The URL can be used to link to this page

Home My WebLink About88593C - Caudle, Robert❑CAMA ❑DREDGE & FILL N9 88593 A B; C D GENERAL PERMIT Previous permit Date previous permit issued New ❑Modification ❑ Complete Reissue ❑ Partial Reissue As authorized by the State of North Carolina, Department of Environmental Quality and the Coastal Resources Commission in an area of environmental concern pursuant to: 15A NCAC ❑ Rules attached. ❑ General Permit Rules available a the following link: www dea gmdCAMArules Applicant Name City Phone Email Affected ❑CW AEC(s): ❑OEA ORW: yes/no State ZIP FEW ❑PTA ❑IHA ❑uW PNA: yes/no Type of Project/ Activity Shoreline Length Access Length Pier (dock) length Fixed Platform(s) Floating Platforms) Finger pier(s) Total Platform area Groin length/# (Bulkhead) Riprap length , - - Avg distance offshore Breakwater/Sill Max distance/ length Basin, channel Cubic yards Boat ramp Boathouse/Boatlift i Beach Bulldozing Other SAV observed: yes no l Moratorium: n/a yes no Site Photos: yes no Riparian Waiver Attached: yes no A building permit/zoning permit may be required by: _ Permit Conditions Agent or Applicant PRINTED Name ❑ ES N PTS ❑SPIMA ❑PWS Authorized Agent - Project Location (County): Street Address/State Road/Lot #(s) Subdivision City Adj. Wtr Body Closest Maj. Wtr. Body Permit Officer's PRINTED Name Signature"PleaseAad compliance statement on back of permit** Signature T1 7A Application Feels) Check#/Money Order Issuing D. (Scale: TAR/PAM/N EUSE/BUFFER (circle one) See note on back regarding River Basin rules ❑ See additional notes/conditions on back IT. (Please Initial) Expiration Date Statement of Compliance and Consistency This permit is subject to compliance with this application and permit conditions. Any violation of these terms may subject the permittee to a fine or criminal or civil action; and may cause the permit to become null and void. This permit must be on the project site and accessible to the permit officer when the project is inspected for compliance. The applicant certifies by signing this permit that: 1) prior to undertaking any activities authorized by this permit, the applicant will confer with appropriate local authorities to confirm that this project is consistent with the local land use plan and all local ordinances, and 2) a written statement from the adjacent riparian property owner(s) has been obtained, or proof of delivery of certified mail notification of the adjacent riparian property owner(s). The State of North Carolina and the Division of Coastal Management, in issuing this permit under the best available information and belief, certify that this project is consistent with the North Carolina Coastal Management Program. River Basin Rules Applicable To Your Project: ElTar - Pamlico River Basin Buffer Rules Neuse River Basin Buffer Rules If indicated on front of permit, your project is subject to the Environmental Management Commission's Buffer Rules for the River Basin checked above due to its location within that River Basin. These buffer rules are enforced by the NC Division of Water Resources. If you have any questions, please contact the Division of Water Resources at the Washington Regional Office (252-946-6481) or the Wilmington Regional Office (910-796-7215). Notes/Additional Permit Conditions: Please ensure all debris associated with the removal or construction of the permitted development is contained within the authorized project area and disposed of in an appropriate upland location. Division of Coastal Management Offices Morehead City Headquarters 400 Commerce Ave Morehead City, NC 28557 252-808-2808/ 1-888-4RCOAST Fax: 252-247-3330 (Serves: Carteret, Craven —south of the Neuse River, Onslow Counties) Elizabeth City District 401 S. Griffin St. Ste. 300 Elizabeth City, NC 27909 252-264-3901 (Serves: Bertie, Camden, Chowan, Currituck, Dare, Gates, Hertford, Pasquotank and Perquimans Counties) Washington District 943 Washington Square Mall Washington, NC 27889 252-946-6481 Fax: 252-948-0478 (Serves: Beaufort, Craven — north of the Neuse River, Hyde, Pamlico, Tyrrell and Washington Counties) Wilmington District 127 Cardinal Drive