71793D - Taylor

q-•z�-mow 1 r vyv
li7 ) CAMA / ❑ DREDGE & FILL N2 71793, A B C O
GENERAL PERMIT Previous permit#
XNew CModification ❑Complete Reissue ❑Partial Reissue Date previous permit issued
As authorized by the State of North Carolina, Department of Environmental Quality
and the Coastal Resources Commission in an area of environmental concern pursuant to 15A NCAC 0 r7 H , 2000
❑ Rules attached.
Applicant Name ROn1r RT pt SfRIA/A 7777;JC*-
Address-& 3 -
S B�^/nlF T-� 1 K/tI L S W
City CiALAR A SN State— ZIP Z 84 [, 7
Project Location: County f Q u N S ov I c K.
Street Address/ State Road/ Lot #(s) 9 9 4- 5
A Nc F- 5Yc E: I.-r
Phone # ( 910) 3 1#7. 071 to E-Mail FISH /NG 0 A'TM C. NI:'r Subdivision ,A,//A
Authorized Agent LAND MAMA G EM>cNT 6 Ruu r', 2N c . City C AAAsASH ZIP 2-94-& 7
Affected )(CW XEW XPTA ❑ ES ❑ PTS Aoswr Phone # (3 10) 492 - 00 01 River Basin /tM l55 Iz
AEC(s): o 6EA ElHHF ElIH ❑ UBA ❑ N/A Adj. Wtr. Body C AL A HASH Riveg at /man /unkn)
❑ PWS:
ORW: yes / 0 PNA yes /©o Closest Maj. Wtr. Body SA MC
Type of Project/ Activity Qf PLACE CoN cRE.TE / WOOVF-N T 1 ER WITH A Ma: W ltA1 SCD ~ I'
OOUEnI f 1' f;R IN XI S_TI NC, rODTPkINT TO MARIA/A (Scale:_J"' =z01)
A ier (dock))IMM t 7' X f 54 '
Platform(s)
ng Platform(s)
Groin
Bulkhead/ R rap length_
avg dicta a offshore_
max distan offshore
Basin, channel
cubic yards_
Boat ramp
Boathouse/ Boatlift
Beach Bulldozing
he QAZE:ao 7/X 10'
i
Shoreline Length + �7
SAV: not sure yes ©o
Moratorium: 4D yes no
Photos: es no
Waiver Attached: X Q no 4
'493q JNANCE QL4445 A CE ST.
A building permit may be required by: row.✓ of CA L A 8 A S N
( Note Local Planning jurisdiction)
Glrl/II•WI.1MINI//I1 J ?NIO
7AYL.OP- ?%I 995b MICE
❑ See note on back regarding River Basin rules.
Notes/Special Conditions O'7Fi. 2000 AND ALL OTH5g LOCAL . STAB AND
FE.PEI2Al- RE&UL.A7"Io NS APPLY.
Agent or Applicant Printed Nalme
Signature ' Please read compliance statement on back of permit
$ 2®C 1274
Application Fee(s) Check #
1 yLFR MC C.'�ujRE
Permit Officer's Prin Name
Um A C
Signature
y lZol9 5' .2019
Issuing ate # Expiration l5ate

LMG
LAND MANAGEMENT GROUP
a DAVEY# company
January 3, 2019
TO: Tyler McGuire
North Carolina Department of Environmental Quality
Division of Coastal Management
127 Cardinal Drive Extension
Wilmington, NC 28405
RE: Calabash Fishing Fleet -Robert Taylor
Tyler,
On behalf of Robert Taylor, I would like to request a General Permit under Section .2000 for the
minor modification and repair to an existing pier. The property is located at 9945 Nance Street in
Calabash, Brunswick County.
The applicant is proposing to repair the wooden shore parallel pier, including converting a portion
of the existing concrete pier to wooden. There are no changes to the existing floating docks,
remaining portion of the concrete pier or existing buildings. See attached permit figures for
complete details.
A waiver from the southern adjacent riparian property owner is attached and the northern
adjacent riparian owner was notified by certified mail.
Please let me know if you have any questions or need anything in addition to process this General
Permit request.
Sincerely,
Greg Finch
Land Management Group
Enclosure: Permit Figures, Adjacent Owner Waiver and Easement, Deed, Agent Authorization and
$200 Fee Check
RECEIVED
JAN 0 3 2019
DCM WILMINGTON, NC
www.lmgroup.net • info(a',lmgroup.net • Phone: [phone] • Fax: [phone]
3805 Wrightsville Ave., Suite 15, Wilmington, NC 28403

PTC11 ► al•(i ► • ••i • T ma
Na-ne of Prop" Owrw RequesWg Pemut AOL TA ?t—e& _
Phork.► Number: �o - 3 7 — [? / (, _
Emad Address: f'IS#L�� 6� ATpV • Ayl f
I oart,#y mat i Ita+re ac,tnonzed rF�C� u�P
AQVV f
to so on my behalf. for the purpose of M*ng for and obtamg SO CAMA perfifst
necessary for ft b&ov V ppropoaed de"+opmeM Lv-thvNr
�����'?�+✓�. t�ID[{� //�?�2eVF,I�?f�J'�� �%c7� Cu.11Tit✓CTrr;�✓
at my property located eI A.11..�,L STM&T E&A
in &VWVICk Cmmty
I flw#W"X re CsftfY MW I ern SU*W4*d So grail. 8nd do xrr fact gran: permission to
Drvfaigr► of Caaste A&nagsM&W sWE Me LOCW POrrnd CNf} er and their agents.to enter
on 0* alo¢nw*0ned fad in eonnecOon wm etvaWtng ,:nformal*n re ,a"end to th,s
Par* apPbcabw-
P;yrtry Nrntr 1nfoe-a60-:
�dISC�T` Tiy �
Prw or Type pima
7 n,$ ecervicas:on, ts valid throug� /Z 13 I 11
JAN 0.3 2019
DCM WILMINGTON, NC

