Name Nell i- Lilvcc\ Cur,r',q
Address _lo l "7 Oc-ea N 'Nd 1(2 r l v e
Phone \A/dMi n-q 4V- /VC ? 94OS
Name C ?'??? r s c? ogle
Address 10 t1 3 OceG ve
Phone \n/r M? nrq any /VC d. U.5
Name G PC E N4er r', Se.S LL c
Address 101) \"" "/, iZ\ d e ri v C'
- r4 Phone 11Mi Vq+CG/v, NC `iri S
A Ap?kcan4 is co-owNCr' w?-44? Cvrr'?es
• A list of previous state or federal permits issued for
work on the proje„^t tract. Include permit numbers,
permitte-, and issuing dates.
I understand that any permit issued in response to this
application will allow only the development described in
the application. The project will be subject to conditions
and restrictions contained in the permit.
I certify that to the best of my knowledge, the proposed
activity complies with the State of North Carolina's
approved Coastal Management Program and will be
conducted in a manner consistent with such program.
I certify that I am authorized to grant, and do in fact,
grant permission to representatives of state and federal
review agencies to enter on the aforementioned lands in
coon----tion with evaluating information related to this
permit application and follow-up monitoring of the
project.
I further certify t:,at the information provided in this
application is truthful to the test of my knowledge.
This is the I y day of TL-We joug
Print Name I\ c? G r V i v C'
S i --nature I Y e?A, -A
I ?^owncr - A-iWr.; as Arf--,
/ $
? • A che_k for S-`SY made payable to the Department of
Environment, Health, and Natural Resources
(DEHNR) to cove: the costs of processing the
application.
• A signed -AEC hamrd notice for projects in
NIA oceanfront and inlet areas.
• A staternent of comniiance with the N.C.
r-nvironmental Policy Ad (N.C.G.S. 113A - 1 to
/V/A 10) 11' the prole-, involves the expenditure of public
funds or use of public lands, attach a statement
documenting compliance with the North Caroh=
Environmetital Polic•. Act.
Please indicate attar. Lments pertaining to your proposed
proj---t.
? DCM M9-2 Excavation and rill Information
_ DCM MP-3 Upland DeveloDment
_ DCM = SuLi„tures information
- DCM M9-5 Bridges and Culverts
_ DCM N9-5 Marina Development
Noy ,-;7.- Ple . re sig'-, and dare each a-ra; hnxw in 1h,
sure proiideg c th-- oo«om of each four.
Revised 03!
Norm DCM-hiP-2
EXVATION ?
CA R 117
R JUN 19 2000
AND
FILL
D! ,-,!SlON OF
(Except bridges and culverts) COASTAL NAANAGEME
Attach this form to Joint Application for CAMA Major
Permit, Form DCM-MP-1. Be sure to complete all
other. sections of the Joint Application that relate to this
proposed project.
Describe below the purpose of proposed excavation or
fill activities. All values to be given in feet.
Access
channel
(ML.w) or (NWL
Canal
Boat
basin
Boat
ramp
Rock
groin
Rock
breakwater
L. EXCAVATION
a. Amount of material to be? excavated fi- m below
MHW or NWL in cubic yards _ N??
b. Type of material to be excavated /V A
c. Does the area to be excavated include coastal
wetlands (marsh), submerged aquatic vegetation
(SAVs) or other wetlands? Yes No
d. Highground excavation in cubic yards-4A
2. DISPOSAL, OF EXCAVATED
MATERIAL
a. Location of disposal area 2A
b. Dimensions of disposal area N?A
c. Do you claim title to disposal area?
Yes No IVIA
If no, attach a lett;r granting permission from the
owner.
Other
(: zcluciing
shomiinc
stabiiistion)
d. Will a disposal area be available for future
maintenance? Yes
If ves, where? No A11 A
Revised 03!95
Average Fine]
Fsis$ Project
Length Width Depth Death
Foy m 6Chi-REP-2
Does the disposal area include any coastal wetlands
(marsh), SAVs or other wetlands? d
Yes No
f. Does the disposal include any area in the water?
Yes No NIA
3. SHORELINE STABILIZATION
a. Type of shoreline stabilization
X Bulkhead Riprap
. ?cc ecl tue __ff
b. Length wall a? l a rcT?iNi?y w??
c. Average distance w terward of MHW or NWL
d' /a D rya ccA -I'S /a,/c4\.,,-
d. Maximum distance waterward of MHW or NWL
0 e
e. Shoreline erosion during precceding 12 months
/VaN E
(Source of information)
f. Type of bulkhead or riprap material
CGNCt?e ? WOad T?SMi_°
g. Amount of fill in cubic yards to be placed below
water level
(1) Riprap 1VC1NF
(2) Bulkhead backfill /VONF
h. Type of fill material -IpSo\? be? "I ?
re?4 tv wa\1 190A „t.sTT1ll
i. Source of fill material V ? Sa u''Cf
4. OTHER FILL ACTIVITIES
(Excluding Shoreline Stabilization)
IV` ( t' 'lir P
?U
a. Will fill material be brought t e'f'°? ? IL
Yes No 1
UI JUN 19 ZQQQ
Reviled Q3!
If Yes,
(1) Amount of material to be placed in the
water NO AI E
(2) Dimensions of fill area
(3) Purpose of fill
b. Will fill material be placed in coastal wetlands
(marsh), SAVs or other wetlands?
?/ Yes No
If Yes,
(1) Dim(e`ns1ions Qf 1 areal t I• x ?'
'tcz? tN7 rcAeG IV , WGII i N• y6L
(2) Purpose of fill Con,crerte -Cr
S?OACGt-`f- wrnn?l
5. GENERAL
a. How will excavated or fill material be kept on site
and erosion controlled? S / L 7" F per, ce ?-
b. What type of construction equipment will be used
(for example, dragline, backhoe, or hydraulic
dredge)? j? -}- _
J 2L t'm ?JG ? C Cn 1
C. Will wetlands be crossed in transporting equipment
to project site? yes V No
If yes, explain steps that will be taken to lessen
environmental impacts. ff
'--oc-oic I A ANN -? 1 1 1 1 OS
App1: t or ;e-= C ?V W? -A e4A
' I".:`, Sirnatm-e
bLf 1 J (/NL° I h Date
CC C T
0
c
•3
r)
C
D
JUN 19 20x0
DIVISION OF
COASTAL MANAGEMI
tn
w
J •
a
C7
Z_
_Z
F-
W
x
w
??
A g
UI -

> O O
CIO w
g4 ..q =0 5,5
?i
V ?
V O
y., L
"¢C U
w
Wv p
z
0
O O t" N
o ? o 0
N ? ?p
? v C N
CU
r
r `6
ouGHr
' 'ma'r ? , !? •• ti ! ? /?' / '; / ?c ? ?' y _
TS-
BM 2
2 5
17 eF 'f 1 a O ?(BM - / \' 1 ?; ? 1 F;'' "?: /, HARBOR
13
rT ISLAND y.r
A1RLl M- S
+Ai
i'.l• i f• / .7?J?,: ?-. 1? •' OLlG HT, \\•? / 1
4
/ SEAG:AT YZ r/n a \ l ; s i
-r ` r4 s Clp / BM
%
•' / ? l ? -OLEANDER
+/ "/ ~'? + /x?• \M'$F1.ORIAL GARDEN5 * \? ?P
ERYI
MONEY ?.
"IS
?X BLOCK r ! E
\\ ONEY'
.6
BLOCK ' P
\7
O CK A\?
2? SHINev
Site „u rV IT
? COAST GUARD f
I
iQe?s... 5j AT10N •'. •+?Ct I
LIGHT
UN 1 9 2000 ?
C , A TAL MANAGEMEN
25 TO SC L ?1Q,
MASONBORO
INLET
Dave and F.-uthMn Phillips
1035 Ocean Ridge Drive
Wilmington, NC, 28405 IL.

