Loading...
HomeMy WebLinkAbout8801_CORR_20191010 Ash Landfill Evaluation ReportSME Ak SEVEE & MAHER_ ENGINEERS October 10, 2019 Ms. Debora Aja Western Environmental Program Supervisor North Carolina Department of Environmental Quality 217 West Jones Street Raleigh, NC 27603 4 Blanchard Road, P.O. Box 85A Cumberland, ME 04021 Tel: 207.829.5016 • Fax: 207.829.5692 info@smemaine.com smemaine.com Subject: Evaluation Report of Slope Pin and Piezometer Monitoring Data Ash Landfill Glatfelter Pisgah Forest, NC Dear Ms. Aja Consistent with Sevee & Maher Engineers, Inc.'s (SME) letter to the North Carolina Department of Environmental Quality (i.e., letter to D. Aja) dated July 9, 2019, Glatfelter has been performing routine monitoring of nineteen slope pins and eleven piezometers at the Ash Landfill in Pisgah Forest, North Carolina. The monitoring was instituted in mid -May, 2019 to address possible landfill movement as identified from previous monitoring of several of those same instruments. This letter addresses monitoring data collected for September 2019. The slope pin monitoring consists of determining the horizontal (i.e., northing and easting) and vertical (i.e., elevation) position of each pin by way of ground survey. Monitoring of the piezometers consists of measuring the depth to water in each piezometer and calculating the water elevation based on a previous elevation survey of the piezometer pipe openings. Figure 1 shows the location and identification of each of the slope pins and piezometers monitored. Survey control for the slope pin and piezometer monitoring is based on permanent control points, which are located near the Ash Landfill perimeter, but outside of the waste limit. The horizontal and vertical position of the control points was refreshed in May 2019 when the weekly monitoring was initiated. The slope pin and piezometer data presented in this letter and subsequent monitoring data letters for the Ash landfill are meant to extend the information provided in the July 9, 2019 letter to NCDEQ. In this way the slope movements and water levels discussed herein draw from complete data sets for the pins and piezometers as collected since survey control at the landfill site was refreshed in May. Please note that the pin monitoring data collected on September 12, 2019 was questioned by the surveyor as having been potentially affected by poor visibility (i.e., fog at the landfill). Specifically, several horizontal distance readings resulted in pin lateral displacements of approximately 1 inch. Previous survey of those same pins had showed lateral displacements of less than %-inch, which is generally the accepted accuracy for the survey instruments and methods for the pin monitoring. The September 24, 2019 survey showed lateral displacement results for all pins similar to those for July and August 2019. ENVIRONMENTAL • CIVIL • GEOTECHNICAL • WATER • COMPLIANCE 19148 20191010da SME Aak SEVEE & MAHER_ ENGINEERS Consequently the pins with lateral displacements of approximately 1 inch for the September 12, 2019 monitoring were treated as outliers for this letter. SLOPE PINS There are nineteen slope pins installed in the surface of the Ash Landfill to monitor for possible slope movement. The pin identifications, in terms their horizontal coordinates and elevations, are listed in Table 1. The pin position information in Table 1 is based on survey completed on May 15, 2019 by Carolina Mountain Survey (CMS) of Brevard, North Carolina. Graphical data displays for the slope pins are presented in Attachment 1 to this letter. The displays show the following: • A plot of the horizontal movement of each pin since May 15, 2019; and • A plot of the vertical movement of each pin since May 15, 2019. It should be noted that the September 2019 measurements of