35156D - Coston

0 CAI,/IA / , DREDGE & FILL 3515 —
GENERAL PERMIT Previous permit # 3('k-2.-
>C New Modification ,omplete Reissue Partial Reissue Date previous permit issued (b-ZS -0- )
As authorized by the State of North Carolina, Department of Environment and Natural Resources and the Coastal Resources Commission in an area of environmental concern pursuant to I 5A NCAC _/ it Lev—
.
s attached.
Applicant Name Tun 1ejiT 6)S fitk, Project Location: County J t& ) tt6A4 Q v 'A '
t�w Address 1 j 6 i U''oh ,./c Street Address/State Road/ Lot#(s)
City At I L M State r 1 C ZIP (1 (` .) .Y v I r si t-l- 1L LS 1)K- .
Phone # ( )7/3—6 3144 Fax # ( ) Subdivision ! J t fl •
Authorized Agent City 1 k/ ZIP 2 g41(311
Affected liliCw >MEW ,fTA S PTS Phone# ( _) H P t i River Basin C 1 it--
AEC(s): ❑OEA ElHHF ❑IH n UBA WA Adj.Wtr. Body k-` V V � (na kn)
❑ PWS ❑FC:
Closest Maj. Wtr. Body rvt,( /
ORW: yeD/ no PNA yes / no Grit. Hab. yes / no
�� Gov ✓--e S0 v r
Type of Project/Activity EA,,St y t i \
I\I ( tale: l�GO/)
Pier(dock)length 'y' )( Z !_ _ _)
T-
Platform(s) RIPATl 3.4Prr4 CL1EP-!DOrVC AS PE/2— --
Finger pier(s) 5e P . + r <CDb �g `' 2 UVfi`-/ 77,../'
Groin length -FC7�— " i L.1 I', iba24c)K� /
number
Bulkhead/Riprap length Cc1,
avg
•
distance offshore �` l
max distance offshore 7,7"<'''N
\\
/ „.,
Basin,channel -,p\
cubic yards I G rErprOSt r
1 Ss )( I Cc -f-L v A--r-• ... _
Boat ramp
Boathouse!Boadift —FPifi`, 6.,,t)kS r"GA1--IRN rC f l t _ ' N,
j>Rbel✓_9 l P.�K 1..)5,T 7 ,,
Beach Bulldozing �c C-TU( IDS S t) V.6,' -
r�
Other-FL. IL- ••-- ,/' A I irL C./'inT'__
UnJ I'Q�1ti)
i
•
: lmne
hore Length N�f i
roc rA, � -- - -PcNIPJ U R— 1�C 1�— C 0 -- -L_ 6-t
AV: not sure yes"�� r
Sandbags: not sure yes no • "FFGP �L'�VAT c AS TO NOT' lr.Fr f.;;'
Y I14 1�(fA-✓1&A'7'UAJ 10 ftg-_ n')rr 'r
Moratorium: n/a yes no iilil
Photos: yes no' /M I111✓ . C f F."L. €,m r4 -r' _ /" . N ` z__
r
Waiver Attached: yes no � �I N4- - I
`� N`I
A building permit may be required by: OJA) O41O✓€V /1 . C See note on back regarding River Basin rules.
Notes/Special Conditions '- 14 'Affilligni •M • W . /-O - S €.1_L ittS. •• J. U 06 h
LU(.4L /`;rA-rE PNIP re6r-R'.AL C.vtt.X, TIt.^jc.19El e;AALI. ELEyA-rE/', A rnlfvimuto oF .
(\e-ov C fV'A RS 1'F 45s}-11Lne • I �Ii- 1 (Y1US-t nibT L ,Jr' NIT U AD TP C NT I('!}FP I AIJ C''' '
•
Is CO TA-- .3
Agent r Applicant Printed N e it cer's Signature
IZ—?-03 3 C)if
Si ture ** e pliance statement on back of permit** Issuing Date Expiration Date
6D --�— 4c2,5 N14-, Cb. 6— i6z?/gam
Application Fee(s) Check it Local Planning Jurisdiction Rover File Name

f f
Statement of Compliance and Consistency
This permit is subject to compliance with this application, site drawing and attached general and specific conditions. Any
violation of these terms may subject the permittee to a fine or criminal or civil action; and may cause the permit to become
null and void.
This permit must be on the project site and accessible to the permit officer when the project is inspected for compliance. The
applicant certifies by signing this permit that I)prior to undertaking any activities authorized by this permit,the applicant will
confer with appropriate local authorities to confirm that this project is consistent with the local land use plan and all local
ordinances, and 2) a written statement or certified mail return receipt has been obtained from the adjacent riparian
landowner(s).
The State of North Carolina and the Division of Coastal Management, in issuing this permit under the best available
information and belief,certify that this project is consistent with the North Carolina Coastal Management Program.
River Basin Rules Applicable To Your Project:
Tar-Pamlico River Basin Buffer Rules Other:
Neuse River Basin Buffer Rules
If indicated on front of permit,your project is subject to the Environmental Management Commission's Buffer Rules for the
River Basin checked above due to its location within that River Basin. These buffer rules are enforced by the NC Division of
Water Quality. Contact the Division of Water Quality at the Washington Regional Office(252-946-6481)or the Wilmington
Regional Office(910-395-3900)for more information on how to comply with thesebuffer rules.
Division of Coastal Management Offices
Central Office Elizabeth City District Washington District
Mailing Address: 1367 U.S. 17 South 943 Washington Square Mall
1638 Mail Service Center Elizabeth City, NC 27909 Washington, NC 27889
Raleigh, NC 27699-1638 252-264-3901 252-946-6481
Location: Fax: [phone] Fax: [phone]
(Serves:Camden,Chowan,Currituck, (Serves: Beaufort, Bertie, Hertford, Hyde,
Parker Lincoln Building
2728 Capital Blvd. Dare,Gates, Pasquotank and Perquimans Tyrrell and Washington Counties)
Counties)
Raleigh, NC 27604
9I9 733 2293 / 1 888 4RCOAST Morehead City District Wilmington District
Fax: [phone] 151-B Hwy. 24 127 Cardinal Drive Ext.
Hestron Plaza II Wilmington, NC 28405-3845
Morehead City, NC 28557 910-395-3900
202-808-2808 Fax: [phone]
Fax: [phone] (Serves: Brunswick,New Hanover,
(Serves:Carteret, Craven, Onslow-above Onslow-below New River Inlet-and
New River Inlet-and Pamlico Counties) Pender Counties)
www.nccoastalmanagement.net Revised I0/05/0I

