Loading...
HomeMy WebLinkAbout20070812 Ver 1_13 Feb 2005 Transmission Line and Project Facility Habitat Assessment, Draft Report (2)_20080502Yadkin Project FERC No. 2197 TRANSMISSION LINE AND PROJECT FACILITY HABITAT ASSESSMENT DRAFT STUD YREPORT FEBRUARY 2005 YADKIN PROJECT FERC No. 2197 TRANSMISSION LINE AND PROJECT FACILITY HABITAT ASSESSMENT DRAFT STUDYREPORT Prepared for ALCOA POWER GENERATING INC. Yadkin Division 293 NC 740 Highway Badin, NC 28009-0576 Prepared by NORMANDEAU ASSOCIATES, INC. 25 Nashua Road Bedford, NH 03110 R-19556.002 February 2005 Transmission Lines Draft Table of Contents Page SUMMARY ........................................................................................................................................ iv 1.0 INTRODUCTION ....................................................................................................................1 2.0 BACKGROUND ......................................................................................................................1 3.0 STUDY AREA ..........................................................................................................................3 4.0 STUDY PURPOSE AND OBJECTIVES ..............................................................................3 5.0 STUDY METHOD ...................................................................................................................3 6.0 SUMMARY OF EXISTING INFORMATION .....................................................................9 6.1 DAM FACILITIES ...............................................................................................................9 6.2 TRANSMISSION LINE CORRIDORS .....................................................................................9 7.0 EXISTING CONDITIONS .....................................................................................................9 7.1 DAM FACILITIES ...............................................................................................................9 7.2 TRANSMISSION LINE CORRIDORS ...................................................................................10 8.0 EFFECTS OF PROJECT OPERATIONS ON HABITAT ................................................19 9.0 CONCLUSIONS ....................................................................................................................21 10.0 REFERENCES CITED .........................................................................................................21 APPENDIX A: List of rare threatened and endangered species for Yadkin Project search Transmission Line Draft 2/17/05 11 Transmission Lines Draft List of Figures Page Figure 1. Locus of Yadkin Project ............................................................................... .........................2 Figure 2. Cover type map of powerlines and the adjacent reservoirs ......................... ......................... 4 Figure 3. High Rock Reservoir dam facility ............................................................... ......................... 5 Figure 4. Tuckertown Reservoir dam facility ............................................................. ......................... 6 Figure 5. Narrows Reservoir dam facility ................................................................... ......................... 7 Figure 6. Falls Reservoir dam facility ......................................................................... ......................... 8 List of Tables Page Table 1. List of plant species observed on Falls and Narrows powerlines during 2004 field surveys. Species names in bold type indicate RTE species ...............................................11 Table 2. Wildlife species or their sign observed in the 2004 Narrows and Falls transmission line surveys ....................................................................................................18 Transmission Line Draft 2/17/05 in Transmission Lines Draft SUMMARY The Transmission Line and Project Facility Habitat Assessment Draft Study Report presents the results of a survey of vegetation cover types and wildlife habitat quality of Yadkin Project lands, including two transmission line sections. The study was conducted by Normandeau Associates, Inc. (NAI) as part of the FERC relicensing process for the Yadkin Project. The study was conducted in accordance with the Final Study Plan that was developed by Yadkin in consultation with the Wetlands, Wildlife and Botanical Issue Advisory Group (IAG). Specific objectives identified in the Final Study Plan included: ¦ Identify vegetation cover types and wildlife habitat types in the vicinity of Project transmission lines, dams and powerhouses. ¦ Evaluate effects of transmission line and facility operation and maintenance on vegetation cover and wildlife habitat. ¦ Identify opportunities for wildlife habitat enhancements on Yadkin Project lands. The Study Area for this assessment includes the Falls and Narrows transmission corridors (approximately 4.4 miles) and lands in the vicinity of the four dams and powerhouses including parking lots and access roads. A preliminary delineation of vegetation cover types was made using aerial photographs taken July 28, 2003 and was verified in the field during three reconnaissance-level surveys conducted between April and October 2004. During the field surveys NAI biologists reviewed vegetation cover types and wildlife habitat quality and also inventoried representative areas as to species, structure and composition. All of the dam-related facilities and both transmission line corridors were visited one or more times during the field surveys. An evaluation was completed of wildlife habitat quality and use by birds, mammals, reptiles and amphibians within representative areas. Results of the surveys showed that the vegetation found on Project lands around the dams and powerhouses and in the transmission line corridors is managed by APGI through a combination of logging to remove tree fall risk, and mowing and herbicides to maintain visibility, appearance and facility access. As a result, the predominant vegetative cover type found in these areas is a mixture of grasses and shrubs. Around the dams and powerhouses, most lands are open areas used for parking and vehicle access. These areas offer relatively low quality habitat for wildlife. Common vertebrate wildlife using these areas include small mammals and small birds, including migratory songbirds. Species likely to be encountered include Gray Squirrel, moles, shrews, lizards, snakes, Carolina Chickadee, Blue Jay, and Cardinal. The Falls and Narrows transmission line corridors are predominantly rolling upland. Scattered rock outcrops and boulders are evident within the transmission line corridors. The vegetation found within the cleared portion of the corridors is generally a mix of herbaceous and shrub species. Grasses, sedges, and regenerating tree species are all common. For the most part, species which are adapted to direct sunlight and generally droughty conditions are dominant, while on either side of the transmission line corridors, where trees provide some shading, there is a narrow band in which species that prefer partial shade and more moisture grow. Several small, mostly intermittent streams drain from the transmission line corridors to the Narrows, Falls or Tillery reservoirs, and both the Transmission Line Draft 2/17/05 1V Transmission Lines Draft Falls and Narrows transmission line corridors cross narrow