Loading...
HomeMy WebLinkAboutRiverbend CCR Visual Removal Verification Report. DUKE April 18, 2019 Mr. Ed Mussler North Carolina Department of Environmental Quality Division of Waste Management 217 W Jones Street Raleigh, NC 27603 Subject: Coal Combustion Residuals (CCR) Visual Removal Verification Report Riverbend Steam Station Dear Mr. Mussler: 526 South Church Street Charlotte, NC 28202 In general accordance with the CCR Surface Impoundments Closure Guidelines for Protection of Groundwater provided by the Division of Water Resources on November 4, 2016, Duke Energy Carolinas, LLC (DEC) has completed the removal of CCR at Riverbend Steam Station. Duke Energy submitted a letter to NCDEQ dated March 21, 2019 to provide notification that dewatering and removal of CCR from the Riverbend Steam Station surface impoundments was completed on March 16, 2019. The letter also stated that Duke Energy will submit the CCR Visual Removal Verification Report by April 30, 2019. The enclosed report from Wood Environment & Infrastructure Solutions, Inc. includes documentation of visual observation of CCR removal and PLM sampling results. If you have any questions on the enclosed information, please contact me at bristol.grohol@duke- energy.com or at 317-838-2719. Respectfully submitted, Bristol Grohol Engineer I - Waste & Groundwater Programs Attachment: Coal Combustion Residual (CCR) Visual Removal Verification Report Riverbend Steam Station ecc: Brandy Costner, NCDEQ Joanna Harbinson, NCDEQ Steve Lanter, NCDEQ Larry Frost, NCDEQ Elizabeth Werner, NCDEQ Ed Sullivan, Duke Energy Chris Varner, Duke Energy Daryl Bouchie, Duke Energy wood. April 15, 2019 Chris Varner Senior Project Manager Duke Energy Carolinas, LLC Riverbend Steam Station 175 Steam Plant Rd, Mount Holly, North Carolina 28120 Chris.Varner@duke-energy.com Subject: Coal Combustion Residuals (CCR) Visual Removal Verification Report Riverbend Steam Station Gaston County, North Carolina Wood Project No. 7810-16-0625 Dear Mr. Varner: Wood Environment and Infrastructure Solutions, Inc. (Wood) is pleased to submit this report documenting observations of CCR removal by visual methods at Riverbend Steam Station. We conclude that visual CCR removal verification criteria has been satisfied in general accordance with Section 3.0 of "Excavation Soil Sampling Plan, Riverbend Steam Station Ash Basin System, Rev. 2, dated December 2018 (Attachment 1), and in accordance with the soil closure guidelines Duke Energy received from the North Carolina Department of Environmental Quality (NCDEQ) on November 4, 2016. This report documents the completion of ash fill removal from the ash basin, cinder pit and ash stack areas. Closure of the primary ash basin and secondary ash basin by removal is required by the North Carolina Coal Ash Management Act of 2014. Excavation within the limits of the ash stack and cinder pit is required by a court order. Background The ash basin system is located at Duke Energy's Riverbend Steam Station in Mount Holly, North Carolina as shown in Figure 1. The original ash basin system consisted of a single basin commissioned in 1957 but was divided into a primary ash basin and a secondary ash basin by constructing an intermediate dam (GASTO-99) in 1979. The intermediate dam was removed in February 2017 as part of the excavation project. The estimated surface area of the combined ash basin is approximately 69 acres. The ash stack, also known as the "dry stack", is an area of ash fill constructed with ash removed from both the primary and secondary ash basins, which covers approximately 29 acres. The cinder pit is a triangular area of approximately 13 acres located on the north side of the rail spur (Figure 2) and was used as a storage area for bottom ash (cinders). A total of 5.35 million tons of material was disposed off -site (including soil commingled with CCR), slightly over the 4.8 to 5.2 million ton pre -excavation estimates. Wood Environment & Infrastructure Solutions, Inc. 2801 Yorkmont Road, Suite 100 Charlotte, North Carolina 28208 Licensures: NC Engineering F-1253, Geology C-247 T:704-357-8600 www.woodplc.com ('Wood' is a trading name for John Wood Group PLC and its subsidiaries) CCR Visual Removal Verification Report April 15, 2019 Riverbend Steam Station Page 2 Wood Project No. 7810181025 The material was disposed at the following facilities: • Waste Management R&B Landfill, Homer, GA (15,762 tons) • Marshall Steam Station, FGD and Industrial Landfills, Catawba Co. NC (88,745 tons) • Brickhaven Structural Fill, Chatham Co. NC (5,227,258 tons) • Republic Services Charlotte Motor Speedway Landfill (19,543 tons) Field Evaluation Field evaluation consisted of conducting visual observations after removal of CCR and collecting samples for testing utilizing polarized light microscopy (PLM). Photographic images were taken and samples were obtained in the vicinity of each grid point marked on Figure 2. After the vertical extension of the primary dam was removed, a column of eleven points was added to the grid between columns 19 and 20 (and in one case between 20 and 21) to capture the exposed crest of the lowered primary dam. These points are identified by the nearest regular grid point ID plus an offset indicator (i.e., O21W50 indicates a point approximately 50 feet west of grid location 021). Wood's construction quality assurance (CQA) personnel conducted visual observations and collected samples between February 11, 2017 and March 16, 2019 for PLM testing and evaluation. Visual CCR Removal Verification Results CCR removal was evaluated based on three criteria: 1. comparison of estimated bottom of CCR grades to post-CCR removal grades; 2. visual observation; and 3. PLM evaluation. Grade Comparison Due to the limited quality of historical data used for the initial estimate of bottom of CCR grades, grade comparison is an unreliable method for verifying ash removal. However, the data is presented in Table 1. Visual Observation Visual observation of CCR removal was performed on a 100-foot by 100-foot grid as shown in Figure 2. The photographic log is included in Attachment 2. PLM Evaluation Sampling at depths of 0 — 6 inches and 24 — 30 inches and visual soil classifications were conducted on the 100-foot grid as shown in Figure 2 for PLM evaluation. Hand auger refusal at depths shallower than 24 inches prevented sampling from 24 — 30 inches at 17 grid locations (M25, M33, P33, R33, 532, T24, T29, U35, W22, W36, Y28, CC19, CC27, DD10, EE21, GG23 and GG24). Due to the presence of ponded rain water at six locations (J32, J33, Q31, P31, S30 and S31) and soils too wet to access on foot but not underwater at three locations (X21, X22 and DD08), sampling was performed by taking a 2-feet deep scoop of material with an excavator bucket, dumping the material on dry ground, and then filling sample jars. Four locations covered by stockpiled soil from the decommissioned intermediate dam were sampled CCR Visual Removal Verification Report Riverbend Steam Station Wood Project No. 7810181025 April 15, 2019 Page 3 by excavating test pits and then filling sample jars with soil excavated from below the stockpiled fill (BB28, 131329, BB31 and 131332) Twenty-one sample locations were offset from the grid point location, as detailed in Table 3. The PLM evaluations were performed by RJ Lee Group, and the results are included in Attachment 3. PLM results indicated a percentage of CCR ranging from not detected (ND) to 26 percent, with 97.5 percent of sample results ranging from ND to 6 percent). The maximum allowable CCR percentage is 50 percent as described in the Excavation Soil Sampling Plan, indicating that CCR removal has been achieved in accordance with the plan. The results of a visual and laboratory soil classification of near -surface materials presented in Table 2 indicate that CCR removal has been achieved in accordance with the plan. Conclusions CCR removal verification criteria have been satisfied in general accordance with Section 3.0 of the Excavation Soil Sampling Plan, Riverbend Steam Station Rev. 2, December 2018, and in accordance with the soil closure guidelines Duke Energy received from NCDEQ on November 4, 2016. Sincerely, Wood, Thomas Maier, PE Senior Associate EngineeI thomas.maier@woodplc.com Attachments: Figure 1— Site Location Map Figure 2 — CCR Removal Verification — 100-ft x 100-ft Sampling Grid Table 1— CCR Removal Grade Comparison Table 2 — Field and Laboratory Documentation Summary Table 3 — Samples Offset from Grid Points Attachment 1— Excavation Soil Sampling Plan for Riverbend Steam Station Attachment 2 — Photographic Log Attachment 3 — Laboratory Test Results — RJ Lee Group — Grid Points Attachment 4 — Riverbend Demonstration of Compliance with CAMA Letter — January 22, 2019 Project Location =�:` N Ruml The Neck / `—' "It Nature 797ff Preserve owans / ` 700it rd wildlife Refuge / 7 1 brake Coy \ / 700 f! \ \ F � Hal O/r,A& !G f s - 16 1 788 ff St �C/ Bey a o�S',b. Ae p r / syEd F ie m V� i o co F 3 0� � yh Dr { Waterford �Ve L'umt>etln aA ;`' vatage ar, G�� `p°z� m ` Dr a [n '/�0' ,Verberytl a o m 00 ,. i .yn•Hwy _ t t Duke Power 6 � - Village ,,• � - p a1 St s' Mountain Q / Island Lake F waters Edge - / Service Layer Credits: Sources: Esri, HERE, DeLorme, Intermap, o VASToN_ — / increment P Corp., GEBCO, USGS, FAO, NPS, NRCAN, F \ — — ME :r Nt�uRr. — _ GeoBase, IGN, Kadaster NL, Ordnance Surv6y, Esri Japan, METI, / �; \ Hon Kong), Esri China (Hong g), swisstopo, Mapmylndia, 0. f \\ ,- o � � I Lsoo 3,000 Feet t OpenStreetMap contributors, and the GIS User Community I �"� \ J - r' / Legend SITE LOCATION MAP ( DUKE Wood. � RIVERBEND STEAM STATION PROJECT BOUNDARY RIVERBEND STEAM STATION ENERGY.: GASTON COUNTY, NORTH CAROLINA PROJECT NO: 7810-16-0625 FIGURE NO: 1 F:\AMEC_Projects\2016\7810-16-0625 GASTO-099 Dam Decommissioning\GIS\MXDs\Cinder Storage Area\SiteMap.mxd, User: leanna.muroski; Checked by: CB; Date: 5/2/2018 1 .060 REV. U 1 2 A B C D E F G H I J K L M N O P Q X Y AA BB,- E CC . 