Loading...
HomeMy WebLinkAbout950008_ENFORCEMENT_20171231Mitchell, Patrick From: Rosebrock, Melissa Sent: Tuesday, June 04, 2013 4:04 PM To: brepoffice@yahoo.com Cc: Mitchell, Patrick Subject: FW: J.C. Shore- Flannery Fork and Payne Branch property Attachments: Payne Branch 1.pdf; Payne Branch 2.pdf; Payne Branch 3.pdf; Payne Branch 4.pdf; Flannery Fork 1.pdf; Flannery Fork 2.pdf; Flannery Fork 3.pdf; Flannery Fork 4.pdf; Flannery Fork 5.pdf Ladonna, Thanks for your quick response to our requests for addressing the water quality complaint received by our office. Additionally, we appreciate you sending the photographs depicting your response. In general, everything looks good. However, I/we still have a couple of questions and I will refer to your photos from Payne Branch as PB and Flannery Fork as FF. You are welcome to "reply" and then type your response under each of the questions below if that is easier for you: PB #1— Silt fencing looks to be installed correctly. Thanks! PB #2 — Was the silt fence re -installed? When we visited 5/21/2013 the bottom portion was not buried. I will let Patrick determine if this is critical. PB #3 and #4 — Looks good. FF #1— Was the photo taken from the road? Le, is the creek in the foreground of the photo? The vegetation has really grown! FF #2 -- As you turn into the property, is this stockpile to the left of the barn? FF #3 — Much better! Is this area to be seeded to establish permanent vegetation? FF #4 — In the photo, was silt fencing eventually installed where the track hoe bucket is currently digging? FF #5 — Is this shot looking towards the road? Thanks again for your assistance in resolving this issue. Melissa Melissa Rosebrock E-mail Address: melissa.rosebrock(@ncdenr.aov NCDENR Division of Water Quality Winston-Salem Regional Office 585 Waughto% n Street, Winston-Salem, NC 27107 (336) 771-5289; fax (336) 771-4630 www.ncwateraualitv.ore E-mail correspondence to and from this address may be subject to the North Carolina Public Records Law and may be disclosed to third parties. From: Ladonna Shore (maiIto: breooffice0)Xahoo,com] Sent: Friday, May 31, 2013 1:27 PM To: Rosebrock, Melissa Subject: J.C. Shore- Flannery Fork and Payne Branch property Mitchell, Patrick From: Rosebrock, Melissa Sent: Wednesday, June 05, 2013 9:28 AM To: laja28605@yahoo.com Cc: Mitchell, Patrick Subject: J.C. Shore and Flannery Fork and Payne Branch Property Thanks for the clarification Ladonna. If any further concerns arise, Patrick will contact you. We have not received any additional complaints. In the future, please let us know if there's anything we can do for you! Best Regards, Melissa Melissa Rosebrock E-mail Address: melissa.rosebrock@ncdenr.gov NCDENR Division of Water Quality Winston-Salem Regional Office 585 Waughtown Street, Winston-Salem, NC 27107 (336) 771-5289; fax (336) 771-4630 www.ncwaterauality.or� E-mail correspondence to and from this address may be subject to the North Carolina Public Records Law and may be disclosed to third parties. From: Ladonna Shore [mailto:laja286050byahoo.com] Sent: Tuesday, June 04, 2013 9:56 PM To: Rosebrock, Melissa Subject: Fw: J.C. Shore- Flannery Fork and Payne Branch property ----- Forwarded Message ----- From: Ladonna Shore <Iaia28605@yahoo.com> To: Ladonna Shore <brepofficeCa7�yahoo.com> Sent: Tuesday, June 4, 2013 8:16 PM Subject: Re: J.C. Shore- Flannery Fork and Payne Branch property From: Ladonna Shore <brepoffice(ZDVahoo.com> To: "laia286050yahoo.com" <Iaia28605(q)_yahoo.com> Sent: Tuesday, June 4, 2013 5:23 PM Subject: Fw: J.C. Shore- Flannery Fork and Payne Branch property ----- Forwarded Message ----- From: "Rosebrock, Melissa" <melissa.rose brockfc)ncdenr.pov> To: " brepofficaa-yahoo;com" <brepofficetcDyahoo.com> Cc: "Mitchell, Patrick" <Patrick.Mitchell(a.NCDENR.gov> Sent: Tuesday, June 4, 2013 4:03 PM Subject: FW: J.C. Shore- Flannery Fork and Payne Branch property Ladonna, Thanks for your quick response to our requests for addressing the water quality complaint received by our office. Additionally, we appreciate you sending the photographs depicting your response. In general, everything looks good. However, I/we still have a couple of questions and I will refer to your photos from Payne Branch as PB and Flannery Fork as FF. You are welcome to "reply' and then type your response under each of the questions below if that is easier for your PB 41 — Silt fencing looks to be installed correctly. Thanks! PB #2 — Was the silt fence re -installed? When we visited 5/21/2013 the bottom portion was not buried. I will let Patrick determine if this is critical. Silt fence was buried. PB #3 and #4 — Looks good. FF #I — Was