Loading...
HomeMy WebLinkAbout75388_Edward J. Tyer, III_20200505 0 LAMA/ '.-'DREDGE & FILL ,' No. 75388 GENERAL PERMIT �'Di leg Previous permit# A "-B C - D ) . .--r 7New ❑Modification El Complete Reissue ❑Partial Reissue Date previous permit issued As authorized by the State of North Carolina, Department of Environmental Quality and the Coastal Resources Commission in an area of environmental concern pursuant to I SA NCAC ? t-/ , - '' . 2} ules attached. Applicant Name 21/2./Aa-1) r-+ 7 YG=1C, Project Location: County ,, ./'.c--,/ Address 277 9 d►1Du-,--,-, ,F c ' r /2o,. Street Address/State Road/Lot#(s) n,----f S z2 ,;,,- City yrvu Llr, G,.u--4--L�e' State/QC ZIP e ,"--;,' > ; ti ,, ., , 4:1j 7 ` 47,Sci • Phone#(z3-2) f/•' - -"7a) 9 E-Mail J�7-ef.C?..9,1•444';1, subdivision ---- - Authorized Agent _ t J I 4., City . .,_..,:., - / =-; G�� -?c ZIP "?---) i 9- Affected CR❑CW EW JPTA ❑ES ❑PTS Phone # ( ) River Basin-IA---240 ,/O ID OEA 711 HHF ❑IH ❑UBA ❑N/A AEC s : Adj.Wtr. Body t ����,� v - rn O man /unkn) ❑ PWS: Closest Maj.Wtr. Body ORW: yes / no PNA yes / ,no -� '-- •1 ' ' 1 Type of Project/Activity .1 :) 74/9 ,rC:'-,4' ,, --I ; _I ; / 4..L. • (Scale:/ - 3 f ) Pier(dock)length -� Fixed Platform(s) __ Floating Platform(s) _ \'i : ! ---' '/Mac Ep f 1 ttX Finger pier(s) i " i I j Groin length / : , I \ / - ( 3r ran,.,,t, P��",) die--, �-,.r..-� t number j i - S 3K4-E /hi. "r. 4,1) 4 Bulkhead/Riprap length_ II -� i I --- `- \ '� 1------;! avg distance offshore_ / I I - : max distance offshore ' 1 1 I I Basin,channel La-. - I I / . icubic yardsi — ► 1 — —i — C sus Gq�a Boat ramp J { - + j fr/tv. - Boathouse/BoatliftI — . — --- " �Gr , 6 H Beach Bulldozing b �1©, �1G,d(�D a 4:' Other/,J.yr�..c_ i L7 7 1 _ j �(®��® " . I kx,-;?-7,..-f O —IA '2., ,,.'t)1. 4 a"i Shoreline Length / ''''', 1 1 .mac 1p SAV: not sure yes - —..4- -- ; L -........ H- .._ 1� --- I 1 i Moratorium: n/a yes I • , U� Photos: yes no .- - _-_-- r Waiver Attached: yes)no c-4'!' A building permit may be required by: ,3y/a r'.),..-r ; 'i) - �c 1,See note on back regarding River Basin rules. (Note Local Planning Jurisdiction) Notes/Special Conditions t'i.A.- -+A 67,4-74t- /t--,,e -,icJ,. 1,i L_./J..J kv42-Q &a�4�t= p f- 2,,� 47A, 5i4_c_ . -5.E L. ri tom•-k,--/) 12 `3^,F j, ,'i2rY/ . 5tE .-4-57Ar .-/C--1-..,;) 9--i //. 2--- v p D L-r c . ..3. h (c/wat // J if'.. �L- ���:c- '7 Ss7i vk VAgent ort Printed Name Permit cer's Printed Name i Signature "Pleases rea mpliance tement on back of permit** Sig ature 20.(, Lt l "PZ"o / I ,,--'/1_7 -2_"2_c) S S tPT tfri 6t)-L 2a7 S) Application Fee(s) Check# Issuing Date Expiration Date Statement of Compliance and Consistency This permit is subject to compliance with this application, site drawing and attached general and specific conditions. Any violation of these terms may subject the permittee to a fine or criminal or civil action; and may cause the permit to become null and void. This permit must be on the project site and accessible to the permit officer when the project is inspected for compliance. The applicant certifies by signing this permit that I) prior to undertaking any activities authorized by this permit,the applicant will confer with appropriate local authorities to confirm that this project is consistent with the local land use plan and all local ordinances, and 2) a written statement or certified mail return receipt has been obtained from the adjacent riparian landowner(s). The State of North Carolina and the Division of Coastal Management, in issuing this permit under the best available information and belief,certify that this project is consistent with the North Carolina Coastal Management Program. River Basin Rules Applicable To Your Project: Tar-Pamlico River Basin Buffer Rules Other: Neuse River Basin Buffer Rules If indicated on front of permit,your project is subject to the Environmental Management Commission's Buffer Rules for the River Basin checked above due to its location within that River Basin. These buffer rules are enforced by the NC Division of Water Resources. Contact the Division of Water Resources at the Washington Regional Office (252-946-6481) or the Wilmington