4 Iy . EE y FF APPROX. LOCATION OF ATTACHMENT 4 SAMPLES GG HH —F— A KKK 3 4 5 6 PERMITTED LIMITS OF DISTURBANCE E NOTE: THE FOLLOWING PREVIOUSLY PROPOSED GRID POINTS WERE NOT WITHIN THE BASINS, CINDER PIT OR ASH STACK AND WERE ELIMINATED: Z18, Z19, AA16, AA17, AA18, AA19, 13614, 131315, 13616, CC13, CC14, DD11, DD12, EE09, EE10, FF07, FF08, GG5, GG6, HH5 AND JJ7. INCHES 1 2 3 TENTHS 10 20 30 tea. U 04/04/2019 7810160625 BASIN CLOSURE SS SS TM TM FINAL REPORT T 03/22/2019 7810160625 BASIN CLOSURE SS SS TM TM UPDATE 17 S 02/19/2019 7810160625 BASIN CLOSURE SS SS TM TM UPDATE 16 R 02/13/2019 7810160625 BASIN CLOSURE SS SS TM TM UPDATE 15 Q 01/24/2019 7810160625 BASIN CLOSURE SS SS TM TM UPDATE 14 P 12/07/2018 7810160625 BASIN CLOSURE SS SS TM TM UPDATE 13 O 11/19/2018 7810160625 BASIN CLOSURE SS SS TM TM UPDATE 12 N 11/06/2018 7810160625 BASIN CLOSURE SS SS TM TM UPDATE 11 M 10/09/2018 7810160625 BASIN CLOSURE SS SS TM TM UPDATE 10 L 09/17/2018 7810160625 BASIN CLOSURE SS SS TM TM UPDATE 9 K 08/28/2018 7810160625 BASIN CLOSURE SS SS TM TM UPDATE 8 REV DATE JOB NO. PROJECT TYPE DES DFTR CHKD ENGR DESCRIPTION 5 6 7 I I I LEGEND LOD PROPOSED LIMITS OF DISTURBANCE O PROPOSED SAMPLE LOCATION (0 LOCATIONS) A CLEARED SAMPLE LOCATION (513 LOCATIONS) • SUBSURFACE ASH AT SAMPLE LOCATION (0 LOCATION) SAMPLED AND AWAITING PLM RESULTS (0 LOCATIONS) (513 TOTAL SAMPLE LOCATIONS) AERIAL IMAGE TAKEN MARCH 7, 2019 BY LDSI. GRID SHOWN (100' x 100') REPRESENTS NC STATE PLANE. 200 0 200 400 FT TITLE wood. RIVERBEND STEAM STATION RIVERBEND SAMPLE GRID Environment & Infrastructure Solutions, Inc. 2801 YORKMONT ROAD, SUITE 100 FOR CHARLOTTE, NC 28208 TEL: (704) 357-8600 FAX: (704) 357-8638 REPORTING LICENSURE: NC ENG: F-1253 NC GEOLOGY: C-247 DUKE rl ENEM%m7Y® SCALE: AS SHOWN DES: TBM DWG TYPE: DWG DFTR : SLS 25 004/04/20 CHKD: CB ABTE 9 ENGR: BM FILENAME: RVB_C901.004.060 SAMPLE GRID.dwg APPD: TBM DWG SIZE DRAWING NO. REVISION ANSI 22' x34D" Figure 2 U 8 9 I I 10 I 0 rn 0 ��o FT_1 C F Plotted By: Sams, Steve Sheet Set: 6226-14-007 ASH POND REMOVAL Layout:.060 RIVERBEND SAMPLE GRID April 03, 2019 04: 00: 56pm Q: \Duke\RiverBend\6226140007_Duke_RB—Pon d_Closure\ToOthers\Duke\RVB_C901.004.060 SAMPLE GRID.dwg Table 1 - CCR Removal Grade Comparison CCR Visual Removal Verification Report Riverbend Steam Station Point ID Estimated Bottom of CCR Elevation (Ref. 1) (ft) Post-CCR Removal Elevation (Ref. 2) (ft) Elevation Difference1,z (ft) E 2 7 716.00 716.00 0.00 E28 700.00 695.00 -5.00 E29 687.00 680.00 -7.00 E30 681.00 677.00 -4.00 E31 694.00 692.00 -2.00 F26 709.00 711.00 2.00 F27 695.00 694.00 -1.00 F28 688.00 683.00 -5.00 F29 683.00 678.00 -5.00 F30 678.00 677.00 -1.00 F31 672.00 674.00 2.00 F32 699.00 697.00 -2.00 G26 709.00 701.00 -8.00 G27 699.00 684.00 -15.00 G28 689.00 679.00 -10.00 G29 684.00 677.00 -7.00 G30 679.00 676.00 -3.00 G31 674.00 674.00 0.00 G32 683.00 681.00 -2.00 H25 713.00 709.00 -4.00 H26 709.00 693.00 -16.00 H27 699.00 683.00 -16.00 H 28 690.00 680.00 -10.00 H 29 685.00 678.00 -7.00 H30 680.00 677.00 -3.00 H 31 674.00 673.00 -1.00 H32 669.00 672.00 3.00 H33 706.00 705.00 -1.00 125 712.00 699.00 -13.00 126 704.00 687.00 -17.00 127 695.00 682.00 -13.00 128 689.00 680.00 -9.00 129 685.00 679.00 -6.00 130 680.00 678.00 -2.00 131 674.00 673.00 -1.00 132 665.00 671.00 6.00 133 692.00 690.00 -2.00 J24 716.00 706.00 -10.00 J25 707.00 693.00 -14.00 J26 698.00 686.00 -12.00 J27 693.00 683.00 -10.00 Table 1 Page 1 of 12 Point ID Estimated Bottom of CCR Elevation (Ref. 1) (ft) Post-CCR Removal Elevation (Ref. 2) (ft) Elevation Difference1,z (ft) J28 688.00 679.00 -9.00 J29 684.00 679.00 -5.00 J30 680.00 678.00 -2.00 J31 673.00 676.00 3.00 J32 664.00 671.00 7.00 J33 677.00 678.00 1.00 K24 714.00 695.00 -19.00 K25 702.00 691.00 -11.00 K26 695.00 686.00 -9.00 K27 691.00 683.00 -8.00 K28 687.00 682.00 -5.00 K29 683.00 679.00 -4.00 K30 679.00 678.00 -1.00 K31 671.00 676.00 5.00 K32 662.00 676.00 14.00 K33 663.00 671.00 8.00 K34 700.00 700.00 0.00 L23 718.00 710.00 -8.00 L24 709.00 690.00 -19.00 L25 700.00 690.00 -10.00 L26 694.00 687.00 -7.00 L27 689.00 684.00 -5.00 L28 685.00 682.00 -3.00 L29 682.00 678.00 -4.00 L30 677.00 676.00 -1.00 L31 669.00 677.00 8.00 L32 660.00 676.00 16.00 L33 653.00 669.00 16.00 L34 685.00 688.00 3.00 M22 -999.00 716.00 See note. M 23 694.00 691.00 -3.00 M 24 679.00 688.00 9.00 M 25 682.00 689.00 7.00 M 26 692.00 688.00 -4.00 M 27 687.00 685.00 -2.00 M 28 684.00 680.00 -4.00 M29 680.00 677.00 -3.00 M30 674.00 677.00 3.00 M31 667.00 673.00 6.00 M32 657.00 669.00 12.00 M33 650.00 669.00 19.00 M34 671.00 677.00 6.00 M35 707.00 707.00 0.00 N22 710.00 705.00 -5.00 N23 678.00 685.00 7.00 Table 1 Page 2 of 12 Point ID Estimated Bottom of CCR Elevation (Ref. 1) (ft) Post-CCR Removal Elevation (Ref. 2) (ft) Elevation Difference1,z (ft) N24 676.00 688.00 12.00 N25 674.00 690.00 16.00 N26 673.00 689.00 16.00 N27 684.00 686.00 2.00 N28 681.00 681.00 0.00 N29 677.00 677.00 0.00 N30 672.00 674.00 2.00 N31 663.00 669.00 6.00 N32 654.00 669.00 15.00 N33 656.00 669.00 13.00 N34 662.00 669.00 7.00 N35 692.00 689.00 -3.00 O21W50 -999.00 717.00 See note. 021 723.00 707.00 -16.00 022 689.00 683.00 -6.00 023 677.00 684.00 7.00 024 676.00 688.00 12.00 025 674.00 707.00 33.00 026 672.00 688.00 16.00 027 672.00 687.00 15.00 028 676.00 683.00 7.00 029 673.00 680.00 7.00 030 667.00 671.00 4.00 031 659.00 669.00 10.00 032 656.00 669.00 13.00 033 663.00 670.00 7.00 034 668.00 677.00 9.00 035 676.00 680.00 4.00 036 713.00 709.00 -4.00 P20W10 -999.00 716.00 See note. P20 -999.00 713.00 See note. P21 704.00 694.00 -10.00 P22 679.00 680.00 1.00 P23 677.00 684.00 7.00 P24 675.00 695.00 20.00 P25 673.00 712.00 39.00 P26 672.00 701.00 29.00 P27 670.00 686.00 16.00 P28 668.00 684.00 16.00 P29 666.00 680.00 14.00 P30 662.00 674.00 12.00 P31 656.00 669.00 13.00 P32 663.00 670.00 7.00 P33 670.00 675.00 5.00 P34 675.00 684.00 9.00 Table 1 Page 3 of 12 Point ID Estimated Bottom of CCR Elevation (Ref. 1) (ft) Post-CCR Removal Elevation (Ref. 2) (ft) Elevation Difference1,z (ft) P35 679.00 690.00 11.00 P36 700.00 696.00 -4.00 Q20W47 -999.00 716.00 See note. Q20 725.00 696.00 -29.00 Q21 687.00 679.00 -8.00 Q22 678.00 679.00 1.00 Q23 677.00 678.00 1.00 Q24 675.00 676.00 1.00 Q25 674.00 676.00 2.00 Q26 672.00 675.00 3.00 Q27 671.00 673.00 2.00 Q28 668.00 670.00 2.00 Q29 662.00 669.00 7.00 Q30 658.00 675.00 17.00 Q31 657.00 670.00 13.00 Q32 670.00 673.00 3.00 Q33 678.00 681.00 3.00 Q34 683.00 682.00 -1.00 Q35 686.00 696.00 10.00 Q36 690.00 704.00 14.00 R20W55 -999.00 717.00 See note. R20 719.00 694.00 -25.00 R21 680.00 677.00 -3.00 R22 679.00 679.00 0.00 R23 677.00 680.00 3.00 R24 676.00 676.00 0.00 R25 675.00 676.00 1.00 R26 673.00 675.00 2.00 R27 672.00 673.00 1.00 R28 670.00 670.00 0.00 R29 665.00 669.00 4.00 R30 658.00 672.00 14.00 R31 666.00 670.00 4.00 R32 678.00 680.00 2.00 R33 684.00 690.00 6.00 R34 688.00 689.00 1.00 R35 691.00 695.00 4.00 R36 695.00 708.00 13.00 S20W50 -999.00 717.00 See note. S20 718.00 697.00 -21.00 S21 685.00 677.00 -8.00 S22 679.00 677.00 -2.00 S23 678.00 678.00 0.00 S24 677.00 676.00 -1.00 S25 676.00 676.00 0.00 Table 1 Page 4 of 12 Point ID Estimated Bottom of CCR Elevation (Ref. 1) (ft) Post-CCR Removal Elevation (Ref. 2) (ft) Elevation Difference1,z (ft) S26 674.00 675.00 1.00 S27 673.00 673.00 0.00 S28 671.00 670.00 -1.00 S29 669.00 669.00 0.00 S30 665.00 684.00 19.00 S31 674.00 682.00 8.00 S32 684.00 688.00 4.00 S33 689.00 701.00 12.00 S34 692.00 706.00 14.00 S35 695.00 695.00 0.00 S36 699.00 706.00 7.00 T20W50 -999.00 717.00 See note. T20 719.00 699.00 -20.00 T21 679.00 676.00 -3.00 T22 672.00 674.00 2.00 T23 679.00 677.00 -2.00 T24 678.00 676.00 -2.00 T25 677.00 676.00 -1.00 T26 675.00 675.00 0.00 T27 674.00 673.00 -1.00 T28 672.00 670.00 -2.00 T29 671.00 669.00 -2.00 T30 670.00 679.00 9.00 T31 682.00 681.00 -1.00 T32 689.00 699.00 10.00 T33 692.00 710.00 18.00 T34 696.00 715.00 19.00 T35 699.00 711.00 12.00 T36 702.00 707.00 5.00 U20W45 -999.00 717.00 See note. U20 720.00 700.00 -20.00 U21 680.00 671.00 -9.00 U22 658.00 673.00 15.00 U23 675.00 675.00 0.00 U24 679.00 677.00 -2.00 U25 678.00 681.00 3.00 U26 676.00 678.00 2.00 U27 675.00 683.00 8.00 U28 674.00 696.00 22.00 U29 673.00 696.00 23.00 U30 672.00 679.00 7.00 U31 672.00 688.00 16.00 U32 693.00 713.00 20.00 U33 696.00 720.00 24.00 U34 699.00 714.00 15.00 Table 1 Page 5 of 12 Point ID Estimated Bottom of CCR Elevation (Ref. 1) (ft) Post-CCR Removal Elevation (Ref. 2) (ft) Elevation Difference1,z (ft) U35 702.00 719.00 17.00 U36 705.00 716.00 11.00 V20W45 -999.00 717.00 See note. V20 720.00 701.00 -19.00 V21 680.00 671.00 -9.00 V22 676.00 672.00 -4.00 V23 683.00 673.00 -10.00 V24 692.00 675.00 -17.00 V25 679.00 678.00 -1.00 V26 678.00 682.00 4.00 V27 676.00 691.00 15.00 V28 675.00 708.00 33.00 V29 674.00 703.00 29.00 V30 674.00 683.00 9.00 V31 674.00 683.00 9.00 V32 689.00 717.00 28.00 V33 698.00 709.00 11.00 V34 701.00 717.00 16.00 V35 705.00 717.00 12.00 V36 709.00 720.00 11.00 W20W40 -999.00 716.00 See note. W 20 719.00 701.00 -18.00 W 21 680.00 667.00 -13.00 W22 685.00 670.00 -15.00 W 23 691.00 671.00 -20.00 W 24 698.00 671.00 -27.00 W 25 686.00 678.00 -8.00 W 26 679.00 686.00 7.00 W27 677.00 706.00 29.00 W 28 676.00 708.00 32.00 W 29 675.00 706.00 31.00 W 30 676.00 688.00 12.00 W 31 676.00 681.00 5.00 