HomeMy WebLinkAboutDEQ-CFW_00078992From: Kritzer, Jamie [/D=[XCHANG[LAB5/OU=EXCHANGEADMINISTRATIVE GROUP
(FYD|BOHF2]SPDLT)/CN=REOP|ENTS/CN=C[E9]C49D01445A]B541B8327DCDCD4O-JBKR|TZ[R]
Sent: 6/2I/I0I77:05:331
To: Talley, Noe||e3[/b=ExchanXeLabs/ou=ExchangeAdministrative Group
(FYD|8OHFZ33PDO)/cn=Redpient$cn=cd9[3Q8%4%I745bcb5a6Ocbe8ZcdMA9'nstaUey];K8acke)\Chris
[/o=ExchangeLabs/ou=ExchangeAdministrative Group
(FYD|8OHFZ33PDO)/cn=Redpient$cn=aef8f6bO6bI]4Zc5b%8%aeO8d%b451ce'cmackey3]
Subject: RE: response
This, too, is a good piece from the opening stanza of what we're intending for the web page, ormaybe that's why you
sent italong inthe first place.
Jamie Kritzer
Communications Director
N.C. Department of Environmental Quality
�01WRIM",
'o Sis ��e
N��h�ann0na�o�0���:nn%�Lmw/an�xnn�b����n���h7�n�Y/xa���
From: Talley, Noe||e8
Sent: Wednesday, June J1,ZOl7J:O7PK4
To: Mackey Chris <Chris.K4ackey@dhhs.nc.gov>; Kritzer, Jamie <jamie.kritzer@ncdenr.Bou`
Subject: RE: response
Thanks. We'll gowith: DHHS is reviewing all available health data and working with the EPA and the Centers for
Disease Control to get their guidance about health risks of Gel EPA is updating its risk assessment on Gel
itisnot known atthis time when this assessment will becompleted.
From: Mackey, Chris
Sent: Wednesday, June J1,JO171:S5PK4
To: Talley, Noe||eS Kritzer,
Subject: III response
Sent: Wednesday, June 2l,2D171:51PK4
To: Shehee,Mina
................ ............................
Subject: Re: response
Thanks for the clarification. I would consider the following combination or a portion thereof:
DIIHS is continuing to review all available health data to make sure we are providing the most accurate and
useful information. We are also working with EPA and CDC to get their guidance about health risks of
GenX. EPA is working to update their risk assessment on GenX; it is not known at this time when this
assessment will be completed.
Zack Moore, MD,:N/lPH
State Epidemiologist and Epidemiology Section Chief
Division of Public Health
North Carolina Department of Health and Human Services
919 546 1725 office
I Q 1,33 2P fax (secure)
.......................... .... zack.iiio�)r(,�f'i�dlilis.nc.L)�ov
- - - - ev ----------------------------- — --------
225 N . N— f c D o,,v e I I St.
Rqleigl�, NC 27603
Service Center
.R.q.1.e.igb.,...Nf 22..(,9.92-1.2.02.
On Jun 21, 2017, at 1:35 PM, Shehee, Mina wrote:
My suggestion:
NC DHHS is reaching out to their federal partners for guidance about health risks surrounding
GenX. Currently, EPA is working to update their risk assessment on GenX. It is not known at this time
when this assessment will be completed.
From: Mackey, Chris
Sent: Wednesday, June 21, 2017 1:29 PM
To: Moore, Zack <zack.moore@dhhs,nc.gov>
Cc: Staley, Danny Coleman, Scott <Scott. Col em an @ d h hs. nc.,-r-?>;
Shehee, Mina <nli�i,-),shehee.@dlili,.3.nc.p-ov>
........................................................................ . ........
Subject: RE: response
DEQ-CFW-00078993
Thanks Zack,
Do you think we need to change this sentence to something like:
The EPA is developing an updated health screening level for GenX which should help with this process,
and NC DHHS is also coordinating with the Centers for Disease Control on health screening levels
From: Moore, Zack
Sent: Wednesday, June 21, 2017 1:12 PM
To: Mackey, Chris <C
LhLis, NIackev'@�dhhsncgov>
Cc: Staley, Danny <D..a.n.n. St I Coleman, Scott <Scott.C.o....l.er..11an..Csd�.>;
Shehee, Mina <rr.-inFj,s�ieli:eere€jhhs.€-tc.ROV>
Subject: Re: response
Copying Mina for her awareness of the concerns from this group with our preliminary health
assessment.
I don't know if any specific response is needed, but if so I think the basic message would be that
we are continuing to review all available health data for this chemical to make sure we are
providing the most accurate and useful information. We also work with federal agencies to make
sure our assessments are complete and comprehensive.
Mina and Danny: Please feel free to weigh in if there's anything to add. Thanks.