the photo taken from the road? i.e. is the creek in the foreground of the photo? The vegetation has really grown! Yes this was taken from our driveway. FF 92 — As you turn into the property, is this stockpile to the left of the barn? This is the only stock pile, it is to the right of the barn standing in our driveway. FF 43 — Much better! Is this area to be seeded to establish permanent vegetation? Yes! FF #4 — In the photo, was silt fencing eventually installed where the track hoe bucket is currently digging? Trackhoe is not digging, it is parked, silt fence goes past stock pile on both ends. FF #5 — Is this shot looking towards the road? Yes Thanks again for your assistance in resolving this issue. Melissa Melissa Rosebrock C-rnail Address: melissa.rosebrocknncdenr.gov NCDENR Division of Water Quality Winston-Salem Regional Office 585 Waughtown Street, Winston-Salem, NC 27107 (336) 771-5289: fax (336) 771-4630 ww w. n ewa tergua I i ty.ore E-mail correspondence to and from this address may be subject to the North Carolina Public Records Law and may be disclosed to third parties From: Ladonna Shore [mailto:brepoffice c,Dyahoo.com] Sent: Friday, May 31, 2013 1:27 PM To: Rosebrock, Melissa Subject: J.C. Shore- Flannery Fork and Payne Branch property �l Page 1 of 1 POL4 .1G I �1G�Gh S hltp://bfl-attacli.ymail.com/L s.fl 603.mail.yahoo.com/ya/securedownload?mid-2%5tD%5E.. 5/31/2013 I -tf-3 Page ] of ] http.11bfl-attach.ymai l.comlus.fl603 -mail .yahoo.comlyalsecuredownload?mid=2%5 f 0%5 £.. 551120 13 4 Page I of 1 ep.l�n,c l�fGnGh �� http://bfl-attach.yinail.comlus.fl 6O3.mail.yahoo.comlyalsecuredownload?mid=2°/ 5 f0%5£.. 5/31 /2013 41 Lr r 4- �- Page 1 of 1 http:lfbfl-anach.ymail.comlus.f1603.mail.yahoo.comlyalsecuredownload?mid=2%5fU%5f.. 5/3112013 4 Page 1 of 1 �1Ccnne+y ��-Yl,-4 � q http:/ibfl-attach.ymA.com/us. fl 603.mail.yahoo.com/ya/securedownload?mid=2%5f0%5f... 5/31 /2013 a w_ i� O "', w ;^�^s w .-.� r N Mil Pam ne, iBrane k I Page 1 of 1 Fri tp 0 0 4 gyp-' i • , ,rr ` _ V ` ,,,r, - •-, .r ._ � ., t'+"r ."',! i "•1�� a•� � � C � t °• � ems,, +�,' �. "�C� � +,� �' t� { �:•h �.+«r� y4�j *^+,m�'�3,,,.,�.• �hw'ti m ^..,- -� m. •"d-��' � AA_- � � - �.i ��v'r�Yc � 'i' �'r7� � �J.�ar1n a �, r �. �"Y" fir. o kph `; It y �4, "�• � �� � �a '.��1! r J't. r, : -�,:� Zvi '+.,^-s,i+r'�'�'Ss.� '" Jk� ;� -,•,. �r � r ��r , �' - � > ,• r _. ...'"C. lr."�Ft=ry �'�,=4. � .. + rkew,.7+ i+ `u� '�� R zc,- '� 4�'?�'���t y> ! f e (? n 41 " it f � 1 � � r t r k; �, af"� �' „-a r } • y �tj r + ' i c http.HbfI-attach.ymail.com/us.fl603.mail,yahoo.com/ya/securedownlo ?mid=2%5f1i%5f... 5/31/2013 inn AWT 'M4"! '�- +•.:y.'19, a rr.{ ].k��' _ 1 114, 11-1 Irk' - a - �.'' a��• t.rr'r""'F - �� '�'"K'if "' '' T' .+"er.i%i" �e����� _ '��, .t��r+•- *„AQ'€�.; .�'.t^ � a " �! �3"�+T" �' `_ �i^ ,R "��� *C„.'P Ins TOM I♦ Sy /� JSaI�' ,I �IS1 1 M yr4 ,� #Yri � •• ; - � ��1 � Sm .N �ti C � s } � � ''. , ij r y . t : ♦+hy�"�4; f � � •1"Z� Itri «, � �' ' : � q}per � i' �1f ,. �..1� ,i_ ` y� .>•* a �►' yY ,y}yy Jt`�_- �, 'I ��� }'���;, i "��� �K��'; 1.' S"i ` �'II�}��T'•`* ��• .�, '`!�, i �'=(,�1 �.„ S "ti A _R � .Y��, n x � x ; k -� -.i+ 1 '2 � � 4 -;L� Ylk �" r • M � ��,,,, ry��'� � �i �rP .., ��.,Ea �'�t'Yi.. .. re _ s.ialWr, A �,' Y., r �f 3:.�1s yY.�•. �d'r a Y.� �7.1 et..h*. ��.:lit !.�` ,�4�... .. PAVPJ6 BR-ANCR 3 Page I of 1 AAMR' wr tt. -17 Z, Z"-Ole r rot A4 httpa/bf1-attach.ymail.com/us.fl 603.mail.�hoo.com/ya/securedownload?mid=2%5fD%5f... 5/31/2013 WN oil It 1, "t To I - jS ' � 1 a 1'f...r "� y �iC�j' � z�,. �` r :` V'S�t\ _•� i �C a��.R, x•�' i '�'..fr „ � f .� - � "" r Yyy?� rr `�^,�`G r ��rl�•c5�yfr ��r �'�,'%^ �. - qr d °."`#. v ti;`� t � }.. .yam W 1 �-•y/,+p� +y i'% 'N' kC. AJ'srt� �S � ar' s • y. � ' f 1 i� N � d' _ t Tsk t �. "� j d 'a.-� rl ,� �nJ{al r '• ,}„ y1 '���,, �.,�#u •4r. C' ,{ . •�yzw's a-� ¢�1 r, dry �, x, x�'*�...' � n ` � £,� .'�sr�l,�,r f�a'�tr �ti+ "�,�',,w� �,•" ,�t" �m?�� � ,•,>a;h �' s .`yLi •G{� 1 Y - ' .� Y ,,r, fC f r. 41�s^' - �"� ��` ���'°�`�, tr#�"�"La�� _ "_air: � Z r ?�• '.:'�a,�c �L,•'+' •�^!'�"y*y"yr�,�r,�.r `"'. is�t„•4.efy �w r °y .. +dTy �" i 3 �" r f ti `�T;r.+� .� r� 4 t J�4 r r- it d r f MS�y�. "4 .•,',r r, �,^ "y- ��r ,.ems« VMS y. r .• ,J.1 .1� L - t ,P i �-f rG rk C'i r�i sr a 'w, {, µ- ! �, - + '4„'f...•S f 4r • lt4 f & 11 a �. e� �Sh a{�y`" r't-,. _ s•f rrnr '"p''R• �.� _ a .�'i rlr �° _,�� �� ?�'-,�B �,.'V � 'R��,r .yam„�,�y � .fir% �A��,,� � awl+ � f � �a'y.q�d � -��' � $!'r "•�•'t �'rt:. a.t _s c 4` k-. �" ~�'� .--/�y4u 7r F FY 3 y`t•H,'cr r, s � f-ra.,i', +y,. y�,R -T�r �y. •r }-•.4 r =r ..f� �. �_�+;�'�.; .. .� slr,'� y. �•_r •. ',X.'3,,.''