W32 686.00 711.00 25.00 W33 701.00 709.00 8.00 W 34 705.00 709.00 4.00 W 35 710.00 720.00 10.00 W 36 713.00 720.00 7.00 X20W40 -999.00 715.00 See note. X20 719.00 700.00 -19.00 X21 684.00 677.00 -7.00 X22 690.00 666.00 -24.00 X23 696.00 666.00 -30.00 X24 701.00 671.00 -30.00 X25 704.00 673.00 -31.00 Table 1 Page 6 of 12 Point ID Estimated Bottom of CCR Elevation (Ref. 1) (ft) Post-CCR Removal Elevation (Ref. 2) (ft) Elevation Difference1,z (ft) X26 680.00 680.00 0.00 X27 678.00 696.00 18.00 X28 677.00 707.00 30.00 X29 677.00 704.00 27.00 X30 677.00 686.00 9.00 X31 677.00 685.00 8.00 X32 695.00 711.00 16.00 X33 703.00 718.00 15.00 X34 709.00 720.00 11.00 X35 715.00 726.00 11.00 Y20W45 -999.00 716.00 See note. Y20 721.00 699.00 -22.00 Y21 688.00 687.00 -1.00 Y22 695.00 689.00 -6.00 Y23 700.00 682.00 -18.00 Y24 703.00 675.00 -28.00 Y25 707.00 674.00 -33.00 Y26 700.00 678.00 -22.00 Y27 680.00 692.00 12.00 Y28 679.00 705.00 26.00 Y29 679.00 704.00 25.00 Y30 679.00 687.00 8.00 Y31 683.00 686.00 3.00 Y32 701.00 699.00 -2.00 Y33 706.00 707.00 1.00 Y34 713.00 709.00 -4.00 Y35 724.00 727.00 3.00 Z3 -999.00 662.00 See note. Z4 -999.00 660.00 See note. Z5 -999.00 667.00 See note. Z6 -999.00 660.00 See note. Z7 -999.00 661.00 See note. Z8 659.00 661.00 2.00 Z9 652.00 663.00 11.00 Z10 655.00 663.00 8.00 Z11 663.00 666.00 3.00 Z12 665.00 664.00 -1.00 Z13 662.00 665.00 3.00 Z14 661.00 663.00 2.00 Z15 663.00 666.00 3.00 Z16 672.00 672.00 0.00 Z17 682.00 682.00 0.00 Z20 724.00 697.00 -27.00 Z21 695.00 687.00 -8.00 Z22 700.00 707.00 7.00 Table 1 Page 7 of 12 Point ID Estimated Bottom of CCR Elevation (Ref. 1) (ft) Post-CCR Removal Elevation (Ref. 2) (ft) Elevation Difference1,z (ft) Z23 703.00 702.00 -1.00 Z24 706.00 691.00 -15.00 Z25 709.00 691.00 -18.00 Z26 711.00 695.00 -16.00 Z27 710.00 700.00 -10.00 Z28 697.00 704.00 7.00 Z29 693.00 705.00 12.00 Z30 699.00 706.00 7.00 Z31 705.00 696.00 -9.00 Z32 703.00 696.00 -7.00 Z33 708.00 706.00 -2.00 Z34 717.00 710.00 -7.00 Z35 -999.00 730.00 See note. AA3 651.00 656.00 5.00 AA4 652.00 649.00 -3.00 AA5 660.00 660.00 0.00 AA6 649.00 655.00 6.00 AA7 641.00 651.00 10.00 AA8 648.00 655.00 7.00 AA9 652.00 657.00 5.00 AA10 655.00 659.00 4.00 AA11 667.00 666.00 -1.00 AA12 677.00 664.00 -13.00 AA13 667.00 662.00 -5.00 AA14 665.00 663.00 -2.00 AA15 671.00 677.00 6.00 AA20 727.00 702.00 -25.00 AA21 701.00 701.00 0.00 AA22 703.00 708.00 5.00 AA23 706.00 709.00 3.00 AA24 708.00 711.00 3.00 AA25 711.00 709.00 -2.00 AA26 714.00 709.00 -5.00 AA27 716.00 712.00 -4.00 AA28 715.00 716.00 1.00 AA29 712.00 716.00 4.00 AA30 712.00 720.00 8.00 AA31 711.00 717.00 6.00 AA32 710.00 703.00 -7.00 AA33 711.00 705.00 -6.00 AA34 720.00 716.00 -4.00 B B4 653.00 648.00 -5.00 B B5 664.00 663.00 -1.00 B B6 650.00 662.00 12.00 B B7 650.00 652.00 2.00 Table 1 Page 8 of 12 Point ID Estimated Bottom of CCR Elevation (Ref. 1) (ft) Post-CCR Removal Elevation (Ref. 2) (ft) Elevation Difference1,z (ft) B B8 653.00 655.00 2.00 B B9 656.00 660.00 4.00 BB10 662.00 665.00 3.00 BB11 673.00 671.00 -2.00 BB12 677.00 672.00 -5.00 BB13 676.00 679.00 3.00 BB17 701.00 681.00 -20.00 BB18 708.00 701.00 -7.00 BB19 714.00 723.00 9.00 BB20 728.00 718.00 -10.00 BB21 706.00 712.00 6.00 BB22 707.00 711.00 4.00 BB23 708.00 717.00 9.00 BB24 710.00 719.00 9.00 BB25 713.00 716.00 3.00 BB26 717.00 712.00 -5.00 BB27 719.00 711.00 -8.00 BB28 718.00 714.00 -4.00 BB29 718.00 720.00 2.00 BB30 719.00 729.00 10.00 BB31 719.00 728.00 9.00 BB32 719.00 724.00 5.00 BB33 719.00 716.00 -3.00 BB34 -999.00 -999.00 See note. CC4 655.00 648.00 -7.00 CC5 664.00 665.00 1.00 CC6 659.00 669.00 10.00 CC7 659.00 666.00 7.00 CC8 653.00 652.00 -1.00 CC9 660.00 665.00 5.00 CC10 665.00 669.00 4.00 CC11 674.00 678.00 4.00 CC12 680.00 679.00 -1.00 CC15 694.00 683.00 -11.00 CC16 700.00 691.00 -9.00 CC17 707.00 722.00 15.00 CC18 713.00 729.00 16.00 CC19 720.00 726.00 6.00 CC20 728.00 726.00 -2.00 CC21 711.00 728.00 17.00 CC22 711.00 721.00 10.00 CC23 712.00 720.00 8.00 CC24 714.00 719.00 5.00 CC25 717.00 724.00 7.00 CC26 720.00 731.00 11.00 Table 1 Page 9 of 12 Point ID Estimated Bottom of CCR Elevation (Ref. 1) (ft) Post-CCR Removal Elevation (Ref. 2) (ft) Elevation Difference1,z (ft) CC27 723.00 729.00 6.00 CC28 725.00 731.00 6.00 DD4 656.00 650.00 -6.00 DD5 668.00 666.00 -2.00 D D6 668.00 674.00 6.00 D D7 666.00 671.00 5.00 D D8 654.00 654.00 0.00 DD9 667.00 666.00 -1.00 DD10 680.00 681.00 1.00 DD13 696.00 693.00 -3.00 DD14 700.00 706.00 6.00 DD15 704.00 709.00 5.00 DD16 708.00 701.00 -7.00 DD17 714.00 723.00 9.00 DD18 723.00 727.00 4.00 DD19 728.00 729.00 1.00 DD20 730.00 726.00 -4.00 DD21 725.00 724.00 -1.00 DD22 722.00 724.00 2.00 DD23 719.00 721.00 2.00 DD24 719.00 721.00 2.00 DD25 721.00 721.00 0.00 DD26 727.00 732.00 5.00 DD27 734.00 737.00 3.00 EE4 656.00 653.00 -3.00 E E5 671.00 672.00 1.00 E E6 672.00 676.00 4.00 E E7 671.00 674.00 3.00 E E8 680.00 683.00 3.00 EE11 686.00 687.00 1.00 EE12 693.00 689.00 -4.00 EE13 697.00 689.00 -8.00 EE14 705.00 704.00 -1.00 EE15 711.00 711.00 0.00 EE16 717.00 725.00 8.00 EE17 729.00 732.00 3.00 EE18 741.00 733.00 -8.00 EE19 744.00 733.00 -11.00 EE20 742.00 731.00 -11.00 EE21 736.00 727.00 -9.00 EE22 731.00 721.00 -10.00 EE23 726.00 721.00 -5.00 EE24 724.00 721.00 -3.00 EE25 727.00 722.00 -5.00 EE26 740.00 740.00 0.00 Table 1 Page 10 of 12 Point ID Estimated Bottom of CCR Elevation (Ref. 1) (ft) Post-CCR Removal Elevation (Ref. 2) (ft) Elevation Difference1,z (ft) FF4 679.00 660.00 -19.00 FF5 677.00 677.00 0.00 FF6 680.00 684.00 4.00 FF9 681.00 676.00 -5.00 FF10 692.00 679.00 -13.00 FF11 694.00 688.00 -6.00 FF12 694.00 692.00 -2.00 FF13 701.00 693.00 -8.00 FF14 709.00 701.00 -8.00 FF15 717.00 711.00 -6.00 FF16 724.00 723.00 -1.00 FF17 738.00 732.00 -6.00 FF18 746.00 739.00 -7.00 FF19 746.00 739.00 -7.00 FF20 747.00 733.00 -14.00 FF21 747.00 724.00 -23.00 FF22 741.00 721.00 -20.00 FF23 737.00 722.00 -15.00 FF24 736.00 723.00 -13.00 FF25 737.00 726.00 -11.00 FF26 750.00 751.00 1.00 GG4 -999.00 684.00 See note. GG7 665.00 678.00 13.00 GG8 677.00 670.00 -7.00 GG9 678.00 677.00 -1.00 GG 10 689.00 678.00 -11.00 GG 11 697.00 683.00 -14.00 GG 12 703.00 693.00 -10.00 GG 13 709.00 698.00 -11.00 GG 14 713.00 699.00 -14.00 GG 15 719.00 710.00 -9.00 GG 16 725.00 715.00 -10.00 GG17 735.00 727.00 -8.00 GG 18 743.00 743.00 0.00 GG 19 745.00 741.00 -4.00 GG20 749.00 743.00 -6.00 GG21 752.00 740.00 -12.00 GG22 756.00 745.00 -11.00 GG23 757.00 752.00 -5.00 GG24 756.00 755.00 -1.00 GG25 757.00 756.00 -1.00 HH6 -999.00 674.00 See note. HH7 673.00 676.00 3.00 H H8 681.00 672.00 -9.00 H H9 692.00 679.00 -13.00 Table 1 Page 11 of 12 Point ID Estimated Bottom of CCR Elevation (Ref. 1) (ft) Post-CCR Removal Elevation (Ref. 2) (ft) Elevation Difference 12 (ft) H H 10 693.00 681.00 -12.00 H H 11 698.00 687.00 -11.00 H H 12 708.00 696.00 -12.00 H H 13 714.00 702.00 -12.00 H H 14 719.00 704.00 -15.00 H H 15 721.00 708.00 -13.00 H H 16 1 725.00 712.00 -13.00 H H 17 731.00 726.00 -5.00 H H 18 739.00 737.00 -2.00 H H 19 745.00 741.00 -4.00 HH20 752.00 751.00 -1.00 JJ8 -999.00 684.00 See note. JJ9 -999.00 695.00 See note. J.110 700.00 704.00 4.00 Jill 707.00 716.00 9.00 JJ 12 715.00 714.00 -1.00 JJ 13 720.00 713.00 -7.00 JJ 14 724.00 716.00 -8.00 JJ 15 726.00 717.00 -9.00 JJ 16 728.00 720.00 -8.00 JJ17 736.00 727.00 -9.00 JJ 18 743.00 742.00 -1.00 Notes: 1. A positive number indicates that the CCR removal grade is higher than the estimated bottom of CCR grade. 2. Sample locations with a-999.00 for elevation were located outside of the waste boundary and did not have an estimated bottom of ash elevation. References: 1. Estimated Bottom of CCR Elevations are from Drawing No. RVB_C901.016.004, entitled "Estimated Bottom of Ash Excavation Grades - Overview", dated 9/18/2018. 2. Post-CCR Removal Elevations are from topographic mapping by LDSI based on 3/7/2019 aerial photography, modified to remove stockpiles in the area of grid Q-U 24-29 and Z-AA 30- 34. These stockpiles of clean material were placed after bottom of ash was encountered. Table 1 Page 12 of 12 Table 2 - Field and Lab Documentation Summary CCR Visual Removal Verification Report Riverbend Steam Station Sequential Number Grid Location Date Sampled Visual Classification - Shallow Visual Classification - Deep PLM Result (Area % Fly Ash) Shallow PLM Result (Area % Fly Ash) Deep PLM Sample Number Shallow PLM Sample Number Deep 1 E27 7/20/2018 red clayey silt red clayey silt 2% ND 2018023069 2018023070 2 E28 9/10/2018 dark brown and red clayey silt dark brown and red clayey silt ND 1% 2018028596 2018028597 3 E29 9/10/2018 red silty clay red silty clay ND ND 2018028582 2018028583 4 E30 9/10/2018 dark brown silty clay dark brown silty clay ND ND 2018028584 2018028585 5 E31 9/11/2018 red, tan and brown clayey silt red, tan and grey clayey silt 2% ND 2018028625 2018028626 6 F26 7/20/2018 red Silt red Silt ND ND 2018023073 2018023074 7 F27 7/20/2018 red and brown silt red and brown silt 1% 1% 2018023071 2018023072 8 F28 9/6/2018 dark red silty clay dark red and tan silty clay 2% ND 2018028566 2018028567 9 F29 9/10/2018 red Silty clay red Silty clay ND ND 2018028580 2018028581 10 F30 9/6/2018 red silty clay with traces of organic matter dark red silty clay 1% ND 2018028560 2018028561 11 F31 9/20/2018 dark brown clayey silt brown and green silty clay ND ND 2018029765 2018029766 12 F32 9/11/2018 red and tan clayey silt red and tan clayey silt 1% ND 2018028633 2018028634 13 G26 4/5/2018 red silt red silt ND ND 2018010652 2018010653 14 G27 7/20/2018 red and tan silt red and tan silt ND ND 2018023075 2018023076 15 G28 9/20/2018 red silty clay red and tan silty clay ND 1% 2018029769 2018029770 16 G29 9/10/2018 dark brown