Loading...
HomeMy WebLinkAboutOak Island_21_22_FinalReportFinal Report Oak Island Renourishment Project 2021/2022 OAK ISLAND RENOURISHMENT PROJECT 2021/2022 TOWN OF OAK ISLAND FINAL REPORT Prepared for: Town of Oak Island 4601 E. Oak Island Drive Oak Island, NC 28465 Project Engineer: Moffatt & Nichol 4700 Falls of Neuse Rd., Suite 300 Raleigh, NC 27609 September 30, 2022 Final Report Oak Island Renourishment Project 2021/2022 1 Oak Island Renourishment Project 2021/2022 Design Project construction began on February 20, 2022 and was completed on April 20, 2022 (59 days) by Great Lakes Dredge and Dock Company Inc. (GLDD). Moffatt & Nichol (M&N) served as the engineer on behalf of the Town of Oak Island (Town). The project design consisted of approximately 765,000 cubic yards (cy) to be placed along 21,500 feet (ft) of shoreline (approximately 4.1 miles) from 3rd Place East to the west end parking lot as shown in Figure 1. Figure 1. Oak Island Renourishment Project 2021/2022 Beach Fill Extent (Sta 465+00 to Sta 680+00) Jay Bird Shoals and Central Reach, shown in Figure 2, were the authorized offshore borrow areas. However, all but a few loads were dredged from Jay Bird Shoals due to sediment compatibility issues in Central Reach. Final Report Oak Island Renourishment Project 2021/2022 2 Figure 2. Jay Bird Shoals and Central Reach Borrow Areas The design template consisted of four typical cross-sections which varied based on two dune tie-in configurations and the presence or absence of a berm. Figure 3 shows the two typical dune tie-in configurations without a berm and Figure 4 shows the two typical dune tie-in configurations with a berm. The design template consisted of a dune designed to withstand a 25-year return period storm. The dune elevation ranged from 13.0 to 15.5 ft North American Vertical Datum 1988 (NAVD88) with a crest width of 10 ft in most locations. However, due to existing grade some locations featured a direct horizontal tie- in to existing ground with varying dune crest width. The front slope of the dune was 4 Horizontal:1 Vertical (H:V) and the back slope of the dune, where applicable, was 5H:1V. The front dune slope broke at elevation 7.0 ft NAVD88 and continued out on a 20H:1V slope until tie in with existing grade from approximately Sta 465+00 to Sta 620+00. From Station 621+00 to Station 677+00 a variable width berm ranging from 60 ft to 65 ft at elevation 7.0 ft NAVD88 was also included in the design to account for accelerated erosion historically experienced on the west end of Oak Island. The construction plans detailing the placement extents, cross-sections, and borrow areas are show in Appendix A. Final Report Oak Island Renourishment Project 2021/2022 3 Figure 3. Typical Cross-Sections Without Berm -20 -18 -16 -14 -12 -10 -8 -6 -4 -2 0 2 4 6 8 10 12 14 16 18 20 -100 -80 -60 -40 -20 0 20 40 60 80 100 120 140 160 180 200 220 240 260 280 300 320 340 360 380 400 420 440 460 480 500 El e v a t i o n ( f t N A V D 8 8 ) Distance to Baseline (ft) Sta 585+00 BD Survey Template Dune Width 10.0'Dune Elevation Variable Dune Toe Elevation 7.0' -20 -18 -16 -14 -12 -10 -8 -6 -4 -2 0 2 4 6 8 10 12 14 16 18 20 -100 -80 -60 -40 -20 0 20 40 60 80 100 120 140 160 180 200 220 240 260 280 300 320 340 360 380 400 420 440 460 480 500 El e v a t i o n ( f t N A V D 8 8 ) Distance to Baseline (ft) Sta 563+00 BD Survey Template Dune Width Variable Dune Elevation Variable Dune Toe Elevation 7.0' Final Report Oak Island Renourishment Project 2021/2022 4 Figure 4. Typical Cross-Sections With Berm -20 -18 -16 -14 -12 -10 -8 -6 -4 -2 0 2 4 6 8 10 12 14 16 18 20 -100 -80 -60 -40 -20 0 20 40 60 80 100 120 140 160 180 200 220 240 260 280 300 320 340 360 380 400 420 440 460 480 500 El e v a t i o n ( f t N A V D 8 8 ) Distance to Baseline (ft) Sta 642+00 BD Survey Template Dune Width 10.0' Berm Elevation 7.0' Berm Width Variable Dune Elevation Variable -20 -18 -16 -14 -12 -10 -8 -6 -4 -2 0 2 4 6 8 10 12 14 16 18 20 -100 -80 -60 -40 -20 0 20 40 60 80 100 120 140 160 180 