Loading...
HomeMy WebLinkAbout20100425 Ver 2_Year 1 Monitoring Report_20120531June 2012 Soil & Environmental Consultants, PA 11010 Raven Ridge Road Raleigh, North Carolma 27614 Phone (919) 846 -5900 Fax (919) 846 -9467 www SandEC com S &EC Project No 11609 D1 IDENR je. N CSU Project No 082059 [5 NCDENR —DWQ AY 3 1 2012 Attn Mr Ian McMillan 1650 Mail Service Center s �WATEH WALIr r Raleigh North Carolina 27699 1650 a aranc Reference Year One Monitoring Report NCSU Centennial Campus N -4 Cluster Stream Restoration Wake County, NC DWQ Protect No 10 -0425, Ver 2 Enclosed please find the Year One Monitoring Report for the above referenced project As you will find in the report, it is our opinion that the stream and its 50 foot riparian buffer have been successfully restored and are currently functioning as intended As per the approved monitoring plan dated February 14 2011 allowance was made for cessation of site monitoring Based on the results of this year s monitoring and at the request of our client we formally request consideration be given for cessation of site monitoring activities We will be happy to discuss the site in more detail at your convenience Please review the enclosed document and provide any comments at your earliest opportunity We thank you for your assistance to date and look forward to the continued success of this project Sincerely SOIL & ENVIRONMENTAL CONSULTANTS, PA David Cooper Project Manager Attachments Year One Monitoring Report dated June 2012 Cc Ms Lynn Swank North Carolina State University NCSU Centennial Campus N -4 Cluster Stream Restoration Year One Monitoring Repo Wake County, North Carohna June 2012 Cataloging Unit — Neuse River Basin 03020201 Prepared For North Carolina State University NCSU Protect No 082059 Soil & Environmental Consultants, PA 11010 Raven Ridge Road Ralwgb, North Carolina 27614 Phone (919) 846 -5900 Fax (919) 846 -9467 www SandEC com Table of Contents 10 Introduction 11 Introduction 12 Protect History 13 Project Components 2 0 Monitoring 2 1 Methodology 2 11 Hydrologic Monitoring 2 12 Stream Stability Monitoring 2 13 Qualitative Vegetation Monitoring 2 2 Results 2 2 1 Hydrologic Monitoring Results 2 2 2 Stream Stability Monitoring Results 2 2 3 Qualitative Vegetation Monitoring Results 2 3 Evaluation of Restoration Success Figure 1— USGS Vicinity Map Appendix A — Monitoring Task Schedule Appendix B — Monitoring Layout Appendix C — Hydrology and Rainfall Data Appendix D — Cross Sections at Restoration Reach Gauge Locations Appendix E — Comparative Site Photos Appendix F — As -Built Survey (By Turner Land Surveying, PLLC) 1 1 1 1 1 2 2 2 3 3 3 3 4 4 5 10 INTRODUCTION 1 11 Introduction tThis monitoring report has been prepared by Soil & Environmental Consultants PA (S &EC) to present and evaluate site monitoring data for the period June 2011 through May 2012 for the North Carolina State University (NCSU) Centennial Campus N 4 Cluster Stream Restoration project located in Raleigh Wake County North Carolina The restored stream drams to an unnamed tributary of Lake Raleigh/Walnut Creek (B NSW) in the ' Neuse River Basin (030402 27 34 (3 5) A vicinity map is included as Figure 1 As a condition of approval of the 401 Water Quality Certification (dated November 30, 2010) The North Carolina ' Department of Natural Resources Division of Water Quality (DWQ) requested that this project be monitored for a period of five (5) consecutive years This monitoring report provides data collected during the first year of the five year monitoring period 12 Protect History North Carolina State University restored a portion of stream at the NCSU Centennial Campus N 4 Cluster Site consisting of approximately 142 linear feet (LF) of previously degraded channel, and the construction of an additional 49 LF of stream following the removal of an existing pipe Construction ' drawings for the stream restoration were prepared by Little & Little Landscape Architects PLLC of Raleigh NC In March 2011, prior to construction