HomeMy WebLinkAboutNC0020559_Annual Performance_20200123 0
r11LA,A-%
o . . ITY OF HENDERSON
;. y' Water Reclamation Facility
t�� . . �� Post Office Box 1434
U'�ice. \.'' Henderson,North Carolina 27536-1434
r�ft C Phone: (252)431-6080 FAX: (252)492-3324
Shipping Address-1646 West Andrews Avenue,Henderson NC 27537
January 23`d, 2020
CERTIFIED MAIL-RECEIPT REQUESTED
Monti Hassan RECEIVED
NC DWR-Water Quality Permitting Section JAN 2 9 2020
Wastewater Branch—PERCS Unit
1617 Mail Service Center
Raleigh,NC 27699-1617 NCDEQ/DWR/NPDES
Re: The 2019 Pretreatment Annual Report (PAR)
City of Henderson
Water Reclamation Facility
NC0020559
Dear Mr. Hassan:
Enclosed please find two copies of the Pretreatment Annual Report(PAR period: January
1 through June 30, and July 1 through December 31, 2019) due March 1, 2020.
If you have questions or need additional information please contact me at 252-431-6085
or Lamont Allen at 252-431-6081.
erely,
Darrel Jo son
Pre-treatment Coordinator
C: Lamont Allen, WRF Director
1
City of Henderson 2019 PAR
1 . Narrative
I /
City of Henderson 2019 PAR
2019 PAR Narrative
GENERAL INFORMATION:
GENERAL PROGRAM INFORMATION:
• The Headworks Analysis was revised for Dissolved Metals standards and was received on
8/16/19. An email was received from Monti Hassan on 11/4/19 stating agreement with the
calculations.
• A revised LTMP was submitted on 12/4/19.
• A revised ERP to address 40 CFR Part 441 Requirements was submitted on 1/4/2020.
• All other dates and information on the Division's Pretreatment Program Information Sheet are
correct.
• A copy of our Program Info sheet is enclosed.
GENERAL PERMIT INFORMATION:
• No permits lapsed or expired prior to renewal
SIU INFORMATION:
Mars Petcare(IUP#0011,Pet Foods)
SNC and other INFORMATION:
SRI was not in SNC this PAR Year.
Please note on the IDSF form that: Arsenic,Cadmium,Chromium,Lead,Mercury,Nickel, Selenium,
Silver,Molybdenum and Ammonia were listed as not required for the 1st 6 month period because our
LTMP annual monitoring requirements for these parameters were met in the 2nd 6 month period.
Cyanide is not required on our LTMP.
Pretreatment Program Info Database printed on: 12/20/2019
for Program Name Henderson IWC%at 7010 96.97 \
WWTP Name Henderson Water Reclamation Facility Stream Information
7010 Flow cfs/mgd 0.2 / 0.13
Program Approval Date 10/21/1983
1010 Flow cfs/mgd 0.17 / 0.11
Pretreatment Status
Full Stream Classification C
Region RRO Basin Number ROA06
County Vance Receiving Stream Name NUTBUSH CREEK
NPDES Number NC0020559
Last PAR Rec 02/07/2019 PAR Due Date 03/01/2020 mercury
NPDES Effective Date 08/01/2019 1631
NPDES Expire Date Current Fiscal 07/17/2019 required
P 03/31/2023 Year PCI Done
POTW is Primary WWTP
TRUE Last Audit on 05/24/2017 Audit Year Next21/22 yes
Design Flow mgd 4.1400 %Design mgd is SIU permitted 1.81 Permitted SIU flow(mgd)[Pt_SIU) .075
WWTP SIU's 1 Program SIUs 11
WWTP CIU's 0 Program CIUs 0 HWA LTMP IWS SUO ERP
date Inactive Date Next Due 04/01/2022 12/31/2019 04/30/2022
Date Received by DWR 03/23/2017 01/30/2017 05/01/2017 11/09/2012 10/20/2008
Date Approved 06/15/2017 04/24/2017 06/14/2017 11/19/2012 11/19/2008
Adopt Date Required
Date Adopted 05/13/2013
Info in this Box from Pt Contacts Date Date Date
