Loading...
HomeMy WebLinkAbout20070298 Ver 1_More Info Received_20070510{• TO May 8, 2007 RE: LMG LAND MANAGEMENT GROUP irrc. Environmental Consultants Mr. Brad Shaver U.S. Army Corps of Engineers P.O. Box 1890 Wilmington, NC 28402-1890 Additional Information for Huff Property; Onslow County, NC Action ID# SAW-2007-00736-067 Dear Brad: 7'0288 -, £.. t , ',; ~at:'_. ?~.~ -;; ~J a s ~ Thank you for your letter dated February 28, 2007 in which you request additional information regarding the Huff Property NWP application. Below is a response to each of your comments. a. Overall this plan is too vague to process. Anywhere you have wetlands abutting roads or lot lines our office needs a smaller scale drawing to evaluate the potential of secondary impacts. The intent is to confirm that lots can be developed without any additional wetlands fill and that platted roads will not have clearing or frlling impacts outside the requested area. At the current scale it is too d~cult to read and make those conclusions. Enclosed is a revised site plan that shows additional project detail. As you will note, significant changes have been made to the site plan. A total of 169 single-family lots, 91 townhomes, and five condominium buildings are proposed. This site plan clearly shows that all proposed buildings will be located outside of any wetlands. b. During the initial wetland verification the property reviewed was much larger than the current project boundary. Please disclose all adjacent property owned by you or related entities. This is necessary to determine if there are any other access options to the property or plans for future development. If there are other reasonably relatedprojects they should be disclosed now and reviewed under one action. Due to different development ideas and timelines, the entire property has been subdivided among the initial owners. Ralph Huff now owns this parcel. I spoke with John Lare, who owns the adjacent parcel. He has no immediate plans to develop his parcel. There are no plans to tie the development of these parcels together. www.lmgroup.net • info@Imgroup.net • Phone: 910.452.0001 • Fax: 910.452.0060 3805 Wrightsville Ave., Suite 15, Wilmington, NC 28403 • P.O. Box 2522, Wilmington, NC 28402 F c. The Corps appreciates the attempts at avoidance and minimization through the use of bridges and bottomless culverts. However, in order to make a no wetland impact determination as portrayed within the plans, the Corps will need better drawings of the crossing areas. Please provide specific drawings of each crossing to include plan and profile view. The current drawings refer to future approved designs but these need to be decided now. If bridges are proposed, please provide the height of the bridge over wetlands as this will be important from a shading standpoint. The current bridge cross sections refer to a height of 3'; please provide evidence that this elevation is high enough not to cause significant shading impacts. Please provide the details of the proposed bottomless culverts where proposed. Enclosed are drawings for each proposed bridge crossing. The applicant has increased the proposed height of the bridges to a minimum of 4' above ground. The typical vegetation located in wetlands at this crossing consists of loblolly pine, red maple, wax myrtle, and red bay trees. These species often grow in the shrub layer of thick forests where little sunlight penetrates through. Given a 50' wideright-of--way, these trees should be able to continue to grow under the proposed bridges. d. At minimum please number the lots so that it is clear which lots will be developed It appears that several lots have wetland portions and it's not clear