LMG
LANDMANAGEMENT GROUP
a DAVEYI company
December 21, 2018
Nance Seafood LLC
1381 Thomasboro Road SW
Calabash, NC 28467-2715
To Whom It May Concern:
Robert E. Taylor is applying for a CAMA General permit for development on their
property located at 9945 Nance Street, Brunswick County, North Carolina. The
specifics of the proposed work are in the enclosed updated drawings.
As the adjacent riparian property owner to the aforementioned project, I am required
to notify you of the development in order to give you the opportunity to comment on
the project. Please review the attached permit application and drawings. Should you
have any objections to this proposal, please send your written comments within 10
days of your receipt of this notice to:
Tyler McGuire
North Carolina Department of Environmental Quality
Division of Coastal Management
127 Cardinal Drive Extension
Wilmington, NC 28405
Comments will be considered by the NC Department of Coastal Management in
reaching a final decision on the application. No comment within 10 days of your
receipt of this notice will be considered as no objection. If you have any questions on
this project, please call me at 910-452-0001, or e-mail me at [e-mail]
Sincerely,
Greg Finch, Agent
Land Management Group, Inc.
Enclosures
!RECEIVED
www.lmgroup.net • Phone: [phone] • Fax: [phone] JAN 0 3 2019
3805 Wrightsville Ave., Suite 15, Wilmington, NC 28403
DCM WILMINGTON, NC

■ Complete items 1, 2, and 3.
■ Print your name and address on the reverse
so that we can return the card to you.
■ Attach this card to the back of the mailpiece,
or on the front if space permits.
1. Article Addressed to:
94NCE &l9F-ocn u c
last Ttt SBO ko RbAo Svc
CA SE-, tVL
111111111 DII 111111111111 IIIIIII 11111111N1 III
9590 9403 0119 5077 8032 20
2. Article Number (transfer from service label)
7005 1820 0002 9135 7934
PS Form 3811, April 2015 PSN 7530-02-000-9053
A. Signature
�J c ❑ Agent
❑ Address
B. Received by (printed Name) C. a of Dyiv
Z2 �
D. Is delivery address different from item 1? Yes
If YES, enter delivery address below: ❑ No
J. ServlCS Type
❑ Adult Signature
❑ Priority Mail Express®
Adult Signature Restricted Dellvery
Certified Mall®
❑ Registered Mallm
❑ �d Mail Restricted
Certified Mail Restricted Delivery
❑ Return Receipt for
❑ Collect on Delivery
Merchandise
❑ Collect on Delivery Restricted Delivery
❑ Signature Conflnnatlon^
❑ Insured Mall
❑ Signature Confirmation
❑ Insured Mail Restricted Delivery
(aver $500)
Restricted Delivery
■ C implete items 1, 2, and 3. A. Signature
■ P t your name and address on the reverse
sdthat we can return the card to you.
■ Attach this card to the back of the mailpiece, B. Received by (Printed Name)
or on the front if space permits.
1. Article Addressed to:
NONCE VF-wn L",'—'
101 TAU4As806 ROq 6VV
CA S*,tVL 2-Not--nIS
111111111 IN 11111111111111111111111111111111111
9590 9403 0119 5077 8032 20
z. Article Number (transfer from service label)
7005 1820 0002 9135 7934
PS Form 3811, April 2015 PSN 7530-02-000-9053
Domestic Return Receipt
❑ Agent
❑ Addressee
C. a of D livery
;7r-7dI,�r
D. Is delivery address different from item 1? ❑ Yes
If YES, enter delivery address below: ❑ No
RECEIVED
JAN 0 3 2019
3. Servicd.i¢PdVI V1t I L M I N U T Q kiokj Qil Express®
❑ Adult Signature
❑ Registered MailTM
Adult Signature Restricted Delivery
❑ Registered Mail Restricted
Certified Mail®
Delivery
Certified Mail Restricted Delivery
❑ Return Receipt for
❑ Collect on Delivery
Merchandise
❑ Collect on Delivery Restricted Delivery
❑ Signature ConfirmationT
❑ Insured Mail
❑ Signature Confirmation
❑ Insured Mail Restricted Delivery
Restricted Delivery
(over $500)
Domestic Return Receipt
RECEIVED
JAN 0 3 2019
DCM WILMINGTON, NC

Rf Y InCsted at Mss Mw" st..* oll Pft, ©Mrrtaet�
on w Caka k RV&
0
Sed aiE ed Geneml Perch drawft&
Sheets 1-4 of 4. dated 121�1212'010,
8
I undamarta that a pittrst. ALYER float ramp bn�kwater, bzouftuse, 1itt. or gram
must be set bade a mini ce of 15' tr n my area of riparian access unless waived by
me. (If you wigh to waivetha. . YOU must irliia�l the apprapriate blank below)
I do not wish to Wave the 15` setback requttemept
(Propeirty C*ner Information) (Adjacent Property 0*-nw tftfcaarmstionj
SiNwxUre
Room tRow
PfV ar Tygm /Yams
"saftw 1rgm aw
Afavgrg
", Ar+ni+nrr
'1 if1Ii :Of OnlEt cra�endar (R&v6WAW 20 ;
Y� • S►QR�ttRE�

