Loading...
HomeMy WebLinkAbout3 - Combined Response to ADI 5July 6, 2021, ADI Letter #5 Response to questions concerning sound study, blasting, and post -reclamation lakes 1. Concerning the sound study your firm conducted for this modification, please provide the items below: a. The reasoning for using a slow response vs a fast response when recording with the sound meters, b. An explanation of how intrusive noises were differentiated from other background noises, and c. Data showing the blasts during the noise study were equivalent in size and location to typical production blasts. WSC Response Responses to questions 1.a. and 1.b. were provided verbally during a TEAMS call between NCDEMLR, Wake Stone Corporation, and WSP, USA Inc. on June 25, 2021. Erich Thalheimer of WSP has summarized those responses in the attached memorandum sent to Sam Bratton, President of Wake Stone Corporation on July 8, 2021. WSC Response to Question 1.c. Two typical production blasts occurred during the noise study data collection period. The first blast occurred on November 18, 2020 at 1:3913M. This blast was located on the-40'MSL production bench (42' bench height) and consisted of 30 blast holes. A total of 14,617 pounds of explosive agents were utilized to generate approximately 16,000 tons of shot rock for production through the primary and secondary plants. The blast event had a maximum duration/delay of 0.238 seconds. The second production blast occurred on December 9, 2020 at 11:36AM. This blast was conducted on the-40'MSL (42' bench height) production bench and consisted of 33 blast holes loaded with 16,335 pounds of explosive agents. This blast generated 13,798 tons of stone for production through the primary and secondary plants. The blast event had a maximum duration/delay of 0.223 seconds. Copies of the complete blast reports, including wiring/delay diagrams are attached, as are weekly operating summaries for the periods of time during which the blasts were conducted. Both production blasts conducted during the noise study data collection were "typical" of production blast events occurring at the Triangle Quarry. Wake Stone has previously provided five years (CY 2015-2019) of blast data at the request of David Miller, State Mining Engineer. Comparison of historical blast data and the blast reports for the two production blasts conducted during the noise study period indicates that both blasts were similar in nature to production blasting that typically occurs at the Triangle Quarry. 2. Reclamation Plan, item 2 of the application, requires that if you plan to reclaim portions of the disturbed area as a lake, to supply an illustration of the location of the body(s) of water on the reclamation map and provide a scaled cross-section(s) through the proposed body(s) of water. Please supply a drawing to meet this requirement. WSC Response to Question 2. In response to question #2 above, Wake Stone has revised its Site Plan set to include Page 13 of 13. This drawing illustrates