PT_Pro Attended Attended Attended
Formal Name g.Prime Phonel ext Fax HWA Wksp IUP Wksp PAR Wksp
Mr.H.Lamont Allen I 11(252)431-6081 I 1(252)492-3324 11 1/24/2017 I
hlallen@ci.henderson.nc.us Director,WRF PO Box 1434 27536
Mr.Darrel Johnson (Prim 11(252)431-6085 J 1252-492-3324 II 1/24/2017 14/18/2012 12/5/2013 I
djohnson@ci.henderson.nc.us Pretreatment Coordinator PO Box 1434 27536
JPretreatment Related NOVs from DWQ ) f T DWR Central Office Contact Monti Hassan
7-1-1996 6/12/96 pci-no inspections DWR Regional Contact Cheng Zhang
6/29/1999 Central Office did PAR review
4/13/2000 tox pretreatment sampling and enforcement
• 1
City of Henderson 2019 PAR
2. Pretreatment program
Summary (PPS)
Chapter 9, PAR Guidance
Pretreatment Performance Summary (PPS)
1. Pretreatment Town Name: City of Henderson WRF
2. "Primary" NPDES Number NCOO 20559
or Non Discharge Permit#if applicable=>
3. PAR Begin Date,please enter O 1/01/yyyy 3._> 1/1/2019
4. PAR End Date, please enter 12/31/yyyy 4.=> 12/31/2019
5. Total number of SIUs, includes CIUs 5.=> 1
6. Number of CIUs 6.=> 0
7. Number of SIUs with no IUP, or with an expired IUP 7.=> 0
8. Number of SIUs not inspected by POTW 8.=> 0
9. Number of SIUs not sampled by POTW 9.=> 0
10. Number of SIUs in SNC due to IUP Limit violations 10.=> 0
11. Number of SIUs in SNC due to Reporting violations 11.=> 0
12. Number of SIUs in SNC due to violation of a Compliance Schedule,CO,AO or similar 12.=> 0
13. Number of CIUs in SNC 13.=> 0
14. Number of SIUs included in Public Notice 14.=> 0
15 Total number of SIUs on a compliance schedule,CO,AO or similar 15.=> 0
16. Number of NOVs,NNCs or similar assesed to SIUs 16.=> 2
17. Number of Civil Penalties assessed to SIUs 17.=> 1
18. Number of Criminal Penalties assessed to SIUs 18.=> 0
19. Total Amount of Civil Penalties Collected 19._> $ $50.00
20. Number of IUs from which penalties collected 20.=> 1
Foot Notes: AO Administrative Order IUP Industrial User Pretreatment Permit POTW Publicly Owned Treatment Works
CIU Categorical Industrial User NNC Notice of Non-Compliance SIU Significant Industrial User
CO Consent Order NOV Notice of Violation SNC Significant Non-Compliance
IU Industrial User PAR Pretreatment Annual Report
revised 1/2018: PAR PPS 2018
City of Henderson 2019 PAR
3 . Significant Non-
Compliance Report
(SNCR)
•
Pretreatment Annual Report (PAR) PAR covers this calendar year => 1/1/2019 - 12/31/2019
Significant Non-Compliance Report (SNCR) Control Authority=program=Town Name => City of Henderson
WWTP =Wastewater Treatment Plant, use separate form for each WWTP WWTP Name => WRF
SIU = Significant Industrial User NPDES # _> NC 0020559
SNC = Significant Non-Compliance
A SNCR Form must be submitted with every PAR, please write:"None" if you had No SIUs in SNC during calendar year
Parameter SNC ? (Yes /No)
IUP Pipe Industry Name or for each 6-month period
# # "Reporting" Jan. - June July- Dec.
NONE
Attach a copy of the Division's "SIUs in SNC Historical Report" for your POTW's SIUs behind this page.
Is the databse correct? Notify the Division of any errors! Database indicates SNC history for previous years
EVERY SNC MUST be explained in the Narrative, How was, is, or will it be resolved?
REPEAT SNCs are serious matters that MUST be explained in the Narrative.