Yl]i

38 6 d' '?
?e -
?, N `' •h ? 339E ,.?
" 0111
,r
J
338e 338 !7
fl?
6217
23
Iru
? ?
Sae ?? ,r
.
0175
?
4175

A a? 3,p
KUR
Z?
^•
16? ?? ?j88T
y 'I'
329
.u
• w?
? 4P
1GR7
OL2E

336
r I
?nl
?J
33

?y B
967

39Ck
t{ ??? //II ? 1 I I
l
2000
? J
D I V 1 .)i ?i? G=
COASTAL f/iAi ACEMENT
Site
$-A v
0 0.
w <
o?
n
m )p
S
? a
V
_. _.
< -3
M (A
IL lUN 19 2000 D

i=N?
co
C7
N
H
D
r
PID '5116-004-026-000 JURISDICTION !NH99 I PIN 3,16818414175000
TAXMAP BLOCK PARCEL SUBLOT
.316818 1141 i,4175 :1000
FEATURE CODE
.l t?! N-7
OWNER (PHILLIPS DAVID MILNE RUTH ' I JUN 19 2000
35,
SITUS ADDRESS -- 1-0 OCEAN RIDGE DR DIVISION OF
CITY w>vt - COASTAL MANAGEMENT
SUBDIVISION (LANDFALL
LEGAL DESCRIPTION ;26R/27R BLK 9 PEMBROKE JONES P
ACCOUNT STATUS ACTIVE
DEED BOOK 1568
PAGE 00-89 INSTRUMENT OF OWNERSHIP WD
LAST SALE DATE 1910913 VACANT OR IMPROVED V
PRICE 495000 REPLACEMENT COST NEW r -
GRANTOR (LANDFALL ASSOCIATES
GRANTEE !PHILLIPS DAVID MILNE R
TAX DISTRICT IWILMING
LAND USE
NHC ZONING IR-20
CITY ZONING
ZONING FLAG
FLOOD ZONE !SAFE
SUBNO - 3385
864916
VOTE PRECINCT !H02
Wednesday, June 14, 2000 Page 1 of 1
PID 151 16-004-024-000 JURISDICTION iNH99? PIN 1316818413082000
TAXMAP BLOCK PARCEL SUBLOT
1316818 i 141 13082 1000
FEATURE CODE IPARCEL
OWNER iDRYSDALE CLIFF
SITUS 1043 OCEAN RIDGE uDR
ADDRESS --
CITY AVM
SUBDIVISION LANDFALL SUBNO 3386
LEGAL DESCRIPTION ,25 BLK 9 PEMBROKE JONES PK
ACCOUNT STATUS ACTIVE
DEED BOOK 1774
PAGE 0138
LAST SALE DATE 940517
PRICE 0
JUN 1 9 2000
DIVISION OF
COASTAL MANAGEMENT
INSTRUMENT OF OWNERSHIP V D
VACANT OR IMPROVED V
REPLACEMENT COST NEW 534478
GRANTOR DRYSDALE CLIFF MARCY
GRANTEE DRYSDALE CLIFF
TAX DISTRICT WILMING
LAND USE Unused Land
NHC ZONING iR-20
CITY ZONING
ZONING FLAG
FLOOD ZONE ;SAFE
VOTE PRECINCT ;H02
Wednesday, June 14, 2000 Page 1 of 1
PID 5116-004-027-000 JURISDICTION NI-199 PIN 316818416217000
TAXMAP BLOCK PARCEL SUBLOT
316818 41 - - 16217 11000
FEATURE CODE ;PARCEL
OWNER IGPC ENTERPRISES LLC
SITUS 1031 OCEAN RIDGE ;DR
ADDRESS ---- -- - - - ---- - - - -- --
CITY WM- ---- ----- -
SUBDIVISION ILANDFALL SUBNO 3386
LEGAL DESCRIPTION 128 BLK 9 PEMBROKE JONES PK
ACCOUNT STATUS ACTIVE
DEED BOOK ;242;
JUN 2000
COASTAL IM NAGEMENT
PAGE ;0j51 INSTRUMENT OF OWNERSHIP VVD
LAST SALE DATE 1980821 VACANT OR IMPROVED V
PRICE 0 REPLACEMENT COST NEW
GRANTOR ;SALTER WILLIAM L TRUS
GRANTEE GPC ENTERPRISES LLC
TAX DISTRICT ; WILMING
LAND USE 'Unused Land
Wednesday, June 14, 2000
NHC ZONING iR-20
CITY ZONING r
ZONING FLAG ;
FLOOD ZONE (SAFE
0.
VOTE PRECINCT H02
Page 1 of 1
PID 51 16-004-028-000 JURISDICTION N1499 ! PIN 316818417306000
TAXMAP BLOCK PARCEL SUBLOT
316818 - 41 ;7306 ;000
FEATURE CODE ,PARCEL
OWNER ICURRIE NEILL A LINDA P
SITUS 1027 OCEAN RIDGE
ADDRESS --- -- ----- - - - - DR - - -
CITY V1T 1
SUBDIVISION LANDFALL i SUBNO -3386
.
LEGAL DESCRIPTION 129 BLK 9 PEMBROKE JONES PK
ACCOUNT STATUS
ACTIVE
?
IDDEZ-VITE
lrl?ll,
JUN i 9
SION
COASTAL IM
NAGS- EMEN
DEED BOOK 2401
PAGE 0641! INSTRUMENT OF OWNERSHIP WD
LAST SALE DATE ',980716 VACANT OR IMPROVED -1
PRICE . 1615000. REPLACEMENT COST NEW
GRANTOR ;SLOCUM JOHN M SUSAN
GRANTEE !CURRIE NEILL A LINDA P
TAX DISTRICT WILMING NHC ZONING IR-20
LAND USE CITY ZONING
ZONING FLAG
FLOOD ZONE [SAFE
1038388
VOTE PRECINCT H02
Wednesday, June 14, 2000 Page 1 of 1
S?Of- \VA41/ - P, p C, C)
ID
s1'5r) Cr-..- IGVIc-Tors
?Vn? ?0 2000
Pre (I-":, r-ecl ?: r- ,
?S ?vc?r??.?.e, i?G So????S
P. O. Box 14?
W I'5 L4s v 1 l i t PEIcG.c ? l N (-
?9'?v> Z56- 9396
r .?3 /'? 1 yM1` ?V
1 ?? ?'Jore? Day
VE
k
? 7n)l JUN t 9 2000 I
DIVISION OF
COASTAL MANAGEMENT
G+?TLiaJ ?',?5 ??ecf S 5 SG,? r ?r5 I S
C/ Do, PC/

JOB: r IIrPs ?C?s?Ch.c? - L ??f COMPUTED BY: DATE: 6 2 oo
DESCRIPTION: __ t 00 year P, Pg S -e CHECKED BY: DATE:
yew r--
55 vw?p _v?^ _'.0,00
-
-- - ,i it
Acrc-s
TD 10',?'
LLE-07 Acres
ovs 7, 8`? ?GI'eS
!JN 19 2000
- - We,?5E. ? G? ,??,r ?.feo?. DIVISION Or=
COASTAL MANAGE' MEN
C_17
t= C ? X °ro
30 /,o Krvrvv -y.BY- ...70 13
Ir f- -TG lco
_y 73
_ 125 C,&: LiFl
ENGINEERS and SCIENTISTS
JOB:
DESCRIPTION:
COMPUTED BY:
CHECKED BY:
DATE:
ti. _I
Luau J
DIVISION O'=
?ASTX?tTVf?iTlti?EfVIENT
F
?/.
0
-e - ------- fix- ?--. _. _ _ _.

