Loading...
HomeMy WebLinkAbout19759D - Shell Fri if.is,..,.........,,,,,-,..,..--,,,---„-..-,„-,R►--„,..,,'._.-... __ .. CAMA AND DREDGE AND FILL • GENERAL Y l a 1 9"7 59 -- D PERMIT -y-i-e.,.,_.,a.a - C� O— `7 — as authorized by the State of North Carolina wA - �91 �T (l 1 - Department of Environment, Health,and Natural Resources and the Coastal Resources Commission in an area of environmental concern pursuant to 15A NCAC 7H I vs O Applicant Name Sl4-eu_ iti.ttatJj' kesocEr N-n,k YoI 44$ Phone Number TC,Q..,-D$eve) Address V,J• rr%I }i a( City r1s Ut nilo L. State N Ci Zip 2848O Project Location (County, State Road, Water Body, etc.) tea Ci•F V./1t16N1Su t R.;' 6eac L , MJA-tom"$ MAso•s -fis let k..►c( I*rTL c O ced,.l , N®w H-tMirrv-er C01 a Nark( . Type of Project Activity EMrr e .'cy A-t'i P.ror.t-swsEr Jr..1, 7 R.-ae 14 gam'I Dsai - PROJECT DESCRIPTION SKETCH (SCALE: TS ) A I LA 71 ( (Sc,G,,4-T Ac tfect . ur Pier(dock) length ®�MPerz14-0 SAND Musr Be. OF CrarhP4T181-e, - . �— C.o t.oR. ,-rs x rt.�e:C) 4 6RA I N .stZG 0 k114 N4;14� ' e. ct SA-p3D. Groin length p '((4.1S rertvt ,, cc .s 1.4 err fLmte.vt., -'gyp.. opt ica04--Plow\ 0 Bilk'WK..]� ikkly Q.equirecQ (ocaL o 11. Ted erAL A•u- or►Z./rr1tr.•,5, number 2 lUOrk Teo e,t, CDv1t.(SrT'i- ALL„ h{lf,Iicalolt„ cac,cii.{^ro+`S c F 7A4'.18oc Bulkhead length t� Li max. distance offshore d1C' ...7-, + IN/ Basin,channel dimensions 7K 1 p 0. e___ v___,.._ f ' / /� '18 2'� ,,,,,_____ . cubic yards kt. — Peon Boat ramp dimensions i L --SouT1a Tel- Other row K cµ '►.uu Lt sev I r i �hQk-iNb• DcG-k. tilrIfiti-4t4 ±l4btF This permit is subject to compliance with this application, site drawing and attached general and specific conditions. Any 9 _ (', violation of these terms may subject the permittee to a fine, iCjit imprisonment or civil action; and may cause the permit to be applicant's signature come null and void. This permit must be on the project site and accessible to the permit officer's signature permit officer when the project is inspected for compliance.The applicant certifies by signing this permit that 1) this pro- , - 4 " G 115 1 — LA - 5 ject is consistent with the local land use plan and all local issuing date expiration date ordinances, and 2) a written statement has been obtained from adjacent riparian landowners certifying that they have no '•7 N objections to the proposed work. attachments Li- . . GENERAL PERMIT COMPUTER FORM APPLICANT NAME: S M U_, „��$ansoi ADDITIONAL NAMES: •k-AT`I4 3 �Lr(c S� 4 AEC DESIG: O kk DEVELOP AREA: . 1 PROJ DESC: C - (Will only take 6) ———— (Will only take 1) a WORK: (Will only take 4) MAINT: (Will only take 4) DVIP: )C 5,9 (will only take 6) ACTION EXPIRATION DREDGE&FILL REQUIRED: CAMA MAJOR DEVEL REQUIRED: I oZ-4-G/ I --L(--lij I e ?,41 tfe or( Resort Hotel all oceanfront suites December 2, 1998 VIA CERTIFIED MAIL RETURN RECEIPT REQUESTED Z 153 205 454 Town of Wrightsville Beach c/o Town Manager Post Office Box 626 Wrightsville Beach, NC 28480 Dear Sir: In accordance with State regulations, we wish to notify you of the dune restoration project Shell Island Homeowners Association, Inc. proposes to protect its property from further damage due to erosion and flooding. The attached site plan and letter to Ed Brooks provide an outline of the proposed project . The State gives you the right to oppose this project by filing objections with the Division of Coastal Management (127 Cardinal Drive Extension, Wilmington, NC 28405) or the Secretary of the North Carolina Department of Environment and Natural Resources (2728 Capital Boulevard, Parker Lincoln Building, Raleigh, NC 27604) . Please feel free to contact me if you have any questions or comments . Sincerely, Michael Stonestreet, Manager Shell Island HOA, Inc . MS/cp cp3441wb.let Enclosure cc : Shanklin & McDaniel, L.L.P. Donna Moffitt, Director D. C.M. 4;ant 44 Z4/460( - _ _ • Resort Hotel all oceanfront suites December 2, 1998 VIA CERTIFIED MAIL RETURN RECEIPT REQUESTED Z 153 205 452 Jerry A. Hailey, Jr. 317 West Chatham Street Cary, NC 27511 Dear Mr. Hailey: In accordance with State regulations, we wish to notify you of the dune restoration control project Shell Island Homeowners Association, Inc. proposes to protect its property from further damage due to erosion and flooding. The attached site plan and letter to Ed Brooks provide an outline of the proposed project . The State gives you the right to oppose this project by filing objections with the Division of Coastal Management (127 Cardinal Drive Extension, Wilmington, NC 28405) or the Secretary of the North Carolina Department of Environment and Natural Resources (2728 Capital Boulevard, Parker Lincoln Building, Raleigh, NC 27604) . Please feel free to contact me if you have any questions or comments. Sincerely fif c(1(1 O'042Zrktd A c .140l Al Michael Stonestreet, Manager er Shell Island HOA, Inc. MS/cp cp3441jh.let Enclosure cc: Shanklin & McDaniel, L.L. P. Donna Moffitt, Director D. C.M. ../e.