200 220 240 260 280 300 320 340 360 380 400 420 440 460 480 500 El e v a t i o n ( f t N A V D 8 8 ) Distance to Baseline (ft) Sta 662+00 BD Survey Template Dune Width Variable Berm Width Variable Dune Elevation Variable Berm Elevation 7.0' Final Report Oak Island Renourishment Project 2021/2022 5 Oak Island Renourishment Project 2021/2022 Construction As part of the construction administration for the project the Contractor generated daily QC Reports covering all aspects of construction and Moffatt and Nichol produced summaries of the weekly construction meetings between Owner, Contractor, Engineer, and Agencies to document all construction activities, both of which can be found in Appendix B. In addition, environmental permitting documentation which guided and established requirements for all aspects of construction activities can be found in Appendix C. Beach Placement As mentioned previously, project construction began on February 20, 2022 with Padre Island which was joined by the Dodge Island on February 21, 2022. The two dredges worked in tandem throughout most of the project, with the Padre Island departing on April 6, 2022, just two weeks before the completion of the project. The project required the use four different sublines spaced evenly along the project extents, two of which used a booster. In general, the western portion of the project was constructed first and then the eastern portion of the project was constructed. The first subline at Sta 608+50 (w/ booster) was utilized to pump east to Sta 572+00 and then west to Sta 642+00. The contractor then moved to the second subline at Sta 656+50 (w/o booster) where they pumped east to tie-in at Sta 642+00 and then west to the western project limit at Sta 680+00. The contractor then moved to the third subline at Sta 534+50 (w/ booster) which was utilized to pump west to tie-in at Sta 572+00 and then east to Sta 520+00. The fourth subline was located at Sta 489+50 (w/o booster) and was utilized to pump west to tie-in at Sta 520+00 and then east to the eastern limit of the project at Sta 465+00. It was originally intended that the sublines utilizing the booster would place material dredged from Jay Bird Shoals and the sublines not using a booster would place material from Central Reach. However, after starting with material from Jay Bird shoals on a booster subline some test loads from Central Reach were dredged to prepare for the switch to a non-booster subline. During this process it was determined that the material from Central Reach was not compatible and an official change was made to the construction process in which the contractor was directed to dredge all remaining material through completion of the project from Jay Bird Shoals. Due to the change in borrow area, which required an increase in price due to borrow area distance, the overall design volume was reduced from 765,000 cy to 745,000 cy in order to keep the overall contract price the same. This volume reduction was accomplished by reducing the initial 60 ft to 65 ft berm width intended for Stations 621+00 to 680+00 on the western end of the project down to 35 ft to 45 ft. In addition, to combat erosion which had occurred since the pre-construction survey was performed, the entire template (dune and slope) along three stretches of shoreline in the portion of the project not containing a berm from Sta 467+00 to Sta 487+00, Sta 511+00 to Sta 525+00, and Sta 569+00 to Sta 616+00 were shifted 5 ft landward. Although the final design volume was reduced to 745,000 cy, storm activity which occurred during the project, extra material required to properly tie-in the dune to existing ground, and some general overfill due to contractor placement accuracy during construction caused the project to reach completion on April 20, 2022 with a total of approximately 768,063 cy of placement. Figure 5 through Figure 9 presents example before and after project conditions of Station 620+00 from a cross section, aerial, and ground view. All cross sections and volumes