the anticipated post -mining Conceptual Reclamation Lakes and includes a scaled cross-section/profile view illustrating existing ground, proposed ultimate grading, and anticipated water surface elevations across the expansion pit and the original Triangle Quarry pit. The Site Plan set, last -revised August 4, 2021, is included in this response package. This drawing set and the PLD Erosion and Sediment Control Plan drawing set will constitute the final site development drawings to be incorporated in the modified mining permit once issued. WSP memo in response to Question 1 WSP USA, Inc. 100 Summer Street Boston, MA 02111 (617) 426 - 7330 www.wsp.com/en-US MEMORANDUM To: Sam Bratton (Wake Stone) From: Erich Thalheimer (WSP) Date: July 8, 2021 Project Name: Wake Stone Quarry Noise Project Number: 31402799.000 Subject: Responses to DEMLR ADI Noise Questions 7/6/21 This memo is intended to respond to recent ADI questions from DEMLR dated 7-6-21 regarding the results of our noise analysis supporting Wake Stone's expansion into Pit 2, and more specifically, our final report of the same dated 3/12/21. The following answers were presented verbally during a conference call with DEMLR on 6/25/21. Question 1a) The reasoning for using a slow response vs a fast response when recording with the sound meters. Answer 1a) The RMS 'slow' time response for decibel levels was used throughout the entire study and report for consistency with the majority of other noise criteria found for parklands (see Table 1 on page 8 of our report), and for the ability to directly compare "Existing" and "Future" sound levels to determine the relative changes associated with expansion into Pit 2 (which was the primary goal of the study to determine). The nature of quarry noise, where machinery is operating constantly, is appropriately averaged (Leq) using the 'slow' response. And the 'slow' response can be used to assess loudest (Lmax) blasting noise for the ability to perform direct comparisons to existing levels (see page 22 of our report). It is not possible to directly compare a sound level using 'slow' to one using 'fast' for a transient event such as blasting. Question 1b) An explanation of how intrusive noises were differentiated from other background noises. Answerlb) The terms "intrusive" and "background" are not formally defined in acoustics and were not relied upon in our study. In our study's case, Wake Stone has been operating out of Pit 1 for decades, and thus was considered to be part of the existing ambient noise soundscape. Ambient noise measurements were performed using many commonly used environmental noise metrics such as Lmax, Leq, L1, L10, L50, L90, Lmin, and Ldn. Conservative noise model predictions of Wake Stone's future noise contribution was performed using the energy - average Leq metric for continuous noise sources and the Lmax metric to isolate blasting noise. Professional Certification: I hereby certify that this plan, specification, or report was prepared or