Loading...
HomeMy WebLinkAboutOI_16-09_DENIAL0/16-0 2l5/2016 CERTIFIED MAIL -INSERT CERTIFIED MAIL # VwC E m6t RETURN RECEIPT REQUESTED James Murray 8 John Murray 514 Market Street Wilmington, NC 28401 RE: DENIAL OF CAMA MINOR DEVELOPMENT PERMIT APPLICATION NUMBER- 01 16-09 PROJECT ADDRESS- 4627 E. Beach Dr. (Lot 14, Block 11, S-2) Dear Mr. Murray: After reviewing your application in conjunction with the development standards required by the Coastal Area Management Act (CAMA) and our locally adopted Land Use Plan and Ordinances, it is my determination that no permit may be granted for the project which you have proposed. This decision is based on my findings that your request violates NCGS 11 3A-1 20(a)(8) which requires that all applications be denied which are inconsistent with CAMA guidelines and Local Land Use Plans. You have applied to build a single family residence seaward of the 1998 static vegetation line which is inconsistent with 15A NCAC 07H .0306(a)(2). Your application is also inconsistent with 15A NCAC 07H .0601, which states that no development shall be allowed in any AEC which would result in a contravention or violation of any rules, regulations or laws of the State of North Carolina or of local government in which the development takes place. On page 88 of the local Land Use Plan, you will find that: Policy 2.A.17: Ocean Hazard Areas: The Town supports State policies that do not conflict with the Town's development regulations, for ocean hazard areas as set forth in Chapter 15NCAC subchapter 7H of the State CAMA regulations. Suitable land uses in ocean hazard areas include ocean shoreline erosion control activities, dune establishment and stabilization. Residential, commercial and recreational land uses and parking lots for beach access are also acceptable uses in ocean hazard areas provided they meet all general and specific standards of 15 NCAC: 7H that do not conflict with the Town's development regulations. If you wish to appeal this denial, you are entitled to a hearing. The hearing will involve appearing before an Administrative Law Judge who listens to evidence and arguments of both parties and then makes a recommendation to the Coastal Resources Commission (CRC). Your request for a hearing must be in the form of a written petition, complying with the requirements of §1508 of General Statues of North Carolina, and must be filed with the Office of Administrative Hearings, 6714 Mail Service Center, Raleigh, NC 27699-6714, within twenty (20) days from the date of this letter. Please contact me so I can provide you with the proper forms and any other information you may E I V ED require. DCM WILMI NGTON, NC 4601 E. Oak Island Drive • Oak Island, North Carolina 28465 Phone: (910) 278-5024 • Fax: (910) 278-1811 • Website: www.oakislandnc.com FEB 052016 You may also petition for a variance from the CRC by means of the procedures described in 15A NCAC 07J .0700. 1 have enclosed a copy of the current rules as well as the CAMA Variance Request Form (DCM Form 11). Respectfully yours, Q Donna F. Coleman, LPO Town of Oak Island cc: Sean Ferrell Wilmington-DCM RECEIVED DCM WILMINGTON, NC FEB 0 5 2016 You may, also.petition for a Variance from the CRC by:means of the procedures descrihed;in 15A,NCAC 07J .0700.. 