AS7A
NCDENR
North Carolina Department of Environment and Natural Resources
Division of Coastal Management
Michael F. Easley, Governor Charles S. Jones, Acting Director William G. Ross Jr., Secretary
February 23, 2004
CERTIFIED MAIL # 7003 1010 0000 0032 1792
RETURN RECEIPT REQUESTED
Mr. John Costa
1118 Audobon Boulevard
Wilmington, North Carolina 28403
Re: CAMA General Permit No. 35156-D
New Hanover County
Dear Mr. Costa:
This letter is to acknowledge receipt of General Permit No. 35156-D which you surrendered to this
Office on February 23, 2004. The surrender of this permit is accepted. As a result, the permit is null and
void and no further work may take place under this permit.
If you have any questions, or if I can provide additional information, please advise.
Si cerely,
Jim regson
Dis rict Manager
cc: Charles Jones, DCM
Merrie Jo Alcoke, DOJ
Jason Dail, DCM
Debra Wilson, LPO
127 Cardinal Drive Extension, Wilmington, North Carolina 28405-3845
Phone: [phone]Fax: [phone]\Internet: nccoastalmanagement.net
An Equal Opportunity\Affirmative Action Employer-50%Recycled 110%Post Consumer Paper

ArcirA
NCDENR
North Carolina Department of Environment and Natural Resources
Division of Coastal Management
Michael F. Easley, Governor Donna D. Moffitt, Director William G. Ross Jr., Secretary
December 8, 2003
Certified Mail- 7002 2410 0006 9368 2266
Return Receipt Requested
Mr. Philip Brooks
4407 Rondo Place
Wilmington, NC 28412
Dear Mr. Brooks:
This letter is in response to your November 17, 2003 and November 18, 2003, correspondence regarding
yours concerns about the proposal by Mr. Jonathan Costa to construct a pier and floating dock on his lot,
adjacent to your property, at 315 Windy Hills Drive, located off of Shannon Drive, in Wilmington,New
Hanover County. Based on the revised drawing provided by the applicant, the proposed pier and dock will not
extend into the 15 foot riparian corridor setback. The proposed project has been determined to comply with the
Rules of the Coastal Resources Commission (7H.1200), and as such, the Division has issued a CAMA General
Permit for the proposed action. I have enclosed a copy of the rules which govern the issuance of permits for
piers, docks and boat houses.
If you wish to contest our decision to issue this permit, you must file for a contested case hearing within
twenty(20) days from the date the permit was issued. I have enclosed the applicable forms and instructions that
must be filed prior to that deadline. Please contact me at [phone], if you have any questions, or if I can
provide any additional information.
Sincerely,
ason Dail
Field Representative
cc James H. Gregson, District Manager, DCM
s:1CAMAUason\Objection\Brooks.Dec.03
127 Cardinal Drive Extension, Wilmington, North Carolina 28405-3845
Phone: [phone]Fax s:\CAMAUason\Objection\Brooks.Dec: 910-350-2004 \ Internet:
http://dcm2.enr.state.nc.us
An Equal Opportunity 1 Affirmative Action Employer-50%Recycled 110% Post Consumer Paper

t• " , ri , ).
,(•
i .-,`,i''•
... '/
•
.•- (, / . r `
. .r. .
r dip
... ,
V-
'i
. f. •.
•
•
•
* •
, .
.44..... ,.......ilko .
'4 , I
..I.
•41 4P
Y .r. '• '.
i. Ir.. ... . .
__,...,.
• I
t.
. ,tt
. •
le '... t •
• 4 J
Lailltil ' reit
i A, • a a.
.0,

+ENDER: COMPLETE THIS SECTION COMPLETE THIS SECTION ON DELIVERY
• Complete items 1,2,and 3.Also complete A. Sign. re-
item 4 if Restricted Delivery is desired. X -4 0 Agent
IN Print your name and address on the reverse 0 Address€
so that we can return the card to you. B. Received by(P' ted Name) C..Date of Deliver
• Attach this card to the back of the mailpiece, (�lrP-a-� �� / % `• G -.
or on the front if space permits. I
D. Is delivery address different fro item 1? ❑Yes
1. Article Addressed to: If YES,enter delivery address below: 0 No
i ,.. „,-(.A
//O/ 6c.-erl4-b /cv"
(.-44.-/!c r' !', 3. Service Type
/
0 Certified Mail 0 Express Mail
Z 1 y t--- ❑ Registered 0 Return Receipt for Merchandis
0 Insured Mail 0 C.O.D.
4. Restricted Delivery?(Extra Fee) 0 Yes
2. Article Number
(Transfer from service label) 6 91 0
r a02
PS Form 3811,August 2001 3150 GOO 8434 102595-02-M-15

