19750D - Kelly

4.-
CAMA AND DREDGE AND FILL
GENERAL
-Y- N f 19750- )
PERMIT (v6r1A.Nc„
as authorized by the State of North Carolina
0 Department of Environment, Health, and Natural Resources and the Coastal Resources Commission
in an area of environmental concern pursuant to 15A NCAC 171-1 • 1200
Applicant Name '\eN i�1' Phone Number 9'1 9 178 3- 18C99
Address 1 O P B l c_n f i► N'1 -111-i►1?)
City State Kid] Zip 01'7 Go i
Project Location (County, State Road, Water Body, etc.) e do C1Ou A4-11 1 107 77-o i+ e r,uc I
To IDSA',1 .,Ac h, I\)ct), KAPcy,— W\r6l . 06-,\A I rr
Type of Project Activity WV-01)G,r 8 (40At I° F t ) i"; nr,ir t- (J►e.,( /LA A im T tO AA„nt,CJ UC K
9-0 lam.± P tk - P e....-t- 33o TI tAb n. a r;vc� w;l nN-r 4 n 1 n1� aka
zeta- o05-3
PROJECT DESCRIPTION SKETCH _ � � �� � ' (SCALE: NOT T(,) )
flier(dock) length
(4' X nE f,ny r)----
Groin length
number
/
Bulkhead length < la `a
no O S �-v\
max.distance offshore
ed OTAT '
Basin,channel dimensions U(1Cv '
,�
15t bow . . 15t
cubic yards 6t-kbAC1 • \JPt • 7 0 0 b' Se-tbN-t-
,!i � l
Boat ramp dimensions > ,n'
Other 101 )( 1 a 1 CIUgk V- ,
r ,
r, (.0Oi LoT
pc,
This permit is subject to compliance with this application, sitey /��( Gl��
drawing and attached general and specific conditions. Any
violation of these terms may subject the permittee to a fine, applicant's signature
imprisonment or civil action; and may cause the permit to be- ,
come null and void.
a,/ ,This permit must be on the project site and accessible to th• permit officer's signature
permit officer when the project is inspected for complianc, Q
The applicant certifies by signing this permit that 1) this pro- a1161GV •Inek"C) - al 1�q
CI
ject is consistent with the local land use plan and all local issuing date expiration date
ordinances, and 2) a written statement has been obtained from
adjacent riparian landowners certifying that they have no attachments (7-}—f • (2UQ
objections to the proposed work.

GENERAL PERMIT COMPUTER FORM
APPLICANT NAME: 3 O k r1 KL`t
ADDITIONAL NAMES: 11
AEC DESIG: P T G' w i DEVELOP AREA:__007 PROJ DES C: F - I�
(Will take --
(WM only take 1)
FORK: (?L I. .' & I a' P (a. I 0 Y. 121
(Will only take 4)
1
P ►2-1 4- x ( 7'
3(g--
MAINT:
(WM only take 4)
BAP: QLaJ lLI- + O(A) 1 2-0
(will only take
t,J Co u
ACTION EXPIRATION
DREDGE&FILL REQUIRED: 12 ! '2./ a 6) 3l a f R 7
CAMA MAJOR DEVEL REQUIRED:

1
•
VI--_ C - c)
, C 4' Page RCll792(ofl7
C __.-C7sFI'Sli—
„........_....„...._. ° ! 7 �o:tOffice 3ox:089
Topsoil Beach. North
j Carolina 284d:-9g3
1 Telephone [phone]
Fax 1910j 328-1560
DI V;SICN OF COASTAL M.1 NAGEMENT
.A.DIAC/i RIPARIAN PROP. RTy O : R.NO iitICA?T02d/Wa
-NP FORM
Name of Individual Applying For?emzit: �- ( /
cG1 ek.A a ()
Address OI Pro e::V: t
1 1 YU uA- AJt►n u z
• p p42i l 62(IC ft\ MC -hin_ct eC
l-of or$ et #,Street or Road,City SE County
I hereby c.., that I own ._e .. e,,
"rfir i�Pty adjacent to the above ref.eac_d propery.The ; a
-'-.s pe mit has described to me as shown on the dr, are 000s:lg for
attached`�wirg the development they are p_*rposa-+,g.A
dretion cr d awhiz with dth ensicrs,should be provided with this letter.
7 I have no objections to this proposal
- . If you have obieccors to what is be^+ie or000sed_please write the Town of:of sail Beach.P. 0. Box 3089,
Topsail Beach.N. C. 284-454-983I,or You may contact Jon Brigs. CA.\2A T PO Officer at 910-33213-2108
wit-: 10 days ofreceiat of this netce. No resuorse is considered the
o same as no obicn You have
_ been
.^. t.$ed by Ca^,;$ed M=il.
WAIVER SECTION
I,1-.1ders nd that a pier,dock,m000ng pilings, breakwater,boat house,lit.or sandbags mnust be set back
minimum ice of 15' from my area of tiparian access tm rss waived by me.(If you wish to waive the
setback.you muse L-iidal the apprepziate Manic below.)
I do wish to waive the 15' setback requirement.
/ `Y 1 di.,not wish to waive the 15' setback te'_uirement.
AOfef t -7--6.4'-//1 ----- /4-. AT
Slt&is.Zz-O O Dal'
,iC 0R4,e_ /r !li �i4�C'/�
Print Name _
Telephone Number With Area Code

CRC-792(c)
• f / 7 Page 12 of 17
p W M o c
R 01.1 li w
p T e = Post Office Sox 3089
Topsail Beach. North Carolina 28445-9B3I
1 Telephone [phone]
Fax [phone]o0
DIVISION OF COASTAL.MANAGEMENT
?ADJACENT RIPARIAN PROPERTY OWNER NOTIFICATION/WAIVE FORM
Name of individual Applying For Pewit p i1 n . Q n C! ifa. ej
Address ofPrcuerty: I b'1 Yu u.-1- A-V
_. _ --- o c r g ig N C.- , Ade.;y
- -
(Lot br Street 1,St;eet or Road,City&.County
I iereby cer that I own property adjacent to the above referenced property.The individual applying for
this perms it has des.need to me as shown on the attached drawing the development they are proposing_A
desertion cr drawing,with dimensions,should be provided with this letter.
I have no objections to this pr000sai.
If you have ebie ors to what is b& ,r000sed.ulease write the Town of To>rsail Beach,P. O. Box 3089
Topsail Beach,N.C.284454-9831,_or you may contact Jon Sri_ , C AM.A LPO Officer at 910-328-2708
withM 10 days of receipt of this notice.No response is considered the same as no objection if you have
been notified by Certified Mail
WAIVER SECTION
•
I, --t nd that a pier,dock,mooring pilinos,breakwater, boat house,lift or sandbags must be set back
minimum distance of 15' from my area of riparian access unless waived by me.(If you wish to waive the
setback,you must Initial the appropnate blank below.)
• I do wish to waive the 15' setback rectzreme t
C- < I do not wish to waive the 15' setback requirement.
r •
aitOVYYI DCLU:Q
S i iar.i a Date
W I L L i 1--1 A y l,t1 AZ7
Print Name (7OQ 3 - -3S, 9
Telephone Number With Area Code