Brunswick County --Register of heeds
Robert J. Robinson
Inst #282464 Book 2207Page 1219
08/05/2005 05:53:23pn Rect
STATE OF NORTH CAROLINA SPECIAL WARRANTY DEED
COUNTY OF BRUNSWICK
I�
THIS DEED, Made this the !; tl.- day of August, 2005, by and between EARLINE P.
NANCE JONES and husband, JOHNNY JONES, of Horry County, South Carolina,
hereinafter referred to as Grantor; to ROBERT E. TAYLOR and wife, SERINA ANN
TAYLOR, of 635 Bennett Trail SW, Calabash, NC 28467, hereinafter referred to as Grantee;
The designation Grantor and Grantee as used herein shall include said parties, their
heirs, successors, and assigns, and shall include singular, plural, masculine, feminine or
neuter as required by context.
WITNESSETH:
THAT said Grantor in consideration of the sum of TEN DOLLARS ($10.00) and other
valuable considerations to it in hand paid by the Grantee, the receipt of which is hereby
acknowledged, has bargained and sold and by these presents does grant, bargain, sell and convey
to the Grantee, in fee simple, all of that certain tract or parcel of land located in Shallotte
Township, Brunswick County, North Carolina, and being more particularly described as follows:
BEING ALL of Parcel A as shown on that map prepared by Bobby M. Long, RLS,
dated October 16,1997, a copy of which is attached to the deed recorded in Book
727 at Page 226 of the Brunswick County Registry, and which is also shown as the
0.26 acre parcel on that survey by James R. Tompkins, PLS, dated March t , 2005 and
and recorded in Map Cabinet 3*� at Page of the Brunswick revised
County Registry. 20051 22,
Earline Nance Jones was the sole devisee under the Will of Joseph L. Nance, Sr.,
who died testate in Horry County, South Carolina, on April 25, 2001. An
exemplified copy of the Will is filed in File No. 02 E 258 in the office of the Clerk of
Superior Court of Brunswick County, North Carolina.
For back reference, see deeds recorded in Book 727 at Page 226, Book 402 at Page
786, Book 338 at Page 874, Book 343 at Page 268, Book 343 at Page 266, Book 451 at
Page 690, Book 466 at Page 916, Book 346 at Page 836, Book 339 at Page 526 and
Book 51 at Page 512, all of the Brunswick County Registry.
RECEIVED
Prepared by The Anderson Law Firm, PLLC
DCM WILMINGTON, NC

Lrist A 2824G4 Book 2207Page: 1220
TO HAVE AND TO HOLD the aforesaid tract or parcel of land and all privileges and
appurtenances thereto belonging to the Grantee, in fee simple.
AND the Grantor covenants with said Grantee, that Grantor has done nothing to impair
such title as Grantor received, and Grantor will warrant and defend the title against the lawful
claims of all persons claiming by, under or through Grantor, except for any exceptions
hereinafter stated.
Title to the property herein described is subject to the following exceptions:
Subject to easements, conditions and restrictions of record, if any, and 2005 ad valorem taxes.
IN TESTIMONY WHEREOF, the Grantor has hereunto set his hand and seal on the
day and year first above written.
(SEAL)
Earline Nance Jones
(SEAL)
^Joh ny(� es
STATE OF NORTH CAROLINA
COUNTY OF BRUNSWICK
Public of the County and State aforesaid, certify
that EARLINE NANCE JO ES and husband, JOHNNY JONES, personally appeared before
me this day and acknowledged the due execution of the foregoing instrument for the purposes
therein set forth.
WITNESS my hand and official seal, this day of August, 2005.
Notary Public
My commission expires: 3 G 7
STATE OF NORTH CAROLINA
COUNTY OF BRUNSWICK Nx: r.' . r a 1fF a -TT
The Foregoing (or annexed) Certificate(s) of
Notaryoes) Public is (are) Certified to be Correct. S t h
This Instrument was tiled for Registration on this Day of _ . _
Ad -
in the Book and page shown on the First Page hereof.
RO E . J. Rl I . N, Register of Deeds RECEIVED
JAN 0 3 2019
DCM WILMINGTON, NC

Illllll lilt IIII . 00IIII II IIIIIIIIIII 82502 P09243390.
fD,���
arunsuiok CountyNC Register oDeeds
pnge 1 o4 20
STATE Of NORTH MOLINA `
COUNTY OF IRUNSM
this Ins4msn h61ou nled ,nr
Rija n;lon Q%@ IOW fOs Ind in Ih,
Beot��Jd tugw
A � nor
STATE OF NORTH CAROLINA
COUNTY OF BRUNSWICK
ROBERT E. TAYLOR and
SERINA ANN TAYLOR,
Plaintiffs,
VS.
DORIS W. NANCE
Defendant.
"'`' 1tFrGl OI AJI? pG#
CASfi.�:�,
IN THE GENERAL COURTS OF JUSTICE
SUPERIOR COURT DIVISION
FILE NO.05 CVS 1903
EASEMENT AGREEMENT,
RIGHT OF FIRST REFUSAL,
SETTLEMENT AGREEMENT, AND
RECIPROCAL RELEASE OF CLAIMS
TAX PARCEL ID NO: 2550005801, 25500057
THIS EASEMENT AGREEMENT, RIGHT OF FIRST REFUSAL,
SETTLEMENT AGREEMENT AND RELEASE OF ALL CLAIMS("Agreement"), made as
of the _L�day of November, 2006, between and among ROBERT E. TAYLOR and SERINA
ANN TAYLOR (hereinafter individually and collectively referred to as "Plaintiffs") and DORIS
W. NANCE (hereinafter referred to as "Defendant"), all collectively sometimes referred to as the
"Parties."
WHEREAS, Plaintiffs are the owners of real property located in the Town of Calabash..
County of Brunswick, North Carolina, more particularly described on Exhibit "A" attached
hereto and incorporated herein by reference ("Plaintiffs' property");
RECEIVED
JAN 03 2019
DCM WILMINGTON, NC

