Loading...
HomeMy WebLinkAboutWQ0004268_Meeting Notes_20151202MEETING SUBJECT: Sager Creek LOCATION: DATE&TIME: Attendees MEETING ATTENDEES LIST 6th Floor Conference Room/FRO December 2, 2015 (Wednesday) @ 10:00 am Affiliation Phone Ema no ,S. //enS o/i) fllr,190 063 g Vi -/..2 beiindo, /news 0 / ,4 hAD/ Lwt 4,47Amma. -7;>0,9fA84e-a--40. .i..),e 9/7- 607- 6933 aaWituii4.4. 1-114vae Ac4r Ger,./ eitc c,-(--eviii 047 AVVis_50e,fels 79°---4 7--103"7, R.0) ill el c ei 5 5.6 c Gig 4,i --n en K A 1 ..,#e,c,aney Z c,l NA Dr) 4(247.- .76C-C?a3 s, SS 4-4 en . Cuti 0 '0 t 1 enz4c AI& fig --cal 3/ ts 2 - 236---- opoz4.5- oseveezio. (Pe9in "6*, Ao4.2-9- 446(4/6 • frei_rz D If twrevaa. 5 3-P - 5--/-- 307 4-iiP/7, briz-e&de/m.oPtee. ' 7/7- .4//s. Ai /"./eb6Q.. fit' • • eN . • 1- t 4-....C...-- f l Co - - - - , a 4! , d ID cue- tf--cos c ye_ /.1 feed i d t 9, • , a '/ /710121C ( 9%7 9: - C . Je64k ' Moen 0 S'axof_o.co,;, irmisiW• 1..rbEZ? 9\ to -433- 3331 tout.&jaitfe facaorl ev. a-cern, DEL MONTE FOODS Allen L Mize Director Agriculture and Technical Services Vegetable Operations 451 Willis Ave Rochelle, IL 61068 815-562-1303 412-320-7193 efax 830-591-6307 cell 830-278-7562 home Allen.Mize@delmonte.com 0 Del Monte Foods, Inc. David Vogl, P.E. • 600 North 15th Street Regional Environmental Manager Rochelle, IL 61068-1002 815-562-1367 P 815-761-1057 C david.vogl@delmonte.com Cultivating Good Food for a Better Life"m Barber, Jim From: Barber, Jim. Sentc Wednesday,! December 02, 2015 4:09 PM -To: 'allen.mize@delmonte.com' Cc: Henson, Belinda (belihda.henson@ncdenr.gov); Honeycutt, Tony,. Subject: Meeting information: Attachments: 2015'Agronmist report and recommendations Sager Creek.Sampson.pdf, Lundy 14 Fert rates 2012.pdf Allen; Attached is the last agronomist evaluation report provided to the Division during out site visit earlier this year. The scanned document hasseveral highlighted areas that provide recommendations to Sager Creek concerning the addition of amendments for soil and crop health: Also there is a-recom..me..ndation.concern.ing reseeding (o.rs riggin if preferred) if bermuda.grass in bare. areas (specific fields not identified, but it appears as a wholesale.recommendation.for the -site). - - A's Sager. Creek. operates the waste management system, an.operational record and maintenance record needs to be.. maintainedto document activities undertaken. at the facility. The agronomist recommendations in the' attached report,. if followed and performed, should be noted in the operation record for inspection by DWR staff during an inspection. An example of.the information placed in the operational record is below: date or dates of activities amounts of amendments applied -(consistent with the recommendation, to; include .lime addition when needed) labeling information of amendments applied applies jSager Creek, farmer,:Crop Production Services,.etc: = see.attached CPS report for Lundy.1-8)' monitoring. wells sampled, along'with effluent sampled. by lab/Sager Creek/third party contractor contacting farmer for hay removal - Maintenance records should note activities related to wastewater equipment used by Sager Creek. Examples of noted activities are -replacing spray heads/risers is specific fields,'calibration data for solid set fields and hard. hose -traveling . guns (a,t least once per permit cycle of five years), aeration of fields, reseeding/sprigging of bermuda in fields/zones, etc. Here are the contacts for the Divisiomof Waste Management— Solid Waste Sectioh,.for perm itting-information concerning -land applying vegetable pieces: http://"portal.ncdenr.ore/c/document library/get .file?uuid=ec8a7812-8d7d-4856-8d53-c496OfO98ad9&groupld=383'61 The main contact is Tony Gallagher, -branch supervisor, at 919-707-8280 or tony.gallagher@ncdenr.gov. As discussed .during out -site visit -of the plant back in. November;: here is the information concerning tax.certification for equipment:used exclusively (100%) fo.r. recycling activities related to managing vegetable.pieces, metal and paper/cardboard recycling: http://Portai.ncdent.org/web/­­wm`/­­sw/­takcert ' r If you have air quality permits for equipment at the plant; here