310563_HISTORICAL_20171231

NUH I H LAHULINA
Department of Environmental Qual

Wa ter Resour ces
Ei`tviRONMENTAL QUAUTY
TGB Farms, LLC
Legacy 2 Farm
153 South Horsepen Road
Harrells, NC 28444
Dear TGB Farms, LLC:
PAT MCCRORY
R y"ftNk1r ,DER VAART
�ecrsfor•
S. JAY ZIMMERMAN
AUG 2 9 2016
August 26, 2016 rfrs_lnr
Water Quality Regional
Wit Operations Section
milRegional Office
Subject: Certificate of Coverage No. AWS310563
Legacy 2 Farm
Swine Waste Collection, Treatment,
Storage and Application System
Duplin County
In accordance with your Notification of Change of Ownership received August 19, 2016, we are hereby
forwarding to you this Certificate of Coverage (COC) issued to TGB Farms, LLC, authorizing the operation
of the subject animal waste management system in accordance with General Permit AWG100000.
This approval shall consist of the operation of this system including, but not limited to, the management
and land application of animal waste as specified in the facility's Certified Animal Waste Management Plan
(CAWMP) for Legacy 2 Farm, located in Duplin County, with a swine animal capacity of no greater than
the following annual averages:
Wean to Finish: Feeder to Finish: Boar/Stud:
Wean to Feeder: Farrow to Wean: 2,035 Gilts:
Farrow to Finish: Farrow to Feeder: Other:
If this is a Farrow to Wean or Farrow to Feeder operation, there may be one boar for each 15 sows. Where
boars are unnecessary, they may be replaced by an equivalent number of sows. Any of the sows may be
replaced by gilts at a rate of 4 gilts for every 3 sows.
This COC shall be effective from the date of issuance until September 30, 2019, and shall hereby void
Certificate of Coverage Number AWS310563 dated October 1, 2014. Pursuant to this COC, you are
authorized and required to operate the system in conformity with the conditions and limitations as specified
in the General Permit, the facility's CAWMP, and this COC. An adequate system for collecting and
maintaining the required monitoring data and operational information must be established for this facility.
Any increase in waste production greater than the certified design capacity or increase in number of animals
authorized by this COC (as provided above) will require a modification to the CAWMP and this COC and
must be completed prior to actual increase in either wastewater flow or number of animals.
Please read this COC and the enclosed State General Permit carefully. Please pn careful attention to the
record keeping and monitoring conditions in this permit. Record keeping forms are unchanged with this
General Permit. Please continue to use the same record keeping forms.
If your Waste Utilization Plan (WUP) has been developed based on site -specific information, careful
evaluation of future samples is necessary. Should your records show that the current WUP is inaccurate
you will need to have a new WUP developed.
State of North Carolina I Environmental Quality I Water Resources
1636 Mail service Center I Raleigh, North Carolina 27699-1636
919 807 6464

The issuance. ofthis COC does not excuse the Permittee from the obligation to comply with all applicable
laws, rules, standards, and ordinances (local, state, and federal), nor does issuance of a COC to operate
under this permit convey any,property rights in either real or personal property.
Per NRCS standards a 100-foot separation shall be maintained between water supply wells and any lagoon,
storage pond, or any wetted area of a spray field.
Please be advised that any violation of the terms and conditions specified in this COC, the General Permit
or the CAWMP may result in the revocation of this COC, or penalties in accordance with NCGS 143-
215.6A through 143-215.6C including civil penalties, criminal penalties, and injunctive relief.
If-any-parts,—requirements,—or-limitations-contained-in-this-COC-are-unacceptabler you -have -the -right -to
apply for an individual permit by contacting the Animal Feeding Operations Program for information on
this process. Unless such a request is made within 30 days, this COC shall be final and binding.
In accordance with Condition II.22 of the General Permit, waste application shall cease within four (4)
hours of the time that the National Weather Service issues a Hurricane Warning, Tropical Storm Warning,
or a Flood Watch associated with a tropical system for the county in which the facility is located. You may
find detailed watch/warning information for your county by calling the Newport/Morehead City, NC
National Weather Service office at [phone], or by visiting their website at:
http://www.weather.gov/mhx/
This facility is located in a county covered by our Wilmington Regional Office. The Regional Office staff
may be reached at 910-796-7215. If you need additional information concerning this COC or the General
Permit, please contact the Animal Feeding Operations Program staff at [phone].
• Sincerely,
L&,2' low
for S. Jay Zimmerman, P.G.
Director, Division of Water Resources
Enclosure (General Permit AWG 100000)
cc. (Certificate of Coverage only for all ccs)
Wilmington Regional Office, Water Qudlity Regional Operations Section
Duplin County Health Department
Duplin County Soil and Water Conservation District
WQROS Central Files (Permit No. AWS310563)
Smithfield Hog Production

A�
NCDENR
North Carolina Department of Environment and Natural Resources
Pat McCrory Donald R. van der Vaart
Governor Secretary
January 22, 2015
CERTIFIED MAIL 7010 0290 0003 0833 9687
RETURN RECEIPT REQUESTED
Kraig Westerbeek, Vice President
Murphy -Brown LLC
PO Box 856
Warsaw NC 28398-0856
Subject: NOTICE OF VIOLATION & INTENT TO ISSUE CIVIL PENALTY
NOV Tracking Number: NOV-2014-DV-0228
Incident No. 201401619
Permit No. AWS310563
Batchelor Sow Farm
Duplin County
Dear Mr Westerbeek:
A review has been conducted of the self reported animal wastewater spill incidentthat occurred atthe subject facility
on September 19, 2014 and documentation submitted to our office following the incident. The Division's Wilmington
Regional Office concludes that the Murphy -Brown LLC committed the following violations associated with the subject
incident:
1. Permit Condition 1 (1) by failing to effectively manage, maintain, and operate their wastewater system so
that there is no discharge to wetlands or surface waters; subject incident constituted making an outlet to
waters of the State for purposes of G.S. 143-215.1(a)(1) for which a permit is required by G.S. 143-215.1.
2. Permit Condition 111 (15) per G.S. 143-215.1(C) by failing to properly issue a press release within 48 hours a
discharge of at least 1,000 gallons to wetlands or surface waters of the State.
3. Permit Condition 111(16) per G.S. 143-215.1(C) by failing to properly publish a public notice for a discharge of
at least 15,000 gallons to wetlands or surface waters of the State and provide proof of publication to the
Division within 30 days after publication.
4. Permit Condition 111(9) (f) by failing to sample within 72 hours and/or provide sample results for the listed
parameters to the Division within 30 days.
The Wilmington Regional Office is providing the Murphy -Brown LLC an opportunity to provide evidence and
It justification as to why the Murphy -Brown LLC should not be assessed a civil penalty for the violations that are
summarized above.
127 Cardinal Drive Extension, Wilmington, North Carolina 28405
Phone: [phone]\ Internet: www.ncdenr.gov
An Equal Opportunity \ Affirmative Action Employer —Made in part by recycled paper

N OV-2014-DV-028 «CAS E_N UM B E R»
January 22, 2015
Page 2 of 2
Please submit a written response and any additional documentation about this incident within 10 business _days
following receipt of this violation. The submittal will be reviewed to determine if a civil penalty assessment by the
Division's Regional Office is warranted.
If you should have any questions, please do not hesitate to contact me or Dean Hunkele with the Water Quality
Section at [phone] or via email at [e-mail].
Sincerely, r
For Zs. rayZimmerman, Acting Director
Division of Water Resources, NCDENR
by James H. Gregson
Regional Supervisor
Water Quality Regional Operations Section
Wilmington Regional Office
Division of Water Resources, NCDENR
Cc: WIRO — WQS File (Hunkele)
Central Files, Water Quality Section

Permit Number AWG100000
Fecal coliform bacteria Five-day biochemical oxygen demand (BOD5)
j Total suspended solids -�LG Total phosphorous
2 u Ammonia nitrogen (NH3N) Lf; Total Kjeldahl nitrogen (TKN)
Nitrate nitrogen (NO3-N)
Monitoring results must be submitted to the Division within thirty (30) days of the
discharge event.
10. In accordance with l SA NCAC 02T .0108(c), the Division may require any monitoring and
reporting (including but not limited to groundwater, surface water or wetland, waste, sludge, soil,
lagoon/storage pond levels and plant tissue) necessary to determine the source, quantity, quality,
and effect of animal waste upon the surface waters, groundwaters or wetlands. Such monitoring,
including its scope, frequency, duration and any sampling, testing, and reporting systems, shall
meet all applicable Division requirements.
11. A copy of this General Permit, the facility's COC, certification forms, lessee and landowner
agreements, the CAWMP and copies of all records required by this General Permit and the
facility's CAWMP shall be maintained by the Permittee in chronological and legible form for
three (3) years. Records include but are not limited to: soil and waste analyses, rain gauge
readings, freeboard levels, irrigation and land application event(s), past inspection reports and
operational reviews, animal stocking records, records of additional nutrient sources applied
(including but not limited to sludges, unused feedstuff leachate, milk waste, septage and
commercial fertilizer), cropping information, waste application equipment testing and calibration,
and records of removal of solids to off -site location(s). These records shall be maintained on
forms provided or approved by the Division and shall be readily available at the facility (stored at
places such as the farm residence, office, outbuildings, etc.) where animal waste management
activities are being conducted.
12. Within fifteen (IS) working days of receiving the request from the Division, the Permittee shall
provide to the Division one (1) copy of all requested information and reports related to the
operation of the animal waste management system. Once received by the Division, all such
information and reports become public information, unless they constitute confidential
information under G.S. § 132-1.2, and shall be made available to the public by the Division as
specified in Chapter 132 of the General Statutes.
13. Regional Notification:
The Permittee shall report by telephone to the appropriate Division Regional Office as soon as
possible, but in no case more than twenty-four (24) hours following first knowledge of the
occurrence of any of the following events:
a. Failure of any component.of the animal waste management system resulting in a discharge
to ditches, surface waters, or wetlands.
b. Any failure of the waste treatment and disposal system that renders the facility incapable of
adequately receiving, treating, or storing the waste and/or sludge.
C. A spill or discharge from a vehicle transporting waste or sludge to the land application field
which results in a discharge to ditches, surface waters, or wetlands or an event that poses a
serious threat to surface waters, wetlands, or human health and safety.
d. Any deterioration or Ieak in a lagoon/storage pond that poses an immediate threat to the
environment or human safety or health.
March 7, 2014

Permit Number AWG100000
4. A representative Standard Soil Fertility Analysis, including pH, phosphorus, copper, and zinc,
shall be conducted on each application field receiving animal waste in accordance with G.S. §
-143=215.10C(e)(6). As of the effective date of this General Permit, the Statute requires that the
analysis be conducted at least once every three years.
An analysis of a representative sample of the animal waste to be applied shall be conducted in
accordance with recommended laboratory sampling procedures as close to the time of application
as practical and at least within sixty (60) days (before or after) of the date of application. Every
reasonable effort shall be made to have the waste analyzed prior to the date of application and as
close to the time of waste application as possible. This analysis shall include the following
parameters:
Nitrogen Zinc
Phosphorus Copper
The Permittee shall record all irrigation and land application event(s) including hydraulic loading
rates, nutrient loading rates and cropping information. The Permittee shall also record removal of
solids and document nutrient loading rates if disposed of on -site, or record the off -site location(s).
These records must be on forms supplied by, or approved by, the Division.
7. A record shall be created and maintained of all transfers of waste between waste structures on the
same site not typically operated in series. Such record shall include at least the identity of the
structure from which the waste was transferred, the identity of the structure receiving the waste,
the date and time of transfer and the total volume of waste transferred.
$. The Permittee must maintain monthly stocking records for the facility and make the records
available to the Department.
9. If, for any reason, there is a discharge from the waste collection, treatment, storage and
application systems (including the land application sites), to surface waters or wetlands, the
Permittee is required to make notification in accordance with Condition III. 13. The discharge
notification shall include the following information:
a. Description of the discharge: A description of the discharge including an estimate of the
volume discharged, a description of the flow path to the receiving surface waters or
wetlands and a site sketch showing the path of the waste:
b. Time of the discharge: The length of time of the discharge, including the exact dates and
times that it started and stopped, and if not stopped, the anticipated time the discharge is
expected to continue.
C. Cause of the discharge: A detailed statement of the cause of the discharge. If caused by a
precipitation event, detailed information from the on -site rain gauge concerning the inches
and duration of the precipitation event.
d. All steps being taken to reduce, stop and cleanup the discharge. All steps to be taken to
prevent future discharges from the same cause.
e. Analysis of the waste: A copy of the last waste analysis conducted as required by Condition
III. 5. above.
f. A waste sample, obtained within seventy-two (72) hours following first knowledge of the
discharge to surface waters or wetlands, from the source lagoontstorage pond, shall be
analyzed for the following minimum parameters:
March 7, 2014

U.S. Postal Service,,.,
CERTIFIED MAIL,,,
RECEIPT
(Domestic Mail Only;
No Insurance
Coverage Provided)
'
For delivery information
OFFICIAL
visit our website
at www.usps.com❑
USE
r
r
_
--
r
r
11 Jill
PS Form 3800. August 2006
See Reverse tar h,structions
■ Complete items 1, 2, and 3. Also complete
item 4 if Restricted Delhrery Is desired.
■ Print your name and address on the reverse
so that we can return the card to you.
■ Attach this card to the back of the maifpiece,
or on the front If space permits.
1. ArtI 1,4ddressed to:
wU✓rwI
n � r
A. Sigltaybre
X ❑ Agent
❑ Addressee
B. agceivyd by(Prrnfe ame)
D. Is deliveryff
address different from item 17 ❑ Yes
If YES, enter delivery address below ❑ No
X 3. Service Type
Certifled Mall- ❑ Priority Mall Express"'
xw G / o Registered ❑ Return Receipt for Merchandise
❑Insured Mail ❑ Collect on Delivery
c� 4. Restricted Delivery? (Extra Fee) ❑ Yes
2. Article Number
{lmnsmr frvm semc,e mtieq 7 010 112 9 0 - 0 0 0 3. 68133 19 6 8 7
PS Form 3811, July 2013 Domestic Return Receipt

Murphy -Brown LLc PO Drawer 856
2822 Hwy. 24 West
Warsaw, NC 28398
Tel: [phone]
Pax:910-293-6957
January 29, 2015
S. Jay Zimmerman
Acting Director �•
Division of Water Resources, NCDENR U If
127 Cardinal Drive Extension FEB
Wilmington, NC 28405
BY:u)r.wi to
Dear Mr. Zimmerman,
In response to the Notice of Violation issued to the Batchelor Farm, Permit No. AWS310563, in
Duplin County on January 22, 2015, and your request for further information, please consider the
following as you determine civil penalty assessments in this matter.
Murphy -Brown LLC regrets the violation that occurred on September 19, 2014 and has done
everything in its power to both immediately mitigate the impact of the discharge on downstream
waters, and to put into place additional safeguards to prevent a similar situation from re -occurring
in the future. Specific to each alleged violation, please see our response to each below:
1. Permit Condition I ( 1) - Failure to effectively manage, maintain, and operate the
wastewater system to prevent discharge.
Murphy -Brown LLC does not dispute any of the facts with regards to the occurrence of
the discharge, as demonstrated by the self -reporting of the event to Regional Staff as
required by permit. A complete description of the event that occurred and actions taken
was submitted to the Division by Mr. Michael Norris in a letter dated September 23,
2014. I have attached this letter for your further review. In addition to this letter,
Murphy -Brown LLC submitted additional information with regards to the volume of the
spill on October 2, 2014 to Mr. Dean Hunkele prepared by Mr. Dave Elkin, P.E. In these
communications, Murphy -Brown LLC provided its confident opinion that the spill
volume was less than 15,000 gallons leaving the property based on engineering
calculations, freeboard level change, and general site observations made during the
remediation efforts. Despite this, Murphy -Brown LLC determined the best course of
action to be to complete the notification process as requested by Mr. Hunkele and the
Division. The fact of the matter was that the spill occurred and we wanted to focus our
efforts on complete remediation and preventing any potential environmental impacts
downstream versus being argumentative on volumes. I think it is important to note for
the record that we were very pleased with our remediation efforts. Due to the quick

response of our environmental staff, we were able to contain the spill at the headwaters of
an adjacent pond and isolate it from impacting the pond itself. Once isolated, we
contacted our neighbors and worked closely with them to gain their consent to begin
recovery. Environmental staff spent over 140 man hours recovering not only the
discharged volume, but the entire volume of water contained in this headwater area. The
cost of these efforts was not the most important factor when compared to the effect of
protecting downstream waters, but we conservatively estimate the cost of our remediation
efforts at $9,816. We feel very confident that we were able to recover all of the
discharged material and land apply it to surrounding crop land.
2. Permit Condition III (15) — Failure to properly issue a press release within 48 hours of a
discharge of at least 1000 gallons
Murphy -Brown LLC issued the attached press release on Monday, September 22, 2014
by FAX transmittal to the only print media outlet providing general coverage in Duplin
County, the Duplin Times, and WEGG radio, the only electronic news media outlet in
Duplin County. The FAX notice was received by the Duplin Times, but repeated
attempts to send it to the radio station failed. Copies of the FAX notices are available for
Your review if necessary. In this case, the 48 hour notice period ended on Sunday and,
therefore, our Monday press release was beyond the 48 hour time period.
3. Permit Condition III (16) —Failure to properly publish a public notice for a discharge of
at least 15,000 gallons and provide proof of publication within 30 days after publication.
On Friday, October 3, 2014, Murphy -Brown purchased a paid advertisement for
publication in the Duplin Times. This was within 10 days of being advised by Mr. Dean
Hunkele by email on September 30, 2014 at 1:25pm that Duplin County was the only
required county for publication. I have attached a copy of the paid advertisement that ran
in the Duplin Times. With regards to providing proof of publication, email and verbal
communication with the Division left us with the impression that the Division was aware
of our Public Notice. No formal written proof was communicated by Murphy -Brown to
the Division. We apologize for this administrative error but have copies of both the
Public Notice and Press Release in our farm files for review as necessary.
4. Permit Condition 111(9) (f) — Failure to sample within 72 hours and/or provide sample
results for the listed parameters to the Division within 30 days.
Murphy -Brown LLC did not sample the lagoon as stipulated in the permit for this event.
I have attached sample results for samples taken on September 19, 2014 in the ditch near
the point of discharge that were used to calculate Nitrogen loading for land application
occurring during remediation efforts, and of both lagoons on the Batchelor Farm taken on
September 18, 2014. These are NCDA samples and do not contain all of the required
parameters found in the permit. Fortunately, it has been some time since we had a spill
occur on a Murphy -Brown farm. Unfortunately, this led to an oversight in not testing for
all parameters as required.
In terms of overall follow up this event, Murphy -Brown LLC used this event and the lessons
learned to not only make modifications to our management system at this farm, but all others in
our system as well. The Batchelor Farm had secondary containment constructed several years

ago that was engineered to capture any discharge that would occur as a result of a recycle system
failure like the one that occurred on September 19'. The secondary containments on this and all
other farms are managed daily by the farm managers to provide protection against discharges. In
this particular case, road grading activities had changed the direction of water flow away from
this most northern cleanout from the designed flow path, and away from the containment area.
This situation was remedied on the Batchelor Farm on September 22, 2014. In addition, an
Objective and Target was created in the Murphy -Brown LLC Environmental Management
System to evaluate all farms for possible by-passing of secondary containments. This process is
ongoing but has been completed throughout much of our system. in addition, all environmental
employees have been re-trained on discharge sampling procedures to insure that we collect the
proper samples should this occur in the future.
Murphy -Brown LLC appreciates the opportunity to provide additional information to the
Division on this matter. This was an unfortunate incident, but we feel we have done everything
in our power to mitigate any potential impact to downstream waters from this particular event,
and have used the lessons learned to improve our entire operation. We appreciate the help your
staff has provided in this effort.
If there are further questions or concerns, please feel free to contact me at [phone] or by
email at kraigwesterbeek(cr�,murphybrownllc.com.
Westerbeek
nvironment and Engineering

PO BOX 56
Mu h v BrowJ.J... WarsawBNC 28398
Murphy Brown East
September 23, 2014
Mr. Kevin Rowland
NCDENR — Division of Water Resources
127 Cardinal Drive Extension
Wilmington NC 28405
RE: Batchelor Farm
Facility # 31-563
Accidental Discharge 9/19/14
Dear Mr. Rowland,
This letter is the follow up to an accidental discharge on the Batchelor farm reported to Dean
Hunkley with DWR on September 19th. The sequence of events on Friday 9119/14 is:
1) The farm personnel found a discharge from the recycle system upon arrival to work on the
morning of September 19th. The farm staff shut down the recycle system and notified the
LNM technician to respond to the accidental discharge. The combined group effort
focused on total containment of the flow and notification of management
2) The complex manager notified the LNM specialist and LNM Director of the spill. The
remediation efforts were immediately inflated, which included bringing in heavy equipment
to effectively contain and recover the effluent
3) After inspecting the site to ensure that all effluent was contained and that the cleanup
procedures were in place, I contacted Dean Hunkley with DWR to report the spill.
4) Remediation included pumping the effluent onto the neighbor's crop fields and Murphy
Brown's coastal fields. Cleanup carried on throughout Friday, Saturday and was
completed Sunday afternoon. Containment dams in the ditch were left in place until
recovery efforts were completed and the pond dams were not removed until Tuesday
afternoon 9/23/14.
5) The spill was contained in a secondary intermittent ditch and a small pond that is fed by
Dario Branch.
6) Our LNM crew brought in trash pumps, tankers, and an Aerway system to aid in the
recovery efforts. We invested over 140 man hours in efforts to recover the effluent that hit
the ground. Our team applied more than 704,000 gallons through Aerway application,
24,000 with a tanker, and 102,000 with trash pumps at a cost of $9,816.
7) Root Cause: A previously repaired joint in the recycle line gave way because the wrong
process was used to make the repair causing it to come apart The effluent flowed down
the farm path and into a drain pipe that dumped into the road side ditch.

• Page 2
Estimate of the discharge:
January 29, 2015
1) In our estimation less than 15,000 gallons of effluent was spilled from the site.
The plan to correct the problems identified from this accidental discharge are to:
1) Correct repair of the recycle line_
2) Ensure there are no other pipe joints at the site that are not correct
3) Build up a berm along the area where the spill occurred to direct any effluent from a spill
to the secondary containments at the site.
a. The corrective actions above have all been completed at this time. See attached
pictures for actions 1 and 3
Included with this letter is a copy of the most current waste analysis as required by the pen -nit.
I have outlined what information I have available as they relate to this accidental discharge. I feel that
Murphy -Brown LLC has responded in an appropriate and responsible manner to the conditions of the
permit
The Environmental Management System (EMS) proved its' effectiveness by providing the structure and
protocol that all parties involved in the response, did so in a timely and effective manner.
If I can be of any further assistance, please feel free to contact me.
Sincerely,
Michael Norris
Environmental Resource Specialist
Murphy -Brown LLC
[phone]

NOTICE OF DISCHARGE OF UNTREATED WASTE
The Batchelor Sow Farm, located at 237 Batchelor Lane,
Kenansville, NC and owned by Murphy -Brown LLC, had a
discharge less than 20,000 gallons of untreated wastewa-
ter originating from a failed recycle line on the farm. The
discharge occurred on September 19, 2014 and was dis-
covered at approximately 7:15am.
The wastewater entered an unnamed tributary of Dark
Branch. Containment and remediation efforts began im-
mediately and the incident was reported to NCDENR. The
spilled wastewater was completely contained on the adja-
cent property and land applied to surrounding crop land.
In addition, the failed recycle line was repaired to prevent
further discharges.
This notice was required by !North Carolina General Stat-
utes Article 21 Chapter 143.215.C. For more information,
please contact Don Butler at [phone].

NCDA&CS Agronomic Division Phone: [phone] Website: www.ncagr.gov/agronomi/
FY15-WO01871
i'�.w..�.r4�'
g ffr
Predictive
Murphy Brown LLC
Client: Mu h
clo Michael Norris
Advisor
r:
i i
k' _
nn
Waste Report
N
Warsaw. NC 28398
,
Duplin County
Sampled: 09/19/2014 Received: 09125/2014
completed: 10103/2014
Farm: Batchelor
Links to Helpful Information
Sample Information
Nutrient and Other Measurements
Nitrogen (N) (ppm) P (ppm)
K (ppm) Ca (ppm) Mq (ppm)
S (ppm) Fe (ppm) Mn (ppm)
Zn (ppm) Cu (ppm) B (ppm) Na (ppm) C (ppm)
Sample ID: BAT01
Total N 0.52
14.1 10.8 3.26
4.93 2.04 0.01
7.60 0.10 0.03 12.2
Waste Code: ALF
Description:
Total Kjeldahl N 14.1 -
Farrow to Ween
pH
DM (%) SS (10-55/cm)
EC (mS/cm)
CCE (V) ALE(1000 gal.) C:N
Lagoon Liq-
Inorganic N
Comments:
NH4-N &30NO3-N
Organic N ; Ni (ppm)
Cd (ppm) Pb (ppm) Al (ppm)
So (ppm) Li (ppm) As
(ppm) Cr (ppm) Co (ppm) Cl (ppm) Mo (ppm)
Urea
Estimate of Nutrients Available for First Crop (lb 11000 gal.)
Other Elements (lb 11000 gal.)
Application Method
N P205 K20 Ca Mg
S Fe Mn Zn
CU B Mo
Cl Na Ni Cd Pb Al Se Li
Irrigation
0.06 0.01 0.14 0.09 0.03
0.04 0.02 T 0.06
T T ;
0.10
Agronomist's Comments:
Aaron Pettit 10/2/2014 8:44 AM
�Gh ncPe- po:-Jf of c��5C-k 9 [�n 19 ItW
North Carolina Reprogramming of the laboratory -information -management system that makes this report possible is being funded
through a grant from the North Carolina Tobacco Trust Fund Commission.
k'y1
Thank you for using agronomic services to manage nutrients and safeguard environmental quality.
It'll.1 Oi0 ifI,+r I f,,;:ISteve Trader, Commissioner of Agriculture.

NCDABCS Agronomic Division Phone: [phone] Website: www.neagr.govlagrenomil
FY15-W001612
+~ Predictive
Client: Murphy Brown LLC
Advisor,-
'� ' , • :`=
cio Michael Norris
PO Box 856
Waste R sport
Warsaw, NC 28396
Duplin County
Sampled: 09/18/2014 Received: 09/18/2014
completed: 09/25/2014
Farm: Batchelor
Links to Helpful Information
Sample Information
Nutrient and Other Measurements
Nitrogen (N) (ppm) P (ppm)
K (ppm) Ca (ppm) Miq (ppm)
S (ppm) Fe (ppm) Mn (ppm)
Z11 (ppm) Cu (ppm) B (ppm) Na (ppm) C (ppm)
Sample ID: 2016A
Waste Code: ALS
Total N 54.4
290 48.2 66.2
35.7 0.73 0.08
0.27 0.14 0.34 125
Description:
Total Kjeldahl N 185
Swine Lagoon Liq..
Inorganic N pH
DM (%) SS (10-5S/cm)
EC (mS/cm)
CCE (YO) ALE(1000 gal.) C:N
Comments:
NH4-N 7,35
NO3-N
21
JUL 2 7�
rganic N Ni (ppm)
Urea
Cd (ppm) Pb (ppm) Al (ppm)
Se (ppm) Li (ppm) As (ppm) Cr 1ppm) Co (ppm) Cl (ppm) Mo (ppm)
Estimate of Nutrients Available for First Crop (lb 11000 gal.)
Other Elements (lb 11000 gal.)
Application Method
N P205 K20 Ca Mg
S Fe Mn Zn
Cu B Mo
CI Na Ni Cd Pb Al Se Li
Irrigation
0.77 1.04 2.90 0.40 0.55
0.30 0.01 T T
T T
1.04
Agronomist's Comments:
Aaron Pettit 924/2014 3:40 PM
L o, 3 0o r- P\
Norlli Carolina
F,�h.n.et� 3unt,Eta+ilCr.7hla.•:,n•is
Reprogramming of the laboratory -information -management system that makes this report possible is being funded
through a grant from the North Carolina Tobacco Trust Fund Commission.
171rn1k parr f 1r r(si ig agrorronlie ,se rric•cs to ntrrneige nrarienls rind sirligucir d enviroinnenud gnalilp.
- Slere •1'rnxler. 0011111li sione). oJ': tla irrr!lrrrc.

NCDA&CS Agronomic Division Phone: [phone] Website: www.ncagr.gov/agronomi/ FY15-W001612
Pag:e2 0f 2
Sample Information
Nutrient and Other Measurements
Nitrogen (N) (ppm) P (ppm) K (ppm) Ca (ppm) Mq (ppm) S (ppm) Fe (ppm) Mn (ppm) Zn (ppm) Cu (ppm) B (ppm) Na (ppm) C (ppm)
Sample ID: 2016b
Total N 57.1 296 61.6 72.1 40.6 1.11 0.11 0.55 0.13 0.37 129
Waste Code: ALS
Description:
Total Kjeldehl N 252
Swine Lagoon Liq.
Inorganic N pH DM (%b) SS (10-531cm) EC (mS1cm) CCE (%) ALE (1000 gal.) C:N
Comments:
NH4-N 7.38
NO3-N
JUL 21 2014
Organic N Ni (ppm) Cd (ppm) Pb (ppm) At (ppm) Se (ppm) Li (ppm) As (ppm) Cr (ppm) Co (ppm) CI (ppm) Mo (ppm)
Urea
Estimate of Nutrients Available for First Crop (lb l 1000 gal.) Other Elements (Ib 1 1000 gal.)
Application Method
N P205 K20 Ca Mg S Fe Mn Zn Cu 8 Mo CI Na Ni Cd Pb At Se Li
Irrigation
1.05 1.09 2.96 0,51 0.60 0.34 0.01 T T T T 1.07
Understanding the Waste Report 4 -additional information: www.ncaar.aovloaronomi(odffilesluwaste.odf 8 www.n a r. ovla rono it ffii slwaste uid df
Nutrient concentrations and other data on this report are provided so that waste materials can be applied at agronomic fates, thereby supplementing or reducing fertilizer application and
preventing environmental contamination. In reading the laboratory Results section, remember that materials with < 15% dry matter (generally liquids) are analyzed as received; all
other wastes are dried first. Values in the Estimate of Nutrients Available for First Crop section are based on the type of waste and method of application you specify and reflect the
fact that only 40-60% of the nitrogen and 70-100% of other nuirients become available within one year of application. The remainder may oar m-a-p not ever become available.
' ppm = parts per million; S = siemens; m5 = millisiemens; T = trace (<0.005 lblunit); EC = electrical conductivity; CCE = calcium carbonate equivalence; ALE = agricultural lime
equivalence; pH = acidity or basicity; DM% _ % dry matter (for semi -solid and solid waste samples, this value facilitates conversion of dry -basis concentrations (ppm) back to wet -basis
of original sample]; C;N ratio = carbon'. nitrogen ratio.
bc�_( l'J o e, - Lc- q C> C=. ►-1 1B
J

MurphrBrown.
Murphy Brown East
September 24, 2014
Morella Sanchez -King
NCDENR — Division of Water Resources
127 Cardinal Drive Extension
Wilmington NC 28405
RE: Batchelor Farm
Facility # 31-563
Accidental Discharge 9/19/14
PO Box 856
Warsaw, NC 28398
ECIVE
SEP 2 5 20%
BY.
Dear Mr. Rowland,
This letter is the follow up to an accidental discharge on the Batchelor farm reported to Dean
Hunkley with DWR on September 19th. The sequence of events on Friday 9/19/14 was:
1) The farm personnel found a discharge from the recycle system upon arrival to work on the
morning of September 19th. The famti staff shut down the recycle system and notified the
LNM technician to respond to the accidental discharge. The combined group effort
focused on total containment of the flow and notification of management.
2) The complex manager notified the LNM specialist and LNM Director of the spill. The
remediation efforts were immediately initiated, which included bringing in heavy equipment
to effectively contain and recover the effluent.
3) After inspecting the site to ensure that all effluent was contained and that the cleanup
procedures were in place, I contacted Dean Hunkley with DWR to report the spill.
4) Remediation included pumping the effluent onto the neighbor's crop fields and Murphy
Brown's coastal fields. Cleanup carried on throughout Friday, Saturday and was
completed Sunday afternoon. Containment dams in the ditch were left in place until
recovery efforts were completed and the pond dams were not removed until Tuesday
afternoon of 9/23/14.
5) The spill was contained in a secondary intermittent ditch and a.small pond that is fed by
Dark Branch.
6) Our LNM crew brought in trash pumps, tankers, and an Aerway system to aid in the
recovery efforts. We invested over 140 man hours in efforts to recover the effluent from
the discharge. Our team pumped and land applied more than 704,000 gallons through
Aerway application, 24,000 with a tanker, and 102,000 with trash pumps at a cost of
$9,816. The vast majority of this volume was freshwater but in order to ensure removal of
the swine effluent mixed in with the fresh water we took these extraordinary measures.
7) Root Cause: A previously repaired joint in the recycle fine gave way because the wrong
process was used to make the repair causing it to come apart. The effluent flowed down
the farm path and into a drain pipe that dumped into the road side ditch.

Hunkele, Dean
From:
Kraig Westerbeek[[e-mail]]
Sent:
Friday, October 03, 2014 10:01 AM
To:
Hunkele, Dean; David Nordin
Cc:
Rowland, Kevin; Gregson, Jim; King, Morelia s; Farnell, John
Subject:
RE: DWR Incident #: 201401619 Bachelor Sow farm spill
Attachments:
Batchelor Farm NOTICE OF DISCHARGE OF UNTREATED WASTE 10314.docx
After conversations with John Farnell this morning relaying the results of your review of the engineering study done on
the Batchelor Farm Spill, the attached Public Notice has been prepared. Please review it and provide approval prior to
us moving forward.
The following guidance from the rule indicates that we should publish this notice in a newspaper having general
circulation in the county in which the discharge occurred ... in this case Duplin County. I believe we have agreed that no
additional counties downstream from the point of discharge will be effected. The county newspaper is the Duplin
Times, so we plan to pay for this Notice to appear in their publication. If this is incorrect, please let me know.
While we are still very convinced that this discharge was less than 15,000 gallons to surface waters, we appreciate the
time and consideration given to our calculations and estimations and your position that it could have possibly been
more. Murphy -Brown has done everything in its power to remediate as completely as possible any downstream
impacts, and feel we have been successful in these efforts. We try to be very transparent in our reporting and
communications with your agency and respect your authority and council in these matters.
Irithi—event of a discherge;of 13,000 gallons or more ofuntreated wastewater to the surface waters of the Stae,;`
publish a notice of the discharge ima:newspaper having general circulation in the.courity in which the discharge occurs
and in each county downstream from the_point of discharge that'is significantly affected by the discharge rThe
Secretary shall determine, at the Secretary's sole discretion, which counties are significantly affected by the discharge
and shall approve the form and content of the notice and the newspapers in which the notice is to be published. The
notice shall be captioned "NOTICE OF DISCHARGE OF UNTREATED SEWAGE". The owner or operator shall publish the
notice within 10 days after the Secretary has determined the counties that are significantly affected by the discharge
and approved the form and content of the notice and the newspapers in which the notice is to be published. The owner
or operator shall file a copy of the notice and proof of publication with the Department within 30 days after the notice
is published. Publication of a notice of discharge under this subdivision is in addition to the requirement to issue a
press release under subdivision (1) of this subsection.
From: Hunkele, Dean [mailto:[e-mail]]
Sent: Tuesday, September 30, 2014 1:25 PM
To: Kraig Westerbeek; David Nordin; Michael Norris
Cc: Rowland, Kevin; Gregson, Jim; King, Morelia s
Subject: RE: DWR Incident #: 201401619 Bachelor Sow farm spill
Importance: High
Hi Kraig,
I was aware of what was sent and to whom, but it was not complete in its distribution. The requirement for press
release (was within 48 hrs now 24 hrs as of 9-22-2014) is simply an announcement to all print & electronic media outlets
having coverage in the county; it may or may not be picked up as a story by the entities you notify. The public notice is
taking out the ad space in major paper with readership in the County of occurrence and upon notification by the agency
to publish in downstream counties. Based on my estimated volume and specifics, then Duplin County would be
sufficient for this incident.
1

Hunkele, Dean
From: King, Morelia s
Sent: Tuesday, September 23, 2014 2:59 PM
To: Gregson, Jim; Hunkele, Dean
Subject: FW: Press Release
Attachments: Notice of Discharge of Animal Waste -Bachelor Farm 9-19-2014.docx
FYI
Morella
Morella Sanchez King
morella.sanchez-kin¢@ncdenr.xov; (P)910 796 7218
From: Michael Norris[ma iIto: [e-mail]
Sent: Tuesday, September 23, 2014 1:29 PM
To: Rowland, Kevin
Cc: King, Morella s
Subject: RE: Press Release
The release was made yesterday to radio station WEGG and to Duplin Times news paper.
From: Rowland, Kevin[mailto:[e-mail]
Sent: Tuesday, September 23, 2014 1:02 PM
To: Michael Norris
Cc: king, Morella s
Subject: Press Release
Michael,
Were you able verify where and when the press release for the spill was made?
Thank you for your time,
Kevin Rowland
Kevin Rowland
Environmental Specialist II
NCDENR Division of Water Resources
Aquifer Protection Section
Wilmington Regional Office
127 Cardinal Drive Extention
Wilmington, NC 28405
kevin.rowlandOncdenr.eov
910-796-7436 office
910-350-2004 fax
910-520-3510 cell

Hunkele, Dean
From: Kraig Westerbeek[[e-mail]]
Sent: Thursday, October 02, 2014 8:56 AM
To: 'Hunkele, Dean; David Nordin; Michael Norris
Cc: Rowland, Kevin; Gregson, Jim; King, Morella s
Subject: RE: DWR Incident #: 201401619 Bachelor Sow farm spill
Attachments: Batchelortimeline10114.xlsx; Copy of Batchelor Recycle Model pdf (2).xisx
Dean, as requested below, I have attached the model that Dave Elkin, PE completed for the recycle system failure at the
Batchelor Farm. For the benefit of all involved, his calculations assume the worst case scenario of the recycle system
failure beginning at the time employees left the farm (40m) to when the incident was discovered at 7:15am the
following morning. Under this worse -case scenario, it appears that the maximum would be 46,009 gallons, with a more
likely number being 39,021 gallons based on normal pump wear, etc. These calculations do take into account the water
that ponded and infiltrated in and around the building pad area, and what was captured prior to it leaving our property.
I am sure that Dave is more than willing to discuss these calculations with you if necessary. He has indicated to me that
he will seal these calculations as requested but that was not convenient to do in electronic format as it is being
distributed here.
In addition to Dave's calculations, I have attached an additional spreadsheet that calculates the potential loss of water at
1 hour increments beginning at 4pm and continuing through 7:15am. We are very confident in our estimated spill
volume of less than 15,000 gallons based on the lack of any discernable drop in lagoon level after the spill, and the
volume of wastewater observed in the downstream drainage area. I was personally on the site during recovery efforts
the day the spill was discovered and viewed the freeboard staff gauge and lagoon, as well as remediation efforts. In
addition to observations of the lagoon staff gauge, it is my opinion that any spill over 15,000 gallons that would have
occurred prior to 11pm would have easily made it past the two culverts that were blocked to stop the flow given the size
of the drainage area and the speed of the flow of water to this location. Based on this, we feel the most likely time of
the pipe failure to be between midnight at lam.
We ask that DENR review the attached information and provide us with your estimations as well so that we can discuss
what needs to be done with regards to additional Public Notice. As stated previously, we are very confident in our
original estimates but appreciate DENR's obligation to review and accept or reject our information. If additional
information is needed, please let me know.
From: Hunkele, Dean [mailto:[e-mail]]
Sent: Tuesday, September 30, 2014 1:25 PM
To: Kraig Westerbeek; David Nordin; Michael Norris
Cc: Rowland, Kevin; Gregson, Jim; King, Morella s
Subject: RE: DWR Incident # ., 201401619 Bachelor Sow farm spill
Importance: High
Hi Kraig,
I was aware of what was sent and to whom, but it was not complete in its distribution. The requirement for press
release (was within 48 hrs. now 24 hrs as of 9-22-2014) is simply an announcement to all print & electronic media outlets
having coverage in the county; it may or may not be picked up as a story by the entities you notify. The public notice is
taking out the ad space in major paper with readership in the County of occurrence and upon notification by the agency
to publish in downstream counties. Based on my estimated volume and specifics, then Duplin County would be
sufficient for this incident.
Based on that lagoon's design and the freeboard level the day of the spill, then what is 1-inch equal to in volume? Why
did we not get the items we asked for from Dave or Michael as part of the report?

ponded area infiltarted into soils
4) flow pipe under road to dam 1
1095 ft length
1.25 ft width
3 in deep
2559.6 gallons none
5) flow path dam 1 under road to dam 2
866 ft length
j 2.5 ft width
3# in deep
4048.6 gallons none
6) flow path dam 2 under field drive to dam 3
960 ft length
2.51 ft width
3j in deep
4488 gallons none
7) flow path dam 3 to dam 4 @ pond
566 ft length
3 ft width
captured waste
waster volume water
behind clams 3 in deep
14,271 gallons ; 3175.3 gallons sements 4-7 none
23,872 gal Total .j gallons none
Having had the opportunity to review the desgn & installation of the recycle sytem, and the downstream flow path
from the Bachelor sow farms I, David S. Elkin certify that the preceding calculation represent due diligence and
application of engineering calcuation and. judgement to model the event which resulted in the release of waste water
outside the designed recycle system.

lRecycle water recovered
ponded area
ow path segment 1) flow path barn to pipe under road
distance 505 ft
length
4 ft
width
0.5 in
deep
84.167
cf
629.57
gallons
2) puddle @ feed
tanks
75 ft
length
15 ft
width
3 in
deep
281.25
cf
2103.8
gallons
3)
puddle @ feed tanks
70 ft
length
20 ft
width
3 in
deep
350
cf
2618
gallons
pture volume'
:€
!anout pipe to:`
Ivert @ road turn
=9,601gallon. 5,351
gallon total
infiltarted into sandy soils
flow path barn to pipe under rd
505 ft length
4 ft width
1.5 in deep
252.5 cf
1888.7 gallons
puddle @ feed tanks
75 ft length
15 ft width
1.5 in deep
140.63 cf
1051.9 gallons
puddle @ feed tanks
70 ft length
20 ft width
1.5 in deep
175 cf
1309 gallons
gallon total

Bachelor Site Information
barn/ recycle pipe lagoon w/ recycel pump
13 flush tanks length 392 ft
1012 ft pipe length width(ave) 200 ft
230 GPM pump capacity (5Hp AMT @ 15.5psiarea 78400 sf
area 1.799816 ac gallons/ inch freeboard
3 inch DR17 HDPE cleanout pipe 48,s72 `gal/in change
Recycle system is designed to evenly distubute the pumped water to all 13 tanks.
therefore 1/13 of flow is
17.7 gpm per tank
0.039 cfs per flush tank
5 ft/s design velocity (new)
0.01 sf 1.14 sq. inch / tank (full opening, typical of 2" valve = 3.14s.i.)
14.79 si sq. inch / open pipe total system normal flow all 13 tanks
7.35 sq.inch 3" cleanout SDR17
22.14 s.i. total open area for discharge of recycle pump during event
33.21% of flow potential to broken 3" HDPE pipe cleanout
76.37 max potential gallons
""Note: Ithe
this is the futhest point of discharge, vs the tanks that are closer to
pump so would be conservative estimate
""Typically after 2+ years of operation; pump and line deliver far less than
original design due to struvite, sludge, & biofilm build up in lines, as well as impeller
90% & pump wear (expected performance 50-90% of new)
68.74 Likely maximum performance with 2 yr run time.
Maximum operation duration
16:00 pm empoyee departure
7:15 am identification of incident
15.25 h_rs max
69,881.07 gal max potential spill 62,892.96 realistic max. gal

Hypothetical
Gallons from
Gallons Contained/
Gallons Reaching
Pipe Break Time
Time(hrs)
Pump(Gal.)
On -site (gallons)
State Waters / Off -site (Gallons)
4pm
15.25
69881
23,872
46009
5pm
14.25
65299
23,872
41427
6pm
13.25
60716
23,872
36844
7pm
12.25
56134
23,872
32262
8pm
11.25
51552
23,872
27680
9pm
10.25
46969
23,872
23097
l0pm
9.25
42387
23,872
18515
llpm
8.25
37804
23,872
13932
12pm
7.25
33222
23,872
9350
lam
6.25
28640
23,872
4768
tam
5.25
24057
23,872
185
3am
4.25
19475
23,872
0
4arn
3.25
14893
23,872
0
5am
2.25
10310
23,872
0
6am
1.25
5728
23,872
0
7am
0.25
1146
23,872
0
7:15am
0
0
23,872
0

Hunkele, Dean
From: Hunkele, Dean
Sent: Thursday, February 26, 2015 1:03 PM
To: Gregson, Jim
Cc: King, Morelia s
Subject: 31-0563 Batchelor Sow spill case
Attachments: 31-0563 Batchelor spill enf costs.xlsx; AWS310563 NO] NOV-2014-DV-0228.docx; email
exchanges.pdf; email exchanges-001.pdf; not response.pdf
Importance: High
Jim,
Please find the attached case info for Raleigh's review.
Based on standard Fast Track assessment guidance for sewer spills, etc. in this regional office and our discussions, this is
what we would assess.
Violation 1
Violation 2
Violation 3
Violation 4
Total CP $1,600
Enf Cost $554.15
$1000
$250
$100
$100 + $150 (sample costs)
Total Assessment = $2,154.15
can Hunkele��. = e
r� Ertir�roa�rrieitt�15d3e�� -`:. -
[ivrt ona os: meter ttescnsrces
Ater Qua�EY• Raponai.OAe� Secii� �: --
Email correspondence to and from this address is subiect to the North Carolina Public Records Law and may be
disclosed to third parties unless the content is exempt by statute or other regulation.
For information about permit applications please visit DENR's Permit Application Tracker using this address:
http://portal.ncdenr.org/web/deao/permit-tracker
The goal of the Fast Track sewer permit program is to issue a permit in no more than 30 business days from receipt of a
complete application and if no addtional information has to be requested upon full review. Please use the tracker to
determine the official application receipt date to allow you to estimate a date for issuance and find the reviewer's
name. Once issued, the record stays on the site for 30 days.
Subscribe to Collection System Updates
i

31-0563 Spill
Staff Name
Time
Rate
Total
Hunkele
Site
4.5
37.09
166.905
Case
3
37.09
111.27
Sanchez -King
Site
4.5
47.44
213.48
Truck
125
0.5
62.5
Grand Total
554.155
Sampling Costs Sacred
Fecal
35
TSS
15
Ammonia
20
BOD
25
TP
20
TN, etc
45
TOTAL
160

vj X ^ Rc wiia �� ems:..'•{.
14
'•.�LE"
ors" �_�".- •-�._ �'.�r� ::_ - �•_'
AN

e

Murphy -Brown, LLC
Grower(s):
Farm Name:
4/16/2009 2822 Hwy 24 West
P.O. Box 856
Warsaw, NC 28398
NUTRIENT UTILIZATION PLAN
Murphy -Brown, LLC
Batchelor Farm
Coun : Du lin
Farm Ca aci :
Farrow to Wean 2035
Farrow to Feeder
Farrow to Finish
Wean to Feeder
Feeder to Finish
Storage Structure:
Storage Period:
Application Method:
Anaerobic Lagoon
>180 days
Irrigation
RECEIVED / DENR / DVvQ
Aquifer Proteet+on Sm*on
APR 16
APR 2 0 2oog
BY:
The waste from your animal facility must be land applied at a specified rate to prevent pollu io
of surface water and/or groundwater. The plant nutrients in the animal waste should be used
to reduce the amount of commercial fertilizer required for the crops in the fields where the waste
is to be applied.
This waste utilization plan uses nitrogen as the limiting nutrient. Waste should be analyzed
before each application cycle. Annual soil tests are strongly encouraged so that all plant
nutrients can be balanced for realistic yields of the crop to be grown.
Several factors are important in implementing your waste utilization plan in order to maximize
the fertilizer value of the waste and to ensure that it is applied in an environmentally safe manner:
1. Always apply waste based on the needs of the crop to be grown and the nutrient
content of the waste. Do not apply more nitrogen than the crop can utilize.
2. Soil types are important as they have different infiltration rates, leaching potentials,
cation exchange capacities, and available water holding capacities.
3. Normally waste shall be applied to land eroding at less than 5 tons per acre per
year. Waste may be applied to land eroding at 5 or more tons per acre annually, but
less than 10 tons per acre per year providing that adequate filter strips are established.
4. Do not apply waste on saturated soils, when it is raining, or when the surface is frozen.
Either of these conditions may result in runoff to surface waters which is not allowed
under DWQ regulations.
5. Wind conditions should also be considered to avoid drift and downwind odor
problems.
6. To maximize the value of the nutrients for crop production and to reduce the potential
for pollution, the waste should be applied to a growing crop or applied not more than
30 days prior to planting a crop or forages breaking dormancy. Injecting the waste or
disking will conserve nutrients and reduce odor problems.
1 of 11

This plan is based on the waste application method shown above. If you choose to change
methods in the future, you need to revise this plan. Nutrient levels for different application
methods are not the same.
The estimated acres needed to apply the animal waste is based on typical nutrient content
for this type of facility. In some cases you may want to have plant analysis made, which could
allow additional waste to be applied. Provisions shall be made for the area receiving waste to
be flexible so as to accommodate changing waste analysis content and crop type. Lime must
be applied to maintain pH in the optimum range for specific crop production.
This waste utilization plan, if carried out, meets the requirements for compliance with 15A NCAC
2H .0217 adopted by the Environmental Management Commission.
AMOUNT OF WASTE PRODUCED PER YEAR ( gallons, ft3, tons, etc.):
CaRacity Type Waste Produced per Animal Total
2035
Farrow to Wean
3212 gallyr
6,536,420 gal/yr
Farrow to Feeder
4015 gallyr
gal/yr
Farrow to Finish
10585 gallyr
gallyr
Wean to Feeder
223 gallyr
gallyr
Feeder to Finish
986 gallyr
gallyr
Total 6,536,420 gallyr
AMOUNT OF PLANT AVAILABLE NITROGEN PRODUCED PER YEAR (lbs): !Based on Farm pumping records
Capacity Type Nitrogen Produced per Animal Total
2035
Farrow to Wean
4.72 Ibs/yr
9,605 Ibs/yr
Farrow to Feeder
6.5 Ibs/yr
Ibslyr
Farrow to Finish
26 Ibs/yr
Ibs/yr
Wean to Feeder
0.48 Ibs/yr
Ibs/yr
Feeder to Finish
2.3 Ibslyr
Ibs/yr
Total 9,605 Ibslyr
Applying the above amount of waste is a big job. You should plan time and have appropriate
equipment to apply the waste in a timely manner.
LAND UTILIZATION SUMMARY
The following table describes the nutrient balance and land utilization rate for this facility
Note that the Nitrogen Balance for Crops indicates the ratio of the amount of nitrogen produced
on this facility to the amount of nitrogen that the crops under irrigation may uptake and utilize
in the normal growing season.
Total Irrigated Acreage: 116.01
Total N Required 1st Year: 26105.09
Total N Required 2nd Year: 22867.1
Average Annual Nitrogen Requirement of Crops: 24,486.10
Total Nitrogen Produced by Farm: 9,605.20
Nitrogen Balance for Crops: (14,880.90)
The following table describes the specifications of the hydrants and fields that contain the crops
designated for utilization of the nitrogen produced on this facility. This chart describes the size,
soil characteristics, and uptake rate for each crop in the specified crop rotation schedule for this
facility.
2of11

Reception Area Specifications
Tract Field Irrigated Soil 1st Crop Time to 1st Crop 1st Crop Lbs NIAc Lbs N Total Ibs N
Acrea e Tvpe Code Applv Yield Ibs NlUnit Residual lAc Utilized
2nd Crop Time to 2nd Crop 2nd Crop Lbs NlAc Lbs N Total Ibs N
Code Apply Yield Ibs NlUnit Residual /Ac Utilized
Total
Lbs NIAc
Total Ibs N
Utilized
T1
1
2.92
Foreston
D
Feb15-June
120.0
1.25
150
438
N
Se"Se"e
55
2.4
132
385.44
282
823.44
2
2.71
Foreston
D
Feb15-June
120.0
1.25
150
406.5
N
Sept -Apr
55
2.4
132
357.72
282
764.22
3
2.69
Foreston
D
Feb15-June
120.0
1.25
150
403.5
N
Seet-Apr
55
2.4
132
355.08
282
758.58
4
2.64
Foreston
D
Feb15-June
120.0
1.25
150
396
N
Sept -Apr
55
2.4
132
348.48
282
744.48
5
2.56
Foreston
D
Feb15 June
120.0
1,25
150
384
N
Se t-
55
2.4
132
337.92
282
721.92
8
2.38
Foreston
D
FeblSJune
120.0
1.25
150
357
N
SeebW
55
2.4
132
314.16
282
671,16
7
1.69
Foreston
I D
Feb15-June
120.0
1.25
150
253.5
N
SeDt-Apr
55
2.4
132
223.08
282
476.58
8
1.85
Autryville
C
Mar -Set
5.5
50
275
508.75
L
Seg:8ff
1
50
50
92.5
325
601.25
9
1.85
Au Ile
C
Mar
5.5
50
275
508.75
L
1
50
50
92.5
325
601.25
10
1.91
AutryylBe
C
Mar -Sept
5.5
50
275
525.25
L
Sept-AprSept-Apr
1
50
50
95.5
325
620.75
11
1.69
Autryvilla
C
Mar -Se t
5.5
50
275
464,75
L
Sept-AprSept-Apr
1
50
50
84.5
325
549.25
12
9.6
Foreston
C
Mar -Sept
6.0
50
300
2880
L
Sept -Apr
1
50
50
480
1 350
3360
13
8.32
Foreston
C
Mar -Sept
6.0
50
300
2496
L
Sept-AprSept-Apr
1
50
50
416
350
2912
14
2.34
Foreston
C
Mar -Set
6.0
50
300
702
L
Sept -Apr
1
50
50
117
350
819
subl-7
3.01
Foreston
D
Mar -Jul
120.0
1.25
150
451.5
N
Sept -Apr
1 55
2.4
1
132
397,32
282
848.82
sub8-11
0,98
Autryville
C
Mar -Set
5.5
50
275
269.5
L
Sept -Apr
1
50
50
49
325
318.5
sub12-14
6,44
Foreston
C
Mar -Set
&0
50
300
1932
L
Se -
1
50
50
322
350
2254
71193
1
33.88
A ills
D
Feb15-June
65.0
1.25
106.25
3599.75
N
Sept, -Apr
45
2.4
108
3659.04
214.25
1 7258.79
4207-F5
Zone 1
1.06
Foreston
D
17015-June
120.0
1.25
150
159
N
Sept -Apr
55
2.4
132
139.92
282
298.92
4207-F5
Zone 2
1.21
Foreston
D
Feb15-June
120.0
1.25
1 150
181.5
N
Sept -Apr
55
2.4
132
159.72
282
341.22
4207-F5
Zone 3
1,28
Foreston
D
Febl5-June
120.0
1 1.25
150
192
N
Se -A r
55
2.4
132
168.96
282
360.96
Optional Lend
71473
1
11.5
Au ills
D
Mar-Ju
85.0
1.25
15
91.25
0
N
Sept -Apr
45
2.4
108
1242
0
0
71473
1
11.6
Autryville
O
Jun" t
30.0
4
0
120
0
0
0
Totals., 116.01 17509.25 9837.54 26105.09
3(a) of 11

Reception Area Specifications
Tract Field Irrigated Soil 1st Crop Time to 1st Crop 1st Crap Lbs N1Ac Lbs N Total Ibs N
Acreage Type Code Apply Yield Ibs NlUnit Residual /Ac Utilized
2nd Crop Time to 2nd Crop 2nd Crop Lbs NIAc Lbs N Total lbs NI
Cocle Apply Yield lips NlUnit Residual lAc Utilized
Total
Lbs NIAc
Total Ibs N
Utilized
T1
1
2.92
Foreston
O
Jun -Set
40.0
4
160
467.2
L
Sept -Apr
1
65
15
50
146
210
613.2
2
2.71
Foreston
O
Jun -Sept
40.0
4
160
433.E
L
S r
1
65
15
50
135.5
210
569.1
3
2.69
Foreston
O
Jun -Sept
40.0
4
160
430.4
L
Sept -Apr
1
65
15
50
134.5
210
564.9
4
2.64
Foreston
O
Jun -Set
40.0
4
160
422.4
L
Sept -Apr
1
65
15
50
132
210
554.4
5
2.56
Foreston
O
Jun -Set
40.0
4
160
409.6
L
Sept -Apr
1
65
15
50
128
210
537.6
6
2.38
Foreston
O
Jun -Set
40.0
4
160
380.8
L
Sept -Apr
1
65
15
50
119
210
499.8
7
1.69
Foreston
O
Jun -Set
40.0
1 4
160
270A
L
Sept -Apr
1
65
15
50
84.5
210
354.9
8
1.85
Au lye
C
Mar -Sept
5.5
50
275
508.75
L
Sept -Apr
1
50
50
92.5
325
601.25
9
1.85
Au i[le
C
Mar -Set
5.5
50
275
508.75
L
Sept -Apr
1
50
50
92.5
325
601.25
10
1.91
Autryvlile
C
Mar -Set
5.5
50
275
525.25
L
Sept -Apr
1
50
50
95.5
325
620.75
11
1.69
Autryville
C
Mar -Sept
5.5
50
275
464.75
1 L
Sept -Apr
1
50
50
84.5
325
549.25
12
9.6
Foreston
C
Mar -Set
6.0
50
300
2880
1 L
Sept-AprSept-Apr
1
50
50
480
350
3360
13
8.32
Foreston
C
Mar -Set
6.0
50
300
2496
L
i Sept-AprSept-Apr
1
50
50
416
350
2912
14
2.34
Foreston
C
Mar -Sept
6.0
50
300
702
L
Sept -Apr
1
50
1 50
117
1 350
819
sub1-7
3.01
Foreston
0
Jun -Set
40.0
1 4
160
481.6
L
Sept -Apr
1
65
15
50
150.5
210
632A
sub8-11
0.98
Autryville
C
Mar -Set
5.5
50
275
269.5
L
Sept -Apr
1
50
50
49
325
31815
sub12-14
6.44
Foreston
C
Mar -Set
6.0
50
300
1932
L
Sept -Apr
1
50
50
322
350
2254
71193
1
33.88
Autryville
O
Jun -Set
30.0
4
120
4065.6
L
Sept-
1
65
15
50
1694
170
5759.6
4207.F5
Zone 1
1.06
Foreston
O
Jun -Set
40.0
4
160
169.6
L
SeptApr
1
65
15
50
53
210
222.6
4207-F5
Zone 2
1.21
Foreston
O
Jun -Set
40.0
4
160
193.6
L
Sept-AprSept-Apr
1
65
15
50
60.5
210
254.1
4207.F5
Zone 3
1.28
Foreston
O
Jun -Set
40.0
4
160
204.8
L
Sept -Apr
1
65
15
50
64
210
268.8
If small
rain hey Is not planted
behind soybeans,
deduct 15 Ib residual from
com.
Totals: 99.01 18216.6 4650.6 22867.1
3(b) of 11

This plan does not include commercial fertilizer. The farm should produce adequate plant
available nitrogen to satisfy the requirements of the crops listed above.
The applicator is cautioned that P and K may be over applied while meeting the N requirements.
In the future, regulations may require farmers in some parts of North Carolina to have a nutrient
management plan that addresses all nutrients. This plan only addresses nitrogen.
In interplanted fields ( i.e. small grain, etc, interseeded in bermuda), forage must be removed
through grazing, hay, and/or silage. Where grazing, plants should be grazed when they
reach a height of six to nine inches. Cattle should be removed when plants are grazed to a
height of four inches. In fields where small grain, etc, is to be removed for hay or silage, care
should be exercised not to let small grain reach maturity, especially late in the season (i.e.
April or May). Shading may result if small grain gets too high and this will definately interfere
with stand of bermudagrass. This loss of stand will result in reduced yields and less nitrogen
being utilized. Rather than cutting small grain for hay or silage just before heading as is
the normal situation, you are encouraged to cut the small grain earlier. You may want to
consider harvesting hay or silage two to three times during the season, depending on the
time small grain is planted in the fall.
The ideal time to interplant small grain, etc, is late September or early October. Drilling is
recommended over broadcasting. Bermudagrass should be grazed or cut to a height of
about two inches before drilling for best results.
CROP CODE LEGEND
Crop Code
Crop
Lbs N utilized / unit yield
A
Barley
1.6 Ibs N 1 bushel
B
Hybrid Bermudagrass - Grazed
50 Ibs N / ton
C
Hybrid Bermudagrass - Hay
50 Ibs N 1 ton
D
Corn - Grain
1.25 Ibs N 1 bushel
E
Corn - Silage
12 Ibs N 1 ton
F
Cotton
0.12 Ibs N 1 Ibs lint
G
Fescue- Grazed
50 ibs N 1 ton
H
Fescue- Hay
50 Ibs N 1 ton
I
Oats
1.3 Ibs N 1 bushel
J
Rye
2.4 Ibs N / bushel
K
Small Grain - Grazed
50 Ibs N / acre
L
Small Grain - Hay
50 Ibs N / acre
M
Grain Sorghum
2.5 Ibs N / cwt
N
Wheat
2.4 Ibs N / bushel
O
Soybean
4.0 lbs N / bushel
P
Pine Trees
40 Ibs N I acre / yr
Acres shown in the preceding table are considered to be the usable acres excluding
required buffers, filter strips along ditches, odd areas unable to be irrigated, and perimeter areas
not receiving full application rates due to equipment limitations. Actual total acres in the fields
listed may, and most likely will be, more than the acres shown in the tables.
See attached map showing the fields to be used for the utilization of animal waste.
4 of 11

SLUDGE APPLICATION:
The following table describes the annual nitrogen accumulation rate per animal
in the lagoon sludge
Farm Specifications PANT rlanimal Farm Totall r
2035 Farrow to Wean 0.84 1709.4
Farrow to Feeder 1
Farrow to Finish 4.1
Wean to Feeder 0.072
Feeder to Finish 0.36
The waste utilization plan must contain provisions for periodic land application of sludge at
agronomic rates. The sludge will be nutrient rich and will require precautionary measures to
prevent over application of nutrients or other elements. Your production facility will produce
approximately 1709.4 pounds of plant available nitrogen per year will accumulate in the lagoon
sludge based on the rates of accumulation listed above.
If you remove the sludge every 5 years, you will have approximately 8547 pounds of plant
available nitrogen to utilize. Assuming you apply this PAN to hybrid bermuda grass hayland at the
rate of 300 pounds of nitrogen per acre, you will need 28 acreas of land. If you apply the sludge
to corn at a rate of 125 pounds per acre, you will need 68.376 acres of land. Please note that these
are only estimates of the PAN produced and the land required to utilize that PAN. Actual values
may only be determined by sampling the sludge for plant available nitrogen content prior to application
Actual utilization rates will vary with soil type, crop, and realistic yield expectations for the specific
application fields designated for sludge application at time of removal.
APPLICATION OF WASTE BY IRRIGATION:
The irrigation application rate should not exceed the intake rate of the soil at the time of irrigation
such that runoff or ponding occurs. This rate is limited by initial soil moisture content, soil
structure, soil texture, water droplet size, and organic solids. The application amount should not
exceed the available water holding capacity of the soil at the time of irrigation nor should the
plant available nitrogen applied exceed the nitrogen needs of the crop.
If surface irrigation is the method of land application for this plan, it is the responsibility of the
producer and irrigation designer to ensure that an irrigation system is installed to properly
irrigate the acres shown in the preceding table. Failure to apply the recommended rates and
amounts of nitrogen shown in the tables may make this plan invalid.
`This is the maximum application amount allowed for the soil assuming the amount
of nitrogen allowed for the crop is not over applied. In many situations, the application
amount shown cannot be applied because of the nitrogen limitation. The maximum
application amount shown can be applied under optimum soil conditions.
Your facility is designed for >180 days of temporary storage and the temporary storage must
be removed on the average of once every 6 months. In no instance should the volume of the
waste stored in your structure be within the 25 year 24 hour storm storage or one foot of
freeboard except in the event of the 25 year 24 hour storm.
It is the responsibility of the producer and waste applicator to ensure that the spreader equipment
is operated properly to apply the correct rates to the acres shown in the tables. Failure to apply
the recommended rates and amounts of nitrogen shown in the tables may make this plan invalid.
Call your technical specialist after you receive the waste analysis report for assistance in
determining the amount of waste per acre and the proper application prior to applying the waste.
5 of 11

Application Rate Guide
The following is provided as a guide for establishing application rates and amounts.
Soil
Application Rate
Application Amount
Tract
Hydrant
_ Type
Crop
inlhr
* inches
T1
1
Foreston
D
0.5
1
2
Foreston
D
0.5
1
3
Foreston
D
0.5
1
4
Foreston
D
0.5
1
5
Foreston
D
0.5
1
6
Foreston
D
0.5
1
7
Foreston
D
0.5
1
8
Autryville
C
0.6
1
9
Autryville
C
0.6
1
10
Autryville
C
0.6
1
11
Autryville
C
0.6
1
12
Foreston
C
0.5
1
13
Foreston
C
0.5
1
14
Foreston
C
0.5
1
subl-7
Foreston
D
0.5
1
sub8-11
Autryville
C
0.6
1
sub12-14
Foreston
C
0.5
1
71193
1
Autryville
D
0.6
1
4207-F5
Zone 1
Foreston
D
0.5
1
4207-F5
Zone 2
Foreston
D
0.5
1
4207-F5
Zone 3
Foreston
D
0.5
1
;ptional Lan
71473 1 Autryville D 0.6 1
71473 1 Autryville O 0.6 1
6 of 11

Additional Comments:
Subfield acreage is the balance of the total field acres minus wet acres
at this site. This acreage will be claimed when making application with an
aerway machine.
Tracts 71193 is leased land. Tracts 71193 & 4207 are optional for this plan and
application to Tract 71193 acreage will be made with an aerway.
Small grain hay behind soybeans is optional for all fields.
T71473 has been leased for a three year period beginning Fall 2006 and
is optional for use. Any of the crops listed may be grown. This land will
be applied to using an aerway type applicator.
This plan revised to include the new solid set sprinklers in Tract 4207 field 5.
7of11