e
NII'll I,I I II III'll IIII I'll fll 250 C JW}y 11-07 o
�13 336 36
000
Brunswick County, NC Register o1 Dead& page 2 or Ze
WHEREAS, Defendant is the owner of real property located in the Town of Calabash.
County of Brunswick, North Carolina, more particularly described on Exhibit "B" attached
hereto and incorporated herein by reference ("Defendant's property");
WHEREAS, a dispute had arisen between the Plaintiffs and Defendant concerning the
properties mentioned above and a pier and dock located behind Plaintiffs' property and
Defendant's property ("Dock Dispute");
WHEREAS, this dispute is presently pending in Brunswick County Superior Court, File
No. 05-CVS-1903; and
WHEREAS, the Parties engaged in a Mediated Settlement Conference which took place
on August 31, 2006, and September 11, 2006, and subsequent negotiations which resulted in a
negotiated Settlement Agreement to resolve all disputes between the Parties, and the Parties
desire to finally resolve all issues regarding said matters.
NOW, FOR AND IN CONSIDERATION OF THE MUTUAL PROMISES MADE
HEREIN, AND OTHER GOOD AND VALUABLE CONSIDERATIONS, THE LEGAL
SUFFICIENCY OF WHICH IS ACKNOWLEDGED, THE PARTIES STIPULATE AND
AGREE AS FOLLOWS:
I. Encroachment Easement. Plaintiffs hereby give, grant and convey unto
Defendant, her successors and assigns, a perpetual casement to maintain that portion of the
building and wood walk located on Defendant's property which is situated on Plaintiffs' property
and to enter upon Plaintiffs' property for the purpose of conducting such repair as is necessary to
continue to maintain said building and wood walk. The area over which the easement for
encroachment is granted is located and shown on the survey prepared by Sherwin D. Cribb
attached hereto as Exhibit "C" and further described on Exhibit "D," Description of Easement
RECEIVED
JAN 03 2019
DCM WILMINGTON, NC

I
III II I IIIlIIIII IIIIIIIII fllllll Bober Pe Ro Aso" 3a 000
runs�lck County. NC Register of Deeds pnge 3 of 20
Area. If the building and wood walk on Defendant's property are destroyed, Plaintiffs shall not
object to and shall consent to the building and wood walk being rebuilt on the present footprint
including the area encroached upon; however, the area of the encroachment cannot be enlarged.
The Parties mutually agree to cooperate with respect to permitting issues in the event of a loss
and subsequent rebuild of the building and wood walk by Defendant or her successors.
a. fo have and to hold the above described easement unto Defendant, her successors
and assigns, forever and in perpetuity; it being agreed that the easement hereby
conveyed is appurtenant to and runs with Defendant's property.
b. Plaintiffs do hereby covenant that they are seised of their respective premises in
fee simple, have the right to convey the interest conveyed and bind themselves,
their successors and legal representatives to warrant and forever defend said
easement granted unto Defendant, her successors and assigns, against the claims
of all persons whomsoever lawfully claiming or to claim the same, or any part
thereof.
2. Ownership of Pier and Dock and Easement.
a. Parties mutually agree that
i. Plaintiffs have ownership and control of that portion of the original dock
and pier located westward from that plank marked with a paint dot by
Wayne Long. The plank marked with a paint dot is the 28`1' plank
westward of the eastern end of the dock and pier as the same was located
prior to the installation of the connector, located and shown on the survey
3
RECEIVED
JAN 03 2019
DCM WILMINGTON, NC

I
IIIIII i I III II II II .il i IIIII I I az�0z PRzi i�s� 3e o00
B—swck County, NC Req—te, of Duds page 4 of 20
prepared by Sherwin D. Cribb attached hereto as Exhibit "C" and further
described on Exhibit "E," Description of Pier Agreement Line; and
ii. Defendant has ownership and control of that portion of the original dock
and pier beginning with and including the plank marked with a paint dot
by Wayne Long and running eastward to the eastern end of the dock and
pier as the same was located prior to the installation of the connector. The
plank marked with a paint dot is the 28`h plank westward of the eastern
end of the dock and pier as the same was located prior to the installation of
the connector, located and shown on the survey prepared by Sherwin D.
Cribb attached hereto as Exhibit "C" and further described on Exhibit
"E," Description of Pier Agreement Line.
b. To the extent that any portion of the dock and pier described in Paragraph 2(a)(i)
above is located within Defendant's riparian corridor, Defendant does hereby
give, grant and convey unto Plaintiffs, their licensees, agents, successors and
assigns, a perpetual casement over and across that portion of the original dock and
pier located westward of that plank marked with a paint dot by Wayne Long, said
plank marked with a paint dot being the 28ih plank westward of the eastern end of
the dock and pier as the same was located prior to the installation of the
connector, located and shown on the survey prepared by Sherwin D. Cribb
attached hereto as Exhibit "C" and further described on Exhibit "E," Description
of Pier Agreement Line.
4
RECEIVED
JAN 0.3 2019
DCM WILMINGTON, NC