is the link for.tax certification with the Division of -Air Qu.ality(httb:i/d6g.statL.nc.us/contact ). It appears that you .need to contact the regional office concerning the Air Quality tax certification process. The regional office supervisor to contact is -Steve Vozzo at 910-433-3361 or steven.vozzo@ncdenr.gov. The wastewater infrastructure. also can. receive tax certification thru the Division of Water Resources for equipment used exclusively for.wastewater management. Here's the link to DWIt (http:%/portal.ncdenr._ore/web/wq/swp/ps/npdes/tax- certification ): Here are a.couple more useful links we:discussed during the meeting this morning: https://sampson.ces..ncsu.edu/ (NC State ag. extension). . http://www.ncagr.gov/agronorhi/`uvrwaste.hten (waste analysis; vegetable pieces) http //www.ncagr.aov/agronomi/rah6me.htm;(NCDA regional agronomist list) . . As you reviewthe provided information; if you have any questions or wish.to discuss; please call the 910-433-3340 or email me. Thanks Jim. Barber. Environmental Engineer NCDENR=DWR-APS Fayetteville *Reg ional.Office 910-433-3340 voice 916 486-0707 fax jim.barber(a)_ncdenr.gov - E-mail correspondence to and from this address may be subject to the North Carolina -Public Records Law and may be disclosed to third. parties.. Go Green! Print this email only when necessary. Thank you for helping NCDENR be environmentally responsible. SAGER CREEK VEGETABLE COMPANY, TURKEY, NC PROCESS WATER SYSTEMS CORRECTIVE ACTION PLANNING MEETING NC DEPARTMENT OF ENVIRONMENTAL QUALITY FAYETEVILLE/RALEIGH, NC December 2, 2015 Meeting Purpose The purpose of this meeting is to review and discuss the existing factory process water systems, discharge permit, and known irrigation management system limitations for crafting a Special Order by Consent ("SOC") to bring the system back into full compliance with lagoon freeboard requirements on a year-round basis as well as into" compliance with all operations and maintenance requirements in the facility's discharge permit (including but not limited to maintaining site fields in a state where ponding and runoff is not a day-to-day concern particularly during the late fall and winter season months). Corrective Action and Implementation Plan Goals We seek the regulatory flexibility and time to complete a comprehensive corrective action and implementation plan for our newly acquired factory by December 31, 2016. The plan will define current site limitations, identify short as well as longer term corrective action needs, and include a schedule for fully implementing the required corrective actions as soon as it is technically and fiscally feasible. The corrective action plan may include different processing of crops, reduced plant production, modified or new storage ponds, new spray irrigation fields, changes to factory manufacturing practices, in -plant water flow reductions, or some combination of all of these actions to bring systems back into hydraulic balance moving into future years. The schedule provided in the implementation plan will be structured to allow our factory to properly budget, design, and implement any new systems without interrupting on -going plant production required to sustain our business during the implementation phases of the project. A. INTRODUCTIONS B. QUICK REVIEW OF SITE TREATMENT AND MANAGEMENT SYSTEMS (REFRESHER FOR THOSE NOT FAMILIAR WITH THE SITE) 1) Vegetable Processing Factory (current factory packing include green beans, sweet potatoes, russet potatoes, various other greens, and dry beans) 2) Permitted Daily Flow = 415,000 GPD (Monthly Average) 3) Process Water Treatment (in sequence): • Screening (with off -site management of screenings as cattle feed at two farms) • Anaerobic/Primary Settling Pond (-3-acres and listed working capacity 50 MG) • Treated Water Storage Pond (-27-acres)* • Spray Fields Zones 1-18a (66.76-acres) plus A-D (100.30-acres) = 167.07-irrigable acres 4) Process Water Flow Monitoring Stations (Discharges Metered to Upper Anaerobic/Primary Settling Lagoon and to Spray Fields)",*** 5) Groundwater Monitoring Wells (13 Monitoring Wells) Sager Creek/NCDEQ Meeting Agenda Page 2 of 6 6) Maximum