that they can be developed without wetland impact. The revised site plan shows lot and unit numbers. No wetland fill will occur for individual lot development. e. The current plan does not appear to choose the least environmentallydamaging practicable alternative. The available high ground along the northern property boundary appears to be abetter location to access the property and thus reduce the wetland impact. It is recognized that the justification for the access road location is to maximize the marketability of the subdivision. Surely there has to be other ways to market the property at the least environmentally damaging location. Innovative landscaping or privacy fencing could protect the entrance from adjacent properties. The high ground along the road could remain the sales office with the adjacent entrance. If this option is deemed impracticable additional justification will need to be disclosed. As noted, the applicant strongly prefers to locate the entrance road in the proposed location. Even with landscaping and fencing, the restaurant/bar would still be visible and audible from a road that was located in this northern section. This road would be the first impression to potential lot owners and positioning it so close to a noisy restaurant/bar would negatively affect sales. In addition, the applicant plans to place a sales center on the upland knob located off of Highway 210, adjacent to the proposed road. Ifthe entrance road were moved to this northern location, a serious traffic concern would be raised with potential purchasers leaving the sales center against 2 traffic, then turning again against traffic into the proposed development. This would be a dangerous traffic situation and is not a practicable alternative. Finally, entrances are better located in the center of properties to increase the distance between approaches from adjacent tracts. f. If the entrance road is determined to be positioned in the least environmentally damaging practicable location, at minimum several culverts will need to be proposed to keep the hydrologic connection between the two wetlands severed by the road. The revised site plan now shows four culverts at this road crossing (Inset 5 of 6}. g. The Corps once again appreciates the consideration of on site preservation as part of the mitigation package. To continue processing, the Corps will need to review the preservation document and the draft recordable preservation map. Enclosed are the draft restrictive covenants. The surveyor is currently preparing a wetlands preservation map and this will be forwarded to your office as soon as it is complete. These documents will be recorded prior to the sale of any lots. I hope this response adequately addresses your concerns. Please let me know if you have any additional questions. Thank you for your assistance with this project. Sincerely, ~~ Kim Williams Wetland Scientist Encl. C: Mr. D. Ralph Huff III Mr. Billy Sutton Mr. Dave Bartone Ms. Joanne Steenhuis, DWQ Mr. Ian McMillan, DWQ LMG LAND MANAGEMENT GROUP irrc. Environmental Consultants May 8, 2007 TO: Ms. Joanne Steenhuis Division of Water Quality 127 Cardinal Drive Extension Wilmington, NC 28405 RE: Additional Information for Huff Property; Onslow County, NC DWQ# 07 0298 Dear Joanne: Thank you for your letter dated March 6, 2007 in which you request additional information regarding the HuffProperty 401 Water Quality Certification application. Below is a response to each of your comments. 