HomeMy WebLinkAbout20240175 Ver 1_Add Info Recvd_20240312Homer, Seren M
From: David Brown <david@jenningsenv.com>
Sent: Tuesday, March 12, 2024 5:27 PM
To: Fuemmeler, Amanda J CIV USARMY CESAW (USA)
Cc: Homer, Seren M; Zan Price
Subject: [External] Re: Mouth of Hardin Creek Restoration Queston/Comment
Attachments: Revised Sheet 2.3 and 2.4 Mouth of Hardin Creek Permit Drawing Revised March 12..pdf
CAUTION: External email. Do not click links or open attachments unless verified. Report suspicious emails with the Report Message button
located on your Outlook menu bar on the Home tab.
Amanda,
Sorry for the delay in responding to your comment. Attached are revised plan sheets 2.3 & 2.4 which show the
stormwater outfalls you noted. On the revised sheets these outfalls flow into a floodplain depression & are no longer a
ditched feature. This is similar to what we constructed on Holly Branch at the Mayland Community College site. This
revision does not change proposed impacts to streams & wetlands. Let me know if you have questions or additional
comments.
Thanks,
David
David Brown, PG
Sr. Geologist, Environmental Services Leader I Jennings Environmental, PLLC
828384 1890
david@jenningsenv.com
iAsheville, NC 'enningseny.com
0
im
This information is confidential and is intended solely for use by the recipient and others authorized to receive it. Any disclosure, copying, distribution or taking action in
relation to this information is strictly prohibited and may be unlawful.
From: Fuemmeler, Amanda J CIV USARMY CESAW (USA) <Ama nda.Jones@usace. army. mit>
Date: Friday, March 1, 2024 at 2:25 PM
To: David Brown <david@jenningsenv.com>
Subject: Mouth of Hardin Creek Restoration Queston/Comment
Mr. Brown,
Hope all is well. Just looking through the PCN and noticed the plan sheet with the stormwater outfalls (attached). Any way to
incorporate having the wetlands/flood plain out there be able to treat/dissipate this versus what is being proposed as a ditch
draining directly to the creek. I'm assuming the current conditions is just that so seems like a good opportunity to correct this if
possible. Thanks for the consideration!
Amanda Jones
Project Manager
US Army Corps of Engineers
Asheville Regulatory Field Office
828-271-7980 ext. 4225
b
W
co
cn
Of
r
z
0
Of
r
co
WIN— 0 A.
r,
.�Ev. IRW IN\
7,T ARMOR STORMWATER
Uji now
e-
R
Me yft- - �y Mr
CONVEYANCE WITH
? to
9M TYP. FLOODPLAIN
—: Z7—'Z: "
NCDOT CLASS 1 RIPRAP
DEPRESSION
A
!�'Aft 4 ft;� �� \ , —_ - ;a W-"-
TO,
At
0�'
7V =7
-�BB
;
i
so Ono
0 0 gicHUR-M-ft
0:111111
assum
owns -
some
ON
.800
"I
monsoon
EMMONS
,mono
SEEM..
PEI%
Samoa as
loommomon
osmosis
M
0 oplaw
MIN -ib - LES!
:m .�1.0000 100
5*gtommmmmmoffim on
museum: a
so ME asom
SEE no, OEM
son
On
01
hii
mono
sm--Eg.m.:.
:11:1�;" 10111 osommosonsbl::
Boom
MOONS
IN s s
........ IS IS 11 0_1 I I is is is in in 1
WIN
so a 1100:1:0slimn
millogim gis
main
0::Inllnll
Imemommummom
... Wiliam so
molown -6000- :Mason 16600 M,,Immsmnmmmmsanm Wiiiialb
Soo
SEE -------- Not" I A BE :4
is
6+00
3100 4—
3095
3090
3085
KIT-Iff
6+'00
cy)
Lq
IN
cl? cy)
cy') (Z)
CN M
(_0
LU
_j
0- LU
co
CD
0-)
CO CD
N co
co
Uj
_j
a_ Uj
1.19%
00
0.00%
7 00
8+00
9+00
1 +00
1 +100
12 00
I
I
I
1
11
3100
CN
00
M
I-
It
1
00
00
00
c�
U?