and red silty clay dark brown and red silty clay 2% ND 2018028578 2018028579 17 G30 9/6/2018 dark brown and tan slity clay dark brown and tan slity clay 2% ND 2018028558 2018028559 18 G31 9/20/2018 red and tan silty clay red and tan silty clay ND ND 2018029767 2018029768 19 G32 9/11/2018 red and tan clayey silt red and tan clayey silt ND ND 2018028631 2018028632 20 H25 4/5/2018 red and grey silt red and tan silt 6% ND 2018010654 2018010655 21 H26 4/5/2018 red silt red silt ND 1% 2018010650 2018010651 22 H27 8/7/2018 red and yellow silt red and brown silt 2% ND 2018025234 2018025235 23 H28 8/7/2018 red and tan silty clay red and tan silt clay ND 3% 2018025236 2018025237 24 H29 9/6/2018 pink and red clayey silt pink and red clayey silt ND 1% 2018028562 2018028563 25 H30 9/6/2018 tan clayey silt red and tan clayey silt ND ND 2018028556 2018028557 26 H31 9/11/2018 red silty clay red silty clay ND ND 2018028627 2018028628 27 H32 10/18/2018 brown silty clay w/5% potential ash brown silty clay ND ND 2018033519 2018033520 28 H33 9/11/2018 red and brown red and brown ND ND 2018028635 2018028636 29 125 7/20/2018 red and grey silt red and tan silt ND ND 2018023067 2018023068 30 126 4/5/2018 red silt red and tan sandy silt 4% ND 2018010648 2018010649 31 127 8/7/2018 red silt red silt 1% ND 2018025232 2018025233 32 128 8/7/2018 red and tan silty clay red and tan silty clay 4% 1% 2018025238 2018025239 33 129 9/6/2018 dark brown silty clay dark brown silty clay 2% ND 2018028564 2018028565 34 130 9/6/2018 dark brown and tan silty clay dark brown and tan silty clay ND ND 2018028554 2018028555 35 131 9/11/2018 dark brown clayey silt with stones dark brown and red clayey silt ND ND 2018028629 2018028630 36 132 10/18/2018 brown and red silty clay brown red silty clay w/trace grey material ND ND 2018033521 2018033522 37 133 9/11/2018 brown and red silty clay brown and red silty clay ND ND 2018028637 2018028638 38 J24 4/4/2018 red and tan silt red and tan silt 3% 7% 2018010627 2018010628 39 125 9/10/2018 red and tan silt red and tan silt ND 2% 2018028594 2018028595 40 J26 4/5/2018 red and grey silt red and tan sandy silt 3% 1% 2018010646 2018010647 41 J27 8/7/2018 red and tan clayey silt red and tan silty clay 1% 3% 2018025230 2018025231 42 J28 9/10/2018 tan, grey and red clayey silt tan, grey and red clayey silt ND ND 2018028592 2018028593 43 J29 9/10/2018 red and tan silty clay red and tan silty clay ND ND 2018028586 2018028587 44 J30 9/6/2018 red and tan slity clay red and tan slity clay 1% 1% 2018028550 2018028551 45 J31 9/20/2018 red tan sandy silt red and black clayey silt ND ND 2018029777 2018029778 46 J32 10/31/2018 about half red brown silty clay, half grey material (composite) about half red brown silty clay, half grey material (composite) ND ND 2018032453 2018032454 47 J33 10/31/2018 about half red brown silty clay, half grey material (composite) about half red brown silty clay, half grey material (composite) ND ND 2018032455 2018032456 48 K24 4/4/2018 red and tan silt red and tan silt 3% 1% 2018010625 2018010626 49 K25 4/5/2018 red silt red sandy silt 4% 3% 2018010661 2018010662 50 K26 8/7/2018 red and pink silt red and pink silt ND 2% 2018025252 2018025253 51 K27 8/7/2018 red and tan silt red silty clay 4% 2% 2018025228 2018025229 52 K28 8/7/2018 red and tan silt red and brown silt ND ND 2018025240 2018025241 53 K29 9/10/2018 red and tan silty clay red and tan silty clay ND 1% 2018028588 2018028589 54 K30 9/6/2018 dark brown clayey silt dark brown clayey silt 7% 0% 2018028552 2018028553 55 K31 9/20/2018 red and grey clayey silt brown and tan sandy silt 1% ND 2018029771 2018029772 56 K32 9/20/2018 red and tan clayey silt red and white clayey silt ND ND 2018029773 2018029774 57 K33 9/20/2018 red and tan sandy silt red tan sandy silt ND ND 2018029775 2018029776 58 K34 9/24/2018 pink, red and tan clayey silt pink and red clayey silt 1% 1% 2018030251 2018030252 59 L23 4/10/2018 red and tan sandy silt red and tan clayey silt ND 1% 2018010936 2018010937 60 L24 5/3/2018 red, black and tan silty clay red and tan silty clay ND ND 2018013629 2018013630 61 L25 8/7/2018 red silty clay red and pink silt ND 1% 2018025251 2018025250 62 L26 8/7/2018 red and brown silt red and tan silt 6% ND 2018025248 2018025249 63 L27 8/7/2018 red silty clay red silty clay ND ND 2018025226 2018025227 64 L28 8/7/2018 red silty clay red silty clay 3% ND 2018025242 2018025243 65 L29 9/10/2018 tan and red clayey silt tan and red clayey silt 2% ND 2018028590 2018028591 66 L30 9/21/2018 red tan clayey silt red tan and black clayey silt 3% ND 2018029979 2018029980 67 L31 10/3/2018 red silty clay red silty clay w black organic matter 1% 3% 2018031746 2018031747 Table 2 Page 1 of 8 Sequential Number Grid Location Date Sampled Visual Classification -Shallow Visual Classification -Deep PLM Result (Area % Fly Ash) Shallow PLM Result (Area % Fly Ash) Deep FILM Sample Number Shallow PLM Sample Number Deep 68 L32 9/20/2018 red and tan sandy silt red and tan sandy silt ND ND 2018029779 2018029780 69 L33 9/20/2018 Light brown and white clayey silt red and white clayey silt ND ND 2018029781 2018029782 70 L34 9/24/2018 red, tan and black clayey silt red, tan and black clayey silt 1% ND 2018030249 2018030250 71 M22 4/10/2018 light brown and tan sandy silt light brown and tan sandy silt ND ND 2018010934 2018010935 72 M23 5/3/2018 red sandy silt red and tan sandy silt ND 1% 2018013633 2018013634 73 M24 5/3/2018 red and tan clayey silt red and tan sandy silt 1% ND 2018013631 2018013632 74 M25 4/5/2018 red silt auger refusal 12% Refusal 2018010663 75 M26 4/5/2018 red and tan silt red and tan silt 5% ND 2018010640 2018010641 76 M27 8/7/2018 red and pink silty clay red and tan silty clay 1% 2% 2018025224 2018025225 77 M28 8/7/2018 red and pink silty clay red and tan silty clay ND 1% 2018025244 2018025245 78 M29 9/21/2018 red and tan silty sand red and tan silty sand 2% 2% 2018029973 2018029974 79 M30 9/21/2018 brown sandy silt red and tan sandy silt 3% 1% 2018029975 2018029976 80 M31 9/24/2018 red, green and tan clayey silt red clayey silt ND ND 2018030247 2018030248 81 M32 9/21/2018 red tan clayey silt red tan silty clay ND 1% 2018029977 2018029978 82 M33 9/14/2018 green and brown clay auger refusal ND Refusal 2018029219 83 M34 9/24/2018 pink, white and tan clayey silt pink, white and tan clayey silt ND 1% 2018030253 2018030254 84 M35 9/24/2018 pink, white and tan clayey silt pink, white and tan clayey silt 2% ND 2018030255 2018030256 85 N22 4/10/2018 red and tan clayey silt red and tan clayey silt ND ND 2018010932 2018010933 86 N23 5/3/2018 red, tan and grey sandy silt red, tan and grey sandy silt 1% 1% 2018013635 2018013636 87 N24 4/5/2018 red, tan and blk silt red and tan silt 2% 3% 2018010664 2018010665 88 N25 10/5/2017 red -brown sandy silt red -brown sandy silt ND ND 2017035129 2017035130 89 N26 4/5/2018 red and grey silt red and tan silt 5% 2% 2018010666 2018010667 90 N27 8/7/2018 red and tan silty clay red and tan silty clay ND 2% 2018025222 2018025223 91 N28 8/7/2018 red and brown silty clay red and brown silty clay 2% 1% 2018025246 2018025247 92 N29 9/21/2018 red and green sandy silt red and tan sandy silt 1% ND 2018029969 2018029970 93 N30 9/21/2018 brown sandy silt brown sandy silt ND ND 2018029971 2018029972 94 N31 9/14/2018 brown clayey silt red tan clayey silt ND 1% 2018029215 2018029216 95 N32 9/14/2018 green and grey clay green and grey clay ND ND 2018029217 2018029218 96 N33 9/14/2018 green and grey clayey silt green, brown and grey clayey silt 1% ND 2018029220 2018029221 97 N34 10/9/2018 reddish clay brown clay with some organic ND ND 2018032422 2018032424 98 N35 9/24/2018 red and brown silty clay red brown and white silty clay 1% ND 2018030257 2018030258 99 021W50 4/13/2018 red and tan sandy silt red and tan clayey silt ND ND 2018011362 2018011363 100 021 4/10/2018 drk brwn silt drk brwn and tan clayey silt ND 1% 2018010930 2018010931 101 022 4/4/2018 red silt red silt 1% 3% 2018010615 2018010616 102 023 4/4/2018 red and grey silt red,white and tan silty sand 6% 2% 2018010613 2018010614 103 024 10/5/2017 yellow -brown sandy silt yellow -brown sandy silt ND ND 2017035127 2017035128 104 025 10/5/2017 red -brown sandy sily red -brown clayey silt 1% ND 2017035125 2017035126 105 026 10/4/2017 red,white,yellow,black sandy silt red -brown sandy silt ND ND 2017035123 2017035124 106 027 4/6/2018 drk brwn, red and black clayey silt drk brwn clayey silt 3% ND 2018010594 2018010595 107 028 9/21/2018 red, tan and black silty clay red tan clayey silt 1% ND 2018029963 2018029964 108 029 9/21/2018 red tan silty clay red tan clayey silt 2% ND 2018029965 2018029966 109 030 9/21/2018 red tan silty clay red tan clayey silt ND ND 2018029967 2018029968 110 031 9/14/2018 green and brown clayey silt green and grey clayey silt 1% 1% 2018029224 2018029225 111 032 9/14/2018 black and brown clayey silt black and brown clayey silt 2% ND 2018029222 2018029223 112 033 10/9/2018 brown sandy clay brown sandy clay ND ND 2018032431 2018032432 113 034 9/25/2018 tan and brown sandy silt tan, brown and white sandy silt ND ND 2018030484 2018030487 114 035 9/24/2018 red clayey silt red and brown clayey cilt ND 1% 2018030241 2018030242 115 036 9/24/2018 red, white and tan clayey silt red, white and tan clayey silt 2% ND 2018030239 2018030240 116 P20W10 4/13/2018 red and tan sandy silt red and tan sandy silt 1% 1% 2018011364 2018011365 117 P20 9/25/2018 red and tan sandy silt red sandy silt 2% ND 2018030502 2018030503 118 P21 9/25/2018 red and tan sandy silt red and tan clayey silt 4% 3% 2018030504 2018030505 119 P22 4/5/2018 red and tan silt red and tan sandy silt 2% 1% 2018010677 