Regional Office(9 I 0-796-7215)for more information on how to comply with these buffer rules. Division of Coastal Management Offices Morehead City Headquarters Washington District 400 Commerce Ave 943 Washington Square Mall Morehead City, NC 28557 Washington, NC 27889 252-808-2808/ I-888-4RCOAST 252-946-648 I Fax: 252-247-3330 Fax: 252-948-0478 (Serves:Carteret,Craven, Onslow- (Serves: Beaufort, Bertie, Hertford, Hyde, North of New River Inlet-and Pamlico Tyrrell and Washington Counties) Counties) Elizabeth City District Wilmington District 40 I S. Griffin St. 127 Cardinal Drive Ext. Ste. 300 Wilmington, NC 28405-3845 Elizabeth City, NC 27909 910-796-7215 252-264-3901 Fax: 910-395-3964 Fax: 252-264-3723 (Serves: Brunswick, New Hanover, (Serves:Camden,Chowan, Currituck, Onslow-South of New River Inlet- Dare,Gates, Pasquotank and Perquimans and Pender Counties) Counties) http://portal.ncdenr.org/web/cm/dcm-home Revised 7/06/17 ADJACENT RIPARIAN PROPERTY OWNER STATEMENT I hereby certify that I own property adjacent to Edward ard re z, d-5 A to r/ y_le- 's (Name 6f Property Owndr)/ property located at 77 / /4uu Mo l' /C c C.-tit /r ge/ (Address, Lot Block, Road, etc.) on lOc n � 'c a �r rr` in if/ Qin 1 J rr<G /4 NC , N.C. (Waterbody) (City/Town arid/or County) The applicant has described to me, as shown below, the development proposed at the above locatio I have no objection to this proposal. I have objections to this proposal. DESCRIPTION AND/OR DRAWING OF PROPOSED DEVELOPMENT (Indnrrellpropasipg detrefopment im(st frtHa tiptian betox(or athactra eil atiin ) WAIVER SECTION I understand that a pier, dock, mooring pilings, boat ramp, breakwater, boathouse, lift, or groin must be set back a minimum distance of 15' from my area of riparian access unless waived by me. (If you wish to waive the setback,you must initial the appropriate blank below.) I do wish to waive the 15' setback requirement. ' I do not wish to waive the 15' setback requirement. (Property Owner Information) (Adjacent Property Owner Information). SignatureU �b U f Signature*i%'J E�wvWJ /l,�Cr /1 fl > Br.`, b✓4 eG Print orT lName / ! Print orType N 271 9 M uuf6 4 £a4 �� / e " to,re JMailingOu kdcpess Cr-c C k �L ' 7a/� Mailing Address G +cu✓i(� Y'/ �/ /� City/State/Zip City/State/Zip 2�� 9/' S 7yd 2 44/2 lot; `a/ r,fra .ac� / Telephone Number/email address c �h Telephone Number/email address Date Date* (Revised Aug.2014) Valid for one calendar year after signature* . i • EX)J1.164 $au + 1-H oust too 'Nitribec,041/46a, S 0.0-039...e.fileateee- --,,Efte_mptpo -0 calkocrscbctes,ce c7,00 rear - ae‘Ga. mis W 1 T L �rd � W rar LAWD• Gasy S 1 o Pc • RAP' T- L A ( G 1 C y ru i Trse #s - tro f'<r I ; ,+ D 1 ADJACENT RIPARIAN PROPERTY OWNER.STATEMENT I hereby certify that I own property adjacent to E AW a/,./ 7y ei o-57, to i �y,tr 's % /�o i` r t 'lame 6f Property Owradr)/ property located at 77 /t'iUu / n (Address, Lot Block, Road, etc.) on Pc.,."4 l, tv A, , in jJoIan 1 J r'r tc /r /VC ; N.C. (Waterbody) (City/Town avid/or County) The applicant has described to me, as shown below, the development proposed at the above • locatio I have no objection to this proposal. I have objections to this proposal. DESCRIPTION AND/OR DRAWING OF PROPOSED DEVELOPMENT (lodnrrdgal proppo"sing development tiji* r/!m descrr'ption below or attach a site drawing) �.� e 'tA r pLhttst t + WAIVER SECTION t understand that a pier, dock, mooring pilings, boat ramp, breakwater, boathouse, lift, or groin must be set back a minimum distance of 15' from my area of riparian access unless waived by me. (If you wish to waive the setback,you must initial the appropriate blank below.) I do wish to waive the 15' setback requirement. I do not wish to waive the 15' setback requirement. (Property Owner Information) - (Adjacent Property Owner Information) km-6- Signature �.I Signature* tVGA,cad ,T / r, . Lrvii $71,E cr -SALLM D(� 4 6 . ( ?t NZ mr e g Print orTypeiName /�1 I Print or Type Name r �p 2 71 1 M t;c.dl, 4 At r iu 4 er/ a agate wlbUCta- o I Vlo CRecic te-D Mailing Address Ma ling Address Q /Ort.c t f1 Crdc /l /VL ? 