A

?o
cl-d
ZA\ _.._._-_.Pr??pr. .? r-?.? . - ?d•--? ?.- _ ro __ ._. ef?..7 _._l.4 ss ... -fro pvcale.,

30 8)
= W 3 ?f-s 7 3 Zc? FS
T
ENGINEERS and SCIENTISTS I /
Qr : 28+l6,S : Nysc >38.2efs U
KP,eDATE: (-Z5 o0
U
Z
r.
C
C
1.
_Q
G
0
V
L
G
L
II?r
vJ
.V
r
11 11
11
11 I I J+ y 11 O M m O N O P I M O I I
W 11 110 v m c19 v 0 I M O 11
11 11 . 11 II
a O 11 11 O 11 O- N v v I M A co O 11
N 11 11 O II r II
V 11 11 ? 11 11
E Z C7 II II 11
6 x 11 II 11 11
? ? 11 11 11
• 11 I I L. 11 v 0 0• N O A v 0 0 11
S C P 11 11 YC 11 AM.OA{pMP VA O 11
G •Z 11 11I 11 11
V 11 I 10M y t l O ?^ N M v 'r 'o A P I I
Z W 1; 11 11 11 11
• N 11 11 11 11
S V OC 11 11 11 II
11 11 11 11
). 11 11 L .••. 11 1o O• .r •D N N _ 11
II II )..C 11 *.OrNV VPV;z 11
11 11 . •? 11 . 11
. C9
11 11 In r•• 11 CD IV m m t In ?O cis
11 11 N 11 11
11 11 11 11
11 11 11 11
11 11 It 11
11 11 L. -+
I11 O In •O N N v 10 N A N 1 I
11 11 ?.C I 19 OMI -P MA OAA 11
11 11
U 11 11
11
11 01 O I•• 11 O-- N N M M v In . p I I
2 r II 11
W
11 A 11 11
11 11
J 11 11 11
m C II • 11 11 11
H w l l 11 L ... • 11 In g v O m m 0. 0 0 I I
Y C 11 11 C 11 l M P N P I M P N N O co 11
U II L 11 Y1 11 • 11
z E n d 11 y i i 0 CD ?- tV N M v In lM I I
W = 11 n 11 p 11
u u
0 3 ii C ii 11 11
W A 11 L 11 11
Iz II 7 11 L..? li P?fOO 10 M10 0 O
it
L II d 11 ?? 11 vao CPn .-M•OMPIn 11
x u
CC II N ?+ 11 O O N N N M M v II
O 11 11 11 11
it
< 11 11 11 11
K 11 II 11
G O 11 11 x 11 II
11
11 11 O2 I I C C C C C 11
~ It 11 11 t ii E E E E •E .L L L L L ii 1 11 1-
IL L.l u u Iz u
W O tl 11 II 11'1 O V1 O O N M •O N v 11
O J II 11 O 11 .-?M •O I N II
o 3 a¢
-0 ° Z p d
U Z
?

U z
a-
r- cc
Q U
O O cc
? a>' O ¢ a,

E N tv
0. ? u 4
V
W?•u ?
a?
` R w v y
e
v
y C N
w V F

G S 00
>% o- V .C
to <
y
3 LZ Q
Q c ? c '-
j .? Z g >
91) =
= a ? Z

h
tY. y ;a LF) I-
M
W en M) en
n O H
0
2
o =
c

a?
CC
ti
JUN 19 2000 J
DIVISION OF
COASTAL MANAGEMENT
11 It 11 11
11
11 I I I I >':. L I I 11 O I A N• O m^v N O A^ N
. ... a. v I I
It 11 I I
II L 11
11 It O \ 11 PaD AInv N.-..00•
11
II 11 O C 11 II
II 11 .- 11 11
11 II ?+ II 11
II 11 11 11
11 II 11 11
11 11 L.-. 11 APInv OP IMA VO 11
11 II ?. L 11 . . . . I> . r. O O .p . 1111
11 11 II
11 11 Ot \ 11 O A'p W% M N ? ? O O 11
11 II IM C 11 11
11 11 11
11 11 ?+ 11 11
11 11 11 to
II
11 11 )+ L 11 ^ on ^ N . 'O N IM I? M 11
11 11 . L 11 .P VO•vPIMM 11
11 11 N C 11 IM A •OVM?-000 11
II 11 •? 11 11
11 11 .... 11 11
II 11 11 11
II II 11 II
11 11 L n 11 MO}M IMNAIMO co o 11
W 11 11 ?. L 11 N M v N P ?O N m v N 11
J II II . .t 11 • 11
m u 11 1 11 O\ I I A• O In v cm .- 0 0 0 11
Z 1 11 r 11 11
H 11 A 11 11
11 11 ?•• II 11
le It
U y 11 • II 11 11 11
II
= 11 11 L II M•O AP tlDA OO Nv 11
t71 II 11 ?. L 11 •pAPAIM V A vN 11
.= o 0 o ii
C9 - u n it it It
u u ?•• a 11
2 11 C 11 II II
2 A 11 L 11 II 11
O 11 7 It L 11 to .0 .O^ O O 11
O? 11
II ?+ 11 ?. L II f00 M M M
H 11 d 11 L It co IM M 11
4 I I o e 11 N\ 11 1 M I M v M N . it
IY 11 11 C II ^ 00 00 tl
11 II II 11
O II 11 •?•• II II
11 II 11 11
Y ? • 11 11 11 11
x 11 11 2 11 11
O 11 II O II
fn II 11 11 C c r It
[ [ It
It it t- W < 11 u 4 it
E E E E E L L L L L ii
Z O 11 11 tY II
II ? II IM O Vl O O N M d N ?} 11
J 11 11 p 11 ? M •p r- N 11
a? V6.
O
0= d
h?3
cc N
O N
U
C
N C y
0
d N
c7 p
E S
O
•? c? O
O C
-Z E
cc o-Ir
? O tr ?
p In
c a
16-
a?cci ?'
In
V
m .0. L. L
V ? tU
(u c c c
3: ya m

N
Q\
O?
aLi
.D
U
d
p
0
u
ea
.o
'B
C-
CU
a`
II 11 II
I I L 11 v co O N M v 11
11 II N N M M M M II
11 11 11
11 11 II
11 It It
It 11 11
It 11 11
11 11 11
11 0
C 11 Q 111 A^ N O I n O 11
In 1nO MA 11
C E 11 I i ^ N N M M M 11
O O 11 11 11
I? ? II II II
r• t 11 11 11
11 II 11
10 v VH
77 11 OC 11 N t!1 O IM O O 11
u 9" V 11 II - N In
W 0 11
OI M 11 11 II
IL 11 L 11 11 11
O O 11 11 II
'? 11 11 II
11 11 11
11 11 II 11
11 11 11 11
11 11 11
11
II 11 11 11
11 11 11
11
11 11 11 N N M 11
II 11 11 M M M II
11 11 II
II 11 11 O O O O It
tl 11 II OC C OC v 11
11 11 N 11 O O O 11
II 11 U II Y Y Y ly II
11 11 L 11 2 2 S H 11
II V 11 7 11
11 Z 11 C II t ( -C to
II
11 11 N II 4 C C 3 11
11 11 11 D O O In 11
11 C 11 II z
II O II x z m 1I1
II I --
"I ?.. Il IL II O 100 11 A
ii c ii L C II O O 7 O 11
u u ?. ••+ ii O •- v O ii
u E u a u.
u u o u u
II Z 11 II II
u A 11
_ n u a
1t II n 11 PP 00 II O
11 11 C II v O In II
11 II L II II
II 11 Yy 11 O ?•- N v 11
II II
11 11 N 11 tl
V1
II 11 11 II
1- 11 . 11 11 --
1- It
•• 11 11 II
C II x 11 C 11 it
O II O II O 11
II II 11 C [ C 11
11
n u It Io II E E E .t ii
II U It L II
2 11 O II 7 II In In O v 11
11 J II O 11 ? ? N 11
Exhibit 11
0
1so 10,000
168 8,000 EXAMPLE (?? (2) (3)
156 6,000 0.41! look" (33 tact) 6'

114
5,000 0.120 ata
-5.
4,000 120 9. 5.
132
3,000 o tact
5
4.
120 11) !.? os . 4.
,000

2,000
RJ L.I TA

(3) !.2 T.T

.
106 3.
a0 is /cat 3.
96 1,000 3.

