86435A_Mueller, Mark & Christine_20211206

- (L N' ) 8643.5 B C D
AAM�CAMA � DREDGE � FILL � 1lG
Previous permit `
ji-
GENERALPERMIT Date previous permit issued L4
t)WA-
)CNew ❑ Modification ❑ Complete Reissue Ra+ +ak-Reissm
As authorized by the
th��e11State of
North Carolina, Department of Environmental Quality and the Coastal Resources Commission in an area of environmental concern pursuant to:
I SA NCAC T l ± .� L._..._._...__._........._._.__._.._.____.— Rules attached. General Permit Rules available at the following fink: wvr,,.deo.ncsovlC gs
Applicant Name UMr I Authorized Agent Plitt"fT VW— (�lLt,►riet.+L Wa t7ffj�j iUY
�.
Address :2L4 Czi—AgM0, %� E7KrWl ti ._...._.... ... Project Location (County): _D;�-
City C z `J ��+ � State,
ZIP 2-'5L �4' Street
�A, dddress/St/ate Road/Lot fi(s) 9 1 rJ 5�_ 6A"Aeu ._.._
Phone # (&4 _5U(L—�t+L.L4 _ s[lY�._..4 i
Email r^ZWY-, MLt.l..UA,,, nn"tJA,Q,{CbV- IAAA61ICo Subdivision
C V W► City 5L"A i("A �21A L V"'*? L2 ZIP
Affected cW s EW PTA j� ES I PTS Adj. Wtr. Body -SeCiw}e- r¢ an/unk)
AEC(s): oEA ( IHA UW [� SPIMA PWS Closest Mai. Wtr. Body CIAW1
54`:.t.t/lLri
ORW: ye no PNA>&o
�n
Type of Project/ Activity (F ) i%Atj't'Y i,i CA Gl i 5r X � 51
yVC:)i U fl-,
_^_ (State:
Shoreline Length i
Access Length '~T
Pier (dock) length
Fixed Platform(s)
Floating Platform(s)
Finger piers)
Total Platform area _
Groin length/#
Bulkhead/ Riprap length
Avg distance offshore
Breakwater/Sill
Max distance/ length
Basin, channel
Cubic yards
Boat ramp
Boathous oat t —_—
Beach Bulldozing
Other
SAV observe& yes no
Moratorium: n a yes no
Site Photos a no
Riparian Waiver Attached:
A building permit/zoniing permit may be required by:
Permit Conditions 19;A FV cPrr. 0-1� w
t;tA
�-
Vic) 0
f ',. ',_ !
Agen r ApDlicant ?R
Signature '*P#ease re t a em n on back of permit"
Application Feels) Check #/Money Order
AND
TARtPAM/NEUSE,rBLIFFER (circle one)
See note on back regarding River Basin rules
112 11W See additional notes/conditions on back
^2) --1$, &
,NCESTATEMENT, (Please initial)__
Permit Officer's PRINTED N e
Signature
Z-- 2C' i GvL2.
Issuing Date Exa r� ation Date

N.C. DIVISION OF COASTAL MANAGEMENT
AGENT AUTHORIZATION FORM
Date 0-,I-) I
Name of Pro Owner Applying for Permit:
i)LOL 71.r�,elljz-
Mailing Address:
P I
�I `i r Q_ 4Jl 1V to act on m
I certifythat I have authorized (agent) 15 6 Y
g
behalf, for the purpose of applying for and obtaining all CAMA Permits necessary to
install or construct (activity)
at (my property located at) I l t1 i (-
This certification
Property Owner Signa
Date

ROY COOPER
Governor
ELIZABETH S. BISER
Secretary
BRAXTON DAVIS
Director
Richard & Karen Galganski
95 Osprey Lane
Southern Shores, NC 27949
NORTH CAROLINA
Environmental Quality
December 6, 2021
Re: Objection to the Issuance of CAMA General Permit No. 86435-A for a Docking Facility Development Project,
located at 97 Osprey Lane, Southern Shores, Dare County.
Dear Mr. & Mrs. Galganski:
The Division of Coastal Management has reviewed your correspondence dated September 30, 2021 and received on
October 5, 2021, in regards to your objection as an adjacent riparian property owner to a permit request from Millstone
Marine Construction, an agent for Mark & Christine Mueller, The permit request was for the construction of a 13'x13' boat
lift and to properly notify you of changes in the existing docking facility's initial orientation and location along the shoreline
of 97 Osprey Lane in Southern Shores, Dare County. On September 16, 2021, DCM Field Representative Sarah Loeffler
conducted a site visit to evaluate the permittee's need for additional permitting, and to address the concerns expressed by
you in a phone call on September 8, 2021.
Under the Coastal Area Management Act (CAMA), the Coastal Resources Commission (CRC) has established Rules for
General Permits for this type of development that are found in 15A NCAC 07H.1200,
The Division has reviewed your objections, along with all aspects of this development proposal for consistency with the
aforementioned Rules, which describe the CRC's standards and guidelines for this type of development. Our review of the
proposed modification has found it to be consistent with the Rules of the CRC and the State's Coastal Management
Program, and that all pre -requisites have been satisfied. Therefore, the Division of Coastal Management issued the
General Permit No. 86435-A on December 6, 2021 (copy attached) for the proposed development.
If you wish to appeal this permit decision, you must file a Third Party Hearing Request Form with the Director of the Division
of Coastal Management within 20 days of the permit issuance date. If you choose to pursue an appeal, please contact
this office so that we can provide you with the appropriate forms and addresses.
If you have any further questions regarding this matter, please do not hesitate to contact Sarah Loeffler or myself at this
office.
Sincerely,
Ron Renaldi, District Manager
Northeast District
cc: Sarah Loeffler, DCM Field Representative
Millstone Marine Construction, Authorized Agent
Mark & Christine Mueller, Permittee
Enclosed
North Carolina Department of Environmental Quality I Division of Coastal Management
Elizabeth City Office 1 401 South Griffin Street, Suite 300 1 Elizabeth City, North Carolina 27909
+ain.c�.era..m 252.264.3901