71/4 Mailing (=creek Nc o27r/ City/State/Zip City/State/Zip 2 all 4/2 1 oo Fd answ §16i4„,1 as a- a sc- 9-7 >> I Telephone Number/email address c �� Telephone Number/email address Yzl ac- ( 7 I J o a o Date Date* • (Revised Aug. 2014) *Valid for one calendar year after signature* I E1f:1.1 '`'n,.1 $du + J710u c r \- 4 24150130 19 1 3 . W LT L. or% i W f`r LAND i G r4sy 5 1 op� • gi4 RA4• T- LARGii cfVCu � Tr.e & K �� _. v tro 13<� \ .: , ) At this section of the Pamlico River on Blounts Bay a long history of erosion can be seen from the stumps that are visible from the shoreline. We are loosing about 1 foot of wetlands each year. If action is not taken soon the wetlands will be gone on this section of the river, as it already is to the immediate East of the property. The erosion is caused by winds out of the North that blow across Blount's Bay (3 miles) and are funneled into the area near the mouth of Blounts Creek. The area to the East of my property has lost its wetlands over the last 30 years and now a 200ft bulkhead has been installed to stop the loss of high land on the property. It will be better for the environment if work is done on my property to protect the remaining wetlands in this area. I envision a permanently protected natural area where native plant and animal species can flourish. The riprap barrier (6ft x100ft-not to exceed 6 inches above the existing wetlands) will protect this area from the wave energy that undercuts the roots of shoreline vegetation. It will also allow for the natural flooding of the area behind the riprap and maintain this fragile ecosystem. -7- )1 , ) t, Cofy 0 -r 11 e , PrI/u,0 �s , / � .4' ( 6I- jXt' u,„, 44h le f vt' 0 -4 /- i urr;te S � 61 v l � if 11 � ` i :. j G � i J / / c ) Edward Tyer J �� Sherry B. Tyer �p ram, j-,�C S 2779 Mouth ofthe Creek Rd A e I/O,, e c'h 0 CY 'i s Blounts Creek,NC 27814 . ;:. r ' North Carolina 10i Coastal Federation 4,4 Working Together for a Healthy Coast Living Shoreline Cost-Share Contract Date: May 1, 2020 Thank you for your interest in installing a living shoreline on your property. This form contains the Agreement ("Contract") and basic information about your project. If you have any questions about this agreement, please contact Erin Fleckenstein at 252 393-8185 or erinf@nccoast.org. Landowner: Edward and Sherry Tyer Property Address: 2779 Mouth of the Creek Road Mailing Address: Same as above Phone: 252 412-7009 Email: edjtyer@gmail.com Permit: CAMA General Permit Living Shoreline Type: Marsh Toe Sill Estimated Linear Feet: 100 Estimated amount of Rip-rap: 80 Tons of beach ball to football sized rip rap Contractor: Installed by landowner and volunteers Cost-Share Grant: 1109 Clean Water Management Trust Fund (CWMTF) Living Shoreline Cost-Share Estimated Total Cost of Living Shoreline: 80 Tons of Rip rap at_$44.75/ton* $3580.00 Installation- Erosion Control Fabric $200.00 CAMA General Permit $200.00 Labor to Install @ $25.43/hr, 160 hrs $4068.80 Total Project Cost $8043.80 Less CWMTF Cost-Share $3980.00 Total Estimated Cost to Landowner**$4068.80 *Riprap of sufficient size is to be purchased from Martin Marietta and installed per N.C. Division of Coastal Management Coastal Area Management Act (CAMA) permit. The living shoreline will be built by the landowner using volunteer labor according to the CAMA permit and the conditions set forth therein. The landowner, as the CAMA permit applicant, is ultimately responsible for permit compliance. "Final cost will reflect the actual expense of rip-rap purchased and timefiabor to install. As a result, the cost share may be higher or lower than the estimated cost above. The landowner may cover their portion of the cost with documentation of time and labor to install the rip rap sill. A written log of dates worked, people and hours spent on installation will be required for volunteer labor to count towards the landowner portion of the cost-share. The landowner will submit all supporting documentation including receipts for supplies, material and permit purchased. In addition, the landowner will supply the required labor log. A final project budget will be developed based on actual project expenses and provided to the landowner upon