Loading...
HomeMy WebLinkAbout20091_Thrift_Rd_BPA_201612121 Brownfields Property Application North Carolina Brownfields Program www.ncbrownfieIds.orq I. PROSPECTIVE DEVELOPER (PD) INFORMATION A. PD information: Entity name Brownstone Properties II, LLC Principal Officer Franklin Norwood Thompson Representative George Newell Whiting Jr. Mailing Address 442 ½ East Main Street Clayton, North Carolina 27520 E-mail address: gwhiting@carolina.rr.com Phone No. 704- 517-8196 Fax No. 919-550-3814 Web site Not Applicable B. PD contact person information (i.e., individual who will serve as the NCBP’s point of contact if different than above): Name George Newell Whiting Jr. Company Mailing Address 442 ½ East Main Street Clayton, North Carolina 27520 E-Mail Address gwhiting@carolina.rr.com Phone No. 704-517-8196 Fax No. 919-550-3814 C. Information regarding all parent companies, subsidiaries or other affiliates of PD (attach separate sheet(s) if necessary): (Use for LLCs) Member-managed or Manager-Managed? Answer: Manager-Managed 2 If manager-managed, provide name of manager and percent of ownership: Name Franklin Norwood Thompson Ownership (%) 25.82 Mailing Address 442 ½ East Main Street Clayton, North Carolina 27520 E-Mail Address nthompson@walthomgroup.com Phone No. 919-553-5400 Fax No. 919-550-3814 For all LLCs, list all members of the LLC and provide their percent of ownership: Name Franklin Norwood Thompson Ownership (%) 25.82 Mailing Address 442 ½ East Main Street Clayton, North Carolina 27520 E-Mail Address nthompson@walthomgroup.com Phone No. 919-553-5400 Fax No. 919-550-3814 Name George Newell Whiting Jr. Ownership (%) 37.39 Mailing Address 442 ½ East Main Street Clayton, North Carolina 27520 E-Mail Address gwhiting@carolina.rr.com Phone No. 704-517-8196 Fax No. 919-550-3814 Name Joe Guarglia, Sr. Ownership (%) 13.19 3 Mailing Address 1424 Kinsdale Drive Raleigh, North Carolina 27615 E-Mail Address Not Applicable Phone No. 919-847-3838 Fax No. Not Applicable Name Joey Guarglia Ownership (%) 13.19 Mailing Address 11401 John Allen Road Raleigh, North Carolina 27614 E-Mail Address Not Applicable Phone No. 919-847-3838 Fax No. Not Applicable **Please note that Brownstone Properties II, LLC has 16 silent members (not listed here) with ownership interests ranging from 0.28% to 3.13%. A list of the silent members can be provided at DEQ request. Managers of manager-managed LLCs are required to execute all brownfield documents for the LLC; as to member-managed LLCs, state name of member who will sign these documents. List all parent companies, subsidiaries and other affiliates: Too many to list here - a list can be provided at DEQ request (Use for Partnerships) Check one:General Partnership Limited Partnership List all partners and percent of ownership: 4 Name Ownership (%) Mailing Address E-Mail Address Phone No. Fax No. Is this person a general or limited partner? Name Ownership (%) Mailing Address E-Mail Address Phone No. Fax No. Is this person a general or limited partner? List all parent companies, subsidiaries and other affiliates: (Use for corporations other than LLCs) (If information is the same as shown in 1.A., please indicate “same as 1.A.” below.) Name Mailing Address 5 E-Mail Address Phone No. Fax No. List all parent companies, subsidiaries and other affiliates: (Use for individuals) (If individual is the same as shown in 1.A., -please indicate “same as 1.A.” above.) Name Mailing Address E-Mail Address Phone No. Fax No. D. Does PD have or can it obtain the financial means to fully implement a brownfields agreement and assure the safe reuse of the property? (Attach supporting documentation such as letters of credit, financial statements, etc.) Answer: YES Explanation: The members of Brownstone Properties II, LLC (hereinafter the “PD”) have been involved with real estate and management for over 20 years and have developed multiple commercial and industrial properties in both North and South Carolina during that time. The PD has the financial means to to fully implement a Brownfields agreement and assure the safe reuse of the property. E. Does PD have or can it obtain the managerial means to fully implement a brownfields agreement and assure the safe use of the property? Answer: YES Explanation: The PD has extensive experience managing real estate projects. In addition, the PD has retained