UNITED STATES POSTAL SERVICE First-Class Mail
111111 Postage& Fees Paid
USPS .
Permit No. G-10
• Sender: Please print your name, address, and ZIP+4 in this box •
Jonathan Costa
1118 Audubon Blvd
Wilmington NC 28403-6204
I„i,ii„1„i„I:I,.,„ii„!i,,„i,rii,,,,I..1,,,tri„i,,,i,II

Philip•
W.Brooks
4407 Rondo PlaceECE1VED
Wilmington,NC 28412 I,•\
November 18,2003 L? NOV 2 1 2003
Mr.Jim Gregson
127 Cardinal Drive Extension COASTALDIV'SION MANAGEMF
ENT
Wilmington,NC 28405
Mr.Jim Gregson,
I appreciate having had the opportunity to meet with you and Mr.Jason Dail yesterday morning,November
17,at your office.This letter is a follow-up to our discussions.
I came in to voice my concerns and objections concerning the letter I received via certified mail from Mr.
John Costa on Monday,November 17th. He sent me a two-page packet,which was his attempt to inform me
of his intent to build a pier on his property,which is adjacent to my property. I will list the problems and
inaccuracies of this communication.
1)Mr.Costa was directed by Donna Moffitt,Director,Division of Coastal Management,North Carolina
Department of Environment and Natural Resources,to resubmit a drawing,which showed his proposed pier
and dock having setbacks based on the riparian corridor established in 1999 by CAMA. He was told by Ms.
Moffitt to send this revised drawing to his adjacent property owners.Mr.Costa did not revise his drawing
as requested but just sent out the same sketch he had used earlier in a prior adjacent notification. In our
discussions yesterday morning,we agreed that his drawing was inadequate and did not show the necessary
changes that Ms. Moffitt directed.
2)Mr.Costa placed some descriptions on the header of his resubmitted proposal that is not acceptable.He
states that his proposed pier and walkway is 372 feet in length. We agreed that using the term"walkway" is
wrong.The entire structure he is proposing is a pier.The entire length of structure he proposes will be set
over land that has been designated by CAMA to be below the marsh line and also his property is designated
on county maps as a salt marsh.Any structure built on his property will have to be elevated and conform to
the general statutes,which CAMA regulates in order to protect wetlands.You specifically informed me that
if a CAMA permit is issued that the term"walkway"is not allowable since the whole structure must be
referred to as a pier. Also,we discussed my conversation with the Assistant Director,Mr.Charlie Jones.
Mr.Jones stated that Mr.Costa's proposed structure,due to its elevation and terrain crossed,is a pier in its
entirety.
3)You acknowledged that Mr.Costa needs to provide this drawing with more details and accuracy to show
dimensions and setbacks.
I find it disturbing that Mr.Costa sent out his second proposal without it having been reviewed by either
you or Mr. Dail,especially due to the directive given to Mr.Costa in a letter by Ms. Moffitt dated
November 03,2003. I feel strongly that Mr.Costa should submit a corrected drawing as directed by Ms.
Moffitt.Then he could send that approved drawing to his adjacent property owners for review. I do not feel
like the adjacent property owners were given the proper notification that is required by North Carolina law.
Respectfully,
*.,k% Y
Philip W. Brooks
cc: Ms.Moffitt

•
" z • . : '
• , • ! /..r) ..t' .•,
— „ •
••
• ; i;!: ;;..-'''•• 1, ; I IL' ri• • ION!' • • 1:‘ '; ' g.$".; ';)
cfn .. ; JO;
. /1!

•
DIVISION OF COASTAL MANAGEMENT
• ADJACENT RIPARIAN PROPERTY OWNER NOTIFICATION/WAIVER FORM
Mr. &Mrs. Jonathan Costa
Name of Individual Applying For Permit: 1118 Audubon Blvd
— Wilmington,NC 28403
Address of Property: 3 t fit;, 14,
(Lot or Street#, Stret or Road)
IAA I " c.)+- iv (
(City and County)
I hereby certify that I own property adjacent to the above-referenced property. The individual
applying for this permit has described to me as shown on the attached drawing the development they
are proposing. A description or drawing, with dimensions, should be provided with this letter.
I have no objections to this proposal.
vw) ✓ 2' 05 j Cc- +c 7Ni is 11 ro
If you have objections to what i being proposed, pl ase write the Division of Coastal
Management, 127 Cardinal Drive Extension, Wilmington, NC 28405 or call 910-395-3900
within 10 days of receipt of this notice. No response is considered the same as no objection if
you have been notified by Certified Mail.
--
WAIVER SECTION
I understand that a pier,dock,mooring pilings,breakwater,boat house or boat lift must be set
bck a minimum distance of 15' from my area of riparian access- unless waived by me. (If you
wish to waive the setback, you must initial the appropriate blank below.)
I do wish to waive the 15' setback requirement.
f tv8 ✓ I do not wish to waive the 15' setback requirement.
Sign N Vao3
te ArPrzA
NeAy e. grclak-s' =��
Print Name NCDENR
NpRiH cuxouruA DePARn4 Nr of
9l b -7 99 -/Z S' (A,,,, q l b - . c2-ST 3 -(C e 11 E+vr�our�prr AND Naist�l RF3otxtCES
'lephone Number with Area Code S:\cama\shells\riparianproperty.fllu