completion of the project. The federation will reimburse up to 50 percent of the total cost of the project, not to exceed$3980.00 outlined above. Please send documentation and a request for payment to:NC Coastal Federation,Attn: Erin Fleckenstein, 637 Harbor Road, Wanchese, NC 27981. Or email to erinf@nccoast.org Please reference CWMTF Cost-Share on your request for payment. Long-Term Use and Maintenance: As a condition of receiving cost-share monies for the installation of the living shoreline, the landowner agrees to leave the living shoreline structure and existing/restored marsh plants in place in perpetuity to ensure that the stabilization, habitat and water quality objectives of the project are met. If title to this land is transferred to another party at any time, it shall be the landowner's responsibility to advise the new owner of this contract. Marsh toe sill shorelines are highly resilient, but they require routine monitoring and minimal maintenance to remain effective. The landowner agrees to provide routine monitoring and maintenance of the structure and marsh plants for at least 10 years after the living shoreline is constructed. Monitoring includes assessing the condition of the structure and marsh and taking photos of the living shoreline from the same location at least once per year and after major storms. Maintenance includes placing rip rap that may roll off after a storm or heavy tide event back on the structure in the unlikely event that they become dislodged from the structure. This may include the purchase of additional rip rap to return the structure to its full function. Please note that maintenance, even after the passage of strong storms, should only result in the replacement or restacking of—10 percent of the sill.The landowner should keep the project area clear of trash and other debris, avoid the use of herbicides within the project area and avoid clearing paths through the marsh that could transmit runoff directly into the adjacent water body and/or create erosion. The landowner may plant the shoreline with plugs of marsh grasses at any time to maintain or increase the function of the living shoreline. The landowner is responsible for any such monitoring and maintenance costs. Monitoring and maintenance activities are to be reported to the North Carolina Coastal Federation annually following construction. Additional guidance on monitoring and maintenance is available from the federation upon request. Your signature below asserts that you have the legal right to enter into this agreement to have the above services performed on the subject property and you agree to the price estimate and conditions above and on the receding page. Signature of Landowner: �" /- 2° Date: Spivey, Kelly From: Edward Tyer <edjtyer@gmail.com> Sent: Thursday,April 30, 2020 7:48 PM To: erinf@nccoast.org Cc: Spivey, Kelly Subject: [External] Grant CAUTION:. xternal en41111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111ents unless you verify.Send all suspicious email as an attachment to `.... The check for my permit goes in the mail Friday morning. I hope we can get started soon. Thanks, Ed Tyer On Mar 31, 2020, at 5:45 PM, Erin Fleckenstein <erinf@nccoast.org> wrote: Ed, I got the clarification needed from my colleague and from what I can tell,yes,I think your project could be eligible for the grant funds.I would encourage you to think about some supplemental plantings,especially because this grant could help to pay for them,and your rock costs are still below/within the grant limits. Regarding the placing of the rock sill,does that orange pole in a few of the pictures you sent represent anything?is that were the rock will be placed?or is there a measurement out from that rock where the sill will be placed? Do you have your permit in hand?or are you waiting to have all your ducks in a row.I believe you only have 120 days for construction once the permit is issued and I'd really like to lay my eyes on the property if possible. Thanks! Erin On Mon, Mar 30, 2020 at 6:09 PM Edward Tyer<edjtyer@gmail.com>wrote: Sounds good,thank you. On Mon, Mar 30, 2020 at 5:29 PM Erin Fleckenstein<erinf@nccoast.orq>wrote: Ed, Thanks for your clarifications.I'm getting some guidance from a colleague on your question and will be back in touch soon. Best, Erin On Fri, Mar 27,2020 at 10:21 AM Edward Tyer<edjtyer@gmail.com>wrote: Our shoreline is less fixed here because of the winds. The gentle grade/slope along with the prevailing winds has produced a shore line zone that is generally 15 feet. Mr Spivey permitted the toe of the rip/rap to be in the middle of that zone. The toe therefore will be at times above the water level and at times under water as much as 18 inches. It all depends on the wind.At the base,the rip rap will be about 6 feet wide extending back from the toe to protect current wetland species . These plants are doing fine and should propagate and survive well once they are protected form the constant wave action we get. Therefore we have not planned to do any plantings but we are open to the idea if upon examination of the site you believe it would be helpful.The rocks elevation according to the permit should be no higher than 6 inches above the adjacent wetlands we are trying to protect . If you google this--SECTION.2400—GENERAL PERMIT FOR PLACEMENT OF RIPRAP REVETMENTS FOR WETLAND PROTECTION IN ESTUARINE AND PUBLIC TRUST WATERS you will find the rules for the permit I am working under and it is specific and detailed. 1 I hope this information will help you determine if it is probable that I might qualify for a grant from your organization. Also CCAP grant deadline for application was last September and no new information is available for this budget years grants. Thanks, I look forward to hearing form you. On Fri, Mar 27,2020 at 9:55 AM Erin Fleckenstein<erinf(ainccoast.orq>wrote: Hi Ed, I got your voice mail.Thanks for your patience. If you could add a few details to the drawing that would be helpful.I need information about how far off the shoreline the rock will be placed-how deep the water is where it will be placed-how high the rock will be when all is said and done(how much will it stick out of the water?). Do you plan to incorporate any marsh grass plantings in the project? Also,there is no formal application process as of yet.The grant was just received by us,so we need a bit of time to prepare our documents and turn it around.Thanks for your patience. For the CCAP funding you would have to reach out to the Beaufort Soil and Water district directly to inquire about their timing. With the information about your design,I'll be in a better position to advise you if I thought the project would be eligible. Best, Erin On Tue, Mar 24, 2020 at 7:49 PM Edward Tyer<edjtyeragmail.com>wrote: I sent in a separate email the drawing I used to get my permit for Mr. Spivey. It's the same drawing my neighbors signed off on and coordinates with the stakes Mr. Spivey put down. My budget : 4 20 Ton Loads of Rip Rap (Beach Ball and Foot Ball Sizes sourced from Martin Marietta , Fountain Quarry) from B E Singleton in Washington NC at $895 per load Total spent$3580 I plan to install the rocks myself with my tractor and family to help. What else do I need to do to apply for the grant? Thanks, Ed Tyer On Tue, Mar 24,2020 at 12:24 PM Erin Fleckenstein <erinf@nccoast.orq>wrote: Hi Ed, Great.Sounds like you are ahead of the game! And Yes,you could potentially qualify for one of the grants. I would need a schematic/drawing of what you plan to include or construct as part of this project.This drawing would be similar to the plan you submit to DCM/CAMA for the permit.And I would need a budget showing what you anticipate spending on the project.We'd have to verify with receipts at the end if you were approved. Construction could not begin until we gave you a"green"light or award notice if you wanted it to qualify for the grant funds.I would need to make a site visit to see the project in person before construction and award. Thanks, Erin On Mon, Mar 23, 2020 at 5:48 PM Edward Tyer<edjtver@gmail.com>wrote: We have had Kelly Spivey come out. He put down stakes for the toe water side of a rock sill to protect the wetlands behind the shore. This permit is different from a General Permit and only cost$200.What