reviewed by me and that I am a duly certified acoustical professional as recognized by the Institute for Noise Control Engineering (INCE). e d, itiL -- ERICH THALHEIMER INCE BOARD CERTIFIED NO. 20104 111 Blasting data in response to Question 2 Wake Stone Corporation Shot # 43 Name of Quarry Triangle Blast Date 12/09/20 Location of Blast North Wall PO# C20-361 Shot GPS N 35" 50" 26.308 W -78" 46" 11.191 Time of Blast 11:36am Bench Elev. of Blast -40 Powder Co. Dyno Nobel Address 1201 H Aversboro Rd. Garner, NC 27529 ATF # NIA Seismograph Location #1 Embassy Suites Seismograph Location #1 Seismograph Operator Stoney Broadwell N 35" 50" 02" Dist. from Seis. to Blast 2481 Feet Seismograph Location #2 Dist. to Nearest Non Quarry Bldg.(Ft.) 2481 N (L) PPV. 0.065 FRO. 19.2 Seismograph Location #3 (T) PPV. 0.053 FRO. 10.7 N (V) PPV. 0.045 FRO. 55.6 Seismograph Location #4 DB. 117 N W 078" 46" 18" W W W Scaled Distance Calculations Air Blast Ground Vibration Unconfined Air Overpressure = U= 0.11 psi Peak Particle Velocity (V) = 0.17 in/sec. Unconfined Air Overpressure =P= 151.81 dBl Confined Air Blast/Overpressure= 116.81 dBl Weather Partly cloudy 45 SHOT PARAMETERS EXPLOSIVES USED Type of Shot Shot Conditions Hole Dia.(►n.) No. of Holes Face Ht. (Ft.) Subdrilling (Ft.) Burden (Ft.) Spacing (Ft.) Stemming (Ft.) Tons per Cubic Yd TOTALTONS POWDER FACTOR COST PER TON Series in Blast No. of Holes per Delay Max pounds per Delay Distance Scaled Accessories/Services Production Wet 5.75 33 42 3 10 12 11 2.24 13798 0.84 0.5598 1 3 1154 73 Shot Bag Unlined 3-1/2 Shot Bag Unlined 4 Bore Trak Monitor Delivery Only Charge 1 Laser Profile 2D Shot Service Technical Service Digishot Surface Wire 1000ft Digishot Surface Wire 1000ft 1 Shot checked by Superintendent Pit Foreman Blaster in Charge Hunter Bratton Hunter Bratton Alvin George Alvin George Cartridge Free Running Blastgel 1070 420 Dyno Mix - 50 lb bagged Dynosplit C 1-1/4x16 Titan 1000 G (QR740) (Bulk) 16269 Dynosplit C 7/8xl6 Boosters Density/Gas Emulsion 1.10 Trojan Spartan SR 3/4 lb 33 SR Trojan 1 lb TOTAL POUNDS 16335 Trojan Spartan 90OG 18/CS 33 DIGISHOT DETONATORS 80 Ft. 60 Ft. 33 ELEC. DETONATORS USED #4 #5 #6 #7 #8 #9 #10 #11 #12 #13 #14 #15 #16 #17 #18 #19 # 20 85'TOTAL 60' TOTAL 24'TOTAL TOTAL DETONATORS USED #4 #5 #6 #7 #8 #9 #10 #11 #12 #13 #14 #15 #16 #17 #18 #19 # 20 30 Ft. 33 Noise Study Operating Summaries Wake Stone Triangle Quarry - Dec. 7 - 12, 2020 Legend: Blue = Primary or Secondary Plant in Production and Processing Stone Red = Primary or Secondary Plant Down for Start-up/Lunch/Repairs Monday Dec. 7 Primary Tons Produced 2,440 Net Hours 2.25 Tons Per Hour 1,084 Pit Loads 40 Loading Shot 6:45 am to 11:30 am Shot was detonated at 11:39 pm Fixing Roads/Maintenance 12:45 pm to 2:15 pm Crushing Time 2:10 pm to 4:30 pm Secondary Tons Produced 1,788 Net Hours 3.00 Tons Per Hour 596 Maintenance 6:45 am to 12:00 pm Lunch/Plant Check 12:00 pm to 12:55 Crushing Time 12:55 pm to 3:00 pm '2A' Screen Timing Belt Broke 