°°;hett 7d,tomr( , ' i7\ • Resort Hotel 1 � all oceanfront suites December 2, 1998 VIA CERTIFIED MAIL RETURN RECEIPT REQUESTED Z 153 205 451 Robert P. Andrews, Jr. 239 Sloan Street Wallace, NC 28466 Dear Mr. Andrews : In accordance with State regulations, we wish to notify you of the dune restoration project Shell Island Homeowners Association, Inc. proposes to protect its property from further damage due to erosion and flooding. The attached site plan and letter to Ed Brooks provide an outline of the proposed project . The State gives you the right to oppose this project by filing objections with the Division of Coastal Management (127 Cardinal Drive Extension, Wilmington, NC 28405) or the Secretary of the North Carolina Department of Environment and Natural Resources (2728 Capital Boulevard, Parker Lincoln Building, Raleigh, NC 27604) . Please feel free to contact me if you have any questions or comments. Sincerely, &ad 9514(096+ SLX/t/k Michael Stonestreet, Manager Shell Island HOA, Inc. MS/cp cp3441ra.let Enclosure cc: Shanklin & McDaniel, L.L.P. Donna Moffitt, Director D.C.M. f ----- ‘ ' ir___))----y •itett 71,44,14 L_-_,2 ,,,„:,)/1 Resort Hotel all oceanfront suites z F b" y� �.�xx� au,A.a i �, �ic� hT3'n ,,i: December 2, 1998 VIA CERTIFIED MAIL RETURN RECEIPT REQUESTED Z 153 205 450 Hutaff, George Henry Trust No. 2 c/o Daniel Martin, attorney WARD AND SMITH, P.A. University Corporate Center 127 Racine Drive P. O. Box 7068 Wilmington, NC 28406-7068 Dear Sir: In accordance with State regulations, we wish to notify you of the dune restoration project Shell Island Homeowners Association, Inc. proposes to protect its property from further damage due to erosion and flooding. The attached site plan and letter to Ed Brooks provide an outline of the proposed project . The State gives you the right to oppose this project by filing objections with the Division of Coastal Management (127 Cardinal Drive Extension, Wilmington, NC 28405) or the Secretary of the North Carolina Department of Environment and Natural Resources (2728 Capital Boulevard, Parker Lincoln Building, Raleigh, NC 27604) . Please feel free to contact me if you have any questions or comments. Si cerely, f" ( q,A Sf 1U 5164 Michael Stonestreet, Manger Shell Island HOA, Inc. MS/cp cp3441gh.let Enclosure cc: Shanklin & McDaniel, L.L. P. Donna Moffitt, Director D.C.M. iff/t(s. 7444,14 S .r4 Resort Hotel all oceanfront suites December 2, 1998 VIA CERTIFIED MAIL RETURN RECEIPT REQUESTED Z 153 205 453 • John W. McAden, Jr. et al . c/o F. H. Elmore Post Office Box 1328 Wilmington, NC 28402 Dear Mr. McAden: In accordance with State regulations, we wish to notify you of the dune restoration project Shell Island Homeowners Association, Inc. proposes to protect its property from further damage due to erosion and flooding. The attached site plan and letter to Ed Brooks provide an outline of the proposed hardened erosion project. The State gives you the right to oppose this project by filing objections with the Division of Coastal Management (127 Cardinal Drive Extension, Wilmington, NC 28405) or the Secretary of the North Carolina Department of Environment and Natural Resources (2728 Capital Boulevard, Parker Lincoln Building, Raleigh, NC 27604) . Please feel free to contact me if you have any questions or comments. Sincerely, /1(d/loa A (. o cf7YSsv\ Michael Stonestreet, Manager Shell Island HOA, Inc. MS/cp cp3441jm.let Enclosure cc: Shanklin & McDaniel, L.L.P. Donna Moffitt, Director D.C.M. • Mkt- November 23, 1998 APPUED TECHNOLOGY&MANAGEMENT OF NORTH CAROUNA,INC. Mr. Ed Brooks Division of Coastal Management 127 Cardinal Drive Extension Wilmington, NC 28405 RE: Shell Island Resort Dune Reconstruction Dear Mr. Brooks: This letter is to respond to your telephone calls of November 10th and 23`d, 1998. As you are aware the initial request to perform work in response to Hurricane Bonnie was sent to Jeff Richter of the USCOE (letter attached) due to the need for authorization from USFWS through the U.S. Army Corps of Engineers to perform work on the beach during the sea turtle nesting season. The USACOE stated that they were waiting on DCM to delineate areas that meet the definition of threatened property. Our communications with your office indicate that the areas north and south of the walkover qualify for beach bulldozing of a dune/berm if all work is performed above the mean high water line (mhwl). This letter is to request written authorization for work to rebuild the dune lost during Hurricane Bonnie for the beach area north of the walkover structure with very limited work south of the dune walkover. It is our understanding that DCM will allow the Shell Island Resort to construct a berm feature to provide protection from flooding and erosion along the front of the building (refer to the attached drawing-area 1). The area north of the walkover qualifies because there was a complete loss of the dune during the hurricane and the beach is steep with full exposure to waves and storm impacts. We have limited dune repair in the area south of the walkover structure fronting the scarped dunes, as discussed. A second area of erosion follows the landward side of the geotextile revetment where 2-3 feet of backfill was lost from during the hurricane (refer to the attached drawing-area 2). This area is located between the north end of the building and the geotextile revetment. The primary source of sand for building a protective berm in Area 1 proposes to use sand from the beach by scraping from the area shown (for the area above the mean high water line to a depth of no more than 12 inches). Fill for Area 2 will be trucked in from offsite using sand material and graded to an elevation that covers the top sand container (shown on the attached drawing). The area to stack the sand along the beach fronting the building is approximately 160 feet by 30 feet (width). Upon filling Area 2, work would start on the berm shown as Area 1 to allow equipment to move across the backside of the sand containers and onto the beach. 