Form name:PAR,SNCR,2001
Date Revised: 1/4/2001
City of Henderson 2019 PAR
4. Industrial Data
Summary Form (IDSF)
Pretreatment Annual Report (PAR)
Control Authority, Industry
Industrial Data Summary Form (IDSF) Town Name=> City of Henderson Name Mars Petcare
Use separate forms for each industry/pipe WWTP Name=> Henderson WRF IUP# '0011
Enter BDL values as<(value) NPDES#=> NC0020559 Pipe# 001
1st 6 months,dates=> 1/1/2019 to 6/30/19
2nd 6 months,dates=> 7/1/2019 to 12/31/19
r tow, mga tsv>u i as i emperature
1st b months 2nd 6 months 1st 6 months 2nd 6 months 1st 6 months -2nd 6 months 1st 6 months 2nd 6 months
Total#of samples=> 181 184 8 8 8 8 9 9
* Maximum (mg/1)=> 0.0338 MGD 0.0276 MGD 93.2 133 139 142 25 28
* or Maximum (lb/d)=>
* 6 mo.using zero Average(mg/1)_> 0.0113 MGD 0.0074 MGD 65.0 92.4 57.9 98.6 15.1 21.6
* or Average Loading(lb/d)=>
%violations,(chronic SNC is>=66%)=> ,, 0.0% 0.0% 0.0% 0.0% 0.0% 0.0% 0.0% 0.0%
%TRC violations,(SNC is>=33 %)=> o n/a n/a 0.0% 0.0% 0.0% 0.0% n/a n/a
%violations,(chronic SNC is>=66%)=> . n/a n/a n/a n/a n/a n/a n/a n/a
%TRC violations,(SNC is>=33%)=> ; n/a n/a n/a n/a n/a n/a n/a n/a
Arsenic -cadmium chromium col)
1st 6 months 2nd 6 months 1st 6 months 2nd 6 months 1st 6 months 2nd 6 months 1st 6 months 2nd 6 months
Total#of samples=> 1 1 1 8 8
* Maximum (mg/1)_> <0.002 <0.00015 <0.002 532 314
* or Maximum (lb/d)=> Not Not Not
* 6 mo.using zero Average(mg/1)=> Required 0.000 Required 0.00000 Required 0.000 230 223
* or Average Loading(lb/d)=>
%violations,(chronic SNC is>=66%)=> ,, n/a n/a 0.0% 0.0%
%TRC violations,(SNC is>=33%)=> o n/a n/a n/a 0.0% 0.0%
%violations,(chronic SNC is>=66%)=> n/a n/a n/a n/a n/a
%TRC violations,(SNC is>=33 %)=> ; n/a n/a n/a n/a n/a
Copper cyanide Lead Mercury
1st 6 months 2nd 6 months 1st 6 months 2nd 6 months 1st 6 months 2nd 6 months 1st 6 months 2nd 6 months
Total#of samples=> 4 5 1 1
* Maximum (mg/I)=> 0.049 0.146 <0.0005 <0.0002
* or Maximum (lb/d)=> Not Not Not Not
* 6 mo.using zero Average(mg/1)=> 0.030 0.060 Required Required Required 0.0000 Required 0.0000
* or Average Loading(1b/d)=>
%violations,(chronic SNC is>=66%)=> ,, 0.0% 20.0% n/a n/a
%TRC violations,(SNC is>=33%)=> 0 0.0% 20.0% n/a n/a
%violations,(chronic SNC is>=66%)=> s n/a n/a n/a n/a
%TRC violations,(SNC is>=33%)=> ; n/a n/a n/a n/a
BDL=>Below Detection Limit mg/I=>milligrams per liter
* POTW must enter at least one of these IUP=>Industrial User Permit lb/d=>pounds per day
four rows, Please indicate how averages were calculated SNC=>Significant Non-Compliance mgd=>million gallons per day
Avg period could be month,Qtr,or 6-month&if BDL,1/2BDL,or zero values used. TRC=>Technical Review Criteria WWTP=>wastewater treatment plant
Chapter: PAR Guidance File name: PAR_IDSF.xls Revision date:August 1,1994 Pagel
Pretreatment Annual Report (PAR) Industry Name Mars Petcare
Industrial Data Summary Form (IDSF) IUP# '0011