professionals, including Hart & Hickman, PC, who are experienced in Brownfields redevelopment and the implementation of Brownfields requirements in particular. These professionals (i) have significant experience with the Brownfields 6 Program and the redevelopment of properties, and (ii) are aware of the work and restrictions that are typically included in Brownfields agreements to assure the safe use of property. The combination of these resources will ensure successful implementation of a Brownfields agreement and safe use of the property. F. Does PD have or can it obtain the technical means to fully implement a brownfields agreement and assure the safe use of the property? Answer: YES Explanation: Please see our responses to Questions I.D and I.E, above. The PD has the technical ability to fully implement a Brownfields agreement and to assure the safe use of the property. It has a range of engineering and environmental experience available to it. In particular, the PD has hired Hart & Hickman, PC to assist with the technical aspects of a Brownfields agreement (including technical “work to be performed”). Hart & Hickman has extensive experience with Brownfields projects in North Carolina and is thoroughly familiar with the technical aspects and requirements of the Brownfields program. G. Does PD commit that it will comply (and has complied, if PD has had a prior project in the NCBP) with all applicable procedural requirements of the NCBP, including prompt payment of all statutorily required fees? Answer: YES (List all NCBP project name(s) and NCBP project ID numbers where PD or any parent company, subsidiary and other affiliate of PD has been a party to.) Not Applicable H. Does PD currently own the property? Answer: The PD currently owns two of the three parcels that will be included in the Brownfields Agreement and is under contract to purchase the remaining parcel. If yes, when did PD purchase the property and from whom? (Provide name, address, telephone number and email address of the contact person for the current property owner.) The PD purchased the 2317 Thrift Road parcel (Parcel ID# 07105114) in April 2012 from A Gift of Love Ministry. The PD purchased portions of the adjacent railroad right-of-way parcel (Parcel ID# 07105121) from CSX Railroad in September 2016. The PD is under contract to purchase the 1225 Berryhill Road parcel (Parcel ID# 07105116). If no, provide the name, address, telephone number and e-mail address of the contact person for the current property owner The 1225 Berryhill Road parcel (Parcel ID# 07105116) is owned by 1225 Berryhill, LLC. Property Owner Contact - Mr. Jake Casteen 415 West Boulevard Charlotte, NC 28203 7 I. If PD does not currently own the property, does PD have the property under contract to purchase? Answer: YES If yes, provide date of contract(s): The PD entered a contract to purchase the 1225 Berryhill Road parcel (Parcel ID# 07105116) on November 7, 2016. If no, when does the PD intend to purchase the property (e.g., after the project is determined to be eligible for participation in the NCBP, after PD receives a draft BFA, after the conclusion of the brownfields process)? To be determined. For the parcel it does not own, the PD will likely purchase the property after eligibility determination and before completion of the BFA, but may wait until the BFA is complete. J. Describe all activities that have taken place on the property since PD or PD’s parents, subsidiaries and/or other affiliates, and/or lessees or sublessees of PD, took ownership of or operated at the property (e.g., industrial, manufacturing or commercial activities, etc.). (Include a list of all regulated substances as defined at NCGS § 130A-310.31(b)(11) that have been used, stored on, or otherwise present at the property while those activities were conducted, and explain how they were used.) The PD purchased the property at 2317 Thrift Road in 2012. The southern portion of the building located on the 2317 Thrift Road parcel has been occupied by an automotive repair facility/U-Haul rental office and a hair salon since the PD purchased the property. Remaining portions of the building have remained unoccupied since it was purchased by the PD. II. SITE INFORMATION A. Information regarding the proposed brownfields property: Proposed project name: Thrift Road & Berryhill Road