3:00 pm to 3:35 pm Crushing Time 3:35 pm to 3:50 pm Chute at N, F, G Clogged 3:50 pm to 4:15 pm Crushing Time 4:15 pm to 4:45 pm Tota l Tons Shipped 1,121.36 Total Customer Trucks Loaded 54 Wednesday Dec. 9 Primary Tons Produced 6,588 Net Hours 6.00 Tons Per Hour 1,098 Ph Loads 108 Start Up 6:45 am to 7:30 am Crushing Time 7:30 am to 11:45 am Shot was detonated at 11:36 am Lunch/Plant Check 11:45 am to 1:15 pm Crushing Time 1:15 pm to 3:00 pm Moving Rip -Rap 3:00 pm to 5:00 pm Secondary Tons Produced 6,760 Net Hours 7.50 Tons Per Hour 901.35 Start Up 6:45 am to 7:10 Crushing Time 7:20 am to 7:20 am 7' Std. Crusher Breaker Tripped 7:20 am to 7:40 am Crushing Time 7:40 am to 7:55 am Metal Detector 7:55 am to 8:05 am Crushing Time 8:05 am to 8:20 am '2A' Screen Center Strap/Screen Cloth Change 8:20 am to 9:45 am Crushing Time 9:45 am to 4:45 pm Total Tons Shipped 4,674.45 Total Customer Trucks Loaded 255 Friday Dec. 11 Primary Tons Produced 7,808 Net Hours 7.75 Tons Per Hour 1,007 Ph Loads 128 Start Up 6:45 am to 7:15 am Crushing Time 7:15 am to 11:50 am Lunch/Plant Check 11:50 am to 1:15 pm Crushing Time 1:15 pm to 4:30 pm Secondary Tons Produced 9,222 Net Hours 7.75 Tons Per Hour 1,190 Start Up 6:45 am to 7:10 am Crushing Time 7:10 am to 7:45 am '2A' Screen Gate Leak 7:45 am to 8:15 am Crushing Time 8:15 am to 11:45 am Lunch/Plant Check 11:45 am to 12:55 pm Crushing Time 12:55 pm to 4:40 pm Total Tons Shipped 4,898.45 Total Customer Trucks Loaded 256 Tuesday Dec. 8 Primary Tons Produced _ 3,904 Net Hours 3.75 Tons Per Hour 1,041 Pit Loads 64 Start Up 6:45 am to 7:40 am Crushing Time 7:40 to 11:45 am Lunch/Plant Check 11:45 am-12:45 pm Moving Materials 12:45 pm to 5:00 pm Secondary Tons Produced Net Hours Tons Per Hour - Start Up 6:45 am to 7:15 am 7' Std. Crusher Breaker Replaced 7:15 am to 6:30 pm Total Tons Shipped 2,551.98 Total Customer Trucks Loaded 142 Thursday Dec. 10 Primary Tons Produced Net Hours Tons Per Hour - Pit Loads Scheduled Maintenance 6:45 am to 5:00 pm Secondary Tons Produced Net Hours Tons Per Hour - Scheduled Maintenance 6:45 am to 5.00 pm Total Tons Shipped 4,220.56 Total Customer Trucks Loaded 233 Saturday Dec. 12 Primary Tons Produced Net Hours Tons Per Hour Pit Loads No Crushing Drilling and Projects Secondary Tons Produced Net Hours Tons Per Hour Total Tons Shipped Total Customer Tru 6:30 am to 12:30 pm Wake Stone Corporation Shot # 40 Name of Quarry Triangle Blast Date 11/18/20 Location of Blast West Wall PO# C20-339 Shot GPS N 35" 50" 21.762 W -78" 46" 9.324 Time of Blast 1:39pm Bench Elev. of Blast -40 Powder Co. Dyno Nobel Address 1201 H Aversboro Rd. Garner, NC 27529 ATF # N/A Seismograph Location #1 Embassy Suites Seismograph Location #1 Seismograph Operator Stoney Broadweil N 35" 50" 02" Dist. from Seis. to Blast 2087 Feet Seismograph Location #2 Dist. to Nearest Non Quarry Bldg.