2006
III I I II II IIIIII III II IIII III Rober P�za ln'0n 39 000
Brunswick County, NC Register of Deeds page 9 of 20
To the extent that any portion of the dock and pier described in Paragraph 2(a)(ii)
above is located within Plaintiffs' riparian corridor, Plaintiffs do hereby give,
grant and convey unto Defendant, her licensees, agents, successors and assigns, a
perpetual easement over and across that portion of the original dock and pier
beginning with and including the plank marked with a paint dot by Wayne Long
and running eashvard to the eastern end of the dock and pier as the same was
located prior to the installation of the connector. The plank marked with a paint
dot is the 28`h plank westward of the eastern end of the dock and pier as the same
was located prior to the installation of the connector, located and shown on the
survey prepared by Sherwin D. Cribb attached hereto as Exhibit "C" and further
described on Exhibit "E," Description of Pier Agreement Line prepared by
Sherwin D. Cribb.
i. To have and to hold the above described easements unto the Parties, their
successors and assigms, forever and in perpetuity; it being agreed that the
easements hereby conveyed are appurtenant to and run with the Plaintiff's'
and Defendant's property.
ii. The Parties hereby bind themselves, their successors and legal
representatives to warrant and forever defend title to said easement
granted, unto each, and their successors and assigns, against the claims of
all persons whomsoever lawfully claiming or to claim the same, or any
part thereof.
5
RECEIVED
JAN 0.3 2019
DCM WILMINGTON, NC

I II II I(II �I I II III I Illl I I I I B2 er ?�29 so"-3a °°°
Brunswick County, NC Register of Deeds oage 6 of 29
c. The Parties mutually agree to maintain their respective docks and piers in good
repair for pedestrian ingress and egress. This covenant does not, however,
constitute a requirement that either party may require the other to rebuild their
respective portion of the dock and pier in the event said facilities are destroyed.
d. The Parties mutually agree to cooperate with respect to CAMA issues about the
connector or other improvements made to the entire dock and pier prior to the
date of this Agreement.
e. To the extent that the Parties desire to make improvements to that portion of the
dock and pier under their ownership and control subsequent to the date of this
Agreement, each party shall deliver to the other plans or drawings of the proposed
improvements as well as any permit applications to be submitted for the proposed
improvements. The plans and applications shall be delivered to the other party
not less than 10 days prior to their submission to governmental or regulatory
agencies. Neither party shall unreasonably object to or unreasonably withhold
consent to the proposed improvements. However, each party shall have the right
to object or withhold consent to any proposed improvements that would impair
the use or value of their respective portion of the dock and pier.
f The Parties further agree that each shall have the absolute right (but not
obligation) to rebuild their respective dock and pier within the footprints
described in paragraphs 2 (a) and (b) above.
3. Non-exclusive Easement to Use Pier and Dock. The Parties hereby give, grant
and convey to each other, their licensees, agents, successors and assigns, a limited, non-exclusive
6
RECEIVED
JAN 0.3 2019
DCM WILMINGTON, NC

ifiiii i i iui i il�if illll �� �� III R.,5 "t I R- 13 o�-3a o0©
Brunswick County. NC Register of Deeds .age 7 of 2E
easement to use each other's property as described herein, and pier and dock for pedestrian
ingress and egress. The limited right applies only to pedestrian access on, over and across their
respective piers and docks and such portion of their respective properties as is required to gain
access to the respective docks and piers. This pedestrian access easement applies to the Parties,
their customers, and their invitees, but does NOT allow one party to make other commercial use
of the other's dock and pier. Further, the Parties agree not to block access on, over and across
each other's dock and pier by erecting a fence or other dividing structure.
a. To have and to hold the above described easements unto the Parties, their
successors and assigns, forever and in perpetuity; it being agreed that the
easements hereby conveyed are appurtenant to and run with Plaintiff's' property
and Defendant's property.
b. The Parties do hereby covenant that they are seised of their respective premises in
fee simple, have the right to convey the interest conveyed and bind themselves,
their successors and legal representatives to warrant and forever defend said
easements granted, unto each other, and their successors and assigns, against the
claims of all persons whomsoever lawfully claiming or to claim the same, or any
part thereof.
4. Right of First Refusal. Plaintiffs hereby give, grant, bargain, sell and convey
unto Defendant a right of first refusal to purchase Plaintiffs' property. If Plaintiffs receive a bona
tide offer to purchase from any third person that they are willing to accept, they shall provide
written notice to Defendant of the offer along with a copy of the offer. Defendant shall provide
written notice to Plaintiffs exercising the right of first refusal to purchase Plaintiffs' property on
7
RECEIVED
JAN 03 2019
®CM WILMINGTON, NC

Jill II III I II I IIIIII IIII IIII II III B2502 P09Rob
31,n,Son 3206
6 000
Brunswick County. NC Register of Deeds page 8 or 20
the same terms contained in the offer within 30 days of receipt of the written notice and offer
from Plaintiffs. In counting the 30 days, day one is the date following actual receipt of the
written notice and offer by Defendant, and the offer expires if not accepted or rejected in writing
at 12 midnight on day 30. If Defendant does not respond or agree in writing to purchase the
Plaintiffs' property on the same terms, Plaintiffs shall be free to sell the property to original
offeror on the terms offered, immediately following expiration of the 30 day right of refusal
period.
a. This Right of First Refusal may NOT be assigned without the written consent of
all Parties, but if assigned by agreement, this Right of First Refusal shall be
binding on the assignee and his heirs and successors.
b. This Right of First Refusal may be waived by Defendant at any time by a
statement in writing, duly executed and notarized, suitable for recording at the
Brunswick County Registry.
c. if not terminated at an earlier time either by written waiver by Defendant or by
the events described in the preceding paragraph, this Right of First Refusal shall
terminate and become null and void from and after October 31, 2026.
d. This Right of First Refusal shall inure to the benefit of and be binding upon the
respective successors, assigns and heirs of the Parties and shall run with the
Plaintiffs' property and the Defendant's property
5. Bathroom Facilities. The parties acknowledge and agree that Plaintiffs will be
constructing Bathroom Facilities on their property, in accordance with applicable local and state
building codes and other applicable ordinances. Plaintiffs shall locate the bathroom facilities on
S
RECEIVED
JAN Q 3 2019
CCM WILMINGTON, NC