Ext. Wilmington, NC 28405-3845 910-796-7215 Fax:910-395-3964 (Serves: Brunswick, New Hanover and Pender Counties) http://portal.ncdenr.org/web/cm/dcm-home Revised 6/01/2021 0ta"twa ❑CAMA El DREDGE & FILL N9 88593 A B C D tALGENERAL PERMIT Previous permit 3 Date previous permit ermit issued E] New ❑ Modification ❑ Complete Reissue ❑ Partial Reissue As authorized by the State of North Carolina, Department of Environmental Quality and the Coastal Resources Commission in an area of environmental concern pursuant to: I SA NCAC ❑ Rules attached. ❑ General Permit Rules available at the following link: www.deq.nc.gov/CAMArules Applicant Name City State ZIP Phone # (_) Authorized Agent Project Location (County): Street Address/State Road/Lot #(s) Subdivision City Affected ❑ CW ❑ EW ❑ PTA ❑ ES ❑ PTS Ad!- Wtr. Body (nat/man/unk) AEC(s): ❑ OEA ❑ IHA ❑ UW ❑ SPIMA ❑ PWS Closest Mai. Wtr. Body ORW: yes/no PNA: yes/no Type of Project/ Activity Shoreline Length I I Access Length Pier (dock) length Fixed Platform(s)— Floating Platform(s) Finger pier(s) Total Platform area Groin length/# Bulkhead/ Riprap length Avg distance offshore Breakwater/Sill Max distance/ length Basin, channel Cubic yards Boat ramp Boathouse/ Boatlift Beach Bulldozing Other SAV observed: yes no Moratorium: n/a yes no Site Photos: yes no Riparian Waiver Attached: yes no A building permit/zoning permit may be required by: Permit Conditions i (Scale ❑ TAR/PAM/NEUSF/BUFFER (circle one) See note on back regarding River Basin rules ❑ See additional notes/conditions on back I AM AWARE OF STATUTES, CRC RULES AND CONDITIONS THAT APPLY TO THIS PROJECT AND REVIEWED COMPLIANCE STATEMENT. (Please Initial) Agent or Applicant PRINTED Name Permit Officer's PRINTED Name Signature "Please read compliance statement on back of permit** Application Fee(s) Signature Check#/Money Order Issuing Date Expiration Date Statement of Compliance and Consistency This permit is subject to compliance with this application and permit conditions. Any violation of these terms may subject the permittee to a fine or criminal or civil action; and may cause the permit to become null and void. This permit must be on the project site and accessible to the permit officer when the project is inspected for compliance. The applicant certifies by signing this permit that: 1) prior to undertaking any activities authorized by this permit, the applicant will confer with appropriate local authorities to confirm that this project is consistent with the local land use plan and all local ordinances, and 2) a written statement from the adjacent riparian property owner(s) has been obtained, or proof of delivery of certified mail notification of the adjacent riparian property owner(s). The State of North Carolina and the Division of Coastal Management, in issuing this permit under the best available information and belief, certify that this project is consistent with the North Carolina Coastal Management Program. River Basin Rules Applicable To Your Project: Tar- Pamlico River Basin Buffer Rules 1-1 Neuse River Basin Buffer Rules If indicated on front of permit, your project is subject to the Environmental Management Commission's Buffer Rules for the River Basin checked above due to its location within that River Basin. These buffer rules are enforced by the NC Division of Water Resources. If you have any questions, please contact the Division of Water Resources at the Washington Regional Office (252-946-6481) or the Wilmington Regional Office (910-796-7215). Notes/Additional Permit Conditions: Please ensure all debris associated with the removal or construction of the permitted development is contained within the authorized project area and disposed of in an appropriate upland location. Division of Coastal Management Offices Morehead City Headquarters 400 Commerce Ave Morehead City, NC 28557 252-808-2808/ 1-888-4RCOAST Fax: 252-247-3330 (Serves: Carteret, Craven -south of the Neuse River, Onslow Counties) Elizabeth City District 401 S. Griffin St. Ste. 300 Elizabeth City, NC 27909 252-264-3901 (Serves: Bertie, Camden, Chowan, Currituck, Dare, Gates, Hertford, Pasquotank and Perquimans Counties) Washington