coves of their respective reservoirs which support a narrow fringe of scrub-shrub habitat. In addition, the Falls transmission line crosses two narrow wetland areas, a wet meadow, in which water is at or near the surface but rarely ponds, and an emergent marsh, in which the water ponds for a sufficient time to support aquatic species. The latter "ephemeral pool" is important habitat to many amphibian species such as salamanders and frogs which use them for breeding. The Falls and Narrows transmission line corridors add to the diversity of habitat within the area that otherwise is characterized by large blocks of woodland, sections of which are under silvicultural management. The mix of herbaceous and shrub habitat abutting timber stands provide structure (vertical and horizontal complexity), an important habitat element for wildlife usage. Because of this habitat diversity, many vertebrate species use the transmission line corridor environment including neotropical migratory birds, resident songbirds and game birds, birds of prey, large and small mammals, reptiles and amphibians. Reptiles find particular value in the "solar window" provided by forest openings of the kind maintained in transmission line corridors. Vegetation within the transmission line corridors and Project Lands associated with the dam facilities are maintained by APGI at specific height limits, depending on location. APGI's maintenance program utilizes herbicide treatments as the major method of control, with mowing or brush cutting used where appropriate. Herbicides applications are not made within 100 feet of the reservoirs. Along the transmission lines, the treatment objectives are to maintain vegetation height while minimizing adverse impacts on sensitive habitats and desirable species such as cedar and dogwood, which will not interfere with the line. By means of spot applications, spray drift to non-target species and soil is kept to a minimum. In sensitive areas such as wetlands, the herbicide Habitat® is used, which is approved for use in wetlands when there is no ponded water. Herbicides are generally applied with either backpack sprayers or from a truck by means of a 600-foot hose. A drift control agent is added to the mix when there is wind and applications are discontinued when wind speed exceeds approximately 10 mph. Herbicides are not applied during rainfall. Historically, the Falls and Narrows transmission line corridors have been maintained to a cleared width of approximately 100-150 feet. In a recent initiative to improve safety and enhance transmission line reliability, APGI recently cleared the Falls transmission line to an average width of 200 feet. This clearing activity resulted in some short-term impacts to vegetation. In the long-term, the widening of the transmission line corridor can be expected to add additional mixed grass and shrub habitat for wildlife use. A similar widening of the Narrows transmission line is scheduled to occur in 2005. Transmission Line Draft 2/17/05 v Transmission Lines Draft 1.0 INTRODUCTION Alcoa Power Generating Inc. (APGI) is applying to the Federal Energy Regulatory Commission for a new license for the Yadkin Hydroelectric Project. The Project consists of four reservoirs (High Rock, Tuckertown, Narrows, and Falls, Figure 1), dams, and powerhouses located on a 38-mile stretch of the Yadkin River in central North Carolina. The Project generates electricity to support the power needs of Alcoa's Badin Works and its other aluminum operations, or is sold on the open market. Because the FERC project boundary generally follows the normal full pool elevation of the reservoirs, Project Lands at the Yadkin Project are generally limited to small areas of land around the dams, powerhouses and two transmission corridors. The two transmission corridors, Narrows and Falls, are Project-dedicated lines that remain within the Yadkin Project Boundary.' The two transmission lines that will remain part of the hydroelectric project include the approximately 2.7- mile Falls, and 1.7-mile Narrows transmission line corridors. The Narrows Line has a four-circuit 13.2 kV transmission line extending from Narrows Dam to the Badin Substation and the Falls Line has a single-circuit 100 kV transmission line extending from Falls Dam to the Badin Substation. The purpose of this study was to evaluate wildlife habitat conditions on Yadkin Project lands, including the areas around the dams and powerhouses and along the two transmission line corridors, and to assess potential impacts on habitat from the maintenance and operation of these facilities. In pursuing this objective, this study considers where necessary the broader area adjoining the Project Lands, much of it Yadkin property, the use or attributes of which may affect or be affected by activities undertaken within or upon the Project Lands. 2.0 BACKGROUND As part of the relicensing process, APGI prepared and distributed, in September 2002, an Initial Consultation Document (ICD), which provides a general overview of the Project. Agencies, municipalities, non-governmental organizations and members of the public were given an opportunity to review the ICD and identify information and studies that were needed to address relicensing issues. To further assist in the identification of issues and study needs, APGI formed Issue Advisory Groups (IAG) to advise APGI on resource issues throughout the relicensing process. Through meetings, reviews and comments, the IAGs assisted in developing the Study Plans for the various resource issues, and will further review and comment on the findings resulting from the implementation of the study plans. The Transmission Line and Project Facility Habitat assessment was guided by the Wetlands, Wildlife and Botanical JAG which was interested in the effects of transmission lines and dam related facilities on vegetation cover and wildlife habitat under existing conditions, assessing how these resources could be affected by existing Project operations including the ongoing maintenance required for Project facilities. The study also examines any changes that may occur as a result of altered Project operations, if proposed. This report presents the findings of this investigation, following implementation of the Final Study Plan, dated June 2003. ' By order dated July 15, 2003 FERC approved a request by Yadkin to remove several other high voltage transmission lines from within the FERC boundary as they had become part of the interstate transmission system. Transmission Line Draft 2/17/05 Transmission Lines Draft Figure 1. Locus of Yadkin Project. Transmission Line Draft 2/17/05 2 Transmission Lines Draft 3.0 STUDY AREA The Study Area for this assessment includes the Falls and Narrows transmission corridors and Project Lands within the vicinity of the four dams and powerhouses (Figures 2-6). The combined length of the two transmission corridors is approximately 4.4 miles. The review included the maintained corridor plus an additional area extending 50 feet beyond on either side. Other Project Lands under the present review included the cleared land and facilities in the immediate area of the four dams, including parking lots and access roads. 