HomeMy WebLinkAboutNC0024406_BCSS_Appendix M_20191231APPENDIX M - SUSTAINABILITY CALCULATIONS
REMEDIAL ALTERNATIVES - INPUTS
CORRECTIVE ACTION PLAN UPDATE
BELEWS CREEK STEAM STATION
DUKE ENERGY CAROLINAS, LLC, BELEWS CREEK, NC
Alternative
Remedial Alternative 1 -
Groundwater
Remediation by MNA
Remedial Alternative 2 -
Groundwater Remediation
by Extraction
Remedial Alternative 3 -
Groundwater Remediation
by Clean Water Infiltration
and Extraction
New Monitoring Wells
Number of MWs
10
10
10
Average depth of MWs (ft. bgs)
67
67
67
Average screen length of MWs (ft.)
10
10
10
Casing material
Sch 80 PVC
Sch 80 PVC
Sch 80 PVC
Well diameter
6
6
6
Borehole diameter
8
8
8
Extraction Wells
Number of Extraction Wells
113
113
Average depth (ft. bgs)
121
121
Average screen length (ft.)
15
15
Total flow (gpm)
90
90
Casing material
Sch 80 PVC
Sch 80 PVC
Well diameter
6
6
Borehole diameter
8
8
Horizontal Wells
Number of Horizontal Wells
1
Length of Each Horizontal Well (ft.)
900
Total flow (gpm)
110
Casing material
Sch 80 PVC
Well diameter
6
Borehole diameter
8
Clean Water Infiltration Wells
Number of Infiltration Wells
47
Average depth (ft. bgs)
141
Average screen length (ft.)
15
Total flow (gpm)
56
Casing material
Sch 80 PVC
Well diameter
6
Borehole diameter
8
Number of pumps
1
Infiltration Galleries
Number of Infiltration Galleries
Total area (acres)
Total flow (gpm)
Pipe material
Pipe diameter
Chemical Injection Wells
Number of Injection Wells
Average depth (ft. bgs)
Average screen length (ft.)
Total flow (gpm)
Casing material
Well diameter
Borehole diameter
Injection Pumps
Tree Wells
Total area (acres)
Trenches
Number of trenches
Length (ft.)
Width (ft.)
De th ft.
Page 1 of 2
APPENDIX M - SUSTAINABILITY CALCULATIONS
REMEDIAL ALTERNATIVES - INPUTS
CORRECTIVE ACTION PLAN UPDATE
BELEWS CREEK STEAM STATION
DUKE ENERGY CAROLINAS, LLC, BELEWS CREEK, NC
Alternative
Remedial Alternative 1 -
Groundwater
Remediation by MNA
Remedial Alternative 2 -
Groundwater Remediation
by Extraction
Remedial Alternative 3 -
Groundwater Remediation
by Clean Water Infiltration
and Extraction
Conveyance Pipe
Pipe length
7000
18000
Pipe material
Sch 80 HDPE
Sch 80 HDPE
Pipe diameter
6
6
Number of conveyance pumps
4
4
Permeable Reactive Barriers
Number of PRBs
Fill Material
Length (ft.)
Width (ft.)
Depth (ft.)
Removal of Waste Materials
Tons of waste
Waste Profile
Treatment Media
Media
Pounds
Well Abandonment
Number of wells
Average well depth
Well diameter
Fill Material
Laboratory Analysis
$ of laboratory analysis spent
Length of Active Remediation
Years of Active Remediation 0 500 36
Notes:
ft. - foot
gpm - gallon per minute
Sch - schedule
HDPE - high density polyethylene
bgs - below ground surface
PVC - polyvinyl chloride
PRB - permeable reactive barrier
MW - monitoring wells
MINA - monitored natural attenuation
Prepared By: GTC Checked By: CBC
Page 2 of 2
APPENDIX M - SUSTAINABILITY CALCULATIONS
REMEDIAL ALTERNATIVES - SUSTAINABILITY
CORRECTIVE ACTION PLAN UPDATE
BELEWS CREEK STEAM STATION
DUKE ENERGY CAROLINAS, LLC, BELEWS CREEK, NC
Remedial Alternative 1 - Groundwater Remediation by MNA
Activities
CO2
Emissions
Percent
Total
Onsite NOx
Emissions
Percent
Total
Onsite SO.
Emissions
Percent
Total
Onsite
PMld
Emissions
percent
Total
Total NOx
Emissions
Percent
Total
Total SO.