horizontal movement are shown as green data points on the Attachment 1 plots in effort to distinguish the recent data from previous data. Discussions with CMS regarding precision and accuracy relative to the horizontal and vertical survey for the slope pins indicates that though the precision provided by the survey instruments used for the pin locations is quite high (to the nearest 0.001 foot or less) it is likely that the accuracy of the horizontal and vertical measurements from a practical standpoint is more or less on the order of % inch (i.e. approximately .05 feet [e.g., about the diameter of a dime]). As such it is important to understand, that for the purposes of this letter, pin movements (both horizontal and/or vertical), which are less than inch as compared to the initial location for the same pin are likely not indicators of landfill movement. Similarly, pin movements in excess of% inch are not considered to be an indication of landfill movement until at least two follow up consecutive readings support that deformation of the landfill has occurred. This consideration of corroborating measurements avoids potential false -positives due to such things as human error. Review of the horizontal movement plots show that the green data points generally fall within the grouping of previous data points, which indicates that little to no pin horizontal movement has occurred since May 2019, within the accuracy of the survey. Similarly, review of the vertical moment plots shows essentially no elevation change for any of the pins since May 2019, within the accuracy of the survey. DI1:7nUFTFRC Eleven piezometers in the Ash Landfill are used to monitor for water level changes in the waste deposit. The piezometer identifications and associated elevations (i.e., the top of the piezometer pipe, piezometer tip, and local ground surface) are listed in Table 2. The piezometer elevation information shown in Table 2 is based on survey performed by CMS in May 2019. Table 2 includes a summary of the water level data collected during the period of May 7, 2019 through September 24, 2019 as well as water levels measured at the Ash Landfill since May 2014. Water level monitoring has been performed in various piezometers in the Ash Landfill since 2007. 19148 20191010da October 10, 2019 Page 2 of 4 SME Aak SEVEE & MAHER_ ENGINEERS Review of the piezometer water levels in Table 2 shows no changes that are considered technically significant with respect to a possible changed condition in the waste deposit. Review of Table 2 also shows that the water levels in the piezometers are suggestive of a water table in the landfill that is at, or near, the lower limit of the waste deposit. Visual inspection of the Ash Landfill's piezometer water level history shows no changes or trends that are considered potentially problematic relative to the geotechnical performance of the waste deposit. CONCLUSIONS AND RECOMMENDATIONS The slope pin monitoring data presented and discussed in this letter indicate that little, if any, movement of the Ash Landfill has occurred since mid -May 2019 or possibly before. The piezometer monitoring data collected for the Ash Landfill shows no apparent changes in the waste deposit water levels that are considered sufficient to cause large vertical deformations or changes in slope stability. The next data evaluation letter to NCDEQ is planned for early November 2019 barring no unforeseen conditions relative to landfill behavior are identified. If you have and questions or comments regarding the contents of this letter, please do not hesitate to contact me. Sincerely, SEVEE & MAHER ENGINEERS, INC. A,� `(/ 471/� Matthew W. Muzzy, P.E. Principal/Senior Geoenvironmental Enginer Attachments cc: Jill Urey, Glatfelter Mike Cody, DMC Remediation & Laboratory Consulting, LLC Jack Garren 19148 20191010da October 10, 2019 Page 3 of 4 0v-1�PZ-2R P74 a I NOTES: 1. BASEMAP ADAPTED FROM RECORD DRAWING TITLED "FINAL GRADING PLAN" BY SME, DATED JUNE 6, 2006. 