2018010678 120 P23 4/4/2018 red & tan clayey silt red & tan clayey silt 9% 1% 2018010611 2018010612 121 P24 10/4/2017 red -brown sandy silt red -brown sandy silt 4% 3% 2017035117 2017035118 122 P25 10/4/2017 red clayey silt red -brown clayey silt ND ND 2017035115 2017035116 123 P26 10/4/2017 red -brown clayey silt red -brown clayey silt ND ND 2017035113 2017035114 124 P27 10/4/2017 red, white, yellow sandy silt red -brown sandy silt ND ND 2017035111 2017035112 125 P28 9/21/2018 red and black clayey silt red, black and tan clay ND ND 2018029955 2018029956 126 P29 9/21/2018 reddish Silty clay red tan and silty clay 2% ND 2018029981 2018029982 127 P30 10/8/2018 tan and brown silty clay tan and white silty clay 1% ND 2018032441 2018032442 128 P31 10/31/2018 mostly red silt, little grey material (sample is composite of grey clumps) mostly red silt, little grey material (sample is composite of grey clumps) 6% 6% 2018034760 2018034761 129 P32 10/9/2018 brown clay brown clay ND ND 2018032429 2018032430 130 P33 10/3/2018 red and tan sandy silt Refusal to drill at 1ft ND Refusal 2018031755 131 P34 9/25/2018 red and tan sandy silt red, tan and white sandy silt ND 2% 2018030488 2018030489 132 P35 10/3/2018 red and tan sandy silt brown silty clay 1% 1% 2018031750 2018031751 133 P36 10/3/2018 red and brown silty clay red and brown silty clay ND ND 2018031744 2018031745 134 Q20W47 4/13/2018 red and tan clayey silt red and tan sandy silt 1% 1% 2018011366 2018011367 135 Q20 5/4/2018 red, tan and green silty clay red and tan silty clay ND ND 2018013639 2018013640 136 Q21 5/4/2018 red and tan silty clay red and tan silty clay ND ND 2018013641 2018013642 137 Q22 4/5/2018 red silt red and tan sandy silt 6% 1% 2018010674 2018010675 138 Q23 4/5/2018 red silt red and tan sandy silt 5% 5% 2018010672 2018010673 139 Q24 4/5/2018 red silt red and tan sandy silt 6% 1% 2018010670 2018010671 Table 2 Page 2 of 8 Sequential Number Grid Location Date Sampled Visual Classification -Shallow Visual Classification -Deep FILM Result (Area % Fly Ash) Shallow FILM Result (Area % Fly Ash) Deep PLM Sample Number Shallow PLM Sample Number Deep 140 Q25 10/4/2017 red -brown sandy silt red -brown sandy silt ND ND 2017035119 2017035120 141 Q26 10/4/2017 red -brown sandy silt red -brown sandy silt ND ND 2017035121 2017035122 142 Q27 10/5/2017 red -brown sandy silt red -brown sandy silt ND ND 2017035131 2017035132 143 Q28 9/21/2018 red tan sandy silt red, white clayey silt ND 3% 2018029957 2018029958 144 Q29 9/21/2018 red tan sandy silt red and tan silty clay ND ND 2018029959 2018029960 145 Q30 10/8/2018 brown and green sand tan, black and green sand 14% ND 2018032439 2018032440 146 Q31 10/24/2018 dark gray clay dark gray clay 1% ND 2018034006 2018034007 147 Q32 10/4/2018 red silty clay red an brown silty clay ND ND 2018031892 2018031893 148 Q33 10/3/2018 red -brown sandy silt red -brown sandy silt 1% 1% 2018031752 2018031753 149 Q34 10/4/2018 brown silty clay brown silty clay ND ND 2018031886 2018031886 150 Q35 9/24/2018 red and tan clayey silt red and tan clayey silt ND 2% 2018030243 2018030244 151 Q36 9/24/2018 red clayey silt red and tan clayey silt 3% 2% 2018030237 2018030238 152 R20W55 4/13/2018 red and tan sandy silt red and tan sandy silt 1% 1% 2018011368 2018011369 153 R20 4/10/2018 red, brown, light tan clayey silt red, brown, light tan clayey silt ND ND 2018010912 2018010913 154 R21 5/4/2018 red, tan and black sandy silt red and tan sandy silt ND ND 2018013643 2018013644 155 R22 4/10/2018 drk brwn clayey silt tan, black and red sandy silt 6% 1% 2018010916 2018010917 156 R23 9/6/2018 red, black and tan clayey silt red, black and tan clayey silt ND ND 2018028568 2018028569 157 R24 4/5/2018 red silt red and tan silt 5% 1% 2018010668 2018010669 158 R25 5/3/2018 red and white clayey silt red clayey silt ND 1% 2018013637 2018013638 159 R26 10/5/2017 red,yellow,white,grey sandy silt red -brown sandy silt ND ND 2017035133 2017035134 160 R27 7/20/2018 red and tan clay red and tan clay 0% 0% 10444581 10444582 161 R28 9/21/2018 brown red clayey silt red tan and black sandy silt ND 1% 2018029961 2018029962 162 R29 10/15/2018 red clayey silt with some organic soil red clayey silt with some organic soil ND ND 2018032884 2018032885 163 R30 10/24/2018 dark gray clay brown silty clay 6% ND 2018034004 2018034005 164 R31 10/9/2018 grey sandy silt grey sandy silt ND ND 2018032427 2018032428 165 R32 10/3/2018 reddish brown silty clay red silty clay ND 1% 2018031748 2018031749 166 R33 10/4/2018 reddish brown silty clay red silty clay ND Refusal 2018031883 167 R34 10/4/2018 red and tan silty clay red and tan silty clay ND ND 2018031890 2018031891 168 R35 9/24/2018 red, tan and black clayey silt red, tan and black clayey silt 2% ND 2018030245 2018030246 169 R36 9/24/2018 red and tan clayey silt red and tan clayey silt 1% 1% 2018030235 2018030236 170 S20W50 4/13/2018 red and tan sandy silt red and tan sandy silt ND 1% 2018011370 2018011371 171 S20 5/4/2018 tan and red clayey silt red and tan silty clay ND 1% 2018013645 2018013646 172 S21 4/10/2018 drk brwn silty clay drk brwn silty clay 1% ND 2018010908 2018010909 173 522 4/10/2018 drk brwn and red silty clay drk brwn, black and red sandy silt 1% 2% 2018010906 2018010907 174 S23 4/10/2018 drk brwn and red clayey silt tan, red and brown sandy silt 2% ND 2018010900 2018010901 175 S24 9/6/2018 brown and tan slity clay brown and tan slity clay 2% 1% 2018028570 2018028571 176 S25 4/6/2018 drk brwn and red clayey silt red and tan silt 3% 2% 2018010582 2018010583 177 526 9/6/2018 drk brwn clayey silt red, tan and drk brwn silt 1% 2% 2018028572 2018028573 178 S27 7/20/2018 red and tan Clay red and tan Clay ND ND 2018023080 2018023081 179 528 10/8/2018 tan and red clayey silt tan red and black clayey silt ND 4% 2018032457 2018032436 180 S29 10/8/2018 red and tan sandy silt red and tan sandy silt ND ND 2018032437 2018032438 181 S30 1/11/2019 grey clayey silt (composite) grey clayey silt (composite) ND ND 2019001085 2019001086 182 S31 1/9/2019 grey clayey silt (composite) grey clayey silt (composite) ND ND 2019001056 2019001057 183 532 10/3/2018 red and brown silt refusal at 1ft ND Refusal 2018031754 184 S33 7/23/2018 red and tan silty clay red and tan silty clay ND ND 2018023088 2018023089 185 534 7/23/2018 red Silt red Silt ND ND 2018023092 2018023093 186 S35 10/15/2018 red and tan silty clay red and tan silty clay ND ND 2018032893 2018032894 187 S36 9/24/2018 red silty clay red silty clay ND ND 2018030233 2018030234 188 T20W50 4/17/2018 red and tan clayey silt red and tan clayey silt 1% ND 2018011872 2018011873 189 T20 4/13/2018 red and tan clayey silt tan and red sandy silt ND ND 2018011352 2018011353 190 T21 8/8/2018 red silty clay red silty clay ND 2% 2018025219 2018025220 191 T22 9/6/2018 tan and grey clayer silt tan and grey clayer silt ND ND 2018028574 2018028575 192 T23 7/20/2018 dark brown and tan silty clay dark brown and tan silty clay ND ND 2018023084 2018023085 193 T24 8/8/2018 red silty clay refusal to drill due to rock ND Refusal 2018025221 194 T25 7/20/2018 red and tan silt red and tan silt 5% ND 2018023077 2018023078 195 T26 8/8/2018 red and tan silty clay red and tan silty clay ND ND 2018025199 2018025202 196 T27 10/15/2018 red silty clay with some organic red silty clay with some organic ND ND 2018032887 2018032888 197 T28 9/25/2018 tan, white and pink sandy silt tan and brown sandy silt 1% ND 2018030492 2018030493 198 T29 10/15/2018 red brown clayey silt Refusal to drill @ 1ft 6% Refusal 2018032886 199 T30 11/29/2018 yellow sand and light gray clay light gray clay 1% ND 2018037481 2018037482 200 T31 10/6/2018 red and brown Sandy Silt tan and brown sandy silt ND ND 2018032466 2018032467 201 T32 12/19/2018 red silty clay red silty clay 1% 1% 2018039839 2018039840 202 T33 7/23/2018 red and brown silty clay red and brown silty clay ND 1% 2018023090 2018023091 203 T34 10/15/2018 light brown, tan clayey silt light brown, tan clayey silt ND ND 2018032889 2018032890 204 T35 10/15/2018 red clayey silt red clayey silt ND ND 2018032891 2018032892 205 T36 9/24/2018 dark brown clayey silt red and brown silty clay 1% 1% 2018030230 2018030232 206 U20W45 4/17/2018 red and tan sandy silt red and tan sandy silt ND ND 2018011874 2018011875 207 U20 4/13/2018 tan sandy silt tan and red sandy silt ND ND 2018011354 2018011355 208 U21 10/24/2018 dark brown gray clay dark gray clay ND 2% 2018033984 2018033990 209 U22 9/6/2018 red and dark brown silty clay red and dark brown silty clay 2% ND 2018028576 2018028577 210 U23 8/8/2018 drk brwn, red and black silty clay brwn, tan and black silty clay 2% ND 2018025207 2018025208 211 U24 8/8/2018 red silty clay red and tan silty clay 2% ND 2018025205 2018025206 212 U25 8/8/2018 red and brown silty clay light brown clay ND ND 2018025203 2018025204 Table 2 Page 3 of 8 Sequential Number Grid Location Date Sampled Visual Classification -Shallow Visual Classification -Deep FILM Result (Area % Fly Ash) Shallow FILM Result (Area % Fly Ash) Deep PLM Sample Number Shallow PLM Sample Number Deep 213 U26 12/7/2018 light brown silty clay brown silty clay w/black organic matter ND ND 2018038550 2018038551 214 U27 10/15/2018 dark brown silty clay red and tan sandy silt 17% ND 2018032882 2018032883 215 U28 9/25/2018 tan, red and white sandy silt tan and white sandy silt ND ND 2018030490 2018030491 216 U29 9/25/2018 tan and brown sandy silt tan and brown sandy silt ND ND 2018030494 2018030495 217 U30 11/29/2018 light gray clay light gray clay ND ND 2018037479 2018037480 218 U31 10/9/2018 brown clay brown clay ND 1% 2018032425 2018032426 219 U32 12/19/2018 red and yellow silty clay red and yellow silty clay