1 have. enclosed. a copy of the current rules as well as the CAMA Variance Request Form (DCM Form 11). Respe6t6y-y9o4 (rs,, Donha'F CdIeman,'LPO Town of Oak'I§land cc: Sean Ferrell Wilmington-DCM Simpson, Shaun From: Donna Coleman <DColeman@ci.oak-island.nc.us> Sent: Friday, February 05, 2016 1:38 PM To: John Murray Cc: planner, Farrell, Sean C; MacPherson, Tara; Simpson, Shaun Subject: CAMA Minor Denial Notification (Murray) Attachments: doc20160205132626.pdf Importance: High Mr. Murray, Please find attached the denial letters for you CAMA Minor Applications (OI 16-09 & OI 16-10) submitted to my office on 1/20/2016. We have discussed the requirements of seeking a variance thru the Coastal Resource Commission and I have attached the required forms. Sincerely Donna F. Coleman, CFM CAMA-LPO / Building Inspector Town of Oak Island (910)201-8047 (930)278-1811fax f,,-(--EIvED OCM WILMWGTON, NC FEB 0 5 2016 Locality-- 2 S� c ..----- :_---------- Permit Number za d t;Esttarine Shorcline —_ORW Shoreline- Public Trust Shorel ne_Othet r (For official use only) GENERAL INFORMATION LAND OWNER !DIVED i Name: John Murray and James Murray 1I1q J j L Address: 514 Market Street City: Wilmington State: NC Zip: 28401 Phone: 910-619-6902 AUTHORIZED AGENT Name: John Murray Address: 514 Market Street City: Wilmington State: NC Zip: 28401 Phone: 910-619-6902 LOCATION OF PROJECT: (Address, street name and/or directions to site. If not oceanfront what is the name of the adjacent waterbody.) Lot 15, Block 11. S-2 Oak Island. North Carolina 28465 g429 E. JA"r-H D2 DESCRIPTION OF PROJECT: (List all proposed construction and land disturbance.) The project consists of a 2500 square foot residence and associated driveways SIZE OF LOT/PARCEL: 7500 square feet .1722 acres PROPOSED USE: Residential ® (Single-family ® Multi -family ❑) Commerical/Industrial ❑ Other ❑ TOTAL ENCLOSED FLOOR AREA OF A BUILDING IN THE OCEAN HAZARD AREA OF ENVIRONMENTAL CONCERN (AEC): 2464 square feet (includes au conditioned living space, parking elevated above ground level, non -conditioned space elevated above ground level but excluding non -load -bearing attic space) COASTAL SHORELINE AREA OF ENVIRONMENTAL CONCERN AECs :SIZE OF BUILDING FOOTPRINT AND OTHER IMPERVIOUS OR BUILT -UPON SURFACES: 3079 square feet (includes the area of the roof/drip line of all buildings, driveways, covered decks, concrete or masonry patios, etc. that are within the applicable AEC. Attach your calculations with the project drawing.) Choose the AEC area that applies to your property: (1)within 75 feet of Normal High Water for the Estuarine Shoreline AEC (2)within 575 feet of Normal High Water for the Estuarine Shoreline AEC, adjacent to Outstanding Resource Waters (3)within 30 feet of the Public Trust Shoreline AEC (Contact your Local Permit Officer if you are not sure which AEC applies to your property.) STATE STORMWATER MANAGEMENT PERMIT: Is the project located in an area subject to a State Stormwater Management Permit issued by the NC Division of Water Quality? YES ❑ NO IZ If yes, list the total built upon area/impervious surface allowed for your lot or parcel. square feet. RECEIVED DCM WILMINGTON, NC JAN 2 8 2016 OTHER PERMITS MAY BE REQUIRED: The activity you are planning may require permits other than the CAMA minor development permit As a service we have compiled a listing of the kinds of permits that might be required. We suggest you check over the list with your LPO to determine if any of these apply to your project. Zoning, Drinking Water Well, Septic Tank (or other sanitary waste treatment system), Building, Electrical, Plumbing, Heating and Air Conditioning, Insulation and Energy Conservation, FIA Certification, Sand Dune, Sediment Control, Subdivision Approval, Mobile Home Park Approval, Highway Connection, and others. STATEMENT OF OWNERSHIP: I, the undersigned, an applicant for a CAMA minor development permit, being either the owner of property in an AEC or a person authorized to act as an agent for purposes of applying for a CAMA minor development permit, certify that