Loading...
HomeMy WebLinkAboutWQ0001669_Regional Office Historical File Pre 2018 (2)t Al'orth Carolina State Univer, School of Agriculture and Life s i r WONEWEEMEMENEMONW- Department of Biological and Agricultural Engineering Box 7625, Raleigh, NC 27695-7625 MEMORANDUM TO: FROM A, R. Rubin, Extens'lon Spr,,,cLajjst Bi p. gical and Agricultuv'al Enqineering SUBJECT R(-',port of 'Investigat-Lon . t.t.acb ,d w s a COPY Of the. t ep or t, for t p-e land application of waste e t R . bt Cooperative Extenskm tt' r°)x itr Agriculture and [tome Pconornics 'azrnd N.(."e State 1Trrtve>r°sptues„ 100 Counties and U. S, L)e tirttartmt cwfAgric"ultu e SITE INVESTIGATION ADDENDUM HICKORY, NORTH CAROLINA The town of Hickory, North Carolina is currently permitted to land treat sludge on several locations throughout Catawba County, North Carolina. Additional sites have been investigated for purposes of land treatment and the purpose of this report is to describe the conditions encountered on to of the additional sites. 'In addition, recur unnendations regarding the application of sludge and appropriate loadings will be made. This report is considered an addendum to the report previously submitted. SITE INVESTIGATION Site Locations Four additional sites were investigated for 'purposes of sludge treatment. These 4 sites include: 1) a farm located approximately I mile from the Henry Fork Plant, 2) a farm south and east of the plant henceforth labeled Finger Farm, 3) the airport property, and 4) Alexander County farms. imosmnah The four additional sites investigated for purposes of land treatment were typical of the piedmont physiogeographic providence of the state. The slope is gentle on all sites and the maximuta slope did not appear to exceed 10%. The first site investigated appeared to have the most severe slope problem and slope did not appear to exceed any maximums whicb can easily tolerate sludge application. In general, the maximum slope encountered on most .its was no more than 5 or 6% and topography should pose little or no limitation to the operation of these land treatment facilities. 2 Soils The soils on all sites appeared to be very well drained upland soils typical of the piedmont. The predominant soil encountered on all sites appeared to be a Cecil/Pacolet-like clay loam or an Appling-like an clay loam. The airport property was drastically disturbed land and a soil profile description for the airport property is really unnecessary. The soils encountered on the natural sites are very similar to those reported in the original, soil sampling program and for that reagon soil profile descriptions for those soils are not 'included in this report arid questions concerning soil profile descriptions can be referred to the original, report. Additional soil sampling was accomplished on the four sites and a portion of the data was provided by the town of Hickory. Site 1, that located nearest the plant, however, had not been sampled at the time of the investigation and sampling was accomplished to determine the physical and chemical properties of' that soil. Soil testing included determination of soil pH, acidity, exchange capacity and nutrient status. In general, the soil testing indicated that each site should receive between .5 and 1.5 tons of lime per acre per year. This should be accomplished prior to receiving any sludge. Additional potassium (between 30 and 50 pounds per acre per year) should also be added to ensure balanced nutrient loadings are placed on the site. The potassium should be added at the same time. as the lime since both constituents move slowly into the soil. The chemical testing indicated that the exchange capacity in the nabs_ it was well above the 5 milliequivalents per hundred gram category; however, the exchange capacity in the topsoil was generally in the 3 to 5 milliequivalents per hundred gram range and for this reason conservative sludge loadings would be recommended. The metal loadings onto Soil pH and supplemental potassium hould be adjusted prier to the application f any sludgeon any site. These amendments should be added a recommended in the soil test. The recommendations are summarized in the table below. Table , 1. Selected sail characteristics and supplement recommendations, Hickory, NC SITE H RECOMMENDED LIME RECOMMENDEDCEO 2 5.2 1.5-" 2. 5.4 /AC / 50 L 5.1. 1.1 T/Ate " 0 /AC 7 Conclusion These land treatment sites appear to be well suited as receiver sites for the town of Hickory. Supplemental site investigations will be accomplished during a subsequent visit to Hickory and a second addendum will be filed. ld Metal, the land area available for sludge application for the town of Hickory should well exceed the laced area required for the assimilation of all of the onstituents encountered in the sludge. The laced application operation; for the town of Hickory will prove to be a very viable land treatment alternative and very coat effective in the long run WC Public utilities Department ' September 4 9 86 North Carolina, Department of Natural Resources and Community Development ttna Mr. Thurman Horne Post Office 'Box 950 Mooresville, North Carolina Sheaf Mr. Horne: In response to your letter of August 21, 1986, concerning disposal: of sludge on Site (Sherrill Property), are making` the following report. City personnel met with Mr. Frank Post of O, Inc. sludge haulers for the City, of Hickory, and Pointed out the violations ions which were occurring. n response to this eat ng, Mr. Poet mat with operators of the sludge spreading equipment to correct thmatter. Attached you will find a written, response from AM CO, Inc. which we fees will correct any future problems. Should more information be needed, please advise. Sincerely, C flu If ;. err Twiggs, Public Utilities Director JT: ddr cc: B. Cary McGee, City Manager r. Frank Foot, AMSCO, Inc. m _. ...ku�5.%�La`+.wY'acFfr�N.whA.P .rowu+asi ,z.:*, + .. ti w:am rmN%kaYas A� atis r August . 1986 Tau _ gar Div. of Env. Man. P. 0. Box 950 Mooresville, 11 Subject: City of Hickory, Buffer one Violation Dear Mr. pare The attached e o and verbal communications have been implemented. PM3CO sincerely apbligizesfor the oPerstor error if edditional corrective actions are required, please contact this office. Sincerely *ours s R drank Post t h ' " r�r' re ON,— R k.: r�. � � ,._ z.. 68 ONS, NC 27102 August4. ', Mr. Jerr,7 "wIg Public Utilities Director it of Hickory "':ickory, N . Subject: D.T.4. Letter August 1 Lena Applicstion ioncc--plipnce Dear Mrs Twigg8, Enclosed is the letter to our Project 'Flanager Find tie corrective actions to be taken to ensure test this il tion of the rermit does not happen again. We sincerely Pooligize that this t ne of i)er for error has occurred. If ;you have any questions, please calf Sincerely yours President., �a e'9'Id:++.wag„.a3e'.aW_.'wdlv*.'. ,.. ,c.^..h'u*°tt+MVNUN, o�c+x.,. v4'rwwa, r't�x&.0 rRv§'• SaWT 'ews ,,.: � ma..<..wwnemk ID&w'u'eA...uv'+-ry the '"kbaP t"x`mbv^: # .. .` w4ew+G'....:vG ""t" Y'3. ,...5 T tW.""":: P if ,. 8 To: Gregg "Matthews From:F. H. Post .subject Buffer Zone Viol,ations, City ef Hickory, & On or about August 1 , 1986, field onerations where inspected by Mr. Thu ,erg Tiorne, pp i Li,-% . ",lor sv LL e 1-. am r* o investigation the Blitr operator had applied sludge within the 100 foot biiffer zone,of the property line of the Sherrill The following procedures will be implemented immediately: �t 1 . Prior to all lard application activities YOU will contact the land owner or farm anger and physically walk over or drive over the fields to identify pr aert lines, e ls, houses, and Press the t require buffer areas. You andthe field operator will then inspect the field and buffer areas will be identified. . Red flags will be. placed to indicate the proper buffer zone areas, f these Drocedures are not implemented accordingly, further her' actions will be taker. ppppp- State of NoCarolina Departmentof Naturali nd Community Development Mooresville l Office James Martin, Governor Albert F. Hilton, Regional Manager rna ram DIVISION OF ENVIRONMENTAL MANAGEMENT August 21, 1986 Mr. Jerry i s, Public Utilities Director City of Hickory Post Office Box 398 Hickory, North Caro lina Subject: Notice of Noncompliance " City; of Hickory Sludge Land Application/Disposal, Permit No. 10k2 Catawba County, N. C. Dear Mr. is: An inspection of the City's land application procedures was made on August 13 and 15, 1986 at Site No. d (Sherrill Property) by Mt.. Thurman borne of this office. This inspection was made in response to a complaint received by this office. As a result of this inspection, it was observed that the City was in violation of condition No. 14 of the subject permit by failing to maintain a minimum buffer of 100 feet to adjacent lando er's property lines. Mr. Horne observed that sludge was applied immediately adjacent to a property line which separates the Sherrill property from the property of Mr. Kenneth lass. All other aspects of the application program that were observed during the investigation appeared to be in conformity with permit requirements. It is requested that you submit a written response by no later than September S, 1986 indicating your intent to take appropriate action to prevent future violations of the permit requirements. In responding please direct your correspondence to the attention. of Mr. Thurman Horne, Natural Resources and Community Development, post office Box 950, Mooresville, North Carolina 28115. Please be advised that violations of the subject permit are subject to possible enforcement action pursuant to NCGS 1 1 21 .6 including assessment of civil penalties up to $10,000 per violation. 919 North 1n Sueft, Po' Box 930, &'oWftv't1C, NC, 811 0 * 'f 4 699 Art . Equal unity Affirmative . Jerry August 21, 1986 If you have any questions concerning this matter, please contact Mr.. Thurman Horne or me at 4663-1699. Sincerely, Ronald L. McMillan Regional Supervisor cc r Gary McGee Catawba :County Health Department SC Ir. Dennis Ramsey JTH ju if NZ, w ww. y « a i, d a _ • . m i m o- P d *x:} . } i ` ! d 4 d i .. # }. n fi „„} 9 . 4 . } t f : } a d } • }..... d .. # } . }. �;. ii } i •i a i • a 6 r« State. says wails not contaminated ByBju Men 14, jj -rte Errvironmental Man- state a4emen Divisio-,j has conc:,,;ded that we "Is 1-ittle Acres are POt nd the wate!' Laminated asays con ;s safe, zrt Sheppard- a spAess thecivisior, at envicGotne" sae.ta' d III.� from four wells and four.""� unsaf e levels 0 f org anize rn 3 L�rl a', %ad heten water that .. The well high found to contain a origirtallY level of an inorganx substance ,was again and found to be tested of Shepoard said the we"' , j6 fv�I a Nj,%tthews w2s, belonging -_ after the second considered safe test. 'Me environmental division had done tests to detertruile whether there was any ground water con- o �onnected tMnoff taraination froln the National starch and Chemical plant on Cedar Springs Road. -The bottom line is there's no evidence, to link the wells w'th ti"e Sheppard sate:. chemical plant," He said ",te water cNtal- sitight traces of azi Orgallic which he substance called pyrene, described as a coal derivative, He said L1114t arnouilt Nems no. I Ursa f E - arid' t�jat p.yrene ,as that cc�jji, occur naur­­ water Srien ._t,; don't know w, U v-11 ' read�ng of the 7 — szafe rz -, La afte, wa s Organic gu4stance Ast week A 3oesz. wells Uffie Aci ztill being tested BY Din Kos's sites, he said, Sheppard said last week C-e The state Division of Er- natural Movement of Water rnad'c- vironmenta, %fanagemenL is sEll, It unlike!,y that the conjar.,11natior a. L Little Acres came testing salr!'Dles from we!j t� at 10 Irorn Na- - of f CaMD ruled Ljt*Ie Acres Traiie� Park t nal S�zrch. but the state has not ;re ore,well wa's founa to Sheppard setts' I Id he expected tl-- Road Wh ed that on, be CuOn'-Llrnirated ]as* weei; Rowan County Health Dej�,-, bu, sailitari an Paula rnaragemen�, Herior saiLf Tuesdav that s,,e 1,�c� said Water sarnp it - 't's rahe bt,'ng ',Ested in tle state !nborLcort- heard romune Moe bout * Tuesday. wells at I tt!e �A :Arms, He 7he er,,--WoPmentai managerner-, said resuits of -,he teFts al Is= tested eight wells las*, WoUld be sent 10 the Mooresviiie W, �' : regio,nai office of the Department eek and got a,, extrernely high acid reading for one sample. of INaftral Resources and r-Om- Rowever. or, retesting the munity Development, well, tne that ate pH reading. ,vironmen- which measures acidity and Shep'pard said the er state found .tal workers have tried to de- alkalinity, was in th terrnsne the kinds of chemicals range, e normal ,that have been made at Natio nal The initial P14 reading was 1.9. -Starch and Chemical Co. on Cedar The normal oH reading is in the 6 .-Springs Road to determine or 7 range.' The lower the pff 'Whether any of the wells contai traces. Nreading, the higher the acidity. -o match has been made, Sheppard said 'the reading rnust -he said. epOf Sb have corne from -a freak sample­ pard said the division's 'Office'. _n improper testing. He said he E forcement and Emre�g_ Or i�ew of o nother high -acid read, -ency Response had toennotified ida�l and was wor kin on the case, It's 'k axon an emergencv,­ Last Mondav, the Mooresvifle -,e "_d sv,vla Ma"hews -"t, it's sermz�,-, enouar�l fo,netifi said" bu ,, an '0 "fit involved in i,L ansafe organic .5ubstance and ad - He Faid :he enforcemern offis�e vised her not to drink- �t, Sf�e saij AA-o;-`ZS on �Cases sUch as ;sasotiae� Tuesdav that, she had pot 'A 01 or chemical spi!1s, j� h ea r d� am! anvthiaa razor'- since a stat.4`i, o t:, e n f, The soh',d and haza.rd�[:uz Wfarker caflfd to tell '-Zr he Ptit goinc tr -esl the %ve;". next door, AM,sion of :,�,e staie Depar-,"Menl �)f S­ Jiuman Resources 81s, not 'rinkingg water froM ; -nntiffled he saidWe Sa, *ha! Ray Paradiowsj�, pjan_ 1.1_ MR d 0Nationaix l Sturc-, said haisz e f, F: a,, -vorkerS ,sampleF, 0M the cher �arrinated ;vazer rical plan,, He said th4, r "'W Site He snid the Compary damn,­s ro, hazarrious waste i ae :- ais r-4(-,,njng < and -­uIj ze C,"eiivereld Ir­,vaste ru c e d io 'fUesda,�,- after- i the Proper disposal ro T, DIVISION CP ENVIRONMENTAL ' AC ENT July 3, ld M O Nl TO: lee Fleming `fir 4-,7 FROM: Dick Peace THROUGH: Rex Gleason JUL 1 PREPAREDBY. Thurman Horne « d R QUALITY SUBJECT: Unpermitted Sludge Disposal SECTION City of Hickory Catawba County As per ;your request, the staff of the MR0 have reviewed the history of Hickory's unpermitted sludge disposal practices and offer this memorandum an attached correspondence, etc., to summarize the events that have transpired.. As can be seen from review of the:: "Chronological FileSummary" there have been numerous incidences, dating back to July 14, 1980, of illegal sludge disposal practices. There have been at bast three 3 letters sent to the City advising them that this activity requires' a permit. There have been at least as many ""warnings" by telephone. The MR0 has tried' to work with theCity to obtain a land application permit, but this has: been a frustrating experience. The Cite has-been aware of permitting requirements for several years but did not make application for permit uatil.early this year(application received January 23, 1984). Upon receiving this application, the Permits & Engineering Unit advised the City of deficiencies in the permit application documents* Since that time, there have been several telephone calls by the P & R Unit ; (Arthur Hagstrdm) and the '' it (Thurman an Horne) to the City (eft. Jerry I i.ggs) trying to get the City to submit the required additional information. Only recently has it appeared that our message has finally gotten through. After- this. latest ;incidence of unpermitted sludge disposal '(as referenced in the newspaper article in question) and our subsequent warnings by telephone and by letter, it appears that the City realizes that we can not tolerate any future such incidences. It appears that. the City has now submitted all of the requested additional information (received in Raleigh June a' 1r} to allow completion c_ f processing ssin their permit application e 'fie City has stressed That it urgentlyneeds a permi t and we are r.x.n their _ i application our priority attention, even though, as we have expressed to the City, they have essentially brought this dilemma on themselves through their procrastination,, In the interim we have advised the City to ,seek permission from:.. the County landfill to dispose of sludge there. If You have any questions or need any additional information, please advise. CITY OF HICKORY'S SLUDGE DISPOSAL CHRONOLOGICAL FILE SUMMARY June 25, 1984 Letter from. Rex Gleason to the Public Utilities Director acknowledging continued unpermitted land application of sludge. The Director was advised to cease such practices immediately. This letter also requested additional information required to complete the application ,cation for a permit to -dispose of sludge by land application. Letter from Rex Gleason to Mr.. ,Jake A. Sion requesting that he cease the transport and disposal of the sludge from the City of Hickory; until a permit had been acquired by the City. June 21, 1984 Complaint investigation (by Mike parker) concerning sludge disposal can land belonging to Dr. dart.,- In a phone call Gene , Haynes with the City of Hickory said he would see that this was stopped. June g, 1934 Complaint investigation by MikeParker) concerning disposal of sludgebyland application on Dr. Hart's property. Through telephone conversation with Dwight Wilson, with the City of Newton it was learned that the sludge was being hauled from the City .of Hickory Wastewater Treatment Plants January ` 3, 1984 Application for sludge land. application permit received. July 27, 1983 Complaint investigation (by Larry Coble) concerning land application of sludge. The investigation found a large pile of sludge in a pasture belonging to Mr. Merritt Smith. fir. Smith planned to apply the sludge to his pasture. Mr. Terry Twi gs of the City of Hickory stated that the City would not haul anymore sludge to Mr. Smith. July 5, 1983 Letter from Rex Gleason to fir-. .Jerry Twiggs, public Utilities Director for the City of Hickory, stating that, land applicatio of sludge without a. permit is a violation of, applicable Regulations. The letter recommended that City not dispose of sludge in this mannea. any .longer until a permit had been obtained. April 19, 1982 Letter from Rex Gleason to the Director of Public Utilities for the City of Hickory acknowledging the illegal ;disposal (i sludge without a permit it by the City of Hickory. "The letter advised that the City of Hickory apply for a permit to dispose of sludge by Land application,. An application for such a, permit was included with the letter. noMMIN ti esou rans & C"Aprvirnunitv Development Jarnes B. Hunt„ Jr., Governor James A, Surnmers, Secretary DIVISION OF ENIVIRON"REINTAL MANAGEMENT Jere 25, 1984 CERTIFIED MAIL Mr. .Jerry Twiggs Public Utilities Director City of Hickory Post Office Box 398 Hickory, N. C. 28603 Subject: Warning letter' Urpe „ i tied Land Application of Sludge City of Hickory Catawba County, N. C. Dear fit. igs On ,June 5, 1984, and June 11, 1984, this Office received complaints concerning land application ofHickory's wastewater treatment pant sludge on two sates: the Hart property and the Wilfong property. Investigations on Tune 8, 1984, and June 11, 1984, revealed that sludge had been land applied on the Wilfong property located at the corner of State Road 2019 gat FordRoad) and State Road 0 Wil.fan Road). You were notified and advised that any land application -of sludge tout a permit is illegal and,should be ceased immediately. This Office received an additional complaint on ,June 20, 984, concerning disposal of sludge on the property owned by Dr.Hart located on state Road 2029 (Hog Hill Road) The complaint vas investigated on .luxe 21, 1984. This investigation revealed that sludge had been disposed of on the Hart property. You :are been alerted that the disposai of wastewater treatment plat sludge by land application requires a permit froi the Division of En i one enta.i Manta ette (letter to you dated April 19, 1982) . You have also been advised that land ap7ltcaticn,,,g ,,. ar a r treatment, plant sludge "xm:s`..ts..a,.ut a ',,`".