Zack Moore, MD, MPH
State Epidemiologist and Epidemiology Section Chief
Division of Public Health
North Carolina Department of Health and Human Services
919 546 1725 office
9-1-9 7'-3 0490 fax (secure)
zack.iiioorcf,'� dlilis,nc.L)_ov
225 N . N— f c D o,,v e I I St.
-R-a-l-eigh--N-C 2---7-(-')0}-':3-
-1�9--()22-ma-fl Service Center
27699-1902
......................................................
On Jun 21, 2017, at 12:41 PM, Mackey, Chris wrote:
DEQ-CFW-00078994
I}nyou have any input from our I}f8{Sside nfthe response?
Sent from ooyiPhone
Begin forwarded message:
From: "Tallcy,NoellcS"
Date: June 2L2Ol7a1||:49:4OAJMEDT
To: Chris" i
}onic"
Subject: response
Your thoughts welcomed. I'm heading into ameeting shortly but will be
available by cell.
From: Talley, Noe||e8
Sent: Wednesday, June 21, 2017 11:43 AM
To: Weiner, Sadie Om/en,]enni
; Tarr, Jeremy K4 White,
Julia VV
Subject: RE: Nina Szlosberg-Landis *Time Sensitive*
Based oninfo shared onthe call this morning, here's what |would
suggest xveshare with the Cape Fear Riverkeeper. Thoughts onwhether
this should come from press office or policy office are welcomed.
Thanks for your inquiry. VVeappreciate and share your concerns about
water quality inthe Cape Fear region.
The North Carolina departments ofEnvironmental Quality and Health
and Human Service* are working together closely to Bet answers for the
public about GenX in their water supply. Here is the statement our
office shared with local media last week:
"Clean water isanecessity and families and businesses inthe Cape Fear
region are understandably concerned about their water. Governor
Cooper has asked the Department ofEnvironmental Quality towork
with the Department of Health and Human Services and local officials to
get tothe bottom ofthis immediately, and todemand answers from the
EPA and the company that produces the chemica|."
Last week, DE[\and DHHSannounced ajoint investigation into the
presence ofGenXinthe Cape Fear River. The initial goals ofthe
investigation are toget updated information onlevels ofGenXinthe
river and water supply and the best available information onpotential
health risks itcould cause. Toaccomplish those goals, DE{lbegan this
week collecting water samples for testing byaprivate lab inColorado
and the EPA. Those test results can then beused toanalyze drinking
water safety. The EPA iudeveloping anupdated health screening level
for GenXwhich should help with this process, and N[ DHHS is also
coordinating with the Centers for Disease Control on health screening
VVeshare your questions for [hemoursand DBQand DHH5will continue
topush the company for answers and action asthe state investigation
continues.
From: Talley, Noe||e8
Sent: Wednesday, June 21, 2017 10:35 AM
To: Weiner, Sadie Cole, Samantha
,;Porte�Ford [ ;HoU,
Eric Lhde,]ama| Barker,
Paul WhiteJu|�aVV
Ow/en,]enni Tarr, Jeremy K8
�Childers, Darryl
Subject: RE: Nina Szlosberg-Landis *Time Sensitive*
Here's what megave VVH{R(only media that has asked our office for a
statement on this, to my knowledge).
Clean water iuonecessity and families and businesses iuthe Cape
Fear region are understandably concerned about their water.
Governor Cooper has asked the Department ofEnvironmental
Quality tnwork with the Department nfHealth and Human
Services and local officials toget tothe bottom ofthis
immediately, and to demand answers from the EPA and the
company that produces the chemical.
Noelle Talley
Office of Governor Roy Cooper
Office: 919-814-2101
From: Weiner, Sadie
Sent: Wednesday, June J1,Z0171O:Z9AM
To: Talley, Noe||e8 Cole, Samantha
' Porter Ford [« ' Ho||
' ' ' '
Eric] Lht|e,]ama| ;Barker,
Paul E �VVhik�Ju|iaVV ;
Ow/en,]enni Tarr, Jeremy K8
�Childers, Darryl
Subject: RE: Nina Szlosberg-Landis *Time Sensitive*
VVeshould share the statement w/ehad with her. NoeUecan you
circulate what that was?
From: Talley, Nod|e5
Sent: Wednesday, June 21,2U171O:24AM
To: Cole, Samantha Weiner, Sadie
] Little, Barker, Paul E
White, Julia ;Om/en,
]enni Tarr, Jeremy M
Childers, Darryl D
Subject: RE: Nina 8z|osberg-Landis*Time Sensitive*
K4yunderstanding isthat DHHShad been invited toparticipate ina
public forum hosted bythe Wilmington Sta[/UN['VVnext week. Not
sure this isthe same thing but I'll find out.