the person listed as landowner on this application has a significant interest in the real property described therein. This interest can be described as: (check one) ® an owner or record title, Title is vested in fee simple, see Deed Book 1438 page 0228 in the Brunswick County Registry of Deeds. ❑ an owner by virtue of inheritance. Applicant is an heir to the estate of , probate was in County. ❑ if other interest, such as written contract or lease, explain below or use a separate sheet and attach to this application. NOTIFICATION OF ADJACENT PROPERTY OWNERS: I furthermore certify that the following persons are owners of properties adjoining this property. I affirm that I have given ACTUAL NOTICE to each of them concerning my intent to develop this property and to apply for a CAMA permit. (Name) (Address) (1) Hewett W Lee Hrs % Reese E Swan PO Box 10481 Southport NC 28461 (2) (3) (4) FOR DEVELOPERS IN OCEAN HAZARD AND ESTUARINE HAZARD AREAS: I acknowledge that the land owner is aware that the proposed development is planned for an area which may be susceptible to erosion and/or flooding. I acknowledge that the local permit officer has explained to me the particular hazard problems associated with this lot. This explanation was accompanied by recommendations concerning stabilization and floodproofing techniques. PERMISSION TO ENTER ON LAND: I furthermore certify that I am authorized to grant and do in fact grant permission to die local permit officer and his agents to enter on the aforementioned lands in connection with evaluating information related to this permit application. This application includes: general information (this form), a site drawing as described on the back of this application, the ownership statement, the AEC hazard notice where necessary, a check for $100.00 made payable to the locality, and any information as may be provided orally by the applicant. The details of the application as described by these sources are incorporated without reference in any permit which may be issued. Deviatipit from these details will constitute a violation of any permit. Any person developing in an AEC without permit is sub' t to civil, criminal and administrative action. day of J uary 016 .1 1-4- Landowner or person authorized to t as his agent for purpose of filing a CAMA pAdnit application RECEIVED DCM WILMINGTON, NC JAN 2 8 2016 AEC HAZARD NOTICE Project Is In An: X Ottion Erodible Area —High Hazard Flood Area Inlet Hazard Area Property Owner: John Douglas and James Winton Murray Property Address: Lot 15, Block 11, S-2 Oak Island NC 28465 Date Lot Was Platted: November 15, 2015 This notice is intended to make you, the applicant, aware of the special risks and conditions associated with development in this area, which is subject to natural hazards such as storms, erosion and currents. The rules of the Coastal Resources Commission require that you receive an AEC Hazard Notice and acknowledge that notice in writing before a permit for development can be issued. The Commission's rates on building standards, oceanfront setbacks and dune alterations are designed to minimize, but not eliminate, property loss from hazards. By granting permits, the Coastal Resources Commission does not guarantee the safety of the development and assumes no liability for future damage to the development. Permits issued in the Ocean Hazard Area of Environmental Concern include the condition that structures be relocated or dismantled ifthey become imminently threatened by changes in shoreline configuration. The structure(s) must be relocated or dismantled within two (2) years of becoming imminently threatened, and in any case upon its collapse