(Ft.) 2087 N (L) PPV. 0.063 FRQ. 9.6 Seismograph Location #3 (T) PPV. 0.060 FRQ. 13.5 N (V) PPV. 0.045 FRQ. 1.4 Seismograph Location #4 DB. 118 N W 078" 46" 18" W W W Scaled Distance Calculations Air Blast Ground Vibration Unconfined Air Overpressure = U= 0.13 psi Peak Particle Velocity (V) = 0.20 in/sec. Unconfined Air Overpressure =P= 153.28 dBl Confined Air Blast/Overpressure= 118.28 dBi Weather SHOT PARAMETERS Type of Shot Shot Conditions Hole Dia.(in.) No. of Holes Face Ht. (Ft.) Subdrilling (Ft.) Burden (Ft.) Spacing (Ft.) Stemming (Ft.) Tons per Cubic Yd. TOTALTONS POWDER FACTOR COST PER TON Series in Blast No. of Holes per Delay Max pounds per Delay Distance Scaled Accessories/Services Sunnv 49 Production Wet 5.75 30 42 3 11 14 9 2.24 16098 1.10 0.4319 1 2 1047 64 Shot Bag Unlined 3-1/2 Shot Bag Unlined 4 Bore Trak Monitor Delivery Only Charge 1 Laser Profile 2D Shot Service Technical Service Digishot Surface Wire 1000ft Digishot Surface Wire 1000ft 1 Shot checked by Superintendent Pit Foreman Blaster in Charge Hunter Bratton Hunter Bratton Alvin George Alvin George EXPLOSIVES USED Cartridge Free Running Blastgel 1070 4x20 Dyno Mix - 50 lb bagged Dynosplit C 1-1/4xl6 Titan 1000 G (QR740) (Bulk) 14557 Dynosplit C 7/8x16 Boosters Density/Gas Emulsion 1.08 Trojan Spartan SR 314 lb 30 SR Trojan 1 lb TOTAL POUNDS 14617 Trojan Spartan 900G 18/CS 30 DIGISHOT DETONATORS 81� 60 1 t. 30 9 t. ELEC. DETONATORS USED #4 #5 #6 #7 #8 #9 #10 #11 #12 #13 #14 #15 #16 #17 #18 #19 # 20 #4 #5 #6 #7 #B #9 #10 #11 #12 #13 #14 #15 #16 #17 #18 #19 # 20 85' TOTAL 60' TOTAL 24'TOTAL 0 0 0 TOTAL DETONATORS USED 60 PTZ 17 � tl G'- 14- 1- r1i I -SN 1 I L Cb JR: T141 4--. t4i 1 11 i lt 1 - I I i IN, TXF 7c�-, I A% 1 -j q— 11 i t F ct J1 Imo, Ilk Noise Study Operating Summaries Wake Stone Triangle Quarry - Nov. 16 - 21, 2020 Legend: Blue = Primary or Secondary Plant in Production and Processing Stone Red = Primary or Secondary Plant Down for Start-up/Lunch/Repairs Monday Nov. 16 Primary Tons Produced 1,647 Net Hours 1.50 Tons Per Hour 1,098 Pit Loads 27 Loading Shot/Setting Pump 6:45 am to 3:30 pm Shot was detonated at 12:39 pm Crushing Time 3:30 pm to 4:45 pm Secondary Tons Produced 3,908 Net Hours 8.25 Tons Per Hour 474 Start Up 6,45 am to 7:10 am Crushing Time 7:10 am to 11:45 am Lunch/Plant Check 11:45 am to 12:55 pm Crushing Time 12:55 pm to 4:45 pm Total Tons Shipped 5,160.32 Total Customer Trucks Loaded 275 Wednesday Nov. 18 Primary Tons Produced 3,904 Net Hours 4.25 Tons Per Hour 919 Pit Loads 64 Start Up 6:45 am to 7:25 am Crushing Time 7:25 am to 9:35 am Feeder Motor Base 9:35 am to 12:45 pm Electrical Controls 12:45 pm to 1:15 pm Crushing Time 1:15 pm to 3:30 pm Shot was detonated at 1:39 pm Feeder Motor Base 3:30 pm to 5:00 pm Secondary Tons Produced 5,434 Net Hours 10.25 Tons Per Hour 530 Crushing Time 6:40 am to 2:40 pm Metal Detector 2:40 pm to 2:45 pm Crushing Time 2:45 pm to 4:45 pm Total Tons Shipped 5,748.03 Total Customer Trucks Loaded 307 Friday Nov. 20 Primary Tons Produced 8,052 Net Hours 7.25 Tons Per Hour 1,111 Pit Loads 132 Start Up 6:45 am to 7:45 am Crushing Time 7:45 am to 11:45 am Lunch/Plant Check 