Site Acreage: 4.43 acres street address(es): 2317 Thrift Road and 1225 Berryhill Road, Charlotte, NC tax ID(s) or PIN(s): 2317 Thrift Road (approximately 2.82 acres): 07105114 1225 Berryhill Road (0.71 acre): 07105116 CSX parcel (0.90 acre) (address not listed): 07105121 past use(s): Portions of the 2317 Thrift Road parcel were reportedly utilized as a military base until the late 1930s. The current parcel building was constructed in the late 1940s and utilized by Rulane Gas Company for vehicle maintenance, a carburetor rebuilding shop, and a 8 propane storage yard. The parcel was acquired by Suburban Propane in 1952 and was utilized for fleet vehicle maintenance until it was purchased by the PD in 2012. The 1225 Berryhill Road parcel (a.k.a. 1201 Berryhill Road) was occupied with the Cities Service Oil Company bulk plant as early as the 1950s and by American Mineral Spirits Company in the 1960s. From approximately the mid-1980s until the early to mid-1990s, the 1225 Berryhill Road parcel was occupied by Cherokee Oil Company and utilized as a waste oil processing facility which accepted waste oil and various hazardous substances. According to information obtained during EPA Emergency Response and Removal Branch (ERRB) and RCRA investigations conducted in the early to mid-1990s, the facility accepted hazardous substances and hazardous wastes that it was not permitted to accept. These hazardous materials were blended with waste oil and stored in 30 cubic yard roll- offs, drums, tanker truck trailers, ASTs, USTs, and three concrete walled above-ground spill containment basins. Waste disposal operations ceased in the mid-1990s when a criminal investigation for conspiracy to violate the Clean Water Act was filed against the owners of Cherokee Oil Company. In 1994, the EPA ERRB completed emergency removal of hazardous materials, hazardous materials containment vessels, and significantly impacted media from the parcel. Portions of the CSX right-of-way have been utilized as a rail spur since at least the 1940s. current use(s): The southern portion of the building located on the 2317 Thrift Road parcel is currently occupied with an automotive repair facility/U-Haul rental office and a hair salon. Remaining portions of the building are currently unoccupied. The 1225 Berryhill Road parcel is currently cleared land utilized by a landscaping company for storage of landscape and tree removal materials and equipment. The CSX right-of-way parcel is currently unoccupied, although a railroad spur is still present through central portions of the parcel. cause(s)/source(s) of contamination: known: 2317 Thrift Road – Laboratory analytical results for groundwater samples collected adjacent to the south and topographically downgradient of the parcel building during Phase II ESA activities conducted in 1997 indicated that low-level chlorinated solvent compounds were detected at concentrations exceeding the 2L Standards. Results of analysis of a groundwater sample collected adjacent to the south and topographically downgradient of the parcel building in 2015 indicated that no compounds were detected above 2L Standards. Laboratory analytical results for soil samples collected on northern portions of the 2317 Thrift Road property by DEQ during investigations associated with the adjacent Cherokee Oil site in 1996 indicate that benzo(a)pyrene and Aroclor-1254 were detected at concentrations above IHSB PSRGs. 9 1225 Berryhill Road – Laboratory analytical results of soil samples collected by DEQ during site investigation activities indicate that several organic and inorganic compounds were detected above IHSB PRSGs suspected: B. Regulatory Agency Involvement: List the site names and all identifying numbers (ID No.) previously or currently assigned by any federal, state or local environmental regulatory agencies for the property. The ID No’s may include CERCLIS numbers, RCRA generator numbers for past and present operations, UST database, Division of Water Quality’s incident management database, and/or Inactive Hazardous Sites Branch inventory numbers. (In many instances, the PD will need to actively seek out this in formation by reading environmental site assessment reports, reviewing government files, contacting government officials, and through the use of government databases, many of which may be available over the