4.0 STUDY PURPOSE AND OBJECTIVES On March 13, and April 25, 2003 the Wetlands, Wildlife and Botanical IAG met and discussed objectives for the transmission line and project facility habitat study. Over the course of those discussions the following objectives were identified for the Transmission Line and Project Facility study. ¦ Identify vegetation cover types and wildlife habitat types in the vicinity of transmission lines, dams and powerhouses. Evaluate effects of transmission line and facility operation and maintenance on vegetation cover and wildlife habitat. ¦ Identify opportunities for wildlife habitat enhancement on Yadkin Project Lands. 5.0 STUDY METHOD A review was completed of existing information available for the two transmission lines and Project Lands associated with the four dams, which included previous material generated during the re- licensing process (Yadkin Inc, 1999; Alcoa Power Generating Inc, 2002) and interviews with key personnel knowledgeable about the vegetation management program (Hunsucker 2004; Olson 2004, Wright 2004). A preliminary delineation of cover types, using stereo-paired aerial photographs taken July 28, 2003, was completed and field-verified during three reconnaissance-level surveys conducted between April and October 2004. Three NAI senior biologists participated, and for several days respectively during each season, they were joined by a local botanist, Peter Diamond, from the North Carolina Zoological Park in Asheboro. Additional field surveys, specifically for reptiles and amphibians, were conducted during June through August by Mark Lewis, also of the North Carolina Zoological Park. Diamond and Lewis conferred with NAI at other times as well, both in print and in person. The field surveys reviewed questionable areas identified in the aerial photo review and also inventoried representative areas as to species, structure and composition. All dam-related facilities and both transmission line corridors were visited one or more times during the field surveys. An evaluation was completed of wildlife habitat quality and use by birds, mammals, reptiles and amphibians within representative areas. Surveys for rare, threatened and endangered (RTE) species on the transmission line corridors were conducted during the ground-truthing work using the Final RTE list developed by the IAG for RTE Transmission Line Draft 2/17/05 Transmission Lines Draft i i i ° =aoF ?a?H ? •Palrimervatle ! ll 9i ; Figure 2. Cover type map of powerlines and the adjacent reservoirs. Transmission Line Draft 2/17/05 4 Transmission Lines Draft HIGH ROCK RESERVOIR Normal Full Reservoir Elevation 623.9 ft 1 1 1 1 1 ? Survey of 50' swath outside of development HIGH ROCK DAM HIGH ROCK POWERHOUSE 1 1 Survey of 50' swath loutside of development 1 TUCKERTOWN RESERVOIR Normal Full Reservoir Elevation 564.7 ft \ ----- Full Pond Field Survey Areas Around High Rock FERC Project Boundary Dam and Powerhouse Roads Fence Yadkin Project - - - - 50' Perimeter H-H+ Railroad Tracks ® Land impacted by 0 50 100 150 250 a Dam Facilities ennngww? Figure 3. High Rock Reservoir dam facility. Transmission Line Draft 2/17/05 5 Transmission Lines Draft 1 \ Survey of 50'smth outside of development TUCKERTOWN RESERVOIR Normal Full Reservoir Elevation 564.7 ft This area inspected visually from footpath TUCKERTOWN TUCKERTOWN POWERHOUSE DAM . / j NARROWS RESERVOIR Normal Full Reservoir Elevation 509.8 ft Survey of 50'swath beyond dam sWCtures ----- Full Pond Field Survey Areas Around Tuckertown FERC Project Boundary Dam and Powerhouse Roads Fence Yadkin Project }}{-?? Railroad Tracks - - - - 50' Perimeter a 75 150 225 375 H ® Land Impacted by Dam Facilities Figure 4. Tuckertown Reservoir dam facility. Transmission Line Draft 2/17/05 6 Transmission Lines Draft NARROWS RESERVOIR Normal Full Reservoir Elevation 509.8 it Visual inspection from East end of d NARROWS DAM Survey of 50'swath \ outside of development NARROWS POWERHOUSE / Survey of bo horelines b / t NARROWS TRANSMISSION \ LINE CORRIDOR \ l o \ ll I FALLS RESERVOI rrnal Full Reservoir Elevgtio 332.8 ft / I I (/ 1 \ / I / I O 1 j O I - l O ---- Full Pond Field Survey Areas Around Narrows FERC Project Boundary Dam and Powerhouse Roads Yadkin Project --?-- Fence - - - - 50' Perimeter ® Land Impacted by 0 100 200 400e Dam Facilities Figure 5. Narrows Reservoir dam facility. Transmission Line Draft 2/17/05 7 Transmission Lines Draft FALLS DAM ??- FALLS RESERVOIR c` Normal Full Reservoir Elevation 332.8 ft Survey of both shorelines by boat FALLS POWERHOUSE \ r J FALLS TRANSMISSION LINE CORRIDOR / j TILLERY ` RESERVOIR ?J , i ----- Full Pond Field Survey Areas Around Falls Dam FERC Project Boundary and Powerhouse Roads -x- Fence Yadkin Project ---- 50' Perimeter ® Land Impacted by o W 100 ieo 250 n Dam Facilities ITTTTSE? Figure 6. Falls Reservoir dam facility. Transmission Line Draft 2/17/05 8 Transmission Lines Draft Species (Normandeau 2004). The list is provided in Appendix A. Scheduling of the field surveys throughout the growing season ensured that all plant species on the search list could be encountered, if present, in a reasonably detectable and identifiable condition during at least one life-history stage. Observations of listed animal species also benefited from the same dispersed effort, as each species' behavior changed from season to season. The relatively large number of listed plant species, many with specialized habitat needs and markedly seasonal manifestations, required the continued services of the local botanist to help refine the survey team's search patterns. 6.0 SUMMARY OF EXISTING INFORMATION 6.1 DAM FACILITIES For the purpose of this review the Project Lands include the associated powerhouses, access roads, and parking lots associated with the four dams. The fenced-in area associated with each dam facility is approximately 1-2 acres in size. Access roads distributed along the length of both transmission line corridors are gated to control public access. 6.2 TRANSMISSION LINE CORRIDORS The length of the transmission line corridor from the Badin Works is approximately 2.7 miles to the Falls Dam and 1.7 miles to the Narrows Dam. The historic width of the cleared corridor for both transmission lines ranged from 100 to 125 feet. The corridor widths are currently being expanded to an approximate total width of 200 feet to minimize the chance of tree falls causing power outages (Olson 2004). Widening along the Falls corridor was 90% complete by Fall 2004. Widening in the Narrows corridor is scheduled to begin in the first quarter of 2005. 7.0 EXISTING CONDITIONS 7.1 DAM FACILITIES Vegetation The Project Lands in the immediate area of the dam facilities include the access road and parking facilities. These areas are fenced to a gated entrance. The vegetation is managed in the immediate area of the parking lots and along the fence lines through a combination of mowing and herbicide to maintain visibility and access. Vegetation is virtually absent within the substations and their fence lines, and shrub and herbaceous vegetation dominate immediately adjacent to the dam buildings and parking areas. Wildlife The cleared lands at the dam facilities are generally open areas used for parking and vehicle access. These areas offer relatively low quality habitat for wildlife. Common vertebrate wildlife using these areas includes small mammals and small birds, including migratory songbirds. Species likely to be encountered include Gray Squirrel, moles, shrews, lizards, snakes, Carolina Chickadee, Blue Jay, and Cardinal. Within the substation limits, vegetation has been eliminated and the area fenced to discourage use by wildlife. Transmission Line Draft 2/17/05 Transmission Lines Draft 7.2 TRANSMISSION LINE CORRIDORS Vegetation The major