02-06 North American Emerald Mine File Pt. 15

/ ROBINSON
/ BRADSHAW 6, HINSON
CHARLOTTE OFFICE
DIRECT DIAL: 704.377.81 12
DIRECT FAx: [phone]
[e-mail]
May 12, 2005
VIA CERTIFIED RETURN RECEIPT
Ms. Marjorie Downey
N.C. Department of Justice
Environmental Division
9001 Mail Service Center
Raleigh, NC 27699
Re: WM. Fred Walker, A V.
N. C. Dept. of Environment and Natural Resources, Case
No. 04-EHR-2162
Dear Marjorie:
Pursuant to your call to Bill Toole last Friday, I enclose copies of photographs responsive
to DENR's discovery requests. These are the only responsive documents submitted to the OAH as exhibits to our recent motions and responses. we have not already
Sincerely,
4 T4
Jennifer F. Revelle
JFR/mra
Enclosures
cc: Mr. William W. Toole (w/o enclosures)
C-932826A 18484.00011
�Qr
MAY 20 1005
IVAY 1 ? `i
Attorneys at Law
Charlotte Office: 101 North Tryon Street, Suite 1900, Charlotte, NC 28246 Ph: 704-377.2536 Fx: 704.378.4000
South Carolina Office: 140 East Main Street, Suite 420, P.O. Drawer 12070, Rock Hill, SC 29731 Ph: 803.325,2900 Fx: 803.325.2929

MAY 2 0 2005
SECTION

f
yJ
t'
1 �
'Ef

I

-�
�:.��
T#.

�
r3
� 4�rtxa lr ♦4 >
� n
S ti

��' Y`f
�r �� � �
��
�ae .�.
� � � 3 �,
-�;.�5. y.., �"..�
1~ _ _

,is

-- ,.
� , ;� ---
�r�
���. �� ��
'„ } �.y�L

� t f�,; r.�,., • �.
P �,
�1� �
<.::. x : ,
ze . ' .
'^`. _ �C
,,;� `:
.,.
r f S i ', a � 5:
^ ii f p
t x;< � t � r `
i�` fr�l c k�riy � �� �� ��li
n
t�{ @ f n7 it �
�: y' let..- r � i- � � y � e 1 �,��,� 1/,
r {L,� % f 1 l � i ..
S�i I � � e-_;h4 �� ,. Diu t � � -.1 �, if
�Q>Y 1� � � _Va � yl��i
b P.� fir) fY Yi � 1 ��� �. av� i� i
1 '�

�r _ iTrI.

- %\/-
. »yam.
.
©
«.\-.

1 41"
zq f*

-r Zia T 5 "( "►. � J i /P'u� 'T v iyt ^+C r ' � r r. leY / - Yf'� i r� } y 4
r . �..�„�..i�'R'���.tj �.r-�i 'N�',- a z.e �i�.d' / - .�.�r-; f l rh'� ,_7 _ t ��"+ - n a/J,•;.
� - J' I N.- r -.vf"z.\ .s. '" / `' • ' ti 2!% 4 IFa ., J.�yi `n y�-',Y 7 y i( i !
`'` � Y� 7.Pr [4 ''\k L �•Y t 1 '} ri J.i i 1 Y '
�?/ ry ,• r`i'`i �. ^§.- i Yvf�� -�� \ � r pt. i tA'•. Y Y T. �j Yy / 7 �� / �•,
- .'„ � ,11, fi, . , +ei 'hc ' �/.1 •�+�I�.1�fA���n Tr., � "'F� i'.1 ♦S
-y E
in
_i ,c ♦i ` `yf4y r `��A. -��'a
At
.� -K. :wig r Y '� � ` � ' � I � � �• t � i t O t .; .
��� '', l��['��"i3 �;'`l `/� .♦C � ;;,[Fi E.y �"��`��� i�rT.ti�.1d7� t�.
.rG�t/ / Y '1, � � f 1 ti��:y l,r � � � /� F\♦.

s 6s
aFr
k t '✓wF ee
a i
r� q,

•t. S 4', �. I� != All{;��'�,{ { i 1�. -4
'uw. , ' 'Rv... - , ), 1 '� �.., k jst�w wp�r � ,. �rµ���•. � 1
�. • y. ,+ �_c,,,.t„r:. . � - - t - pax ' "J � 4 i �=t\\YY.xf-'` .
�.. W t'� p//.�/ i 1ST xt... _ 1y{♦ . d �".
tow
x4
Ac
\, 7,•i .. `, a .. 11 S. �♦ �� r,l$ ijY�R � Y
vt
.�v z ., � "' � J: a p � j• � �,�t k}e}\ ,� �ztL+.Eiii ,
h �
7d? !
�,��� yf, 1 •fix I I'
fin' ir, �.� ••� -.l � I