or subsidence. The best available information,, as accepted by the Coastal Resources Commission, indicates that the annual long-term average ocean erosion rate for the area where your property is located is a feet per year. The rate was established by careful analysis ofaerial photographs of the coastline taken over the past 50 years. Studies also indicate that the shoreline could move as much as 3Q6- feet landward in a major storm. The flood waters in a major storm are predicted to be about q feet deep in this area Preferred oceanfront protection measures are beach nourishment and relocation of threatened structures. Hard erosion control structures such as bulkheads, seawalls, revetments, groins, jetties and breakwaters are prohibited. Temporary sand bags may be authorized under certain conditions. The applicant must acknowledge this information and requirements f notice in the space below. Without the proper plicationwillnotbecomplete. 1 January 2, 2016 Applicant Signature Date SPECIAL NOTE: This hazard notice is required fordevelopment in areas subject to sudden and massive storms and erosion. Permits issued for development in this area expire on December 31 of the third year following the year in which the permit was issued. Shortly before work begins on the project site, the Local Permit Officer must be contacted to determine the vegetation line and setback distance at your site. If the property has seen little change since the time ofpermit issuance, and the proposed development can still meet the setback requirement, the LPO will inform you that you may begin work. Substantial progress on the project must be made within 60 days of this setback determination, or the setback must be remeasured. Also, the occurrence ofa major shoreline change as the result of a storm within the 60-day period will necessitate remeasurement of the setback.. It is important thatyou check with the LPO before the pemritexpires for official approval to continue the work after the permit has expired. Generally, if foundation pilings have been placed and substantial progress is continuing, permit renewal can be authorized. It is unlawful to continue work afterpermit expiration. For more information, contact. �Ot�lnt A Local Permit Officer 4c,ol E, Oak Tsbr.d Address Oak Trio d, 1� C z8yt05- Locality (910) 001- g0 49 Phone Number dC.olervrar�@ c'i. oak_6gnJ. ()C.us RECEIVED DCM WILMINGTON, NC JAN 2 S 2016 Revised Receipts for Certified Mail (Staple Here) January 11, 2016 Hewett W. Lee Hrs % Reese E. Swan PO Box 10481 Southport, NC 28461 Dear Adjacent Property: This letter is to inform you that I, John Douglas Murray have applied for a CAMA Minor Permit on my property at Lot 15, Block 11, S-2 Oak Island NC 28465 in Brunswick County. As required by CAMA regulations, 1 have enclosed a copy of my permit application and project drawing(s) as notification of my proposed project. No action is required from you or you may sign and return the enclosed no objection form. If you have any questions or comments about my proposed project, please contact me at (910) 619-6902, or by mail at the address listed below. If you wish to file written comments or objections with the Town of Oak Island CAMA Minor Permit Program, you may submit them to: Donna F. Colemam Local Permit Officer for the Town of Oak Island 4601 E. Oak Island Dr. Oak Island, NC 28465 inc ely'� John D. Murray 514 Market Street Wilmington, NC 28401 RECEIVED DCM WILMINGTON, NC JAN 2 8 2016 U.S. Postal Service"' CERTIFIED MAIL° RECEIPT Djirhk. w=ly. _..;;. . PDr informatignriVJSiPour�website at www.usps. con, • Qer6*e�irYrberfy r..r�•IiMYIIYn�'�'!'