NUTRIENT UTILIZATION PLAN CERTIFICATION
Name of Farm: Batchelor Farm
Owner: Murphy -Brown, LLC
Manager:
Owner/Manager Agreement:
I/we understand and will follow and implement the specifications and the operation and
maintenance procedures established in the approved animal waste nutrient management
plan for the farm named above. llwe know that any expansion to the existing design capacity
of the waste treatment and/or storage system, or construction of new facilities, will require a
new nutrient management plan and a new certification to be submitted to DWQ before the new
animals are stocked.
I/we understand that I must own or have access to equipment, primarily irrigation equipment,
to land apply the animal waste described in this nutrient management plan. This equipment
must be available at the appropriate pumping time such that no discharge occurs from the lagoon
in the event of a 25 year 24 hour storm. I also certify that the waste will be applied on the land
according to this plan at the appropriate times and at rates which produce no runoff.
This plan will be filed on site at the farm office and at the office of the local Soil and Water
Conservation District and will be available for review by NCDWQ upon request.
Name of Facility Owner: Murphy -Brown, LLC
Signature:
Date
Name of Manager (if different from owner):
Signature:
Date
Name of Technical Specialist: M. Kevin Weston
Affiliation: Murphy -Brown, LLC.
Address: 2822 Hwy 24 West, PO Drawer 856
Warsaw, NC 28398
Telephone: [phone]
Signature:
Date
8 of 11

NUTRIENT UTILIZATION PLAN
REQUIRED SPECIFICATIONS
Animal waste shall not reach surface waters of the state by runoff, drift, manmade
conveyances, direct application, or direct discharge during operation or land application.
Any discharge of waste which reaches surface water is prohibited.
2 There must be documentation in the design folder that the producer either owns or has an
agreement for use of adequate land on which to properly apply the waste. If the producer
does not own adequate land to properly dispose of the waste, he/she shall provide
evidence of an agreement with a landowner, who is within a reasonable proximity,
allowing him/her the use of the land for waste application. It is the responsibility of the
owner of the waste production facility to secure an update of the Nutrient Utilization Plan
when there is a change in the operation, increase in the number of animals, method of
application, recieving crop tvpe, or available land.
Animal waste shall be applied to meet, but not exceed, the nitrogen needs for realistic crop
yields based upon soil type, available moisture, historical data, climatic conditions, and
level of management, unless there are regulations that restrict the rate of applications for
other nutrients.
4 Animal waste shall be applied to land eroding less than 5 tons per acre per year. Waste
may be applied to land eroding at more than 5 tons per acre per year but less than 10 tons
per acre per year provided grass filter strips are installed where runoff leaves the field (See
USDA, NRCS Field Office Technical Guide Standard 393 - Filter Strips).
5 Odors can be reduced by injecting the waste or disking after waste application_ Waste
should not be applied when there is danger of drift from the land application field.
6 When animal waste is to be applied on acres subject to flooding, waste will be soil
incorporated on conventionally tilled cropland. When waste is applied to conservation tilled
crops or grassland, the waste may be broadcast provided the application does not occur
during a season prone to flooding (See "Weather and Climate in North Carolina" for
guidance).
Liquid waste shall be applied at rates not to exceed the soil infiltration rate such that runoff
does not occur offsite or to surface waters and in a method which does not cause drift
from the site during application. No ponding should occur in order to control odor and flies.
8 Animal waste shall not be applied to saturated soils, during rainfall events, or when the
surface is frozen.
9 of 11

NUTRIENT UTILIZATION PLAN
REQUIRED SPECIFICATIONS
(continued)
9 Animal waste shall be applied on actively growing crops in such a manner that the crop is
not covered with waste to a depth that would inhibit growth. The potential for salt damage
from animal waste should also be considered.
10 Nutrients from waste shall not be applied in fall or winter for spring planted crops on soils
with a high potential for leaching. Wastelnutrient loading rates on these soils should be
held to a minimum and a suitable winter cover crop planted to take up released nutrients.
Waste shall not be applied more than 30 days prior to planting of the crop or forages
breaking dormancy.
11 Any new swine facility sited on or after October 1, 1995 shall comply with the following:
The outer perimeter of the land area onto which waste is applied from a lagoon that is a
component of a swine farm shall be at least 50 feet from any residential property boundary
and canal. Animal waste, other than swine waste from facilities sited on or after October 1,
1995, shall not be applied closer than 25 feet to perennial waters.
12 Animal waste shall not be applied closer than 100 feet to wells.
13 Animal waste shall not be applied closer than 200 feet of dwellings other than those
owned by the landowner.
14 Waste shall be applied in a manner not to reach other property and public right-of-ways.
15 Animal waste shall not be discharged into surface waters, drainageways, or wetlands by
discharge or by over -spraying. Animal waste may be applied to prior converted cropland
provided the fields have been approved as a land application site by a "technical
specialist". Animal waste shall not be applied on grassed waterways that discharge
directly into water courses, and on other grassed waterways, waste shall be applied at
agronomic rates in a manner that causes no runoff or drift from the site.
16 Domestic and industrial waste from washdown facilities, showers, toilets, sinks, etc., shall
not be discharged into the animal waste management system.
10 of 11

NUTRIENT UTILIZATION PLAN
REQUIRED SPECIFICATIONS
(continued)
17 A protective cover of appropriate vegetation will be established on all disturbed areas
(lagoon embankments, berms, pipe runs, etc.). Areas shall be fenced, as necessary, to
protect the vegetation. Vegetation such as trees, shrubs, and other woody species, etc.,
are limited to areas where considered appropriate. Lagoon areas should be kept mowed
and accessible. Berms and structures should be inspected regularly for evidence of
erosion, leakage, or discharge.
18 If animal production at the facility is to be suspended or terminated, the owner is
responsible for obtaining and implementing a "closure plan" which will eliminate the
possibility of an illegal discharge, pollution and erosion.
19 Waste handling structures, piping, pumps, reels, etc., should be inspected on a regular
basis to prevent breakdowns, leaks and spills. A regular maintenance checklist should be
kept on site.
20 Animal waste can be used in a rotation that includes vegetables and other crops for direct
human consumption. However, if animal waste is used on crops for direct human
consumption, it should only be applied pre -plant with no further applications of animal
waste during the crop season.
21 Highly visible markers shall be installed to mark the top and bottom elevations of the
temporary storage (pumping volume) of all waste treatment lagoons. Pumping shall be
managed to maintain the liquid level between the markers. A marker will be required to
mark the maximum storage volume for waste storage ponds.
22 Waste shall be tested within 60 days of utilization and soil shall be tested at least annually
at crop sites where waste products are applied. Nitrogen shall be the rate -determining
nutrient, unless other restrictions require waste to be applied based on other nutrients,
resulting in a lower application rate than a nitrogen based rate. Zinc and copper levels in
the soil shall be monitored and alternative crop sites shall be used when these metals
approach excessive levels. pH shall be adjusted and maintained for optimum crop
production. Soil and waste analysis records shall be kept for a minimum of five years.
Poultry dry waste application records shall be maintained for a minimum of three years.
Waste application records for all other waste shall be maintained for a minimum of five
years.
23 Dead animals will be disposed of in a manner that meets North Carolina regulations.
11 of 11

NUTRIENT UTILIZATION PLAN
REQUIRED SPECIFICATIONS
Animal waste shall not reach surface waters of the state by runoff, drift, manmade
conveyances, direct application, or direct discharge during operation or land application.
Any discharge of waste which reaches surface water is prohibited.
2 There must be documentation in the design folder that the producer either owns or has an
agreement for use of adequate land on which to properly apply the waste. If the producer
does not own adequate land to properly dispose of the waste, he/she shall provide
evidence of an agreement with a landowner, who is within a reasonable proximity,
allowing him/her the use of the land for waste application. It is the responsibility of the
owner of the waste production facility to secure an update of the Nutrient Utilization Plan
when there is a change in the operation, increase in the number of animals, method of
application, recievinq crop type, or available land.
Animal waste shall be applied to meet, but not exceed, the nitrogen needs for realistic crop
yields based upon soil type, available moisture, historical data, climatic conditions, and
level of management, unless there are regulations that restrict the rate of applications for
other nutrients.
4 Animal waste shall be applied to land eroding less than 5 tons per acre per year. Waste
may be applied to land eroding at more than 5 tons per acre per year but less than 10 tons
per acre per year provided grass filter strips are installed where runoff leaves the field (See
USDA, NRCS Field Office Technical Guide Standard 393 - Filter Strips).
Odors can be reduced by injecting the waste or disking after waste application. Waste
should not be applied when there is danger of drift from the land application field.
6 When animal waste is to be applied on acres subject to flooding, waste will be soil
incorporated on conventionally tilled cropland. When waste is applied to conservation tilled
crops or grassland, the waste may be broadcast provided the application does not occur
during a season prone to flooding (See "Weather and Climate in North Carolina" for
guidance).
7 Liquid waste shall be applied at rates not to exceed the soil infiltration rate such that runoff
does not occur offsite or to surface waters and in a method which does not cause drift
from the site during application. No ponding should occur in order to control odor and flies.
8 Animal waste shall not be applied to saturated soils, during rainfall events, or when the
surface is frozen.
9of11

NUTRIENT UTILIZATION PLAN
REQUIRED SPECIFICATIONS
(continued)
9 Animal waste shall be applied on actively growing crops in such a manner that the crop is
not covered with waste to a depth that would inhibit growth. The potential for salt damage
from animal waste should also be considered.
10 Nutrients from waste shall not be applied in fall or winter for spring planted crops on soils
with a high potential for leaching. Waste/nutrient loading rates on these soils should be
held to a minimum and a suitable winter cover crop planted to take up released nutrients.
Waste shall not be applied more than 30 days prior to planting of the crop or forages
breaking dormancy.
11 Any new swine facility sited on or after October 1, 1995 shall comply with the following:
The outer perimeter of the land area onto which waste is applied from a lagoon that is a
component of a swine farm shall be at least 50 feet from any residential property boundary
and canal. Animal waste, other than swine waste from facilities sited on or after October 1,
1995, shall not be applied closer than 25 feet to perennial waters.
12 Animal waste shall not be applied closer than 100 feet to wells.
13 Animal waste shall not be applied closer than 200 feet of dwellings other than those
owned by the landowner.
14 Waste shall be applied in a manner not to reach other property and public right-of-ways.
15 Animal waste shall not be discharged into surface waters, drainageways, or wetlands by
discharge or by over -spraying. Animal waste may be applied to prior converted cropland
provided the fields have been approved as a land application site by a "technical
specialist". Animal waste shall not be applied on grassed waterways that discharge
directly into water courses, and on other grassed waterways, waste shall be applied at
agronomic rates in a manner that causes no runoff or drift from the site.
16 Domestic and industrial waste from washdown facilities, showers, toilets, sinks, etc., shall
not be discharged into the animal waste management system.
10 of 11

NUTRIENT UTILIZATION PLAN
REQUIRED SPECIFICATIONS
(continued)
17 A protective cover of appropriate vegetation will be established on all disturbed areas
(lagoon embankments, berms, pipe runs, etc.). Areas shall be fenced, as necessary, to
protect the vegetation. Vegetation such as trees, shrubs, and other woody species, etc.,
are limited to areas where considered appropriate. Lagoon areas should be kept mowed
and accessible. Berms and structures should be inspected regularly for evidence of
erosion, leakage, or discharge.
18 If animal production at the facility is to be suspended or terminated, the owner is
responsible for obtaining and implementing a "closure plan" which will eliminate the
possibility of an illegal discharge, pollution and erosion.
19 Waste handling structures, piping, pumps, reels, etc., should be inspected on a regular
basis to prevent breakdowns, leaks and spills. A regular maintenance checklist should be
kept on site.
20 Animal waste can be used in a rotation that includes vegetables and other crops for direct
human consumption. However, if animal waste is used on crops for direct human
consumption, it should only be applied pre -plant with no further applications of animal
waste during the crop season.
21 Highly visible markers shall be installed to mark the top and bottom elevations of the
temporary storage (pumping volume) of all waste treatment lagoons. Pumping shall be
managed to maintain the liquid level between the markers. A marker will be required to
mark the maximum storage volume for waste storage ponds.
22 Waste shall be tested within 60 days of utilization and soil shall be tested at least annually
at crop sites where waste products are applied. Nitrogen shall be the rate -determining
nutrient, unless other restrictions require waste to be applied based on other nutrients,
resulting in a lower application rate than a nitrogen based rate. Zinc and copper levels in
the soil shall be monitored and alternative crop sites shall be used when these metals
approach excessive levels. pH shall be adjusted and maintained for optimum crop
production. Soil and waste analysis records shall be kept for a minimum of five years.
Poultry dry waste application records shall be maintained for a minimum of three years.
Waste application records for all other waste shall be maintained for a minimum of five
years.
23 Dead animals will be disposed of in a manner that meets North Carolina regulations.
11 of 11

03/02/2007 FRI 18:00 FAX [phone] WRLNNI 4— DWQ Wilmington
IA 001/006
r
Murphypff
Murphy Brown LLc
PO Box 856
2822 Hwy 24 West
Warsaw, NC 28398
Phone [phone]
Fax [phone]
Fax Transmittal Sheet
Fax: Pages:
Phone: Date:
Re: CC:
❑ Urgcnt ❑ For Review ❑ Please Comment ❑ Please Reply ❑ Please Recycle

a
03/02/2007 FRI 18:00 FAX [phone] WRLNR1 44-> DWQ Wilmington
Q 002/006
PLAN OF ACTION(Poa) FOR HIGH FREEBOARD AT ANIMAL FACILITIES
Facility Number: 31-563 County. Duplin
Facility Name: Batchelor Sow
Certified Operator Name: Ron Taylor Operator Number: 27466
1. Current liquid levet(s) in inches as measured from the current liquid level in the lagoon to the
lowest point on the top of the dam for lagoons without spillways; and from the current liquid level
in the lagoon to the bottom of the spillway for lagoons with spillways.
Lagoon 1 Lagoon 2 Lagoon 3 Lagoon 4 Lagoon 5
Lagoon Name/ID: A B
Spillway(Y or N); N N
Level(inches): 18 17
2. Check all applicable items
Liquid level is within the designed structural freeboard elevations of one or more structures.
Five and 30 day Plans of Action are attached. Hydraulic and agronomic balances are
within acceptable ranges.
X Liquid level is within the 25 year 24 hour storm elevations for one or more structures. A
30 day Plan of Action is attached. Agronomic balance is within acceptable range.
Waste is to be pumped and hauled to off site locations. Bolume and PAN content of waste
to be pumped and hauled is reflected in section III tables. Included within this plan is a list
of the proposed sites with related facility numbers, number of acres and receiving crop
information. Contact and secure approval from the DWQ prior to transfer of waste to a site
not covered in the facilitys CAWMP.
Operation will be partially or fully depopulated.
*Attach a complete schedule with corresponding animal units and dates fro depopulation
*if animals are to be moved to another permitted facility, provide facility number, lagoon
freeboard levels and herd population for the receiving facility
3. Earliest possible date to begin land application of waste: 3/3/2007
I hereby certify that I have reviewed the information listed above and included within the
attached Plan of Action, and to the best of my knowledge and ability, the information is
accurate and correct.
David Nordin
Facia' OwnerlManager (print)
a dity Owne /Manager (signature)
Phone: [phone]
Date: 3/2/2007

03/02/2007 FRI 18:00 FAX [phone] WRLNXI r DWQ Wilmington 19 003/006
11. TOTAL POUNDS OF PAN STORED WITHIN STRUCTURAL FREEBOARD AND/OR 25 YR.I24
HR. STORM STORAGE ELEVATIONS IN ALL WASTE STRUCTURES FOR FACILITY
1. Structure ID: Batchelor A
line m =
441.9 lb PAN
2. Structure 1D: Batchelor B
line m =
240.6 lb PAN
3. Structure ID:
line rn =
lb PAN
4. Structure ID:
line rn =
lb PAN
5. Structure ID:
line m =
lb PAN
6. Structure ID:
line m =
lb PAN
n. lines 1 +2+3+4+5+6= 682.4 lb PAN
III. TOTAL PAN BALANCE REMAINING FOR AVAILABLE CROPS DURING 30 DAY DRAW DOWN
PERIOD. DO NOT LIST FIELDS TO WHICH PAN CANNOT BE APPLIED DURING THIS 30 DAY PERIOD.
o. tract #
p. field #
q. crop
r. acres
s. remaining IRR
2 PAN balance
Wave)
L TOTAL PAN
BALANCE FOR
FIELD pbs.)
column r x s
u. application window*
1C
Corn
2.92
81.56
238.2
Mar -July
2C
Corn
2.71
81.83
221.8
Mar -Jul
3C
Corn
2.69
66.73
179.5
Mar -Jul
4C
Corn
2.64
76.87
202.9
Mar-Ju
5C
Corn
2.56
83.76
214.4
Mar-Juty
'State current crop ending application date or next crop application beginning date for available
receiving crops during 30 day draw down period.
v. Total PAN available for all fields (sum of column t) = 1056.8 lb. PAN
IV. FACILITY'S POA OVERALL PAN BALANCE
w. Total PAN to be land applied (line n from section 11) = 682.4 lb. PAN
PoA (30 Day) 2/21 /00

03/02/2007 FRI 18:01 FAX [phone] WRLNM1 -44 AwQ Wilmington
IA 004/006
x. Crops remaining PAN balance (line v from section ill) _
y. Overall PAN balance (w - x)
1056.8 lb. PAN
.374 lb. PAN
Line y must show as a deficit. If line y does not show as a deficit, list course of action here including pump and
haul, depopulation, herd reduction, etc. For pomp & haul and herd reduction options, recalculate new PAN
based on new information. If new fields are to be included as an option for lowering lagoon level, add these
fields to the PAN balance table and recalculate the overall PAN balance. If animal waste is to be hauled to
another permitted facility, provide information regarding the herd population and lagoon freeboard levels at the
Irrigation onto existing spray fields will continue as weather and field conditions permit. Additional land is
available for pumping if needed.
PoA (30 Day) 2121/00

' 03/02/2007 FRI 18:01 FAX [phone] WRLN11 Hyy DWO Wilmington
Q 005/006
PLAN OF ACTION (PoA) FOR HIGH FREEBOARD AT ANIMAL FACILITIES
30 DAY DRAW DOWN PERIOD
1. TOTAL PAN TO BE LAND APPLIED PER WASTE STRUCTURE
1. Structure Name/Identifier (ID): Batchelor A
2. Current liquid volume in 25 yr.124 hr. storm storage & structural freeboard
a. current liquid level according to marker
18.0 inches
b. designed 25 yr.124 hr. storm & structural freeboard
19.0 inches
c. line b - line a (inches in red zone) =
1.0 inches
d, top of dike surface area according to design
(area at below structural freeboard elevation)
F 93799 R2
e. line cJ12 x line d x 7.48 gallonslif
58468 gallons
3, Projected volume of waste liquid produced during draw down period
f. temporary storage period according to structural design
180 days
g. volume of waste produced according to structural design
232630 ft3
h. current herd # 2035 certified herd #1 2035
actual waste }produced = current herd ;# x line g =
232630 #l3
certified herd #
i. volume of wash water according to structural design ®fe
j. excess rainfall over evaporation according to design 123228 ft3
k. (lines h + i + j) x 7.48 x 30 days/line f= 443636 gallons
4. Total PAN to be land applied during draw down period
I. current waste analysis dated 1 t24120D7 0.88 Ibs11000 gal.
m. ((lines e + k)11000) x line I = 441.9 lbs. PAN
REPEAT SECTION I FOR EACH WASTE STRUCTURE ON SITE.
(Click on the next Structure tab shown below)
PoA (30 Day) 2/21/00

03/02/2007 FRI 18:01 FAX [phone] WRLIXl --DWQ Wilmington IA006/006
PLAN OF ACTION (POA) FOR HIGH FREEBOARD AT ANIMAL FACILITIES
30 DAY DRAW DOWN PERIOD
I. TOTAL PAN TO BE LAND APPLIED PER WASTE STRUCTURE
1. Structure Name/Identifier (ID): Batchelor B
2. Current liquid volume in 25 yr./24 hr. storm storage & structural freeboard
a. current liquid level according to marker 17.fl Inches
b. designed 25 yr./24 hr. storm & structural freeboard 19.0 inches
c. line b - line a (inches in red zone) = 2.0 inches
d. top of dike surface area according to design
(area at below structural freeboard elevation) 1 Q1781 fe
e. line c/12 x line d x 7.48 gallons/ft3 126862 gallons
3. Projected volume of waste liquid produced during draw down period
f. temporary storage period according to structural design 180 days
g. volume of waste produced according to structural design 116315 ft3
h, current herd # 110Q certified herd # 11Qfl
actual waste produced = current herd # x line g =
certified herd #
i. volume of wash water according to structural design
j. excess rainfall over evaporation according to design
k. (lines h + i + j) x 7.48 x 30 days/line f=
4. Total PAN to be land applied during draw down period
1. current waste analysis dated 1 1124120Q7
m. ((lines e + k)/1000) x line 1 =
REPEAT SECTION I FOR EACH WASTE STRUCTURE ON SITE.
(Click on the next Structure tab shown below)
PoA (30 Day) 2/21100
116315 ft3
�ft3
616 i 4 ft3
221818 gallons
0.69 Ibs/1000 gal.
240.6 Ibs. PAN

Waste Management Plan Changes
RECEI�D
lAN 2 2 2007
Facility l_ —S�> Farm
This farms Waste Management Plan has made the following changes:
9 Crop changes
❑ Wetted Acres
❑ Increased Acreage
❑ Decreased Acreage
❑ Changed Irrigation Design
❑ Change in Farm type
❑ Plan based on 3 Years On Farm Records
❑ Other
Comments:
A - % -off
Date

Murphy -Brown, LLC 1/18/2007 2822 Hwy 24 West
P.Q. Box 856
Warsaw, NC 28398
NUTRIENT UTILIZATION PLAN
Grower(s): Murphy -Brown, LLC
Farm Name: Batchelor Farm
Countv: Duolin
Farrow to Wean
2035
Farrow to Feeder
Farrow to Finish
Wean to Feeder
Feeder to Finish
Storage Structure:
Anaerobic
Storage Period:
>180 days
Application Method:
Irrigation
The waste from your animal facility must be land applied at a specked rate to prevent pollution
of surface water and/or groundwater. The plant nutrients in the animal waste should be used
to reduce the amount of commercial fertilizer required for the crops in the fields where the waste
is to be applied.
This waste utilization plan uses nitrogen as the limiting nutrient. Waste should be analyzed
before each application cycle. Annual soil tests are strongly encouraged so that all plant
nutrients can be balanced for realistic yields of the crop to be grown.
Several factors are important in implementing your waste utilization plan in order to maximize
the fertilizer value of the waste and to ensure that it is applied in an environmentally safe manner:
1. Always apply waste based on the needs of the crop to be grown and the nutrient
content of the waste. Do not apply more nitrogen than the crop can utilize.
2. Soil types are important as they have different infiltration rates, leaching potentials,
cation exchange capacities, and available water holding capacities.
3. Normally waste shall be applied to land eroding at less than 5 tons per acre per
year. Waste may be applied to land eroding at 5 or more tons per acre annually, but
less than 10 tons per acre per year providing that adequate filter strips are established.
4. Do not apply waste on saturated soils, when it is raining, or when the surface is frozen.
Either of these conditions may result in runoff to surface waters which is not allowed
under DWQ regulations.
5. Wind conditions should also be considered to avoid drift and downwind odor
problems.
6. To maximize the value of the nutrients for crop production and to reduce the potential
for pollution, the waste should be applied to a growing crop or applied not more than
30 days prior to planting a crop or forages breaking dormancy. Injecting the waste or
disking will conserve nutrients and reduce odor problems.
1 of 8

This plan is based on the waste application method shown above. If you choose to change
methods in the future, you need to revise this plan. Nutrient levels for different application
methods are not the same.
The estimated acres needed to apply the animal waste is based on typical nutrient content
for this type of facility. In some cases you may want to have plant analysis made, which could
allow additional waste to be applied. Provisions shall be made for the area receiving waste to
be flexible so as to accommodate changing waste analysis content and crop type. Lime must
be applied to maintain pH in the optimum range for specific crop production.
This waste utilization plan, if carried out, meets the requirements for compliance with 15A NCAC
2H .0217 adopted by the Environmental Management Commission,
AMOUNT OF WASTE PRODUCED PER YEAR ( gallons, W, tons, etc.):
Capacity Type Waste Produced per Animal Total
2035
Farrow to Wean
3212 gal/yr
6,536,420 gal/yr
Farrow to Feeder
4015 gal/yr
gal/yr
Farrow to Finish
10585 gal/yr
gallyr
Wean to Feeder
223 gaUyr
gal/yr
Feeder to Finish
986 gaUE
gaUyr
Total 6,536,420 gal/yr
AMOUNT OF PLANT AVAILABLE NITROGEN PRODUCED PER YEAR (lbs): `Based on Farm pumping records
Capacity Type Nitrogen Produced per Animal Total
2035
Farrow to Wean
4.72 lbs/yr
9,605 lbs/yr
Farrow to Feeder
6.5 ibslyr
lbs/yr
Farrow to Finish
26 lbs/yr
lbs/yr
Wean to Feeder
0.48 lbs/yr
lbs/yr
Feeder to Finish
2.3 lbs/yr
lbs/yr
Total 9,605 lbs/yr
Applying the above amount of waste is a big job. You should plan time and have appropriate
equipment to apply the waste in a timely manner.
LAND UTILIZATION SUMMARY
The following table describes the nutrient balance and land utilization rate for this facility
Note that the Nitrogen Balance for Crops indicates the ratio of the amount of nitrogen produced
on this facility to the amount of nitrogen that the crops under irrigation may uptake and utilize
in the normal growing season.
Total Irrigated Acreage: 119.54
Total N Required 1 st Year: 27100.55
Total N Required 2nd Year: 23608.4
Average Annual Nitrogen Requirement of Crops: 25,354.48
Total Nitrogen Produced by Farm: 9,605.20
Nitrogen Balance for Crops: (15,749.28)
The following table describes the specifications of the hydrants and fields that contain the crops
designated for utilization of the nitrogen produced on this facility. This chart describes the size,
soil characteristics, and uptake rate for each crop in the specified crop rotation schedule for this
facility.
2 of 8

Reception Area Specifications
Tract Field Irrigated Soil 1st Crop Time to 1st Crop ist Crap Lbs NlAc Lbs N Total Ibs N
Acrea e Type Code Apply Yield Ibs NlUnit Residual lAc Utilized
2nd Crop Time to 2nd Crop 2nd Crop Lbs N1Ae Lbs N Total Ibs N
Code Apply Yield Ibs N1Unit Residual /Ac Utilized
Total'
Lbs NIAc
Total lbs N
Utilized
T1
1
2.92
Foreston
C
Mar -Jul
120.0
1.25
150
438
N
Se t-A r
55
2.4
132
385A4
282
823.44
2
2.71
Foreston
D
Mar -Jul
120.0
1.25
150
406.5
N
Sept -Apr
55
2.4
132
357.72
282
764.22
3
2.69
Foreston
D
Mar -Jul
120.0
1.25
150
403.5
N
Sept -Apr
5EL
2.4
132
355.08
282
758.58
4
2.64
Foreston
D
Mar -Jul
120.0
1.25
150
396
N
Se t-A r
55
2A
132
348.48
282
744.48
5
2.56
Foreston
D
Mar -Jul
120.0
1.25
180
384
N
Sept -Apr
55
2.4
132
337.92
282
721.92
6
2.38
Foreston
D
Mar -Jul
120.0
1.25
150
357
N
Se t-A r
55
1 2.4
132
314.16
282
671.16
7
1 1.69
Foreston
D
Mar -Jul
120.0
1.25
1
150
253.5
N
Sept -Apr
55
2A
132
223.08
282
476.58
B
J 1.85
Autr villo
C
Mar -Set
5.5
50
275
508.76
L
Se t-A r
1
50
50
92.5
325
601.25
9
1.85
Auyyvibe
C
Mar -Set
5.5
50
275
508.75
L
Se t-A r
1
50
50
92.5
325
601.25
10
1.91
Aulryvilla
C
Mar -Set
5.5
50
275
525,25
L
Se t-A r
1
50
5D
95.5
325
620.75
11
1.69
Autryville
C
Mar -Sept
5.5
50
275
464.76
L
Sept -Apr
1
50
50
84.5
325
549.25
12
9.6
Foreston
C
Mar -Sot
6.0
50
300
28M
L
Sept --Apr
1
50
50
480
350
3360
13
8.32
Forestay
C
Mar -Set
6.0
50
300
2496
L
Se t-A r
1 1
50
50
416
350
2912
14
2.34
Foreslon
C
Mar -Sept
6.0
50
300
702
L
Sept -Apr
1
50
1 50
117
1 350
819
subl-7
3.01
Foreston
D
Mar-Jui
120.0
1.25
150
451.5
1 N
Se t-A r
55
2.4
132
397.32
282
848.82
Sub8-11
0.98
Autr ville
C
Mar -Set
5.5
50
275
269.5
L
Sept -Apr
1
50
50
49
325
318.5
sub12-14
6.44
Foreslon
C
Mar -Set
6.0
50
300
1932
L
Sept -Apr
1
50
50
322
350
1 2254
71193
1
33.88
Autryvillu
D
Mar-Jui
85.0
1.25
106.25
3599.75
N
Sept -Apr
45
2A
108
3659.04
214.25
7258.79
4207
5
7.08
Forestcfi
D
Mar -Jul
120.0
1.25
150
1062
N
Sept -Apr
55
1 2.4
132
934.56
282
1996.56
O donal Land
71473
1
11.5
Autr ville
D
Mar -July
65.0
1.25
15
91.25
0
N
Se 1-A r
45
2.4
108
1242
0
0
71473
1
11.5
Autr ville
O
June -Set
30.0
4
0
120
0
0
0
Totals: 119.54 18078.75 10303.8 27100.55
3(a) of 8

Reception Area Specifications
Tract Field Irrigated Soil 1st Crop Time to 1st Crop 1st Crop Lbs NIAc Lbs N Total IbsN
Acreage Type Code Apply Yield Ibs NlUnit Residual IAc Utilized
2nd Crop Time to 2nd Crop 2nd Crop Lbs NlAc Lbs N Total tbs N
Code Appiv Yield fbs N/Unit Residual lAc Utilized
Total
Lbs NlAc
Total Ibs N
Utilized
T1
1
2.92
Foreston
O
Jun -Set
40.0
4
160
467.2
L
Sept -Apr
1
65
15
50
146
210
613.2
2
2,71
Foreston
O
Jun -Set
40,0
4
160
433.6
L
Sept -Apr
1
65
15
50
135.5
210
569.1
3
2,69
Foreston
0
Jun -Set
40.0
4
160
430.4
L
Sept -Apr
1
65
15
50
134.5
210
564.9
4
2.64
Foreston
O
ion -Sept
40.0
4
160
422.4
L
Sept -Apr
1
65
15
50
132
210
554.4
5
2.56
Foreston
O
Jun -Set
40,0
4
160
409.6
L
Sept -Apr
1 1
65
15
50
128
210
537.6
6
2.38
Foreston
O
Jun -Set
40.0
4
160
380.8
L
Sept -Apr
1
65
15
50
119
210
499.8
7
1.69
Foreston
O
Jun -Set
40,0
4
160
270.4
L
Se t-A rM15
15
50
84.5
210
354.9
8
1.85
Aut ille
C
Mar -Set
5.5
50
275
508.75
L
Sept -Apr
50
92.5
325
601.25
9
1.85
Au vile
C
Mar -Set
5.5
50
275
508,75
L
Se t-A r
50
92.5
325
601.25
10
1.91
Autr ville
C
Mar -Set
5.5
50
275
525.25
L
Sept -Apr
50
95.5
325
620.75
11
1.69
Autr ville
C
Mar -Set
5.5
50
275
464.75
L
Sept -Apr
50
84.5
325
549.25
12
9.6
Foreston
C
Mar -Set
6.0
50
300
2880
L
Sept -Apr
50
480
350
3360
13
8.32
Foreston
C
Mar -Set
6.0
50
300
2496
L
Se t-A r
50
416
350
2912
14
2.34
Foreston
C
Mar -Set
6.0
50
300
702
L
Sept -Apr
1
50
50
117
350
819
sub-1-7
3.01
Foreston
O
Jun -Set
40.0
4
160
481.6
L
Se t-A r
1
65
15
50
150.5
210
632.1
sub8-11
0.98
Autr ille
C
Mar -Set
5.5
50
275
269.5
L
Sept -Apr
1
50
50
49
325
318.5
sub12.14
6.44
Foreston
C
Mar -Set
6.0
50
300
1932
L
Sept -Apr
1
50
50
322
350
2254
71193
1
33.68
Aulr villa
O
Jun -Set
3C.0
4
120
4065.6
L
Sept -Apr
1
65
15
50
1694
170
5759.E
4207
5
7.08
Foreston
0
Jun -Set
40.0
4
160
1132.8
L
Sept -Apr
1
65
15
50
354
210
1486.8
If small
rain hay is not oianled behind soybeans,
deduct 15 lb residual from corn,
Tofals: 96.54 16781.4 4827 23608.4
3(b) of 8

This plan does not include commercial fertilizer. The farm should produce adequate plant
available nitrogen to satisfy the requirements of the crops listed above.
The applicator is cautioned that P and K may be over applied while meeting the N requirements.
In the future, regulations may require farmers in some parts of North Carolina to have a nutrient
management plan that addresses all nutrients. This plan only addresses nitrogen.
In interplanted fields ( i.e. small grain, etc, interseeded in bermuda), forage must be removed
through grazing, hay, and/or silage. Where grazing, plants should be grazed when they
reach a height of six to nine inches. Cattle should be removed when plants are grazed to a
height of four inches. In fields where small grain, etc, is to be removed for hay or silage, care
should be exercised not to let small grain reach maturity, especially late in the season (i.e.
April or May). Shading may result if small grain gets too high and this will definately interfere
with stand of bermudagrass. This loss of stand will result in reduced yields and less nitrogen
being utilized. Rather than cutting small grain for hay or silage just before heading as is
the normal situation, you are encouraged to cut the small grain earlier. You may want to
consider harvesting hay or silage two to three times during the season, depending on the
time small grain is planted in the fall.
The ideal time to interplant small grain, etc, is late September or early October. Drilling is
recommended over broadcasting. Bermudagrass should be grazed or cut to a height of
about two inches before drilling for best results.
CROP CODE LEGEND
Crop Code Crop
A
Barley
B
Hybrid Bermudagrass - Grazed
C
Hybrid Bermudagrass - Hay
D
Corn - Grain
E
Corn - Silage
F
Cotton
G
Fescue- Grazed
H
Fescue - Hay
I
Oats
J
Rye
K
Small Grain - Grazed
L
Small Grain - Hay
M
Grain Sorghum
N
Wheat
O
Soybean
P
Pine Trees
Lbs N utilized / unit yield
1.6 lbs N 1 bushel
50 lbs N 1 ton
50 lbs N / ton
1.25 lbs N / bushel
12 lbs N / ton
0.12 lbs N / lbs lint
50 lbs N / ton
50 lbs N 1 ton
1.3 lbs N 1 bushel
2.4 lbs N 1 bushel
50 lbs N 1 acre
50 lbs N 1 acre
2.5 lbs N 1 cwt
2.4 lbs N 1 bushel
4.0 lbs N 1 bushel
40 lbs N 1 acre / yr
Acres shown in the preceding table are considered to be the usable acres excluding
required buffers, filter strips along ditches, odd areas unable to be irrigated, and perimeter areas
not receiving full application rates due to equipment limitations. Actual total acres in the fields
listed may, and most likely will be, more than the acres shown in the tables.
See attached map showing the fields to be used for the utilization of animal waste.
4 of 8

SLUDGE APPLICATION:
The following table describes the annual nitrogen accumulation rate per animal
in the lagoon sludge
Farm Specifications PANT r/animal Farm Total/ r
2035 Farrow to Wean 0.84 1709.4
Farrow to Feeder 1
Farrow to Finish 4.1
Wean to Feeder 0.072
Feeder to Finish 0.36
The waste utilization plan must contain provisions for periodic land application of sludge at
agronomic rates. The sludge will be nutrient rich and will require precautionary measures to
prevent over application of nutrients or other elements. Your production facility will produce
approximately 1709.4 pounds of plant available nitrogen per year will accumulate in the lagoon
sludge based on the rates of accumulation listed above.
If you remove the sludge every 5 years, you will have approximately 8547 pounds of plant
available nitrogen to utilize. Assuming you apply this PAN to hybrid bermuda grass hayland at the
rate of 300 pounds of nitrogen per acre, you will need 28 acreas of land. If you apply the sludge
to corn at a rate of 125 pounds per acre, you will need 68.376 acres of land. Please note that these
are only estimates of the PAN produced and the land required to utilize that PAN. Actual values
may only be determined by sampling the sludge for plant available nitrogen content prior to application
Actual utilization rates will vary with soil type, crop, and realistic yield expectations for the specific
application fields designated for sludge application at time of removal.
APPLICATION OF WASTE BY IRRIGATION:
The irrigation application rate should not exceed the intake rate of the soil at the time of irrigation
such that runoff or ponding occurs. This rate is limited by initial soil moisture content, soil
structure, soil texture, water droplet size, and organic solids. The application amount should not
exceed the available water holding capacity of the soil at the time of irrigation nor should the
plant available nitrogen applied exceed the nitrogen needs of the crop.
If surface irrigation is the method of land application for this plan, it is the responsibility of the
producer and irrigation designer to ensure that an irrigation system is installed to properly
irrigate the acres shown in the preceding table. Failure to apply the recommended rates and
amounts of nitrogen shown in the tables may make this plan invalid.
"This is the maximum application amount allowed for the soil assuming the amount
of nitrogen allowed for the crop is not over applied. In many situations, the application
amount shown cannot be applied because of the nitrogen limitation. The Maximum
application amount shown can be applied under optimum soil conditions.
Your facility is designed for >180 days of temporary storage and the temporary storage must
be removed on the average of once every 6 months. In no instance should the volume of the
waste stored in your structure be within the 25 year 24 hour storm storage or one foot of
freeboard except in the event of the 25 year 24 hour storm.
It is the responsibility of the producer and waste applicator to ensure that the spreader equipment
is operated properly to apply the correct rates to the acres shown in the tables. Failure to apply
the recommended rates and amounts of nitrogen shown in the tables may make this plan invalid.
Call your technical specialist after you receive the waste analysis report for assistance in
determining the amount of waste per acre and the proper application prior to applying the waste.
611IMS ]

Application Rate Guide
The following is provided as a guide for establishing application rates and amounts.
Soil
Application Rate
Application Amount
_ Tract
Hydrant
Type
Crop
inthr
* inches
T1
1
'Foreston
D
0.5
1
2
Foreston
D
0.5
1
3
Foreston
D
0.5
1
4
Foreston
D
0.5
1
5
Foreston
D
0.5
1
6
Foreston
D
0.5
1
7
Foreston
D
0.5
1
8
Autryville
C
0.6
1
9
Autryville
C
0.6
1
10
Autryville
C
0.6
1
11
Autryville
C
0.6
1
12
Foreston
C
0.5
1
13
Foreston
C
0.5
1
14
Foreston
C
0.5
1
subl-7
Foreston
D
0.5
1
sub8-11
Autryville
C
0.6
1
sub12-14
Foreston
C
0.5
1
71193
1
Autryville
D
0.6
1
4207
5
Foreston
D
0.5
1
)ptional Lan
71473 1 Autryville D 0.6
71473 1 Autryville O 0.6
6 of 8

Additional Comments:
Subfield acreage is the balance of the total field acres minus wet acres
at this site. This acreage will be claimed when making application with an
aerway machine.
Tracts 71193 and 4207 are leased land. This land is optional for this plan and
application to the acreage will be made with an aerway.
Small grain hay behind soybeans is optional for all fields.
T71473 has been leased for a three year period beginning Fall 2006 and
is optional for use. Any of the crops listed may be grown. This land will
be applied to using an aerway type applicator.
7 of 8

NUTRIENT UTILIZATION PLAN CERTIFICATION
Name of Farm: Batchelor Farm
Owner: Murphy -Brown, LLC
Manager:
Owner/Manager Agreement:
Ilwe understand and will follow and implement the specifications and the operation and
maintenance procedures established in the approved animal waste nutrient management
plan for the farm named above. I/we know that any expansion to the existing design capacity
of the waste treatment and/or storage system, or construction of new facilities, will require a
new nutrient management plan and a new certification to be submitted to DWQ before the new
animals are stocked.
Ilwe understand that I must own or have access to equipment, primarily irrigation equipment,
to land apply the animal waste described in this nutrient management plan. This equipment
must be available at the appropriate pumping time such that no discharge occurs from the lagoon
in the event of a 25 year 24 hour storm. I also certify that the waste will be applied on the land
according to this plan at the appropriate times and at rates which produce no runoff.
This plan will be filed on site at the farm office and at the office of the local Soil and Water
Conservation District and will be available for review by NCDWQ upon request.
Name of Facility Owner:
Signature:
Murphy -Brown, LLC
•
Name of Manager (if different from owner):
Signature:
Name of Technical Specialist: Amy E. Roberson
Affiliation: Murphy -Brown, LLC.
Address: 2822 Hwy 24 West, PO Drawer 856
Warsaw. NC 28398
Telephone: [phone]
o=i
Date
Date
Signature: ► �� ��
Date
8of8

NUTRIENT UTILIZATION PLAN
REQUIRED SPECIFICATIONS
Animal waste shall not reach surface waters of the state by runoff, drift, manmade
conveyances, direct application, or direct discharge during operation or land application.
Any discharge of waste which reaches surface water is prohibited.
2 There must be documentation in the design folder that the producer either owns or has an
agreement for use of adequate land on which to properly apply the waste. If the producer
does not own adequate land to properly dispose of the waste, he/she shall provide
evidence of an agreement with a landowner, who is within a reasonable proximity,
allowing him/her the use of the land for waste application. It is the responsibility of the
owner of the waste production facility to secure an update of the Nutrient Utilization Plan
when there is a change in the operation, increase in the number of animals, method of
application, recievinq crop type, or available land.
3 Animal waste shall be applied to meet, but not exceed, the nitrogen needs for realistic crop
yields based upon soil type, available moisture, historical data, climatic conditions, and
level of management, unless there are regulations that restrict the rate of applications for
other nutrients.
4 Animal waste shall be applied to land eroding less than 5 tons per acre per year. Waste
may be applied to land eroding at more than 5 tons per acre per year but less than 10 tons
per acre per year provided grass filter strips are installed where runoff leaves the field (See
USDA, NRCS Field Office Technical Guide Standard 393 - Filter Strips).
i 5 Odors can be reduced by injecting the waste or disking after waste application. Waste
should not be applied when there is danger of drift from the land application field.
When animal waste is to be applied on acres subject to flooding, waste will be soil
incorporated on conventionally tilled cropland. When waste is applied to conservation tilled
crops or grassland, the waste may be broadcast provided the application does not occur
during a season prone to flooding (See "Weather and Climate in North Carolina" for
guidance).
Liquid waste shall be applied at rates not to exceed the soil infiltration rate such that runoff
does not occur offsite or to surface waters and in a method which does not cause drift
from the site during application. No ponding should occur in order to control odor and flies.
8 Animal waste shall not be applied to saturated soils, during rainfall events, or when the
surface is frozen.
1 of 3

NUTRIENT UTILIZATION PLAN
REQUIRED SPECIFICATIONS
(continued)
17 A protective cover of appropriate vegetation will be established on all disturbed areas
(lagoon embankments, berms, pipe runs, etc.). Areas shall be fenced, as necessary, to
protect the vegetation. Vegetation such as trees, shrubs, and other woody species, etc.,
are limited to areas where considered appropriate. Lagoon areas should be kept mowed
and accessible. Berms and structures should be inspected regularly for evidence of
erosion, leakage, or discharge.
18 If animal production at the facility is to be suspended or terminated, the owner is
responsible for obtaining and implementing a "closure plan" which will eliminate the
possibility of an illegal discharge, pollution and erosion.
19 Waste handling structures, piping, pumps, reels, etc., should be inspected on a regular
basis to prevent breakdowns, leaks and spills. A regular maintenance checklist should be
kept on site.
20 Animal waste can be used in a rotation that includes vegetables and other crops for direct
human consumption. However, if animal waste is used on crops for direct human
consumption, it should only be applied pre -plant with no further applications of animal
waste during the crop season.
21 Highly visible markers shall be installed to mark the top and bottom elevations of the
temporary storage (pumping volume) of all waste treatment lagoons. Pumping shall be
managed to maintain the liquid level between the markers. A marker will be required to
mark the maximum storage volume for waste storage ponds.
22 Waste shall be tested within 60 days of utilization and soil shall be tested at least annually
at crop sites where waste products are applied. Nitrogen shall be the rate -determining
nutrient, unless other restrictions require waste to be applied based on other nutrients,
resulting in a lower application rate than a nitrogen based rate. Zinc and copper levels in
the soil shall be monitored and alternative crop sites shall be used when these metals
approach excessive levels. pH shall be adjusted and maintained for optimum crop
production. Soil and waste analysis records shall be kept for a minimum of five years.
Poultry dry waste application records shall be maintained for a minimum of three years.
Waste application records for all other waste shall be maintained for a minimum of five
years.
23 Dead animals will be disposed of in a manner that meets North Carolina regulations.
3of3

OF WArFR Michael F. Easley, Governor
O� pG William G. Ross Jr., Secretary
North Carolina Department of Environment and Natural_ Resources
j Alan W. Klimek, P. E., Director
Division of Water Quality
May 1, 2003
Murphy Family Farms
Batchelor Sow Farm
PO Box 759
Rose Hill NC 28458
Subject: Certificate of Coverage No. AWS310563
Batchelor Sow Farm
Swine Waste Collection, Treatment,
Storage and Application System
Duplin County
Dear Murphy Family Farms:
On April 28, 2003, the North Carolina General Assembly ratified Senate Bill 733 which directs the
Division of Water Quality (Division) to extend the.expiration.date.of the -Swine Waste Operation General
Permit AWG100000. Therefore, the General Permit has been re -issued by the Division to extend the
expiration date to October 1, 2004. During the period of this extension the Division will be working with
all interested parties on the development of a new version of the Non -Discharge General Permit.
In accordance with your application received on February 13, 2003 and in accordance with the directive
of Senate Bill 733, we are hereby forwarding to you this Certificate of Coverage (COC) issued to
Murphy Family Farms, authorizing the operation of the subject animal waste collection, treatment,
storage and land application system in accordance with General Permit AWG100000. The issuance of
this COC supercedes and terminates your previous COC Number AWS310563 which expired on April
30, 2003.
This approval shall consist of the operation of this system including, but not limited to, the management
of animal waste from the Batchelor Sow Farm, located in Duplin County, with an animal capacity of no
greater than an annual average of 2035 Farrow to Wean swine and the application to land as specified in
the facility's Certified Animal Waste Management Plan (CAWMP). If this is a Farrow to Wean or
Farrow to Feeder operation, there may also be one boar for each 15 sows. Where boars are unneccessary,
they may be replaced by an equivalent number of sows. Any of the sows may be replaced by gilts at a
rate of 4 gilts for every 3 sows
The COC shall be effective from the date of issuance until October 1, 2004.. Pursuant to this COC, you
are authorized and required to operate the system in conformity with the conditions and limitations as
specified in the General Permit, the facility's CAWMP, and this COC. An adequate system for collecting
and maintaining the required monitoring data and operational information must be established for this
facility. Any increase in waste production greater than the certified design capacity or increase in number
of animals authorized by this COC (as provided above) will require a modification to the CAWMP and
this COC and must be completed prior to actual increase in either wastewater flow or number of animals.
If your Waste Utilization Plan has been developed based on site specific information, careful evaluation
of future samples is necessary. Should your records show that the current Waste Utilization Plan is
inaccurate you will need to have a new Waste Utilization Plan developed.
The issuance of this COC does not excuse the Permittee from the obligation to comply with all applicable
laws, rules, standards, and ordinances (local, state, and federal), nor does issuance of a COC to to
P er-this permit convey any property rights in either real or personal property.
ENR
Non -Discharge Permitting Unit
1617 Mail Service Center, Raleigh, NC 27699-1617
Customer Service Center
An Equal opportunity Action Employer
Internet httpJ/h2o.enr.state.nc.us/ndpu
Telephone [phone] Fax [phone]
Telephone [phone]
50% recycled/10% post -consumer paper

Upon abandonment or depopulation for a period of four years or more, the Permittee must submit
documentation to the Division demonstrating that all current NRCS standards are met prior to restocking
of the facility.
Per NRCS standards a 100 foot separation shall be maintained between water supply wells and any
lagoon or any wetted area of a spray field.
Please be advised that any violation of the terms and conditions specified in this COC, the General Permit
or the CAWMP may result in the revocation of this COC, or penalties in accordance with NCGS 143-
215.6A through 143-215.6C including civil penalties, criminal penalties, and injunctive relief.
If you Oish to continue the activity permitted under the General Permit after the expiration date of the
General Permit, an application for renewal must be filed at least I80 days prior to expiration.
This COC is not automatically transferable. A name/ownership change application must be submitted to
the Division prior to a name change or change in ownership.
If any parts, requirements, or limitations contained in this COC are unacceptable, you have the right to
apply for an individual permit by contacting the staff member listed below for information on this
process. Unless such a request is made within 30 days, this COC shall be final and binding.
This facility is located in a county covered by our Wilmington Regional Office. The Regional Office
Water Quality Staff may be reached -at (910)-395-3900. If you need additional information concerning
this COC or the General Permit, please contact Sue Homewood at [phone] ext. 502.
Sincerely,
v
for Alan W. Klimek, P.E.
Enclosures (General Permit AWGI00000)
cc: (Certificate of Coverage only for all cc's)
Wilmington Regional Office, Water Quality Section
Duplin County Health Department
Duplin County Soil and Water Conservation District
Permit File AWS310563
NDPU Files

�1ar. ze, '�;LOCa. 31-5ca3
PRODUCER: - Batchldr Farm
LOCATION: P4 Box 759
Rose Hill, NC 28+458
TELEPHONE: [phone]
TYPE OPERATION: Farrow - wean
NUM13ER OF ANIMALS: 2035
(Design Capacity)
The waste from your animal facility must be land applied at a specified rate to prevent pollution
of surface and/or groundwater. The plant nutrients in the animal waste should be used to
reduce the amount of commercial fertilizer required for the crops in the fields where the waste
is to be applied. This waste utilization plan uses nitrogen as the limiting nutrient. Waste
should be analyzed before each application cycle. Annual soil tests are strongly encouraged
so that all plant nutrients can be balanced for realistic yields of the crop to be grown.
Several factors are important in implementing your waste utilization plan in order to maAmize
the fertilizer value of the waste and to ensure that it is applied In an environmentally safe
manner. Always apply waste based on the needs of the crop to be- grown and the nutrient
content of the waste. Do not apply more nitrogen than the crop can utilize. Soil types are
important as they have different infiltration rates, leaching potentials, cation exchange
capacities, and available water holding capacities. Normally waste shall not be applied to land
eroding at greater than 5 tons per acre per year. With special precautions, waste may be
applied to land eroding at up to 10 tons per year. Do not apply waste on saturated soils, when
it is raining, or when the surface is frozen. Either of these conditions may result in runoff to
surface waters which is not allowed under DEM regulations. Wind conditions should also be
considered to avoid drift and downwind odor problems. To maximize the value of nutrients for
crop production and to reduce the potential for pollution, the waste should be applied to a
growing crop or applied to bare ground not more than 30 days prior to planting, Injecting the
waste or disking will conserve nutrients and reduce odor problems.
The estimated acres needed to apply the animal waste is based on typical nutrient content for
this type of facility. Acreage requirements should be based on the waste analysis report from
your waste management facility. Attached you will find infortnation on proper sampling
techniques, preparation, and transfer of Waste samples to the lab for analysis.
This waste utilization plan, if carried out meets the requirements for compliance with 15A
NCAC 2H.0217 adopted by the Environmental Management Commission.
Page 1

mount of YVaste Produced Per Year, (gallons, ft. tons. etc.i
2,035 animals X AM (tons) waste/animal/year =
Amount of Plant Available Nitrogen (PAN) Produced Per Year
2,035 animals X 5,A lbs. PAN/animal/year =
Guide Std. 633)
12,393 (tons) wastelyear.
10,989 tbs. PAN/year. (PAN from N.C.
Tech
Applying the above amount of waste is a big job. You should plan time and have appropriate
equipment to apply the waste in a timely manner
The following acreage will be needed for waste application based on the crop to be grown and
surface application:
Table 7: ACRES OWNED BY PRODUCER
Tract Field Soil Crop Lbs. N Acres Lbs. N Month of
# No. Type Per Acre Utilized Application
T1
1
Fo
Wheat
110
17.59
1,934.00
Sept -April
T1
1
Fo
Soybeans
120
17.59
2,110.80
June -Sept
T1
3
Fo
Bermuda (H)
300
20.26
6,078.00
March - Oct
T1
2
AuB / FOA
Bermuda (H)
287.5
7.30
2,098.75
March - Oct
"*OPTIONAL*
2
AuB / FoA
Small Grain (G)
50
7.30
365.00
Sept -April
Total ( 45.151 12,222.45_j
`This N is from animal waste only. if nutrients from other sources such as commercial fertilizer are
applied, they must be accounted for.
NOTE: The applicator is cautioned that P and K may be over applied while meeting the N
requirements. Beginning in 1996 the Coastal Zone Management Act will require farmers In some
eastern counties of North Caroline to have a nutrient management plan that addresses all nutrients.
This plan only addresses Nitrogen.
Page 2

Table 2. ACRES WITH AGREEMENT OR LONG TERM LEASE
(Agreement with adjacent landowner must be attached)
(Required only If operator does not own adequate land (see
Required Specification 21)
bract Field Soil Crop Lbs. N Acres Lbs. N Month of
# No. Type Per Acre* Utilized Application
See footnote for Table 1.
Totals from above Tables
Acres Lbs. N
Utilized
Table 1 45.15 12,222
Table 2
Total 45.15 12,222
Amount of N Produced 10,989
Surplus or Deficit (1,233)
NOTE. The Waste Utilization Plan must contain provisions for periodic land application of sludge at
agronomic rates. The sludge will be nutrient rich and will require precautionary measures to prevent over
application of nutrient or other elements.
Page 3

':i'.i K"IX is+:ii "•:i a+.+,:': t Kt Wii a%tnK F•::. K:t•:i..v •:iiiG�tiRitt ti:iii'i�i1k{i"::`:L;: iiiit}::2i•:++•:t•i:.z:r{.:i.:ttt:::j.:.+:Lr �:i:+:i.v tiiLv:vii.•i4 ;..•�w0' i\Kritiii'
Ott.. n.;::,:..}t• . §' ,�.Lv
See attached map showing the fields to be used for the utilization of waste water.
Application of Waste by Irrigation
Field Soil Type Crop Application Application
No. Rate "F Amount In.
1
FOA
Row Crops
0A
.5-1.0
2,3
AUB/FoA
Bermuda
0.5
.5-1.0
THIS TABLE IS NOT NEEDED IF WASTE IS NOT BEING APPLIED BY IRRIGATION, HOWEVER A SIMILAR TABLE WILL
BE NEEDED FOR DRY LITTER OR SLURRY.
Your facility is designed for 180 days of temporary storage and the temporary storage must
be removed on the average of once every 6 MONTHS. In no instance should the volume of
waste being stored in your structure exceed Elevation "see lagoon design.
Call the local Natural Resources Conservation Service (formerly Soil Conservation Service) or Soil
and Water Conservation District office after you receive the waste analysis report for assistance in
determining the amount per acre to apply and the proper application rate prior to applying the
waste.
Narrative of operation; Acres shown are "wetted" acres. Residual Soybean PAN taken from
wheat crop. Small grain overseed in field 2 is optional.
Page 4

REQUIRED SPECIFICATIONS
Animal waste shall not reach surface waters of the state by runoff, drift, manmade
conveyances, direct application, or direct discharge during operation or land application.
Any discharge of waste which reaches surface water is prohibited.
2 There must be documentation In the design folder that the producer either owns or has
an agreement for use of adequate land on which to property apply the waste. If the
producer does not own adequate land to property dispose of waste, he/she shall provide
a copy of an agreement with a landowner who Is within a reasonable proximity, allowing
himther the use of the land for waste application. It is the responsibility of the owner of
the facility to secure an update of the Waste Utilization Plan when there is a change in
the operation, Increase in the number of animals, method of utilization, or available land.
3 Animal waste shall be applied to meet, but not exceed. the nitrogen needs for realistic
crop yields based on soil type, available moisture, historical data, climatic conditions, and
level of management, unless there are regulations that restrict the rate of application for
other nutrients.
4 Animal waste shall be applied to land eroding _less than 5 tons per acre per year. Waste
may be applied to land that is eroding at 5 or more tons, but less than 10 tons per acre
per year providing grass filter strips are installed where runoff leaves the field. (See
FOTG Standard 393 - Filter Strip).
5 Odors can be reduced by injecting the waste or disking after waste application. Waste
should not be applied when there is danger of drift from the irrigation field.
6 When animal waste is to be applied on acres subject to flooding, it will be soil
incorporated on conventionally tilled cropland. When applied to conservation tilled crops
or grassland, the waste may be broadcast provided the application does not occur during
a season prone to flooding. (See "Weather and Climate In North Carolina" for guidance.)
7 . Liquid waste shall be applied at rates not to exceed the soil infiltration rate such that
runoff does not occur offsite or to surface waters and in a method which does not cause
drift from the site during application. No ponding should occur In order to control odor or
files.
8 .Animal waste shall riot be applied to saturated soils, during rainfall events, or when the
surface is frozen.
Pap 5

REQUIRED SPECIFICATIONS
(continued)
17 A protective cover of appropriate vegetation will be established on all disturbed areas
gagoon embankments, berms, pipe runs, etc.). Areas shall be fenced as necessary to
protect the vegetation. Vegetation such as trees, shrubs, and other woody species, etc.,
are limited to areas where considered appropriate. Lagoon areas should be kept mowed
and accessible. Berms and structures should be inspected regularly for evidence of
erosion, leakage or discharge.
18 If animal production at the facility is to be suspended or terminated, the owner is
responsible for obtaining and implementing a "closure plan" which will eliminate the
possibility of an illegal discharge, pollution and erosion.
19 Waste handling structures, piping pumps, reels, etc., should be inspected on a regular
basis to prevent breakdowns, leaks and spills. A regular maintenance checklist should
be kept on site.
20 Animal waste can be used in a rotation that includes vegetables and other crops for
direct human consumption. However, if animal waste is used on crops for direct human
consumption -it should only be applied pre -plant with no further applications - anima! waste
during the crop season.
21 Highly visible markers shall be installed to mark the top and bottom elevations of the
temporary storage (pumping volume) of all waste treatment lagoons. Pumping shall be
managed to maintain the liquid level between the markers. A marker will be required to
mark the maximum storage volume for waste storage ponds.
22 Waste shalt be tested within 60 days of utilization and soil shall be tested at least
annually at crop sites where waste products are applied. Nitrogen shall be the rate -
determining element. Zinc and copper levels in the soil shall be monitored and
aitemative crop sites shall be used when these metal approach excessive levels. pH
shall be adjusted for optimum crop production and maintained. Soil and waste analysis
records shall be kept for five years. Poultry dry waste application records shall be
maintained for three (3) years. Waste application records for all other waste shall be
maintained for rive (5) years.
23 Dead animals will be disposed of in a manner that meets North Carolina regulations.
Page 7

.WSTE LJT1LgUQN PLAN AC2REMENT
Name of Penn: @atchlor Farm
Owner/ ManagerAgm menf
1 (we) understand and will follow and implement the specifications and the operation and
maintenance procedures established In the approved animal waste utilization plan for the
farm named above. I (we) know that any expansion to the existing design capacity of the
waste treatment and storage system or construction of new facilities will require a new
certification to be submitted to the Division of Environment Management (DEM) before
the new animals are stocked. I (we) also understand that there must be no discharge of
animal waste from this system to surface waters of the state from a storm event less
severe than the 25-year, 24hour storm. The approved plan will be filed on -site at the
farm office and at the office of the local Sall and Water Conservation District and will be
available for review by DEM upon request.
Name qf-rility Owner. Murphy Farms, LLC T
(Ploaae p nU
Signature- Date: /
Name /anager pf different from owner): s k
Signature: Date:
Name of Technical Specialist: (Please pdno Kraig A. Westerbeek
Affiliation: Mu h Family -Farms
Address ()
Signature:
v 4ttV V

PAN APPLICATION SUMMARY
BATCHLOR FARM
DUPLIN COUNTY
199g
Bermuda
Pull #
Acres
PAN App.
Total
1
2.92
116.63
337.6
2
2.71
183.43
497.1
3
2.69
124.82
335.8
4
2.64
151.16
399.0
5
2.56
130.7
334.6
6
2.38
85.56
203.6
7
1.69
96.12
162.4
8
1.85
20.6
38.1
9
1.85
59.89
110,8
10
1.91
24.6
47.0
11
1.69
20.8
35.2
12
1.58
26.6
42.0
13
1.03
25.8
42.1
14
1.69
24.9
42.1
15
2.23
61.9
138,0
16
3.67
99.7
365.9
17
3.41
252.87
862.3
18
3.45
134.67
464.6
Total = . 4458.2
MOM
Bermuda
Small Grain
Pull #
Acres
PAN App.
Total
1-1
2.92
88.6
258.42
1-2
2.71
65
170.16
1-3
2,69
90.6
243.714
1-4
2.04
48.2
127.249
1-5
2.68
48.3
123.648
1-6
2.3a
20.2
62.350
1-7
1.69
11.8
19.942
3-2A
1.69
46.6
78.754
3-28
2.23
47.9
106.817
3-3
3.67
40,4
148.268
3-4
3.41
65.3
222.673
3-5
3,45
70.4
242.80
Total = 1810.87
Total 1999 - 6269.1
Small Grain
Pull
Acreage
PAN App
Total
Pull
Acreage
PAN App
Total
1
2.92
285.9
834.8
1
2.92
144.4
421.6
2
2.71
169
458.0
2
2.71
76.3
206.8
3
2.69
217.9
$86.2
3
2.69
$3.1
223.5
4
2.64
278.9
736.3
4
2.64
53.9
142.3
5
2.56
254.7
652.0
5
2.56
110,8
283.1
6
2.38
145.7
30.8
6
2.38
11.6
27.6
7
1.69
13.34
22.6
7
1.69
0
0.0
6
1.65
21
38.9
8
1.85
0
0.0
9
1.86
59.8
110.0
9
1.85
0
0.0
10
1.91
90.6
173.0
10
1,01
25
47.8
11
1.69
16.3
27.5
11
1.69
0
0.0
31A
1.58
11.8
18.8
31A
1.56
26.8
42.3
31113
1.63
78.1
127.3
31 B
1.03
0
0.0
32A
1.69
196
331.2
32A
1.69
26.1
44.1
328
2.23
178.1
397.2
32B
2.23
7.4
16.5
33
3.67
120.4
441.9
33
3.67
29.7
109.0
34
3.41
284.E
070.5
34
3.41
36.5
121.1

35
3.45
206
707.3
38
.3.48
88.9
309.4
Total
7290.0
Total 2000 PAN
90T7.2
M II
Bermuda
Pull #
Ades
PAN App.
Total
1
2.92
287.4
839.2
2
2.71
269
729.0
3
2.89
190.8
513.3
4
2.64
261.8
091.2
5
2.66
346.7
887.6
8
2.38
153.2
384.8
7
1.69
130.1
219.9
8
1.85
121
223.9
9
1.85
41.6
77.0
10
1.91
211.7
404.3
11
1.69
19.7
33.3
31 A
1.58
87
137.6
318
1.63
133.2
225.3
32A
1.69
109.1
184.4
328
2.23
120.8
269.4
33
3.67
293.3
1076.4
34
3.41
294.2
1003.2
35
3.46
200.5
$91.7
36
3.48
55.5
193.1
Total =
8764.1
2001 PAN
Total =
9380.1
m
35 3.45 29.4 101.4
36 3.48 0 0.0
Total = 1787.2
Small Grain
Pull #
Acres
PAN App,
Total
1
2.92
27.2
79A
2
2.71
0
0.0
3
2.69
28.5
76.7
4
2.64
0
0.0
5
2.56
0
0.0
6
2.38
0
0.0
7
1.69
0
0.0
$
1.85
0
0.0
9
1.35
0
0.0
10
1.91
0
0,0
11
1.69
0
0.0
31
9.6
38.2
366.7
32
8.32
11.2
93.2
33
2.34
0
0,0
Total = 816.0

April 16, 2003
CERTIFIED MAIL
RETURN RECEIPT REQUESTED
Murphy Family Farms
PO Box 759
Rose Hill NC 28458
SUBJECT: Notice of Violation
Request for Information
Inadequate Freeboard
Batchelor Sow Farm
#31-563
Duplin County
Dear Sir or Madam:
Michael F. Easley
Governor
William G. Ross Jr., Secretary
Department of Environment and Natural Resources
Alan W. Klimek, P.E. Director
Division of Water Quality
On March 20, 2003, a representative of your animal operation informed the Division of
Water Quality (DWQ) that there was inadequate freeboard in the lagoon(s) serving this facility.
This lack of adequate freeboard is in non-compliance with the Certificate of Coverage
issued to this facility on August 25, 1997. In addition to this Notice of Violation (NOV), this
non-compliance is subject to an appropriate enforcement action by DWQ. This action can
consist of one or more of the following: a civil or criminal enforcement action; an injunction;
and/or a requirement to apply for coverage under an individual permit. The action chosen will
be based on complete evaluation of all factors that resulted in the inadequate freeboard; the
actions taken to restore the needed freeboard; and the actions being proposed to prevent the
problem from reoccurring.
To assist us in our review, please provide the Wilmington Regional Office with an
evaluation of the reasons for the freeboard violation(s) and a strategy to prevent future freeboard
violation(s). This evaluation and strategy must include but is not limited to the following:
Current Freeboard level(s)
Freeboard level records in the lagoon(s) for the past •12 months up to the date of submittal
Spraying records for the past 12 months up to the date of submittal
NDENR
Customer Service. Mailing Address: Telephone (919) 733-SOM Location:
1-877-623-6748 1617 Mail Service Center Fax [phone] N. Salisbury St.
Raleigh, North Carolina 27699-1617 State Courier #52-01-01 Raleigh, NC 27699-1617
An Equal Opportunity/Affirmative Action Employer
50% recycled/ 10% post -consumer paper
h ttpl/h2o. en r. state. nc. us