. �' r � �r,:r � 4 y .r. 7: •-••� • • r� e _q�*+ /h}�� .�• fir. � � ���',�/.�Y:J� A�{•,• �'�!Rs,.v.T I ��'S� rLti��• " sK. fa i •�I ,t r.h +•� •��+ �,_.-. '}=¢>�.1° r{qr f�.r6S s.��� 5 �"s,}y •r, +...y' �'.. - hoc ` * �� �{ }L s� ' s(� }ir}u� 1• y Via' ��' ' .,,7 •Z >��:-�r`'�c''�a S:yl,. E 3 dy,��ii -, �aE•.''Z i .• :�'r''1•rS�,.:/�;� 1 t , -�,�;.� rb.. �C'r1,�*�"�v Z. g'� flw ,� U• FAA r ���•�+�,r ,; 1'y}'�'a..'_ Ru•i• •Y•I th s ! .y'. ...'. c �w`�"''�"i 1s-.+'ts�'�� y ��.�A.r i'��J)/,z ���A r��f ��•r �y t _ �-: .e>;...° • r' � » _ ,..+. f .G � J(,4 i f r' i 1 °{•kd� � ' 1 ' ..c��lLL f � t ,. . ; �'. •` �,+'ir,1.' 'Y".� h '� r �Fy.,, } V- .Cf; Old � �'-� - �� '+ ! �•i-�l °� it r ..z-1• :•4: ay ;r•„ z.y• K .-are+' � •: il ""` .3 - r • � � •S. M ��T' � _ i,,�•';~.._ .�y !' �� rr.�- ��ci*:.dl z y�+.re��• '_�� •7 �1 * . '¢`M .. •s . t.. a' �. . r ,Q� ,gyp r • � ,. • ,� ° � •.X} �y,,, �. � ` �'ryr A �.' "r* , • �^' � � � ' [,:•� � s } fir' � •�� ;'-'�-+�✓"� -R• Y *; ^ .. � •. • �' ' •,"tom n+sA.t` �'' ;;ti irT�,•r- . 4� '� !':. ,'�•-c r I �•+ ;' y 1 N A • ._ .. �� rifr Sr ... y�� ,{tom: �7 1,.•t��j� ��i,'� �M+ Yfr���( SC��'s�✓t�, Af y«7• x..�i,t,,;e'ws..-w,�fy� "�' �'`� r � .d�,s• •%' r�'��?4+ K�•�c�j �: � -� ir,(;' -' .r •� �, �� •f ,., �, �,'• � ' �„� M .vYf^ �� `"• `'a 4'w'-"� w +`•'c'• '� -rr•! s� ''c�-t -' C,;�,..Yr�r"�✓ _� .. ±„ �, 'r~1""#: �s�' J r � 1,." =� r,,,Y" s r'" ��.:. .p• "'-+ .^ o j rs''' cam' `�'r�' Z" sol,.r.-a- jy ;,�r�"i�'�`•� tfs'� yTi �±:' t k} vs, �rr'''t`r "+$rwP �C�J"� u•' �•", �,,,:` . f'�� r,� �:"��,+�, *5A •s�"�� +��' ` r tg�,.,�.�s /era ;,�'? �� �T�,���. - • : v', v'�r•' _ �L'+4, �'�� f t^'f � 4"•f;,f%z'� �/���(�• �,�•P }- �,�-:�.. "�`+lt. ,r. �,, ,. -. r+Sq ,�•w. x'"' ti '.,, •h+a'�y i' nk '''�y`}�•+�t-..�,'. stt)y ti ` ..5-r q. fL'•. �S��F• �iCYM� � � 13� H Y , .c d �� �,j].��1 I i �.yi I. �: • -'" 'r y ^1F r.+ `r •r r� �4i•„��,,, •;,� ,..i�C �. Ste' � •Fji � yty ` k« 7 y.x. �`,.."°'" .�+.- { �,���ft� "r'` _F.� � r'•y�.�� s.'��"� vp� �; .a is i °! �i�e- +'"1'; y xu.�-rL � l.e r +C�y its ��ss''• �' pit x,..r ";'-. IT vN— {fir 3, ,r' •Vy o w •_��, �yr�"°'��'��� jar• �+� '�•,ry� ,1 `r �' -t 4. - r� :-'��.+•;r +"•,,i _ T �, J'' +. fir. �� : .. i t s""L7 r '4„�� Z. .�•.T•,w�"r.Ne• {" t yyy���--'rrrrrF r , .., �.y r:* a'.Sa�,`.=rrr' - _ '�n•,r,;, x.zyi.s. _�„•.,, ` �, P ;?ib1• ' ^3 r,�_� � 7i ,J'�.«, r •�' .+w. V7�"y. k.�r�T+'J >•'Cy - .k. .i w .a��j,4� µin' ..f�.:�s�.ira ".. .i. -S7 `�� ""'�� r d r` Y� r ��'. 4��"JM`'-.'�� "�' ?�f� �--�'1��x'�'~ ! �' x, f�' • i-rr +c�'`Y.� t ;`r• Cel MYO r J ".' /w ' r`�s7 E• y i is a '' a i t `,•Si r' , ,r� i+ �� Y,� //` • „+./ ` "�.- � r•� ^(.-�;..��, art-+���'�i 1 i ,y.�,3.•6 �+Y �" F" ��i•",a+..- �• "�1:�'+ �,��'���`- .+�N �'�w,.j�.ra�,a�,aS,� 7[{,j��'L� µ �, t+., ' _,����.�• rah "�l'�' Yri.lt ty t�� i1 s r.r ;' r ,•�'�•r a i� x r• -r_ •le.. 1L !t y<' �� i . �'' I '•3 . +mir�(„�w-'+y J *' ,.a } .>"� ..rr }w.--��,t_�,t �l�y, K,( �5�r�1�, s���. ��„v'� `•' •. sue.- < •d• � n :. ��.'.•fe'Y� r �y �{ . i '�iU? ti ��Y YY) "� 3 j'ir�. qr r` ' r xA w � f + •K i� A . �_ l" �,��t 4 { may, U r' " �d' . � •.,�,.,..» d _ � �" �,y��y a. �/�/" .rF a -t. y - ��F -(�+x ry+ .Ywr� �r s �' �'�i.: rY!" �i�'1rl +'�ar1 k rt�`f}'. � � ""•y� � +r„ '' �F. �A +r• �f� v !'� •�C r,��yw--�4T, p'._'i7 J Jr � � f��y r »et"` ems'} �" � 'f" { "'-' i4`s. »---^^' rr .. �• �r rF � 4: ,a�x *. �� ., ,�, r '� * � •-�.�' ... *�,�`,�.'�+_,��..i1 �. r � N " :.ter fir,' rtl� {� ..-.� �-y.a.:•rr��� `r'�a-`,,.;�a •�'. } f + ,r :• f . .�,7 tN "x ,..� 1M" ']ty "�"1 -r-� .•. Y+ ,s:.�1+ (r %'"y' ' -.>f f � ..r-P.. � .-1' .sA, ' .r�— #�y'�r' Aw /f 1 ' -- �, t{ [ 'Lem, � G �• tif- :.: .'".,i.T 4�'- 6 I ,� sr ar i-; ,, � ��.q• v �a•3. .�s'+,+• •rK r�.G - 1'-+i'. r r' �',y .wr�� � "• �'. '� r✓f { ��..-'!� :ram''' t"r�,»�x�'�a ,rw t :.i"R'� � ! o- y f yam' „-�'.� / 1� .�� -�•- •-Sx'. r. �-.e�j� y i ,.., y ��'rrvr'�:�,i ...� �'i.� • � � w /'��.��4.1 / .�r.i� .'' �'(+rF .s ; ; Y y� �� 4 � • J`' i 1�,�'�`{ $ ` ! � Y� � ? r•.-. i w.r' � r7 r S +� 1 . t r • ' �. �' ��x t'"r`� � y _ ' fi + 'i. 'r, � c ry z, �' r'•fr�':�r. • !l..17 R'%!'. r^r :'4 �".°+-.rr$C' •'ram-t�i� r�'�vr YY�r r ' �s om r r - t *_#:�;Y. `7 i i}...� �.. �-' a: _ . >.. . � � S•" _.(�� ,,�� : ,���'�� - �' ram-+ � � �f i -n �T�3s•'i'r�, s �i'1�*v� .- - lE, .F ti -y� �a 9 J1{` �i r �' �* � :fxs � • . s. _ 't � `� " � �u-�� a4 Cr t� Y _ r 6 h✓ , -i�Y �t r.Pl� ix � e"j}�4 � e Z�{ � r --+/ f' - ,�, r�w�Y � - `', �� ' ;•�f'ry�, [� oc -, +�.. •; �ryr t T�i �,c €Of r!. f�fy+ � = �r�� t M O _ '4 r - _ 4 •i ii.'. i V ,. ,ri�.� T �[•S �tFt N,y'P • r �� "' Y Y:i �.1� � iF _ u1 q �: '-�rY,{�a � �`K} �j;,' 't '` L {- k �ra ...:. { ' Y F•' �'` � Al r .b r r Ewff. d ,�,.', . - C: _ _. Y , *�, f ` �•' � �.y ' � -r } iC r r+*h���� Y�Pq�-' ;, �, _ Z 'r �. ON � r .