Stanback, John

.,pitEDGE & FILL No. 74488
®GP-1411 /RAL PERMIT Previous permit# A B C D
❑,Nv❑odification +' M[]Complete Reissue []Partial Reissue Date previous permit issued
As authorized by the State of North Carolina, Department of Environmental Quality
and the Coastal Resources Commission in an area of environmental concern pursuant to I SA NCAC
❑ Rulesattached.
Applicant Name - / J 't Project Location: County ! �'
Address j % Street Address/ State Road/ Lot (s) -
t r
City ,t I : �), State / !,'ZIP
Phone # ( f )j I ! ' E-Mail Subdivision _
Authorized Agent City ZIP _ r
Affected CW ❑ EW ❑ PTA ❑ ES ❑ PTS Phone # O _ River Basin
AEC(s): OEA ❑ HHF ❑ IH ❑ UBA ❑ WA Adj. Wtr. Body - _ _ (nat /man /unkn)
❑ PWS:
ORW: yes / no PNA yes / no Closest Maj. Wtr. Body - -
Type of Project/ Activity
Pier (dock)length
Fixed Platform(s)
Floating Platform(s)
Finger pier(s)
Groin length
number
Bulkhead/ pray le gth_
avg distance offshore_
max distance offshore
Basin, channel
cubic yards
Boat ramp
Boathouse/ Boatl
Beach
Other
(Vt11,. �J1
(Scale: f ) )
Shoreline Length 6� t_LJ
SAM not sure yes no — --
I
Moratorium: n/a yes no
Photos: �yes no
Waiver Attached: rre//s no
`_,.
A building permit may be required by: (,. %, �/' ❑ See note on back regarding River Basin rules.
( Note Local Planning jurisdiction) r
lC- r- ,� �. �!(cC� f4b
Notes/ Special Conditions � f ! �' G i
.1104.-�-:1
Agent or Applicant Printed Name Permit Officer'Printed Name -----
Signu'*Please read compliance statement onback ofpermit ** Signature' j-='"`
Application Feels) - Check# Issuing Date Expiration Date
t

Sty
CSC, ;�-
Tan Parcel Information:
Carteret County, N .
C
Owner: ALLRED,KATHRYN H
Current PIN: 733505094058000
Site Address:
o
S 't
90
a t `
Mailing Address:
//����`�
12811DLEWOOD DRIVE
z
ASHEBORO NC 27205
>•
' rik
Legal Description:
TR 2 LBA RENTALS LLC
Prior PIN: 08003Bollo
-
> �4
City Limits:
i
Rescue District:
ggQ2
Fire District: HARKERS ISLAND FIRE
]
Tax District: 8
Township: HARKERS ISLAND
tl
Use: VACANT
Land Value: $153450 NBHD: 80016
Bldg Hid Sq Ft:
Bldg Value: $o
Bldg Tot Sq Ft: o
Other Value: $o year Built:
Total Value: $153,450 Noise Leveh
Y
el
Sale Price: $o AICUZ Zone:
Deeded Acres: 0.436 GISAcres: 0.449
Plat Ref: 32 / 118 Roll Type: R
.�e
Deed Ref:1454 / 34o Deed Date: 20130725
Bedrooms: $aihrOOmS:
aN=Sfa
Ptlnted May 8, 201
Ne

AGENT AUTHORIZAON FOR rAMA PERMIT APPLICATION
Name of Property Owner Requesog Permit: Tv 4 �
Mailing Address: 7 3 G C. F% l
Phone Number: 9t �( 6 q y 2— I U/
Email Address: d fo�N �n c L� ya �v • c O
I certify that I have authorized
Agent r Contractor
to act on my behalf, for the purpose of applying for and obtaining all CAMA permits
necessary for the following proposed development:
at my property located at -1- y `I /'o / / y t''/`
in C� e A e� e t County
ii. rr �' t f Le ✓
1 furthermore certify that 1 an, authorized to grant, and do in fact grant permission to
Division of Coastal Management staff, the Local Permit Officer and their agents to enter
on the aforementioned lands in connection with evaluating information related to this
permit application.
Property Owner Information:
l a f 2 1 I (� I
Date
certification is valid through / l
sst

Davenport, Ryan
From: Grainger Coughtrey <[e-mail]>
Sent: Wednesday, April 17, 2019 10:51 AM
To: Davenport, Ryan
Subject: [External] John Stanback Agent Authorization Form
Hi Ryan,
I have included the Agent Authorization form for John Stanback in this email. We are still waiting on one of the
adjacent property owner green cards but will get that to you as soon as we can.
Thanks,
Grainger