Inadequate Freeboard
Page 2
Rainfall records for the past 12 months for this site up to the date of submittal (if
available)
Cropping system and PAN specified in the CAWMP. If the cropping system was not in
compliance with the facility's CAWMP, provide details of the cropping system in place
for the past 12 months.
A summary of actions taken to restore the needed freeboard in the lagoon(s) including but
not limited to removal of animals from the site, delay of restocking of animals, pumping
and hauling waste to another site (specify site), securing additional irrigation equipment,
and securing additional spray sites.
A description of water conservation measures in use at the facility and the date(s)
installed.
If the lagoon level(s) are still in violation of the facility's CAWMP and Permit, provide
an updated Plan of Action as to how the facility will return to compliance.
Provide a detailed description of the actions taken or proposed to be taken to insure that
there are no further freeboard violations at this facility.
This information must be received by the Wilmington Regional Office at the following
address no later than 10 days following receipt of this letter.
Division of Water Quality
127 Cardinal Drive Extension
Wilmington, NC 28405-2845
Once this information is received and evaluated by the DWQ staff, a determination will
be made as to the appropriate compliance/enforcement actions to be taken. Each case will be
evaluated on its own merit. The efforts by the owner/producer to notify DWQ of the problem,
efforts made to resolve the problem once identified, and efforts proposed to prevent future
problems will be positive factors in this determination.
Nothing in this letter should be taken as removing from you either the responsibility or
liability for this non-compliance or future cases of non-compliance. If you have any questions
regarding this letter, please do not hesitate to contact our Wilmington Regional Office Staff at
[phone].
Sincerely,
��
Alan W. Klimek, P.E.
Director
cc: Wilmington Regional Office
Non -Discharge Compliance/Enforcement Unit
Central Files

t
Murphy -Brown LLC
PO Drawer 856
2822 Hwy. 24 West
Warsaw, NC 28398
Tel: 910-22DI� 33 1
Fax: 910- ir
_<
?bg
Mr. Sliver,
The following farm within the Murphy -Brown, LLC system had plan _
amendments made to extend pumping windows and add additional PAN where needed.
The plan amendments are attached for each farm.
Farm Name Facility Number
Batchelor Farm 31-563 .
If there are any questions please let me know.
Regards,
�ToddRowe, CCA
Agronomist
Murphy -Brown, LLC

14
CAWMP AMENDMENT
Batchelor
7/28/03
This amendment is intended to extend the pumping window on corn. Nitrogen is
accumulated within the plant up to physiological maturity. The R2 growth stage (blister)
is critical because Nitrogen accumulated in vegetative plant parts begin to move into
reproductive plant parts and kernels are beginning dry matter accumulation. Nitrogen
should be applied to this growth stage to maximize the utilization of Nitrogen by the
plant. Knowing that the R2 stage occurs approximately 75-80 days after emergence, then
Nitrogen applications should continue up to this point. Upon a field visit it was
determined that the corn is in growth stage R1. With the R2 stage occurring
approximately 10-14 days after the RI stage, Nitrogen applications should continue until
August 10, 2003.
4
Manager
Technica Specialist
Ze rC F
Date
D to

CAWMP AMENDMENT
Batchelor
7/25/03
This amendment is intended to provide additional Nitrogen to the corn crop.
Tissue analysis was conducted on the corn crop on July 14, 2003. The results of this
analysis indicated the plants to be low in Nitrogen. Upon evaluation of the tissue sample
results and the crop that is planted, it is found that additional Nitrogen is required for the
corn crop. The additional Nitrogen is mainly due to the wet weather conditions that have
been seen so far this growing season. Several processes have caused Nitrogen to be Iost
from the soil and restricted uptake by the plant. This additional Nitrogen is for
supplementation of the required PAN in the waste management plan.
Hydrant
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
FEW. -A,
I ITI M R.
Manager
o J�e,c�e� CAI¢
Technical Specialist
Supplemental Nitrogen per acre (pounds)
15.0
Date
Date
ate
15.0
15.0
15.0
15.0
15.0
15.0

Freeboard Notification
Subject: Freeboard Notification
Date: Fri, 27 Jun 2003 17:12:02 -0400
From: "Britt, RO (BOC)" <[e-mail]>
To: "'stonewall. [e-mail]"' <[e-mail]>
CC: "Nordin, David"<[e-mail]>
The following farm has a PoA that expires on 6/28/03. It is currently at the following levels:
Permit # Farm Lagoon
310563 Batchelor A
310563 Batchelor B
Murphy -Brown, LLC
Kenansville Division
Freeboard Level Date
23" 6/27/03
24" 6127103
If you have any questions or comments, please contact David Nordin at 910-296-3731.
of 1 7/16/2003 3:05 PM

PoA Lagoon Level Update Murphy -Brown, Kenansville
Subject: PoA Lagoon Level Update Murphy -Brown, Kenansville
Date: Fri, 11 Apr 2003 15:25.15 -0400
From: "Britt, RO (BOC)" <[e-mail]>
To: "'[e-mail]"' <[e-mail]>,
"'[e-mail]"' <[e-mail]>
CC: "Nordin, David"<[e-mail]>
The following is an update of the lagoon levels currently under PoA's for the Murphy -Brown Kenansville Davison.
The following readings were recorded Friday, April 11, 2003.
Farm C.O.C. Lagoon Lagoon
# I.D. Level
Smith -Alderman 31-6 A 21
B 16
Bachelor 31-563 A 16
B 16
1 of 1 7/16/2003 3:32 PM

Lagoon Levels
Subject: Lagoon Levels
Date: Tue, 27 May 2003 15:14:06 -0400
From: "Nordin, David"<[e-mail]>
To: "'Rick. shivcr@ncmail. nct"' <[e-mail]>
CC: "'[e-mail]"' <[e-mail]>1
"'[e-mail]"' <[e-mail]>
Batchelor Sow Farm
Permit # 310563
Lagoon Level A - 18 inches B - 18 inches
5127/03
The lagoons are not in compliance. A PoA will follow for this notification. If I can be of further assistance, please
call at 910 - 296 - 3731.
David Nordin
Murphy Brown LLC
Kenansville Division
1 of 1 7/16/2003 3:25 PM

Lagoon Freeboard Notification
Subject: Lagoon Freeboard Notification
Date: Wed, 23 Apr 2003 11:24:52 -0400
From: "Cavenaugh, Tonya"<[e-mail]>
To: "'[e-mail]"' <[e-mail]>
The following farm's PoA expires today, 4/23/03. Their current freeboard level is as follows:
Permit # Farm # Date Level Taken Level
31-563 Batchelor 4/23/03 A - 19"
B-19"
The following farm's PoA expires 5/15/03. Their current freeboard level is as follows:
Permit # Farm #
31-6 Smith -Alderman
1 onya Cavenaugb
111urply .Brown L.L C
Kenan.;ville Dirisim
[phone]
Land 6 Nutrient Management
Adminifmative A ii rtaw
Date Level Taken Level
4/19/03 A - 22"
B-21"
Name: Notebook.jpg
. Notebook.ipg Type: JPEG Image (image/jpeg)
Encoding: base64
1 of 1 7/16/2003 3:27 PM

Lagoon Freeboards
Subject: Lagoon Freeboards
Date: Mon, 14 Jul 2003 16:29,01 -0400
From: "Nordin, David"<[e-mail]>
To: "'[e-mail]"' <[e-mail]>
CC: "'[e-mail]"' <[e-mail]>,
"'[e-mail]"' <Rick,[e-mail]>
Freeboard Levels - Murphy Brown LLC Kenansville Division - 7/14/03
Farm Facility#
2147 31 - 468
Batchelor 31 - 563
Turner Sow 31 - 57
3620
31 - 400
Scott
31 - 5
Envirotech
31 - 177
3090
31 - 678
2149
31 - 567
2704
31 - 375
Lagoon Level
17 inches
A - 17 inches
B - 17 inches
S1 - 14 inches
S2 - 14 inches
S3 - 17 inches
18 inches
15 inches
S1 - 18.5 inches
18 inches
16 inches
16 inches
2706 31 - 375 10 inches In addition to a 30 day PoA, a 5 day PoA will be submitted for
this farm.
If you have any further questions, please call me at 910 - 296 - 3731.
Thank You
David Nordin
Land & Nutrient Management
Murphy Brown LLC
Kenansville Division
l of 1 7/16/2003 3:02 PM

Lagoon Level Up Date
Subject: Lagoon Level Up Date
Date: Thu, 10 Apr 2003 15:43:41 -0400
From: "Britt, RO (BOC)" <[e-mail]>
To. "'[e-mail]"' <[e-mail]>,
"'[e-mail]"' <[e-mail]>
CC: "Nordin, David"<[e-mail]>,
"Williamson, Dawn" <dawnwilliamson@mu phybrownllc.com>
The following lagoon levels are less than 19 inches.
Farm C.O.C. Lagoon Lagoon
# ID Level
Smith -Alderman 31-6 A 20
B 18
A PoA will be submitted for the Smith -Alderman farm as soon as possible. A PoA has been submitted for the
Bachelor farm (31-563). The following is an update on the lagoon levels at this facility as of 4/10/03.
Farm C.O.0 Lagoon Lagoon
# ID Level
Bachelor 31-563 A 17
B 17.5
1 of 1 7/16/2003 3:35 PM

Lagoon Levels
Subject: Lagoon Levels
Date: Tue, 27 May 2003 15:14:06 -0400
From: "Nordin, David"<[e-mail]>
To: "'Rick. [e-mail]"' <[e-mail]>
CC: "'[e-mail]"' <[e-mail]>,
"'[e-mail]"' <[e-mail]>
Batchelor Sow Farm
Permit # 310563
Lagoon Level A - 18 inches B - 18 inches
5/27/03
The lagoons are not in compliance. A PoA will follow for this notification. If I can be of further assistance, please call
at 910 - 296 - 3731.
David Nordin
Murphy Brown LLC
Kenansville Division
1 of 1 5/28/2003 10:07 AM

I F
Ma b. May 28 03 04:19p MURPHY-BROWN 9102933138
=11AY 2003
PLAN OF ACTION(Poa) FOR HIGH FREEBOARD AT ANIMAL FACILITIES ``-""---------____�-
Facility Number. 31-563 County: Duplin
Facility Name: Batchelor Sow
Certified Operator Name: f) Operator Number:
1. Current liquid level(s) in inches as measured from the current liquid level in the lagoon to the
lowest point on the top of the dam for lagoons without spillways; and from the current liquid level
in the lagoon to the bottom of the spillway for lagoons with spillways -
Lagoon 1 Lagoon 2 Lagoon 3 Lagoon 4 Lagoon 5
Lagoon Name/ID: A B
Spillway(Y or N): N N
Level (inches): 18 18
2. Check all applicable items
Liquid level is within the designed structural freeboard elevations of one or more structures.
Five and 30 day Plans of Action are attached. Hydraulic and agronomic balances are
within acceptable ranges.
X Liquid level is within the 25 year 24 hour storm elevations for one or more structures. A
30 day Plan of Action is attached. Agronomic balance is within acceptable range.
Waste is to be pumped and hauled to off site locations. Bolume and PAN content of waste
to be pumped and hauled is reflected in section III tables. Included within this plan is a list
of the proposed sites with related facility numbers, number of acres and receiving crop
information. Contact and secure approval from the DWO prior to transfer of waste to a site
not covered in the facility's CAWMP.
Operation will be partially or fully depopulated.
*Attach a complete schedule with corresponding animal units and dates fro depopulation
"if animals are to be moved to another permitted facility, provide facility number, lagoon
freeboard levels and herd population for the receiving facility
3. Earliest possible date to begin land application of waste:
l hereby certify that 1 have reviewed the information listed above and included within the
attached Plan of Action, and to the best of my knowledge and ability, the information is
accurate and correct
1�r� Phone: 110 /�6 3 7,3%
F cility Owner/Manager (print)
Date: -
Facility Owner2M er (signature)

, Mar 21 03 03: 30p MURPHY-BROWN 9102933138 p, 3 1 , Mar 21 b3 03: 29P MURPHY-BROWN 8102933138 p. 2
PLAN OF ACTION (PoA) FOR HIGH FREEBOARD AT ANIMAL FACILITIES
30 DAY DRAW DOWN PERIOD
1. TOTAL PAN TO BE LAND APPLIED PER WASTE STRUCTURE
1. Structure Name/identifier (ID): Batchelor D28
2. Current liquid volume in 25 yrJ24 hr. storm storage & structural freeboard
a. current liquid level according to mariner F1$.0 inches
b, designed 25 yr.124 hr. storm & structural freeboard 9A inches
c, line b - line a (inches in rec zone) = 1.0 inches
d. top of dike surface area according to design
(area at below structural freeboard elevat'on) 93799 ftZ
e, line c112 x line d x 7,.48 gallons/W 53468 gallons
3. Projected volume of waste liquid produced during draw down period
3 t - s-4 3
PLAN OF ACTION(Poa) FOR HIGH FREEBOARD AT ANIMAL FACILITIES
Facility Number. 31-563 County: Duplin
Facility Name-. Batchelor Sow
Certified Operator Name: D. S Operator Number: (0�-Q
1. Current liquid level(s) in inches as measured from the current liquid level in the lagoon to the
lowest point on the top of the dam for lagoons without spillways; and from the current liquid level
in the lagoon to the botom of the spillway for lagoons with spillways.
Lagoon Name/ID
5pillway(Y or N):
Level(inches):
Lagoor 1 Lagoon 2 Lagoon 3 Lagoon 4 Lagoon 5
D28
N
2. Check all applicable items
18 7-
Liquid level is within the designed structural freeboard elevations of one or more structures.
Five and 30 day Plans of Action are attached. Hyaraulic and agronomic balances are
within acceptable ranges.
f. temporary storage perod according to structural design
180 days
X Liquid level is within the 25 year24 hour storm elevations for one or more structures. A
30 day Plan of Action is attached. Agronomic balance is within acceptable range.
g. volume of waste produced according to structural design
232630 ft3
Waste is to be pumped and hauler to off site iocaticrs. Bolume and PAN content of waste
h. current herd # 20 35 certified herd #1 2o-151
to be purnped and nauled is reflected in section M tables. Included within this plan is a list
of the proposed sites with related facility numbers, number of acres and receiving crap
actual waste produced = current herd # x line g =
232630 ft'
Information. Contact and secure approval from the DWO prior to transfer of waste 'o a sire
not covered in the facility's CAWh7P.
certified ; Ierd #
_ _ _ Operation. ill be partially or fully depopulated-
_
t. volume of wash water according to structural design
Oft3
*Attach a cempiete schedule with corresponding animal units and dates frc deoopulati;;n
*if animals are to be moved to another permitted facility, provide facility number, lagoon
j. excess rainfall over evaporation, according to design
i23228,ft3
freeboard levels and herd population for ine receiving facility
k. ,lines 11 + i + j) x 7.48 x 30 daysAine f=
443636 gallons
3. Earliest possible date to begin land application of wasle:
4. Total PAN to be land applied during draw down period
I hereby certify that 1 have reviewed the Information listed above and included within the
attached Plan of Action, and to the best of my knowledge and ablilly, the information Is
I- current waste analysis dated 03101/2003
1.80 ;bs11000 gal.
accurate and correct. '
m. ((lines e + k)11000) x line 1
903.8 lbs. PAN
. ),<0r J Nv r d / n. - Phone: J1 D 27 44 -33731
Facill O'hnerlManager (print)
REPEAT SECTION 1 FOR EACH WASTE STRUCTURE ON SITE.
d Gu_ � 2 Date: 3 - 2 ` - d3
(Click on the next Structure tab shown below)
Facility Owner+Manager (signature)
�.
PoA (30 Day) 2J21100
Jr

,Mar 21 03 03:30p MURPHY-BROWN 9102933138 p.4
II. TOTAL POUNDS OF PAN STORED WITHIN STRUCTURAL FREEBOARD ANDIOR 25 YR.124
HR. STORM STORAGE ELEVATIONS IN ALL WASTE STRUCTURES FOR FACILITY
1. Structure ID: Batchelor D28
line m = 903.8 lb PAN
2. Structure ID:
line rn =
Ib PAN
3. Structure ID:
line m =
lb PAN
4. Structure ID:
line m =
lb PAN
5. Structure ID:
line m =
lb PAN
5. Structure ID:
line'rn =
lb PAN
n.lines 1+2+3+4+5+6= 903.8lbPAN
III. TOTAL PAN BALANCE REMAINING FOR AVAILABLE CROPS DURING 30 DAY DRAW DOWt
PERIOD_ DO NOT LIST FIELDS TO WHICH PAN CANNOT RE APPLIED DIJRINP THIS an DAY PFlRInn
balance12 PAN
:.
'State current crop ending application date or next crop application beginning date for available
receiving crops during 30 day draw dowr, Deriod.
v. Total PAN available for all fields (sum of column t) W 2098.8 lb. PAN
IV. FACILITY'S PoA OVERALL PAN BALANCE
w. Total PAN to ba land applied (line n from section 11) = 903.8 Ib. PAN
PoA (30 pay) 2I21100

Mar 21 03 03:30p MURPHY-BROWN 9102933138 p.5
x. Crop's remaining PAN balance (fine v from section III) = 2098.8 lb- PAN
y. Overall PAN balance (w - x) _ -1195 lb. PAN
Line y must show as a deficit. If line y does not show as a deficit, list course of action here including pump and
haul, depopulation, herd reduction, etc. For oump & haul and herd reduction options, recalculate new PAN
based on new information. If new fields are to be included as an option for lowering lagoon level. add these
fields to the PAN balance table and recalculate the overall PAN balance. If animal waste is to be hauled to
another permitted facility, provide information regarding the herd population and lagoon freeboard levels at the
receiving facility.
,Irrigation onto existing spray fields will continue as weather and field conditiors permit. Additional land is -- j
available for pumping if needed. j
i
i
I
PoA (30 Day) 2l21100

1'o
70 F 7 1
m
C3 Postage
S
. $
u7 Certified Fee
Ln
,
1 ru Return Receipt Fee
p (Endorsement Required)
Pos mark
H"
p ResMcted De kW Fee
Cl (Endorsement Required)
j I
$ �^}
Y
I p 7btsl Postage & Fees
11S
�— —
r9
p
Street. APL No.; 1
or PO Box
ip---------

Michael F. Easley, Governor
William G. Ross Jr., Secretary
North Carolina Department of Environment and Natural Resources
December 15, 2003
Murphy Family Farms
Mr. David Nordin
785 Hwy. 24/50
Warsaw, NC 28398
Subject. Rescission of Notice of Violation /
Issuance of Notice of Deficiency
Batchelor Sow Farm
Facility # 31-563
Duplin County
Dear Mr. Nordin:
Alan W. Klimek, P.E. Director
Division of Water Quality
Thank you for your submittal of the information requested in our letter dated April 15, 2003. We
greatly appreciate the effort that you made in compiling this information and sending it to our
Wilmington Regional Office by the date required. We also appreciate the fact that you reported
the problem with high freeboard to our staff as required by your permit and worked with our
staff to manage the problem once it occurred.
Upon review and consideration of the information submitted, the Wilmington Regional Office has
determined that no further compliance/enforcement actions will be taken by the Division for
these high freeboards. w
Also, based on your actions to properly operate your facility, the Division of Water Quality
hereby rescinds the Notice of Violation that was issued to you on April 15, 2003 and replaces it
with this Notice of Deficiency.
In the future, please continue to evaluate ways to maintain freeboard levels in the required range.
These methods include, but are not limited to, water conservation practices, adding additional
application sites, updating your cropping systems, adding additional and/or more flexible
application equipment, and maintaining the lagoon levels at the lowest allowable and appropriate
levels throughout the year. Our staff looks forward to continuing to work with you and your
Technical Specialist to evaluate and implement any needed changes to your system.
s' pA
NCDENR
Customer Service. Mailing Address: Telephone: [phone] Location:
1 800 623-7748 1617 Mail Service Center Fax: [phone] N. Salisbury St.
Raleigh, NC 27699-1617 State Courier #52-01-01 Raleigh, NC 27699-1617
An Equal Opportunity 1 Affirmative Action Employer
50% recycled ! 10% post -consumer paper
htfp:llh2o.en r. state. n C. us

Inadequate Freeboard
David Nordin
December 15, 2003
Page 2
Thank you again for your cooperation. If you have any questions, please do not hesitate to
contact the staff of our Wilmington Regional Office at 910-395-3900.
Sincerely,
Rick Shiver
Water Quality Regional Supervisor
CC: Kraig Westerbeek, Murphy -Brown, LLC
Billy Houston, Duplin County Soil and Water Conservation District
Patrick Fussell, DSWC
Wilmington Files 31-563
Non -Discharge Compliance and Enforcement Unit
Central Files
0

�1 !4-�UU3 I'M Ub; bb V11 8UU - LANANUTRIENT
F`
Murphy -Brown.
Kenansville Division
785 Hwy. 24/50
Warsaw, NC 28398
[phone]
To: SA%,Le-wa-jX V&S
J(Ij wl �ti� /IY A
Date: _,. 'l 0y /ga2
81U W283 F. U1/18
Land & Nutrient Management
From: David Nordin, Manager
Tonya C.avenaugh, Assistant
R. O. Britt, Specialist
J. D. Suggs, Specialist
Don LaCoe, Auditor
Fax: l - 91a 3a . aoo�i
Number of pages, including cover sheet: I� -

T14-2003 TBU 05;57 PM BOC - LAND&NUTRIENT 9102961283
P. 06/18
PLAN OF ACTION(Poa) FOR HIGH FREEBOARD AT ANIMAL FACILITIES
Facility Number: 31-563 County: Duplln
Facility Name: Batchelor Sow
Certified Operator Name:D Operator Number: 675te,26
01
1. Current liquid level(s) in inches as measured from the current liquid level in the lagoon to the
lowest point on the top of the dam for lagoons without spillways; and from the current liquid level
In the lagoon to the bottom of the spillway for lagoons with spillways.
Lagoon 1 Lagoon 2 Lagoon 3 Lagoon 4 Lagoon 5
Lagoon Name11D: A a
Spillway(Y or N): N N
Level(inches): 19 16
2. Check all applicable items
Liquid level is within the designed structural freeboard elevations of one or more structures.
Five and 34 day Plans of Action are attached. Hydraulic and agronomic balances are
within acceptable ranges.
X 1_lquld level is within the 25 year 24 hour storm elevations for one or more structures. A
30 day Plan of Action is attached. Agronomic balance is within acceptable range -
Waste Is to be pumped and hauled to off site locations. Bolume and PAN content of waste
to be pumped and hauled is reflected in section III tables. Included within this plan Is a list
of the proposed sites with related facility numbers, number of acres and receiving crop
information. Contact and secure approval from the DWO prior to transfer of waste to a site
not covered In the facllity's CAWMP.
Operation will be partially or fully depopulated.
`Attach a complete schedule with corresponding animal units and dates fro depopulation
`if animals are to be moved to another permitted facility, provide facility number, lagoon
freeboard levels and herd population for the receiving facility
3. Earliest possible date to begin land application of waste:
I hereby certify that I have reviewed the information listed above and Included within the
attached Plan of Action, and to the best of my knowledge and ability, the information is
accurate and correct.
AL4 &ems L 1-d Phone: [phone] '373/
acility Owner/Manager (print)
- -Z?2/3 LL_C - Date:
Facility Owner/Manager (signature)

V-14-2003 THU 05:58 PH BOO - LAND&NUTRIENT 9102961283
P. 07/18
PLAN OF ACTION (PoA) FOR HIGH FREEBOARD AT ANIMAL FACILITIE1
30 DAY DRAW DOWN PERIOD
I. TOTAL PAN TO BE LAND APPLIED PER WASTE STRUCTURE
1. Structure Name/Identifier (ID): Batchelor B
2. Current liquid volume in 25 yr_124 hr. storm storage & structural freeboard
a. current liquid level according to marker 16.0 inches
b. designed 25 yr./24 hr. storm & structural freeboard 19.0 inches
c. line b - line a (inches in red zone) = 3.0 inches
d. top of dike surface area according to design
(area at below structural freeboard elevation)
101781 ft�
e. line c112 x line d x 7.48 gallonsR
190293 gallons
3. Projected volume of waste liquid produced during draw down period
f_ temporary storage period according to structural design
18D days
g. volume of waste produced according to structural design
116315 ft3
h. current herd # 1100 certified herd # 1100
actual waste produced = current herd # x line g =
116315 ft3
certified herd #
i. volume of wash water according to structural design L— 01ft3
j. excess rainfall over evaporation according to design 61614 1?
k. (lines h + i + j) x 7.48 x 30 days/line f= 2211918 gallons
4. Total PAN to be land applied during draw down period
I. current waste analysis dated 07/21/2003 1.50 Ibs11000 gal.
m. ((lines e + k)11000) x line 1= 618.2 lbs. PAN
REPEAT SECTION I FOR EACH WASTE STRUCTURE ON SITE.
(Click on the next Structure tab shown below)
PoA (30 Day) 2/21 /00

R,,_14-2003 THU 05:58 Ply BOC - LAND&HUTRiENT 9102961283
P. 08/18
II. TOTAL POUNDS OF PAN STORED WITHIN STRUCTURAL. FREEBOARD AND/OR 25 YR.124
HR. STORM STORAGE ELEVATIONS IN ALL WASTE STRUCTURES FOR FACILITY
1.
Structure ID_ Batchelor A
line rn =
lb PAN
2.
Structure ID, Batchelor B
line m = 618.2 lb PAN
3.
Structure ID:
line m =
lb PAN
4.
Structure ID:
line m =
lb PAN
S.
Structure 10:
line m =
lb PAN
8.
Structure ID:
line m =
lb PAN
n.lines 1+2+3+4+5+6= 618.2lbPAN
Ill. TOTAL PAN BALANCE REMAINING FOR AVAILABLE CROPS DURING 30 DAY DRAW DOW!
PERIOD_ DO NOT LIST FIELDS TO WHICH PAN r-ANNnT RI: APPLIP11 11I1R1NC THIS An nAV PFRInn
o. tract #
p. field #
q. crop
r. acres
s. remaining IRK.
2 PAN balance
(Iblacre)
t. TOTAL PAN
BALANCE FOR
FIELD (I be.)
column r x s
u. application windows
1
2 HB
Bermuda May
1.85
88.69
164.1
Mar -Oct
2 H9
Bermuda Hay
1.85
60.92
112.7
Mar -Oct
2 H10
Bermuda Hay
1.91
82.13
156.9
Mar -Oct
2 HI
Bermuda Ha
1.69
117.39
198.4
Mar -Oct
'State current crop ending application date or next crop application beginning date for available
receiving crops during 30 day draw down period.
v. Total PAN available for all fields (sum of column t) = 632.0 lb. PAN
IV. FACILITY'S PoA OVERALL PAN BALANCE
w. Total PAN to be land applied (line n from section II) = 618.2 lb. PAN
PoA (30 Day) 2121100

R-W2003 THU 05:58 Ply BOO - LR ANUTRIBNT 9102961283 P, 09/18
x, Crop's remaining PAN balance (line v from section ill) = 632.0 lb. PAN
y, Overall PAN balance (w - x) _ -14 lb. PAN
Line y must show as a deficit. If line y does not show as a deficit, list course of action here including pump and
haul, depopulation, herd reduction, etc. For pump & haul and herd reduction options, recalculate new PAN
based on new information. If new fields are to be included as an option for lowering lagoon level, add these
fields to the PAN balance table and recalculate the overall PAN balance. If animal waste is to be hauled to
another permitted facility, provide information regarding the herd population and lagoon freeboard levels at the
Irrigation onto existing spray fields will continue as weather and field conditions permit. Additional land is
available for pumping if needed.
PoA (30 Day) 2/21100

ofo-5 Coe -
PLAN OF ACTION(Poa) FOR HIGH FREEBOARD AT ANIMAL FACILITIES
Facility Number: 31-563 County: Duplin
Facility Name: Batchelor Sow
Certified Operator Name: 'i J 5 Operator Number: 0 G �, C�
1. Current liquid level(s) in inches as measured from the current liquid level in the lagoon to the
lowest point on the top of the dam for lagoons without spillways; and from the current liquid level
in the lagoon to the bottom of the spillway for lagoons with spillways.
Lagoon 1 Lagoon 2 Lagoon 3 Lagoon 4 Lagoon 5
Lagoon Name/ID: A B
Spiltway(Y or N): N N
Level(inches): 17 17
2. Check all applicable items
Liquid level is within the designed structural freeboard elevations of one or more structures.
Five and 30 day Plans of Action are attached. Hydraulic and agronomic balances are
within acceptable ranges.
X Liquid level is within the 25 year 24 hour storm elevations for one or more structures. A
30 day Plan of Action is attached. Agronomic balance is within acceptable range.
Waste is to be pumped and hauled to off site locations. Bolume and PAN content of waste
to be pumped and hauled is reflected in section Ill tables. Included within this plan is a list
of the proposed sites with related facility numbers, number of acres and receiving crop
information. Contact and secure approval from the DWQ prior to transfer of waste to a site
not covered in the facility's CAWMP.
Operation will be partially or fully depopulated.
*Attach a complete schedule with corresponding animal units and dates fro depopulation
*if animals are to be moved to another permitted facility, provide facility number, lagoon
freeboard levels and herd population for the receiving facility
3. Earliest possible date to begin land application of waste:
I hereby certify that I have reviewed the information listed above and included within the
attached Plan of Action, and to the best of my knowledge and ability, the information is
accurate and correct.
_4/ur0k re� //-e &Ilod /E,ePhone: 9lo•;294-373/
�TFacility Owner/Manager (print)
Date:
Facility Own r/Manager (signature)

PLAN OF ACTION (PoA) FOR HIGH FREEBOARD AT ANIMAL FACILITIES
30 DAY DRAW DOWN PERIOD
I. TOTAL PAN TO BE LAND APPLIED PER WASTE STRUCTURE
1. Structure Name/identifier (ID): Batchelor A
2. Current liquid volume in 25 yr.124 hr. storm storage & structural freeboard
a. current liquid level according to marker 17.0 inches
b. designed 25 yr.124 hr. storm & structural freeboard 19.0 inches
c. line b - line a (inches in red zone) = 2.0 inches
d. top of dike surface area according to design
(area at below structural freeboard elevation) 93799 ftZ
e. line c112 x line d x 7.48 gallonslft3 116936 gallons
3. Projected volume of waste liquid produced during draw down period
f. temporary storage period according to structural design 186 days
g. volume of waste produced according to structural design 232fi30 ft3
h. current herd # 935 certified herd # 935
actual waste produced = current herd # x line g =
certified herd #
i. volume of wash water according to structural design
j. excess rainfall over evaporation according to design
k. (lines h + i + j) x 7.48 x 30 days/line f=
4. Total PAN to be land applied during draw down period
I. current waste analysis dated 06/24/2003
m. ((lines e + k)11000) x line I =
REPEAT SECTION I FOR EACH WASTE STRUCTURE ON SITE.
(Click on the next Structure tab shown below)
232630 ft3
®ft3
123228 ft3
443636 gallons
1.30 Ibs11000 gal.
728.7 lbs. PAN
PoA (30 Day) 2/21/00

PLAN OF ACTION (PoA) FOR HIGH FREEBOARD AT ANIMAL FACILITIES
30 DAY DRAW DOWN PERIOD
I. TOTAL PAN TO BE LAND APPLIED PER WASTE STRUCTURE
1. Structure NamelIdentifiier (ID): 113atchelor B
2. Current liquid volume in 25 yr.124 hr. storm storage & structural freeboard
a. current liquid level according to marker
b. designed 25 yr.124 hr. storm & structural freeboard
c. line b - line a (inches in red zone) =
d. top of dike surface area according to design
(area at below structural freeboard elevation)
e. line c112 x line d x 7.48 gallonslft3
3. Projected volume of waste liquid produced during draw down period
f. temporary storage period according to structural design
17.0 inches
19.0 inches
2.0 inches
101761 ftz
126862 gallons
180 days
g. volume of waste produced according to structural design 116315 ft3
h. current herd # 1100 certified herd # 1100
actual waste produced = current herd # x line g =
certified herd #
i. volume of wash water according to structural design
j. excess rainfall over evaporation according to design
k. (lines h + i + j) x 7.48 x 30 days/line f=
4. Total PAN to be land applied during draw down period
I. current waste analysis dated 1 06/24/2003
m. ((lines e + k)11000) x line I
REPEAT SECTION I FOR EACH WASTE STRUCTURE ON SITE.
(Click on the next Structure tab shown below)
116315 ft3
©ft3
61614 ft3
221818 gallons
1.80 Ibs11000 gal.
627.6 lbs. PAN
PoA (30 Day) 2/21/00

II. TOTAL POUNDS OF PAN STORED WITHIN STRUCTURAL FREEBOARD AND/OR 25 YR.124
HR. STORM STORAGE ELEVATIONS IN ALL WASTE STRUCTURES FOR FACILITY
1. Structure ID: Batchelor A
2. Structure ID: Batchelor B
3. Structure ID:
4. Structure ID:
5. Structure ID:
6. Structure ID:
line m = 728.7 lb PAN
line m = 627.6 lb PAN
line m = lb PAN
line m = lb PAN
line m = lb PAN
line m = lb PAN
n. lines 1 +2+3+4+5+6= 1356.4 lb PAN
Ill. TOTAL PAN BALANCE REMAINING FOR AVAILABLE CROPS DURING 30 DAY DRAW DOWF
PERIOD. DO NOT LIST FIELDS TO WHICH PAN CANNOT BE APPLIED DURING THIS 30 DAY PERIOD
o. tract #
p. field #
q. Crop
r. acres
s. remaining IRR
2 PAN balance
(lblacre)
t. TOTAL PAN
BALANCE FOR
FIELD (lbs.)
column r x s
u. application windowf
11
2 H8
Bermuda Hay
1.85
144.16
266.7
Mar -Oct
2 H9
Bermuda Hay
1.85
150.84
279.1
Mar -Oct
2 H10
Bermuda Ha
1.91
170.52
325.7
Mar -Oct
2 H11
Bermuda Hay
1.69
182.97
309.2
Mar -Oct
1 H1
Corn
2.92
46.21
134.9
Mar -Jul
1 H2
Corn
2.71
41.09
111.4
Mar -Jul
'State current crop ending application date or next crop application beginning date for available
receiving crops during 30 day draw down period.
v. Total PAN available for all fields (sum of column t) = 1426.9 Ili. PAN
IV. FACILITY'S PoA OVERALL PAN BALANCE
w. Total PAN to be land applied (line n from section II) =
1356.4 lb. PAN
PoA (30 Day) 2/21100

x. Crop's remaining PAN balance (line v from section Ili) = 1426.9 lb. PAN
y. Overall PAN balance (w - x) _ -71 lb. PAN
Line y must show as a deficit. if line y does not show as a deficit, list course of action here including pump and
haul, depopulation, herd reduction, etc. For pump & haul and herd reduction options, recalculate new PAN
based on new information. If new fields are to be included as an option for lowering lagoon level, add these
fields to the PAN balance table and recalculate the overall PAN balance. If animal waste is to be hauled to
another permitted facility, provide information regarding the herd population and lagoon freeboard levels at the
Irrigation onto existing spray fields will continue as weather and field conditions permit. Additional land is
available for pumping if needed.
PoA (30 Day) 2/21/00

MURPHY
F AM 1 l Y F A R M S
Division of Water Quality
Wilmington Regional Office
127 Cardinal Drive Ext.
Wilmington, NC 28405
Dean Hunkele
Dear Mr Hunkele,
As required by your agencies freeboard guidance document dated 1/31/2000, this letter is
intended to outline a plan of action aimed at lowering the lagoon level at the Batchlor
Farm (lagoon 1) to a level adequate for both structural stability and a 25 year, 24 hour
storm.
We have approximately 50 acres of small grain overseed available for irrigation at this
time. PAN balances for the fields to be used show that we still have 25 % of our 100 lb.
target available. When field conditions improve, we will begin making frequent, light
applications to the small grain. On this farm, we could transfer water to the newer lagoon
if needed, however, that would bring it closer to the 19" mark than we would like.
Therefore, if the current weather conditions continue, we should be able to lower the
lagoon level to below minimum requirements within 30 days through irrigation.
If there are any questions or concerns, please call me at [phone] ext. 4556 or John
Bizic at ext. 4589.
4
ekterbeek
Family Farms
2/ 1 /00
Post Office Box 759, Rose Hill, North Carolina 28458, [phone], FAX [phone]

APR-07-00 01:40 PM P.09
�)Om�*'C'*3ti-`3`. 31-5-63
MARILYN Land & Nutrient Management Data History Inquiry 4/07/UO
LNMHSTINQ Murphy Family Farms 13:57:41
Farm# _ 2016 Lagoon#: Report Date: 10/01/99 Div#:
SDI Ref#: Options: 5-More Details
Farm
Lag Report
SDI Free Board
Consumption
Rainfall Contract
Opt No:
No:
Date
Div#
Ref#
Level
Per Head
Water
Inches Gal Pump
2016
1
10/02/99
10
114541
17
6.11
85060
1.10
2016
1
10/09/99
10
175231
20
6.83
94980
.50
2016
1
10/16/99
10
175904
16
7.10
98160
4.20
2016
1
10/23/99
10
176653
24
6.89
95190
.43
2016
1
10/30/99
10
177335
23
7.12
98210
2016
1
11/06/99
10
178019
19
6.89
97280
2016
1
11/13/99
10
178712
17
8.32
118800
2016
1
11/20/99
10
179414
16
10.68
149490
2016
1
11/27/99
10
180137
18
7.44
105850
2016
1
12/04/99
10
180797
19
6.21
88390
2016
1
12/11/99
10
181448
23
5.90
84210
2016
1
12/18/99
10
182117
24
9.05
129560
F3-Exit F5-Refresh
(C)Copyright 1998-99.Anchor Applications & Solutions, Inc All Rights Reserved

APR-07-00 01:40 PM P.10
MARILYN Land & Nutrient Management Data History inquiry 4/07/00
LNMHSTINQ Murphy Family Farms 13:57:41
Farm# : _ 2016 Lagoon#: Report Date: 10/01/99 Div#:
SDI Ref#: _ Options: S=More Details
Farm
Lao
Report
SDI Free Board
Consumption
Rainfall Contract
Opt No: No:
Date
Div#
Ref#
Level
Per Head
Water Inches_ Gal Pump
2016
1
12/25/99
10
182844
22
10.14
144 580
2016
1
1/01/00
10
183516
23
9.78
139140
2016
1
1/08/00
10
184211
23
5.45
78610
2016
1
1/15/00
10
184913
23
4.22
60410
2016
1
1/22/00
10
185609
19
4.50
64630
2016
1
1/29/00
10
186271
15
4.40
63790
2016
1
2/05/00
10
186956
18
4..67
66860
2016
1
2/12/00
10
187684
18
4.83
69090
2016
1
2/19/00
10
188339
18
4.90
70100
2016
1
2/26/00
10
189054
23
4.57
65300
2016
1
3/04/00
10
189723
21
5.23
75000
2016
1
3/11/00
10
190478
23
4.68
67560
F3-Exit FS=Refresh
(C)Copyright 1998-99.Anchor Applications & Solutions,Inc.All Rights Reserved

APR-07-00 01 :48 PM
MARILYN Lana & Nutrient Management Data Histor _In uir 4/U-i/UU
LNMH STINQ Murphy Family Farms 13:57:41
Fa rrn# 2016 Lagoon#: Report Date: 10/01/99 Div#:
SDI Ref#: Options: 5-More Details
Farm
Lag
Resort
SDI Free Board
Consumption
Rainfall Contract
Opt No: No:
Date
Div#
Ref#
Level
Per Head
Water
Inches
2016
1
3/18/00
10
190977
7,8
4.81
69600
_GalPump
2016
1
3/25/00
10
191871
25
4.99
72870
2016
1
4/01/00
10
192510
20
5.14
74380
2016
2
10/02/99
10
174541
20
6.11
65060
1.10
2016
2
10/09/99
10
175231
26
6.83
94980
.50
2016
2
10/16/99
10
175904
21
7.10
98160
4.20
2016
2
10/23/99
10
176653
21
6.89
95190
.45
2016
2
10/30/99
10
177335
23
7.12
98210
2 016
2
11/06/99
10
178019
23
6.89
97280
2016
2
11/13/99
10
178712
25
8.32
118800
2016
2
11/20/99
10
179414
26
10.68
149490
2016
2
11/27/99
10
180137
26
7.44
105650
F3=Exit F5=Refresh R
(C)Copyright 1998-99.Anchor Applications & Solutions►Inc.All Rights Reserved
L

i
�
b
m
b
00
CM
.D Ed
�
_
a>
00
r''
c
V
3 E
Z
m
ml
c
aw
•FBI
CO
•�
t7
Cc
w�w,,
CD
m
O
�Vz
o�t
,
CL
■ Complete items 1, 2, and 3. Also complete
item 4 if Restricted Delivery is desired-
■ Print your name and address on the reverse
so that we can return the card to you.
■ Attach this card to the back of the mailpiece,
or on the front if space permits.
1. Article Addressed to
A. Received by (Please Print Gearly) B. Date of Delivery
C. Sign ture
XZ�� ❑Agent
a Addressee
D. Is delivery add different from item 1? 0 Yes
If YES, enter delivery address below: ❑ No
Mr. Kraig Westerbeek II-
Murphy Family Farms
PO Box 759 s. Servi pe
Rose Hill, NC 28458 Cert+fied Mail ❑ Express Mail
❑ Registered ❑ Return Receipt for Merchandise
0 Insured Mail 0 C.O.D.
4. Restricted Delivery? (Elora Fee) ❑ Yes
2. Article Num r(CA, frpe�J
J r� !�J
4
PS Form 3811, July 1999 Domestic Return Receipt 102595-99-M-1799

State of North Carolina
Department of Environment
and Natural Resources
r
Wilmington Regional Office
James B. Hunt, Jr., Governor
NCDENR
Bill Holman, Secretary
Kerr T. Stevens, Director
ENVIRONMENT Ar4o NATURAL REsbuRCEs
Division of Water Quality
April 13, 2000
CERTIFIED MAIL # P 328 829 378
RETURN RECEIPT REQUESTED
Mr. Kraig Westerbeek
Murphy Family Farms
Batchelor Farm
PO Box 759
Rose Hill, NC 28458
Subject: Notice of Deficiency
Batchelor Farm
Facility Number: 31-563
Duplin County
Dear Mr. Westerbeek:
This is to notify Murphy Family Farms, who holds a non -discharge permit for an animal waste
disposal system pursuant to 15A NCAC 2H .0200 and North Carolina G.S. 143.215.1, of a deficiency of
Animal Waste Permit AWS 310563.
On January 26, 2000, it was reported by your facility that the freeboard level in lagoon was not in
compliance with levels of 17 inches. Therefore, this notice is being sent in accordance with the Division of
Water Quality's (DWQ) high freeboard policy.
You should have submitted a Plan of Action to obtain compliance within a stipulated time frame
depending on your lagoon level. The following procedure is to be implemented whenever the freeboard
level in any lagoon is not in compliance:
1. Notify DWQ Wilmington Regional Office within 24 hours
2. Submit appropriate Plan of Action documents obtained from DWQ, Soil & Water district
office, or Service Company
3.. Provide DWQ Regional Office with weekly updates
4. Notify DWQ Regional Office when compliance is attained.
It is highly recommended that this facility: 1) explores and initiates measures to conserve fresh
water usage and 2) make any necessary changes to the waste management system and/or waste
utilization plan to help maintain appropriate lagoon levels.
127 North Cardinal Dr., Wilmington, North Carolina 28405 Telephone [phone] FAX [phone]
An Equal Opportunity Affirmative Action. Employer recycled/10% post -consumer paper

Information contained in this database is from non agency sources and is considered unconfirmed
Farm Emergengy Call Form
Farm Number
— ®
Date 11/26/2000
Farm Name
lBatchelor Sow Farm
Time
Owner Frist Name
Call Number Fn
Owner Last Name
IMUrphy Family Farms
IS Reporfing Q Complaint
Source
O n Bizic — I
Breached
Q Yes Q O
Freeboard Level 1 117
Depopulated
Q Yes 0
Freeboard Level 2
Overflowed
Q Yes Q O
Freeboard Level 3
LQ Issue
Q Yes 0 O
Freeboard Level 4
PermissionToPump
Q Yes Q O
Freeboard Level 5
Inudated
0 Yes Q O
Flooded
Q Yes Q O
Freeboard Level 6
Pumping Equipment
Q Yes Q O
comments
nneWa . s.IeCelue .. e.. ..an....
...an ..ena ere .in a.. e.. ; ase.an..........
21212.0.0.0.1 ..........................................................................................................................................................................................................
....................................................................................................................................................................................................•.........
...................................................................................................................................................................................................................................
...................................................................................................................................................................................................................................
...................................................................................................................................................................................................................................
........................................................................................................................................................w.........................................................................
............................................................................................................................................................................................................................I...-
...................................................................................................................................................................................................................................
...................................................................................................................................................................................................................................
....................................................................................................................................................................................................•..............................
........................... .......................................................................................................................................................................................
•..................................................................................................................................................................................................................................
........................................................................................................................................................................................................................
...................................................................................................................................................................................................................................
...................................................................................................................................................................................................................................
...................................................................................................................................................................................................................................
....................................................................................................................................................................................................•.............................•
I....................
I................
I..........

ANIMAL WASTE MANAGEMENT PLAN CERTIFICATION FOR NEW O CEXPAnNDEDEEDLOTS
Please return the completed form to the Division of Environmental Management at the address
form.
Name of farm (Please print): Batchelor Farm !
GAP �
Address: P. O. Box 759 Rose Hill, NC 28458
Phone No.: I County: Duplin
Farm location: Latitude and Longitude: 350 00' 5'1770 56 06' (required). Also, please attach a copy of a county road
map with location identified. Type of operation (swine, layer, dairy, etc.): Swine
Design capacity (number of animals): 2035 Sows Farrow to Wean
Average size of operation (12 month population avg.): 2035 Sows
Average acreage needed for land application of waste (acres): 35.7
Technical Specialist Certification
As a technical specialist designated by the North Carolina Soil and Water Conservation Commission pursuant to
15A NCAC 6F .0005, 1 certify that the new or expanded animal waste management system as installed for the farm named
above has an animal waste management plan that meets the design, construction, operation and maintenance standards
and specifications of the Division of Environmental Management and the USDA -Soil Conservation Service and/or the North
Carolina Soil and Water Conservation pursuant to 15A NCAC 2H .0217 and 15A NCAC 6F .0001-.0005. The following
elements and their corresponding minimum criteria have been verified by me or other designated technical specialists and
are included in the plan as applicable: minimum separations (buffers); liners or equivalent for lagoons or waste storage
ponds; waste storage capacity; adequate quantity and amount of land for waste utilization (or use of third party): access or
ownership of proper waste application equipment; schedule for timing of applications; application rates; loading rates; and
the control of the discharge of pollutants from stormwater runoff events less severe than the 25-year, 24-hour storm.
Name of Technical Specialist (Please print): M. Kevin Weston
Affiliation: Murphy Family Farms, Inc
Address (Agency): P. 0.. Box 759 Rose Hill, NC 28458 Phone No. [phone]
Signature: Date:
OwnerlManager Agreement
I (we) understand the operation and maintenance procedures established in the approved animal waste management plan
for the farm named above and will implement these procedures. I (we) know that any additional expansion to the existing
design capacity of the waste treatment and storage system or construction of new facilities will require a new certification to
be submitted to the Division of Environmental Management before the new animals are stocked. I (we) also understand
that there must be no discharge of animal waste from this system to surface waters of the state either through a man-
made conveyance or through runoff from a storm event less severe than the 25-year, 24-hour storm_ The approved plan
will be filed at the farm and at the office of the local Soil and Water Conservation District.
Name of L
Signature:
Name of Manager, if different from owner (Please Print):
Signature:
Date:
Note: A change in land ownership requires notification or a new certification (if the approved plan is changed) to be
submitted to the Division of Environmental Management within 60 days of a title transfer.
- - DEM USE ONLY: ACNEW# jjQ 3
31-563

FAMILYFARMS
August 8, 1995
Department of Environment, Health and Natural Resources
Division of Environmental Management
Water Quality Section,-., ing Branch y
P. O. Box 29535
Raliegh, NC 27626-0535
Attn: Mr. Steve Tedder, Chief
RE: Batchelor Farm - Swine Facility Certification
Duplin County, NC
Dear Mr. Tedder:
Enclosed is the certification form for the above referenced swine farm. By this letter, the Owner
certifies that the following crops will be planted or sprigged within 180 days of the stocking
date of the farm. Stocking Date: 9/y/9f
_Barley ✓Rye
✓Bermuda Grass (Graze/Hay/Pasture) _Small Grain (Graze/Hay)
_Corn (Grain/Silage) _Sorghum
_Cotton _Wheat
_Fescue (Graze/Hay/Pasture) _Oats
�Other(Explain)
The lagoon effluent will be applied to the crops Iisted above by
Center Pivot Irrigation (Installed/Not Installed)
Solid Set Irrigation (Installed/Not Installed)
Traveling Gun/Reel Irrigation (Owned/Not Owned)
Third Party Applicator
,,"Other (Explain) Morvrsc GW.�
Name of Technical Specialist: M. Kevin Weston
Signature: a%' 7✓ Dater/Z9-
Name of Land Owner. Murphy Family Farms
cc: Murphy Family Farms
Kim Patram, Murphy Family Farms Construction Department
Post. Office Box 759, Rose Hill, North Carolina 28458, [phone], FAX [phone]

- -State of North Carolina
Department of Environment,
Health and.Natural Resources 4 • •
Division of Environmental Management
James B. Hunt, Jr., Governor PI
Jonathan B. Howes, Secretary
A. Preston Howard, Jr., P.E., Director
March 23, 1994
Calvin Oates
Rt 1 Box 129-D
Kenansville NC 28349
Dear Mr. Oates:
This is to inform you that your completed registration form required by the recently
modified nondischarge rule has been received by the Division of Environmental Management
(DEM), Water Quality Section.
On December 10, 1992 the Environmental Management Commission adopted a water
quality rule which governs animal waste management systems. The goal of the rule is for animal
operations to be managed such that animal waste is not discharged to surface waters of the state_
The rule allows animal waste systems to be "deemed permitted" if certain minimum criteria are
met (15A NCAC 2H .0217). By submitting this registration you have met one of the criteria for
being deemed permitted.
We would like to remind you that existing feedlots which meet the size thresholds listed
in the rule, and any new or expanded feedlots constructed between February 1, 1993 and
December 31, 1993 must submit a signed certifications form (copy enclosed) to DEM by
December 31. 1997. New or expanded feedlots constructed after December 31, 1993 must
obtain signed certif cation before animals are stocked g,n the farm. Certification of an
approved animal waste management plan can be obtained after the Soil and Water Conservation
Commission adopts rules Iater this year. -
We appreciate you providing us with this information. If you have any question about
the new nondischarge rule, please contact David Harding at [phone].
Sincerely,
a
Steve Tedder, Chief
Water Quality Section
P.O. Box 29535, Raleigh, North Carolina 27626-o535 Telephone [phone] FAX [phone]
An Equal OpporiuNty Affirmative Action Employer 50% recycled/ 10% post -consumer paper

Operator:BATCHLOR SOW FARM County: DUPLIN �• / Date: 10/12/94
Distance to nearest residence (other than owner): 0.0 feet
1. AVERAGE LIVE WEIGHT (ALW)
0 sows (farrow to finish) x 1417 lbs. - 0 lbs
0 sows (farrow to feeder) x 522 lbs. = 0 lbs
0 head [ 1 x 135 lbs. - 0 lbs
1100 sows farrow to wean) x 433 lbs. = 476300 lbs
head (wean to fee er x 30 lbs. = 0 lbs
Describe other : 0
Total Average Live Weight = A76300 lbs
2. MINIMUM REQUIRED TREATMENT VOLUME OF LAGOON
a
Volume = 476300 lbs. ALW x Treatment Volume(CF)/lb. ALW
Treatment Volume(CF)/lb. ALW = 1 CF/lb. ALW
Volume = 476300 cubic feet
3. STORAGE VOLUME'FOR SLUDGE ACCUMULATION
Volume = 0.0 cubic feet
j 4. TOTAL DESIGNED -VOLUME
Inside top length (feet) -------------- ------ 325.0
Inside top width (feet) ---------------------- 325.0
Top of dike elevation (feet)----------------- 102.7
Bottom of lagoon elevation (feet)------------ 92.7
Freeboard ( feet) ------------------------------- 1.0
Side slopes (inside lagoon)-------------------- 3.0 : 1
Total design volume using prismoidal formula
SS/END1 SS/END2 SS/SIDE1 SS/SIDE2 LENGTH WIDTH DEPTH
I 3.0 3_0 3.0 3_0 319.0 319.0 9.0
AREA OF TOP
LENGTH * WIDTH =
319.0 319.0
AREA OF BOTTOM
LENGTH * WIDTH =
265.0 265.0
101761 (AREA OF TOP)
70225 (AREA OF BOTTOM)
AREA OF
MIDSECTION
LENGTH
* WIDTH * 4
292.0
292.0
34.1056 (AREA
OF MIDSECTION * 4)
CU. FT.
= [AREA TOP +
(4*AREAt._MIDSECTION)
+ AREA -.BOTTOM]
101761. 0
341056. 0, . ,_,,,,,
70225.0
,,9 ax-
�3��;�+�'i�;✓4, � a %±i "„''.�=y �'"� ;:YES- 4 .+ =lid-�� a►.:j ... � . r.. �2; r; .. . s.-,
_ � , �,. • _
DEPTH

Department of Environment, Health and Natural
Division of Environmental Management
Water Quality Section
e it
ces Of 1093
If the animal waste management system for your feedlot o ratXo:
is designed to serve more than or equal to 100 head of cat'`
horses, 250 swine, 1,000 sheep, or'30,000 birds that are served
by a liquid waste system, then this form must be filled out and
mailed by December 31, 1993 pursuant to 15A NCAC 2H.0217 (c) in
order to be deemed permitted by DEM. Please print clearly.
Farm Name: Batchelor Sow Farm
Route 1 Box 129-D
Kenansville, NC 28349
Duplin County '919-296-0107(F)/296-1690(H)
Owner(s) Name:
Manager(s) Name:
Lessee Name:
Farm Location (Be as specific as possible: road names,,
direction, milepost, etc.) : From -Kenansville, take NC 11/903 N 4.0 �Ps v) Ic
4` V r rn f e f -r p r- /_.�--/ ' miles; turn Lt. at Wesley chapel onto SR -
1516 (Wesley Chapel Rd); go 0.7 mile,
farm sign post on Lt.; follow dirt farm
road for 1.0 mile to farm. (T`--26 min.;
TD=20 miles.)
Latitude/Longitude if known: QBSP # 16-133-20-25
Design capacity of animal waste management system (Number and
type of confined animal (s) : 1 Coo 4 O(,j EL,r a -`t`o e er
ti
Average animal population on the farm (Number and typeof
animal (s) raised) : ) 0 ?- O Stn w 5 larrvw - h - -(,e��ir`
Year Production Began: } ASCS Tract No.: i 3 -a 13
Type of- Waste. Management. System Used: .anaet-obic- lCgknor\ wt-Aln
Solkj S-ef_ irf�CaQ7�Ul1 SYStefy) _ _Lj
Acres Available for Land Application of Waste: �[a
owners) Signature(s)Date: %
- - - - -.�JL+ _� Date :
(Jane Mitchell, Serviceman)

Plan Amendment to Include S&WCC Chronic Rainfall Practices and Standards through March 31, 2000
i If this facility can comply with its existing permit and CAWMP it must do so.
2
Temporaty Addition of New Sprayfields (') (Check appropiate boxes.)
0 A - acres of cropland.CEs crt op a used:
[] B. acres of hardwood woodland @ 100 lbs PAN / acre added.
0 C. acres of pine woodland added @ 60 lbs PAN / acre added.
3 Summer Perennial Grass (Check appropriate box.)
[*] A. " Application window extended for 46.03 acres of perennial grass until first killing frost
[] B. An additional 50 lbs of PAN applied to acres of perennial grass prior to killing frost
4 PAN application Increased for Small! Grains & Winter Grasses to be harvested. (Check appropriate box.)
A. PAN application increased up to 200 lbs per acre for 46.03 acres of small grains or winter grasses to be harvested.
0 B. PAN application increased up to 150 lbs per arse for acres of overseeded summer perennial included in 3.B,
5 Waste Analysis (Check appropriate box.)
0 A. Prior to December 1st, 1999 the calculation of PAN will be based on a 35% reduction of the last analysis taken
prior to the first 25 year 24 hour storm event. (Current waste analysis must be used after Dec. 1 st.)
B. Use current waste analysis to determine PAN.
-a
6 RgQui red - Maximum Nitrogen Utilization Measures for Small Grains and Winter Grasses.
A. Use of higher seeding rates,
B. Timely harvest of forage to increase yield, and
C. Irrigation during periods of warmer weather.
7 Required - irrigation Management Techniques to Reduce Runoff and Ponding Potential.
A. Making frequent, fight irrigation applications, and
B. Not irrigation immediately before predicted rainfall
6 The owner / manager is required to manage the movement of animals to and from the facility to minimize environmental
impacts, ensure compliance with the facility's permit and amended CAWMP, and avoid discharge to surface waters.
9 Authorization to use the additional practices included in the amendment expires if a facility discharges to surface waters.
Any discharge is a violation and may result in an enforcement action.
10 The owner / operator is required to keep records of all waste applications.
11 This revision must include a map or sketch of new land application areas.
Facility Number 31 - 563 Batchelor
Facility Name
Morph ,amily Farms Kral Westerbeek
Facility Own / anage e R T ethnical S ialis me
Facility Owner / Manager Si ture z )ie�chnial peciaiist Signature
Date 11/11/99 l Date ' 11/11/99
This document must be filed at the SWCD officd and be attached to the facilities CAWMP
and be available for inspection at the facility
(') New temporary sprayfields must meet applicable buffer and setback requirements. Waste must not be applied to wetlands"

State of North Carolina
Department of Environment
and Natural Resources
Division of Water Quality
James B. Hunt, Jr., Governor
Bill Holman, Secretary
Kerr T. Stevens, Director
Murphy Family Farms
Batchelor Sow Farm
PO Box 759
Rose Hill NC 28458
Dear Murphy Family Farms:
1 0 •
NCDENR
NORTH CAROLINA DEPARTMENT OF
ENVIRONMENT AND NATURAL RESOURCES
December 30, 1999
Subject: Fertilizer Application Recordkeeping
Animal Waste Management System
Facility Number 31-563
Duplin County
This letter is being sent to clarify the recordkeeping requirement for Plant Available Nitrogen (PAN)
application on fields that are part of your Certified Animal Waste Management Plan.
In order to show that the agronomic loading rates for the crops being grown are not being exceeded, you
must keep records of all sources of nitrogen that are being added to these sites. This would include nitrogen
from all types of animal waste as well as municipal and industrial sludges/residuals, and commercial fertilizers.
Beginning January 1, 2000, all nitrogen sources applied to land receiving animal waste are required to
be kept on the appropriate recordkeeping forms (i.e. IRR1, IRR2, DRY], DRY2, DRY3, SLUR1, SLUR2,
SLD1, and SLD2) and maintained in the facility records for review. The Division of Water Quality (DWQ)
compliance inspectors and Division of Soil and Water operation reviewers will review all recordkeeping during
routine inspections. Facilities not documenting all sources of nitrogen application will be subject to an
appropriate enforcement action.
Please be advised that nothing in this letter should be taken as removing from you the responsibility or
liability for failure to comply with any State Rule, State Statute, Local County Ordinance, or permitting
requirement.
If you have any questions regarding this letter, please do not hesitate to contact Ms. Sonya Avant of the
DWQ staff at [phone] ext. 571.
Sincerel ,
Kerr T. Stevens, Director
Division of Water Quality
cc: Wilmington Regional Office
Duplin County Soil and Water Conservation District
Facility File
1617 Mail Service Center, Raleigh, North Carolina 27699-1617 Telephone [phone] Fax [phone]
An Equal Opportunity Affirmative Action Employer 50% recycled/10% post -consumer paper

Revised April 20, 1999.
JUSTIFICATION & DOCUMENTATION FOR MANDATORY WA DETERMINATION
Facility Number 3� -
Farm Name: S�
On -Site Representative:` iL
Inspector/Reviewer's Name:
Date of site visit:
Date of most recent WUP:
Operation is flagged for a wettable
acre determination due to failure of
Part ll eligibility item(s) F1 F2 F3 F4
JOperation not required to secure WA
determination at this ti a based on
exemption E1 E2 E E4
Operation pended for wettable acre -
rn determination based on Pl P2 P3
Annual farm PAN deficit: pounds
Irrigation Systems) - circle#hard-hose traveler, 2. center. -pivot system; 3. Iinear--move system;'
4. stationary sprinkler system w/permanent pipe; 5. stationary sprinkler system w/portable pipe;
fi. stationary gun system w/permanent pipe; 7. stationary gun system w/portable pipe
PART I. WA Determination Exemptions (Eligibility failure, Part 11, overrides Part I exemption.)
El Adequate irrigation design, including map depicting wettable acres, is complete
- and signed by an I or PE.
E2 Adequate D, and D2/D3 irrigation operating parameter sheets, including map -
f depicting wettable acres, is.complete and signed by an I or PE.
V E3 Adequate D, irrigation operating parameter sheet, including map depicting
wettable acres, is complete and signed by a WUP.
E4 75% rule exemption as verified in Part Ill. (NOTE:75 % exemption cannot be
applied to farms that fail the eligibility checklist in Part 11. Complete eligibility
checklist, Part 11--Fl F2 F3, before completing computational table in Part 111).
PART If. 75% Rule .EligibilityChecklist and .Documentation of WA Determination
Requirements. _WA Determination .required -because_operation .fails une of.the .eligibility
requirements listed ]below:
_ F1 Lack .of:acreagewhich -resulted in:Dverapplicationzf-wastewater--.(PAN) on:spray_
field(s):2ccordingfofarm'siasttwo years:Df�rrigation-xecords.-.
F2 Unclear,:iIlegibie,-or lack of -information/map.
_ F3 Obviousfieldiimitations-(numerous:ditches;failurefo:deductlequired_-_
buffer/setback�creage;mr25%':oftotal-acreageddentified in AWitllP=includes _ `:
small ,-irregularly-shapedfelds�-fields:less7than�mcresfor#ravelersmr_less- han
2 acresfor.-stationary-sprinklers).
F4 WA determination required because CAWMP credits field(s)'s acreage -in excess
of 75% of the respective field's total acreage as noted in table in Part 111.

Revised April 20, 1999
Facility Number _-
Part Ill. Field by Field Determination of 75% Exemption Rule for WA Determination
TRACT FIELD TYPE of TOTAL CAWMP FIELD COMMENTS
NUMBER NUMBEW-2 IRRIGATION ACRES ACRES %
SYSTEM
I I !
E ! I I I !
FIELD NUMBER' hydrant, yell. zone, or:point numbers maybe used in place of field numbers deoendino on CAWMP
and type of irrication system. If pulls, etc. cross more -than one field, .inspector/reviewer will have to combine fields to
calculate 75% leld by field determination for exemption; -otherwise_ operation will be subject to WA determination.
FIELD NUMSER2 - must be clearly defineated 66Yma_p.
COMMENTS' -back-up fields with CAWMP acFea9emxceeding75% of its total:acres and having -received less than 50%
of its annual PAN as documented in the farm'sprevious-Awo years' (1997 & 1998) of irrioaiionTecords,-cannot serve -as -the
sole basis -for -requiring a WA Determination. -:-Back-up fields -must -be -noted in the -commentzection-and musfbe accessible
by irrigation system_
Part IV. Pending WA Determinations
P1 Plan lacks .followinginformation :
P2 Plan -revision -may:satisfy-75% rule based on adequate overall PAN deficit -and by
adjusting -all field acreage--to-below 75% use -rate
P3 Other (ie/in process of installing new irrigation system):

:gin P :-E-
M RPHY
FAMILY FARMS
July 15, 1998
NCDENR - DWQ
127 North Cardinal Dr.
Wilmington, N.C. 28405
Subject: Notice of Deficiency at Batchelor F 31-563
Dear Wrenn:
JUL 1 71998
Murphy Family Farm's staff Technical Specialist Kevin Weston revised the Nutrient
Utilization Plan (NUP) for Batchelor on June 4, 1998, but had not yet left a copy on the
farm because he was awaiting the results of some in-house surveying.
I am enclosing a copy of the updated NUP that includes all current spray fields. All
spray records will coincide with this plan's stipulations.
If you have any questions, please call John Bizic at 910-289-6439.
Sincerely,
John Bizi
Land & Nutrient Manager
JB/mt
GAMMIREN.DOC
attachment
cc: Harold Jones
Sandra Weitzel
Garth Boyd
Robert L. Matthews

State of North Carolina
Department of Environment
and Natural Resources
Wilmington Regional Office
James B. Hunt, Jr., Governor
Wayne McDevitt, Secretary
Division of Water Quality
July 6, 1998
Certiifled MaB # Z 312 648 152
Return Receipl Requested
Mr. John Bizic .
Murphy Family Farms
Batchelor Sow Farm
PO Box 759
Rose Hill, North Carolina 28458
Cox
mi
f
NCDENR
NoF" C^Fm uN^ Du-w-rmEtrr of
ENVIRONMENT AND N/GIJRAL ResouRces
Subject: SECOND NOTICE OF DEFICIENCY
Batchelor Sow Farm
Facility Number: 31-563
Duplin County
Dear Mr. Bizic :
On June 30, 1998, staff from the Wilmington Regional Office of the Division of Water
Quality inspected you animal operation and the lagoon(s) serving this operation. It was observed
that waste had been applied to fields not listed in the Waste Utilization Plan (WUP). Based on an
August 26, 1997 inspection by DWQ staff, a prior Notice of Deficiency was issued for applying
waste to fields that were not part of your WUP
Applying waste to fields not in your WUP is a violation of your Certified Animal Waste
Management Plan (CAWMP), and subsequent infractions may result in a Notice of Violation and
include a civil penalty. All fields on which waste is to be applied must be listed in the CAWMP.
Waste application to the fields not in the WUP should be discontinued until the situation can be
corrected. In addition, the correct PAN loading rate for the small grain overseed should be used
when calculating the nitrogen balances in the spray records. We suggest that you contact your
service company, local NRCS or Soil and Water District office for any assistance they may be
able to provide to correct the situation.
To remain a deemed permitted facility, you must notify this office in writing within seven
(7) days of the receipt of this notice, what actions will be taken to comply with your waste
management plan. Failure to do so may result in the facility losing it's deemed permitted status,
requiring it to obtain an individual non discharge permit.
127 North Cardinal Dr., Wilmington, North Carolina 28405 Telephone 9I0-395-3900 FAX [phone]
An Equal Opportunity Affirmative Action Employer 50% recycled/10% post -consumer paper

Mr. Bizic
July 6, 1998
Page 2.
Please be aware it is a violation of North Carolina General Statutes to discharge wastewater
to the surface waters of the State without a permit. The Department of Environment, Health and
Natural Resources has the authority to levy a civil penalty of not more than $10,000 per day per
violation.
When the required corrective actions are complete, please notify this office in writing at
the address below. If you have any questions concerning this matter, please call David Holsinger
or Brian Wrenn at 910-395-3900.
Sincerely,
_ f ]
Brian L. Wrenn
Environmental Specialist
cc: Harold Jones, County Soil and Water Conservation
Sandra Weitzel, NC Division of Soil and Water Conservation
Dr. Garth Boyd, Murphy Family Farms '
Operations Branch
Wilmington Files
S. IWQS1BRIANWIDEF981D UPLIM3I-563-2.DEF

Producer: MWRPH•t FAMILY Ft?-hs - '8A'TC-NeLo;z FARM
Location: +-'t-i- I 36x 12R -D Jeeu..Hs�+«E , N[ ZZ3y9 fK ,v4'
Telephone: (4ec 296 - 61 e7
Type Operation: Fq xxaw - l c1eAAt
Numb e; of Animals: Z o 3 s
(Desig. Capacity)
The waste from your animal facility must be land applied at a specified rate ro prevent
p oLiudon of sarface and/or groundwater. The plant nutrients in the animal waste should
be us--d to reduce the amount of commercial fera�izer required for the crops in the fields
where the waste is to be applied. This waste utilization plan uses nitro zm as the limhmg
nu";ent_ Waste should be ana vzed before each application cycle. Annual z_01-1 tests are
=onely encouraged so tat all plant nutrients can be balanced for realistic :ields or the
LT-ap _o be mown.
S e_ al factors are imporazit in inmlementing your waste utliratzon plan in order to
---, ire the ferahzer value of the waste and to ensure that it is applied in a
ew,&i onmentally safe manner, Always apply waste based on the needs of the :.;op to be
Sr0Vv3 and the nument conteat of the waste. Do not apply more nitrogea tYan the crop
cah tit':;ize. Sod types are i=ortant as they have different infiltration rates, leac=3 z
tloziam:4- is, cation exchange capacities, andavailablewater holding capacities. -Normally
w-as-,e shall ttot be applied to land eroding at greater than 45 tons per acre pe: vest. With
s-aeciai precautions, waste maybe applied to land a.od as at up to 10 tons per acre per
yea_. Do not apply waste on saturated soils, when it is ramming, or when the sar=-ace is
frozem Either of these conditions may result in runoffto surface waters which is not
allowed under DEM regulations. Wind conditions should also be considered to avoid drift
aad dowuwind odor problems. To maxartzize the value of nutrients for crop production
and to reduce the potential for pollution, the waste should be applied to a gowing crop or
appLed to bare ground not more thazi 30 days prior to planting- bajecring the wale or
C=-K;-_g will conserve numents and reduce odor problems.
The es-,;—..ated acres needed to apply the animal Lease is based on typical nun;. mt content
for this rLpe of facility. Acreage requirements should be based on the was.- analysis
rep or, from your waste rsauaaement facility. Attached you will find information on
propel sazripling techniques, preparation, and transfer ofwase samples to the lab for
a:-, ad sis.
This w.•aste utilization plan, if carried out, meets'the requirements for co=haace with 15A
14'CAC 2H.0217 adopted by the Environmental ivta.nagenaent Commission.