would I have to do to apply for your grant? I plan to buy the riprap and install it myself. Do you think I would qualify for one of you grants? On Mon, Mar 23, 2020 at 5:23 PM Erin Fleckenstein<erinf( nccoast.orq>wrote: 2 Hi Ed. It looks pretty shallow along that shoreline.I would think a sill and marsh grass plantings could work. It looks like one of your neighbors may have a bulkhead but most of the shoreline is unstabilized at this point.If you were to install a sill with marsh plantings that might help set a chain reaction and example for the rest of your neighbors. We are not engineers so I can not design anything for you,but I can provide the attached schematic drawings of conceptually what I think would work for your shoreline. If you are interested you could reach out to a firm that could help design something specific for your shoreline. We've worked closely on past projects with Mary Margaret at Restoration Systems: Mary-Margaret S McKinney,RF mmckinnevta restorationsystems.com Director of Coastal Restoration Restoration Systems, LLC 252.333.9852 And Brian Rubino at Quible Engineering: Brian D. Rubino, P.G. brubino(ciquible.com Vice President Quible&Associates, P.C. t 252.491.8147 www.quible.com [quible.comj And this website has lots of great resources:https://www.nccoast.org/protect-the-coast/estuarine-shorelines/ jnccoast.orgl including other contractors and engineer firms that you could reach out to. We do have a grant program that is getting under way and if you designed a living shoreline project that met our requirements it would potentially be eligible for funding(50%of the cost of the project,up to$5,000). We are still working out the details of this project but hope to announce it soon. Your local soil and water conservation district may also be administring a grant program called the CCAP program(Community Conservation Assistance Program,pronounced sea-cap).They also help to cost-share with private landowners on things like marsh sills.It would be worth reaching out to the local administrator to ask(252-946-4989 ext.3). Also,it seems that your project could be designed and permitted with a General Permit through your local Division of Coastal Management office(252-946-6481 Kelly Spivey, District Manager). Either Brian or Mary-Margert could help to ensure you would have a project that met those design standards. I'm happy to chat more,or meet with you in person after this virus and social distancing pass.Please let me know if you have any other questions or need additional information. All the Best, Erin On Mon, Mar 23,2020 at 11:13 AM Edward Tyer<edjtyer(a)gmail.com>wrote: Kim gave us your email address. Thank you for agreeing to look at our erosion issues. Wind from the N, NE,and NW hurt us the most. It is blowing across Blounts Bay which is about 3 miles. We would like to save our wetland using a natural approach. Any input you could provide would be appreciated. You can call or text 252 412 7009. Thank you, Ed and Sherry Tyer 3 NC Division of Coastal Mgt. Habitat Impact Computer- Sheet Applicant Ct2 jv/°2O Date: sMA`! Zv2p • II General Permit#: 5-3 5,15 • Describe below the HABITAT disturbances for the application. All values should match tie name,and units of measurement found in your Habitat code sheet TOTAL Sq. Ft FINAL Sq,Ft. TOTAL Feet FINAL Feet (Applied for. (Anticipatedfinal (Applied for. (Anticipated final DISTURB TYPE Disturbance total disturbance. Disturbance disturbance. Habitat Name Choose One includes any Excludes irry total includes Excludes any anticipated restoration any anticipated restoration and/or restoration or and/or temp restoration ortemp impact • • temp impacts) impact am cunt) temp impacts) amount) .0SNA-(iL.O UJ ' 2 Ron Dredge 0 Fill Both 0 Other 0 lee O r—e- !'Zoo • Dredge❑ Fill❑ Both 0 Other 0 Dredge❑- Fill❑ Both 0 Other 0 • Dredge❑ RI❑ Both ❑ Other 0 Dredge 0 Filt 0 Both ❑ Other 0 • Dredge 0 Fill❑ Both 0 Other 0 • Dredge❑ Fill❑ Both ❑ Other 0 Dredge❑ Fill❑ Both ❑ Other 0 Dredge❑ Fill❑- Both 0 Other 0 Dredge❑ RI❑ Both ❑ Other 0 • Dredge❑ Fill❑ Both 0 Other 0 Dredge 0 Fill❑ Both ❑ Other ❑ Dredge❑ RI❑ Both ❑ Other❑ Dredge❑ Fill❑ Both ❑ Other 0