201 North Front Street, Suite 201 Wilmington, North Carolina 28401 TEL (910) 762-0800 FAX (910) 762-6250 November 23, 1998 Mr. Ed Brooks Page 2 of 2 The property owners would like to perform this work during the week following Thanksgiving (i.e. December 3 to December 11). Please contact me at your earliest convenience to discuss final authorization for this work. Sincerely, Karyn M. Erickson, P.E. Vice President KME/clh attachments cc: Susan McDaniel, Shanklin & McDaniel, L.L.P. Mike Stonestreet, CAMS Kevin Walker, Atlantic Diving and Marine Contractors, Inc. 11/30/98 10:04 V1 352 375 0995 APPLIED TECH tgjUUZ/UU3 `\ �- MASON'S INLET DiERCEker �� `ok►mot r� -/-----___"-=----......... -'^---..„,_--------___ .. _ ____----,_„----- _—,.... --\\N. _,.. .............______.......,......„,,...: •r.00, -I� ' VI, N,:7- --:-...-'-‘----NMP.--2 IN: 1 '14,,, 101 FlOg arc:rig lk AR 2 /ii /i /a, tt: 11 „°" v�errs ntE ii,L . r. cR... aEn.Rt / \1.. '0+6 li.-; 3 r.M..c / / ,i\ 1 / °V.'- '1 1 ,; A. isi A 191::,- / • `��3 // ' 4,\ 13 „s„.„,‘ 0.,... / \ i G . . t‘ /r I \ ' ,\p/i/ xul I % 11111 / lie\ i ¢;. Sea . ue.ct LFC NQ / \. .\\\. •m• maMloni c 9IA1t.•T0.1I0N / / 1 / \• 1 \ sup ..D.. b&MIME IIERIRMZ Won / 1�, 11.11 1 0. BEINI ,//i/ 1 I \ M r�.WWI Oi BE.Cq wI(T OMEi.msom40 Pr orois k tlIT.M M.MOM sEAEY6EN t1.MO ta• I//O. I I . L MelMMT ta .L IIOw M COOpTES FEET NEFEMNCC TwE IIaT i ` 3.KIITRx KCr.IOMS x K l FEET FEMEM Wong, ThE DwM, I 1 ,\ \ 0E00E11C WIFFIUL e.Tw.Ora%Wm U..',MU. I ! 1�1 \ • I \ • .11i' `\.. \ \ . 11V,Wei• 1 t 'I oI: I t 1 I I 1 I •' j ' 1 • ir I 1 I i � 1 1 ,\ i \ r c 1 1 I o I 101 1 I I. I I I I i 1 I I 1 �• // 1 ' / I I I w I I I t na i 1 I / w I IIi IIIo I I I 1 I i ,� J N I I I I I ' 1 1 P. 1 "t1 I r�° I 1 to I i s I t C y H II ; n 1 2 II I ' 1 ti \-1- . I I (1, ./ I I 1 1 1 I I 1 I II II i ` I I/ ' H \ C\ Iit 6 Ipplied Technology 6t Monogement. Inc. m ,,,,, �,, se. wn c N w '. • r./[ R n I APu.s I DUNE RECONSTRUCTION PROJECT I 7P0 era IJ14 711«I, S.�Id a eva .aril Iv c Cain""11` ri.:d° 7Zi06 AT SHELL ISLAND FIESOExI- —_ 1 A1M November 23, 1998 APPLIED TECHNOLOGY&MANAGEMENT OF NORTH CAROUNA,INC. Mr. Ed Brooks Division of Coastal Management 127 Cardinal Drive Extension J Wilmington, NC 28405 NOV 2 4 1998 D1V1S1(v, ;F RE: Shell Island Resort Dune Reconstruction COASTAL !MANAGEMENT Dear Mr. Brooks: This letter is to respond to your telephone calls of November 10th and 23`d, 1998. As you are aware the initial request to perform work in response to Hurricane Bonnie was sent to Jeff Richter of the USCOE (letter attached) due to the need for authorization from USFWS through the U.S. Army Corps of Engineers to perform work on the beach during the sea turtle nesting season. The USACOE stated that they were waiting on DCM to delineate areas that meet the definition of threatened property. Our communications with your office indicate that the areas north and south of the walkover qualify for beach bulldozing of a dune/berm if all work is performed above the mean high water line (mhwl). This letter is to request written authorization for work to rebuild the dune lost during Hurricane Bonnie for the beach area north of the walkover structure with very limited work south of the dune walkover. It is our understanding that DCM will allow the Shell Island Resort to construct a berm feature to provide protection from flooding and erosion along the front of the building (refer to the attached drawing-area 1). The area north of the walkover qualifies because there was a complete loss of the dune during the hurricane and the beach is steep with full exposure to waves and storm impacts. We have limited dune repair in the area south of the walkover structure fronting the scarped dunes, as discussed. A second area of erosion follows the landward side of the geotextile revetment where 2-3 feet of backfill was lost from during the hurricane (refer to the attached drawing-area 2). This area is located between the north end of the building and the geotextile revetment. The primary source of sand for building a protective berm in Area 1 proposes to use sand from the beach by scraping from the area shown (for the area above the mean high water line to a depth of no more than 12 inches). Fill for Area 2 will be trucked in from offsite using sand material and graded to an elevation that covers the top sand container (shown on the attached drawing). The area to stack the sand along the beach fronting the building is approximately 160 feet by 30 feet (width). Upon filling Area 2, work would start on the berm shown as Area 1 to allow equipment to move across the backside of the sand containers and onto the beach. 201 North Front Street, Suite 201 Wilmington, North Carolina 28401 TEL (910) 762-0800 FAX (910) 762-6250 November 23, 1998 Mr. Ed Brooks Page 2 of 2 The property owners would like to perform this work during the week following Thanksgiving (i.e. December 3 to December 11). Please contact me at your earliest convenience to discuss final authorization for this work. Sincerely, ijt_ati,--. Karyn M. Erickson, P.E. Vice President KME/clh attachments cc: Susan McDaniel, Shanklin & McDaniel, L.L.P. Mike Stonestreet, CAMS Kevin Walker, Atlantic Diving and Marine Contractors, Inc. Y APPLIED TECHNOLOGY 6 MAIAGEMEN1,INC. /70 NW 43RD STREET,SUITE 8 GAINESVIELE,FL 32e06-7419 September 3, 1998 (352)375-8700 FAX 375-0995 Mr. Jeff Richter U.S. Army Corps of Engineers D j zw a, P.O. Box 1890 Wilmington, NC 28402 J N0V 2 4 1998 RE: General Permit for Emergency Beach Work CD DI VI SI ON OF Shell Island Homeowners Association, Inc. ASTAL MANAGEMENT ATM File No. 96-769-13 Dear Mr. Richter: As discussed