Amount of Waste Produced Per Yeartzallons fE ton_s etc_
ZD 3 S auimal,S Xb 12(aM waste/animai/year =1Z 393 ( ) wastelyear,
Amount of Plant Available Nitrogen (PAN) Produced Per. Year
za 3 f anm�ais X S_Y Is. P 4N/anima Vyear = La gQ 9 lbs.. PAN/year. (PAN from N. C. TeclL
Guide Std. 633)
Applying the above amount of waste is a big job. You should plan time and have
appropriate equipment to apply the waste in a timely -manner.
b
7-he following acreage will be needed for waste application based on the crop to be grown
and StifIce application:
1 aaiz 1: ACRES OWNED BY PRODUCER
Trac: Feld Soiii Crop Lbs. N Acres Lbs. N -M01-I h of
No. T ve Per Ac. * Utilized Amobcation
T 1
I I I F A �"
30o
I Z8.,F1
I F& 3
IAUR,. -&r.
T1
I Z I a -F-A
Z?. S
I /o. y
l z994
ILUK" -6,-r.
I I I
I
I
I
1
I I I
!
!
I
I
T'f
F&A - A,,T3
39, z Y
i 3 q a Y
I 1'r-r4?,zr<
I ! 1
I
I
1 I I
(
I
I
1 I I
I
I
I I I I
I
!
I I I
I
!
1 1 !
1
1
I 1 I I
I
I
Toral 1 39• ?Y 11.5�sL` I
This 1u is from animal waste only. if nutrients from other soarers such as co'rrrxrCL t
fertili.:.er• are applied, they must be accounted for. N must be based on realistic yield
e'x ecrariorl-
NOTE' The applicator is cautioned that P and K may be over applied while met--ing theN
requiremcnu Beginning in 1996 the Coastal Zone Managerrzent Act will require fan -.rrs in
sorrre eastern counties ofNorrh Carolina to have a nutrient rr-anagement plan that addresser
all nut�-ients. Thu plan only addresses Nitrogem

r.V" ..�...''.~`.�,. �.•" ..+�"�-^1.,"'�;
Table Z: ACRES WITH AGREEMENT OR LONG TERIM LEASE
(Agreement with adjacent Iandowner must be attached)
(Required only if operator does not own
adupate land (see Required Specification 21)
Tract Field Soil Crop Lbs_ N Acres Lbs. N Month of
No. Type Per Ac. Utffized Aupkadon
I I i
i I
I I
I I I I !
I f I f
f I I I f I i
I I f I I i
( I f ! f I I
i f I I i I f
Total I
See foatrrote for Taole L
Totals from above Tables
Acres Lbs. N
Utilized
Table I 31. x q
Table Z
Total 39.2 If SS b
Amount of N Produced is 9 �r
Surplus or-ve-fcit qS 7 7
NOTE: The Waste Utilization Plan must contain provisions for periodic land
application of sludge at agronomic rates. The sludge will be nutrient rich and will
require precautionary measures to prevent over application of nutrients or other
elements.
3

See arrached map showing the fields to be used for the utilization of waste water.
Application of Waste by Irrigation
Fels. Soil Type Crop Application Application
N o. Rate (In%Hr) Amount DO
FoA f 13AM.-ag
U. S
I
2
A,3 - F.A
I�
I
AA -r
� - .� Aka i � ,?,,s
o.
i
I
f
I
l
�
s =rvL LS NOT :�k-�� � :V4Sir tiOT HF�'Cr?.DPZ�.^�7 3Y L��:C-:�-ON, a wj-V .4, MC. -I xI L= � ZL
BE =--) FOR DRY LT~ =- V LU.:ZRY.
Yotz :aclity is designed for /8odays of temp orary storage and the temnor,1 storage
:maisr be removed oa the average of once every TYiQN HS. In no -iisance should
the volume of waste beiaQ stored in your structure excee- Elevation ?EA e
Cail the local Natural Resources Conservation Service (formerly Soil Corsanxffon
Ser-v, ce) or Soil and Watex Conservation Dist icr office afer you receive the wale
analv;.; report for assir:uce in determmmg the auzounr per acre to apply au,d the proper
apvLca=on rate prior to applying the waste.
Narrad've of operation:
��LD! fN4t-7i /r� 'LA-J /AFLa 141?i1
ANo AcA�--4GE s ,49e 1AAI64r/1jLE . /- 7 4AC
rr rtca / Ar0 o07r 6f r-//. A0W f.- rrE[D L kor o.- A- A --gel
Y itt o✓Er�fEEnED N..*1v R'r }tG1+Arr Fob t�irrBd- A?Pe,avT...�
4

AT -
M.
- "•.�.........N..�..:,::2�'Ya:::1vC�rn"r'crk.r.......:... - r"'. ".. .
REQ MED SPECIFICATIONS
1. Animalwaste shall not reach surface waters of the sate by runoff; dry manmade
conveyances, direct application, or direct discharge during operation or laud
application- Any discharge of waste which reaches surface water is prohioked.
2. There must be documentation is the design folder that the producer ehher owns orhas
an agreement for use of adequate land on which to properly apply the waste. If the
producer does not own adequate laud to properly dispose of waste, hefshe shall
provide a copy of as azeement with a landowner who is within a reasonable
proximity, allowing him&er the use of the laud for -waste application. It is the
�resa onssibility of the owner of the facility to secure an update of the Wale lititiration
PIan when there is a change in the operation, increase za the number of animpis,
method ofutiiizatioa, or avatUble Iand.
3. anal waste shall be applied to meet, but not exceed, the nitrogen-nmis orrealistic
crop yields based on soil type, available moisture, historical data, cE=-,zc conahions,
a.nd level of management. unless there are resularions that restrict the r_:e o
aoo.;catioa for other ut 4 eats. V
4_ Anizmal waste shall be applied to land eroding less than 5 tons per
W ace may be applied to land that is eroding at S or more tons, but less Linan 10 tons
p =- awe per year proyiag *ass ffer strips are ssalled where runoz leaves the field_
(S ee FOTG Standard :93 - Finer Strip).
5. Odors can be reduced by injecting the waste or di skin g after waste appika=on. Waste
suould not be applied.�itea there is danger of dries from the irrigation yesd
6_ Z"v Bien animal waste is to be applied on acres subje- to riooding, it with be sots
iucorn orated on cone-ndonallytilled cropland. When applied to copse -nation tined
crops or grassland, the waste maybe broadcast provided the application does not
occur during a season prone to flooding. (See "Weather and Climate in Nora
Carol.ina" for guidance.)
7_ Liquid waste shall be applied at rates not to exceed the sod infiltration rate suci that
r,Woii does not occur o=e or to surface waters acid ia a method which does not
caLse drift from the site duzina application.. No poadi:ag should occur is orde_, to
control odor or flies.
S. rti waste shall aot be applied to saturated soils, during rainfall events, or when the
st_;Lce is frozen.

REQUIRED SPECIFICATIONS
(continued)
9. Animal waste shall be applied on actively growing crops in such a mahaer that the
crop is not covered with waste to a depth that would inhibit growth. The poteatialfor
salt damage from animal waste should also be considered.
10. Waste nutrients shall not be applied in fall or winter for spring planted crops on soils
with a high potential, for leaching. Waste nutrient loading rates on these sous should
be held to a minimum and a suitable winter cover crop planted to take up rel=,sed
nutrients. Waste shall not be applied more than :3 0 days prior to planting of the crop
--or forages breaking dormancy.
11. Anv new swine fac7ity sited on or after October 1,.1995 shall comply wrh -dte
following: Mae outer perimeter of the land area onto which waste is applied Tom a
lazoon that is a comonmt of a swine farm shall be ar least 50 feet from =,, residential
property boundary anduom any perennial seam or river (other than as —=I i rion
d=ch or canal wage other than swhae wale mom facilities sited on or a:re<
Oc-cober 1, 1995), s 21 not be applied closer than 25 fee: to perennial watW. (See
Standard 393 - FI-er. Sys).
12. —imal waste shalt not be applied closer than 100 et to wells.
1- . -17-urinal waste shall aot be applied closer than 200 Peer of dwellings other th—:r: those
owned by the landowz—.-
lzt. Waste shall be apuded in a manner not to reach ozaer property and public ,ri.Lzr-off
'rays.
15. Animal waste shall not be discharged into surface waters, dram.a4eways, or wetlands
by a discharge or by over -spraying. Animal waste may be applied to prior converted
wetlands provided they have been approved as a land application site by a "tNhnical
specialist". Animal wale shallnot be applied on was ed waterways that discaarge
directly into water courses, and on other grassed warer xays, waste shall be applied at
a g onomic rates in a manner that causes no runoffor drift from the site.
16. Domestic and indusu.al waste from washdowa fat ilixties, showers, toilets, sue, etc.,
-:nail not be discharged into the animal waste management sysem

REQ=D SPECFiCATIONS
(continued)
IS- If animal production at the facility is to be suspended or terminated, the owner is
responsible for obrainin; and implementing a "closure plan" whichAU- diabate the
possibility of an Megai discharge, poRudon and erosion.
19. Waste handling structures, piping, pumps, reels, erc., should be inspected on aregalar
bass to prevent breakdowns, leaks, and spflls. A regaiar maintenance checkshould
b e kept on site.
20. An3mai waste can be used in a rotation that includes vegetables and oth- cvnshr
direct human consu=don. However, if animal waste is used on crops for direct
hu=am consumption ltshould only be applied preplant with no further appEcations of
animal waste dutm; dhe crop season.
21. 1Ugh1y visible markers _hail be installed to mark the top and bottom eia:ations of the
tenororary storage (pumping volume) of all waste =eatment lagoons. P—=Mg shall
be managed to maintain the Hauid level between the =arlk- A mare: wid be
required to mar the maxiraum storage volume for wale storage pones.
22. Wasre shall be tested 69 days of uOization and soil shall be tes:d at le=
a=uaily at crop sites wne;e waste products are applied_ Nzffogen shi be the rate_
ee.e-�rTis�n,g element T.mc and copper levels in the soils shall be monaored and
alre;uative crop sizes shall be used when these meras approach excessi,•e leItIS. pH
shad be adjusted for optimum crop production and ==tained. Sod and war-z:
aaa?ysis records shall be kept for five years. Poult� r dry waste application rw:ords
szall be maintained for three (3) years. Was;.e application records for ad otter wee
wall be maintained for five (5) years.
23. Dead animals will be disposed of in a matnzer that melts North Carolinz :-Mllstions.
W

WASTE UTII,LZATTON PLAN AGREEMENT
,Name of Farm: 8 T G 1f L0 +Z ��q
Owner/Manager ,4greement
I (we) understand and will follow and implement the sp eccification and the opa-xdon and
maintenance procedures established i a the approved animal waste utilization plan for the
farm named above. I (we) ]mow that any expansion to the existing design capacity ofthe
was"re treatment and storage system or constriction of new facilities will rewire anew
cerdEcation to be submitted to the Division of Environment Managemeat (DEM) before
the new animals are stocked- I (we) also understand that there must be no urge of
ar�innaI waste from this system to surface wasters of the state from a storm e-,rent less
severe than the 25-year, 24--hour storm The approved plan will, be filed on-sse at the
far= office and at the oats of the local Soil and Water Conservation Dis�-r Md will be
ava fable for review by DEM upon reques_
Name of Facility Owner: AI LAzpK-1 FA rAI L-r FAQf-5
Si=a=.,-e: Date: f-1 / 1
Name of J. Ler(If di&.nmt from owner):
S i=arLL:re: Date:
Name of Technical Speriaiisz (Pleaseprinr)rh�t. ,��y�na l~l� sro.�
AH*I Lion: MLArt?Ny FAm.L-`r FiXmS
Aadz,ess (Ageacy). '?o . &,. 7S ?- P-
�oSe 14,1.L AIC z F ys?
Sias tie 1•i,-- Gc%j Date: y/9�

NUH I H UAHULINA
Department of Environmental Qual

Water Resources
ENVIPONMENl'nL QUAL�7Y
TGB Farms, LLC
Legacy 2 Farm
753 South Horsepen Road
Harrells, NC 28444
Dear TGB Farms, LLC:
PAT MCCRORY
Guverao:'
R MeftNk1r bLDER V A A R T
.iecTefGr'
S. JAY ZIMMERMAN
AUG 2 9 2.016
August 26, 2016 is ecror
Water Quality Regional
Wil, Operations Section
Regional Office
Subject: Certificate of Coverage No. AWS310563
Legacy 2 Farm
Swine Waste Collection, Treatment,
Storage and Application System
Duplin County
In accordance with your Notification of Change of Ownership received August 19, 2016, we are hereby
forwarding to you this Certificate of Coverage (COC) issued to TGB Farms, LLC, authorizing the operation
of the subject animal waste management system in accordance with General Permit AWG100000,
This approval shall consist of the operation of this system including, but not limited to, the management
and land application of animal waste as specified in the facility's Certified Animal Waste Management Plan
(CAWMP) for Legacy 2 Farm, located in Duplin County, with a swine animal capacity of no greater than
the following annual averages:
Wean to Finish: Feeder to Finish: Boar/Stud:
Wean to Feeder: Farrow to Wean: 2,035 Gilts:
Farrow to Finish: Farrow to Feeder: Other:
If this is a Farrow to Wean or Farrow to Feeder operation, there may be one boar for each 15 sows. Where
boars are unnecessary, they may be replaced by an equivalent number of sows. Any of the sows may be
replaced by gilts at a rate of 4 gilts for every 3 sows.
This COC shall be effective from the date of issuance until September 30, 2019, and shall hereby void
Certificate of Coverage Number AWS310563 dated October 1, 2014. Pursuant to this COC, you are
authorized and required to operate the system in conformity with the conditions and limitations as specified
in the General Permit, the facility's CAWMP, and this COC. An adequate system for collecting and
maintaining the required monitoring data and operational information must be established for this facility.
Any increase in waste production greater than the certified design capacity or increase in number of animals
authorized by this COC (as provided above) will require a modification to the CAWMP and this COC and
must be completed prior to actual increase in either wastewater flow or number of animals.
Please read this COC and the enclosed State General Permit carefully. Please pgy careful attention to the
record keeping and monitoring conditions in this permit. Record keeping forms are unchanged with this
General Permit. Please continue to use the same record keeping forms.
If your Waste Utilization Plan (V UP) has been developed based on site -specific information, careful
evaluation of future samples is necessary. Should your records show that the current WUP is inaccurate
you will need to have a new WUP developed.
State of North Carolina l Environmontal Quality I Water Resources
1636 Mail service Center I Raleigh, North Carolina 27699.1636
919 807 6464

The issuance; of4his COC does not excuse the Permittee from the obligation to comply with all applicable
laws, rules, standards, and ordinances (local, state, and federaI), nor does issuance of a COC to operate
under this -permit convey any property rights in either real or personal property.
Per NRCS standards a 100-foot separation shall be maintained between water supply wells and any lagoon,
storage pond, or any wetted area of a spray field.
Please be advised' that any violation of the terns and conditions specified in this COC, the General Permit
or the CAWMP may result in the revocation of this COC, or penalties in accordance with NCGS 143-
215.6A through 143-215.6C including civil penalties, criminal penalties, and injunctive relief.
If any parts, requirements, or limitations contained in this COC are unacceptable, you have the right to .
apply for an individual permit by contacting the Animal Feeding Operations Program for information on
this process. Unless such a request is made within 30 days, this COC shall be final and binding.
In accordance with Condition II.22 of the General Permit, waste application shall cease within four (4)
hours of the time that the National Weather Service issues a Hurricane Warning, Tropical Storm Warning,
or a Flood Watch associated with a tropical system for the county in which the facility is located. You may
find detailed watch/warning information for your county by calling the Newport/Morehead City, NC
National Weather Service office at [phone], or by visiting their website at:
hqp://www.weather.g
This facility is located in a county covered by our Wilmington Regional Office. The Regional Office staff
may be reached at 910-796-7215. If you need additional information concerning this COC or the General
Permit, please contact the Animal Feeding Operations Program staff at [phone].
Sincerely,
for S. Jay Zimmerman, P.G.
Director, Division of Water Resources
Enclosure (General Permit AWG100000)
cc: (Certificate of Coverage only for all ccs)
r Wilmington' Regional Office, Water Quality Regional Operations Section
Duplin County Health Department
Duplin County Soil and Water Conservation District
WQROS Central Files (Permit No. AWS310563)
Smithfield Hog Production

NCDENR
North Carolina Department of Environment and Natural Resources
Pat McCrory Donald R. van der Vaart
Governor Secretary
January 22, 2015
CERTIFIED MAIL 7010 0290 0003 0833 9687
RETURN RECEIPT REQUESTED
Kraig Westerbeek, Vice President
Murphy -Brown LLC
PO Box 856
Warsaw NC 28398-0856
Subject: NOTICE OF VIOLATION & INTENT TO ISSUE CIVIL PENALTY
NOV Tracking Number: NOV-2014-DV-0228
Incident No. 201401619
Permit No. AWS310563
Batchelor Sow Farm
Duplin County
Dear Mr Westerbeek:
A review has been conducted of the self reported animal wastewater spill incident that occurred at the subjectfacility
on September 19, 2014 and documentation submitted to our office followingthe incident. The Division's Wilmington
Regional Office concludes that the Murphy -Brown LLC committed thefollowing violations associated with the subject
incident:
1. Permit Condition 1 (1) by failing to effectively manage, maintain, and operate their wastewater system so
that there is no discharge to wetlands or surface waters; subject incident constituted making an outlet to
waters of the State for purposes of G.S. 143-215.1(a)(1) for which a permit is required by G.S. 143-215.1.
2. Permit Condition 111 (15) per G.S. 143-215.1(C) by failing to properly issue a press release within 48 hours a
discharge of at least 1,000 gallons to wetlands or surface waters of the State.
3. Permit Condition 111(16) per G.S. 143-215.1(C) by failing to properly publish a public notice for a discharge of
at least 15,000 gallons to wetlands or surface waters of the State and provide proof of publication to the
Division within 30 days after publication.
4. Permit Condition 111 (9) (f) by failing to sample within 72 hours and/or provide sample results for the listed
parameters to the Division within 30 days.
t;
The Wilmington Regional Office is providing the Murphy -Brown LLC an opportunity to provide evidence and
.:`justification as to why the Murphy -Brown LLC should not be assessed a civil penalty for the violations that are
summarized above.
127 Cardinal Drive Extension, Wilmington, North Carolina 28405
Phone: [phone]\ Internet: www.ncdenr.a£ov
An Equal Opportunity \ Affirmative Action Employer —Made in part by recycled paper

N OV-2014-DV-028<<CASE_N U M B E R))
January 22, 2015
Page 2 of 2
Please submit a written response and any additional documentation about this incident within 10 business days
following receipt of this violation. The submittal will be reviewed to determine if a civil penalty assessment by the
Division's Regional Office is warranted.
If you should have any questions, please do not hesitate to contact me or Dean Hunkele with the Water Quality
Section at [phone] or via email at Dean. [e-mail].
Sincerely, , 1
For S. ay Zimmerman, Acting Director
Division of Water Resources, NCDENR
by lames H. Gregson
Regional Supervisor
Water Quality Regional Operations Section
Wilmington Regional Office
Division of Water Resources, NCDENR
Cc: WIRO — WQS File (Hunkele)
Central Files, Water Quality Section
;r

Permit Number AWG1.00000
S Fecal coliform bacteria 9LS Five-day biochemical oxygen demand (BOD5)
j S Total suspended solids �L(3 Total phosphorous
Ammonia nitrogen (NH3-N) KN) �f� — Total Kjeldahl nitrogen (T
Nitrate nitrogen {403-N)
Monitoring results must be submitted to the Division within thirty (30) days of the
discharge event.
10. In accordance with 15A NCAC 02T .0108(c), the Division may require any monitoring and
reporting (including but not limited to groundwater, surface water or wetland, waste, sludge, soil,
lagoon/storage pond levels and plant tissue) necessary to determine the source, quantity, quality,
and effect of animal waste upon the surface waters, groundwaters or wetlands. Such monitoring,
including its scope, frequency, duration and any sampling, testing, and reporting systems, shall
meet all applicable Division requirements_
11. A copy of this General Permit, the facility's COC, certification forms, lessee and landowner
agreements, the CAWMP and copies of all records required by this General Permit and the
facility's CAWMP shall be maintained by the Permittee in chronological and legible form for
three (3) years. Records include but are not limited to: soil and waste analyses, rain gauge
readings, freeboard levels, irrigation and land application event(s), past inspection reports and
operational reviews, animal stocking records, records of additional nutrient sources applied
(including but not limited to sludges, unused feedstuff leachate, milk waste, septage and
commercial fertilizer), cropping information, waste application equipment testing and calibration,
and records of removal of solids to off -site location(s). These records shall be maintained on
forms provided or approved by the Division and shall be readily available at the facility (stored at
places such as the farm residence, office, outbuildings, etc.) where animal waste management
activities are being conducted.
12. Within fifteen (15) working days of receiving the request from the Division, the Permittee shall
provide to the Division one (1) copy of all requested information and reports related to the
operation of the animal waste management system. Once received by the Division, all such
information and reports become public information, unless they constitute confidential
information under G.S. § 132-1.2, and shall be made available to the public by the Division as
specified in Chapter 132 of the General Statutes.
13. Regional Notification:
The Permittee shall report by telephone to the appropriate Division Regional Office as soon as
possible, but in no case more than twenty-four (24) hours following first knowledge of the
occurrence of any of the following events:
a. Failure of any component.of the animal waste management system resulting in a discharge
to ditches, surface waters, or wetlands.
b. Any failure of the waste treatment and disposal system that renders the facility incapable of
adequately receiving, treating, or storing the waste and/or sludge.
C. A spill or discharge from a vehicle transporting waste or sludge to the land application field
which results in a discharge to ditches, surface waters, or wetlands or an event that poses a
serious threat to surface waters, wetlands, or human health and safety.
d. Any deterioration or leak in a lagoon/storage pond that poses an immediate threat to the
environment or human safety or health.
9 March 7, 2014

Permit Number AWGI00000
4. A representative Standard Soil Fertility Analysis, including pH, phosphorus, copper, and zinc,
shall be conducted on each application field receiving animal waste in accordance with G.S. §
143-215.1 OC(e)(6). As of the effective date of this General Permit, the Statute requires that the
analysis be conducted at least once every three years.
5. An analysis of a representative sample of the animal waste to be applied shall be conducted in
accordance with recommended laboratory sampling procedures as close to the time of application
as practical and at least within sixty (60) days (before or after) of the date of application. Every
reasonable effort shall be made to have the waste analyzed prior to the date of application and as
close to the time of waste application as possible. This analysis shall include the following
parameters:
Nitrogen Zinc
Phosphorus Copper
6. The Permittee shall record all irrigation and land application event(s) including hydraulic loading
rates, nutrient loading rates and cropping information. The Permittee shall also record removal of
solids and document nutrient loading rates if disposed of on -site, or record the off -site location(s).
These records must be on forms supplied by, or approved by, the Division.
7. A record shall be created and maintained of all transfers of waste between waste structures on the
same site not typically operated in series. Such record shall include at least the identity of the
structure from which the waste was transferred, the identity of the structure receiving the waste,
the date and time of transfer and the total volume of waste transferred.
8. . The Permittee must maintain monthly stocking records for the facility and make the records
available to the Departrnent.
9. If, for any reason, there is a discharge from the waste collection, treatment, storage and
application systems (including the land application sites), to surface waters or wetlands, the
Permittee is required to make notification in accordance with Condition III. 13. The discharge
notification shall include the following information:
a. Description of the discharge: A description of the discharge including an estimate of the
volume discharged, a description of the flow path to the receiving surface waters or
wetlands and a site sketch showing the path of the waste.
b. Time of the discharge: The length of time of the discharge, including the exact dates and
times that it started and stopped, and if not stopped, the anticipated time the discharge is
expected to continue.
C. Cause of the discharge: A detailed statement of the cause of the discharge. If caused by a
precipitation event, detailed information from the on -site rain gauge concerning the inches
and duration of the precipitation event.
d. All steps being taken to reduce, stop and cleanup the discharge. All steps to be taken to
prevent future discharges from the same cause.
e. Analysis of the waste: A copy of the last waste analysis conducted as required by Condition
III. 5. above.
f_ A waste sample, obtained within seventy-two (72) hours following first knowledge of the
discharge to surface waters or wetlands, from the source lagoon/storage pond, shall be
analyzed for the following minimum parameters:
8 March 7, 2014

U.S. Postal Service.,,
CERTIFIED MAIL,
RECEIPT
(Domestic Mail Only;
No Insurance
Coverage Provided)
'
For delivery information
.i! -A
OFFICIAL
visit our website
at www.usps.comn
�...
i
A
. •
P5 Form 3800. August 2006
See Reverse for Instructions
■ Complete items 1, 2, and 3. Also complete
item 4 if Restricted Delivery is desired.
■ Print your name and address on the reverse
so that we can return the card to you.
■ Attach this card to the back of the mailpiece.
or on the front if space permits.
1. Art C .^,,4ddressed to:
A. ]ig�X❑Agent
❑ Addressee
B..Rqce1v0 by arse) of
{i 'M'n'F1V
D. Is delivery 'address different from item 1? ❑ Yes
If YES, enter delivery address below: ❑ No
3. service Type
Certified Malls Q Ariority Mail Express?
❑ Registered ❑ Return Receipt for Merchandise
❑ Insured Mail ❑ Collect on Delivery
4. Restricted Delivery? (Extra Fee) ❑ Yes
2. Article Number
(Trarrster from serfte faben I 7 010 0290 0003 0633 9 6 8 7 i r
PS Form 3811, July 2013 Domestic Return Receipt

Murphy- B 1 QwnLLC PO Drawer 856
2822 Hwy. 24 West
Warsaw, NC 28398
Tel: [phone]
Fax:[phone]
January 29, 2015
S. Jay Zimmerman Acting Director E C F� g�
Division of Water Resources, NCDENR
d
FEB a 4
127 Cardinal Drive Extension il
L►-'"^is
Wilmington, NC 28405 p
BY.-
Dear Mr. Zimmerman,
In response to the Notice of Violation issued to the Batchelor Farm, Permit No. AWS310563, in
Duplin County on January 22, 2015, and your request for further information, please consider the
following as you determine civil penalty assessments in this matter.
Murphy -Brown LLC regrets the violation that occurred on September 19, 2014 and has done
everything in its power to both immediately mitigate the impact of the discharge on downstream
waters, and to put into place additional safeguards to prevent a similar situation from re -occurring
in the future. Specific to each alleged violation, please see our response to each below:
1. Permit Condition 1(1) - Failure to effectively manage, maintain, and operate the
wastewater system to prevent discharge.
Murphy -Brown LLC does not dispute any of the facts with regards to the occurrence of
the discharge, as demonstrated by the self -reporting of the event to Regional Staff as
required by permit. A complete description of the event that occurred and actions taken
was submitted to the Division by Mr. Michael Norris in a letter dated September 23,
2014. I have attached this letter for your further review. In addition to this letter,
Murphy -Brown LLC submitted additional information with regards to the volume of the
spill on October 2, 2014 to Mr. Dean Hunkele prepared by Mr. Dave Elkin, P.E. In these
communications, Murphy -Brown LLC provided its confident opinion that the spill
volume was less than 15,000 gallons leaving the property based on engineering
calculations, freeboard level change, and general site observations made during the
remediation efforts. Despite this, Murphy -Brown LLC determined the best course of
action to be to complete the notification process as requested by Mr. Hunkele and the
Division. The fact of the matter was that the spill occurred and we wanted to focus our
efforts on complete remediation and preventing any potential environmental impacts
downstream versus being argumentative on volumes. I think it is important to note for
the record that we were very pleased with our remediation efforts. Due to the quick

response of our environmental staff, we were able to contain the spill at the headwaters of
an adjacent pond and isolate it from impacting the pond itself. Once isolated, we
contacted our neighbors and worked closely with them to gain their consent to begin
recovery. Environmental staff spent over 140 man hours recovering not only the
discharged volume, but the entire volume of water contained in this headwater area. The
cost of these efforts was not the most important factor when compared to the effect of
protecting downstream waters, but we conservatively estimate the cost of our remediation
efforts at $9,816. We feel very confident that we were able to recover all of the
discharged material and land apply it to surrounding crop land.
2. Permit Condition III (15) — Failure to properly issue a press release within 48 hours of a
discharge of at least 1000 gallons
Murphy -Brown LLC issued the attached press release on Monday, September 22, 2014
by FAX transmittal to the only print media outlet providing general coverage in Duplin
County, the Duplin Times, and WEGG radio, the only electronic news media outlet in
Duplin County. The FAX notice was received by the Duplin Times, but repeated
attempts to send it to the radio station failed. Copies of the FAX notices are available for
your review if necessary. In this case, the 48 hour notice period ended on Sunday and,
therefore, our Monday press release was beyond the 48 hour time period.
3. Permit Condition I1I (16) —Failure to properly publish a public notice for a discharge of
at least 15,000 gallons and provide proof of publication within 30 days after publication.
On Friday, October 3, 2014, Murphy -Brown purchased a paid advertisement for
publication in the Duplin Times. This was within 10 days of being advised by Mr. Dean
Hunkele by email on September 30, 2014 at 1:25pm that Duplin County was the only
required county for publication. I have attached a copy of the paid advertisement that ran
in the Duplin Times. With regards to providing proof of publication, email and verbal
communication with the Division left us with the impression that the Division was aware
of our Public Notice. No formal written proof was communicated by Murphy -Brown to
the Division. We apologize for this administrative error but have copies of both the
Public Notice and Press Release in our farm files for review as necessary.
4. Permit Condition ID (9) (f) — Failure to sample within 72 hours and/or provide sample
results for the listed parameters to the Division within 30 days.
Murphy -Brown LLC did not sample the lagoon as stipulated in the permit for this event.
I have attached sample results for samples taken on September 19, 2014 in the ditch near
the point of discharge that were used to calculate Nitrogen loading for land application
occurring during remediation efforts, and of both lagoons on the Batchelor Farm taken on
September 18, 2014. These are NCDA samples and do not contain all of the required
parameters found in the permit. Fortunately, it has been some time since we had a spill
occur on a Murphy -Brown farm. Unfortunately, this led to an oversight in not testing for
all parameters as required.
In terms of overall follow up this event, Murphy -Brown LLC used this event and the lessons
learned to not only make modifications to our management system at this farm, but all others in
our system as well. The Batchelor Farm had secondary containment constructed several years

ago that was engineered to capture any discharge that would occur as a result of a recycle system
failure like the one that occurred on September 19'. The secondary containments on this and all
other farms are managed daily by the farm managers to provide protection against discharges. In
this particular case, road grading activities had changed the direction of water flow away from
this most northern cleanout from the designed flow path, and away from the containment area.
This situation was remedied on the Batchelor Farm on September 22, 2014. In addition, an
Objective and Target was created in the Murphy -Brown LLC Environmental Management
System to evaluate all farms for possible by-passing of secondary containments. This process is
ongoing but has been completed throughout much of our system. In addition, all environmental
employees have been re-trained on discharge sampling procedures to insure that we collect the
proper samples should this occur in the future.
Murphy -Brown LLC appreciates the opportunity to provide additional information to the
Division on this matter. This was an unfortunate incident, but we feel we have done everything
in our power to mitigate any potential impact to downstream waters from this particular event,
and have used the lessons learned to improve our entire operation. We appreciate the help your
staff has provided in this effort.
If there are further questions or concerns, please feel free to contact me at [phone] or by
email at kraigwesterbeekkmurphybrownllc.com.
Westerbeek
❑vironment and Engineering

i�' y rphpBrownu. W Box 856
lrlulr■n Warsaw, NC 28398
Murphy Brown East
September 23, 2014
Mr. Kevin Rowland
NCDENR — Division of Water Resources
127 Cardinal Drive Extension
Wilmington NC 28405
RE: Batchelor Farm
Facility # 31-563
Accidental Discharge 9/19/14
Dear Mr. Rowland,
This letter is the follow up to an accidental discharge on the Batchelor far} reported to Dean
Hunkley with DWR on September 19th. The sequence of events on Friday 9/19/14 is:
1) The farm personnel found a discharge from the recycle system upon arrival to work on the
morning of September 19th. The farm staff shut down the recycle system and notified the
LNM technician to respond to the accidental discharge_ The combined group effort
focused on total containment of the flow and notification of management
2) The complex manager notified the LNM specialist and LNM Director of the spill. The
remediation efforts were immediately initiated, which included bringing in heavy equipment
to effectively contain and recover the effluent.
3) After inspecting the site to ensure that all effluent was contained and that the cleanup
procedures were in place, I contacted Dean Hunkley with DWR to report the spill.
4) Remediabon included pumping the effluent onto the neighbor's crop fields and Murphy
Brown's coastal fields. Cleanup carried on throughout Friday, Saturday and was
completed Sunday afternoon. Containment dams in the ditch were left in place until
recovery efforts were completed and the pond dams were not removed until Tuesday
afternoon 9123114.
5) The spill was contained in a secondary intermittent ditch and a small pond that is fed by
Dark Branch.
6) Our LNM crew brought in trash pumps, tankers, and an Aerway system to aid in the
recovery efforts. We invested over 140 man hours in efforts to recover the effluent that hit
the ground. Our team applied more than 704,000 gallons through Aerway application,
24,000 with a tanker, and 102,000 with trash pumps at a cost of $9,816.
7) Root Cause: A previously repaired joint in the recycle line gave way because the wrong
process was used to make the repair causing it to come apart. The effluent flowed down
the farm path and into a drain pipe that dumped into the road side ditch.
Ll�

• Page 2
Estimate of the discharge:
January 29, 2015
1) In our estimation less than 15,000 gallons of effluent was spilled from the site.
The plan to correct the problems identified from this accidental discharge are to:
1) Connect repair of the recycle line.
2) Ensure there are no other pipe joints at the site that are not correct.
3) Build up a berm along the area where the spill occurred to direct any effluent from a spill
to the secondary containments at the site.
a. The corrective actions above have all been completed at this time. See attached
pictures for actions 1 and 3
Included with this letter is a copy of the most current waste analysis as required by the permit
I have outlined what information I have available as they relate to this accidental discharge. I feel that
Murphy -Brown LLC has responded in an appropriate and responsible manner to the conditions of the
permit
The Environmental Management System (EMS) proved its' effectiveness by providing the structure and
protocol that all parties involved in the response, did so in a timely and effective manner.
If I can be of any further assistance, please feel free to contact me.
Sincerely,
Michael Norris
Environmental Resource Specialist
Murphy -Brown LLC
[phone]

Notice of Discharge of Animal Waste
On September 19, 2014, the Bachelor swine farm (facility # AWS-031563) located
at 237 Bachelor Lane, Kenansville, N.C. experienced a discharge of swine
wastewater. The farm is owned by Murphy -Brown LLC. As soon as the discharge
was discovered Murphy -Brown personnel notified the N.C. Department of Natural
Resources Water Office. The discharge resulted from a broken pipe which is a
component of the farm's nutrient management system. The volume of the
discharge was estimated to be less than 15,000 gallons. The wastewater entered
an unnamed tributary of Dark Branch. The Murphy -Brown emergency response
plan was initiated and personnel from the company was able to contain the
discharge by constructing temporary earthen dams. The company's emergency
response personnel deployed pumps and other equipment to recover the
discharged liquid and apply it to cropland on the farm.
This notice was required by North Carolina General Statutes, Article 21, chapter
143.2215.C.

NOTICE OF DISCHARGE OF UNTREATED WASTE
The Batchelor Sow Farm, located at 237 Batchelor Lane,
Kenansville, NC and owned by Murphy -Brown LLC, had a
discharge less than 20,000 gallons of untreated wastewa-
ter originating from a failed recycle line on the farm. The
discharge occurred on September 19, 2014 and was dis-
covered at approximately 7:15am.
The wastewater entered an unnamed tributary of Dark
Branch. Containment and remediation efforts began im-
mediately and the incident was reported to NCDENR. The
spilled wastewater was completely contained on the adja-
cent property and land applied to surrounding crop land.
In addition, the failed recycle line was repaired to prevent
further discharges.
This notice was required by North Carolina General Stat-
utes Article 21 Chapter 143.215.C. For more information,
please contact Don Butler at [phone].

NCDA&CS Agronomic Division Phone: [phone] Website: www.ncagr.gov/agronomU
FY15-W001871
Predictive
Client: Mu h
Murphy Brown LLC
Advisor;
�r +:';`�
c/o Michael Norris
AAA
II*�`II
Waste Report
PO Box 856
Warsaw, NC 28398
Duplin County
Sampled: 09/19/2014 Received: 09/25/2014
Completed: 10103/2014
Farm: Batchelor
Links to Helpful Information
Sample Information
Nutrient and Other Measurements
Nitrogen (N) (ppm) P (ppm)
K (ppm) Ca (ppm) Mq (ppm)
S (ppm) Fe (ppm) Mn (ppm)
Zn (ppm) Cu (ppm) B (ppm)
Na (ppm) C (ppm)
Sample ID: BAT01
Total N 0.52
14.1 10.8 3.26
4.93 2.04 0.01
7.60 0.10 0.03
12.2
Waste Code: ALF
Description:
Total Kjeldahl N 14.1
Farrow to Ween
pH
DM (%) SS (10-SS✓cm)
EC (mS1cm)
CCE (%) ALE(1000 gal,)
C:N
Lagoon Liq.
Inorganic N
NH4-N 6:30
Comments:
NO3-N
Organic N Ni (ppm)
Cd (ppm) Pb (ppm) Al (ppm)
Se (ppm) Li (ppm) As
(ppm) Cr (ppm) Co (ppm)
Cl (ppm) MO (ppm)
Urea
Estimate of Nutrients Available for First Crop (lb 11000 gal.)
Other Elements (lb 11000 gal.)
Application Method
N P205 K20 Ca Mg
S Fe Mn Zn
Cu B Iwo
CI Na Ni Cd Pb
At Se Li
Irrigation
0.06 0.01 0.14 0.09 0.03
0.04 0.02 T 0.06
T T
0.10
Agronomist's Comments:
Aaron Pettit 10/2/2014 8:44 AM
VGA, r%cape- ao:-4 of C�iSCV,,,- rT ar% CT/ f 9 I(W
North Carolina Reprogramming of the laboratory -information -management system that makes this report possible is being funded
y` through a grant from the North Carolina Tobacco Trust Fund Commission.
Thank you for using agronomic services to manage nutrients and safeguard environmental quality.
y::„ s 1: 1i;l:,:l,::,�,.joj1 - Steve Troxler, Commissioner ofAjZriculture.

NCDABCS Agronomic Division Phone: [phone] Webslte: www.ncagr.gov/agronomY FY15-W001612
Y, •, Predictive
f&
&, ir�
I u j ib I
Waste Report
Client: Murphy Brown LLC Advisor.
CIO Michael Norris
PO Box 855
Warsaw, NC 28398
Duplin County
Sampled: 09I18/2014 Recalved: 09/18/2014 completed: 09/2512014
Farm: Batchelor Links to Helpful Information
Sample Information
Nutrient and Other Measurements
Nitrogen (N) (ppm) P (ppm) K (ppm) Ca (ppm) Mg (ppm)
S (ppm) Fe (ppm) Mn (ppm) Zn (ppm) CU (ppm) B (ppm) Na (ppm) C (ppm)
Sample ID: 2016A
Total N 54.4 290 48.2 66.2
35.7 0.73 0.08 0.27 0.14 0.34 125
Waste Code: ALS
Description:
Total Kjeldahl N 185
Swine Lagoon Liq..
Inorganic N pH DM (%) SS (10.55/cm)
EC (mS✓cm) CCE (90) ALE(1000 gal.) C.,N
Comments:
NH4-N 7.35
NO3-N
JUL 2 7 21drganc
N Ni (ppm) Cd (ppm) Pb (ppm) Al (ppm)
Urea
Se (ppm) Li (ppm) As (ppm) Cr ippm) Co (ppm) Cl (ppm) Mo (ppm)
Estimate of Nutrients Available for First Crop (lb / 1000 gal.)
Other Elements (lb 11000 gal.)
Application Method
N P205 K20 Ca Mg S Fe Mn Zn
Cu B Mo Cl Na Ni Cd Pb Al Se Li
Irrigation
0.77 1.04 2.90 0.40 0.55 0.30 0.01 T T
T T 1.04
Agronomist's Comments:
Aaron Pettit 9/24/2014 3:40 PM
,Norl h Carolina
i��heia,c 1pn:IundU::nt:1.•.a�q+
Reprogramming of the laboratory -information -management system that makes this report possible is being funded
through a grant from the North Carolina Tobacco Trust Fund Commission.
l hank},oar,for using agronontir services to manage nuti ienrs and safeguard em4ronnnewal quulhy.
- Stare Troxter. C rjwmissioner of.•Ixyricrdlure.

NCDAACS Agronomic Division Phone: [phone] Website: www.ncagr.gov/agronomi/ FY15-WO01612
Page 2 of 2
Sample Information
Nutrient and Other Measurements
Nilrogen (N) (ppm) P (ppm) K (ppm) Ca (ppm) MQ (ppm) S (ppm) Fe (ppm) M11 (ppm) ,Zn (ppm) Cu (ppm) 8 (ppm) Na (ppm) C (ppm)
Sample ID: 2016b
Total N 57.1 296 61.6 72.1 40.6 1.11 0.11 0.55 0,13 0,37 129
Waste Code: ALS
Description:
Total Kjeldahl N 252
Swine Lagoon Liq.
pH DM (%) SS (10-55✓cm) EC (mS/cm) CCE (%) ALE(1000 gal.) C:N
Inorganic N
Comments:
NH4-IV 7.38
NO3-IV
JUL 212014
Organic N Ni (ppm) Cd (ppm) Pb {ppm) Al (ppm) So (ppm) L( (ppm) As (ppm) Cr (ppm) Co (ppm) Ct (ppm) MO (ppm)
Urea
Estimate of Nutrients Available for First Crop (lb 1 1000 gal.) Other Elements (lb 1 1000 gal.)
Application Method
N P20s K20 Ca Mg S Fe Mn Zn CU 8 Mo CI Na Ni Cd Pb Al Se Li
Irrigation
1.05 1.09 2.96 0.51 0.60 0.34 0.01 T T T T 1.07
Understanding the Waste Report' - additional information: www.ncaor.aov/agronomi/pdffiles/uwastg,pdf & www,ng_acr.gov(agronomllpdffileslwasteguide,Pdf
Nutrient concentrations and other data on this report are provided so that waste materials can be applied at agronomic rates, thereby supplementing or reducing fertilizer application and
preventing environmental contamination. In reading the Laboratory Results section, remember that materials with < 15% dry matter (generally liquids) are analyzed as received; all
other wastes are dried first. Values in the Estimate of Nutrients Available for First Crop section are based on the type of waste and method of application you specify and reflect the
fact that only 40-60% of the nitrogen and 70-100% of other nutrients become available within one year of application. The remainder may or may not ever become available.
` ppm = parts per million; S = siemens; mS = millisiemens; T = trace (<0.005 Ib/unit); EC = electrical conductivity; CCE = calcium carbonate equivalence; ALE = agricultural lime
equivalence; pH = acidity or basicity; DM% = % dry matter [far semi -solid and solid waste samples, this value facilitates conversion of dry -basis concentrations (ppm) back to wet -basis
of original sample]; C:N ratio = carbon:nitrogen ratio.
Lr a � � 1B
bc�_C'�Iel o r

Murphy Brown .,.
Murphy Brown East
September 24, 2014
Morella Sanchez -King
NCDENR — Division of Water Resources
127 Cardinal Drive Extension
Wilmington NC 28405
RE: Batchelor Farm
Facility # 31-563
Accidental Discharge 9/19/14
PO Box 856
Warsaw, NC 26398
EIEIVE
SEP 2 5 2014
$Y:
Dear Mr. Rowland,
This letter is the follow up to an accidental discharge on the Batchelor farm reported to Dean
Hunkley with DWR on September 19th. The sequence of events on Friday 9119/14 was:
1) The farm personnel found a discharge from the recycle system upon arrival to work on the
morning of September 19th. The farm staff shut down the recycle system and notified the
LNM technician to respond to the accidental discharge. The combined group effort
focused on total containment of the flow and notification of management.
2) The complex manager notified the LNM specialist and LNM Director of the spill. The
remediation efforts were immediately initiated, which included bringing in heavy equipment
to effectively contain and recover the effluent.
3) After inspecting the site to ensure that all effluent was contained and that the cleanup
procedures were in place, I contacted Dean Hunkley with DWR to report the spill.
4) Remediation included pumping the effluent onto the neighbor's crop fields and Murphy
Brown's coastal fields. Cleanup carried on throughout Friday, Saturday and was
completed Sunday afternoon. Containment dams in the ditch were left in place until
recovery efforts were completed and the pond dams were not removed until Tuesday
afternoon of 9/23/14.
5) The spill was contained in a secondary intermittent ditch and a small pond that is fed by
Dark Branch.
6) Our LNM crew brought in trash pumps, tankers, and an Aerway system to aid in the
recovery efforts. We invested over 140 man hours in efforts to recover the effluent from
the discharge. Our team pumped and land applied more than 704,000 gallons through
Amway application, 24,000 with a tanker, and 102,000 with trash pumps at a cost of
$9,816. The vast majority of this volume was freshwater but in order to ensure removal of
the swine effluent mixed in with the fresh water we took these extraordinary measures.
7) Root Cause: A previously repaired joint in the recycle line gave way because the wrong
process was used to make the repair causing it to come apart. The effluent flowed down
the farm path and into a drain pipe that dumped into the road side ditch.

• Page 2
Estimate of the discharge:
September 24, 2014
1) In our estimation less than 15,000 gallons of swine effluent was spilled from the site.
The estimate is based on lagoon level observations following the discharge in
comparison to previous readings, as well as on the ground estimates of effluent
volumes observed.
The plan to correct the problems identified from this accidental discharge are:
1) Correct repair of the recycle line.
2) Ensure there are no other pipe joints at the site that are not correct.
3) Build up a berm along the area where the spill occurred to direct effluent from any
potential future spill to the secondary containments at the site.
a. The corrective actions above have all been completed at this time. See attached
pictures for actions 1 and 3
Included with this letter is a copy of the most current waste analysis as required by the permit.
I have outlined what information I have available as they relate to this accidental discharge. I feel that
Murphy -Brown LLC has responded in an appropriate and responsible manner to the conditions of the
permit.
The Environmental Management System (EMS) proved its' effectiveness by providing the structure and
protocol that all parties involved in the response, did so in a timely and effective manner.
If I can be of any further assistance, please feel free to contact me.
Sincerely,
A j-y
Michael Norris
Environmental Resource Specialist
Murphy -Brown LLC
[phone]

Hunkele, Dean
From:
Kraig Westerbeek[[e-mail]
Sent:
Friday, October 03, 2014 10:01 AM
To:
Hunkele, Dean; David Nordin
Cc:
Rowland, Kevin; Gregson, Jim; King, Morella s; Farnell, John
Subject:
RE: DWR Incident #: 201401619 Bachelor Sow farm spill
Attachments:
Batchelor Farm NOTICE OF DISCHARGE OF UNTREATED WASTE 10314.docx
After conversations with John Farnell this morning relaying the results of your review of the engineering study done on
the Batchelor Farm Spill, the attached Public Notice has been prepared. Please review it and provide approval prior to
us moving forward.
The following guidance from the rule indicates that we should publish this notice in a newspaper having general
circulation in the county in which the discharge occurred ... in this case Duplin County. I believe we have agreed that no
additional counties downstream from the point of discharge will be effected. The county newspaper is the Duplin
Times, so we plan to pay for this Notice to appear in their publication. If this is incorrect, please let me know.
While we are still very convinced that this discharge was less than 15,000 gallons to surface waters, we appreciate the
time and consideration given to our calculations and estimations and your position that it could have possibly been
more. Murphy -Brown has done everything in its power to remediate as completely as possible any downstream
impacts, and feel we have been successful in these efforts. We try to be very transparent in our reporting and
communications with your agency and respect your authority and council in these matters.
in the.event of a discharge of 15,000 gallons or more of untreated wastewater to the surface waters of Lhe State;
publish.a notice of :the discharge in a newspaper having general circulation in,,the county in.which.the discharge occurs
and in `each county downstream from the point of discharge thai is significantly affected by the aischarge The
Secretary shall determine, at the Secretary's sole discretion, which counties are significantly affected by the discharge
and shall approve the form and content of the notice and the newspapers in which the notice is to be published. The
notice shall be captioned "NOTICE OF DISCHARGE OF UNTREATED SEWAGE". The owner or operator shall publish the
notice within 10 days after the Secretary has determined the counties that are significantly affected by the discharge
and approved the form and content of the notice and the newspapers in which the notice is to be published. The owner
or operator shall file a copy of the notice and proof of publication with the Department within 30 days after the notice
is published. Publication of a notice of discharge under this subdivision is in addition to the requirement to issue a
press release under subdivision (1) of this subsection.
From: Hunkele, Dean [mailto:[e-mail]]
Sent: Tuesday, September 30, 2014 1:25 PM
To: Kraig Westerbeek; David Nordin; Michael Norris
Cc: Rowland, Kevin; Gregson, Jim; King, Morella s
Subject: RE: DWR Incident #: 201401619 Bachelor Sow farm spill
Importance: High
Hi Kraig,
I was aware of what was sent and to whom, but it was not complete in its distribution. The requirement for press
release (was within 48 hrs now 24 hrs as of 9-22-2014) is simply an announcement to all print & electronic media outlets
having coverage in the county; it may or may not be picked up as a story by the entities you notify. The public notice is
taking out the ad space in major paper with readership in the County of occurrence and upon notification by the agency
to publish in downstream counties. Based on my estimated volume and specifics, then Duplin County would be
sufficient for this incident.

Hunkele, Dean
From: King, Morelia s
Sent: Tuesday, September 23, 2014 2:59 PM
To: Gregson, Jim; Hunkele, Dean
Subject: FW: Press Release
Attachments: Notice of Discharge of Animal Waste -Bachelor Farm 9-19-2014.docx
[a
Morella
Morelia Sanchez King
morella.sanchez-kin ncdenr. ov (P)910 796 7218
From: Michael Norris fmailto:MichaelNorris(Omurphybrownllc.coml
Sent: Tuesday, September 23, 2014 1:29 PM
To: Rowland, Kevin
Cc: King, Morelia s
Subject: RE: Press Release
The release was made yesterday to radio station WEGG and to Duplin Times news paper.
From: Rowland, Kevin[mailto:[e-mail]]
Sent: Tuesday, September 23, 2014 1:02 PM
To: Michael Norris
Cc: King, Morella s
Subject: Press Release
Michael,
Were you able verify where and when the press release for the spill was made?
Thank you for your time,
Kevin Rowland
Kevin Rowland
Environmental Specialist II
NCDENR Division of Water Resources
Aquifer Protection Section
Wilmington Regional Office
127 Cardinal Drive Extention
Wilmington, NC 28405
kevin.rowland (&ncdenr.eov
910-796-7436 office
910-350-2004 fax
910-520-3510 cell

Hunkele, Dean
From: Kraig Westerbeek[[e-mail]]
Sent: Thursday, October 02, 2014 8:56 AM
To: Hunkele, Dean; David Nordin; Michael Norris
Cc: Rowland, Kevin; Gregson, Jim; King, Morelia s
Subject: RE: DWR Incident #: 201401619 Bachelor Sow farm spill
Attachments: Batchelortimeline10114.xlsx; Copy of Batchelor Recycle Model pdf (2).xlsx
Dean, as requested below, I have attached the model that Dave Elkin, PE completed for the recycle system failure at the
Batchelor Farm. For the benefit of all involved, his calculations assume the worst case scenario of the recycle system
failure beginning at the time employees left the farm (40m) to when the incident was discovered at 7:15am the
following morning. Under this worse -case scenario, it appears that the maximum would be 46,009 gallons, with a more
likely number being 39,021 gallons based on normal pump wear, etc. These calculations do take into account the water
that ponded and infiltrated in and around the building pad area, and what was captured prior to it leaving our property.
I am sure that Dave is more than willing to discuss these calculations with you if necessary. He has indicated to me that
he will seal. these calculations as requested but that was not convenient to do in electronic format as it is being
distributed here.
In addition to Dave's calculations, I have attached an additional spreadsheet that calculates the potential loss of water at
1 hour increments beginning at 4pm and continuing through 7:15am. We are very confident in our estimated spill
volume of less than 15,000 gallons based on the lack of any discernable drop in lagoon level after the spill, and the
volume of wastewater observed in the downstream drainage area. I was personally on the site during recovery efforts
the day the spill was discovered and viewed the freeboard staff gauge and lagoon, as well as remediation efforts. In
addition to observations of the lagoon staff gauge, it is my opinion that any spill over 15,000 gallons that would have
occurred prior to 11pm would have easily made it past the two culverts that were blocked to stop the flow given the size
of the drainage area and the speed of the flow of water to this location. Based on this, we feel the most likely time of
the pipe failure to be between midnight at lam.
We ask that DENR review the attached information and provide us with your estimations as well so that we can discuss
what needs to be done with regards to additional Public Notice. As stated previously, we are very confident in our
original estimates but appreciate DENR's obligation to review and accept or reject our information. If additional
information is needed, please let me know.
From: Hunkele, Dean [mailto:[e-mail]]
Sent: Tuesday, September 30, 2014 1:25 PM
To: Kraig Westerbeek; David Nordin; Michael Norris
Cc: Rowland, Kevin; Gregson, Jim; King, Morelia s
Subject: RE: DWR Incident #: 201401619 Bachelor Sow farm spill
Importance: High
Hi Kraig,
I was aware of what was sent and to whom, but it was not complete in its distribution. The requirement for press
release (was within 48 hrs now 24 hrs as of 9-22-2014) is simply an announcement to all print & electronic media outlets
having coverage in the county; it may or may not be picked up as a story by the entities you notify. The public notice is
taking out the ad space in major paper with readership in the County of occurrence and upon notification by the agency
to publish in downstream counties. Based on my estimated volume and specifics, then Duplin County would be
sufficient for this incident.
Based on that lagoon's design and the freeboard level the day of the spill, then what is 1-inch equal to in volume? Why
did we not get the items we asked for from Dave or Michael as part of the report?

ponded area infiltarted into soils
4) flow pipe under road to dam 1
1095 ft length
1.251ft width
L__'1 in deep
2559.6 gallons none
5) flow path dam 1 under road to dam 2
866 ft length
2.5 ft width
3 in deep
4048.6 gallons none
6) flow path dam 2 under field drive to dam 3
960 ft length
F2.5 ft width
31in deep
4488 gallons none
7) flow path dam 3 to dam 4 @ pond
566 ft length
� 1ft width
in deep
3175.3 gallons sements 4-7 none
23,872.. gal Total ! gallons none
Having had the opportunity to review the desgn & installation of the recycle sytem, and the downstream flow path
from the Bachelor sow farms I, David S. Elkin certify that the preceding calculation represent due diligence and
application of engineering calcuation and. judgement to model the event which resulted in the release of waste water
outside the designed recycle system.