• TROUT AVE.(60'R/W-20'PAVED) \•
i• (P.KNAIL,)..--'-
• TROUT AVE. \ CRC-792(c)
EP
CONTROL PT. 6'pSp4,` Page 10 of 17
P •..
CL ps. o I ..
INTERSECTION `"
SPOT AVE.3 PP RNA
RAN S 39'40'00'E — _ -
60.00' EIF'J
EIP (Bent)
(Bent) w
_ z
n
LEGEND a
EP=EDGE OF PAVEMENT D A
L U
RAN=RIGHT OF WAY E w
EIP=EXISTING IRON PIPE/PIN C K ! w
PP=POWER POLE CONC. w
n\
K 13.1
•
ELEC=OVERHEAD POWERLINE -_PO
' •
•
O
RCH j
34.0'
I D WOOD FRAME
4 I E SFD 1
w I C b [ HEAT PUMP&
o N I K b <o ELEC SERVICE
0
,- 1-- I ENCL. • ''' ~O N al
Q AREA ~ • o
�.• Z 0 01 1st.FL. n
_>.
I DECK 7- 1
/N(- A6 I I
\ /f 1 0
X.'°c I 1 T
\\ \,Voe, I D ! NEW TOPSAIL BEACH
I E I SUBDIVISION
s.
N 'N I C I 12 13
11 ) -✓ 1 K .1k J --
1st
FL
1.63'TO FACE O
OF 94 E 2 17•TO FACE
!�T1 BULKHEAD'.�1 EIP - F IP OF BULKHEAI
iTi�S1S! ,� I —N 35'50'39•W.. , ....,
59.5 j'o ,,, 't i ` T ,T
\ 1 0'WIDE I DOCK . - '
CONC. BULKHEAD - --- 31_.. 1.0'WIDE
-- '� ,_ _O CONC.BULKHEAD
,. •
„_._ -
CANAL»1
• loW u3 -c ry CK 1 4.... ram 'Lk
VICINITY MAP�NOT TO SCALE) / WO HI P OPERTY IS LOCATED IN A
l OPSAIL SOUND SITE SPECIAL FLOOD HAZARD AREA
1 - -- — -_..
w 1 Q iwiHL
Q I Q ¢SPOTAVE.v O
i� O I1r
1 12 m 1 F-
OCEAN BLVD. _..„- --- — —
THE RATIO OF PRECISION
AS CALCULATED IS 1 10.000
s JAMES P VERT,RLS L-3585
�---- A-TD%-1TTIi`O-CrAN
SURVEY FOR
ACME
I 1 E
JOHN S. &WIFE,BARBARA J.KELLEY H Iv'
SURVEYING & MAPPINI
TOWNSHIP COUNTY STATE DATE SCALE P.O. BOX 2650,SURF CITY.NC 28445
TOPSAIL
FENDER NC 06-27-98 1.'=20' PHONE/FAX[phone]
20 10 0 20
- - liSION ! —Nem_--a__..-.

STATE OF NORTH CAROLINA BEFORE THE NORTH CAROLINA
COASTAL RESOURCES COMMISSION
COUNTY OF PENDER
IN THE MATTER OF: )
PETITION FOR VARIANCE ) FINAL ORDER
BY JOHN and BARBARA ) OCT '4`l
KELLEY ) DIV( jO,\
-OA TAL MANAGEMENT
This matter was heard on oral arguments and stipulated facts at the regularly scheduled
meeting of the North Carolina Coastal Resources Commission (hereinafter CRC) on September 24,
1998, in Morehead City, North Carolina pursuant to N.C.G.S. § 113A-120.1 and T15A NCAC
7J.0700, et seq. Associate Attorney General Mary Penny Thompson appeared for the Department
of Environment and Natural Resources, Division of Coastal Management; Petitioners John and
Barbara Kelley chose not to appear. '
Upon consideration of the record documents and the arguments of the parties, the CRC
adopts the following:
STIPULATED FACTS
1. Petitioners' property is located at 107 Trout Avenue, Topsail Beach, North Carolina
in Pender County. The lot fronts a man-made canal approximately one and a half miles from New
Topsail Inlet. It is not located on an ocean-facing shoreline and does not contain oceanside
characteristics such as dunes or wetland vegetation.
?. Both an Estuarine Waters Area of Environmental Concern (AEC) and an Ocean
Hazard AEC overlap Petitioner's lot.
3. Petitioners sought a CAMA General Permit to replace existing canal decking and
ramps with an uncovered boat lift, a finger pier and a floating dock.
4. The proposed development consists of a boat lift not exceeding 400 square feet and