�ex:`m.a.::`"t .:%oa:,d. the: Divisica of Environmental ental anage ent is a violation of N. Q General Statute I43-Z•..33 (letter to von dated jul 5, 1983) You are also r� de that u viclatr.ca.s of thin nature are subject to civil penalties of up in !10,000 per dal per 7iolation. :..Lie to continuing violations of N. C. General Statute 14-2 M5 b - ( 9), you are again advised that land application of :Mudge without a permit is illegal and should cease immediately. ediatel,,. s Office will have no alternative than to reccmmend enforcement action if any future violations occur. r. Jake e i " on has also been advised tha.t`. the transporting and disposal of the sludge in such a manner -is illegal and should be: ceased immediately. You are also re indod that additional information is needed in order to rocess pour- application:. nor a -permit fo'r land application of -sludge, =a:ti.. h was recel."v e a u"9�;'r°� c.'a t"i? t�•'?:-,"�;CMl�i 4'ie�.. �. ""` �;. "� .`:" �',: &3 C `1 s"tSl .`sF�'"3i. $ati�aoC,as4ltlu �, +",�", i, = �71*,'�ft�%C ,';3°+0.�:�.%���' r, , W page Two June 25, 1984 January 23, 1984. You were notified that additional information was necessary in a letter dated February 3, 1984, from Mr, H. Dale Crisp. These items have not yet been answered satisfactorily. Numerous telephone calls from this Office zo you and from the Raleigh Office to you have taken place since the February 3, 1984 letter to you, but the necessary information has not yet been received. If you still have questions in regards to the permit application, please contact either Mr. Thurman Horne of this Of f ice at 1704) 663-1699 or Mr. Arthur Hagstrom of the Raleigh Off ice at (919) 733-5083. k Again, you are reminded that until such time as you apply for and receive a permit for the land application of sludge, all such land application of sludge is illegal and should be ceased immediately. If not, appropriate 'enforcement action will be recommended. if you should have any questions, please contact either Mr. Hike Parker, Ms. Tana Fryer, or me at (704) 663-1699. Sincerely, ORM-IHNAL SIGNIED BY D. Rex Gleason, P. E. cc: Mr. Mike Parker Water QuaIK7 Regional Engineer Mr. Jake SigmDn Catawba County Health Department Re (elorment 'c jarnes B, Hunt,, Jr., Governor James A. Surrar�^ers, Secretary IN y At ,tune E5, 19'E CERTIVIEDI Mr. ..sake A. Sig on acute 1 Ear: 488 Newton, N. C. E8653 Subject: Warning getter Unpermitted pared Appination of Sludge City of Hickory Catawba County, N . C. Dear Mr. St.gcn It has been brought to the attention of this Office that you have been transporting sludge from the City of Hickory's wastewater treatment facilities and land applying the sludge. You should be aware that this constitutes trans- porting and disposal of wastewater treatment sludge. Since neither you or the. City has a permit for the land application of Hickory's sludge, you are in iolation of A C. General Statute 1-E1.5.1{ .; 1t is requested that you immediately cease the transport and disposal of the sludge from the City of Hickory until such time as the City has received the necessary land application permit. Please be advised that: continued:violations of the aforementioned Statute are subject to possible enforcement action including the assessment of civil penalties at up to $10,000 per day per violation. It ycu should have any guasticns regarding this please du not hesitate to contact h . Aike Parker, Ms. Tana Fryer or me ate 704) 663-1699. Sincerely, D. Rex Gleason, P. Z. Water Quality Regional Engineer cc: Catawba jounty Health Department yry ... ggs Xr. Mike TP n } +ul�"i3i�t?70466 .. COMPLAW , R!V�" Name of Cowlainant: Address, Tel phone w -- Directions t Site. ,sm Nature of CoEplaint: s Ih u � ecfig,;{g Received Date: , Time: dy. Corresoondenwe Prepared Z . n % aR.el3l o& G 3 A a * 4 s t py s ) R q�.+m op�t \{p q{ f, � ... Po COMPLAINT FORM, tiJ Address: Tel one n Directions to Site. • P Nature a , t s m ,- Received Sv: Date. Time: Date(s) port s a e, Ana t North Carolina Department of Natural Resources &Community Development Jarnes B. Hunt, Jr., Govemor Joseph W. Grirnsley, Secretary DIVISIO14 OF ENVIRONMENTAL �,,MAGE MENT July 29, 1983 Ms. A -Lice Spencer Route 4, Box 21 Conover, T7. C. 28613 Subject* Complaint Investigation Merritt Smith Property Carawba County, N,. C. Dear Ms. Spencer: Attached is a copy of the Report of Investigation regarding the subject complaint. The Report should be self- xpl to ; however, if you have any questions, please contact Mr. Larry D. Coble or me. Sincerely, D. Rex Gleason, P. E. Water Quality Regional Engineer Attachment cc: Mr. Jerry Twiggs Catawba County Health, Department TD C: s i u, M"O—�v''Ap �4eg�t'ua� kl'�jfj ST'rkw'_ C, 2 I'50GSC Teierm'xl�� NORTH KROLINA XPARTMEN7 OF NATURAL RESOURCE"> AND COMMUNITY DEVELOPMENT DIVISION OF&VIRONMENTAL MANAGEMENTe. WASTEWATR*NA GEMENT POST OFFICE BOX 950 MOORESVILLE,,NOPT? CAROL IA 28115 RENOR7 OF PLACE VISITED m DATE Highway 16 ner:h of Conor veRIVER BASIN C L_awba M Larn� le 13 n TIME SPE-17 4 hour APIOD. Cod ------- E -- PERSONS CONTACTED 'mr. Merritt Smi Hi REASON FOR VISIT investigate C M laint COPIES TO: Mr. Jerry Twiggs Catawba County He4lth Department REPORT: On July 27, 1983, this Office received a complaiht from Ms. Alice Spencer of Route 4, Box 21, Conover, N. C. The complaint concerned odors from 4ludge being applied to pasture land. The aludge was from the City of Hickory's at ate treatment Kant and the pasture land belonged to Mr. Merritt Smith. - On july 28, 1983, W. Smith was 0ntacted and an investigation was conducted of the pasture land. It was noted that a rather large pile of dryed sludge was located in *ha` center of the pasture across from W. Smith's house. Mr. Smith statc zhar he pianne! to ioad the sludge into a manure spreader and apply it to his pasture. it appearei :hat no sludge had been on this site for some rime. Mr. Sminh indicatel zhat none had been hauied for 6-2 weeks. Adequate buffers appeared to hav been left betasen the sludge pile and any surface waters. it is expected that therf will be no impact on any nearby streams. Upon return to the -MG, Mr. Jerry Twiggs, Director of Kilities for the Cit,m- of Hickory, was contacted and the problem explained to him. nr. Two ggs was verr! concerned about the problem. He stated that no sludge had been taken to Mr. Smith'E- property for at least several months. He al.80 stated that the City would not haul anymore to Mr. Smith and if the sludge on site was creating a serious problem the,. - City would remove the sludge for disposal in the landfill. Is is recomnended if the problem continues, that is. Spencer contact this Office and our 'itaf f .ail i contact the City to remove the sludge; otnerwise, no murthe"® action is recommended or this time—, Mr. Jerry Tviggs :. Page,. r July , 19-83 "if you have any questionsi please co3dtact ter. Larry D. Coble' or Sincerely, p ( lam. , . l , Rex Gleason, P. E. h. Water Quality RegionalEngineer . 'Attachment -f Alexander County Health Department nt Catawba County HealtIn Department LDC.-sju w ;�-ell a v It ... ... t Jerry 3iractor of Publici ` Hicory Post Wfice Box 398 ;a. A Land: Apaglicatiott of Sludge City of Hittory Catawba CoWTt'YW': Aorth Carolina :y Dear . It has been brtjuqht to the attention of the staff of thi s 0"Itca that the City of Hickory lsludge .�Permit from the fvi ooff' Environmental'Management. application� obtainIn order to, i l :. .. ft"Wat data to Insuret disposaT V is not harrAful to the Thts, reportsboald c=t&in,zIW9e analysis, sail chwwtwfstial l tablewells,, water i tics, application-. rates and disoosal procedures. Upon receipt of VIA completed applitations and the engioes.ring report-*, Officethis 7 i. If you have any ``additionalease watact Larry Cable orme. By ;. 7 LDC s e w 324 lst Ave., S. W. I v JR, U.0, 01PLOMATAW 'Taylors °lle, N. C. TAYLOASWLE r1.e HEALTHCHRECTOR .April 8, 198 AiR Mr. ex Gleason N. C. �1. of Natural Resource dj .unity Development 91.9 North Main Street; Mooresville, North Carolina 811f Dear lmr. Gleason„ We have received a complaint from fir. Gary pope on the City of Hickory for discharging sludge onto a pasture owned by . Clyde Bolick in the Bethlehem i.ty. His property is located on State Road 1149. Following a telephone conversation with Mr. D. Frank Olive with the Division of Health Services and Mr. Robert Apple, Solid and Hazardous Waste Sanitarian, I was notified to contact your, nffi+ e and inform you of this site. If we can be of farther assistance, please tall. Sincerely, 'ferry Bolick Sanitarian T n Na e z y a �y:bu sm-a . Sw"w.,,, rt4.l.�:t�+.._ri e tea„ a + , r w � .. .,,�. �m P `P Yr w. i 4w a".»'»aw. i.� u3 d=uv ���,.:$ di"w •�..y�-�'.���p .m w.. ".,� " .c of Ccmp1,-;n $M Yea $ 'k+ S B y.. on of � TM, Conn jzha-g .. .. w'. e i _ zo 04 won m' x location w Ota M„t $a': .r � L. i :.! i tl Mom. w . wa '6.i bra x r" `.�. !w 4:+.. �,. T 4. kF:a+ S ' 4. �sra A �.. 3 5 i i e . t .`.s prelimiriar-v f final): a. f , - AT.:- , n m NORTH CAROLINA DEPARTMENT OF NATURAL RESOURCES AND COMMUNITY DEVELOPMENT DIVISION OF ENVIRONMENTAL MANAGEMENT WATER QUALITY SECTION POST OFFICE BOX 950 ORESVILLE, NORTH CAROLINA 28115 REPORT OF Complaint Investigation PLACE VISITED Mr. Ralph Pollard Residence DATE July 10, 1980 ADDRESS 3445 15th Avenue, S. W., Hickory, N. C. RIVER BASIN Catawba TIME SPENT BY WHOM Thurman Horne PERSONS CONTACTED Mr. Ra'lph Pollard REASON EON VISIT Complaint of odor coming from sludge being dumped by the City of Hickory onto adjacent property. COPIES TO: Mr, Ralph Pollard REPO Investigation revealed that on two occasions around the latter part of June, sludge from the Hickory Wastewater Treatment Plant had been spread on a garden owned by Mr. Tom, y Barnard. Mr. Pollard explained that at the time, the weather was hot and humid and the associated odors were a nuisance. Since that time, the sludge had been plowed under and several rains had he i Ped to dui his h the odor to what Mr. Pol I and felt was a tot erabl e I eves . It appears, from talking to Mr. Pollard, that this is the first time this has happened and that if it does not occur again, the problem will be solved. I discussed this matter with Mr. Jerry Twiggs, "its. of Hickory, and Mr. Twiggs has agreed to refrain from spreading any sludge in this area. DIVISIOX OF EAVIRONME3TAL July 14, 1980 It. Ralph Pollard 3445 15th Avenue, S . Hickory, North CarolinaI subject: Cospilint, Investigation CatawbaCounty Dear Mr. Pollard; for your reviews is�a copy of my investigotion report. I you bave anyquestions or if you need our,assistance. please call. Si EThurman Horne Permits rl Attachment JTH:se A y -4 North Carolina Department of Natural ,k uc Rp= James . Hunt, Jr., Governor dames A. Summers, Secretary k October '1 , 1984 Mr. Jerry 'T i s Director of Public Utilities Oily of Hickory Post Office Box 398 Hickory, North Carolina 28601 Subject:: hickory ;Sludge Application Site Permit No. 15P1 Catawba County, North Carolina Dear Mr. igs: This Letter is to confirm the conversation, on September 28, 1984, between you and r. Monty Payne of this Office, ice, regarding problems noted at: the City's sludge application sites. The problems noted by fir, Payne were: Mauser Fa — Livestock is grazing in the pastured where the: sludge is being, applied, dry sludge is being piled up instead of being spread. Boman Farm lode is being applied too close to the stream and livestock is allowed to graze where the sludge is being applied. Please have the above problems corrected as soon as possible, Also, these Pe It vi€lat ons may, be 'added to the enforcement recommendation pending against the City. If these violations continue to occur, your Permit to land apply sludge at these sites may also be revoked. If you have any questions concerning this matter, please do not hesitate to contact Mr. Payne or me Sincerely, o P. Rex Gleason, P. P. Water Quality Regional:- Engineer cc: Catawba County Health Department �WS` p: se tviooresvilleReqoxnal Office P 0, Box 950, 919 North Main Street. Mooresville, N, C, 9 115-09 0 `oiephrine °7941 r93-i69 MM. sAr Kinrth n Ra t � larv.e B Hunt,Jr­ Governor Jarnes A, Surnmers, Secretary DIVISION OF ENVIRMIENTAL MNIAGEMENT w f Dear We acknowledge receipt of the following documents f:w 19 uft=i.t application , IN ngineering plans p clfic_ tlon Your project has been assigned to r �,, _ � .. for a detailed engineering revises. All project documents ai will be reviewed with respect to the proposed wastewater facilities. , This review will not commit this Division to, approving n. an ion of these treatment facilities or increase of floe ate in the future,. Prior to the issuance of the permit, you vill, be advised, f the recommendations and comments of this Division. You will also be informed of any matter which needs to be resolved Our revises are c d led based on receipt date; of complete informations. The it tus checked below are ueed d before your project can be reviewed. -,-_permit application (copies enclosed) engineering pinns signed and sealed b sp cifi.atio --other s.ditld � � F The above checked info your aplicdtl n package wi Division's "A is needed by If you have any questions, please call the revieu 919/733-5083. Sincerely, t r Vf <r.. L0, NO µe. H, C /meb An Equal Opportunity Affirmative Action err L Ter i awt.n U nu, be aware that RECO Dg rr ; Tie: c1 T prirar it this t elepfa CAMLINA ENVIRONMFNTAL MXNAGE.#,MNTCOMMISSION A?ARTMNT OF NATURAL SOURCEAND COMMUTY ;DEVELOPMENET pppppp- zlemen: to accordance with the provisions of Article11 of Oiapter I""a , General Statutes of North Carolina aa amended, application is hereby made by Public utilities (Name of board, individual or others) of the in the county 14 �.l1axe, town. Ita�j district or edtablishment) of to the North Carolina Envireumatal Management (Locatlon of;ptdt Commission, p tt of Natural Resources and Commmity Development for the approval of the accoupanying plans, specifications, and other data submitted herewith touting the M Sal and for da "Permit" for the distcrge o (, dtrtxnl t herwastes) from the fie=v Fork Plant and the Rxtheast Plant (severs, pretreatment facilities, treatment plan serving :to of It .p It , ttt .tutlon or industry, etc.)(Naze- of treatment plant) or ground waters, tributary to at (Nam of ter course) ZLOIM�ion Of trearment plant) .., b �. -• ..prepared,by iu tt (Address) It is eatimatedthat treatmut works will provide adequate to capacity to serve the -". for a pled of 2 years, at Vhich e it is estimated the average daily sewage or waste flow, will not exceed S .. It is furtherexpected that the treatment works will affect overall reductions In pollution d follows: . . .. -day 200 C , suspended algid total. lids , cal n bacteria , d t terials* The coat of the proposed nt is eatizated to ere , punping atatna treatment plant , other The worms will be completed on or before l a The applicutt hereby agrees that the propowid corks will be constni tsd in strict accordance with the approved puns and specifications or subwquently approved changn th r in and further agrees to place its operation under the rue of a competent pawn and to mamtm and operatt the plant acowding to the btst acetpted practice and in accordance `th the pians and spoHfications appmved by the Conivession, Sutter. City of Hickcry Mailing Hickon,,, Mr., err y Twiggs 'Attachment February 3, 1984 1. Provide scaled site topo maps for the disposal areas in question. Show where sludge is to be applied, property lines, potable water wells, surface waters, and site access. (Where is site in relation to WWTP's?) 2. Submit an E.P. toxicity analysis and indicate ift—cif -sludges. 3. Indicate, specifically, how sludge will be applied. at equipment will be used, bow site cover will be harvested and when. 4. Note buffer zones on the application site map. We recommend the following: a. wells - 100 ft. d. property lines 100 ft. b. surface water - 100 fte, right of ways 50 ft. c. residences - 100 ft. f. drainage ways 50 ft. 5. Indicate exactly how much land will be used. 6. Is the application area in a flood plain? 7. How is sludge stored during inclement weather? 8. Is the land owned by the City? If not we require that you submit a letter of acceptance from the land owner or a copy of the land use agreement. k copy and an example agreement is enclosed. Januax- 1� i I'ORTH CAROLINA ENVIRONMENTAL AGE T'COMMISSION DEPARTMENT OF NATURAL SOURCES AND COMMUNITY DEVELOPMENT Gentlemen: In accordance with;the provisions of Article 21 of Chapter 1, General Statutes of North Carolina as amended, application is hereby made by Public Utilities nt of board,�iudividual or others f the City of Hi:c oxT in the county (l- of city, village, town, sanitary district or establishment) of Catawba to the North Carolina Environmental Management (Location of proect Commission, Department of Natural sources and Community; Development for the approval; of the accompanying plans, specifications, and other data submitted herewith covering the of t and for a "Permit" for the discharge of sludge (savage, industrial waste or other wastes) from the HenryFork Plant and NbrtLeg_tst__P11ant (severs, pretreatment facilities, or treatment plant) serving City of Hickory into (Name of municipality,insiituti or industry, etc.) (Name of treatment Plant) or ground waters, tributary to at (N water course (Location of treatment plant) e plans for the proposed works ks have been prepared by Cit of Hickory iaider 'Firm) of Pa 0. Box 33, Hickory, N. C. 28603 (Address) t is estimated that treatment works will provide adequate capacity to serve the City of ! t for a period of 2 years, at which time it is estimated the average daily sewage or waste flow will not exceed gallons. it is further expected that the treatment works will affect overall reductions in pollution as follows: .O.D. ( -day , suspended solids LL total solids ', coliform bacteria and toxic materials*. The cost of the proposed works is estimated to be: wers pumping station treatment plant , other The works will be completed on or before lg The applicant hereby agrees that the proposed works will be constructed in strict accordance with the approved plans and specifications or subsequently approved changes therein and further agrees to piece its operation under the care of a competent person and to maintain and operate the plant according -to the best accepted practice and in accordance with the plans and specifications approved by the Commission. Signature. '` r Title: Public tilities Director P. 0 398 Mailing Address: Hickon, N : C, 28603 *Specify percentage reduction for each toxic substance, using additional sheet, if necessary, Ro the 41CATI ,' n in d PEMII do hereby certify that Llly appeared before . this day and acknowledged ns f . ;his h day, of july 1 N. C. DIVISION P ENVIROtMiNTAL MANAGEMENTSTANDARD, AGRELHENT FOR THE,LAND APPLICATION OF dASTE SLUDGE ON PRIVATE LAND NAME PW1P: Henry ForkWASTEWATER TREATMENT OWNERP P: Ci t Of Hi� LOCATIONOF ' : d ad just siouth of, llick6ry TYPE,OF SLUDGE iq i I FARM NO. FIELD LOCATION,OF LAND Six nii1essoutheast of Henry ork Plant OWNER OF PROPERTY b t Mamer LESSEE OF PPP °it tit LAND USE OR CROPPING PATTERNS Permanent Pasture ,INTENDEDSS OR DISPOSITION OF CROPS site will not be harvested The under i ne land owner or his `represertative,hereby permits the, hereinafter referred to as the Per ittee, to apply s I u-­dg e from the Wastdt4aier Treatment Plant Upon the land at the 1oQ&U0--n;—hdwn as,described in the attached doeuments in accordance with the restrictions, s ipnl Lions and exceptions shown belong. The landowner or his representative rcteivds,,i consideration, fall use of the nutrient valu6 of the applied sludge while the, Pe ittee'e eeeies in consideration, the useof the and described above! for the disposal -of digested sludge. This agreement shall remain in effect for an initial period o . , e rs. Following the initial 10 year period, this e reeme nt' shell remain in effect from one year to the next year, until; cancelled as stipulated below. The undersigned land owner or his representative - and the Permittee agree to abide with the following restrictions and stipulationsn�ntil such'time Ass written notification,' given nicety days in' 'advance, modifies, or dame s : . this agreement. dog r ht t�cisii ontr t t Ik ,. CITY OF HICKORY p .CUR 4ATED PUBLICUTILITIES DEPARTMENT M74-7 . i US 1, Shown on topo mp is where sludge will be applied, property lines, wells, surface water, drainage,d location of residences, 2. Sludge will be hauled by tanker truck at the rate of 3,5,00 gallon per truck load and dispersed, site will not be harvested. . Sludge is stored in drying beds& 4. d to be used 5V acres, 5. Henry Fork Wastewater Treatmnt Plant location is les southeast of site. HICKORY, 1C45 .11 March 27, 19 5 Mr. Th rmon Horn N. C a Department Environmental Management 919 N. Main St. Mooresville, NC 28115 Re: Hickory Land Application Persia Dear Mr. Horne.; The approximate acreage available for sludge application at each of the proposed sites included in the January 30, 1985 permit applications for the City of Hickory is presented below. This acreage does not include the areas within the various buffer zones. Name of Pro em pro ssssate As~ea �A�re 1.. Hickory Airport (Landfill Area) 40 2. Raley/Reeves (Alexander Co.) 9.9 s Ro an (Alexander Co.) 31 4 Finger (Catawba Co.) C 5 Griffin (Catawba Co.)15. 