2. EXISTING TOPOGRAPHY FROM GOGGLE EARTH. 3. LOCATIONS FOR PIEZOMETERS AND PINS PROVIDED BY CAROLINA MOUNTAIN SURVEY OF BREVARD, NORTH CAROLINA. DWG: WATER LEVEL PROFILE LMN: FIG 1 ASH PIN CTB: SME-STD REV: .e. RAVEL ACCESS// DAD (TYP) \ ASH 3 ASH-2 D 1-34 / ♦ ASH-1 i ASH 33 A ASH-6 ASH-4 OASH-31-- 22I0 DD D D V7 / -B-9A,B D ASH-21�J 2210- ) ASH-27 0 �12g 1 a LEGEND FIGURE 1 BORING/PIEZOMTER LOCATION ASH LANDFILL MONITORING LOCATIONS PIN LOCATION GLATFELTER PISGAH FOREST, NORTH CAROLINA SME 50 0 100FEET SEVEE & MAHER ENGINEERS Table 1 Slope Pin Locations Ash Landfill Glatfelter Northing Easting Elevation Ash 1 570549.94 898426.71 2204.07 Ash 2 570556.09 898409.74 2197.38 Ash 3 570561.64 898397.03 2193.52 Ash 4 570529.81 898336.47 2179.00 Ash 5 570534.66 898322.32 2174.87 Ash 6 570541.59 898448.83 2211.56 Ash 21 570403.20 898484.27 2211.74 Ash 22 570369.96 898476.59 2200.85 Ash 23 570333.40 898466.36 2187.47 Ash 24 570292.66 898455.95 2172.25 Ash 25 570217.85 898436.32 2152.01 Ash 26 570180.30 898423.20 2134.82 Ash 27 570144.38 898411.75 2125.72 Ash 31 570524.17 898429.41 2207.71 Ash 32 570534.80 898391.89 2195.02 Ash 33 570545.92 898352.62 2181.69 Ash 34 570555.49 898313.90 2169.56 Ash 35 570565.97 898274.38 2155.42 Ash 36 570573.70 898239.54 2143.34 Northings, Easting, and Elevation based on survey by Carolina Mountain Survey, May 15, 2019 Table 2 Piezometer Water Level Elevations Ash Landfill Glatfelter Piezometer Piezometer Elevations Date B8 B9-A B9-B B10-A B10-B PZ-2 PZ-2R PZ-3 PZ-4 PZ-5 Q88V7 Elevation of Piezometer Top Opening (feet) 2119.91 2215.40 2215.90 2178.08 2178.51 2122.06 2120.01 2170.46 2199.56 2204.19 2233.17 Elevation of Piezometer Tip (feet) 2097.96 2166.10 2158.41 2125.55 2138.05 2102.06 2088.07 2119.76 2167.64 2152.69 2155.91 Ground Elevation at Piezometer (feet) 2119.25 2213.56 2213.61 2175.52 2175.59 2119.16 2119.26 2166.39 2196.13 2200.50 2230.14 Shading indicates Dry Piezometer Shading indicates Broken and Dry Piezometer Elevation of Water Level in Piezometer (feet) 5/3/14 2099.68 2146.09 2157.71 2132.05 2137.67 2102.05 2096.65 2129.66 2162.53 2151.68 2178.12 8/13/14 2099.20 2146.02 2157.71 2131.80 2137.67 2102.04 2096.63 2129.30 2162.52 2151.68 2176.13 11/5/14 2098.59 2145.15 2157.70 2131.74 2137.67 2102.04 2096.22 2129.04 2162.52 2151.67 2174.43 2/7/15 2099.49 2144.65 2157.71 2131.78 2137.68 2102.04 2096.63 2129.23 2162.53 2151.68 2173.50 5/8/15 2098.01 2144.41 2157.70 2131.62 2137.67 2102.06 2096.66 2129.16 2162.53 2151.67 2174.19 8/11/15 2097.56 2144.05 2157.70 2130.98 2137.67 2102.02 2095.91 2128.41 2162.53 2151.67 2172.81 11/17/15 2101.22 2143.37 2157.70 2130.36 2137.67 2102.31 2097.19 2128.15 2162.53 2151.67 2172.26 2/12/16 2101.41 2145.37 2157.70 2132.23 2137.67 2102.26 2097.26 2129.77 2162.53 2151.67 2178.98 5/24/16 2097.56 2145.75 2157.70 2131.88 2137.67 2102.25 2096.19 2129.46 2162.53 2151.67 2178.99 8/16/16 2098.21 2145.61 2157.70 2131.28 2137.67 2102.26 2096.31 2128.30 2162.53 2151.67 2175.17 11/15/16 2097.55 2144.32 2157.70 2130.69 2137.67 2102.23 2095.81 2127.78 2162.53 2151.67 2172.22 2/15/17 2098.86 2142.87 2157.70 2127.68 2137.67 2102.17 2096.26 2126.97 2162.53 2151.67 2169.48 5/9/17 2100.76 2141.76 2157.70 2119.39 2137.67 2102.19 2097.03 2127.23 2162.53 2151.67 2168.97 8/15/17 2098.64 2141.62 2157.70 2130.10 2137.67 2098.47 2100.12 2128.34 2162.53 2151.67 2170.75 11/14/17 2100.26 2141.97 2157.70 2130.18 2136.23 2098.81 2100.12 2128.18 2161.76 2151.67 2171.30 2/16/18 2101.08 2142.81 2157.70 2130.96 2136.23 2103.06 2097.67 2129.08 2161.76 2151.66 2173.15 5/15/18 2099.35 2144.15 2157.70 2131.73 2137.23 2102.17 2096.64 