Use separate forms for each industry/pipe Pipe# 001
1MCKe1 eienium river -Lmc
1st 6 months 2nd 6 months 1st 6 months 2nd 6 months {1st 6 months 2nd 6 months 1st 6 months 2nd 6 months
Total#of samples=> 1 1 1 4 4
* Maximum (mg/1)=> 0.0061 <0.002 <0.0005 0.147 0.068
* or Maximum (lb/d)=> Not Not Not
* 6 mo.using zero Average(mg/1)=> Required 0.0061 Required 0.000 Required 0.0000 0.068 0.062
* or Average Loading(lb/d)=>
%violations,(chronic SNC is>=66%)=> ,, n/a n/a n/a 0.0% 0.0%
%TRC violations,(SNC is>=33 %)=> Q n/a n/a n/a 0.0% 0.0%
%violations,(chronic SNC is>=66%)=> n/a n/a n/a n/a n/a
%TRC violations,(SNC is>=33%)=> i n/a n/a n/a n/a n/a
Molybdenum pH (Std unit) lull & tirease 1 KN
1st 6 months 2nd 6 months 1st 6 months 2nd 6 months 1st 6 months 2nd 6 months 1st 6 months 2nd 6 months
Total#of samples=> 1 9 9 4 4 8 8
* Maximum (mg/I)=> 0.002 7.4-9.6 6.9-8.3 7.6 25.0 22.1 40.1
* or Maximum (lb/d)=> Not
* 6 mo.using zero Average(mg/1)=> Required 0.002 n/a n/a 2.6 8.8 14.1 27.1
* or Average Loading(lb/d)=>
%violations,(chronic SNC is>=66%)=> ,, n/a n/a 0.0% 0.0% 0.0% 0.0% 0.0% 12.5%
%TRC violations,(SNC is>=33%)=> o n/a n/a n/a n/a 0.0% 0.0% 0.0% 0.0%
%violations,(chronic SNC is>=66%)=> l n/a n/a n/a n/a n/a n/a n/a n/a
TRC violations,(SNC is>=33%)=> i n/a n/a n/a n/a n/a n/a n/a n/a
1 otal Y Ammonia
1st 6 months 2nd 6 months 1st 6 months 2nd 6 months
Total#of samples=> 8 8 1
* Maximum (mg/1)_> 15.3 40.0 9.4
* or Maximum (lb/d)=> Not
* 6 mo.using zero Average(mg/I)=> 7.6 9.7 Required 9.4
* or Average Loading(lb/d)=>
%violations,(chronic SNC is>=66%)=> ,, 0.0% 0.0% n/a
TRC violations,(SNC is>=33 %)=> 0 0.0% 0.0% n/a
%violations,(chronic SNC is>=66%)=> r n/a n/a n/a
%TRC violations,(SNC is>=33%)=> i n/a n/a n/a
BDL=>Below Detection Limit mg/1=>milligrams per liter
* POTW must enter at least one of these IUP=>Industrial User Permit lb/d=>pounds per day
four rows, Please indicate how averages were calculated SNC=>Significant Non-Compliance mgd=>million gallons per day
Avg period could be month,Qtr,or 6-month&if BDL,1/2BDL,or zero values used. TRC=>Technical Review Criteria WWTP=>wastewater treatment plant
Chapter: PAR Guidance File name: PAR_IDSF.xls Revision date:August 1,1994 Page3
City of Henderson 2019 PAR
5. Allocation Table
Copy of Henderson HWA AT Dissolved Metal Criteria,Worksheet Name: AT Printed: 1/23/2020, 9:09 AM
Page 1 of 5
Allocation Table Spreadsheet Instructions:
Headworks last approved: 06/15/17 1)Applicable Values should be entered in the Heavy Bordered cells. Rest of worksheet is protected,password is"2".
2)Formulas are discussed in the Comprehensive Guidance,Chapter 6,Section C.
Allocation Table updated: 08/02/19 3)HWA and AT worksheets in this workbook are linked. Pollutant Names,MAHLs,Basis,and Uncontrollable load in
Permits last modified: 09/11/17 this AT worksheet are automatically entered from the HWA spreadsheet. This includes pollutant names in columns AT
through BK.