i
•
r
•
•
•
- - • - -
•
•
•

. '-
earYll . -
DIVISION OF COASTAL MANAGEMENT
ADJACENT RIPARIAN PROPERTY OWNER NOTIFICATION/WAIVER FORM
Name of Individual Applying For Permit: At,� ., �, ,,_ C E-,5--(-;
Address of Property: 3 ( r (A-)t :.i (---I -(( k•-•-
(Lot or Street#, Street or Roa,,,d
r
IA-}1IIA-1I_44-b 4—‘ NI -e it-d 14-1,---? 0 Le...L./
(City and Count') .
I hereby certify'that I own property adjacent to the above-referenced-property. The individual
P Pely
applying for this permit has described to me as shown on the attached drawing the development they
are proposing. A'description or drawing,_with dimensions, should be provided with this letter:- --
I have no objections to this proposal. -
Pi/° .X s-hve.33 ty Q;,i ec 1
If you have objections to what is being proposed, please write the Division of Coastal
Management, 127 Cardinal Drive Extension, Wilmington, NC 28405 or call 910-395-3900
within 10 days of receipt of this notice. No response is considered the same as no objection if
you have been notified by Certified Mail.
WAIVER SECTION .
• I understand that a pier,dock, mooring pilings, breakwater, boat house or boat lift must be
I : set bck a minimum distance of 15'from my area of riparian access-unless waived by me. (If
you wish to waive the setback,you must initial the appropriate blank below.)
• I do wish to waive the 15' setback requirement.
X I do not wish to waive the 15' setback requirement.
ME I ' 3/41e,‘/
4_Sign N. ,
Date � 1
:i.pA
ieki, lAia
W7ht. g rem ki- , f::.. N,'•:;,:.- - I •-
Print Name f
47/0 -Rq _ /p/�/ - Gorti 'NCDENR
/ `� / NomM CJulotow.Downworr or
EIMRONMFJfr AND NautAL RE]OURCES
Telephone Number with Area Code
•
S:lcamalshellslriparianproperty.frm
s
i

Philip and Stephanie Brooks
"• •c , ,
4407 Rondo Place `,.� ,
Wilmington,NC 28412 � ,w ` J
•
March 06, 2004 _.
Division of Coastal Management
127 Cardinal Drive Extension •f!`3+ ° �;
Wilmington,NC 28405 GO, S `1
Mr. Gregson:
We strongly object to the proposal that we received.from Mr: Costa's attorney for him to
build a pier and dock at 315 Windy Dills Drive.We were told by Mr.Jason Dail that Mr.
Costa had already received his permit for this proposal and that we had to commence the
request for a third party appeal if we objected. Since the permit has already been issued to
Mr. Costa,this seems to be a futile correspondence. Let it be noted that we received this
adjacent riparian property owner notification on March 5, 2004,but the permit had been
issued on February 24, 2004.
We should have received Mr. Costa's preliminary work plat drawing of his proposal with
this notification;instead, we received a copy of Mr. Dail's-drawing from the permit after it
. had already been issued.
We have objected twice before to applications by Mr. Costa for proposals to build on this
property and our concerns have never changed the decision to issue a permit.
You may contact Mr. Charles Jones for details of our objections, since we had to submit
them to him in our request fora third party hearing on this"new"permit. You will find
many General Statutes which we allege have been violated by the issuance of this"new"
permit. C3it 365't4- D�
Sincerely,
Philip W.Brooks
Stephanie B. Brooks -

Philip W. Brooks
Stephanie B. Brooks ',4 „�
4407 Rondo Place
Wilmington, NC 28412 ,k \ 9
March 17, 2004 O1, 1S10 OFI ME�1S
Dear Mr. Dail: GO p,SSP\''M A
Today we received your letter dated March 9, 2004, sent to our home via certified mail.
We felt a response was necessary because your letter seemed to represent a completely
different position than that given to us when we spoke to you in person on February 24,
2004.
As you are aware, at that meeting we told you Mr. Costa had not informed us of his intent
to build a pier and dock on his property and we were completely shocked that he had been
granted a"new" permit. We were also completely unaware that he had rescinded permit
#35156-D until we spoke with you that day by telephone. As proof to CAMA of
notification, he had indeed submitted a"green card"; however, to reiterate, this card was
obtained only because of a letter Mr. Costa sent to us offering his properties for sale. We
were able to show you this letter, as well as our response letter with matching certification
numbers to document what had transpired. Again, this correspondence was not an
attempt to inform us of his intent to build a pier and dock. When you examined these
letters along with their envelopes and matching certified-date-stamps, you were satisfied
by the evidence. You spoke with Mr. Gregson on the phone, in my presence, over this
apparent breach of protocol and collectively your office decided to suspend Mr. Costa's
"new" permit until he properly notified us as required by regulation. In a letter dated
February 25, 2004, Mr. Gregson informed Mr. Costa that his"new" permit would remain
in suspension until we were given proper notice. On March 3, 2004, we received a letter
from you dated February 24, 2004. This letter informed us that we had 20 days from the
date Mr. Costa's"new" permit was written to complete our request for a third party
hearing, giving us only a few days to file our second request for a third party appeal. We
strongly disagreed with this time line because it was inconsistent with what we had
previously been told regarding suspended permits and request for appeal; yet, you would
not consider our objections and held firm to this deadline, Later, on March 5, 2004, we
received a telephone call from Mr. Gregson confirming that our position regarding the
deadline was indeed correct; however, by that time our second request for a third party
hearing had already been submitted to Mr. Jones and the Attorney General's Office.
On March 5, 2004, we received a letter from Mr. Costa's attorney (dated March 2, 2004)
with an attached copy of the"new" permit drawing rendered by CAMA, rather than an
actual work plat of Mr. Costa's intention. Only today, March 17, 2004, did we receive for
the first time a work plat enclosed in your letter to us dated March 9, 2004, notifying us of
Mr. Costa's intentions to build a pier and dock on the property. Although we appreciate
the notifications, no where in CAMA's regulations do we find that CAMA officials
themselves must take on the task of informing adjacent property owners of proposed