III1IIIIII IIII IIIIIIIIII�IIII IIII RobertB2502 PJ. Rob
0932 �';o07-2006
n:3B NO
Brunswick County, NC Register of Deeds page 9 of 2E
their property, across and on the northern side of Nance Street ("up the hill") unless precluded
from building the Bathroom Facilities on the northern side of Nance Street by municipality or
local government agency. In that event, Plaintiffs must provide Defendant with evidence that
they are precluded by municipality or local government agency from constructing the Bathroom
Facilities on the northern side of Nance Street. After providing such evidence to Defendant,
Plaintiffs may construct the Bathroom Facilities on their property on the southern side of Nance
Street but shall construct the Bathroom Facilities on the western half of the Plaintiffs' property.
The Parties mutually agree to cooperate with respect to permitting issues about Plaintiffs
Bathroom Facilities.
h. Insurance Agreement. So long as the Parties to this Agreement (or their heirs or
devisees) are the owners of the properties concerned, the Parties agree to maintain liability
insurance for the benefit of their respective customers and invitees on the docks and piers, in the
minimum amount of $1,000,000.00 and agree to provide proof of coverage to the other party
upon request.
7. Agreement Not to Disparage the Other Party's Business. In the recognition
that each can benefit from encouraging business for the other, the Parties mutually agree not to
disparage, by words or actions, the other party or the other party's businesses, not to dissuade
others from patronizing the other's businesses, and not to take actions which tend to jeopardize
the profitability of the other's businesses.
8. Cash Payment. Plaintiffs agree to pay to Defendant in settlement of the disputed
claims between the parties and in consideration for the above agreements the sum previously
9
RECEIVED
JAN 03 2019
DCM WILMINGTON, NC

II I II I I I I I N I II I I II I'll I I III II M NI L J. Robinson
380000
Brunswick County, NC Register of Deeds pegs 10 of 20
agreed to by the Parties. The sum shall be paid by Plaintiffs to Defendant in cash or cash
equivalent at the time of the execution of this Agreement by the Parties.
9. Documents and Timetable.
a. Promptly upon execution of this Settlement Agreement, the Parties shall prepare,
execute and file with the Court such Stipulations. Notices or other documents as
are necessary to dismiss and terminate with rP eLdicc all claims and
counterclaims in the above -described Civil Action.
b. Additionally, the parties agree to promptly record this Agreement at the
Brunswick County Registry.
c. The Parties agree to prepare such other and further documents as are necessary
and appropriate to effectuate the terms of this settlement.
M Release of All Claims. All Parties hereto fully understand and agree that upon all
Parties' execution and recording of this Agreement, and the payment required by Paragraph 8,
this Agreement shall constitute a mutual, full, complete and final release, settlement, satisfaction,
and compromise of any and all claims, losses, demands, damages, causes of action, whether in
law or in equity. of whatsoever kind and nature, from the beginning of time up to and including
the date that this release of claims becomes effective, arising from or concerning the Dock
Dispute or claims asserted or that could have been asserted in the Litigation (except for the
performance and promises contained herein), for or against the Parties and their affiliates, heirs,
executors, beneficiaries, administrators, representatives, officers, directors, shareholders,
members, managers, employees, successors and assigns and respective insurers.
10
RECEIVED
JAN 03 2u'iy
DCM WILMINGTON, NC

111111 II I I II'IIIIINIIIII 1152502 P0934 an,sa5 38 300
8—nswick County, NC Re9keter of Deeds page 11 of 20
H. Dispute Resolution. If a dispute arises out of or relates to this Agreement or any
of the Documents described in paragraph 9 above, or the breach of any of them, the Parties shall
endeavor to settle the dispute first through direct discussions between the parties. If the Parties
are not able to settle the dispute within thirty (30) days after written Notice of the dispute, the
Parties shall submit the dispute to mediation as follows:
a. Mediation. If the dispute cannot be settled as set forth herein above, the Parties
shall endeavor to settle the dispute by mediation under the current rules for Forth
Carolina Court Ordered Mediation before recourse to any other dispute resolution
procedures. Once one party files a written request for mediation with the other
party, the Parties agree to conclude such mediation within sixty (60) days of tiling
of the request. Either party may terminate the mediation at any time after the first
session, but the decision to terminate shall be delivered in person by the patty to
the other party and the mediator.
b. Litigation. If the dispute cannot be settled by mediation within sixty (60) days,
the Parties may file an action in Brunswick County Superior Court or the federal
district court for the Eastern District of North Carolina.
12. Notices. All written notices provided for in this Agreement or in the Documents
called for herein shall be deemed given if delivered personally to a responsible representative of
the party or if sent by facsimile (with written confirmation copy following) or by certified mail to
the party at its address specified herein. Either party may from time to time, by written notice to
the other, as herein provided, designate a different address to which to send notices. Notices
shall be provided in the most expeditious manner possible.
RECEIVED
JAN a3 2019
0CM WILMINGTON, NC

06
IIIIIII IIII IIIII IIIIN Lill I�I Illr of Daeds pa� j,� 12 ne�20
Brunswick County,
Mr. and Mrs. Robert E. Taylor Ms. Doris W. Nance
635 Bennett Trail SW 1381 Thomasboro Road SW
Calabash, North Carolina 28467 Calabash, North Carolina 28467
13. It is understood and agreed that this settlement is a compromise of disputed
claims and that any payment and concessions made hereunder is not to be construed as an
admission of liability on the part of the persons, each of whom expressly denied liability.
14. All Parties hereto agree to pay and bear their own attorneys' fees, experts' fees,
mediator's fees, and all other costs and expenses in connection with all matters, things and
documents referred to herein, and the negotiation, preparation, execution and performance of this
Agreement.
15. In entering into this Agreement, the Parties represent that the terms of this
Agreement are fully understood and voluntarily accepted and that this Agreement contains the
entire agreement between the Parties hereto, that all prior understandings, representations and
agreements are merged into this Agreement, and the terms of this Agreement are contractual and
not merely recital.
16. In addition to all other remedies at law or in equity pertaining to any breach
hereof, specific performance shall be available to compel a Party's performance of this
Agreement.
17. All warranties, representations, covenants, agreements and releases contained
herein shall survive the execution of this Agreement.
12
RECEIVED
JAN 03 2019
DCM WILMINGTON, NC