�� aft. - .D y oq � - ��9d•� V , � �I`kr� * _ P f r���Q-��j� ' `�'h3;�..��1.'Fr��` r. �� N -,y3 •'�i, ilF.,o il��le f""� .# a• �U' A c ��`t� eCry _ ..4,-' ,f% ..�ci %j, r i�t i r r •-��. - - ) .:}. Alr� `�� • 41 " yy !! r' ? 'g r i4 r - .A .r,.,.� a 9.^� Y� �,* t.F+ ,Y y= • Lx r - y'' � �1• F' r • , '' . -_ .� - .. Qsl ori." `xi -err, ��� •� '�� ;i?'�,''�ca_ '•�. �ye j;� U } �,e--ram _ • ,,, _ �' �. �4Ys�� p� ��aiy �'�;� s: 'rt�' '�t. � � �y},� �,� o 'lit - �1 � - t « � • � f� �,.i .0 j3�:��' .. `� �,�p�'}` "if.,.) � �i�fak _� r) �2`��'�r, �.;- �� Y�#F 'IJ �,�trr,r,(f` c Y •� r •it'"'L {6 � �� •o' .�. } +Y s � t-,!t iff � ,Cy n,. tR• - f ' � ( It - �L .]"' �2�' - y't kt !� tY� �iC 4����'�#l�S�'��[' Sc'.1 � - °� � dr � ° � �• . o � .;� � . � � F ��.��,), ,� .. df � stogy �t� .r � � . ' mV', w-+ 9. e� r °wit r#r , '>�'sr! -b•.i •,/Ld �'4� %. J�r+r �.e L� .1 Qua .! �fE,l n .T1 ..r/ rlJ■� -'L� � ,�'r�.f * i-.. ry '11 t._'+•s�� ��`�9' P;.if_i � ,0�` �� cf J t t - ;' �� n{ � tfi• � � �i ' r F� �*�t n p: '{it� � ��Sf�. �� ;F� �..ya y R, lu lr&ENR North Carolina Department of Environment and Natural Resources Division of Water Quality Pat McCrory Charles Wakild, P, E. Governor Director May 24, 2013 Mr. J.C. and Mrs. Ladonna Shore 706 Flannery Fork Road Blowing Rock, NC 28605 SUBJECT: Complaint Investigation -- Animal Waste Stockpiles J.C. Shore Farm Facility No. 95-0007 Watauga County Dear Mr. and Mrs. Shore: John E. Skvarla, III Secretary This letter is a follow-up to the complaint investigation conducted on May 22, 2013 by the Division of Water Quality (DWQ). The investigation was conducted by DWQ staff members Mr. Patrick Mitchell and Ms. Melissa Rosebrock from the Winston-Salem Regional Office, As a reminder, this investigation occurred in response to an anonymous complaint alleging animal waste (horse manure) runoff from stockpiles located on your properties located at 706 Flannery Fork Road and Parcel No. 2809918125000 located on Payne Branch Road. A copy of the complaint investigation report is attached for your review. Site located at 706 Flannery Fork Road: On the date of our investigation, DWQ staff noted several areas for animal waste to potentially enter Flannery Fork from stockpiles located along the bank of Flannery Fork (see enclosed Photos Page 1). Flannery Fork is rated as a Water Supply-Il; Trout, and High Quality waters of the State. Per discussion and verbal agreement during the investigation, you stated that you would move the animal waste stockpiles at this site 25 feet or greater from the banks of Flannery Fork and reinstall the silt fencing properly to contain any runoff. It is our expectation that the buffer area along the entire length of stream also be seeded and vegetated. NC Administrative Code 02T .1303(a)(3)(B) requires "a vegetative buffer (separation) of at least 25 feet is maintained from a perennial stream or perennial waterbody" to animal waste. Also, please be aware that any unpermitted discharge of animal waste into Flannery Fork (even during rain events) is illegal per NC General Statute 143-215.1(a)(1). Site located „on Payne Branch Road (Parcel ID2809918125000): On the date of our investigation, DWQ staff noted areas for animal waste to potentially enter an unnamed tributary to Flannery Fork (Water Supply-11; Trout, and High Quality waters of the State) from stockpiles located onsite (see enclosed Photos Page 2). Per discussion and verbal agreement during the investigation, you stated that you would move the animal waste stockpiles at this site 100 feet or greater from surface waters (i.e. Neighbors Pond, Unnamed Tributary and the Wetland Area) and reinstall the silt fencing properly to contain any runoff. It is our expectation that the area where stockpiles were originally located be seeded and vegetated. Again, be aware that the unpermitted discharge of animal waste into any surface waters of NC (even during raid events) is illegal per NC General Statute 143-215.1(a)(1). . Ni 3 585 Waughtown Street, Winston-Salem, North Carolina 27107 Qlle Phone: 336-771-50001 FAX: 336-771.4631 North Caroli na Internet: www,ncwatefgualijy.oLqNaturally An Equal Opportunity 1 Airmlalive Action Employer J.C. and Ladonna Shore May 24, 2013 Page 2 of 2 Flannery Fork is a tributary to the South Fork New River, which is rated as class "C:+" waters of the state. This designation identifies waters that are subject -to a special management strategy specified in 15A NCAC 213 •.0225 the Outstanding Resource Waters (ORW) rule, in order to protect downstream waters designated as ORW. ORW