2129.47 2161.76 2151.67 2176.05 8/14/18 2100.66 2145.00 2157.70 2132.09 2138.23 2102.13 2097.20 2129.68 2161.76 2151.67 2179.33 11/27/18 2101.77 2146.50 2157.70 2132.38 2139.23 2102.10 2097.66 2129.99 2163.76 2151.67 2180.27 2/15/19 2100.90 2147.40 2157.70 2132.83 2140.23 2102.11 2097.23 2130.46 2161.67 2151.69 2184.67 5/7/19 2100.81 2165.48 2157.85 2132.66 2137.70 2102.11 2097.01 2130.05 2161.76 2169.78 2187.02 5/24/19 2099.75 2165.64 2157.87 2132.72 2137.70 2102.15 2096.21 2130.19 2163.78 2151.80 2186.57 5/28/19 2100.06 2165.62 2157.82 2132.68 2137.68 2102.13 2097.03 2130.18 2163.80 2151.79 2186.48 6/4/19 2098.93 2165.61 2157.84 2132.52 2137.68 2102.08 2097.56 2129.97 2163.81 2151.79 2185.98 6/11/19 2098.51 2165.64 2157.85 2132.52 2137.68 2102.10 2096.63 2130.01 2163.81 2151.79 2185.65 6/18/19 2098.94 2165.65 2157.86 2132.64 2137.69 2102.10 2096.58 2130.13 2163.81 2151.81 2185.34 06/25/19 2099.03 2165.65 2157.85 2132.50 2137.69 2102.10 2096.60 2130.97 2163.82 2151.81 2184.92 07/02/19 2098.96 2165.65 2157.85 2132.59 2137.67 2102.08 2096.53 2130.00 2163.81 2151.79 2185.56 07/09/19 2098.45 2165.61 2157.84 2132.39 2137.67 2102.10 2096.47 2129.86 2163.81 2151.79 2184.12 07/16/19 2098.24 2165.64 2157.84 2132.39 2137.68 2102.08 2096.43 2129.85 2163.81 2151.79 2183.74 07/23/19 2098.31 2165.65 2157.84 2132.39 2137.71 2102.05 2096.51 2129.86 2163.81 2151.79 2183.37 07/30/19 2098.37 2165.48 2157.85 2132.35 2137.68 2102.07 2096.42 2129.75 2163.81 2151.79 2182.97 08/13/19 2098.06 2175.50 2157.86 2132.35 2137.69 2102.11 2096.42 2129.74 2163.82 2151.81 2182.21 08/30/19 2098.39 2175.50 2157.80 2131.17 2137.67 2102.10 2096.48 2129.48 2163.81 2151.79 2183.22 09/13/19 2097.81 2175.50 2157.85 2132.11 2137.68 2102.07 2096.37 2129.43 2163.80 2151.79 2180.52 09/24/19 2097.67 2175.50 2157.85 2132.21 2137.68 2102.06 2096.29 2129.49 2163.80 2151.79 2180.03 ATTACHMENT 1 SLOPE PIN DATA DISPLAYS SME SEVEE & MAHER ENGINEERS Ash 1 570550.05 w 5 3 12 Date Northing Ea sting Elev Pointri 5/15/2019 570549.94 898426.71 2204.07 1 5/21/2019 570549.92 898426.68 2204.07 2 5/28/2019 570549.94 898426.71 2204.08 3 6/4/2019 570549.93 898426.70 2204.08 4 6/13/2019 570549.93 898426.71 2204.06 5 6/21/2019 570549.94 898426.72 2204.06 6 6/25/2019 570549.92 898426.71 2204.06 7 7/2/2019 570549.93 898426.72 2204.05 8 7/9/2019 570549.93 898426.71 2204.07 9 7/16/2019 570549.93 898426.72 2204.06 10 7/24/2019 570549.92 898426.72 2204.06 11 7/30/2019 570549.93 898426.71 2204.05 12 8/13/2019 570549.93 898426.70 2204.05 8/28/2019 570549.93 898426.70 2204.05 9/12/2019 570549.93 898426.72 2204.06 N16 9/24/2019 570549.92 898426.70 2204.04 Ash 2 570556.10 H u l7 z 510556.05 2 0 Z 570556.00 858409.70 898409.75 898409.8C EASTING - FEET HORIZONTAL MOVEMENT Ash 2 2197,45 LL z 0 2197.40 w 2197.35 5/5/2019 6/4/2019 7/4/2019 8/3/2019 9/2/2019 10/2/2019 DATE VERTICAL MOVEMENT SLOPE PIN MOVEMENT DATA SLOPE PIN - ASH 2 HORIZONTAL AND VERTICAL MOVEMENT ASH LANDFILL GLATFELTER PISGAH FOREST, NORTH CAROLINA NOTE: S M E DATA PLOTS BASED ON MAY 15, 2019 THROUGH SEVEE & MAHER SEPTEMBER 242019 MONITORING PERIOD. , ENGINEERS DWG: ASH PINS LMN: LMN CTB: SME-STD REV: 10/8/2019 5 8 6 1 3 � 4 � 10 13 r � 15 I 9 11�-12 z 7 14 • Date Northing Easting Elev Pointk 5/15/2019 570556.09 898409.74 2197.38 1 5/21/2019 570556.07 898409.71 2197.39 2 5/28/2019 570556.08 898409.73 2197.40 3 6/4/2019 570556.08 898409.73 2197.40 4 6/13/2019 570556.08 898409.73 2197.38 5 6/21/2019 570556.08 898409.75 2197.38 6 6/25/2019 570556.07 898409.73 2197.38 7 7/2/2019 570556.09 898409.74 2197.37 8 7/9/2019 570556.08 898409.74 2197.39 9 7/16/2019 570556.08 898409.75 2197.38 10 7/24/2019 570556.07 898409.73 2197.38 11 7/30/2019 570556.08 898409.75 2197.38 12 8/13/2019 570556.07 898409.73 2197.37 13 8/28/2019 570556.07 898409.74 2197.37 14 9/12/2019 