extending no more than 13 feet onto Petitioners' property; a 4-foot by 20-foot stationary finger pier;
a 3-foot by 12-foot finger pier (from the stationary finger pier to the floating dock); and a 10-foot by
12-foot floating dock.
5. The adjacent neighbors have no objections to the project.
6. The Division of Coastal Management denied Petitioners' General Permit request on
August 17, 1998 due to its inconsistency with Rule 15A NCAC 7H.1200 which allows piers and
docks in an Estuarine Waters AEC, but prohibits them in an Ocean Hazard AEC.
7. Piers and floating docks are common structures along man-made canals in estuarine
waters.
Based on the foregoing, Stipulated Facts, the Commission makes the following:
CONCLUSIONS OF LAW
1. The CRC has jurisdiction over the parties and the subject matter.
2. The parties have been correctly designated and there is no question of misjoinder or
nonjoinder of parties.
3. All notices for the proceeding were adequate and proper.
4. Application of 15A NCAC 7H.1201 to deny Petitioners a general permit for construction
of a pier and floating dock on his property will result in practical difficulties or unnecessary
hardship to Petitioners in that Petitioners will be unable to have water access.
5. The hardship is caused by conditions peculiar to Petitioners' property which is within both
the Estuarine Shoreline and Ocean Hazard Area of Environmental Concern, but has characteristics
of an estuarine rather than an ocean shoreline.
6. The Commission could not reasonably have anticipated, at the time of adoption, that the

3
general permit for construction of piers, docks and boat houses, T15A NCAC .1200, would not be
available to certain property owners on estuarine shorelines because of expansion of the ocean
hazard AEC to include the estuarine shoreline in some areas.
7. The proposed development is within the spirit, purpose and intent of the Commission's
rules in that the rules allow construction of piers, docks and boat houses on estuarine shorelines and
Petitioner's property has the characteristics of an estuarine shoreline.
THEREFORE, the petition for variance from T15A NCAC 7H.1201 is GRANTED and a
CAMA general permit shall be issued for installation of a pier, floating dock and boatlift waterward
of Petitioners' property consistent with the standards otherwise set out in the referenced general
permit rules.
This the �. , ��
day of 0;%' -f-�Gtt , 1998.
- i;vim- 1 /"
Eugene B. Tomlinson, Jr., Chairman
Coastal Resources Commission

FUNCTION=> C NEXT PERMIT=> GENERAL PERMIT ENTRY/UPDATE RRD16(
PERMIT NO: GP19750 DISTRICT: I COUNTY: PENDER
AEC DESIG: PT EW APP FEE: 50 . 00 REGIONAL REP: RUSSELL
APPLICANT NAME: KELLY, JOHN
MAILING ADDRESS : 1208 BLENHEIM DRIVE
CITY: RALEIGH STATE: NC ZIP: 27612
LOCATION: 107 TROUT AVE WATER BODY: MAN MADE CANAL
LOCATION ADDRESS: (WHEN DIFFERENT FROM MAILING)
CITY: TOPSAIL BEACH STATE: NC ZIP:
DEV AREA: 0 . 07 PROJECT DESC: P-12 STATE PLANE COORD X: Y:
WORK: BL 12 12 00 0 PR 10 12 00 0 PR 4 17 00 0
MNT:
IMP: OW 144 OW 120 OW 68
ACTION EXPIRATION
DREDGE AND FILL: 12 02 98 03 02 99
CAMA MAJOR DEVELOPMENT:
MESSAGE: ENTER DATA YOU WISH TO CHANGE
PF1=HELP PF2=MAIN MENU PF3=PERMIT MENU PF4= PREVIOUS SCREEN PF5=ADD NAMES

•
•
ROBERT B. PHIEL,JR. 580
PH.910-392-0053 NCDL 9883818330 66-19/530 NC
WI MINGTTOULOO , (<7 i ?. 702
WILMINGTON,NC 28405 --- <
/ S `,(
Pay to f (1:L��-c_- J $ 5
Order of -- .. - -
x:Dollars
Na onsBank
Nations Bank,N.A.
For
1:0 5 3000 L 9 61: 0006527958570 0 580116o