5-. Hart (Catawba Co.) 8 . Sherrill/Scherche Fars (Catawba Co.) g TOTAL 341. If there are any questions, or if further information is required, please contact see. Yours vary truly, t CHARL S E. SHUE, P.E. CGS/ c :s CITY OF HICKORY Public Utilities iti wrt ar t CERTIFIED April. 27, 1987 �M S�' clo ��'w �` Mr. Thurman Horne NC DEPARTMENT OF NATURAL RESOURCES AND COMMUNITY ELO C Box 950 f rar wr L NC Lf ak 1, `mw �r�x� 1�`n Dear Mr.Horne: SUBJECT: Permit #10587R2 This is to advise you of the measures taken by the City o Hickory to correct actions taken by the City of Hickory haulers, as el.l as, our contract 'haulers wh e resulted n a violation of our permit. In investigating why our drivers were applying l d in an improper area, I found that they were following the instructions of the property owner. They were advised that the property owner r could not approve areas for sludge disposal which were no n the permit. After talking with the property owner her and advising him of the violation, I do not think this will occur again. We ;r moved all the grass within the non--p rinitt d area; the area was then raked into ;ridges which ch were vacuumed up with city truck. The material was thew taken to our landfill for proper disposal. A sample was taken from the well and the results how d be known by April 30th. We have contracted a local farm supply dealer to apply lime to the area. T additional information is needed or should you have any questions concerning the above, please advise. Sincerely, . any Twiggs Public Utilities Director bb m s Asti Raleigh re vineWashington Fayetteville Wilmington Winston-Salem DIVISION OR ENVIRONMENTAL MANAGEMENT Date: April 29, 197 `"RAND"UM T Rory McMillan , Regional Supervisor FROM: Kent Wiggins, Coordinator Enforcement & Emergency Response SUBJECT: Document Review and Recommendation Case Name: Case Number: EMC WQ 84-14 Act II County: Rowan Attached please find a request for a Special Order by Consent. The real.e of the regional office lee In the preparation of this document is outlived in the 7(b) procedures manual. Please draft an SOC document including an attachment reflecting all limits and current monitoring frequencies using the manual as guide The document, accompanied by a regional dhee 4' � n staff report including n recommendations, should be submit � }to ' s office as soon as possible. ' 3 f you have any questions please call me at 91733 3. � Document 'hype: Addition" . Instructions. Per Mr. Benton's-request,please C process a . . soon''as possible. T 1987APR 217 dy`y%%' SSALISBURY'.,4''.'�, iP vt: ,:.i ' �'md a.�84J 100. a: ¢ N. C. WA TER IRESOURCES City of Salisbury April 17, 1987,q , y Mr. R. Paul N11m � ° r Director s ��t,r�� E." , .. Division of Environmental Management Post Office Box 27687 APR 91 8 Raleigh, NC 27611 , Dear Mr. Wilms: I air writing to advise you of the status of Spe i l Order,by Consent CMC WQ 84-14 A (NPDES # NCCU C 4) which outlines permit conditions for the City of Salisbury's Grants Creek Regional Wastewater Treatment Plant. While the city has made progress in meeting the terns of the S. O� C , we were not able to meet the March 17, 1987 deadline for awarding of construction contracts for upgrading the plant. Authorization to construct > as not received until after April 10, 1987 (copy attached). The project has now been let out for bids with the bid opening scheduled for May C, 1 7� We are not certain at this time how this will affect the date of completion of construction on this project. Please be assured that we intend to complete this project in a timely manner as soon as possible after the award of contract. 1 apologize for the lateness of this notice of non-compliance. Please call either myself or Public Utilities and Engineering Director, Colin Vest if we may be; of assistance in this or other matters of mutual concern. Sincerely, SALISBURY WATER RESOURCES r l µ C. Kelly Patton Superintendent c: David Treme Cohn Fast Peirson and Whitman (Marshall Staten) Mooresville Regional Office t Past Office Box 479 SaUsbu N.C. 28144 State of North Carolina Department of Natural Resources and Community Development Division of Environmental Management 512 North Salisbury Street * Raleigh, North Carolina 27611 James G. Martin, Governor R. Paul Will S. -Romas Rhodes, Semto April 10, 1987 Director Mr. David Treme, City manager City Hof Salisbury P.O. Box 479 Salisbury, EC 28144 SUBJECT: Permit No. NCO023844 Authorization to Construct City of Salisbury Grants Creek Wastewater Treatment Improvements EPA Project No. C370408-04 Dear Mr. Treme. The final plans and specifications for the subject project have been reviewed and found to be satisfactory. Authorization is hereby granted for the construction of modifications to the Grants Creek wastewater treatment facility to provide a total treatment capacity of 7.5 MGD to consist of the addition of an influent flow splitter box, repair of the existing primary treatment system consisting of removal and replacement of the existing mechanical equip- ment, the installation of a new primary treatment system to parallel the existing system consisting of new dual mechanical bar screens and new dual grit removal units, a four (4) bay influent screw pump station equipped with three (3) screws each rated at 5 f=, a new influent parshall flume, a 90 foot diameter secondary clarifier, additional chlorine contact tank volume, an enclosed sulfur dioxide dechlorination unit, cascade post aeration, a new return sludge pump station with three (3) submersible non -clog 1,040 gpm return sludge pumps and one (1) 100 gpm submersible non -clog sludge wasting pump, a new effluent parshall flume, and an effluent sampler. pt)nution Prrienrion PaYs PO fk)x 27687, Ralcigj), Noni-i Camlina 27611,7687 'relephone 919-733-7015 An Equal Opportunity Affimiative Artion Ernpky�cr Do not proceed with construction until the Authorization -to -Award package, EEO, and MBE documentation/certification have been reviewed, and you are in receipt of our approval if Federal Funding Is desired for project construction. The permittee shall employ an actively State certified wastewater treatment plant operator to be in responsible charge of the wastewater treatment facilities. Such operator must hold a valid State certificate of the grade at least equivalent to the classification assigned to the wastewater treatment facilities by the Certification Commission. When a new chief operator must be obtained to be in responsible charge of the new facilities, it is required that this be done by the time the construction of the facili- ties is 50% completed. This Authorization -to -Construct is issued in accordance with Part III, Paragraph C of NPDES Permit No. NCO023844 issued December 19, 1985, and shall be subject to revocation unless the wastewater treatment facilities are constructed in accordance with the approved plans, specifications, and supporting documents; and are in compliance with the conditions and limitations specified in Permit No. NCO023844, The permittee shall obtain a sludge analysis and a sludge E.P. toxicity analysis; and obtain approval of these analyses from the Division of Health Services, Solid Waste Management Branch prior to the disposal of any sludge from the new wastewater treatment plant. Copies of the analyses, supporting documents, and approvals shall be submitted to the Division of Environmental Management's Water Quality Section and the Regional Office. During the construction of the proposed additions/nodifications, the permittee shall continue to properly maintain and operate the existing wastewater treatment facilities at all times, and in such manner, as necessary to comply with the effluent limits specified in the *APES Permit. You are reminded that it is mandatory for the project to be constructed in accordance with the North Carolina Sedimentation Pollution Control Act and, Ehen cable, the North Carolina Dam Safety Act. In addition, the specifications must clearly state what the contractors responsibilities shall be in complying with these acts. The selling or free distribution of wet, dried, composted sludge or sludge -like materials from wastewater facilities without prior review and approval by this Division is illegal. -2- PPPF PP7, one (1) set of final approved plans and specifications Is to be forwarded to, yOd, one l) set to the Environmental protection Agency (EPA), and two ( sets to the Corps of Engineers. f you have any questions or need additional information, please contact Mr. Sill Hoffman, telephone number 919/ 3-6900. Sincerely, Paull Wilms cc: Rowan County Health Department Pe it on and Whitman Mooresville regional Office Walter D. Taft Arthur Mouberr ` W. S. Hoffman Bobby Blow Cecil Madden, Jr. Carmine Forcinito Brenda Chesson EPA EMU CP w -3 SALISBURY WA TER OURCES City of Sal isbury April 17, 1987 Mr. R. Paul Wilms Director Division of Environmental Management Post Office Box 7687 Raleigh,; NC 27611 Dear Mr. Wilms; I am writing to advise you of the stags of Special Order by Consent EC WQ 84-1 D (NPDES # N002388 which outlines permit conditions for the City of Salisbury's Grants Creek Regional Wastewater Treatment Runt. While the city has made progress in meeting the terms of the S. 0. C.,'we were not able to meet the March 17, 187 deadline for awarding of construction contracts for upgrading the plant; Authorization to construct was not received until after April 10, 1987 (copy attached). The project has now been let out for bids with the bid opening scheduled for May C, 1987. We are not certain a this time how this will affect the date of completion of construction on this project; Please be assured that we intend to complete this project in a timely manner as soon as possible after the award of contract I apologize for the lateness of this notice of non-compliance. Please call either myself or Public Utilities and Engineering Director, John Vest if we may be of assistance in this or other natters of 'mutual concern. Sincerely, SAL..IS URY WATERRESOURCES ei ,y Patton Superintendent . �Tq. OF NATURE" AND cc: David Treme C (0Q1),1n N1,ry Dn John Vest Pei rson and Whitman (Marshall Statdn) p2,11 1987 Mooresville Regional Office Post Office Box 479 Salisbury, N.C. 28144 #f MAY " 1003 State of North Carotin Dart f Natural Resources and Community v l ra nt Division of Environmental n ment 12 North Salisbury Raleigh, North Carolina 27611 James G. Martin, Governor May 16, 1988 It a Wilms S. Thomas es, r Director Mr. W. .Jerry Twiggs, Director of Public Utilities City of Hickory P.O. Box 398 Hickory, NC 28603 St311CT: Amendment to Permit No 10587103 City of Hickory Land Application of Sludge Catawba County Dear Mr. T i s In accordance with a letter dated May 13, 1988, we are amending Permtt No. 105 7R3 to delete the A.L. them arnerproperty from Condition No. 32. This Hermit amendment does not alter` any other;conditions or l tmitnions specified in Permit No. 10587R3, If you bave any questions or need addi t. i onm l information, please contact Ms.' Babette McKem4e, telephone 919/733-5083, ext 546. _ Sincerely, R. l'aaal Wilms cc: C tawb a County Health Deprartment gcataresvi l lei Regional Supervisor Dennis R. Ramsey scn Inc AM/Is pollutlor" Pretcrtion fig:, RO Box 27687 Raleigh NDrth C.arohna 37611 76" Telephone 919�733.7M5 jj► A- r:—J A-- � wa ment of Natural , Resources &Community Development James B. Hunt, Jr®, Governor James A. Summers, Secretary' DIVISION OF F' I ONMEN AL MANAGEME July I6 1984 Mr. Dan Hudson Route I, Box 6' Vile C. 28168 Subject: Complaint Investigation, Sludge Disposal - :fir.; Hama Property Catawba County, N. C. Dear Mr.Hudson: This _letter is to confirm the investigation of your complaint;can June 1984 ;and June 21, 1984. Attached please find one (1) copy of the 'subject complaint investigation report The report should be self-explanatory; however, if you have any questions or need any further assistance, please do not hesitate to contact Ms. Tana D. Fryer, Mr. Mike Parker, or ea We appreciate your assistance and concern in this mattes. an leason, P. F. Water Quality Regional Engineer Attachment a„ 'III F : s is Mooreavifle Regional Office PC Box 950, 919 North Main Street, mooresvii1e, N C 28115-09 0 "%lephonc, 704/6 3-t599 PF7N0,P','-HCAROLINA DEPARTMENT Or; NA URA" RESOURCES AND COMMUNITY EE ELOPMENT DIVISSION OF ENVIRONMENTAL MANA"GrEMENT WATER QUALITY SECTION POST OFFICE BOX 950 EEC" OF Complaint investigation Hart Property June , 1984 ' I DATE June 21, 1984 ADDRESS R 029; Vale, N. C. RIVER Catawba By WHOMi e Parker TIME_&V EMI hours PERSONS CONTACTED Tom purling; Jake i on, Terry, Twiggy s, Dwight Wilson, Ce;ne Haynes REASON FOR VISIT To investigate complaint of: disposal of sludge COPIES TO: Mr, Tom Spurling bcc Mr. Dan Hudson Mr. Harald gdronce REPORT: on June 5, 1984, this Office received a complaint through Mr. Tom Spurling of the Catawba County Health Department regarding; the disposal of sludge on Dr. Hart"s property allegedly by ;;the City of Newton's trucks. The complainant complained of odor and of spillage on the road. Mr. Dwight Wilson with ' the City of Newton was contacted by telephone by Mr. Larry Coble of this Office concerning this matter. Mr. Wilson informed ter. Coble that the sludge as being hauled from the City of , Hickory's wastewater treatment facilities. Mr. Jerry Twi.ggs with the City of Hickory was also contacted, He was rem n ed that land application without a permit is illegal and should be ceased immediately. Can June g, 1984, Mr. Mike Parker of this Office investigated. At that time, no evidence of sludge disposal: was found Can June 20, 1984, this Office received an additional complaint concerning; the lend application of sludge ;on Dr. Hart's property, The complainant said that he had observed two loads of sludge being hauled the previous day, June 19, 1984. He complained of the land: application of sludge and of the odor. He gave more specific directions to the site. Can June 21, 1984, Mr. lie Parker investigated the second complaint and discovered that sludge had indeed been disposed of on the Hart property. Mr. Tw ,ggs could not be contacted, but Mr. Gene Haynes with the City of Hickory -2- was notified. He said he would stop the land application of sludge without a permit. In a warning letter dated June 25, 1984, Mr. Jerry Twiggs was reminded that the land application of sludge without a permit is illegal and should be ceased immediately. Mr. Twiggs, was also informed that this Office would have no alternative than to recommend enforcement action should future violations occur. During an investigation of land application of sludge at a different site, it was determined that trucks belonging to Sigmon Brothers Dairy were responsible for the transport and land application of the sludge and not the City of Newton's trucks. Mr. Jake Sigmon has been notified in a warning letter dated June 25, 1984, that land application of sludge is illegal and that he should immediately cease the transport and disposal of sludge until such time as the City of Hickory has received the necessary land application permit. Z North Department Natural f : t x A '^ '" � : � � l n 8 ryry pp James rat,Jr., rN ." . Secretary r fit.. DIVISION OF ENVIRONMENTAL KkNAGEMIENT llrand Mrs. Jay Wilfo-t-ig outr..'. 1, t Box 387 Newton, N. 8658 Subject: Complaint Investigation Sltadge Disposal on WilfongProperty Catawba County, ''. C. Dear Mr. and sirs. Wilf n : This letter i:: to confirm the investigation of your complaint an June 11, r 1.8 a Attached please find a copy of the subject complaint investigation report. The report should be self-explanatory; however, if you have any questions or need any further assistance, please do not hesitate to contact Ms. Tana D. Fryer, Mr... Nike Parker, or me. We appreciate your assistance and concern in this matter. Sincerely, a f Wa`Ler Quality Regional. Engineer Attachment x T d ib MooresvHle hiE tgbnal Office F` 0 Box 950,919 Nwth Mwn Street, Pa oor. vifle N G. 2 t 0,95,'"cskF phone 70 4/66, 9 An Equaf OpX)rarirrrrit} Affirmative f�'f,a;7loyer- FF NORTH CAROLINA DEPARTMENT OF KIATURAt, RESOURCES AND COMMUNITY DEVELOPMENT DIVISION OF ENVIRONMENTAL PIANAGEMENT WATER QUALITY SECTION POST OFFICE BOX E MOORESVILLE, NORTH CAROLCAROLINA 28115 REPORT OF orapla;int invest ati n PLACE VISITED WilfongProperty DATE June 11, 1984 ADDRESS Sly 2019 and SR 020 Catawba BY WHOMMike Parker TIME SPENT hours PERSONS CONTACTED Mr. 