84 800
_•
s00 _-
s00 +
72 400 2.
W Soo
?%
(
1.5
1
5
Z ?
3 U
S .

= 60 v 200
1.5
Z W
0 54
P
100 o
> 48 co
80 z
J
4= t
60 _
IL
1.0
1.0
ENTRANCE
CA
4 S
LE
TYPE

: 1.0
W
W
36
ZL?
30
(1) sssere ad" with W
3 .f
.!

33 ??• AN/NII
o .f

I
it 0 t!) Gramm sod with W
30 "Newell = .• .8
(3) oracoa sod •e
=7 ?? Ne1Ntles
to
!4 6 .T
1b
\?a a To me oasis (2) « (3) rciNt
O 5 berlsestally to "Ole (I).tlloc
4 "a straight IoadeN 11" "Tough
0 and o $sales, or reverse as 6
'
3 illoatrated. .e
77
t 7
! `J I ?? 'i
1
2 ; i
15 JUN 19 21iui S
. s
Iwo .s .

COASTAL (;DANA `
HEADV ATER DEPTH FOR
CONCRETE PIPE CULVERTS
HEADWATER SCALES 2113
aEVISEM MAY 19x4 WITH INLET CONTROL
•uR[w a ?uu.IC MAW w. I+ss
VI-11
MEMORANDUM
TO: John Dorney Regional Contact: i- St nhuis
Non-Discharge Branch WO Supervisor: Rick Shiver
Date:
SUBJECT: WETLAND STAFF REPORT AND RECOMMENDATIONS
Facility Name David & Ruth Ann Phillips County New Hanover
Project Number 00 1102 County2
Recvd From DCM Region Wilmington
Received Date 8/22/00 Recvd By Region
Project Type storm wall
Certificates Stream Stream Impacts (ft.)
Permit Wetland Wetland Wetland Stream Class Acres Feet BE
Type Type Impact Score Index Prim. Supp. Basin Req. Req. CAMA sM O Y O N I 18-87 SA HQW 30,617. 0.02F
?- F__
?- Q Y O N ?????? ? ? ?..?
Mitigation Wetland
MitigationType Type Acres Feet
Is Wetland Rating Sheet Attached? Q Y O N Did you request more Info? Q Y O N
Have Project Changes/Conditions Been Discussed With Applicant? Q Y O N
Is Mitigation required? p Y p N Recommendation: Q Issue 6 Issue/fond O Deny
Provided by Region: Latitude (ddmmss) 341351
Longitude (ddmmss) 774806
Comments:
This office has no major objection to the proj P -t as proposed. There is however mitigation required
for this porject. The applicant has received a NW 18 in the past for 0.10 AC (DWO project # 94008).
This and the fact that landfall has impacted over an acte of wetlands would require this project to
have mitigation.

?/ r"---&- - 61?L,9
cc: Regional Office
Central Office 0--
Page Number 1
Facility Name David & Ruth Ann Phillips County New Hanover

Project Number 00 1102 Regional Contact: J. Steenhuis
Date: 9/7/2000
Comments (continued from page 1):
cc: Regional Office Page Number 2
Central Office
State of North Carolina
Department of Environment
and Natural Resources
Division of Water Quality
James B. Hunt, Jr., Governor
Bill Holman, Secretary
Kerr T. Stevens, Director
11k.9WA •
NC ENR
NORTH CAROLINA DEPARTMENT OF
ENVIRONMENT AND NATURAL RESOURCES
September 29, 2000
New Hanover County
DWQ Project No. 001.102
David and Ruth Ann Phillips
1035 Ocean Ridge Drive
Wilmington, NC, 28405
Dear Mr. and Ms. Phillips:
On August 22, 2000. the NC Division of Water Quality received your application for a 401
Water Quality Certification to impact 0.02 acre of wetlands in order to construct a storm wall on
your property in New Hanover County. Since the cumulative wetland impacts associated with
your property (DWQ #94-0008) and the Landfall Subdivision exceed one acre, compensatory
stream mitigation will be required in accordance with 15A NCAC 2H.0506(h). You have the
following options for satisfying the wetland mitigation requirement associated with this project:
1. Payment into the North Carolina Wetland Restoration Program, if the WRP will accept
the responsibility for conducting this mitigation work, or
2. Preparing and implementing a wetland mitigation plan on your own.
We strongly suggest that you locate a mitigation site within the same river sub-basin as your
project. If you elect to propose payment into the WRP in lieu of developing your own mitigation
plan, please contact Mr. Ron Ferrell at [phone] to ask whether the WRP will be able to add
this project to their schedule. If so, you should obtain written verification from the WRP and
provide a copy of their concurrence to this office. Please note that the Wetland Restoration
Program (WRP) rules require rounding of wetland restoration amounts to one-quarter acre
increments (15A NCAC 2R.0503(b)).
Until this information is received, I will request (by copy of this letter) that the Corps of
Engineers place this project on hold. Also, this project will be placed on hold for our processing
due to incomplete information (15A NCAC 2H.0507(h)). I can be reached at [phone].
orney
cc: Corps of Engineers Wilmington Field O
Wilmington DWQ Regional Office
File Copy
Central Files
Richard V. Civelli. 139 Stokley Road, Wilmington, NC, 28403
Division of Water Quality - Non-Discharge Branch
401/Wetlands Unit, 1621 Mail Service Center, Raleigh, NC 27699 Telephone [phone] FAX [phone]
An Equal Opportunity Affirmative Action Employer - 50% recycled/10% post consumer paper
DEPARTMENT OF THE ARMY
i / WILMINGTON DISTRICT, CORPS OF ENGINEERS
69 DARLINGTON AVENUE
I- I WILMINGTON, NORTH CAROLINA 28403
REPLY TO
ATTENTION OF: "
August 29, 2000
I'
I''".` NEE Ilrr IL': ( !!'.
Regulatory Division W???
Action ID No. 200001601
David and Ruth Ann Phillips
103 5 Ocean Ridge Drive
Wilmington, North Carolina 28405
Dear Mr. and Mrs. Phillips:
On July 24, 2000, we renewed general permit No. 198000291 (copy enclosed), that provides
Federal authorization for construction activities that receive authorization from the State of North
Carolina.
A review of your application received August 18, 2000, for Department of the Army
authorization to construct two retaining walls, fill, landscape and create a pond adjacent to the
Intracoastal Waterway near Wilmington, New Hanover County, North Carolina, indicates it to be a
candidate for Federal authorization under this general permit. Accordingly, the administrative
processing of your application will be accomplished by the North Carolina Division of Coastal
Management. Comments from Federal review agencies will be furnished to the State.
If your application must be withdrawn from this general permit process for any reason, you will
be informed regarding its further management. If there are no unresolved differences in State-Federal
positions or policies, the final action taken on your application by the State will result in your receiving
written notice from us that your application is consistent with the general permit and you may
commence your activity. Only after receiving such confirmation should you begin work.
Your application, pursuant to Section 10 of the River and Harbors Act and Section 404 of the
Clean Water Act, has been assigned Action ID No. 200001601. It will be coordinated by the
undersigned, available at telephone [phone].
Sincerely,
Jeffrey H. Richter
Regulatory Project Manager
Enclosure
Copies Furnished (without enclosure):
Mr. Doug Huggett
Division of Coastal Management
North Carolina Department of
Environment and Natural Resources
1638 Mail Service Center
Raleigh, North Carolina 27699-1638
Mr. William L. Cox, Chief
Wetlands Section - Region IV
Water Management Division
U.S. Environmental Protection Agency
61 Forsyth Street, SW
Atlanta, Georgia 30303
Mr. John Dorney
Division of Water Quality
North Carolina Department of
Environment and Natural Resources
1621 Mail Service Center
Raleigh, North Carolina 27699-1621
Dr. Garland B. Pardue, Field Supervisor
U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service
Fish and Wildlife Enhancement
Post Office Box 33726
Raleigh, North Carolina 27636-3726
Mr. Larry Hardy
National Marine Fisheries Service
Habitat Conservation Division
Pivers Island
Beaufort, North Carolina 28516
Mr. C. Robert Stroud, Jr., District Manager
Wilmington Regional Office
North Carolina Division of
Coastal Management
127 Cardinal Drive Extension
Wilmington, North Carolina 28405-3845