ND ND 2018039841 2018039842 220 U33 3/16/2019 tan and red clayey silt tan and red clayey silt 2% 2% 2019008067 2019008079 221 U34 10/2/2018 pink and tan sandy silt tan and red sandy silt 3% 2% 2018031764 2018031765 222 U35 10/4/2018 red silty clay Refusal at 1 ft (hit rock) ND Refusal 2018031882 223 U36 10/2/2018 red clayey silt red clayey silt ND ND 2018031757 2018031758 224 V20W45 4/17/2018 red and tan sandy silt red and tan sandy silt ND 1% 2018011876 2018011877 225 V20 4/13/2018 red and tan clayey silt red and tan clayey silt ND ND 2018011356 2018011357 226 V21 10/24/2018 red and brown clay red and tan sandy silt ND 1% 2018033993 2018033994 227 V22 8/8/2018 red silty clay red silty clay ND 3% 2018025209 2018025210 228 V23 8/8/2018 red and tan silty clay red and tan silty clay ND ND 2018025212 2018025211 229 V24 8/8/2018 red and tan silty clay red and tan silty clay ND 1% 2018025213 2018025214 230 V25 8/8/2018 red and tan silty clay red and tan silty clay 1% 2% 2018025215 2018025216 231 V26 9/25/2018 dark brown, black and red sandy silt dark brown sandy silt ND 6% 2018030498 2018030499 232 V27 9/25/2018 dark brown sandy silt dark brown, black and red sandy silt 3% 1% 2018030496 2018030497 233 V28 11/19/2018 red and yellow silt red and yellow silt ND ND 2018036898 2018036899 234 V29 10/25/2018 red silty clay red and yellow silty clay ND ND 2018034241 2018034250 235 V30 11/30/2018 red silt & dark gray organic yellow silt & dark gray organic ND 5% 2018037499 2018037500 236 V31 1/31/2019 gray clayey organic brown silt & light gray clay ND ND 2019003080 2019003081 237 V32 11/30/2018 red silty clay red silty clay ND ND 2018037507 2018037508 238 V33 3/16/2019 red and brown silty clay red and brown silty clay 2% 1% 2019008080 2019008081 239 V34 3/16/2019 tan, red and dark brown silty clay red and dark brown silty clay 3% 2% 2019008082 2019008083 240 V35 10/4/2018 red silty clay red silty clay w black organic matter 1% ND 2018031884 2018031885 241 V36 10/2/2018 red clayey silt red clayey silt ND ND 2018031759 2018031760 242 W20 4/13/2018 red and tan clayey silt red and tan clayey silt ND ND 2018011358 2018011359 243 W20W40 4/17/2018 red and tan sandy silt red and tan sandy silt 1% 2% 2018011878 2018011879 244 W21 1/23/2019 dark brown and grey tan clayey silt ND ND 2019002230 2019002231 245 W22 10/24/2018 brown silty sand hand auger refusal at -1' ND Refusal 2018033991 246 W23 10/25/2018 dark brown clayey silt yellowish gray clay ND ND 2018034240 2018034249 247 W24 8/8/2018 red and tan silty clay red and tan silty clay ND ND 2018025217 2018025218 248 W25 12/7/2018 red and yellow silty clay red and yellow silty clay ND ND 2018038554 2018038555 249 W26 9/25/2018 tan and red sandy silt tan white sandy silt ND ND 2018030500 2018030501 250 W27 11/19/2018 red and brown silt red and yellow silt 3% 1% 2018036902 2018036903 251 W28 11/19/2018 red, yellow, and white silt red, yellow, and white silt ND ND 2018036896 2018036897 252 W29 10/25/2018 reddish brown silty clay red, yellow, and white silt 1% ND 2018034242 2018034251 253 W30 11/30/2018 light gray clay with yellow silt light gray clay with yellow silt ND ND 2018037491 2018037492 254 W31 11/30/2018 yellowish brown sand light gray clay 2% ND 2018037493 2018037494 255 W32 11/30/2018 red clayey silt red clayey silt ND ND 2018037489 2018037490 256 W33 3/14/2019 red and and tan clay red and and tan clay 2% 3% 2019008007 201900--- 8 257 W34 3/14/2019 tan and red silty clay tan and red silty clay 2% 2% 2019008009 2019008010 258 W35 10/2/2018 red Silty Sand red silty sand 3% 2% 2018031762 2018031763 259 W36 10/2/2018 red Silty clay refusal to drill due to rock ND Refusal 2018031761 260 X20W40 4/17/2018 red and tan clayey silt red and tan Silty clay ND ND 2018011880 2018011881 261 X20 10/24/2018 red clay and white silt red clay and white silt 4% 1% 2018034008 2018034009 262 X21 1/22/2019 dark grey and black silt (composite) dark grey and black silt (composite) 3% ND 2019001892 2019001893 263 X22 1/22/2019 dark grey and black silt (composite) dark grey and black silt (composite) 10% 13% 2019001894 2019001895 264 X23 1/31/2019 brown, green and gray clay gray sandy clay ND ND 2019003086 2019003087 265 X24 1/31/2019 red and tan silt Gray and brown silty clay ND ND 2019003088 2019003089 266 X25 12/7/2018 light gray clay w/green organic matter light gray clay w/green organic matter ND ND 2018038540 2018038541 267 X26 1/31/2019 tan clayey silt with traces of organics tan clayey silt with traces of organics ND 5% 2019003090 2019003091 268 X27 10/25/2018 yellow silt and gray clay yellow and white silty clay ND 2% 2018034239 2018034248 269 X28 11/19/2018 red clayey silt yellow and red silt 3% 2% 2018036904 2018036905 270 X29 11/21/2018 red and yellow silt red and yellow silt ND ND 2018036970 2018036971 271 X30 1/31/2019 white, yellow silt and gray organic light gray clay with red silt ND ND 2019003084 2019003085 272 X31 11/30/2018 light gray clay light gray clay ND ND 2018037503 2018037504 273 X32 11/30/2018 red and yellow clayey silt red and yellow clayey silt ND ND 2018037487 2018037488 274 X33 3/14/2019 tan and red clay tan and red clay 3% 3% 2019008005 2019008006 275 X34 3/14/2019 red and brown clay red and brown clay 3% 3% 2019008003 2019008004 276 X35 3/14/2019 brown and tan silty clay brown and tan silty clay ND ND 2019008001 2019008002 277 Y20W45 4/17/2018 red and tan sandy silt red and tan sandy silt ND ND 2018011882 2018011883 278 Y20 1/23/2019 red and tan clay red Clay ND ND 2019002214 2019002215 279 Y21 1/23/2019 tan Sandy silt tan Sandy silt 2% 2% 2019002212 2019002213 280 Y22 10/24/2018 red and yellow silt red and white silt 5% 1% 2018034010 2018034011 281 Y23 10/24/2018 red, tan, and white silt tan, red, and white silt 2% ND 2018034012 201803401-1 282 Y24 1/31/2019 tan clayey silt gray and tan clayey silt ND ND 2019003097 2019003098 283 Y25 1/31/2019 Gray sandy clay Gray sandy clay 1% 1% 2019003095 2019003096 284 Y26 1/31/2019 Gray sandy clay Gray sandy clay 1% 1% 2019003092 2019003093 285 Y27 10/25/2018 yellow silty sand light gray clay with yellow sand ND ND 2018034238 2018034247 Table 2 Page 4 of 8 Sequential Number Grid Location Date Sampled Visual Classification -Shallow Visual Classification -Deep FILM Result (Area % Fly Ash) Shallow FILM Result (Area % Fly Ash) Deep FILM Sample Number Shallow PLM Sample Number Deep 286 Y28 1/31/2019 brown sand auger refusal 3% Refusal 2019003094 287 Y29 11/19/2018 dark reddish brown silt with gravel yellow silt and light gray clay 3% ND 2018036900 2018036901 288 Y30 11/30/2018 light gray clay $ dark gray organic light gray clay 13% 1% 2018037497 2018037498 289 Y31 1/31/2019 light gray clay & dark gray organic light gray clay with brown silt ND 1% 2019003082 2019003083 290 Y32 11/30/2018 yellow silt and light gray clay light gray clay ND ND 2018037485 2018037486 291 Y33 10/22/2018 Light brown sand with silt Light brown sand with silt 1% ND 2018033513 2018033514 292 Y34 10/22/2018 red and grey sandy silt red and grey sandy silt 1% 3% 2018033511 2018033512 293 Y35 10/22/2018 red and pink sand with silt red and pink sand with silt 3% 1% 2018033505 2018033506 294 Z03 10/1/2018 brown and red sandy silt brown and light red sandy silt ND 6% 2018031219 2018031220 295 Z04 10/1/2018 Light brown sandy silt Light brown sandy silt ND ND 2018031217 2018031218 296 Z05 10/1/2018 tan and red sandy silt tan and light red sandy silt 2% 2% 2018031221 2018031222 297 Z06 10/1/2018 tan and brown sandy silt tan and brown sandy silt 1% 4% 2018031225 2018031226 298 Z07 10/8/2018 red and tan sand red and tan sandy silt ND ND 2018032447 2018032448 299 Z08 10/4/2018 red and brown silty clay red and brown silty clay ND ND 2018031870 2018031871 300 Z09 10/4/2018 red and brown silty clay red and brown silty clay ND ND 2018031892 2018031893 301 Z10 10/4/2018 brown silty clay brown silty clay ND ND 2018031866 2018031867 302 Z11 10/5/2018 red and brown silt red and brown silt 1% ND 2018033513 2018033514 303 Z12 10/5/2018 red and brown silt red and brown silt ND ND 2018032024 2018032025 304 Z13 12/19/2018 red and brown silty clay red and gold silty clay 1% 1% 2018039820 2018039821 305 Z14 12/19/2018 brown clayey silt brown clayey silt 1% ND 2018039822 2018039823 306 Z15 1/9/2019 dark brown sandy silt dark brown and tan sandy silt ND ND 2019001043 2019001044 307 Z16 1/9/2019 brown sandy silt red sandy clay ND ND 2019001058 2019001059 308 Z17 1/9/2019 dark brown clay with hue of organic red Clay 3% ND 2019001047 2019001048 309 Z20 1/23/2019 tan sandy silt tan sandy silt ND ND 2019002218 2019002219 310 Z21 1/23/2019 red clay red sandy clay ND ND 2019002216 2019002217 311 Z22 1/23/2019 red clay red clay ND ND 2019002226 2019002227 312 Z23 10/25/2018 red and yellow silt red and yellow silt 1% 2% 2018034234 2018034243 313 Z24 10/25/2018 yellow silty sand light gray and yellow sand ND ND 2018034235 2018034244 314 Z25 10/25/2018 red with yellow silt red clayey silt ND ND 2018034236 2018034245 315 Z26 10/25/2018 red silty sand red silty sand 1% ND 2018034237 2018034246 316 Z27 1/31/2019 brown and tan sand brown and tan sand 1% ND 2019003103 2019003104 317 Z28 1/31/2019 red clayey silt red clayey silt 1% ND 2019003105 2019003106 318 Z29 11/21/2018 red silt red and yellow silt ND ND 2018036972 2018036973 319 Z30 2/11/2017 no visible ash no visible ash ND ND 10398168 10398169 320 Z31 11/2/2018 tan silt and gray clay light gray sandy clay ND ND 2018035262 2018035263 321 Z32 11/2/2018 light gray clay light gray clay ND ND 2018035264 2018035265 322 Z33 10/24/2018 red and tan micacious silt red, tan, and white silt ND ND 2018034001 2018034002 323 Z34 10/22/2018 Yelowish pink sand