District 943 Washington Square Mall Washington, NC 27889 252-946-6481 Fax: 252-948-0478 (Serves: Beaufort, Craven - north of the Neuse River, Hyde, Pamlico, Tyrrell and Washington Counties) Wilmington District 127 Cardinal Drive Ext. Wilmington, NC 28405-3845 910-796-7215 Fax:910-395-3964 (Serves: Brunswick, New Hanover and Pender Counties) http://portal.ncdenr.org/web/cm/dcm-home Revised 6/01/2021 ROY COOPER Governor ELIZABErH S. BISER Secretary BRAXTON DAVIS Dlrecmr 10/12/2022 Lois A. Flemming 5008 Lakeshore Drive New Bern, NC 28562 Dear Lois A. Flemming: NORTH CAROLINA Environmental Quality This letter is in response to your letter dated 9/17/2022 regarding your concerns about the proposal by Mr. Robert Caudle to install a bulkhead located within Wilson Creek at 5006 Lakeshore Drive in New B6m, Craven County." The proposed project has, been determined to comply with the Rules of the Coastal Resources Commission (7H. 1100),`and as such, a permit has been issued to authorize the development. I have; enclosed a copy of the permit, as well as the relevant statutes. If you wish to contest our decision to issue thlrpermt, `you may file a request for a Third- lered,by the Chairman of the Coastal Resources Commission. The hearing request must be, filed with the Director, Division of Coastal Management, in writing and must be received within twenty (20) days after the disputed permit decision is made. I have enclosed the applicable farms and instructions that must be filed prior to that deadline. Please contact meat (252) 515-5417, if.you have any questions, or if I can provide any additional information. Party Hearing. The request for a Si re Heather Styron District Manager DEQ� ��emmmr North Carolina Department of Environmental Quality I DIvIslon of Coastal Management Morehead City Office 1 400 Commerce Avenue I Morehead City, North Carolina 28557 252SISS400 Lois A. Flemmivtg 5008 Lakeshore Drive New Bern NC 28562 September 17, 2022 NC Division of Coastal Management 400 Commerce Ave. Morehead City NC 28557 I am objecting to the construction of a bulkhead on the property next to me. See attached documentation. I have seen multiple sources discuss how bulkheads will cause increased erosion to adjacent properties due to the inability of the bulkhead to absorb wave energy, therefore deflecting it to adjacent properties. I've attached two examples of what I have read. On my own property I have been trying to encourage a natural vegetation buffer to maintain a healthy ecosystem as recommended by your own website and Clemson University's Life at the Water's Edge. But I'm concerned with whether a natural buffer is going to be able to handle the additional erosive wave force a neighboring bulkhead could produce. When I first moved here, Cypress Lake did not have a waterway connection to public waters. There was little to no boat traffic creating wakes and waves. That situation changed several years ago and now small motorboats and jet -skis do come into the lake creating more wave action. There is more erosion occurring and it concerns me that this wall could direct even more destructive forces against my property. It will create an additional expense for me to counteract any associated destruction of my property as well as lower my property value. Please let me know what action I need to take in this regard. Sincerely, RECEIVED SEP 21 2022 DCh4-MHD CITY N.C. DIVISION OF COASTAL MANAGEMENT ADJACENT RIPARIAN PROPERTY OWNER NOTIFICATION/WAIVER FORM CERTIFIED MAIL • RETURN RECEIPT REQUESTED or HAND DELIVERY (Top portion to be completed by owner or their agent) Name of Property Owner: Robert Caudle Address of Property: 5006 Lakeshore Dr., New Bern, NC Mailing Address ofowner:5006 Lakeshore Dr., New Bern, NC 28562 owner's email: rlCaudle(cD_aol.COm Owner's Phone#: 919-345-5863 Agent's Name: Bobby Cahoon Construction, Inc. Agent Phone#: 252-249-1617 Agent's Email: bobbycahoonconstruction &yahoo.com ADJACENT RIPARIAN PROPERTY OWNER'S CERTIFICATION (Bottom portion to be completed by the Adjacent Property Owner) I hereby certify that I own property adjacent to the above referenced property. The individual applying for this