I" I
REPLY TO
ATTENTION OF:
Regulatory Division
Action ID No. 200001601
Mr. John Dorney
Division of Water Quality
North Carolina Department of
Environment and Natural Resources
1621 Mail Service Center
Raleigh, North Carolina 27699-1162
Dear Mr. Dorney:
August 29, 2000

Reference the application of Davis and Ruth Ann Phillips for Department of the Army
authorization and a State Water Quality Certification to construct two retaining walls, fill,
landscape and create a pond adjacent to the Intracoastal Waterway near Wilmington, New
Hanover County, North Carolina. Your receipt of this letter verifies your acceptance of a valid
request for certification in accordance with Section 325.2(b)(ii) of our administrative regulations.
We are considering authorizing the proposed activity pursuant to Section 404 of the Clean
Water Act, and we have determined that a water quality certification is required under the
provisions of Section 401 of the same law. A Department of the Army permit will not be granted
until the certification has been obtained or waived.
r?) o !ID
DEPARTMENT OF THE ARMY
WILMINGTON DISTRICT, CORPS OF ENGINEERS
69 DARLINGTON AVENUE
WILMINGTON, NORTH CAROLINA 28403
According to our administrative regulations, 60 days is reasonable for State action.
Therefore, if you have not acted on the request, or asked for an extension of time, by October 21,
2000, the District Engineer will deem that waiver has occurred.

Questions or comments may be addressed to the undersigned, available at telephone (910)
251-4636.
Sincerely,
Jeffrey H. Richter
Regulatory Project Manager
Copy Furnished:
Mr. Doug Huggett
Division of Coastal Management
North Carolina Department of
Environment and Natural Resources
1638 Mail Service Center
Raleigh, North Carolina 27699-1638

DEPARTMENT OF THE ARMY
WILMINGTON DISTRICT, CORPS OF ENGINEERS
P.O. BOX 1890
WILMINGTON, NORTH CAROLINA 28402-1890
IN REPLY REFER TO February 28, 2001
Regulatory Division
Action 1D No. 200001601 and State Permit No. 015-01
David and Ruth Ann Phillips
1035 Ocean Ridge Drive
Wilmington, North Carolina 28405
Dear Mr. and Mrs. Phillips:
go ??d ?k
MAR Y 1 2001
Reference your application for a Department of the Army (DA) permit to construct two
retaining walls, fill, landscape and create a pond, adjacent to the Atlantic Intracoastal Waterway,
at 1035 Ocean Ridge Drive, Landfall Subdivision, Wilmington, New Hanover County, North
Carolina.
Your proposal has been reviewed and found to be consistent with the provisions and
objectives of general permit 198000291. Therefore, you may commence constriction activity in
strict accordance with applicable State authorization and the enclosed plan. Failure to comply
with the State authorization or conditions of the general permit could result in civil and/or
administrative penalties.
If any change in your work is required because of unforeseen or altered conditions or for
any other reason, plans revised to show the change must be sent promptly to this office and the
North Carolina Division of Coastal Management prior to performing any such change or
alteration. Such action is necessary as revised plans must be reviewed and the authorization
modified.
Questions or comments may be addressed to Lillette Moore, Wilmington Field Office,
Regulatory Division, telephone [phone].
Sincerely,
Wayne Wright, Chief'
Regulatory Division
Enclosure

Copies Furnished (with enclosure)-
Chief, Source Data Unit
NOAA/National Ocean Service
ATTN: Sharon Tear N/CS261
1315 East-West Hwy. Rm. 7316
Silver Spring, Maryland 20910-3282
Mr. John Dorney
Division of Water Quality
North Carolina Department of
Environment and Natural Resources
1621 Mail Service Center
Raleigh, North Carolina 27699-162 1
Mr. William L. Cox, Chief
Wetlands Section - Region IV
Water Management Division
U.S. Environmental Protection Agency
61 Forsyth Street, SW
Atlanta, Georgia 30303
Mr. Doug Huggett
Division of Coastal Management
North Carolina Department of
Environment and Natural Resources
1638 Mail Service Center
Raleigh, North Carolina 27699-1638
Dr. Garland Purdue, Field Supervisor
U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service
Fish and Wildlife Enhancement
Post Office Box 33726
Raleigh, North Carolina 27636-3726
Mr. Ron Sechler
National Marine Fisheries Service
Pivers Island
Beaufort, North Carolina 28516
Mr. David Rackley
National Marine Fisheries Service
NOAA
219 Fort Johnson Road
Charleston, South Carolina 29412-9110
Mr. C. Robert Stroud, Jr., District Manager
Wilmington Regional Office
North Carolina Division of Coastal Management
127 Cardinal Drive Ext.
Wilmington, North Carolina 28405-3845

1
1
I
1
I
9 444
v
y
m !
i
N ?" v ................ Z",

( F r b• - is

I
i
s »°a? Sa.» o

R
4
?
DD
$.?4 asit.o
S
°?9?o
g
nL,a'
•
°
oR
xSc
FL ??
J
\ q !
aZ?"
\
J
?f

1 J J
o
` W
m
j
Z
I N ?
'

it U
' O

I c
Li 54? L
^0
n
O j \ V
nQ
V
CD
Q
i
Z
A
A I ?
W U
rn
I
I
i
u
I
Z
IA
O V
A IU
w ?
r'i
z
CIO
O V
?I U
O O
m
? J
?,? ?a6\f
549'32'32"E m?.v +
237.79' --f rt
q I y + + + + + S?o?s•f
0C
E• `?J? + I + + %p
+ + +
Pd•. Sk" + + Cli
L co c;

N

A
+ N
A
U +
O a? a m` +
j
- ?
e

r .
m + +
ry + +
+ +
+
O O
u yq r (n
+ N

r + I w c ;

N49'42'04"W
- -
L ?? b
?• + N
+ L
N
_
- - - - -
--219.071
-
??? -
-- -?

w
_..?..-
(
11
;u N F + I - ?
C
Lo +

u + +
d+ VI
-
b U J
Ot O ??
+
;
I
+ + O
N
?L
z n r ? I W
l'.(
,
m o uu "' -h

n + + + - -,
? I + YI
mom I + I T
- N49'42'04"W 214.78' tot C% + + o° o
177.65'
20.13' Z
16
00' `
°
.
n
? 2
y v

O
o m
O
P n
I

,
_' a a
? n
D . 1O
w
co

o `X
CD
a
S tz u O
l
o
cn 3
R. O
i
!
o O
R'
' CD o p
C Z S n O m
C"
" ((D
o CD n
? ? n
>v n n
? ? ?c o? u `? ? Q L
b O ? i 7? ? g ? n

a N ? ? /? Q
? L?l ?
r ° r9i
a rl
- n
U
p

?• z 0 n i
O ?
rn _ S

J
r
?'' r
W r
W r-
t.+ r
W r
N r
N r
N r
N r
N r
N r
N r'
N r-
I r
N r
I r
I r
I
r r
r
r
r
;
r r r r r r r r r r r
I I
? W N -- O t0 U V rn O p
W
N N
?
O
rp
W
V --' -'
Or U -'
.A -
W -
rJ ....
I I I I I I Z
O ID W V Or U A W
N ? m