1. Impact Justification (Avoidance and Minimization) It appears that impacts associated with the crossing can be minimized by moving the alignment of the crossing in a more northern direction to avoid and minimize wetland impacts. Please revise the narrative and plans accordingly. As noted, the applicant strongly prefers to locate the entrance road as depicted in the proposed site plan because arestaurant/bar exists on the adjacent tract very close to this northern property line. Even with landscaping and fencing, this establishment would still be visible and audible from a road that was located in this northern section. This road would be the first impression to potential lot owners and positioning it so close to a noisy restaurant bar would negatively affect sales. In addition, the applicant plans to place a sales center on the upland knob located off of Highway 210, adjacent to the proposed road. If the entrance road were moved to this northern location, a serious traffic concern would be raised with potential purchasers leaving the sales center against traffic, and then turning again against traffic into the proposed development. This would be a dangerous traffic situation and is not a practicable alternative. Finally, from an engineering standpoint, entrances are better located in the center of properties to increase the distance between approaches from adjacent tracts. 2. Mitigation You will be required to place a deed notification/deed restriction on the remaining wetlands on the project. Please provide a notarized copy of the draft deed notification/restriction, covenants, preservation (if required by the Corps) language that, at a minimum, notify future lot owners that there are wetlands on the property, which are protected by the NCDivision of Water Quality and the US Army Corps of Engineers. If you plan on preserving the www.lmgroup.net • info@Imgroup.net • Phone: 910.452.0001 • Fax: 910.452.0060 3805 Wrightsville Ave., Suite 15, Wilmington, NC 28403 • P.O. Box 2522, Wilmington, NC 28402 remaining wetlands on the tract, please provide a notarized copy of the draft language that will accomplish preservation. Enclosed are the draft restrictive covenants. The surveyor is currently preparing a wetlands preservation map and this will be forwarded to your office as soon as it is complete. These documents will be recorded prior to the sale of any lots. 3. NPDES General Stormwater Permit No. NeG010000 Monitoring Requirements Upon the approval of an Erosion and Sedimentation Control Plan issued by the Division of Land Resources or a DLR delegated local erosion and sedimentation control program, an NPDES General stormwater permit (NCG010000) administered by DWQ is automatically issued to the project. This General Permit allows stormwater to be discharged during land disturbing construction activities as stipulated by conditions in the permit. If your project is covered by this permit (applicable to construction projects that disturb one or more acres), full compliance with permit conditions including the sedimentation control plan, self- monitoring, record keeping and reporting requirements are required. This project will disturb greater than one acre of land and will need an Erosion and Sedimentation Control Permit. The applicant will comply with all applicable permit conditions covered under the NPDES General Stormwater Permit. I hope this response adequately addresses your concerns. Please let me know if you have any additional questions. Thank you for your assistance with this project. Sincerely, ii (,,,, `,~..~,~. --~ ~'`-~-- , Kim Williams Wetland Scientist Encl. C: Mr. D. Ralph Huff III Mr. Billy Sutton Mr. Dave Bartone Mr. Ian McMillan, DWQ Mr. Brad Shaver, ACOE 2 ~ur~oz~~ ~ZON `~.uno~ moisup ~ o dEyq ~oEduiI gezanp ;~ s~s~~u~ ~a~dLUI pu~~arn o ado ~ ~ z ~ w ~' m ~ sd ~H ~ X w O d~ U W J~W_O ¢ ~ r-a ~ w O O (n Q~~3 W W d 0o O -~ cn ao N Z w CO ~. w _,_,._. Q ~ r z ~ _ ~_ II ~ I- W N W (n ~ N~ W C7 T ~ r-;r J (n 0 Z Z U ° N W Z J ~ V' Q Q ~' Q ~ ri7 i,`P ~. .t CC U Z ~ ~ ~ z Q ~--i ~ WOWJUN OU I ~ ~:. _.._ '_~ ti; (n} ZOp~~ ~ J x ~ z~~~Za. ~Q~w^ W`n N dr_.,r' "~ ,yam; ~O ~oQZw Z x W ~ .