V
Pi
. ,
, ' 1
.,.
.. ..
. . * •
....-A0018 .VI qii:iticl
. '. .
..,, , •:-..,.;:r' tor* ,,.11.,•,;7.f.i .il!.htitilit?
. . .. .
. - ' •-.._.:,Not (i • ..i. ,zi(i.t/i)P0A V -i..-.
e t s414
. . ... .
- itgl'igittl°iflOtei !-;)0!;.:'..c 1 fiXFt'l .
•••••:- -. ; ; . .476400 , tll Ii.li,,j(1-
. . . . :•••*: • - sk" .. ..
t i 54 fll I:J:.:,fiii1,1.10 ;0 i `..,q)11+TI, l'!;') ,;.',..! -V,:'+.: .4=-:''; '. '.' ;f.':'i..61 A t,-;tgt) -:-;);.21.,: li.J.Okiin'7114.161 !:,T./ yilbrq r. -• ' .
. . •
• Altno4 I.,. .;'' '.tdpirT,V1 ,... , '.;:..)friLj '. ' '1"f.-i I,•''' '' `r.41.11S';`..?(.i '414;e?93Df; ,)i, ', Iiig(ta91.,6110..C:1 f37,6
. . „.
. .i''S'..-y`Trati iv) 71‘..-.t..:(1 . '. ii ,,- -.- --,,;f) ., ;),. :-.,,-1,I :,;IJ 0! f"'"ii:• ,t01 ,.,g/II c!,:fif!-,riel...11,11'i1ti•b
. ..;•, •. ..,... JAW• • .
.. . . „ -
yt• •
,..-:-• .- .. - - . -
•
...' .
ttlytt/l( tcp, k:!...fi '... , ' ' ' ,..!,,.,. 1:10; .-:;.,,,r Ti..,r1i'...,-y... 460: fa ,;:-.Aviii00,4;t,kly
- ti'..-.ri 9riJir;c1,1 b3-kr;11? ''J1-:1,:falc.: .!?..,,),.- i.: ,', lani.; 'r,.ocig i, !': ......tooblitiS i:aitt,if.bitsici,:;.?
, . ,..:...' lifrrr; , b?-ti7,;-..n t.1i:...-.' f•-•!! EJlTi :%'•",T)Iciv;it,-., Glii .;i•V.',!! '''1' '' r'01'..-:q.!...'ii:)1e*:n.1).-.Ai1k1:...
.':'....if.-to(ftul yd rst..; isrli ury, 'ft; •i ,..,,f.(,)(F. -, ,,,., irt.fr --(.?-011 f'.- •"-. i. ,
--'' ;-:•]..n .1 ..,..1;:1,..1-(4: .%5\,--..1 ,..,'..,.. , .4.„.-, ftl-)1,_?•.'.'. $ 1y4rrlizii.4,1 T,'.J9/Oni .:..)s.fi.3,-rf i7,:iiiir)iri ito.'.
-1 ', . '' :-!I:,.,•'',. :% .iti :!''. ..:1.1..i PT' g')I".;TitA F`!'e /.114 'T'',..i. .• ' it. 41 n ',1•.;'.3frei •71f:f; 1) (14-0C.,"") - . .,.
f.,'; .•.,;,: •.:,. .;•• ;.,•?1?.1.1i : !;',&- 153T`3! ...;?,11,)( ..•.5T 11...P-t Pi...dlr./a vg, ,•!•.,!:,•-'! › '1) : (i.7 v ;!1-
....--, :,)1::!,,,114,50.0) ,iii.: ,rVii-4.it', 101-r:gifirsi; 1;,..yi :,...;%-cf Ilijilli.r. ..';:.. r.:•!.. /1',.ifirtr..;1". • '
• . ....;)fil i"....H.' '..f.iil t.0,1 • `;fri! ;(''..r.)17.,' !..;.,-(,.. 'Tr.if f f; biii;j C,'; ',• •:: , . .i() ?it rirdlcii 0.'1 P:if"-•:••:11:.:
b•r-.W.• -.":J ...rg ' 1;"0 . '.: 1,;.-,.1;'- T' •••• 9.1,...iti' rill-irts ?. . - .!..'..i!'., iiiyi 3(!f.)1,. •-•-t.)12,..),
... ,,
'• ...', ri .; .--,,--.1'.c; H.? .4.;.:.).:14.-i ;ill -..'i ;:f :..:.,• ) ..N rill!' •r.-!0:)•;12 '07
"'1•1' , ; •• +. '.0.--..,..1.e.iii," ;.; ... -6; :).'„ ti...;.f,.., •A,,r).., `,,l'ciltiinfirn+ !.)' ii ;.,,' 4",11••31T.'!:) ri-...f...j'71i .41`..),..i.,(1(14