Noe||eTaUey
Deputy Communications Director
Office ofGovernor Roy Cooper
Office:919'814'ZlO1
Mobile: 9192lO'l255
From: Cole, Samantha
Sent: Wednesday, June Zl,IO171O:1OAM
To: Weiner, Sadie ;Porter,Fond[
Talley, NoeUeS HoU,
Eric Lhde,]ama| Barker,
Paul
Subject: FW: Nina Szlosberg-Landis *Time Sensitive*
From: Emily Donovan
Sent: Wednesday, June Z1,ZU171O:l3AK8
To: Governor's Press Office
Subject: Nina Sz|osber8-Landis*Time Sensitive*
We're trying to reach Gov. Cooper today before our Community
Forum nnGenX happening TONIGHT a16nmin
Wilmington. The press has been invited. Local public officials
have been invited tnattend from New Hanover and Brunswick
lf possible, hcre are the would like movement or
5pm today:
-WnhovcstrnngcnncorumabnutDHOBS'mouhlichcolth
statement. \�e �inktheir oa}oul@�onm"/erevvrong. Our scientists
inWilmington spoke with [NHBS on Monday and were not
satisfied with [NHDBS'ainability to clarify how the assessed the
known risk. It is my understanding [�F8HS miscalculated the risk
by omagnitude of three. Basically, [>H[H|S imtelling the public that
Gco7{iu lO0Os safer to consume than any PF()A/PF[)S. Wotake
issue with that assessment. WE WANT THAT ROLLED BACK
ASAP!!
- To my knowledge we have not heard any public statements from
Gov. Cooper on this entire issue and that is getting noted. If there
has been one and we missed it, my apologies... information has
been flowing quickly here. If no official statement has been made
to date, we are concerned by that.
- In that public statement we'd like to know that the State is doing
ALL it can to address this concern locally. Chemours released a
public statement yesterday offering to voluntarily halt all discharge
of GenX into our water supply. We have questions surrounding
that.
1. How is Chemours going to capture, remove, and dispose of the
wastewater containing GenX?
2. Sounds like this was a voluntary move on Chemours' part. Yet,
the statement only specified Chemours and not Kuraray or any
other facility at the Fayetteville Works site that has access to the
discharge permit and pipes. Does this mean that there will be NO
GenX discharged in any form or any amount from the facilities in
the DuPont, Chemours, or Kuraray complex at any point in time
from now on? Will Chemours be entering into a consent order to
ensure this is the case?
3. How will Chemours ensure that the drinking water drawn from
the Cape Fear River is safe in the future? What remediation steps
will be imposed on them?
Ultimately, we are asking for a better line of communication
between our local stakeholders and the State officials to ensure
greater transparency on this public health issue.
Here is the press release for tonight's Community Forum. it
outlines our speakers. I look forward to working with you on this
issue.
June 19, 2017
GenX
DEQ-CFW-00078998
Chemours' private, closed door, meeting with government officials
and CFPUA left everyone with more questions than answers. Cape
Fear River Watch is assembling a panel of environmental and
health stakeholders and professionals on Wednesday, June 21 from
6:OOPM - 8:OOPM at the Coastline Convention Center located in
downtown Wilmington for a Community Forum to address public
confusion and concern.
Former Wilmington mayor, Harper Peterson, will moderate this
discussion. The following professionals and educators have signed
on to give public statements and answer questions regarding
emergent contaminants in our shared water supply:
1. Dr. Lawerence Cahoon, PhD professor UNCW (biological
oceanographer)
2. Dr. Susanne Brander, PhD professor UNCW
(ecotoxicologist)
3. Kemp Burdette, Cape Fear Riverkeeper
4. Adam Wagner, StarNews reporter (only reporter invited to
Chemours' meeting).
5. John F. Green 11, attorney
6. Dr. David Hill, M.D. pediatrician at Kidz Care Pediatrics
Efforts are underway to form a coalition of citizens, community
stakeholders, professionals, and educators called Clean Cape
Fear. Find us on Facebook: @CleanCapeFear to partner with us or
follow our efforts.
Cape Fear River Watch, a 501 (c)3 nonprofit organization, has been
working to protect and improve the water quality of the Lower
Cape Fear River Basin through Education, Advocacy, and Action
since 1993. Cape Fear River Watch engages residents of our
watershed through programs to preserve and safeguard our river.
Our Cape Fear Riverkeeper is a member of the Waterkeeper
Alliance, an international clean water advocacy organization.
rdl,, P*N'
y �11'41�,� b
DEQ-CFW-00078999
P*."," ,ae�J sur� offici'al'
Email correspondence to and from this address is subject to the North Carolina Public Records Law and may be
disclosed to third parties by an authorized State official. Unauthorized disclosure of juvenile, health, legally privileged,
or otherwise confidential information, including confidential information relating to an ongoing State procurement effort,
is prohibited by law. If you have received this email in error, please notify the sender immediately and delete all records
of this email.
Y
N
o
DEQ-CFW-00079000