internet.) Agency Name/ID No: 2317 Thrift Road – Suburban Fleet Maintenance - NCD986198810 (Small Quantity Generator until 1997) 1225 Berryhill Road – Cherokee Oil – NCD980799019 (IHSB) C. In what way(s) is the property is abandoned, idled, or underused? The Site is located in a fast growing area approximately 1 mile north of uptown Charlotte. Despite the Site’s prime location, only portions of the existing building on the 2317 Thrift Road parcel have been utilized for an automotive repair/U-Haul rental office and a hair salon. A majority of the building is unoccupied. The 1225 Berryhill Road parcel has been undeveloped since the mid-1990s and is currently used by a landscaping company for storage of equipment and materials. The railroad spur on the CSX parcel is currently unused by the rail line. Based on current low density use and proximity to uptown Charlotte, the Site is being significantly underused. D. In what way(s) is the actual or possible contamination at the property a hindrance to development or redevelopment of the property (attach any supporting documentation such as letters from lending institutions)? Assessment activities conducted at the site have previously identified chlorinated solvent related impacts in groundwater on the 2317 Thrift Road parcel. Additionally, soil samples collected in the northern portion of the 2317 Thrift Road parcel by DEQ during assessment activities associated with the adjacent former Cherokee Oil incident identified PAH and PCB impacts. The former Cherokee Oil incident occurred on the 1225 Berryhill Road parcel and assessment activities conducted by the EPA and DEQ indicate that residual VOC, SVOC, and metal impacts likely remain in soil on this parcel. Thus, Brownfields protection is important to address risks for the safe redevelopment of the Site. Further, the availability of financing for redevelopment of the Site will likely depend on the Site’s entry into the Brownfields Program. 10 E. In what way(s) is the redevelopment of the property difficult or impossible without a brownfields agreement (attach any supporting documentation such as letters form lending institutions)? Please see the response to Question II.D. above. F. What are the planned use(s) of the redeveloped brownfields property to which the PD will commit? Be as specific as specific as possible. Mixed-use commercial and residential G. Current tax value of brownfields property: Parcel 07105114 (2.28 acres): $502,400 Parcel 07105116 (0.71 acre): $64,400 Parcel 07105121 (0.90 acre): To be Determined H. Estimated capital investment in redevelopment project: $3.5 million I. List and describe the public benefits that will result from the property’s redevelopment. Be as specific as possible. (Examples of public benefits for brownfields projects include job creation, tax base increases, revitalization of blighted areas, preserved green space, preserved historic places, improving disadvantaged neighborhood quality-of-life related retail shopping opportunities, affordable housing, environmental cleanup activities or set asides that have community or environmental benefits. In gauging public benefit, NCBP places great value upon letters of support from community groups and local government that describe anticipated improvements in quality of life for neighboring communities that the project will bring about. The inclusion of such support letters with this application is recommended and encouraged.) 1. Creation of additional jobs during construction and redevelopment of the Site, as well as permanent commercial and industrial jobs. 2. Spur to additional community investment and development in the area resulting in further tax base and employment opportunities. 3. Positive impacts on the surrounding business community. 4. Tax base improvement with regard to real property and business activity in the surrounding area, including both increased property tax bases and taxes associated with increased economic activity. 5. Beneficial use of the property and creation of density in a rapidly-densifying area, thereby avoiding the use of “green space” in other areas of the community. 6. Aesthetic enhancements. 