.. ,34.t .i .G. im.;I:ji:ii....:,11yu ly;tityptii ,i. .?,t1 ry,....: f' ,,1 •.: ..•.-1, ir ;!..,,7
. : tlit,:.ft.,.,t :J;....,..0.,: TIfl ''...;''). ' ')il ' 'la trifil CJ04,) TIA t4aT11'.‘ ;Ini fr ,J!..*i.; 'it'or, . ; -•.... ,: : . •fi,r ,4*)...:.
.„.., • 1,11.-!)! 1.: i* . ..-)-*,.:,,.; ••• , i)'.:7 .-..'7,i'Ion rdr;!)-tg.iry.,•,,,, .,;-) .., 9,1 •,tf! li,:,:;pf:„161;, :fi
- ...C. p.;.1 11) 1);0,7; - 1,.:t ::•..c. 4, ... . i...; : , ..:,-..:, ,., . ,..,-1,,i,
ii 1!)..t litAl? '...;-7'nit, •.:4.5 ;7i' ..! :. ',.-6.1.1.:' J., ,,../.7 1 q;1,?•,. . '.'- ' -1.
. ,
111 ti°)“-41:-. ,,--ttzci inicl...; '.. •-t .?-.,k.tp---, ',6-...tf) ii!:1•!. • ' r ', e '-.- ' •':' f'' .•.; *•4.ii ' rt!.:.;/ 1!7 ,i,. i
'•,-:1',
Aitaff /:4itift illi-,.'i 1 *_..,...:2 :::_..r. .....-7--'• •''', Yi .7t-;.__ ___ .
1,:?*,,,.., ,I.Y,•,!-eigg-1•.i. ;4 ';!!!1',' t :, '.'.:.'q 1)::)1''' —V: • 1-.;..r.';:-....:'. ''/1')'. - 5
...:':•1 ,49C.1.!: ,.,.. . ..J.; CC: ....,i;' . • '.1.r1 ..ri• '' .i, gli.i!'! 11';!i . . ...i '''.i) 1.•'-':: •:!:. : :.-iY.‘1(.;') ..1.!
IHT.Ir.,•:-..,:..,)1 !'t(,1.1G0f.l. 1/10 ii:111 til .‘fi ..,: *:: ..) "k=i,:f.i)70 .‘.!f, . I,. •••1,". .-. , :49(-11. $' : ' .:'''•K,-: ,,
frl•T'Vi ii;i-T..; F., T.: ''l 1--.4.1kr !-.ef,:.•.),.. -.„.;. .):,;.:; . ., If.:, ,Itie-J1. -.4-...1'..y.;';i..,..!:, ;•:;41.x.tr.;,,B,f). -..qiiLl.;..,1_, z.
".:.{.> ,. !n}-.-J.C....,'a :41,-,:,ttik ,A.F 1;i1r, ..:1...ti -,.r rif .iv. ..i,' . )cislin n4d.siiiv9ii .. -
• . . . .
. . •
f14141.e.'467r,I.,) ilrip.)111= ,. t,'S'i'',:) rM i'fi'ii131; •i ';.• i...;vi',-4-t .,,,,', .4.00Z,..,?. iii..?-iiitifi0
' f iti tkekaileifili...,I ,i..i'/LA 7)'id b4/..f&Iftai 4.‘T.i.an'itt tirmut.- ..1-jfff :.I, 7 ire) ,,,L.:143befiD.E.Irl:,NS rili ti. . .
. , , .....,../, 0'' ib.i;:',.,Iii7Oft::V. .t ti.:.1401 ;,`Fit)01!,VM.0 .;;0;;tie 1 0 i -..,..i.ta,..:) II 4.1..o. .,;1.ii- 'i 11...itt* 1 '
. .
q1111 .* ' • • icu.itY4itriyiron -4)15!;' .Q.-fb-tAIV t,:)1.f.>1.) r.f"-cli 't");';',1 '0.0';
. - • ;.'•ttiio-v4rir -ykrf..futtfliith; tr1.4)(10a4 :•,.[ti ni, .. ..••••:.: !.-.'. .F. -1!)ig S 1.; ;..16 '.:)1 .'flO:irtlAti4iA49 ::) API ,.L.
-I
,i...
• . . ,;*;-1;:17.:10 1:Ii.„&..1 1st-0 till,.....: -,.• ot: Efsjiti....'i.,:;;:i •• .6 i I:' :T-:.: ''''''''..t; i 1.;11 ..Pnv.!41:.,-.4:44.*Trat . ti•j:*,•:, .
" i..‘, •;:,,..:,iorq f,.• .. .frilqr,,,,,-.1 ;!;•_::..,,;rhp rroiiii1(>:,.1?..w ,;-"r i .:.,•-i , f/ p,b,,i (filmil ,I
. V .
-...:
. ^ -
. .•
-. . .. .
.. ,.
, ..