�7'�^'1r� S Y a a — — r` CertKed Mall Fee $3.45 O 9 S cea ,see p,eotaa...m Teen wwopl-w 0402 ra ❑neam Reo-lot0 l7 ❑netan Recdpt (elac4aW S 11 Postmark C3 �Dvi Melt ReatMaddMY uu HDtD 0 �AdAt 54na[we Regaled oMue Sigv.RestrkteC D*M $ O Postage S s $2.30 01/15/2016 Total Postage and FeesED f8.55 S Seel To , 1{^ a --Jy��-}JS{AI-�IGIr�(J.C�G}9 5wc`q O SfinefarMgrp-�.Ar� r�°' ftl ADJACENT RIPARIAN PROPERTY OWNER STATEMENT FOR CAMA MINOR PERMITS I hereby certify that I own property adjacent to John Murray's property located at Lot 15, Block 11, S-2 Oak Island NC 28465 in Brunswick County on the Atlantic Ocean, in Oak Island, N.C. He has described to me as shown in the attached application and project drawing(s), the development he is proposing at that location, and, I have no objections to his proposal. (APPLICATION AND DRAWING OF PROPOSED DEVELOPMENT ATTACHED) Signature Print or Type Name Telephone Number Date RECEIVED DCM WILMINGTON, NC JAN 2 8 2016 Appointment of Authorized Agent CAMA Minor Permit Application I, James Winton Murray, an owner of the property located at Lot-14 Block-11 S-2 and Lot 15, Block- 11 S-2 Oak Island NC 28465 subject to the Application of a CAMA Minor Permit, do hereby appoint John Douglas Murray, as my authorized agent regarding this application, to provide testimony and evidence and respond to testimony and evidence on my behalf and to represent me regarding this application. � lam_ G�/�.�,--_ �'7.t.r.-,�-- / z • 2 3 -1 S Property Owner Signature Date hers!rtk County, North Carolina I certify that the following person(s) appeared before me this day, each acknowledging to me that he or she signed the foregoing document: Date: ROMONA W OWENS Notary Public Notary��— Forsyth Co., North Carolina y Commisslon Expires Mar. 39, 2919 My commiss on expires: (-�t• 20 -Z, Authorized Agent Signatures Date 1V6W (4 6AM A' County, North Carolina I certify that the following person(s) appeared before me this day, each acknowledging to me that he or she signed the foregoing document: Date: Notary Public My commission expires: Catherine H. Beaman j NOTARY PUBLIC New Hanover County, NC RECEIVED DCM WILMINGTON,'NC JAN 2 S 2016 514 Market Street, Wilmington NC 28401 phone 910.762.2621 jar 910.762.8506 . H , , , , , , www.bmhemh.com January 13, 2016 Ms. Donna F. Coleman Local Permit Officer for the Town of Oak Island PO Box 10481 Southport, NC 28461 Re: CAMA Minor Permit Dear Ms. Coleman: a�eYien 1�19�I� Please find enclosed the required information for the CAMA Minor Permit, including certified mail receipt for the adjacent property owner, for Lot 15, Block 11, S-2, Oak Island, North Carolina 28465. y`q q E , %,1,, Please let me know if you need further information. Sinc y N MURRAY HEMINGWAY ARCHITECTS John D. Murray, AIA JM/cb Attachments: General Information Site Drawing/Application Checklist Letter to Adjacent Property Owner Adjacent Riparian Property Owner Statement AEC Hazard Notice Before You Build Appointment of Authorized Agent Survey Map, Sheet A1.00, Sheet A2.00 RECEIVED DCM WILMINGTON, NC JAN 2 8 2016 . � 11'4" 18'4" COV. DECK 10'-0" DECK ; STORAGE - IN 1 1 1 ' 0 0 o d {} 1 4W-0" o e o � 1 1 h o 0 0 ' 1 1 n___a_____q 1 ' COV. ' :DECK' 8-_OR OPEN ---- _ _ _ _ e DOPEN ECK DECK � 5 301-W GROUND LEVEL SECOND FLR. LEVEL , 801-6" ;ATLANTIC FIRST REAR REAR OCEAN I LINE I PROPERTY I SETBACK OF LINE I LINE VEGETATION i t , I , 1 I I I , , 1 ' 1 - 41'-0" � I I I FENCE 12 . _ - _ LINE m 9'-0'. -451-0=11---- PILING EMBEDDED 10'-0" MINIMUM 200 SF OF STORAGE W/BREAKAWAY WALLS STATIC VEGETATION - - - - - -- - 1264 SO. FT. THIRD FLR. - - - - -1200 SQ. Fr. - - - SECOND FLR_ mia®i�imai® f 111-4" j THIRD FLR. LEVEL Building Floor Plans t-00 scale: 1" = 20'-0" OPEN DECK (FRONT FRONT 1 EAST SETBACK (PROPERTYBEACH LINE LINE , DRIVE I ' 1 , I " 1 1 I � ' 1 1 I ' , I , , ----- -----�------- *------------- ---- 1 , %.