11 Special Note: Please describe all environment-friendly technologies and designs PD plans to utilize in its redevelopment strategy. For example, environment friendly redevelopment plans could include: Leadership in Energy and Environmental Design (LEED) Certification, green building materials; green landscaping techniques such as using drought resistant plants; energy efficient designs, materials, appliances, machinery, etc.; renewable sources of energy, and/or recycling/reuse of old building materials such as brick or wood. The use of environmentally friendly technologies will be considered during redevelopment. J. Who will own the brownfields property when the Notice of Brownfields Property is filed with the register of deeds at the conclusion of the brownfields process? (If information is the same as 1.A. above, please indicate.) Name The PD intends to own the Site parcels at the conclusion of the Brownfields process. Mailing Address E-Mail Address Phone No. Fax No. III. OTHER REQUIRED INFORMATION A. Brownfields Affidavit: PD must provide its certification, in the form of a signed and notarized original of the unmodified model brownfields affidavit provided by NCBP, that it did not cause or contribute to contamination at the property and that it meets all other statutory eligibility requirements. (Note: The form to use for this affidavit is attached to this application. It must be filled out signed notarized, and submitted with this application.) Is the required affidavit, as described above, included with this application? Answer: YES B. Proposed Brownfields Agreement Form: PD must provide the completed form Proposed Brownfields Agreement. (Note: The form to use for this document is attached to this application. It must be filled out, initialed, and attached on your submittal.) Is the required Proposed Brownfields Agreement, as described above, included with this application? Answer: YES C. Location Map: PD must provide a copy of the relevant portion of the 1:24,000 scale U.S.G.S. topographic quadrangle map that shows the property clearly plotted, and that measures at least an 8 ½ by 11 inches. (Note: these maps can be purchased through the above link, or often through retail outdoor recreation stores that can print out the relevant map. Often environmental reports have location maps that use this type of map as the base for its location map.) Is the required location map included with this application? 12 Answer: YES D. Survey Plat: PD must provide a preliminary survey plat of the brownfields property with the property boundaries clearly identified, and a metes and bounds legal description that matches the property description on the plat. At this stage of the brownfields process; one or more existing survey plats from a previous property conveyance will suffice. (Before the brownfields project enters the public comment phase of the brownfields process, the PD will be required to submit a final brownfields survey plat which includes the information listed in the brownfields survey plat guidance.) Is the required preliminary survey plat included with this application? Answer: YES E. Site Photographs: PD must provide at least one pre-redevelopment photograph of the property, in either hard copy or electronic format that shows existing facilities and structures. Please note that the NCBP prefers to have electronic photos instead of or in addition to hard copies. Electronic copies of photographs should be emailed to ShirIey.Liggins@ncmail.net with a clear indication as to which Brownfields Application they apply. Are photographs of the property included with this application? Answer: YES Have electronic copies of the photographs been emailed to NCBP? Answer: YES F. Environmental Reports/Data: If it makes an affirmative eligibility determination, the NCBP will request that PD provide any and all existing environmental reports and data for the property. However, the brownfields process may be expedited if PD submits such reports/data with this application. Are any environmental reports/data being submitted with this application? Answer: YES If environmental reports/data are being submitted with this application, please provide the title, date and author of each item being submitted: 13 2317 Thrift Road 1. Phase I Environmental Site Assessment Report, 2317 Thrift Road, Charlotte, NC, Geraghty & Miller, Inc., January 22, 1996 2. Soil Sample Analytical Results, Cherokee Oil Company, 1201 Berryhill Road, Charlotte, NC, State of North Carolina Department of Environment, Health, and