0
■ Complete Rem@ 1. 2, and 3.:::.:
A 31
x Print your name and address do the reverse.
X
O Addressee
oo that we can return the card toyou. '..
B -
red
_ .. C, to of Ivey
R Attach this Cartt to the back of the mallpteoe,
or 6h the front If space permits:
-
O. Is---addreee dl5eren
17 Yee.. .
1 Article Addreeeed to.
It:YE3 enter dbWery add ess
low: ❑ Nd .:
Duv,� y Mao �r
Gti tv; l ( NL 2746
ff11
II�'I
�II
3' ServloeType '.'. .•
OPdaay Mall �.
Oa
IIIIIII'I
IIII
IIIIIIII�III'II
IIILI
II
II
'
®�aNgpin Realddan7a'�aaY.-
0Mally
94024886 9033672 95
95'
9
G9Man
❑ odmMau Redndd'oeuey :�'.
.
❑ iawm aapi0
t& Mna and"...,
..
oCocolAeaaOnDamyinahery gaetrlaedeeetrry' o acoanfmatbn.
118 1130. 0000 2800 1671
T] Inaaed MN
[jayamMalateetrahaoalwn
RaaulaodDWI+av
...
PS: Form3811 ,J2015PSN7530-0700053'''
ury
- :...
Oomestlo Return Reoapt
._

UNITEDSTATES
A POSTAL SERVICE
April 25, 2019
Dear Grainger Coughtrey:
The following is in response to your request for proof of delivery on your item with the tracking number:
EE45 9535 871 U S.
Item Details
Status:
Status Date / Time:
Location:
Postal Product:
Extra Services:
Actual Recipient Name:
Delivered
April 19, 2019, 12:55 pm
MARSHALLBERG, INC 28553
Priority Mail Express 1-DayTM
Insured
PO to Addressee
Up to $100 insurance included
G JOHNSON
Note: Actual Recipient Name may vary if the intended recipient is not available at the time of delivery.
Weight: 3.Ooz
Street Address: 254 LUCILLE LEWIS DR
City, State ZIP Code: MARSHALLBERG, NC 28553-9714
Recipient Signature
Signature of Recipient:
• \;ll'P4'��- III i'v✓ .�
tI IAddress of Recipient: r
Note: Scanned image may reflect a different destination address due to Intended Recipient's delivery instructions on file.
Thank you for selecting the United States Postal Service® for your mailing needs. If you require additional
assistance, please contact your local Post OfficeTM or a Postal representative at 1-800-222-1811.
Sincerely,
United States Postal Service®
475 L'Enfant Plaza SW
Washington, D.C. 20260-0004

April 11, 2019
Mr Roy Brownlow, CAMA District Manager
400 Commerce Ave.
Morehead City, NC 28557
252-808-2808 ext 217 Fax: [phone]
roan. davenportna,ncdenr. Qov
CAMA Field Officer — Down East Carteret County
Heather.M. Stvron(a)ncdenr.gov
CAMA Field Officer —Beaufort and Beaufort ETJ
Reference: John Stanback `s CAMA Proposed Project located at:
249 Polly Way Lane €i
Marshallberg, NC 28553
Agent: Grainger Coughtrey, Newport, NC 252-562-3453 A" X t VT
Design: Carolina Silvics, Edenton, NC. DwM4pa�
Mr. Brownlow, Mr. Davenport, Ms. Styron 1�+
I received certified mail notification of this proposed CAMA project as an adjacent property
owner at 1309 Marshallberg Rd Marshallberg NC 28553. I have not discussed this project with
my neighbor but I do have some concerns. It is my understanding that I must respond to the
proposed project materials I received within ten days to express my concerns or objections. This
letter is notification of my concerns/objections to this project. Mr. Stanback is a good neighbor
and I can understand his desires to stabilize his waterfront property using a living -shoreline
approach. I understand the potential benefits of a living shoreline to Mr Stanback and potentially
to my adjacent property. However, the Project Description (315 feet marsh toe revetment using
oyster shell bags) and Site Plan (by Carolina Silvics — Edenton, NC) do not provide sufficient
information on the proposed project to allow me to confidently fully support this application.
I do have severe erosion concerns adjacent to my property and Mr. Stanback's proposed project.
Thus, I contacted Mr. Jay Sauber (noted NC Water Quality Expert) and Antonio B. Rodriguez,
(Ph.D. Coastal Geology and Geophysics) at UNC's Institute of Marine Sciences. While I
generally support a living-reef/shoreline approach to stabilization, the proposed plan appears to
leave a possible unprotected gap between my property and Mr. Stanback's proposed oyster shell
deployment. This gap could receive increased wave energy at a very sensitive area near the
property line. The project (with my potential waiver of the 15 foot setback) should consider
connecting the oyster shell revetment directly to the rock reinforced waterfront on my property.
The project should also consider the benefits of establishing a living -shoreline inclusive of
plantings and perhaps SAV. As proposed, it is not clear to me if the project will impact seagrass
and there is No information provided on how wide the revetment will be. Based on my
discussions with Dr. Rodriguez, The height of the revetment is important because you want it to
turn into a vibrant oyster reef. If the revetment is constructed properly, the live oysters could
promote sedimentation, which would potentially be good for my property as well. But if there is

a gap additional wave energy could exacerbate the current erosion problem between our
properties. According to Dr, Rodriguez, The top of the oyster shell reef needs to be in the lower
part of the intertidal zone, exposed to air only about 30-40% of the time. The project proposal
that 1 received did not have any specifics other than just "no higher than 6 inches from the
elevation of the existing marsh substrate". The project description needs more details and needs
to be at the elevation where oysters grow best. The description of 6 inches above where marsh
grows is probably not good. If constructed correctly, without possible gaps in protection, with
the objective of the revetment turning into an oyster reef then it could be a positive impact on
both Mr. Stanback's property and my property as well. If this project is simply building a high
wall out of bagged oysters, then I would be very concerned about the increases in transfer of
wave energy towards my property and would offer my objections.
Siqn�erely,
Danny Mu hy�
245 Windsor Rd
Greenville NC 27858
Cc: Mr. John Stanback
736 E. Franklin St.
Chapel Hill, NC 27514
[e-mail]
RECEIVED
APR 12 Z019
DCM-MHD CITY