earlier today, the beach fronting the Shell Island Resort lost a large length of the dune feature and experienced significant losses during Hurricane Bonnie. Specifically, there are 3 areas that eroded during the storm, which require repairs. These areas include: • The loss of 24-30 inches of fill material landward of, and covering, the top container of the geotextile revetment fronting Mason's Inlet. Loose debris will be removed and offsite fill material will be used to infill the area as shown on the attached drawing. All work will occur well above mean high water. • The complete loss of the dune north of the existing walkover structure fronting the northeast side of the Resort. The existing beach is low, flat and mildly sloped from +7 seaward to the Atlantic Ocean. We are requesting authorization to reconstruct a dike/dune feature along the beach using sand obtained by beach scraping along the beach located 100 feet south of the dune walkover structure (refer to the attached drawing). • The dune located under the dune walkover and extending south 150 feet lost 25-58 feet horizontally leaving a vertical scarp with a narrow section of dune. We are proposing to add sand along the face of the eroded scarp to prevent a breakthrough along a distance of 80 to 100 feet. This will function as a transition to the dike/dune to the north of the walkover structure and to prevent a breakthrough where the dune was severely eroded under the walkover. Attached are 3 pairs of photographs that show the condition of the beach along the face of the building. One week prior to the storm, the distance from the edge of the pool to the seaward edge of the dune was measured in connection with the 98-9/96-769/R IC HTF R/090398C H F R VI September 3, 1998 Mr. Jeff Richter Page 2 of 2 construction of the dune walkover, a distance of 107 feet. The existing distance is 49 feet, which indicates a loss of 58 feet. As a structure faces the south channel bank of an inlet, storm induced tides and waves readily inundate the beach and shoreline causing significantly greater uprush and erosion impacts than along beaches 500 to 1000 feet distant from the inlet. For this reason, it is very important to rebuild the protective dune along this 200-foot length of beach. The source of the sand for the latter two areas of work would be obtained by scraping a maximum of 12 inches of sand along an area located between the mean low water line and the mean high water line south of the dune overwalk. This area is shown on the attached figure. The scraped sand would be transferred to build the dike/dune using a loader. Also attached is a memorandum to Kevin Moody summarizing Susan McDaniel discussion with Stephanie Carter, who monitors sea turtle nesting along the Town of Wrightsville Beach. Ms. Carter indicates that she has observed no nesting in the area fronting the Resort. In addition, Ms. McDaniel, who works as counsel to the SIHA, spoke with Ruth Boettcher today. Ms. Boettcher has confirmed with Ms. Carter that she will continue monitoring the nesting activities until the sand scraping and dune reconstruction project is completed. We will provide Ms. Carter's telephone number to the contractor so that they can communicate regarding nesting activities. I also understand that Ms. Boettcher has left a voice mail for Kevin Moody in order to obtain the federal authorization of a waiver on the sea turtle moratorium. We are anxious to begin work in order to protect the property from further damage due to impending fall and winter storms. Please let us know if you require additional information or if you have any questions concerning this request. Sinc rely, ilia— Karyn M. Erickson, P.E. Vice President enclosures KME/clh cc: Mr. Bob Stroud Mr. Ed Brooks Ms. Susan McDaniel — via facsimile: 910-251-1773 A 1k l IPPLII0 UDE=I M1110IHIuI.104 • 98-9/96-769/R ICHTE R/O9O398C HE R'IL s ; Ir• - Wit¢ :-- i.-. - i iity ,. , 7,4 ok ....10 * 1� -- • saitriowrr 7ti s' ;41:4..: N 1- 4. . Si', . � .� dyt. y .. Y r 1. Site conditions at Shell Island Resort Following Hurricane A I.I, Bonnie along the North Side of the Hotel Fronting Mason's APPLIED TECHNOLOGY&MANAGEMENT.INC. Inlet 111111 11111111111111. 11 161tiIi �- ---.-. w 9 www�wu 1 ------ •. swEwo iiiI ��������� •� ti 11 -------� 1111. 11 HER I 111111-----RUU . - �. I �- = _ • _..... • wow., I III - _ - -•;. `, fir' • 4�.^ 2. Site Conditions at Shell Island Resort Following Hurricane 1 III I Bonnie along the Northeast Side of the Hotel Fronting the APPLIED TECHNOLOGY&MANAGEMENT.INC. Atlantic Ocean -Ill -7.-t MI, •lift A " Fi'.' -11 s w "iii 3. Site Conditions at Shell Island Resort Following Hurricane A 1 I Bonnie along the East Side of the Hotel Fronting the Atlantic APPLIED TECHNOLOGY&MANAGEMENT.INC. Ocean and Showing the South of the Dune Overwalk SHANKLIN & MCDANIEL, L.L.P. ATroRNEvs AT LAW POST OFFICE Box 1 347 214 MARKET STREET WILMINGTON, NORTH CAROLINA 28402-1347 TELEPHONE(910) 762-9400 • TELEFAX(910) 251-1773 KENNETH A.SHANKLIN• •Board Certified Specialist in SUSAN J.MCDANIEL Real Property Law—Residential, Business,Commercial and Industrial H.NUNALEE,IV Transactions MEMORANDUM TO: Kevin Moody U.S . Fish and Wildlife TELEFAX: (919) 856-4556 FROM: Susan J. McDaniel DATE: September 2, 1998 RE: Shell Island Homeowners Association, Inc . Our File iJo. 91063 , 001 Tony Caudle, Town Manager of the Town of Wrightsville Beach, advised me that Stephanie Carter is responsible for the Wrightsville Beach turtle watch. Ms- Carter advised me by telephone early this afternoon that