In

"?
Ou

N
N
O

N

W
N _
N

t?0
to

°r
OU

OOi
y

("'
(p
U

O
?
_

V
?
(N

V
W

W
rD
m

O
O
W

A
O
W

O(
O
OD

U
W
A A

lp N
m
V

lP
Q

pp

p
V

A Z

•"' _.. N W m 2
LO M U
N A t0 J O W O N Z
Q) V ? N ? a N N v? V N U A N G7

V7
V Z
A V1
A Z

W N
P Z

U Z

W Z

O Z
N Z Z Z Z Z Z V1 Vl N l!1 V7 Vl Vl Vl Z
Z Z (/1 Z Z Z VI Z Z Z
C
v
il• Or
U W
CS rn
O
O 'O N
b V t0 °, u
A W a
OD T
t.71 a
Lb W
P V
W O N
°1 W a
pp v Or V N DD Of -V Or W O Z

.'
m
N O O
i P l.n
W V
-' O
a O
N N
W N
0
> l0
W V:
(.+ V
W N V N N Q m O O V J. W d Cl CS ) -i
V N N W :[7 D
r
E •
m O N t? Of Ol tp N O N A r O N U (Jr 1U N
A
• Ql
• N
V r
N r./i (.!? N A O Vj r•,? N N rm-
t0 V A V m U °f Oi C? O'1 G) frl
f r'?' '^ m ? m m m m m m m f f m m m m m mmmmmm
mmmm
`^O
Yn
? J
1
m
D
?1G

( 1 i ? H
E7

off `.
UI ? :
3

V ( N (
Y
V, ' ¦ r ¦ ?

?
y
o "
aN .Or. AAh
N O F9
a, Is O 0 0 0 0 o
?
c
zs
Q n cn (n
v l?1 ?. W
.~+?D
.•.

LL cnCA(Ar
Cn CA Cn G

' C
O (D
0
?
N 00 .D <

O 00 F-+ fD
C a
N

t
01% ?"N?
o U IT
1-Il
Cw
n
o a
•. l
?o1.0? w

T
w cm

o C7
F^
0
(Q
w Z3
rt A Q C,_ Cl
N
\
/

vr ? 'L3
jyL
?
\ p;.
Q A7
7c
isd. \
?f• \ rL
?9,ppd/'grey \ \ \
00
\ \ dl,ra/ Sid
CO V ? Ln A W N ~ \O O 1b

=
0 K
m I
0
Q' X
(D =.
Co
O X
C
W
w
(C) co
V Cr) v, M
?o
m -{
ID -0
I
I
J

_W
5-
O cD
wa
?w
!v
cn p?
N
?a
(D g
w
w
Cl)
CD
C1
V
O
00 /
+0 oA CD((DD
`
00
V a A
CD
Ko
?
w
rtel:: a
? `
w
cn'
w
o' -
D
CD -0

(D { v
? O
<
NO
-O
00
CL
cn p• 1
r-
(D
I. It
\ f°
?\ co
T w
\ <
CD
I ZE
=0
O?
y fD.y+
N
O .. ? I

-- - - - - - - - - - - -
N \
M A W
O
CD
rn
Cn
rv N N -+ -? .... .... ?.??.... _. Co 00 VCnVI A W N
N O cD co J m (7i.A W N O
O n

•

N CD (V7r'1f h?
C:)
O CD
N

O

A
o I
A
m I
w ,
CL ,
I
W W /
Cl) o I
_(n
J ?
m -?
(D
0
-

o?
0
A
=o
iz :3
,:?
Cf)
r?
(D •oo
(D p
M

W (n
O

W
C/)
1
1' r
?4
-8
m
?F O
<?
0
J
0
-
n

1
cnE
r ?
ro
W ?
O I
C I
N
(D ?
W
CD (D I
I
I
I
I
I

I--,
,
lot
ot-
Q
p,,,!
F??+ P-4-
? CD
W M
(n 'IV
N
4 crq
(D
C) Fr F?
W n
CM
G ?
O C

I? \
N.
1 \
I \\
I
1
1
n I
? can /
/ !D
(D
N
7
cn'
CD
J I
I
I
I
1
I
I
I
I
I
I
I I
II A
I O
1 A
I O
I ?
I I a
1 I
1 I
cp M?-j n
n < G) 0
cn 0

F- •
- N cD , cD n
ii Cu Q _Q
A? v? .., .:..., ..? ..:..:., o

- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -
-
-

OD)
......t:::.......... .
?,

.....................

.
.
.
..
:.:.
:.
.
..
..
.
..

is •,:? ,: ,: •1: ,1
..:.....::..:..:..:.
?a
10,
a..
M
O
O D
G7

r< C
-' z

of OO o
0 Q- m -n
`D D m

/11 _1111

1-01,
1 C- rn --
cn (,o
n ?
r
- rt H
()
(D
rt r-'.
O Q•
0
n
Cn
n
r-r
O
O
O
c Lp
(D
cn 0
N
O
O
00
6'-4" max/ 9varies
-cnn
m
w
.A.
W
w
o -'_
100
-1
1
O
D
JUN 19 2000
DIVISION OF
COASTAL MANAGUA
w
a

?n
•
3

Q
J
I
Q .
0
Z
z
Q
F-
w

Q
Z g
0

v
p"1
r? r
V1J ? ? P-?1
A-j
? l)
uN
W
_h
V ?
U O
U
¢
G
v ?
w O
?z
CD
CD o c CD
o0
C
Ln ?p
v N

9'-4°112'
Existing
grade
=i
o;
rl
1
Philips Residence
Schematic Storm Wall • Section thrLL Outlet Valve
Scale: 1 " = 1' 0"
a5, a,cxo
JUL 2 7 2000
DIVISION OF
COASTAL MANArl::nn :Ki-r-
a
I d 3 C? c d5 ? Df
??; .,5 4---0
7De- S 5 Y ?. I c o I c` 4 Y, s
.Jc?n? ? 2000
Pre C-6 r.eCl ? r-
• , d V. (f•
CPO. Box I45
s v I I 1 e
?q??> Zs6- 93gs
r •1, t\ 111 N'
L. Py
rry Bpi ??,??? V J ?; l U
r`rlrfa:::?`?ti l?-?
rc ?o r ed \r
JUN 19 2000
DIVISION OF
COASTALMANACEMENT
G4TLIPJ ??5 r??Cr S s J c,'e r? Ci 5 ?s
Zzo O/C? ,Do'.1 y . Rd .
1, /Y ,, 5

JOB: Rr llrps ks,clP?c2 COMPUTED BY DATE: 6 2 00
DESCRIPTION: 100 `/Par- Ppe S'i Z-e- CHECKED BY DATE:
r-r,n ?,?.? O_... _. x-11. _ .._???e . _S?• 2 ...
vv,,,P.v•?s
-Ass
Ac,,-cs
Z-P7 kr-e-s E IVE
8 ? A-c re s
J

,rv rv vs . y By
-
-3
S/
110
L 71b ... J-, = Z - LY
/ Sd 3 ? 38 s-
2 Ss
q 73
76//?.T- 7L
J
s? 3y? - I
UN 1 9 zuuu
DIVISION OF
COASTAL MANAGEMEN
v
. 30 /,o
...7v -3 ..
JOB: , I < a, ce ?c?r ?r,? l l
DESCRIPTION: 100 ` e ?? Ze
COMPUTED BY. KPR DATE: 6 5-o0
CHECKED BY- DATE:
DIVISION OF
I 1 I I J - - - A-STALL MANAG'EME -t
rx