570556.08 898409.75 2197.38 15 9/24/2019 570556.07 898409.74 2197.36 16 Ash 3 570561.70 LL _ 10 • rr r • • • r • r • Date Date Northing Fasting Elev Point#f 5/15/2019 570561.64 898397.03 2193.52 1 5/21/2019 570561.63 898397.01 2193.52 2 5/28/2019 570561.63 898397.02 2193.54 3 6/4/2019 570561.63 898397.02 2193.54 4 6/13/2019 570561.63 898397.02 2193.52 5 6/21/2019 570561.63 898397.02 2193.52 6 6/25/2019 570561.63 898397.03 2193.52 7 7/2/2019 570561.63 898397.04 2193.51 8 7/9/2019 570561.63 898397.02 2193.52 9 7/16/2019 570561.63 898397.03 2193.52 10 7/24/2019 570561.62 898397.03 2193.52 11 7/30/2019 570561.63 898397.03 2193.51 12 8/13/2019 570561.63 898397.03 2193.51 13 8/28/2019 570561.62 898397.02193 2.51 14 9/12/2019 570561.63 898397.04 2193.52 15 9/24/2019 570561.63 898397.04 2193.50 16 Ash 4 570529,90 w LL z 570529,85 x 6 7 10 3 Z n 16 8 15 12 c 1 2 4 11 1 14 13 570529.80 898235.40 898336.45 898336.50 EASTING - FEET HORIZONTAL MOVEMENT Ash 4 2179.05 w w z ❑ 2179.00 7- 7 Lu 2179.95 5/512D19 6/4/2019 7/4/2019 8/3/2019 9/2/2019 10/2/2019 DATE VERTICAL MOVEMENT SLOPE PIN MOVEMENT DATA SLOPE PIN - ASH 4 HORIZONTAL AND VERTICAL MOVEMENT ASH LANDFILL GLATFELTER PISGAH FOREST, NORTH CAROLINA NOTE: SM E DATA PLOTS BASED ON MAY 15, 2019 THROUGH SEVEE & MAH ER SEPTEMBER 24, 2019 MONITORING PERIOD. ENGINEERS DWG: ASH PINS LMN: LMN CTB: SME-STD REV10/8/2019 : Date Northing Easting Elev Pointq 5/15/2019 570529.81 898336.47 2179.00 1 5/21/2019 570529.82 898336.43 2179.00 2 5/28/2019 570529.82 898336.47 2179.02 3 6/4/2019 570529.81 898336.44 2179.02 4 6/13/2019 570529.82 898336.45 2179.00 5 6/21/2019 570529.81 898336.44 2179.00 6 6/25/2019 570529.82 898336.45 2179.00 7 7/2/2019 570529.81 898336.45 2179.00 8 7/9/2019 570529.82 898336.44 2179.01 9 7/16/2019 570529.82 898336.45 2179.00 10 7/24/2019 570529.81 898336.44 2179.01 11 7/30/2019 570529.82 898336.46 2179.00 12 8/13/2019 570529.81 898336.45 2179.00 13 8/28/2019 570529.81 898336.45 2179.00 14 9/12/2019 570529.82 898336.47 2179.00 15 9/24/2019 570529.81 898336.47 2178.99 16 Ash 5 570534-70 F w 11 12 Date Northing Easting Elev Point ri 6/15/2019 670634.66 898322.32 2174.87 1 6/21/2019 670634.66 898322.31 2174.87 2 6/28/2019 670634.67 898322.33 2174.89 3 6/4/2019 670634.67 898322.31 2174.89 4 6/13/2019 670634.66 898322.31 2174.87 6 6/21/2019 670634.66 898322.31 2174.87 6 6/25/2019 670634.67 898322.32 2174.87 7 7/2/2019 670634.66 898322.31 2174.87 8 7/9/2019 570534.67 898322.31 2174.88 9 7/16/2019 570534.66 898322.31 2174.87 10 7/24/2019 570534.66 898322.31 2174.88 11 7/30/2019 570534.67 898322.33 2174.87 12 8/13/2019 570534.67 898322.32 2174.86 13 8/28/2019 570534.66 898322.31 2174.87 570534.66 898322.332174.88 fl9/12/2019 9/24/2019 570534.67 898322.332174.86 Ash 6 570541.65 w 12 Date Northing Easting Elev Point q 5/15/2019 570541.59 898448.83 2211.56 1 5/21/2019 570541.60 898448.77 2211.54 2 5/28/2019 570541.60 898448.79 2211.55 3 6/4/2019 570541.59 898448.80 2211.55 4 6/13/2019 570541.60 898448.79 2211.53 5 6/21/2019 570541.59 898448.78 2211.53 6 6/25/2019 570541.59 898448.80 2211.52 7 7/2/2019 570541.60 898448.80 2211.52 8 7/9/2019 570541.59 898448.79 2211.53 9 7/16/2019 570541.59 898448.80 2211.52 10 7/24/2019 570541.59 898448.79 2211.52 11 7/30/2019 570541.60 898448.80 2211.52 12 8/13/2019 570541.59 898448.78 2211.51 13 8/28/2019 570541.59 898448.79 2211.51 14 9/12/2019 570541.60 898448.81 2211.52 15 9/24/2019 570541.58 898448.79 2211.51 16 Ash 21 570403.30 Lu w LL z 570403.25 5 12 1 2 3 2 7 oM 9 A 10 4 1 0 570403.20 898484.20 898494.25 998494.30 FASTING - FEET HORIZONTAL MOVEMENT Ash 21 2211.75 W LL Z O 2211.70Lu - H a Lu J W 2211.65 5/5/2019 6/4/2019 7/4/2019 8/3/2019 9/2/2019 10/2/2019 DATE VERTICAL MOVEMENT SLOPE PIN MOVEMENT DATA SLOPE PIN - ASH 21 HORIZONTAL AND VERTICAL MOVEMENT ASH LANDFILL