classification is intended to protect unique and special waters having excellent water quality and being of exceptional state or national ecological or recreational significance. Stream samples were not obtained for either site at the time of investigation. However, there is certainly the potential for a violation of NC water quality standards during rain events and if conditions are allowed to deteriorate. The quantity of animal waste that you are receiving in a given year is currently unknown. It is estimated that you have greater than 100 tons of animal waste stockpiled at the above described sites. Be aware that NC Administrative Code 02T .1403(a) requires that: • Persons accepting or purchasing animal waste at a rate of 100 tons or less per year must apply the waste at no greater than agronomic rates; and maintain a setback of at least 25 feet from a perennial stream or waterbody. • In addition to the above listed requirements, persons accepting or purchasing over 100 tons of animal waste per year must also do the following: register with DWQ prior to accepting or purchasing the manure; animal waste shall not be stockpiled within 100 feet of a perennial stream or waterbody; animal waste shall not be stockpiled uncovered for greater than 15 days; along with the other requirements contained within section .1403(a)(2). If you are hauling greater than 100 tons of animal waste per year, please register with the Division prior to accepting or purchasing any additional manure. The office recommends that you cover the existing animal waste stock piles. The Division of Water Quality appreciates your cooperation and efforts thus far in preventing potential violations and discharges. DWQ requests that you notify this office within thirty (30) days of receipt of this letter that the proposed corrective actions have been completed. Should you need technical assistance, we urge you to contact the Watauga County Soil and Water Conservation District/Natural Resources Conservation Service office at (828) 264-0842. Your cooperation in this matter is much appreciated. If you have any questions, please contact Mr. Patrick Mitchell or me at (336) 771-5000. Sincerely, Sherri V. Knight, P.E. Regional Supervisor, Aquifer Protection Section enc: Site photos (Page 1 & 2) Investigation Report cc: Watauga County Health Department ' Mr. Brian Chatham, Watauga County SWCDINRCS DWQ-APS-Confined Animal Feeding Operations Unit / r—WSRO = APS-Files= . r' 'w� �""' M W A ' f y 1 . ATO I.'(, rf ,r �rw+` . r,—" 1. CIA 1, 'C � ..,..� � � � J' \`.�..z'�1�`�>'�.�' •�a-< 4 r�� i 54 h A. M?' y eti S { eF r Grp qS lr� M t _• k, ��., 2`, ,� •ti„+� h � *tin �LL6N, �"y,.5- � N:G �..,��,gl F ^ s Y S 0 Division of Water Quality Division of Soil and Water Conservation ❑ Other Agency Facility Number; 950007 Facility Status: Active Permit: AWD950007 ❑ Denied Access Inspection Type: Compliance InsQection, _ Inactive or Closed Date: Reason for Visit: County: Watauga _ _ Region: Winston-Salem Date of Visit: 05/22/2013 Entry Time: 10:50 AM Exit Time: 12:30 PM Incident #: Farm Name: J.C. Shore Farm _ „ „ -, , „ „ , Owner Email: Owner: J C Shore Phone: Mailing Address: 706 Flannery Fork Rd _____ glowing Rock NC 28605 Physical Address: Blowina Rock NC 28605 Facility Status: ❑ Compliant ■ Not Compliant Integrator: Location of Farm: Latitude: Longitude: Hwy 321 toward Bolwing Rock, R onto Payne Branch Rd, L onto Flannery Fork Rd, Farm on Right. Question Areas: Dischrge & Stream Impacts Other Issues Certified Operator: Operator Certification Number: Secondary OIC(s): On -Site Representative(s): Name Title Phone 24 hour contact name J.C. Shore Phone: 828-295-4700 On -site representative Ladonna Shore Phone: 828-295-4700 Primary Inspector: Patrick Mitchell Inspector Signature: _ Secondary Inspector(s): Melissa Rosebrock Phone: Date: 2 3�z i, 1 3 Phone: Page: 1 Permit: AWD950007 Owner - Facility: J C Shore Facility Number: 950007 inspection Data: 05122/2013 inspection Typo: Compliance Inspection Reason for Visit: Complaint Inspection Summary: On May 22, 2013 WSRO staff members Patrick Mitchell and Melissa Rosebrock conducted site visits at two locations (a 46.35 acre tract located on Payne Branch Road (Parcel ID 2809918125000]; and at address 706 Flannery Fork Road), both in Blowing Rock). Both of these properties are owned and operated by J.C. and Ladonna Shore. The site visits occurred as result of an anonymous complaint received by the WSRO concerning improper placement of horse manure stockpiles and potential impact to surface waters. The subsequent investigation revealed the following details for each site: Parcel ID 2809918125000: A mixture