cover type within the Falls transmission line corridor is shrubby grassland bordered by woodland, with the exception of a segment that crosses a maintained golf course. The Narrows transmission line corridor is also shrubby grassland bordered by woodland except for the westernmost slope adjoining the town of Badin, where the land has been maintained as turf grass. There are two distinct habitats within the transmission line corridors: terrestrial shrub/grassland and freshwater shrub-scrub/emergent wetland. The Falls and Narrows transmission line corridors are predominantly rolling upland, the Falls having generally steeper slopes. Scattered rock outcrops and boulders are evident within the transmission line corridors. The terrestrial shrub/grassland habitat has a moisture gradient as a result of aspect and shade effects from adjacent woodlands. Species adapted to direct sunlight and generally droughty conditions are dominant, while an edge effect is apparent on either side of the transmission line corridors along a narrow band in which can grow species that are adapted to partial shade and more moisture. In addition, north-facing slopes also favor species that prefer moister, cooler habitats. Several small, mostly intermittent streams drain from the transmission line corridors to the Narrows, Falls or Tillery reservoirs, depending on location. The vegetation is generally a mix of herbaceous and shrub species as summarized in Table 1. Common species include the following: bush clovers (Lespedeza spp.), beard grasses (Andnopogon spp.), sedges (Canex spp.), foxtail grasses (Setania spp.), Meadow Fescue (Festuca elation), Small White Aster (Aster vimineus), Ragweed (Ambrosia antemisiifolia), St. Johnsworts (Hypenicum spp.), Lobelia spp., black-eyed susans (Rudbeckia spp.), goldenrods (Solidago spp.) and panic grasses (Panicum spp.) in the herbaceous layer, with regenerating Loblolly Pine (Pinus taeda), Water Oak (Quercus falcata), Shortleaf Pine (Pinus echinata), and Black Locust (Robinia pseudoacacia) in the shrub layer. Vine species are also common, including greenbrier (Smilax spp.) and rose (Rosa spp.). Species diversity is enhanced by relatively shady north-facing slopes and by bordering trees that shade a narrow band on either side of the transmission line corridor. Species that commonly occur along either edge of the transmission line corridor include Black Cherry (Prunus serotina), Poison Ivy (Rhus radicans), Black Oak (Quercus velutina), Red Maple (Acer rubrum), serviceberry (Amelanchier spp.), Sassafras (Sassafras albidum), and Deciduous Holly (Ilex decidua). Both the Falls and Narrows transmission line corridors cross narrow coves of their respective reservoirs. The dominant wetland classes, using the US Fish and Wildlife Service cover type classes (Cowardin et al. 1979), include a narrow scrub-shrub wetland fringe, which borders the Narrows segment, and on the Falls transmission line corridor, two narrow, headwater emergent wetland swales. One headwater wetland is a wet meadow, in which water is at or near the surface but rarely ponds, and the other an emergent marsh, in which the water ponds for a sufficient time to support aquatic species. The emergent marsh may meet the criteria of an ephemeral or seasonal pool, which dries out periodically and therefore is fishless or contains few or occasional fish (Center for Reptile and Amphibian Conservation and Management 2004). Ephemeral pools are an important habitat, as many amphibian species such as Spotted and Marbled Salamanders (Ambystoma spp.) and Upland Chorus Frog (Pseudacris triseriata) are highly dependent on them for breeding. Transmission Line Draft 2/17/05 10 Transmission Lines Draft Table 1. List of plant species observed on Falls and Narrows powerlines during 2004 field surveys. Species names in bold type indicate RTE species. FALLS POWERLINE Cleared Upland Aesculus sylvatica Agalinis purpurea Ailanthus altissima Alisma subcordatum Allium sp. Ambrosia artemisiifolia Ambrosia sp. Ambrosia trifida Amianthemum muscaetoxicum Amorpha schwerinii Andropogon (Schizachyrium) scoparius Andropogon elliottii Andropogon ternarius Andropogon virginicus (A.glomeratus) Antennaria plantaginifolia Antennaria sp. Anthoxanthum odoratum Apocynum cannabinum Aristida sp. Aristida sp. Artemisia vulgaris Asclepias tuberosa Asclepias verticillata Asparagus ofcinalis Asplenium platyneuron Aster cf. vimineus Aster novae-angliae Baccharis halimifolia Bidens aristosa Botrychium sp. Bromus tectorum Campsis radicans Carex digitalis Carex squarrosa Cassia (Chamaecrista) nictitans Cassia obtusifolia Castilleja coccinea Ceonothus americanus Chamaecrista (cf. Cassia) Chasmanthium latifolium Chrysanthemum leucanthemum Cimicifuga racemosa Cirsium vulgare Clitoria mariana Coreopsis verticillatum Cratageus crusgalli Croton glandulosa Crotonopsis sp. Cunila oreganoides Cynodon dactyloides Broom-sedge Clasping-leaf Dogbane NARROWS POWERLINE Cleared Upland Allium sp. Andropogon (Schizachyrium) scoparium Andropogon spp. bluestem grass species Apocynum cannabinum Asclepias verticillata Aster novae-angliae Coreopsis major Short-beard Plume Erianthus brevibarbis Grass Erianthus contortus Eupatorium aromaticum Small Dog-fennel Eupatorium capillifolium Thoroughwort Eupatorium serotinum Gnaphalium sp. Cudweed species Hypericum prolificum Hypericum punctatum Lespedeza spp. Lespedeza cuneata Chinese Bush Clover Lonicera japonica Monarda fistulosa Oxalis violacea Panicum anceps Beaked Panic Grass Pass flora incarnata Phlox cf subulata Pycnanthemum sp. Schizachyrium (cf. Andropogon) scoparium Senecio sp. Smilax rotundifolia Sorghastrum nutans Indian Grass Tridens jlavus Purple-top Vaccinium arboreum Valerianella radiata Edge Ailanthus altissima Cercis canadensis Ligustrum sinense Pinus virginiana Scrub Pine Prunus serotina Black Cherry Viburnum prunifolium Woods Asplenium platyneuron Carya glabra Pignut Hickory Lonicera x Bella Piptochaetium (cf. Stipa) Polypodium virginianum Quercus alba White Oak Quercus rubra Northern Red Oak Transmission Line Draft 2/17/05 11 Transmission Lines Draft Table 1. (Continued) FALLS POWERLINE Cyperus ovularis Danthonia spicata Spiky Oat-grass Daucus carota Desmodium sp. (not orbiculata) Dichanthelium lanuginosum Dichanthelium sp. Duchesnea indica Eragrostis hirsuta Erechtites hieracifolia Erianthus brevibarbis Bent-awn Plume Erianthus contortus Grass Erigeron philadelphicus Daisy Fleabane Erigeron spp. species Eupatorium aromaticum Small Dog-fennel Eupatorium capillifolium Thoroughwort Eupatorium hyssopifolium Eupatorium rotundifolium Eupatorium rugosum Euphorbia sp. Festuca elation Meadow Fescue Festuca myuros Galactia volubilis Galium sp. Gelsemium sempervirens Geranium cf. virginianum Gnaphalium obtusifolium Gnaphalium purpureum Helianthus atrorubens Helianthus laetiflorus Hieracium spp. Hawkweed species Houstonia caerulea Houstonia purpurea Hypericum gentianoides Hypericum hyperzcoides Hypericum mutilum Hypericum prolificum Hypericum punctatum St. Johnswort Hypericum spp. species Hypericum stragalum Hystrix patula (Elymus hystrix) Ilex laevigata flex opaca Kuhnia eupatorioides Lactuca sp. Lathyrus sp. Chinese Bush Lespedeza cuneata Clover Lespedeza procumbens Lespedeza virginica Leucanthemum vulgare Liquidambar styraciflua Lobelia cf spicata Lobelia inflata Lobelia puberula NARROWS POWERLINE Quercus stellata Rhus aromatica Stipa avenacea Symphoricarpos orbiculatus Vaccinium arboreum Needle Grass Farkleberry Transmission Line Draft 2/17/05 