'Tom Sperling, Mr. & Mrs. day Wilfon , fir. .ferry Twiggs, fir. Jake Si Mori REASON FOR VISIT To investigate complaint of disposal of sludge COPIES TO: Mr. Teem Spurlirn , Catawba County Health Department r. mike barker r. &' ors. lay Wilfong REPORT n dune ll, 1. S , this Office received a complaint through Mr. Tom Spurling of the Catawba County Health Department regarding the disposal of sludge on the Charles, Wilfong property, and of the odor -associated' with the sludge. n dune 11, 1984, r. Mike parker of this Office investigated. Mr. Parker's investigation revealed that sludge from the City of Hickory's wastewater facilities was being lance applied on the Wilfong property located at the corner of SR 2019 (Rocky Ford Road) and SR 2020 ( ilfon Road). r Jerry i s with the City of Hickory was also contacted. He was reminded that land application without a permit is illegal and should be ceased immediately. Sigmon Brother's Dairy was responsible for the transport and disposal of wastewater treatment plant sludge. Mr. Jake 'Sigmon with Si on Brothers Dairy was notified that the land; application of sludge without a permit is illegal and the transport and application of the sludge should be ceased Both Mr. Twiggs and fir. "Si m n were notified by latter to immediately cease the land application of sludge until such time as the City of Hickory has received the necessary land application permit. A follow-up investigation revealed the sludge had been turned under. firs. .Tarr Wilfong was contacted, and she was satisfied with the result. North Carolina Department of Natural Resources & Commun'ty Development « u James , Hunt, Jr., Governor Jam asr r rt + ° DIVISION OF ENVIRTIMENTAL �ADAGE`114ENT October 16 1984 Mr. ferry Twiggs Public Utilities Director Cite of Hickon,. w Pot Office Box 398 Hickory, Hart"h Carolina 2860 E proposed Pump, n11haul of Wastewater from Caldwell Industrial Service, Inc. Dear Mr. Twiggs: In your letter of September 24, 1984, you asked for our advice in considering Caldwell Industrial Service's request to haul 500 S d of truck washing water to a point tributary to the HenryForkWastewater Treatment Plant review of our files indicates that this facility Is In compliance with permit effluent limitations and has sufficient hydraulic capacity to dccom date: this flow. Considering these factors and considering that this is wash at r from the exterior washing only of Caldwell's trucks, this Office would have no objection to the proposal. However, you should be aware that the City of Hickory -is still responsible for operating the wastewater treatment plant in compliance with the ter ; and Limitations of the pernAt and: this letter should by no means be construed as relieving the City from that responsibility. If you have any questions, please cull Thurman Horne or :see $ 7041663-ld g Sincerely, ; i D. Rex Gleason dater Quality Regional Engineer CC: Mr. W. Ronald Haynes, 1'. E. N C' a.... µ .:,. CITY OF HICKORY m �cPUBLIC UTILITIES coo tis x A, y af,rijkL 6t Taylorsville, N. C. This T. give permission to theCity Hickoryand/or ,, contractors to apply sludge on property immediately adjacent t,6 m= property line. START I State of North Carolina Department of Natural Resources and Community Development Mooresville Regional Office James G. Martin, Governor S, Thomas Rho&,, Secretary DIVISION OF ENVIRONMENTAL MANAGEMENT August 12, 1985 Mr. B. Gary McGee City Manager City of Hickory Hickory, N. C. 28603 Subject: Land Application of Sludge City of Hickory Catawba Co. Dear Mr. McGee: Thank you very much for your letter dated August 1, 1985. We appreciate you taking the time to keep us updated on your efforts to improve sludge application procedures and record keeping. We particularly appreciate your personal committment to these efforts. With respect to the records presented to its during our meeting on July 15, 1985, 1 felt it might be advisable to provide some further clarification as to their adequacy and some suggestions for possible improvements. The records which were presented are considered to be adequate with respect to the requirements of the old permit (10587Rl). However, the requirements of your new permit (10587R2), issued on May 22, 1985, are some what more demanding than these records will accomodate. As you will recall, in our meeting we reviewed some monitoring report forms which should now be used in order to meet the new permit requirements. We believe that these forms will not only provide us with the information we need for compliance monitoring, but they can also be a tool to assist your staff in managing,the program of land application. If you or any of your staff have any questions concerning these forms or if we can be of any other assistance to you, please call Thurman Horne or me at (704/663-1699). Again, we appreciate your efforts and we look forward to an improved working relationship. Sincerely, D. Rex Gleason, P.E. Water Quality Regional Engineer JTH:pb 919 North Main Street, P.O. Box 950, Moontsville, NC. 28115-0950 * "ref cphonc 704-663-169.9 An Fqual Opportunity Affinnative Action Employer a' CITY OF HICKORY 0*P'6iA'TCV OFFICE Of Ti4e coo f t "414 seaactvwd X0001 Ow August 1, 1985 Hr. D. hex Gleason, Water Quality Regional Engineer N.C. Department of natural Resources and Community Development' P.O.Box 950 Mooresville, N.C.28115-0950 Dear Rex: Thank you for the opportunity to meet with you and Thurman Horne on July 16, 1985. 1 believe our meeting was beneficial and productive,. I believe the +ity's contractor did improperly apply sludge on the Dr. Robe,rt Hart property:. As Jerry Twiggs and I indicated to you;, any application of sludge which dues not meet permit conditions is immediately corrected when we become aware of any improper application. On the site where the violation took place, there is a grass airstrip. Our contracted mauler was instructed as to which end of the airstrip to begin application. Apparently, the inst-ructions were misunderstood since application began on the opposite end. When we became aware of the problem, we immediatelZ stopped sludge application on this site, o prevent a reoccurance of this problem we have staked the buffer areas on all our permitted sites. Also, we have divided our sites into subsites and identified each subarea.. We will monitor each subarea to determine the area covered in a week by sludge generated at our plants. This will provide us with a measure of the loading rates on each parcel. We are not now applying sludge to the Hart property. I trust our record keeping, as you viewed same on July lb, of sludge applications from the two treatment plants is satisfactory® However, would appreciate any assistance you can provide to insure that we are keeping records in accordance with our permit. e by no means want to be in violation of our permit, state or federal regulations. Please let me know pesonall if you have further concerns or problems with Hickory's sludge app cation procedures.. it is cetainly not y desire for Hickory to constitutea problem for your office. Letter to U. Rex Gleason Page August 1, 1985 Hex, I would like to provide you with an executive summary of regional sludge composting facility to be built here. The $6 million project has been approved for funding by the State and is currently being reviewed by the U.S Environmental Protection Agency. We anticipate favorable review and hope to begin construction this fall._When this project is completed, the City of Hickory, as well as all m nicipialities and septic tank haulers in Catawba County, will have an alternative to land application of sludge. Please let me Arnow if I can be of further assistance. please come by City Hall when you're in the'Hickory area. Sincerely, CITY OF HICKORY #C4-;V B. Cary McGee City Manager Enclosures cc: t �+ HCAic : dat RECEIVED MAY 3 0 S85 CITY MANAGERts OFFICE Piry nr It'lenov State of North Carolina Department of Natural Resources and Community Development 512 North Salisbury Street # Raleigh, North Carolina 27611 James G Martin, Governor S. Thornas Rhodes, Secretary DIVISION OF ENVIRONMENTAL MANAGEMENT May 23, 1985 Mr. B. Gary McGee City Manager City of Hickory P. 0. Box 398 Hickory, North Carolina 28603 SUBJECT: Advance of Allowance Project No. C370389-12A Hickory -Newton Sludge Composting Dear Mr. McGee: This acknowledges receipt of the application and supporting documents requesting an advance of allowance for the design of subject project. The application has been reviewed by our staff and the following was noted: 1. Based upon the State's approval of the 201 Plan amendment, the estimated eligible construction cost is $4,716,500. Therefore, the allowance factor would be 5.3721. The corresponding estimated allowance would be $4,716,500 x .053721 x .55, or $139,356. 2. Since the 201 Plan amendment has not yet received full EPA approval, the above calculations are preliminary at this time. Please Be advised that once the State of North Carolina receives funds for advances of allowance and the 201 Plan receives full EPA approval, the amount of advance will be recalculated and your application processed for funding. If you have any questions, please advise. Sincerely, t hief Construction Grants Section BB:tja cc: Mr. Tom Fahnestock Mr, Bobby Blowe Mrs. Gail Blowe PO Box 27687, Ralr*h, North Carolina 27611-7687 Telephone 919-733-4984 An Equal Opportunity i Affirmative Action Empkryer SIATE OF NORTH CAROLINA DEPARTMENT CP NATURAL RESOURCES. AND CC .NITy DEVELOPMENT DIVISION CP ENV R N NTAL MANAGEMENT APPLICATION FOR ADVANCE CP ALLOWANCE 40 CPR 35.2025 Name City of Hickory Street 76-Tiorth Center Pb 0. Box City Hickory, N. Ca Zip Code 28603 "Telephone Numbe Description As iklndet�inthe Vinding of a� m � rya Calculation of Advance a. Current estimated building cost 6,000,000 Multiplier from Federal Regulations . 7 £ 184,041 ., Population of Applicant 4 , 000 r �r � � w w: • �seiCr"�ra �+�*a7► t . Estimated date for initiating design of project December 4, 1984 b. Estimated date design will be 10complete January 1, 1985 c. Estimated date design will be 0 complete April 1, 1985 d. Estimated date design will be submitted for review August 1, 1985 b. CERTIFICATION e attached statements and exhibits are hereby made part of this application and the undersigned representative of the Applicant certifies that the information in the application and the attached statements and exhibits is true, correct, and complete to the best of his knowledge and belief. He further certifies that: He has been authorized to file this application by formal action of the governing body of the Applicant as i evidenced by the ATTACHED CERTIFIED COPY OF AUTHORIZATION MADE BY THE APPLICANT'S GOVERNING BODY the governing body of the Applicant is familiar with the EPA Rules and Regulations Governing advance of allowance, and the "ENC Procedures for Administration of PA Advances ofAllowance", and the Applicant, has substantially complied or will substantially comply with all Federal, Mate, and Local laws, rules, regulations, and ordinances ,applicable to the Project. 7. NAME AND TITLE OF REPRESENTATIVE 8. SIGNATUREOF "REPRESENTATIVE: :. DATE City Manager CERTIFICATE OF RECORDING OFFICER The undersigned duly qualified and acting City Clerk of the City of Hickory does hereby certify: That the above attached resolution is a true and correct copy of the resolution authorizing the filing of an application for advance of allowance witb the State of North Carolina as regularly adopted at a legally convened meeting of the Hickory City Council duly held on the 7th day of May, 1985; and, further, that such resolution has been fully recorded In the journal of proceedings and records in nW office. IN WITNESS WHEMM, I have hereunto set my hand this Sth day of May, 1985. tricia �W.Wi�liam�sC�ity C�lerk City of Hickory ow WHEREAS, Section 3 of the Municipal Wastewater 'Treatment_ Construction Grant Amendments of 1981 P.L. 7-11 authorizes funds to be advanced to potential grant applicants for costs of preparation of construction drawings and specifications; p ores, and WHEREAS, 40 CFR 35.2025 provides guidance for making application for an advance of allowance, and WHESEAS, the City of Hickory intends to request an advance of allowance to aid in the design of wastewater facilities; li ties; p NOW THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED, BY THE HICKORY CITY COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF HICKORY: That B. Gary McGee, City Manager, and successors so titled, i hereby authorized to execute and file an application on behalf of the City of Hickory with the State of North Carolina for are advance to aid in the design of wastewater facilities. That B. Gary McGee, City Manager, and successors so titled, is hereby authorized and directed to furnish such information as the appropriate federal or State agencies may request in connection with such applications or the project and to execute such other documents as may be required in connection with the application, That the City of Hickory has substantially complied or will substantially comply with all Federal, State, and Local laws, rules, regulations, and ordinances applicable to the project and to federal and tate'grann s and loans pertaining thereto. Adopted this the 7th day of May , 1985 d Hickory, North Carolina., WilliamR. Mc nald, III Mayor AGENDA 1) Need for Study and Introduction of Burmeister, Wright & Associates, P.A. by Jerry Triggs, Director of Public Utilities, City of Hickory 2) Objects and Approach of Study and Definitions of Composting by John Burmeister, P.E. 3) Specifics of Proposed Regional Facility, Cost and Impact by Recil H. Wright, P.E. NEED eriationj� cbmpc;whq� and land appli� iv * 1010 rlifAilo t4�,tillv ng was, however, singled e area. In order to N. C. Department of amendment was required ster, Wright & Associates, Iendment to include the ckory, Newton, Conover BURMEISTER, WRIGHT & ASSOCIATE , P.A. The firm of Burmeister, Wright & Associates, P.A. is a civil engineering consulting firm based in Charlotte, N. C. The firm is headed by principals John Burmeister and Revil Wright who are here tonight to discuss the findings of the 201 Amendment. This firm has done a considerable amount of work in and around this area including engineering projects for the City of Newton, the Town of Maiden, the City of Asheville, the City of Cherryville and others. Recil Wright was born and grew up in Catawba County and presently resides on Highway 16 just south of Newton. The 201 Amendment has been completed by this firm in a satisfactory manner to all parties. I am confident in their ability to perform the additional engineering work related to the composting facilities. I will now turn the presentation over to John Burmeister, who will describe some of the 201 Amendment findings. M OBJECT AND 'APPROACH The approach taken in developing the necessary design criteria for the composting facilities was first to determine 'both the present and future quantities of sludge generated from; each of the municipalities. Secondly,' was to determine hoer much the present steer of sludge disposal was costing the individual municipalities. These numbers formed a ;basis for comparing the regional composting facilities to serve the communities. The following chart shows the estimated total yearly operation and maintenance costs for all of the municipalities over the next 20 years. These costs do not include any capital expenditures that. will he necessary if the present systemof sludge disposal is continued ART I TOTAL ANNUAL 0 & M COSTS PRESENT PRACTICES 1,500 Vt325,300 ZZ- Average Cost 1 I , 1,77, $575,800 500 10 1 Years Costs for the regional composting facilities 'were 'then developed for several different techniques of composting. The cost evaluations included consideration of capital ;and operation and maintenance`coss, and sale of manufactured compost material _� WHAT IS PS Before proceeding any further, it may be appropriate to describe what composting is and some of the methods of manufacturing as it applies to the regional facility we will be discussing. Composting is a process that converts organic materials into humus -like product using aerobic organisms. Composting_is a natural process and 1 am sure that any of you that have piled up any leaves and; gone back later to see the results will know what composting and the results of composting are. Composting of sewage sludge consists of simply adding a buying or carbonaceous material to sludge from which the water;has been partially removed. The carbonaceous or bulking material can be almost anything including sawdust, bark, woodthips, peanut bulls, rice hulls, or any other similar material.. The addition of the air and combination of the carbonaceous materials causes n endothermic reaction and heat is generated. The process of composting takes roughly 14 days in a controlled environment. Chart 11 illustrates in simplified manner how sewage compost is manufactured' ART 11 COMPONENTS OF SLUOGE COMPOSTING s GASES o S SLUDGE BULKING MICROBES HEAT MATERIAL 1 have with me tonight several samples of compost which you have in front of you. This material is most suited for nursery usage, golf courses, turf farms and the like.; The markets for this material are ;.numerous. Recent market research in the Asheville area has determined that all materials can be readily sold and Morganton has a composting facility and is presently selling all that is manufactured. Where are several methods of manufacturing of sewage compost. Two of the most applicable methods were analyzed in depth in the amendment, including the "Static Pile System" and the "Mechanically Enclosed System". The "static pile system" as the name implies relies on creating large p iles of the sludge and bulking material mixture and blowing air into the i piles until the composting process has finished. The system requires considerable land area, is very labor intensive, and subjected to weather. The "mechanical enclosed system" relies on the use of art► enclosed tank in which the composting process takes place. This system requires a larger capital investment than the static pile system, but is far less labor intensive. It is also more environmentally sound, since the system is enclosed. Other advantages of the enclosed system is that it is unaffected by weather and is odor free. I would like to now turn the presentation over to Recil Wright who will go into the specifics of the regional facility. 4 REGIONAL COMPOSTIOG FACILITY Based on the cost, environmental and subjective analysis performed in the amendment, the proposed disposal methods for the Hickory -Newton Complex were selected. The chosen method was to compost sludges in an enclosed system that will be located central to the four municipalities. The tentative site that has been selected is near the existing Fairgrove Wastewater Treatment plant located on Clark Creek, just south of Highway 64-70. The proposed composting facility would be designed to meet the needs of the communities over the next 20 years and will have an ultimate capacity to process 20 tons per day of dry sludge. At start-up, these facilities will be treating approximately 50% of this amount. The "mechanical enclosed system" includes reactors in which the actual composting process takes place; carbonaceous storage tank; air blowers and scrubbers; conveyor and solids handling system; and associated buildings and structures. Sludges from the treatment plants will be transported to the regional facility for dewatering. Delivery of the sludges to the regional plant will be accomplished by either pumping or by hauling in tankers. Sludge from Newton's Clark Creeik plant and Hickory's Henry Fork plant will be pumped to the regional facility. It is planned to haul the sludges from Hickory's Northeast Plant, Conover's plants, and Longview's plant by tanker to the facility. Two tankers will suffice initially although they will have to be replaced within ten (10) years plus the purchase of an additional tanker. A schematic of the major components of the regional facility are shown in Chart III on page 6. 5 UPS anker Sludge Sludge pump -Northeast W__' -Henry Ford -Conover -Clark Creek - n iew- trey units __ 00 l Filtrate Dewatered Creed u tfa l Bilk Reactor material Air__ c� Storage Curs Ream Compost for Sale CHARTIII REGIONAL COMPOSTING SYSTEM Capital costs of the entire system is estimated to be $7,109,000. This amount uld be offset by Federal Grants totaling up to f the eligible costs„ 17eimplementation of the project will result in an overall savings to all the municipalities over the present methods of disposal.