permit has described to me, as shown on the attached drawing, the development they are proposing. A I DO NOT have objections to this proposal. Ufa ,ADO have objections to this proposal. If you have objections to what is being proposed, you must notify the N.C. Division of Coastal Management (DCM) in writing within 10 days of receipt of this notice. Correspondence should be mailed to 400 Commerce Ave., Morehead City, NC 28557. DCM representatives can also be contacted at (252) 808-2808. No response is considered the same as no objection if you have been notified by Certified Mail. WAIVER SECTION I understand that any proposed pier, dock, mooring pilings, boat ramp, breakwater, boathouse, lift, or groin must be set back a minimum distance of 15' from my area of riparian access unless waived by me (this does not apply to bulkheads or riprap revetments). (If you wish to waive the setback, you must sign the appropriate blank below.) I DO wish to waive some/all of the 15' setback -OR- Signature of Adjacent Riparian Property Owner I do not wish to waive the 15' setback requirement (initial the blank) Signature of Adjacent Riparian Typed/Printed name of ARPO: 1-0 S _l% tom— ( 7/��1 Mailing Address ofARPO: ARPO's email: /oj'-snbi10 gfPCL l' ARPO's Phone#: L) 9A 63q - 63 1' a p Date: / - % oZ oL *waiver is valid for up to one year from ARPO's Signature* Revised July 20217 D SEP ,1 1`022 DCM-ir;i-Q C[Tv ROBERT CAUDLE 5006 LAKESHORE DRIVE NEW BERN, NC DESCRIPTION We propose to install a new wooden seawall. Wall will be 144' long with 4' +/- exposure. This includes a 10' long wingback on the left side of the property and a 16' long wingback on the right side. RECEIVED SEP 21 2022 DCrv,-h1HD CITY 2019 Shoreline Stabilization Techniques - NYS Dept. of Environmental conservation Turtles and amphibians have free access to land, while retaining walls (seen below) block this access, preventing mating and spawning. This is the very same shoreline, after landowner had installed a retaining wall: The effects are clearly seen, as the lush ecosystem is quickly destroyed. Harmful Shoreline Alterations The following types of alterations and shoreline protection lead to increased erosion, structural damage and the destruction of the shoreline ecosystem: Bulkheads and Retaining Walls Normally a natural, gradual slope will absorb the energy of the wave. Bulkheads and retaining walls cause waves to crash into the shore. Much of the energy of these waves is sent downwards into the water at the base of the wall. The dirt or "substrate" is slowly dug out from under the wall's foundation, eventually causing it to lean and then tumble into the water. Additionally, water draining from upland builds up behind the wall, pushing the wall from behind, especially during freeze -thaw cycles. Construction of a bulkhead or retaining wall can also increase the erosion rates on nei s. The effect of a bulkhead on adjacent ,From an environmental standpoint, retaining walls are by far the most � destructive method of stabilization. With retaining walls, the vegetated ar that would normally provide shelter, places to feed, breeding and nesting areas is cleared and built over, quickly and completely destroying the ecosystem. Not only are retaining walls the most expensive and environmentally harmful option, but when it eventually collapses you'll be left with a staggering repair bill. This is especially un-bulkheaded property troublesome in cases where Courtesy of US Fish and Wildlife Service structures such as houses, garages, etc. are built close to the wall. If the wall fails, you may find the accompanying structure going down with it. No matter how extensive, the collapse of a retaining wall is inevitable. If you already have a retaining wall installed, you may want to A retaining wall failure completely remove the wall and rework the area using one of our recommended methods. However, in some locations, you may not be able to utilize one of these options. If this is the case, the Department may recommend that you build the wall further back (landward) from the existing wall, rather than building.a_new wall further out into the water. RECEIVED