Natural Resources, July 31, 1996 3. Phase II Environmental Site Assessment, Suburban Propane, 2317 Thrift Road, Charlotte, NC, Fluor Daniel GTI, November 25, 1997 4. Limited Site Investigation, Thrift Road Commercial Building, 2317 Thrift Road, Charlotte, NC, Terracon Consultants, Inc., December 3, 2015 1225 Berryhill Road 1. Sample Analysis Request, Cherokee Resources, Inc. 1201 Berryhill Road, Charlotte, NC, NC Department of Environment, Health, and Natural Resources, July 29, 1991 2. Correspondences, Cherokee Oil Company Site, 1201 Berryhill Road, Charlotte, NC, State of North Carolina Department of Environment, Health, and Natural Resources, September 26, 1983 through May 29, 1996 3. Affidavit To Obtain Administrative Inspection Warrant For Particular Condition Or Activity, 1201 Berryhill Road, Charlotte, NC, Douglas B. Moore, District Court Judge, March 6, 1996 IV. ADDITIONAL REQUIRED FORMS The following forms are to be filled out and submitted with the application including the Responsibility and Compliance Affidavit and the Proposed Brownfields Agreement. Submittal of the Affidavit requires signature and notarization, and the Proposed Brownfields Application requires an initial. 16 Preliminary Proposed Brownfields Agreement I. Property Facts a. Property Address(es): 2317 Thrift Road, 1225 Berryhill Road, and portions of the adjacent CSX right-of- way (address is not listed), Charlotte, NC b. Property Seller(s): 1225 Berryhill, LLC c. Property Buyer: Brownstone Properties II, LLC d. Brief Property Usage History: Portions of the 2317 Thrift Road parcel were reportedly utilized as a military base until the late 1930s. The current parcel building was constructed in the late 1940s and utilized by Rulane Gas Company for vehicle maintenance, a carburetor rebuilding shop, and a propane storage yard. The parcel was acquired by Suburban Propane in 1952 and was utilized for fleet vehicle maintenance until it was purchased by the PD in 2012. The 1225 Berryhill Road parcel (a.k.a. 1201 Berryhill Road) was occupied with the Cities Service Oil Company bulk plant as early as the 1950s and by American Mineral Spirits Company in the 1960s. From approximately the mid-1980s until the early to mid-1990s, the 1225 Berryhill Road parcel was occupied by Cherokee Oil Company and utilized as a waste oil processing facility which accepted waste oil and various hazardous substances. According to information obtained during EPA Emergency Response and Removal Branch (ERRB) and RCRA investigations conducted in the early to mid-1990s, the facility accepted hazardous substances and hazardous wastes that it was not permitted to accept. These hazardous materials were blended with waste oil and stored in 30 cubic yard roll-offs, drums, tanker truck trailers, ASTs, USTs, and three concrete walled above-ground spill containment basins. Waste disposal operations ceased at the parcel in the mid-1990s when a criminal investigation for conspiracy to violate the Clean Water Act was filed against the owners of the Cherokee Oil Company. In 1994, the EPA ERRB completed emergency removal activities at the site. Portions of the CSX right-of-way have been utilized as a rail spur since at least the 1940s. e. The planned reuse will potentially involve the following use classification(s) (check all that apply): School/childcare/senior care X Residential (multi-family) X Commercial, retail (specify) X Other commercial (specify) X Office X Light industrial Heavy industrial Recreational Open space Other (specify) II. Contaminant Information 17 a. The contaminant situation at the property is best described by the following (check all that apply): X Contaminants are from an on-property source(s) X Contaminants are from an off-property source (suspected) Contaminants are from an unknown source(s) Contaminants have not yet been documented on the property 18 b. Contaminated Media Table. (If known, check appropriate boxes below) Contaminant Types Soil Groundwater and/or Surface Water Private Wells Vapor Intrusion Known Suspected Known Suspected Known Suspected Known Suspected o r g a n i c s Chlorinated Solvents (list): TCE   X     X Petroleum: ASTs X USTs X Other X X   X     Other (list): PCBs X        i n o r g a Metals (list): Barium Lead Mercury Zinc X   X   i c s Other (list):       III. Protective Measures I am prepared to take steps