Annual Hydraulic Application Rates by Field (Various by Field = 9.26 — 65.62 inches) 7) Maximum Annual Plant Available Nitrogen Summer (Various by Field = 200-300 lbs. N/ac) 8) Maximum Annual Plant Available Nitrogen Winter (All Fields = 50 lbs. N/ac) This lagoon may actually cover more than 27-acres based on our recent review of the pond layout but this needs to be verified through an on -site survey. Further, current lagoon depths need to be factored for planning purposes. **Flow meter at lift station in rear of factory and at new pump station at lower water storage pond. ***Plant sanitary wastewater flows to the plant lagoons are currently not being metered and screened wastewater being returned to the plant for gutter flushing is not being metered (return flows to the plant are now being estimated at—100,000 GPD and this estimated flow is now being subtracted from the flows being metered at the factory lift station for reporting on the factory monthly DMR) "Permit does not define winter. CAN WE EXPECT MORE RESTRICTIVE OR ANY DIFFERENT REQUIREMENTS IN A RENEWED WASTEWATER IRRIGATION SYSTEM PERMIT (WHICH IS PENDING RENEWAL)? C. COMPLIANCE UPDATE 1) Current Operations Lagoon Levels* 2) Daily Process Wastewater Discharges 3) Current Site Field Conditions • Rye grass (surface disked and broadcast seeded) into Bermuda Grass this Fall per Tony Honeycutt's instructions (this seeding technique will be followed moving forward to ensure best winter cover) • It is very difficult to drill seed at the site due to the scattered nature of the site solid sets (the solid sets do not line-up in neat square blocks for easy maneuvering of tractors and farm implements) • Fields fall planted Oct. 11— 26 • Much improved/better rye grass cover this year (this is probably due to the improved planting technique recommended by Tony Honeycutt) • Height of rye grass currently at > 2-inches • Annual Agronomist review of site conditions will take place next spring (Jan. — Mar. 2016) and we plan to implement any recommendations provided in the review in 2016 (this annual review is a permit requirement) 4) Existing site groundwater quality and nitrogen and organic loadings at the site do not appear to be limiting at this time (this will be analyzed in further depth as part of the proposed facility corrective action plan) *Freeboard in the site settling and storage ponds cannot be less than two feet at any time. Be aware that compliance with freeboard in the large treated water storage pond cannot be less Sager Creek/NCDEQ Meeting Agenda Page 3 of 6 than two feet from the top of the pond before its banks were raised to protect the pond from the nearby stream overtopping its banks in a major flooding event. D. FACTORY WATER SAVINGS ACTIVITIES COMPLETED TO DATE AND OTHER WATER SAVINGS CONSIDERATIONS IN PROCESS (OPEN TO ANY NCDEQ IDEAS AND INPUT) 1) Leak Repairs, Reducers, and Float Valves (Short List of Projects Completed in November 2015)* Project Description Projected Water Savings --GPD-- Flume Repairs 18,000 Replace Cooking Canal Packing (North and West Factory Canals) 24,000 Repair Leak on Municipal Water Line Entering Plant 600 Install Water Reducers (Various Systems) 42,000 Wash Reel Water Repairs 6,000 New Float Valves on Various Tanks 63,000 TOTAL ESTIMATED DAILY WATER SAVINGS 153,600 'Note that more costly and technically involved water savings opportunities have been identified such as modifications/ changes to the factory recirculating cooling tower, collection/reuse of the Malo cookers cushioning waters, changes to the factory can washers, use of more lowflow misting nozzles throughout the factory, use of solenoids on various systems to shut-off fresh water flows when production stops, etc. 2) New SOPs, Employee Training, and Checklists in Process to Ensure Proper Operation of Equipment to Conserve Water (Short List of Focus Areas Provided Below) • Daily checks and repairs as needed to assure Malo cooker canals, reservoirs, product dump tanks, and water return tanks are in good repair and flow controls are correct • Daily checks on blanchers to assure shells are not cracked and water controls are functioning correctly • Daily