Recycle water recovered
ponded area
flow path segment 1) flow path barn to pipe under road
distance 505 ft
length
4 ft
width
0.5 in
deep
84.167
cf
629.57
gallons
infiltarted into sandy soils
flow path barn to pipe under rd
505 ft length
4 ft width
1.5 in deep
252.5 cf
1888.7 gallons
2) puddle @ feed tanks
puddle @ feed tanks
75 ft length
75 ft length
15 ft width
15 ft width
3 in deep
1.5 in deep
281.25 cf
140.63 cf
2103.8 gallons
1051.9 gallons
3) puddle @ feed tanks
puddle @ feed tanks
70 ft length
70 ft length
20 ft width
20 ft width
3 in deep
1.5 in deep
350 cf
175 cf
2618 gallons
1309 gallons
pture volume:
ianout p€p'e`to
Ivert @ road turn €
9,601 gallon 5,351 gallon total 4,250 gallon total

Bachelor Site Information
barn/ recycle pipe lagoon w/ recycel pump
13 flush tanks length 392 ft
1012 ft pipe length width(ave) 200 ft
230 GPM pump capacity (5Hp AMT @ 15.5psi area 78400 sf
area 1.799816 ac gallons/ inch freeboard
3 inch DR17 HDPE cleanout pipe 48,872 !gal/in change
:ycle system is designed to evenly distubute the pumped water to all 13 tanks.
refore 1/13 of flow is
17.7 gpm per tank
0.039 cfs per flush tank
5 ft/s design velocity (new)
0.01 sf 1.14 sq. inch / tank (full opening, typical of 2" valve = 3.14s.i.)
14.79 si sq. inch / open pipe total system normal flow all 13 tanks
7.35 sq.inch 3" cleanout SDR17
22.14 s.i. total open area for discharge of recycle pump during event
33.21% of flow potential to broken 3" HDPE pipe cleanout
76.37 max potential gallons
****Note: this is the futhest point of discharge, vs the tanks that are closer to the
pump so would be conservative estimate
****Typically after 2* years of operation; pump and line deliver far less than
original design due to struvite, sludge, & biofilm build up in lines, as well as impeller
90% & pump wear (expected performance 50-90% of new)
68.74 Likely maximum performance with 2 yr run time.
laximum operation duration
16:00 pm empoyee departure
7:15 am identification of incident
15.25 hrs max
69,881.07 gall max :potetnial spill 62,892.96 realistic max. gal

Hypothetical
Gallons from
Gallons Contained/
Gallons Reaching
Pipe Break Time
Time(hrs)
Pump(Gal.)
On -site (gallons)
State Waters / Off -site (Gallons)
4pm
15.25
69881
23,872
46009
5pm
14.25
65299
23,872
41427
6pm
13.25
60716
23,872
36844
7pm
12.25
56134
23,872
32262
8pm
11.25
51552
23,872
27680
9pm
10.25
46969
23,872
23097
10pm
9.25
42387
23,872
18515
11pm
8.25
37804
23,872
13932
12pm
7.25
33222
23,872
9350
lam
6.25
28640
23,872
4768
tam
5.25
24057
23,872
185
3am
4.25
19475
23,872
0
4am
3.25
14893
23,872
0
5am
2.25
10310
23,872
0
6am
1.25
5728
23,872
0
lam
0.25
1146
23,872
0
7:15am
0
0
23,872
0

Hunkele, Dean
From: Hunkele, Dean
Sent: Thursday, February 26, 2015 1:03 PM
To: Gregson, Jim
Cc: King, Morella s
Subject: 31-0563 Batchelor Sow spill case
Attachments: 31-0563 Batchelor spill enf costs.xlsx; AWS310563 NOI NOV-2014-DV-0228.docx; email
exchanges.pdf; email exchanges-001.pdf; not response.pdf
Importance: High
Jim,
Please find the attached case info for Raleigh's review.
Based on standard Fast Track assessment guidance for sewer spills, etc. in this regional office and our discussions, this is
what we would assess.
Violation 1
Violation 2
Violation 3
Violation 4
Total CP $1,600
Enf Cost $554.15
$1000
$250
$100
$100 + $150 [sample costs]
Total Assessment = $2,154.15
Email correspondence to and from this address is subiect to the North Carolina Public Records Law and may be
disclosed to third parties unless the content is exempt by statute or other regulation.
For information about permit applications please visit DENR's Permit Application Tracker using this address:
http://portal.ncdenr.org/web/deao/permit-tracker
The goal of the Fast Track sewer permit program is to issue a permit in no more than 30 business days from receipt of a
complete application and if no addtional information has to be requested upon full review. Please use the tracker to
determine the official application receipt date to allow you to estimate a date for issuance and find the reviewer's
name. Once issued, the record stays on the site for 30 days.
Subscribe to Collection System Updates
1

31-0563 Spill
Staff Name
Time
hate
Total
Hunkele
Site
4.5
37.09
166.905
Case
3
37.09
111.27
Sanchez -King
Site
4.5
47.44
213.48
Truck
125
0.5
62.5
Grand Total
554.155
Sampling Costs Saved
Fecal
35
TSS
15
Ammonia
20
BOD
25
TP
20
TN, etc
45
TOTAL
160

31- r�i3
Murphy -Brown, LLC 4/16/2009 2822 Hwy 24 West
P.O. Box 856
Warsaw, NC 28398
NUTRIENT UTILIZATION PLAN
Grower(s): Murphy -Brown, LLC
Farm Name: Batchelor Farm
c:oun
F
Farrow to Wean 2035
Farrow to Feeder
Farrow to Finish -
Wean to Feeder
Feeder to Finish
Storage Structure:
Storage Period:
Application Method:
Anaerobic Lagoon
>180 days
Irrigation
RECEIVED / DENR / DV4
Aquifer Protedlon SaWan
APR 16 '2009
Rj TCPaVRD
APR 2 0 zoos
BY;
The waste from your animal facility must be land applied at a specified rate to prevent pollu io
of surface water and/or groundwater. The plant nutrients in the animal waste should be used
to reduce the amount of commercial fertilizer required for the crops in the fields where the waste
is to be applied.
This waste utilization plan uses nitrogen as the limiting nutrient. Waste should be analyzed
before each application cycle. Annual soil tests are strongly encouraged so that all plant
nutrients can be balanced for realistic yields of the crop to be grown.
Several factors are important in implementing your waste utilization plan in order to maximize
the fertilizer value of the waste and to ensure that it is applied in an environmentally safe manner:
1. Always apply waste based on the needs of the crop to be grown and the nutrient
content of the waste. Do not apply more nitrogen than the crop can utilize.
2. Soil types are important as they have different infiltration rates, leaching potentials,
cation exchange capacities, and available water holding capacities.
3. Normally waste shall be applied to land eroding at less than 5 tons per acre per
year. Waste may be applied to land eroding at 5 or more tons per acre annually, but
less than 10 tons per acre per year providing that adequate filter strips are established.
4. Do not apply waste on saturated soils, when it is raining, or when the surface is frozen.
Either of these conditions may result in runoff to surface waters which is not allowed
under DWQ regulations.
5. Wind conditions should also be considered to avoid drift and downwind odor
problems.
6. To maximize the value of the nutrients for crop production and to reduce the potential
for pollution, the waste should be applied to a growing crop or applied not more than
30 days prior to planting a crop or forages breaking dormancy. Injecting the waste or
disking will conserve nutrients and reduce odor problems.
1 of 11

This plan is based on the waste application method shown above. If you choose to change
methods in the future, you need to revise this plan. Nutrient levels for different application
methods are not the same.
The estimated acres needed to apply the animal waste is based on typical nutrient content
for this type of facility. In some cases you may want to have plant analysis made, which could
allow additional waste to be applied. Provisions shall be made for the area receiving waste to
be flexible so as to accommodate changing waste analysis content and crop type. Lime must
be applied to maintain pH in the optimum range for specific crop production.
This waste utilization plan, if carried out, meets the requirements for compliance with 15A NCAC
2H .0217 adopted by the Environmental Management Commission.
AMOUNT OF WASTE PRODUCED PER YEAR ( gallons, ft', tons, etc.):
Capacity Type Waste Produced per Animal Total
2035
Farrow to Wean
3212 gal/yr
6,536,420 gal/yr
Farrow to Feeder
4015 gaVyr
gal/yr
Farrow to Finish
10585 gal/yr
gaVyr
Wean to Feeder
223 gaVyr
gaVyr
Feeder to Finish
986 gaVyr
gaVyr
Total 6,536,420 gal/yr
AMOUNT OF PLANT AVAILABLE NITROGEN PRODUCED PER YEAR (ibs): *Based on Farm pumping records
Capacity Type Nitrogen Produced per Animal Total
2035
Farrow to Wean
4.72 Ibs/yr
9,605 Ibs/yr
Farrow to Feeder
6.5 Ibs/yr
Ibs/yr
Farrow to Finish
26 Ibs/yr
Ibs/yr
Wean to Feeder
0.48 Ibs/yr
Ibs/yr
Feeder to Finish
2.3 Ibs/yr
lbslyr
Total 9,605 Ibs/yr
Applying the above amount of waste is a big job. You should plan time and have appropriate
equipment to apply the waste in a timely manner.
LAND UTILIZATION SUMMARY
The following table describes the nutrient balance and land utilization rate for this facility
Note that the Nitrogen Balance for Crops indicates the ratio of the amount of nitrogen produced
on this facility to the amount of nitrogen that the crops under irrigation may uptake and utilize
in the normal growing season.
Total Irrigated Acreage: 116.01
Total N Required 1st Year: 26105.09
Total N Required 2nd Year: 22867.1
Average Annual Nitrogen Requirement of Crops: 24,486.10
Total Nitrogen Produced by Farm: 9,605.20
Nitrogen Balance for Crops: (14,880.90)
The following table describes the specifications of the hydrants and fields that contain the crops
designated for utilization of the nitrogen produced on this facility. This chart describes the size,
soil characteristics, and uptake rate for each crop in the specified crop rotation schedule for this
facility.
2of11

Reception Area Specifications
Tract Field Irrigated Soil 1st Crop Time to 1st Crop 1st Crop Lbs NlAc Lbs N Total lbs N
Acrea e Type Code Apply Yield lbs NlUnit Residual fAc Utilized
2nd Crop Time to 2nd Crop 2nd Crop Lbs NlAc Lbs N Total lbs N
Code Apply Yield lbs NlUnit Residual IAc Utilized
Total
Lbs NIAc
Total lbs N
Utilized
Ti
1
2.92
Foreston
D
Feb15-June
120.0
1.25
150
438
N
I Set
55
2.4
132
385.44
282
823.44
2
2.71
Foreston
D
17015-June
120.0
1.25
150
406.5
N
Sept -Apr
55
2.4
132
357.72
282
764.22
3
2.69
Foreston
D
Feb15-June
120.0
1.25
150
403.5
N
Sepj-Apr
55
2.4
132
355.08
282
758.58
4
2.64
Foreston
D
Feb15•June
120.0
1.25
150
396
N
Se t-A r
55
2.4
132
348.48
282
744.48
5
2.66
Foreston
D
Feb15-June
120.0
1.25
150
384
N
Se t- r
55
2.4
132
337.92
282
721.92
6
2.38
Foreston
D
Feb15-June
120.0
1.25
150
357
N
Sept -Apr
55
2.4
132
314.16
282
671.16
7
1.69
Foreston
D
Feb15-June
120.0
1.25
150
253.5
N
Se t-A r
55
2.4
132
223.08
282
476.58
8
1.85
Au ills
C
Mar -Set
5.5
50
275
508.75
L
Sept -Apr
1
50
50
92.5
325
601.25
9
1.85
Au ille
C
Mar -Set
5.5
50
275
508.75
L
Sopt-Apr
1
50
50
92.5
325
601.25
10
1.91
AutryvjHe
C
Mar -Set
5.5
50
275
525.25
L
Sept -Apr
1
50
50
95.5
325
620.75
11
1.69
Au ills
C
Mar -Sept
5.5
50
275
464.75
L
Sept -Apr
1
50
50
84.5
325
549.25
12
9.6
Foreston
C
MarmSept
6.0
50
300
2880
L
Sept -Apr
1
50
50
480
350
3360
13
8.32
Foreston
C
Mar -Sept
6.0
50
300
2496
L
Soot -Apr
1
50
50
416
350
2912
14
2.34
Foreston
C
Mar -Set
6.0
50
300
702
L
Sept-AprSept-Apr
1
50
50
117
350
819
subs-7
3.01
Foreston
D
Mar -Jul
120.0
1.25
1 150
451.5
1 N
Sept-AprSept-Apr
55
2.4
132
397.32
282
848.82
sub8-11
0.98
AutryvlDo
C
Mar -Sept
5.5
50
275
269.5
L
Sept -Apr
1
50
50
49
325
318.5
sub12-14
6.44
Foreston
C
Mar -Set
0.0
50
300
1932
L
Sept-AprSept-Apr
1
50
50
322
350
2254
71193
1
33.88
Atitryville
D
Feb15-June
85.0
1.25
106.2$
3599.75
N
Sept -Apr
45
2.4
108
3659.04
214.25
1 7258.79
4207-F5
Zone 1
1.06
Foreston
D
Fobl5-June
120.0
1.25
150
159
N
Se t- r
55
2.4
132
139.92
282
298.92
4207-F5
Zone 2
1.21
Foreston 1
D
Feb15-June
120.0
1.25
150
181.5
N
5e t•A r
55
2.4
132
159.72
282
341.22
4207-F5
Zane 3
1.28
Foreston
D
Feb15-June
120.0
1.25
150
192
N
SeDt-ADr
55
1 2.4
132
168.96
282
360.96
O tionalLand
71473
1
11.5
Aut Illo
D
Mar-Juty,
85.0
1.25
15
91.25
0
N
Seat -Apr
45
2.4
108
1242
0
0
71473
1
11.5
Autryville
O
June -Set
30.0
4
0
120
0
0
0
Totals: 116.01 17509.25 9837.84 2fif05.09
3(a) of 11

Reception Area Specifications
Tract Field Irrigated Soil 1st Crop Time to 1st Crop 1st Crop Lbs N1Ac Lbs N Total lbs N
Acrea e Tvve Code Apply Yield lbs NlUnit Residual IAc Utilized
2nd Crop Time to 2nd Crop 2nd Crop Lbs N/Ac Lbs N Total lbs N
Code Apply Yield lbs N1Unit Residual /Ac Utilized
Total
Lbs NIAc
Total lbs N
Utilized
T1
1
2.92
Foreston
O
Jun -Sept
40.0
4
160
467.2
L
Sept -Apr
1
65
15
50
146
210
613.2
2
2.71
Foreston
O
Jun -Sept
40.0
4
160
433.6
L
see!.8pr
1
65
15
50
135.5
210
569.1
3
2.69
Foreston
O
Jun -Set
40.0
4
160
430.4
L
Sept -Apr
1
65
15
50
134.5
210
564.9
4
2.64
Foreston
O
Jun -Set
40.0
4
160
422.4
L
Sept -Apr
1
65
15
50
132
210
664.4
5
2.56
Foreston
O
Jun -Sept
40.0
4
160
409.E
L
Sept -Apr
1
65
15
50
128
210
537.6
6
2.38
Foreston
O
Jun -Set
40.0
4
1 160
380.8
L
Se •A r
1 1
65
15
50
119
210
499.8
7
1.69
Foreston
O
Jun -Set
40.0
4
160
270.4
L
Sept -Apr
1
1 65
15
1 50
84.5
1 210
354.9
8
1.85
ALAMille
C
Mar -Sept
5.5
50
275
508.75
L
Sept -Apr
1
50
50
92.5
325
601.25
9
1.85
Au ills
C
Mar -Set
5.5
50
275
508.75
L
Sept -Apr
1
50
1
50
92.5
325
601.25
10
1.91
Au ills
C
Mar -Set
5.5
50
275
525.25
L
SeRL6pr
1
50
50
95.5
325
620.75
11
1.69
Autryville
C
Mar -Sat
5.5
50
275
464.75
L
Sept -Apr
1
50
50
84.5
325
549.25
12
9.6
Foreston
C
Mar -Set
6.0
SO
300
2880
L
Sept -Apr
1
SO
50
480
350
3360
13
8.32
1 Foreston
C
Mar -Sept
6.0
50
300
2496
L
Sept-AprSept-Apr
1
50
50
416
350
2912
14
2.34
Foreston
C
I Mar -Sept
6.0
1 50
300
702
1 L
SeDt-ADr
I 1
50
50
117
350
819
subl-7
3.01
Foreston
O
Jun -Set
40.0
4
1 160
481.6
L
Sept -Apr
1
1 65
15
1 50
150.5
1 210
632.1
sub8-11
0.98
Autryville
C
Mar -Sept
5.5
50
275
269.5
L
Sept -Apr
1
50
50
49
325
318.5
sub12-14
6.44
Foreston
C
Mar -Sept
6.0
50
300
1932
L
Sept-AprSept-Apr
1
50
SO
322
350
1 2254
71193
1
33.88
Autryville
O
Jun -Set
X0
4
120
4065.6
L
Sept -Apr
1
65
15
50
1694
170
5759.6
4207-F5
Zone 1
1.06
Foreston
O
Jun -Set
40.0
4
160
169.6
L
Se t- r
1
65
15
50
53
210
222.6
4207-F5
Zone 2
1.21
Foreston
O
Jun -Set
40.0
4
160
193.6
L
Sept-AprSept-Apr
1
65
15
50
60.5
210
254.1
4207-F5
Zone 3
1.28
Foreslon
0
Jun -Set
40.0
4
160
204.8
L
Sept -Apr
1
65
15
50
64
210
268.8
If smatic3rainhavisnotolanted
behindsovbeans,
deduct 15
lb residual from
cam.
Totals: 93.01 18216.6 4650.5 22887.1
3(b) of 11

This plan does not include commercial fertilizer. The farm should produce adequate plant
available nitrogen to satisfy the requirements of the crops listed above.
The applicator is cautioned that P and K may be over applied while meeting the N requirements.
In the future, regulations may require farmers in some parts of North Carolina to have a nutrient
management plan that addresses all nutrients. This plan only addresses nitrogen.
In interplanted fields ( i.e. small grain, etc, interseeded in bermuda), forage must be removed
through grazing, hay, and/or silage. Where grazing, plants should be grazed when they
reach a height of six to nine inches. Cattle should be removed when plants are grazed to a
height of four inches. In fields where small grain, etc, is to be removed for hay or silage, care
should be exercised not to let small grain reach maturity, especially late in the season (i.e.
April or May). Shading may result if small grain gets too high and this will definately interfere
with stand of bermudagrass. This loss of stand will result in reduced yields and less nitrogen
being utilized. Rather than cutting small grain for hay or silage just before heading as is
the normal situation, you are encouraged to cut the small grain earlier. You may want to
consider harvesting hay or silage two to three times during the season, depending on the
time small grain is planted in the fall.
The ideal time to interplant small grain, etc, is late September or early October. Drilling is
recommended over broadcasting. Bermudagrass should be grazed or cut to a height of
about two inches before drilling for best results.
CROP CODE LEGEND
Crop Code Crop
A Barley
B Hybrid Bermudagrass - Grazed
C Hybrid Bermudagrass - Hay
D Corn - Grain
E Corn - Silage
F Cotton
G Fescue- Grazed
H Fescue- Hay
I Oats
J Rye
K Small Grain - Grazed
L Small Grain - Hay
M Grain Sorghum
N Wheat
O Soybean
P Pine Trees
Lbs N utilized / unit yield
1.6 ibs N 1 bushel
50 Ibs N 1 ton
50 Ibs N 1 ton
1.25 Ibs N / bushel
12 Ibs N / ton
0.12 Ibs N 1 Ibs lint
50 Ibs N 1 ton
50 Ibs N 1 ton
1.3 ibs N 1 bushel
2.4 Ibs N 1 bushel
50 Ibs N 1 acre
50 Ibs N 1 acre
2.5 Ibs N I cwt
2.4 Ibs N 1 bushel
4.0 Ibs N 1 bushel
40 Ibs N 1 acre 1 yr
Acres shown in the preceding table are considered to be the usable acres excluding
required buffers, filter strips along ditches, odd areas unable to be irrigated, and perimeter areas
not receiving full application rates due to equipment limitations. Actual total acres in the fields
listed may, and most likely will be, more than the acres shown in the tables.
See attached map showing the fields to be used for the utilization of animal waste.
4of11

SLUDGE APPLICATION:
The following table describes the annual nitrogen accumulation rate per animal
in the lagoon sludge
Farm Specifications PAN/ r/animal Farm Totall r
2035 Farrow to Wean 0.84 1709.4
Farrow to Feeder 1
Farrow to Finish 4.1
Wean to Feeder 0.072
Feeder to Finish 0.36
The waste utilization plan must contain provisions for periodic land application of sludge at
agronomic rates. The sludge will be nutrient rich and will require precautionary measures to
prevent over application of nutrients or other elements. Your production facility will produce
approximately 1709.4 pounds of plant available nitrogen per year will accumulate in the lagoon
sludge based on the rates of accumulation listed above.
If you remove the sludge every 5 years, you will have approximately 8547 pounds of plant
available nitrogen to utilize. Assuming you apply this PAN to hybrid bermuda grass hayland at the
rate of 300 pounds of nitrogen per acre, you will need 28 acreas of land. If you apply the sludge
to corn at a rate of 125 pounds per acre, you will need 68.376 acres of land. Please note that these
are only estimates of the PAN produced and the land required to utilize that PAN. Actual values
may only be determined by sampling the sludge for plant available nitrogen content prior to application
Actual utilization rates will vary with soil type, crop, and realistic yield expectations for the specific
application fields designated for sludge application at time of removal.
APPLICATION OF WASTE BY IRRIGATION:
The irrigation application rate should not exceed the intake rate of the soil at the time of irrigation
such that runoff or ponding occurs. This rate is limited by initial soil moisture content, soil
structure, soil texture, water droplet size, and organic solids. The application amount should not
exceed the available water holding capacity of the soil at the time of irrigation nor should the
plant available nitrogen applied exceed the nitrogen needs of the crop.
If surface irrigation is the method of land application for this plan, it is the responsibility of the
producer and irrigation designer to ensure that an irrigation system is installed to properly
irrigate the acres shown in the preceding table. Failure to apply the recommended rates and
amounts of nitrogen shown in the tables may make this plan invalid.
"This is the maximum application amount allowed for the soil assuming the amount
of nitrogen allowed for the crop is not over applied. In many situations, the application
amount shown cannot be applied because of the nitrogen limitation. The maximum
application amount shown can be applied under optimum soil conditions.
Your facility is designed for >180 days of temporary storage and the temporary storage must
be removed on the average of once every 6 months. In no instance should the volume of the
waste stored in your structure be within the 25 year 24 hour storm storage or one foot of
freeboard except in the event of the 25 year 24 hour storm.
It is the responsibility of the producer and waste applicator to ensure that the spreader equipment
is operated properly to apply the correct rates to the acres shown in the tables. Failure to apply
the recommended rates and amounts of nitrogen shown in the tables may make this plan invalid.
Call your technical specialist after you receive the waste analysis report for assistance in
determining the amount of waste per acre and the proper application prior to applying the waste.
5of11

Application Rate Guide
The following is provided as a guide for establishing application rates and amounts.
Soil
Application Rate
Application Amount
Tract
Hydrant
Type
Crop
inlhr
" inches
T1
1
Foreston
D
0.5
1
2
Foreston
D
0.5
1
3
Foreston
D
0.5
1
4
Foreston
D
0.5
1
5
Foreston
D
0.5
1
6
Foreston
D
0.5
1
7
Foreston
D
0.5
1
8
Autryville
C
0.6
1
9
Autryville
C
0.6
1
10
Autryville
C
0.6
1
11
Autryville
C
0.6
1
12
Foreston
C
0.5
1
13
Foreston
C
0.5
1
14
Foreston
C
0.5
1
sub1-7
Foreston
D
0.5
1
sub8-11
Autryville
C
0.6
1
sub12-14
Foreston
C
0.5
1
71193
1
Autryville
D
0.6
1
4207-F5
Zone 1
Foreston
D
0.5
1
4207-F5
Zone 2
Foreston
D
0.5
1
4207-F5
Zone 3
Foreston
D
0.5
1
)ptional Lan
71473 1 Autryville D 0.6 1
71473 1 Autryville O 0.6 1
6 of 11

Additional Comments:
Subfield acreage is the balance of the total field acres minus wet acres
at this site. This acreage will be claimed when making application with an
aerway machine.
Tracts 71193 is leased land. Tracts 71193 $ 4207 are optional for this plan and
application to Tract 71193 acreage will be made with an aerway.
Small grain hay behind soybeans is optional for all fields.
T71473 has been leased for a three year period beginning Fall 2006 and
is optional for use. Any of the crops listed may be grown. This land will
be applied to using an aerway type applicator.
This plan revised to include the new solid set sprinklers in Tract 4207 field 5.
7of11

NUTRIENT UTILIZATION PLAN CERTIFICATION
Name of Farm: Batchelor Farm
Owner: Murphy -Brown, LLC
Manager:
Owner/Manager Agreement:
I/we understand and will follow and implement the specifications and the operation and
maintenance procedures established in the approved animal waste nutrient management
plan for the farm named above. I/we know that any expansion to the existing design capacity
of the waste treatment and/or storage system, or construction of new facilities, will require a
new nutrient management plan and a new certification to be submitted to DWQ before the new
animals are stocked.
I/we understand that I must own or have access to equipment, primarily irrigation equipment,
to land apply the animal waste described in this nutrient management plan. This equipment
must be available at the appropriate pumping time such that no discharge occurs from the lagoon
in the event of a 25 year 24 hour storm. I also certify that the waste will be applied on the land
according to this plan at the appropriate times and at rates which produce no runoff.
This plan will be filed on site at the farm office and at the office of the local Soil and Water
Conservation District and will be available for review by NCDWQ upon request.
Name of Facility Owner: Murphy -Brown, LLC
Signature:
Name of Manager (if different from owner):
Signature:
Date
Date
Name of Technical Specialist:
M. Kevin Weston
Affiliation:
Murphy -Brown, LLC.
_
Address:
2822 Hwy 24 West, PO Drawer 856
_
Warsaw, NC 28398
Telephone:
[phone]
Signature:
Date
8 of 11

NUTRIENT UTILIZATION PLAN
REQUIRED SPECIFICATIONS
Animal waste shall not reach surface waters of the state by runoff, drift, manmade
conveyances, direct application, or direct discharge during operation or land application.
Any discharge of waste which reaches surface water is prohibited.
2 There must be documentation in the design folder that the producer either owns or has an
agreement for use of adequate land on which to properly apply the waste. if the producer
does not own adequate land to properly dispose of the waste, he/she shall provide
evidence of an agreement with a landowner, who is within a reasonable proximity,
allowing him/her the use of the land for waste application. It is the responsibility of the
owner of the waste production facility to secure an update of the Nutrient Utilization Plan
when there is a change in the operation, increase in the number of animals, method of
application, recievinq crop type, or available land.
3 Animal waste shall be applied to meet, but not exceed, the nitrogen needs for realistic crop
yields based upon soil type, available moisture, historical data, climatic conditions, and
level of management, unless there are regulations that restrict the rate of applications for
other nutrients.
4 Animal waste shall be applied to land eroding less than 5 tons per acre per year. Waste
may be applied to land eroding at more than 5 tons per acre per year but less than 10 tons
per acre per year provided grass filter strips are installed where runoff leaves the field (See
USDA, NRCS Field Office Technical Guide Standard 393 - Filter Strips)_ -
5 Odors can be reduced by injecting the waste or disking after waste application. Waste
should not be applied when there is danger of drift from the land application field.
When animal waste is to be applied on acres subject to flooding, waste will be soil
incorporated on conventionally tilled cropland. When waste is applied to conservation tilled
crops or grassland, the waste may be broadcast provided the application does not occur
during a season prone to flooding (See "Weather and Climate in North Carolina" for
guidance).
7 Liquid waste shall be applied at rates not to exceed the soil infiltration rate such that runoff
does not occur offsite or to surface waters and in a method which does not cause drift
from the site during application. No ponding should occur in order to control odor and flies.
8 Animal waste shall not be applied to saturated soils, during rainfall events, or when the
surface is frozen.
9 of 11

NUTRIENT UTILIZATION PLAN
REQUIRED SPECIFICATIONS
(continued)
9 Animal waste shall be applied on actively growing crops in such a manner that the crop is
not covered with waste to a depth that would inhibit growth. The potential for salt damage
from animal waste should also be considered.
10 Nutrients from waste shall not be applied in fall or winter for spring planted crops on soils
with a high potential for leaching. Waste/nutrient loading rates on these soils should be
held to a minimum and a suitable winter cover crop planted to take up released nutrients.
Waste shall not be applied more than 30 days prior to planting of the crop or forages
breaking dormancy.
11 Any new swine facility sited on or after October 1, 1995 shall comply with the following:
The outer perimeter of the land area onto which waste is applied from a lagoon that is a
component of a swine farm shall be at least 50 feet from any residential property boundary
and canal. Animal waste, other than swine waste from facilities sited on or after October 1,
1995, shall not be applied closer than 25 feet to perennial waters.
12 Animal waste shall not be applied closer than 100 feet to wells.
13 Animal waste shall not be applied closer than 200 feet of dwellings other than those
owned by the landowner.
14 Waste shall be applied in a manner not to reach other property and public right-of-ways.
15 Animal waste shall not be discharged into surface waters, drainageways, or wetlands by
discharge or by over -spraying. Animal waste may be applied to prior converted cropland
provided the fields have been approved as a land application site by a "technical
specialist". Animal waste shall not be applied on grassed waterways that discharge
directly into water courses, and on other grassed waterways, waste shall be applied at
agronomic rates in a manner that causes no runoff or drift from the site.
16 Domestic and industrial waste from washdown facilities, showers, toilets, sinks, etc., shall
not be discharged into the animal waste management system.
10 of 11

NUTRIENT UTILIZATION PLAN
REQUIRED SPECIFICATIONS
(continued)
17 A protective cover of appropriate vegetation will be established on all disturbed areas
(lagoon embankments, berms, pipe runs, etc.). Areas shall be fenced, as necessary, to
protect the vegetation. Vegetation such as trees, shrubs, and other woody species, etc.,
are limited to areas where considered appropriate. Lagoon areas should be kept mowed
and accessible. Berms and structures should be inspected regularly for evidence of
erosion, leakage, or discharge.
18 If animal production at the facility is to be suspended or terminated, the owner is
responsible for obtaining and implementing a "closure plan" which will eliminate the
possibility of an illegal discharge, pollution and erosion.
19 Waste handling structures, piping, pumps, reels, etc., should be inspected on a regular
basis to prevent breakdowns, leaks and spills. A regular maintenance checklist should be
kept on site.
20 Animal waste can be used in a rotation that includes vegetables and other crops for direct
human consumption. However, if animal waste is used on crops for direct human
consumption, it should only be applied pre -plant with no further applications of animal
waste during the crop season.
21 Highly visible markers shall be installed to mark the top and bottom elevations of the
temporary storage (pumping volume) of all waste treatment lagoons. Pumping shall be
managed to maintain the liquid level between the markers. A marker will be required to
mark the maximum storage volume for waste storage ponds.
22 Waste shall be tested within 60 days of utilization and soil shall be tested at least annually
at crop sites where waste products are applied. Nitrogen shall be the rate -determining
nutrient, unless other restrictions require waste to be applied based on other nutrients,
resulting in a lower application rate than a nitrogen based rate. Zinc and copper levels in
the soil shall be monitored and alternative crop sites shall be used when these metals
approach excessive levels. pH shall be adjusted and maintained for optimum crop
production. Soil and waste analysis records shall be kept for a minimum of five years.
Poultry dry waste application records shall be maintained for a minimum of three years.
Waste application records for all other waste shall be maintained for a minimum of five
years.
23 Dead animals will be disposed of in a manner that meets North Carolina regulations.
11 of 11

NUTRIENT UTILIZATION PLAN
REQUIRED SPECIFICATIONS
Animal waste shall not reach surface waters of the state by runoff, drift, manmade
conveyances, direct application, or direct discharge during operation or land application.
Any discharge of waste which reaches surface water is prohibited.
2 There must be documentation in the design folder that the producer either owns or has an
agreement for use of adequate land on which to properly apply the waste. If the producer
does not own adequate land to properly dispose of the waste, he/she shall provide
evidence of an agreement with a landowner, who is within a reasonable proximity,
allowing him/her the use of the land for waste application. It is the responsibility of the
owner of the waste production facility to secure an update of the Nutrient Utilization Plan
when there is a change in the operation, increase in the number of animals, method of
application, recievinq crop type, or available land.
3 Animal waste shall be applied to meet, but not exceed, the nitrogen needs for realistic crop
yields based upon soil type, available moisture, historical data, climatic conditions, and
level of management, unless there are regulations that restrict the rate of applications for
other nutrients.
4 Animal waste shall be applied to land eroding less than 5 tons per acre per year. Waste
may be applied to land eroding at more than 5 tons per acre per year but less than 10 tons
per acre per year provided grass filter strips are installed where runoff leaves the field (See
USDA, NRCS Field Office Technical Guide Standard 393 - Filter Strips).
5 Odors can be reduced by injecting the waste or disking after waste application. Waste
should not be applied when there is danger of drift from the land application field.
6 When animal waste is to be applied on acres subject to flooding, waste will be soil
incorporated on conventionally tilled cropland. When waste is applied to conservation tilled
crops or grassland, the waste may be broadcast provided the application does not occur
during a season prone to flooding (See "Weather and Climate in North Carolina" for
guidance).
i Liquid waste shall be applied at rates not to exceed the soil infiltration rate such that runoff
does not occur offsite or to surface waters and in a method which does not cause drift
from the site during application_ No ponding should occur in order to control odor and flies.
8 Animal waste shall not be applied to saturated soils, during rainfall events, or when the
surface is frozen.
9of11

NUTRIENT UTILIZATION PLAN
REQUIRED SPECIFICATIONS
(continued)
9 Animal waste shall be applied on actively growing crops in such a manner that the crop is
not covered with waste to a depth that would inhibit growth. The potential for salt damage
from animal waste should also be considered.
10 Nutrients from waste shall not be applied in fall or winter for spring planted crops on soils
with a high potential for leaching. Waste/nutrient loading rates on these soils should be
held to a minimum and a suitable winter cover crop planted to take up released nutrients.
Waste shall not be applied more than 30 days prior to planting of the crop or forages
breaking dormancy.
11 Any new swine facility sited on or after October 1, 1995 shall comply with the following:
The outer perimeter of the land area onto which waste is applied from a lagoon that is a
component of a swine farm shall be at least 50 feet from any residential property boundary
and canal. Animal waste, other than swine waste from facilities sited on or after October 1,
1995, shall not be applied closer than 25 feet to perennial waters.
12 Animal waste shall not be applied closer than 100 feet to wells.
13 Animal waste shall not be applied closer than 200 feet of dwellings other than those
owned by the landowner.
14 Waste shalt be applied in a manner not to reach other property and public right-of-ways.
15 Animal waste shall not be discharged into surface waters, drainageways, or wetlands by
discharge or by over -spraying- Animal waste may be applied to prior converted cropland
provided the fields have been approved as a land application site by a "technical
specialist". Animal waste shall not be applied on grassed waterways that discharge
directly into water courses, and on other grassed waterways, waste shall be applied at
agronomic rates in a manner that causes no runoff or drift from the site.
16 Domestic and industrial waste from washdown facilities, showers, toilets, sinks, etc., shall
not be discharged into the animal waste management system.
10of11

03/02/2007 FRI 18:00 FAX [phone] WRLNMJ 444 DWQ Wilmington 001/006
a
or
Murp1hy,,BrownL.
~~
Murphy Brown LLc
PO Box 856
2822 Hwy 24 West
Warsaw, NC 28398
Phone [phone]
Fax [phone]
Fax Transmittal Sheet
` VV�
Fax: _ Pages:
Phone: Date:
Re: CC:
❑Urgent ❑ For Review ❑ Please Comment ❑ Please Reply ❑ Please Recycle

NUTRIENT UTILIZATION PLAN
REQUIRED SPECIFICATIONS
(continued)
17 A protective cover of appropriate vegetation will be established on all disturbed areas
(lagoon embankments, berms, pipe runs, etc.). Areas shall be fenced, as necessary, to
protect the vegetation. Vegetation such as trees, shrubs, and other woody species, etc.,
are limited to areas where considered appropriate. Lagoon areas should be kept mowed
and accessible. Berms and structures should be inspected regularly for evidence of
erosion, leakage, or discharge.
18 If animal production at the facility is to be suspended or terminated, the owner is
responsible for obtaining and implementing a "closure plan" which will eliminate the
possibility of an illegal discharge, pollution and erosion.
1g Waste handling structures, piping, pumps, reels, etc., should be inspected on a regular
basis to prevent breakdowns, leaks and spills. A regular maintenance checklist should be
kept on site.
20 -Animal waste can be used in a rotation that includes vegetables and other crops for direct
human consumption. However, if animal waste is used on crops for direct human
consumption, it should only be applied pre -plant with no further applications of animal
waste during the crop season.
21 Highly visible markers shall be installed to mark the top and bottom elevations of the
temporary storage (pumping volume) of all waste treatment lagoons. Pumping shall be
managed to maintain the liquid level between the markers. A marker will be required to
mark the maximum storage volume for waste storage ponds.
22 Waste shall be tested within 60 days of utilization and soil shall be tested at least annually
at crop sites where waste products are applied. Nitrogen shall be the rate -determining
nutrient, unless other restrictions require waste to be applied based on other nutrients,
resulting in a lower application rate than a nitrogen based rate. Zinc and copper levels in
the soil shall be monitored and alternative crop sites shall be used when these metals
approach excessive levels. pH shall be adjusted and maintained for optimum crop
production. Soil and waste analysis records shall be kept for a minimum of five years.
Poultry dry waste application records shall be maintained for a minimum of three years.
Waste application records for all other waste shall be maintained for a minimum of five
years.
23 Dead animals will be disposed of in a manner that meets North Carolina regulations.
11 of 11

0
03/02/2007 FRI 18:00 FAX [phone] WRLNN1 4-*4 DWQ Wilmington
Q 002/006
PLAN OF ACTION(Paa) FOR HIGH FREEBOARD AT ANIMAL FACILITIES
Facility Number: 31-563 County: Duplin
Facility Name: Batchelor Sow
Certified Operator Name: Ron Taylor Operator Number. 27466
1. Current liquid levet(s) In inches as measured from the current liquid level in the lagoon to the
lowest point on the top of the dam for lagoons without spillways; and from the current liquid level
in the lagoon to the bottom of the spillway for lagoons with spillways.
Lagoon 1 Lagoon 2 Lagoon 3 Lagoon 4 Lagoon 5
Lagoon Name/ID: A B
Spillway(Y or N): N N
Level(inches): 18 17
2. Check all applicable items
Liquid level is within the designed structural freeboard elevations of one or more structures_
Five and 30 day Plans of Action are attached. Hydraulic and agronomic balances are
within acceptable ranges.
X Liquid level is within the 25 year 24 hour storm elevations for one or more structures. A
30 day Plan of Action is attached_ Agronomic balance is within acceptable range.
Waste is to be pumped and hauled to off site locations. Bolume and PAN content of waste
to be pumped and hauled Is reflected in section III tables. lncluded within this plan is a list
of the proposed Was with related facility numbers, number of acres and receiving crop
information. Contact and secure approval from the DWO prior to transfer of waste to a site
not covered in the facility's CAWMP.
Operation will be partially or fully depopulated.
'Attach a complete schedule with corresponding animal units and dates fro depopulation
*if animals are to be moved to another permitted facility, provide facility number, lagoon
freeboard levels and herd population for the receiving facility
3. Earliest possible date to begin land application of waste: 3/3/2007
I hereby certify that I have reviewed the Information listed above and included within the
attached Plan of Action, and to the best of my knowledge and ability, the information is
accurate and correct.
David Nordin
Facia' OwnerlManager (print)
a l ity Owne !Manager (signature)
Phone: [phone]
Date: 312/2007

03/02/2007 FRI 18:00 FAX [phone] WRLNXI 444 DWQ Wilmington
Q 003/006
11. TOTAL POUNDS OF PAN STORED WITHIN STRUCTURAL FREEBOARD ANDIOR 25 YR.I24
FIR. STORM STORAGE ELEVATIONS IN ALL WASTE STRUCTURES FOR FACILITY
1. Structure ID: Batchelor A
line rn =
441.9 lb PAN
2. Structure ID: Batchelor B
line rn =
240.6 lb PAN
3. Structure ID:
line m =
lb PAN
4. Structure ID:
line m =
lb PAN
5. Structure ID:
line m =
lb PAN
6. Structure ID:
line m =
lb PAN
n. lines 1 +2+3+4+5+6= 682.4 lb PAN
Ill. TOTAL PAN BALANCE REMAINING FOR AVAILABLE CROPS DURING 30 DAY DRAW DOWN
PERIOD. DO NOT LISP' FIELDS TO WHICH PAN CANNOT BE APPLIED DURING THIS 30 DAY PERIOD.
o. tract #
p. field #
q. crop
F. acres
s. remaining IRR
2 PAN balance
(ib/acre}
t TOTAL PAN
BALANCE FOR
FIELD (Ibs.)
column r x s
u. applicaiion w9ndow'
1C
Corn
2.92
81.56
238.2
Mar -Jul
2C
Corn
2.71
81.83
221.8
Mar -Jul
3C
Corn
2.69
66.73
179.5
Mar -Jul
4C
Corn
2.64
76.87
202.9
Mar -July
5C
Corn
2.56
83.76
214.4
Mar -July
'State current crop ending application date or next crop application beginning date for available
receiving crops during 30 day draw down period.
v. Total PAN available for all fields (sum of column t) = 1056.8 lb. PAN
IV. FACILITY'S PoA OVERALL PAN BALANCE
w. Total PAN to be land applied (line n from section 11) = 682A lb. PAN
PoA (30 Day) 2121/00

03/02/2007 FRI 18:01 FAX [phone] WRi,Nf1 4- DWQ Wilmington
Q 004/006
x. Crop's remaining PAN balance (line v from section 111) =
y. Overall PAN balance (w - x)
1056.8 lb. PAN
-374 lb. PAN
Line y must show as a deficit. If line y does not show as a deficit, list course of action here including pump and
Maui, depopulation, herd reduction, etc. For pump & haul and herd reduction options, recalculate new PAN
based on new information. if new fields are to be included as an option for lowering lagoon level, add these
fields to the PAN balance table and recalculate the overall PAN balance. If animal waste is to be hauled to
another permitted facility, provide information regarding the herd population and lagoon freeboard levels at the
Irrigation onto existing spray fields will continue as weather and field conditions permit. Additional land is
available for pumping if needed.
PoA (30 Day) 2121/00

03/02/2007 FRI 18:01 FAX [phone] WRLNItl -•— DWQ Wilaington
IA 00s/006
PLAN OF ACTION (PoA) FOR HIGH FREEBOARD AT ANIMAL FACILITIES
30 DAY DRAW DOWN PERIOD
I. TOTAL PAN TO BE LAND APPLIED PER WASTE STRUCTURE
1. Structure Namelidentifier (ID). I Batchelor A
2. Current liquid volume in 25 yrJ24 hr_ storm storage & structural freeboard
a. current liquid level according to marker 18.0 inches
b. designed 25 yr.124 hr. storm & structural freeboard 19.0 inches
c. line b - line a (inches in red zone) = 1.0 inches
d. top of dike surface area according to design
(area at below structural freeboard elevation) 93799 fie
e. line ell x line d x 7.48 gallons/ft3 58468 gallons
3. Projected volume of waste liquid produced during draw down period
f. temporary storage period according to structural design 180 days
g. volume of waste produced according to structural design 232630 ft3
h. current herd # 2035 certified herd # 2035
actual waste produced = current herd #f x line g =
certified herd #
i. volume of wash water according to structural design
j. excess rainfall over evaporation according to design
k. (lines h + i + j) x 7.48 x 30 days/line f=
4. Total PAN to be land applied during draw down period
I. current waste analysis dated I 1 /24/2007
m. ((lines e + k)11000) x line I =
REPEAT SECTION I FOR EACH WASTE STRUCTURE ON SITE.
(Click on the next Structure tab shown below)
POA (30 Day) 2/21100
232630 ft3
]ft3
�l23228 ft3
443636 gallons
0.88 Ibs/l000 gal.
441.9 Ibs_ PAN

03/02/2007 FRI 18:01 FAX [phone] WRL.NI11 -,44 DW8 Wilmington R11006/006
PLAN OF ACTION (PoA) FOR HIGH FREEBOARD AT ANIMAL FACILITIES
30 DAY DRAW DOWN PERIOD
1. TOTAL PAN TO BE LAND APPLIED PER WASTE STRUCTURE
1. Structure Namelidentifier (ID): Batchelor B
2. Current liquid volume in 25 yr.124 hr. storm storage & structural freeboard
a. current liquid level according to marker 17.0 Inches
b. designed 25 yr.124 hr. storm & structural freeboard 19A inches
c. line b - line a (inches in red zone) = 2.0 inches
d. top of dike surface area according to design
(area at below structural freeboard elevation) 101761 fe
e. line 6112 x line d x 7.48 gallon&V 126862 gallons
3. Projected volume of waste liquid produced during draw down period
f. temporary storage period according to structural design I 180 days
g. volume of waste produced according to structural design 116315 W
h. current herd # 1100 certified herd # 1100
actual waste produced = current herd # x line g = 116315 fe
certified herd #
I. volume of wash water according to structural design
j. excess rainfall over evaporation according to design
k. (lines h + i + j) x 7.48 x 30 daysAine f=
4. Total PAN to be land applied during draw down period
I_ current waste analysis dated 1/24/2007
m. ((lines e + k)t1000) x line
REPEAT SECTION I FOR EACH WASTE STRUCTURE ON SITE.
(Click on the next Structure tab shown below)
PoA (30 Day) 2121100
©fe
61614 fe
221818 gallons
0.$9 lbs11000 gal.
240.6 lbs. PAN

Waste Management Plan Changes
RECEIVED
JAN 2 2 Z007
Facility Farm °`etc t c �� +►-1
This farms Waste Management Plan has made the following changes:
ACrop changes
❑ Wetted Acres
❑ Increased Acreage
❑ Decreased Acreage
❑ Changed Irrigation Design
❑ Change in Farm type
❑ Plan based on 3 Years On Farm Records
❑ Other
Comments:
-%-o1)
Date

Murphy -Brown, LLC 1/18/2007 2822 Hwy 24 West
P.O. Box 856
Warsaw, NC 28398
NUTRIENT UTILIZATION PLAN
Grower(s):
Farm Name:
Murphy -Brown, LLC
Batchelor Farm
County: Du fin
Farm Capacity:
Farrow to Wean 2035
Farrow to Feeder
Farrow to Finish
Wean to Feeder
Feeder to Finish
Storage Structure: Anaerobic
Storage Period:
Application Method:
>180 days
Irrigation
Lagoon
The waste from your animal facility must be land applied at a specified rate to prevent pollution
of surface water and/or groundwater. The plant nutrients in the animal waste should be used
to reduce the amount of commercial fertilizer required for the crops in the fields where the waste
is to be applied.
This waste utilization plan uses nitrogen as the limiting nutrient. Waste should be analyzed
before each application cycle. Annual soil tests are strongly encouraged so that all plant
nutrients can be balanced for realistic yields of the crop to be grown.
Several factors are important in implementing your waste utilization plan in order to maximize
the fertilizer value of the waste and to ensure that it is applied in an environmentally safe manner:
1. Always apply waste based on the needs of the crop to be grown and the nutrient
content of the waste. Do not apply more nitrogen than the crop can utilize.
2. Soil types are important as they have different infiltration rates, leaching potentials,
cation exchange capacities, and available water holding capacities.
3. Normally waste shall be applied to land eroding at less than 5 tons per acre per
year. Waste may be applied to land eroding at 5 or more tons per acre annually, but
less than 10 tons per acre per year providing that adequate filter strips are established.
4. Do not apply waste on saturated soils, when it is raining, or when the surface is frozen
Either of these conditions may result in runoff to surface waters which is not allowed
under DWQ regulations.
5. Wind conditions should also be considered to avoid drift and downwind odor
problems.
6. To maximize the value of the nutrients for crop production and to reduce the potential
for pollution, the waste should be applied to a growing crop or applied not more than
30 days prior to planting a crop or forages breaking dormancy. Injecting the waste or
disking will conserve nutrients and reduce odor problems.
1 of 8

This plan is based on the waste application method shown above. If you choose to change
methods in the future, you need to revise this plan. Nutrient levels for different application
methods are not the same.
The estimated acres needed to apply the animal waste is based on typical nutrient content
for this type of facility. In some cases you may want to have plant analysis made, which could
allow additional waste to be applied. Provisions shall be made for the area receiving waste to
be flexible so as to accommodate changing waste analysis content and crop type. Lime must
be applied to maintain pH in the optimum range for specific crop production.
This waste utilization plan, if carried out, meets the requirements for compliance with 15A NCAC
2H .0217 adopted by the Environmental Management Commission.
AMOUNT OF WASTE PRODUCED PER YEAR ( gallons, W, tons, etc.):
Capacity Type Waste Produced per Animal Total
2035
Farrow to Wean
3212 gal/yr
6,536,420 gal/yr
Farrow to Feeder
4015 gal/yr
gallyr
Farrow to Finish
10585 gallyr
gallyr
Wean to Feeder
223 gal/yr
gal/yr
Feeder to Finish
986 gal/yr
gaVyr
Total 6,536,420 gallyr
AMOUNT OF PLANT AVAILABLE NITROGEN PRODUCED PER YEAR (lbs): *Based on Farm pumping records
Capacity Type Nitrogen Produced per Animal Total
2035
Farrow to Wean
4.72 Ibs/yr
9,605 Ibs/yr
Farrow to Feeder
6.5 Ibs/yr
Ibs/yr
Farrow to Finish
26 ibslyr
Ibs/yr
Wean to Feeder
0.48 1bs/yr
Ibs/yr
Feeder to Finish
2.3 Ibs/yr
lbs/yr
Total 9,605 I bs/yr
Applying the above amount of waste is a big job. You should plan time and have appropriate
equipment to apply the waste in a timely manner.
LAND UTIL17ATION SUMMARY
The following table describes the nutrient balance and land utilization rate for this facility
Note that the Nitrogen Balance for Crops indicates the ratio of the amount of nitrogen produced
on this facility to the amount of nitrogen that the crops under irrigation may uptake and utilize
in the normal growing season.
Total Irrigated Acreage: 119.54
Total N Required 1st Year: 27100.55
Total N Required 2nd Year: 23608.4
Average Annual Nitrogen Requirement of Crops: 25,354.48
Total Nitrogen Produced by Farm: 9,605.20
Nitrogen Balance for Crops: (15,749.28)
The following table describes the specifications of the hydrants and fields that contain the crops
designated for utilization of the nitrogen produced on this facility. This chart describes the size,
soil characteristics, and uptake rate for each crop in the specified crop rotation schedule for this
facility.
2 of 8

Reception Area Specifications
Tract Field Irrigated Soil 1st Crop Time to 1st Crap 1st Crop Lbs NIAc Lbs N Total Ibs N
Acreacte Type Code Apply Yield Ibs NlUnit Residual !AC Utilized
2nd Crop Time to 2nd Crop 2nd Crop Lbs NIAc Lbs N Total Ibs N
Code Apply Yield Ibs NlUnit Residual /Ac Utilized
Total
Lbs NIAc
Total lbs N
Utilized
T1
1
2.92
Foreston
D
Mar -Jul
120.0
1.25
150
438
N
Se 1-A r
55
2.4
132
385.44
282
823.44
2
2.71
Foreston
D
Mar -Jul
120.0
1.25
150
406.5
N
Sept -Apr
55
2.4
132
357.72
282
764.22
3
2.69
Foreston
❑
Mar -Jul
120.0
1.25
160
403.5
N
Se 1-A r
55
2.4
132
355.08
282
758.58
4
2.64
Foreston
D
Mar -Jul
120.0
1.25
150
396
N
Sept -Apr
55
2.4
132
34&48
282
744.48
5
2.50
Foruston
D
Mar -Jul
120.0
1.25
150
384
N
$e t-A r
55
2.4
132
337.92
282
721.92
6
2.38
Foreston
D
Mar -Jul
120.0
1.25
150
357
N
Sept -Apr
55
2.4
132
314.16
282
671.16
7
1.69
Foreston
D
Mar -Jul
120.0
1.25
150
253.5
N
Sept -Apr
55
2.4
1 132
223.08
1 282
476.58
8
1.85
Autr ville
C
Mar -Sept
5.5
50
275
508.75
L
Sept -Apr
1
50
50
92.5
325
601.25
9
1,85
Au tryville
C
Mar -Set
5.5
50
275
508.75
L
Sept -Apr
1
50
50
92.5
325
601.25
10
1.91
Aulryville
C
Mar -Set
5.5
50
275
525.25
L
Sept -Apr-
1
50
50
95.5 1
325
620.75
11
1.69
Autr ville
C
Mar -Set
5.5
50
275
464.75
L
Sept -Apr
1
50
50
84.5
325
549.25
12
9.6
Foreston
C
Mar -Sat
6.0
50
300
2880
L
Sept -Apr
1
50
50
480
350
3360
13
8.32
Foreston
C
Mar -Set
6.0
50
300
2496
L
Sept -Apr
1
50
50
416
350
2912
14
2.34
Foreston
C
Mar -Set
6.0
50
1 300
702
L
Sept -Apr
1
50
50
117
350
819
subl-7
3.01
Foreston
❑
Mar -Jul
120.0
1.25
150
451.5
N
Se t-A r
55
2.4
132
397.32
282
84&82
sub8.11
0.98
Autr itle
C
Mar -Set
5.5
50
275
269.5
L
Se t-A r
1
50
50
49
325
318.5
sub12-14
6.44
Foreston
C
Mar -Set
6.0
50
300
1932
L
Se t-A r
1
50
50
322
350
2254
71193
1
33.88
Autr villa
D
Mar -Jul
85.0
1.25
106,25
3599.75
N
Se t-A r
45
2A
108
3659.04
214.25
7258.79
4207
5
7.08
Foreston
Q
Mar -Jul
120.0
1.25
ISO
1062
N
Se t-A r
55
2.4
132
934.56
282
1996.56
O lional Land
71473
1
11.5
Aulr ville
D
Mar-Juty
85.0
1.25
15
91.25
0
N
Sept -Apr
45
2A
108
1242
0
0
71473
1
11,5
Autr ville
O
June -Set
30.0
4
0
120
0
0
0
Totals: if9.54 1803&75 10303.8 2r100.55
3(a) of 8

Reception Area Specifications
Tract Field Irrigated Soil ist Crap Time to 1st Crop 1st Crop Lbs NlAc Lbs N Total Ibs N
Acrea e Type Code Apply Yield Ibs NlUnit Residual /Ac Utilized
2nd Crop Time to 2nd Crop 2nd Crop Lbs N/Ac Lbs N Total rbs N
Coda Apply Yield lbs. NlUnit Residual /Ac Utilized
Total
Lbs NlAe
Total Ibs N
Utilized
T1
1
2,92
Foreston
O
Jun -Set
40.0
4
160
467.2
L
Sept -Apr
1
65
15
50
146
210
613.2
2
2.71
Foreston
0
Jun -Set
40.0
4
160
433.6
L
Sept -Apr
1
65
15
50
135.5
210
569.1
3
2.69
Foreston
O
Jun -Set
40.0
4
160
430.4
L
Sept r
1
65
15
50
134.5
210
564.9
4
2.64
Foreston
O
Jun -Set
40.0
4
160
422.4
L
Se t-A r
1
65
15
50
132
210
554.4
5
2.56
Foreston
O
Jun -Set
40.0
4
160
409.E
L
Se t-A r
1
65
15
50
128
210
537.6
6
2.38
Foreston
0
Jun -Set
40.0
4
160
380.8
L
Sept -Apr
1
65
15
50
119
210
499.8
7
1.69
Foreston
0
Jun -Set
40.0
4
160
270.4
L
I Sept -Apr
1
1 65
15
1 50
84.5
1 210
354.9
8
1.85
Autryville
C
Mar -Set
5.5
50
275
508.75
L
Sept -Apr
1
50
50
92.5
325
601.25
9
1.85
AutryyWe
C
Mar -Set
515
50
275
508.75
L
Se t-A r
1
50
50
92.5
325
601.25
10
1.91
Aulryville
C
Mar -Set
5.5
50
275
525.25
L
Sept -Apr
1
50
50
95.5
325
620.75
11
1169
Autr ville
C
Mar -Set
5.5
50
275
464.75
L
Sept -Apr
1
50
5o
84.5
325
549.25
12
9.6
Foreston
C
Mar -Set
6.0
50
300
2880
L
Sept -Apr
1
50
50
480
350
3360
13
8.32
Foreston
C
Mar -Set
6.0
50
300
2496
L
Sept -Apr
1
50
50
416
350
2912
14
1 2.34
Foreston
C
Mar -Set
6.0
50
300
702
L
Sept -Apr
1
50
50
117
350
819
subl-7
3,01
Foreston
O
Jun -Set
40.0
4
160
481.6
L
Se t-A r
1
65
15
50
150.5
210
632.1
sub8-11
0.98
Aulryville
C
Mar -Set
5.5
50
275
269.5
L
Se t-A r
1
50
50
49
325
318.5
subl2-14
6.44
Foreston
C
Mar -Set
6.0
50
300
1932
L
Sept -Apr
1
50
50
322
350
2254
71193
1
33.88
Autryville
O
Jun -Set
30.0
4
120
4065.6
L
Sept -Apr
1
65
15
50
1694
170
5759.6
4207
5
7.08
Foreston
O
Jun -Set
40.0
4
160
1132.8
L
Sept -Apr
1
65
15
50
354
210
1486.8
If small
grain hay is
not planted
behind soybeans,
deduct 15 lb residual from
corn.
Totals: 96.54 18781.4 4827 23606.4
3(b) of 8

This plan does not include commercial fertilizer. The farm should produce adequate plant
available nitrogen to satisfy the requirements of the crops listed above.
The applicator is cautioned that P and K may be over applied while meeting the N requirements.
In the future, regulations may require farmers in some parts of North Carolina to have a nutrient
management plan that addresses all nutrients. This plan only addresses nitrogen.
In interplanted fields ( i.e. small grain, etc, interseeded in bermuda), forage must be removed
through grazing, hay, and/or silage. Where grazing, plants should be grazed when they
reach a height of six to nine inches. Cattle should be removed when plants are grazed to a
height of four inches. In fields where small grain, etc, is to be removed for hay or silage, care
should be exercised not to let small grain reach maturity, especially late in the season (i.e.
April or May). Shading may result if small grain gets too high and this will deiinately interfere
with stand of bermudagrass. This loss of stand will result in reduced yields and less nitrogen
being utilized. Rather than cutting small grain for hay or silage just before heading as is
the normal situation, you are encouraged to cut the small grain earlier. You may want to
consider harvesting hay or silage two to three times during the season, depending on the
time small grain is planted in the fall.
The ideal time to interplant small grain, etc, is late September or early October. Drilling is
recommended over broadcasting. Bermudagrass should be grazed or cut to a height of
about two inches before drilling for best results.
CROP CODE LEGEND
Crop Code
Crop
Lbs N utilized / unit yield
A
Barley
1.6 Ibs N 1 bushel
B
Hybrid Bermudagrass - Grazed
50 Ibs N / ton
C
Hybrid Bermudagrass - Hay
50 lbs N 1 ton
D
Corn - Grain
1.25 Ibs N / bushel
E
Corn - Silage
12 Ibs N 1 ton
F
Cotton
0.12 Ibs N 1 Ibs lint
G
Fescue - Grazed
50 lbs N / ton
H
Fescue - Hay
50 Ibs N 1 ton
I
Oats
1.3 lbs N 1 bushel
J
Rye
2.4 Ibs N 1 bushel
K
Small Grain - Grazed
50 lbs N 1 acre
L
Small Grain - Hay
50 Ibs N / acre
M
Grain Sorghum
2.5 lbs N 1 cwt
N
Wheat
2.4 Ibs N 1 bushel
O
Soybean
4.0 Ibs N 1 bushel
P
Pine Trees
40 Ibs N 1 acre 1 yr
Acres shown in the preceding table are considered to be the usable acres excluding
required buffers, filler strips along ditches, odd areas unable to be irrigated, and perimeter areas
not receiving full application rates due to equipment limitations. Actual total acres in the fields
listed may, and most likely will be, more than the acres shown in the tables.
See attached map showing the fields to be used for the utilization of animal waste.
4 of 8

SLUDGE APPLICATION:
The following table describes the annual nitrogen accumulation rate per animal
in the lagoon sludge
Farm Specifications PANT rlanimal Farm Total/ r
2035 Farrow to Wean 0.84 1709.4
Farrow to Feeder 1
Farrow to Finish 4.1
Wean to Feeder 0.072
Feeder to Finish 0.36
The waste utilization plan must contain provisions for periodic land application of sludge at
agronomic rates. The sludge will be nutrient rich and will require precautionary measures to
prevent over application of nutrients or other elements. Your production facility will produce
approximately 1709.4 pounds of plant available nitrogen per year will accumulate in the lagoon
sludge based on the rates of accumulation listed above.
If you remove the sludge every 5 years, you will have approximately 8547 pounds of plant
available nitrogen to utilize. Assuming you apply this PAN to hybrid bermuda grass hayland at the
rate of 300 pounds of nitrogen per acre, you will need 28 acreas of land. If you apply the sludge
to corn at a rate of 125 pounds per acre, you will need 68.376 acres of land. Please note that these
are only estimates of the PAN produced and the land required to utilize that PAN. Actual values
may only be determined by sampling the sludge for plant available nitrogen content prior to application
Actual utilization rates will vary with soil type, crop, and realistic yield expectations for the specific
application fields designated for sludge application at time of removal.
APPLICATION OF WASTE BY IRRIGATION:
The irrigation application rate should not exceed the intake rate of the soil at the time of irrigation
such that runoff or ponding occurs. This rate is limited by initial soil moisture content, soil
structure, soil texture, water droplet size, and organic solids. The application amount should not
exceed the available water holding capacity of the soil at the time of irrigation nor should the
plant available nitrogen applied exceed the nitrogen needs of the crop.
If surface irrigation is the method of land application for this plan, it is the responsibility of the
producer and irrigation designer to ensure that an irrigation system is installed to properly
irrigate the acres shown in the preceding table. Failure to apply the recommended rates and
amounts of nitrogen shown in the tables may make this plan invalid.
`This is the maximum application amount allowed for the soil assuming the amount
of nitrogen allowed for the crop is not over applied. In many situations, the application
amount shown cannot be applied because of the nitrogen limitation. The maximum
application amount shown can be applied under optimum soil conditions.
Your facility is designed for >180 days of temporary storage and the temporary storage must
be removed on the average of once every 6 months. In no instance should the volume of the
waste stored in your structure be within the 25 year 24 hour storm storage or one foot of
freeboard except in the event of the 25 year 24 hour storm.
It is the responsibility of the producer and waste applicator to ensure that the spreader equipment
is operated properly to apply the correct rates to the acres shown in the tables. Failure to apply
the recommended rates and amounts of nitrogen shown in the tables may make this plan invalid.
Call your technical specialist after you receive the waste analysis report for assistance in
determining the amount of waste per acre and the proper application prior to applying the waste.
5of8

Application Rate Guide
The following is provided as a guide for establishing application rates and amounts.
Soil
Application Rate
Application Amount
Tract
Hydrant
Type
Crop
inlhr
* inches
T1
1
-Foreston
D
0.5
1
2
Foreston
D
0.5
1
3
Foreston
D
0.5
1
4
Foreston
D
0.5
1
5
Foreston
D
0.5
1
6
Foreston
D
0.5
1
7
Foreston
D
0.5
1
8
Autryville
C
0.6
1
9
Autryville
C
0.6
1
10
Autryville
C
0.6
1
11
Autryville
C
0.6
1
12
Foreston
C
0.5
1
13
Foreston
C
0.5
1
14
Foreston
C
0.5
1
subl-7
Foreston
D
0.5
1
sub8-11
Autryville
C
0.6
1
sub12-14
Foreston
C
0.5
1
71193
1
Autryville
D
0.6
1
4207
5
Foreston
D
0.5
1
)ptional Lan
71473 1 Autryville D 0.6 1
71473 1 Autryville O 0.6 1
6 of 8

Additional Comments:
Subfield acreage is the balance of the total field acres minus wet acres
at this site. This acrea a will be claimed when making application with an _
aerway machine.
Tracts 71193 and 4207 are leased land. This land is optional for this plan and
application to the acreage will be made with an aerway.
Small grain hay behind soybeans is optional for all fields.
T71473 has been leased for a three year period beginning Fall 2006 and
is optional for use. Any of the crops listed may be grown_. This land will
be applied to using an aerway type applicator.
7of8

NUTRIENT UTILIZATION PLAN CERTIFICATION
Name of Farm: Batchelor Farm
Owner: Murphy -Brown, LLC
Manager:
Owner/Manager Agreement:
Ilwe understand and will follow and implement the specifications and the operation and
maintenance procedures established in the approved animal waste nutrient management
plan for the farm named above. I/we know that any expansion to the existing design capacity
of the waste treatment and/or storage system, or construction of new facilities, will require a
new nutrient management plan and a new certification to be submitted to DWQ before the new
animals are stocked.
Ilwe understand that I must own or have access to equipment, primarily irrigation equipment,
to land apply the animal waste described in this nutrient management plan. This equipment
must be available at the appropriate pumping time such that no discharge occurs from the lagoon
in the event of a 25 year 24 hour storm. I also certify that the waste will be applied on the land
according to this plan at the appropriate times and at rates which produce no runoff.
This plan will be filed on site at the farm office and at the office of the local Soil and Water
Conservation District and will be available for review by NCDWQ upon request.
Name of Facility Owner: Murphy -Brown, LLC
Signature: ` k%` T1
Date
Name of Manager (if different from owner):
Signature:
Date
Name of Technical Specialist: Amy E. Roberson
Affiliation: Murphy -Brown, LLC.
Address: 2822 Hwy 24 West, PO Drawer 856
Warsaw. NC 28398
Telephone: [phone]
Signature: ► ' 1 u-T
Date
8 of 8

NUTRIENT UTILIZATION PLAN
REQUIRED SPECIFICATIONS
Animal waste shall not reach surface waters of the state by runoff, drift, manmade
conveyances, direct application, or direct discharge during operation or land application.
Any discharge of waste which reaches surface water is prohibited.
2 There must be documentation in the design folder that the producer either owns or has an
agreement for use of adequate land on which to properly apply the waste. If the producer
does not own adequate land to properly dispose of the waste, he/she shall provide
evidence of an agreement with a landowner, who is within a reasonable proximity,
allowing himlher the use of the land for waste application. It is the responsibility of the
owner of the waste production facility to secure an update of the Nutrient Utilization Plan
when there is a change in the operation, increase in the number of animals, method of
application, recievinq crop type, or available land.
Animal waste shall be applied to meet, but not exceed, the nitrogen needs for realistic crop
yields based upon soil type, available moisture, historical data, climatic conditions, and
level of management, unless there are regulations that restrict the rate of applications for
other nutrients.
4 Animal waste shall be applied to land eroding less than 5 tons per acre per year. Waste
may be applied to land eroding at more than 5 tons per acre per year but less than 10 tons
per acre per year provided grass filter strips are installed where runoff leaves the field (See
USDA, NRCS Field Office Technical Guide Standard 393 - Filter Strips).
Odors can be reduced by injecting the waste or disking after waste application. Waste
should not be applied when there is danger of drift from the land application field.
6 When animal waste is to be applied on acres subject to flooding, waste will be soil
incorporated on conventionally tilled cropland. When waste is applied to conservation tilled
crops or grassland, the waste may be broadcast provided the application does not occur
during a season prone to flooding (See "Weather and Climate in North Carolina" for
guidance).
Liquid waste shall be applied at rates not to exceed the soil infiltration rate such that runoff
does not occur offsite or to surface waters and in a method which does not cause drift
from the site during application. No ponding should occur in order to control odor and flies.
8 Animal waste shall not be applied to saturated soils, during rainfall events, or when the
surface is frozen.
1 of 3

NUTRIENT UTILIZATION PLAN
REQUIRED SPECIFICATIONS
(continued)
Animal waste shall be applied on actively growing crops in such a manner that the crop is
not covered with waste to a depth that would inhibit growth. The potential for salt damage
from animal waste should also be considered.
10 Nutrients from waste shall not be applied in fall or winter for spring planted crops on soils
with a high potential for leaching. Waste/nutrient loading rates on these soils should be
held to a minimum and a suitable winter cover crop planted to take up released nutrients.
Waste shall not be applied more than 30 days prior to planting of the crop or forages
breaking dormancy.
11 Any new swine facility sited on or after October 1, 1995 shall comply with the following:
The outer perimeter of the land area onto which waste is applied from a lagoon that is a
component of a swine farm shall be at least 50 feet from any residential property boundary
and canal. Animal waste, other than swine waste from facilities sited on or after October 1,
1995, shall not be applied closer than 25 feet to perennial waters.
12 Animal waste shall not be applied closer than 100 feet to wells.
13 Animal waste shall not be applied closer than 200 feet of dwellings other than those
owned by the landowner.
14 Waste shall be applied in a manner not to reach other property and public right-of-ways.
15 Animal waste shall not be discharged into surface waters, drainageways, or wetlands by
discharge or by over -spraying. Animal waste may be applied to prior converted cropland
provided the fields have been approved as a land application site by a "technical
specialist". Animal waste shall not be applied on grassed waterways that discharge
directly into water courses, and on other grassed waterways, waste shall be applied at
agronomic rates in a manner that causes no runoff or drift from the site.
16 Domestic and industrial waste from washdown facilities, showers, toilets, sinks, etc., shall
not be discharged into the animal waste management system.
2of3

NUTRIENT UTILIZATION PLAN
REQUIRED SPECIFICATIONS
(continued)
17 A protective cover of appropriate vegetation will be established on all disturbed areas
(lagoon embankments, berms, pipe runs, etc.). Areas shall be fenced, as necessary, to
protect the vegetation. Vegetation such as trees, shrubs, and other woody species, etc.,
are limited to areas where considered appropriate. Lagoon areas should be kept mowed
and accessible. Berms and structures should be inspected regularly for evidence of
erosion, leakage, or discharge.
18 If animal production at the facility is to be suspended or terminated, the owner is
responsible for obtaining and implementing a "closure plan" which will eliminate the
possibility of an illegal discharge, pollution and erosion.
19 Waste handling structures, piping, pumps, reels, etc., should be inspected on a regular
basis to prevent breakdowns, leaks and spills. A regular maintenance checklist should be
kept on site.
20 Animal waste can be used in a rotation that includes vegetables and other crops for direct
human consumption. However, if animal waste is used on crops for direct human
consumption, it should only be applied pre -plant with no further applications of animal
waste during the crop season.
21 Highly visible markers shall be installed to mark the top and bottom elevations of the
temporary storage (pumping volume) of all waste treatment lagoons. Pumping shall be
managed to maintain the liquid level between the markers. A marker will be required to
mark the maximum storage volume for waste storage ponds.
22 Waste shall be tested within 60 days of utilization and soil shall be tested at least annually
at crop sites where waste products are applied. Nitrogen shall be the rate -determining
nutrient, unless other restrictions require waste to be applied based on other nutrients,
resulting in a lower application rate than a nitrogen based rate. Zinc and copper levels in
the soil shall be monitored and alternative crop sites shall be used when these metals
approach excessive levels. pH shall be adjusted and maintained for optimum crop
production. Soil and waste analysis records shall be kept for a minimum of five years.
Poultry dry waste application records shall be maintained for a minimum of three years.
Waste application records for all other waste shall be maintained for a minimum of five
years.
23 Dead animals will be disposed of in a manner that meets North Carolina regulations.
3of3

o�O� W A r�R��
r^
0 Ni� C
Murphy Family Farms
Batchelor Sow Farm
PO Box 754
Rose Hill NC 28458
Dear Murphy Family Farms:
Michael F. Easley, Governor
William G. Ross Jr., Secretary
North Carolina Department of Environment and Natural Resources
Alan W. Klimek, P. E., Director
Division of Water Quality
May 1, 2003
Subject: Certificate of Coverage No. AWS310563
Batchelor Sow Farm
Swine Waste Collection, Treatment,
Storage and Application System
Duplin County
On April 28, 2003, the North Carolina General Assembly ratified Senate Bill 733 which directs the
Division of Water Quality (Division) to extend the expirationdate. oftheSwine Waste Operation General
Permit AWG100000. Therefore, the General Permit has been re -issued by the Division to extend the
expiration date to October 1, 2004. During the period of this extension the Division will be working with
all interested parties on the development of a new version of the Non -Discharge General Permit.
In accordance with your application received on February 13, 2003 and in accordance with the directive
of Senate Bill 733, we are hereby forwarding to you this Certificate of Coverage (COC) issued to
Murphy Family Farms, authorizing the operation of the subject animal waste collection, treatment,
storage and land application system in accordance with General Permit AWG100000. The issuance of
this COC supercedes and terminates your previous COC Number AWS310563 which expired on April
30, 2003.
This approval shall consist of the operation of this system including, but not limited to, the management
of animal waste from the Batchelor Sow Faun, located in Duplin County, with an animal capacity of no
greater than an annual average of 2035 Farrow to Wean swine and the application to land as specified in
the facility's Certified Animal Waste Management Plan (CAWMP). If this is a Farrow to Wean or
Farrow to Feeder operation, there may also be one boar for each 15 sows. Where boars are unneccessary,
they may be replaced by an equivalent number of sows. Any of the sows may be replaced by gilts at a
rate of 4 gilts for every 3 sows
The COC shall be effective from the date of issuance until October 1, 20DC Pursuant to this COC, you
are authorized and required to operate the system in conformity with the conditions and limitations as
specified in the General Permit, the facility's CAWMP, and this COC. An adequate system for collecting
and maintaining the required monitoring data and operational information must be established for this
facility. Any increase in waste production greater than the certified design capacity or increase in number
of animals authorized by this COC (as provided above) will require a modification to the CAWMP and
this COC and must be completed prior to actual increase in either wastewater flow or number of animals.
If your Waste Utilization Plan has been developed based on site specific information, careful evaluation
of future samples is necessary. Should your records show that the current Waste Utilization Plan is
inaccurate you will need to have a new Waste Utilization Plan developed.
The issuance of this COC does not excuse the Permittee from the obligation to comply with all applicable
laws, rules, standards, and ordinances (local, state, and federal), nor does issuance of a COC to rate
under1his-permit_convey any. property rights in either real or personal uroyerty. mil►
K ` ?EI Ft
Non -Discharge Permitting Unit
1617 Mail Service Center, Raleigh, NC 27699-1617
Customer Service Center
An Equal Opportunity Action Employer
Internet http:Uh2o.enr.stale.nc.us/ndpu
Telephone [phone] Fax [phone]
Telephone [phone]
50% recycled/10% post-Gonsumer paper

Upon abandonment or depopulation for a period of four years or more, the Permittee must submit
documentation to the Division demonstrating that all current NRCS standards are met prior to restocking
of the facility.
Per NRCS standards a 100 foot separation shall be maintained between water supply wells and any
lagoon or any wetted area of a spray field.
Please be advised that any violation of the terns and conditions specified in this COC, the General Permit
or the CAWMP may result in the revocation of this COC, or penalties in accordance with NCGS 143-
215.6A through 143-215.6C including civil penalties, criminal penalties, and injunctive relief.
If you kish to continue the activity permitted under the General Permit after the expiration date of the
General Permit, an application for renewal must be filed at least I80 days prior to expiration.
This COC is not automatically transferable. A name/ownership change application must be submitted to
the Division prior to a name change or change in ownership.
If any parts, requirements, or limitations contained in this COC are unacceptable, you have the right to
apply for an individual permit by contacting the staff member listed below for information on this
process. Unless such a request is trade within 30 days, this COC shall be final and binding.
This facility is located in a county covered by our Wilmington Regional Office. The Regional Office
Water Quality Staff maybe reached -at -(910)-395-3900. If you need additional information concerning
this COC or the General Permit, please contact Sue Homewood at [phone] ext. 502.
Sincerely,
for Alan W. Klimek, P.E.
Enclosures (General Permit AWGI00000)
cc: (Certificate of Coverage only for all cc's)
Wilmington Regional Office, Water Quality Section
Duplin County Health Department
Duplin County Soil and Water Conservation District
Permit File AWS310563
NDPU Files