11:45 am to 1.05 pm Crushing Time 1:05 pm to 4:45 pm Secondary Tons Produced 5,573 Net Hours 9.75 Tons Per Hour 572 eta t Up 6.45 am to 7:00 am Crushing Time 7:00 am to 4:45 pm Total Tons Shipped 5,919.43 Total Customer Trucks Loaded 302 Nov. 17 Primary Tons Produced 8,296 Net Hours 7.00 Tons Per Hour 1,185 Pit Loads 136 Start Up 6:45 am to 7.45 am Crushing Time 7:45 am to 10:15 am Metal Detector 10:15 am to 10:35 am Crushing Time 10:35 am to 11:30 am Lunch/Plant Check 11:30 am to 1:10 pm Crushing Time 1:10 pm to 4:45 pm Secondary Tons Produced 5,697 Net Hours 9.25 Tons Per Hour 616 Start Up 6:45 am to 7:05 am Crushing Time 7:05 am to 12:50 pm Unclog Dust Sprayer 12:50 pm to 1:10 pm Crushing Time 1:10 pm to 5:00 pm Total Tons Shipped 5,905.43 Total Customer Trucks Loaded 304 Nov. 19 Primary Tons Produced 7,686 Net Hours 6.75 Tons Per Hour 1,139 Pit Loads 126 Start Up 6.45 am to 7:30 am Crushing Time 7:30 am to 7:45 am Feeder Motor Base 7:45 am to 10:15 am Crushing Time 10:15 am to 4:30 pm Secondary Tons Produced 4,819 Net Hours 8.25 Tons Per Hour 584 Start Up 6:45 am to 7:15 am Crushing Time 7:15 am to 11:45 am Lunch/Plant Check 11:45 am to 12:55 pm Crushing Time 12:55 pm to 4:45 pm Total Tons Shipped 6,087.51 Total Customer Trucks Loaded 317 Nov. 21 Primary Tons Produced Net Hours Tons Per Hour - Pit Loads No Crushing Drilling and Moving Materials 6:30 am to 2:30 pm Secondary Tons Produced Net Hours Tons Per Hour Total Tons Shipped Total Customer Trucks Loaded Blast Data 2019 Date # of holes Max Delay Shot # Elevation 01/03/19 44 258 1 0 01/11/19 37 248 2 -40 01/18/19 38 248 3 -40 01/29/19 46 348 4 -40 02/08/19 33 228 5 -40 02/18/19 36 243 6 -40 02/26/19 31 233 7 -40 03/01/19 31 223 8 -40 03/07/19 33 218 9 -40 03/13/19 36 298 10 0 03/22/19 26 198 11 0 03/29/20 38 258 12 0 04/05/19 36 277 13 -40 04/16/19 29 218 14 -40 04/24/19 30 238 15 0 05/08/19 34 346 16 -40 05/17/19 41 238 17 0 05/22/19 57 177 18 -80to-130 06/04/19 41 268 19 -40 06/07/19 53 192 20 -80 to -130 06/18/19 37 278 21 -40 06/25/19 46 444 22 -40 07/01/19 50 192 23 -80 to -130 07/08/19 49 337 24 -40 07/12/19 53 192 25 -80 to -130 07/19/19 23 218 26 0 07/30/19 45 337 27 -40 08/07/19 37 277 28 0 08/13/19 26 228 29 -40 08/22/19 39 317 30 0 08/29/19 36 297 31 0 08/30/19 49 177 32 -80 to -130 09/10/19 25 218 33 0 09/13/19 28 208 34 -80 to -130 09/19/19 26 218 35 -40 09/24/19 31 238 36 -80 to -130 09/27/19 1 0 37 -40 10/03/19 31 204 38 -80- to -130 10/11/19 20 184 39 0 10/15/19 30 262 40 -80 to -130 10/18/19 27 209 41 -40 10/29/19 28 262 42 -80 to -130 11/06/19 28 213 43 -80 to -130 11/11/19 19 208 44 -40 11/14/19 46 478 45 -40 11/25/19 28 296 46 -130 12/05/19 20 278 47 -40 12/05/19 13 145 48 0 12/18/19 28 274 49 -130 Blast Data 2018 Date # of holes Max Delay Shot # Elevation 1/9/2018 27 193 1 -40 to -80 1/11/2018 31 198 2 0 1/16/2018 42 245 3 -40 to -80 1/24/2018 32 317 4 0 1/31/2018 32 327 5 0 2/12/2018 36 160 6 -40 to -80 2/19/2018 33 229 7 0 2/27/2018 59 219 8 -40 to -80 3/6/2018 31 189 9 0 3/9/2018 