checks to assure pressure and paddle washers on all lines are functioning correctly on flow control • Dry clean-up of all factory areas (before hose wash -down) where possible • Check and shut -down all running and leaking hoses (in process of equipping all hoses with spring -loaded shutoff nozzles) 3) Development of Plant Environmental Sustainability Management Team ("Green Team") • Project in process (water conservation includes both technical and human areas) • We seek to start a plant -wide environmental protection awareness revolution (conserving water, energy, recycling, etc.) • Working to change human behaviors and expectations about water -use • Employee participation and team work very important for success moving forward 4) Company Wide Product Re -Alignment Manufacturing Study in Progress to Push Efficiency as well as to Further Mitigate Plant Water Management Regulatory Issues (Total Number of Pack/Water Discharge Days at the Factory may be Reduced by as Much as 90 Days Starting as Soon as Next Year) • Some high water use plant manufacturing (such as green beans and spinach production) may be shifted to more efficient/modern Del Monte plants in other Sager Creek/NCDEQ Meeting Agenda Page 4 of 6 regions of the country that have excess manufacturing capacity and the ability to properly manage the production wastewater • Plant production has been further reduced from CPo flay work weeks (no processing on weekends) to reduce even more process water production and bring factory discharges more into balance with existing site storage pond freeboard and spray irrigation system limitations • Next fall (fall 2016) only cleaned and/or was ed potatoes may be processed at the factory (this will likely increase factory raw product costs but would measurably reduce the amount of process wastewater discharged during the rainy and cool fall/winter season months because the plant will not have to do much washing of the potatoes before the start of processing) • Possible shift to more ,¢sy bin production and less production of other more intensive water use manufacturing crops such as greens • Smart and measured re -investments in factory processing equipment over the next 3-5 years will improve product through -put and may reduce the need for the factory to run for so many days (this in turn will reduce the total annual process water discharges) E. DOMESTIC SANITARY WASTEWATER (SEEK TO WORK WITH NCDEQ TO FULLY IMPLEMENT REQUIRED UPGRADES DURING 2016) 1) Description of current systems` • Septic/Pump Tank(s) • Chlorination • Discharge to Industrial Wastewater Line 2) Condition of current systems 3) Proposed corrective action plan (system being designed to serve 400 workers at an estimated flow of 25 GPD/worker which equates to 10,000 GPD total flow per day) • New Septic Tank/Recirculation Tanks • New Conveyance System • E-Z Treat System • UV Disinfection • Spray irrigation of treated wastewater along with plant process water (note that based on our review of factory piping systems it appears that sanitary wastewater has historically been part of the plant processing water irrigation stream) 4) Proposed location/placement of new treatment system (see site plans) 5) Projected final system effluent quality (10 mg/L BODS; 10 mg/L TSS; and Fecal Coliforms < 200 colonies/100 ml) with sample location prior to industrial wastewater line 6) EZ-Treat System Technology Approvals: • NSF/ANSI Standard 40— Residential Onsite Systems (see NSF Letter) • NSF/ANSI Standard 245 — Nitrogen Reduction (pending, see NSF Letter) • NSF/ANSI Standard 350 — Onsite Water Reuse Approval (pending, see NSF Letter) Note: The above NSF/ANSI standards are the strictest certifications for domestic wastewater regarding on -site systems Sager Creek/NCDEQ Meeting Agenda Page 5 of 6 7) Preliminary project schedule (highly dependent on site permitting/possible public notice requirements and the weather during the construction phase of the project): • Design and Preparation of Permit Applications (2 Months) • NCDEQ Review/Permitting (3 Months) • Order and Fully Install Equipment (5 Months) • Start -Up and Training (1 Month) • Total Project Design, Permitting, Installation, and Start -Up Time (11 Months) 8) Modification of site wastewater irrigation system permit (Will our factory discharge permit need to be modified to list/include our sanitary domestic wastewater?) 