S &EC installed a reference hydrology monitoring gauge upstream of the restoration reach and ram gauge on site Construction of the stream restoration was performed by Riverworks, Inc of Cary NC between July 2011 and August 2011 Construction oversight was provided by Little & Little Landscape Architects ' Following construction an as built survey of the restored stream was performed by Turner Land Surveying PLLC of Raleigh NC in August 2011 For reference this survey is provided as Appendix F ' Subsequently hydrology gauges were installed within the restoration reach and monitoring of the restored stream and buffers by S &EC began in August 2011 Planting of woody vegetation as per the approved planting plan was performed by NCSU in November 2011 13 Protect Components ' As described on the approved Construction Drawings restoration of the N 4 Cluster stream included (but was not limited to) a restored dimension pattern and profile of the stream the installation of rock structures to provide for grade control and improve bed form construction of a concrete sill at the upstream end of the restoration and installation of an impervious geomembrane to reduce the potential for the loss of channel hydrology of the restoration reach Prior to restoration of the stream the stream buffer and surrounding area was covered with Kudzu (Puerarra lobata) As part of the restoration this invasive species was removed from the restored reach the upstream buffer and the surrounding area to prevent future invasion The 50 foot stream buffer of the restoration reach was then planted with woody tree and shrub species and seeded with herbaceous ground cover 2 0 MONITORING The purpose of monitoring of the restored stream and buffer is to document the overall effectiveness of the restoration including stream stability comparative hydrology of the upstream reference reach and the restored reach and the success of planted vegetation and absence of invasive species Site monitoring will be performed for a period of five years or until approval is given by DWQ to discontinue monitoring This report serves as the Year One Monitoring report As per the agreed upon monitoring schedule hydrologic data collection during Year One was performed monthly and stream stability monitoring was performed quarterly The monitoring frequency for Years Two through Five will consist of quarterly hydrology data collection and annual stream stability monitoring Monitoring reports will be submitted to DWQ by June 1 S` each year For reference the schedule of specific monitoring tasks is provided as Appendix A Site monitoring dates and activities performed by S &EC during Year One are described in the following table Date Activitv February 16 2011 pre construction site observation March 18, 2011 pre construction reference reach hydrology and rain gauge installation April 22 2011 pre construction gauge download June 27 2011 pre construction gauge download, monitoring device installation coordination meeting with Contractor and Engineer August 26 2011 post construction hydrology gauge installation and photo point establishment overall observation September 27 2011 gauge download and overall site observation October 30, 2011 gauge download and overall site observation November 28 2011 gauge download, photo monitoring planting observation overall site observation December 27 2011 gauge download and overall site observation January 30 2012 gauge download and overall site observation February 29 2012 gauge download photo monitoring and overall site observation March 29 2012 gauge download and overall site observation April 30 2012 gauge download and overall site observation May 9 2012 gauge download photo monitoring and overall site observation 2 1 Methodology This section includes information concerning, 1) hydrologic monitoring 2) qualitative stream stability monitoring and 3) qualitative vegetation monitoring These data will be used for comparison with data from subsequent monitoring years 2 11 