POTw=> Henderson WRF
NPDES#=> NC0020559
FLOW BOD
Industry Type Renewal Modification Date Permit Limits Permit Limits
IUP INDUSTRY NAMES Permit Pipe of Effective Effective Permit Conc. Load
Count (ps.hst alphabetidy) number number Industry Date Date Expires MGD gal/day mg/1 lbs/da
1 MARS PETCARE 0011 0001 Pet Food 04/03/17 06/01/17 04/03/22 0.0750 75,000 345.00 215.80
2
3
4
5 _
6
7
8
9
10
Column Totals=> 0.07501 75,000 ( 216
Basis=> NPDES NPDES
MAHL from HWA(lbs/day)=> NPDES Permitted Flow=> 4.1400 7309
Uncontrollable Loading(lbs/day)=> 2.2173 3661
Total Allowable for Industry(MAIL)(lbs/day)_> 1.9227 3648
Total Permitted to Industry(lbs/day)=> 0.0750 216
MAIL left(lbs/day)=> 1.8477 3432
Percent Allow. Ind. (MAIL)still available(%)=> 96.1 % 94.1 %
Percent MAHL still available(%)=> 44.6% 47.0%
5 Percent MAHL(lbs/day)=> 0.2070 365
HWA.AT
- Revised:November 2005
Copy of Henderson HWA AT Dissolved Metal Criteria,Worksheet Name: AT Printed: 1/23/2020, 9:09 AM
Page 2 of 5
Allocation Table
Headworks last approved: 06/15/17
Allocation Table updated: 08/02/19
Permits last modified: 09/11/17
Pores=> Henderson WRF
NPDES#=> NC0020559
TSS Ammonia Arsenic Cadmium Chromium
Industry Permit Limits Permit Limits Permit Limits Permit Limits Permit Limits
IUP INDUSTRY NAMES Permit Pipe Conc. Load Conc. Load Conc. Load Conc. Load Conc. Load
Count (please list alphabeticly) number number mg/1 lbs/day mg/1 lbs/day mg/1 lbs/day mg/1 lbs/day mg/1 lbs/day
1 MARS PETCARE 0011 0001 340.00 212.67 _
2 ,._-
3
4
5 - I
6 ii
1
7
8
9 f
�^
10
Column Totals=> 1 213 0 I 0.0000 I 0.00001 ( 0.0000
Stream Stream
Basis=> Design Design Stream Std Std Std
MARL from HWA(lbs/day)=> 10358 1035.83 0.3586 0.1016 1.2053
Uncontrollable Loading(lbs/day)=> 4383 386.49 0.0925 - 0.0555 0.2404
Total Allowable for Industry(MAIL)(lbs/day)=> 5976 649.34, 0.2661 _ 0.0461 0.9649
=> _ 0.0000 0.0000
1 Permitted to Industry(lbs/day) 213 0.00 0.0000
Total _
MAIL left(lbs/day)=> 5763 649.34 0.2661 0.0461 0.9649
Percent Allow.Ind. (MAIL)still available(%)=> 96.4% 100.0% 100.0% 100.0% 100.0%
Percent MAHL still available(%)=> 55.6% 62.7% 74.2% 45.4% 80.1 %
5 Percent MAHL(lbs/day)=> 518 51.79 0.0179 0.0051 0.0603
HWA.AT
Revised:November 2005
Copy of Henderson HWA AT Dissolved Metal Criteria,Worksheet Name: AT Printed: 1/23/2020, 9:09 AM
Page 3 of 5
Allocation Table
Headworks last approved: 06/15/17
Allocation Table updated: 08/02/19
Permits last modified: 09/11/17
Po,-w=> Henderson WRF
NPDES#=> NC0020559
Copper Cyanide Lead Mercury Molybdenum
Industry Permit Limits Permit Limits Permit Limits Permit Limits Permit Limits
IUP INDUSTRY NAMES Permit Pipe Conc. Load Conc. Load Conc. Load Conc. Load Conc. Load
Count (please list alphabeticly) number number mg/1 lbs/day mg/1 lbs/day mg/1 lbs/day mg/1 lbs/day mg/1 lbs/day
1 MARS PETCARE 0011 0001 0.0750 0.0469
2 i.., I ii
3
4 I..
5
6
7 1
8 �.