there are no turtle nests in the vicinity of Shell Island Resort . I specifically asked her if any nests have been observed within 600' of Mason' s Inlet or within 50' south of the Shell Island walkover, and she said that none have been observed. However, since the last official nest ever recorded at Wrightsville Beach was recorded on September 9, Ma . Carter will continue to monitor each morning until our beach scraping is completed. If you need to speak with Ms . Carter directly, you can reach her at (910) 256-4913 . sm0200a. em cc : Mr. Bob Stroud - via facsimile : 350-2004 Mr. Ed Brooks - via facsimile : 350-2004 Ms . Karyn Erickson - via facsimile : (352) 375-0995 S ke.11 J=savS 2esorf sort SECTION A-A ' )o�'eX' DUNE RECONSTRUCTION PROJECT 15 Line Survey Date 1` 31 ` 11 — — — 000 1 17 SEP 97 L _ _ _��C ./. � 000 1 23 NOV 98 10 / 5--1 I // O> 5 VV1►A' Votore -varies c 0 0 co w �).% NOV 2 4 1998 -5— DIVISION OF COASTAL MANAGEMENT - 10 I I I I I I I 0 20 40 60 80 100 120 140 160 Dist from Building, FT r coSGili\( —6 —B STPkT c o Ni 2+ 5o otiOAA.6\1T bO28� DUNE RECONSTRUCTION PROJECT 15 \ Line Survey Date \ / 025^ \ i - - -\ — — / \ {E----(5 -i �Z�l�►�r�} 1 1 S E P 98 �I 025 '4ZoPos) 23 NOV 98 '�� 5 10 \ / —1I U-ai 5 l�ntt v ��es - - - - � o v m.e_ c 0 z (A _ _ cubic v1a�ds� -�� C 0 a--, 0 co > 7--,-_,. -,: a) W NOV 2 4 1998 -5 DIVISION OF COASTAL MANAGEMENT - 10 I I I I I F I I 0 20 40 60 80 100 120 140 160 Dist . from Monument, FT w � II 1 APPLIED TECHNOLOGY G MAPAGEMENT.INC. 2770 NW 43RD STREET,SUITE B GAINESVILLE,FL 32606-7419 September 3, 1998 (352)375-8700 FAX 375-0995 Mr. Jeff Richter — � ����,.s I�. .. U.S. Army Corps of Engineers P.O. Box 1890 Wilmington, NC 284020 q 98 RE: General Permit for Emergency Beach Work PRF`9; ` ON F Shell Island Homeowners Association, InPJAS TAL MANAGEMENT ATM File No. 96-769-13 Dear Mr. Richter: As discussed earlier today, the beach fronting the Shell Island Resort lost a large length of the dune feature and experienced significant losses during Hurricane Bonnie. Specifically, there are 3 areas that eroded during the storm, which require repairs. These areas include: • The loss of 24-30 inches of fill material landward of, and covering, the top container of the geotextile revetment fronting Mason's Inlet. Loose debris will be removed and offsite fill material will be used to infill the area as shown on the attached drawing. All work will occur well above mean high water. • The complete loss of the dune north of the existing walkover structure fronting the northeast side of the Resort. The existing beach is low, flat and mildly sloped from +7 seaward to the Atlantic Ocean. We are requesting authorization to reconstruct a dike/dune feature along the beach using sand obtained by beach scraping along the beach located 100 feet south of the dune walkover structure (refer to the attached drawing). • The dune located under the dune walkover and extending south 150 feet lost 25-58 feet horizontally leaving a vertical scarp with a narrow section of dune. We are proposing to add sand along the face of the eroded scarp to prevent a breakthrough along a distance of 80 to 100 feet. This will function as a transition to the dike/dune to the north of the walkover structure and to prevent a breakthrough where the dune was severely eroded under the walkover. Attached are 3 pairs of photographs that show the condition of the beach along the face of the building. One week prior to the storm, the distance from the edge of the pool to the seaward edge of the dune was measured in connection with the September 3, 1998 Mr. Jeff Richter Page 2 of 2 construction of the dune walkover, a distance of 107 feet. The existing distance is 49 feet, which indicates a loss of 58 feet. As a structure faces the south channel bank of an inlet, storm induced tides and waves readily inundate the beach and shoreline causing significantly greater uprush and erosion impacts than along beaches 500 to 1000 feet distant from the inlet. For this reason, it is very important to rebuild the protective dune along this 200-foot length of beach. The source of the sand for the latter two areas of work would be obtained by scraping a maximum of 12 inches of sand along an area located between the mean low water line and the mean high water line south of the dune overwalk. This area is shown on the attached figure. The scraped sand would be transferred to build the dike/dune using a loader. Also attached is a memorandum to Kevin Moody summarizing Susan McDaniel discussion with Stephanie Carter, who monitors sea turtle nesting along the Town of Wrightsville Beach. Ms. Carter indicates that she has observed no nesting in the area fronting the Resort. In addition, Ms. McDaniel, who works as counsel to the SIHA, spoke with Ruth Boettcher today. Ms. Boettcher has confirmed with Ms. Carter that she will continue monitoring the nesting activities until the sand scraping and dune reconstruction project is completed. We will provide Ms. Carter's telephone number to the contractor so that they can communicate regarding nesting activities. I also understand that Ms. Boettcher has left a voice mail for Kevin Moody in order to obtain the federal authorization of a waiver on the sea turtle moratorium. We are anxious to begin work in order to protect the property from further damage due to impending fall and winter storms. Please let us know if you require additional information or if you have any questions concerning this request. Sinc rely, Karyn M. Erickson, P.E. itoVice President enclosures KME/clh cc: Mr. Bob Stroud A "�' "r Mr. Ed Brooks COASTAL MA���A�u��v�c�T Ms. Susan McDaniel — via facsimile: 910-251-1773 .1 MEI TECMIILIEE I MAMIIEMEME.INC 'x. "A Ail • - • • �� - 'fir .