20091202 Ver 1_Shoreline Stabilization_20091110

Kmi tt. Walter, IT, I.11'
139 Count r-moo l Drive
Purest City, NC 28043
I'honeTax (828) 24X-1210, ('ell (X28) 429-24(,6
I'll Number 19856
Kim B. WARNER, PE, -L-LC- 0 9- 1 2 0 2
November 6, 2009 ILS\M=Uwig S PA I
Division of Water Quality NOV 1 4 2009
Fxpress Review Permitting
1650 Mail Service Center DENR?WATEIWRY
VMETUilAS AND STDll1M?ATATER BRANCH
Raleigh, N('27699-1650
RE: Permit Application - Sefton and Mary Abbott Project, 173 Tryon Bay Circle, Lake Lure, NC 28746
Dear Sirs:
The attached information is furnished to secure a permit for the proposed replacement of a retaining wall
and seawall at the Abbott lake home located at 173 Tryon Bay Circle in Lake Lure, N.C. '['lie retaining
wall has recently been described as "in a hazardous condition" by the Senior Inspector of the Rutherford
County Inspections and Planning Department. In addition, the inspector noted that "tic only practical
solution I see is complete removal and reconstruction under the design and supervision of a licensed
engineer" (Copy enclosed). The attached plans provide an engineered solution on essentially the same
footprint as the existing stricture. The seawall must also be removed and replaced because it has tailed as
well and will not provide adequate support for the new retaining wall in its present condition.
In addition to the information provided as requested in section 11 of the application, there are several
photographs of the existing structure included in the package.
"Chc Town of Lake Lure has given notice that the lake level will be lowered from early December until
late January'. Mr. and Mrs. Abbott would like to take advantage of this opportunity and undertake this
difficult project during this time period. Approval of this application as soon as possible would be
appreciated
If you have any questions or concerns you may contact me at one of the numbers or the entail address
listed above.
Sincerely,
Kim B. Warner
The following is an abbreviated application form for those applying for a 401 Water Quality
Certification to impact FERC (Federal Energy Regulatory Commission) regulated lake shore or
bottom under the U.S. Army Corps of Engineers Permit GP30. This Application cannot be used
for wetland or stream impacts. Please provide five (5) copies of this application and supporting
information as well as a non-refundable application fee to the Division of Water Quality of $240.00
for impacts to lake bottom of less than I acre and $570.00 for impacts to lake bottom of greater or
equal to 1 acre.
Applications should be sent to: 0 9- 2 0 2
Division of Water Quality 401 Oversight/Express Review Permitting
1650 Mail Service Center
Raleigh, NC 27699-1650
1. Applicant Information
Owner/Applicant Information
Name: 7 y-row ANN? Mkl V Q VJ?o`jT
Mailing Address: 34 7-15n CAS Fri LS5 7 Q4 A D
FAMVIEWT _ 14 ?8734
Telephone Number:
E-mail Address
82$ . c' u . 1Jq S Fax Number: N/A (CELL BZB. 242.05
MARY. A 950T7'49 VA.,( OV --
2. Agent Information (A signed and dated copy of the Agent Authorization letter must be attached
if the Agent has signatory authority for the owner/applicant.)
Name: 6A Y. y n JgIL '
Company Affiliation: ELM V. ULV,9E1- FE LL6
Mailing Address:
Telephone Number
riwwao Dll.. otF.S 1 lit
I Z40 (A Z4 , Z 4 64) Fax Number:
AV- 'U3043
628. Z48. tZ40
E-mail Address
Il. Protect Information
AW5Z?u?.?pL . N ET'
Attach a vicinity map clearly showing the location of the property with respect to local landmarks such
as towns, rivers, and roads. Also provide a detailed site plan showing property boundaries and
development plans in relation to surrounding properties. You may use the diagram below to make a
hand sketch of your project. Also, see the example below for guidance. Both the vicinity map and site
plan must include a scale and north arrow. The footprints of all buildings, impervious surfaces, or other
facilities must be included.
1. Location
County: 1? V i NC f.FD212 Nearest Town: _ LAKC Lots
Subdivision name or site address (include phase/lot number): o; -g-vow VAS/ Gt 9CL6
Directions to site please include road numbers, landmarks, etc. (This is not necessary if an adequate
vicinity map is included):
TA - ZZZ q5 MA c t? c.or 5'41 rZ T{Z o 9 O806F,
2. Describe the existing land use or condition of the site at the time of this application: VSVLLOKP
I Property size (acres): 0.1
4. Nearest body of water (stream/river/sound/ocean/lake): LAKE CIO
5. Describe the purpose of the proposed work: RE Pt,l ?(K T l t?4 IeAwA LL AND RTA I IJ l W4
WALL, Wt-[W AN 15MI465-acv 5TPcrVK AFFRA1M TELY THE SA96 S Lm A5 THE
EX15TtW ?;TCLUCT1Jpg, tWdlki7 To ?uftp-r E M-rjNl V(„lrLLIWl)
6. List the type of equipment to be used to construct the project: ' W14 WOW-1gOt9w, , q f_
7. Amount of impact (including all excavation, backfill, rip rap, retaining walls, etc.) below the
normal pool lake level in square feet or acres: Ig Lp SAP OW L If . 1NI T A L415V
A p dX MA`Tr,i,Y 5' [916 LAKE . TOIALW4 Q PPQ.AMATaN 160
8.a. Amount of impact (including all clearing, back fill, excavation, rip rap, retaining walls, etc.)