Hydrologic Monitoring A total of three (3) Infinities U S A hydrology monitoring gauges were installed on the site along with a single Infinities U S A rain gauge On March 18 2011 prior to construction of the stream restoration one hydrology monitoring gauge was installed immediately upstream of the restored stream reach to record hydrologic conditions adjacent to the reference reach At this 2 time, the ram gauge was also installed to document site rainfall On August 26 2011, immediately following construction of the stream restoration, two hydrology monitoring gauges were placed adjacent to the restored stream channel one adjacent to a raffle and one adjacent to a pool The locations of all hydrology monitoring gauges are shown in Appendix B on the Monitoring Layout (Sheet 1) 2 12 Stream Stability Monitoring Sixteen (16) photographic monitoring points were established to qualitatively document stream stability The locations of these photo points are shown in Appendix B (Sheet 1) To assess continued channel stability during Year One photographs were taken at quarterly intervals for comparison As required by DWQ stream stability documentation at photographic monitoring points during Years Two through Five will be performed on an annual basis 2 13 Qualitative Vegetation Monitoring No specific vegetation monitoring or survival criteria were established by DWQ for this project however qualitative evaluation and observations of planted specimens, herbaceous ground cover and invasive plant species were made during monthly monitoring visits 2 2 Results This section includes a summary and discussion of site monitoring results for hydrology stream stability and vegetation For additional information, the interested reader is referred to the appendices 2 2 1 Hydrologic Monitoring Results Data collected by the upstream reference gauge and the two restoration reach gauges was compared to observe the effectiveness of the impervious geomembrane in reducing hydrologic loss from the restoration reach Prior to the construction of the restored section of stream water level at the upstream reference gauge was generally between 2 and 8 inches below the ground surface During the construction period between June 17'h and around August 6t' 2011 when a temporary coffer dam was in place immediately upstream of the restoration reach the water level in the reference reach increased fluctuating between approximately I and 18 inches above the ground surface Following construction and removal of the coffer dam water level at the upstream reference gauge has generally fluctuated between approximately 0 85 inch above and 5 inches below the ground surface Water level at restoration reach Gauge 1 adjacent to a riffle showed distinct increases in response to recorded rain events Rainfall driven water level increases of 5 inches were common throughout Year One monitoring Gauge 1 however, did not show a change in water level due to the presence and subsequent removal of a check dam at the downstream end of the restoration suggesting that the flooding effects of this dam did not extend upstream as far as the gauge location Water level at Gauge 1 has averaged 18 38 inches below the ground surface over the course of this year s monitoring with a maximum level of 12 56 inches below the ground surface Restoration reach Gauge 2 adjacent to a pool showed more uniform hydrology, with water levels fluctuating less drastically in response to rainfall events The maximum rainfall driven water level increase at this gauge was approximately 3 inches Water level at Gauge 2 however was more affected by the presence and subsequent removal of the check dam at the downstream end of the restoration Water level at Gauge 2 has averaged 17 02 inches below the ground surface over the course of Year One monitoring with a maximum level of 9 6 inches below the ground surface Rainfall recorded during 2011 (for the period March 18 2011 through December 31 2011) was 23 82 inches Rainfall recorded to date