~ Q~Z p wUU J O tzY O `.'WO;~ ~`~ .~.~~ OJ 000 ~ W W ~ Ra ° .-, Ul W O F ,...._ -T -a ~ Q H m Z Q QZ~~O Z¢Q <..:__ ~ ~ J JQ Z W ¢mcnZ W Cam ~k'y ~-- <2 ~~ ~(n0 O cn ~ J ~ In - Z J Q Z ~ !~ C~..1 t GL ~ c.•i ~ W () N W J - (n W WQpp~ OS W~~W ~ QQ .. _,• ~ IJ.iT SOU WQW7J ~ W ~~r,^,,.~k'~ ~ ZJU Z~Z~U7 Q Z I P ~ ~ g 1 t p I ,~ d~~ ,~~• ~,~,.,,,,,,• o ~~ ~, ~ a --.,...Q ~..~.. '„ ~~b z N ~k J Y .% , J ~ J Z Q w ~ oa ' ~~ ~ ao ~ o C' Q J r r ~......,, ; ~° ~ o ~~o O3w r ~ ~ C\2 o ~ ~ ~ ,~ ~ ~ ~ ~~}.• f . . `t,.~ o oo,~ °~ oo ~ - O~ O O Iz O ~ . y~--- ®~ w ~, z Z L~ 1'7 ~ ~ ® ~ m ~ i;~ Q O W ~ H o~ Z aN l ~ n ~ ® ~.~t O ~ ~ ~ r c~~^ ~' .t C OW W a ~ _ _ W ~i W 1 0 ® °ov - ~ ~ o ~; o ,~ - _ ~.w~.. o . ~_ ~b ~^ o ~~ --_ - r h r ~ ~ 0 0 0 ---„- _ ~-~ ~ ; ~ o~ ~ ~~ ~~ \ ~W 1 - a a ~ ~ O ~ :/ '~ ~ ~ ~ w~ ~ ~ ~ Z .~ ~` ,~ i. . Fc' a~( ~ p Q ~ a'" ~~. O ~ O ~`-' Z `r ~ N O I__ ~J ° O - i U Z L~ N ~~" ~ o ~ a ~ ~ ~ ~ ~~ ,!~ ~ zQ vWi o ~ CGS ~ ° ~ Z W~ - ~ ~J~. oo._. o z Z ~'- ~.,~ ~ Z Q can a (~ Z W ~ J Z W F- (n W W O~ W ~ ~ 00~ ~ Z 0.. ~ 1 /' _.. .. :_ ~ . EXISTING WETLAND' ~ AREA' /` s ~' ~ { ~ . _ ~ GTH ~ ~'---~_'._ OFIN~T n.~._ _ - / Q ^^~' y ~ WETLAND NOTES: WETLANDS FLAGGED BY: LAND MANAGEMENT GROUP, INC. 3805 WRIGHTSVILLE AVE.-STE. 15 WILMINGTON, N.C. 28403 PHONE: (910)452-0001 WETLAND FLAGS FIELD LOCATED BY: GRAPHIC SCALE JIM BLANCHARD AS50CIATES tzo o so t2o 240 443 SARECTA ROAD KENANSVILLE, NC 28349 PHONE: (910)296-1921 1 inch = 120 ft. NOTE: LOT LAYOUT SHOWN IS CONCEPTUAL ONLY, 0 ~U ~~ ~ ~~ o ~Z ~-~' ~~ ~ x~U O t~/a LEGEND ~ I` ~ EXISTING WETLAND ~1Li!~~ WETLAND IMPACT INSET 1 OF 6 C E UPLAND A I C'CiRp 2p, i II 9~c~ Oq0 I `"` ' PROPOSED MFR ~ ' ,~ '~ SPAN (48') E UPLAND ~~~ ~ ``~ ~` ~ ~ ` ~~ ,/ / ~ ~'1 E ,_ / q `-~t, UPLAND PROPOSED ~ ~ PROF'. qg~ SPAN (122') \. ,,,ROAD FAS MENrF SPAN 1 (NO WETLAND IMPACT) WETLAND NOTES: WETLANDS FLAGGED BY: LAND MANAGEMENT GROUP, INC. 3805 WRIGHTSVILLE AVE.-STE. 15 WILMINGTON, N.C: 28403 PHONE: (910)452-0001 WETLAND FLAGS FIELD LOCATED BY. JIM BLANCHARD ASSOCIATES 443 SARECTA ROAD KENANSVILLE, NC 28349 PHONE: (910)296-1921 SEE INSET 6 FOR SECTIONS ~ I h_ p` 1, 2Q k SPA.. N ~2 (NO WETLAND IMPACT) GRAPHIC SCALE 50 0 25 50 100 1 inch = 50 ft. N 0 TE: LOT LAYOUT SHOWN IS CONCEPTUAL ONLY C~ N ~U ~~ O ~ Z' '~ C/) ~ ', rd ~ x~U O LEGEND 0 EXISTING WETLAND INSET 2 OF 6 ~ y ~o ~. ~ ~~a~ X- ~~ ~ ~' o~-!~` 'k ~ ~~ I ,~ ~ ;` ~ ,~ ~~ ~, ~„~ i ~~~~,~ ~~ ~PROP05ED y .SPAN (1EU) ~~~~ , i~ I N ~O ~O-o -yam . - i ~ ~± ~N ~ ~~~2 ~~ ~, 2~ i SPAN 3 (NO WETLAND IMPACT) WETLAND NOTES: 'WETLANDS FLAGGED BY: ', LAND MANAGEMENT GROUP, iNC. 3805 WRIGHTSVILLE AVE.-STE. 15 WILMINGTON, N.C. 28403 PHONE: (910)452-0001 WETLAND FLAGS FIELD LOCATED BY: ~ JIM BLANCHARD ASSOCIATES 443 SARECTA ROAD KENANSVILLE, NC 28349 PHONE: (910)296-1921 s ~~ ~ , C UPLAND SEE INSET 6 FOR SECTIONS GRAPHIC SCALE 50 0 25 50 100 1 inch = 50 ft. NOTE: LOT LAYOUT SHOWN IS CONCEPTUAL ONLY CCf d' O ~S U ~~ a~z 0 ~~~ r~ b w O LEGEND 0 EXISTING WETLAND INSET 3 OF 6 SPAN ~4 (NO WETLAND IMPACT) f ~~~~ ~ ~~ Q~~~ ~ 0~ Q' ~,-EXISTIt~JG WETLP,NG. OQ~p ~ / AFZEA ~ Q ~pP / `UPLAND \, / PROPOSED SPAN (45') ~~~ ~~Y~o UPLAND ~ `~; SPAN #5 (NO WETLAND IMPACT) WETLAND NOTES: WETLANDS FLAGGED BY: LAND MANAGEMENT GROUP, INC. 3805 WRIGHTSVILLE AVE.-STE. 15 WILMINGTON, N.C. 28403 PHONE: (910)452-0001 WETLAND FLAGS FIELD LOCATED BY: JIM BLANCHARD ASSOCIATES 443 SARECTA ROAD KENANSVILLE, NC 28349 PHONE: (910)296-1921 SEE INSET 6 FOR SECTIONS ~ ~ GRAPHIC SCALE 50 0 25 50 100 1 inch = 50 ft. C~ C~ ~U ~~~ O!