above the normal pool lake level and 50 feet land-ward in square feet or acres:
A? P POXXIKAISUY Ifoo `5 a. V .
8.b. Please describe vegetation above the normal pool lake level and 50 feet landward to be impacted
(number of trees for instance): 110 TtZ;E5, tV t ITAVA?Ja N UO Ve5 4 /
GIEG-V UWL4- OW ?ouT4EWl 7WO9e ,V L404 . LILL YC 9tVLANTS2

Applica{it/Agent's Signature / Date
(Agent's signature is valid only if an authorization letter from the applicant is provided.)
JUL-10-2009 15:03 RUTH. CO. BUILDING INS 820 287 6338
klieks Owens, Director Slane Dotsaua, Building Inspector
Jason Ruff, Assistant Director Donny Searcy, County Planner
Charks Lattimore, Senior Inspedor Jerry Stensland, Cuttnral Planner
Steve S'dt, Building Inspector Eric Bradley, Eire Inspector
Robin Sparks, Building Iuspedor Ruth Sams, Administrative
Rutherford County
Inspections And Planning
July 10, 2009
Sheila Spicer
Town of Lake Lure
Lake Lure NC 28746
Fax; {8285 625-8371
Dear Sheila,
As per your request, I have examined the retaining wail at 173 Tryon Bay
Circle. It is, indeed, in a hazardous condition. it has sagged, leaned, and
bulged until it appears in danger of total failure. Failure would likely
damage the boathouse below it and would expose the house foundation to
erosive undermining.
The only practical solution I see is complete removal and reconstruction
under the design and supervision of a licensed engineer.
CDL/rds
141 West Third Street, Rutherfordtou, NC 28139 + 828-287-6435 ? 828-
287-6338 (FAX)
P.01i01
TOTAL P.01
Charles D. Lattimore Senior Inspector
CD ?
D°°k/ep
a th °Qe
s
N _
_0 •
CD
a
O
Z
m
I ?1 C6?
I i M o
I? I o N I
I ? i i i ? ,,,? W ? t ': •
Q -'00 OQ??00-'ON01 O I
Z ( N?'p>p-?pNNNOf I j
O N i 1
D I i i I j? i r r;
s
F 4 ?G
Z
° (2) CD
4 ;
4 ?: r
: law-
f
> ' ..
'0j N4 °
s e , ?
r W CD
r _
C) 0
Q- i (p r+ 0 ? 011. o1
(D o 0 10, N ir 0 O O c? - - ,
j4p ^ i Do
q 10 71 00 \ -
Q Q Q Csl CAD
966 < 00 Q ! r r
1p
PRELIMINARY RETAINING WALL PLAN FOR EXISTING SHEET ENGINEERED BY DATE 10-08-09 SIGNIFICANT CARE AND EFFORT HAVE BEEN TARN
MARY & SEFTON ABBOTT KIM B. WARNER, PE, LLC REV TO ENSURE THAT THESE PLANS ARE CORRECT AND
PLAT 1 139 COUNTRYWOOD DRIVE REV COMPLETE. HOWEVER, KIM B. V ARNER, PE, LLC
173 TRYON BAY CIRCLE REV ASSUMES NO LIABILITY EXCEPTTOMAKE
SCALE3137=1'1Y FOREST CITYNC28043 CORRECTIONS AND REISSUE COPIES AS REQUIRED.
LAKE LURE, INC 28748 -1 3 PE NO 11'65 REV
FILENAMEABBOTT RET WALL
6 ?- ?9 M« Z °
I ? ; I t i l
O
O I o f I N j'
O j ? J t I
? I I I J I
D
Deck ! 1 r ; ? ? ,,
h z .
z Ouse
? ?°;.? \ D.,I•i'. .. _
M o `? 1?rf r'
00
0 2°ys? 7 rf
z
mX O?
z? ? m
G) CD :O r m r-
N? r-m D X00 .
It? i
000 1` 4
\\\ /// i t s \ \
=Z to D aicD?