- Savings will be proportionate to the Federal share that can be obtained and the actual amount and price of the compost sold. A chart has been prepared which illustrates the overall savings to the four municipalities. This is shown in Chart IV. CART I ANNUAL SAVINGS ENCLOSED COMPOSTING vs PRESENT PRACTICE Present Disposal practices $1,077,000 1,000 Compost -Sales at C per Ton kC> 750 ' 500 See 250 Example Below � S SC 75 100 Funding Percentage n example of the savings would e to assure that SS funding is received for the capital costs and that on the average-S of the compost is sold at $20 per ton over the life of the facility. The net annul cunt of the compost system would be $430,000 per year vs, $1,077,000 using the present disposal practices or a new average savings of $647,000 per year. SUMMARY It has been demonstrated in the 201 Amendment Study that 'comp ost` cost effective, environmentallysound and permanent meths of disposal s a sludges produced in theHickory-Newton Complex area. al of the The project has been placed on the funding list with the City of as a lead agency and Is scheduled for construction at the start o the Hickory eairt 1986, which commences in October, ethFederal municipalities for the funds for preparation o the plans sand specifications pec to reimburse the has been receive from the N. C. Department of Natural Resources ands Community Development. It is necessary to have the Plans and specifications ready b 1985 in order to be eligible for the construction money as it becomes avaiabl We should move as soon as possible to commence with preparation o 'th e. and specifications in order to b reader for this money. e plans - MRO CONFERENCE ROOM Log Sbeet MRO Staff Member (s) Holding Meeting: e-- t", Division/ Section: ,;94 Date: Time. Attendees e e e t ocation etlle X, C, Al, A- 4- xz, -A, Ae -leof 4,1— Alla K C Ae -7 7 A^4 5, e 01 x State of North ; r ►lin Departmentrah Resources and Community Mooresville Re0onalOffi Jame G. Martin, Governor S. nomas Rhorles, Secretary DIVISION OF ENVIRONMENTAL MANAGEMENT July 1, ld a The Honorable William R. McDonald, III Mayor, City of Hickory Post Office Box 398 Hickory, N. C. 28603 Subject: "violations of Permit for Sludge Land Application Permit No. 187R: City of Hickory Catawba County Dear Mayor or McDonald In response to complaints received concerning the it's sludge disposal practices, Mr. J. Thurman Horne of this Office conducted a site 'investigation on Thursday, dune 27, 1985. as a'result of this investigation it was observed that the City has violated several of the minimum buffer requirements stipulated in conditions number 13, 1., and 15 of the subject permit. The violations were noted for recent surface applications of sludge on areas of the. Dr. Robert dart, III property. The following violations of the aforementioned buffer requirements were noted: l Sludge has been applied approximately 80 feet from a potable water Drell. The permit requires a minimum buffer of 100 feet be maintained. Sludge has been applied within .n approximately 100 feet of an existing occupied residences The permit requires a minimum buffer of 200 feet be maintained: Sludge has been applied within approximately 15 feet of an adjacent lando er's property line. The permit requires a minimum buffer of 100 feet be maintained. In addition to these violations, you should be aware that an investigation was conducted on Thursday. May 2, 1985 which revealed that the :City was in violation of condition No. lq of the subject permit for failing, to maintain adequate records of sludge applications. Further, in a letter to Mr. Jerry Twiggs, Director of Public Utilities, City of Hickory from Mr. D. Rex Gleason dated October 1, 1984, the City was advised of observed violationof permit requirements and informed that continued violations might result in revocation of the subject permit. 19 North th in Street, R . k ix 950, Mooresville, NC 2 115 50 # Telephone e704-663-1699 An Equal Opportunity Affin-native Action Empkryer The honorable William R. McDonald, III Page o July 1,1985 Naturally we are concerned that violations of the permit have continued to occur, especially since the City was just recently assessed civil penalties as a result of past violations associated with sludge disposal. It is because of this concern with the continuing, violations that we request your presence - and that of all City Officials and personnel you deem appropriate at our Office in Mooresville, 919 North Main Street, at 10:00 A.M. on Tuesday, July 16, 1985. Please be prepared to discuss the reasons for the continuing, violations. You should be aware that ;due to the continuing violations this Office is considering a recommendation to revoke the subject ;permit and/or to assess additional civil penalties. If you have any questions regarding, this muter,and/or if the time established for the meeting, is inconvenient, please contact Mr. J. Thurman Horne or me at -1699. Sincerely', D. Rex Gleason, P. E. Water Quality Regional Engineer cc: Mr. L. P. Benton, Jr. Legal Affair Mr. Paul Wilms Mr. Dennis Ramsey Mr. perry Nelson Catawba County health Department JTH: s j u September 2, 1' CLIENT: City P. Hick ATTENTION: Gaon A.s SAMPLE IDENTIFICATION: Sample #1 HenryFork Plant Sludge Sample #2 N EPlant Sludge ANALYSIS: Leachate Analysis Sample #1 '` 1 End in <0.00002 40.00002 Linda < 0. 00000 <0. 000 Methoxyclor 40.00020.000 7'' , 4, TF(Sily ) 40.0068 <0.0003 ANALYZED BY, B. A. S . LABORATORIES, INC. N. C. CERTIFICATE NO. 40 N. C. CERTIFICATE NO. 004 E.P.A. CERTIFICATE NO. 000 MICHAEL R. BANKER D. A NE WILSON 1 1 -1 Central Avenue —Charlotte, North Carolina 28204,—(704) 376-8646 "�tri�r a better Environment" OCTOBER 14., V98.2' REFERENCE NO- 82-1502 DATE RECEIVED.- SEPTEM CLIENT: CITY 0 P, 0. H I CKOR 'ATTENTION: JERRY LRNT LANT ANALYS IS S F 1PIPLE TOTAL FISH, CHROM I t COPPER*, N I C i-,'E L. ZINC, F LEAD, F CADM I Ut SELENIUM, PPM 121021"* Et 01:32 MERCURY,. PPM II_'O. 00005 00005 ANALYZED BY, S. R. W. LAP)RATORIE, INC. NC, CERTIFICATE NO. 004 EP. A. CERTIFICATE NO. 02009— S.C. CERTIFICATE NO. 99004 MICHAEL R. SANK"ER D. ANNE ant ILSON "TESTING3 FOR A BETTER ENVIRONMENT" AGRICULTURAL EXTENSION North Carolina State University SERVICE School of Agriculture and Life SciRnces Department of Biological and Agricultural Engineering Box 7625, Raleigh, NC 27695-7625 Telephone (919) 737-2675 MEMORANDUM TO: FROM : A. R. Rubin, Extension Specialist Biological and Agricultural Engineering SUBJECT : Report of Investigation Attached is a copy of the report for the land application of waste at Aid :bb i'r.inomfisw JPfon-*nn W-1, i� A irnrtxxa rang #atrnaM-nrLnmL-* A&TnnAMr- Statp rininomits as- Ina irbuntipg and tl S. DeDartmentafAjvrkultune SITE INVESTIGAT10N ADDENDUM NORTH CAROLINA The town of Hickory, North Carolina is currently permitted to lad treat sludge on several locations ns throughout Catawba County, North'' Carolina. Additional sites have been investigated ;for purposes of land treatment and the purpose of this report is to describe the: conditions encountered on four of the additional ;sites. In addition, 'recommendations regarding the application of sludge and appropriate loadings will be made. This report is considered: an addendum to the report previously submitted. SITE INVESTIGATION Site Locations Four additional sites were investigated for purposes of sludge treatment. These 4 sites include: l a farm located approximately I mile from the Henry Fork plant, 2l`a farm south and east of the plant henceforth labeled Finger Farm, l the airport property, and l Alexander County farms 'lropo raph, The four additional sites` investigated for purposes of land treatment were typical of the piedmont phsiojgeographiic providence of the state. The slope is gentle on all sites and the maximum Mope; did not appear to exceed 10%. The first site investigated appeared to have the most severe slope problem and slope did not appear to exceed any maximums which can easily tolerate sludge application. In general, the maximum slope encountered on most sites was no more than 5 or 62 and topography should pose little or no limitation to the operation of these land treatment facilities. s 'Soils r The soils on all sites appeared to be very well drained upland soils typical of the piedmont. The predominant soil encountered on all sites appeared to be a Cecil pacolet-like clay loam or an A plin -like sandy clay loam. The airport property was drastically disturbed Band and a soil profile description for the airport property is really unnecessary. The soils encountered on the natural siteq are very similar to those reported in the original soil sampling program and for that reason soil profile descriptions for those soils are not included in this report and questions concerning soil profile descriptions can be referred to the original report. Additional soil > sampling was accomplished can the fur sites and a; portion of the data was provided by the town of Hickory. Site 1, that located nearest the plant, however, had not been sampled at the time of the investigation and sampling was accomplished to determine the physical and chemical properties of that soil. Soil testing included determination of soil pH, acidity, exchange rapacity and nutrient status. In general, the soil testing indicated that each site should receive between .5 and 1.5 tams of lime per acre per year. This should be accomplished prior to receiving any sludge. :additional potassium (between 30 and pounds per acre per year) should also be added to ensure balanced nutrient loadings are placed on the site. The potassium; should be added: at the same time as the lime since both constituents move slowly into the soil`. The chemical testing indicated that the exchange capacity in the, sub -soil was well above the 5 milliequivalents per hundred gram category; however, the exchange capacity in the topsoil was generally in the 3 to 5 millie uivalents;per hundred gram range and for this reason conservative sludge loadings would be recommended. The metal loadings ;onto 7the site can be calculated based upon the lov range for the EPA sludge ppp,application, Exchange capacity in the sandy and sandy 'loam topsoil was sufficiently low to warrent this conservatism. WASTE CHARACTERISTICS AND SLUDGE LOADINGS' The sludge generated at the Hickorywastewater treatment facility has been analyzed by a commercial laboratory and determined to b non -toxic. I addition, nutrient analysis have been performed on the sludge and that data was submitted with the original report. All calculations were accomplished with the initial report and are not necessary in this addendum. Any questions regarding sludge loadings should be answered in the initial or original report. if there have been significant changes in the quality of the sludge generated at the sludge or if there have been significant changes in the industrial processes ongoing in the; town of Hickory, then additional sludge characterization data may be necessary and subsequent calculations for determining land application rates way be necessary. For purposes of this report, however, the sludge loadings onto the four additional sites are identical to those originally recommended. Cana ement The sites investigated are currently either well managed grasslands in fescue or Sericea hespede a or fallow land which is currently poorly managed. The fallow site should be cut,, limed and supplemental nutrients should be applied prior to any sludge application. Sludge loading onto the poorly managed site should begin lightly and proceed up to the maximum loading. The airport site, currently in Sericea Lespedeza, should be, cut prior to receiving sludge. The heavy stand of ge icea' Lespede a currently on that site will be an excellent receiver as will the fescue on Field l and the fescue pasture in Alexander County. 4 Soil pH and supplemental potassium shoul application of any sludge on any site. These recommended in the sail teat. The recommends below.. Table 1. Selected soil characteristics and aiii Hickory, WC l TEli 11 il 1 5.2 1. A It 50 5.2 1.5 p 30'. 5. .7 T/AC/YR 5 5.1 1.1 yp 80 Conclusion These land treatment sites appear to be the town of Hickory." app le ntal site in e during a subsequent visit' to Hickory and a se, total, the land area available for sludge app should well exceed the land area required for e adjusted prior to the sendments should be added as Ana- are summarized in the table plement recommendations, ilk . 1y 1"f 1 k 3.7 1 suited as receiver sites for atone will be accomplished id addendum will be filed. In aation for the town of Hickory ie assimilation of all of the the town of Hickory will prove to be a very viable land treatment alternative and very cost effective in the long run.' W.C. DIVISION OF ENVIRMUNTAL KkKAGMNT STANDARD AGREE21MNT FOR THE LAND APPLICATION pppppr Of WASTE SLUDGE ON PRIVATE 1AN NAKE OF WWTP Henr. Fork I'lant WASTEWATER OWNER OF P: City of Hickory t south of Hickory TYPE, OF SLUDGE liquid FARM NO* FlELD Five LOCATION' ' miles f Ike rPlant LAND OWNER OF PROPERTY Mr4 ' Mrs. CyeorgeImo. Finger LESSEE OF PROPERTY Cite of Hickory, LAND US E OR CROPPINC, PATTERNS -INTENDED p lTI OF CROPS The undersigned :land Dinar or his repror,ent tii a -:he reb. its thet. � f IrJ� ., hereinafter referred tas the Permittee, to apply sludge from the n , Fork PI t aata afar Treatneni Fla tt opoti the land at :the locittpn a o as , i ad .; tl.e`�ettached documents in accordance witt the restrietiots,, stipul4 tions and exceptions shown below. The landowner or his representative receives,,, consideration, full as of the nutrient versa of the applied sludge while the Fermittee ataiva ra a datati , t o a tea laid described above for the disposal � . aatad ssludge. This agreezent shall raa airs in of fact for an initial periodf . . years. ;Following the initial a a t ear.tyear, period, this 'a raa at. shall ra a" In affect fry ney ar t 'until cancelled as stipulated below. The undersigned land owner of his a eprsee ativ and the iP itt a agree t abide Faith he folly« n restrictions stipulation's.until such, -time a written n tifi ati , given ninety 0 aye fw adv na d f cancels this agreement.' x x . h- ° o- tither -party can discontnue-ser,,�iceat any t° a n :x v (Cbntinued) LAND MNM August 13, 1984 DATL NUM CAROLI MI CATAINR4 I eRr1ify that GeorgeL. Finger personally p this the di)e executionof the forgoing iDstrawnt- V;lr,,rGSS v Ccurnission Expires 11-22-85 'TAPS" PUBLIC N CITY OF HICKORY - �"° srssc�saaa^ta POSr CHICKORY, NOS i 2 + 22-260 C@u4 Office of the City Manager Bch 11, 1986 T"ATUT) TA AND r . Thurman Home, P.E. N.C. Department of= Natural Resukirces and Coniunity Development P.O. Box 950 Mooresville, NC 28115-0950 Dear Thurman I appreciate your Marsh 5, 1986 telephone s aii regaraing the manner in dish Hickory's sludge hauling contractor is lead applying our sludge. t that time, I ind.is t d to you teat we were, talking to ANISCd, Inc. of Clemmons, N.C. regarding that company's ability to serve Hickory. sat pleased to advise that we have now sired AMSCO, Inc. effective two weeks from now on d year to year basis. We have agreed upon 20 per gallon. Services is be furnished include: 1. 'Truck leading as required. 2. Transportation Fleet. Two Tand ii Axle Road Tractors B. Two Sealed Tank Trailers 00 Gallon Capacity) . Sludge Application. A. Specialized high floatation sludge application vehicle equipped with surface application or sub surface injection equipment. 4. Trained, full time operators and field management personnel. . daintoin all records as required by the North Carolina Department of Natural Resources anb Cormiunity Development W Comply with all federal, state and local rules and regulations 7. Provide insurance as required. s. Assist in permitting additional lead as required. rppp"' Letter to Thurman Horne Page March 11, 1986 Thank you, Thurman, for your interest. We had hoped the present hu u e , Sigmon Brothers of Newton, N.C., uu t3e able to adjust to meet our needs, but it ars they will not. I feel we have giver) th i) every opportunity. Please do not hesitate to call me again if there are matters needing my attention. CITY OF HICKORY B. Gary McGee City Manager cc: W.,- Jerry Twiggy Mayor McDonald and City Council Members II, I " " x s f 04 x` State of North Carolina , Department of Naturala and Community Development Division of Environmental Management 512 North Salisbury Street * Raleigh, North Carolina 27611 ,Jaynes G, Martin, Governor R. Paul `"Films S. Thomas Rhodes, Secretary September 6, 1986 Director . B. Gary McGee City 'Manager City of Hickory P.C. Box 398 Hickory, NC 28603 SUBJECT: CT: State -EPA Approval of the Revised Plans and Specifications City of Hickory Regional Sludge Compost Facilities PA Project;No. 0 1 ' Dear Mr.McGee: e review for completeness and adequacy of your reprised project con- struction plans and specifications has been concluded by the Construction Grants Section of the North Carolina Division of Environmental Management. The revisions to subject plan documents for site modifications are hereby approved. One 1 set of the reprised plates and specifications will be forwarded to you, and one (1) set to the Corps of Engineers, Inspection Branch, under separate cover. You are reminded that one ( set of plans and specifications identical to the approved set must be available at the project site at all times. Upon completion of the project construction, the Grantee: shall submit___ a letter confirming that the project has been constructed in accordance with the plans and specifications approved by the State, "As -built" plans will need to be submitted with any changes color -coded on the plans if the above con- firmation Gannet be made, :x i �..pv •�"p:: . 31 �� R fi k rc 'R. z �s , t LAAL Pollution Prevention PaYs P.M, Box ? c wi, Raicigh, North Carolina 27611-768 'Felephone 9191 ;"33-7015, .An Equal Opportunity Affirmative 4cdon rnplover Nor . B. Cary Mee City,n er 'age September , 198 If there are any questions concerning this matter, please de not hesitate to contact W. S. Hoffman .t (919) 7 p- 9 0. Sincerely, Walter D. Taft Jr., Chief Construction Grants Section CM:aap _ee Charlotte Corps of Engineers Burmeister, Wright & Assoc. Mooresville Regional Office Mr. Walter "daft Mr. Bobby Bloe Ms. Brenda Cheson Mr. Cecil Madden, Jr. EMU CPS CITY OF HICKORY — POST OMCE BOX 398 # HICKORY, NORM CAROLINA 28603 7 /3 - a6Y+4-v9: 1 s coo Office of the Cats Ma October 7, 1985 „fir. D. Rex,/Gleason, 'Water Qual[t Regional Evi ineer N.C. Department of Natural liesour e and C(',mrTnunity Development P.O. Box 950 Mooresville, NC 28115-0950 Dear t thought I would share with you this article on research being; undertaken at one of our sludge application ,sites« Please let Riga know if you have any uestion or want further i I4,i:orniat i on Sincerely, CITY OF HICKORY 0*-14�- B. GryMcGGee City .11anager Enclosure B4SRe C b d a r } Waste Water Treatment Site Improvements OK'd By City Frorn Page 1A slightly larger and more attractive, the vol tart' nesation of fi . 