33 164 10 -40 3/13/2018 40 317 11 0 3/26/2018 38 287 12 -40 4/3/2018 34 223 13 -40 4/10/2018 29 208 14 -40 4/17/2018 33 228 15 -40 4/20/2018 27 238 16 0 4/24/2018 24 237 17 -40 4/27/2018 36 228 18 -40 5/4/2018 32 208 19 -40 5/11/2018 39 288 20 -40 5/22/2018 46 268 21 -40 5/30/2018 33 237 22 -40 6/5/2018 29 258 23 0 6/11/2018 36 278 24 -40 6/18/2018 37 228 25 -40 6/25/2018 40 238 26 -40 6/28/2018 28 238 27 0 7/2/2018 21 198 28 0 7/10/2018 40 258 29 -40 7/20/2018 44 238 30 -40 7/26/2018 41 318 31 -40 8/7/2018 38 282 32 -40 8/14/2018 35 238 33 -40 8/29/2018 29 258 34 0 9/11/2018 38 253 35 -40 10/3/2018 46 278 36 -40 10/16/2018 42 238 37 0 10/22/2018 46 338 38 -40 10/30/2018 45 278 39 -40 11/7/2018 44 318 40 -40 11/21/2018 46 338 41 -40 12/7/2018 41 298 42 -40 12/19/2018 42 318 43 -40 12/19/2018 32 228 44 -40 Blast Data 2017 Date # of holes Max Delay Shot # Elevation 1/6/2017 34 247 1 40 1/16/2017 32 231 2 40 1/18/2017 28 208 3 0 1/20/2017 34 233 4 40 1/26/2017 17 178 5 40 1/27/2017 51 357 6 0 2/1/2017 36 277 7 0 2/7/2017 20 227 8 0 2/10/2017 41 336 9 0 2/16/2017 43 307 10 0 2/20/2017 24 247 11 40 2/27/2017 47 311 12 0 3/3/2017 33 268 13 0 3/7/2017 30 287 14 40 3/8/2017 44 165 15 40 3/13/2017 37 265 16 0 3/17/2017 42 258 17 0 3/17/2017 40 120 18 40 to 80 (ramp development) 3/23/2017 27 247 19 40 3/27/2017 40 272 20 0 3/28/2017 44 120 21 40 to 80 (ramp development) 4/3/2017 17 168 22 40 4/7/2017 32 208 23 40 to 80 (ramp development) 4/10/2017 34 307 24 0 4/12/2017 44 276 25 0 4/19/2020 33 217 26 0 4/19/2017 22 155 27 40 to 80 (ramp development) 4/27/2017 29 218 28 40 to 80 (ramp development) 5/2/2017 34 267 29 40 5/9/2017 29 238 30 40 5/16/2017 30 247 31 40 to 80 (ramp development) 5/19/2017 41 278 32 0 5/22/2017 41 248 33 0 5/26/2017 31 238 34 40 6/2/2017 32 238 35 0 6/13/2017 96 288 36 40 to 80 (ramp development) 6/15/2017 33 228 37 40 6/22/2017 29 238 38 40 6/29/2017 38 248 39 0 7/6/2017 32 218 40 40 7/11/2017 49 258 41 0 to 40 (ramp development) 7/17/2017 50 267 42 0 7/20/2017 25 188 43 40 7/26/2017 36 415 44 40 8/1/2017 37 267 45 0 8/4/2017 39 184 46 0 to 40 (ramp development) 8/11/2017 32 208 47 0 8/16/2017 47 274 48 0 to 40 (ramp development) 8/22/2017 21 237 49 40 8/25/2017 38 248 50 0 8/25/2017 6 80 51 0 to 40 (ramp development) 9/1/2017 48 241 52 0 9/6/2017 21 178 53 40 9/14/2017 50 291 54 0 9/20/2017 34 232 55 0 10/4/2017 50 318 56 0 10/11/2017 39 278 57 3 10/17/2017 62 236 58 -40 to -80 (sink) 10/18/2017 48 377 59 0 10/20/2017 18 179 60 0 10/25/2017 64 195 61 -40 to -80 (sink) 10/26/2017 29 169 62 0 10/31/2017 34 268 63 0 11/6/2017 31 268 64 0 11/9/2017 52 298 65 0 11/14/2017 44 273 66 0 11/17/2017 36 268 67 0 11/28/2017 15 119 68 0 11/28/2017 32 298 69 0 11/30/2017 42 161 70 -40 to -80 (sink) 12/5/2017 32 229 71 0 12/8/2017 34 190 72 -40 to -80 (sink) 12/8/2017 31 283 73 0 12/14/2017 21 149 74 0 12/19/2017 38 193 75 -40 to-80(sink) 12/22/2017 30 139 76 0 Blast Data 2016 Date # of holes Max Delay Shot # Elevation 1/6/2016 36 247 1 40 1/12/2016 28 