September 30, 2021
Richard Galganski
95 Osprey Lane RECEIVED
Southern Shores, NC 27949
OCT 0 5 2021
Division of Coastal Management
401 S. Griffin Street aCi�n-EC
Suite 300
Elizabeth City, NC 27909
RE: Adjacent Riparian Property Owner Notification
97 Osprey Lane, Southern Shores, NC
In response to the received Boatlift addition for owner Mark Mueller:
OBJECT. Owner Mueller's original application for proposed pier depicted the structure in or
about the middle of the 140' bulkhead, which in good faith, was not objected to. However, in a
bad faith move and without further notice, owner shifted the structure to the far end of the
bulkhead, settling within 1' of the permitted 15' off the adjacent property line. The proposed
boat lift sits parallel and as close as permitted by rules to our existing boat launch. It is clear
that the owner intended to leave his sightline undisturbed without any regard to his neighbor
by producing an unnecessary hardship to the egress and ingress to our boat launch.
Although we are of the understanding the application of this structure will most likely be
permitted under the existing rules, the deception exhibited by the applicant is unacceptable.
When an application is submitted for approval it should be held to the intent presented. The
owner could have comfortably shifted the structure utilizing any other portion of the 140'
bulkhead, especially in light of the fact the property to his right has no pier, bulkhead or boat
launch and is not occupied by a full time resident. Further, the applicant is not a full-time
resident and will not be utilizing the structure on any routine basis making his deception even
more callous.
RICHARD GAL I, owner 95 Osprey Lane
REN GALGANSKI4owner 95 Osprey Lane

September 23rd, 2021
Richard Galganski
95 Osprey Lane
Kitty Hawk N.C.
27949
Reference: Boatlift addition for Mark Mueller
Mr. Galganski:
We have been hired to construct a new pier and bulkhead on your neighbor's property by
Mark Mueller. I did not include a boatlift when we originally permitted the pier. This
notice is for the boatlift addition. Enclosed is an adjacent property owner consent form
and drawing of the proposed change required by Coastal Management to be sent to you.
If you have no objections please sign and date the form and return it to us in the stamped
envelope provided. Should you have objections please follow the instructions on the
form.
Have a great day
Kevin Lineberger
Estimator
Millstone Marine Construction, Inc.
252-202-2678 cell
0 C T 13 2021

W
o
�
Y
O
v
60b� 9TTE 2000 0922 620Z
c•a
n~•
16-
E6EZ 9TTE 2000 0922 6M

Postal Service'
�TIF]Fn MAIL' RECEIF
M Domestic Awl Vinly
27R4�
0954
7G
$3.75
04
m S.,� eas kb=4ddf*OEyfPfR?"
13
to
ru
rij
0 Retum Recd-Pt py)
0 Pet = Receipt (C%C rt:,-)
LI Ctflod M.1 Rest eM —1-Y $
[]AdaugnatxeR-i-d $ tlf- —
[]AduttSlgr--wmRest;cted0o:M'Y_S
$0.78
u C T 2 6 2021

September 23rd, 2021
Anne Thomas
99 Osprey Lane
Kitty Hawk V.C.
27949
Reference: Boatlift addition for Mark Mueller
Ms. Thomas:
We have been hired to construct a new pier and bulkhead on your neighbor's property by
Mark Mueller. I did not include a boatlift when we originally permitted the pier. This
notice is for the boatlift addition. Enclosed is an adjacent property owner consent form
and drawing of the proposed change required by Coastal Management to be sent to you.
If you have no objections please sign and date the form and return it to us in the stamped
envelope provided. Should you have objections please follow the instructions on the
form.
Have a great day
Kevin Lineberger
Estimator
Millstone Marine Construction, Inc.
252-202-2678 cell
Rt��et-.
0 C T 1 3 2021
DCM-EC

Pier for 97 Osprey Lane Revised
J

This map is prepared
from data used for the
inventory of the real
property for tax
purposes. Primary
"'.
information sources such
as recorded deeds. plats.
>v
wills, and other primary
public records should be
consulted for verification
of the information
97 Osprey LN
Southern Shores NC, 27949
Parcel: 022309000
Pin: 986709264113
Owners: Mueller, Mark -Primary
Owner
Mueller, Christine -Primary Owner
Building Value: $184,000
Land Value: $351,700
Misc Value: $0
Total Value: $535,700
Tax District: Southern Shores
Subdivision: So/sh 114-117 126,127 200-
202
Lot BLK-Sec: Lot: 10 Blk: 126 Sec:
Property Use: Residential
Building Type: Ranch
Year Built: 1988
e:
84.67

M-1
&moo 11
e-
4 - m