Xf
S — �
I ,
PoE
T Vt � • 1
1 i TTii• • a , ' 11 •
• � ;� j , a ' I ,, • 1
•s E
6 1
Ir
r " I I •Y.i { y.t
{�` a / fl •a l I1 1 1 "t Jf.M1A;` j�„Cef
x Ah
Of
t .. ' f yl ••t ' 11 , ,, 1 Itl �6f.h' k
/Pjj 1 � •' t 1
It 111 i
147
71 C ,.f 4.111i
1 i r
-OtfJY 4.
g I
}a •y1 � t ( M i fi 1 1
,' Y �tl „4�5' '1 t 1 n .1 •�I t 1 1 1! 1`' 1 •'t a
%} f �I ••1 III ex'
M1 !j � �K �,f 1 j1Y 1 • x f
t 1 f� �j •� _% 1 •
f
1 _

,r
+:

3i", V441M, elit � g �,A
Pvm�
Mall

a�� ° .
.+n �, �;
�� ,-
� mow...---
:_„ . ..,
=��.
i

y tr.
(t:z
_ax.-',.

r t
It
. i
�6
I
{
` t..
d 4
I_-
.
� 1
1r.4 N •� 1 , �'. S
ti
r C }
I it i t a
{IL
az 1
I Y
�J
f Y�
r �
�
I
F
r9
t rA i
1
t
d
y
La�^��

•c `
N-15`.�'
5.
y� 9
f.vY .�.Y
'sue N'Fv,y1`J J: ♦
/ .✓ .i ��yay�� r�hl l � 'Y (� a ti �„' A a tJ ix�{+ .. � }C'm• �+,� �.._cs.. '.•`.er ,.... -
s �
dL
14
i
'_' . ,•. 1""-; �.
vm
44
r _ _ t_ .yam Yt ,S '' t _ Oyu -oaf �•R, �_' y t - I ✓ , _:
�, :I 5 �ST ���\ /�3�3�! ir'• �'.! t H, ~ // mot^ ��L ..y{
' 1 I . t ,'':`} � l/ � 'S"w ! <::�� .0 :I `Y`�'`�£I.l' .AD 44{' ✓eiin4 W 1+`:.
J
�v� 5 s 1.` / Z �� it '.. .i ,. ox .sc>�a. yy ♦ r �--,-,.✓ r .""'� .-^++w...
r:.
t I '
✓1 9 - %� f Y� A G ✓��
j i k'•
,'.e - .. ,ter. .'�v 7A� � i.. r n -. .. .•'�.. � s.

Y c\' r a �. ' r -{ x I t a r! •� i >-f % _.. � t I
'�
Y d�� �4'>' � L Y ( 1, ^d• � } 1 � � '� d\
4 J y
!� { '�'•'' � .� r t I rFSd ii ` � r-S.
IIP
{yZj a tit",
e "/CC
t g, yy aI
$�} < _ � E a >• it r �., y..
t f r �'i/�`a..,T-'-�� � � ', `rJ<f _ems .�'. r; 7`•, - � - _' '
11
SS
Y 1 ? i' •✓
xip -•�f .3 M/ X 7
e x.
r dam. r C ,l",. �j�l / �i41. r $ S�. �': , f�°j.� 1 tr `T'rt � I . •� �
?4A
,•>i�•k�r r T��k� r" ',r t u/ r al t'<. � � r!' .-:d rN F ' t. r'''' x . -
��� .� F sr rd •+.r yi r /: JI trw �` ! S y -S t '
.r... �'�,,, T•y+ f' a;i �. y m tt a -tt y ,
yNs*' ,y Wes, { r r i �":F F�� "� ,. kr ,ys r ♦, T< '; i\ �
i 'V•(d ! # J �..r � � "�sf/:' q ss a r=�4o 3y ]r �;iy
L Y IT f`✓ 9' 2 G1 / d '�'Y ✓"�^ iv �1� � �' xr ~ ��77( F
.-F', r � �'. � x •t } a' � � rjy,_,ei� Err „��� \i F�t' sx�mt�.
•.„ r -�'' Y� ,��,t� � � �� � ! rr ry .'FS�� t yr� ��.L i 'yag[4,��;iq��
r•.r2 r }� Mtn; ti r r d- yt',� j$ v ✓` lrs-
St �="{
ah<-r� a�rrs��F�� r � ti � ✓Y L r^� J . F\ (��3+`.�t 1 �+ f ,
sJF' .f'y. .' --� In{'� tn.at �.',y4y�r•� 6f„ t.T �`.t
riv.,..