� fi ..` :�_ `��•�_ . •, .. 'mow .'� . 1. Site conditions at Shell Island Resort Following Hurricane / I Bonnie along the North Side of the Hotel Fronting Mason's APPLIED TECHNOLOGY&M AGEMENT.INC. Inlet ��� 11 1_Ni ------- 111111111 •� 11 1 E 1 I _------- ■� 11 ■ � ����i111111111111111111111111111111t .11 .111. 1 - 7' _ s!!1.i1a(®,01i9i may: •': am •- • 411110111/1.11 11.IA • 2. Site Conditions at Shell Island Resort Following Hurricane / 1 Bonnie along the Northeast Side of the Hotel Fronting the APPLIED TECHNOLOGY&MANAGEMENT.INC. Atlantic Ocean 1 1111 1 _Y . -- ram- T " ` �' 42" .--•-.111 12.11111-111ANIIIIIII -- _ .�..... _ - -- .- _ - r -- tea_. 3. Site Conditions at Shell Island Resort Following HurricaneA wII 1 I Bonnie along the East Side of the Hotel Fronting the Atlantic APPLIED TECHNOLOGY&MANAGEMENT.INC. Ocean and Showing the South of the Dune Overwalk • • SHANKLIN & MCDANIEL, L.L.P. ATTORNEYS AT LAW Posi OFFICE Box 1347 214 MARKET STREET WILMINCTON, NORTH CAROLINA 28402-1347 TELEPHONE(910) 762-9400 • TELEFAX(910) 251-1773 KENNETH A.SHANKLIN• •Board Certified Specialist in SUSAN J.MCDANIEL Real Property Law—Residential, Business,Commercial and THOMAS H.NUNALEE,IV Industrial Transactions ll MEMORANDUM ry,fi' ir I�A.ti' TO: Kevin Moody U.S. Fish and Wildlife TELEFAX: (919) 856-4556 FROM: Susan J. McDaniel DATE: September 2, 1998 RE: Shell Island Homeowners Association, Inc . Our File No. 91063 . 001 Tony Caudle, Town Manager of the Town of Wrightsville Beach, advised me that Stephanie Carter is responsible for the Wrightsville Beach turtle watch. Ms. Carter advised me by telephone early this afternoon that there are no turtle nests in the vicinity of Shell Island Resort . I specifically asked her if any nests have been observed within 600' of Mason' s Inlet or within 50' south of the Shell Island walkover, and she said that none have been observed. However, since the last official nest ever recorded at Wrightsville Beach was recorded on September 9, Ms . Carter will continue to monitor each morning until our beach scraping is completed. If you need to speak with Ms . Carter directly, you can reach her at (910) 256-4913 . sm0a00a.teem cc : Mr. Bob Stroud - via facsimile: 350-2004 Mr. Ed Brooks - via facsimile : 350-2004 Ms. Karyn Erickson - via facsimile: (352) 375-0995 ,y rDR »a` rI A QTA I nniv �T SHANKLIN & MCDANIEL, L.L.P. ATTORNEYS AT LAW POST OFFICE Box 1 347 214 MARKET STREET WILMINGTON, NORTH CAROLINA 28402-1347 TELEPHONE (910) 762-9400 • TELEFAX (910) 251-1773 KENNETH A.SHANKLIN' * Board Certified Specialist in SUSAN J.MCDANIEL Real Property Law—Residential, Business,Commercial and G.GRADY RICHARDSON,JR. Industrial Transactions December 2, 1998 Mr. Ed Brooks Division of Coastal Management 127 Cardinal Drive Extension Wilmington, NC 28405 Re : Shell Island Resort Dune Reconstruction Our File No. 96136 . 001 Dear Mr. Brooks : Enclosed please find the $50 . 00 permit application fee for the application submitted by Karyn Erickson by letter dated November 23 , 1998 . Copies of notices to adjoining riparian owners will follow under separate cover. If you have any questions, please call . With kind regards, I remain Sin erely yo rs, (-Y4L >vA �fc Susan J. McDaniel SJM/bd Enclosure BD1701.LET cc : Mr. Forrest Deshields Mr. Michael Stonestreet Ms . Karyn Erickson 4;;;44e1(. 2 -I'4: daelOW Resort Hotel all oceanfront suites December 2, 1998 VIA CERTIFIED MAIL RETURN RECEIPT REQUESTED Z 153 205 454 Town of Wrightsville Beach c/o Town Manager D Ira' ( 1 1d Post Office Box 626 Wrightsville Beach, NC 28480 ' �. Dear Sir: In accordance with State regulations, we wish to notify you of the dune restoration project Shell Island Homeowners Association, Inc. proposes to protect its property from further damage due to erosion and flooding. The attached site plan and letter to Ed Brooks provide an outline of the proposed project . The State gives you the right to oppose this project by filing objections with the Division of Coastal Management (127 Cardinal Drive Extension, Wilmington, NC 28405) or the Secretary of the North Carolina Department of Environment and Natural Resources (2728 Capital Boulevard, Parker Lincoln Building, Raleigh, NC 27604) . Please feel free to contact me if you have any questions or comments. Sincerely, inj V\C13-\"-4 -`"& Michael Stonestreet, Manager Shell Island HOA, Inc. MS/cp cp3441wb.let Enclosure cc: Shanklin & McDaniel, L.L.P. Donna Moffitt, Director D.C.M. • 7,14444 Resort Hotel all oceanfront suites December 2 1998 � �L 0 VIA CERTIFIED MAIL RETURN RECEIPT REQUESTED Z 153 205 452 Jerry A. Hailey, Jr. 317 West Chatham Street Cary, NC 27511 Dear Mr. Hailey: In accordance with State regulations, we wish to notify you of the dune restoration control project Shell Island Homeowners Association, Inc. proposes to protect its property from further damage due to erosion and flooding. The attached site plan and letter to Ed Brooks provide an outline of the proposed project . The State gives you the right to oppose this project by filing objections with the Division of Coastal Management (127 Cardinal Drive Extension, Wilmington, NC 28405) or the Secretary of the North Carolina Department of Environment and Natural Resources (2728 Capital Boulevard, Parker Lincoln Building, Raleigh, NC 27604) . Please feel free to contact me if you have any questions or comments . Sincerely /)'f( c(I 42Lti SSA Michael Stonestreet, Manager Shell Island HOA, Inc. MS/cp cp3441jh.let Enclosure cc: Shanklin & McDaniel, L.L. P. Donna Moffitt, Director D.C.M. ;� �� ?