for the project can be found in Appendix D. Final Report Oak Island Renourishment Project 2021/2022 6 Figure 5. Station 620+00 Typical As-Built Cross Section -20 -18 -16 -14 -12 -10 -8 -6 -4 -2 0 2 4 6 8 10 12 14 16 18 20 -100 -80 -60 -40 -20 0 20 40 60 80 100 120 140 160 180 200 220 240 260 280 300 320 340 360 380 400 420 440 460 480 500 El e v a t i o n ( f t N A V D 8 8 ) Distance to Baseline (ft) Sta 620+00 Template BD Survey AD Survey Final Report Oak Island Renourishment Project 2021/2022 7 Figure 6. Station 620+00 (Looking North) Pre-Construction Ground Photo (GLDD photo 2/9/22) Figure 7. Station 620+00 (Looking North) Post-Construction Ground Photo (GLDD photo 5/3/22) Final Report Oak Island Renourishment Project 2021/2022 8 Figure 8. Station 620+00 (Looking West) Pre-Construction Ground Photo (GLDD photo 2/9/22) Figure 9. Station 620+00 (Looking West) Post-Construction Ground Photo (GLDD photo 5/25/22) Final Report Oak Island Renourishment Project 2021/2022 9 Tilling Sediment quality resulting from the Phase I 2020/2021 Oak Island Renourishment Project resulted in the requirement to perform tilling in last year’s project area as well as the Phase II 2021/2022 project area after construction was complete. Therefore, throughout the beginning to middle of March (March 9 – 10 & March 13 – 15), the Phase I 2020/2021 project area was tilled. Upon completion of the western half the of Phase II 2021/2022 project, tilling was completed from the west end parking lot to 51st Pl W at the end of March. Upon completion of the eastern portion of the project, tilling from 51st Pl W to 3rd Pl E was completed at the end of April once all equipment was off the beach. Tilling was performed from the base of dune out to Mean High Water (MHW). GLDD was able to till the areas of concern prior to April 30, 2022 using the equipment shown in Figure 10. Figure 10. Tilling Equipment On Site Final Report Oak Island Renourishment Project 2021/2022 10 Post & Rope In conjunction with the beachfill placement, post and rope fences were installed, by GLDD’s subcontractor Emerald Forest Incorporated, at emergency vehicle accesses, public beach accesses, and homeowner walkovers (approximately every 200 ft). All access points were identified by Town staff. Emergency vehicle accesses and public vehicle accesses were 10 ft wide and the homeowner walkovers were 5 ft wide. Due to a delay in receiving the supplies, GLDD installed temporary stakes and tape fences to guide the public over the dunes to prevent foot traffic where not intended until the post and rope were delivered and installed. Approximately 8,170 ft of post and rope were installed throughout the project. An example of the post & rope is presented in Figure 11. Figure 11. Example Post & Rope Installation at Homeowner Shared Walkway Final Report Oak Island Renourishment Project 2021/2022 11 Oak Island Renourishment Project 2021/2022 Borrow Area Utilization Jay Bird Shoals The Jay Bird Shoals borrow area is located approximately one (1) mile off the shore of Caswell Beach (east of Oak Island) near the mouth of the Cape Fear River (see Figure 2). The borrow area was divided into 3 zones with different target elevations to conserve material for future projects. The permitted elevations for the Zones were as follows: Zone 1 -28 ft NAVD88, Zone 2 -37 ft NAVD88, and Zone 3 -29 ft NAVD88. These elevations include a two foot overdredge which was allowed in each zone. A magnetic anomaly stretches diagonally across Zone 3 and part of Zone 2. A 50 ft buffer was applied to either side of the magnetic anomaly during dredging. In addition a portion of Zone 1 was excluded due to incompatible material. Pre- and post- dredge surveys were taken of the borrow area in January and May 2022, respectively, to determine dredge impacts. These surveys are presented in Figure 12. Figure 12. Jay Bird Shoals BD and AD Surveys The difference in elevation between the BD and AD surveys was then calculated to determine the change in the borrow area as a result of