M
Z.- e;LGCDL_ 31 - S(n3
PRODUCER: Batchldr Farm
LOCATION: PO BOX 759
Rose Hill, NC 28458
TELEPHONE: [phone]
TYPE OPERATION: 1-arrow - wean
NUMBER OF ANIMALS: 2035
(Design Capacity)
The waste from your animal facility must be land applied at a specified rate to prevent pollution
of surface and/or groundwater. The plant nutrients in the animal waste should be used to
reduce the amount of commercial fertilizer required for the crops in the fields where the waste
is to -be applied. This waste utilization plan uses nitrogen as the limiting nutrient. Waste
should be analyzed before each application cycle. Annual soil tests are strongly encouraged
so that all plant nutrients can be balanced for realistic yields of the crop to be grown.
Several factors are important in implementing your waste utilization plan in order to maAmize
the fertilizer value of the waste and to ensure that it is applied in an environmentally safe
manner. Always apply waste based on the needs of the crop to be. grown and the nutrient
content of the waste. Do not apply more nitrogen than the crop can utilize. Soil types are
important as they have different infiltration rates, leaching potentials, cation exchange
capacities, and available water holding capacities. Normally waste shall not be applled to land
eroding at greater than 5 tons per acre per year. With special precautions, waste may be
applied to land eroding at up to 10 tons per year. Do not apply waste on saturated soils, when
it is raining, or when the surface is frozen. Either of these conditions may result in runoff to
surface waters which is not allowed under DEM regulations. Wind conditions should also be
considered to avoid drift and downwind odor problems. To maximize the value of nutrients for
crop production and to reduce the potential for pollution, the waste should be applied to a
growing crop or applied to bare ground not more than 30 days prior to planting, Injecting the
waste or disking will conserve nutrients and reduce odor problems.
The estimated acres needed to apply the animal waste Is based on typical nutrient content for
this type of facility. Acreage requirements should be based on the waste analysis report from
your waste management facility. Attached you will find information on proper sampling
techniques, preparation, and transfer of waste samples to the lab for analysis.
This waste utilization plan, if carried out, meets the requirements for compliance with 15A
NCAC 2H.02117 adopted by the Environmental Management Commission.
Page 1

Amount of Waste Produced Per Year (gallons_ ft. tons. etca
2,035 animals X §M (tons) waste/animal/year =
Amount of Plant Available Nitrogen (PAN) Produced Per Year
2,036 animals X 5,4 lbs. PAN/animal/year =
Guide Std. 633)
12,393 (tons) waste/year.
10,989 lbs. PAN/year. (PAN from N.C.
Tech
Applying the above amount of waste is a big job. You should plan time and have appropriate
equipment to apply the waste in a timely manner
The following acreage will be needed for waste application based on the crop to be grown and
surface application:
Table 1: ACRES OWNED BY PRODUCER
Tract Field Soil Crop Lbs. N Acres Lbs. N Month of
# No. Type Per Acre Utilized Application
T1
1
Fo
Wheat
110
17.59
1,934.90
Sept -April
T1
1
Fo
Soybeans
120
17.59
2,110.80
June -Sept
T1
3
Fo
Bermuda (H)
300
20.26
6,078.00
March - Oct
T1
2
AuB 1 FoA
Bermuda (H)
287.5
7.30
2,098.75
March - Oct
"OPTIONAL"
2
AuB 1 FoA
Small Grain (G)
50
7.30
365.00
Sept -April
Total L—_ 45.151 12,222.45 J
;This N is from animal waste only. If nutrients from other sources such as commercial fertilizer are
applied, they must be accounted for. N must be based on realistic yield Mectatlon.
NOTE: The applicator is cautioned that P and K may be over applied while meeting the N
requirements. Beginning in 1996 the Coastal Zone Management Act will require farmers in some
eastern counties of North Caroline to have a nutrient management plan that addresses all nutrients.
This plan only addresses Nitrogen.
Page 2

Tract _ Field Soil Crop Lbs. N Acres Lbs. N Month of
`. -Application
* See footnote for Table 1.
Totals from above Tables
Acres Lbs. N
Utilized
Table 1 45.151 12,222
Table 2
Total 45.15 12,222
Amount of N Produced 10,989
Surplus or Deficit (1 233)
NOTE., The Waste Utilization Plan must contain provisions for periodic land application of sludge at
agronomic rates. The sludge will be nutrient rich and will require precautionary measures to prevent over
application of nutrient or other elements.
Page 3

+�� i�, <•2`t`Lv'civn n:[:v`'.ky t`rk� :;#>:'�'c:... w [['�#2'
.. L; �aa,.-.k���z4 ,.:�:3;ir:.::;ixxr�.c�i� :czziiL�. or :• <„.
See attached map showing the fields to be used for the utilization of waste water.
Application of Waste by Irrigation
Field Soil Type Crop Application Application
No. Rate (IniHr) Amount (In.)
1
FoA
Row Crops
0.4
.5-1.o
2,3
AuB/FoA
Bermuda
0.5
.5-1.0
THIS TABLE IS NOT NEEDED IF WASTE IS NOT BEING APPLIED BY IRRIGATION, HOWEVER A SIMILAR TABLE WILL
BE NEEDED FOR DRY LITTER OR SLURRY.
Your facility is designed for 180 days of temporary storage and the temporary storage must
be removed on the average of once every 6 MONTHS. In no instance should the volume of
waste being stored in your structure exceed Elevation `see lagoon design.
Cali the local Natural Resources Conservation Service (formerly Soil Conservation Service) or Soil
and Water Conservation District office after you receive the waste analysis report for assistance in
determining the amount per acre to apply and the proper application rate prior to applying the
waste.
Narrative of operation: Acres shown are "wetted" acres. Residual Soybean PAN taken from
wheat crop. Small grain overseed in field 2 is optional.
Page 4

REQUIRED SPECIFICATIONS
Animal waste shall not reach surface waters of the state by runoff, drift, manmade
conveyances, direct application, or direct discharge during operation or land application.
Any discharge of waste which reaches surface water Is prohibited.
2 'There must be documentation In the design folder that the producer either owns or has
an agreement for use of adequate land on which to property apply the waste. If the
producer does not own adequate land to properly dispose of waste, he/she shall provide
a copy of an agreement with a landowner who is within a reasonable proximity, allowing
him/her the use of the land for waste application. It Is the responsibility of the owner of
the facility to secure an update of the Waste Utilization Flan when there Is a change in
the operation, increase in the number of animals, method of utilization, or available land.
3 Animal waste shall be applied to meet, but not exceed, the nitrogen needs for realistic
crop yields based on soil type, available moisture, historical data, climatic conditions, and
level of management, unless there are regulations that restrict the rate of application for
other nutrients.
4 Animal waste shall be applied to land eroding less than 5 tons per acre per year. Waste
may be applied to land that Is eroding at 5 or more tons, but less than 10 tons per acre
per year providing grass filter strips are installed where runoff leaves the field. (See
F'OTG Standard 393 _ Filter Strip)_
5 Odors can be reduced by injecting the waste or disking after waste application. Waste
should not be applied when there is danger of drift from the irrigation field.
S When animal waste is to be applied on acres subject to flooding, it will be soil
incorporated on conventionally tilled cropland. When applied to conservation tilled crops
or grassland, the waste may be broadcast provided the application does not occur during
a season prone to flooding. (See "Weather and Climate in North Carolina" for guidance.)
7 . Uquid waste shall be applied at rates not to exceed the soil infiltration rate such that
runoff does not occur offsite or to surface waters and In a method which does not cause
drift from the site during application. No ponding should occur in order to control odor or
flies.
8 Animal waste shall not be applied to saturated soils, during rainfall events, or when the
surface is frozen.
Page 5

REQUIRED SPECIFICATIONS
(continued)
9 Animal waste shall be applied on actively growing crops In such a manner that the crop is
not covered with waste to a depth that would Inhibit growth. The potential for salt
damage from animal waste should also be considered.
10 Waste nutrients shall not be applied in fall or winter for spring planted crops on soils with
a high potential for leaching. Waste nutrient loading rates on these soils should be held
to a minimum and a suitable winter cover crop planted to take up released nutrients.
Waste shall not be applied more than 30 days prior to planting of the crop or forages
breaking dormancy.
11 Any new swine facility sited on or after October 1, 1095 shall comply with the following:
The outer perimeter of the land area onto which waste Is applied from a lagoon that is a
component of a swine farm shall be at least 50 feet from any residential property
boundary and from any perennial stream or river (other than an irrigation ditch or canal.
Animal waste other than swine waste from facilities sited on or after October 1, 1995),
shall not be applied closer than 25 feet to perennial waters. (See Standard 393 - Filter
Strips).
12
13
14
15
16
Animal waste shall not be applied closer than 100 feet to wells.
Animal waste shall not be applied closer than 200 feet of dwellings other than those
owned by the landowner.
Waste shall be applied in a manner not to reach other property and public right-of-ways.
Animal waste shall not be discharged Into surface waters, drainageways, or wetlands by
discharge or by aver -spraying. Animal waste may be applied to prior converted wetlands
provided they have been approved as a land application site by a "technical specialist".
Animal waste shall not be applied on grassed waterways that discharge directly into water
courses, and on other grassed waterways, waste shall be applied at agronomic rates in a
manner that courses no runoff or drift from the side.
Domestic and industrial waste from washdown facilities, showers, toilets, sinks, etc., shall
not be discharged Into the animal wasto management system.
Page 6

REQUIRED SPECIFICATIONS
(continued)
17 A protective cover of appropriate vegetation will be established on all disturbed areas
(lagoon embankments, berms, pipe runs, etc.). Areas shall be fenced as necessary to
protect the vegetation. Vegetation such as trees, shrubs, and other woody species, etc.,
are limited to areas where considered appropriate. Lagoon areas should be kept mowed
and accessible. Berms and structures should be inspected regularly for evidence of
erosion, leakage or discharge.
18 if animal production at the facility is to be suspended or terminated, the owner is
responsible for obtaining and Implementing a "closure plan" which will eliminate the
possibility of an illegal discharge, pollution and erosion.
19 Waste handling structures, piping pumps, reels, etc., should be inspected on a regular
basis to prevent breakdowns, leaks and spills. A regular maintenance checklist should
be kept on site.
20 Animal waste can be used in a rotation that includes vegetables and other crops for
direct human consumption. However, if animal waste is used on crops for direct human
consumption, it should only be applied pre -plant with no further applications animal waste
during the crop season.
21 Highly visible markers shall be installed to mark the top and bottom elevations of the
temporary storage (pumping volume) of all waste treatment lagoons. Pumping shall be
managed to maintain the liquid level between the markers. A marker Y411 be required to
mark the maximum storage volume forwaste storage ponds.
22 Waste shall be tested within 60 days of utilization and soil shall be tested at least
annually at crop sites where waste products are applied. Nitrogen shall be the rate -
determining element. Zinc and coppsr levels In the soil shall be monitored and
alternative crop sites shall be used when these metal approach excessive levels. pH
shall be adjusted for optimum crop production and maintained. Soil and waste analysis
records shall be kept for five years. Poultry dry waste application records shall be
maintained for three (3) years. Waste application records for all other waste shall be
maintained for five (6) years.
23 Dead animals will be disposed of in a manner that meets North Carolina regulations.
Rage 7

W$TE UTfI.I M1j PLAN A REEMENT
Name of Farm: Batchlor Farm
Owner/ Manager Agreement
I (we) understand and will follow and implement the specifications and the operation and
maintenance procedures established in the approved animal waste utilization plan for the
farm named above. I (we) know that any expansion to the existing design capacity of the
waste treatment and storage system or constructlon of new facilitles will require a new
certification to be submitted to the Division of Environment Management (DEM) before
the new animals are stocked. I (we) also understand that there must be no discharge of
anlmat waste from this system to surface waters of the state from a storm event less
severe than the 25-year, 24-hour storm. The approved plan will be filed on -site at the
farm office and at the office of the local Soil and Water Conservation District and will be
available for review by DEM upon request_
Name Owner Murphy Farms, l.l_C
01?eaas p nQ N~
Date: / o .,
Name of anager (if different from owner): k ,
Signature: jj_ Date:
�h Lb
Name of Technical Specialist: (Please prints Kraig A. Westerbeek
Affiliation: Mu h Famff Farms
Address Q
Signature:
v saltv v

PAN APPLICATION SUMMARY
BATCHLOR FARM
DUPLIN COUNTY -
1"9
Bermuda
Pull # Acres
PAN App.
Total
1
2.92
115.63
337.6
2
2.71
183.43
497.1
3
2.60
124.82
335.8
4
2.64
151.16
399.0
5
2.56
130.7
334.6
6
2.38
85.56
203.8
7
1.69
96.12
102.4
8
1.85
20.6
38.1
9
1.85
59.89
110.8
10
1.91
24.6
47.0
11
1.69
20.8
35.2
12
1.58
26.6
42.0
13
1.63
25.8
42.1
14
1.69
24.9
42.1
15
2.23
61.9
138,0
16
3.67
99.7
365.9
17
3.41
252.87
$62.3
1$
3.45
134.67
464.8
Total x - 4458.2 -
290-0
Bermuda
Small Grain
Pull #
Acres
PAN App,
Total
1-1
2.92
88.6
268.42
1-2
2.71
65
176.15
1-3
2.69
90.8
243.714
1-4
2,64
48.2
127.248
1-5
2.68
48.3
123.648
1-6
2.38
20.2
62.350 .
1-7
1.69
11.8
19.942
3-2A
1.69
46.6
78.754
3-28
2.23
47.9
106.817
3-3
3.67
40.4
148,268
3-4
3.41
65.3
222.073
3-5
3.45
70.4
242.80
Total - 1810.87
Total 1999 m 6269.1
Small Grain
Pull
Acreage
PAN App
Total
Pull
Acreage
PAN App
Total
1
2.92
285.9
834.8
1
2.92
144.4
421.6
2
2.71
169
458.0
2
2.71
76.3
206.8
3
2.69
217.9
586.2
3
2.69
83.1
223.5
4
2.64
278.9
736.3
4
2.64
53.9
142.3
5
2.56
254.7
662.0
5
Z56
110.E
283.1
8
2.38
145.7
348.8
6
2.38
11.6
27.0
7
1.60
13.34
22.5
7
1.69
0
0.0
8
1.85
21
38.9
8
1.85
0-
0.0
9
1.85
59.8
110.0
9
1.85
0
0.0
10
1.91
90.6
173.0
10
1.91
25
47.8
11
1.69
16.3
27.6
11
1.69
0
0.0
31A
1.58
11.8
18.6
31A
1.58
26.8
42.3
31 B
1.63
78.1
127.3
31 B
1.03
0
0.0
32A
1.69
196
331.2
32A
1.69
28.1
44.1
S28
2.23
178.1
391.2
32B
2.23
7.4
18.6
33
3.67
120.4
441.9
33
3.67
29.7
109.0
34
3.41
284.6
970.5
34
3.41
36.5
121.1

35
3.45
205
707.3
38
3.48
88.9
309.4
Total
7290.0
Total 2000 PAN
9077.2
20011
Bermuda
Pull #
Ames
PAN App.
Total
1
2.92
287.4
839.2
2
2.71
269
729.0
3
2.69
190.6
513.3
4
2.64
261.8
091.2
5
2.66
346.7
887.6
8
2.38
153.2
304.8
7
1.69
130.1
219.9
8
1.85
121
223.9
9
1.85
41.8
77.0
10
1,91
211.7
404.3
11
1.69
19.7
33.3
31 A
1.58
87
137.6
318
1.63
138.2
225.3
32A
1.69
109.1
184.4
32B
2.23
120.8
269.4
33
3.07
293.3
1076.4
34
3.41
294.2
1003.2
35
3.46
200.5
691.7
36
3.48
55.5
193.1
Total =
8704.1
2001 PAN
Total
9380.1
35 3.45 29.4 101.4
36 3.48 0 0.0
Total Y 1787.2
Small Grain
Pull # Acres
PAN App,
Total
1
2.92
27.2
79.4
2
2.71
0
0.0
3
2.09
28.5
70.7
4
2.64
0
0.0
5
2.56
0
0.0
6
2.38
0
0.0
7
1.69
0
0.0
8
1.85
0
0.0
9
1.85
0
0.0
10
1.91
0
0.0
11
1.69
0
0.0
31
9.6
38.2
366.7
32
8.312
11.2
93.2
33
2.34
0
0.0
Total = 616.0

o��F warF9 pG
co AIM r
Michael F. Easley
Governor
William G. Ross Jr., Secretary
Department of Environment and Natural Resources
p -C Alan W. Klimek, P.E. Director
Division of Water Quality
April 16, 2003
CERTIFIED MAIL
RETURN RECEIPT REQUESTED
Murphy Family Farms
PO Box 759
Rose Hill NC 28458
SUBJECT: Notice of Violation
Request for Information
Inadequate Freeboard
Batchelor Sow Farm
#31-563
Duplin County
Dear Sir or Madam:
On March 20, 2003, a representative of your animal operation informed the Division of
Water Quality (DWQ) that there was inadequate freeboard in the lagoon(s) serving this facility.
This lack of adequate freeboard is in non-compliance with the Certificate of Coverage
issued to this facility on August 25, 1997. In addition to this Notice of Violation (NOV), this
non-compliance is subject to an appropriate enforcement action by DWQ. This action can
consist of one or more of the following, a civil or criminal enforcement action; an injunction;
and/or a requirement to apply for coverage under an individual permit. The action chosen will
be based on complete evaluation of all factors that resulted in the inadequate freeboard; the
actions taken to restore the needed freeboard; and the actions being proposed to prevent the
problem from reoccurring.
To assist us in our review, please provide the Wilmington Regional Office with an
evaluation of the reasons for the freeboard violation(s) and a strategy to prevent future freeboard
violation(s). This evaluation and strategy must include but is not lirnited to the following:
Current Freeboard level(s)
Freeboard level records in the lagoon(s) for the past- 12 months up to the date of submittal
Spraying records for the past 12 months up to the date of submittal
NCDE tR
Customer Service: Mailing Address: Telephone [phone] Location:
1-B77-623-6748 1617 Mail Service Center Fax [phone] N. Salisbury St.
Raleigh, North Carolina 27699-1617 State Courier #52-01-01 Raleigh, NC 27699-1617
An Equal Opportunity /Alrirmafive Action Employer
50% recycled/ 10% post -consumer paper
httpYh2o.enr.s1ate.nc us

Inadequate Freeboard
Page 2 .-- _-------
Rainfall records for the past 12 months for this site up to the date of submittal (if
available)
Cropping system and PAN specified in the CAWMP. If the cropping system was not in
compliance with the facility's CAWMP, provide details of the cropping system in place
for the past 12 months.
A summary of actions taken to restore the needed freeboard in the lagoon(s) including but
not limited to removal of animals from the site, delay of restocking of animals, pumping
and hauling waste to another site (specify site), securing additional irrigation equipment,
and securing additional spray sites.
A description of water conservation measures in use at the facility and the date(s)
installed.
If the lagoon level(s) are still in violation of the facility's CAWMP and Permit, provide
an updated Plan of Action as to how the facility will return to compliance.
Provide a detailed description of the actions taken or proposed to be taken to insure that
there are no further freeboard violations at this facility.
This information must be received by the Wilmington Regional Office at the following
address no later than 10 days following receipt of this letter.
Division of Water Quality
127 Cardinal Drive Extension
Wilmington, NC 28405-2845
Once this information is received and evaluated by the DWQ staff, a determination will
be made as to the appropriate compliance/enforcement actions to be taken. Each case will be
evaluated on its own merit. The efforts by the owner/producer to notify DWQ of the problem,
efforts made to resolve the problem once identified, and efforts proposed to prevent future
problems will be positive factors in this determination:
Nothing in this letter should be taken as removing from you either the responsibility or
liability for this non-compliance or future cases of non-compliance. If you have any questions
regarding this letter, please do not hesitate to contact our Wilmington Regional Office Staff at
[phone].
Sincerely,
lan W. Klimek, P.E.
Director
cc: Wilmington Regional Office
Non -Discharge Compliance/Enforcement Unit
Central Files

_V
Murphy -Brown LLC
PO Drawer 856
2822 Hwy. 24 West
Warsaw, NC 28398
Tel: 910-293h34
Fax:
Mr. Shiver,
The following farm within the Murphy -Brown, LLC system had plan
amendments made to extend pumping windows and add additional PAN where needed.
The plan amendments are attached for each farm.
Farm Name Facility Number
Batchelor Farm 31-563
If there are any questions please let me know.
Regards,
Todd Rowe, CCA
Agronomist
Murphy -Brown, LLC

N
CAWMP AMENDMENT
Batchelor
7/28/03
This amendment is intended to extend the pumping window on corn. Nitrogen is
accumulated within the plant up to physiological maturity. The R2 growth stage (blister)
is critical because Nitrogen accumulated in vegetative plant parts begin to move into
reproductive plant parts and kernels are beginning dry matter accumulation. Nitrogen
should be applied to this growth stage to maximize the utilization of Nitrogen by the
plant. Knowing that the R2 stage occurs approximately 75-80 days after emergence, then
Nitrogen applications should continue up to this point. Upon a field visit it was
determined that the corn is in growth stage R1. With the R2 stage occurring
approximately 10-14 days after the RI stage, Nitrogen applications should continue until
August 10, 2003.
L�� 7
Manager
-'-� &I
Technical -Specialist
-.256
Date
Z,9 e�3
D to

CAWMP AMENDMENT
Batchelor
7/25/03
This amendment is intended to provide additional Nitrogen to the corn crop.
Tissue analysis was conducted on the corn crop on July 14, 2003. The results of this
analysis indicated the plants to be low in Nitrogen. Upon evaluation of the tissue sample
results and the crop that is planted, it is found that additional Nitrogen is required for the
corn crop. The additional Nitrogen is mainly due to the wet weather conditions that have
been seen so far this growing season. Several processes have caused Nitrogen to be lost
from the soil and restricted uptake by the plant. This additional Nitrogen is for
supplementation of the required PAN in the waste management plan.
HHydrant
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
Iff
I
RE, ME
.11
A I " � x ,.-
-- - —
Manager
Aft..'e. cep
lc� Technical Specialist
Supplemental Nitrogen per acre (pounds)
15.0
15.0
15.0
15.0
15.0
15.0
15.0
Date
Date
7 2r C-
ate

Freeboard Notification
Subject: Freeboard Notification
Date: Fri, 27 Jun 2003 17:12:02 -0400
From: 'Britt, RO (BOC)" <[e-mail]>
To: '" stonewall. [e-mail]"' <[e-mail]>
CC: "Nordin, David"<[e-mail]>
The following farm has a PoA that expires on 6/28/03. It is currently at the following levels:
Permit # Farm _Lagoon
310563 Batchelor A
310563 Batchelor B
Murphy -Brown, LLC
Kenansville Division
Freeboard Level Date
23" 6127/03
24" 6/27103
If you have any questions or comments, please contact David Nordin at 910-296-3731.
I of 1 7/16/2003 3:05 PM

PoA Lagoon Level Update Murphy -Brown, Kenansville
Subject: PoA Lagoon Level Update Murphy -Brown, Kenansville
Date: Fri, 11 Apr 2003 15:25:15 -0400
From: "Britt, RO (BOC)" <[e-mail]>
To: "'Chester.Cobb@,nemaiI.net"' <[e-mail]>,
"'[e-mail]"' <[e-mail]>
CC: "Nordin, David" <[e-mail]>
The following is an update of the lagoon levels currently under PoA's for the Murphy -Brown Kenansville Davison.
The following readings were recorded Friday, April 11, 2003.
Farm C.O.C. Lagoon Lagoon
# I.D. Level
Smith -Alderman 31-6 A 21
B 16
Bachelor 31-563 A 16
B 16
1 of 1 7/16/2003 3:32 PM

Lagoon Levels
Subject: Lagoon Levels
Date: Tue, 27 May 2003 15:14:06 -0400
From: "Nordin, David"<[e-mail]>
To: "'Rick. shiver@ncmailnet"' <Rick.shiver@ncmailnet>
CC: "'stonewall.mathis@ncmaiLnet"' <stonewall.mathis@ncmailnet>,
"'chester.cobb@ncmailnet"' <chester.cobb@ncmailnet>
Batchelor Sow Farm
Permit # 310563
Lagoon Level A - 18 inches B - 18 inches
5/27/03
The lagoons are not in compliance. A PoA will follow for this notification. if I can be of further assistance, please
call at 910 - 296 - 3731.
David Nordin
Murphy Brown LLC
Kenansville Division
1 of 1 7/16/2003 3:25 PM

Lagoon Freeboard Notification
Subject: Lagoon Freeboard Notification
Date: Wed, 23 Apr 2003 11:24:52 -0400
From: "Cavenaugh, Tonya"<[e-mail]>
To: "'[e-mail]"' <[e-mail]>
The following farm's PoA expires today, 4/23/03. Their current freeboard level is as follows:
Permit # Farm # Date Level Taken Level
31-563 Batchelor 4/23/03 A - 19"
B - 19"
The following farm's PoA expires 5/15/03. Their current freeboard level is as follows:
Permit # Farm #
31-6 Smith -Alderman
Tanya Cavenau,gh
A,luiply Brown LLC
Kenanftille Dizi.rion
[phone]
Land e; Aruttaentltilana,getnant
Admim trative 1 IsAislant
Date Level Taken Level
4/19/03 A - 22"
B-21"
Name: Notebook.jpg
Natebook.ipg Type: JPEG Image (image/jpeg)
Encoding: base64
1 of t 7/16/2003 3:27 PM

Lagoon Freeboards
Subject: Lagoon Freeboards
Date: Mon, 14 Jul 2003 16:29:01 -0400
From: "Nordin, David"<[e-mail]>
To: "'[e-mail]"' <stonewall. mathis@ncmail. net>
CC: "'[e-mail]"' <[e-mail]>,
"'Rick. [e-mail]"' <Rick. shiver@ncmail. net>
Freeboard Levels - Murphy Brown LLC Kenansville Division - 7/14/03
Farm Facility# Lagoon Level
2147 31 - 468
17 inches
Batchelor 31 - 563
A - 17 inches
B - 17 inches
Turner Sow 31 - 57
S1 - 14 inches
S2 - 14 inches
S3 - 17 inches
3620 31 - 400
18 inches
Scott 31 - 5
15 inches
Envirotech 31 - 177
S1 - 18.5 inches
3090 31 - 678
18 inches
2149 31 - 567
16 inches
2704 31 - 375
16 inches
2706 31 - 375
Winches In addition to a 30 day PoA, a 5 day PoA will be submitted for
this farm.
If you have any further
questions, please call me at 910 - 296 - 3731.
Thank You
David Nordin
Land & Nutrient Management
Murphy Brown LLC
Kenansville Division
l of 1 7/16/2003 3:02 PM

Lagoon Level Up Date
Subject: Lagoon Level Up Date
Date: Thu, 10 Apr 2003 15:43:41 -0400
From: "Britt, RO (BOC)" <[e-mail]>
To: "'[e-mail]"' <[e-mail]>,
"'[e-mail]"' <[e-mail]>
CC: "Nordin, David"<[e-mail]>,
"Williamson, Dawn"<[e-mail]>
The following lagoon levels are less than 19 inches.
Farm C.O.C. Lagoon Lagoon
# ID Level
Smith -Alderman 31-6 A 20
B 18
A PoA will be submitted for the Smith -Alderman farm as soon as possible. A PoA has been submitted for the
Bachelor farm (3l'-563). The following is an update on the lagoon levels at this facility as of 4110/03.
Farm C.O.0 Lagoon Lagoon
# ID Level
Bachelor 31-563 A 17
B 17.5
I of 1
7/16/2003 335 PM

Lagoon Levels
q�y
Subject: Lagoon Levels
Date: Tue, 27 May 2003 15:14:06 -0400
From: "Nordin, David"<[e-mail]>
To: "'Rick. [e-mail]"' <[e-mail]>
CC: "'[e-mail]"' <[e-mail]>,
"'[e-mail]"' <[e-mail]>
Batchelor Sow Farm
Permit # 310563
Lagoon Level A - 18 inches B - 18 inches
5/27/03
�i
The lagoons are not in compliance. A PoA will follow for this notification. If 1 can be of further assistance, please call
at 910 - 296 - 3731.
David Nordin
Murphy Brown LLC
Kenansville Division
of 1 5/28/2003 10:07 AM

May 28 03 04:19p MURPHY-BROWN 9102933138
=e
�?AY 3 0 2003
PLAN OF ACTION(Poa) FOR HIGH FREEBOARD AT ANIMAL FACILITIES
Facility Number Number. 31-563 County: Duplin
Facility Name: Batchelor Sow
Certified Operator Name: Operator Number: a0
1. Current liquid level(s) in inches as measured from the current liquid level in the lagoon to the
lowest point on the top of the dam for lagoons without spillways; and from the current liquid level
in the lagoon to the bottom of the spillway for lagoons with spillways.
Lagoon 1 Lagoon 2 Lagoon 3 Lagoon 4 Lagoon 5
Lagoon Name/ID: A B
5piltway(Y or N): N N
Level(inches): 18 18
2. Check all applicable items
Liquid level is within the designed structural freeboard elevations of one or more structures.
Five and 30 day Plans of Action are attached. Hydraulic and agronomic balances are
within acceptable ranges.
X Liquid level is within the 25 year 24 hour storm elevations for one or more structures. A
30 day Plan of Action is attached. Agronomic balance is within acceptable range.
Waste is to be pumped and hauled to off site locations_ Bolume and PAN content of waste
to be pumped and hauled is reflected in section III tables. Included within this plan is a list
of the proposed sites with related facility numbers, number of acres and receiving crop
information. Contact and secure approval from the DWQ prior to transfer of waste to a site
not covered in the facility's CAWMP.
Operation will be partially or fully depopulated,
'Attach a complete schedule with corresponding animal units and dates fro depopulation
'If animals are to be moved to another permitted facility, provide facility number, lagoon
freeboard levels and herd population for the receiving facility
3. Earliest possible date to begin land application of waste:
I hereby certify that 1 have reviewed the information listed above and included within the
attached Plan of Action, and to the best of my knowledge and ability, the Information is
accurate and correct.
Mu" 16g"-� tj e Ae- Phone: 41D • -2/�' 3731
F cility Owner/Manager (print)
Date:
Facility OwneriManp_qer (signature)

May 28 03 04:19p MURPHY-BROWN 9102933138 P.3
PLAN OF ACTION (PoA) FOR HIGH FREEBOARD AT ANIMAL FACILITIE:
30 DAY DRAW DOWN PERIOD
I. TOTAL PAN TO BE LAND APPLIED PER WASTE STRUCTURE
1. Structure Name/Identifier (lD): Batchelor A
2. Current liquid volume in 25 yr./24 hr. storm storage & structural freeboard
a. current liquid level according to marker t$.0 inches
b_ designed 25 yr.124 hr. storm & structural freeboard 19.0 inches
c. line b - line a (inches in red zone) = 1.0 inches
d. top of dike surface area according to design
(area at below structural freeboard elevation) 93799 ftz
e. line cJ12 x line d x 7.48 gallons/ft3 58468 gallons
3. Projected volume of waste liquid produced during draw down period
f. temporary storage period according to structural design 1$0 days
g, volume of waste produced according to structural design 232630 ft3
h. current herd # 935 certified herd # 935
actual waste produced = current herd # x line g = 232630 ft'
certified herd #
i. volume of wash water according to structural design ®ft3
j. excess rainfall over evaporation according to design 123228 ft3
k. (lines h + i + j) x 7.48 x 30 days/line f= 443636 gallons
4. Total PAN to be land applied during draw down period
I. current waste analysis dated 04/2812003 0.87 lbs/1000 gal.
m. ((lines e + k)/1000) x line I = 436.8 ibs. PAN
REPEAT SECTION I FOR EACH WASTE STRUCTURE ON SITE.
(Click on the next Structure gals shown below)
PoA (30 Day) 20/00

Mau 28 03 04:20p MURPHY-BROWN 9102933138 p.4
PLAN OF ACTION (PoA) FOR HIGH FREEBOARD AT ANIMAL FACILITIES
30 DAY DRAW DOWN PERIOD
I. TOTAL PAN TO BE, LAND APPLIED PER WASTE STRUCTURE
1. Structure Namelldentifier (113): 1 Batchelor B
2. Current liquid volume in 25 yrJ24 hr_ storm storage & structural freeboard
a. current liquid level according to marker 18.0 inches
b. designed 25 yrJ24 hr. storm & structural freeboard I 19.0 inches
c. line b - line a (inches in red zone) = 1.0 inches
d, top of dike surface area according to design
(area at below structural freeboard elevation) 101 7611fiz
e. line c112 x line d x 7.48 gallonslft3 63431 gallons
3. Projected volume of waste liquid produced during draw down period
f. temporary storage period according to structural design 180 days
g- volume of waste produced according to structural design 116315 ft3
h. current herd # 1100 certified herd #1 1100
actual waste produced = current herd # x line g = 116315 f1l3
certified herd #
i. volume of wash water according to structural design
j. excess rainfall over evaporation according to design
k. (lines h + i + j) x 7.48 x 30 days/line f=
4. Total PAN to be land applied during draw down period
I. current waste analysis dated 1 04/2812003
m. ((lines e + k)11000) x line I =
REPEAT SECTION I FOR EACH WASTE STRUCTURE ON SITE.
(Click on the next Structure tab shown below)
PoA (30 Day) 2121100
1�ft3
616�'1 �4iift3
221818 gallons
1.80 Ibs11000 gal.
513A lbs. PAN

May 28 03 04:20P MURPHY-BROWN 9102933138 P.5
11. TOTAL POUNDS OF PAN STORED WITHIN STRUCTURAL FREEBOARD ANDIOR 25 YRJ24
HR. STORM STORAGE ELEVATIONS IN ALL WASTE STRUCTURES FOR FACILITY
1. Structure ID: Batchelor A
line m =
436.8 lb PAN
2. Structure ID: Batchelor B
line m =
513.4 lb PAN
3. Structure ID:
line m =
lb PAN
4. Structure ID:
line m =
lb PAN
5. Structure ID:
line m =
-lb PAN
6. Structure ID:
line m =
lb PAN
n. lines 1 +2+3+4+5+6= 950.3 lb PAN
Ill. TOTAL PAN BALANCE REMAINING FOR AVAILABLE CROPS DURING 30 DAY DRAW DOW?
PERIOD_ DO NOT LIST FIELDS TO W141CH PANT CANNOT RE APPLIED DURING THIS 3n DAY PERIOD
o. tract #
p. field #
q. crop
r. acres
s. remaining IRR
2 PAN balance
(lb/acre)
TOTAL PAN
BALANCE FOR
FIELD (lbs.)
column r x s
u. application wiidowl
1
2 H8
Bermuda Hay
1.85
197.90
366.1
Mar -Oct
2 H9
Bermuda Hay
1.85
208.04
384.9
Mar -Oct
2 H10
Bermuda Hay
1.91
214.02
408.8
Mar -Oct
2 H11
Bermuda Hay
1.69
224.20
378.9
Mar -Oct
'State current crop ending application date or next crop application beginning date for available
receiving crops during 30 day draw down period.
v. Total PAN available for all fields (sum of column t) = 1538.7 lb. PAN
IV. FACILITY'S PoA OVERALL PAN BALANCE
w. Total PAN to be land applied (line In from section 11) = 950.3 lb. PAN
PoA (30 Day) 2/21100

May 28 03 04:20p MURPHY-BROWN
9102933136
p.6
Y. Crop's remaining PAN balance (line v from section 111)
Y. Overall PAN balance (w - x)
1538.7 lb. PAN
-588 lb. PAN
Line y must show as a deficit. If line y does not show as a deficit, list course of action here including pump and
haul, depopulation, herd reduction, etc. For pump & haul and herd reduction options, recalculate new PAN
ibased on new information. If new fields are to be included as an option for lowering lagoon level, add these
fields to the PAN balance table and recalculate the overall PAN balance. If animal waste is to be hauled to
another permitted facility, provide information regarding the herd population and lagoon freeboard levels at the
reoeivina facility-
Irrigation onto existing spray fields will continue as weather and field conditions permit. Additional land is
available for pumping if needed.
PoA (30 Day) 2/21100

S Mar 21 03 03:29p MURPHY-BROWN 9102933138 p.2
31- S_4 3
PLAN OF ACTION(Poa) FOR HIGH FREEBOARD AT ANIMAL FACILITIES
Facility Number. 31-563 County: Ouplin
Facility Name: Batchelor Sow
Certified Operator Name: �� V�� Operator Number: as (0 ID-0
1. Current liquid level(s) in inches as measured from the current liquid level in the lagoon to the
lowest point on the top of the dam for lagoons without spillways; and from the current liquid level
in the lagoon to the boLom of the spillway for lagoons w7t;n spillways.
Lagoon 1 Lagoon 2 Lagoon 3 Lagoon 4 Lagoon 5
Lagoon blame/lD: D28
Spillway(Y or N): N
Lavel(inches): 18
2. Check all applicable items
Liquid level is within the designed structural freeboard elevations of one or more structures.
Five and 30 day Plans of Action are attached. Hyaraulic and agronomic balances are
within acceptable ranges.
X Liquid level is within the 25 year 24 hour storm elevations for one or more structures. A
30 day Plan of Action is attached. Agronomic balance is within acceptable range.
Waste is to be pumped and hauled to off site locaticns. Bolume and PAN content of waste
to be pumped and hauled is reflected in section III tables. Included nrithfn this plan is a list
of the proposed suss with related facility numbers, number of acres and receiving crop
Information. Contact and secure approval from ;he DWQ prior to transfer of waste to a sire
not covered in the facility's CAWh9P.
Operation.wili be partially or fully depopulated.
*Attach a complete schedule with corresponding animal units and dates frc depopulaUzin
*if animals are to be moved to another permitted facility, provide facility number, lagoon
freebeare levels and herd population for the receiving facility
3. Earliest possible date to begin land application of waste:
I hereby certify that I have reviewed 1he Information listed above and included within the
attached Plan of Action, and to the best of my knowledge and ability, the Information Is
accurate and correct.
�>d Jr Np I d / n. Phone: ql o •.2 �9 ',37,3I
Facili OwrerlManager (print)
_ Date: 3 ` 21 ` 03
Facility Owne,ONIIanager (signature)
. ...:<:' '.:'; . �'.,..... t-_. - ..,. , i'. � ,ice=. 't' !:x.:. : •. a ..,._ �' 3: 'c,e .. p � y:;.
je

Mar 21 03 03:30p
MURPHY-BROWN
9102933139
P.3
PLAN OF ACTION (PoA) FOR HIGH FREEBOARD AT ANIMAL FACILITIE.
30 DAY DRAW DOWN PERIOD
I. TOTAL PAN TO BE LAND APPLIED PER WASTE STRUCTURE
1. Structure Name/Identifier (0): Batchelor D2&
2. Current liquid volume in 25 yr.124 hr. storm storage & structural freeboard
a. current liquid level according to marker 18.Q inches
b. designed 25 yr./24 hr. storm & structural freeboard i 9.0 inches
c. line b - line a (inches in rec zone) = 1.0 inches
d. top of dike surface area -according to design
(area at below structural freeboard elevaton) 93799 ftT
e. line c/12 x line d x Z.48 gallons/W 53468 gallons
3. Projected volume of waste liquid produced during draw down period
L temporary storage period according to structural design 180 days
g. volume of waste produced according to structural design 23263U fts
h_ current herd # 2Q35 certified herd # 2035
actual waste produced = current herd # x line q = 232&iC ft3
certified nerd #
i. volume of wash water according to structural design
j. excess rainfall over evaporation according to design
k. (lines h + i + j) x 7.48 x 30 says/line i=
4. Total PAN to be land applied during draw Gown period
I. current waste analysis dated 03101/200-4
rn. ((lines e + k)/1000) x line I =
REPEAT SECTION I FOR EACH WASTE STRUCTURE ON SITE.
(Click on the next Structure tab shown below)
PoA (30 Day) 2121100
ft3
i ft3
443636 gallons
1.8-0 ibs/1000 gal.
903.8 lbs. PAN

,Mar 21 03 03:30p MURPHY-BROWN 9102333138 p.4
11. TOTAL POUNDS OF PAN STORED WITHIN STRUCTURAL FREEBOARD ANWOR 25 YR.124
HR. STORM STORAGE ELEVATIONS IN ALL WASTE STRUCTURES FOR FACILIT't
1. Structure ID: Ba:chelcr D28
line rn =
903.8 Ib PAN
2_ Structure ID:
line m =
Ib PAN
3. Structure ID:
line m =
Ib PAN
4. Structure ID:
line m =
Ib PAN
5. Structure ID:
line m =
Ib PAN
6. Structure ID:
line'rn =
Ib PAN
n.lines 1+2+3+4+5+6= 903.8lbPAN
III. TOTAL PAN BALANCE REMAINING FOR AVAILABLE CROPS DURING 30 DAY DRAW DOWt
PERIOD. DO NOT LIST FIELDS TO WHICH PAN CANNOT BE APPLIED DURING THIS 30 DAY PERIOD
o. tract # P. field ## q. crop r. acres s. remaining IRR L TOTAL PAN u. applicaiian window'
2 PAN balance BALANCE FOR
EIoiacre) FIELD (tbs.)
column r x s
i 2 Bermuda Hay T 30i 287.501 2098.$ 1viar-Oct
v _ - , w.. --1. ....... .y ..l.F..................., - ...," ­r - ...vy........y -......v �... ....... .......
receiving crops during 30 day draw do+nrr. period.
v. Total PAN available for all fields (sum of column t) = 2098.8 lb. PAN
1V. FACILITY'S PoA OVERALL PAN BALANCE
w. Total PAN to be land applied (line n from section II) = 903.8 lb. PAN
PoA (30 Day) 2121 /00

Mar 21 03 03:30p MURPHY-BROWN 9102933138 p.5 1
x. Crop's remaining PAN balance (line v from section lll) =
y. Overall PAN balance (w - x)
2098.8 lb_ PAN
-1195 lip. PAN
Line y must show as a deficit. If line y does not show as a deficit, list course of action here including pump and
haul, depopWation, herd reduction, etc. For pump & haul and herd reduction options, recalculate new PAN
based on rew information, If new fields are to be included as an option for lowering lagoon level, add these
fields to the PAN balance table and recalculate the overall PAN balance_ If animal waste is to be hauled to
another permitted facility, provide information regarding the herd population and lagoon freeboard levels at the
Irrigation onto existing spray fields will continue as weather and field conditions permit. Additional land is �
iavai!abie for pumping if needed. I
PoA (30 Day) 2/21/00

M
r=1
Ln
IM
S
�Ln
LJ"1
ru
IO
C3
m
!O
I�
irq
a
7 M
F`IVL
- -
USE
Postage
WNW Fee
Return AeceEpt Fee
(Endorsement Required)
Posbnark
Elam
Resfrfeted Delivery Fee
(Endorsement Aequired)
Total Postage & Fees $
Street, Apt No.; ' �''�
arPO8oYN0. 1
(�
y� , ! v }/�' `�i
�1j
�S_ti:�.-1
e, `A1 .-
.._..
. I, I .�,.:11:. _ --

0
VArF9
a
I
Murphy Family Farms
Mr. David Nordin
785 Hwy. 24/50
Warsaw, NC 28398
Dear Mr. Nordin:
Michael F. Easley, Governor
William G, Ross Jr., Secretary
North Carolina Department of Environment and Natural Resources
December 15, 2003
Subject: Rescission of Notice of Violation /
Issuance of Notice of Deficiency
Batchelor Sow Farm
Facility # 31-563
Duplin County
Alan W. Klimek, P.E. Director
Division of Water Quality
Thank you for your submittal of the information requested in our letter dated April 15, 2003. We
greatly appreciate the effort that you made in compiling this information and sending it to our
Wilmington Regional Office by the date required. We also appreciate the fact that you reported
the problem with high freeboard to our staff as required by your permit and worked with our
staff to manage the problem once it occurred.
Upon review and consideration of the information submitted, the Wilmington Regional Office has
determined that no further compliance/enforcement actions will be taken by the Division for
these high freeboards. �
Also, based on your actions to properly operate your facility, the Division of Water Quality
hereby rescinds the Notice of Violation that was issued to you on April 15, 2003 and replaces it
with this Notice of Deficiency.
In the future, please continue to evaluate ways to maintain freeboard levels in the required range.
These methods include, but are not limited to, water conservation practices, adding additional
application sites, updating your cropping systems, adding additional and/or more flexible
application equipment, and maintaining the lagoon levels at the lowest allowable and appropriate
levels throughout the year. Our staff looks forward to continuing to work with you and your
Technical Specialist to evaluate and implement any needed changes to your system.
.i
A A
CE)ENR
Customer Service: Mailing Address: Telephone: [phone] Location:
1 800 623-7748 1617 Mail Service Center Fax: [phone] N. Salisbury St
Raleigh, NC 27699-1617 State Courier #52-01-01 Raleigh, INC 27699-1617
An Equal Opportunity 1 Affirmative Action Employer
50% recycled 1 10% post -consumer paper
http :11 h 2 o. e n r. state. n c. us

Inadequate Freeboard
David Nordin
December 15, 2003
Page 2
Thank you again for your cooperation. If you have any questions, please do not hesitate to
contact the staff of our Wilmington Regional Office at 910-395-3900.
Sincerely,
Rick Shiver
Water Quality Regional Supervisor
CC: Kraig Westerbeek, Murphy -Brown, LLC
Billy Houston, Duplin County Soil and Water Conservation District
Patrick Fussell, DSWC
Wilmington Files 31-563
Non -Discharge Compliance and Enforcement Unit
Central Files
C4

14--2UUJ 'CriU Ub: bb V11 HUU - LANANUCKIENT
MurphyBrownL.
Kenansville Division
785 Hwy. 24/50
Warsaw, NC 28398
[phone]
To;'t �-qw't'
li_-
�(�j 1" nIton
Date:
U1WH1283 P. U1/18
Land & Nutrient Management
From: David Nordin, Manager+-'
Tony& Cavenaugh, Assistant
R. O. Bxitt, Specialist
J. D. Suggs, Specialist
Don LaCoe, Auditor
Fax: l - 9P , 3,50_aoby-
Number of pages, including cover sheet: Lj`

AT 14-2003 THU 05:57 PH BOC - LAND&NUTRIENT 9102961283
P. 06/ 18
PLAN OF ACTION(Poa) FOR HIGH FREEBOARD AT ANIMAL FACILITIES
Facility Number: 31-563 County: Duplln
Facility Name: Batchelor Sow
Certified Operator Name' &V565 LZ Operator Number: a5G26
1. Current liquid level(s) in inches as measured from the current liquid level in the lagoon to the
lowest point on the top of the dam for lagoons without spillways; and from the current liquid level
in the lagoon to the bottom of the spillway for lagoons with spillways.
Lagoon 1 Lagoon 2 lagoon 3 Lagoon 4 Lagoon 5
Lagoon Name/ID' A B
Spiliway(Y or N): N N
Level(inches): 19 16
2. Check all applicable items
Liquid level is within the designed structural freeboard elevations of one or more structures.
Five and 30 day Plans of Action are attached. Hydraulic and agronomic balances are
within acceptable ranges.
X Liquid level is within the 25 year 24 hour storm elevations for one or more structures. A
30 day Plan of Action is attached, Agronomic balance is within acceptable range_
Waste Is to be pumped and hauled to off site locations. Bolume and PAN content of waste
to be pumped and hauled is reflected in section III tables. Included within this plan Is a list
of the proposed sites with related facility numbers, number of acres and receiving crop
information, Contact and secure approval from the DWO prior to transfer of waste to a site
not covered In the facllity's CAWMP.
Operation will be partially or fully depopulated.
*Attach a complete schedule with corresponding animal units and dates fro depopulation
*if animals are to be moved to another permitted facility, provide facility number, lagoon
freeboard levels and herd population for the receiving facility
3. Earliest possible date to begin land application of waste:
I hereby certify that I have reviewed the information listed above and Included within the
attached Plan of Action, and to the best of my knowledge and ability, the information is
accurate and correct.
! ac ;Qls.y/�71t� LLe 1}}2wd ����1� Phone: 9/0 -.2�6 -3731
acility Owner/Manager (print)
- 13 L4e- Date:
Facility Owner/Manager (signature)

914-2003 THU 06:58 PH BOC - LAND&NUTRIENT 9102961283 P. 07/18
PLAN OF ACTION (PoA) FOR HIGH FREEBOARD AT ANIMAL FACILITIE:
30 DAY DRAW DOWN PERIOD
1. TOTAL PAN TO BE LAND APPLIED PER WASTE STRUCTURE
1. Structure Name/Identifier (ID): Batchelor B
2. Current liquid volume in 25 y►.124 hr_ storm storage 6 structural freeboard
a. current liquid level according to marker 16.0 inches
b. designed 25 yr.124 hr. storm & structural freeboard 19.0 inches
c. line b - line a (inches in red zone) = 3.0 inches
d. top of dike surface area according to design
(area at below structural freeboard elevation) 101761 ft�
e, line ell x line d x 7.48 gallonse 190293 gallons
3. Projected volume of waste liquid produced during draw down period
f_ temporary storage period according to structural design 180 days
g. volume of waste produced according to structural design 116315 f?
h. current herd # 1100 certified herd # 1100
actual waste produced = current herd # x line g = 116315 ft3
certified herd #
i, volume of wash water according to structural design
j, excess rainfall over evaporation according to design
k. (lines h + i + j) x 7.48 x 30 daysiline f=
4. Total PAN to be land applied during draw down period
I. current waste analysis dated 1 07/21/2023
m. ((lines e + k}11000) x line I =
REPEAT SECTION I FOR EACH WASTE STRUCTURE ON SITE.
(Click on the next Structure talc shown below)
_Jfe
61614 W
221818 gallons
1.50 Ibs/1000 gal.
616.2 lbs. PAN
PoA (30 Day) 2/21/00

AT-14;2003 THU 05:58 PM BOC - LAND&NUTRIENT 9102961283
P. 08/18
Ill. TOTAL POUNDS OF PAN STORED WITHIN STRUCTURAL FREEBOARD ANDIOR 25 YR.124
HR. STORM STORAGE ELEVATIONS IN ALL WASTE STRUCTURES FOR FACILITY
1.
Structure ID: Batchelor A
line m =
lb PAN
2.
Structure ID- Batchelor B
line rn = 618.2 ib PAN
3.
Structure ID:
line m =
lb PAN
4.
Structure ID: _
line m =
lb PAN
5.
Structure ID:
line m =
lb PAN
6.
Structure ID:
line m =
lb PAN
n. lines 1 +2+3+4+3+6= 618.2 lb PAN
III. TOTAL PAN BALANCE REMAINING FOR AVAILABLE CROPS DURING 30 DAY DRAW DOW#
PERIOD_ DO NOT LIST FIEI_nS TO WHtCIN PAN ceNNOT RF APPLIFn HARING TWIS'An nev PFRInn
o. tract #
p. field #
q. crop
r. acres
e. remaining IRR
2 PAN balance
(lblacre)
t TOTAL PAN
BALANCE FOR
FIELD (lbs,)
column r x s
u. application window'
1
2 H8
Bermuda Hay
1.85
' 88.69
164.1
Mar -Oct
2 H9
Bermuda Hay
1.85
60.92
112.7
Mar -Oct
2 H10
Bermuda Ha
1.91
82,13
156,9
Mar -Oct
2 H11
Bermuda Hay
1.69
117.39
198.4
Mar -Oct
'State current crop ending application date or next crop application beginning date for available
receiving crops during 30 day draw down period.
v. Total PAN available for all fields (sum of column t) = 632.0 lb. PAN
IV. FACILITY'S PoA OVERALL PAN BALANCE
w. Total PAN to be land applied (line n from section Il) = 618.2 Ib. PAN
PoA (30 Day) 2-121100

1-14'2003 THU 05:58 PH BOO - LAND&NUTRIENT 9102961283 P. 09/18
x. Crop's remaining PAN balance (line v from section 111) = 632.0 lb. PAN
Y. Overall PAN balance (w - x) = -14 Ib. PAN
Line y must show as a deficit. If line y does not show as a deficit, list course of action here including pump and
haul, depopulation, herd reduction, etc. For pump & haul and herd reduction options, recalculate new PAN
based on new information. if new fields are to be included as an option for lowering lagoon level, add these
fields to the PAN balance table and recalculate the overall PAN balance. If animal waste is to be hauled to
another permitted facility, provide information regarding the herd population and lagoon freeboard levels at the
Irrigation onto existing spray fields will continue as weather and field conditions permit. Additional land is
available for pumping if needed.
PoA (30 Day) 2/21/00

- c
Ll 0[0-3
PLAN OF ACTION(Poa) FOR HIGH FREEBOARD AT ANIMAL FACILITIES
Facility Number: 31-563 County: Duplin
Facility Name: Batchelor Sow
Certified Operator Name: , Jb --s Operator Number: �? �T rti � C]_
1. Current liquid level(s) in inches as measured from the current liquid level in the lagoon to the
lowest point on the top of the dam for lagoons without spillways; and from the current liquid level
in the lagoon to the bottom of the spillway for lagoons with spillways.
Lagoon 1 Lagoon 2 Lagoon 3 Lagoon 4 Lagoon 5
Lagoon Name/ID: A B
Spillway(Y or N): N N
Level(inches): 17 17
2. Check all applicable items
Liquid level is within the designed structural freeboard elevations of one or more structures.
Five and 30 day Plans of Action are attached. Hydraulic and agronomic balances are
within acceptable ranges.
X Liquid level is within the 25 year 24 hour storm elevations for one or more structures. A
30 day Plan of Action is attached. Agronomic balance is within acceptable range.
Waste is to be pumped and hauled to off site locations. Bolume and PAN content of waste
to be pumped and hauled is reflected in section III tables. Included within this plan is a list
of the proposed sites with related facility numbers, number of acres and receiving crop
information. Contact and secure approval from the DWQ prior to transfer of waste to a site
not covered in the facility's CAWMP.
Operation will be partially or fully depopulated.
Attach a complete schedule with corresponding animal units and dates fro depopulation
*if animals are to be moved to another permitted facility, provide facility number, lagoon
freeboard levels and herd population for the receiving facility
3. Earliest possible date to begin land application of waste:
I hereby certify that I have reviewed the information listed above and Included within the
attached Plan of Action, and to the best of my knowledge and ability, the information is
accurate and correct.
�uf)4 &,udg ,C/-C 4IAOid /,4r,� Phone: 1%16-2gl-373j
Facility Owner/Manager (print)
" e Date: 7411, 0
Facility Own r/Manager (signature)

PLAN OF ACTION (PoA) FOR HIGH FREEBOARD AT ANIMAL FACILITIEE
30 DAY DRAW DOWN PERIOD
I. TOTAL PAN TO BE LAND APPLIED PER WASTE STRUCTURE
1. Structure Name/Identifier (ID): I Batchelor A
2. Current liquid volume in 25 yr.124 hr. storm storage & structural freeboard
a. current liquid level according to marker 17.0 inches
b. designed 25 yr.124 hr. storm & structural freeboard 19.0 inches
c. line b - line a (inches in red zone) = 2.0 inches
d. top of dike surface area according to design
(area at below structural freeboard elevation) 93799 ftZ
e. line c112 x line d x 7.48 gallonslft3 116936 gallons
3. Projected volume of waste liquid produced during draw down period
f. temporary storage period according to structural design 180 days
g. volume of waste produced according to structural design 232630 ft3
h. current herd # 935 certified herd # 935
actual waste produced = current herd # x line g =
certified herd #
i. volume of wash water according to structural design
j. excess rainfall over evaporation according to design
k. (lines h + i + j) x 7.48 x 30 days/line f=
4. Total PAN to be land applied during draw down period
I. current waste analysis dated 06/24/2003
m. ((lines e + k)11000) x line I =
REPEAT SECTION I FOR EACH WASTE STRUCTURE ON SITE.
(Click on the next Structure tab shown below)
232630 ft3
f �1ft3
�12322�8Jft3
443636 gallons
1.30 Ibs11000 gal.
728.7 lbs. PAN
PoA (30 Day) 2/21/00

PLAN OF ACTION (PoA) FOR HIGH FREEBOARD AT ANIMAL FACILITIES
30 DAY DRAW DOWN PERIOD
I. TOTAL PAN TO BE LAND APPLIED PER WASTE STRUCTURE
1. Structure Na me/identifier (I D): I Batchelor
2. Current liquid volume in 25 yr./24 hr. storm storage & structural freeboard
a. current liquid level according to marker
b. designed 25 yr.124 hr. storm & structural freeboard
c. line b - line a (inches in red zone) =
d. top of dike surface area according to design
(area at below structural freeboard elevation)
e. line c/12 x line d x 7.48 gallons/ft3
3. Projected volume of waste liquid produced during draw down period
f. temporary storage period according to structural design
17.0 inches
19.0 inches
2.0 inches
101761 1ft2
126862 gallons
180 days
g. volume of waste produced according to structural design 116315 ft 3
h. current herd # 1100 certified herd # 1100
actual waste produced = current herd # x line g = 116315 ft3
certified herd #
i. volume of wash water according to structural design
j. excess rainfall over evaporation according to design
k. (lines h + i + j) x 7.48 x 30 daystline f=
4. Total PAN to be land applied during draw down period
I. current waste analysis dated 1 06/24/2003
m. ((lines e + k)/1000) x line I =
REPEAT SECTION I FOR EACH WASTE STRUCTURE ON SITE.
(Click on the next Structure tab shown below)
©ft3
61614 ft3
221818 gallons
1.80 Ibs/1000 gal.
627.6 Ibs. PAN
PoA (30 Day) 2/21/00

II. TOTAL POUNDS OF PAN STORED WITHIN STRUCTURAL FREEBOARD AND/OR 25 YR./24
HR. STORM STORAGE ELEVATIONS IN ALL WASTE STRUCTURES FOR FACILITY
1.
Structure ID: Batchelor A
line m =
728.7 lb PAN
2.
Structure ID: Batchelor B
line m =
627.6 lb PAN
3.
Structure ID:
line m =
lb PAN
4.
Structure ID:
line m =
lb PAN
5.
Structure ID:
line m =
lb PAN
6,
Structure ID:
line m =
lb PAN
n. lines 1 +2+3+4+5+6= 1356.4 lb PAN
Ill. TOTAL PAN BALANCE REMAINING FOR AVAILABLE CROPS DURING 30 DAY DRAW DOW?
PERIOD_ DO NOT LIST FIELDS TO WHICH PAN CANNOT BE APPLIED DURING THIS 30 DAY PERIOD
o. tract #
p. field #
q. crop
r. acres
s. remaining IRR
2 PAN balance
(lb/acre)
t. TOTAL PAN
BALANCE FOR
FIELD (Ibs.)
column r x s
u. application window'
1
2 H8
Bermuda_Nay
1.85
144.16
266.7
Mar -Oct
2 H9
Bermuda Hay
1.85
150.84
279.1
Mar -Oct
2 H10
Bermuda Hay
1.91
170.52
325.7
Mar -Oct
2 H11
Bermuda Hay
1.691
182.97
309.2
Mar -Oct
1 H1
Corn
2.92
46.21
134.9
Mar -Jul
1 H2
Corn
2.71
41.09
111.4
Mar -Jul
'State current crop ending application date or next crop application beginning date for available
receiving crops during 30 day draw down period.
v. Total PAN available for all fields (sum of column t) = 1426.9 lb. PAN
IV. FACILITY'S PoA OVERALL PAN BALANCE
w. Total PAN to be land applied (line In from section II) = 1356.4 lb. PAN
PoA (30 Day) 2121/00

x. Crop's remaining PAN balance (line v from section III) = 1426.9 lb. PAN
y. Overall PAN balance (w - x) _ -71 lb. PAN
Line y must show as a deficit. If line y does not show as a deficit, list course of action here including pump and
haul, depopulation, herd reduction, etc. For pump & haul and herd reduction options, recalculate new PAN
based on new information. If new fields are to be included as an option for lowering lagoon level, add these
fields to the PAN balance table and recalculate the overall PAN balance. If animal waste is to be hauled to
another permitted facility, provide information regarding the herd population and lagoon freeboard levels at the
Irrigation onto existing spray fields will continue as weather and field conditions permit. Additional land is
available for pumping if needed.
PoA (30 Day) 2121/00

A` URPHY
FAMILY FARMS
Division of Water Quality
Wilmington Regional Office
127 Cardinal Drive Ext.
Wilmington, NC 28405
Dean Hunkele
Dear Mr Hunkele,
As required by your agencies freeboard guidance document dated 1/31/2000, this letter is
intended to outline a plan of action aimed at lowering the lagoon level at the Batchlor
Farm (lagoon 1) to a level adequate for both structural stability and a 25 year, 24 hour
storm.
We have approximately 50 acres of small grain overseed available for irrigation at this
time. PAN balances for the fields to be used show that we still have 25 % of our 100 lb.
target available. When field conditions improve, we will begin making frequent, light
applications to the small grain. On this farm, we could transfer water to the newer lagoon
if needed, however, that would bring it closer to the 19" mark than we would like.
Therefore, if the current weather conditions continue, we should be able to lower the
lagoon level to below minimum requirements within 30 days through irrigation.
If there are any questions or concerns, please call me at [phone] ext. 4556 or John
Bizic at ext. 4589.
urphy Family Farms
2/l/00
Post Office Box 759, Rose Hill, North Carolina 28458, [phone], FAX [phone]

APR-07-00 01:48 PM P.09
7.
�j Z rflc, d 3► -�3". 3/ - 563
MARILYN Land & Nutrient Management Data History Inquiry 4/07/00
LNMHSTINQ Murphy Family Farms 13:57:41
Farm# _ 2016 Lagoon#: Report Date: 10/01/99 Div#:
SDI Ref#: Options: 5-More Details
Farm Lag Report
Opt No: No: Date Div#
2016 1 10/02/99 10
2016 1 10/09/99 10
2016 1 10/16/99 10
2016 1 10/23/99 10
2016 1 10/30/99 10
2016 1 11/06/99 10
2016 1 11/13/99 10
2016 1 11/20/99 10
2016 1 11/27/99 10
2016 1 12/04/99 10
2016 1 12/11/99 10
2016 1 12/18/99 10
SDI Free Board
Consumption
Raintall Contract
Ref#
Level
Per Head
Water
Inches Gal Pump
174541
17
6.11
85060
1.10
175231
20
6.83
94980
.50
175904
16
7.10
98160
4.20
176653
24
6.89
95190
.45
177335
23
7.12
98210
178019
19
6.89
97280
178712
17
8.32
118800
179414
16
10.68
149490
180137
18
7.44
105850
180797
19
6.21
88390
181448
23
5.90
84210
182117
24
9.05
129560
F3RExit F5-Refresh
(C)Copyright 1998-99.Anchor Applications & Solutions, Inc .All Rights Reserved

APR-07-00 01:40 PM P_10
MARILYN Land & Nutrient Management Data History inquiry 4/07/00
LNMHSTINQ Murphy Family Farms 13;57;41
Farm# _ 2016 Lagoon#: Report Date: 10/01/99 Div#:
SDI Ref#: _ Options: S=More Details
Farm
Lag
Report
SDI Free Board
Consumption
Rainfall Contract
Opt No:
No:
Date
Div#
Ref#
Level
Per Head
water Inches_ Gal Pump
2016
1
12/25/99
10
182844
22
10.14
144580
2016
1
1/01/00
10
183516
23
9.78
139140
2016
1
1/08/00
10
184211
23
5.45
78610
2016
1
1/15/00
10
164913
23
4.22
60410
2016
1
1/22/00
10
185609
19
4.50
64630
2016
1
1/29/00
10
186271
15
4.40
63790
2016
1
2/05/00
10
186956
18
4:67
66860
2016
1
2/12/00
10
187684
18
4.83
69090
2016
1
2/19/00
10
188339
18
4.90
70100
2016
1
2/26/00
10
189054
23
4.57
65300
2016
1
3/04/00
10
189723
21
5.23
75000
2016
1
3/11/00
10
190478
23
4.68
67560
F3=Exit F5=Refresh
(C)Copyright 1998-99.Anchor Applications & Solutions,Inc.All Rights Reserved

APR-07-00 01:48 PM P.11
MARILYN Land & _Nutrient Management Data Histo ywlnquiry 4/0'i/uu
LNMHSTINQ Murphy Family Farms 13:57:41
Fa rmO 2016 Lagoon#: Report Date: 10/01/99 Div#:
SDI Ref#: Options: 5-More Details
Farm
Lag
Report
SDI Free Board
Rainfall Contract
Opt No:
No:
Date
Div#
Ref#
Level
_Consumption
Per Head
Water
Inches Gal Pum
2016
1
3/18/00
10
190977
28
4.81
69600
2016
1
3/25/00
10
191871
25
4.99
72670
2016
1
4/01/00
10
192510
20
5.14
74380
2016
2
10/02/99
10
174541
20
6.11
85060
1.10
2016
2
10/09/99
10
175231
26
6.83
94980
.50
2016
2
10/16/99
10
175904
21
7.10
98160
4.20
2016
2
10/23/99
10
176653
21
6.89
95190
.45
2016
2
10/30/99
10
177335
23
7.12
99210
2016
2
11/06/99
10
178019
23
6.89
97280
2016
2
11/13/99
10
178712
25
8.32
118800
2016
2
11/20/99
10
179414
26
10.68
149490
2016
2
11/27/99
10
180137
26
7.44
105850
F3=Exit F5=Refresh
(C)Copyright 1998-99.Anchor Applications & Solutions, Inc, All Rights Reserved
20

b
m
0
IL`
cn
oQ
'M
c�
M1
�. i°
CDN
y w
00
°gm3�°��
fl.
too 4. n
�:
COW
` C
0.
C
z OC L3
L 6.
O
m
rL
L66 L aunt '008£ 1uuo:1 Sd
■ Complete items 1, 2, and 3. Also complete
A. Received by Tease PrintClearfy)
S. Date of Delivery
` item 4 if Restricted Delivery is desired.
■ Print your name and address on the reverse
so that we can return the card to you,
cure
❑
■ Attach this card to the back of the mailpiece,
IG.sign
Agent
4z"It
or on the front if space permits.
❑ Addressee
D. is delivery add different from item 1? ❑ Yes
if YES, enter delivery address below: ❑ No
1. Article Addressed to:
Mr. Kraig Westerbeek
Murphy Family Farms
3. Servi e
PO Box 759
Rose Hill, NC 28458
6G.rtified Mail ❑ Express Mall
❑ Registered ❑ Retum Receipt for Merchandise
❑ Insured Mail ❑ C.O.D.
4. Restricted Delivery? (Extra Fee) ❑ yes
2. icfe Num r �Copyhm service ! eQ
� I
J?�r �,
Ps Form 3811, July 1999 Domestic Return Receipt 102595-99-M-1789 J

r0,
State of North Carolina
Department of Environment
and Natural Resources
•
Wilmington Regional Office
James B. Hunt, Jr., Governor
NCDENR
Bill Holman, Secretary
Kerr T. Stevens, Director
ENVIRONMENT ANP NATUF2AL RESOURCES
Division of Water Quality
April 13, 2000
CERTIFIED MAIL_ # P 328 829 378
RETURN RECEIPT REQUESTED
Mr. Kraig Westerbeek
Murphy Family Farms
Batchelor Farm
PO Box 759
Rose Hill, NC 28458
Subject: Notice of Deficiency
Batchelor Farm
Facility Number. 31-563
Duplin County
Dear Mr. Westerbeek:
This is to notify Murphy Family Farms, who holds a non -discharge permit for an animal waste
disposal system pursuant to 15A NCAC 2H .0200 and North Carolina G.S. 143.215.1, of a deficiency of
Animal Waste Permit AWS 310563.
On January 26, 2000, it was reported by your facility that the freeboard level in lagoon was not in
compliance with levels of 17 inches. Therefore, this notice is being sent in accordance with the Division of
Water Quality's (DWQ) high freeboard policy.
You should have submitted a Plan of Action to obtain compliance within a stipulated time frame
depending on your lagoon level. The following procedure is to be implemented whenever the freeboard
level in any lagoon is not in compliance:
1. Notify DWQ Wilmington Regional Office within 24 hours
2. Submit appropriate Plan of Action documents obtained from DWQ, Soil & Water district
office, or Service Company
3._ Provide DWQ Regional Office with weekly updates
4. Notify DWQ Regional Office when compliance is attained.
It is highly recommended that this facility: 1) explores and initiates measures to conserve fresh
water usage and 2) make any necessary changes to the waste management system and/or waste
utilization plan to help maintain appropriate lagoon levels.
127 North Cardinal Dr., Wilminerton, North Carolina 28405 Telephone [phone] FAX [phone]
An Equal Opportunity Affirmative Action.Employer 50%, recycled/10% post -consumer paper

f�
Mr. Kraig Westerbeek
April 13, 2000
Page 2
The Division of Water Quality will take no further action for this reported incident at this time.
DWQ may pursue additional actions including civil penalties, injunctive relief, or revocation of your
Animal Waste Permit AWS 310563 for future occurrences..
If you have any questions concerning this matter please do not hesitate to contact either Mr.
Stonewall Mathis or myself at [phone].
Sincerely,
Dean Hunkele
Environmental Specialist
cc: Harold Jones, Duplin County Soil and Water Conservation
DWQ Non -Discharge Operations Branch File
DWQ Wilmington Animal Files 31-563
S:1WQSIANIMALS1DUPLIN12000131-563 Batchelor NOD.wpd

Information contained in this database is from non agency sources and is considered unconfirmed
Farm Emergency Call Form
Farm Number
©` ®
Date
Farm Name
a C e Or Sow Farm
Time
Owner Frist Name
Call Number
Owner Last Name
[Murphy Family Farms
p Reportng 0 Complaint
Source
O n Bizic
Breached
0 Yes 0 O
Freeboard Level 1 117
Depopulated
10 Yes 0 O
Freeboard Level 2
Overflowed
10 Yes 0 O
Freeboard Level 3
LQ Issue
0Yes 0 O
Freeboard Level 4
PermissionToPump
10 Yes 0 O
Freeboard Level 5
Inudated
0 Yes 0 O
Flooded
0 Yes 0 O
Freeboard Level 6
Pumping Equipment
0 Yes 0 O
comments
0neWak
..........
1212Q0.0�...................................................................................................................................................:................... ...............................
...............................................................................................I................................................................................................................................
...................................................................................................................................................................................................................................
...................................................................................................................................................................................................................................
...................................................................................................................................................................................................................................
...................................................................................................................................................................................................................................
............................ ................. ..................... .................................................... .................................................................................... I........................
........................ ................................................................................................................................................................... I ....................................... .
...................................................................................................................................................................................................................................
...................................................................................................................................................................................................................................
...................................................................................................................................................................................................................................
...................................................................................................................................................................................................................................
...................................................................................................................................................................................................................................