7
rl-�
IN
co
IN
co
T_
I-
co
T_
M
CD
LO
CD
o)
6
00
cl�
C6
c?
r--:
C?
r_�
(6
M
M
M
M
00
00
00
00
r'_
00
r_
00
M
00
00
C)
C)
C)
c)
C)
CO
C)
r-_
C)
U-)
C)
C)
M
C)
C)
00
C)
M
CO
U-)
co
C:)
CO
Itt
co
00
CO
n
M
0)
M
+
co
+
CO
+
co
+
CO
+
+
r__
>
+
oo
+
00
+
00
+
0')
+
M
C)
CD
Uj
W
Uj
W
Uj
W
Uj
W
a_
W
a_
W
a_
W
a_
W
a_
W
a_
W
a_
W
a_
LU
0-
LU
0-
LU
0-
LU
-2-36 �r,
0
PR.BANKFULL
�50 %
0.00
I
0�0
0.00% � �16
-1.995,
Z 0
EX. STORMWATER
OUTFALL (TYP.)
EX. GRO UND
PR. THALWEG
0.00
I I I
Nt
I I I
cr)
Cy)
C)
00
00
00
Lr)
Cy)
L0
L0
M
c\1
a)
00
IN
0�
00
Nt
(7) m
00 0?
1-
00 LO
r- cq
(D
1
(.0
Lr)
C)
00
00
00
00
00
00
00
00
00
00
(0
CD 0c)
CD
C) I,-
C) C)
C) (Z)
C)
C) CO
C) P
CD
CD
+
CO cy)
CO LO
co +
CO C)
CO -It
co +
cy) 0c)
cy) cy)
co +
CO
+
(D
+
r'-
+
00
+
00
.. 00
>
:�; +
00
:�; +
cy)
.. Cy)
>
bi
i
Uj 0-
LU
_j
Uj a_
C)
L-U,
Uj
LU
_j
Uj a_
LU 6
_j
Uj 0-
Uj
_j
Uj
bi
_j
Uj a_
Uj
_j
LU a_
Uj
_j
LU
bi
_j
LU
7+00 8+00 9+00
-1.99
0.00% RY
: -1 %
L.-52
03
No.o"'O%��"'o
-0-86%
3095
3090
KIT-W
KIT -ore.
c\1
LO
co
T_
LO
00
It
oo
00 r'_
c\1
rl-
0') LO
IN
0')
LO CD
0?
00
Lo .
't CO
CO 0�
t
1,-
00
00 r'_
CID r'_
CID r1_
00 (0
CO 0-)
CID
C)
C) +
C) 0-)
C) It
C) +
C) 00
C)
a)
CO +
co CD
CO +
CO +
co
co +
CO
+
0)
C)
>
>
Uj
Uj
Uj
Uj
Uj
LU
LU
_j
_j
_j
_j
_j
_j
_j
a_
Uj a_
Uj
Uj a_
Uj a_
Uj
Uj a_
Uj
10+100 11+100 12+100
NU I Lzb:
2 CL N
0 <
1. CONTRACTOR TO IDENTIFY AND
PROTECT EX. UTILITIES. z
-777-12.
f>
<
ct
cn
0�
0
DISTURBANCE OF WETLANDS,
z
TREES, AND/OR WOODY VEGETATION
ED
0
Z
0
Uj
SHALL BE KEPT TO MINIMUM EXTENT
>_
co
�z
0
PRACTICAL TO COMPLETE WORK.
W
0
co
LU
Z
0
co
RESTORE ACCESS PATHS AND
z
co
STORAGE AREA(S) TO ORIGINAL
CONDITION UPON COMPLETION OF
c'
W
>
0
THE PROJECT OR UPON SUCH TIME
AS DIRECTED BY THE PROJECT
OWNER AND ENGINEER.
ON —SITE ROCK MATERIAL MAY BE
REUSED FOR STRUCTURES, AT THE
DIRECTION OF THE ENGINEER.
CONSTRUCTED RIFFLE CAN BE
REPLACED WITH WOODY RIFFLE OR
ENHANCED HABITAT RIFFLE, AT THE
APPROVAL OF THE ENGINEER.
TOE WOOD TO EXTEND 10'INTO
DOWNSTREAM RIFFLE BANK. TOE
WOOD CAN BE REPLACED WITH
ROCK TOE, AT THE APPROVAL OF
THE ENGINEER.