GLATFELTER PISGAH FOREST, NORTH CAROLINA NOTE: SM E DATA PLOTS BASED ON MAY 15, 2019 THROUGH SEVEE & MAH ER SEPTEMBER 24, 2019 MONITORING PERIOD. ENGINEERS DWG: ASH PINS LMN: LMN CTB: SME-STD REV10/8/2019: e No Ash 22 570370.C5 w uw z 570370.00 13 11 Date Northing Easting Elev Point ri 5/15/2019 570369.96 898476.59 2200.85 1 5/21/2019 570369.99 898476.55 2200.86 2 5/28/2019 570369.98 898476.56 2200.87 3 6/4/2019 570370.01 898476.53 2200.85 4 6/13/2019 570369.99 898476.56 2200.86 S 6/21/2019 570370.04 898476.51 2200.85 6 6/25/2019 570369.99 898476.55 2200.86 7 7/2/2019 570370.01 898476.56 2200.84 8 7/9/2019 570369.98 898476.67 2200.85 9 7/16/2019 570370.01 898476.65 2200.84 10 7/24/2019 570369.99 898476.57 2200.85 11 7/30/2019 570370.01 898476.53 2200.83 12 8/13/2019 570370.01 898476.55 2200.82 13 8/28/2019 570369.98 898476.57 2200.84 14 9/12/2019 570370.06 898476.51 2200.83 15 9/24/2019 570369.98 898476.58 2200.83 16 Ash 23 570333.50 15 Lu LL L) z 570333.45 r Q Z 570333.40 898466.28 898466.34 898466.40 EASTING - FEET HORIZONTAL MOVEMENT Ash 23 2187.50 Lu W LL � z p 2187.45 H 7 J W 2187.40 5/5/2019 6/4/2019 7/4/2019 8/3/2019 9/2/2019 10/2/2019 DATE VERTICAL MOVEMENT SLOPE PIN MOVEMENT DATA SLOPE PIN - ASH 23 HORIZONTAL AND VERTICAL MOVEMENT ASH LANDFILL GLATFELTER PISGAH FOREST, NORTH CAROLINA NOTE: SM E DATA PLOTS BASED ON MAY 15, 2019 THROUGH SEVEE & MAH ER SEPTEMBER 24, 2019 MONITORING PERIOD. ENGINEERS DWG: ASH PINS LMN: LMN CTB: SME-STD REV: 10/8/2019 6 4 13 g 7 10 � � 5 12 2� 1 11 Date Date Northing Easting Elev Point# 5/15/2019 570333.40 898466.36 2187.47 1 5/21/2019 570333.42 898466.34 2187.48 2 5/28/2019 570333.42 898466.35 2187.49 3 6/4/2019 570333.43 898466.32 2187.47 4 6/13/2019 570333.42 898466.35 2187.48 5 6/21/2019 570333.47 898466.31 2187.48 6 6/25/2019 570333.43 898466.34 2187.49 7 7/2/2019 570333.44 898466.35 2187.47 8 7/9/2019 570333.40 898466.36 2187.48 9 7/16/2019 570333.42 898466.35 2187.47 10 7/24/2019 570333.41 898466.37 2187.48 11 7/30/2019 570333.43 898466.33 2187.47 12 8/13/2019 570333.43 898466.35 2187.47 13 8/28/2019 570333.40 898466.36 2187.47 14 9/12/2019 570333.48 898466.30 2187.47 15 9/24/2019 570333.40 898466.37 2187.47 16 Ash 24 570292.75 HLu ■ 28 Date Northing Easting Elev Point 11 5/15/2019 570292.66 898455.95 2172.25 1 5/21/2019 570292.70 898455.91 2172.26 2 5/28/2019 570292.73 898455.90 2172.26 3 6/4/2019 570292.71 898455.90 2172.25 4 6/13/2019 570292.70 898455.92 2172.26 5 6/21/2019 570292.74 898455.88 2172.25 6 6/25/2019 570292.70 898455.91 2172.27 7 7/2/2019 570292.72 898455.91 2172.24 8 7/9/2019 570292.68 898455.93 2172.26 9 7/16/2019 570292.71 898455.90 2172.26 10 7/24/2019 570292.69 898455.92 2172.25 11 7/30/2019 570292.72 898455.90 2172.24 12 8/13/2019 570292.70 898455.92 2172.24 13 8/28/2019 570292.67 898455.93 2172.25 14 9/12/2019 570292.75 898455.87 2172.24 15 9/24/2019 570292.67 898455.94 2172.24 16 Ash 25 570217.95 Lu W W LL z 570217.90 15 4 8 i�■ 5a31 ■ 9 13 10 ■ �r 16 14- ,-2 570217.35 898436.25 898436.30 898436.35 EASTING - FEET HORIZONTAL MOVEMENT Ash 25 2152.05 W • LL Z O 2152.00 i- ■ Q W ui 2151.95 5/5/2019 6/4/2019 7/4/2019 8/3/2019 9/2/2019 10/2/2019 DATE VERTICAL MOVEMENT Date Northing Easting Elev Point# 5/15/2019 570217.85 898436.32 2152.01 1 5/21/2019 570217.85 898436.33 2152.00 2 5/28/2019 570217.89 898436.30 2152.02 3 6/4/2019 570217.89 898436.29 2152.01 4 6/13/2019 570217.88 898436.31 2152.01 5 6/21/2019 570217.92 898436.28 2152.01 6 6/25/2019 570217.89 898436.30 2152.02 7 7/2/2019 570217.90 898436.30 2152.00 8 7/9/2019 570217.87 898436.32 2152.01 9 7/16/2019 570217.88 898436.30 2152.01 10 7/24/2019 570217.88 898436.31 2152.01 11 7/30/2019 570217.89 898436.29 2152.00 12 8/13/2019 570217.88 898436.30 2152.00 13 8/28/2019 570217.85 898436.32 2152.00 14 9/12/2019 570217.93 898436.27 2152.00 