•
construction. This is the responsibility of the person seeking a permit and further supports
our position that much effort is being put forth to advance Mr. Costa's"new" permit by
not consistently applying the standard of law as set forth by the General Statutes which
govern CAMA's activities. We believe that this concerted effort by CAMA to finalize Mr.
Costa's permit before allowing us our legal right to object to this"new" permit is
inexcusable.
As before, we eagerly anticipate the opportunity to be heard by an administrative law
judge on these important matters.
ST)
Sincerely, /dy r,z,„4
of 1 9
OF
Philip and Stephanie Brooks ONIS\ONAGMENT
COp,STA` MA
cc Charles Jones, DCM
cc Eugene Tomlinson, CRC

ILITIsmii_m_acasiAL_KANAGEMENT -
'ADJACENT RIPARIAN PROPERTY OWNER NOTIFICATION/W S Tea an,,..
s--
Name Of Individual Applying For Permit: oe-ke...+1L-0-.
Address Of Property: 3 '----. jj.I ttll
(Lot or Street #, Stre t or Road, City & County)
I hereby certify that I own property adjacent to the above-
referenced property. The individual applying for this permit has
described to me as shown on the attached drawing
�proposing. the development
they, are P P g. .A description or drawing, with dimensions,
should be provided with this letter.
I have no objections to this proposal .
o b�Alt o -Ka.. ro cg
Q DT[]DpCPC� fl� Pn4Ea� WT1 !-a rl,
'L Cardinal ID'ri"r`
- •Fx't'an
I .understand that a pier, dock, moor•
�J Piliags, breakwater, boat
house or boat lift must be set back a minimum distance of 15' :rem
area of riparian access - unless waived by me.
waive the setback, you must initial the appropriate(If a wish to blank •below-.)
�.� I do wish to waive the 151setback re requirement.
putb______x_ I t wish -to waive the 151setback
requirement..
Sign Name
•. k /iJ77 toj �
Print •Nam ©'.:'- q� _ :. .y >:. '� • •
Telephone-Numb er With Area •Code ..5
•
NORT1-I CAROUNA DV.Ar,TrEN^• Or
ENVIRONMENT AND N41JRA�P..tsouR`s

,
_____---- , L.„...._. ,_ /..„,, , , ,....
7 -'5 ' y r ( -tz ....._ /, ,:-K- L (--t
C cl:t Lo. rt., /_e , ,..if--- ___ ._ 3 Y/. ---6 — 0 6(±1.,
6( - `./-e__ __
(5 ( / .i'" :1-- -24 . 3 57 SZ -- . -- 1'-C_ v•-..ey Zt 4_,, /
1r) 6-\ l-, .-( Le_) / -e 4-' 1--1__} c_< ,-/--e" f--4,_
/ , C.,0 C--- it e...,
, .
C''. l/ "e Lti L Ci / i v !-r
To � c, C ,

.C. -29' 03(YON) 08 :45 DEHNR COSTAL MGMT TEL:[phone] P. 001
h .
ATA
Vert 2?
NCDENR c t -
North Carolina Department of Environment and Natural Resources
Division of Coastal Management
Michael F. Easley,Governor Donna D. Moffitt, Director William G.Ross Jr.,secretary
Fax Transmittal
Date: December 29, 2003
To: Jim Gregson
DCM Wilmington
Fax#: [phone]
From: Sheila Green
#Pages: 2, including cover sheet
Re; Suspension of Work to Jonathan B. Costa
1638 Mail Service Center, Raleigh, North Carolina 27699-1638
Phone: [phone] FAX: [phone] Internet: www.nccoastalmanagement,net
An Equal Opportunity 1 Affirmative Action Employer—50%Recycled 110%Post Consumer Paper

/1

DEC, -29' 03.01.0N) 08:46 DEHNR COSTAL MGnT TEL:[phone] P. 002
•• rcrA
NCDENR
North Carolina Department of Environment and Natural Resources
Division of Coastal Management
Michael F. Easley, Governor Donna D. Moffitt, Director William G.Ross,Jr.,Secretary
December 29, 2003
Mr. Jonathan B. Costa
1118 Audubon Blvd.
Wilmington, NC 28403
CERTIFIED RAIL.
RETURNRECEIPT REQUESTED
Re: Suspension of Work/Appeal of CAMA Permit Decision
Dear Mr. Costa:
The Chairman of the Coastal Resources Commission, Eugene Tomlinson, has received a request
for an administrative hearing to challenge CAMA Minor Permit#35156-D, The Third Party Hearing
Request was filed on behalf of petitioner Stephanie and Philip Brooks on December 23, 2003. Under
N.C.G.S. §113A-121.1 (the Coastal Area Management Act), your CAMA permit is automatically
suspended upon receipt of a hearing request and will remain suspended until either: (1) the Chairman
denies the hearing request(under standards set out in the statute): or(2) there is a final Coastal
Resources Commission decision on the permit appeal, You may not undertake any development under
the permit until further notice after Chairman Tomlinson issues his decision.
The Division of Coastal Management will prepare a recommendation for the Chairman on
whether to grant or deny the hearing request. The Chairman must make a decision within 15 days after
receipt of the hearing request. If you wish to submit any materials for the Chairman's consideration in
ruling on the request for contested case hearing, please send them to me as soon as possible.
erely,
Donna D. Moffitt
cc: Chairman Gene Tomlinson
Jim Gregson
Office of the Attorney General
•
1638 Mail Service Center, Raleigh, North Carolina 27699-1638
Phone: [phone]\FAX: [phone] Internet: http:l/www.nccoastalmanagement,net
An Equal Opportunity\Affirmative Action Employer—50%Recycled 110%Post Consumer Paper