7. FLOODPLAIN DEPRESSIONS TO NOT
EXCEED 18" BELOW BANKFULL
ELEVATION. LOCATION SUBJECT TO
CHANGE AT THE DIRECTION OF THE
ENGINEER.
SHEET INDEX
<
C)
C)
z
+
Z
Z
-:]
CN
D
L
D
0
9r—
0
c)
0
z
0
<
C)
(D
C:)
0
(D
3:
z
c)
+
F
C/)
D
<
F
0�
—
�:
Qc)
Lu
0
<
<
cf)
<
Z
U)
Z
LL,
z
�e
LU
0
W
0�
LLJ
z
0
LU
0�
C)
LU
0
LLJ
0
z
13�
00
a_
LL
0
C)
LL
0
00
I—
0�
Z
z
<
z
0
n
7 SAMUEL ASHE DRIVE
ASHEVILLE, NC 28805
DATE: 3/12/2024
SCALE (34"X22"): ill = 30'
SCALE (1 7"X1 1 "): ill = 60'
0 30 60
SCALE IN FEET
PR HARDIN CREEK - SCALE: HOR 1" = 30'; VERT 1" = 3' SHEET NUMBER
NOT TO
SCALE 2.3
A
7
1>
4,
N, -n -S
>
Q
i f
r
f
J,
Z' V_
TYP. FLOODPLAIN 4� 4__
I 'I
Aw
DEPRESSION
D(i
'_X
% Nor 10
VX\ oe
N"OV111 '"N SAN
SAN
lo x
i N V, C,
SAN
SAN
7SA:
lip ["%a M Now
4 SAN
SAN F\NA\( k,
0
% N ------- J
P, C/) /'y' '00""�� \ I I 'x
:ol\ F
py
'T
A
FPT
A1 v TIE OUT TO SOUTH
PT\\ -1 -' '- 11�
uy FORK NEW RIVER
0- ro 7
cy)
C14
20
C14 01 GRADE BANKS 4:1
't Jjj
C14
CD DOWNSTREAM OF
N
C4
SEWER CROSSING
Y
3\ —.v\
o' I
4/'o TYP. ROCK TOE
=3 FP_ MIX OF NCDOT CLASS 1
'70 ------ 11 �rp*
:PT
y
ui & CLASS B ROCK TO
0 1101 FWAY ------------- FWAY -
BE PACKED AROUND
_j
Ir
\N,
A(
PIERS IN CHANNEL
411*�\ N TYP. CONSTRUCTED RIFFLE
C) s I
uj
00 two is m
TYP. LOG J-HOOK VANE BOULDER J-HOOK. CHANNEL
PR BRIDGE CROSSING. logo imp I f \'
� I BED ON RIGHT SIDE TO BE
w w mot' cn I
SEE SHEET 2.5 _14\ I. I I >
TYP. TOE WOOD 0.5'HIGHER THAN LEFT.
w Mg ON -16— —
-n
v
to
0')
b
w
co
C/)
0�
r
z
r
co
X_
121100
13+100
14+100
15+�00
6+100
17+100
co
't
00
9
CIO
't
o?
11
CD
q
Lo
co
co
11
m
G�
m
Iq
3095
O� co,
G� Lo'
Lo
co
co
r*-: C_�
cq C)
CD
m 00
m C)
"t 00
"t C)
(D co
co C)
CD CO
CN C)
co co
rl_ CD
00
CD
co 00
m 0
00 co
'�t C)
co 00
m CD
C) 00
c\1 C)
+ co
+ co
+ co
+ co
+ co
+ co
+ co
+ co
+ co
+ co
CN
M
co
Lo
Lo
co
co
I
LU
_j
Lu
_j
LU
_j
Lu
_j
uj
_j
ui
_j
LU
_j
ui
_j
Lu
_j
ui
_j
a_ ui
a_ ui
a_ ui
a_ w
a_ ui
0- ui
a_ Lu
a_ Lu
a_ ui
0- ui
c'? c�
co 00
CD 00
+ CD
co
3090
>
ui
U) Lu
-0-86%
—7-
3085 —
-.05%
PR.BANKFULL
Q�o -2.00%
0.00%
(b.
0\0
-2.130
Yo
143 �o
1%
col�j
3080
0. 00%
-2-29%
EX. TRAIL CULVERT
131%
TO BE REMOVED
I
PR. THALWEG
TYP. LOG J-HOOK VANE
1
1
3075 --
I
I
EX.