12 Transmission Lines Draft Table 1. (Continued) FALLS POWERLINE Lonicera japonica Lonicera x Bella Heller's Birdsfoot Lotus helleri Trefoil Mecardonia acuminata Melia azedarach Melinis mutica Microstegium vimineum Miscanthus sinensis Monarda fistulosa Nandina domestica Oenothera fruticosa Oxalis sp. Violet Wood Oxalis violacea Sorrel Panicum anceps Panicum clandestinum Panicum depauperatum Panicum distans Panicum sp. Paspalum boscianum Paspalum cf. laeve Paspalum sp Pass flora incarnata Phlox sp. Phyllanthus sp. Phytolacca americana Pinus echinata Pinus taeda Pinus virginiana Piptochaetium (cf. Stipa) Plantago aristata Plantago virginica Polygala curtisii Polygala nuttallii Prunella vulgaris Pteridium aquilinum Pueraria lobata (P. montana) Pycnanthemum tenuifolium Pyrrhopappus carolianus Quercus falcata Rhynchosia tomentosa Rhyncospora sp. Robinia hispida Rosa carolina Rubus argutus Rudbeckia fulgida Orange Rudbeckia hirta Coneflower Ruellia caroliniana Pursh's Wild Ruellia purshiana Petunia Rumex sp. Salvia lyrata Schizachyrium (cf.Andropogon in part) Schrankia microphylla Scirpus cyperinus Scleria sp. Senecio smallii Transmission Line Draft 2/17/05 13 Transmission Lines Draft Table 1. (Continued) FALLS POWERLINE Senecio sp. Bristle Grass Setaria spp. species Sisyrinchium sp. Smilax hispida Solanum carolinense Solidago canadensis Canada Goldenrod Solidago erecta Solidago nemoralis Sorghastrum eliottii Sorghastrum nutans Sorghum halepense Johnson Grass Staphylea trifolia Stipa (Piptochaetium) avenacea Stylosanthes bijlora Styrax americana Symphoricarpos orbiculatus Tephrosia hispidula Tragia urticifolia Trichostema dichotoma Blue-curls Tridens jlavus Purple-top Tripsacum dactyloides Ulm us alata Valerianella sp. Verbascum sp. Verbena brasiliensis Yellow Verbesina occidentalis Crownbeard Verbesina virginica Wetland 1 Acer rubrum Perennial Bent- Agrostis perennans grass Arthraxon hispidus Hairy Joint-grass Aster puniceus Bidens aristosa Boehmeria cylindrica Carex baileyi Carex tribuloides Cyperus strigosus Dichanthelium sp. 1 Witch Grass Dichanthelium sp. 2 species Festuca elatior Glyceria sp. Helenium autumnale Juncus coriaceus Juncus effusus Smooth Rush Lespedeza cuneata Liquidambar styracijlua Lobelia cardinalis Lobelia puberula Lonicera japonica Microstegium vimineum Mimulus ringens Oxalis violacea Parthenocissus quinquefolia Pinus taeda Transmission Line Draft 2/17/05 14 Transmission Lines Draft Table 1. (Continued) FALLS POWERLINE American Platanus occidentalis Sycamore Polygonum sagittatum Prunus serotina Rhyncospora sp. Scirpus sp. Scirpus polyphyllus Leafy Bulrush Typha latifolia Ulmus rubra Verbesina occidentalis Wetland 2 (vernal pool/headwater stream) Alisma subcordatum Carex baileyi Carex lupulina Hop Sedge Witch Grass Dichanthelium sp. 2 species Diodia virginiana Eleocharis sp. Hypericum mutilum Juncus sp. Leersia oryzoides Rice Cutgrass Microstegium vimineum Panic Grass Panicum large species Polygonum sp. Short-bristlle Rhyncospora corniculata Beakrush Scirpus sp. Scirpus cypermus Woolgrass Smilax glauca Edge of clearing Acer rubrum Ailanthus altissima Amelanchier sp. Asplenium platyneuron Cercis canadensis Redbud Clitoria mariana Coreopsis major Diospyros virginiana Persimmon Gaylussacia frondosa Dangleberry Hypericum stans Ilex decidua Juniperus virginiana Eastern Red Cedar Liquidambar styracijlua Lonicera japonica Magnolia grand flora Melia azedarach Pinus echinata Prunus serotina Black Cherry Quercus phellos Quercus velutina Black Oak Robinia cf pseudoacacia Sassafras albidum Toxicodendron radicans Viburnum prunifolium Vitis rotundifolia Woodsia obtusa Cliff Brake Transmission Line Draft 2/17/05 15 Transmission Lines Draft Table 1. (Continued) FALLS POWERLINE Forest Acer rubrum Acer saccharum leucoderme Aesculus sylvatica Painted Buckeye Alnus serrulata Amelanchier arborea Botrychium dissectum Carya glabra Pignut Hickory Carya ovata Carya tomentosa Celtis occidentalis Celtis tenuifolia Chrysogonum virginianum Clematis cf. viorna Flowering Cornus jlorida Dogwood Crataegus cf crusgalli Fraxinus americana Houstonia purpurea Hypericum fruticosum flex laevigata flex decidua flex opaca Juglans nigra Ligustrum japonicum Liquidambar styracijlua Sweet Gum Liriodendron tulipifera Microstegium vimineum Morus rubra Nyssa sylvatica Black Gum Oxalis venosa Oxydendrum arboreum Panicum clandestinum Pinus echinata Shortleaf Pine Pinus taeda Loblolly Pine Pinus virginiana Scrub Pine Platanus occidentalis Polypodium virginianum Polystichum acrostichoides Prunus serotina Quercus alba White Oak Quercus coccinea Quercus falcata Southern Red Oak Quercus marilandica Quercus nigra Quercus prinus (Q. montana) Chestnut Oak Quercus rubra Quercus stellata Post Oak Quercus velutina Styrax grandifolia Thalictrum thalictroides Ulm us alata Vaccinium arboreum Viburnum rufidulum Viburnum dentatum Vitis rotundifolia Transmission Line Draft 2/17/05 16 Transmission Lines Draft Common species within the wet meadow wetland include sedges (Carex spp.), rushes (Iuncus spp.), mannagrasses (Glyceria spp.), bulrushes (Scirpus spp.), Narrow-leaved Cattail (Typha angustifolia), Upland Bentgrass (Agrostis perennans), and Arrow-leaved Tear-thumb (Polygonum sagittatum). Common species within the emergent marsh, where water ponds periodically, includes Woolgrass (Scirpus cyperinus), Short-bristle Beakrush (Rhynchospora corniculata), Rice Cutgrass (Leersia oryzoides), and Water Plantain (Alisma subcordatum). Red Maple (Acer rubrum), American Sycamore (Platanus occidentalis), Brookside Alder (Alnus serrulata) and Sweet Gum (Liquidambar styracifua) are common shrub-scrub species fringing the marsh edge. There are three readily distinguishable woodland cover types bordering the transmission line corridors: mixed hardwood, mixed hardwood/softwood, and softwood stands. Typical hardwood tree species include White Oak (Quercus alba), Scarlet Oak (Quercus coccinea), Southern Red Oak (Quercus falcata), Blackjack Oak (Quercus marilandica), Tulip Tree (Liriodendron tulipifera), Sweet Gum, Painted Buckeye (Aesculus sylvatica), Pignut Hickory (Carya glabra), Shagbark Hickory (Carya ovata), and Mockemut Hickory (Carya tomentosa). The softwood stands, which include those under silvicultural management, include Loblolly Pine (Pinus taeda), Shortleaf Pine (Pinus echinata), and Scrub Pine (Pinus virginiana). Invasive species observed within the dam facility lands and transmission line corridors include Chinese Bushclover (Lespedeza cuneata) in relatively open, dry sites and Nepalese Browntop (Microstegium vimineum) in relatively moist ones. The highly disturbed vegetation surrounding dam facilities is dominated by primarily woody or climbing invasives: Tree of Heaven (Ailanthus altissima), Kudzu (Pueraria lobata (P. montana)), Japanese Privet (Ligustrum japonicum), Wisteria spp., and climbing roses (Rosa spp.). Wildlife The Falls and Narrows transmission line corridors add to the diversity of habitat within the immediate area. Both transmission line corridors cross large blocks of woodland, sections of which are under silvicultural management. The mix of herbaceous and shrub habitat provides additional structure (vertical and horizontal complexity), an important habitat element (Conner and Dickson 1997; DeGraaf and Rudis 1986). Many vertebrate species use the transmission line corridor environment as a necessary or preferred part of a larger home range or territory. These include neotropical migratory birds, resident songbirds and game