56 he said, acres of Eiji Mills property on 't"h r- arr presented the Housing In another rnattee council ap- s nth Street, , adjacent to Inter - Assistance Flan to the council. proved a resolution establishing Iuss state . ltilr one spoke at a public Cities receiving +Cora ity _ compensation for pro rt at the hearing on the aster. velop nt block Grant fund s must corner of First Str t, S, and submit updated plans, which include Seventh avenue, SW, at $23, Council also: gave final approval to a su et' of housing conditions, as. • It ik a controversial amendmepnt to ,the the current site of the business e cit 's atoning ordinance regarding sessn�nent of then s of lower�in- Spot. come households, and specific goals Residents o multifamily development an office area have said: and institutional Wes; held an sac- d locations for development of asw loiterers at the business have af- sisted housing for indeiuhtely fect t sage of ties Iiidpeview utie�e session on l atinh or housed lower -income families. library branch across the street, but Lion of businesses or industries, rr id the new i "vir. McGee said the city has initiated bust k ease action; end approved she tually identical" to discussions with the property owner, re Wing of the property of Charles F, one ' in p Pc d Macila Hrittain on Old Shelby, effect, It includes goals for public and with a vote, Will proceedwith ha�using, housing' habilitation, fed the negotiations to acquire the prop ad. oral laorrie o rship low -interest erty. Arnong potential uses of the mo esx d hhusing for ties elder- Property are returning it to rresiden ly d handicap he id, teal use, or re-establishing a business cil also anthori a uest there, he said, fora gait of $Ill; to ,ass in the gather matter, council v to e i of the Nest Hickory for advertise for public hear' on a +Citi , �.. ter.. � parking ordinance end- ment which Would establish two-hour The city recently learned that the parking during the hours from 9 a. gin. state is making .the funds available to b: 30 p:rn, on the east side of First for senior citizen center develop Street, NE,,between Third Avenue, went, Carr explained. NEt and Fourth Avenue, N , behind r id thecenter's expansion is FryaRegional Medical Center, told council that the With cltybudge,at $91,500 under the current has had a number ofpro am, tl complaints about the the parking prom there.city will able to make addition In other business, council approved Ub V I Vatmiul if.. .,Pl"U I-& t W0% w&l r W Am%& ow t 0% NA JVk A-k 60"k Kld start of the project, said , a a ll Barrier said, by Martuillilt #t, R*Wd Wmff Pbalograi Researchers will then monitor the way the sludge ' , Right, Takes r Howard Kidd, Left, Roy Price Watch See Project, Page 7A k r M .vk r. Donald'fie Eaddy, Director Agronomic Division ncvb Corolinal i of A r uitur JamesGraham 0 Commissioner W1111am G. Parham, .pry Commissioner 1 onaM Connor Route Box 1015 ., ,d.'5 W C nno)t: t: w gg a+ bat iau: 0 $ d 51" e k�de.7'eP`u Cs� pg3^jj gg ax „.. ez Tla' iS -61-tePty to You trek Jte,6mAed to me .the Go e. rjo ' 064 ce 04 CitizenA66ai&6 dated 9123185 c e 0, dd e 4 ed ,t ve o ten, ktque t . " t cc n Atudrie apptication &one the City 04 dc* The app&ovat 60& apptication 06 thiz matetiat, must care 64om .the Divizion o6 EnviAonmentaZ Managemewt. T have contacted Ot. MthuA Howie Aky and cuzsed you,% conceAn teWt him. He Auggated that you contact him nd he woutd advize You onthe p p op e channeU to 6ottow with appUcation of this mateAiat. Ak. MOube"y'saddkeAS andphn h e A4tkuk uoubmy DiviSion o4 EnvZtomentateaa PO Box 27687 Ra-teigh, No4th Ca&otina 27611 Phone --8 k. MoubmAy at4o gave me the name, addkess, and phone ne n �Legionat Ojjice .in MOO&UviUe tthat you can contact 16 your. dezite, to do 6o. The contact peuon in MOCAUvitte t. Rex Gteason 919 Nokth Main StAeet p vitae, Nokth Catotina, 28115 Phone 704-663-1699 the apptication o f 6,tudge i6 outside OuA e .ezp nSib i tr ,am JoUmding- YOUA et�t .t S Moab and ' e are. p " eracr� - e e r tie the e a the era o f NoAth C tina and car advise you on how to handte th " matmiat., OOA Deco de 6how that kle teceived tAkee oit Sampfn 6tom the dispo,6at Site on May 5, 1985 and maited tke upott on May 22, 1985. 14 aye can aszi6t you in the Jutuke with OuA 40,itt" t 4e4vice we witl be happy to der Ao., Blue Ridge Road Center Dept. AG P.0, Box 27647, Raleigh, N.C. 27611 1733-2655 Ai N ,. _ A ffirr'P ,IIw,,Q ACIj `4 ��a PPPPPPP' . Donatd Connor SeptembeA 27, 1985 Page " hope na,6 you.gin nq .on and Since-tetg YowG&, M. Ray TuckeA,g Ag)tonomic Division, . A. A. Donatd W. Eaddy, Ditecto& Aqtonomic Division, . # '. . , Rateigh, ". , c. A4thu4 MoubeAAy Division c6 Env ° g PO Box 27687 Rate,igh, N. C. 27611 At. Rex Gteason Divis,ton of Envi4onmentat Management Mootesvi,Ue, N. C._28115 Gov '' of ° " State Capitot Rate"g, N. C. 27611 t� d MORPOstATrO PUBLIC UTILITIES 0.+ 0 AIRPORT R PROPERTY HICKORY MUNICIPALwy 1. Shown on tOPo map is where sludge will be applied, property lines, ll., surface water, drainage, and location of residences. 2. Yp Sludge will be hauldd by , tanker truc'i. at the rate o 3500 gal. per t k load and dispersed,'siteill not be harvested. .. Sludge is stored in drying beds. 4. Land to be used 109 acres. . N.E. Masts eater Treatment Plant location is 5 miles northeast of,site. N .8 Henry Pork Waste- at r Treatment Plant location isa wiles southeast of site. A• r A. W L_h POR TOP I E ,INC: 1215 C E L L_ AVENUE REFERENCE' O 2 2 4 C �a C:TE FCaE"EC e - ���� �$1984 CIL�IEL#T CITY OF HIC=L4��R � �� � tnip HICKORY, NC TTENTION TERRY TWICis ,,AticLE IDENTIFICATION: SRMPLE #1. NORTH EAST PLANT SAMPLE #21 HENRY FORK PLANT AN L'S I . is Cl. 54 NICKEL, PP . 2 22 El. 866 R-SENIC, PPM C.013 4 0096 SELENIUM, PPM 0. 0 : 0, 0 LLm.':EC S. 19. L . L FIBOR TORIE I N.. CERTIFICATE NO. 004 E. = ; CERTIFICATE NO. 02006 S. C.. RT E I CATE CSC I ` -H E R. BANKER-, �}® LS "TESTING FOR A BETTER ENVIRONMENT" w 3 P U „- „4 REWRENCE NO,: 2 5687-1324 „ ,TE w' CLIENT: E , K _> A77 EN WN; jerry SAMPLE 0ENUFKAT:00 n mla 02: Nortn E s s i ,AN ., p k , ro_ Arsenic Ba ,. y i,Cadmium 6 v " (Q.0121 Chromium S ••. .» 0.025 Copper .„ 1 1 2 =a Lead Selenium 3113 v a 0 . � m Aercar' ANALYZED u S. A, W. z _ E S!NC. C. NO. 48 p CERTIFICATE _. 37 xn � r . w NNE QLSON� t �qfyw+gles s September 2, 1982 }. REFERENCE NO.: 02F 00 NATO RECEIVED: June 9, 1982 CLIENT: City of Hickory' PERNMTS & ENGINEERING R. 0. Box 398 Hickory, N- C. 28603 ATTENTION: Don A Brook Asst. Public Utilities Director SAMPLE IDENTIFICATION: Sample I Henry Rork Plant Sludge Sludge' ANALYSIS: L ach to Analysis Sample 2 Mg/1 ndri < 0. 00002 40.00002 Linda < 0. 00000 < 0. 0 000 Methoxyclor '-0.0002 0.00037 Toxaphu 0. 00002 40.00002; 2, �0.0000 0.0000 2, , P(Sily 0.00 0.0003 ANALYZED , B. A. W. LABORATORIES, INC. N. C. CERTIFICATE NO. 48 N. C. CERTIFICATE NO. 004 E.P.A. CERTIFICATE NO. 0200 MICHAEL R. BANKER D. NIA "CILSN -1215-1 Centraf, Avenuharlotte, North Carolina- 0 04 -(704) 370- 0 0 i L i a i h r-eO h I AGRONOMIC DIVISION, Wc. bEPARTMENT OF AGRICULTURE, F IIOG5 ROAD CENTER, RALEIGH,'I . , PfiONE., () - /05/83 X COUNTY EXTENSION CHAIRMAN °COPIES SENT TO: :7t, 2655 RT I BOX 60CC HLITT SA,NIDEkS HICKORY H I CKGRY NC 28601 JA-MESHICKORY FARM LOCATION (COUNTY ): Y FIELD INFORMATION �.. APPLIES, Lbhff htw r;. sw z}5 VAk 6t t C`EC as", y raw � I Y i SUGGESTED fFFT"FY3T FOR FiS P rOP tl f CROP TO BE GROWN LA 7l =r iNOTE SEE CROP'To SE r r FIELD INFORMATION SAMPLE PREVlOUS CROP aLA'pLCE.D ..$PRE IFF ra F i, o-7`,. FC Il SISU. I � Nh'o c l 11.10 4.I .; r SUGGESTED TREATMENT FOR F�FIST CROP (OR YEAR` Tea i Fes°+ i...._._... � F * al+ P i Si. it 1. 4 � %d 74..i — ab � k S t � i t f �d3, nPoPL^.`'. PR Ev 4JIJa ✓M visas PPLVE 14 ! �. kNl»,€ ".'""",w..m....€. ».w.w�..�,�.......«..w.,.n.v.-.....+�u....�«�w.q.,�.aw.e..�«.w�0.,... &A Q_ah9E r �P'Y' LAST ".¢?%1 I 4 CEFIELD INFORMATION C 1a�: PK r PI � �� � [ b0.4 1 2 t e n C tl R' mi CROP a .�YEAR)" . F �. rT 's St1 i i TREATMENT E - S z n TE -, r vcs E, tmaa a rP Grp 14 1 T r s FIELD INFORMATION SAMPLE eb`e,�.Lt p�J l."+�,u �E 3v � 1APP4.NCC5 4,9MEPERT LAST CRCs �} ol, P�iFwi �� 4tt `w �� CEC DS A ..... .........�»...PH E E r e ASS j P. ro f E t " In SUGGESTED TREATMENT FOR FIRST CROP R Ia YE; 6 ",.,. noTs I �£ } E i s S r'u h�S t."� �FdiPVri1USC.1S r: RC}Fa .0 I { daH Pdn lEzi LAMI, Ped.i" i [ F �- 9tfxr k clC CAL-'� Ac pH F f o tun"} 9$#i .,e3srw t 4tl tjETED TREATMENT FOR F" RST CROP (OR YEAR { C Fd'C. To— kYePitdy C..:9r Ii................�-� _—w:.l AL (S ,a .. mR2 „... aw:.E aCP"fyPCCS E:Y.. Ta 4TiTl'v'\1 r t ;"d4:iE " TEST RESULTS (N.C. tests will not compare dirlRCUy 10 RUr bers obtairied by athermethods,] "T» °a`„,: Claw MIN - WrOlop ES- - Paw Sarara, n , % o9 C C &�§,k'.'� A IftgrreLiu , %n; C,'Ec '.NO,t4 - NiTra.n N, rnqukthe S&O - I inerat #, ganS: the - Acidity, megj a£ cm` hire-9 f4on..panfte InL,ex � C«t-„,tsr - ;xrrs>•rs;+raSann N,jnt*� R �= £3t a ais:. [ pH - Hydrogen -ion AcOvity n-1 - Zinc Index Na � ":rra'�raarrr, rsrt�qlFt.i fie,: HINT , = Hvnit c Matter, Percent by voii, P& - Phosphorus Index Cu-I - Capper kidex 'Ivav weight per bruduane, aCM, K.. I - rats atrium 8cha;x S r - Sulfate Sulfur 3nd"- (:stirs€, Each. Cap., rnagI100 cm' f O-% 4Csa6cLuni, %of CEC C.I Solubl a Sal, pnci± � a Tw READ SUPPLEMENTAL ERIAL AND x v t y 1 Nino,' — !sz, r, N !-a ;VN@EkS HICKORY S S .'. : ^, x;:•.ta,: idea a t E w� �.�ESTED TREAT111,1ENT FOR SECOND CROP (OR YEAM" _ — `tMa� 4 a0P TO ME C],,. UA-4 .y �. � �o k? kF9� , C. I e. „r ,„, �6'9� w STE. 5 � �� I � at?r� i 0 w, 1 "k s, y TEST RESULTS __ ..__., a, `m,., � .-.+�wa.: � e:s % a ....., � sa�r�; r,a-,�o r :�.s c. 1 7 —S.i � 5s a Aao�.�� :u!?���a N. t 1 1+ H 0 SUGGESTED TREATMENT FOR SECOND CROP 1CR s'`;-EA "'. o` 71 "- F 0 tc „R 'NN LAl E # �`J 3 P:,=,� � 1: na:, N 6";�. � k f I k = _ TEST RESULTS P 7 K r :p cam';.. MqP , 2 MA i � .�sa_t R us-e � �wd � ;M� & � °^&CA��3 # tm4N Na k (� +) d Ala ((( 6.6 15.4 :1 11 SUGGESTED TREAVVIENT FOR SECOND CROP (OR YEAR�— T .««_..w.-..,._. xxxqq "ti4, gM1k 3tk�m Eii,"."®°T£)1r Ci Psi C3'oV'tV'.,..M.,..._:...... L!=bE �.:i __,..«W.,..�,.,............«... .. K.,':5..�:..... : 4 v#roe U ......^^^^,m...s.^� P�¢tY `. Ta E B p 9G $N j NOIS � I _ a TEST RESULTS ...._.a.,.....-..._,-.�,..... yea. r............-^.+ w E a5 ca - 3 1 : r �aa _ k ,4 �« . N NN. �� W;t, E 1 1 1 o 1; - a 1 1 .. �. SUGGESTED�S N T aOR FOR SECOND CROP OA x*, is v4av SEE CR C'P TO8E GROWNmk4�i �.: C ? � .:,...�- � �s iifl 7E + a l + 1 I � e .,,..._.�:,_.a...mm�..,..gym...-.,.»-�..:-..-�.,�. ,..�....»�,.,..��,...�...,�:....�.�..�...�...,..�.:..:,..�....e.,,.�..:....�M..v...�.�.....,,�:a...,..,.�.d....��.�,.,P,:�N.................,.:��:,�,»-.��,.:..�;�.,�.-,�.�....�.,,.�,,.�,�..F,.....,.�.�,�.�»«w. .,�.„� T S RESULTS ._. ...,.,y.,.,.�.�.,,..»..k»�..,� ....,�.�.,_.,.,... ...i. _Miv r,E.c if; a t ata� *r+ t i F~,a E.. M�,rS a Eke" EbSai N. , UtsGESTE D IRE "a ME T FOR S CCND CROP IOR YEAR)** R)** . .,�s. :r pen4 GFE 1 o-'Pt UP TO BE GROVV N t, ¢»++E Aj '0 K 0 h�M1=3 .. C. Ufa .,M...,.�..,..,� mn NOSEE TE �,,... lVf1T tl f g + 4, .:ti ` Nitrwv N, rng,°dm' o NIE T - tw s/a, M — sbs.a 11000 sq, *k.... K. SP.orov , M Rbs,) ot"w00 xq ft Zn Znc NHA Amrntan urn N, rrgr`ram N -+ Nnrogen, M - lbs,/1000 so. Ft. Mg - Magnesium a - soran Na - Sodium, -7)e i100 crn' a kin - Maara ne f , ";; r us�ara�ih2te, Pub - ��as.,'ifY�fi sq. t,, twit `� C;t+Pd��Me x Test Uvel is qunflonable. lies supplemental &t ra 1. d-,",11ATERIAL AND BACK OF REPORT FOR FURTHER DETAIL AGREEMENT FOR THE LAND APPLICATION DT WASTE SLUDGE DPI PRIVATE LAND NAME OF WWTP: Northeast WASTEWATER TREATMENT PLANT OWNER T : City of 1l1 er TYPE OF SLUDGE liq4id r FARM NO. m FIELD NO. LOCATION OF LEAD 428681 OWNER CP PROPERTY LESSEE OF PROPERTY LAND USE OR CROPPING PATTERN -pasture 191i l INTENDED USE OR DISPOSITION OF CROPS fescue The undersigned lamed owner or his representative hereby permits the City of HickoxT here i mraf to r refer rid t ` as the Pe r i tt+ e, t app y d ream t e iortheast Wastewater Treatment Plant upon the Iand at the location shown s described in the attached documents in accordance with the restrictions, stipulations and exceptions shown below. The land owner or his representative receives, in c nsider ti lm fall use '+ f the nutrient value of the applied sludge while the Perrnittee receives, In consideration, the use of the land described above for the disposal of digested sludge. This agreement shall remain In effect for an Initial period of` years. Following the Initial year period, this ;agreement shall remain in effect from one year t -the year until cancelled as stipulated below. The undersigned land owner or his representative and the Per ittee agree to abide with the following restrictions and stipulations until such time as written notification, given ninety D days in advance, modifies or cancels this agreement. RESTRICTIONS: I TINUE MIS AGPJD.MR fD OWN, E DTE PERMITTEE NORTH CAROLINA CATAWBA COUNTY 1, the undersigned Notary Public, do hereby certify that r . , personally appeared before rye this day and acknowledged the due execution of the foregoing Instruments THE y hand and notarial seal, this ' ay f _,�� .rr m 1984. WOCILLE F. t40TARY PUBLIC No u c TAReCOUNTY, m My C expires! pi res m '- a r + a REC'ClDEN CD North Carolina Deportment of Natural Resources Arad Community 13evelopm y USE ONLY lseratlr ItdlsMtsl►art Environmental munclorement Convarissainst � r NON-DISCIIAREE PERMIT APPLICAT104WITS& Covorys in aeenrdmnce with N.E. General Statutes Chapter 143, Article I Applicant triatoo of istrinal, individual, or othwa): ApplicationData. t City unIl F'rogedt (moire 0( clty, villagr, town, sanitary district tsNabt€aftmesit)e City of Hickory FOR: Brief Project Description: .: Nmrt-Clrachary�e Trmttnnt/1_}i.rptzsal Facilities Pretreatment Facilities Amendment: Land Application o Sewer Collection System (prifinte) Sewage Sludge F,xtend writer and Sower Systems (Public) h (see enclosed report) A'rlt� Of'"rt5°l°�;A�lyrl Amending Permit # 10587R2 Sewage Slwtdge/lnduatrial Wilt Other Waste From (sowors, prstreatmont facilities, treatment plants), Servanq (city, institution, industr I - Henry Fork and North East WWTP t I Hickory, N . . Inca Inane of tteaatment ptffwj; I obutwa'y To lnamm of **set course); N/A I At (location of trrotrnant plant): River Road - Cloninger' Mill Pond, Hickory, N.C. Name and +�anplrer Address of "rt pa rtrartrtq Firm: AMSCO, Inc. P.O. Box 568 Clemmons, N.C. 27012 Tteotmersf Winks Capacity to Sa e# Inamo of protect); - Far Ina. yrs.) - Average daily Gallons Sewage ae oste Flaw: Fo rk ark and Northeast t 3 y 3 Afle t 'trail Reducswon in Pollution (nor oppticatla fie sewer projsicts), Fseimorad Caetst Toxic Materials (Specify a ench, add pages it naedod) 11. O.1). ( -day I;) N/A N/A N t v acwct Sat* pendt d Snla`d Pumping ' N/A N A Station N/A Treatment 1'I A1- Sfl.II3 N A N /" Plant N/A •" father (specify) �fA IA f:tt)ifrarwwa flarttria sip tad Completion Darr:N f TOTAL MATERIALS lid 1 IApplicant a;s�urett that proptaced works will he constructed, supervised, operated and rmain'taitted in Accordancewith approved plans and Wino ifications or approved chang" thereto. treat home Title; Mailing Address: Jerry T ` PublicUtilitiesDirector City of Hickory Sr rvatv're a . Bel 3 ,98 Hickory, N.C. 28603 INS I RUC T tot ,It+rn L ape os. If -of apptrr:pbie, antot NSA, . Socu€o at.prapreote signorutr tmayorr'city manager for municipality, chatrrean for sanatory district ootd awrnor/ptape€ official of carpi ro t.o tar lkgafly canvlowtod bawd Of commission ]n charge or proposed wavitst, A letter of authorisation ws +equired fratwt propmr"dfficmat „t_ design eng;neot or other agent Signs 'spolication, 3. Satb ,t to N.r, G3aparFn+dnt al Natural Reaarore" and Community Drvalapeoant,Environmental Atanaq mont Rolaigh, NC, l€ n o€Rganat and Rest copy of o plirowrarr, 2 seta of hoolitod plans, s eiftcataons and other supporting data as required by tnrsaean goalie. NOTE Aor^lrcer,on •#vtv-s at* sthtdufod an waeeept of COMPLETE information. f anerolly,'30 sieve are required for pollution abatrnent projects, 9t1 days R'ar oth#o projects FOR ASSI'S1 ANCE, cell the Stare Office (919) 733.712I as the opsp.apriarr field adios listed Irstlaur 'Ashevttlo (704) 251,3341 'kFaartsaille (7 A) 663.1699 °Weshinpton f919) 46 481 Pet s inaton-3ale f9191 T t.23S1 A"ate m $wrest 919 North main Strtet 1502 North Moffitt Striae Setwe Creep trway otans«oat Asheville, NCgR1' Mooresville, tf p 20115 Isoxhinvitnt. NC 27889 inectim-seta , t C 27106 'Fovirttavrllo 1 19) 486.1SA1 "Rat—sh f9191 733.2314 t it 'nos f911i12$6.4161 .r.rr 7t4 wstcha+rte Rerrfdenq Olox 27667 oyerrovrtlo,MC 28301 7223 atri�betsville Avostsoor dttata,¢, C 2 411 €l 'iogy , Nic 28403 Ep7RECEIVED .0gaw,lib' ern State of North Carolina Department of Natural Resources and Community Development Division cal Environmental Management 512 North Salisbury Street Raleigh, North Carolina 27611 James G. Martin, Governor August 24, 1989 R. Pal Wilms William W. Coe , .Jr., Secretary Director Mr. B. Gary McGee,-' City Manager City of Hickory Hickory, North Carolina 2860 SUBJECT: City of Hickory State -EPA Approval of the Revised 'Plans Regional 'Sludge Compost Facilities EPA Project No. C 7t1 9-12 Treat Mr. McGee: The review for completeness and adequacy of your, project construc- tion plans has been concluded by the Construction Grants Section of the North Carolina Division of Environmental Management. The revisions to subject plan documents as designed by Ashebrook, Simon and Hartley are hereby approved. One (1) sat of the revised plans will be forwarded to you, and one (1) set to the Corps of Engineers, Inspection Branch, under separate cover. you are reminded that erne; 1 set of plans and: specifications identical to the approved set must be available at the project site at all times. Upon completion of, the project construction the Grantee shall submit a Letter confirming that the project has been constructed in accordance with the plans and specifications approved by the State. "As -built" plans will need to be submitted with any changes color -coded on the playas if the above confirmation cannot be made. I',0. Fox 37687, l Adgh, NOrth Caroliaw 276117687 Telephone 919 733.7015 An I-qual 01)portunmty.A1Trraaative Acton Employer slop Mr. B. Gary McGee, City Manager August 24, 1989 Page 2 If there are any questions concerning this matter, please do not hesitate to contact Mr. W. S. Hoffman at (919) 733-6900. Sincerely, /o n R. In Cu� we" ief C stru onstruction Grants Section CM,vk cc: EPA Hazen & Sawyer - Raleigh & Charlotte Office Mooresville Regional Office CE - Charlotte Tom Fah, estock Allen Wahab Don Evans Valerie Helms Cecil Madden clu EMU GPF ov �r r= State of North Carolina Department of Natural Resources n Community Development Vdn. Division of Environmental Management 512 forth Salisbury Street • Raleigh, h, forth Carolina 27611 James G. Martin, Governor 1 . Paul Wilms William W. Cobey,fir., Secretary Director August 14, 1989 Thomas Lundy,Manager Catawba County F.C. Box 889 Newton N.C. 28658 Subject: Pertnit ApplicationNo.WQOO(Y2154 City of Hickory Land Application of Sludge from Huffman Finishing Company Catawba County Dear Mr. Lundy e Division of Environmental Management has received a application from the City of Hickory to include sludge from Huffman Finishing Company in their land application program. Should you desire to corntnent on this application as it relates to your interests, please do so by September 14,1989. If you have any questions, please contact Cis. Babette McKemie at 919/ 7 - 18 . Sincerely, Az <5'41011 Xrthtlr Mouberry, P. E., Supervisor .Rermits and Engineering Unit cc: Babette McKemie Mooresville Regional Supervisor P.O.Pollution Prevention Pays Box 27687, Raleigh, North Carolina 27611-7687 Telephone 91 -7 -701 s An Equal Opportunity Affirmative Action Employer DIVISION OF E!'IVIRONMENTAL MANAGEMENT November i 1983 %IEMOANDU TO: Allen Kahan A EIg BY: Thnrnran Hor � .. SUBJECT: Response to Technical to�Ttnents Sludge Disposal Hickory -Newton 1 utilities Plan Amendment Project No. C 370389-01 Catawba County, North Carolina Appropriate staff of the Mooresville Regional Office have reviewed the subject documents and offer the following comments and observations: i Reference: Response to Comment No. The engineer has mentioned that the Town of Long View does not intend to abandon its wastewater treatment plant* Actually, this giant has ceased discharging to surface waters, but is still being utilized for pretreatment with the effluent being connected to the Henry Tort Wastewater Treabrront Pleat for further treatment, If you have any questions or geed any additional information, Dl'oas advise Thurman Roane or, nra;°. JT , so s � DIVISION OF ENVIRONMENTAL MANAGEMENT' k � a �}} T 4 a o4 E M 0 R A {ps N D U M,. y. �S, O: Mr. Bill Hodge, e, OfficeM er Mooresville Regional Office r. Copy Batten, Pend Local Programs Planning Branch' Mr. Forrest Westall, Mead Technical Services Branch FROM: Mr. T. Allen Wahab, Supervisor Local Planning na e ent Unit SUBJECT: Response to 'Technical_ Comments Sludge Disposal l Hickory -Newton ,1 Facilities Plan Amendment E Project No.. 70389-0 Transmitted herewith are two copies of the subject Amendment for the Mooresville Regional Office and one copy for the. Technical Services Branch,. These are for your files. Please return: your comments to this office., S SR/ j . Enclosure cc: Richard Peace LPMU `r GP++ L' DepartmentNorth Carolina Resources &Community Development James B. Hunt, Jr, Governor Joonph K Grik"C sI , Secretary October 20, 1983 DIVISIONOF ENVIRONMENTAL MANAGEMENT Robert F. HeIm Mrector TOephone 9 19 731701 Per. Bob White Economic "Development Coordinator Western Piedmont Regional Council of Governments P. C. Box 306 Hickory, North Carolina '2360 Subject: Response to Technical. Comments Sludge Disposal Hickory -Newton 201 Facilities Plan Amendment Project No. C37038-01, Dear Mr. White: This is to ackno Id e the receipt of the subject amendment. Review of this report has been initiated. You will be notified upon completion. If ;you have any questions or comments, please contact the. Local., Planning Management Unit at (19) 733-6900. Sincerely, T. Allen Wahab, Supervisor Locale Planning Management Unit PJh cc City of Hickory City of Newton City of Conover Burmeister, Wright and associates Mooresville Regional Office Walter Taft, Jr. Coy Batten LPMU C P POLL TION PREVENTION Pal YS P 0, Box 27667 RaIeiqh, I . C, 77611-7687 An Equal Opportunity Affirmative Action Employer �Jpss x u i a °:_ js.uom,ppa sulss.'Innsgns iixoi pra jc�, cz� p:mpaj a rjuazaad padS. * . '' TG SaMMA :DTrqrki :a110 ° taaa� q adds Ti a ptm suvId aq1 qjm aourpioan ui ptm aapovid pajdaam isaq'agi oilurpxmr itmId aip airtiodo put wammm 01 put uoisad ua dwon s jo am aql aap uo!i a {a sia aorld of saeLdr saq nj ptm ungx paAojdde Apuanb=qm sc, such pur surld pomiddr MP 41. p.a+ ur Pun uk paimumoo dq Ipm r4jam pasc doid otp Imp saaAu Aqw.