dredging. Elevation differences are presented in Figure 13. Elevation differences less than 0.5 ft were excluded from the color scale to clearly identify areas that were dredged. As can be seen, the majority of dredging occurred in Zone 2 with some dredging occurring along the southwest boundary in Zone 3 and minimal dredging occur right at the southern boundary of Zone 1 where it intersects with Zone 2. The deepest dredge cut was 14.01 ft. It is estimated that 19,934 cy of material was removed from Zone 1, 1,007,841 cy from Zone 2, and 74,068 cy from Zone 3 for a total of Final Report Oak Island Renourishment Project 2021/2022 12 1,101,842 cy of dredging. It should be noted that some natural accretion, up to 2.5 ft, occurred in Zone 1 and Zone 3 in the 4 months between surveys as represented by the pink color shading in Figure 13. More information about the borrow area utilization, including load by load dredge production information and daily dredge track lines, can be found in the daily QC reports in Appendix B. Figure 13. Jay Bird Shoals Borrow Area Cut Depths Central Reach The Central Reach borrow area is located approximately 2.3 miles offshore of Oak Island, just west of the Middleton Avenue bridge (see Figure 2). The borrow area was divided into 4 zones with different target elevations based on sediment compatibility. The permitted elevations for the Zones were as follows: Zone 1 -40 ft NAVD88, Zone 2 -41.7 ft NAVD88, Zone 3 -39.9 ft NAVD88, and Zone 4 -42.0. These elevations include a two foot overdredge which was allowed in each zone. A portion of the borrow area spanning all four zones was excluded from use due to use by the adjacent project on Holden Beach. Pre- and post- dredge surveys were taken of the borrow area in January and May 2022, respectively, to determine dredge impacts. These surveys are presented in Figure 14. Final Report Oak Island Renourishment Project 2021/2022 13 Figure 14. Central Reach BD and AD Surveys The difference in elevation between the BD and AD surveys was then calculated to determine the change in the borrow area as a result of dredging. Elevation differences are presented in Figure 15. Elevation differences less than 0.5 ft were excluded from the color scale to clearly identify areas that were dredged. It should be noted that only a few test loads were dredged out of the Central Reach borrow are before the material was deemed to be poor quality and the contractor was directed to use Jay Bird Shoals as the sole sediment source. Therefore, the differences in the BD and AD surveys are very minimal. As can be seen, only a few track lines are visible based on the elevation changes in the borrow area. Minimal dredging was performed in Zones 1, 2, and 4. The deepest dredge cut was 1.94 ft. It is estimated that 51,998 cy of material was removed from the Central Reach Borrow Area in Zones 1, 2, and 4. More information about the borrow area utilization, including load by load dredge production information and daily dredge track lines, can be found in the daily QC reports in Appendix B. Final Report Oak Island Renourishment Project 2021/2022 14 Figure 15. Central Reach Borrow Area Cut Depths Final Report Oak Island Renourishment Project 2021/2022 15 Oak Island Renourishment Project 2021/2022 - Other Project Features Relocation Trawling Trawling activities were initiated 24 hrs prior to start of construction. Subcontractor Coastwise Consulting performed the trawling and relocation activities. One trawler (Lady Paige) was on site throughout the entire project which was deemed sufficient due to the fact that the dredges would be digging in the borrow area at alternating times. Daily trawl relocation reports, sturgeon capture and relocation forms, sea turtle capture and relocation forms, and dredge sea turtle take forms can be seen in the daily QC reports in Appendix B. Throughout the project, the following relocations and takes occurred: • Atlantic Sturgeon: 27 non-lethal relocations • Green Turtle: 0 non-lethal relocations • Loggerhead: 