birds, birds of prey, large and small mammals, reptiles and amphibians. Reptiles find particular value in the "solar window" provided by forest openings of the kind maintained in transmission line corridors. The discovery of Six-lined Racerunner lizards (Cnemidophorus sexhneatus) in the Falls transmission line during the survey may indicate that this heat-loving species is taking advantage of basking opportunities not easily available otherwise in the study area. The presence of Timber Rattlesnake (a Special Concern species in NC - see following paragraph) in the Falls transmission line may also owe much to the same opportunity for efficient thermoregulation (Lewis 2004). Table 2 provides a summary of species observed during the transmission line corridor field review. Rare, Threatened and Endangered Species Lotus helleri and Ruellia purshiana, both of which are listed by the state as Significantly Rare, were identified in the Falls transmission line corridor east of Falls Rd. The natural habitat of both species includes open-canopy forest, but wildfire suppression in the Project Area probably affords them less Transmission Line Draft 2/17/05 17 Transmission Lines Draft Table 2. Wildlife species or their sign observed in the 2004 Narrows and Falls transmission line surveys. Common Name Scientific Name Narrows Falls Birds Blue jay Cyanocitta cristata x Bluebird, eastern Sialia sialis x Chickadee, Carolina Poecile carolinensis x Crow, American Corax brachyrhynchos x Cuckoo, yellow-billed Coccyzus americanus x Eagle, bald Haliaeetus leucocephalus x Flycatcher, Acadian Empidonax virescens x Flycatcher, great crested Myiarchus crinitus x Goldfinch, American Carduelis tristis x Hawk, red-tailed Buteo jamaicensis x Hummingbird, ruby-throated Archilochus colubris x Indigo bunting Passerina cyanea x x Kingfisher, belted Ceryle torquata x Tanager, summer Piranga rubra x x Thrush, wood Hylocichla mustelina x Towhee Pipilo erythrophthalmus x x Tufted titmouse Baeolophus bicolor x Turkey Meleagris gallopavo x Vireo, red-eyed Vireo olivaceus x x Vulture, black Coragyps atratus x x Vulture, turkey Cathartes aura x x Warbler, black and white Mniotiha varia x Warbler, magnolia Dendroica magnolia x Warbler, parula Parula Americana x Warbler, pine Dendroica pinus x Warbler, prairie Dendroica discolor x Warbler, prothonotary Protonotaria citrea x Woodpecker, red-bellied Melanerpes carolinus x Wren, Carolina Thyothorus ludovicianus x x Reptiles Fence lizard Sceloporus undulatus x Racerunner, six-lined Cnemidophorus sexlineatus x Skink, ground skink Scincella lateralis x Snake, black racer Coluber constrictor x Snake, eastern hognosed Heterodon platyrhinos x Snake, rat Elaphe obsolete x Snake, ringneck Diadophis punctatus x Snake, timber rattler Crotalus horridus x Snake, worm Carphophis amoenus x Turtle nest Emydidae x x Turtle, box Terrepene Carolina x x Amphibians Egg masses Rana clamitans x Green frog Acris crepitans x Northern cricket frog Hyla crucifer x Spring peeper Hyla versicolor x S. gray treefrog Acris spp. x Cricket frog chorusing x Salamander tadpoles x Toad tadpoles x Toad, American Bufo americanus x Mammals Red Squirrel Tamiasciurus hudsonicus x Rodent Cricetidae x White-tailed deer Odocoileus virginicus x Transmission Line Draft 2/17/05 18 Transmission Lines Draft opportunity than previously for widespread persistence outside the managed clearings characteristic of power transmission systems. Both species are relatively short and weak-stemmed and appear to do best in relatively dry sites, where drought-hardy and taller plants (e.g. Andropogon virginicus, Apocynum cannabinum) may be present but discontinuous in cover. Transmission lines maintain linear openings of varying soil moisture as they cut across a landscape's heights and hollows, exposing the primarily herbaceous community to sun at every angle for differing lengths of time. Conditions favorable to a great diversity of light-demanding herbaceous plant species therefore may be found within these artificial landscape features. Continual human disturbance of such features, however, does not necessarily work to the benefit of some rare species. For instance, neither population of L. helleri and R. purshiana could be found in autumn following their initial discovery in June, due to disturbance during maintenance and widening of the transmission line corridor. However, both species are perennial and will likely resprout next year, and in the long term, may actually benefit from the widening of the transmission line corridor. Timber Rattlesnake (Crotalus horridus) was the only target animal species on the RTE list observed during the 2004 surveys. One gravid female was found in the Falls Dam transmission line corridor, east of Falls Road. This observation confirms anecdotal reports of other rattlesnake sightings in the vicinity of the Falls Dam transmission line as a result of logging operations carried out during the summer and autumn of 2004 (Olson 2004). Rattlesnakes overwinter in a hibernaculum, which typically consists of deep outcrop fissures and boulder piles with a southern aspect. Several instances of this resource occur within or adjacent to the transmission line. Sunny locations near a rattlesnake hibernaculum provide the animals each spring with an important means of elevating body temperature efficiently after their period of winter quiescence. This opportunity for efficient thermoregulation is particularly important for gravid females, whose young develop faster and emerge sooner if provided with an optimal basking environment. The young may also benefit by increased food availability and cover in the open habitats within the right-of-way. A gravid female basking in the transmission line right-of-way probably indicates the presence of a hibernaculum in close proximity, one which the same female is likely to use for the duration of her life, especially with the continued availability of optimal basking locations (Lewis 2004). The larger of the two emergent wetlands that cross the Falls Dam transmission line affords potentially suitable habitat for the two target amphibian species, Mole Salamander (Ambystoma talpoideum) and Four-toed Salamander (Hemidactylium scutatum). Although no salamander egg masses were observed there during 2004, one unidentified salamander larva was observed in October 2004. Confirmation of the presence of these salamander species requires revisitation of the wetland during winter or early spring to detect breeding activity. Set in an upland environment remote from the reservoirs, however, this wetland faces no impact from water-level management changes. 