necessary to make the property suitable for its planned uses while fully protecting public health and the environment. I propose that NCBP consider a brownfields agreement that will make the property suitable for the planned use(s) through the following mechanism(s) (check all that apply): Contaminant remediation to risk-based levels. X Engineered Controls (e.g., low permeability caps, vapor mitigation systems, etc) X Land use restrictions that run with the land that will restrict or prohibit uses that are unacceptable from a risk assessment/management perspective. (Important Note: In any final brownfields agreement generated by the NCBP, land use restrictions will ultimately come with the continuing obligation to Attachment A Site Location Map 0 2000 4000 APPROXIMATE SCALE IN FEET N U.S.G.S. QUADRANGLE MAP QUADRANGLE 7.5 MINUTE SERIES (TOPOGRAPHIC) CHARLOTTE EAST, NORTH CAROLINA 1991 TITLE PROJECT SITE LOCATION MAP THRIFT ROAD & BERRYHILL ROAD SITE 2317 THRIFT ROAD & 1225 BERRYHILL ROAD CHARLOTTE, NORTH CAROLINA DATE: JOB NO: REVISION NO: FIGURE: 11-17-16 0 1BRN-001 SITE Attachment B Preliminary Survey Plat REVISION NO. 0 2923 South Tryon Street-Suite 100 Charlotte, North Carolina 28203 704-586-0007(p) 704-586-0373(f) License # C-1269 / #C-245 Geology JOB NO. BRN-001 DATE: 11-18-16 FIGURE NO. 2 THRIFT ROAD & BERRYHILL ROAD SITE 2317 THRIFT ROAD & 1225 BERRYHILL ROAD CHARLOTTE, NORTH CAROLINA PRELIMINARY SURVEY PLAT MAP LEGEND SITE PROPERTY BOUNDARY ADJACENT PARCEL BOUNDARY NOTE: AERIAL IMAGERY OBTAINED FROM MECKLENBURG COUNTY GIS DEPARTMENT (2012). JAY STREET CSX ROW TRACT TUCKASEEGEE ROAD T H R I F T R O A D DRUM STREET BE R R Y H I L L R O A D F R E E D O M D R I V E (1225) (2317) S:\ A A A - M a s t e r P r o j e c t s \ B r o w n s t o n e P r o p e r t i e s - B R N - T h r i f t R o a d B r o w n f i e l d s \ F i g u r e s \ S i t e M a p . d w g , F I G 2 , 1 1 / 2 2 / 2 0 1 6 1 0 : 1 7 : 1 1 A M , z b a r l o w Attachment C Site Photographs Photograph 2: Northern portions of the 2317 Thrift Road parcel viewed from the east. BR N - 0 0 1 THRIFT ROAD & BERRYHILL ROAD SITE 2317 THRIFT ROAD & 1225 BERRYHILL ROAD CHARLOTTE, NORTH CAROLINA 2923 S. Tryon Street, Suite 100 Charlotte, NC 28203 704.586.0007(p) 704.586.0373(f) Photograph 1: Site building located on the 2317 Thrift Road parcel viewed from the east. Photograph 4: Northern portion of the CSX right-of-way parcel viewed from Berryhill Road. BR N - 0 0 1 THRIFT ROAD & BERRYHILL ROAD SITE 2317 THRIFT ROAD & 1225 BERRYHILL ROAD CHARLOTTE, NORTH CAROLINA 2923 S. Tryon Street, Suite 100 Charlotte, NC 28203 704.586.0007(p) 704.586.0373(f) Photograph 3: Automotive repair garage/U-Haul office located in the southern portion of the 2317 Thrift Road parcel. Photograph 6: Eastern portions of the 1225 Berryhill Road parcel viewed from the northwest. BR N - 0 0 1 THRIFT ROAD & BERRYHILL ROAD SITE 2317 THRIFT ROAD & 1225 BERRYHILL ROAD CHARLOTTE, NORTH CAROLINA 2923 S. Tryon Street, Suite 100 Charlotte, NC 28203 704.586.0007(p) 704.586.0373(f) Photograph 5: Landscaping business operations on western portions of the 1225 Berryhill Road parcel . Attachment D Environmental Reports (provided on attached CD) 2317 Thrift Road  Phase I Environmental Site Assessment Report, 2317 Thrift Road, Charlotte, NC, Geraghty & Miller, Inc., January 22, 1996  Soil Sample Analytical Results, Cherokee Oil Company, 1201 Berryhill Road, Charlotte, NC, State of North Carolina Department of Environment, Health, and Natural Resources, July 31, 1996  Phase II Environmental Site Assessment, Suburban Propane, 2317 Thrift Road, Charlotte, NC, Fluor Daniel GTI, November 25, 1997  Limited Site Investigation, Thrift Road Commercial Building, 2317 Thrift Road, Charlotte, NC, Terracon Consultants, Inc., December 3, 2015 1225 Berryhill Road  Sample Analysis Request, Cherokee Resources, Inc. 1201 Berryhill Road, Charlotte, NC, NC Department of Environment, Health, and Natural Resources, July 29, 1991  Correspondences, Cherokee Oil Company Site, 1201 Berryhill Road, Charlotte, NC, State of North Carolina Department of Environment, Health, and Natural Resources, September 26, 1983 through May 29, 1996  Affidavit To Obtain Administrative Inspection Warrant For Particular Condition Or Activity, 1201 Berryhill Road, Charlotte, NC, Douglas B. Moore, District Court Judge, March 6, 1996