eiiik AMA / DREDGE & FILL N O 35156-I
ENERAL PERMIT
Previous permit# 3 1-i'
New nModification omplete Reissue ❑Partial Reissue Date previous permit issued 1 b—2S --0-7,
As authorized by the State of North Carolina, Department of Environment and Natural Resources
and the Coastal Resources Commission in an area of environmental concern pursuant to I5A NCAC — , ( d .
/' ' f s attached.
Applicant Name COS Project Location: County N4 Dili
Address I,I I g obo,I tit/ Street Address/State Road/Lot#(s)
City Vrt(-410k State NC—ZIP Z rifbai _ 31S WiNif>1 OIL[s 1)/2—
Phone # ( _)793-1,3604. Fax# ( ) Subdivision S J/`101.3 `l Q---
i Authorized Agent l City � I l/Yk, 0�-�ZIP - M
O"1
Affected �CW EW ,TA "0.4S PTS Phone# ( )'5__A1 River Basin CF-it.
AEC(s): OEA HHF IH UBA N/A Adj. Wtr. Body naAftraio kn
PWS: FC: /
Closest Maj.Wtr. Body 6ro r-e,SA
ye ORW: % no PNA yes no / Crit. Hab. yes / no
Type of Project/Activity t on sf7'V c -r'o to F;elr 4 47 l,r f, doL.0_ \
( cale: -V I' 60' )
Pier(dock)length(/f) — /
Platform(s) RI f f loft-NOD D0 _AS 1:2C/2--
Finger pier(s) 5 E p r. 24- i 2.f' 3f-etina>la5.
:: ior,
n length -FQ2 pPn LAP $0-00 11 \ i
number j
head/Riprap _ lit. . ' i t b v)� �__ :� : . �A i
max distance offshore _
Basin,channel_ —I! \ r7 N, 'R
cubic yards \ / Fe, ��t]PO` D C?f K37Z/F(�
Boat ramp / 2-r J X g/ OCT€12
Boathouse/Boatlift Pi,',I1if f3•.oks rt PAP ic►.t coktalP -AS
"PRoP tj . -- P. -u s-�7 Zo 03
Beach Bulldozing S'TO c S S 4)t21/&1 PDIL
\ f et-1
OtherQ� .. / _- �7b
n1 COSTA
`d'X181 , rt—
'1
Shoreline Length 7? + ex-- � �, r
SAV: not sure yes'`:: my 44 Ply r NP(o � S( 1P LL es---,
Sandbags: not sure yes Q Tit" N �P(T�D -ro NOT" J if•f'I"6g..E
yesr, / m �
/
Moratorium: n/a �;
VII1 - iNVj'&A-7foti) IN D#L OUT" OF _.
+--
Photos: es n. -Mt+ C -1,e )N1 Prp,1/)(Lt%N-J— ( PTf\fN�i(1,, .
Waiver Attached: yes no �� LAND I IJ�o 1
A building permit may be required . : NQiJ x, s(GI/ "• . See note on back regarding River Basin rules.
Notes/Special Conditions •A (_ o+J 5f4Dtt_I_- • I/L., (id • • 1 ✓JELL_ AS AL* • 1
L*C"-L./STINTE Pt PFePPRAL— Rfi6,Uf-TtzJJS_'Fes- S AA L-L- e=C E I--€V ATE C) Ps nl i ri i m Igo OF V
\e o 'YiE s fx,i-ffly . QI�K.4 rtAUST NMI- Ale ► NT° ADTAc-Et.JT gl PAK-/A-n1 CDCg/Paer
--Obi--007 0, ,.
—`W
Agent rApplicant Printed N e ir mit•.' cer'sSign.- re
12-4-63 3 04
Si tore pliance statement on back of permit** Issuing Date Expiration Date
Pa t'35 6. b—I61gIg4a --
Application Fee(s) Cfeck# Local Plan ing Jurisdiction Rover File Name

1Z - .
. - Statement of Compliance and Consistency
This permit is subject to compliance with this application, site drawing and attached general and specific conditions. Any
violation of these terms may subject the permittee to a fine or criminal or civil action;and may cause the permit to become
null and void. .
This permit must be on the project site and accessible to the permit officer when the project is inspected for compliance. The
applicant certifies by signing this permit'that_I)prior to undertaking any activities authorized by this permit,the applicant will
confer with appropriate local authorities to confirm that this project is consistent with the local land use plan and all local
ordinances, and 2) a written'statement or certified mail return receipt has been obtained from -the"adjacent riparian
landowner(s). , - - --- -
The State.of North Carolina and the Division of Coastal Management, in issuing this permit-under the best available
information and belief,certify that this project is consistent with the North Carolina Coastal Management Program.
•
River Basin Rules Applicable To Your Project: _
i
1-1 Tar-Pamlico River Basin Buffer Rules Other: .
I I Neuse River Basin Buffer Rules -
If indicated on front of permit,your project is subject to the Environmental Management Commission's Buffer Rules for the
River Basin checked above due to its location within that River Basin. These.buffer rules are enforced by the NC Division of
Water Quality. Contact the Division of Water Quality at the Washington Regional Office(252=946-6481)or the Wilmington
Regional Office.(9 I 0-395-3900)for more information on how to comply with thesebuffer rules.
Division of Coastal Management Offices .
Central Office Elizabeth City District . . Washington District
Mailing Address: ' - 1367 U:S.17 South , `"`N, 943 Washington Square Mall
. 1638 Mail Service Center Elizabeth City,,NC 27909 -_ '. Washington, NC 27889
Raleigh, NC 27699-1638' 252-264-3901 `., 252-946-6481
Location: Fax: [phone]' N„ ' Fax: [phone] '
Parker-Lincoln Building (Serves:Camden,Chowan,Currituck, '(Serves:Beaufort,Bertie,Hertford,Hyde,
2728 Capital Blvd. Dare,Gates,Pasquotank and Perquimans Tyrrell and Washington.Counties)
Counties)
Raleigh, NC 27604 . - :
9 19-733-2293/ I-888-4RCOAST
Fax: [phone] Morehead City District' '• Wilmington District
151.-B Hwy. 24 127 Cardinal Drive Ext.
. Hestron Plaza II - ' .• Wilmington, NC 28405-3845
Morehead City, NC 28557 •910-395-3900
202-808-2808 ., ,, 1 Fax: [phone]
Fax: [phone] (Serves:Brunswick,New Hanover,
• (Serves:Carteret,Craven,Onslow-above ' Onslow-below New River Inlet-and
New River Inlet-and Pamlico Counties) Pender Counties)
www.nccoastalmanagement.net Revised I0/05/01