Permanent Docks SEP 21 2022 https://w .dec.ny.gov/permitst67096.html DCbt-hiHr) CITY �/11 9/13/22, 3:12 PM Bulkheads: Bad News for Shoreline Protection? Tensar, q Tensar Americas Blog Bulkheads: Bad News for Shoreline Protection? w I by Steve Williams, P.E., on Jan 24, 2020 4:31:11 PM Average water levels are on the rise around our nation's coasts and waterways which have people scrambling to find efficient methods to save our eroding shores. However, some of these erosion methods may actually cause more harm than good. Bulkheads, vertical structures installed parallel to the water, have been used to protect valuable land from being eaten away by harsh wave energy. However, studies have shown that bulkheads may actually encourage erosion because they ✓� simply deflect the wave energy to other areas along the shore. Nearby areas / without coastal protection suffer instead. What about coastal protection from major storm events? When it comes to a hurricane and storm surge, isn't a solid bulkhead the way to go? Actually, they may offer less protection than you think. This article from Scientific American details how a majority of the bulk heads installed in the Outer Banks of North Carolina suffered damage by Hurricane Irene while the natural marsh shorelines were not impaired. If something that appears solid and strong like a bulkhead can't protect our coasts, then what's the answer? Creating structures that absorb wave energy has shown to be the better approach. Armor stone revetments placed out into the waterway work to dampen the wave energy. This video, captured by the USACE Buffalo District, offers an excellent side, ,. z U 0 https:/Iinfo.tensarcorp.com/bulkheads-bad-news-for-shoreline-protection 115 AGENT AUTHORIZATION FOR CAMA PERMIT APPLICATION Name of Property Owner Requesting Permit: 20be4 -c— J. Mailing Address: Phone Number: E Email Address: 17-� CANJ eja A,& ca& I certify that I have authorized to act on my behalf, for the purpose of applying for and obtaining all CAMA permits necessary for the following proposed development: S��ce�►.e�- � seams\\ at my property located at _S00& l..a,k O'V-e in L��ye� County. 1 furthermore certify that l am authorized to grant, and do in fact grant permission to Division of Coastal Management staff, the Local Permit Officer and their agents to enter on the aforementioned lands in connection with evaluating information related to this permit application. Property Owner Information: Signature Print or Type Name owneR Title ! aoaa Date This certification is valid through 9 1 / ! OA3 ■ Complete items 1, 2, and 3, a slg ture ■ Print your name and address on the reverse X ❑ Agent so that we can return the card to you. ❑ Addressee ■ Attach this card to the back of the mailpiece, or on the front ff space permits. Iv by (Prin ate ollDelivery 1 ��1/ t. Artcle Addressed to: D. Is delivery address different from Rem 1? ❑ yes ►M�.f YYirs.�¢y�JO-Vv' gr:i1 It YES, enter delivery address below. p No .5. soo4 LakeSl ' fir, n1 C afrs"� III'III'I I'll I'llll III llllill Illll IIIIII III III entice Type 11 Priority Mail Expresse Cl MMaail 9590 102 7408 2055 8601 D Adult Slanature Pageto etl Delivery � COWAd WHO ❑ cxdned Mee ❑ R�egep�erred RestAMed 22 Restriced Delivery ❑ go cn DN" n c-•:_- - ❑ SO%wm Ow matmm- 0 SWnature CW mation 2. Article Number dmnsLac>mm �.:ro rebn 7021 0950 0000 1368 Resettled Del 9641 Restricted Delivery -ted Delivery PS Form 3811, July 2020 PSN 7530-02-OM9053 Domestic Return Receipt N.C. DIVISION OF COASTAL MANAGEMENT ADJACENT RIPARIAN PROPERTY OWNER NOTIFICATION/WAIVER FORM CERTIFIED MAIL • RETURN RECEIPT REQUESTED or HAND DELIVERY (Top portion to be completed by owner or their agent) Name of Property Owner: Robert Caudle Address of Property: 5006 Lakeshore Dr., New Bern, NC Mailing Address ofOwner5006 Lakeshore Dr., New Bern, NC 28562, Owners email: ricaudle(a_aol.com owner's Phone#: 919-345-5863 Agent's Name: Bobby Cahoon Construction, Inc. Agent Phone#: 252-249-1617 Agents Email: bobbycahoonconstruction yahoo.com ADdACENTl MklAN PROPERTY dWNER'S CERTIFICATION (Bottom Portion to be completed by the Adiacent Property Owner) I hereby certify that I own property adjacent to the above referenced property. The Individual applying forthis permit has described to me, as shown on the attached drawing, the development they are proposing. A 100 NOT have objections to this proposal. 