9) Routine monitoring of treated sanitary discharges (Flows, BOD, TSS and Fecal Coliforms?) 10) Licensed operator needed for new domestic wastewater treatment system? `NOTE: Factory domestic wastewater combines with the facility's food processing water after the screening operation and does not pass over the facility process water screens. F. PRELIMINARY CORRECTIVE ACTION PLAN STUDY ELEMENTS/TASKS (SUBJECT TO NCDEQ INPUT AND APPROVAL) Vr TASK 1: Determine Factory ring +u/auring Processes and Operations (Five -Year Plan) • Types of crops • Days of production (5 or 7 day work week, 2 or 3 shift days, etc.) • Processing days (crop type/impacts daily volumes of wash water production) • Raw product sourcing and quality analyses (e.g., cleaned and washed potatoes versus direct field harvested potatoes) 2) TASK 2: Complete In -Plant Fw and L,oa2 1eduction Plan (Water Reduction and Conservation Plan) — UvD"L!1 / W`/ / 1 • • Water use survey/ audit (including metering screened water being returned to the factory for gutter flushing) • Phased approach (start with the most obvious and lowest -cost water savings options) • Reuse/recycle water one or more times where possible • Refine factory SOPs, employee training, etc. • Life cycle/ROI costing (these costs need to be aligned with any costs that may be required to expand the land application site or re -do the site pond systems to handle current plant water flows) 3) TASK 3: Determine Process Wastewater Flow and Loadings (this task to be completed in parallel with Tasks 1 and 2) • Daily, weekly, monthly, and annual flows (needed for proper pond and land application site water balance sizing calculations) • N and BOD discharges (potential site limiting parameters in addition to too much water) • N and BOD seasonal discharges (current permit limits nitrogen discharges to no more than 300 lbs. PAN/YR and 50 lbs. PAN/winter) 4) TASK 4: Analyze Ability of Existing Factory Treatment/Storage Ponds and Land Application Sites to Properly Treat and Manage Process Wastewater Flows and Loadings • Verify sizing, conditions, and limitations of existing treatment ponds • Complete hydraulic, N, and BOD loading a Iyse Sager Creek/NCDEQ Meeting Agenda Page 6 of 6 • Monthlyhydraulic and nutrient balances will closely factor historical rainfall, temperatures, and evapotranspiration rates • Projected hydraulic and nutrient loadings will be compared to the site's existing discharge permit limitations for pond freeboard and spray field applications • Overall assessment of existing factory process wastewater systems to manage projected process wastewater flows and loadings 5) TASK 5: Develop and Select Preferred Corrective Actions (the full scope of this task will be based on the outcome of the above work tasks and in particular the analyses completed in Task 4). Corrective actions to be evaluated under this task may include one or more of the following or some combination of the following: • Different processing of crops • Reduced plant production • Changes to factory manufacturing practices • In -plant flow and loading reductions (source water/wastewater point reductions) • Modified or new storage ponds • Expanded spray irrigation (irrigate processing waters across more land) 6) TASK 6: Prepare Implementation Plan, Cost Estimates, and Schedule • Listing of selected corrective actions • Cost estimates (preliminary baseline capital and O&M engineering cost estimates) • Implementation Schedule "Supplemental Task: The factory also plans to develop a proper closure plan for the pit (created to increase the lower facility pond banks) located south of Fields A2 and A3. Our goal is to get this pit area cleaned of debris and to fill or re -grade the pit so that it no longer collects rainfall. G. ACTION ITEMS, NEXT STEPS, ASSIGNMENTS, AND ANY OTHER ITEMS H. MEETING CLOSE SAGER CREEK VEGETABLE COMPANY, TURKEY, NC. PROCESS WATER SYSTEMS CORRECTIVE ACTION PLANNING MEETING NC DEPARTMENT OF