ANIMAL WASTE MANAGEMENT PLAN CERTIFICATION FOR NEW O CEXPAnNDEDEEDLOTS
Please return the completed form to the Division of Environmental Management at the address
form. � r'
Name of farm (Please print): Batchelor Farm
Address: P. O. Box 759 Rose Hill, NC 28458
Phone No.: I County: Duplin
Farm location: Latitude and Longitude: 350 00' 5U' I Tr 55' 06" (required). Also, please attach a copy of a county road
map with location identified. Type of operation (swine, layer, dairy, etc.): Swine
Design capacity (number of animals): 2035 Sows Farrow to Wean
Average size of operation (12 month population avg.): 2035 Sows
Average acreage needed for land application of waste (acres): 35.7
Technical Specialist Certification
As a technical specialist designated by the North Carolina Soil and Water Conservation Commission pursuant to
15A NCAC 6F .0005. I certify that the new or expanded animal waste management system as installed for the farm named
above has an animal waste management plan that meets the design, construction, operation and maintenance standards
and specifications of the Division of Environmental Management and the USDA -Soil Conservation Service and/or the North
Carolina Soil and Water Conservation pursuant to 15A NCAC 2H .0217 and 15A NCAC 6F .0001-.0005. The foilowing
elements and their corresponding minimum criteria have been verified by me or other designated technical specialists and
are included in the plan as applicable: minimum separations (buffers); liners or equivalent for lagoons or waste storage
ponds; waste storage capacity; adequate quantity and amount of land for waste utilization (or use of third party); access or
ownership of proper waste application equipment; schedule for timing of applications; application rates; loading rates; and
the control of the discharge of pollutants from stormwater runoff events less severe than the 25-year, 24hour storm.
Name of Technical Specialist (Please print): M_ Kevin Weston
Affiliation: Murphy Family -Farms, Inc
Address (Agency): P. 0.. Box 759 Rose Hill, NC 28458 _ Phone No. 910 289-2111
Signature: Date:
Owner/Manager Agreement
I (we) understand the operation and maintenance procedures established in the approved animal waste management plan
for the farm named above and will implement these procedures. I (we) know that any additional expansion to the existing
design capacity of the waste treatment and storage system or construction of new facilities will require a new certification to
be submitted to the Division of Environmental Management before the new animals are stocked. I (we) also understand
that there must be no discharge of animal waste from this system to surface waters of the state either through a man-
made conveyance or through runoff from a storm event less severe than the 25-year, 24hour storm_ The approved plan
will be filed at the farm and at the office of the local Soil and Water Conservation District.
Name of L
Signature:
Name of Manager, if different from owner (Please Print):
Signature: Date.
Note: A change in land ownership requires notification or a new certification (if the approved plan is changed) to be
submitted to the Division of Environmental Management within 60 days of a title transfer.
— -- - — -- DEM USE ONLY: ACNEVO _P(t5©RQ.3
3r-563

MU R P H Y
F A M I L Y F A R M S
August 8,1995
Department of Environment, Health and Natural Resources
Division of Environmental Management
Water Quality Section_Pt�annirgBranch 3
P. O. Box 29535
Raliegh, NC 27626--0535
Attn: Mr. Steve Tedder, Chief
RE: Batchelor Farm - Swine Facility Certification
Duplin County, NC
Dear Mr. Tedder:
Enclosed is the certification form for the above referenced swine farm. By this letter, the Owner
certifies that the following crops will be planted or sprigged within 180 days of the stocking
date of the farm. Stocking Date: 9f�/9f
_Barley ✓Rye
_✓Bermuda Grass (Graze/Hay/Pasture) Small Grain (Graze/Hay)
Corn (Grain/Silage) __Sorghum
Cotton _Wheat
_Fescue (Graze/Hay/Pasture) Oats
�Other(Explain)
The lagoon effluent will be applied to the crops listed above by
Center Pivot Irrigation (Installed/Not Installed)
_Solid Set Irrigation (installed/Not Installed)
_Traveling Gun/Reel Irrigation (Owned/Not Owned)
Third Party Applicator
✓Other (Explain) /"Ipva 15cE G •�
Name of Technical Specialist•. M. Kevin Weston
Signature: % Date: 9///9S
Name of Land Owner: Murphy Family Farms
Signatu
cc: Murphy Family Farms
Kim Patram, Murphy Family Farms Construction Department
Post Office Box 759, Rose Hill, North Carolina 28458, [phone], FAX [phone]

State of North Carolina
- - -Department of Environment,
Health and.Natural Resources
Division of Environmental Management
James B. Hunt, Jr., Governor
Jonathan B. Howes, Secretary
A. Preston Howard, Jr., P.E., Director
March 23, 1994
Calvin Oates
Rt 1 Box 129-D
Kenansville NC 28349
Dear Mr. Oates:
This is to inform you that your completed registration form required by the recently
modified nondischarge rule has been received by the Division of Environmental Management
(DEM), Water Quality Section.
On December 10, 1992 the Environmental Management Commission adopted a water
quality rule which governs animal waste management systems. The goal of the rule is for animal
operations to be managed such that animal waste is not discharged to surface waters of the state.
The rule allows animal waste systems to be "deemed permitted" if certain minimum criteria are
met (15A NCAC 2H .0217). By submitting this registration you have met one of the criteria for
being deemed permitted.
. We would like to remind you that existing feedlots which meet the size thresholds listed
in the rule, and any new or expanded feedlots constructed between February 1, 1993 and
December 31, 1993 must submit a signed certification form (copy enclosed) to DEM by
DecemJjtr 311297 New or expanded feedlots constructed after December 31, 1993 must
obtain signed certification before animals are stocked on the farm. Certification of an
approved animal waste management plan can be obtained after the Soil and Water Conservation
Commission adopts rules later this year. -
We appreciate you providing us with this information. If you have any question about
the new nondischarge rule, please contact David Harding at [phone].
Sincerely,
_% a� -
Steve Tedder, Chief
Water Quality Section -
P.O. Box 29535, Rdeigh, Borth Carolina 27626-0535 Telephone [phone] FAX [phone]
An Equal opportunity Affirmative Action Employer 50% recycled/ 1 Q% past -consumer paper

<l
Operator:BATCHLOR SOW FARM County: DUPLIN ' / Date: 10/12/94
Distance to nearest residence (other tha.n owner): 0.0 feet
1. AVERAGE LIVE WEIGHT (ALW) / /
0 sows (farrow to finish) x 1417 lbs. — 0 lbs.
A:ih
ows (farrow to feeder) x 522 lbs. = 0 lbs
ead 1 x 135 lbs. = 0 lbs
ows farrow to wean) x 433 lbs. — 476300 lbs
ead {wean to fee er x 30 lbs. = 0 lbs
Describe other 0
Total Average Live Weight = 476300 lbs
2. MINIMUM REQUIRED TREATMENT VOLUME OF LAGOON
r
Volume = 476300 lbs. ALW x Treatment Volume(CF)/lb. ALW
Treatment Volume(CF)/lb. ALW = 1 CF/lb. ALW
Volume = 476300 cubic feet
3. STORAGE VOLUME'FOR SLUDGE ACCUMULATION
Volume = 0.0 cubic feet
4. TOTAL DESIGNED VOLUME
Inside top length (feet)--------------------- 325.0
Inside top width (feet)---------------------- 325.0
Top of dike elevation (feet)----------------- 102.7
Bottom of lagoon elevation (feet)------------ 92.7
Freeboard ( feet) ----------------------------- 1.0
Side slopes (inside lagoon)------------------ 3.0 : 1
Total design volume using prismoidal formula
SS/END1 SS/END2 SS/SIDE1 SS/SIDE2 LENGTH WIDTH DEPTH
3.0 3.•0 3.0 3.0 319.0 319.0 9.0
AREA OF TOP
LENGTH * WIDTH =
319.0 319.0
AREA OF BOTTOM
LENGTH * WIDTH =
265.0 265.0
AREA OF MIDSECTION
LENGTH * WIDTH * 4
292.0 292.0
101761 (AREA OF TOP)
70225 (AREA OF BOTTOM)
34.1056 (AREA OF MIDSECTION * 4)
CU. FT. _ [AREA TOP + (4*AR EA•,,MIDSECT.ION) +. AREA,:,BOTTOM] * DEPTH
�, : • 101761 . 0 t• 341056. 0,,:. 70225.0
'Y'4�;��: �=a?i =s''• ��.�»%_ki'!� ,ct. .: t�:a '�- �.r ..<. .^;w t" , r�r'1:�'.'�.. ,�:

5D. Volume of 25 year — 24 hour storm
Volume = 7.0 inches / 12 inches per foot * DA
Volume = 61614.6 cubic feet
TOTAL REQUIRED TEMPORARY STORAGE
5A.
116316
cubic
feet
5B.
0
cubic
feet
5c.
61615
cubic
feet
5D.
61615
cubic
feet
TOTAL
239545
cubic
feet
6. SUMMARY
Temporary storage period====================)
180
days
Rainfall in excess of evaporation===========)
7.0
inches
25 year — 24 hour rainfall==================)
7.0
inches
Freeboard===================================)
1.0
feet
Side slopes_________________________________)
3.0
: 1
Inside top length===========================)
325.0
feet
Inside top
325.0
feet
Top of dike elevation=======================)
102.7
feet
Bottom of lagoon elevation==================)
92.7
feet
Total required volume=======================)
715845
cu.
ft.
Actual design volume========================)
769563
cu.
ft.
Seasonal high watertable elevation (SHWT)===)
95.0
feet
__ __ __ ________ _ __
Stop pumping elev._______________________�__)
98.8
feet
Must be ) or = to the SHWT e1ev.==========>
95.0
feet
Must be ) or = to min. req. treatment el.=)
98.7
feet
Required minimum treatment volume===========)
476300
cu.
ft.
Volume at stop pumping elevation============)
490260
cu.
ft.
cr...Art- n11mninn elev._________________________)
100.8
feet
Must be at bottom of freeboard & 25 yr. raintall
Actual volume less 25 ter.— 24 hr. rainfall==>
707948
cu.
ft.
Volume at start pumping elevation===========)
679520
cu.
ft.
Required volume to be pumped================)
177930
cu.
ft.
Actual volume planned to be pumped=======___)
189260
cu.
ft.
Min: thickness of soil liner when required==)
1.5
feet
7. DESIGNED BY: APPROVED BY:p<tale'(
DATE: /r/�/z�93� DATE: l9/-Zf
NOTE-JS.EE ATTACHED WASTE UTILIZATION PLAN -
w ry ''x•'. s
COMMENTS:—

5. TEMPORARY STORAGE REQUIRED
DRAINAGE AREA:
Lagoon (top of dike)
Length * Width =
325.0 325.0 105625.0 square fleet
Buildings (roof and lot water)
0.0 square feet Describe this area.
` TOTAL DA 105625.0 square feet
Design temporary storage period to be 180 days.
5A. Volume of waste produced
Feces & urine production in gal./d,ay per 135 lb. ALW 1.37
1
Volume = 476300 lbs. ALW/135 lbs. ALW * 1.37 gal/day 180 days
Volume = 870041 gals. or 116315.7 cubic feet
56. Volume of wash water
This is the amount of fresh water used for washing floors or volume
of fresh water used for a flush system. Flush systems that recircu
the lagoon water are accounted for in 5A.
Volume = 0.0 gallons/day * 180 days storage/7.48 gal -
per
Volume = 0.0 cubic feet
5C. Volume of --11 cvrpcG of evaporation
use p,:, ,.od of time when rainfall exceeds evaporation by largest am
180 days excess rainfall - 7.0 inches
Volume = 7.0 in * DA / 12 inches per foot
Volume = 61614.6 cubic feet
r
"IIH:h'�vj, i5 :•) ^t � _�•_yC _.icy 1•
• � V•4;.. T4 �h�� �v �.. � Iti.Y/

REGISTRATION FORM FOR ANIMAL FEEDLOT OPERATIOAS
Department of Environment, Health and Natural ReO. rces "93
Division of Environmental Management
Water Quality Section a 3� �9p&"•t�Ty
If the animal waste management system for your feedlot ott� 'ra,on--
is designed to serve more than or equal to 100 head of ca,'..ti
t"
horses, 250 swine, 1,000 sheep, or'30,000 birds that are served
by a liquid waste system, then this form must be filled out and
mailed by December 31, 1993 pursuant to 15A NCAC 2H.0217 (c) in
order to be deemed permitted by DEM. Please print clearly.
Farm Name: Batchelor Sow Farm
Route 1 Box 129-D
Kenansville, NC 28349
Duplin County '919-296-0107(F)/296-1690(H)
Owner(s) Name:
Manager(s) Name:
Lessee Name:
—nO
Farm Location (Be as
specific aspossible.: road
names,, j
�4.0
direction, milepost,
etc.) : From
Kenansville, take NC
11/903 N 3:ty) c'
4' ✓ r n
miles;
turn Lt. at Wesley Chapel onto SR-)
1516
(Wesley Chapel Rd);
go 0.7 mile,
farm
sign post on Lt.; follow
dirt farm
road
for 1.0 mile to farm.
(TT=26 min.;
TD=20
miles.)
Latitude/Longitude if known: QBSP # 16-133-20-25
Design capacity of animal waste management system (Number and
type of confined animal (s) : 1000 SO(,cW :±s:fJEi-
Average animal population on the farm (Number and type,of
animal (s) raised) : > a 1 0 Sn w5 Bcirrvcv - tQ - '{--Itf 5
Year Production Began: ASCS Tract No.: 3a 90 q3o
Type of- Waste. Management System Used: _ay)GLe''O6C ICtQoQn c.u•- `l
Sol tS s e t rr c; ct`f'� nn sY stee
.Acres Available for Land Application of Waste: �7-k O
Owner(s) Signature(s)c Date: C`
_. Date:.��3
(Jane Mitchell, Serviceman)
3l -5-1o3

Plan Amendment to Include S&WCC Chronic Rainfall Practices and Standards through March 31, 2000
i if this facility can comply with its existing permit and CAWMP it must do so.
2 Temporaty Addition of New Sprayfields (') (Check appropiate boxes,)
-- 71 A acres of cropland. List crop op We used:
0 B. acres of hardwood woodland @ 100 lbs PAN 1 acre added.
0 C. acres of pine woodland added @ 60 Ibs PAN I acre added.
.. -
3 Summer Perennial Grass (Check appropriate box.)
A. ' Application window extended for 46.03 acres of perennial grass until first killing frost
0 B. An additional 50 lbs of PAN applied to acres of perennial grass prior to killing frost
4 PAN application increased for Small Grains & Winter Grasses to be harvested. (Check appropriate box.)
0 A. PAN application increased up to 200 lbs per acre for 46.03 acres of small grains or winter grasses to be harvested.
0 B. PAN application increased up to 150 lbs per acre for acres of overseeded summer perennial included in 3.B.
5 Waste Analysis (Check appropriate box.)
[] A Prior to December 1st, 1999 the calculation of PAN will be based on a 35% reduction of the last analysis taken
prior to the first 25 year 24 hour storm event. (Current waste analysis must be used after Dec. 1 st.)
0 B. Use current waste analysis to determine PAN.
ti
6 Required - Maximum Nitrogen Utilization Measures for Small Grains and 1Ninter Grasses.
A Use of higher seeding rates,
B. Timely harvest of forage to increase yield, and
C. Irrigation during periods of warmer weather.
7 Required - Irrigation Management Techniques to Reduce Runoff and Ponding Potential,
A. Making frequent, right irrigation apprications, and
B_ Not irrigation immediately before predicted rainfall.
8 The owner I manager is required to manage the movement of animals to and from the facility to minimize environmental
impacts, ensure compliance with the facility's permit and amended CAWMP, and avoid discharge to surface waters.
9 Authorization to use the additional practices included in the amendment expires if a facility discharges to surface waters.
Any discharge is a violation and may result in an enforcement action.
10 The owner / operator is required to keep records of all waste applications.
11 This revision must include a map or sketch of new land application areas.
Facility Number 31 - 563
Batchelor
Facility Name
Murphy amil Farms Krai Westerbeek
Facility Own 1 anage e R Technical S ialis me ITI
Facility Owner /Mana�qert­ure i ethnical. pecialist Signature
Date t 1111l99 Date 11/11/99
This document must be filed at the SWCD offict; and be attached to the facilities CAWMP
and be available for inspection at the facility
(') New temporary spraylields must meat applicable buffer and setback requirements. Waste must not be applied to wetlands.

State of North Carolina
Department of Environment
and Natural Resources
Division of Water Quality
James B. Hunt, Jr., Governor
Bill Holman, Secretary
Kerr T. Stevens, Director
Murphy Family Farms
Batchelor Sow Farm
PO Box 759
Rose Hill NC 28458
Dear Murphy Family Farms:
IoAILF!W'A
4 � •
NCDENR
NORTH CAROLINA DEPARTMENT OF
ENVIRONMENT AND NATURAL RESOURCES
December 30, 1999
Subject: Fertilizer Application Recordkeeping
Animal Waste Management System
Facility Number 31-563
Duplin County
This letter is being sent to clarify the recordkeeping requirement for Plant Available Nitrogen (PAN)
application on fields that are part of your Certified Animal Waste Management Plan.
In order to show that the agronomic loading rates for the crops being grown are not being exceeded, you
must keep records of all sources of nitrogen that are being added to these sites. This would include nitrogen
from all types of animal waste as well as municipal and industrial sludges/residuals, and commercial fertilizers.
Beginning January 1, 2000, all nitrogen sources applied to land receiving animal waste are required to
be kept on the appropriate recordkeeping forms (i.e. IRR1, IRR2, DRY], DRY2, DRYS, SLUR I, SLUR2,
SLD1, and SLD2) and maintained in the facility records for review. The Division of Water Quality (DWQ)
compliance inspectors and Division of Soil and Water operation reviewers will review all recordkeeping during
routine inspections. Facilities not documenting all sources of nitrogen application will be subject to an
appropriate enforcement action.
Please be advised that nothing in this letter should be taken as removing from you the responsibility or
liability for failure to comply with any State Rule, State Statute, Local County Ordinance, or permitting
requirement.
If you have any questions regarding this letter, please do not hesitate to contact Ms. Sonya Avant of the
DWQ staff at [phone] ext. 571.
Sincerel ,
Z
Kerr T. Stevens, Director
Division of Water Quality
cc: Wilmington Regional Office
Duplin County Soil and Water Conservation District
Facility File .
1617 Mail Service Center, Raleigh, North Carolina 27699-1617 Telephone [phone] Fax [phone]
An Equal Opportunity Affirmative Action Employer 50% recycled/10% post -consumer paper

Revised April 20, 1999
JUSTIFICATION & DOCUMENTATION FOR MANDATORY WA DETERMINATION
Facility Number e-�` -
Farm Name: S
, w
On -Site Representative:- r_S\ L
Inspector/Reviewer's Name:
Date of site visit:
Date of most recent WUP: ( 1
Operation is flagged for a wettable
acre determination due to failure of
Part 11 eligibility item(s) Ft F2 F3' F4
JOperation not required to secure WA
determination at this ti a based on
exemption E1 E2 CEJ E4
Operation pended for wettable acre
.-
determinationbased on P1 P2 P3
Annual farm PAN deficit: pounds
Irrigation System(s) -circle #hard -hose traveler; 2. center:pivi t system; 3. linear -move system;
4. stationary sprinkler system w/permanent pipe; b. stationary sprinkler system wlportable pipe;
6. stationary gun system wlpermanent pipe; 7. stationary gun system w/portable pipe
PART 1. WA Determination Exemptions (Eligibility failure, Part II, overrides Part I exemption.)
E1 Adequate irrigation design, .including map depicting wettable acres, is complete
and signed by an I or PE.
E2 Adequate D, and .D203 irrigation operating parameter sheets, including' -map
depicting wettable acres, is. complete and signed by an I or PE.
E3 Adequate D, irrigation operating parameter sheet, including map depicting
wettable acres, is complete and signed by a WUP.
E4 75% rule exemption as verified in Part Ill. (NOTE:75 % exemption cannot be
applied to farms that fail the eligibility checklist in Part 11. Complete eligibility
checklist, Part 11-.F1 F2 F3, before completing computational table in Part 111).
PART 11. 75% Rule -Eligibility -Checklist and Documentation of WA Determination
Requirements. WA Determ_ ination .required tbecause-operation fails :one of.the eligibility - -- - _ -
requirements listed -below:
_ F1 Lack.ofacreagewhichTesulteddn:over-pplicationmf-wastewater-(PAN) on:spray-
fleld(s) according-tofarm'sdast-twoyearspf:rmgation-xecopds.
F2 Unclear,: -illegible,- -or lack ofinformation/map.
F3 Obvious -field —limitations -(numerous:ditches,failurefo:deduct:required ------
bufferlsetbackacreage;mr2b%':of#otalacreageadentitiedln-LAWMP::includes _ -
small, -irregularly -shaped fields =-fields :less than75acresfort-avelersmrlessfhan
2 acres for.-stationarysprinklers).
F4 WA determination required because CAWMP credits feld(s)'s acreage -in excess -
of 75% of the respective field's total acreage as noted in table in Part 111.

Revised April 20, 1999
Facility Number -
Part III. Field by Field Determination of
75% Exemption
Rule for WA Determination
TRACT
NUMBER
FIELD
NUMBER',2
TYPE OF
IRRIGATION
SYSTEM
TOTAL
ACRES
CAWMP
ACRES
FIELD
%
COMMENTS3
-
i
I
i
FIELD NUMBER'- hydrant, pull, zone, or:point numbers may be used in place of field numbers depending on CAWMP
and type of irrigation - system- If pulls, etc. cross -more -than one field, inspector/reviewer will have to combine fields to
calculate 75% field by field determination for exemption; -otherwise operation will be subject to WA determination.
FIELD NUMBER' - must be clearly delineated'driiriap.---- --
COMMENTS' 'back-up fields with CAWMP acreage:exceeding75% of its total -acres and having received less than 50%
of its annual PAN as -documented in the farm's-previous -two years' (1997 & 1998) of irrigation 7ecords, cannot serve -as -the
sole basisfor-requiringa WA Determination:hack-up:fieldsrnust-be-noted in the -commentzecfion-and must be accessible
by irrigation system.
Part IV. Pending WA Determinations -
P1
Plan -lacks:foliowing information:
P2 Plan -revision -may:satisfy?5% rule based on adequate overall PAN deficit -and by
adjusiing-all field -acreage--to -below 75% use°rate
P3 Other (ie/in process of installing new irrigation system):

JUL -1 71998
MURPHY
F AM I L Y F A R M S
July 15, 1998
NCDENR - DWQ
127 North Cardinal Dr.
Wilmington, N.C. 28405
Subject: Notice of Deficiency at Batchelor F 31-563
Dear Wrenn:
Murphy Family Farm's staff Technical Specialist Kevin Weston revised the Nutrient
Utilization Plan (NUP) for Batchelor on June 4, 1998, but had not yet left a copy on the
farm because he was awaiting the results of some in-house surveying.
I am enclosing a copy of the updated NUP that. includes all current spray fields. All
spray records will coincide with this plan's stipulations.
If you have any questions, please call John Bizic at 910-289-6439.
Sincerely,
John Bizi
Land & Nutrient Manager
JB/mt
GAJB\V;MN.DOC
attachment
CC.' Harold Jones
Sandra Weitzel
Garth Boyd
Robert L. Matthews

State of North Carolina
Department of Environment
and Natural Resources
Wilmington Regional Office
James B. Hunt, Jr., Governor
Wayne McDevitt, Secretary
Division of Water Quality
July 6, 1998
Certified Mail # Z 312 648 152
Return Recgi"equested
Mr. John Bizic .
Murphy Family Farms
Batchelor Sow Farm
PO Box 759
Rose HUI, North Carolina 28458
AT.: '
NCDEiTR
NORTH CARoum^ DEFARiMENT or
ENVIRONMENT ANo N,aLnAL RESOURCES
Subject: SECOND NOTICE OF DEFICIENCY
Batchelor Sow Farm
Facility Number: 31-563
Duplin County
Dear Mr. Bizic :
On June 30, 1998, staff from the Wilmington Regional Office of the Division of Water
Quality inspected you animal operation and the lagoon(s) serving this operation. It was observed
that waste had been applied to fields not listed in the Waste Utilization Plan (WUP). Based on an
August 26, 1997 inspection by DWQ staff, a prior Notice of Deficiency was issued for applying
waste to fields that were not part of your WUP
Applying waste to fields not in your WUP is a violation of your Certified Animal Waste
Management Plan (CAWMP), and subsequent infractions may result in a Notice of Violation and
include a civil penalty. All fields on which waste is to be applied must be listed in the CAWMP.
Waste application to the fields not in the WUP should be discontinued until the situation can be
corrected. In addition, the correct PAN loading rate for the small grain overseed should be used
when calculating the nitrogen balances in the spray records. We suggest that you contact your
service company, local NRCS or Soil and Water District office for any assistance they may be
able to provide to correct the situation.
To remain a deemed permitted facility, you must notify this office in writing within seven
(7) days of the receipt of this notice, what actions will be taken to comply with your waste
management plan. Failure to do so may result in the facility losing it's deemed permitted status,
requiring it to obtain an individual non discharge permit_
127 North Cardinal Dr., Wilmington, North Carolina 28405 Telephone [phone] FAX [phone]
An Equal Opportunity Affirmative Action Employer 50% recycled/10% post -consumer paper

Mr. Bizic
July 6, 1998
Page 2.
Please be aware it is a violation of North Carolina General Statutes to discharge wastewater
to the surface waters of the State without a permit. The Department of Environment, Health and
Natural Resources has the authority to levy a civil penalty of not more than $10,000 per day per
violation.
When the required corrective actions are complete, please notify this office in writing at
the address below. If you have any questions concerning this matter, please call David Holsinger
or Brian Wrenn at 910-395-3900.
Sincerely,
Brian L. Wrenn
Environmental Specialist
cc: Harold Jones, County Soil and Water Conservation
Sandra Weitzel, NC Division of Soil and Water Conservation
Dr. Garth Boyd, Murphy Family Farms
Operations Branch
Wilnvngton Files
S. IWQSIBRLSNWWEF981DUPLIM31-563-2.DEF

. e �
-:-: .. n-.v:....... .. ....:....,
Producer: ML1RPHj F,&mmy FAxMf - 8ATGHP-LnM- F-i4�M
Location: Iei. i 16x 12,) -a eF_,Wl'l5VILLE. , NC z8.7C/7 SR ►s/G
Te'lennone: (4,o) z 9to - bra 7
Type Operation: FAP.Z&w - WEAN
N gab er of Animals: ze, 3 S
(Desigzz Capacity)
Toe waste from your anianal facility must be land applied at a specified rate to prevent
po ��udon of surface. and/or m-oundwater. T"ne plant nuzdents in the Animd wale shoaid
be used to reduce the amoum of commercial femlizer requixed for the crops in the fields -
whezt the waste is to be anpHed- This waste utilization plan uses nitrosen as the Em�g
n-L ent_ Waste should be analyzed before each application cycle. Annul sou tests are
,=o-a eucourazed so that ail olant nutrients can be balanced for reaiis�c acids of the
croo _o be =own.
Seve, al factors are i=onaat in b=lementma your waste utili=tioa plan in orderZo
r-- - . ze the fertilize. value or the waste and to ensure that it is applied k an
en,rir o=entaIiy sate rnan-er. Always apply waste based on the needs of thhe .—.op to be
and the nutrent content of the waste. Do not apply more nitrogen. t :a the crop
can u ::ize. Sufi types are i ortant as they have differ�t infiltration rates. ?esch a
pcte=riaLs. cation exchange capacities, and available water holding capacmes_ -Normally
was-,--- shall not be applied to land eroding at heater than -4 tons per acre per near With
sp eciz% precautions, waste maybe applied to land e-:od:—,-z at up to 10 tons per acre per
Vea_- Do not apply wale on saturated soils, when it is rab:�g, or when the s,,=.- ce is
frozez- Either of these conditions may result in runoff to surface waters which is not
allowed under DEM remotions. Wind conditions should also be considered to avoid drift
anal downwind odor problems. To maximize the value of nutrients for crop production
and to reduce the potential for pollution, the waste should be applied to a °-owing crop or
applied to bare ground not more thaw 30 days prior to planting. Injecting the waste or
w-ill conserve nutreats and reduce odor proble=s.
T"ne eszimated acres needed to apply the animal waste is based on typical content
for tbi s type of facility. Acreage requirements should be based on the waste analysis
repo.,- from your waste management facility. Attached you will find information on
prone. sazztnling techniques, preparation, and transfer o£waste samples to the lab for
ar ai sis_
T'ais waste utilization plan, if carried out, meets'the requirements for cO=Eance with 15A
;tirCAC 2 H_0217 adopted by the Environmental Pylanageme-nt Commission.

Amount of Maste Produced per Year(gallons, fr�- tons_ etc.)
ZD 3 S nniTnalG � Dq(a °ol waste/animaYyear = /z 393 ( ) waste/year.
Amount of Plant Available Nitrogen (PAN) Produced Per Year
za3s animals X 4�1 lbs. PANL/min= lyear = to9 9 lbs. RAN/year. (PAN from M C. Tech.
Guide Std. 633)
Applying- the above amount ofwaste is a big job. You should plan time and have
appropriate equipment to apply the waste in a tamely manner.
Mae following acreage wM be needed for waste application based on the crop to be gown
and suzface application:
T a5lz 1: ACRES OWNED BY PRODUCER
T'rac-, Field Sou Crop Lbs. N Acres Lbs. N -Month of
No. Tyme Per Ac. * Uti ized ADDlication
T i
1 r I Fe A text,,,. ("
3oe>
I ze. F1
I -.-&113
JAUPL'x - filer.
T 1
I Z I, - RA
Z» . S
f hO y
I Z99 4
iMg" -Oar.
i I I
I
I
I
1
I I I
I
i
I
f
7-1
I^ A"y F.A - A-3 I Zre IRrE wo.s
Moo
139. z y
1 3 9 z y
1,<dM
I I f
I
I
I
1
I I I
I
1
I I !
f I
1
I f I I
I
! I I
I
I
I I I I
I
f
Total 3 9. z Y I , r se. `
This N is from animal waste only. If nutrients from other sources such as cansn-.erdal
ferzzli—r are applied they must be accounted far. N mast be based on realirtit v'
e rec:anion.
NOTE- The applicator is cautioned that P and K maybe over applied while mee..ng the N
requcremcerrt . Beginning in 1996 the Coastal Zone Management Act will require far^ -.ens in
some eastern counties of North Carolina to have a nutrient j=a-nagement plan that addresses
all nu�ients. Dzis plan only addresses Nitrogen.

Table 2: ACRES WrM AGREE. ENT OR LONG TERIM LEASE
(Agreement with adjacent Iandowner anus: be at=hed)
(Required only if operator does not own
adequate Iand (see Required Soecifcation 2D
Tzact Field Soil Crop Lbs_ N Acres Lbs. N Month of
No. Type Per Ac. Utilized Application
I 1
f ! 1
_ i 1
! l !
i i y i i I
i
1 1 1 ! 1
1 ! I I 1 I
I ! I f 1 1 I
1 i I i 1 I f
f I I I f 1 f
I I I 1 I ( 1
Total i I
" See faotnote for Taole 1.
Totals from above Tables
Acres Lbs. N
Utilized
Table I 31). zY ) S4L
Table 2 f
Total 31.2 Y
Amount of N Produced is 9 TI
Surplus o Etch y
NOTE- The Waste Utilization Plan must contain provisions for periodic land
application of sludge at agronomic rates. The sludge will be nutrient rich and will
require precautionary measures to prevent over application o{nutrients or other
3

Sze arrached map showing the fields to be used for the utilisation of waste water.
Application of Waste by Irrigation
Feld Soil Type Crop Application AnDlicatian
No. Rate (In/Hr) Amount (In.)
F. 1 �3 RMa.aA
U.
Z
4w3 - F.A
o. s
1
N-r
I"F.A- Aka RYE Are:2�f
D, <f
!
C
L ABLE NCT NEEM) _ ,WAS :S NOT SF�'*iG APPi= 3Y UZ OA__o: i. Eo6V 4 A 5�.f_1R- iE = IIl.
n der :—EM FOR DRY Lrr=7OR_SiL3ILY.
You : ac city is desined:`ar/f days ofteruporary storatre and the tenmorar; storase
rmi.s be removed on the average of once every INfONTHS. In no !asmms should
the volume of waste be±Q stored in your structure exceed Elevation 44e."A.,Go#uGE
Call the local Natural Resources Conservation Service (formerly Soil Corszra:;an
ServfczJ or Soil and Ware: Conservation District office after you receive the wase
anal-,, :s report for asarzance in determinin- the amount ve; acre to apply true the proper
application rate prior to applying the waste.
Narrarr: e of operation: A,ec.o r x,,e,5 a,f ��c..r 9 of ,Qz < „� / �^ � P?.,
SNP AcR--,4afS .ORB 1XAF&4r/lit.& . %RI=1G4 Ty n.+ Rac rro.rif l-7 4XE
�r ee-P / 4&0 qO071mcs, $-// I'+E[D Z. . Avz ax At, pcoees
'► !St o✓Er�fffnEa c.r.*a �t'Y yr6F�r� Foe "•rrt,� APPc�cArr•�
4

RE-QUaFD SPECIFICATIONS
I. Am mal waste shall not reach surface waters of the sate by runoff; drift, manmade
conveyances, direct application, or direct discharge during operation or land
application. Any discharge of waste which reaches surface water is prohfaiten
2. There must be documentation is the design folder that the producer exher owns or has
an agreement for use of adequate land on which to properly apply the waste. ifthe
producer does not own adequate land to properly dispose of waste, he'she shall
provide a copy of an agreement with a landowner who is within a reasonable
proximity, allowin; him&er the use of the land for waste application It is the
7resp onsbility of the owner of the facility to secure an update of the Waste Utziintion
Plan when there is a change in the operation, increase in the number of arimal
method ofutiUmdon, or available land...
:3. ariimal waste shag be applied to meet, but not exceed, the nitrogen nee^ :`brrealistic
crop yields based on soil type, available mois=L e, his-c-orica. data, cUmadc coad;ons,
d level ofman aset`ent. unless there are re-gulations feat restrict the r_ze or
application for other au menis.
�. T--zal wale shall be appLed to Land erod n. less thau 5 tons per ac.e pet ;err.
Ur as-4e may be applied to ]and that is eroding at 5 or more tons, but less -Lh la tons
p r acre per year pro,,iag grass filter strips are ihraiie3 where runoff ? aves the fiel&
(See FOTG Standard =9: - Fu-ter Strip).
Odors can be reduced by injec-ung the waste or d��g after waste app" on. Waste
should not be applied there is danger of driE. from the irrigation te.L
6. ti�i pea animal wane is to be applied on acres subje= to flooding, it wiH be soil
incorporated on conven-donaUy tilled cropland- When applied to conservation triHed
crops or grassland, the waste may be broadcast provided the application does not
occur during a seasoa prone to floodiaQ_ (See "Weath- and Climate in Nor-.1h
CaroEua" for guidance.)
7_ Liauid waste shall be applied at rates not to exceed the soil infiltration rate sac: that
moil does not occur offste or to surface waters and in a method which does not
cause drift from the site during application- No poadiag should occur in order to
contr oI odor or flies.
$. A..; waste shall not be applied to saturated soils, dig rainfall events, or When the
st::�5ace is frozen.

REQUIRED SPECIFICATIONS
(continued)
9. Animal waste shall be applied on actively growing crops in such a manner tat the
crop is not covered with waste to a depth that would inhibit growth_ The potentialfor
salt damage from animal waste should also be considered.
10. Waste nutrients shall not be applied in fall or winter for spring planted crops on soils
w.iTh a high potential for leaching. Waste nutrient loading rates on these sorts should
be held to a minlTmim and a suitable winter cove. crop planted to take up released
nutrients. Waste shall not be applied more than 30 days prior to planting of the crop
-or forages breaiffi; dormancy.
11. Any new swore faulty shed oa or after October I,.1995 shall comply with he
following: The pure: perimeter of the land area onto which waste is applies rom a
lazoon that is a co=onmt of a swine farm shall be at least 50 feet from anv rmideatial
property boundary and mom. any perennial seam or _ever (other than as isadon
c ch or cant L,—,l waste other than swine wale from facilities ,sited or. or alter
Oc-cober 1, 1995), kaail not be applied closer than 25 feet to perennial water. (See
Standard 393 - FUt--- Sys).
I2_ A -,imai waste shall not be applied closer than 100 fee: to wells.
I- . A—ainaal waste shall not be applied closer than 200 feet of dwellings other 'tH= those
owned by the landowner.
I �Vaste shall be appL='ed in a manner not to reach of ter property and pubLc rzLtMof-
ways_
15. A=imal waste shall not be discharged into surface waters, draiaageways, or wetlands
by a discharge or by over -spraying. Animal waste may be applied to prior converted
wetlands provided they have been approved as a land application site by a "txhnical
s-c ecialist". Animal waste shall n6t be applied on was ad waterways that discharge
directly into water courses, and on other grassed waterways, waste shall be applied at
a=" onomic rates m a trinner that causes no runoff or drift from the site.
16. Domestic and industrial waste from washdowa facilities, showers, tofle:s, s;a , etc.,
shall not be discharaed into the animal waste management system

REQUIRED SPECIFICATIONS
(continued)
IS. If animal production at the facflzty is to be suspended or terminated, the owr<eris
resp onsble for obtaigm; and implementing a "closure plan" which wxi eiiuz ate the
possaoiliry of anIezal discharge, pollution and erosion
19. Waste handling structures, piping, pumps, reels, erc., should be inspeced m a regular
bass to prevent breakdowns, leaks, and spi;Ils. A regular maintenance checklia should
be kept on site.
20. Animal waste can be used in a rotation that includes vegetables and oth- coos for
direct human consu=tion. However, if aniTnn] waste is used on crops for =- ect
human consumption it should only be applied preplant with no further 3DpHczdm of
anmal waste durin, the crop season.
21. !, drhly visible marke , shah be installed to mars the top and bottom e:-z&as of the
e=orary srorasre (nu=inz volume) of all waste =earzneat lagoons. :hQ dllill
be managed to mainta-�a- the liquid level between th-a markers. A marszr will be
required to mark the -ri?dr T,r, storage volume for waste storage ponds.
22. W ase shall be tested •,�,irhbt 69 days of utriization and soil shall be tested at least
annually at crop sires where waste products are applied_ Nitrogen shz2be the rate-
detez==' g element Zinc and copper levels in the soils shall be mon Lored =d
alremative crop saes yali be used when these metals approach excessive lvie!s. pH
shall be adjusted for optimum crop production and maintained. Sots and wasze
analysis records shall be knt for five years. PoultL r dry waste application :-words
shall be maintained for three (3) years. Wasteon applicatirecords for it of e: waste
shall be maintained for &e (5) years.
23. Dead animals will bedisoosed of in a manner that meets North Caroliaa re_gnIations.

_
WASTE UTILIZATION PLAN AGREEMENT
-eva- -a of Farm: r%+iZA'\
C4vnsr1Ma= EP Ao 2e11I212
I (we) understand and w$ foRow and implement the sp ecif cation and the operation and
maintenance procedures established in the approved animal waste utMzzdmplan for the
farm named above. I (we) know that any expansion to the cxist?ag design capacity ofthe
wake treatment and storage system or construction ofnew faciimes wM req= anew
cerdacation to be submitted to the Division of Environment Management (DEM) before
the new animals are stocked. I (we) also understand that there must be no discharge of
animal waste from this system to surface wasters of the slate from a storm ri= less
S�•Je� e than the 25-year, 24-hour storm The approved plan wiH be fled ou-tee at the
5= office and at the once of the local Soil and Water Conservation. Dis'c6r, and wRl be
avaiable for review by DEM up on request -
Name of Fa
Sz�atu: e:
N a=e of
Si=arure:
Owner'. MNzpHY FAK«Y FAr-t,5
dff-e:eat from owner):
Date: Ll f-1 0 V
Date:
Nanxe of Technical Spe-.iz&,� (Please print) M. E v.M W & rro.,J
Aff dadon: oz-Lov FAM14Y Fr1RM5
Address (Acreacy): t�.0 . 76,,. 7S 9- z
Sias —. �.� Gt/ Date: ti'�9P

ANMAL, WASTE UTiLIZ -n N AGREEMENT
(Needed only ifadditional land has to be leased etc.)
L _ _ - , hereby give pernisQon to
apply anima i waste from his Waste Utilization System on acres of my Ind for
the duration of time shown below.
S understand that this waste cnmains nitrogen, phosphorous, potassium, and other trace
eleme=ts and when properly applied should not harm my land or crops. I also umdmstmd
that the use ofwaste wMred= my need for caxamearcinl fertilizer.
s'
. Adjaceut Landowner. Date;
Was= Producer.
Date:
Techical Represeatatve: Date:
SWCD Representative:
Date:
Teztz of Agreement: _ , 19 to 20.
( mmwn of Ten Years on Cast Shored Ite=)
(SeeRegwred Specifrcalfor. Mo. ?_)
9

Vole 1: ACRES OWNED BY PRODUCER
Tract Field Soil Crop Lbs. N Acres Lbs. y Monrh of
�= No_ T e Per Ac. *` Utilized An Iication
I ! I f
! ! I !
f I ! ! I I I
I ! ! I f !
! ! f I
I I I
! I I
I I I I I 1
! I 1 I I I I
! I I t I ►
I I I I f I !
I I I f ! I I
I f I I I !
I I I I ! I I
f I f I I ! I
I ! ! f ! 1 I
I I I I 1 ! 1
1 f I 1 ! 1
I ! I I ( I I
i I f ! f•
! f 1 I I
! ! I I I I
I I ! ! I
I I I I ! I I
I I I I f I
! ! 1 ! I ! I
I ! I I I f
! ! f f f I
I I f I I I
I I i I
! I I I 1
I t ! f I I !
Total
We

Batchelor Farm
IIP�S # Routing Flow Rate Acres
2016 1
167
4.23
2
167
4.23
3
167
4.23
4
167
4.23
5
167
4.23
6
167
4.23
7
167
3.43
8
167
2.64
9
167
2.64
10
167
2.73
11
167
2.42
Total Acreage pumped on
39.24
Page 1

••.'F' �,y t' `•j,l"i:i 'f,I ✓l[ irrr fir. , 1'•'1 _��•"' � J�: � ••
r1 I •,f .• •'S ,'� ' � {��f• � ' -! �rfi��<�•a�w'F.�L't-y��••� •�•Ir?�i G Y'r �� " E•�t�
_ r: t ►:' S.i.• I. Al
j� ` r�• �t � , M f� ��y�; � tom' yi: t�(�4'
,.I , �r � x�+r�1J� y rR� : C'.'Y.iY���i-� �� �, ��`� F��}�-L1J;�' ti�r�i �.x•.4=��' E;''Y�.
41
PA
rq
ZI
�T. � E:r ������,��f�,,;��r r�'�xa+r` �",�LL�����:�{?`"" r'�'r... v:y. �f �'f %J.. .r � �1`'4��;•►�.,
�] l� ' fV '� .-i•� ���'S4'S.'• i•i:w. fj iy� dr ' ,�} r� ` •�., Yt tf.
L �k �1�N`'7►: ''"� � .rlr''}'� �a•�j f�^'�: '' r5S'F *, fk ti:. �'� �� c'�•�+- �� 'tl�r�a1•
E.U' : ��: � i� i�� fj'y ��� JC �tJ � . , I [. G. �+rr� .�� L * �• r � �� '. � Il
�" f "., fl ��,•� } S . .Pun L-? ? ,
s i:a�' °� 4 jR((++�r''3 `► ` 4w' llt' "�"�' �'" rr ,�;' ;'�Jr� `4
i-� r' ^ •" ,L` w }kkk ',1 r .6 a ''` :4 r ''•�, 's'[ Poll -
LP
LL
1� � '? L 41 i 1+ •�
Ct
11
'� �,�, 1 1 1 ' �• � •t —� � ',r��}..��Ja � L
1` O�ttt• - � :i � `
k.-'�i+�.��`ir .F s��r� ! �• J .w ��!F 1 � � fix' ; : �•��`
•�, �, �• '� if �OLLL
��'�r , Imo' , 1 �� .+i•
��'J �•y r r �}
l
lit It I
Z �1•. ,r., yl••1 , , y7�� rg. 't±l t rrr i}'~d { , .i� 1 �•S t r
I, � tt��xf .iJ'�4, �, ;�! r�� .� �.��j � �� 74f.' r fi `, ������.fs�� x• � �.0 11. 1. �r� �'
.. ..�•..;.,�- •� 't+��'��!•►. 1w L{{ �,',�J,�l ,+<t ,� 1 � �,�., '� rt 3j. Y .�Ckvr r •r�. '�Z i
_ 1.)�L� .. �rtr.�l. JI,1u��Z.Ka �..5.'�'�'i.lrlt. • .,� { .�i•r�t• «ti',,$•'`•�.;R t

„,'.I'i1• ` r -; /' • l „w� , P. ,, r I rr r fir,; •'#\� �l
I�1• \ ` ,�, _.,7'''3�C..h`r D*51 ,' � u4 R r� T'�>r L 1 fir.} e :.+. - t ` � \ {sty � '
�a'� ti�..%''1'�,'•i < rd 9 r t 3 r -+'� i c •�• �-aQ .S �� ` \� jT� ,�
ly � ta” J,'? rn-•. sJi r.� r •r `r' „ p t �•� \7 �''�. a 'Z`�• �
o.,-+�, r? 'K CYO/':4 r. , • r- "� ' „1 »' I \ a . `_' ' '�rT ±r.! r".•. + ,e N.t 4 r..:r .., yl,,. � 1 •�.', t, h� -, ''�'Y � !.`:•'1� }' 't � 1 \\ ` �� \ V
�,\ 1� .•: f �^;')t'�'=,� ,I', t• y.. F.• ` t ... ,J' I �\V
r't ^ - •r f S i �'f' � �r,. i._ :•,. r � �1.; 's.jt "...L-•4' 't ♦fir •f �
�v .T _ •'r , ,— ., / ..'yn,4 r.:. f! ,i 4 is , .Kti.•. `tit 't r '.•!�r-•1�,�,`:. ,'r•f ' t � r'.Y •F �' � . �..'.• 1! j�� \ `\
•+.a ,..f� e.7.'• �:.•P ra' rM1. w.: .`•�r�h-'-r• ". _,yyn� '�' ; �- .a• ^ C \��`l' '
,i• `•' r � 11 t�:- a .-1 .s r•• s . �^ : cr •, z K;,.! `.,� / u
,c7A r , w r...�' (. ► r �' ' I + r }'' : iJ' •I .i ��":, �.� `` r / �:r• /' (� (a ��,;
r. t.°►�!�•' •?` .,rr• !R'. !,�r i. Ir. yrr A'. '� ;,.. r4'.'f f' :!r`;-.t `' R:, �/,.1 Q ,♦\ w r
r•'ll.'kr'�r.'•: } .r ti+a Sf s'. al ., �,f .v', fi 1 •-r /� �. ' .'<. i... i f
►3''•1:' y'�r , •\ I .l ^'v; .�. f� `.[. \
-r, `_r, +1:.'y '- ,, S'Iiy''r 1 :r '�. ix,*+ 1�V�f j:► r.�. �+tt •t..� +�'' •ti •, r`� Q�r��r • ; f 1' irk
r .' /• . r, . i .1 r•.r = `.•'•! I ► C, r f k .f.. S f' . r<� . ,.�..'r.•� y 1.. { ••.' `n( vl! I?�4 / r ' ' / .
} • ;i�r=, .; `' F' ' er:r r` ! • A� aM1 ,f
r
� :. IY.'" !•�'i^'�'' :Ir[:'ly:;r• :i5 i-pr• fv'�~'.F,..Y,..r,C,���: 'j' � I{/..•�•G?.l�' 'r�°� y�'�rat;,.' � � -'•1 yiL�T,�
,.I. ,�y:lr•!-.,.n ,Sr�. � ..I,j.� �••:.s ) � 'P r`i Vie'4.. ,Ii' �.-��,r •.1` ..xx `� 1
• ♦ ,. .c',tI �j r.;•v !fir':{.'• •'4•�.C� +M.: f�.r '�� _ t�:'i�Lr •w!'. 'rt [:!�..�' �. J', �, r1 �, �,3,,. 1:�, ��. ..1 :-ti, f \� -!
lrj� :� ^.;J.a'. ilG f _ a? r--'S•'.-r- iM I ,R 7' `a.�-::' "Y r`ta,}�+w 17� •�:`f 1 j,�:%jr`ir£}•'r l.•: .y;1 • ,� \l•
Z�r t • ':h.}.if= ` ',' e� it i .., t *, yt. .. tt_ , r
e+ <.t.•r � *+e / r7�.r, �•;',i.;* { { \. LNti 1�, w *,y[- ^, Y V }} +i �•y.r, � Jl•• � ..: i y•?!•,rr ��, P.
SSry� :� Fr,� !. �'.;. -i�c. , f ..,, , r. `�- �' -.* i.. _ r..,y , +,1(k-: +��, i +1�' c � r, i.\ rr y•r �.� f.� a,Sas rJ /�t�a. J �. f �/�r R
�, 1? �• i ,,t �f. F7' ,->n 'a•�L."ram �sriTdy� r'y �.:� F'• l' +v f'r' rr �' Z r . ".�I+i ,' I '!/ } � � 1 ? � / _ �% •/ "i �' �
w��.. vrL,Y4r...i�'Y' a,llj ;� '► .-'f�'' � ,•.,,•.r_ ��'.:. :�;:;- '7se.N•'+•Y`• � _S �X�lr•.::•��7�./ r � Q f� `,['�
s _ .�' ��, j,�i ., . r t _ ., ,, s • + ..et �• 's r• { K.A (f ....r, ir:�` ' a• • - :,,'i J';:' v. Y,.yt rti \
I.`:�.
-f , ,1 �'yr - .,a 1. ,. f ,. f','... a; ,• -C'.: :'!. .rw .+, • r.. �4t1'♦' wy..-r •'1 R n.
t: ..y[."'l ra:l' a"y-�' , � f r .,, .,rr , . r ,4y •,• r..:r : r Jr• r i ✓ - :? tr :.r ; r. r 1 (`•" •}l�= ,.,' j N,� / � { � 1 9 fV f, r h va ��
'[ -Y : , i r r .r r , -, + � '^ t r e.'a • Lr:. ! F•: • - •. 'r e, ' ir' - � «. �^ '�f L} jy \ \
� � .�.�(rr.+ _y. :i,.�t'!'.'ir r- �k•.' � a/�" ..� ��.;t,. }�.•:�a .4•. ..i'•••�•`j' '� �:0 .,v f( '1,� I :�
is �'1!Sy,l'i L�� + yr� .•. „r ���• ` � ,.. +� r '^^^"" ��� r � I/ a'
1:'�>��.'+�„J. rr�r ° M• ♦?'� Icy ,, i1 /.• �...•.� '.: ,a,ti'.;•�=fir: r. /,r�.� \ Iiri`,Y�,j.°% f w�, \,[�A1 1
.ter + f.r i":�f#1i� ,rl .:F,':.'. __ •ar•�.:.,.L• j`]{"'. '/,{1/, �e.�.�ryr ;�'. r•t„yt;'�.•f �i �` i• �f�' !/I'4 '•f.i '`'�':.;�'\
. fit•,')--. ,f Ya•r/r"{f - .l tiY�r x�,i. '�'fr; :J �}�} w;::''�r ,l �: •i +,1 •`.'.'_:: i�,. .' �• t 1 r � ..'I '+'
•! Call.', i fir•• �. •'"•,w. `.� :+ If., +^ ,w_ ' �'..;•', r• � r. ' , .. , "'•!`�.-.��•� :Ix ,,. '�.j ...' `• 1 �,i
•: :'��' 'i' y'''T: .•M.r '(lil .i• -�'d• •," .:.,�., .. ..�rlrtl:I - `: ... '.•-.�i+'wLl..r's:�:+f..•.r. , �tiyty-�.. r t 1',•,.. ,•t` /
.17�lr' r ar ,•'t. l;,,'�'�.¢..�1�••,it���aa' it .yy' y. ��.' aa. •r. 1 Y S �� r+!�+Ily� r �r1, s.,♦� '/.f;:
L tom ..+y {{ •"y r.. '♦ .rw^,.I'p :;i J .C-,.. �'e,'"p ',;ry `` rf.3 7 �'. •►. �.��:+C1' ■. !��+j •1 , •/{r :•r:•''f'� �.r i1..?i r1•{' ♦ : 1 �°'� !''{r• ,t • I a
'�!`�ti • � ' I''� �, �'1•rr�l: i'.�. •.�¢. Il}. �•► r � y� �, 'y.>'_ •i;., '1,. �.. -.f � �r�,•'y I'1��1 r+" r� � i y�1 �v i. % i�41ir�'r r �'1+�' '. �,V
yti. ?C� _Y; "'{ • i..• r r C.,. I �,: }F r"? + .. •�r f, .r0..: j`' �1'!� • j '( �,[, _� 1�.:/� �., .C}_a.. •.� 1. , y \ ly f
•.i e�14�4+'�����1ASt1~� S'�'J' •'r LR ,•` i� ;��: �'�`�C• r'� �• i '.�.a ��l..,�.,'�:•• ,c yi +~�-;�"J� .mar--�, � .r (\ � r,` �, r .� �/� !v 1 ��'
��[.�h �ti,r„�,„(��iiM -/+• !/. f��ra ��. k. l+ .r•,.. r;�, �..--..� rat•'t. i '. w �_ i 1'•�'M ' •4}r ''1 :• :,.1 , `��".' O � � tf ., t `..',� I !� nJ• +. � .
r"'p!1 v ,•*�' . Y; •.� r •`'1 ....- _„ .. .�_.• - .�; ,, �V rr� ,I(' =' ,' i:. 1 ' •' 1 , �� � + f" TA\ 1
`1'��i' �• �:i}tr�,:: ,? •�' f ., r M[r..;';x`:�:-� • tt.' 1�-fir: t+ ��:.•,-:'3/�'(L:�,: , .,, rr,'r .��, i j�,r I,,.V�1 '(r ::� 4`y i♦• � r•. a�, . I, :`vr. :� ` '�
;'t �„ ;n:F xjF- r•S' 'S-• r''�..r :i••.�, n ».r.•• �,. • _ .^ • ' ,:'�I.r :� a'f 'r, : '� - .' --! ♦ a
•ry'r•t, rrr�S_iv�'r i.'•'+' k.....t.._ ar,•r/ 1 R �rlY r� '�!+-a+.+ i� .*,<i rt(':'r'r �.� i;'et:•/ 1 `O , � -. .,
~F�;.11.Sr�J•eif .s!"' l:;yi: r•[ ..i i l: ts-•. tf.+ `��.-si,;f" J-•r` { 'r.i :i:• _ .,r .��/ !►fir fir:. ^'� S L•r f• •�:,�� �� ,
ra; r' "r f .•r �f ''.x:�' 't' �. r"+t ^�,;,., k.>. { : ,� K.•.•f•`�a" ' ti�-� r. _5� '.:' �fj• i - tico• f
:,,f.• r��r:/L"`/'.�f'Ws .�,t'r.. i�.w. .�tt,, i 1�• ,1,� ..w. r•rr (:T F'�.t ✓..,"ti i.'i:, y•'f',. r� Y�� '•� s(i•! fi•. �1 y7,. ��:.1. _ •r. ilf .-,4 .. �?...,y;v.
Y'7'- .%, '� �:�:: j' h;•Y J� y s. .1 i r�{f h,�7::,.,.'i I C1� �1 ��/ ' •�1 ��'��'.tf��I
ji.. "' i'iy;.►�^yi .,'3't try`• r y.,F ,, ./,��j' " !�"i.�� .r: •4h /i .•% �,7 ''^L "i11..' ••:%•°•, .•� ii '..�
IW Iyti 'Y,'Ysf..; Y P.r .. �' i :4 f f .li•.,y r f ?' J i tl .1/ ,i., .' /� f.•'• ..
�;J�`;.�' �ry�r�'• ',:e= ;A��}`,,� `�.:Cr�-:'.n•'�'�e'•,'• r •' ���"`�'��p,�,�"~r�•'��� Tii�i t� , y j'.I•rlri.li+�: r lir C_� ',',y"„'�
.'! i�,'�' C,i �^r,�rTn r'.. Shy, ... ry:r „yr � yr1. '.;'.-._'� �. r. .� �• � 4 �.�%. �• �• M ��rr�-� .r ,: r. � a � i�' `_ -�
i: �4� �.��?. *� �'•c'••5i � �.f�t 1 R � ;F � r .. �';wn , ,,,r. � �"' h.y {.f.e' r .1 �' 1 �I � 1 ''TC,. . �.��,%• :a' 'r '�' .r.-�:?.t•� ti'k i -: .. �,• .1 �.�� {,v ,liwt a:•.'�', �: `* `/ ./, �% T. -
if 1•
r^.� sic':i:ri+t ,`.!�'-•+•r2•.^':..:, ",;=irF i.''r�-' r ,�}' Ise,' T ', �.�,•I,...,^/!
��L ..t4 V f..A� w _ .•'''r.r rr:' !• a ',�'' a J "'1 t ary4 •�t II '�F.',s
4 i M ."� R•. Y} Nr `r, 4 •, "�'l' �r r J „r ' .' � !, 1 i yfi �!
a°y.,: ,+r ni{•:, r� �, � +i i;•' -!� •• � �.��^••:!!a •lt�"I.e'S".• � �'�.e
ly
.'l .'�+' _'r•�,.'.' ,.., .►,..,. -r;; f r r�...rr�,,6=.+1,?r:A•.1 TA '1 \ •` Y - j ���
{1-S.,Jr:' '' ,�_.�,• �'r,fi,.4f .+r.rr�•`;rr•J1` f %r'K "i:�.'.• w� tl�� �. rti .
r'• •` %- n..: ��,,.:• ,i1'="•' ..;, of :,�".%�•sr:1 .r! :',,r r,� �� •L°r �;'t .r/ $C:l gst `�i'Slt, �S+i !�, �'�` f ,•�' • .•�•1 e_ �_`+' ?�
'�- ,r_r •nN� f rr; 1, r !'s-1 .F .) - r �4 _:f1 :,.sf ...f•- L �..:f ?'4.'
�'.. ;, • r . z : r R r't: i if stir .. '+ 11< .!� +.r. Alf,
�.. �.,: r rr 'i•C•, .Y' �' ,: ,: '�i •'i r.,�,. n:f t .Iir�r * Y'1r rC,•�Y't .rJ, t.� ar k� ��.r• e(:�.• 1:�+' !�"`.`Z.;• _+' I ,.,
i' y•. yj
�.F�e .tl ..r ra :�; +L:,tC'• 1 1.= ,sT•:>:- �'' •i\ .�r...•.Il'; .'." rrl. XiNI''��rF "la!l;r7:,,, h-
,1•• IfJ'1_ti' �i.�,. r � !'f ".; �;t `r1 •. :i. Mf; ..+•� r•f'�.y�r...r�_ �,.��'1 ••fir ,s1•�r'` ...�".•�-+��'`4.^.,'rr:r•.Ci j:'iir � �
•k L, d 4 , .n $'t•, . 1' i. ; Y e• it ,• r - 1: ' J 1. �': � w y • � r sr�'��,�•�•
� r, i f . •'i"' '" � r• r° A .'v .Jr %+ C_ . v V• • .rX r''i1
t r• •'i r r / } �,,J � /♦,7 .'i r ♦ � '� ••+C 1111= � 1,._ h
•d i ! !. �. :rJ!r.(F Fir`' A•. �•' r. a ti �'.} f1;;, / tl�; '�r J'Ivatl�f 1
Ki'1 � r ` TM r '`ti '•.� ..' ( k • . : 1 I� n 1+. ! /,� [,� r r
�••I,`�ia•'' S•yi, .j:'���1`,�'.,� fl;•,/ . Ia, ,Jtr � 1i.• '�!'. (r`r p�' ,•�. t11 1 ' ,jf..• •, �hj v fl r ti
,� .ram •c^� •l,.� �.j,f"rwl.r'�'�;..: .. , •i�' ���'�'� •;�� .�:_at't %fir'. yk .-.`i,+ •.rr r, 'k•;i.+„ '.,': ►` ��'; .,••rl� t1.
� 1 �` � f �SIl. . t� •:� ! .,'� 'r•I'•:i.. i• +'• r. ' r,r' t a ', •i;re Gi,� ''r'ar ,•}'. { � r
s;rr �1�;,.� %• Y: 1 , '' t1. r1 't a i•'y` , .c' ' 1;,�(�,. �.a �_.� : f'' :� ti . yyy,,. �1
1 ••::; i
i r _ ' ra w , P ' 1' +r'. i .v ' ,ti�i •'•' r'..1.: .r f•
_f N•_ "_ i� *' :.'l.'•i''. 'tea'.-% •► t, i, ! �•, `�! Ir,- r..+ti 1 a '
/ r'q �. '•/� .�r•. �.,' ,.:?! + Y, 5,.1 .a'. rrr' y • y:1.1 •, T r;� fI., ,i. •�'. a :.. r 'i�:' r. �I•.:',}! x . :x • .r
4' t •,��,1r.'�,••w� r'� ''* :!',rr .1 _.�fy ,.r^ 7� i%.4':..':•'••,�' •. ,.t•.�;j•,•'.`.Ii,lr•: ••/,J �•
b; .r /•, .� j r. !ti .i },.`�.: �. M r •.+ /T�l•1.,} '•r!,.i +!y: ,n,,• ,+`!r' " i'r" �•w •I %�
Y' �, 1 � `,}• y - rt„ ,i ji,'. t'''• •. ~ �+ ,y .l .f' '� '(''k4;' C f�.� ••i. .•tv,t,'F 3••, ` li •.�� •r""`'- � • 1, •'r''' a
tillMA F",o'n Y."' "t•'.'i r�'{e ..! ::�.: ' �. •i!]rr. M •y'.• 1...'i,r,4d, ry. �, .�; rs�.(�.i. ' .., ,- '... � �
y/ S !f4%?� .��••a ;e'' .'.r i,;, •'�' t '�. •, ,�. .r :., In
^•r ,l•C.�y�'r, •!.^ '.Ft �'�_t��.y �'..!':. ''• rt t^ �'•r• .�r• J' f. ,;N` + .• ,p..1 , .'v.� .i ',.k4.' ::�. .I _ '1 �!1+�r•:f+.
:'i:•:i 'r'• `i;�'.:.- r• a • •••i'.` •.,. '(:` -%' w7vy �,.• ?� •�:1�' '��r ! • i.'..,:i.. •y': i. '-
• •• if i F!!• '- ,•' , Y' ',e ,, t• ' tr i•:�' : M• • ' i 4.5: 6'ti+, i i }l•, .. 1} ',..;{'•.
!t ,i .3.. .,r,•,/S'�/♦•• is r. [+ F.(Y X %' 1 +-r'Grk'
. .r .t . •r fr. .. �4t �.. 'l�S:r '.l ite'.ti•• '�. _ .: '~-ice}: 'atli�l+�.��:-,`..t�4:,i:ir... ,1'•i•, ,

j '��i irl5i
r
�5 e
�Mrrn� f
'• aI � '
f
�Fy
�ss'r`:r.':.'•.�.5�,.�2 ash
_shi orr�
t
r
- yti:`� tit it;
l yA1-�'itl..�
44—"'r ,t 'aj!T07,;6 '•Y .L t� , i. • J rs?. � r '
T• {v it (i' ri` 3 w ✓' _,. �y rA Li r,`r 1,* � t
a 1 r r': r , ',..> Sas k:Mr, - dl- { 5 7►�k Y'i Rl pr[5 �� tr 'y4 Sx«{' V r 7fi. 1! 4.(TE`i
a, { , L A ',j.- ,Y1 A. •r � ip; (-;�_Ltf JS'' P t
g � 'a r . r F^ t r N f '•-�;31+h' �l i .�dt } sL'ii(}��S I�.i
Jwas
'
. �ir f > ) ,r � --i .i�l 0 -' •' -f� { �r F' !R '��t`. : !�
_i Ti%t {r\ c ! � r 1 ��i�.f �Y• 'rb � 4 r.i r )'
iw rrl 1 ,1 ih 1 r X !i+ ry r" yJ ' Its�(�r�
,'� �+�' I .i: '�•ri Iy` �- � �{, C.' � i !r �{_ , t{F� �',Ip �5 r�f �t �'.rf rr4'�-�f ' 1w3� W � �- -Y {`}>•f 1Ft B�Ky . it �{`f a �.f�f."'
r" t
�a�`. � �w� tlji�p.ryw.�j�t�tr�rT`�rrw-'� t j✓ � s
.�`.,1 'k.. ��f �+ssrl w � (�. }� - r t r;Ir � •, -:`.�r r il'Y h .�
,v. ,..°��•FTlr'?`.r':.tt-.�,i='rifi?59.�Ak�.e%�tl1 t.,.�°P.- Y`....,. ',f .. ,.,4 �',I!'�.':�'M����

