HomeMy WebLinkAbout20140990 Ver 1 _PermitNoncomplianceLetter _20170823U.S. ARMY CORPS OF ENGINEERS
Wilmington District
Action ID: SAW -2014-01878
County: A
NOTIFICATION OF UNAUTHORIZED ACTIVITY / PERMIT NONCOMPLIANCE
Property Owner / Responsible
Party Avery County Fire Commission
Attn.: Mr. Johnny Mathes
Address P.O. Box 160
Plumtree, NC 28644
Telephone Number 828-260-5957
Size and Location of Property (waterbody, Highway name/number, town, etc.): The site located at
the Frank Volunteer Fire Department, at 699 North 19E Hwy, near Newland, North Carolina. Coordinates
are: 36.0792 N and -82.0023 W.
Description of Unauthorized Activity / Permit Noncompliance: The Corps issued a general permit
verification (Nationwide Permit 39) on November 18, 2014 which authorized the placement of fill/pipe in
82 linear feet of stream channel and 0.01 acre of wetlands for the construction of an entrance/access to a
new firehouse. The Corps has found the permittee to be in noncompliance with the issued general permit
verification. There is approximately 240 linear feet of perennial stream channel and 0.02 acre of wetlands
that have been filled and the work that was conducted does not match the plans that were submitted and
subsequently approved. The work as described above is complete and there is no on-going construction
activities on the site. Please see attached site sketch for reference and note that this is an approximate
sketch/depiction based on an August 16, 2017 site visit/meeting.
Indicate Which of the Following Apply:
Unauthorized Activity River and Harbor Act, Section 10 (33 USC 403)
X Noncompliance with Permit X Clean Water Act, Section 301 (33 USC 1311)
Unless you have a Department of the Army Permit for the above described activity, it is a violation of
federal law as specified above. You have agreed to do no further work in waters or wetlands without the
required Department of the Army Permit. Any further unauthorized work in waters or wetlands will be
considered an intentional violation of federal law. If you do no further work in waters and wetlands, and
perform the remedial action requested below, the Corps of Engineers will take no further action in this
matter. If you continue to work in waters and wetlands without the required authorization, and/or fail to
perform the requested remedial action, the Corps will take further administrative action, and may request
the U.S. Attorney to file suit against you. If you need further information about the Corps of Engineers
regulatory program, please contact Amanda Jones at telephone number 828-271-7980 ext 4225.
Remedial Action Required:
A new permit application needs to be submitted requesting authorization to allow all or a portion of the
unauthorized fill to remain in place. Updated/current plans should be submitted that clearly shows and
calculates impacts to scale and the purposes for those impacts. Any application should include avoidance
and minimization discussions as to the need for the large amount of impervious area (to include parking
and helipad uses) for which the stream/wetland appears to have been filled. This application should also
include a compensatory mitigation plan that will adequately compensate for any proposed impacts beyond
150 linear feet of stream channel. Information in the form of stream quality assessment forms (i.e.
NCSAM) should be submitted to document any mitigation ratio below 2:1 for proposed permanent stream
impacts. If on-site removal of a portion or all of the fill material is proposed, then a plan needs to be
submitted to show/calculate which areas will be restored and how these impacted areas will be restored to
pre -construction contours. If restoration is proposed, then a monitoring plan should be submitted as well.
The above information should be submitted by September 29, 2017 to avoid referral of this matter to the
U.S. Attorney and/or Environmental Protection Agency for administrative penalties and/or civil action.
Please contact me at the email/phone number below if there are any questions or if you would like to request
additional time to respond to this matter.
We also recommend that you contact Mr. Andrew Moore at the North Carolina Division of Water Resources
to determine any additional permitting requirements associated with a 401 Water Quality Certification such
as storm water detention/treatment. His address is noted below and can be reached at (828) 296-4500.
Your signature acknowledges receipt of this notification. Return a signed copy of this notification to
the Asheville Regulatory Field Office.
US Army Corps of Engineers -Wilmington District
Attn.: Amanda Jones
Asheville Regulatory Field Office
151 Patton Avenue, Room 208
Asheville, NC 28801
amanda.i ones(a,usace.army.mil
828-271-7980 extension 4225
Property Owner / Responsible Party/Agent Signature
FOR THE COMMANDER
Scott Jones, Asheville Regulatory Field Office Chief
Date August 23, 2017
CF:
NC DEQ-DWR, Andrew Moore, 2090 US Highway 70, Swannanoa, NC 28778 (via email)
snWtor3
1
ANNA WATSON
DEEDBOOK 100,PAGE 12,9 1 ZION
RESIDENTIAL USE { IET
" M1
MAT
WAN
}
/-0, CL1
CFWTEA 1r w1w9 a�lli
IMJ,rFD9p 1A' W . .
} 1.iP :AOFI►R �\ WELL � • • `
14LL. FRIM b � 7 • t`
?���,•�'_ _ r 'fit•
1111E
ANNA
SIFT �PpWE ' � L
�r '
Di ac
Di ac
.