-- ^^ -

lc_
_C,L fp CA-
0 C'?(fL /??O
S
r
.-?'.t!?.G---ode ??y. -?------.
W c'
I . /
__....lt. t e r .
C?7= Z/ 3 ?f-s 7 3 2 ?S
CAELin
e ? - /?j o? /?Ccl?p= 3A? 16.5c?s
ENGINEERS and SCIENTISTS
Qr = 2e+I6,S : yySc?s >38.2c?s F--?6- q Fi- 9 01 1 O
11 11 II II
11 II L.
11 O.-M1 cowrN%0 PIn O 11
W It II )•. C 11 OvLOP O v OIn O 11
II •? II . • II
d O II 11 11 O 11 O -NvvN I,- O O 11
U II II O 11 .- '11
V II 11 .- 11 II
E 2 U 11 11 II II
O 2 11 11 11 11
? ? 11 II 11
U X11 11 L 11 vOPNOI- OO it
O GL 11 11 T C 11
s u La If at \M10hM MP'r 1` O II
Z u ,
O 11 11 II O`•-• 11 O?'-NMVV?01? P II
II N 11 11
LL W 11 11 11 11
?+ •
U tY z 11 11 11
S II If It
11 II
II II ?C 11 •0 In .r .r P V \?O II
•? II 11 In u II Orr NM M.r In .0 m II
II 11 N 11 II
11 N II 11
II 11 11
11 II 11 II
11 11 L 11 Oto ?O N N 'y
•pNtiN 11
L II 11 A C 11 .O OM ?- [p 11
II II 0, r-
11 II
L U 11 11 O •-• II O .-NNMM V V1 ?O II
2 11 II II 11
?• J ? 11 n 11 11 II
m c u n
4 O t1 II j? 11
/1 H ?•• 11 11 L 11 In d V OOMP 0CD
11
YY.•.•1I OI II 11 )•. C II V1 P N P In P N N O W II
.U U C 11 ••- II 11 11
CJ Z II L 11 In ?+ II 0 0 .-• r• N N M ?f E In In II
L _ n ii 11 II
W n
u
_ 0
W n 11 L II II II
IX 11 7 II L•.-, II P.rPco 0M000 ii
•- 11 u 11 J•. C 11 ?rOOln r-M•O MP I, 11
1 I I d I I j I I 11
Z 11 l1C 11 N `•• 11 O O N N N M M ?r II
L.• O 11 11 11 11
C II 11 II 11
11 II 11 II
< 11 11 11 I I
K •• II 11 II 11
7 2 II II 2 (1 II
C D O 11 11 O 11 II
?Jl ? ¢ n u< u E E E E E L L L L L u
cJ a U u u u u
p W O II 11 -D 11 In O Vl O O N In d N ?t 11
O J It II O 11 •-- '- M 10 .--• N 11
c?
Q
.o p
°
?, z o
y v

U O V Ld Q U

rJ C LLa z O CC`

?`_• L
W O u a?i
'
a

LO c >, c
cis U U U
cu
0
I.- ILI
L
C:. U O O C
?? Q• O 'L.
Q 3

3 u Q-vi
Q c 0
V) >
2 Z O- >
_
on
z
= c tu
ai

N Itui u trV W)
M U M
`
^ G
., ?
E C)
rn ??
?
p o p
U
•
t
=

G a.
U G =
O .i
O
V 'V

I? ? ? ?• IJ 1 v I ?
JUN 1 9 2000
DIVISION OF
COASTAL MANAGEMENT
II 11 11 II
II II '-T II ON NCO fbr-NC2 N II
11 11 L II d v M P J O v II
11 11 O \ 11 Pmr`?vNr- • II
II II O C II "" O O 11
11 11 ? ? 11 II
II II ?•• II II
11 II 11 11
II II 11 II
II 11 L 11 cPtnvO P Vlti 11
11 II ?. L 11 LA1`t•vwOO q, 11
11 11 L II ` II
I I I I O\ I I co N O in M N.- O O 11
11 II to C 11 II
11 11 II 11
II II u II 11
u n u u
11 II II 11
11 II •• L 11 !2 :2 N^"D MAM II
II 11 L II PvP VPInM 11
11
II 11 In \ 11 W ,- C)?t O 00 11
11 II N C 11 II
11 II II 11
II 11 ?-• 11 II
II II 11 11
11 II 11 ' 11
II II L II M O In I„N/?Ir1 O wLO II
W II 11 ?. L II NM VNP.O NOD vN 11
Cn tl II , L II 11
m u II II O \ II t?.O II'1 .1 Nr.--O O O 11
< 2 11 II [ II II
'- n n If - It
11
1 . 11 " 111 II
u C It II
11
U 0 II 11 11
.'Z II ?7 11 L •--, 11 M •0 1- P LID O O N .t 11
W fT II O II j. L II •O 1? P L? In ?r f? V N 11
C 11 •? 11 i L 11 • II
OI E ii d ii C ii .01n ?r t?1 0 00 II
Iz -- n d u - u
?- .- u u ?-• II 11
7L 11 C 11 11 II
S n II L II 11 11
O II 7 II L II LO .O .O^ O2 LOM II
11 ? II j, L II O O M M P II
'-- 11 fU 11 L II tL] In M II
4 II K II N \ II In Ln V M N • 11
LY 11 11 C II r' O O O O 11
11 11 11 II
? II It u II II
II II II 11
? " 11 tl 11 II
•- 2 11 II 2 II 11
fn O` 11 11 O II C C C C C it
11
W ¢ II ii < ii E E E E E L L L L s it
s o u u m a 11
11 11 I!Y O Vl O O N M •O N ?f II
J 11 II O II r .-- M •p •- N 11
? o -
0
o Z a
?N3
o ?
U IU
In
Lcl
IU V
ti o ?-
M o
0
O
on
O
CZ 0 0
rn p In
21 '2
aU C4 a>
G'• U
N •f°.• L. .C
U •C C C1
3= Lcp
N
0\
IT
C
a?
D
0
u
ca

2
I-
tQ
C.
N
II II
I I L 11 v co O N M IT
I I
11 11 N N M M M M 11
11 11 II
II II II
11 II 11
11 11 II
II 11 II
II 11 11
11 II
C II QI II ?P NO O? II
II 11 O Min II
N E 11 II .-N NM MM 11
C 11 11 11
O .•. O 11 II 11
+ 11 11 II
•? ? II II II
A v V 11 11
7 H 11 cc 11 N In O N O O 11
Q\ V
11
W m 11 11 11 ?-N In CD
11 11
?- II L 11 11 II
II
O O 11 11 II
... w II II II
II 11 11
-------------------
II 11 II II
II II II
11 II 11 11
II 11 II II
II 11 II
11 II 11 V9 M
m II
II II II M M M II
II 11 11 of
11 II II O 0 O O II
II II II K K K 17 II
II II d II O p O II
II II u 11 )- Y Y d 11
II 11 L II S 2 S H 11
II U 11 7 II II
11 2 11 0 n<<< m u
if 11 H n¢¢< 3 u
It 11 II O O O In
11
11 C II II 2 2 2 =3 II
11 O II 11 II --
II 11 d 11 OM L00
11 n
1 1:71 11
11 C II L C :i 9 9 O
II 11 ?.. ?+ II O - ?f O 11
u E u it u
u-• it o it
n
II II O II II ¢
II A II 11 11
II n If II it it
11 d 11 0-01 O O II p
u 1 11 c u v o In n
11 II L II • II
II II ?•. u II O ? N v 11
II II II
11 11 N 11 11 ,
II 11 II II V
< II • II 11 11 --
F- II •• 11 11 11
< II 2 11 C II p
C3 II O 11 O 11 II
II "' 11 11 C C C II
1-- 11 1-- 11 ? _
Z) 11 < It III 11 E E E L 11
CL 11 u II L 11 . II
Y 11 O 11 7 11 / n on O v 11
•--• II -1 11 O 11 •-- 10 N 11