AUOUST 9 STREAM SAMPLING 1
Du li'P n Co. E'arms:
Bien Co. -Farms Fender Co. Farms
1.) Smith/Alderman
Dogwood Bulltail 1&2 Sow
2.) Batchelor Sow
Edge
3.) Bostic
Evergreen
4.) Coble
Lisbon 1 &2
5.) Corbett 1-4
Blueberry
6.) Dell Farm
Holmes Sites 1-11
7.) DM Sec 2
Williams
8.) DM Sec 3
FoxFire
9.) Wendy 3-8
Frenches Creek
10.) DM Sec 4
11.) Hairr 1
12.) J.T. Brinkley S arm � n
13.) Kilpatrick p
14.)M&H ` �}
15.) M&M1Rivenbark !",c7Yi�Q l� U 1 p�1� - V)qv C(,
16.) Ma9 1 &2
17.) Mag 4
18.) Merritt
19.} Nahunga
20.) Pegleg Complex V
21.} Sands Farm
22.) Brown/Ritter/Scott S 1v j
23.) Sow Spa `
24.) Vestal 1 &2 5 � 1�5 Q�r� ��- 11V
25.) Waters 1 &2
26.) Waters 3&5
27.) Wendy 1&2 \pj�� �� VQS \ �rJ� ��� �jQ,4
28.) Mellville 1 V
29.) Mellville 2 SOCY1 Q/ -S N C G A Q I
i
MURPHY FAMILY FARMS Confidential Sheetl
Page 1

Wilson/Greene Co. Farms
Elm City
Hilltop
Lindell 1&2
Sampson Co. Farms
Garland/Petty
Ingold
Sholar
Simmons
Southern Pines 1&2
Smith/Alderman
Kerr
Riverfront
Harrells
Tomahawk
CC Farm
MURPHY FAMILY FARMS Confidential Sheeti
Page 2

A-
m
N
- �
C m
� y
�
-a
1� - o
m
rq
�
V m
ri
M
m r > m
0 8 c
d
DQz0
.. i
rg g 1= a
l!jctV '408E W10d Sd
m SENDER:
rcpnp�ate flame t $rldrar 2 Far Sdd�tionaf SBrVECBe.
I also t+YM to receive the
m
■ Complete
dnaame arm adddrres4s
following services (for an
m
■Print on the reverse d fts form so that we can return this
card to you.
BXtrB fee):
.
81
■Attach this form to the frortt of the mai[piece. or on the badc it space does not
1- © Addressee's Address
m
■WrIteReftim Reaefpt Requested' an the rnafipleca below the amide number.
■The Return ReceiptM the data
to whom the delivered
2. 0 Restricted Delivery
y l
C
will sham artide was and
delivered.
Consult postmaster for fee.
o
a
3. Article Addressed to: ' -
Number
4a ArtlG;/2 1
Z u
m
WO
L%
4b. Service Type
°C
❑ Registered rtified
/�•
❑ Express Mall ©Insured
❑ Return Receipt for Merchantfise p COD
5
f
7. Date of Delive
a
o
5. Recelved By: (Print Name)
8. Addressee's Address (Only if requested
a,
and fee is paid)
m
�l
6. lgna re: (, ddressee or Agent)
o
X
PS Form 3811, December 1994
102595-97-e-ot79 Domestic Retum Receipt

A r"
State of North Carolina
Department of Environment
and Natural Resources
Wilmington Regional Office
James B. Hunt, Jr., Governor
Wayne McDevitt, Secretary
Division of Water Quality
July 6, 1998
Certified Mail # Z 312 648 152
Return Receipt Requeste
Mr. John Bizic
Murphy Family Farms
Batchelor Sow Farm
PO Box 759
Rose Hill, North Carolina 29458
1•s
Ad bd�
NCDENR
NORTH CAROLINA DEPARTMENT OF
ENVIRONMENT AND NATURAL RESOURCES
Subject: SECOND NOTICE OF DEFICIENCY
Batchelor Sow Farm
Facility Number: 31-563
Duplin County
Dear Mr. Bizic' :
On June 30, 1998, staff from the Wilmington Regional Office of the Division of Water
Quality inspected you animal operation and the lagoon(s) serving this operation. It was observed
that waste had been applied to fields not listed in the Waste Utilization Plan (WUP). Based on an
August 26, 1997 inspection by DWQ staff, a prior Notice of Deficiency was issued for applying
waste to fields that were not part of your WUP
Applying waste to fields not in your WUP is a violation of your Certified Animal Waste
Management Plan (CAWMP), and subsequent infractions may result in a Notice of Violation and
include a civil penalty. All fields on which waste is to be applied must be listed in the CAWMP.
Waste application to the fields not in the WUP should be discontinued until the situation can be
corrected. In addition, the correct PAN loading rate for the small grain overseed should be used
when calculating the nitrogen balances in the spray records. We suggest that you contact your
service company, local MRCS or Soil and Water District office for any assistance they may be
able to provide to correct the situation.
To remain a deemed permitted facility, you must notify this office in writing within seven
(7) days of the receipt of this notice, what actions will be taken to comply with your waste
management plan. Failure to do so may result in the facility losing it's deemed permitted status,
requiring it to obtain an individual non discharge permit.
127 North Cardinal Dr., Wilmington, North Carolina 28405 Telephone [phone] FAX [phone]
An Equal Opportunity Affirmative Action Employer 50% recycled/10% post -consumer paper

A
Mr. Bizic
July 6, 1995
Page 2.
Please be aware it is a violation of North Carolina General Statutes to discharge wastewater
to the surface waters of the State without a permit. The Department of Environment, Health and
Natural Resources has the authority to levy a civil penalty of not more than $10,000 per day per
violation.
When the required corrective actions are complete, please notify this office in writing at
the address below. - If you have any questions concerning this matter, please call David Holsinger
or Brian Wrenn at 910-395-3900.
Sincerely,
Brian L. Wrenn
Environmental Specialist
cc: Harold Jones, County Soil and Water Conservation
Sandra Weitzel, NC Division of Soil and Water Conservation
Dr. Garth Boyd, Murphy Family Farms
Operations Branch
Wilmington Files
S:1 WQSIBRUAWIDEF981D UPLIM3l-563-2.DEF

0 Division of Soil and Water Conservation [3 Other Agency,
Division of Water Quality
Routine O Com hint O Follow-u of DWins ection O Follow-up of DSWC review O Other
Date of InsPection �o S
Facility Number - •
Time of Inspection 0' 24 hr. (hh:mm)
© Registered JM Certified [3Applied for Permit' 13 Permitted JE3 Not Operational Date Last Operated:
Farm Name: .......... L 16t"l
ar.... ... la) ..... ......................................................... Countv:.... i................................................................
OwnerName: ............... �.........tc ..................... Phone No:...qr..:.L1--..........................................
Facility Contact: yyr qi 6jLC tLt,C.. ju..t&...... Title: ................................................... I ...... Phone No: ..
Se �ti.M.�- A .....................
Mailing Address :........�5�... :�K,........ ............................................... ........:.................. ...... ... ......................................... S%.........
OnsiteRepresentative: ......... btLkY........................ ............................... Integrator: ............ kv.q.....................................................
��� jj��n�[ u
Certified Operators„!1./..lit!:�`.:•'••t/•=--------------------- �, L �, , , ...... Operator Certification Number;..-�-�-
....................................... ..................
Location of Farm:
v ..
..---------------------••-----......-- ..........
Latitude Longitude �•' ®"
Number of Lagoons / Holding NP& I0 Subsurface Drains Present ❑ LagoonArea I0 Spray Fie td Area
y r a
❑ No Liquid Waste Management System S µ
General
1. Are there any buffers that need maintenancelimprovement? ❑ Yes E4 No
2. Is any discharge observed from any part of the operation? ❑ Yes 19 No
Discharge originated at: [I Lagoon' ❑ Spray Field [3 Other
a. If discharge is observed, was the conveyance man-made?
b. If discharge is observed, did it reach Surface Water? (if yes, notify DWQ)
c. If discharge is observed, what is the estimated flow in gal/min?
d. Does discharge bypass a lagoon system? (lf yes, notify DWQ)
3. Is there evidence of past discharge from any part of the operation?
4. Were there any adverse impacts to the waters of the State other than from a discharge?
5. Does any part of the waste management system (other than lagoons/holding ponds) require
maintenance/improvement?
5. Is facility not in compliance with any applicable setback criteria in effect at the time of design?
7. Did the facility fail to have a certified operator in responsible charge?
7/25/97
Cl Yes] No
Cl Yes] No
❑ Yes 11 No
❑ Yes No
❑ Yes (P, No
[0 Yes ❑ No
❑ Yes P No
❑ Yes � No
Continued on back

Facility Number: S t — SL 3
8. Are there lagoons or storage ponds on site which need to be properly closed?
Structures (Lagoons,11olding Ponds, Flush Pits, etc.)
9. Is storage capacity (freeboard plus storm storage) less than adequate?
Structure I' Structure 2 Structure 3 Structure 4
Identifier: l z
Freeboard(ft): ............. ..`................ .......... ............................................................................................
10, Is seepage observed from any of the structures'?
11. Is erosion, or any other threats to the integrity of any of the structures observed?
❑ Yes No
❑ Yes No
Structure 5 Structure 6
12. Do any of the structures need mainten ance/improvement'?
(If any of questions 9-12 was answered yes, and the situation poses
an immediate public health or environmental threat, notify DWQ)
13. Do any of the structures lack adequate minimum or tnaximunt liquid level markers"
Waste Application
14. Is there physical evidence of over application?
(If in excess of WMP,,`or runoff entering waters of tthe State, notify DWQ)
15. Crop type ..................•' 5:! v0. ..................._....Si.?X � ..................... ........ ..................................... .............
.
16. Do the receiving crops differ with those designated in the Animal Waste Management Plan (AW,MP)?
17. Does the facility have a lack of adequate acreage for land application?
18. Does the receiving crop need improvement?
19, Is there a lack of available waste application equipment?
20. Does facility require a follow-up visit by same agency?
21. Did Reviewer/[nspector fail to discuss review/inspection with on -site representative?
22. Does record keeping need improvement?
For Certified or Permitted Facilities Only
23. Does the facility fail to have a copy of the Animal Waste Management Plan readily available?
24. Were any additional problems noted which cause noncompliance of the Certified AWMP?
25. Were any additional problems noted which cause noncompliance of the Permit'?
......................................
❑ Yes (RNo
❑ Yes tO No
0 Yes ❑ No
0 No.violations or deficiencies were noted during this:visit.- .You4ill receive no further
correspondence about this..visit:.: • :
❑ Yes QNo
❑ Yes CO No
❑ Yes [UNo
❑ Yes 10 No
M Yes ❑ No
❑ Yes M No
to Yes Cl No
❑ Yeti 4 No
M Yes ❑ No
❑ Yes No
( Yes ❑ No
Yes ❑ No
Cotnments:(iefee to,question #): Explain any.NTS answers and/or any recommendations or any other comtments'RA��'
Use drawings ,of facility to better'explain `situations: (usc additional pages as itecessarv) �.
- A covL��-tom r�.w,� S'�"� U1-e Si.o� 2 � ui �o t ru�l �oaiC.p�c �+-ov�- �yB'+^ �Lk4lnl►� f `�'�..� �
a ��4�c e►� _s6fr, c.lAW d ; vetrS� 0 i OnS11. } 1 f
{2. l d 1 a�oor x W"'4A\S 1\G' 0 �P 0Olpd, �o,vt &,t as Oh {n� �e )ooK-s St,.j L., it°4ej�{o,hd.
"-.fi o" Spam, Vikkvd (��(S� a� ab ; ac 4-a (, Sa.- # 2 5 maul t1 ri-�Vvj,
lB. Ct)��ihve t ►� )ic, e4kbV<,k 6krmvtj4 c"- -
ph N
swbAl 4�C n. Rvn,fc_V rj l p,_ M5. (A*ts y t WJ[J be ty. � it r�. �l�o,� �.3 igti iti.�rma,�ar.
� e ti}1� eLt�r c K�b`��_ �l,oult1� [ it� 1 t` � Iniuj �P,�, ca it-�_r.s Lcwlta
�1'W41 r,niil a�Ar� Tti n-nnL d.ni. llA`.lnnr o�`Carpuv\k1m:• nn 6 4Iikrak - < � 1DS/Ac- 7/25/97 rA
Reviewer/Inspector Name OWKn
Reviewer/Inspector Signature: Date: Q

10 Routine O ComplainFollow-up of DWQ inspection 0 Follow .up of DSWC review 0 Other j
p
Facility Number
Date of inspection 1/21198
31 563
_. Time of Inspection 0900 24 hr. (hh:mm)
© Registered ® Certified 13 Applied for Permit ® Permitted 13 Not Operational I Date Last Operated:
Farm dame•. 1at�a�r.Say.kaen........................ ..................... County: D�xa............... `iRO..........
Owner Name:................... ................................ Mnr..A.fly.FatW yFar..ms......................... Phone No:
Facility Contact: Da,.Ud.i'jCgker............................................... Title: Lastd.&.NUtr..M L.T.eCh........ Phone No:...................................................
MailingAddress: P. .Box..759............................................................................................ RORC.Hill.A.0 ........................................................ Z8.4,58 .............
Onsite Representative: X&Y.1d,.GleGker........................................................................... Integrator: Mulrphyfamilyflar s.......................................
Certified Operator:Rkbard.................. ly ........ Operator Certification Number:
Location of Farm:
. r st.sxtitti.a (e..a�� zap tir atc y;Q,7S nai l.nnx.#lt.�lamt tiam.x iti .; Q3.::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::......::::::::::::: —
E
�.
Latitude 35 ' 00 ' S0 Longitude F 55 I Ob
Design Current
-
Design .Current =
Design Current
Swine Capacity Population
Poultry_ _ -Capacity
Population Cattle ` ,-
Capacity Population
ElWean to Feeder
10 Layer
❑Dairy
❑ Feeder to Finish
ID Non -Layer
❑ Non-Dairy
Farrow to Wean
2035-
Lj Farrow to Feeder
❑ Other
Farrow to Finish
=
-
Total Design Capacity
2,035
Gilts
-_.
-TotALSSLW
881,155
oars
Number of Lagoons / Holding Ponds 2 ❑ Subsurface Drains Presen# ❑ Lagoon Area ❑ Spray Field Area
❑ No Liquid Waste Management System
General
1. Are there any buffers that need maintenance/improvement? ❑ Yes ❑ No
2. Is any discharge observed from any part of the operation? ❑ Yes ❑ No
Discharge originated at: ❑ Lagoon ❑ Spray Field ❑ Other
a. If discharge is observed, was the conveyance man-made? ❑ Yes ❑ No
b. If discharge is observed, did it reach Surface Water? (If yes, notify DWQ) ❑ Yes ❑ No
c. If discharge is observed, what is the estimated flow in gal/min?
d. Does discharge bypass a lagoon system? (If yes, notify DWQ) ❑ Yes ❑ No
3. Is there evidence of past discharge from any part of the operation? ❑ Yes ❑ No
4. Were there any adverse impacts to the waters of the State other than from a discharge? ❑ Yes ❑ No
5. Does any part of the waste management system (other than lagoons/holding ponds) require ❑ Yes ❑ No
maintenance/improvement?
b. Is facility not in compliance with any applicable setback criteria in effect at the time of design? ❑ Yes ❑ No
7. Did the facility fail to have a certified operator in responsible charge? ❑ Yes ❑ No
7/25/97 Continued on back

Facility Number; 31-563
r
S. Are there Iagoons or storage ponds on site which need to be properly closed?
❑ Yes
❑ No
Structures (Laeoons.Holding Ponds. Flush Pits. etc.)
9. Is storage capacity (freeboard plus storm storage) less than adequate?
® Yes
❑ No
Structure I Structure 2 Structure 3 Structure 4 Structure 5
Structure 6
Identifier:..QId.............. ............. N.= ............. ..
Freeboard(ft) 1,25 ..............1..5_8.............................................................................................................................................................
10. Is seepage observed from any of the structures?
❑ Yes
❑ No
11. , Is erosion, or any other threats to the integrity of any of the structures observed?
❑ Yes
❑ No
12. Do any of the structures need maintenance/improvement?
❑ Yes
❑ No
(If any of questions 9-12 was answered yes, and the situation poses an
immediate public health or environmental threat, notify DWQ)
13. Do any of the structures lack adequate minimum or maximum liquid level markers?
❑ Yes
❑ No
Waste Application
14. Is there physical evidence of over application?
❑ Yes
❑ No
(If in excess of WMP, or runoff entering waters of the State, notify DWQ)
15. Crop type.............................................................................•-•-•---..................•-------.........................................................----................................................
....
16. Do the receiving crops differ with those designated in the Animal Waste Management Plan (AWMP)?
❑ Yes
❑ No
17. Does the facility have a lack of adequate acreage for land application?
❑ Yes
❑ No
18. Does the receiving crop need improvement? ❑ Yes ❑ No
19. Is there a lack of available waste application equipment? ❑ Yes ❑ No
20. Does facility require a follow-up visit by same agency? ❑ Yes ❑ No
21. Did Reviewer/Inspector fail to discuss review/inspection with on -site representative? ❑ Yes ❑ No
22. Does record keeping need improvement? ❑ Yes ❑ No
For Certified or Permitted Facilities jQglj
23. Does the facility fail to have a copy of the Animal Waste Management Plan readily available? ❑ Yes ❑ No
24. Were any additional problems noted which cause noncompliance of the Certified AWMP? ❑ Yes ❑ No
25. Were any additional problems noted which cause noncompliance of the Permit? ❑ Yes ❑ No
No. violation's -or. deficiencies.vvere noted during this'visit. -You-will receive no further. .
correspondence: about this visit. '
done as a follow up to check freeboard. Due to freeboard being less than adequate a Notice of referral will be sent to
O-WiRO.
7/25/97
r- 2
Reviewer/Inspector Name . John M. Fitzgerald •
Reviewer/Inspector Signature: Date:
Farility Nnsnhiwt 11 —46-A Rofo ni Tncnortinnr 1171104

p Division of Soil and Water Conservatiq�aOperation Review s"
p Division of Soil and \Pater Conser ation Compliance:nsp tion ati r '�
Ml Dig isioii of Water Quality Comphance�lnspection
p•Other Aaencv -Operation Review
1p I:n!FIlme C t.(Imhl:llilt p ! Irallc•etlon p i,mio '-tilt of review Vttier I
4'. -
I ;_!-tispt-ctinll F__TM3� 24 hr. (hh:mm)
p Registered ® Certified p Applied for Permit 6 Permitted Itj , of operational Date Last Operated:
Farr„ Miniv- Batchelor.Sate;_.E,ttriu_.......--••..................................................................... County: Duplin WiRO
ONVItt - n'an!r............... ...................... Phone No
F:wili'% r:r:ntavl:.................................................... ._..-title:I.... Phone No:
....................................................
i1'}ailis:e arll?:cs: Ro..Rox.:259...................
................
Rosp- iILAC......................................................... 28-45R............ .
(lrtcil< .......................................................................................................... Integrator:MiltCjhy..Family.Earms.....................................
Crrlit"—i Operator: Richard ................................. D.O.11nell'N ........................................... Operator Certification Number: 1.7.192.............................
Location of Fat'tn:
Latitus?r 0•®. �l
csrgn U Ell, ren
Swine Capacitv Population
❑ Wean to Ireeder
❑ Feeder to Finish
g, arrow to can
_0
❑ Farrow to Feeder
❑ Farrow to Finish
❑ Gilts
❑ Boars
E.nitcitude ©•
esign Current
Poultry Capacity Population-: Cattle
❑ Layer p airy
❑ Non -Layer 1[3 on-
❑ Other
Total WAg' n "Capa `
Total SSL
Number of Lagoons / Holding Pon: is I� ❑ u stir ace rains res
❑ o Liquid Waste ana
1. Arc there any buffers that need rtl3iitlenarlcerintprovenlent?
2. is anv discharge observed front any hart of the operation?
Discll;tr�c on ir:a,, , c. []Lagoon ❑ Spray Field []Other
a. lfilischan_,: i r,! s; :+ :'...,.!: rite conveyance plan-ninde?
b, if discltnr•_,c i �. 4I reach Surface Watcr`' (lives, notify DWQ)
C. I' (l:tiC�i ll':'. n'•.:,: ! ty;,... I< Illc: estimated iln« in +—nl lhltn?
d; Dfl"'s ill Cai:!''_ ' t'"' I'' ,' ::' E: 5\'Steill'' (If \'es. notify DWQ)
3, is there evidence of past dischar�,e front an%, part of tile operation?
4. Were there any adverse inhpacis to the 1%-,mers of the State other than from.a discharge?
l VIAL:-!
Capacity PopulkionF.
airy
s
city2,035
n Area l] Spray Held Area
p Yes p No
5. Does any part of the waste niana-enient sysieni (other than lagoons/ltolding ponds) require
m aintenance/improvement?
6. is facility not in compliance n'idi any applicable setback criteria in effect at the time of design?
7, Did the facility fail to have a certified operator in responsible charge?
7/25197
p Yes p No
p Yes p No
p Yes p No
p Yes ❑ No
❑ Yes p No
p Yes p No
p Yes p No
❑ Yes p No
❑ Yes p No

d I If
Facility Numberi 3 —1— T-1-37]
8. Are there lagoons or storage ponds on site which need to be properly closed?
Z7 -
E3 Yes
[3 No
9. Is storage capacity (freeboard plus storm storage) less than adequate?
L3 Yes
a No
Structure I Structure 4 Structure 5
Structure
6
. ........................ ......... ......... ......................... ... ............................. .. ................................... ...................................
...................................
17!
10. Is seepage observed from any Of the SIRIC111reS?
E3 Yes
[3 No
11. Is erosion, or any other threats to the inte"rily of any of the structures observed?
[3 Yes
E3 No
12. Do any of the structures need i-n-,iiiitcii,-itice/iiiiprovement?
13 Yes
13 No
(if any of questions 9-12 was answered yes, and the situation poses an
immediate public health or environniental threat, notify DWQ)
13. Do any of the structures lack adequate mininitim or maximum liquid level markers?
13 Yes
[3 No
14. Is there physical evidence of over application?
[3 Yes
j3 No
(If in excess of WMP, or runoff entering waters of the State, notify DWQ)
I
IS. Crop type .................................. ............... __ ........................................................ ....... .............. . .......... . ................. . ...............................................................
16. Do the receiving crops differ Nviih those designated in the Animal Waste Management Plan (AWMP)?
[3 Yes
r _I No
IT Does the facility have a lack of adequate acreage for land application?
[3 Yes
[3 No
18. Does the receivint, crop need improvement?
[3 Yes
[3 No
19. Is there a lack of available waste application equipment?
[3 Yes
E3 No
20. Does facility require a follow-irp visit by same agency?
j3 Yes
[3 No
21. Did Reviewer/inspector fail to discuss reviexv/inspection with on -site representative?
0 Yes
E3 No
22. Does record keeping need improvement?
13 Yes
[3 No
For Cerlifitcrt or
23. Does the facility fail to have a copy of the Animal Waste Management Plan readily available?
r�
[3 Yes
[3 No
24. Were any additional problems noted which UlUsc noncompliance of the Certified AWMP?
[3 Yes
rl No
25. Were any additional problems noted which cause noncompliance of the Permit?
[3 Yes
[3 No
Q.-_oyiqkitions. or ncrencies,ivere.nrited -during7 this visit:. You vnill receive noFfurther . - -
.......... * ...... ...... , .................. ........ ...................................
fill$'
... ................... . ............ I ... .......
In ent (refer
to
Corn question;#): Explain
.,Use. ter
7&
Visit was made to assess if facilit), is a likely candidate for State groundwater study. Observations of spray. field borders were made
from public roads.
Poor quality of permit map made it difficult to determine the exact location of spray fields. The field "adjacent fb-SR1516 (iind farm
entrance) had ponded water in places.
One house (newer/brick) was located across SR 1516 from the northeast end of front field. A well was seen '(b_ric'k'c'6ver); how'e"v"er,
17
he house and well are a little far from spray field border.
One manufactured home is located directly across SR1516from front'field. Awell was, seen'(wood
One house (older) is located at southeast end of front field.
--7/25/9.7
lReviewer/Inspector Name AndrewG..'HcIrni"V'F_
Reviewer/Inspector Signature: Date:

State of North Carolina
Department of Environment,�Yt.
Health and Natural Resources
Division of Water Quality
JUG 18 1997
[BY:
James B. Hunt, Jr., Governor
Jonathan B. Howes, Secretary
A. Preston Howard, Jr., P.E., Director
July 16, 1997
CERTIFIED MAIL
RETURN RECEIPT REQUESTED
Murphy Family Farms
Batchelor Sow Farm -
PO Box 759
Rose Hill NC 28458
Farm Number: 31-563
Dear Murphy Family Farms:
31'r
EHNR
You are hereby notified that Batchelor Sow Farm, in accordance with G.S. 143-215.10C, must
apply for coverage under an Animal Waste Operation General Permit. Upon receipt of this letter, your
farm has thirty (30) days to submit the attached application and all supporting documentation. In
accordance with Chapter 626 of 1995 Session Laws (Regular Session 1996), Section
19(c)(2), any owner or operator who fails to submit an application by the date specified
by the Department SHALL NOT OPERATE the animal waste system after the specified
date. Your application must be returned within thirty (30) days of receipt of this letter. Failure to submit
the application as required may also subject your facility to a civil penalty and other enforcement actions
for each day the facility is operated following the due date of the application.
The attached application has been partially completed using information listed in your Animal
Waste Management Plan Certification Form. If any of the general or operation information listed is
incorrect please make corrections as noted on the application before returning the application package. The
signed original application, one copy of the signed application, two copies of a general location map, and
two copies of the Certified Animal Waste Management Plan must be returned to complete the application
package. The completed package should be sent to the following address:
North Carolina Division of Water Quality
Water Quality Section
Permits and Engineering Unit
Post Office Box 29535
Raleigh, NC 27626-0535
If you have any question concerning this letter, please call Mike Lewanddwski at [phone]
extension 362 or Dave Holsinger with the Wilmington Regional Office at [phone].
Sinc ely,
A. Preston Howard, Jr., P.E.
cc: Permit File (w/o encl.)
Wilmington Regional Office (w/o encl.)
P.O. Box 29535, Raleigh, North Carolina 27626-0535 Telephone [phone] FAX [phone]
An Equal Opportunity Affirmative Action Employer 50% recycled/ 10% post -consumer paper

State of North Carolina
Department of Environment,
Health and Natural Resources
James B. Hunt, Jr., Governor
Jonathan B. Howes, Secretary
November 12, 1996
Murphy Family Farms
Batchelor Sow Farm
PO Box 759
Rose Hill NC 28458
SUBJECT: Operator In Charge Designation
Facility: Batchelor Sow Farm
Facility ID#: 31-563
Duplin County
Dear Farm Owner:
Senate Bill 1217, An Act to Implement Recommendations of the Blue Ribbon Study
Commission on Agricultural Waste, enacted by the 1996 North Carolina General Assembly,
requires a certified operator for each animal waste management system that serves 250 or more
swine by January 1, 1997. The owner of each animal waste management system must submit a
designation form to the Technical Assistance and Certification Group which designates an
Operator in Charge and is countersigned by the certified operator. The enclosed form must be
submitted by January 1, 1997 for all facilities in operation as of that date. Failure to designate a
certified operator for your animal waste management system is a violation of 15A NCAC 2H
.0224 and may result in the assessment of a civil penalty.
If you have questions concerning operator training or examinations for certification, please
contact your local North Carolina Cooperative Extension Service agent or our office.
Examinations have been offered on an on -going basis in many counties throughout the state for
the past several months and will continue to be offered through December 31, 1996.
Thank you for your cooperation. If you have any questions concerning this requirement please
call Beth Buffington or Barry Huneycutt of our staff at 91gn33-0026.
Sincerely,
A. Preston Howard, Jr., ector
Division of Water Quality
Enclosure
cc: Wilmington Regional Office
Water Quality Files
44%
P.O. Box 27687, W FAX [phone]
Raleigh, North Carolina 2761 1-7687 �� An Equal Opportunity/Affirrnative Action Employer
Voice 919-715-4100 50% recycled/10% post -consumer paper

D
5EA 151997
BY:
FAMILYFARMS
NCDEHNR
Division Of Water Quality
Wilmington Regional Office
127 Cardinal Drive Extension
Wilmington, NC 28405
Response to Notice of Deficiency of Batchelor Farm # 31-563
Dear Division of Water Quality:
The following actions have been planned or completed in response to your staff inspection
on August 26, 1997.
1. Lagoon 41 freeboard was lowered by transfering liquid to lagoon #2, out of which we
are irrigating. Both lagoons currently have greater than 20" of freeboard.
2. MFF Technical Specialist Kraig Westerbeek is revising the farm certification to include
the expanded field in the back of the farm This is acreage we added when we
converted the irrigation system from solid -set to traveler.
3. Wash outs in the sprayfields have been graded by a tractor and will be smoothed by
disking at the end of September when we plant rye. Some ditches in or around the
sprayfields will be filled in at the same time to reduce future washouts.
If you have any questions, call John Bizic or Kraig Westerbeek at 910-289-6439.
Thank You.
�) G
John Bizic
Land and Nutrient Manager
jb:ph
nodbat. doc
cc: Dr. Garth Boyd, Andy Murray, David Gleckler, Harold Jones, Sandra Weitzel
Post Office Box 759, Rose Hill, North Carolina 28458, [phone], FAX [phone]

State of North Carolina
Department of Environment
and Natural Resources
Division of Water Quality
James B. Hunt, Jr., Governor
Wayne McDevitt, Secretary
A. Preston Howard, Jr., P.E., Director
June 26, 1998
Murphy Family Farms
Batchelor Sow Farm
PO Box 759
Rose Hill NC 28458
IT
4 NCDENR ITT?;
f
NORTH CAROLINA DEPARTMENT OF
ENVIRONMENT AND NATURAL RESOURCES
Subject: Reissuance of Certificate of Coverage
No.AWS310563
Batchelor Sow Farm
Swine Waste Collection, Treatment, Storage and
Application System
Duplin County
Dear Murphy Family Farms:
The Division of Water Quality modified the Swine Waste Operation General Permit originally issued to
this facility on August 25, 1997. In accordance with the issuance of the revised General Permit, we are
forwarding this Certificate of Coverage (COC) to Murphy Family Farms, authorizing the operation of
the subject animal waste collection, treatment, storage and land application system in accordance with
General Permit AWG100000. This approval shall consist of the operation of this system including, but
not limited to, the management of animal waste from the Batchelor Sow Farm, located in Duplin
County, with an animal capacity of no greater than 2035 Farrow to Wean and the application to land as
specified in the Certified Animal Waste Management Plan (CAWMP).
The COC shall be effective from the date of issuance until April 30, 2003, and shall hereby void
COC No AWS310563 dated August 25, 1997. The COC shall hereby incorporate by reference any
specific conditions of the previous COC issued to this facility. The purpose of this COC is to allow
coverage under the revised General Permit. Please review the revised General Permit (enclosed) and pay
particular attention to Condition II.10 regarding tree removal from lagoon embankments, Condition III .1
regarding inspection frequency of the waste treatment, storage and collection system and Condition II1.6
regarding notification requirements for system failures, spills and emergencies. Pursuant to this COC,
you are authorized and required to operate the system in conformity with the conditions and limitations
as specified in the General Permit, the facility's CAWMP, and this COC, with no discharge of wastes to
surface waters. An adequate system for collecting and maintaining the required monitoring data and
operational information must be established for this farm. Any increase in waste production greater than
the certified design capacity or increase in number of stocked animals above the number authorized by
this COC will require a modification to the CAWMP and this COC and shall be completed prior to
actual increase in either wastewater flow or number of animals.
Please be advised that any violation of the terms and conditions specified in this COC, the
General Permit or the CAWMP may result in the revocation of this COC, or penalties in accordance
with NCGS 143-215.6A through 143-215.6C including civil penalties, criminal penalties, and injunctive
relief.
P.O. Sox 29535, Raieigh, North;Carolina 27626-0535 Telephone,919-733�7015 FAX [phone]
An Equal Opportunity Affirmative Action Employer 50% recycled/ 10% post -consumer paper

Certificate of Coverage AWS310563
Batchelor Sow Farm
Page 2
Upon notification by the Division of this COC's expiration, you shall apply for its renewal. This
request shall be made within 30 days of notification by the Division.
This COC is not automatically transferable. A name/ownership change application must be
submitted to the DWQ prior to a name change or change in ownership.
If any parts, requirements, or limitations contained in this COC are unacceptable, you have the
right to apply for an individual non -discharge permit by contacting the engineer listed below for
information on this process. Unless such a request is made within 30 days, this COC shall be final and
binding.
The subject farm is located in the Wilmington Regional Office. The Regional Office Water
Quality Staff may be reached at [phone]. If you need additional information concerning this
COC or the General Permit, please contact J. R. Joshi at [phone] ext. 363.
Sincerely,
for A. Preston Howard, Jr., P.E.
cc: (Certificate of Coverage only for all cc's)
Duplin County Health Department
Wilmington Regional Office, Water Quality Section
Duplin County Soil and Water Conservation District
Permit File

State of North Carolina
Department of Environment, Health, and Natural Resources
Wilmington Regional Office
James B. Hunt, Jr. Division of Water Quality Wayne McDevitt
Governor Secretary
August 29, 1997
Qcrfifled Mail # Z 312 639 920
Return Regeipt Requested
Attn.: John Bizic
Murphy Family Farms
Batchelor Sow Farm
PO Box 759
Rose Hill, NC 28458
Dear Murphy Family Farms:
Subject: NOTICE OF DEFICIENCY
Batchelor Sow Farm
Facility Number: 31-563
Duplin County
On August 26, 1997, staff from the Wilmington Office of the Division of Water Quality inspected your
animal operation and the lagoons serving this operation. During the inspection, it was observed that lagoon
#1 had insufficient freeboard. The level of this lagoon should be lowered and maintained in accordance with
the NRCS guidelines and the State 2H .0200 rules governing animal waste management systems. USDA-
NRCS guidelines require a minimum of one foot and seven inches of freeboard. This is based on the amount
of storage space needed to contain a 25-year, 24 hour design storm event without a discharge.
During the inspection, it was also observed that you are applying waste on spray fields that are not part
of your certified animal waste management plan. If you intend to continue using these fields, they must be
immediately incorporated into the plan. Spray application in these fields should be discontinued until your
plan is officially changed.
Finally, extensive wash outs were observed in your spray fields. These areas should be corrected
immediately. In addition, spray application in these areas should be avoided until the problem is corrected.
127 Cardinal Drive Extension, Wilmington, N.C. 2M5-3845 • Telephone [phone] • Fax [phone]
An Equal Opportunity Affirmative Action Employer

Murphy Family Farms
August 29, 1997
Page 2
To remain a deemed permitted facility, you must notify this office in writing within fourteen (14) days
of the'receipt of this notice, what actions will be taken to comply with your certified animal waste management
plan. Failure to do so may result in the facility losing its deemed permitted status and being required to
obtain an individual non discharge permit.
Please be aware it is a violation of North Carolina General Statutes to discharge wastewater to the
surface waters of the State without a permit. The Division of Water Quality has the authority to levy a civil
penalty of not more than $10,000 per day per violation.
If you have any questions concerning this matter, please call Andy Helminger, Brian Wrenn, or Dave
Holsinger at 910-395-3900.
Sincerely,
Andrew G. Helminger
Environmental Specialist
cc: Harold Jones, Duplin County Soil and Water Conservation
Sandra Weitzel, NC Division of Soil and Water Conservation
Garth Boyd, Murphy Family Farms
Operations Branch
Wilmington.File.s
S. I WQS 1 AND YA 131-563. D EF

State of North Carolina
Department of Environment,
Health and Natural Resourc(
Division of Water Quality
James B. Hunt, Jr., Govemor
Wayne McDevitt, Secretary
A. Preston Howard, Jr., P.E., Di
Kraig Westerbeek
Batchelor Sow Farm
Murphy Family. Farms
PO Box 759
Rose Hill, NC 28458
Dear Mr. Westerbeek:
BY:
A T4
EDEHNR
August 15, 1997
Subject: Application No. 31-563
Additional Information Request
Batchelor Sow Farm
Animal Waste Operation
Duplin County
. The Permits and Engineering Unit has completed a preliminary engineering review of the subject
application. Additional information is required before we can continue our review. Please address the
following by September 14, 1997:
1) _ The Liquid Animal Waste Operations Permit Application states that 28 acres are cleared and
available for application. The Waste Utilization Plan states that 35.7 acres are required for .
the proper management of this facility. It appears that insufficient lands are available for the
proper management of this facility. Please provide additional documentation describing the
acreage that is cleared and available for waste application.
Please reference the subject permit application number when providing the requested information.
All information should be signed, sealed, and submitted in duplicate to my attention at the address
below. The information requested by this letter, must be submitted on or before September 14, 1997, or
the Division will return your application as incomplete in accordance with 15A N.C.A.C. 2H .0200 and
your facility will be considered to be operating without a permit.
Please be advised that operation of the subject animal waste management system without a valid
permit is a violation of North Carolina General Statute 143-215.1 and will subject you to the enforcement
authority of the Environmental Management Commission.
If you have any questions regarding this request, please call me at [phone], extension 362.
Sincerely,
Michael T. Lewandowslci
Environmental Engineer
State Engineering Review Group
cc: Wilmington Regional Office, Water Quality
Permit File
P.O. Box 29535, Raleigh, Forth Carolina 27626-0535 Telephone [phone] FAX [phone]
An Equal Opportunity Affirmative Action Employer 50% recycled/ 10% post -consumer paper
L \..

State of North Carolina
Department of Environment,
Health and Natural Resources
Division of Water Quality
AUG 2 7 1997 i • •
James B. Hunt, Jr., Govemor
Wayne McDevitt, Secretary
A. Preston Howard, Jr., P.E., Director
Kraig Westerbeek
Batchelor Sow Farm
PO Box 759
Rose Hill NC 28458
Dear Kraig Westerbeek:
C)EHN =
August 25, 1997
Subject: Certificate of Coverage No. AWS310563
Batchelor Sow Farm
Swine Waste Collection, Treatment, Storage
and Application System
Duplin County
In accordance with your application received on August 14, 1997, we are forwarding this
Certificate of Coverage (COC) to Farm No. 31-563, authorizing the operation of an animal waste
collection, treatment, storage and land application system in accordance with the State's General Permit
(attached). This approval shall consist of the operation of this system including, but not limited to, the
management of animal waste from the Batchelor Sow Farm, located in Duplin County, with an animal
capacity of no greater than 2035 Farrow to Wean and the application to a minimum of 35.7 acres of land
as specified in the Certified Animal Waste Management Plan (CAWMP). y .
The COC shall be effective from the date of issuance until December 31, 2001. Pursuant to this
COC, you are authorized and required to operate the system in conformity with the conditions and
limitations as specified in the General Permit, the facility's CAWMP, and this COC, with no discharge of
wastes to surface waters. An adequate system for collecting and maintaining the required monitoring data
and operational information must be established for this farm. Any increase in waste production greater
than the certified design capacity or increase in number of stocked animals above the number authorized by
this COC will require a modification to'the CAWMP and this COC and shall be completed prior to actual
increase in either wastewater flow or number of animals.
In accordance with General Statue 143-215.10C, Animal Waste Management Plans shall include
the following components:
- A checklist of odor sources and best management practices to minimize these sources.
A checklist of insect sources and best management practices to minimize these sources.
- Provisions set forth for acceptable methods of disposing of mortalities.
- Provisions regarding emergency action plans.
Your existing Certified Animal Waste Management Plan must include the above elements, by
December 31, 1998. Documentation of the certification -must be available to inspectors onsite. Submittal
of the amended certification statement shall be required upon renewal of your permit coverage in 2001. .
Please be advised that any violation of the terms and conditions specified in this COC, the General
Permit or the CAWMP may result in the revocation of this COC.
P.O. Box 29535, Raleigh, North Carolina 27626-0535 Telephone [phone] FAX [phone]
An Equal Opportunity Affirmative Action Employer 50% recycled/ 10% post -consumer paper

Upon notification by the Division of this COC's expiration, you shall apply for its renewal. This
request shall be made within 30 days of notification by the Division.
-r^ �•
1 i 1�� � D 1 i.k
This COC is not automatically transferable. A name/ownership change application must be
submitted to the DWQ prior to a name change or change in ownership.
If any parts, requirements, or limitations contained in this COC are unacceptable, you have the
right to apply for an individual non -discharge permit by contacting the engineer listed below for
information on this process. Unless such a request is made within 30 days, this COC shall be final and
binding.
The subject farm is located in the Wilmington Regional Office. The Regional Office Water Quality
Staff may be reached at [phone]. If you need additional information concerning this COC or the
General Permit, please contact Mike Lewandowski at [phone] ext. 352.
Sincerely,
A. Preston Howard, Jr., P.E.
CC' (Certificate of Coverage only for all cc's)
Duplin County-Health-Department---�,
cWilmuigton.R"egiorial:Affice, Water Quality -Section
Duplin County Soil and Water Conservation District
Penriit File

State of North Carolina a
Department of Environment, Health and Natural Resources
--. Division of Water Quality
_ Non -Discharge Permit Application Form /Survey
Au(i2 �gg7 (THIS FORM MAY BE PHOTOCOPIED FOR USE AS AN ORIGINAL)
General Permit - Liquid Animal Waste Operations
The following questions have been completed utilizing information on file with "e
Division. Please review the information for completeness and make any corrections
which are appropriate. If a question has not been completed by the Division, ple@_�;e
complete as best as possible. Do not leave any question unanswered.
Application Date: � � 3 I� 1
I. REQUIRED ITEMS CHECKLIST
Please indicate that you have included the following required items by signing your initials in the space provided next to ea h T
item.
Applicants Initi
1. One completed and signed original and one copy of the application for General Permit - Animal
Waste Operations;
2. Two copies of a general location map indicating the location of the animal waste facilities and
field locations where animal waste is disposed;
3. Two copies of the Certified Animal Waste Management Plan (CAWMP). If the facility does
not have a CAWMP, one must be completed prior to submittal of a general permit application
for animal waste operations.
II. GENERAL INFORMATION:
1. Farm's name: Batchelor Sow Farm
2. Print Land Owner's name: Murphy Family Farms _
3. Land Owner's Mailing address:
City: RoSe Hill NC _ _ Zip: 28458
Telephone Number:
4. County where i'arm is located: Duplin
5. Farm Location (Directions from nearest major highway. Please include SR numbers for state roads. Please include a copy —
of a county road map with the Iocation of the farm identified). From Kenansville. take NC 11/903 N 4.0 miles: turn Lt.-9
Wesley Chapel onto_SR-Ul6: go 0.7 mile. farm sign plc st on Lt.: follow dirt farmroad for 1.0 mile to farm.
6. Print Farm Manager's name (if different from Land Owner):--eal4irr$a J11.0t lqP- f l i o
7. Lessee's / Integrator's name (if applicable; please circle which type is listed): Murphy Family Farms
31 - 563
FORM: AWO-G-E 2/26/97 Page 1 of 3

M
III. OPERATION INFORMATION:
1. Farm No.: 3 1-5
2. Operation Description: Swine operation
Farrow to Wean
2035 - Certified Design Capacity
Is the above information correct? Ea yes; a no. If no, correct below using the design capacity of the facility
of Swine No. of Aqimals Tyne of Poultrx No. of Animals Tv oe of Cattle No. of Animals
0 Wean to Feeder 0 Layer 0 Dairy
0 Feeder to Finish 0 Non -Layer 0 Beef
0 Farrow to Wean (# sow) 0 Turkey
0 Farrow to Feeder (# sow)
0 Farrow to Finish (# sow)
Other Type of Livestock on the farm: _ No. of Animals:
3. Acreage cleared and available for application: 28.00 -; Required Acreage (as listed in the CAWMP): 35.7
4. Number of Lagoons: �_ ; Total Capacity: 060 Cubic Feet (f13)
Number of Storage Ponds: ; Total Capacity: Cubic Feet (ft3)
5. Is animal waste being applied on any field which has subsurface drains? YES or (please circle one)
6. Are subsurface drains present in the vicinity of or under the lagoon? YES or C99 (please circle one)
IV. APPLICANT'S CERTIFICATION:
I, ./A ,.,12 L I r"n i .f 6/a rM S
this application lor . AU(-- r v-rr
has been reviewed by me and is accurate and comph
application are not completed and that ifl required
will be returned to me as incompleta. /4
Signature L!!f:�
V.
I,
(Land Owners name listed in question II.2), attest that
(Farm name listed in question II.1)
to the best of my knowledge. I understand that if all required parts of this
pporting information and attachments are not included, this application package
Date ­7 — I I —1 1
S CERTIFICATION: (complete only if different from the Land Owner)
(Manager's name listed in question II.6), attest that this
application for 13CAG �`16 +r (Farm name listed in question 11.1)
has been reviewed by me and is accurate and complete to the best of my knowledge. I understand that if all required parts of this
application are not completed and that if all required supporting information and attachments are not included, this application package
will be returned as incomplete.
Signature
Date I - 31- q 7
THE COMPLETED APPLICATION PACKAGE, INCLUDING ALL SUPPORTING INFORMATION AND MATERIALS,
SHOULD BE SENT TO THE FOLLOWING ADDRESS:
NORTH CAROLINA DIVISION OF WATER QUALITY
WATER QUALITY SECTION
PERMITS AND ENGINEERING UNIT
POST OFFICE BOX 29535
RALEIGH, NORTH CAROLINA 27626-0535
TELEPHONE NUMBER: [phone]
FORM: AWO-G-E 2/26/97 Page 2 of 3

Producer: jV\,,,,r7 I lA,v.t}j t"C7.rM5 — I&, C.\.1U+r �A ryvl
Location: JA. I- Sox lag-1> a5341 3i;� 1616
Telephone: (q,o) act(. -- o i o -7
Type Operation: �arrp.,a- wGa r-.
..0
Number of Anim,, s : ao3 5
(Design. Capacity)
The waste from your animal facility must be land applied at a;,
specified rate to prevent. pollution of surface and/or groundwa r.
The plant nutrients in the animal waste should be used to reduce
the araaurit of commercial fertilizer required for the cwops in the
fields where the waste is to be applied. This waste utilization
plan uses nitrogen as the limiting nutrients Waste should be
analyzed before each application cycle. Annual. soil tests are
strongly encouraged so that all- plant nutrients can be balanced. for
raalis,.ic yields of the crop to be grown.
Several factors are important in implementing your waste
utillzation plan in arder to maxinize the fertilizer value of the
waste and to- ensure that it is applied in an environmentally safe
mmnnez. Always apply Waste basea on the needs of the crop to be
grown and the,nutrientcontent K the waste. Do not apply more
nitrogen than the crop can utilize. Soil types are imnvrMant as
they haves different infiltration rates, leaching potantia c , cation
exchange capacities, and available Hater holding capacities..
normally waste shall not be applied to land eroding at greater than.
5 tons per acre per year., .With special precautions, waste may be
applied to land eroding at up to !0 tons per acre per year. mo •no4
apply waste aA saturated sails, when -it is raining, or when the
sur=ace is. frozen. Either of these conditions may result in rundR
to surface waters which is not allowed under. DEM ragulations. Wind
conditions should also be considered to avoid drift and downwind
odor probloms . To maximize the value of nutrients for crop
production and to reduce the potential For pollution, the waste
should be applied to,a growing crop or applied to bare ground not
more than 30 days prior to. planting. Injecting- the waste or
d=string will conserve nutrients and reduce odor problems.
The estimated acres needed to apply the animal waste is based on
typical. nutrient content- for this type: of. facility. Acreage
requirements should be based on the waste analysis report Eras your
waste :management facility. Attached you will find. information. on
pwoper sampling 'techn.iques, preparation, and transfer of waste
samples to the lab for analysis.
This waste utilization plan, if. carried out, meats the requirements
for compliance with 15A NCAC 2H.0217 adopted by•the Environmental
Management Commission.
1

Amou=f of Waste Produced per Year(gallons, ft3, tans, etc.)
3 5 ar:smals X apt.) waste/animal/year =, `fol `,—Z
wastelyear� iO(*nt . )
wa.
ouf.t o¢ plant Vazlab Witrn en_ (PAN) Produced fie= Year
a23 S anizaals XsPAN/animal/year 10 IVIlbs . PAN/year,
(PAN frost H. C. Tech. Guide Std. 633) ,
Applyi-aq the above amount of waste is a big job. You should plan
time and have appropriate egiiipment to apply the waste fin a timely
Manner.
The .following acreage will be needed for waste application based on.
the crap to be grown and surface application:
Table 1:
Tract 'Field ,soil Crap
7r No . Type'
ACRES OWNED .BY PRODUCER
1,39. N Acres Lbs. N Month of
Per AC.*, utilized Applicatioa
���'i-
►�—
Fes+-t��
- �
-�
. • .—.
-_ - -
«�!��
F
�.
EM
...
Total 5.1 tr .a5
fiIOAa.► acacied ck—^.%wlly
This N is from animal waste only. rf autrients fgm other
sources such as aa=erclal fertilizer are applied, they must be
accounted far. N must be ba ed on reslzstYc Kield_=ectatlon.
I oTZ ; The applicator is cautioned. that P and. K maybe over applied.
while saeeti.ug the H requirements. Begi.aaing ,in. 1996 the. Coastal-
ZoAe 9anagement Act Will require farmers is s0=0 eastern counties
of North cara3ina to have a nutrient management- plan t_hit. addresses
all nutrfeats. This plan only- addresses Nitragezn.
2

Table 2; ACRES WITH AGREEMENT OR LONG TERM LEASE-
otgreameat with $dincent jam dar+aer =St be attachad)
(2Agairad only Sf operator dQ0.9 Mot as►a
adaquato Zand jaoo Required Spoc.ification 2J1
Tzact Field soil Crop Lbs, N Acres Lbs. N Month of
# TYPO Per Ac.# Utilized Application
Sea �foQtxate for TabZn I.
Totals from above Tables
Acres Lbs. N
Utilized.
Table I
Table 2
Total I i °+ 1 • d
Amount of N Produced {O
.:'surplus yr eflcit -- Cpa�• ��
NOTE_ fihe Haste. Ut;lIfor
._
periadic land application of Sludgeat agrono=1a rates- The
sludge will. be nutrient rich and wi1I require, preeautionary
measures to prevent over application of nutrients Or- Other.
elexaents.
3

See attachedmap showinT the fields to be used for tize uti3iaaf ien
Qf Writs water.
Application of Haste by Irrigatioa
risld $oil Type f Crop Application j Application]
Nc. I Rate(ln/Kr) I Amount(ln.)
Fo -a
A,,B - Fad _
n
Bcrena q
ev% %A
I
0.5
a.5
0.5
NOT Vrz2zD -Sr Saa= rY UZ 1191NO .127=7 Br sRF =k2:OK, XQWXV= A SMdZAR M"Z= WILL BE
UzzZ....]' FOR DAr Lxr.-= OR SL17 =.
Your facility is designed for. 110 days vf•temparary storage and
the temporary storage mustbe removed on the average of once every
G MONTHS, In no instance should the volume of waste being
stared in your structure exceed Elevation
tail the local Natural Resources conservation service (.ea=erly
5oi3 Conservation Service) oe soil aad Water Conservation District
off ice after you receive the waste analysis report for.'assistance
is determining the amount per acre to apply and the proper
application rate prior to applying the waste.
4

UQUIRFD SPECIFICATIONS
I- Animal waste sham, not reach surface graters of the state
by runoff, drift, manmade conveyances, direct application,
or direct discharge during operation or land application.
Any.discharge of waste which reaches surface water is.
prohibited. Illegal, discharges are subject to the -
assessment of civil penalties of $lo,000 pet day by the
Division of Environmental Management for every day the
discharge continues,
2.. The Field Office must have documentation in the design.
folder that the producer either owns or has Long term
access to adequate land an which to properly apply the
waste. If the producer does not own adequate land to.
properly dispose of waste, he shall provide MRCS with a
copy of a Written aSraement (sample enclosed) with a
landowner who :s within a reasonable. pro: imity, allowing
him/her: the use of. the land for waste application. for the
life expectancy of the production facility. It is the
responsibiliU of the owner of the facility cc secure an,
update of the 'Waste Uciazation Plan when there is a
change in the operation, increase in the number of
animals, mathod of utilization, or available land.
3. Animal Wasta shall be applied to meet, but not exceed, the
Xitrogea.needs for realistic Crop yields based on Soil
type, available moisture, histoxzcal data, clitate
conditions, and level of management, unless there are
regulations that restrict the rate of application for
ocher nutrients.
4. Animal -waste may be applied to land that has a. 'Resource.
Management System (RUS) or an Alternative Conservation.
System UCS). If an ACS is used the sail loss'shall be no
greater than 14 tons per acre per year and appropriate
filter strips will.be used where runoff leaves the field.
These filter strips will be in addition to "Buffers"
re aired by V M. [See FOTG Standard 393 - Filter Strips
and Standard 390 (Interim) - Riparian Forest. Buffers . I
5. odors can be, reduced by, inj ec_timg the wastz or disking
after waste application. Waste should not be applied. when
the wind is blowing.
6. When animal waste is to be applied on. acres subject to
flooding, it will be soil incorparaced on convtntionall.y
tilled cropland. When applied ro conservation tilled
crops or grassland, the waste may be broadcast provided_
the application does not occur during a season prone to
flooding. (See "Weather. and Climate in North Carolina" in
the Technical Reference - Environmentfile for. guidance.)
5

REQUIRM SPECIFICATIONS
7. Liquid waste shall be applied at races not to exceed the
soil infiltration rate such that runoff does not occur
offsite* or to surface waters aad in a method which does
not cause drift from the site during application. No
ponding should occur in order to controJ. conditiow
conducive to odor or dies and provide =1 ormiry of
application,.
8. Animal waste shall not be'applied to saturated soils,
during rainfall. events, or wtien the surface is frozen.
9. An-.ma1 waste shall be applied- an actively growing Gro��rrs in.
such a manner than no more than 20 to 25 percent of zhe
leaf area is covered_
10. Waste nutrients shall. not be. applied in fall or printer for
spring planted crops on soils with a high potential for
leaching. Waste nutrient loading rates on these soils
should be held to a minimum and a suitable w4inter. cover
crop plaaced.to tska up released nutrients. Waste shall
noz.be applied more than 30 days prior to punting of the
crop on bare soil.
11. Animal waste shall not be applied closer than\-25 faet to
surface water. This distance: may be reduced for watars
that are not perennial provided adequate vegetative filter
strips are present. (Sea StaiZdard 393 - Filter Strips)
12. Animal, waste shall not be applied closer th= 1O0 faer to
Wells.
13. Animal waste shall not be applied closer than 400 feet of
dwellings other than those owned by the landowner.
14. Waste shall. be applied in a manner not to reach other
property and public right-o f - vays .
Animal. waste shall not be discharged into surface waters,
dra.inaggways or warlands by a discharge or by over-
sprayinq. Animal waste may Ise applied to prior converted.
wetlands provided they have been approvedas a land
application site by a '"technical. specialisto - Minimal.
waste should. not be applied on grassed. waterways that.
discharge.diredtly into water courses, and only then at
agronomic rates provided the application causes no runoff -
or dxift- from the site,

Rr-Q.URED SPECIFICATIONS
t��nLaai
16. Domestic and industrial waste from washdown facilities,
showers, toilets, sinks, etc.,. shall. not be discharged
into the animal waste management system.
17. Lagoons and other an overed waste containment structares
must maintain a max-ii= operating level to provide
adequate storage for a 25-year, 24-hoar stoma event -in
Addition to the one (1) foot mandatory freeboard.
18. A' protective cover of appropriate vegetation will -be -
established on. all disturbdd areas (lagoon embankments,
berms, pipe runs, etc.)_ If. needed, special vegetation
shall ba provided for these areas and shall, be fenced, as
necesgary, to protect the vegetation. Vegetation such as
trees, shrubs, and other woody species, ate. are limited
to areas where cousiderad appropriate, Lagoon. areas
should be kept moored and accessible. Lagoon be=iz and.
structures should be inspected regularly for evidence of
erosion, leakage, or discharge.
i9. If animal production at the 9acility is to be suspended or.
terminated, the Owner is responsible for obtaining and
implementing a 'closure plan" which will eliminate the
possibility of an illega1 discharge, pollution and
erosion
z❑ . Fasts handling structures, piping, pumps, reels„• tetd,.,
should be inspected on a regular basis to prevent
breakdowns, leaks, and.spills. A regular maintenance
checklist should be kept on. site.
7

WASTE TJTILIZATION 2LAN AGREE w NT
xarse of Far=: C. H LO K Spy 1:5AFM
O•crner/Manager Agre=ent
I (ore) understand and. will £oLlowand impleiaent the specification
and the operation and maintananca procedures established in the
approved animal waste utilization plan for the farm. named above_ I
(we) know that. any expansion. to the existing design- capacity of the
waste treatment and. storage system or construction of new
facilities will require a new certification to be submitted to the
Division of Environment Managemant (DEK) before, the nev, aaimals are -
stocked. I (we) also understand that there must be no discharge of
animal waste from this system to surface wa9ters of the state from
a- sta= event less severe than the 25--year, 24--hour storm. The
approved plan will be filed on -site at the farm office and at- the.
off3:ce of the' local Sail and. Water cnnsezvation District and will.
be ava.i? able for. review by DFH upon request.
:Tame of Facility owner: F ,M.,Fc-.,- r,, 5
fPxaa.a print)
Signatstre: nDate:
v
Name of Hanager(If different from owner) :
Siggature; Date;
Name of Technical Syecialist: (Please PrInN f o. %
r
Af iliat on :r' V-r• 5
Address (Agency).: d
S±S=a-' .uze
5

A WA TE IL2 ATIO A EIN • -
(Va"ed •.2j 19 addifloael 1AAd ,ACC. Dr 19=44, e00.)
�'r • hereby TWO.
permisslon, to apply. anMal waste from Es waste. Utilization system
on acres of my land for the duration of time shown below..
I understand that this waste contains nitrogen, phosphorous,
potassium, and other traces elements and when. properly applied:
should not harm my Land or crops. I also t=derstan& that the use
of waste, will reduce my need for commercial fextilizer ..
Adjacent Landowners Date:
Waste Producer: Date:
Technical Representative: Date:
SWCD Representative; Date:
Term of Agreement 19 to , 20w
RF{bL,r. n! Ten X.jet en Cast Shteed YtaRX)
(See Acquired SSecifleatiom No. .2.)
W,

aNC. MUNuMENT PROPERTY LINE
,t C F
� d .
� zoo
200
1 inch = 2QQ
W

��;��'r.,'�r 'j, i'1 � 7}�4 �:tizl s /yh}�yl�: F.:xrr_.��/�`.;�`-�'�� f:_f'• 'A �'*%:.�'+'iw17_`�I �4• , ..'
y'i:r;;�' `w' � - �� 4'�i .a,..r ' F _w �.r-. �•�' �: � � '�f ` +t.'�v. .'n
-e!ao- -•''� ter.,- � � ! `�i� j:.:
\ .' � r�'�_,: �!r • < � _.. ,, , _ <,, r ,• ,;,�`� �: i"-: f. � %�!i . ' � „�r ."'�i��,L!!r /.i,}ti K �::"t Q•,\;� is
� �/ i i'`{�rw�'��.,�1� T,. � �" +' � 1r"` a_•• �1 ,�i+,aSJjs" �, �'+ .�✓.y't�l�.� •. �j !iC',3 ':
+S i �• + tl.e p 1 e � � r j � 1' 1 V „Y. ;- r' hT T�- '.� 1, �� �1 SS %; .
�� 1.,�. :;JCS. ��a� ^�,.s �•/"] '-tl 1'' '/' - ��@Jp�.� S.'��,� ��-f �'r' 7?�� ! :'l���M4 � ':%��'`�_� �.L
` , f tll ��� �.-, .,, 1' �.. � �, j f � �, . � fJ ri �, ; : [{1�•,���,'-'1 :r;{•".a � � �,j'� � �4r '+1 � ear q�
/ � •t� e �; S 'rr -7 •tr .( w � 3f1�r :y� '�3i '� '�in` �I � �� ��'� � A ?,e -s 45 s- �dr '✓'`-• '''ti' ' tYi�' � ,^ G •r •o�Y� � � �
�.n a , ti �. '�'., r` 3 Yx• ��i �wysyl ••, G •s ! ,,. _ -. �r�, t
,�; _r , �,-: ',% '� �S a+�+�� ��:. 1 r ti }rti ��� �'� . �• s�.t s La tool.
'�7�.��-�
•y' �1;. e:,!{! •�, � - h s . . ,�•¢� �I G : . � ,y y :+ �� � �.s . , -sue �'r- >� . :7'
■■91 �.i f . 1 �F,n..�'y'K I r it • . r� ' �' ff f1r 1 ��i,'F�'� ,'!�• ;G 1'` '. rsr•: /•'-,1 ,. ?'. '. - •, +.
•I �'� ..y �r - ..:{.•�1/' �`4..r'N.``.t: �Y, jr( \R',r 'L ' i y ��' r•i�•• T r' �.,
�� , it , .:i- �.��: .a'' a',lti♦. y - ••
�. � - Y. l .7 C'=..r 7 I.,a(; j�, y- i ��-V. •� �j � J•� �� lg.. l ys,.
'�• �'' i ►T .,1 �j.%y t ;.� • .f : iN,�► 1 ;C. �f'i'„ `� :t,: ;i .�a"•:. tr � � .'y�c: 'r �,a n '�q•.,,..p; � � �- :'fit#2�
UO
Al
Olb
Akol
ir
M.. ". \IV
}�"� •n:� !.1 S - .r � ^. ��,i% "� .;r ���3'!t' �'^, i r�ir � -�. :r ,t. '�j !, . ..ai.
,;'�::�tt - �� • � r-.{l.:r;{.. -.Mf�•s��-�•`s".� �e •i>'t -' ,''`sFa '� '�r � !� .1'"- ,
'.1 �' y;fl .�`�•i�ad �, � �, ..'.jt�• ?. � r . '?��?., `•4;� _?v: � .'1.,. ;` .ars; C` �i�1��`�:. - -�/-
� ( e �,tl r,' _ � �Y .!Its k. 1 '":fir"' u•. .. �� F RS'•� L f� S' �...'.y.•-,. 1 1MM
' Q'�c-: �� '•a_� ,.
•: lr �' T.ti :r �Pw l 1 '.YM, .. �1e}:� y• _ •t.`• � fyb' „'%"�L� "
• 1.. '�' •?.•Y� " 4 - ' i. ��_ •�} 4• sr.���(� : i' /`: r. �� ; �, �;, 'r � •�•��ti�i,,,I , ,ice r
'i- r ! }tit; � �ry�5 ';Y' S .'f: � 1 4 1,,� '���•�R'�v'��:
►rfM�y*1t.. Q,wlKy,.,dkS;
�' �f" .-r!3'-F' +,p•. .f `i• 'T, L:.,,:'I Jo .L.. 'tCF � :t''{ •:J'�: I (Tr•+4' :i Tt i. `tlr���r' r
'.i 1i` t1. s1�'4, ,li- y(•• sr.1 �.41.1{a �.. ,�1;� A
yr.jr+a. �G� F, l 1' ," i •i -+c�j •.1 ti �• ,.l �yyR �� •„ti.
-�, .�1Dr '•.•+rive' .',�,��i:'i. ,, ,` •�r. •F:;' t' S .+i• 1 ,r.•^.ft.. , .t, ,tlai' . '•.
47
'� , sik ,j��1�i�+ t Ii• fir' .�r r,' i 1- tl F' '� i •:t"'
1. i��F-.r,J r.# < *• 1 �� .,� 'r' h1.ti� 1�tr r' ,'u r t' r l'r..,•F. 'n�, .°!' .'.. .�; u
r �i y',,g �,Y.� r- 't", "��:r ,;• f � �a?}r '� ', ii- ,•i ,��•: •�f�, ,_• '�� 'i
f N •� i+r _ e ! l - i �a L ,�,{;4� :,.� 'f.. a �. L r (�,��-lj�L�,� ` LL i .':rr' �.• ��' y .
y�,, (, �rTY � ].n '``'art { i(r r� k .r.. r a.:�-.:'��•:,7••ti,.t -'''b ', f�
h � � ��r ,1 �;� .�� �j' F i + ;1S {.C� y r.n: -r,\ :�,t ,s �,IF'' -,�,: 1•,•, ,^
► a +sit .i,,,.j;, .* �� r %: i;.1w4,/•�ar f, .5 r 7 '• '. .. :. ,r.
�f. t s T „�• �M'S Y ,: `ir. i , ,:.r � 4:F 'e,.a.: `4.

io
O
-- 10

i
m SEND R:
V ■ Complete items 1 and/or 2 for additional services. I also wish to receive the
m ■complete items 3.4a, and 4b. following services (for an
■ Print your name and address on the reverse of this form so that we can return this extra fee):
card to you.
y ■Attach this form to the front of the mailpiece, or on the back if space does not 1. ❑ Addressee's Address
m ■Wnte Return Receipt Requested' on the mallpiece below the amide number. 2. ❑ Restricted Delivery
■ The Return Receipt will show to wham the articia was delivered and the date
c delivered. Consult postmaster for fee.
0
-0 3. Article Addressed to: 4a. Article Number
M �
06 ,&-Z t L O
0 I 41A�
4b. Service Type
} ML_r Cl-Registered t�-C ified
❑-Expi6ss.'Mail ❑ Insured
❑ Retum Receipt for Merchandise ❑ COD
7. Date of Delivery
Cy
5. eived By: (Print Name) , 8. Addressee's Address (Only if requested
If and fee is paid)
g 6. Signature: (A dressea or gent)
a. X
M
PS Form 3811, December 1994 Domestic Return Receip