during 2012 (for the period January 1 2012 through May 9 2012) was 11 90 inches Hydrologic and rainfall data are presented graphically in Appendix C For reference cross sections at each hydrology gauge location are presented in Appendix D 2 2 2 Stream Stability Monitoring Results Based on a comparison of photos taken at quarterly intervals and general observation of the condition of the restored stream during monthly monitoring visits the stream appears to have maintained its constructed dimension pattern and profile with no indications of departure Natural sediment transport and sorting of stream bed material was observed, including the formation and migration of bars and deposition of sediment No excessive erosion around or beneath any structures or down cutting of riffles was observed Any evidenced erosion bare banks or failing structures observed in future monitoring years will be documented and a plan implemented to repair problem areas Comparative site photographs are presented in Appendix E The as built survey of the restored stream reach (by Turner Land Surveying PLLC) is provided as Appendix F 2 2 3 Qualitative Vegetation Monitoring Results Although no specific vegetation monitoring or survival criteria were established by DWQ for this project observations of planted specimens made during monthly monitoring visits suggest a survival rate of close to 100% The use of large, containerized trees and shrubs within the stream buffer has led to the rapid beginning of a new canopy over the restored section of stream channel Volunteer woody trees and shrubs were not observed within the restoration reach buffers during Year One monitoring Herbaceous ground cover from temporary and permanent seeding measures was observed to be generally vigorous and dense and very few areas were noted to be occasionally sparse in herbaceous cover during the course of monitoring Overseeding of bare areas adjacent to the stream was performed following the removal of the downstream check dam, and subsequent drop in water elevation Temporary herbaceous ground cover grew to a height of over five feet in some areas requiring a one time spring maintenance of this vegetation to increase sunlight for planted shrubs During Year One monitoring very few small resprouts of Kudzu were observed Monitoring and control of these resprouts will continue as needed Multiflora Rose (Rosa multiflora) Privet (Ligustrum sinense) and English Ivy (Hedera helix) are three other invasive species that were observed in small numbers in the stream buffer upstream of the restoration reach During Year One monitoring, these plants were not observed to be a dominant component of the vegetation ' and are not currently considered to be problematic These invasive plants will also be monitored for future control efforts as needed ' 2 3 Evaluation of Restoration Success — Year One (2011 -2012) Based on our site observations (channel morphology and buffer vegetation) and recorded hydrology data it is our opinion that the restored stream is functioning as intended The stream appears stable planted trees and shrubs in the stream buffer are large and have shown vigorous growth and very high survival and herbaceous ground cover is dense Specific interpretation of recorded hydrology in the substrate adjacent to the stream at this time would be premature However it is not evident from general site observation and hydrology data that water is being lost and it appears that the upstream sill and impervious geomembrane are functioning as intended A continued comparison of channel adjacent hydrology over time will help to identify any trends Based on collected data to date, the restoration effort has shown success during monitoring Year One W I Appendix A — Monitoring Task Schedule m m m®= m= m= m m r r = _ m Act «S x c m a o0: 0 x O LL > o GC oio Q Q ep A C X X X X t��pp — d 9 OAK x N 01 C c a x C o C ;a 0 x a , 7 S O o a P T x x X X =moo OaK N O1 C C e « a x c � m Q o ¢ � 3 m e m a° « m x C @ cm o c 3m O Ol m C _ U X X X X = e C p N c � o — 3 — m m cx a > CD x m � 0 N dr � L O O c « a X — O W Q O > L O C _d O c m c m °c O m X Cy 0 a ° o m O o K v 1� Lwa � D cep m 3 X X X x 3� y d m 3 m m c v m o+ cm` « C n x c c Y m E �ma « c _ X X X X o 0 cn M m M a� �g m o v p � v N S C O t A p c m e Q E op O c X X X X X X X X X x X X a o p e V O CL Ir- m0 C d C C w d V m _ d � e O m L Y a� x x O 09 W m � O Z Q: E � c Vl m m } m = CL o a m m .