? %?,n per. ? \ ? ?? ? • ` ?`
PRELIMINARY RETAINING WALL PLAN FOR PLOT SHEET ENGINEERED BY DATE 10-08-09 SIGNIFICANT CARE AND EFFORT HAVE BEEN TAKEN
MARY & SEFTON ABBOTT KIM B. WARNER, PE, LLC REV TO ENSURE THAT THESE PLANS ARE CORRECT AND
PLAN 2 139 COUNTRYWOOD DRIVE REV COMPLETE. HOWEVER, KIM B. WARNER PE, LLC
173 TRYON BAY CIRCLE REV ASSUMES NO LIABILITY EXCEPTTO MAKE
LAKE LURE, NC 28746 SCALE-337=1'0 OF 3 PE FOREST NO CITY, 19NC856 28043 REV CORRECTIONS AND REISSUE COPIES AS REQUIRED.
FILEN4AEABBOTf qET Wrllt
PRELIMINARY RETAINING WALL PLAN FOR ELEVATION SHEET ENGINEERED BY DATE 10-011-09 SIGNIFICANT CARE AND EFFORT HAVEBEEN TAKEN
MARY & SEFTON ABBOTT
AND SECTION KIM B. WARNER, PE, LLC REV TO ENSURE THAT THESE PLANS ARECORPECTAND
COMPLETE HOWEVER
KIM B
WARNER PE
LLC
3 139 COUNTRYWOOD DRIVE REV ,
.
,
173 TRVON BAY CIRCLE
SCALE AS NOTED
FOREST CITY
28043 REV ASSUMES NO LIABILITY EXCEPTTOMAKE
LAKE LURE,
NC 28746 OF 3 ,
PE NO 1988556
REV CORRECTIONS AND REISSUE COPIES AS REQUIRED.
raeNnNeneaon r?T wnu

`r=te
z
` f?
O
co
N
O
N
_ _
Whitney Rd. Pdemnrial Hwy° '

blag Nall Tryon gay Circle 9
Set 2® card R/V~ (Asp~lalf}
Pdemorlal Hwy° b f
f J
i , ~k ~ ~
1 ~ ~ W 1ss
Girls Gamp Rd°
IPF Ca d Rebar ~ pPe „
i1. Highway 9
N02°00°00"E PT ,
~ 39.40° Tie Line IPF L4 ~`bS 2 PI e i ti~ ~ (Basis of Bearing] p
I~ot To Scale ~y~s'~ • PT C,~ _ PT _ I ~ ;
I iPF ~ti PT I",.:
Capped Rebar N$5°31'12`°E PT i':~ ~
57.00 S$2°44'4"E SB2°44°4$"E ~ ° t) ~ 9 Sii$°10 4~ E 25.00 4,75' PT
24.67
~ i ::l :'i i. t" h•..t t . • . •.d .•:t'~" t 7 p . , ,:h.::•?,••• ; ~ • • PT 1 f 2 Pipe
• • ' • ' ' • , t ~ ;
9PF ! Iran Pin Found ~ ~ , ' • I Yi• •1.,
r PI • Iron Pin .et 5 ~ Rebar • ~°°~5 ,t • ~ : ~ °
IPS 1 f Meg Nail •.ti °i`' , ` M1'•' M1,`:. 07-':x.. "I i ;t ~ ~ i Set ,N~•;,r•..,:. i.~.. •
~ Unmarked F ®int / d'` 1 sp a t ,•r. a..~._..__~ _._v._~I . _ _ _ . _ _ _...__~m _ _ ..~.~_~d_. _ : , ' "'Rail Road's Asphalt • IPF IPF
:S Ike Found 'j'~ ~Oa i Utility Pole ~ , _ ;'i.,• P , . , 1/2" pipe
,
-0E- i Overhead Electric , s,. ~tv.~, ...~1• `~t•:.~•,. ~ . . • , } ~ • . S • • R ~..:!v
6 Water M®ter ~ ~ .r ~ 1. - , 3 4 Reb r ' ! • A____.__..._.~. ~ _ _ ~ _.._m..~.~.. ~ ~ e
~ v~'' ~ $$,261 ''.c~ ®-ACJ--C9°®-®-i Privacy Fence °a° 060 Meg Nai!