15 9/24/2019 570217,85 898436.33 2152.00 16 SLOPE PIN MOVEMENT DATA SLOPE PIN - ASH 25 HORIZONTAL AND VERTICAL MOVEMENT ASH LANDFILL GLATFELTER PISGAH FOREST, NORTH CAROLINA NOTE: SM E DATA PLOTS BASED ON MAY 15, 2019 THROUGH SEVEE & MAH ER SEPTEMBER 24, 2019 MONITORING PERIOD. ENGINEERS DWG: ASH PINS LMN: LMN CTB: SME-STD REV: 10/8/2019 Ash 26 570180.35 LuLu 570180.30 _z x 4 Z 570190.25 893423.15 898423.20 898423.25 EASTING - FEET HORIZONTAL MOVEMENT Ash 26 2134.85 Lu LL Z D 2134.80 H J W 2134.75 5/5/2019 6/4/2019 7/4/2019 8/3/2019 9/2/2019 10/2/2019 DATE VERTICAL MOVEMENT SLOPE PIN MOVEMENT DATA SLOPE PIN - ASH 26 HORIZONTAL AND VERTICAL MOVEMENT ASH LANDFILL GLATFELTER PISGAH FOREST, NORTH CAROLINA NOTE: SM E DATA PLOTS BASED ON MAY 15, 2019 THROUGH SEVEE & MAH ER SEPTEMBER 24, 2019 MONITORING PERIOD. ENGINEERS DWG: ASH PINS LMN: LMN CTB: SME-STD REV10/8/2019 : 5 3 �, 7 13 12110 a� 2 x 1 14 16 Date Northing Easting Elev Point q 5/15/2019 570180.30 898423.20 2134.82 1 5/21/2019 570180.31 898423.19 2134.84 2 5/28/2019 570180.33 898423.17 2134.82 3 6/4/2019 570180.32 898423.19 2134.82 4 6/13/2019 570180.35 898423.16 2134.82 S 6/21/2019 570180.32 898423.18 2134.84 6 6/25/2019 570180.34 898423.18 2134.82 7 7/2/2019 570180.31 898423.19 2134.83 8 7/9/2019 570180.31 898423.19 2134.82 9 7/16/2019 570180.32 898423.19 2134.83 10 7/24/2019 570180.31 898423.20 2134.82 11 7/30/2019 570180.33 898423.17 2134.82 12 8/13/2019 570180.32 898423.19 2134.81 13 8/28/2019 570180.30 898423.19 2134.82 14 9/12/2019 570180.37 898423.16 2134.82 15 9/24/2019 570180.29 898423.21 2134.82 16 Ash 27 570144.45 F 15 7 3 a 4 12 4 0 �" 2 6 a, °' = 1Q 11 1 14 16 L Date Date No Ash 31 570524.25 r w it Z 570524.20 rcc Z 570524.15 998429.35 898429.40 898429.45 EASTPNG - FEET HORIZONTAL MOVEMENT Ash 31 2207.75 w W Z ❑ 2207.70 ti W W 2207.65 5/5/2019 5/4/2019 7/4/2019 8/3/2019 9/2/2019 10/2/2019 DATE VERTICAL MOVEMENT SLOPE PIN MOVEMENT DATA SLOPE PIN - ASH 31 HORIZONTAL AND VERTICAL MOVEMENT ASH LANDFILL GLATFELTER PISGAH FOREST, NORTH CAROLINA NOTE: SM E DATA PLOTS BASED ON MAY 15, 2019 THROUGH SEVEE & MAH ER SEPTEMBER 24, 2019 MONITORING PERIOD. ENGINEERS DWG: ASH PINS LMN: LMN CTB: SME-STD REV10/8/2019 : 1 10 12 q 8 3 6 ■ 13 5 16 � 7 TM � � 14 15 2 g ` 11 4 - g Date Northing Easting Elev Point N 5/15/2019 570524.17 898429.41 2207.71 1 5/21/2019 570524.16 898429.38 2207.71 2 5/28/2019 570524.17 898429.42 2207.72 3 6/4/2019 570524.17 898429.40 2207.72 4 6/13/2019 570524.17 898429.40 2207.70 5 6/21/2019 570524.17 898429.40 2207.69 6 6/25/2019 570524.17 898429.41 2207.69 7 7/2/2019 570524.17 898429.42 2207.69 8 7/9/2019 570524.16 898429.41 2207.70 9 7/16/2019 570524.17 898429.41 2207.69 10 7/24/2019 570524.16 898429.41 2207.69 11 7/30/2019 570524.17 898429.42 2207.69 12 8/13/2019 570524.17 898429.42 2207.68 13 8/28/2019 570524.16 898429.41 2207.68 14 9/12/2019 570524.17 898429.42 2207.69 15 9/24/2019 570524.17 898429.42 2207.67 16 Ash 32 570534.85 r w 7 12Lu 570534.80 8 13 Date Northing Fasting Elev Point ri 5/15/2019 570534.80 898391.89 2195.02 1 5/21/2019 570534.79 898391.87 2195.02 2 5/28/2019 570534.80 898391.91 2195.03 3 6/4/2019 570534.80 898391.89 2195.03 4 6/13/2019 570534.80 898391.89 2195.01 S 6/21/2019 570534.80 898391.90 2195.01 6 6/25/2019 570534.80 898391.90 2195.01 7 7/2/2019 570534.80 898391.91 2196.00 8 7/9/2019 570534.80 898391.90 2195.02 9 7/16/2019 570534.80 898391.90 2195.01 10 7/24/2019 570534.80 898391.90 2195.01 11 7/30/2019 570534.80 898391.91 2195.01 12 8/13/2019 570534.80 898391.92 2195.00 13 8/28/2019 570534.79 898391.89 2195.01 14 9/12/2019 570534.80 898391.93 2195.01 15 9/24/2019 570534.80 898391.91 2195.00 16 Ash 33 570545.95 0 5 6 w Lu Z 570545.90 2 O Z 570545.85 898352.55 898352.60 898352.65 EASTING - FEET HORIZONTAL MOVEMENT Ash 33 2181.15 w w u. z O 