9
i I
10
Column Totals=> 0.0469 ( 0.0000 I 0.0000 0.000000 1 0.0000
Stream Sludge
Basis=> NPDES Std Stream Std Ceiling
MAHL from HWA(lbs/day)=> 7.3075 0.6928 0.012327 0.8741
Uncontrollable Loading(lbs/day)=> 0.9616 0.3144 0.005548 0.0555
Total Allowable for Industry(MAIL)(lbs/day)=> 6.3459 0.3784 0.006779 0.8186
Total Permitted to Industry(lbs/day)_> 0.0469 0.0000 0.000000 0.0000
MAIL left(lbs/day)=> 6.2990 0.3784 0.006779 0.8186
Percent Allow.Ind. (MAIL)still available(%)_> 99.3 % 100.0% 100.0% 100.0%
Percent MAHL still available(%)=> 86.2% 54.6% 55.0% 93.7%
5 Percent MAHL(lbs/day)=> 0.3654 0.0346 0.000616 0.0437
HWA.AT
- Revised:November 2005
Copy of Henderson HWA AT Dissolved Metal Criteria,Worksheet Name: AT Printed: 1/23/2020, 9:09 AM
Page 4 of 5
Allocation Table
Headworks last approved: 06/15/17
Allocation Table updated: 08/02/19
Permits last modified: 09/11/17
POTW=> Henderson WRF
NPDES#=> NC0020559
Nickel Selenium Silver Zinc TKN
Industry Permit Limits Permit Limits Permit Limits Permit Limits Permit Limits
IUP INDUSTRY NAMES Permit Pipe Conc. Load Conc. Load Conc. Load Conc. Load Conc. Load
Count I (please list alphabeddy) number number mg/1 lbs/day mg/1 lbs/day mg/1 lbs/day mg/1 lbs/day mg/1 lbs/day
1 MARS PETCARE 0011 0001 0.2100 0.1314 40.00 25.02
2
3
4
5
6 ... -
7 1 �.1 . ,
8
9
10
Column Totals=> 0.0000 0.00001 0.0000 0.13141 I 25.02
Sludge Stream Stream
Basis=> Ceiling Std Stream Std Std Design
MAHL from HWA(lbs/day)=> 3.8461 0.1972 _ 0.0047 27.4259 1208.4660
Uncontrollable Loading(lbs/day)=> 0.2034 0.0925 _ 0.0555 2.3670 623.1899
Total Allowable for Industry(MAIL)(lbs/day)_> 3.6427 0.1048 _ -0.0507 25.0589 585.28
Total Permitted to Industry(lbs/day)=> 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 0.1314 25.02
MAIL left(lbs/day)=> 3.6427 0.1048 -0.0507 24.9275 560.26
Percent Allow. Ind. (MAIL)still available(%)_> 100.0% 100.0% 100.0% 99.5 % 95.7%
Percent MAHL still available(%)=> 94.7% 53.1 % -1072.0% 90.9% 46.4%
5 Percent MAHL(lbs/day)=> 0.1923 0.0099 0.0002 1.3713 60.42
HWA.AT
- Revised:November 2005
Copy of Henderson HWA AT Dissolved Metal Criteria,Worksheet Name: AT Printed: 1/23/2020, 9:09 AM
Page 5 of 5
Allocation Table
Headworks last approved: 06/15/17
Allocation Table updated: 08/02/19
Permits last modified: 09/11/17
POTw=> Henderson WRF
NPDES#=> NC0020559
Total Phos. COD Oil and Grease
Industry Permit Limits Permit Limits Permit Limits
IUP INDUSTRY NAMES Permit Pipe Conc. Load Conc. Load Conc. Load
Count (please list alphabeticly) number number mg/1 lbs/day mg/1 lbs/day mg/1 lbs/day
1 MARS PETCARE 0011 0001 45.00\ 28.15 690.0000 431.60 75.0000 46.91
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
Column Totals=> 28.151 I 431.5950 46.9125
Basis=> Design
MARL from HWA(lbs/day)=> 241.69
Uncontrollable Loading(lbs/day)=> 88.76
Total Allowable for Industry(MAIL)(lbs/day)=> 152.93
Total Permitted to Industry(lbs/day)=> 28.15
MAIL left(lbs/day)=> 124.78
Percent Allow.Ind. (MAIL)still available(%)_> 81.6%
Percent MAHL still available(%)=> 51.6%
5 Percent MARL(lbs/day)=> 12.0847
HWA.AT
Revised:November 2005
City of Henderson 2019 PAR
6. Significant Industrial
User (SIU)
Compliance Schedules
City of Henderson 2019 PAR
None
City of Henderson 2019 PAR
7. Public Notice
City of Henderson 2019 PAR
None
City of Henderson 2019 PAR
8. Other Information
•
City of Henderson 2019 PAR
None