4% ADO have objections to this proposal. n you nave oDfecfions to what is being proposed, you must notify the N.C. Division of Coastal Management (DCM) In writing within 104ays of receipt of this notice. Correspondence should be mailed to 400 Commerce Ave., Morehead City, NC 28557. DCMrepresentafives can also be contacted at (252) 808-2808. No response is considered the same as no objection if you have been notified by Certified Mail. WAIVER SECTION I understand that any proposed pier, dock, mooring pilings, boat ramp, breakwater, boathouse, lift, or groin must be set back a minimum distance of 15' from my area of riparian access unless waived by me (this does not apply to bulkheads or riprap revetments). (if you wish to waive the setback, you must slan the appropriate blank below.) I DO wish to waive some/all of the 16 setback -OR- Signature of Adjacent Riparian Property Owner 1 do not with to waive the 15' setback requirement -(initial the blank) Signature of Adjacent Riparian Pro Owner. Typed/Printed name of ARPO: j S ��J? -�Y%Zc'1 / LJX /Jj Mailing Address ofARPO: Sowx J'a'yn5JWrC Y Z .. ARPO's eemall: o1_sn bi1 c-,Qg4ia /- `ARPO's Phone#: otSa o97 - 6 3 0 Q, Date: 7 - oZ� •waiver Is valid for up to one year from ARPO's Signature* Revised July 2021 Lois A. Fletn mivtg 5008 Lakeshore Drive New Bern NC 28562 September 17, 2022 Bobby Cahoon Construction 6003 Neuse Road Grantsboro NC 28529 I have notified the DCM per the notification form and am waiting to see what the next steps are. I am concerned that the seawall will increase the erosion of my property, causing me sizeable expense to correct (and unaffordable at this time) and lowering my property value. Mr. Caudle has already reduced my property value by installing a tall solid fence with tall evergreen plantings along the side of my property which greatly reduces my property's view of Cypress Lake. There are other forms of shoreline stabilization that would work well yet cause less damage. I realize seawalls are your business but perhaps one of these other forms would be viable? ROBERT CAUDLE 5006 LAKESHORE DRIVE NEW BERN, NC DESCRIPTION We propose to install anew wooden seawall. Wall will be 144' long with 4' +/- exposure. This includes a 10' long wingback on the left side of the property and a 16' long wingback on the right side. Parcel ID Owner: Mailing Address Property Address: Description : Lot Description Craven County Geographic Information System Craven County does NOT warrant the inforrnation shown on this page and should be used ONLY for tax assessment purposes. This report was created by Craven County GIS reporting services on 9/7/2022 1:14:29 PM 8-207-1 -018 CAUDLE, ROBERT J 5006 LAKESHORE DR NEW BERN NC 28562 5006 LAKESHORE DR LOT 18 LAKEVIEW EST$ Assessed Acreage: 0.711 Deed Reference: 3551-0135 Recorded Survey: Estate Number: Land Value: $70,000 Improvement Value: $277,670 Total Value: $347,670 Subdivision: LAKEVIEW ESTATES Calculated Acreage: 0.710 Recorded Date: 10 25 2018 Tax Exempt: No # of Improvements: 4 City Name: NEW BERN Fire tax District : Drainage District : Special District : Land use: RESIDENTIAL - ONE FAMILY UNIT Recent Sales Information SALE DATE Sellers Name Buyers Name Sale Type Sale Price 10/25/2018 HARRELL, ROBERT P & CAUDLE, ROBERT J STRAIGHT $385,000 SUZANNE R TRANSFER 7/5/2017 PETERSON, JOHN & HARRELL, ROBERT P & STRAIGHT $350,000 VIVIAN M SUZANNE R TRANSFER 1/18/2005 EDWARDS, MICHAEL W PETERSON, JOHN & VIVIAN STRAIGHT $301,500 & SHARON N M TRANSFER 8/2/2004 MUSE, DAVID A & EDWARDS, MICHAEL W & STRAIGHT $285,000 REBECCAL SHARON N TRANSFER 11/2/1994 B C H L INC MUSE, DAVID A & REBECCA STRAIGHT $44,000 L TRANSFER List of Improvements to Site Type of Structure Year Built Base Area 1st Floor Value RESIDENTIAL CONSTRUCTION 1995 1862 $255,250 GARAGE LOW COST 2017 375 $15,980 BOAT DOCK/PIER-RESIDENTIAL 2005 190 $4,220 STORAGE BUILDING-DETACHED-RES 2013 120 $2,220 Lt`u� - ;;;ice • � � \: _ .° I C p