DEQ-CFW_00053766

From: Mick Noland [mickno|andAyfaypwc.com]
Sent: 8/I5/20173:18:45PN1
To: Holman, Sheila [/b=ExchanXeLabs/ou=ExchangeAdministrative Group
(FYD|BOHFI]3PDLT)/cn=Kecipients/cn=94a3f69674d34b759b3bd8]4a97IO5c5-szho|man]
Subject: RE: Call about Dioxane
OK Iwill beout Friday.
Mick
The information contained inthis communication (including any attachment) is privilegedundconfidcnto]
information that iuintended for the sole use nfthe addressee. Access nothis communication bvanyone else im
unauthorized. lfthe reader iunot the intended recipient, oranemployee nragent responsible for delivering this
communication tothe intended recipient, you are hereby notified that any distribution orcopying ofthim
communication is strictly prohibited and may beunlawful. If you have received this transmission in error,
please reply and notify uanfthis error and delete this message. Finally, the recipient should check this
communication and any attachments for the presence of viruses. The Public Works Commission of the City of
Fayetteville, NC, accepts no liability for any damage caused by any virus transmitted by this communication.
From: Holman, Sheila [mailto:[e-mail]',
Sent: Tuesday, August 15, 2017 7:54 AM
To: Mick Noland
Subject: RE: Call about Dioxane
I will contact you later this week to discuss.
Sheila Holman
Assistant Secretary for the Environment
N[DELl
1601 Mail Service Center
Raleigh, N[Z7699'l6O1
Phone/Fax: [phone]
Fnmrn: Mick Noland
Sent: Monday, August 14,JO171U:1JAM
To: Holman, Sheila
Subject: FVV: Call about Dioxane
Hi Sheila,
Not sure how we rnanaged thus far with me having your email entered incorrectly, I'm sure this one will go through.

Thanks, Mick
The information contained in this communication (including any attachment) is privileged and confidential
information that is intended for the sole use of the addressee. Access to this communication by anyone else is
unauthorized. If the reader is not the intended recipient, or an employee or agent responsible for delivering this
communication to the intended recipient, you are hereby notified that any distribution or copying of this
communication is strictly prohibited and may be unlawful. If you have received this transmission in error,
please reply and notify us of this error and delete this message. Finally, the recipient should check this
communication and any attachments for the presence of viruses. The Public Works Commission of the City of
Fayetteville, NC, accepts no liability for any damage caused by any virus transmitted by this communication.
From: Mick Noland
Sent: Friday, August 04, 2017 10:43 AM
To: 'Zimmerman, 3ay (jay.zimmermanOncdenr.gov)'; '[e-mail]'
Cc: 'Shelia Holman (shelia.holman(cbncdenr.go
Subject: FW: Call about Dioxane
Jay/Linda,
Wanted you to be aware of my email to Shelia, I haven't gotten a response. Another editorial today (see highlight). As I
said below in my email to Shelia, "I'm requesting that the State re-evaluate their response to the Dioxane issue to see if
more can be done sooner to get it out of our drinking water."
Thank you for your consideration.
EM
Our View: The fight for a cleaner river needs a strong leader
Thursday
Posted Aug 3, 2017 at 71:43 PM
Share
The river that runs through this region ties together a host of interests, needs and concerns. ANThat happens upstream and
downstream can have a profound effect on our lives.
The Cape Fear is the state's largest and arguably Most Important river basin. It winds through 200 miles of North Carolina, from
the Piedmont, across the edge of the Sandhills and down through the coastal plain, eventually flowing into the Atlantic near
Southport. On its way, the river touches 29 of the state's 100 counties, The basin covers 9,000 square miles. It also is the most
industrialized river basin in the state, which is part of its wealth and its problems.
01-10 institution Is trying to tic together all the interests cif the river basin's residents. The Cape Fear River Assembly was
founded in 1973 to advocate for good management of the river, its tributaries and the land around it. The assembly has kept a
fairly low profile in recent years too low, considering the serious problems that the river and its users are facing. But that
DEQ-CFW-00053767