• 74141,0e( Resort Hotel all oceanfront suites T7N `�J , `\ December 2, 1998 D p ajL�_ Yi `4 1 rAL MANAGE .Yiy 1T VIA CERTIFIED MAIL RETURN RECEIPT REQUESTED Z 153 205 451 Robert P. Andrews, Jr. 239 Sloan Street Wallace, NC 28466 Dear Mr. Andrews : In accordance with State regulations, we wish to notify you of the dune restoration project Shell Island Homeowners Association, Inc. proposes to protect its property from further damage due to erosion and flooding. The attached site plan and letter to Ed Brooks provide an outline of the proposed project . The State gives you the right to oppose this project by filing objections with the Division of Coastal Management (127 Cardinal Drive Extension, Wilmington, NC 28405) or the Secretary of the North Carolina Department of Environment and Natural Resources (2728 Capital Boulevard, Parker Lincoln Building, Raleigh, NC 27604) . Please feel free to contact me if you have any questions or comments. Sincerely, ACkad cf ( + , w� Michael Stonestreet, Manager Shell Island HOA, Inc. MS/cp cp3441ra.let Enclosure cc: Shanklin & McDaniel, L.L. P. Donna Moffitt, Director D. C.M. [fly ‘c4, 744,40( Resort Hotel all oceanfront suites > s1 � .� December 2, 1998 ` _ i ., v i VIA CERTIFIED MAIL RETURN RECEIPT REQUESTED Z 153 205 450 Hutaff, George Henry Trust No. 2 c/o Daniel Martin, attorney WARD AND SMITH, P.A. University Corporate Center 127 Racine Drive P. O. Box 7068 Wilmington, NC 28406-7068 Dear Sir: In accordance with State regulations, we wish to notify you of the dune restoration project Shell Island Homeowners Association, Inc. proposes to protect its property from further damage due to erosion and flooding. The attached site plan and letter to Ed Brooks provide an outline of the proposed project . The State gives you the right to oppose this project by filing objections with the Division of Coastal Management (127 Cardinal Drive Extension, Wilmington, NC 28405) or the Secretary of the North Carolina Department of Environment and Natural Resources (2728 Capital Boulevard, Parker Lincoln Building, Raleigh, NC 27604) . Please feel free to contact me if you have any questions or comments. Sipcerely, 41( Cl/1ga SibA(10i4(14 Michael Stonestreet, Manger Shell Island HOA, Inc. MS/cp cp3441gh.let Enclosure cc: Shanklin & McDaniel, L.L. P. Donna Moffitt, Director D.C.M. RD 44,e,„t 74400( • Resort Hotel all oceanfront suites 1x9f�� h Y"A�j �2'Y.+���1 R 1 gq. 3�W'.u�Y lr..i+ 'S$" • :. December 2, 1998 11. VIA CERTIFIED MAIL RETURN RECEIPT REQUESTED Z 153 205 453 John W. McAden, Jr. et al . c/o F. H. Elmore Post Office Box 1328 Wilmington, NC 28402 Dear Mr. McAden: In accordance with State regulations, we wish to notify you of the dune restoration project Shell Island Homeowners Association, Inc. proposes to protect its property from further damage due to erosion and flooding. The attached site plan and letter to Ed Brooks provide an outline of the proposed hardened erosion project . The State gives you the right to oppose this project by filing objections with the Division of Coastal Management (127 Cardinal Drive Extension, Wilmington, NC 28405) or the Secretary of the North Carolina Department of Environment and Natural Resources (2728 Capital Boulevard, Parker Lincoln Building, Raleigh, NC 27604) . Please feel free to contact me if you have any questions or comments. Sincerely, 1 . /11(CC Vta,k Ab topt-m Y u./\ Michael Stonestreet, Manager Shell Island HOA, Inc. MS/cp cp3441jm.let Enclosure cc : Shanklin & McDaniel, L.L. P. Donna Moffitt, Director D.C.M. /QM_ November 23, 1998 APPLIED TECHNOLOGY&MANAGEMENT OF NORTH CAROUNA,INC. Mr. Ed Brooks Division of Coastal Management 127 Cardinal Drive Extension Wilmington, NC 28405 RE: Shell Island Resort Dune Reconstruction Dear Mr. Brooks: This letter is to respond to your telephone calls of November 10th and 231d, 1998. As you are aware the initial request to perform work in response to Hurricane Bonnie was sent to Jeff Richter of the USCOE (letter attached) due to the need for authorization from USFWS through the U.S. Army Corps of Engineers to perform work on the beach during the sea turtle nesting season. The USACOE stated that they were waiting on DCM to delineate areas that meet the definition of threatened property. Our communications with your office indicate that the areas north and south of the walkover qualify for beach bulldozing of a dune/berm if all work is performed above the mean high water line (mhwl). This letter is to request written authorization for work to rebuild the dune lost during Hurricane Bonnie for the beach area north of the walkover structure with very limited work south of the dune walkover. It is our understanding that DCM will allow the Shell Island Resort to construct a berm feature to provide protection from flooding and erosion along the front of the building (refer to the attached drawing-area 1). The area north of the walkover qualifies because there was a complete loss of the dune during the hurricane and the beach is steep with full exposure to waves and storm impacts. We have limited dune repair in the area south of the walkover structure fronting the scarped dunes, as discussed. A second area of erosion follows the landward side of the geotextile revetment where 2-3 feet of backfill was lost from during the hurricane (refer to the attached drawing-area 2). This area is located between the north end of the building and the geotextile revetment. The primary source of sand for building a protective berm in Area 1 proposes to use sand from the beach by scraping from the area shown (for the area above the mean high water line to a depth of no more than 12 inches). Fill for Area 2 will be trucked in from offsite using sand material and graded to an elevation that covers the top sand container (shown on the attached drawing). The area to stack the sand along the beach fronting the building is approximately 160 feet by 30 feet (width). Upon filling Area 2, work would start on the berm shown as Area 1 to allow equipment to move across the backside of the sand containers and onto the beach. 