+ a A ea .9 m a a V m a m 2 r W _ C C M CL m Z � aU Wo V Z y m m m®= m= m= m m r r = _ m I Appendix B - Monitoring Layout 1 -4O 1 inoA` i ON21OIINOW wua :'ON aaa4 a14ll aaays :�3PueS mmm ,U.16?13nINn ilvIG oN `,dNno7 3`�VM L946-M (616) WA • 0069-968 (616) :awg4 • 419LZ VU!IOIEJ W -N `4$!319)1 • PEUN aPP!11 iW^E2j 01011 o� _ "1.a1eo VNnowO ul�JON :a�aglo :"o'je'oj Vd `SlUtly tSIIO3 T"UaWUOJIAU3 V TIOS :umea0 &A rod 311S NOIld-JOlS321 WH3?J1S addv 31V0 No11d1�0s�a n3i H 6091 1 tb -N GnjA ) IVINN31Ngo nc33N SNOISIn3?J ON A�aroad I a�afo.ad LU J Z Z Z ' J W OL �z�z cn Q w omlu QD D z JO(nJ z Q �d =rLJQ T) U' z�� Ln Z J QJ J z =00� 1- zL ( LU m AU-U-� o LU-'OOm O U' r LLJ > }OOQ G- O oL 0 w= O rnOOo� w O JQ UU Q oo�0 CL/ z^ y ZU zQ Q O u�ot z F- U U OWQ� 0 z O� ILJ �� LU J ��> > LLI OU OZ z �0 J O U 10 D LLJ LLJ IL O O Q� �y J Z~ O J Q U Q z ~ K�m= } OJ�U zz W O �,a �7 Q F-!zuQw 0O Ja / 0U=� OUz w (li U J J J W z Q Z oz z < Z Jam/ J Qp ��// w W ww�U- lulu Oz F Jz O027< 0 U fir. ��Ornw���Q yp z{ / ��OXU%U / oL !- i—' zOOQ DOJO �I—w � 0�/wJ uOo�COz��� .� °� ": W -L uQ LJnJ JQ jam -1 U LLJ �Z i .. w a 9 R i N (J� � O ' z o' U Q T) (r)� J z O pj O o[ UT � ! lu ay Q O Z Ln Q 1 % -J � i O i Q ' N ` Z n w W J LL- 0/ a� lL O Z Iry (J) (W LU j Q LU O O z < _Z � Ui W O O z � W 339 O Q O U o Q II p 6 U 11:1 N I z C) ac W w zo � mar rn O OOH U (— = o J LU p= p� Q O w ? zU C OQ D o U ° O0 ' O 3ill�p ," O U SNdwb� N/vv O N O mp APAjnGqjlngGVUOPPGeg ono e-( uuo4won:)gpue s wmed 6o91 1 16661 1- 1 1sgo\Zoag\ :apj I Appendix C - Hydrology and Rainfall Data 09 � O ,^ N V o M V C L AMA O N 0 r 1 i L� 0 Cl) N W U �p f+ � • L V) O C) Im Z L L- unr-SZ L L -unr-g L L L -unr-L L L L -unr-v L L- AeW-gZ L L- AeW-LZ L L-AeW-t L L L-AeW -L L L- ad`d-OC L Lady -CZ O L L-jdy -g L 0. L L -AV -6 CD rn L L L -ady -Z O � ll L L- aeW -gZ O T 2 L L -aeW -6 L 'O L L-aeW-Z L Q i O � � •O r v � tot L p }+ V E E O � Vi L .OMEN so. � C� . Q N i T000 � � O in L . _ L �i•r ' w v � > as L L L- unr-SZ L L -unr-g L L L -unr-L L L L -unr-v L L- AeW-gZ L L- AeW-LZ L L-AeW-t L L L-AeW -L L L- ad`d-OC L Lady -CZ O L L-jdy -g L 0. L L -AV -6 CD rn L L L -ady -Z O � ll L L- aeW -gZ O T 2 L L -aeW -6 L 'O L L-aeW-Z L Q LL -aeW -S L L- qaj -gZ L L-gGJ-6 L L L -qa=I-Z L L L-gaI -5 L L- uer-6Z L L -Uef -ZZ L L -uef -5L L L -uer-g 1111 1111 111 llll�- L L -Uef'- L o o U') o LO o LO sa4:)u i `Jejem of uldea �■ == r r r m m r m m= m === • N V � M L V � C E W � L v Gi D o T N a P* r O>% M� 75 �1■r � L O° 0 LM CL E O V E cn Z � L 0 Cl) O U 2 `I C) LO o U") O U') o cv L L- 09(1-O£ L L- Oaa-£Z L L -09(1-9 L L L -0aa -6 L L -Oaa -Z L L-AON -SZ L L-^ON-9 L L L- ^ON- L L L L -nON-V L L-10O-9Z .O L L -IOO- L Z ,O O 0 L ' c� L L-daS -p£ O ;_+ L L-das-£Z O L L -das -g L 4- O L L -daS -6 W L ca � O � v E ca O � > O �s v O i c� Q O L Q� � L 0 ca as v cv cn 0 ♦L^ V C) LO o U") O U') o cv L L- 09(1-O£ L L- Oaa-£Z L L -09(1-9 L L L -0aa -6 L L -Oaa -Z L L-AON -SZ L L-^ON-9 L L L- ^ON- L L L L -nON-V L L-10O-9Z L L -daS -Z L L-6nb-9Z L L-6nb-6 L L L- End -ZL L L -6ny -S L L-Inf -6Z L L -Inf -ZZ LL-Inf -5L L L -Inr-8 L L-Inf - L SaLIOu i `ialaM of uldaa m = = = = r = m r = = = = = r = r r .O L L -IOO- L Z ,O L ' c� L L-daS -p£ O ;_+ L L-das-£Z O L L -das -g L 4- O L L -daS -6 L L -daS -Z L L-6nb-9Z L L-6nb-6 L L L- End -ZL L L -6ny -S L L-Inf -6Z L L -Inf -ZZ LL-Inf -5L L L -Inr-8 L L-Inf - L SaLIOu i `ialaM of uldaa m = = = = r = m r = = = = = r = r r N TMMM O N V � (I) O L � low N r 1� O N r 1 � 0 � L 0 O •L CL E U cn qq* ev L � C Z .O 4001 C Cl) O (m) 2 Z v � O Z �- unr-tZ Z � -unr-L � Z � -unr-o � Z � -unr -£ U-Aew-LZ Z �-Aevvoz Z � -Aew -E I Z �- Aew -g Z �-AV-6Z Z �- ady -ZZ C L Z � -ady -q a Z � -ady -g c L Z � -ady- 0 z [- aew -gZ O Z � -aew -g � O Z -aew- 0 Z � -aew -v Z �-ga=j-9Z Z[-qa=1-6� Z �-gaj-Z � Z [-qa=I-5 Z�-uer-6Z z L- uer -zz Z � -Uer-S � Z � -uer -g Z � -uer- o U') o U-) o u7 0 LO N saLlou i `jejem of uldea U C N r � V 0 �+ r 1 � O N 0 0 L 0 = � O I.L � O C/) e� L � f+ d Z � .O -W Cl) (.) O Z � f r; � �- aaa -08 � �-aaa-BZ � � -090-9 � � -aaa -6 � � -aaa -Z � � -AOWSZ � � -noN -8 � � � -noN- � � � � -noN -t �-100- Z .O in C: C_ 0U IL O � -daS -08 + � -daS -BZ O � � -daS -g O 0 -daS -6 0 Da) co- �� _da S- Z T I � �- aaa -08 � �-aaa-BZ � � -090-9 � � -aaa -6 � � -aaa -Z � � -AOWSZ � � -noN -8 � � � -noN- � � � � -noN -t LO o m O U") o LO o N N tY) sagou i `aa}eM of uldea � �- Env -9Z � �-6ny-6 � CL � �- 6nv-Z� CD M � � -6ny -S � � -Inf -6Z � � -Inf -ZZ � � -Inr-S � �� -Inf-8 � �-Inf -� �-100- Z .O in C: C_ 0U IL O � -daS -08 + � -daS -BZ O � � -daS -g O 0 -daS -6 0 Da) co- �� _da S- Z T I LO o m O U") o LO o N N tY) sagou i `aa}eM of uldea � �- Env -9Z � �-6ny-6 � CL � �- 6nv-Z� CD M � � -6ny -S � � -Inf -6Z � � -Inf -ZZ � � -Inr-S � �� -Inf-8 � �-Inf -� yam, N I�/ N I.L. r � � O cn '3 N O '^ N V � 1 N V �p }, a cv � a Z �L C/) O U Z Z �-unr -t z Z � -unr-L � Z � -unr-0 � z� -unr -c Z �-Aen-zz Z �-AeW-OZ z �- AeN -E � U-) o U") o Z �- AeN -q Z �-AV-6Z Z �-AV -ZZ 3 ML Z � -AV -q a Z -ady -g 'i Z �-AV- 0 ._ z �- aew -qZ O 2 Z � -aew -g 0 z �-aen -t Z �- qaj -9Z Z � -gGJ-6 � Z � -gaj-Z � Z � -gaj-5 Z �- uer -6Z z �- uer -zz z � -uer -5 L Z � -uer -g Z -uer- L c� I!a�l � L I (D 3: F- = ,m (Du) I I I� sat4oui `aajeM of uldea = = = = m m = m ■. m = m m = = = = = m � �-oaQ -oc � �_Oaa -EZ � �-08a-9 � sagou `aaleM of u4daa m m .. = m = == m= m m m == r O N �- noN -SZ r � -noN-B � N L - - � -noN � � CD � -noN -tl V r V t r N CV oo TM O 0 C � N p �- daS -oc �- daS -£Z ,i -daS -g O o0 a� CL -do S -6 m O C'4 co M_ -- E M_ O - �� -da S Z +I �- find -9Z L 0 -finb -6 -finy -Z � d. E .o _ (D c � -finy -5 O =Q �� = v 0.0 �- Inr -6Z m G� 0 .Q � � I r ZZ ♦, o °0 z� " O •- ti.i O -Inr-8 U-) o U') o sagou `aaleM of u4daa m m .. = m = == m= m m m == oowft% ON o� N N > C;) 0 40 N 0 M� r. AW m cc ') 0 0 AW A O v r 1 L = Q L G7 �+ a cn L Z i t Cl) C (a) 2 Z �- unr-vz Z � -unr-L � Z � -unr -0 � Z � -unr -E Z �- AeW-Lz o L o L o Un o r- N N M sagau i `ialeM of Li}daa Z �- Aen-OZ Z �- Aew -c � Z �- Aew -q Z �-AV-6Z Z �- add -zZ 10 'i Z � -ady -q a Z -ady -g C CD L Z� -ady- +0 NE Z I -aen-SZ O Z� -aew -e 0 Z � -aen -t Z �- qa=j-9Z Z � -q@J-6 � Z �-qa=I-Z � Z � -qaj -5 Z �- uer-6Z z �-Uer-zz z � -Uer -S � z � -uer -e z � -uer- � m > DS C_ =_ OL C7 U I O,_- N 'm I) r ♦ 1'► O V N O 7 � O r OT 0 N r L 0 C ,N CL tC LE cn U AW CD ED L R V� Z o � o V Z L L- unr-SZ L L-unr-8 L L L -unr- L L L L -unr -v N 00 (o N 00 CO d' N O saLloul `llejulem L L -Ae vv � Z L L -Aewtr L L L- AeA -L L L -AV -OE L L -AV-E Z L L -add -9 L L L -add -6 L L -add -Z L L- aen-9z LL- aeW-6L L L -aen-Z L L L -a e" -S L L- gaj-9Z L L-gaj-6 L L L-ga=I-Z L L L-qa=j-9 L L- uer -6Z L L- uer -zz L L- uer -SL L L -uer -g L L -uer- � 13 O 0. O NE O O m w m a� o0oft O N ■� L 1 � V O O .0 0 L O ON AMA 5 a EO .0 L Q L wo L � c� V� z 0 L O M 0 i co 20 (a) Z N 00 Cfl d" N 00 CD N O -aaa -9 � -aaa -6 � -aaa -Z �-^ON-SZ � -noN -9 � -noN- � � �-nON-V �- }a0-8Z 13 a Flom � -IaO-L ,a L � O - daS -pc i �AaS -£Z O y.. �AaS -g O �A@S -6 �A@S -Z �- 6nV-9Z � -6nV -6 � - 6n`d-Z � � -6nb -S � -Inf -6Z - -- �-Inf -ZZ �-Inr-S �77 i N 00 Cfl d" N 00 CD N O sat4oui `llejul m N O N 1 0.0 N T 0 CD M� N Alma r; 0 m Ama LL = O E(n i Q AW O U) R L m V � V L Z :0 0 cl) (a) Z Z -unr -vZ Z � -unr -L � Z � -unr -0 � Z � -unr -c Z �- AeW-LZ Z �- Aen-OZ Z � -Aen-E � Z �- AeW-g Z � -AV-6Z Z �- ady -ZZ MO d' N i Cfl Z -ady -s; 0. Z -ady -g = _a d _ Z y G O }+ 2 Z � -aen -g O N 00 C4 d' N 00 Cfl N O Z � -aen -t Z �-ga=j-9Z Z � -qa=1-6 � Z � -qaj -Z � Z �-qa=j-5 Z -uer -6Z Z �- uer -zz Z � -uer -5 � Z � -uer -e Z � -uer- � r rr r �r r r r r �r r r■ rr r■ ■r r rr r ■r rr ' Appendix D —Cross Sections at � Restoration Reach Gauge Locations N Ul O O + O O O O X N O � O N 70 cb v O c + �p O CD Co v N CD 0 m 0 c rn co v fi 0 v fi 0 v c c9 CD v O 0 U) � O 0 + z O - N Cb CD fi o o- m 0 0 J O O O O O O M ELEVATION (feet) O O O O O O — Ul O O z (i U) C � � Z D rn rn 0 rn N D 0 rn N 0—�0 0 0 z z 0 z Z D rn � rn D n rn z N n 3�, _ Q2 D - z Z rn r G� D C rn z (i U) C � � Z D rn rn 0 rn N D 0 rn N 0—�0 0 0 z z 0 z N CJ1 O O + O O O + O O X + U) O N N O O p � W v c clz� O CO + 00 v N CD O G� 0 c rn cu v ct O c v v c, I G> v c CO a O + O U) Cn D O +O z O m c� cb o 0 J O + O O + O O O + O O + O + N ELEVATION (feet) O O O O O O O O Z C� C —DI 0 Z G> O p D C G') 70 70 rn O rn o rn rn � n rn O O O O Z < D D C) N U1 -A -p rn � � Z D rn N z Z rn Z C� C —DI 0 Z G> O p D C G') 70 70 rn O rn o rn rn � n rn O O O O Z Appendix E — Comparative Site Photos Im a va e N 01 N O r V/ C N �D N O h+ r� I �z o� o � n C7 � a A� (D �n a� 0 w 0 0 O A O CS O CD �p N O_ r N b A� (D N O M O1 N o N 3 N O N In N O� N O r+ r+ KO °e A 3 A 'S N �O N O i.r �z �c CD W CD o� �n �v o� WCD �n a� O O O 'r CD b O !D n e.v z 0 o CD �O N O N N rD N O_ N p �O N O N sm _ N N O /i O A A Z N N O r+ �z —c o � �v o� ID CD CEl O A� O (D 'C O CD A z 0 �CD oCD �D N O � N N N O i 5 a� N O rr N 0 _ N N O r %i O A O A It N b N O �z s. n �c CD _ �a -0 ;* CD O 0 CD b O CD n r.r z 0 �CD o CD O N O -- N `C W A O ON A CT 't C N N O N 4 N O N OQ C ryr N Q� N O r~+ /i C A A �s N �O N O rr �z �c o� . ' CD K b /? a� O P� A it O (D n fr O Q� lD O N � O L, N O C A7 N �D N O_ oil N F. N O rr N i C QQ y N O� N O z 0 a N �O N O ►r �z f� C n m � o � ;Y �s VI N 'r O Al CD aA 1.02. CD C) z 0 O N O d N N r0 N O M P A; N O N O� N O r r %I O �e N N O rr r. "� ■i A A7 �z �c v� o 'T1 � a� O ^s O O 'C O fD n z 0 �N �o N 04 fo C A7 , N N O ■r N GA a� N O r+ N A cisy N N O w+ /i O A C A , N N O �z s. n Mmii CD o� o E. CA N `0 %F O O O C CD b t 0. N n z 0 oN �o q N N N O N L7 �D N O N C y N O� N O rr Ii C A Q A N �O N O �z �c a� ;n O �.t P� O O 1, "O. CD n z 0 O N � O d ,_, N ht N N �o N O N a 4 t N r/ < eD a A N �O N O �z s. n �c M9 o� wCD 0 K C CD i; 0. (D n z CD 0 O N � O d N 1 i 1 1 1� C N 1� N O OR N i 1 4 1� N O N i i BIN N O� N O iFo 0 N N O rr �z CD s. n �c o� ., i� O P� O O N lI lD A z 0 O N � O N _ _ ' N r0 N O b A� (1Q y N O �-n 0� N 3 as N O N _ N O� N O C 0 P N N O �z �c o� o � O m O O N `0 �t O CD a z 0 O N � O 7 N ITI fo cr C 07 N r0 O rr N GA w �o N O N N N O E� A 3 N �D N O �z �c CD �. o � DCD :n a� O O '.i fD E O. (D n z 0 O N � O d N F. �O N O N FIR C �Q C y ems► N O� N O 5 O A A N N O rr V �z �c o� a O O CD "'t p CD n e� z all (D 0 O N � O d N IMP A IIALA F. �O N O N FIR C �Q C y ems► N O� N O 5 O A A N N O rr V �z �c o� a O O CD "'t p CD n e� z all (D 0 O N � O d N _ N r0 N O N C� as �o N O N _ N O� N O C 0 c N N O �z s� c a9 W CD WCD aIPD O O r: O it o n r. z 0 o, O N N I' 1 �t C A� N N O N t 'T1 A� !1Q .r O M 4 N O N 1 C C N O� N Ii O C A a N rD N O r+ r Yom+ C1 cp z �c y. o� cn K �n a O Al O O li O. O A z 0 O N � O d t) � Appendix F — As -built Survey � (By Turner Land Surveying, PLLC) op UjW 'JNU3nansONVla3Nanl ► Leo q(m) m NL - N t400 aw - zoco-d 8LfiL9L9I8L8) - Y09LZ ON 48101�J �4iO e8PWe1`J LOZ£ 311d JNUl3n21nS aMdl 2�3N21n1 �- VNIl0VVD KNON AlNnOJ 3)IVM MUM 2��1Sf1�� �N-Sf1dW�dO ��/INN31N3� NOIIVIOJLS311 Wd381S 11A, 1 m �n $ 11 y � \ V �- r F k3mns runs -sd 711 w W V / J U Z ''^1 V! D 5L L LLU O —� I.I. 5 W O W Ewa co aZ 0 F- 0 I/A) C- s w W w I- V } °z f z U � v z �°�6 U bW � h �o 34yi Ai17f8bdy� H waos / w zJ Z �w w S W, 100=2911 O z I I I Lu fij� I w� Q z p l dill � QpQ r O + N / ,b ift 0,Hz�jNba 1P�OY�o �_�$- LL, N �W F a O we vdy 10 wt1g; a z C MR o z 101 � zz o Z fl z F P L.WP AS2 � X2 o �'o -clul ��M1 i' X01 eo aw id v m� OI 1— 1�12Zc - - oz I r I 1211SN0_0 ONJ 96 L l +Z _I I 1 Lz o££ 0££ 11S 3NO1S � 6SL +L �* 06ZL -� I I 66Z� -- L I f s 9Zf L6 £ 6Z1 J L I 66ZC _ -. or I 6Zf LSX L 6Z£7,, IIF- 6 8Z I I L _ A9 _1 m. I � II I 9 t- i— I 94 8Z£ IIIS 3NOlS 4 + YWO 03H? , � I I �f 1` I£ i - 0 flZ.fr— pg� Y LZf I 9a£ _ I ot+ F 9 I Z£ Eb£ -� LZ£ yry gg9Z�Z��£ - I Or* O J � w .