appears to be changing. The assembly will hold three forums in late September to educate residents about their river and to hear
their concerns. 'Ve'd like people to learn more about the river,"' assembly Executive Director Tom Hoban told an Observer
reporter, "why it's vital to our lives and vital to our economics, and appreciate how sonic decisions individuals make can affbet
the river."
The forums will bring in experts about the river basin to give presentations. Hoban says he expects to hear different concerns
from the river's different regions issues like runoff and new construction III the Triangle area, flooding and water supply in
the Fayetteville area, and fisheries and recreation in the Wilmington area.
We hope, though, that there is also a common thread tying together all of us who live in the river basin: industrial pollution. We
have known for several years now that 1,4-dioxane, a carcinogenic ingredient in paint thinners and other commercial products,
is found in the Cape Fear's water, sometimes at worrisome levels. It appears to be coming from somewhere in the Piedmont,
which means it likely affects most of the basin from which thousands of residents get their drinking water. None of our
municipal water -treatment plants have the
households throughout the basin.
success,
to filter the dioxane out, which means it's coming out of the taps in many
And now we also have GenX, a chemical related to the manufacture of Teflon, which is produced at the former DuPont, now
Chemours, plant on the Cumberland-Bladen count-,, line. It is a likely carcinogen. Researchers have also found manN, related
compounds in river water. Like the dioxanel, there is no practical way to I ifter it out of'our water supply. Residents in the
IA"ill-flington area are outraged, especially by the revelation that the local plant may have been dumping GenX into the river for
three decades. Some of them are holding a protest at the plant site on N.C. 871 today.
In addition to all its other problems, the Cape Fear is an industrial sewer, and residents throughout the basin should be furious.
We find it surprising that they aren't, and that may be from a lack of education. We hope the Cape Fear River Assembly will
provide more or that education and help lead efforts to clean up the river's troubled waters. It should begin with the toxic
industrial chemicals that are flowing out of our faucets. That's the issue that should be at the top of the assembly's agenda at
every one of its meetings.
H'I"['P:IINVWW.FAYORSERVER.('OMIOMINI ON1201708031OLJli,-VIEW-FIGII'I'-FOR-Cl-,f:ANER-RIVER-
NEEDS-STRONG-LEADER
From: Mick Noland
Sent: Tuesday, 3uly 25, 2017 9:10 AM
Subject: Call about Dioxane
DEQ-CFW-00053768

Tried to call, your voice mail was broken up and I couldn't tell what your schedule was. | wanted totalk with you about
the Dioxane initiative. | can't help but observe the way the State rushed to action on GenX, throwing everything you
have at the problem toget the GenXuut ofthe water. | know the Dioxane issue is more complicated, but it's been
months getting equipment, setting standards and sounds like it will be months before letters go out to the suspect cities
to even start monitoring. Add to that there are many more people drinking Dioxane (including Wilmington) than
GenX. Why are the responses to similarly suspect carcinogens so starkly different? | have attached another op-ed piece
that ran this past weekend more or less asking the same question. | think time is running out for the State to act
definitively on Dioxane before it becomes another public relations fiasco for the State (especially considering how long
the State has known about this and still has no monitoring data from the suspect cities or definitive information as to
which industries are discharging the material into the dty'swaste water treatment tsd|ities] Another point is the high
levels that showed up in Pittsborothat were alarming. |'m not sure what their levels are these days. | have attached a
power point presentation that Detlef Kanappe put together relative to a study PWC and other Urban Water Consortium
members funded to try and get some answers rather than waiting on the State to get something going. The levels that
were showing up in Pittsboru were alarming. |'m requesting that the State re-evaluate their response to the Dioxane
issue tosee ifmore can bedone sooner toget itout ofour drinking water.
Thank you for your consideration,
Mick Noland, PE
Chief Operations Officer
Water Resources Division
City of Fayetteville
955 Old Wilmington Road
Fayetteville, NC 28302