2181.70 H 7 w w 2181.65 5/5/2019 b/4/2019 7/4/2019 8/3/2019 9/2/2019 10/2/2019 DATE VERTICAL MOVEMENT SLOPE PIN MOVEMENT DATA SLOPE PIN - ASH 33 HORIZONTAL AND VERTICAL MOVEMENT ASH LANDFILL GLATFELTER PISGAH FOREST, NORTH CAROLINA NOTE: SM E DATA PLOTS BASED ON MAY 15, 2019 THROUGH SEVEE & MAH ER SEPTEMBER 24, 2019 MONITORING PERIOD. ENGINEERS DWG: ASH PINS LMN: LMN CTB: SME-STD REV: 10/8/2019 g 15 3 2 ``1LL1 • � I�/ 13 4 16 8 7 11 12 Date Northing Easting Elev Point ri 5/15/2019 570545.92 898352.62 2181.69 1 5/21/2019 570545.92 898352.59 2181.69 2 5/28/2019 570545.93 898352.62 2181.71 3 6/4/2019 570545.92 898352.61 2181.71 4 6/13/2019 570545.93 898352.60 2181.69 S 6/21/2019 570545.92 898352.61 2181.69 6 6/25/2019 570545.92 898352.62 2181.69 7 7/2/2019 570545.93 898352.62 2181.69 8 7/9/2019 570545.92 898352.62 2181.70 9 7/16/2019 570545.93 898352.61 2181.69 10 7/24/2019 570545.92 898352.62 2181.70 11 7/30/2019 570545.92 898352.63 2181.69 12 8/13/2019 570545.93 898352.63 2181.69 13 8/28/2019 570545.92 898352.61 2181.69 14 9/12/2019 570545.93 898352.64 2181.70 15 9/24/2019 570545.92 898352.62 2181.68 16 Ash 34 s7Dsss.ss W W LL L9 z 570555.50 I- s O Z 570555.45 898313.85 898313.90 898313.95 EASTING - FEET HORIZONTAL MOVEMENT Ash 34 2169.60 Lu w LL • 2 O 2169.55 7 Lu J W 2169.50 5/5/2019 5/4/2019 7/4/2019 8/3/2019 9/2/2019 10/2/2D19 DATE VERTICAL MOVEMENT SLOPE PIN MOVEMENT DATA SLOPE PIN - ASH 34 HORIZONTAL AND VERTICAL MOVEMENT ASH LANDFILL GLATFELTER PISGAH FOREST, NORTH CAROLINA NOTE: S M E DATA PLOTS BASED ON MAY 15, 2019 THROUGH SEVEE & MAHER SEPTEMBER 242019 MONITORING PERIOD. , ENGINEERS DWG: ASH PINS LMN: LMN CTB: : SME-STD REV10/8/2019 11 1 12 2 1D 13 3� • �-- 15 7 _! 16 8 � Date Northing Easting Elev Pointq 5/15/2019 570555.49 898313.90 2169.56 1 5/21/2019 570655.48 898313.91 2169.56 2 5/28/2019 570555.48 898313.89 2169.56 3 6/4/2019 570555.48 898313.92 2169.58 4 6/13/2019 570555.48 898313.90 2169.59 5 6/21/2019 570555.47 898313.90 2169.56 6 6/25/2019 570555.47 898313.90 2169.56 7 7/2/2019 570555.48 898313.91 2169.56 8 7/9/2019 570555.47 898313.92 2169.56 9 7/16/2019 570555.48 898313.91 2169.57 10 7/24/2019 570656.48 898313.90 2169.57 11 7/30/2019 570656.48 898313.92 2169.56 12 8/13/2019 570555.48 898313.92 2169.56 13 8/28/2019 570555.47 898313.90 2169.56 14 9/12/2019 570555.47 898313.93 2169.57 15 9/24/2019 570555.47 898313.91 2169.55 16 Ash 35 570566.05 w LL L7 Z 570566.00 12 Date Northing Easting Elev Point It 5/15/2019 570565.97 898274.38 2156.42 1 5/21/2019 570565.98 898274.36 2156.42 2 5/28/2019 570565.97 898274.38 2156.44 3 6/4/2019 570565.97 898274.36 2156.45 4 6/13/2019 570565.97 898274.39 2156.43 6 6/21/2019 570565.97 898274.37 2156.42 6 6/25/2019 570565.97 898274.39 2156.42 7 7/2/2019 570565.96 898274.38 2156.42 8 7/9/2019 570565.97 898274.39 2156.44 9 7/16/2019 570565.97 898274.37 2156.43 10 7/24/2019 570565.97 898274.38 2156.43 11 7/30/2019 570565.98 898274.42 2156.43 12 8/13/2019 570565.97 898274.39 2156.42 13 8/28/2019 570565.97 898274.37 2156.42 14 9/12/2019 570565.97 898274.39 2156.43 15 9/24/2019 570565.97 898274.38 2156.41 16 Ash 36 570573.75 w LL l7 � Date Northing Easting Elev Point ri 5/15/2019 570573.70 898239.54 2143.34 1 5/21/2019 570573.68 898239.57 2143.34 2 5/28/2019 570573.69 898239.55 2143.35 3 6/4/2019 570573.69 898239.56 2143.37 4 6/13/2019 570573.69 898239.54 2143.37 5 6/21/2019 570573.68 898239.56 2143.35 6 6/25/2019 570573.68 898239.56 2143.35 7 7/2/2019 570573.67 898239.57 2143.35 8 7/9/2019 570573.68 898239.56 2143.35 9 7/16/2019 570573.68 898239.55 2143.36 10 7/24/2019 570573.68 898239.57 2143.35 11 7/30/2019 570573.68 898239.58 2143.35 12 8/13/2019 570573.67 898239.57 2143.34 13 8/28/2019 570573.68 898239.56 2143.35 14 9/12/2019 570573.68 898239.57 2143.36 15 9/24/2019 570573.68 898239.57 2143.34 16