yellow and brown sand with silt 2% 2% 2018033509 2018033510 324 Z35 10/22/2018 red and tan silty clay with organics red and brown sand with silt ND 1% 2018033507 2018033508 325 AA03 11/8/2018 dark gray sandy silt brown silt with dark gray silt 8% ND 2018035947 2018035950 326 AA04 10/1/2018 red silty clay red Silty Clay 1% ND 2018031215 2018031216 327 AAOS 10/1/2018 white and brown sand white and brown sand ND 1% 2018031235 2018031236 328 AA06 10/1/2018 red and brown clayey silt tan and brown sand 1% ND 2018031223 2018031224 329 AA07 10/8/2018 grey fine grained material (suspected organics) grey fine grained material (suspected organics) ND ND 2018032443 2018032444 330 AA08 10/4/2018 red silty clay red silty clay ND ND 2018031878 2018031879 331 AA09 10/4/2018 reddish brown silty clay reddish brown silty clay ND ND 2018031876 2018031877 332 AA10 10/4/2018 red and brown silty clay red and brown silty clay ND ND 2018031860 2018031861 333 AA11 10/6/2018 red silty sand red sandy silt ND ND 2018032462 2018032463 334 AA12 10/5/2018 red clayey silt red clayey silt ND ND 2018032020 2018032021 335 AA13 1/9/2019 dark brown and tan sandy silt red Sandy clay ND ND 2019001045 2019001046 336 AA14 1/9/2019 tan sandy silt tan sandy silt ND ND 2019001049 2019001050 337 AA15 2/8/2019 black cinders and ash black cinders and ash 19% 8% 2019004231 2019004232 338 AA20 1/23/2019 dark brown sandy clay dark brown sandy clay 15% ND 2019002220 2019002221 339 AA21 1/23/2019 tan and red silty sand tan sandy silt 2% ND 2019002222 2019002223 340 AA22 1/23/2019 tan sandy silt tan sandy silt ND ND 2019002224 2019002225 341 AA23 2/1/2019 tan silt tan and white silt 1% 1% 2019003168 2019003169 342 AA24 2/1/2019 red and tan silt red and tan silt ND ND 2019003166 2019003167 343 AA25 2/1/2019 red silt red clayey silt ND ND 2019003164 2019003165 344 AA26 2/1/2019 red silt red silt with gravel ND ND 2019003162 2019003163 345 AA27 2/1/2019 brown sandy silt red sandy silt ND ND 2019003160 2019003161 346 AA28 2/11/2017 no visible ash no visible ash ND ND 10398170 10398171 347 AA29 2/11/2017 no visible ash no visible ash ND ND 10398172 10398173 348 AA30 2/11/2017 no visible ash no visible ash ND ND 10398164 10398165 349 AA31 2/11/2017 no visible ash no visible ash ND ND 10398175 10398176 350 AA32 10/24/2018 light gray sandy silt light gray sandy silt ND ND 2018033997 2018033998 351 AA33 10/24/2018 red brown silty sand brownish gray silt 1% ND 2018033995 2018033996 352 AA34 10/22/2018 tan and red sand with silt tan and red sand with silt 3% 2% 2018033515 2018033516 353 BB04 8/15/2018 grey and tan clayey silt grey and tan clayey silt 6% 0% 2018025837 2018025838 354 BBOS 10/1/2018 black and brown sandy silt black and brown sandy silt 3% 3% 2018031233 2018031234 355 BB06 10/1/2018 tan and white sand white sand ND 1% 2018031227 2018031228 326 BB07 10/8/2018 grey, red and black clayey material grey, red and black clayey material ND ND 2018032445 2018032446 357 6608 10/4/2018 red and brown silty clay red and brown silty ND ND 2018031858 2018031859 Table 2 Page 5 of 8 Sequential Number Grid Location Date Sampled Visual Classification -Shallow Visual Classification -Deep FILM Result (Area % Fly Ash) Shallow FILM Result (Area % Fly Ash) Deep FILM Sample Number Shallow PLM Sample Number Deep 358 BB09 10/4/2018 brown silty clay red brown silty clay ND ND 2018031868 2018031869 359 BB10 10/4/2018 reddish brown silty clay red and brown silty clay ND ND 2018031862 2018031863 360 BB11 10/6/2018 red sandy silt red sandy silt ND ND 2018032464 2018032465 361 BB12 1/9/2019 red sandy clay red and tan sandy clay 1% ND 2019001039 2019001040 362 BB13 1/9/2019 red sandy silt red sandy silt ND ND 2019001041 2019001042 363 BB17 2/28/2019 dark brown silt red and dark brown clayey silt ND ND 2019006294 2019006295 364 BB18 2/28/2019 red clay red clay ND 3% 2019006292 2019006293 365 BB19 2/13/2019 dark brown and red silty clay dark brown and red silty clay ND ND 2019004807 2019004808 366 BB20 2/4/2019 red sandy clay red sandy clay ND 2% 2019003351 2019003353 367 BB21 2/4/2019 red and tan silty clay red and tan sandy silt 1% ND 2019003349 2019003350 368 BB22 2/4/2019 dark brown and grey sandy silt white and grey sand 3% 2% 2019003347 2019003348 369 BB23 2/7/2019 brown sandy silt brown sandy silt 3% 3% 2019004214 2019004215 370 BB24 2/1/2019 red silt red silt 3% 5% 2019003176 2019003177 371 BB25 2/1/2019 red silt red clayey silt 6% 3% 2019003174 2019003175 372 BB26 2/1/2019 red and tan silt tan, red, and white silt 3% ND 2019003172 2019003173 373 BB27 2/1/2019 red and tan silt red, tan, and white silt 6% ND 2019003170 2019003171 374 BB28 12/19/2018 red brown sandy silt red brown sandy silt ND ND 2018039833 2018039834 375 BB29 12/19/2018 bluish gray clay (composite) grayish brown clay (composite) 23% ND 2018039835 2018039837 376 BB30 2/11/2017 no visible ash no visible ash ND ND 10398166 10398167 377 BB31 12/19/2018 red and yellow sandy silt (composite) red and yellow sandy silt (composite) 4% ND 2018039832 2018039833 378 BB32 12/19/2018 brown silty clay brown silty clay ND 2% 2018039837 2018039838 379 BB33 10/24/2018 red and brown silty clay reddish brown sand 3% 4% 2018033999 2018034000 380 BB34 10/22/2018 red and brown silty clay red and brown silty clay 3% 2% 2018033517 2018033518 381 CC04 10/1/2018 dark brown, black stoney sand dark brown, black stoney sand 12% 21% 2018031237 2018031238 382 CC05 10/1/2018 red clayey silt red and tan clayey silt ND ND 2018031231 2018031232 383 0006 12/7/2018 tan sandy clay brown silty clay ND ND 2018038558 2018038559 384 CC07 4/6/2018 red clayey silt red clayey silt ND 2% 2018010365 2018010366 385 CC08 10/4/2018 brown and dark sandy clay brown sandy clay 1% ND 2018031874 2018031875 386 CC09 10/4/2018 brown silty clay brown and red silty clay 1% 1% 2018031872 2018031873 387 CC10 10/4/2018 red and brown silty clay tan and brown silty clay ND ND 2018031864 2018031865 388 CC11 10/4/2018 red sandy silt red and brown silty clay ND ND 2018031880 2018031881 389 CC12 12/19/2018 red and gold silty clay red and gold sandy silt 2% 1% 2018039818 2018039819 390 CC15 2/28/2019 red and white clayey silt red and white clayey silt 2% 2% 2019006296 2019006297 391 CC16 2/28/2019 tan and red silt tan and brown silt 1% 1% 2019006298 2019006299 392 CC17 2/28/2019 dark brown silty clay red and dark brown silty clay 3% ND 2019006300 2019006301 393 CC18 2/14/2019 dark brown and grey silt dark brown, green and grey silt 2% 1% 2019004980 2019004981 394 CC19 2/14/2019 dark grey silt with organics Refusal due to roots 9% Refusal 2019004979 395 CC20 2/4/2019 white and pink sand white and tan sand 2% 3% 2019003353 2019003354 396 CC21 2/13/2019 red clayey silt tan and red clayey silt ND ND 2019004803 2019004804 397 CC22 2/13/2019 red clay tan sandy silt ND 3% 2019004805 2019004806 398 CC23 12/19/2018 red silty clay red and gold silty clay 3% 1% 2018039828 2018039829 399 CC24 12/19/2018 red silty clay red silty clay ND ND 2018039826 2018039827 400 CC25 12/19/2018 red silty clay red silty clay 1% ND 2018039824 2018039825 401 CC26 12/7/2018 red silty clay red silty clay 2% ND 2018038562 2018038563 402 CC27 1/9/2019 dark brown clayey silt with hues of grey Refusal due to rocks ND Refusal 2019001055 403 CC28 1/9/2019 dark brown mixed with Gravel fines red and tan sandy silt 2% 1% 2019001053 2019001054 404 DD04 8/15/2018 tan and grey sandy silt black sand with fine gravel 5% 9% 2018025839 2018025840 405 DD05 10/1/2018 green and brown sandy silt white and tan sand 1% ND 2018031229 2018031230 406 DD06 4/6/2018 red sandy silt tan silty sand ND 1% 2018010367 2018010368 407 DD07 4/6/2018 red silt red silt ND ND 2018010369 2018010370 408 DD08 12/13/2018 dark grey silty clay w/wood particles dark grey silty clay w/wood particles 6% ND 2018039215 2018039219 409 DD09 12/13/2018 grey silty clay dark grey silty clay w/potential ash 1% ND 2018039220 2018039221 410 DD10 12/13/2018 red silty clay refusal due to rock at 1 ft ND Refusal 2018039222 411 DD13 2/27/2019 red sandy clay red sandy clay 1% 3% 2019006091 2019006092 412 DD14 2/27/2019 grey and white sandy silt grey and white sandy silt ND ND 2019006085 2019006086 413 DD15 2/27/2019 red and white sandy silt red and white sandy silt 2% 2% 2019006089 2019006090 414 DD16 2/27/2019 red and white sandy silt red and white sandy silt 2% 39/. 