of horse manure, bedding materials (sawdust & straw) and wood chip mulch was present onsite in two separate stock pile areas. One large stockpile being adjacent to Payne Branch Road on the shoulder slope and the other large stockpile being at the toe slope next to an unnamed tributary to Flannery Fork (Tributary to South Fork New River), see attached photos. The stockpile next to the unnamed tributary was approximately 60 to 70 feet from the stream and a freshwater pond on the neighboring property to the north. There was also a wetland area present between the stream and the subject stockpile that drained into the neighboring freshwater pond; the distance between the wetland area and the stockpile was less than 30 feet. It should be noted that the owner had placed silt fencing downslope of the stockpiles in an effort to contain any runoff. However, the silt fencing was not properly installed and there was evidence of runoff flowing under the silt fencing. Recommended stockpiles be moved back further away from the wetland area and that the silt fencing be reinstalled properly. 706 Flannery Fork Road: A large amount of stockpiles of horse manure and bedding materials (sawdust & straw) mix was present onsite in several areas adjacent to Flannery Fork (Tributary to South Fork New River). These stockpiles were placed as close as stream bank from Flannery Fork (see attached photos). It should be noted that the owner had placed silt fencing downslope of the stockpiles in an effort to contain any runoff. Again, the silt fencing was not properly installed and evidence of runoff flowing under the silt fencing was observed. Recommended stockpiles be moved back further away from Flannery Fork and that the silt fencing be reinstalled properly. The horse manure and bedding mix for each site was received from Blowing Rock Equestrian Preserve. NC Administrative Code 02T .1303(a)(3)(B) requires that "a vegetative buffer (separation) of at least 25 feet is maintained from a perennial stream or perennial waterbody" to animal waste. This office recommends establising a vegetative cover after moving the stockpiles. While surface water samples were not taken on the date of our complaint investigation, there is certainly the potential for a violation of NC water quality standards, if the present conditions at each of the subject sites are not corrected. DWO to send a Notice of Deficiency to the owner of the subject properties requesting that corrective action be taken. Page: 2 Permit: AWD950007 Owner -Facility: J C Shore Faclllty Number: 950007 Inspection Date: 05/22/2013 Inspection Type: Compliance Inspection Reason for Visit: Complaint Regulated Operations Design Capacity Current Population Other Animals ❑ Animals Other Total Design Capacity: Total SSLW: Page: 3 Permit: AWD950007 Owner - Facility: J C Shore Facility Number: 950007 Inspection Date: 05/22/2013 Inspection Type: Compliance Inspection Reason for Visit: Complaint Discharges & Stream Impacts Yes No NA NE 1. Is any discharge observed from any part of the operation? ❑ ■ ❑ ❑ Discharge originated at: Structure ❑ Application Field ❑ Other ❑ a. Was conveyance man-made? ❑ ❑ ■ ❑ b. Did discharge reach Waters of the State? (if yes, notify DWQ) ❑ ❑ ■ ❑ c. What is the estimated volume that reached waters of the State (gallons)? d. Does discharge bypass the waste management system? (if yes, notify DWQ) ❑ ❑ ■ ❑ 2. Is there evidence of a past discharge from any part of the operation? ■ ❑ ❑ ❑ 3. Were there any observable adverse impacts or potential adverse impacts to Waters of the State other than ❑ ■ ❑ ❑ from a discharge? Otherlssues Yes No NA NE 28. Did the facility fail to properly dispose of dead animals within 24 hours and/or document and report ❑ ❑ ■ ❑ mortality rates that exceed normal rates? 29, At the time of the inspection did the facility pose an odor or air quality concern? If yes, contact a regional ❑ ❑ ■ ❑ Air Quality representative immediately, 30. Did the facility fail to notify regional DWQ of emergency situations as required by Permit? (i.e., discharge, ❑ ❑ ■ ❑ freeboard problems, over -application) 31. Do subsurface tile drains exist at the facility? ❑ ❑ ■ ❑ If yes, check the appropriate box below. Application Field ❑ Lagoon / Storage Pond ❑ Other ❑ If Other, please specify 32. Were any additional problems noted which cause non-oompliance of the Permit or CAWMP? ■ ❑ ❑ ❑ 33. Did the Reviewerllnspector fail to discuss reviewlinspection with on -site representative? ❑ ■ ❑ ❑ 34. Does the facility require a follow-up visit by same agency? 