9 non-lethal relocations, 1 lethal dredge take • Kemps Ridley: 19 non-lethal relocations, 1 lethal dredge take • Leatherback: 1 non-lethal relocation Sediment Sampling Due to initial concerns about sediment quality, it was decided that the twice a week sediment sampling requirements in the specifications should be increased to daily sediment sampling until all parties were comfortable with material quality. Therefore, sediment sampling was performed on a daily basis from February 21, 2022 to March 9, 2022 after which the protocol switched to collection of samples every other day for the remainder of the project. Table 1 presents a summary of the sediment samples results throughout the project. As can be seen, a majority of sediment samples met the State sediment criteria of ≤6% gravel, ≤11% granular, ≤7% fines, and ≤25% calcium carbonate. It should be noted that a sediment sample at Sta 562+00, taken in early April, did not meet the gravel, granular, or calcium carbonate requirements. However, samples taken before and after did meet the State requirements, indicating that it was likely a small pocket of incompatible material which was dredged from the borrow area and did not impact a large portion of the beach. Sediment sample lab analysis tables and graphs can be seen in Appendix E. In addition to grain size analysis, wet and dry Munsell Color was also documented to alleviate agency concerns about sediment color, specifically darkness of material, that could impact sediment temperature which has been correlated to affecting the gender of newly hatched sea turtles. Final Report Oak Island Renourishment Project 2021/2022 16 Table 1. Sediment Sampling Lab Analysis Summary Beach Raking As a result of last year’s project and conditions at an adjacent beach using material from Central Reach, contract and permit requirements specified beach raking should occur before and after construction to remove surface rocks. However, pre and post construction conditions were document by GLDD indicating beach raking did not need to occur. The permitting agencies were in agreement that the beach raking operation could be dismissed due to the absence of rocks on the beach before and after placement. Therefore, change orders were developed to remove this process and fee from the overall project. Dune Planting Under a separate contract, the Town entered into agreement with subcontractor Coastal Transplants to grow and plant 275,000 plants along the crest and landward slope of the dune. Dune planting began on May 23, 2022. All plants grown and installed were Sea Oats and were installed with 24 inch spacing. The contractor completed initial planting in the project area on June 29, 2022. Due to dry weather, the contractor immediately returned to replant several areas that did not survive, finishing on July 25, 2022. One additional area was replanted at the end of August. Upon project completion, approximately 245,200 plants were installed, 44,400 of which were replacement plants for those that did not survive the dry weather during planting. A final walkthrough was performed on September 26, 2022, establishing an 80% survival rate as required by the contract. The contractor utilized UTV’s and small trailers to haul Beach Sample Gravel (%)Granular (%)Sand (%)Fines (%)Carbonate (%)Wet Munsell Dry Munsell Sta 609+00 (2/21/22)2.75 8.88 88.28 0.09 25.51 10YR-5/1 10YR-6/1 Sta 605+00 (2/22/22)3.35 8.74 87.88 0.03 23.25 10YR-5/1 10YR-6/1 Sta 595+00 (2/23/22)1.87 6.16 91.91 0.06 23.04 10YR-4/1 10YR-6/1 Sta 589+00 (2/24/22)1.73 5.99 92.19 0.09 17.98 10YR-5/1 10YR-6/1 Sta 582+00 (2/25/22)3.93 8.09 87.73 0.25 23.27 10YR-5/1 10YR-6/1 Sta 574+00 (2/26/22)1.46 3.77 94.62 0.15 15.93 10YR-5/1 10YR-7/1 Sta 611+00 (2/27/22)2.41 7.67 89.62 0.30 19.05 10YR-5/1 10YR-7/1 Sta 615+00 (2/28/22)1.63 5.99 92.16 0.22 15.17 10YR-5/1 10YR-7/1 Sta 620+00 (3/1/22)1.75 6.45 91.61 0.19 20.16 10YR-5/1 10YR-7/1 Sta 623+00 (3/2/22)2.95 5.19 91.38 0.48 11.75 10YR-5/1 10YR-7/1 Sta 625+00 (3/3/22)5.52 3.95 90.31 0.22 10.65 