GROUND
12+00
CD
00
C)
_j
a_ ui
7 0
3095
r 3090
SANITARY SEWER
LINE SUSPENDED
OVER CHANNEL
� 3085
3080
3075
Lo
co
It
CN
rl-
1
00
m
rl-
co
't
N
N
Lo
co
r--
r-�
N
00
N
(D
(o
o?
m
cli
c� C's
cy�
c�
06
m co
r.
6
CD
00 7
m 00
00 00
r-- co
00
co
00 00
00 4
00 co
00 CD
00 CD
00 co
00
C)
r'-
00 co
rl-
N
r'- 00
r'- (D
r- CD
r- CD
r-
co
CD +
CD "T
CD co
CD +
CD N
CD r__
CD
+
CD
CD a)
0
+
CD -'t
CD M
CD +
CD N
CD
+
m
co +
co +
m
M +
M +
co
Lo
Co +
M +
m
M +
M +
M r'_
M +
M
N
'r__
:�;
co
co
IV-
Lo
V_
Lo
IV-
co
V_
co
'-
—
>
> I-
>
LU
Lu
Lu
uj
Lu
uj
uj
ui
ui
LU
ui
ui
uj 0
uj
uj
_j
_j
_j
_j
_j
_j
_j
_j IL:
_j
_j
_j
_j
_j —
_j
_j
0-
Lu
Lu 0-
Lu 0-
Lu
Lu 0-
Lu 0-
Lu
Lu a_
Lu 0-
Lu
Lu a_
Lu a-
Lu 2
Lu a-
Lu
13+00 14+00 15+00 16+00 17+00 18+00
NOTES: m
N
<
1. CONTRACTOR TO IDENTIFY AND
PROTECT EX. UTILITIES. z
2.
3.
f>
<
ct
cn
0�
0
DISTURBANCE OF WETLANDS,
z
TREES, AND/OR WOODY VEGETATION
ED
0
Z
0
ui
SHALL BE KEPT TO MINIMUM EXTENT
�z
0
PRACTICAL TO COMPLETE WORK.
W
0
co
Lu
Z
0
co
RESTORE ACCESS PATHS AND
Q)
z
co
STORAGE AREA(S) TO ORIGINAL
CONDITION UPON COMPLETION OF
c'
w
>
0
THE PROJECT OR UPON SUCH TIME
>
w
AS DIRECTED BY THE PROJECT
OWNER AND ENGINEER.
4.
ON -SITE ROCK MATERIAL MAY BE
00
REUSED FOR STRUCTURES, AT THE
>_
1_
<
z
m
+
DIRECTION OF THE ENGINEER.
z
z
_j
r*-_
Ir-
o
D
u
o
0
z
5.
CONSTRUCTED RIFFLE CAN BE
FZ
<
10
CD
REPLACED WITH WOODY RIFFLE OR
0�
0
(D
m
z
C)
+
ENHANCED HABITAT RIFFLE, AT THE
co
<
APPROVAL OF THE ENGINEER.
w
Ill-
<
0
<
<
F---
c/)
�:
co
Z
0
6.
TOE WOOD TO EXTEND 10'INTO
LIJ
uj
ui
Z
y
uj
C)
DOWNSTREAM RIFFLE BANK. TOE
0�
UJ
0
yj
0�
O�
WOOD CAN BE REPLACED WITH
0
z
ui
0�
0
co
ui
a_
0
o
u_
ROCK TOE, AT THE APPROVAL OF
—
0
u-
0
z
I_
0
THE ENGINEER.
<
Z
Z
Z
�:
<
7.
FLOODPLAIN DEPRESSIONS TO NOT
0
EXCEED 18" BELOW BANKFULL
ELEVATION. LOCATION SUBJECT TO
CHANGE AT THE DIRECTION OF THE
ENGINEER.
SHEET INDEX
7 SAMUEL ASHE DRIVE
ASHEVILLE, NC 28805
DATE: 3/12/2024
SCALE (34"X22"): ill = 30'
SCALE (1 7"X1 1 "): ill = 60'
0 30 60
SCALE IN FEET
PR HARDIN CREEK - SCALE: HOR 1 " = 30'; VERT 1 " = 3'
NOT TO
SCALE
SHEET NUMBER
2.4