W, Iw1Ejs
\\
inDr20
1
-CRED1 \•
-
- —
111111w1w
cFN1EA ur.w n
L �
nr,E,0lYtnl:ArED 7,
'
-
\\
S dr y
F1mu norl iwYY
r3un0
� -"'- - . •y-�1
u7tor.
-,v MY—
- nEr•cw
RM�
�.
ANNA WATSON 11 F MFR F
DEED EK" 138, PAGE 1072 1 4 L
eau-ua62 1
TRACT TWO
MAP BOOK 18, PAGE 101
•^'SON M=,�� -
I -
rennial ' (.
RPW
RESIOE"AI USE 1 0.86ACRE
1 FRANK VOL. FIRE DEPT.
DEED BOOM 4pG.
^' PAGE 1884
1'.la 0201.2"6311
RESIDENTIAL USE
rnMvrD
„r\ glr.,MwrY7
,nanr4r hlSrrl amour PDQ
u,nolsa.
fOFSt�tIG;
1
1> )r
1P
1S
CwP
NUInvAY
+ � . ,41�
FRANK V.F.D, Inc.
DEED BOOK 119. PAGE 4%
< SURVEY BY ROBERT E. GRIN D31
\ PLS1.1294
DATED llll=ER B. 1979
9'.1792415
1 .structure
/
to be
DEED BOOK 118, PAGE 240
SUIRVEY BY ROBERT F. GRINDSTAFF
PLS L-1294
DATED AUGUST 28, 1979
LOT
Reg
rDENTIAL USE
TO
[y F
'41Yq
J O $ T¢j0. }S
0:
o..ww.�_ww�.....v<
o Hrix
C
j .mon
O
r rima»*»w .Dn3 �r4».«arw.rw LL
a wrr rwr`wwww.rrm Y
LL
.„.F,wit4F U
- --- adweO Bromlvwsu•..WOF4Wl w
AKri»Y».idrrNDx uiDUFMt.»cxdl['.wrcwaawaJlEYIA 0.rnrmwDwid
� htlrow,frdluHM»»<w.taac:nnuw». dv,n'»tro,oa_«»mw»a rrerears
.t ••aexr, i L t
�C�M �.V� �rv,�riOlwiWlwb.Wd,IM!>liwYY.rl r�Frr nfRemm�m
v
-
wrn+e we'0r`rav wam��w.w' ssoe.,.�w...._nruwa«ar"�"iw�� 4
.wo3?'-•.r�ream w.r�n.r ivu`':rarin.�wav,rewa cnsu.,:�asaa $ITE GRADNG
va.:eee: Arc(N,dr�w•MR,rs /,ND FROSM
x�Sw.nw»ua+.darty vzwSw OONTROL S;AN
OWN 5-1
SCALE
ltmpadY blain UIIN aM,KrF,r ar A1r». ve-»oR SlwrS,w,r S 7 C^
L
SIFT �PpWE ' � L
�r '
Di ac
Di ac
.
W, Iw1Ejs
,w
`1
I ?alp.�1.
111111w1w
41D'<
RtOP71E INOII
rNa EOLrw
.
- nEr•cw
RM�
�.
(jam p;>•' rnvrm
TERRY WILSON
Imo Io
DEED BOOK 118, PAGE 240
SUIRVEY BY ROBERT F. GRINDSTAFF
PLS L-1294
DATED AUGUST 28, 1979
LOT
Reg
rDENTIAL USE
TO
[y F
'41Yq
J O $ T¢j0. }S
0:
o..ww.�_ww�.....v<
o Hrix
C
j .mon
O
r rima»*»w .Dn3 �r4».«arw.rw LL
a wrr rwr`wwww.rrm Y
LL
.„.F,wit4F U
- --- adweO Bromlvwsu•..WOF4Wl w
AKri»Y».idrrNDx uiDUFMt.»cxdl['.wrcwaawaJlEYIA 0.rnrmwDwid
� htlrow,frdluHM»»<w.taac:nnuw». dv,n'»tro,oa_«»mw»a rrerears
.t ••aexr, i L t
�C�M �.V� �rv,�riOlwiWlwb.Wd,IM!>liwYY.rl r�Frr nfRemm�m
v
-
wrn+e we'0r`rav wam��w.w' ssoe.,.�w...._nruwa«ar"�"iw�� 4
.wo3?'-•.r�ream w.r�n.r ivu`':rarin.�wav,rewa cnsu.,:�asaa $ITE GRADNG
va.:eee: Arc(N,dr�w•MR,rs /,ND FROSM
x�Sw.nw»ua+.darty vzwSw OONTROL S;AN
OWN 5-1
SCALE
ltmpadY blain UIIN aM,KrF,r ar A1r». ve-»oR SlwrS,w,r S 7 C^
L