201 North Front Street, Suite 201 Wilmington, North Carolina 28401 November 23, 1998 Mr. Ed Brooks Page 2 of 2 The property owners would like to perform this work during the week following Thanksgiving (i.e. December 3 to December 11). Please contact me at your earliest convenience to discuss final authorization for this work. Sincerely, ,gut, Karyn M. Erickson, P.E. Vice President KME/clh attachments cc: Susan McDaniel, Shanklin & McDaniel, L.L.P. Mike Stonestreet, CAMS Kevin Walker, Atlantic Diving and Marine Contractors, Inc. 11/30/98 10:04 '1 352 375 0995 APPLIED TECH COUL•/UU;s \' \� ��__ ��-'-'::::'' MASON'S INLET Ew+xtin j C: � saws sacs ��_..- - ��—__ laTu -- . kA" ...........___-___ v ) v,... .. __... . 0 . 1 . ...... OE BABoLuer pep AR ,,2 / '�// / • 1 Mom of / k. 1� � 0 _ lllCr7SNLE N. !Wax Wry1� OAt CE 70wEEt1 ,\. i b:: z . vAiiiii Racer 0...: .• '. 11:9$ jam.•��4 C3vox B %6". \N III 1111���• 1 li 1 1'n ,1 awbp.G / 1 `'.1 ', IEYrE9Q / / II \\.,.%11111'' \1 II of• wOwTON1wC%Port+STPOO* / I 1 �" 00) IIEFE1KbCC a7w 1 1>I 1 , \ \ mom. lCffS I I\ .1I ,1,`1 1.' BEKn•NO»4E1 Cww.DL KaOMD or / /// 1 I ` ` �, r..•.CPB k BRvAi0 ASSDGNES 0w SEPTEMBER 11*PO 12. 1.811 , \ \7.n0Mt0wTti C001201N►RS*1UM FEET RIT [C T*I' 1/t7 I I norm,WEIIIWI G7W. l S,PERM*. O.C'.*TOMS i•FEET KKIIEMDE TOE*OOP*. I I OE00E7K K1L emu.o.n.o.Sfr lt�Ell• 1 1 1 ` \ R1W I — `To.•u o,.b I V 1 iname ( / il II / ineMome I N u 0 l i N 7 i co 71 / c/j i I co I o I I_ ' I I'\ I I7 ' I I I en / a 1 Gri I I I ; I I , I ' I Ill ! ' II I I r I I I' d j li y Ia /II ....-.------- 1 I ' 1 \ i \I.-- . II 1\ 11 \It I, \ ( III i ` I /J i i �'` '1 1' c\ I._ \ 1 it )pl ed Technology 6c lvlonagernent, Inc, �m fte• �„ sa pm c DUNE RECONSTRUCTION PROJECT 2770 4 Sl,ev1, !..dt el •A..� WI C { ■ c.;„. �_acos AT SHELL ISLAND RESORT Ate. .. c ,�.'1�,,. (351) 375—e7pp _ - r,.n,. w. • All h6.a IitTle'•nw•M1e1i Wn 4l �.�1' —"� R�►n Y.4d.a^Pt. SHANKLIN & MCDANIEL, L.L.P. ATTORNEYS AT LAW POST OFFICE Box 1 347 214 MARKET STREET WILMINGTON, NORTH CAROLINA 28402-1347 TELEPHONE (910) 762-9400 • TELEFAX (910) 251-1773 KENNETH A.SHANKLIN' ' Board Certified Specialist in SUSAN J.MCDANIEL Real Property Law—Residential, Business,Commercial and G.GRADY RICHARDSON,JR. Industrial Transactions December 2 , 1998 Mr. Ed Brooks Division of Coastal Management 127 Cardinal Drive Extension Wilmington, NC 28405 Re : Shell Island Resort Dune Reconstruction Our File No. 96136 . 001 Dear Mr. Brooks : Enclosed please find the $50 . 00 permit application fee for the application submitted by Karyn Erickson by letter dated November 23 , 1998 . Copies of notices to adjoining riparian owners will follow under separate cover. If you have any questions, please call . With kind regards, I remain Sin erely yo rs, (VIC&:-t/ Susan J. McDaniel SJM/bd Enclosure BD1701.LET cc : Mr. Forrest Deshields Mr. Michael Stonestreet Ms . Karyn Erickson FUTCTION=> A NEXT PERMIT=> GENERAL PERMIT ENTRY/UPDATE RRD16( PERMIT NO: GP19759 DISTRICT: I COUNTY: NEW HANOVER AEC DESIG: OH APP FEE: 50 . 00 REGIONAL REP: BROOKS APPLICANT NAME : SHELL ISLAND RESORT HOA MAILING ADDRESS : 2700 N LUMINA CITY: WRIGHTSVLE BE STATE: NC ZIP: 28480 LOCATION: NORTH END OF WRIGHTSVL BEACH WATER BODY: MASON INLET LOCATION ADDRESS : ADJ MASONS INLET/WRIGHTSVL BEA (WHEN DIFFERENT FROM MAILING) CITY: WRIGHTSVL BEA STATE: NC ZIP: DEV AREA: 0 . 01 PROJECT DESC: C-18 STATE PLANE COORD X: Y: WORK: OT 0 0 00 0 0 0 00 0 0 0 00 0 0 0 00 I MNT: 0 0 00 0 0 0 00 0 0 0 00 0 0 0 00 I IMP: BC 55800 0 0 0 0 0 ACTION EXPIRATION DREDGE AND FILL: CAMA MAJOR DEVELOPMENT: 12 04 98 01 04 99 MESSAGE: INV EXPIRATION, PF1=HELP PF2=MAIN MENU PF3=PERMIT MENU PF4= PREVIOUS SCREEN PF5=ADD NAMES FIRST NATIONAL BANK 66- 134/531 • WILMINGTON,NC 28403 'CHECK NO. CHECK DATE VENDOR N O SHELL ISLAND RESORT HOA C/O CAMS 000542 11/23/98 D. C.M. 2002 EASTWOOD ROAD SUITE 202 WILMINGTON, NC 28403 L CHECK AMOUNT ] FIFTY AND 00/100 DOLLARS************************** $***********50 . 00 PAY TO THE ORDER OF D.C.M. AU it V J WIF -- II'00054211' 40531.01, 34L4 820L0527911' cHFCK NO. VENDOR: D.C.M. 13123198- 000542 OUR REF. NO. YOUR INV.NO. INVOICE DATE INVOICE AMOUNT AMOUNT PAID DISCOUNT TAKEN 742 CK REQ/11/23/98 11/23/98 50 . 00 50 . 00 . 00 SHELL ISLAND RESORT HOA Check total 50 . 00 • FIRST NATIONAL BANK 66- 134/531 WILMINGTON,NC 28403 (CHECK NO. CHECK DATE VENDOR NO. SHELL ISLAND RESORT HOA C/O CAMS 000542 11/23/98 D.C.M. 2002 EASTWOOD ROAD SUITE 202 WILMINGTON, NC 28403 CHECK AMOUNT FIFTY AND 00/100 DOLLARS************************** $***********50 . 00 PAY TO THE ORDER OF D.C.M. AU H I URE v00054211' 1:053L0L340: 820L052790 CHECK NO. VENDOR: D. C.M. 11/23/98 000542 OUR REF. NO. YOUR INV.NO. INVOICE DATE INVOICE AMOUNT AMOUNT PAID DISCOUNT TAKEN 742 CK REQ/11/23/98 11/23/98 50 . 00 50 . 00 . 00 SHELL ISLAND RESORT HOA Check total 50 . 00