-q imilddt, aiLt ro of q 10 UO P94OTdmoz ;aq TTTA GAJOA aqI japo f '-t UOTIVISss six pajvwTqsa sT 94ion posodoid, a,qa To javaq o 'vTiaaoeqv=ojT,-fooSPTIOS TV404 PT-1 pap doses ' ( :9AOTT0J Ov UOT3nTTod T T p p =0 IOU TTT^ AOTJT P ORVIOAV OtP Psi pd a d .d ( * *'AaMPTH 8 " " q d uaoq w,.... uvTd Dwell ja 'w go ' ;< IV AjvanqTa4 IsaeavA punoat ao North Carolina Department of Natural Resources &Community Development James B. Hunt, Jr., Governor James A. Summers, Secretary DIVISION OF ENVIRONMNTAL MANAGEMENT September 7, 1984 CERTIFIED MAIL RETURN RECEIELffqUESTED 14r. Jerry Twiggs Public Utilities Director City of Hickory Post Office Box 398 Hickory, North Carolina 28603 Subject: Warning Letter Unpermitted Land Application of Sludge City of Hickory Catawba, County, North Carolina Dear Mr. Twiggs. As you are aware, yesterday, September 6, 1984, an investigation was made of several potential sludge land application sites in the Rickety, area. The investigation was made at your request and involved Dr. Bob Rubin, North Carolina State University; Mr. Ed Nolly, SCS; Mr. Thurman Horne of this Office and Mr. Nuitt Sanders and you representing the City. One of the sites vitich was investigated was the abandoned landfill at the airport (you were not present during this part of the investigation). At the landfill site, Mr. Horne observed that sludge has been dumped in mounds several feet high in an area of the site inmediately adjacent to a steep embankment. In d Slud his action is a (9). appli, over for a cease A Iri n iders, it is our understanding that this )ry Northeast wastewater treatment facility. rth Carolina General Statute 143-215.1 1, on numerous occasions, that land Lt. in or in addition to our pending recommendation for enforce is now under consideration. Mooresvffle Regional Office P. 0, Box 950,919 North Main Street, Mooresville, N. C, 28115-0950 Telept I A A ffi,r tlwa A -fine, Pmnfrwa, �e piles ipplies ;hould :ions are :lusion which DIVISIONOF EWRONMENTAL A MANAGEMENT IP North Carolina Department of Natural �w Roer, F Fie€m *w_ rResources &Community Development Dirpc"for � -... :James B Hunt, Jr- Gtrrvmr James A, sUrnme$, Sec,,.ka€1` September 26, 1984 MEMORANDUM TO: Dick peace, Regional Supervisor Mooresville Regional Office � . A THF1U; L.P. Benton, Jr., Head �... , Enforcement & Emergency esp0n"se Branch FROM: Richard Lasater fL F ,SUBJECT Enforcement Grade Report City of Hickory Land Disposal of Sludge Without a& Permit t W -1 Catawba County The e ea d action package identified above has been reviewed and graded. The actin received a letter grade of "A-". The following items were considered and weighed as indicated to give the above grade a Investigation and investigation documentation: 25 (b) Enforcement action report format r antiati n : 10 (c) Enforcement action report content: d Findings and decisions and draft assessment document: 1 Total points: g Ihave counted off five points from the investigation documentation grade as w f there is no mention that the land application permit was issued on ALAgUSt 1984, followed by a second permit on August 30, 1984, Another five points were deducted from the enforcement action report content grade as no mention t was made as to the; current compliance of the City of Hickory with their permit. t-a .. am 17 N i U' K—' Ni U N T Y D P 'Vo' T :R 10, "I M� 1�7 14 1,1. E N T �t L 7 E- R Q `L; A L I T Y S E C 10 N' POST OFFICE BOX 950 M0")RE-SVILLE, NORT�i rAROLINA 28115- REPORT OF Unper-mitted Sludge Dumping PL,ACE VISITED Proposed Hickory Sludge Disposal Site DATE July 30, 1984 ADDRESS Hickory, N. C. RIVER BASIN Catawba BY WHOM I'lichael L. Parker TIME SPENT 4 hours PERSONS CONTArTED No One REASON FOR VISIT ity of Hickory uld dump waste slud&e on 7/30/84 between 8:30 9;30 A.M. COPIES TO: REPORT: On June 30, 1984 at 0815 h6urs� this X Office arrived at the 'Hickory Munici LVal to investigate the anonymous report that City of Hickory employees would dump waste sludge from one of Hickory's municipal WWTP's on property owned by the airport Upon arrival the writer waited at v4iatl I a g , e point whicb I allowed a clear view of the airport property. At approximately 0912 hours a City of -Hickory dump truck carrying a load of dried sludge passed by the writer and entered a gate leading onto the airport property. The writer followed, and observed,city employees preparing to V A,--brve <"p the sludge. Althouh, gthetoosethe actual l-wr1te, K4 P `!� ging since it wao hidden beftaiii," ""' fete l-i" UM,7 ,,thesludge, the 4 6mployees were photographed I 'e, e w r t e r - VA kt!i�d far ap proximately 5 minutes to see if additional truck's "camie., On Wednesday, August 1, 1984, the writer again tra sit,",nd was able to enter through A section of fence...wmrroundin the oit s under repair. The 9- l writer found (observed) approximAtes '', 12",�P of -d rICI had been Z", NORTH =DEPARTMENT µ i" ems: a,�.. , lu a.., �'`i� ChNATURAL RESOURCES %S COMMILINITY DEVELOPMENT DIVISION OF ENVIRONMINTAL VONGEMENT WATER P, QUALITY POST OFFICE BOX 950 REPORT OP Unpermitted Sludge Dumping PLACE VISITED Proposed Hickory Sludge Disposal Site DATE July 30, 1984 ADDRESS Hickory, N. C. RIVER'BASIN Catawba BY W.Hom er r ours Michael � SPENT PERSONS CONTACTED No One REASONFOR VISIT Aou ludon/0 COPIES a N. II� ENVi A TENT T AGREEMENT FOR THE LAND APPLICATION OF 'WASTE SLUDGE ON PRIVATE LAND NAME OF WWTP: n Fork Plant WASTEWATER TREATMENT PLANT OWNER t otof Hi w TI f TYPE OF SLUDGE l w ---------------- FIELD LOCATION I err h ° Farm i�. � ��`x C. 28658 OWNERp PROPERTY Mr- H. W. Sherr"' LESSEE PER LAND USE OR CROPPINGPATTERNS I TEUSE OR DISPOSITIONOFCROPS" The undersigned lard owner of his representative ,hereby permits the'- City of' I, hereinafter° referred; to as the per i.ttee, to apply sludge from the nry Wastewater Treatment lent a the land at the a'ti� hr� as escri.'be =n t e attached documents in ad ordance with the restrietis s� tigaxla� tions and exceptions shown below. The landowner or his representative racemes,, consideration, full use of the nutrient ° el f the applied sludge;while the,Permittee receives, in consideration, "the use of the laud described ah e for he isp s l ° f digested,sludge. This agreement small remain in effect for an initial period of Following the initial year period, this agreement. shallremain in effect from one, year to the next year,, until cancelled as stipulated below. The undersigned land ownerear his representative,'., and the Permittee agree to abide with the following restrictions 'n stipulations, until such:time s written ;�tifie tin, given ninety days i eds�e, ddifis " eenels this agreement. RESTRICTIONS:` thr par .t= has the tight to d ant ` this �nt t. t;' NOM CAROLINA AT 1, the undersigned Notary Public, do hereby certifY 'that per--, nally appeared before ne this day and a6mowledged ,the .. vv,IIT=S nF hand and notarial, seal thi-S day of 4rm ru Ic _r NOTARY PUBUC i REPORT M4.21"2 M3YA Phiy IRS KUYSTEA CACULINAhe MC 444sa— au)LAICf,IC if.:k YC.,ti Yk' �j rw v t qqrryy @ y Y yy`^p� �yy ��qq Y&rF:...C4.,M 1"91� Nf. 1 4d p.�+ypy yy�� �f�yy 13.3 1QQ! ;Mi.jpn +� g y, y5+ y, g,@ �y(051*14,ass � i I. } �R` 4� �R#G Yt +1+5 w�IMq �f it ,ynCC i�c#F A TRFA rw �� YPk:nl .�1 k l0.FiX S riO4 d' q m.. . . ..vx.... .,......a...,�... .f. > .. .. ., ... .., vam.m ;�+suw. t.�t� err nr [ x ,.. _.t+. �,.n .a and raFt„kiY,ara„iaa sJ rw,.,, c4'hk7 tl,S#t AtS644d"il . 0 0 0 12E} MIA 0.1 'SM 0.4 k,.o fy 3' 22 61.6 1's.7 tb** , 3 46 . ,U€aaE, itro-r#Fa Ybst 6Iw,rrs 8"ht�„rl ifiea.e "0''0 -110 0 0 0. it 1 .. «.. ! .. .. ... e .& («J,✓ f'tl4" aY tv rTin S 9C,axa .... hra, nex n.r i�>xPE. . . .... . .... .,,�_.. .« ... 331 ' fES/ftiGAXIM AIR 0.2 ,0.9 1.4 93 0-4 *.3 *13 34 63.+4 33.9 1"+ 0*0 " 62 ..YE„u1.,4 rw,�.Ik.G kr+,wa"a.d =mVr sS tara..a 4h6itN;�a#c a`1,6Ati.*' .. a 3IM M. '1 a_w. «_ .. _.._ i tl i 040 o o o 0 ( 1 322 � ! MitN 1.t 3 .,....d.,........ M .. 13*4 100 o.o .. �. 7.,4 , 59 76 3o.* 14.8 1" . 14's 3s34 ",ii3reza k..oi&.Gi V ha r'. • e - 4 i tt+cr�a�,�m i .Swz .�. . «,. a ._ tr a HvL"€Wk 4.3ww.I'4aj, ..... t v . UT NL.24482 * w g cta 54ai6EiWCHEW FAKMS A T Aia 6A dPki`CkWzlk4ta4 .{6 .b4R Im MIN 0.3 i *ll*14164 +I ' .2 77 L#2 6.1 p26 24 57.3 �7.6 466+ 064 56 4a'i.9 i".sl i";1�k. L. IF46 r'k �krt ,ai ue.✓Yi d'Gli c� k:Pitb i#L!,^.4 ry �Et r � # 4{Rx:W Pan.k U#d1M4'Je � .• ., ,a 6 t m4e "v My � to 6 13 u JNvr qy_y y� �y p+ {�_ �p �.y �y. p �p y5 p � Epp I d¢ ed vt 0- 09 � [3 0- 1(1 V: , M d 4e �y x N i e �F Ytl� j} ...:_. p A #Ix ( PA%Y63G.Sw�i3Y " o-t < t d 'XeH �'i j p .. St ,uE fnt! d4 N N i'L x 5l4 !T1 146 04IN Ll 3 P.67 6.8 44 0.4 6.3 009 ; 36 62.1 49.3 166+ 653 ' 5 a_.s..b asa..0 �,4 sy saMti Jai t,&kt'�ta hid ai YkANk it c.y d Cse . .„ F �.c,ac 69 .� 90 6U1la ' ` _. _.k..4ziYM .. a „ R °x �*iF � Wt+tb+ika,.w'�h4.rb^ E s mr , •` x ' * a u n. � E vx 9vF s, z M � � Ca.H Pa � .u. d051+1A 9bli t + 1 . i 4 4 6 T14d 4164 . 1.12 I .-* Ipq .0 7...6� lob+ 46 65.3 ! 3.4 166 39d 66 ,_ ......., .a b...,.e...,.� ,. ,. ,. ,'�Ut,�t,aa: Ciia. E,l d#sa. tv FPYEt .e •�S+CVYia4 t.dwtBPkrt 9Y@tx {y� �F �+:HwW Y4.A ar§rcFFtd# tnw'Ea ' ,�•. «. , �a . . •., .. w,...... ... `,52 ...n. mku e,2 �Bva 'iSd si: Y6CV4ti ia[ t ;�16 Y idi f�: �..aiP i z � d T t Mt 90 Aq 4 q 43 03U-4350 0 0 0 1z i r s �t xu qv 4 ��y � X .. k .,sM. � e •n w v, ,.. � i E� .a.}u .J Mf �Rlmt�k 1 H4e � l�3�11iM531� t 3 E { i {} 5tt1GlTl $IN 0.3 1*03 4.5 6 .6 6 Q Uzi Z2 60.7 16.4 160+ 053 6,2 !! � r .+t.ts�c lr. to bs:a. +..o-,x}t i ae.Fk9 F3z 9 ¢. ii t,�r"=aass ka .upd "" a,v a a4e�s 3 Mal 1 i 0,,4t.4.livot?CROP )kVL.,M C,. �1Ta# ? bt 100 I69�i--11 0 Q i) ii 12 � ... ., . �_.._ .:ems. ..:... t'd LU 60 1* E 1L/ Tl Alk = 41.2 0.67 6.9 94 U.4 6.4 oug 30 (a�4z.o .i14.o 1541 ial j 54 e5' %/111N !t 0.� lw141� �464 1 C}wt4� 4�74��i1�t�.. iY ti 11 1S L� € i � a 4kw+P M``6YSULFS ON 4. ¢u�im Kt�Id[ ' t .. ax � � n s , , s3 i r 'M as = :, Fd, ^. 4.i rui • .. 71 tit, ­0 �,A At I}w +t c.t� fd'a•44. Afrual 2• Nc ixtsi„alra. vFtr 4+.ut ,Y[l, a,: +it'a3 .. ... 1#1 M4 YF R M I�iI a Ma'addfµi: ortt::a1$�'pi'•q kGBbn..rtA.f4'Y �F�d+%.k dp°�uh tlFl,�XYYi➢JM1i :, .,.�. ,'. qe&mdAR .u..p 4re5JP� n°jU n= +kt Y( IN M1419 , .2 .1. 15.2- I .0 .% 16 ...,-, �S Nilis?31= 66 Y2.1 8 1 25 F E 432'Y d:YMRJ'M"YU�4d+PZYeYY.A# # y { a er Yt •aH!»4 Y.k`$N f tlk.N m i4'kA}Q a- � 85fQiM1 10-00 a o o 0 12 Uo Ito NB � � v MIA 0.3 1*01 N .�•.,: 4*9 84 oos 4*0 027 . 12 61.* 1,9.7 1,667 44 i ;xd.P 45�N,:i'JflN�°tlt. cw9 d+atA$dY'd .a4 e fat 9X 4 e P4 o.+6 tl "- `.. � ,• .,-,. n- ` S:Wi,R#Nw4 trru a„be#n eN da a-',.< ,• t 4M1�4 M1 X a # a >• ea� 6 etr.ti @19Yp14. }tb F& ¢`M Y,a AOit ° J 1 Nt .flR 1 it £IdiO' )W,- It 0 0 0 ac� J puP a-. •� PMv #, Nu M14��,4 321 FESIMAXAM, M! MIN 0*2 V-92 7*4 95 0A *#5 01 * �� i�.4 ,2i�.'� 1� � « b i »rm4 4axa i. ".a kd.M.m Yk Fm x.eY `�. [k .'!ft_,4 3.i`ie JP" d1Wo C�r;i'fWn �` au.. .. r. � i,rpr a .<.S. a.sv 'rR �v�s87(j " •} •_ � t't To 0 Q. L P,490-120­460-oso 0 0 0 0 12 ' fi+$,i{S$i`d #"x.iP6laiw«�R i0.J,b #c tiY � Amy r++^..wa w:Y3reY • ••...m«,..,, 4 a ra } pp .v3�a 322 FB I rli� MI IN ,emu M 0*2 1.0 13.4► ,iO4 0*0 7*4 159 Ito410.40, 1466 1 « 16 334 .s�}ik6-u 1Ff.}TPc6 M4 t'CL Vak @1All' G&Y.i B�H(.ii 1t., €" r ., ...m.,.m„.. ,. ... .. .... ., +,w.,KP tl+r Bi iwubasw�� i.toW 'ia+ ft °" . i ii,` T £,.... 5 µ TAM, It . 0-20 Q 0-20 0 0 0 0, 12 t cf u.A,a tM i3A M'dA:f dS N rot t'fi&.±vkn u.aap{�wa ek Mxt 7 a t: ....• v' 1 N<x w • ....4M�Fw mR. rrawapNn:..• .. .� ,. .,. -.... _ _ � t )Xt `P Y.,f�{Y .w§ib Wx Xa4a vis near , -s.X .•� := s , , - '4t'POAJ r ifi L MME M F AA14S pu box 109 ROYSTEA oAALLIhA NEWTON WTQh MSG 65 __r,._ .-...... MIN � 0.3 i.U4 y 5. 1 77 1.2 1,6.1 026 Z4 51.3 17.+6 ,166+ " 064 i :5c. d WG"i Tt6> tPRt aa0", 1t rdE to I C''kkit <r Vt urea `.I t, Ph€ .. i$rraa v*§� #`e;p r4 emrC7t§t'ii Ri-R^Pa.Jh++�Yrt Yks dir99"" : {„#G$ X4u`led d1Y60.YdsR+ � � stl.il £i p N re a I �. r a ub+ , e Y i �",�' '• x G Pao- too 0 d a 0. 0 ; 1 M % 65* 1A 0531 ., 141N 0.3 0.87 6.41 94 G.ir 6* 3 009 36 62.1. 49.3 o6+ 053 �52 �at.xGa i.Sa}tk>G"E Wa„i°let"Et+da»>A'4, M+ak",L ee "a't,+i e, *" "atn4 adi:: Ra fiver rOki ��.ia�$`yr.,��++�;.ab"rw,ttrt k+p,r;G§d 130 Fkj-460 0 0 0 G 12 re a.ir utwa t23: FES/ G/T1m r4 MIN 0.2 1.12 18.4 XOO 0.0 7.6 106+ 46 05.3 13.4 166* 396 460 St,Fiae„a 4.EW lrsekrrvu,�, ,as•u vaaa R"B°taR.tg'#, art'',Vt ictn; d° :>r„e,n.«+, s#X. t�h,-tfi6-Na h6t&tart.,r.r-aJ *l Vt4+i`fk.A.W L z _.r .. :.. . a j xu d T 1 M FM a 6.0 #1 i aT 0 30-050 � G r 0 a 0 , 12 5'3.M! l MIN 0*3 x1.03_.; .5, ,. 112 u.1M 6.11 132+4 22 bu.7 i15 � � 62 SUi iUac 4 A'@ U 8 ^rL r. t r J. i A 4 u. UR t e s„ .a pp E FS'k olI IM m iM1 i.2 t1. 7 6.9 94 }. . 11G 3G 2.Mi . G.G .15 051 56 �. .. t :tiAt.�LSC': t.d.A 4&tA .+9a ;c rCcx vddai$'t S.s 3rt °.�k.4-4 b,kY..,P Jlktd AM^P 'R #..Y'id _ raa ka _ i tsar. T1MN N ; 0.0 100-200 120-1 0 1170-090 0 G 0 Mi 12 x (tS ,c.,txx4 ar 6.,t u0wi, { I North uarolina Department of Natural Resources &Community Development 4 , James. Hum Jr., G errs � et A, Summers, Secretary DIVISION OF ENVIRONMENTAL MANAGFMFNT October 1,,1984 r Larry cC ,ears Route 1, Box 398 Newton, N. C . 28658 Subject: Hickory Sludge Application Site (Mauser Farm) Catawba County Dear Mr. McClean: ;ached please rigid a copy of the Water Quality Investigation Report or file investigation conducted' on September 26, 1984 by Nor. Monty Payne of this Office. If ou should have anyr questions concerning this ratter or require additional information, please do not hesitate to contact Mr. Payne or re at (704) 663-1699, Sincerely, Water Quality Regional Engineer Enclosure Catwo a County Health paxr tment MDP:sju 9 ,ores lF? Reg i onW Office P 0, Bti3tt;^"��'', `.� 39 Ncxth Main Streo moofesviHe, N C 28 1 w. 0`,`l53C Tek ,)hwl )e ,#F0,1�'�rP�,' vs 9'v .P Y ... �. ... .. n. r ; n , , ..0 °~Sludge application Manusr Farm Mouser Fann 9/26/84 Catawba Monty D. Payne 2 hours n #C - w* r TED o One REASON FOR VISIT complaints about odors COPIES Catawba County Health Dept; Steve Fumster w. Y Larry McClean k. Can Friday, day September 21, i984 this Office received a complaint concerning odors coming from sewage being land applied on the Mau er Farm, The complainant did not see how the sludge was being applied, but complained about the odor steadily increasing over the past three and one --half creeks;' An. investigator (Monty Mayne) from this Office went to the Mauser Farm to see what was actually occurring. He found that both Bret and dry sludge was being applied to the land. The wet sludge was being spread on the surface evenly; the day sludge was;not being spread, but was being piled gip. After further investigation Mr. Payne could find only two infractions occurring at the site livestock is being allowed to graze on the site; and the dry, sludge is being plied up instead of being spread Odors on the day of investigation were not detectable, but the investigator did note how odors could arise when the wet sludge is being applied to the land® letter is being sent to the City of Hickory to inform them of their infractions. t Resource 'll,�° James B, gun, Jr., ` U 1 11tf L-1011MUIA 1 IC71 1 Sovernor James A, rn r ,, Secretary DIVISION OF EINVIRONHENTAL KANAGE1,F01I The Honorable William R. McDonald, III Mayor, City of Hickory Post i Office Box 398 Hickory, North Carolina 28603 Subject: Notice of Enforcement Conference Sludge Land Application City of Hickory' Catawba County, North Carolina Dery Mayor your McDonald: You and/or other representative of the City of Hickory, which you deem necessary, are hereby requested to be present in this Office on July l 1984 at 10:00 A. M. to explain 'why this Office should not proceed with enforcement recommendation for violalions of the North rolinta General Statutes caused by land application of wastewater treatment plant sludge without permit. Violations of this nature are subject to enforcement action by this Division which could result in,: fvi fines of tea 10,000 per day per violation. If the above date/time is not suitable, please advise Mr. Larry Coble or e as soon as possible. f you have any questionslon this matter, please feel free to, contact this Office. Sincerely, FRA1d 775 1146, D. Rex Gleason, P. E. Water Quality Regional Engineer cap: Mr. Jerry Twiggs Mr. Wilfred A. Wells Mr. L. P. Benton, Jr. Ms. Tana D. Fryer - ..;, Q se DIVISION OF ENVIRONMENTAL ]HAINAGENTEN7 July 1, :984 z�pT"l0RA'vNt` I TO lee Fleming . FROM tilo Peace T111RO.TGt,.a. Rex Gleason SI7B 1patlT t ULnpe zaaltted Sludge Disposal Cite of Hickory Catawba County ; As per your request, the staff of the M Cl have reviewed the history of Hickory's unpermitted sludge disposal practices and offer this memorandum and attached correspondence,, etc. to summarize the events that have transpired. As can be seen from review of the "Chronological File Summary" there have, been numerous incidences, dating back to July 14, 1980, of illegal sludge disposal practices-. There have been at least three (3) letters sent to the City, advising there that this activity repulses a permit. There have been at least as many ti warnings" by telephone. The KRO has tried to work with the City to obtain a land application permit beat this has been a; frustrating e: paerleatee. The City has been aware of pe lttlra requirements for several years but did not make application for permit until early this year (application received January 3, 1984).y, bpo . receiving this application the Permits d Engineering Licit: advised the C itv of elcrtici.encies in the permit application documents. Since that time there have been several- telephone calls by the P & E Unit (Arthur Ha d trom) arad _ the MRO (Thurman porno) to the City (Mr. Jerry Twiggs) trying to get the City to submit the required additional infosraaa con. Only: recently has it appeared that our message hafinally gotten through. After this latest incidence of unpermitted sludge disposal. (as referenced in the newspaper article in question) and our subsequent warnings by telephone and by letter, it appears that the City realise.s that we can not tolerate any future such incidences. It appears that the City has now submitted all of the requested additional. information; (received in Raleigh June 27, lSdd) to allow compl,at:ion of processing their permit application. Tl:e City has stressed that itt urgently needs a permit and. we ,:are glaring their application out, priority ; attention, even though, as we have expressed to the City, tlxe;w have essentially brow 1;€t this dilettmia on themselves through darer procrastinations In the interim we have advised the City to seek perrn ss°ion from the County landfill to dispose of sludge there If you have any questions or need anyadditional. information, please advise. dTHsu, CITY. OF HICKORY'S SLUDGE DISPOSAL CHRONOLOGICAL FILE SU1*1ARY June 25, 