8.0 EFFECTS OF PROJECT OPERATIONS ON HABITAT The transmission line corridors and Project Lands associated with the dam facilities are maintained by APGI primarily to ensure the safe and reliable operation of the Project. Most of these areas have maintained vegetation heights within specific limits, depending on location. As a result of this vegetation management program, wildlife habitat is affected. The program utilizes herbicide Transmission Line Draft 2/17/05 19 Transmission Lines Draft treatments as the major method of control, with mowing or brush cutting used where appropriate. Herbicides are not allowed within 100 feet of the reservoir. The management program within Project Lands includes application of herbicides to maintain bare ground in gravel areas and along fence lines, with a first application in March and a follow-up application in July (Wright 2004). Depending on weather conditions, a third treatment may be applied later in the summer. Herbicides are rotated with a mix of three types of chemicals: contact herbicide (e.g. Roundup® or Krenite®), pre-emergent herbicide (e.g. Oust®), and postemergent herbicide (e.g. Arsenal®). A fourth herbicide, Habitat, is used in the vicinity of the emergent wetlands. Typically, vegetation is managed within the transmission line corridors by the application of herbicides, generally on a 3-year rotation within each corridor (Wright 2004). Additional treatments may be requested by APGI when the need arises. The treatment objectives are to maintain vegetation height while minimizing adverse impacts on sensitive habitats and desirable species such as cedar and dogwood (Juniperus and Cornus spp. respectively), which will not interfere with the line. By means of spot applications, spray drift to non-target species and soil is kept to a minimum. Two mixes are used depending on the vegetation present. For control of hardwood species and shrubs a mix of Roundup® and Arsenal® with a surfactant is applied. The herbicide treatment used for softwoods is Krenite® with a surfactant. In sensitive areas such as wetlands, the herbicide Habitat® is used, which is approved for use in wetlands when there is no ponded water. Herbicides are applied with either backpack sprayers or from a truck by means of a 600-foot hose. A drift control agent is added to the mix when there is wind and applications are discontinued when wind speed exceeds approximately 10 mph. Herbicides are not applied during rainfall. Off-road vehicle use is restricted by gates at most access points on the transmission line corridors, which helps prevent soil erosion and adverse impacts on wildlife. The access roads and parking areas to all dams are paved, which reduces erosion into the reservoirs. APGI is currently in the process of expanding the corridor width on both of the Project transmission lines. This expansion is being done to improve system safety and reliability. Expansion of the transmission lines involves clearing trees and other woody vegetation from approximately 25-50 feet on either side of the existing corridor. This work was completed on the Falls transmission line in 2004 and is scheduled to occur on the Narrows transmission line in 2005. Once this initial transmission line widening is completed, there are no proposed or anticipated changes in Project operation that will affect the transmission line corridors or the maintained lands at the dams. Timber harvesting associated with the current transmission line corridor expansion and nearby lands has had temporary impacts on soils and vegetation due to the operation of heavy equipment. But in the long- term, it is anticipated that the expanded corridors will benefit game species such as White-tailed Deer, Turkey and Bobwhite as well as some non-game species. A widened transmission-line corridor, especially one that has been recently cleared, may reduce or eliminate the crossing movements of some animals (e.g. small birds and mammals) that now may include both forested edges in one territory. However, most of the impacts to many area-sensitive species with a need for large, intact forest have already occurred, since much of the adjoining forest managed for timber production. Before that, forested land was fragmented by agriculture, more intensively than it is now. Area- sensitive species would have undergone the preponderant impacts of forest fragmentation centuries ago, and more recently at the time the original transmission lines were cut out of the newly regenerating forest. Transmission Line Draft 2/17/05 20 Transmission Lines Draft The current vegetation management program used by APGI for maintenance of its transmission lines and project facilities utilizes herbicides appropriate to the control of target species and sensitive environments. Continued facility maintenance using appropriately selected and applied herbicides should have no adverse impacts on the use of these areas by wildlife. However, to ensure that the desired effects are being achieved, the program should be periodically reviewed to ensure that adverse impacts are avoided. Such a review could, for example, reassess application methods and herbicide use near water bodies, and RTE species. In addition, APGI should consider some modifications to its routine maintenance operations to better protect existing habitats and species of importance. For example, logging equipment could be routed around sensitive habitats such as wetlands and rare and endangered species habitats. An upland buffer could be maintained around wetlands in which motorized vehicles are prohibited. Crossings of wetlands could be at established points using best management practices to control sediment and erosion. Such management guidelines for generally enhancing wildlife habitat as well as the known RTE species occurring on the Falls powerline should be developed with consultation with experts in those species. 9.0 CONCLUSIONS The continued operation and maintenance of the Yadkin Project facilities and reservoirs will not impact the habitats associated with the Falls and Narrows transmission line corridor, and maintained lands associated with the four dams. The current expansion of the Falls and Narrows Transmission corridors will result in an increase in shrubby grassland habitat in an area dominated by woodland. The use of herbicides in vegetation management should be periodically reviewed to ensure that impacts to rare and endangered species habitats and wetlands are minimized, and herbicide selection follows the approved label guidelines. 10.0 REFERENCES CITED ALCOA Power Generating Inc.2002., Yadkin Hydroelectric Project, FERC No. 2197-NC, Initial Consultation Document. September. Yadkin Division, Badin, North Carolina. Center for Reptile and Amphibian Conservation and Management. 2004. Available at http://herpcenter.ipfw.edu/ (accessed 24 November 2004). Conner, R.N. and J.G. Dickson. 1997. Relationships between bird communities and forest age, structure, species composition and fragmentation in the west Gulf Coastal Plain. Texas Journal ofScience. 49(3) Supplement: 123-138. Cowardin, L.M., V. Carter, F.C. Golet, and E.T. LaRoe. 1979. Classification of Wetlands and Deepwater Habitats of the United States. US Fish and Wildlife Service, FWS/OBS-79/31. Washington D.C. DeGraaf, R.M. and D.D. Rudis. 1986. New England wildlife habitat, natural history and distribution. USDA Forest Service General Technical Report NE-108. Hunsucker, Ken. 2004. Pers. Comm. ALCOA, Badin, North Carolina. Lewis, M. 2004. RTE Species Survey - Yadkin Project: Reptiles & Amphibians. Undated letter report to Normandeau Associates, Inc. North Carolina Zoological Park, Asheboro, NC. 3 pp. Normandeau. 2004. Rare, Threatened and Endangered (RTE) Species Survey Report. Prepared for Alcoa Power Generating Inc., Badin, NC. Transmission Line Draft 2/17/05 21 Transmission Lines Draft Olson, Marshall. 2004. Pers. Comm. ALCOA, Badin, North Carolina. Wright, Byron. 