2019006087 2019006088 Table 2 Page 6 of 8 Sequential Number Grid Location Date Sampled Visual Classification -Shallow Visual Classification -Deep FILM Result (Area % Fly Ash) Shallow FILM Result (Area % Fly Ash) Deep PLM Sample Number Shallow PLM Sample Number Deep 415 DD17 2/14/2019 dark brown sandy silt dark brown sandy silt ND 1% 2019004984 2019004985 416 DD18 2/14/2019 tan sandy silt tan sandy silt 1% 2% 2019004982 2019004983 417 DD19 1 2/14/2019 red sandy silt red sandy silt ND ND 2019004977 2019004978 418 DD20 2/14/2019 tan and red silty clay tan and red silty clay with organics 2% ND 2019004975 2019004976 419 DD21 2/14/2019 tan and brown sandy silt tan and brown sandy silt 2% 2% 2019004973 2019004974 420 DD22 1/11/2019 tan sandy silt tan sandy silt 1% ND 2019001083 2019001084 421 DD23 1/11/2019 red clay red and dark brown clay ND ND 2019001060 2019001061 422 DD24 12/19/2019 red and yellow silty clay red and yellow silty clay 7% 13% 2018039830 2018039831 423 DD25 12/7/2018 tan and red sandy clay red and white sandy clay 2% ND 2018038568 2018038569 424 DD26 12/7/2018 white and red sandy clay white, red, and yellow silt ND ND 2018038560 2018038561 425 DD27 1/9/2019 tan Sandy silt tan and red sandy silt 2% ND 2019001051 2019001052 426 EE04 10/1/2018 black stoney sand black stoney sand 4% 16% 2018031241 2018031242 427 EE05 4/6/2018 It brwn sandy silt It brwn clayey silt 1% 1% 2018010371 2018010372 428 EE06 4/6/2018 It brwn sandy silt red silt 2% ND 2018010373 2018010374 429 EE07 4/6/2018 red clayey silt red silt 2% ND 2018010375 2018010376 430 EE08 12/19/2018 red silty clay with gray sand gray sandy clay 3% ND 2018039843 2018039844 431 EE11 1/31/2019 tan silt tan and white silt ND 3% 2019003099 2019003100 432 EE12 1/31/2019 red silt red and tan silt 2% 1% 2019003101 2019003102 433 EE13 2/27/2019 tan and brown sandy silt red and brown clayey silt 1% ND 2019006071 2019006072 434 EE14 2/27/2019 red clayey silt red clayey silt ND 1% 2019006083 2019006084 435 EE15 2/27/2019 red sandy clay tan and red clayey silt ND ND 2019006081 2019006082 436 EE16 2/27/2019 dark brown clayey silt red sandy clay 5% 1% 2019006079 2019006080 437 EE17 2/14/2019 red sandy silt red sandy silt ND ND 2019004986 2019004987 438 EE18 2/14/2019 red sandy silt red sandy silt ND ND 2019004988 2019004989 439 EE19 2/14/2019 tan and red clay tan and red clay 1% 2% 2019004990 2019004991 440 EE20 2/14/2019 tan and brown sandy silt tan and brown sandy silt 3% 2% 2019004992 2019004993 441 EE21 1/11/2019 white sand with hues of tan silt refusal ND Refusal 2019001072 442 EE22 1/11/2019 tan silty clay red silty clay 2% ND 2019001070 2019001071 443 EE23 1/11/2019 tan sandy silt tan sandy silt 4% ND 2019001062 2019001063 444 EE24 1/11/2019 red and tan sandy silt red and tan sansy silt 2% ND 2019001068 2019001069 445 EE25 12/7/2018 red and white sandy clay red and white sandy clay ND ND 2018038560 2018038561 446 EE26 12/7/2018 red and white silty clay red and white silty clay 4% 2% 2018038546 2018038547 447 FF04 10/1/2018 black stoney sand black stoney sand 26% 19% 2018031239 2018031240 448 FF05 11/29/2018 red and brown silt red and yellow clayey silt ND ND 2018037483 2018037484 449 FF06 12/7/2018 brown sandy clay brown sandy clay 1% ND 2018038552 2018038553 450 FF09 2/15/2019 tan and red clay tan and red clay 1% 2% 2019005019 2019005020 451 FF10 2/15/2019 tan and red silty clay dark brown and grey silty clay 1% 2% 2019005021 2019005022 452 FF11 2/15/2019 tan and red silty clay tan sandy silt ND ND 2019005023 2019005024 453 FF12 2/27/2019 tan clayey silt red silty clay 2% 2% 2019006075 2019006076 454 FF13 2/27/2019 brown silty clay brown silty clay 1% 1% 2019006073 2019006074 455 FF14 2/27/2019 red clayey silt brown clayey silt 1% 3% 2019006077 2019006078 456 FF15 2/4/2019 grey clayey silt with organics red and tan sandy silt 4% 1% 2019003345 2019003346 457 FF16 2/28/2019 grey and black silt with organic red clayey silt 5% 1% 2019006290 2019006291 458 FF17 2/14/2019 dark brown clayey silt dark brown clayey silt 3% 2% 2019004994 2019004995 459 FF18 2/14/2019 tan and red sandy silt tan and red sandy silt 4% 1% 2019004996 2019004997 460 FF19 2/14/2019 tan and red clay tan and red clay 2% 1% 2019004998 2019004999 461 FF20 1/11/2019 tan and red silty clay tan and red silty clay ND ND 2019001081 2019001082 462 FF21 1/11/2019 tan Sand tan sand 1% ND 2019001073 2019001074 463 FF22 1/11/2019 red and tan clayey silt red Silty clay with hues of organic 2% 2% 2019001066 2019001067 464 FF23 1/11/2019 red and tan clay red clay ND 1% 2019001064 2019001065 465 FF24 12/7/2018 red and yellow silty clay red and yellow silty clay ND ND 2018038542 2018038543 466 FF25 12/7/2018 red, yellow, and white silt red and brown silt ND 2% 2018038544 2018038545 467 FF26 12/7/2018 red silty clay red and white silty clay ND 3% 2018038548 2018038549 GG04 12/7/2018 red and white silty clay red and orange sandy clay ND 1% 2018038556 2018038557 �470 GG07 2/13/2019 red and tan clay red and tan clay ND ND 2019004787 2019004788 GG08 2/15/2019 dark brown sandy silt dark brown sandy silt 3% 2% 2019005025 2019005026 471 GG09 2/15/2019 red sandy silt red sandy silt ND 1% 2019005027 2019005028 Table 2 Page 7 of 8 Sequential Number Grid Location Date Sampled Visual Classification -Shallow Visual Classification -Deep PLM Result (Area % Fly Ash) Shallow FILM Result (Area % Fly Ash) Deep PLM Sample Number Shallow PLM Sample Number Deep 472 GG10 2/15/2019 dark brown and red clay dark brown and red clay ND ND 2019005029 2019005030 473 GG11 2/13/2019 white sand white sand ND ND 2019004789 2019004790 474 GG12 1/29/2019 red silt red silt 2% 1% 2019002666 2019002667 475 GG13 1/29/2019 red and tan silt red and white silt ND 2% 2019002664 2019002665 476 GG14 1/29/2019 brown silty clay and organic brown silt 2% 1% 2019002662 2019002663 477 GG15 1/29/2019 brown clay brown and gray sandy clay ND 1% 2019002631 2019002632 478 GG16 1/29/2019 brown sand and organic brown silty clay ND ND 2019002633 2019002634 479 GG17 1/29/2019 brown silt and organic greenish gray sand 13% ND 2019002635 2019002636 480 GG18 1/29/2019 red and tan silt greenish gray clay and organic 1% 1% 2019002637 2019002638 481 GG19 2/15/2019 tan sand tansand 1% 1% 2019005031 2019005032 482 GG20 1/11/2019 brown sandy silt brown sandy silt ND 2% 2019001079 2019001080 483 GG21 1/11/2019 brown clayey silt brown clayey silt 3% ND 2019001075 2019001076 484 GG22 1/11/2019 tan and red clay red and tan silty clay ND 1% 2019001077 2019001078 485 GG23 12/7/2018 red sandy clay refusal due to rock at 1 ft 1% Refusal 2018038570 486 GG24 12/7/2018 tan sandy clay refusal due to rock at 1 ft ND Refusal 2018038571 487 GG25 12/7/2018 red and orange sandy clay red and orange sandy clay 1% ND 2018038566 2018038567 488 HH06 2/7/2019 brown sandy silt dark red sandy silt 1% 1% 2019004216 2019004217 489 HH07 2/13/2019 red and tan sandy silt red, grey and tan sandy silt ND ND 2019004791 2019004792 490 HH08 2/15/2019 tan clay tan clay ND ND 2019005013 2019005014 491 HH09 2/15/2019 red sandy silt red sandy silt ND 1% 2019005015 2019005016 492 1-11-110 2/15/2019 brown and tan clay brown and tan silty clay 1% ND 2019005017 2019005018 493 HH11 2/13/2019 white and red sand white and red sand ND ND 2019004793 2019004794 494 HH12 1/29/2019 tan sandy silt grayish tan sandy silt ND ND 2019002660 2019002661 495 HH13 1/29/2019 white and tan silty sand white and tan silty sand ND ND 2019002643 2019002644 496 HH14 1/29/2019 red and white silt red and white silt 1% ND 2019002641 2019002642 497 HH15 1/29/2019 red silty clay red silty clay ND 1% 2019002660 2019002630 498 HH16 1/29/2019 brown clayey silt brown sand 2% 1% 2019002656 2019002657 499 HH17 1/29/2019 brown silt red and tan silt 1% ND 2019002655 2019002656 500 HH18 1/29/2019 reddish brown silt red and tan silt ND ND 2019002653 2019002654 501 HH19 1/29/2019 brown and white silty sand white and brown sandy silt 3% ND 2019002649 2019002650 502 HH2O 1/29/2019 red, tan, and white silt tan, white silt and gravel 2% ND 2019002651 2019002652 503 JJ08 2/13/2019 dark brown and red clayey silt dark brown and red clayey silt ND ND 2019004795 2019004796 504 JJ09 2/13/2019 red clay red and dark brown clay 3% 1% 2019004797 2019004798 505 JJ10 2/13/2019 red sandy silt red and tan sandy silt ND ND 2019004799 2019004800 506 1111 2/13/2019 red clayey silt red clayey silt ND 1% 2019004801 2019004802 507 JJ12 2/8/2019 red and orange silt red and orange silt 2% 2% 2019004233 2019004234 508 JJ13 2/5/2019 red silty clay red silty clay ND ND 2019003706 2019003707 509 JJ14 2/5/2019 dark brown silty clay brown silty clay 8% 5% 2019003704 2019003705 510 JJ15 2/5/2019 brown sandy silt red Sandy clay 6% 2% 2019003702 2019003703 511 1116 2/5/2019 red and grey sandy silt brown and grey sandy silt 2% 5% 2019003692 2019003701 512 JJ17 2/4/2019 red clayey silt red and tan sandy silt 1% 1% 2012003343 2019003344 513 JJ18 1 1/29/2019 red and yellow silt red and white silt 2% ND 2019002639 2019002640 Table 2 Page 8 of 8 Table 3 - Summary of Grid Points with Offsets CCR Visual Removal Verification Report Riverbend Steam Station Point ID Approximate Offset from Grid Point Reason for Offset DD04 30' W Sample taken at the base of steep slope due to safety concerns. DD10 20' N Sample taken at offset because grid point was located on railroad balllast. H25 25' S Sample taken at the base of steep slope due to safety concerns. H32 20' W Sample taken at offset due to ponded water at the grid point location. 132 20' W Sample taken at offset due to ponded water at the grid point location. J32 10' W Sample taken at offset due to ponded water at the grid point location. J33 10' S, 10' W Sample taken at offset due to ponded water at the grid point location. K24 35' S, 25' W Sample taken at the base of steep slope due to safety concerns. N22 25' W Sample taken at the base of steep slope due to safety concerns. 021W50 50' W Sample taken at crest of the Primary Dam in addition to normal grid sampling. P20W10 10' W Sample taken at crest of the Primary Dam in addition to normal grid sampling. Q20W47 47' W Sample taken at crest of the Primary Dam in addition to normal grid sampling. R20W55 55' W Sample taken at crest of the Primary Dam in addition to normal grid sampling. S20 40' E Sample taken at the base of steep slope due to safety concerns. S20W50 50' W Sample taken at crest of the Primary Dam in addition to normal grid sampling. T20W50 50' W Sample taken at crest of the Primary Dam in addition to normal grid sampling. U20W45 45' W Sample taken at crest of the Primary Dam in addition to normal grid sampling. V20W45 45' W Sample taken at crest of the Primary Dam in addition to normal grid sampling. W20W40 40' W Sample taken at crest of the Primary Dam in addition to normal grid sampling. X20W40 40' W Sample taken at crest of the Primary Dam in addition to normal grid sampling. Y20W45 45' W Sample taken at crest of the Primary Dam in addition to normal grid sampling. Table 3 Page 1 of 1