~v. _ . ~.~_-_m~um ._a__~w M~. °~-lD House ~ • ,a•• o~` :;~,.y~:: Set --1026 rotas tF . Ct •t. • ~ .,.....v. ,
"-1~ ,w i ~ 1 .m. ~..m...,.,.._.,. .......____-°~..._~.~....v_. a ap ~ ,r
--'°lDI6 d / , 1012 !Q~ ~I4 , •p•' °•:•w'•• . ..~.,d.,.~...i,_., 101 ul
^^"1014 i •..'r • I ._.,1D1 ..r
~m_....,_____.... _..__:._..__m~.~~.~._.... -1m ' ~ Quit Clairn Area e ~ • I _ , --t~'"~f'4 ° • ' . a ~ ~e D.6. 9$$ P 3$2 ,rte ~ ~ 0 c``m+
I lea, c . ~ ' ~ • c`~ ~ _ ~ __d.~ _ _ ~ Ga~erd Earl Qavis 1`4
~ ° y _ o ry .97 Tie Line <c~ „__.__~._v--___.__._ E_._._._ _....._.._._._w_.~~.__.... ...._.a__a IPF l~i ' l4 ~0r ~ . ~ rn
c a p ~ 2 Pie ~o d. • ~ ti
sr i
" ~ . • i ; • + ~ _ Rererence IPS • _
1 °a 15.23 S7T0T20'°E r ~ W ~ •5,~ • 1 m '1 •,•''•~;::>.i 44e$5 Tie line
Date. z , ~ , . ~t,t ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ :t'W;::+•• ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ •°•i. • ~ t: ° ` See Oetail °'A"° for more detail ~ '
on the sauthern boundary line. o + oned R1 N ta<•-
I-i p _ Ref. a~~t~ Uaak: 3 i `,tew i 0 ~ 'o '"r•,• ,.r i
• : . _ t _ P ~ •7q~•re ~ • -"'0 IPF 2" pipe
..I t'~ ~z~ i ; Q ' ~ r ~ a , , • • u,., . . . rz ~ i Ref. Plat Do®k. ~ ~ ' ~ ,
Tai Parcel Nurr~ber: i ; ' , ~ gg ,~.u.:~~ 17.06
` ~ IPF a, IPF 5eavaall ~ ~ ~ I 1 f2 Plpe
1 f?,a Pipe With Nall
Drawn ~y: dart Chief; , , y.~. ~ Reference IPF N52°52'3$°°W 0 ,
44.$6' PT ' 1/2 Pipe , ..,,~~~aa ~I~ - 0$1.23
DUVG File; , . ' ~`I
r; _ Seavaall
i
_ , NOTES:
®AIl distances are horizantal unless other~ise noted. I _ n
All acreage is by ooordlnate method. ~._.~_m ~ _ .......,.m .
LINE DEAkING DISTAN _ ~__59 03°5~°W ' _ 10 $7
This is a Class A" Survey L1 ~ _.mr '~L2 ' N30°56°02°°E ~ _ 9.51 ~ 1 x.67 6 s °F ; 1.51
Surveyor has made no investigation or independent search for SCE f n umbrances r strictive covenants ownershi l3 ~ N50 4913$°°W 11.60 easements o record, e c e L.__..Y _ .....__....u. 11.60 ' F.
title evidence, or and focts that an occurote and current title 20 0 TO 20 ~b0 r L4 ~ N39'10°2~~E 0.50
search may disclose. , l5 ~n::~~ N62 50.02,. ~ _ 9 74 m 9.74.
~ No attempt has been made as a part of this boundary survey to ~ T_.-...___~_._ I _.~t l ~~6 I_N06 2214$° W 3 00 obtain or show data concerning existence, size, depth, conditron, ~ l7 I N$T~g130°'~T , ~ 9.93W t9 3.00
capacity, or location of any utility or municiple/public service ZQ ~Oe> CO the Inch _A___._ _.N.r._
facility. For information regarding these utilities or facilities, please contact the appropriate agencies. ~
1
. '
- - „ r m IlunnNl ~ ~~J JJ J ~JJJ ~J ~ J ~ ..J'!! ° r svn n r su erve°ian fr rn an actual su ve ade S ~ i certsfy that this reap ~+as d a u de my p s o y ~~~b _ ? r 1 jC
under my supervision {dead desoription recorded in gook $134, Pg. 439 or other ~ CA~O
reference source _ that the boundaries not curve dare ~ ~I ~ ~ - indioated os drovan from infnrrnation in 13ook_®~_, Pg°_®_." or other reference ;~~;•'0~ 0'°., ' 1 2 2
souroe___~...; that the ratio of recision or positional accuraoy is 1:10000; and ~ ~ ; y . ~ ' p
that this ma meets the re ulrements of The Standards Of Practice for land Surveying _ SEAL ` P 9 _ t _ _ in NorthCaroNna (21 NCAC 5S. 1600)•" This 1$th day of August, 2009. _ (r-393 - F~ ~ _ _ `~'I ~ ~ ~ f' ,
- „ i _ i i ~ ~ r
9 , ,
t ~ ~ ~r
I~ark~. Freeman, PLS L-3943 ryHiiiliNtt~ • r ~,.r " ~ ~ ~
_ ~
CapyrightAFreeman Land Surveyng, PLLC. All rights reserved. No port of this drawing may be reproduced by photocopying, recording or by any I •
means, or stared, processed or transmitted in or by any computer or other system tgithout the poor artten permission of the ~rveyor. This f , - License Ido° P-4164 is valid only f~ the parties hereon.
_ _ ~ ,~s•