11 [ j 1 i 1111 I IN � � I III B2502 P0936 _07_2008
tl 35: 38 000
Robert J. Robinson
Brunswick County, NC Register of Oeed5 p—je t3 of 20
18. This Agreement shall not he modified or amended except by an instrument in
writing signed by all Parties hereto affected by said amendment or modification.
19. This Agreement shall be governed and interpreted by the laws of the State of
North Carolina, without giving effect to conflicts of laws principles.
IN WITNESS WHEREOF, the Parties have caused this instrument to be executed in
their names, and the individual Parties hereto have set their hands and seals and adopted as their
seal the typewritten word "SEAL" appearing beside their names.
_ r ,L I (SEAL)
Robert Taylor, Plaintit
(SEAL)
Serina Taylor, Plaintitt"
13
U(,J—1 �.c% �^ '---9 _ _ (SEAL)
Doris W. Nance, Defendant
RECEIVED
JAN 0.3 2019
DCM WILMINGTON, NC

Illnl I III I I III IIIIII►IIIIIIIII III B2 2 3. Rob 390000
Brunsuiok County, NC Rsglsker of Deeds page 14 of 20
STATE OF NORTH CAROLINA
COUNTY OF NEW HANOVER
I, /CLlf//c M- 1",11h!e a Notary Public for said County and State, do
hereby certify that Robert E. Taylor personally came before me this day and acknowledged the
due execution of the foregoing instrument.
WITNESS my hand and notarial seal, this the day of IV",v <p{L. 2006.
My Commission Expires:
STATE OF NORTH CAROLINA
COUNTY OF NEW HANOVER
NOTARY PUBLIC
•eww�ww.�
M.
�re,
_ �pTAR ►-
pUBL\G
•
•,��pFk C�� •++
wYs wM••
1, &4h e-l/c-of , e , a Notary Public for said County and State, do
hereby certify that Serina Ann Taylor personally appeared before me this day and acknowledged
the due execution of the foregoing instrument. ^^ //
WITNESS my hand and notarial seal, this the of `1/0` Alle , 2006.
My Commission Expires:
c-owo Id, � "//
Act f�-
NOTARY PUBLIC
14
•'� M.
, oTAR }-
z
jOUBL\,- r
•'r�►�FR C�J,•',
RECEIVED
JAN Q 3 2019
DCM WILMINGTON, NC

I IIIII IIII I IIIIIII I IIIII III Robert P09 o ,r'so�-38000
Brunswick County, NC Register of Deeds oage 15 of 20
STATE OF NORTH CAROLINA
COUNTY OFS-�R brunSwiCK
1, T� & 46Cr _ ____ , a Notary Public for said County and State, do
hereby certify that Doris W. Nance personally appeared before me this day and acknowledged
the due execution of the foregoing instrument.
WITNESS my hand and notarial seal, this the 2 of NOVeMW , 2006.
My Commission Expires:
3-30- 201c7
10AtIAOR-U—BLIC
-------------
OFFvJ ",.L SEAL
' BRU�15YJi�K COU�!TY
rARA S. F AZ(i _ {ER _
. EX ves
W
RECEIVED
JAN 03 2019
DCM WILMINGTON, NC

B2bert 17 39i' o�-3ae00
Brunswick County, NC Register of Deeds page 16 of 2e
TAX PARCEL ID NO: 2550005801
Those certain lands and premises, lying and being in the County of Brunswick,
North Carolina and more particularly described as follows:
Being all of Parcel A as shown on that map prepared by Bobby M. Long,
RLS, dated October 16, 1997. a copy of which is attached to the deed
recorded in Book 727 at Page 226 of the Brunswick County Registry, and
which is also shown as the 0.26 acre parcel on that survey by James R.
Tompkins, PLS, dated March 1, 2005 and revised April 22, 2005 and
recorded in Map Cabinet 33 at Page 47 of the Brunswick County Registry.
Earline Nance Jones was the sole devisee under the Will of Joseph L.
Nance, Sr., who died testate in Horry County, South Carolina on April 25,
2001. An exemplified copy of the Will is filed in File No. 02 E 258 in the
Office of the Clerk of Superior Court of Brunswick County, North
Carolina.
For back reference, see deeds recorded in Book 727 at Page 226, Book
402 at Page 786, Book 338 at Page 874, Book 343 at Page 268, Book 343
at Page 266, Book 451 at Page 690, Book 466 at Page 916, Book 346 at
Page 836, Book 339 at Page 526 AND Book 51 at Page 512, all of the
Brunswick County Registry.
EXHIBIT
q
RECEIVED
JAN U 3 2019
0CM WILMINGTON, NC

I I I I III II I IIIIIIIIII��IIIIIIII una'b-1 POMJ. R..2502 ;son 3a�j°a
Brunswick County, tglster o4 D. eds pnge 17 of 20
TAX PARCEL [D NO: 25500057
Those certain lands and premises, lying and being in the County of Brunswick, North
Carolina more particularly described as follows:
Being all of Parcel B as shown on that map prepared by Bobby M. Long, RLS,
dated October 16, 1987, a copy of which is attached to the deed recorded in Book
744, Page 222 of the Brunswick County Registry, which is also shown as Tract 1
and Tract 2 on that map recorded in Map Cabinet 33 at Page 430 of the Brunswick
County Registry.
'9 EXHIBIT
9 13
RECEIVED
JAN 03 2019
OCM WILMINGTON, NC