10YR-5/1 10YR-7/1 Sta 627+00 (3/4/22)1.68 6.57 91.62 0.13 15.24 10YR-6/1 10YR-7/1 Sta 634+00 (3/5/22)3.59 11.27 84.77 0.37 23.03 10YR-5/1 10YR-7/1 Sta 639+00 (3/6/22)0.36 1.87 97.59 0.18 9.01 10YR-6/1 10YR-7/1 Sta 642+00 (3/7/22)1.77 4.55 93.34 0.34 19.28 10YR-5/1 10YR-6/1 Sta 656+00 (3/8/22)2.61 6.6 90.36 0.43 22.77 10YR-4/1 10YR-7/1 Sta 652+00 (3/9/22)1.95 2.61 95.16 0.28 10.06 10YR-5/1 10YR-7/1 Sta 658+00 (3/11/22)0.89 4.78 93.91 0.42 12.16 10YR-5/1 10YR-7/1 Sta 663+00 (3/14/22)0.76 4.3 94.8 0.14 11.78 10YR-5/1 10YR-6/1 Sta 668+00 (3/16/22)0.95 4.92 94.08 0.05 14.95 10YR-5/1 10YR-7/1 Sta 671+00 (3/18/22)1.25 4.29 94.36 0.1 14.47 10YR-5/1 10YR-7/1 Sta 534+00 (3/20/22)2.16 7.91 89.84 0.09 23.33 10YR-4/1 10YR-6/1 Sta 545+00 (3/22/22)1.55 5.36 92.79 0.3 14.65 10YR-5/1 10YR-8/1 Sta 494+00 (3/27/22)0.87 4.75 94.26 0.12 14.21 10YR-5/1 10YR-6/1 Sta 554+00 (3/29/22)2.63 8.95 88.17 0.25 27.66 10YR-5/1 10YR-7/1 Sta 503+00 (4/2/22)1.84 5.12 92.85 0.19 11.9 10YR-4/1 10YR-6/1 Sta 562+00 (4/3/22)6.82 15.83 77.35 0 26.84 10YR-3/1 10YR-5/1 Sta 573+00 (4/4/22)2.97 10.19 86.6 0.24 15.98 10YR-5/1 10YR-7/1 Sta 523+00 (4/8/22)1.12 4.95 93.83 0.1 16.35 10YR-5/1 10YR-7/1 Sta 522+00 (4/10/22)1.15 5.07 93.64 0.14 14.2 10YR-5/1 10YR-6/1 Sta 508+00 (4/11/22)0.14 1.53 98.04 0.28 11.12 10YR-5/1 10YR-7/1 Sta 510+00 (4/12/22)1.38 3.5 94.69 0.43 14.6 10YR-5/1 10YR-6/1 Sta 518+00 (4/14/22)1.97 4.58 93.06 0.39 18.62 10YR-5/1 10YR-6/1 Sta 487+00 (4/16/22)0 0.59 99.36 0.05 4.45 10YR-6/1 10YR-7/1 Sta 479+00 (4/18/22)0 2.8 96.38 0.82 7.79 10YR-5/1 10YR-7/1 Final Report Oak Island Renourishment Project 2021/2022 17 equipment (plants, hoses, tools, coolers, markers) with blue lay flat hose for water. Guidance by the permitting agencies concerning equipment restrictions and coordination regarding turtle monitoring were followed. Figure 16 presents an example of the dune planting. Figure 16. Recently planted section of dune (M&N photo 7/25/22) Temperature Monitoring A site visit was conducted on April 28, 2022 to install waterproof temperature loggers within the 2020/2021 and 2021/2022 placement areas to collect sand temperature data. Four temperature loggers were re-installed within the 2020/2021 renourishment area (SE 58th St, 29th Pl E, 11th Pl E, and 6th Pl E) and six temperature loggers were installed within the 2021/2022 renourishment area (5th Pl W, 17th Pl W, 27th Pl W, 42nd Pl W, 51st Pl W, and 57th Pl W). Two control station loggers were installed on ether end of Oak Island at the west end parking lot and SE 67th St. The loggers were buried at a depth of 18 inches (which represents sea turtle nest depth) along the face of the dune, approximately halfway up the dune face or at an elevation of 12 ft NAVD88. Data will record temperatures at 1-hour intervals through summer 2022. Data will be downloaded every two weeks and will be provided to the agencies. Each monitoring station will include color documentation every two weeks. Sediment color will be monitored 6 inches from the surface. Photos of the dune and shoreline will be collected at each sampling location to establish a visual log. Figure 17 presents the ten monitoring locations within the project areas and 2 control stations. Final Report Oak Island Renourishment Project 2021/2022 18 Figure 17. Station Locations for Sand Temperature and Sand Color Monitoring Oak Island Renourishment Project 2021/2022 Final Cost and Funding The final construction cost of the project, excluding engineering, was $17,648,935.15. This is just slightly higher than the original awarded amount of $17,134,000.00 due to a small overage in final pay volume and use of Jay Bird Shoals for the entire project. The project was funded partly by the Federal Emergency Management Agency (FEMA) Hurricane Matthew claim of approximately $7.6M. Additional grant money to extend the scope of the project was received from the Hurricane Florence Disaster Recovery Fund Coastal Storm Damage Mitigation of approximately $1.3M. The Town paid for the remaining portion of the project ($8.7M).