208 2 40 1/20/2016 27 257 3 80 1/28/2016 43 297 4 0 2/1/2016 31 208 5 40 2/3/2016 21 188 6 80 2/10/2016 44 257 7 0 2/22/2016 46 248 8 0 2/25/2016 17 237 9 80 3/1/2016 31 188 10 40 3/8/2016 43 277 11 0 3/14/2016 49 258 12 0 3/21/2016 34 208 13 80 3/24/2016 29 247 14 40 3/31/2016 46 288 15 0 4/5/2016 23 244 16 80 4/11/2016 44 378 17 40 4/14/2016 45 334 18 80 4/20/2016 46 333 19 40 4/27/2016 44 278 20 0 5/5/2016 44 268 21 80 5/12/2016 50 321 22 40 5/19/2016 43 237 23 40 5/26/2016 85 181 24 40 to 80 (ramp development) 6/1/2016 28 275 25 40 to 80 (ramp development) 6/7/2016 41 289 26 40 6/21/2016 43 268 27 0 6/22/2016 73 186 28 40 to 80 (ramp development) 6/27/2016 23 237 29 40 to 80 (ramp development) 7/6/2016 36 228 30 40 7/12/2016 26 168 31 40 7/14/2016 40 258 32 40 7/19/2016 24 227 33 40 to 80 (ramp development) 7/25/2016 29 208 34 40 7/25/2016 21 168 35 40 to 80 (ramp development) 8/1/2016 39 228 36 0 8/3/2016 25 124 37 40 to 80 (ramp development) 8/5/2016 43 258 38 0 8/10/2016 24 188 39 40 8/17/2016 26 147 40 40 to 80 (ramp development) 8/19/2016 35 248 41 0 8/25/2016 36 238 42 0 8/25/2016 24 143 43 40 to 80 (ramp development) 9/1/2016 27 228 44 40 9/1/2016 32 162 45 40 to 80 (ramp development) 9/12/2016 34 290 46 40 9/16/2016 40 247 47 0 9/22/2016 25 257 48 40 9/19/2016 52 177 49 40 to 80 (ramp development) 9/29/2016 38 307 50 40 10/4/2016 36 231 51 0 10/7/2016 22 208 52 40 10/13/2016 42 297 53 0 10/19/2016 36 231 54 0 10/21/2016 24 247 55 40 10/25/2016 31 261 56 0 11/1/2016 35 336 57 40 11/7/2016 34 218 58 0 11/14/2016 33 231 59 40 11/17/2016 34 335 60 0 11/28/2016 34 277 61 40 12/1/2016 31 208 62 0 12/7/2016 37 247 63 0 12/13/2016 33 198 64 40 12/15/2016 29 208 65 0 12/21/2016 23 305 66 40 12/28/2016 28 208 67 0 Blast Data 2015 Date # of holes Max Delay Shot # Elevation 1/6/2015 41 277 1 40 1/15/2015 42 277 2 80 1/22/2015 40 257 3 80 2/4/2015 32 306 4 80 2/11/2015 38 247 5 40 3/4/2015 28 257 6 80 3/11/2015 25 257 7 40 3/18/2015 31 257 8 80 3/24/2015 41 277 9 40 4/2/2015 53 315 10 40 4/8/2015 32 237 11 80 4/15/2015 33 297 12 40 4/20/2015 38 267 13 80 4/24/2015 13 207 14 40 5/5/2015 42 243 15 40 5/7/2017 40 297 16 40 5/14/2017 32 228 17 40 5/20/2015 31 267 18 80 5/27/2015 36 198 19 40 6/1/2015 14 215 20 40 6/3/2015 32 286 21 80 6/10/2015 30 277 22 40 6/16/2015 38 238 23 0 6/24/2015 39 238 24 80 7/1/2015 32 297 25 40 7/8/2015 36 238 26 80 7/13/2015 44 302 27 40 7/17/2015 36 238 28 80 7/24/2015 30 250 29 80 7/30/2015 38 332 30 40 8/6/2015 43 313 31 80 8/13/2015 33 238 32 40 8/18/2015 33 228 33 40 8/25/2015 32 228 34 40 9/3/2015 29 218 35 80 9/10/2015 36 307 36 40 9/16/2015 32 228 37 40 9/22/2015 29 218 38 80 9/28/2015 35 286 39 40 10/1/2015 28 316 40 10/7/2015 28 208 41 10/13/2015 31 267 42 10/19/2015 24 286 43 10/22/2015 24 199 44 10/27/2015 24 247 45 10/29/2015 31 321 46 11/5/2015 32 218 47 40 11/11/2015 26 296 48 80 11/16/2015 13 178 49 40 11/24/2015 47 277 50 40 12/3/2015 57 307 51 80 12/9/2015 34 247 52 40 12/15/2015 40 267 53 40 12/18/2015 28 225 54 0