1 ■ ❑ ❑ ❑ Page: 4 Watauga County, NC Page 1 of 1 Summary Profile Owner Sales Resldenbal Commercial OBY Land Sketch Full Legal Agncuitural Map Para l Troe Values (:6rSinlf'.1119 PAR10:2808591066000 SR 1541 FLANNERY ROCK RD Parcel ParID Tax Year S1TUS Addess City, State, Zip Unit # Unit Description NBHD Class Land Use Code Living Units CAMA Acres Zoning Map # Jan 1 Values Land Value. Building Value Appraisal Total Exemptions or Exclusions Taxable Total Owner Mailing Tax Year Sequence Number Owner Number Owner Malting Address City, State, Zip Legal Description Township City Code ]unsdiction (Tax Code District) Unit Desc Unit # Book Page Legal Desc 1 Deeded Acres Sala Date Book 05-JUL-05 018 I CONTACTUS I HELP Watauga County Home 0 Property Records -..-.,_ ............................... Owner Address Parcel ID Advanced Map Search SHORE, J C 706 PLANNeRY FORK RD CURRENT RECORD N 4 34of81 �► N 2808591066000 Return to Search Results 2013 706 FLANNERY FORK RD REPORTS Property Record Card 0390 - DECK HILUPAYNE BRANCH RD AREA i .v.W...-�_...w. m, AG - AGRICULTURAL R01 - RESIDENTIAL 1 FAMILY 35.91 2808-59-1066.000 46,900 77,800 124,700 as 124,700 as 2013 0 1511030 SHORE, I C 706 FLANNERY FORK RD BLOWING ROCK NC 28605 03 - BLOWING ROCK F12 - BLOWING ROCK P01B 307 SR 1541 FLANNERY ROCK RD 35.91 Page Sale Pricy Grantor 307 Grantee Data Copyright Watauga County, NC [Privacy Polley) Last Updated: 05/23/2013 Site Design Copyright 1999-2009 Akanda Group LLC. All rights reserved. IQ Printable Summary Printable Version http://www.wataugacounty.org/ias/Datalets/Datalet.aspx?sIndex=8&idx=34 5/23/2013 [; jy, JL y a' 9 •' +\ i ,,�-'L 0."'r1 J ': ~ . '�j ._,. rr•" i�. Sa. a„k •J l'� ti' OFT ,^ y, ��a .a r,3,�i� �, , , A,��Q��c71"��'�//�, �.ti '� ,_�'S1 ¢ �s•1 i. 4+' r �'• ` � of � �'� �:��;+.t nr - ,,,'} .! i• } - ..-' 'r�' `tom- '�� ��� b J 4 1,},A `t • ^rr` 3.'t `" Y �} - i- s�y�. r,�,�' t•`C�a: � 1 `��k„'`;'.i!'•i�1`�, _ , +4 .�. ' .c .Y f �trt�r'5� ,1`t'1�^.+��,j14 �t i.. •�.r�1i•�`d+`'o ��, 1�; Y ! ( FM. -'4 �� 1 "•w. �`. �! �1 ;'r,'} r' ��,���y.;•+r. �f�'r: •`'',�"�'�. - k .Lv Avri'� + a k'�SM1_�}'�.� � �rr._ _may I �F �1�y1 �•*Y+•{f+v `� t�:�, '1-}H��g Yx -�# i.�•; �elS r` 'ti i f.V.:,F ,,�-I` ��?k' ti.•�+ '�'•.� 17.. �!+ 7 .i, ' + ,y!p1,, '� '�"'''��y"..r.•� ,�'�� � � •;' �7,¢• 1. f .1. � +� }C '►, r �I� ' '�, s` � - � r'� l+Q - ' k 9r �., t` � e h'"7'�� _ �.r �,�i p+r+ f ,� `•4"`�t�i� .�' �. ..��� • nil f�' rs't�]{�af' .t .- 4� • � rx a 'M� � ti' �+ 1` �t'� '�~ s � r• � , S •fir � r� h+� 5- 'i1y,,' �♦'�w� ,';�+ t,�. ' r/�"���.�� it ... '�ri�- ♦� �: � +r� w x� R. y-�^_a r 7 f�c .a T,r �L'x J-aiP��� � C. ,� ��i�r �tii s :. r � �_� '� ryc �•: w � `M• 1 � P,C.f �- �'4ltl,� ~ tj c, ! _ .�" � � - �'* ' •-ti, .� �at il � �'r v� � r .f � � �.�`k1x' J S•t tf t�I+y� �Not;� � 4 rr a q + s 7� •,I+;t '�� �� �r i `'Y' �' �#•Y i �,µ,f ;� � {^r �-35� �i p - -' tiny � w � �- � r� r. ,.� ���r �' l '��l'� i✓'ry .n+ rt l Y' �'4r, � fit . r "`+lr �. , r <F�l• ; '� x �. �'% y },!, " •,� � .rt rflr•. "5- M. plot a �• ��*'wwh.'�}. �.''S`.L trot: •s+.'. � rt;J,,. ` ^ t � 4•` ati,1 � _y ' `R� � +y p x ls.�� ay tY r ♦ a ,`, Fb } 'f0 d • t i rY ? r 11 u-f 1,If 'i4 AS 1, � ?�+ w� 'i•} �! r C�'�,? �.7�t . , \ i4 �*• L� � ; � � � �4^ iS�3G� .�y4 �y 3 ', Y'44 -•,1 ���''k:� . .f•' .;yx L L v tit; i� �� ' 1,�.Y 5i 1 , Y �h '� {ti •� Fti hi{ fie, N w (� ���Y. �, § `~..c�•� -.}'•� ey�'•,t{ .: a �� •'tia�'.�i � } �� "� -� ©`� �* �Y f� '�' �?}� �y �'1+.'� L: f t . _ r. �F•wh e n��� t"�i +c` ► : w < a1„1 Crsfwy nL ilE"71 y . , � G%.. � - � •,\,•. ,} �: y ,. � �;,:x- ,r a7� �'} t ��4-+,� rigs.. tir,�y� k � .•,KV„ ��. �r � . ?\t�., � �ti" �;.3,r.1 �{ Z ' * �j k rz. �y •k� h i { r�'i�� i � 1� 1 7 �y '�7 J� X ti 04, i,rr , ti' � w �, .� }. �� t� cs:h �� ,, .• � i t a'+ •.. y S � ,� �i.� .� 1r w , - :�1, T 7 t 7 C' 4 r. !' }�♦ per r i��`y 1• 1 +r`�._.. Y,.�tT.ti:•r.t L. :7.`4 �.y.�l�."�: �',.,5,'r�`�`�i..a�,.k�+. ,� :.s'._'_'.+w',��. ..�:��W.1�: S9Si'L Watauga County, NC Page 1 of I Summary Profile Owner Sales Residential Commercial OBY Land Sketch Fu€i Legal Agricultural Map Parr"nl Tree va€aa5 Comments PARID:2809918125000 FLAT TOP RD Parcel ParlD Tax Year SIfUS Addess City, State, Zip Unit # Unit Description NBHD Class Land Use Code Uving Unit$ CAMA Acres Zoning Map # Jan i Values Land Value. Building Value Appraisal Total Ce9Ona6= Exemptions or Exclusions Taxable Total Owner Mailing Tax Year Sequence Number Owner Number Owner Mailing Address City, State, Zip Legal Description Township City Code Jurlsdlctlon (Tax Code District) Unit Desc Unit # Book Page Legal Desc 1 Deeded Acres Sale Date Book 15-NOV-04 1026 Property Records Owner Address Parcel ID Advanced Map Search SHORE, ZELMA VERLEE .ZELMA VERLEE SHORE REVOCABLE LIVING TRU 2291 PAYNE BRANCH RD 2809918125000 2013 2291 PAYNE BRANCH RD 11 0390 - DECK HILL/PAYNE BRANCH RD AREA AG - AGRICULTURAL RO1 - RESIDENTIAL 1 FAMILY 46.35 2809-91-8125-000 289,500 94,500 384,000a m m ...... 