�I��IIIIII II 'IIIIIIII'llllllli'of 20
Brunswick County, NC RR llillllr of pssd
� �.��� w lA CwCVNFI YWx_9 / Y1[tnu
r . Ul � Mn a l•a .,��.W.li
aM rtWxWh or ,�x \ � WWI aF,r[t•x. P�
` CA�BASH R,VEft
.�
TRACT :
LEGEND
w �qw
TRACT I
ry fOH J [IlwUt � •,�
1 x w•zenr c
4F Y
OAK $TB66T w V� I cows a `a n alu ,� Y1wN. 01
r�
SUE ■ 11
EXHIBIT
n.
AGREEMENT LINE
DORIS NANCE
VgMl9 U�
xC NIOIQ9pW Wq A/N.1W t-EOM
M 1.w110 •y
R OK K Ayb-
• EXHIBIT
RECEIVED
JAN 0 3 2019
OCM WILMINGTON, NC

II I III I I II 11 I II Ifl IIII I' I I I RB2502obert J Ro ; =o� 3e°°°°
Brunswick County t4C R*gister of Oeeds page 19 of 20
Shenvin D Cribb
N C Professional Land Surveyor L-1099
1 144 Shipyard Blvd.
Wilmington, N. C. 28412
Phone [phone]
fax [phone]
October 30, 2006
Description
Of Easement Area Which Contains
That Portion of Captain Nance
Seatood Restaurant Which Lies
West of the Dividing Line Between Doris Nance
And Robert Taylor
Beginning at the intersection of the center -lines of Oak Street (40 foot right-of-
way) and River Road (60 foot right-of-way), also known as SR 1 166 in Calabash, North
Carolina. Go thence South 29 degrees 18 minutes 35 seconds East 128.46 feet, along the
center -line of said River Road to an old "PK" Nail. Go thence South 21 degrees 12
minutes 15 seconds East 31.65 feet. a tie line, to an old railroad spike. Go thence South
62 degrees 22 minutes 53 seconds West 30.37 feet to an old iron rod at the northernmost
comer of Tract 1, as described in a deed to Doris W Nance recorded in Rook 2278 at
Page 619 of the Brunswick County Registry. Go thence South 62 degrees 17 minutes 46
seconds West 87.98 feet, along the northerly line of said Nance Tract to an old iron rod.
Go thence South 18 degrees 28 minutes 44 seconds East 162 00 feet, along the westerly
line of said Nance Tract and the easterly line of a tract deeded to Robert E. Taylor and
wife Serina A Taylor by deed recorded in Book 2207 at Page 1219 of the Brunswick
County Registry, to an old iron rod THE TRUE POINT OF BEGINNING. Running
thence from said beginning point:
South 18 degrees 28 minutes 44 seconds East 25.21 feet, along the dividing line
between said Nance and said Taylor Tracts to a point; thence
North 32 degrees 34 minutes 15 seconds West 24.48 feet. along a new line to a
point. thence
3. North 57 degrees 26 minutes 45 seconds East 6.14 feet, to the point of beginning.
The above described easement contains 75 square feet. more or less. The same
being a portion of said Taylor Tract.
EXHIBIT
RECEIVE[
JAN 03 2019
CCM WILMINGTON, NC

0
•
IBrunswick
I II�i'llN���i)Illr of D�sdJ.
s pobiage 20n f 200
Sherwin 1) Cribb
N C Prolessinnal Land Surveyor I -1099
1144 Shipyard Blvd.
Wilmington, N. C 28412
Phone [phone] October 30, 2006
Fax [phone]
Description
Of Pier Agreement line
For
Doris Nance
Beginning at the intersection of the center -lines of Oak Street (40 foot right-of-
way) and River Road (60 foot right -of -sway) also known as SR 1 166 in Calabash. North
Carolina. Go thence South 29 degrees 18 minutes 35 seconds East 128.46 feet, along the
center -line of said River Road to an old "PK- Nail Go thence South 21 degrees 12
minutes 15 seconds East 31 65 feet, a tie line, to an old railroad spike. Go thence South
62 degrees 22 minutes 53 seconds West 30.37 feet. to an old iron rod at the northernmost
comer of Tract 1. as described in a deed to Doris W. Nance recorded in Book 2278 at
Page 619 of the Brunswick County Registry. Go thence South 62 degrees 17 minutes 46
seconds West 87.98 feet, along the northerly line of said Nance Tract to an old iron rod.
Go thence South 18 degrees 28 minutes 44 seconds East 263.27 feet, along the westerly
line ofsaid Nance Tract to an old iron rod. Go thence North 52 degrees 32 mir•-• 51
seconds East 16.62 feet, leaving the westerly line of said Nance Tract to a new iron pipe.
Go thence South 37 degrees 27 minutes 09 seconds East 53.63 feet, to a new "PK" Nail
on the northerly edge of a pier. THE TRUE POINT OF BEGINNING. Running thence
from said beginning point:
South 37 degrees 27 minutes 09 seconds East 5.24 feet, to a "PK" Nail on the
southerly edge of said pier.
The above described 5.24 foot line is the agreed line. on an existing pier, between
Doris Nance and Robert Taylor. Doris Nance's interest lies East of said line and Robert
Taylor's interest lies West of said line.
RECEIVED
JAN 03 2019
CCM WILMINGTON, NC