ENVIRONMENTAL QUALITY FAYETEVILLE/RALEIGH, NC December 2, 2015 A. DOMESTIC SANITARY WASTEWATER (SEEK TO WORK WITH NCDEQ TO FULLY IMPLEMENT REQUIRED UPGRADES DURING 2016) 1) Description of current system • Septic/Pump Tank(s) • Chlorination • Discharge to Industrial Wastewater Line 2) Condition of current system 3) Proposed corrective action plan (system being designed to serve 400 workers at an estimated flow of 25 GPD/worker which equates to.1:49 0 GPD total flow per day) • New Septic/Recirculation Tanks • New Conveyance System • E-Z Treat System • UV Disinfection • Spray irrigation of treated wastewater along with plant process water (note that based on our review of factory piping systems it appears that sanitary wastewater has historically been part of the plant processing water irrigation stream) 4) Proposed location/placement of new treatment system (see site plans) 5) Projected final system effluent quality (10 mg/L BOD5; 10 mg/L TSS; and Fecal Coliforms < 200 colonies/100 ml) with sample location prior to industrial wastewater line. 6) EZ-Treat System: technology approvals NSF/ANSI Standard 40 — Residential Onsite Systems (see NSF Letter). NSF/ANSI Standard 245 — Nitrogen Reduction (pending, see NSF Letter). NSFI/ANSI Standard 350 —Onsite Water Reuse Approvals (pending, see NSF Letter). (these are the strictest certifications for domestic wastewater regarding on -site systems) 7) Preliminary project schedule (highly dependent on site permitting and the weather during the construction phase of the project): 3f - 1 ' V • Design and Preparation of Permit Applications (2 Months) `r • NCDEQ Review/Permitting (3 Months) • Order and Fully Install Equipment (5 Months) • Start -Up and Training (1 Month) • Total Project Design, Permitting, Installation, and Start -Up Time (1 n ) 8) Modification of site wastewater irrigation system permit (Will our factory discharge permit need to be modified to list/include our sanitary domestic wastewater?) 9) Routine monitori n of treated sanitary dijarges (Flows, BOD, TSS and Fecal Coliforms?) 10) Licensed operator need'd for new domestic astewater treatment system? NOTE: Factory domestic wastewater combines with the facility's food processing water after the screening operation and does not pass over the facility process water screens. NSF NSF International OFFICIAL LISTING NSF International Certifies that the products appearing on this Listing conform to the requirements of NSF/ANSI Standard 40 - Residential Wastewater Treatment Systems This is the Official Listing recorded on October 16, 2014. E-Z Treat P.O. Box 176 Haymarket, VA 20618 703-753-4770 Facility: Rocky Mount, NC Rated Capacity Model Number Gallons/Day Classification #600 600 Class I #1200 1200 Class I Note: Additions shall not be made to this document without prior evaluation and acceptance by NSF International. 1 of 1 C0173848 789 N. Dixboro Road. Ann Arbor, Michigan 48105-9723 USA 1-800-NSF-MARK / 734-769-8010 www.ns£org NSF International October 29, 2015 Mr. Carl Perry E-Z Treat Systems, LLC 1700 Davis St Rocky Mount, NC 27803 Dear Carl, I am writing to provide E-Z Treat written permission to use the preliminary data for the E-Z Treat model #600 Wastewater Treatment system currently under test for NSF/ANSI Standard 245 and NSF/ANSI Standard 350-Wastewater. Currently the unit is meeting the requirements of both NSF 245 and 350. The unit is producing an average of 66% Nitrogen Reduction, and producing an average effluent Turbidity of 2 NTU, CBOD of 2 mg/L, TSS of 2 mg/L, and E. Coli of 6 MPM/100 ml. This test will be completed at the end of November 2015, and at that time, if the criteria still meet the requirements of the Standards; we will Certify the E-Z Treat #600 treatment system to NSF/ANSI Standard 245, and 350-Wastewater Official Listing. Please contact me with any questions you may have. Sincerely, Sharon Steiner Business Unit Manager Wastewater Treatment Unit Program 734-827-6846 (Voice) 734-827-7790 (Fax) steiner@nsf.org (E-mail) cc: corporate correspondence (CO0173848) P.O. Box 130140 Ann Arbor, MI 48113-0140 USA 734-769-8010 1-800-NSF-MARK Fax 734-769-0109 E-Mail: info@nsf.org Web:http://www.nsforg