2004. Pers. Comm. NaturChem, Lexington, South Carolina. Yadkin, Inc. 1999. Application for Commission Authorization to amend Project License, Project No. 2197-038, December. Badin, North Carolina. Transmission Line Draft 2/17/05 22 Transmission Lines Draft APPENDIX A List of Rare, Threatened and Endangered Species for Yadkin Project Search Transmission Line Draft 2/17/05 0 r 0 v 0 N W 0 U1 Appendix Table 1. Final List of Rare, Threatened and Endangered Species for Yadkin Project Search for Terrestrial and Wetland Species only, Including Insects. Birds and Aquatic Wildlife were handled by others. Scientific Name Common Name Source State* Federal* County Habitat Notes Priority Amorpha schwerinii Piedmont indigo-bush 1 SR-T M, R, S, Dd dry forests Aster georgianus Georgia aster 1,2 T Cl M, R, S, Dd open woods and roadsides Aster mirabilis Piedmont aster 1 SR-T S rich slopes and bottomlands Baptisia alba Thick-pod white wild indigo 1 SR-P M, S open woodland clearings Baptisia albescens Thin-pod white wild indigp 1 SR-P M, R, S open woodland clearings Cardamine dissecta Dissected toothwort 1 SR-P M, R, Dd rich woods, bottomlands Carex impressinervia Ravine sedge 1,2 SR-T FSC M wet forests Cirsium carolinianum Carolina thistle 1 SR-P M, R forests, disturbed areas, basic soils Helenium brevifolium Littleleaf sneezeweed 1 E M, R bogs, seeps, riverbanks Helianthus schweinitzii Schweinitz's sunflower 1, 2, 3 E E M, R, S, Dd open woods and roadsides Plantago cordata Heart-leaf plantain 1 E Dd beds of small, slate-bottomed perennial streams Porteranthus stipulatus Indian Physic 1 SR-P M, Dd forests and open woods, mainly over mafic rocks Solidago plumosa Yadkin River goldenrod 1,2 E FSC M, S riverside rocks Solidago radula var. radula Western rough goldenrod 1 SR-P S dry woodlands over mafic rocks Secondary Ambystoma talpoideum Mole salamander 1 SC M, R fish-free semipermanent woodland ponds Anemone berlandierz Southern anemone/thimbleweed 1 SR-P M, R, S thin soils around rock outcrops Carex bushii Bush's sedge 1 SR-P R open wet areas Collinsonia tuberosa Piedmont horsebalm 1 SR-P M rich hardwood forests Corynorhinus rafinesquii Rafinesque's big-eared bat * * * E FSC old buildings, hollow trees, caves, mines, near water Crotalus horridus Timber rattlesnake 1 SC M, S, Dd rocky, upland forests Fothergilla major Large witch-alder 1 SR-T M, S dry ridgetop or bluff forests Gomphus abbreviatus Spine-crowned clubtail 1 SR M rivers Gomphus fraternus Midland clubtail 1 SR S rocky rivers Hemidactylium scutatum Four-toed salamander 1 SC M wetlands in hardwood forests Hexalectris spicata Crested coralroot 1 SR-P S, Dd, D dry or mesic woods on basic soils Quercus austrina Bluff oak 1 SR-P M bluff and bottomland forests Ruellia purshiana Pursh's wild-petunia 1 SR-O M glades, woodlands over mafic/calcareous rocks Spartina pectinata Freshwater cordgrass 1 SR-P M freshwater marshes Stachys sp I Yadkin hedge nettle 1 SR-T M sandy edges of forested floodplains Tradescantia virginiana Virginia spiderwort 1 SR-P M rich woods on circumneutral soils Verbena rzparia Riverbank vervain 1,2 SR-T FSC S habitat not known Transmission lines Echinacea laevigata Smooth coneflower 1, 2, 3 E-SC E M glades and open areas over mafic rocks Gnaphalium hellerz var hellerz Heller's rabbit tobacco 1 SR-P M, R, Dd dry woodlands, openings, glades over mafic rocks Helianthus laevigatus Smooth sunflower 1 SR-P M, R, S shaly open woods and roadsides -9 O y tA' y O O `r V' CD C4 (continued) v o' r CD 0 v 0 N W 0 LrI Appendix Table 1. (Continued) Scientific Name Common Name Source State* Federal- County Habitat Notes Lotus helleri Carolina birdfoot-trefoil/Heller's trefoil 1,2 SR-T FSC R, S, Dd, D open woods over clay soils, roadsides Parthenium auriculatum Glade wild quinine 1 SR-T M glades and openings over mafic rocks Excluded Arabis missouriensis Missouri rockcress 1 SR-P S thin soils around basic rock outcrops Aster laevis var concinnus Narrow-leaf aster 1 SR-P S forests, woodland borders over mafic rocks Baptisia minor Prairie blue wild indigo 1 T S glades and open forests on basic soils Clemmys muhlenbergii Bog turtle 2,3 T T/SA Dd bogs, wet pastures Cyperus houghtonii Houghtons umbrella sedge 1 SR-P dry soil Desmodium ochroleucum Cream ticktrefoil 1,2 SR-T FSC D sandy/rocky woodland openings Dicanthelium annulum Ringed witch grass 1 SR-P dry, sandy or rocky woods, borders of thickets Dodecatheon meadia var meadia Eastern shooting star 1 SR-P S, Dd rich rocky woods over mafic or calcareous rocks Erynnis martialis Mottled duskywing 1 SR M upland woods, needs Ceanothus americanus Fixsenia favonius ontario Northern oak hairstreak 1 SR M dry oak-dominated woods Gomphus consanguis Cherokee clubtail 1 SR D spring-fed streams Helenium pinnatifidum Dissected sneezeweed 1 SR-P R savannahs and open mucky sites flex amelanchier Sarvis holly 1 SR-P M blackwater swamps and riverbanks Isoetes piedmontana Piedmont quillwort 1 T R granite flatrocks and diabase glades Isoetes virginica Virginia quillwort 1,2 SR-L FSC R upland depression swamp forests Juglans cinerea Butternut 2 FSC S coves, stream benches, rock ledges Lilium canadense ssp editorum Red Canada lily 1 SR-P S bogs, wet meadows Lindera subcoriacea Bog spicebush 1,2 E FSC M streamhead pocosins, white cedar swamps, bogs Masticophis flagellum Coachwhip 1 SR S dry sandy woods, pine/oak sandhills Matelea decipiens Glade milkvine 1 SR-P S, Dd thin woodlands over mafic or calcareous rocks Minuartia unifiora Single-flowered sandwort 1 E R granite flatrocks Oxypolis ternata Savanna/Piedmont cowbane *** FSC wetlands, wet swales, bogs Pellaea wrightiana Wright's cliff-brake 1 E-SC S rock outcrops, mafic or with nutrient-rich seepage Pituophis melanoleucus melanoleucus Northern pinesnake 1,2 SC FSC M dry, sandy woods, pine/oak sandhills Platanthera integra Yellow fringeless orchid 1 T R savannas Portulaca smalhi Small's portulaca 1 T R granite flatrocks and diabase glades Puma concolor couguar Eastern cougar 1, 2, 3 E E M needs open forest Quercus prinoides Dwarf Chinquapin oak 1 SR-P S dry, rocky slopes Rhus michauxii Michawes sumac 1, 2, 3 E-SC E D sandhills, sandy forests, woodlands and edges Silphium terebinthinaceum Prairie dock 1 SR-P D diabase glades, open/semi-open areas, mafic rocks Sistrurus miliarius Pigmy rattlesnake 1 SC M pine flatwoods, pine/oak sandhills Solidago ptarmicoides Prairie goldenrod 1 E R diabase glades 9 y tA' y, O O `r V, fD C4 (continued) v 0 CD 0 v 0 N 20 0 LrI Appendix Table 1. (Continued) Notes: 1 NC Natural Heritage Program County lists updated May 2003, NHP List of Rare Animal Species 2001, and NHP list of Rare Plant Species, 2002 2 US Fish & Wildlife Service North Carolina County lists updated 2/2003 3 US Fish and Wildlife Service TESS State list updated 2/2004 * based on NCNHP County lists updated May 2003 ** based on USFWS County lists updated 2/2003 *** State and/or Federally listed but not found in counties CI = Consideration for listing- no protected status E = Endangered E/PT = Endangered Potentially Threatened E-SC = Endangered but available commercially FSC = Federal Special Concern - no protected status SC = Special Concern SR = Significantly Rare SR-L = Significantly Rare Limited SR-O = Significantly Rare Other SR-P = Significantly Rare Peripheral SR-T = Significantly Rare Throughout T = Threatened T/SA = Threat. due to Similarity of Appearance - no effect on land-management activities by private landowners Counties S Stanly R Rowan M Montgomery Dd Davidson D Davie Expert Reviewers Dr. Alan Weakley, Curator, UNC Herbarium, Chapel Hill, NC Dr. Moni Bates, NC Plant Conservation Program Dr. Peter Diamond, NC Zoological Park, Asheboro, NC Sarah McRae, Natural Heritage Program, Raleigh, NC Dr. Mary Kay Clark, NC Museum of Natural Sciences, Raleigh, NC Mr. Mark Lewis, NC Zoological Park, Asheboro, NC Dr. Dennis Herman, NC Museum of Natural Sciences, Raleigh, NC 9 y tA' y O' r y