1984 Letter from Rex Gleason to the Public 'Utilities Director acknowledging continued unpermitted land application of sludge, The Director was advised to cease such practices immediately. This letter also requested additional information required to complete the application for a permit to dispose of sludge by land application. Letter from Rex Gleason to Mr. Jake A. Siption requesting that he cease the transport and disposal of the sludge from the City of Hickory until a permit had been acquired by the City. June 21, 1984 Complaint investigation (by Mike Parker) concerning sludge disposal on land belonging to Dr. Hart. In a phone call Gene Haynes with the City of Hickory said he would see that this was stopped. June 8, 1984 Complaint investigation (by Mike Parker) concerning disposal of sludge by land application on Dr. Hart's property. Through telephone conversation with Dwight Wilson with the City of Newton it was learned that the sludge was being hauled from the City of Hickory Wastewater Treatment plants. January 23, 1984 Application for sludge land application permit received. July 27, 1983 Complaint investigation (by Larry Coble) concerning land application of §ludge. The investigation found a large pile of sludge in a pasture belonging to Xr. Merritt Smith. Mr. Smith planned to apply the sludge to his pasture. Mr. Jerry Twiggs of the City of Hickory stated that the city would not haul anymore sludge to Mr. Smith. July 5, 1983 Letter frcm, Rex Gleason to Mr. Jerry Twiggs, Pi-Iblic Utilities Director for the City of Hickory, stating that land application of sludge without a permit: is a violzition of applicable Regulations. The letter reconnended that City not dispose of sludge in this manner any longer until a permit had been obtained. April 19, 1982 Letter from Rex Gleason to the Director of Public Utilities for the City of Hickory acknowledging the illegal disposal of sludge without a permit by the City of Hickory. The letter advised that the City of Hickory apply for a permit to dispose of sludge by land application, An, application, for such a permit was included with the letter. :'' July 14, 1980 Complaint investigation (by Thurman Horne) concerning sludge disposal on a garden owned by Tommy Barnard. The investigation revealed that sludge was applied on the garde', at two occasions and had been plowed under, Mr. Jerry Twiggs, City of Hickory, agreed to refrain from spreading sludge ir, this area again. n Carolinallorth Resources &Community Development �h. James B. Hunt, Jr„ Governor James, �r�nr r , Stref r DIVISION F ENVIRONIMENTAL M� Nr EMENT ,July Id, 1,984 Mr. Harold< Scronce Route 1, Box 64 Subject: Complaint Investigation Sludge Disposal - Dr. Haritts Property Catawba County, N. C. Dear Mr. tronce„ This letter is to confirm the investigation of your complaint on were 21 1984. Attached please find one (:1) copy of the subject complaint investigation report. p self-explanatory; ;questions `ffia rd cart s�z�nid 11�� self la;�at�r c�er, �.f pan �a�re an or need any further assistance, please do not hesitate to contact Ms. Tana I m Fryer or tie. We appreciate gar assistance and concern in this matter. Sier / w- e Fate ' uality Regional Engineer Attachment e �s `1Df°:jn 4 oore vWe Recponal Office. PO Box 950,919 Nor'$r�'o ain Strad oorewswik, , C , 811 - 9 C Telephone ne 70td 6i•1r 9C An Equaf OpporlLmity A;Ffis^a?iative Actia 3 Empfoyer 1H CAROLINA DEPARIMENT OF NATURAL, RESOURCES AND COMMU14ITY DEVELOPMENT DIVISION OF ENVIRONMENTAL MANAGEME11T WATER QUALITY SECTION POST OFFICE BOX 950 MOORESVILLE, NORTH CAROLINA 28115 REPORT OF Sludge Disposal -City of Hickory PLACE VISITED Bovman Farm DATE ADDRESS S. 1�. 1573, Conover, North Carolnia RIVER BASIN — Catawba BY WHOM Daivd W. Richardson TIME SPENT 3 hours PERSONS CONTACTED Mr, Bowman, Owner of the property in question REASON FOR 'VISIT City of Hickory land applying sludge without a 'valid Land Application Permit COPIES TO: On July 3, 1984 at 1330 Regional Office to report tha property and that the sludge at the Moresville Regional C Office investigate the site, of the application of the alu An investigator approximately 1520 hou` portion of the propert,, and had allowed the sli took a sample of the a, Later, the invest of the properties bein� that sludge, id the ar �bnday, July 2, 1984 b- DATA NT Y �Q C akds ampia Typo n�m E is t 9 We a yccae r GNX f u ` sN + � ZJ630 A a'SSr �0 # d t d t Gr•,; 14 r ., hiss #v .P666 k 11 spa &tawrus RtPt� 2� -- C #kaartla�� r t#w Ct �csaa5hcs t Cyr Orucs 5006f i�a 11 s cs it 1037 k , ro aixnv, r# h % P# r # 1 ( can crse hseaprr�s Extro ars s s 1C d5 `a. a 1Ints akecai dais itbawan4d 2 @ pcin� n2!yw-�acskier!�m_.�m �y an A, d k'" kbi it s ,# crags Paar bsu� Sac#,,; 2 ctV;nily "crciditY � 4 431 2 t €3 ' 2242 px i ac9 ita dfr ssi C4Oud C sw0'¢; 60vtart 32 16 b7 k North Carolina Department of Natural Resources &Community Development James B. Hunt Jr, Governor Joseph W. 'Gri slev Secretary DIVISION OF FNVIRONMENTAL MANAGEMENT July 5, 1983 CERlIFIED N=L RETURN RECFIPT REQUESTED it. Jerry Twiggs Public Utilities Director City of Hickory Post Office Box 398 Hickory, N. C. 28603 Subject: Unpermitted Land Application of Sludge City of Hickory Catawba County, N. C. Dear Mr. Twiggs: Reference is made to my letter to you dated April 19, 19,82 (a copy of which is attached). This letter advised that this Office was aware that the City of Hickorwas land applying wastewater treatment plant sludge without the necessary Permits from the Division of Environmental Management. It also set foigth the Items needed to acquire these Proper Permits. As of this writing this Office has not received an application for Permit to land apply sludge. On June 27 and June 28, 1983 this Office received complaints concerning land application of sludge. On June 30, 1983 an investigation found that sludge had been applied to grass lands owned by Mr. Clyde T. Bolick located off Highway 127 in Alexander County. This Office has no record of this site being Permitted for sludge disposal. As the results of these complaints Mr. Don Brooks with the City was contacted and advised not to apply any more sludge to Mr. Bolick's property. Mr. Bolick was also advised that any land application of sludge without Permit was illegal and should not be done. This is to advise you that land application of wastewater treatment plant sludge without a Permit is a violation of N. C. General Statute 143-215.1. Violations of this nature are also subject to enforcement action by this Division. Enforcement actions of this nature are subject to civil fines of up to $10,000 per day per violation. You are: hereby requested to cease disposing of sludge on land without first obtaining an appropriate Permit. Moc"ros,"Me Reg! anal Office P, 0, Box 950,919 North Ma4i Street, MooresviHe, N. C 2811 50 Telephone 7tA/f.r33-1GQQ F-,4r. JerryJerry, Twa Page July , 1 ' If you have any questions, please coiftact Mr. Larry D. Coble or me. Sincerely, , :. hex -Gleason, P. E. Water Qualiy Regional n Knee Attachment cc: Alexander County Health Depa n Catawba County Health Department 4 L C sju NORTH AR LI A DEPARTMENT OF NATURAL RESOURCES AND COMMUNITY DEVELOPMENT DIVISION OF ENVIRONMENTAl.. MANAGEMENT DATER QUALITY SECTION POSE` OFFICE BOX 950 MOORESVILLE, NORTH AR I II REPORT OF Sludge Disposal -City ;;of Hickory PLACE VISITED Bowman Farm DATA: 7/3/84 ADDRESS S. H. 1573, Conover, Hearth Carolnia RIVER BASIN Catawba BY WHOM llayd W. Richardson TIME SPENT 3 hours PERSONS CONTACTED Mr, Bowman, Owner of the property in question REASON FOR VISIT City of Hickory land applying sludge; without a valid Land Application Permit COPIES T REPORT On July 3 1984 at 1330 hours, Mr. Richard H. Peace telephoned the Mooresville Regional Office to report that the City of hickory had dumped sludge on the Bowman property and that the sludge was still wet. Mr. Peace is the Regional Supervisor at the Mooresville Regional Office. Mr. Peace suggested that personnel from the Office investigate the site, collect samples of the sludge, and take photographs of the application of the sludge. An investigator from this Office arrived at the Bowman property at approximately 1520 hours. Sludge had been recently applied to the field. portion of the property had been recently graded where the sludge; was applied and had allowed the sludge to flow into a nearby tributary. The investigator' took; a sample of the sludge for analysisand photographs of the disposal area; Later, the investigator met with 2r-. Bowman, the owner, and inspected all of the properties being used for sludge disposal. Mr. Bowman told the investigator that sludge, in the area where the sample was collected, was placed there on Monday, July 2, 1984 by the City of Hickory. North Carolina Department of Natural 1 James Hunt, ., Governor c r Resources &Community Development James . Summers, ,Secretary DIVISION vIRONTmE 'TAIL MANAG ,NTT June 25, 1984 CERTIFIED TW IT RETURN RECEIPT REqjEf D Mr. Jake A. Siginon Route 1., Box 488 Newton, N. C. IS 5 Subject: Warning Letter nperi itted Land Application of Sludge City of is ory Catawba County, N. C. Dear Mr. Si mon It has been brought t to the attention of this €1lliee that you have been transporting sludge from the City of Hickory's wastewater treatment facilities and land applying the sludge. You should be aware that this constitutes trans- porting and disposal of wastewater treatment sludge. Since neither you or the City has a permit for the land application of Hickory's sludge., you are in violation of N. C. General Statute 14 15 "1( It :is requested that you immediately cease the transport and disposal of the sludge from the City of Hickory until such time a the City has received the necessary land application permit. Please be advised, that continued violations of the aforementioned Statute are subject to possible enforcement action including the assessment of civil penalties of up to $10,000 per day per violation. If you should have any questions regarding this please do not hesitate to contact Mr. Mike e 'Parker, Ms. Tana Fryer or ' se at (70 61699. Srocs �1 D. Rex Gleason, Pe E. Water Quality' Regional Engineer cc: Catawba County Health Department Mr. Jerry Twiggs i. Mike Parker " °Ili' : sj d mooresvilleRegbnaloffice P. 0, 0, 919 North Halm Sheaf, rhoore ville, N.C. 2 11 -0950 "Telephone 70416 i f CERTIFIED IL RETURN RpCEIPT REQUEST r. Jerry Twiggs Public Utilities Director City of Hickory Post Office Box 398 Hickory, N. C. 28603 Subject; Warning Setter Unpermitted Sand Application of Sludge City of Hickory Catawba County, I . C. Dear Mr. i ga On June- , 1984, and dune 11, 1984, this Office received complaints concerning land application of Hickory's wastewater treatment plant sludge on two sites: the Hart property and the Wilfong property. Investigations can dune 8, 1984, and Tune 11 1984, revealed that sludge had been land applied on the Wilfeng property, located at the corner of State Road 2019 (Rocky Ford Road) and State Road 2020 (Wilfong Road) . You were notified and advised that any land application of sludge -ithout a permit is illegal and should be teased immediately. This Office received an additional complaint on June 20, 1984, concerning disposal of sludge on the property owned byDr. Hart located art State load 2029 (Rog Hill Road) . The complaint was investigated on dune 21, 1984. ala investigation revealed that sludge had been disposed of can the Hart property. You have been alerted that the disposal of wastewater treatment plant sludge by land application requires a permit from the Division of Environmental management (letter to you dated April '1 , . g . You have also been advised that land application of wastewater treatment plant sludge without a permit from the Division of Environmental Management is a violation of N. C. General Statute 1 1 1( (letter to you dated Jul; 5, 1983). You are also reminded that violations of this nature are subject to civil penalties of up to $10,000 per day per violation. snauiu cease;LmmeuiaLeiy. inis viii-ce wtii enforcement gent action if any future violation you are; al and 3 recommend iapoaal of r W Jerry !i ,7iggs Page Two June 251, 1984 January 23, -11984. You were notified that additional information was necessary in a letter dated February 3, 1984, from Mr. H. Dale Crisp. These items lien"'rd not yet been answered satisfactorily. Numerous telephone calls from this Office to you and, front the Raleigh Office to you have taken glace since: the February d 1984 letter to you, but the necessary information has, not yet been received. If you still have questions in regards to the permit application, please s n ant either Mr. Thurman Horne of t1lis Office at 704) 663-1699 or Mr. Arthur Hagstrom of the Raleigh Office Again, vati are reminded that until. such time as you apple for and receive a permit for the land application ation of sludge, all such lewd application of sludge is illegal and should be teased immediately. if not, appropriate enforcement action will be recommended. If you should have any questions, please contact either Mr. Mike Parker, Ms. Tana Fryer, or me at ( 66 -1 99 Sincerely, Mlj 3iraL sty �1 D. Reap Gleason, P. E. Water Quality Regional Engineer cc: Mr. Dike Parker Mr. Jake Sigmon Catawba un Health Department r Lee Fleming rp Art'Tastrm be or d n Emergency en Response Mr. Harold Scrnn e D :sj K%57DtR7XE7 .. RESOURCES a.: I T Y } F. WATFA QUALITY SECTION POST OFFICE BOX A t t ' i ti 2EIIS REPORT OF Compinint, Investigation PLACE : V �, Hart Property June ` , 1984 - IDtr µ DATE June 21, 1984 ADDRESS SR 2029; Vane, N. C. RIVER BASIN Catawba Mike Parker �y __x- a PERSONS C("yt,�T!^'�d ED S.C1m Spur".king; Jake igaaon; Jerry Twiggs, Dwight Wl.iMxo , Gene Haynes: REASON FOR VISIT To investigate complaint of disposal of sludge COPIES TO: Mr. Tom Spurling 4 11 REPORT: On June 5, :-1984 this Office rt:,a,eived ar complaint tk ros,rgb Mr. Tom Spurling of the:: Catawba County Health Department regarding the disposal of sludge dge on Dr. Har 's, property allegedly gedl by the City of Newton's trucks. The complainant complained ed of odor and of u.il arge on the road. Mr. Dwight Wilson with the City of Newton was contacted by telephone by . i, r . Lm,.s'.'ry. Coble of t.i'a_i.s Office concerning this matter. Mr. a Wilson 7.Ci1or€red Mr. Coble that the uli7v`ge is being hauled from the City of ` AL"ry' ".ed,`st k:catk treatment facilities. Mr. Jerry Twiggs with the City of Hickory was :also contacted. He was reminded that land application without as permit is illegal and should be cHe=anaak immediately. On June 8, 1984, MrMike Parker of this fic investigated. At that time, no evidence of sludge disposal was found, n ,::une 20, 1984, this Officer received an additional complaint concerning the lac c a ,vase Dr. Hart' property. r:t��. �°'e complainant ak �rkwapi�.t.��atk,a�ra �.��. t�c�c.,� p p��aact that pay 1<:� observed two .toads of sludge being hauled the previous day, June 19, 1984. He complained of the land application on of sludge and of the odor. He gave more specific directions to the site. On June 1, 1984, Mr... Mike Parker investigated the second complaint and discovered that sludge had indeed been disposal of on the Hart property. Mr. 'iv i g g s could not be contacted, but Mr. Gene Haynes with the City of Hickory 9- was notified. He said he would stop the land application of sludge Witnout a permit. In a warning letter dated June 25, 1984, Mr. jerry Iviggs was reminded that the land application of sludge without a permit is illegal and should be ceased immediately Mr. Twiggs was also informed that this Office would have no alternative than to recommend enforcement action should future violations occur. During an investigation of .and application of sludge at a different Ate, it was determined that trucks belonging to Sigmon Brothers Dairy were responsible for the transport and land application of the sludge and not the City of Newton's trucks. Mr. Jake Sigmon has been notified in a warning lettur dated June 25, 1984, that land application of sludge is illegal and that he should immediately cease the transport and disposal of sludge until such time as the City of Hickory has received the necessary land application permit. al w ","WERT DIVISION OF C4Y1R0ME3TAL WAGEMEIT April 19. 1982 Mr. Jerry Twiggs Director of Public Uties City of Hickory Post Office Sax 193 Uickary, North Carolina 2-86,03 Subject: Land Application of Sludge MY of Hickory Catawba County, North Carolina War 4r. Twiggs: It has Wen Wuqhi to the attention of the staff of this Office tnat the City of hickory is posing was ter treat;'ient plant sludge by land a0lication with a Per fraq the IDon of Environmental Management. In nwAss M nhfi4n A Dn". 4+ +Am r4*" -411 4*-- w- 44iv --, an- artu afjcnnjcopies aiong wine an engineering report c* tainio" suffftiUt data tO Insure tnet disposal of the sludge is not harmful to thle environment. This report ShoUld Contain sludge analysis, soil characteristics, Watkn maps of the disposal area, method of disposal, location of monitoring wells, water table depths, limiting characteristics, application rates aid disposal procedures. Upon receipt of the completed applications and the engineering report, this Office will Veqln to process your rentiest ft,)r, ,gee it If you have any questions or require additional information, please contact Larry Cable or me. %IGINAL SICNEP, RVY S. W 040ason, P. E. WAtIP Quality W#Wvisor tet Wamba County Ault sopmrtmen Alexander County Health Separtment i1se city or nicXUZY P. 0. BOX 398„ Hickory, NC 28601 Subject: Sludge Treatment By Chlorine i t i A Project e Dear Mr. Wells. As you may, be aware, the use of chlorIne in the Cityof Hickory'waste- water treatment works as a sterilant, oxihnt, or l conditioner i one tends to pibdnce chemical reactions which resul.t in the vDrmation of a number of chlorinated hydrocarbons. The National~ Wildlife Federation :pasaas urged the Environmental Protection new (EPA) In a nags release (cope attached) dated February 14, 1979, to 'restrict the use chlOtine for waste sludge stabilization. EPA is conducting studies an the uses opyhlorinerelative to aste sludge treatment, and has prepared draft policy; concerning nt and future 'projects involving such at .. copy the aft li i attached. ched. i draft poll noted tha processethe processes have potentialnn t l impacts through release of unqaantifind chlorinated organics. While no recorgnendation was made to exclude chlorine sledge oxidation, it was suggestedthat alternative proc consr feed for sludge treatment because of the �'votential risk. If the chlorine oxidation process is an existing thcl of waste sludge atmxt, the following procedures were s e t-ecl l l the draft of ic. ,- 1. Recycle the filtrate, centrate, or decant nt to the head of a treatment plant, or treat the liquid phase with (.,-a n adsorption (the Q of the liquid d phase should also ;be neutralized to acceptable levels). µ As the preferred method, dispose of t ho solids through use of secured landfills or land llu t hydrogeologically isolated sites. Treat leachates Pram secured landfills with carbon adsorption as required to tlna " n surface or :.tun titers. mail spreading leacontamination t used disposal, incorporate the solids In the soils to avoid their consumption by animals. .far Eqwo0Mx%P'"Wn4 qirmaWe Acs`em Employer Protection Agency will be taking a closer look at the potential 'for the qenera- tion of chlorinated hydrocarbons and at the efftctiveness of Controls which are currently being applied to this type sludge tiandling facility. If I can be of assistance or can provide yoti with additional information, please advise. Sineerely yours, Original Slr�,ned ft A. E WRORTE A. F., Mcftorie Director Attachments cc, Environmental Protection Agency Harwood Beebe Company Catawba County Health Department Richard Peace Mr. L. P. Benton, Jr. Rr. Coy M. Batten Mr. A. C. Turnage,Jr. Mr. W. S. Hoffman 1 X w•' x