(/1Z 'd ~', x~~ NOTE: LOT LAYOUT SHOWN IS CONCEPTUAL ONLY. ~ rn LEGEND ~ L_ ~ EXISTING WETLAND INSET 4 OF 6 50' R/W (PRIVATE EASEMENT) SHELF LANE LANE LANE SHELF PROPOSED SHOULDER SHOULDER GRADE 1 '/ ~~\~~\~~~~~~~~~ WETLAND F ~L ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~j~~j~ EXISTING CROSS SECTION A-A GROUND (WETLAND) NOT TO SCALE 45' R/W (PRIVATE EASEMENT) PROPOSED SHELF LANE LANE SHELF GRADE SHOULDER SHOULDER 1 '/ ~~\~~\~~~~~~~~~ Wj LT AND ~ L\~/j~~"/ ~j~~j~~j~~j~~j~~j~~j/~~j/~ EXISTING CROSS SECTION B-B GROUND (WETLAND) NOT TO SCALE EXISTING WETLANDS 0 N ~~j ~~j~ ~~j~~j~ ~~j ~~j~~j~~j~~j ~ ~~j~ 4'MIN. 0 18" RCP PROPOSED WETLAND FILL - 470 LF (TYP.) PROPOSED BRIDGE (NO WETLAND IMPACT) ENTRANCE ROAD PROFILE PIER SUPPORTS AS NECESSARY NOT TO SCALE EXISTING GROUND (WETLAND) a PIER SUPPORTS AS NECESSARY ENTRANCE BRIDGING CROSS-SECTION C-C Huff Property NOT TO SCALE Impact Cross-Sections Onslow County, North Carolina INSET 5 OF 6 SHELF/ SHOULDER 45' R/W (PRIVATE EASEMENT) PROPOSED LANE ~ LANE PROPOSED BOTTOMLESS CONSPAN OR APPROVED SHELF/ SHOULDER EQUAL PROPOSED GRADE PIER SUPPORTS AS NECESSARY EXISTING CROSS SECTION D-D WETLAND NOT TO SCALE ROAD SURFACE NO WETLAND N O FILL PROPOSED ~ '~ EXISTING WETLANDS BOTTOMLESS CONSPAN OR APPROVED E U ~""~ ~ Q AL a ~ ~ ~ CROSS SECTION E-E PIER AS SUPPORTS °z ~ NECESSARY ~ ~ ~ (SPAN LENGTH VARIES) a O ~ ~' Z ~ NOT TO SCALE w J ~ SPAN END FOUNDATION (OUTSIDE OF WETLAND) ~ ~ L~ 'Cj x ~ U O INSET 6 OF 6 PRELIMINARY DRAFT (D~ayteliime: 4127120019:06 am DECLARATION OF COVENANTS, CONDITIONS"" ~~' WLMAIM16114411 AND RESTRICTIONS FOR [GOOSE BAY PLANTATION] THIS DOCUMENT REGULATES OR PROHIBITS THE DISPLAY OF THE FLAG OF THE UNITED STATES OF AMERICA OR STATE OF NORTH CAROLINA. THIS DOCUMENT REGULATES OR PROHIBITS THE DISPLAY OF POLITICAL SIGNS. interest in such losses may be prohibited from participating in the settlement negotiations, if any, related to the loss; and 6.3 Owner's Insurance. By virtue of owning a Unit upon a Lot, each Owner covenants and agrees with all other Owners and with the Association to carry property insurance covering risks of physical loss for both the Unit and any other insurable improvements on the Lot for the full insurable replacement cost thereof, less a reasonable deductible, unless any Subsidiary Association having jurisdiction over such Owner's Unit and Lot carries such insurance pursuant to any Supplemental Declaration or otherwise. Such property insurance shall include windstorm and hail coverage, and, if full insurable replacement cost is not reasonably available for such coverage, actual cash value may be substituted. Each Owner shall, upon request from the Association, provide evidence of insurance coverage to the Association. Each Owner further covenants and agrees that in the event of damage to or destruction of the Unit or any other structures on or comprising his or her Lot, he or she shall proceed promptly to repair or to reconstruct in a manner consistent with the original construction or such other plans and specifications as are approved in accordance with Article 11 of this Declaration. Alternatively, the Owner shall clear the Lot of all debris and ruins and maintain the Lot in a neat and attractive, landscaped condition consistent with the Community-Wide Standard. The Owner shall pay any costs which are not covered by insurance proceeds. 6.4 Loss Adjustment, Repair and Proceeds. With respect to any loss covered by the policy (or policies) of the Association, it shall be adjusted by the Association and matters pertaining to the disbursement of proceeds of such insurance and the repair or replacement, including termination of the Project, shall be governed by the applicable provisions of the Act. Article 7. Conservation Areas Covenants. 