Exhibit 11
ISO 10,000
0-
Ise 6,000 EXAMPLE (?) (2) (3)
136 6,000 D•42 lack" (3.5 test) 176.
144 6,000 0.120 cts
132 4,000 0 mw 5.
0 too
3,000 {,
120 (1) 2.3 BBB 6• 4.
2,000 W 2.1 7.4
108 (3) _.: T.7 14.
3.
'D I. too 3.
96 1,000 3.
Boo
84 --
600 / 2• 2-
500
¢ 72 400
Z 300
¢ tt? / u? ? ¢ IBS IBS
= 60 U. 200 / s 3 W 1.5
64
W 40 n 100
J ¢ BO p
42 60 W 1.0 1.0
0 o ENTRANCE °
W 4 SCALE TYPE W 1.0
W 36 2L7 30 (1) $aware ad" with- t ?
.11
` 33 Aegds»II 39
It ?.? 0 (17 Greg" se/ with
W
2? ego hoodwell
30 = •B B
.B
(3) Greg" and
27 ?rsleetlst
10
24 .T
R7 i??,0 6 To wee seta (2) of (3) Molest
21 \ 5 herl:Mtslly to sseis (1), IAN
4 ass straight inclined lime te?eelph
D and 0 sales, or reverse as
.6
3 illestreted. 6
T! A17
2
1' JUN 19 2000 j .6
1.0 ,6 .S
DIVISION OF
COASTAL MANA?Pr?; 4i" TER `iTER DEPTH FOR
HEADWATER SCALES 283 CONCRETE PIPE CULVERTS
REVISED MAY 0641 WITH INLET CONTROL
BUREAU Of KOOK ROAD! .?AK 1`043
VI-11
?? 0 / 0
C ?
0
w
1 0, ° LJ-LLI
t`I '+N z o
-J. 0
z661. 2z a eN.9"3S a3Si k('' - _ ,
J . 1 r 1f t '
Cl)
Q v Q
1661 'o ?2 k-1 n c ,.?
I-OM -DNIISIX3
1661 1 snsn!? r ?d bM J r1 b ?: S ?/ Q :??! 1 R! I ti
1"M ?3S!A3;1, N v
:31ON 1 1 1
0661 'C,7 839W31d35 (I Vg011 ,
.0 07313 3NI!
dl-I Mud \ \ 7A 7h
/ r. 13
?30 '0 11
oil
• `' :: T _.
mom
?' .,,.. • ?: .,' ? ' '??, i? a Ste. `• ' -
1 rr :r ?i(:.'. yr., / , i• ??}r + ?t?1? ?(qr ???, Y ^I? t r? ?"? ..r?? ?_
r, that ,A'. A •u r ?.i. (. 1,. !W !?'{.?^ '?"'r tLw?'l?1,ry?:. .. .d'.hi'??• ? ?? ' N•?' ti' `-
/
.oo
p r ac. l: 1?
POW
dolo
10,
18 0l
/
/ `/rte {, R'? 1
.0010,
10,
F
z
W
C U- w
O
O

°' z<
Oz
d

?F
U)
O

U
U
I?.
fn
cU
m
L
_LM
C
(n
(ll
LL
N (?
c
-ca
1
N
O '
1
I
1
1
N M d' U-)(Of- 00 01 .- r-Mrr? r
I
I
I'
I'
II I
II 1
I \ \
I
I
I ?
I 1
I
I
? J
I T ? ?
oQ
_ cn oQ

cc! rn
Q
O

CIO w .,4
cf)
?
O
0
?:
Z
l
00 rn O N (h a LO
N N \ N N N N
C Q
Z
Lj t
?r ?2 r r(2

'
\ 1
ti ,I
I
\ ? I

c ?.
z

0 3
¢u p

\ v?
vO
oz

N 0 o
o
on ?

o.-NCOain co n m rn o N m v rn
N C7 'R rncon ap o) .--.- .-.-.-? .- .- N N N N N N

\I I ?y H
7
O
N
WO=
II ,
I
ro,", "I O O O
NN N NN
c?a?:? r I ; r
7 I :•ir:::.......f.
::i::
??::..•.ii:: '••r:::..
O 1 f.i:ii ::.f:!}•:::;;: : .':::} iiis i'r'r •::•i:T:i: i.:::•:: f'iii:.:.
Ua \
cU
.n
a?
0
I
c
I
\
0
:':•::'
2 0 ? r
I
U
3
m
jo m
a?
I
}
z
a
T
1 }}tt y I
..........................................................................................
1. ?.
...............................................................................................
\ oo+ I
I
i ter. ':•:?i:: i .....•:.::.i..?r.:::ii: :•::•ii::i•::•:ii:•::::ici•::::':::•i:•:i:•isi:i:::ii:•::•i:::::•i:•:::.:' ::•:::• :..... O) N
is :: is
II
I
L
y
........
..:....
i I
f0
I \
X
R?'
?::•:iii:?'•..::..,..'•'..•.•:i?::•:•?'•i:.??'•'?' •
I
I
..,,.r..?•?
.,?
F}xr.
i
I
•?:•:':••''t
:•:::
I
I
N
U
QI
C C
y
.`.?::i;;.....::
y
'X •y I
O
W
I
00
I
t
- r
r
i
I
I
N C
O
c0
'O
I
:::x::;:•:'•' Ir U N
}} -O (d "?'
:f::;1:i.'..*.i:•.. C C C
C' ?(d
U
ct?
O
i. I
I
ca -0 3
::
1
I !
---- --------
1
:t
+1:.
?'i_:
i...
?:Y r'' ::.
...:} i s:" :•.tr: E..... :• ?? i r i k?tiy??;:;his??{{rr,.,.?i::•:.
.:....
......:
.. N
N N N N N
r
Z
U- O ? w
:. I Q y ra O
N z C N
O o
Qv cn
.? Q ?Z
N
.IZ",cu
Q
Lf)
en rl:?
I cu t\
Z (71
O
O
O
N
L
T
C
/xew 131-.9
11 u - 1 LII
0
T

V
1

IMEN,
O
T
W

1 a
O 110 1G 4
1

m
iil
Ir-------- -•

?'"-1I o U- W
cm 0 0
? c
? 0
j
N Q
c" o
Q

co - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -

O

T
O V T ^'
0 W v W Ca
U C E U 3 N W
M a OOC ?•C
0 C13
U
O
'^O
^\J
O
^V
rA
V J
•
W
/V
W
r^ +J _
1"? V J V /
O
U
v
u
.,-4
H
•
CL$ ?
? •c
? O Q
v ?
_o
r,
;}v^x.,/1..1' II
T
U ca
(j) cn
n
CO
O
T M < 11 %%
z
LL J
1 0?? ?o
? ?
I- W
i Z661 ?Z U.1&431436
0351 !l '' . I
' O J 1 ' f, t? Q
c? o P? u
2
1661 al< J lnP
V-113M 'ONI1sIX3
1661 109 lsnqnv 4,kft?l 31VM - VISVOOd231NI I..ZNH
Id-11.3M o3SIA3a
I 1 .
310N
11l 0661 '£Z .N38W31dgs 031400"1 !
0 0"1313 3N17 •d'O'O
7A
d13
z mot tiz m 7h
Til
.? 4.:04N
Val
CL- 180 '011
s`` s
J-1' ?, ry' ,•,,
• r ?.;
• .?. ?!?' J ?? .?? ',1 •. r+? ?, J{f r.' ~r.? +. j,.y K!n' 'e,•y,1i. ?1? 4?0 y?i 'ft'- t ..+ i ??
9 'tar' ; ?[ ?? Q 4 tY+f r 1 '
' Y ,• qtr. ,w a '1..• ?
f:W:
r
idl
11,00 T? , ti! 1 I 1
?
- • ? + ,?. , ti 1y Y^ ?,111. . 1 ?
MOW s
77,
/ /9) ?` ??
Ass"
#VOW L
AWF
el e-o-.
?- >
.oooo
,.,oo, _ r
' / ?1/? ?? y'?? -tom `1 ' 1,? • ?'
/oo, loop