384,000 2013 0 1603919 SHORE, ZELMA VERLEE .ZELMA VERLEE SHORE REVOCABLE LIVING TRU 2269 PAYNE BRANCH RD BLOWING ROCK NC 28605 03 - BLOWING ROCK F02 - BOONE FIRE SERVICE DISTRICT 1026 266 FLAT TOP RD 46.35 Page Sale Price Grantor 266 0 Grantee Data Copyright Watauga County, NC [Privacy Policy] Last Updated: 05/23/2013 7 Site Design Copyright IM-2009 Aldsnda Group LLC. All rights reserved. I CONTACTUS I HELP Watauga County Home CURRENT RECORD lafI I Return to Search Results REPORTS Property Record Card I Printable Summary Printable Version http://www.wataugacounty.org/ias/Datalets/Datalet.aspx?slndex=9&idx=1 5/23/2013 Incident/Complaint Investigation Sheet r re- A�b` 950007 --------------------------- Project Description/Name: I,L-15r11ti1 . Time of Arrival: 0- Date: S- Z2_ z 01 3 On -site Person(s) and contact info: Weather Conditions/Air Temperature: � Details (conversations, descriptions, surface waters, eta): �'�o- �ti �y� �4 (fJ Z_L:. �S�t'S its GCr/p%c 71 4 lU, 33yW 31Uyp,'y19,.�> Lp�dry, •`� p a - { 1 I- __�l � n 9.., 1 jJ_ 54,,ck- ;I,, ;.5 ti 2.d _LL S 3b 7-3 4, IJ, ILA Krjia 92F -zG - 2404 28- - GY4, 6e4 Csird- f'n 4)("1 4. l �_ Ake._ ❑ Check if -Additional information is recorded on reverse ofpage. Sample Information Sample Site Description/Name & # DO m /L % DO Saturation Conductivity S/m Temperature o pH Other(s) GPS: Collection Time Additional Comments (stream bottom, odors, clarity, organisms, algae, fungal, sediment depth, etc.,.) Collector Names Sample Site Description/Name & # DO m /L % DO Saturation Conductivity S/m Temperature pH Other(s) GPS: Collection Time Additional Comments (stream bottom, odors, clarity, organisms, algae, fungal, sediment depth, etc...) Collector Names : Sample Site Description/Name & # DO m /L % DO Saturation Conductivity S/m Temperature pH Other(s) GPS: Collection Time Additional Comments (stream bottom, odors, clarity, organisms, algae, fungal, sediment depth, etc...) Collector Names : Time of Departure: ji � � r\ M Additional DPtailc• —7dG c.. F -4,- K,1 ._t_ -27LOS, Additional Samples Information Sample Site Description/Name & # DO m /L % DO Saturation Conductivity S/m Temperature pH Other(s) GPS: Collection Time Additional Comments (stream bottom, odors, clarity, organisms, algae, fungal, sediment depth, etc...) Collector Names : Sample Site Description/Name & # DO m /L % DO Saturation Conductivity S/m Temperature pH Other(s) GPS: Collection Time Additional Comments (stream bottom, odors, clarity, organisms, algae, fungal, sediment depth, etc...) Collector Names : Sample Site Description/Name & # DO m /L % DO Saturation Conductivity S/m Temperature pH Other(s) GPS: Collection Time Additional Comments (stream bottom, odors, clarity, organisms, algae, fungal, sediment depth, etc...) Collector Names : Time of Departure: A TA NIV Irk V_ r : • - . in 1i •�RT M�"y t'l� f .y. ±+.L' . {.� •fir �ff�i4� �}, !-sl � '1.'J ..fir 4 w. .. �•� tom. ]!- r PHONE LOG ❑ Call Received AMessage Received ❑ Call Returned ❑ CalI Made El Left Message Call Purpose Xcomplaint ❑ Inspection ❑ Non-compliance Reporting ❑ Info Request Caller Information Name of Caller/Facility: *XQA I ek 6 ks Telephone Number(s): Nk Remain Anonymous? OWS ❑ No ❑ NA Mailing Address: NA Date & Time Received:. S!) 71 z-o r 3 ® B 1 519 am Subject Information County: Wa�o� Facility &/or Responsible Person(s):. Telephone Number(s): Mailing Address: Wescription (directions, address/location, source of pollution, nature of incident, surface water body &/or wells ' impacted, amount spilled, when did it start/fmish, etc.):—D J kola a!! l,,_ "rile- a P-14, (Additional information can be recorded an reverse if needed) Referred by: Ad,V-, . Z DWO Information Action Taken or Referred to: Received by: P. Mitchell PHONE LOG ❑ Call Received ❑ Message Received ❑ Call Returned ❑ Call Made ❑ Left Message Call PuMose ❑ Complaint ❑ Inspection ❑ Non-compliance Reporting ❑ Info Request Caller Information Name of Caller/Facility- Telephone Number(s): Remain Anonymous? ❑ Yes ❑ No ❑ NA Mailing Address: Date & Time Received: Subject Information County: ..__ Facility &/or Responsible Person(s): Telephone Number(s); Mailing Address: , Description (directions, address/location, source of pollution, nature of incident, surface water body &/or wells *-i impacted, amount spilled, when did it start/finish, etc.): (Additional information can be recorded on reverse ifneeded) Referred by: DWQ Information Action Taken or Referred to: Received by: P. Mitchell