-- 5'-0" @ GRADE Site Section & Building Site Elevation A2.00 scale: 1" = 20'-0" A R C H 1 T f 514Mmk S8 WAmmgw, NC 28MI Td-(910)'/62-2621 Fu-(910)962-8506 c L i 3 2 L i sCd t, s Cd 0 a) CO O' -a Co o t r 0 p ~' 0) J E c f i' A2.00 1 I.S. S 0 °53'23' W 1.5 T mI l ��m N �� D m C2 Z y Z ml n 09'53'23' W .10' —� o D Z r . LINE BEARING DIET E i. L1 S 77°49'32' E 16. I i oN L2 58873'3TE L3 S 83°251T L4 S 79°38'22• E L5 .. S 79°38'2E my l ' L6 � 5 78'14'SV E 18 35' � � / L7 'M.=12'E 1 2a - LB_ 585°1§0'08'E .81' - P I` 9-5 — S09°53'23°W I.S. MAP OF SURVEY FOR JAMES WINTON MURRAY JOHN DOUGLAS MURRAY — — — — $ 99W— , I.S. I m / mw o0 � m 14 S 09953'23' W m 150.1210'- �- 1 � I� Im Z I I0 c 15 �. im f __ — �— .�.� I.S. `r S'.09°5323° W �7ENtROACHMENT I ' N= 59381.91 I E--2268621.50 AREA SE 49TH ST. PUBLIC PARKING AREA I 50' PUBLIC RNII I _ (UNIMPROVED) I I o �° q TOWN OF OAK ISLAND, BRUNSWICK COUNTY, N.C. I 4 SE 49TH W DATE: NOVEMBER 18, 2015 ICAIpp�•,, ....... , 1 I LEGEND - `��� O OFE$S/p.;...Ir � _: . E.I. EXISTING IRON _� ; QQ' '�(; � I CERTIFY THAT THIS MAP WAS DRAWN UNDER MY SUPERVISION I.S. IRON SET = SEAL = SURVEY MADE UNDER MY SUPERVISION (FROM REFERENCES A' E.C.M. EXISTING CONCRETE MONUMENT = = THAT THE BOUNDARIES NOT SURVEYED ARE INDICATED AS DRA • L-2876 F AS SHOWN HEREON: THAT THE RATIO OF PRECISION OR POSRIC NOTES pR•- IS 10.000+ ; ANDTHATTHISMAP MEETSTHEREOUIR 1. FOR REFERENCE SEE M.B. 1- PG. 99, DB 1350 PG 239S 1.1t '� •' : THE STANDARDS OF PRACTICE FOR LAND SURVEYING IN NORTH (i1 sUK <v 2. AREA COMPUTED BY COORDINATE METHOD. �i,� 7QE.``��� (21 NCAC 58.1800). THIS 19TH DAY OF NOEMBER . 2015. 3. SURVEYED IN NOEMBER OF 2015. �i4. ALL DISTANCES ARE HORIZONTAL. ,� G' A, wP �\% 5. VERTICALATUM RELATIVE TO NAVO 88 '7j�11111I ACTUAL 0 20 40 60 IEREON)' INFORMATION (RACY F N.C. D 3?MENT) (2007 ADJU I — F;1�SSE 49TH S_T. II 50' PUBLIC R1W 1 ( I I I I I 1 I I i ANOVER DESIGN SERVICES, P.A. LAND. SURVEYORS, ENGINEERS, LAND PLANNERS FIRM CERTIFICATE No. C597 T T THIS LOT IS IN A FLOOD HAZARDOUS AREA ZONE VE EL 18 PER NC FLOOD MAP. WIL FLORAL PARKWAY w ( ) WILMINGTON, N.C. 28403THIS MAP IS NOT FOR RECORDATION PHONE(910)343-8002 DRAWING# 0 0 4 CALCULATIONS - FOOTPRINT AREA HOUSE (FOOTPRINT AREA) 1740 SQUARE FEET CONCRETE DRIVEWAY 2785 SQUARE FEET LOT 13 (HEWETTW. LEE I REESE, E. SWAN) 5 6 7 8 T2 12 11 10 9 8 7 6 11 `L FIRST LINE I; I! J I I I I r- OF VEGETATION I\ I IW _I IIII o I LL 1 J00 79t-10'.' 1 SETBACK FROM LINE I I I III I f 20'-0"� � f I I I I I PLAN FOOTAGE TOTALS GROUND LEVEL 200 SQ. FT. SECOND FLR. LEVEL 1280.HTG. SQ. FT. SEC. FLR. GOV. FRONT DECK 64 SQ. FT. SEC. FUR. OPEN FRONT DECKS 176 SQ. FT. SEC. FUR. COV. REAR DECK 113 SQ. FT. SEC. FUR. OPEN REAR DECK 187 - SQ. FT. THIRD FUR. LEVEL 1264 HTG. SO. FT. THIRD FUR. OPEN FRONT DECKS 176 SO. FT. THIRD FUR. REAR COV. DECK 113 SQ. FT. THIRD FLR.4REAR OPEN DECK 187 SO. FT: HEATED TOTAL 2464 HTG. SO. FT. ' OVERALL 3680 SQ. FT. w ' of LL¢ I 1 pj LLQ Q ZZ W� Z WE QJ QJ CONCRETE _ DRIVEWAY ULL Ua 0_ 09 D 53. W c wo 150 00' LOT 14 ROOF �� 5 O.H. 30 u tt tt ' SF VEGETATION 1 Qi�0 m C f%f lWM 8'x8" PILh . LOT 15 \ 1 (MUR"Ay' JAMES WINTON I 8 JOHN DOUGLAS) ` I 5 l IMPERVEOUS FOOTAGES HOUSE FOOTAGE 1377SQ. FT. CONCRETE DRIVEWAY 1.1548 SQ. FT. TOTAL IMPERVEOUS 2925 SQ. FT. 1 I 1 STATIC 1 1 VEGETATION 1 LINE I I 1 1- I5 1 o O 1 '-4" — — —.-35' 10' - -------- ---=_--T"N FRONTT 1 SETBACK. _150.00' S09D53'23"W _ _ 1 -' /'S 1 1 I STATIC 1 VEGETATION 1 5 I LINE / 1 � 1 1 Conceptual Site Plan A1.00 scale:1 20'-0" p PLAN NORTH-