7.1 Conservation Areas. The areas shown on the recorded plats of [Goose Bay Plantation], including the plat filed with the Register of Deeds in Map Book at Page , as "conservation areas" shall be maintained in perpetuity in their natural or mitigated condition. 7.2 Conservation Areas Covenants. No person or entity shall perform any of the following activities on such conservation areas: (a) Fill, grade, excavate, or perform any other land disturbing activities; (b) Cut, mow, burn, remove, or harm any vegetation; (c) Construct or place any roads, trails, walkways, buildings, mobile homes, signs, utility poles or towers, or any other permanent or temporary structures; 18 (d) Drain or otherwise disrupt or alter the hydrology or drainage ways of the conservation area; (e) Dump or store soil, trash, or other waste; (f) Graze or water animals, or use for any agricultural or horticultural purpose. The covenants set forth in this Section 7.2 are intended to ensure continued compliance with the mitigation condition of a Clean Water Act authorization issued by the United States of America, U.S. Army Corps of Engineers, Wilmington District, Action ID ,and therefore may be enforced by the United States of America. These covenants are to run with the land, and shall be binding on the Owners, Association, and all parties claiming under it. 7.3 Amendment. The covenants set forth in this Article 7 pertaining to conservation areas may not be altered, rescinded, or modified without the express written consent of the U.S. Army Corps of Engineers, Wilmington District. Article 8. Permit: Transfer, Responsibilities and Covenants. 8.1 Transfer to and Acceptance by Association. Declarant shall, at its sole cost and expense, initially construct all Stormwater Management Facilities required to be located upon the Property or upon any property annexed into the Property by Declarant to the standards required by the Permit. Upon completion of the initial construction of the Stormwater Management Facilities, Declarant shall transfer the Permit and Declarant's responsibilities under the Permit to the Association and the Association shall accept such transfer. Thereafter, upon completion of the initial construction of the Stormwater Management Facilities required by the applicable Permit for any additional property annexed by Declarant into the Property pursuant to this Declaration, Declarant shall transfer the applicable Permit and Declarant's responsibilities under the Permit applicable to the property annexed by Declarant into the Property to the Association. The Association shall accept the transfer from Declarant of the applicable Permit and responsibilities under the Permit. Transfers of any such Permit shall occur upon the earlier to occur of (i) the date the North Carolina Department of Environment and Natural Resources allows the transfer of the Permit to occur; or, (ii) the date after which at least fifty percent (50%) of the Lots therein are conveyed to Owners other than Declarant; and, in the case of property hereinafter annexed into the Property by Declarant as provided herein, the date after which at least fifty percent (50%) of the annexed Lots are conveyed to Owners other than Declarant. Prior to any such transfer of the Permit, the Stormwater Management Facilities for the Property, including any property annexed by Declarant into the Property, shall be certified to the Association and the State of North Carolina, either by state inspection or by a licensed engineer, as being in compliance with the applicable Permit prior to such assignment or transfer. 19