Emissions
Percent
Total
Total PM10
Emissions
Percent
Total
Total
Energy
Used
Total
Energy
Used
percent
Total
metric ton
%
metric ton
%
metric ton
%
metric ton
%
metric ton
%
metric ton
%
metric ton
%
MMBTU
MWH
Material Productions
40.79
76.12
NA
-
NA
-
NA
-
1.7E-02
17.4
2.7E-02
72.8
3.8E-03
35.8
1.1E+04
NA
98.55
Transportation -Personnel
4.93
9.21
NA
-
NA
-
NA
-
1.1E-02
10.6
1.0E-03
2.8
1.6E-04
1.5
6.5E+01
NA
0.6
Transportation-Equip/materials
0.49
0.92
NA
-
NA
-
NA
-
1.5E-04
0.2
2.7E-06
0.0
1.4E-05
0.1
6.4E+00
NA
0.1
Equipment Use and Misc
7.10
13.25
6.8E-02
100.0
6.9E-03
100.0
6.1E-03
100.0
7.2E-02
71.7
9.0E-03
24.4
6.7E-03
62.6
8.6E+01
0.0E+00
0.8
Residual Handling
0.27
0.51
0.0E+00
-
0.0E+00
-
0.0E+00
-
8.8E-05
0.1
3.6E-06
0.0
7.2E-06
0.1
1 3.8E+00
NA
0.0
Total
53.59
100
6.79E-02
100.0
6.93E-03
100
6.11E-03
100
1.00E-01
100
3.67E-02
100
1.07E-02
100
1 1.11E+04
0.00E+00
1 100
Remedial Alternative 2 - Groundwater Remediation by Extraction
Activities
COz
Emissions
Percent
Total
Onsite NOx
Emissions
Percent
Total
Onsite SO.
Emissions
Percent
Total
Onsite
Emissions
percent
Total
Total NOx
Emissions
Percent
Total
Total SO.
Emissions
Percent
Total
Total PMlo
Emissions
Percent
Total
Total
Energy
Total
Energy
percent
Total
metric ton
%
metric ton
%
metric ton
%
metric ton
%
metric ton
%
metric ton
%
metric ton
%
MMBTU
MWH
%
Material Productions
1,414.27
2.90
NA
-
NA
-
NA
-
3.4E+00
1.9
2.2E+00
1.4
7.8E-01
4.0
2.5E+06
NA
87.42
Transportation -Personnel
25.02
0.05
NA
-
NA
-
NA
-
1.8E-02
0.0
1.3E-03
0.0
1.7E-03
0.0
3.2E+02
NA
0.0
Transportation-Equip/materials
0.98
0.00
NA
-
NA
-
NA
-
3.1E-04
0.0
5.5E-06
0.0
2.7E-05
0.0
1.3E+01
NA
0.0
Equipment Use and Misc
47,358.03
97.05
1.5E+00
100.0
1.5E-01
100.0
1.3E-01
100.0
1.7E+02
98.0
1.6E+02
98.6
1.8E+01
95.9
3.6E+05
6.1E-01
12.6
Residual Handling
1 0.27
1 0.00
1 0.0E+00
0.0E+00
0.0E+00
8.8E-05
0.0
3.6E-06
0.0
7.2E-06
0.0
3.8E+00
NA
1 0.0
Total
1 48,798.57
1 100
1 1.45E+00
100.0
1 1.49E-01
100
1 1.31E-01
100
1 1.77E+02
100
1.63E+02
100
1.92E+01
1 100
2.84E+06
6.05E-01
1 100
Remedial Alternative 3 - Groundwater Remediation by Clean Water Infiltration and Extraction
Activities
CO2
Emissions
Percent
Total
Onsite NOx
Emissions
Percent
Total
Onsite SO.
Emissions
Percent
Total
Onsite
PMld
Emissions
percent
Total
Total NOx
Emissions
Percent
Total
Total SO.
Emissions
Percent
Total
Total PM10
Emissions
Percent
Total
Total
Energy
Used
Total
Energy
Used
percent
Total
metric ton
%
metric ton
%
metric ton
%
metric ton
%
metric ton
%
metric ton
%
metric ton
%
MMBTU
MWH
Material Productions
3,000.91
18.22
NA
-
NA
-
NA
-
8.5E+00
11.3
5.2E+00
13.6
1.9E+00
12.2
6.2E+06
NA
98.26
Transportation -Personnel
56.80
0.34
NA
-
NA
-
NA
-
3.0E-02
0.0
1.7E-03
0.0
4.1E-03
0.0
7.2E+02
NA
0.0
Transportation-Equip/materials
0.98
0.01
NA
-
NA
-
NA
-
3.1E-04
0.0
5.5E-06
0.0
2.7E-05
0.0
1.3E+01
NA
0.0
Equipment Use and Misc
13,411.01
81.43
3.3E+01
100.0
3.4E+00
100.0
3.0E+00
100.0
6.7E+01
88.7
3.3E+01
86.4
1.4E+01
87.8
1.1E+05
6.2E-01
1.7
Residual Handling
0.27
0.00
0.0E+00
-
0.0E+00
-
0.0E+00
-
8.8E-05
0.0
3.6E-06
0.0
7.2E-06
0.0
3.8E+00
NA
0.0
Total
16,469.98
100
3.30E+01
100.0
3.37E+00
100
2.97E+00
100
7.55E+01
100
3.81E+01
100
1.58E+01
100
6.26E+06
6.15E-01
100
Notes:
CO, - Airborne emissions of carbon dioxide
MMBTU - Million British Thermal Units
NOx - Airborne emissions of nitrogen oxides (combination of nitrogen monoxide and nitrogen dioxide)
SOx - Airborne emissions of sulfur oxides (combination of sulfur monoxide, sulfur dioxide, sulfur trioxide, and others)
PM,o - Airborne emissions of particulate matter that is 10 micrometers or less in diameter
Prepared By: GTC Checked By: CBC
Page 1 of 1