�....�.. L 1 \ z^ EL EL �-- O 1- O mU� 2N x II X F O v�JQ x DDS04 erne 0vF- 4 JZW II Z = mgj 0 -d0 II O N'I w w ,� w� Q z p l dill � QpQ r O + N / ,b ift 0,Hz�jNba 1P�OY�o �_�$- LL, N �W F a O we vdy 10 wt1g; a z C MR o z 101 � zz o Z fl z F P L.WP AS2 � X2 o �'o -clul ��M1 i' X01 eo aw id v m� OI 1— 1�12Zc - - oz I r I 1211SN0_0 ONJ 96 L l +Z _I I 1 Lz o££ 0££ 11S 3NO1S � 6SL +L �* 06ZL -� I I 66Z� -- L I f s 9Zf L6 £ 6Z1 J L I 66ZC _ -. or I 6Zf LSX L 6Z£7,, IIF- 6 8Z I I L _ A9 _1 m. I � II I 9 t- i— I 94 8Z£ IIIS 3NOlS 4 + YWO 03H? , � I I �f 1` I£ i - 0 flZ.fr— pg� Y LZf I 9a£ _ I ot+ F 9 I Z£ Eb£ -� LZ£ yry gg9Z�Z��£ - I Or* N ca CL �- 2 co) Z OF Z J�U� ULL�? �ONw W (L H�U W N co) W W J W co) n. U) z Z z v w \ z^ U >m 7 � N ca CL �- 2 co) Z OF Z J�U� ULL�? �ONw W (L H�U W N co) W W J W co) n. U) z Z z v aM DNIA3I1MrWNt/1M3NMflL MMM Puiwg LL—MO - 3a0'AB *as -Linn - wo-d 9MiMUS) - MMLZ ON 46PWd 'ENO 96PWOJ LOZ£ 0l1d JNUl mns ONVI b3Nun1 r 1,r � \\ a� -Q^ _~ C' MI LL MM "I S W tylJ -gljN Z 1!� KF agW p2 _HIM I L O OM W II Z- r r 2A3lsnio VN-sndWd0 IVINN31N30 N0llb*l0lS3U Wb32:11S ,Umns bins -se \ \ 30 ENGIN EKED FILTER S RIP tL z U O � �r J cp wn` n. n � �a =n W th mll 3 z O 0 Z JN 2 �3 00 tn� ww c� \ \ \ \ I \ \ I YY ygy gg gg r- O O 1 N 66 tff a. m ° ° x r. II - �— --1 09, - - }} N N >W> Etn O vx§ jDD Ovw mNa I z J00 O- mZ O WNO N�> Lu ¢ZI U Z to O � U � O I a �dtLN 1- - --I- T I- T T-r IO j O '0 010101010 O O 2 Z a to OD O O N O O M M O tD .i O iu-) W w I n co co ikw r0 MIM 11104,01 MIMIYN)`M 1MI 1 ! Lam!_ i IF (ZFF-- Il0 O OIO10 I-10OIO rh all�iW GnD IO) M O) to IN l*lM N h 0. OZ NIN N N N M M'M MIM aI IM MIM IM IM n rn MIM M U' fz `� I I ' ' Z d tnD O))� GOD a 0IN1� N � 0(9 I0 0 0 O —IN MIM MIM Q �I2— M M f7I Ih M M M ') M VI�M IM M MM M MIM 117 M to I0 ED I I I�IN NIrn OW10I0 010G �IN aI< a ZJIM Mn v0 M h K)i in IM IM Iri 0 10 OO N OIM 010 O v F iNI +Im 0m °+I+ + + t +) FQ- Cpl0 0 l� �� �J 9192 _ a _ G a W .,taw � Sonze C WWW 'Td� 000000 } ryryuu�� LL {r{ Lu 8 -21 uj -{ w Z A O V p 1H aNaG� zz m m m ZZ1908 �N cu 0 N LY lff OM I I I I I 1 - a 6900 i i- - -� -- -r- , 0¢ Wt- -TN 10£f (qi I I I � wo -©I ntt 6L 6Z£1 oo� �Y a0161 6Z� 33 7"" DL lI ZZZZZWJ I I 1 0 IIII I I i I I I I I N IZZU1 ss U I I YY� N9 fff n�n-_� gI gI dS Fi 8 id 6 b1 7d 09+ I I I I IIN_ Std lf£ 04h L _ I 1 I I a91 LS off I_ I - I — 1 CM ( 9 6U —r 09 W n�. M yif 1 -J—. �119f I f I I I , 1811501£ I - -- 09 s M M y �; f1 M y o w 9 fi -i I ' I _ pn a I Nz_j__- FO FO J 13 Rte}; O Z W I I IOp wn` n. n � �a =n W th mll 3 z O 0 Z JN 2 �3 00 tn� ww c� \ \ \ \ I \ \ I YY ygy gg gg r- O O 1 N 66 tff a. m ° ° x r. II - �— --1 09, - - }} N N >W> Etn O vx§ jDD Ovw mNa I z J00 O- mZ O WNO N�> Lu ¢ZI U Z to O � U � O I a �dtLN 1- - --I- T I- T T-r IO j O '0 010101010 O O 2 Z a to OD O O N O O M M O tD .i O iu-) W w I n co co ikw r0 MIM 11104,01 MIMIYN)`M 1MI 1 ! Lam!_ i IF (ZFF-- Il0 O OIO10 I-10OIO rh all�iW GnD IO) M O) to IN l*lM N h 0. OZ NIN N N N M M'M MIM aI IM MIM IM IM n rn MIM M U' fz `� I I ' ' Z d tnD O))� GOD a 0IN1� N � 0(9 I0 0 0 O —IN MIM MIM Q �I2— M M f7I Ih M M M ') M VI�M IM M MM M MIM 117 M to I0 ED I I I�IN NIrn OW10I0 010G �IN aI< a ZJIM Mn v0 M h K)i in IM IM Iri 0 10 OO N OIM 010 O v F iNI +Im 0m °+I+ + + t +) FQ- Cpl0 0 l� �� �J 9192 _ a _ G a W .,taw � Sonze C WWW 'Td� 000000 } ryryuu�� LL {r{ Lu 8 -21 uj -{ w Z A O V p 1H aNaG� zz m m m ZZ1908 �N cu 0 N LY lff OM I I I I I 1 - a 6900 i i- - -� -- -r- , 0¢ Wt- -TN 10£f (qi I I I � wo -©I ntt 6L 6Z£1 oo� �Y a0161 6Z� 33 7"" DL lI ZZZZZWJ I I 1 0 IIII I I i I I I I I N IZZU1 ss U I I YY� N9 fff n�n-_� gI gI dS Fi 8 id 6 b1 7d 09+ I I I I IIN_ Std lf£ 04h L _ I 1 I I a91 LS off I_ I - I — 1 CM ( 9 6U —r 09 W n�. M yif 1 -J—. �119f I f I I I , 1811501£ I - -- 09 I N 961f — — —I of t I — I fi -i I ' I I j -1 ^I I Nz_j__- 00+0 I