ADJACENT RIPARIAN PROPERTY OWNER STATEMENT
I hereby certify that I own property adja(mnl to � J ti � fl eo L x- 4 s
property located at
(Name of Property Owner)
Z 4�r 1'.• !! (,J�:,, 1 � ., �
ri s
(AddrQas, lot, Block, Road, etc.)
on t t . i in N.C.
aterbod _
(W y) (CityRown n~a" clot County)
The applicant has described to me, as shown below, the development proposed at the above
location.
I have no objection to this proposal.
I have objections to this proposal.
DESCRIPTION AND/OR DRAWING OF PROPOSED DEVELOPMENT
(Individual proposing development must fill in description below or attach a site drawing)
WAIVER SECTION
1 understand that a pier, dock. mooring pilings, boat ramp, breakwater, boathouse, lift, or groin
must be set back a minimum distance of 15' from my area of riparian access unless waived by
me. (if you wish to waive the setback, you must initial the appropriate blank below.)
I do wish to waive the 15' setback requirement.
I do not wish to waive the 15' setback requirement.
(Property Owner information) (AdjacAnt Property Owner Information)
•Srynartrre
a,l,r t,..�•-etc
Print or Type Nome
_��A t-, L t'r.-..
Mailing Address
1_h nt i_ 1-4111r (L 27,�i`�
City
214 61! Z1 G T C eC,-,,
Telephone Number/email address
Darr
hn wr
Printa�Ype
Addmss�o�
lefephprre Number/ email address r' 1
ikrr�.
1 —RECEIVED
'Valid for one calendar year after signature'
(h'eviawd Aug.W41 2 2019
DCM-MHD CITY

CERTIFIED MAIL • RETURN RECEIPT REQUESTED
DIVISION OF COASTAL MANAGEMENT
ADJACENT RIPARIAN PROPERTY OWNER NOTIFICATIONIWAIVER FORM
Namc of Property Owner.
Address of Property:
h Ll of P, / /y (.-c; s,
(Lot or Street #, Street or Rend,
i
& County)
Agent's Name#; v'afin,u ��>k���tL Mailing Address: 36OR Nc.-Z4_
Agent's phone#: ZJS S62- 3453 Ne�Porfi• NG Zs57o
I hereby certify that I own property adjacent to the above referenced property, The individual
applying for this permit has described to me as shown on the attached drawing the development
they are proposing. A descrioM or drawing th dimenskans must be Provides! with this -letter.
_- I have no objections to this proposal. _ V _ I have objections to this proposal.
Ityou have objections to what is being proposed, you mu8t notify the Division of Coastal Management
(DCM) in writing within 10 days of roColpt of this notice, Contact information for OCM offices is
available at htrp feYrwta nacoastfltrtt to taemrnt nc rroyeb�em/sta17-11stlna orby calling 1-888-4RCOAST.
WAIVER SECTION
I understand that a pier, dock, mooring pilings, boat tamp, breakwater, boathouse, or lift must
be set back a minimum distance of IIV from my area of riparian access unless waived by me. (if
you wish to waive the setback, you must initial the appropriate blank below.)
I do wish to waive the 16' setback requirement.
I do not wish to waive the 15' setback requirement.
(Pro7rty Owner information)
Sigifalure
i r
..��`fri �•T'G r� ��c. r. k
Print or Type Name
73 � L t'r•�. (C (,� �•t
Mailing Address
C{,rnrr l�.rr �t 7fj�
Glyn alelZilp r
�r�6in yla�u S•c�.a�r<,t<i��' rNw%r,,c,,,
Teiephorre Number / Email Address
FU
WIC
(Ripar a Property 7LL4
Information)
t
h
Print or ype Name
Ll (� CcJ ; h 4 <0
MC
Ackrmss
ee';
ldyllare/Iip � M �� r yl3 LID 1 er /vPA. ,CVP
Telephone Vumber / Finail Address
d RECEIVED
Id _ /q
rk,r 1 2019
{Revised Ar{��t}7�
DCM-MHD CITY

Project Location Map
Proposed Oyster Shell Bag
Marsh Toe Revetment
Date Prepared: March 30, 2019
Mapping Source: Google Earth,
03/30/2019
Project Description
The location of the proposed oyster shell
bag marsh toe revetment and sill at the
property shown to the left is shown in the
photograph below (yellow line). The total
length of the marsh toe revetment will be
approximately 315 linear feet, with a gap
every 100 feet.
The marsh toe revetment will be constructed
by layering oyster shell bags perpendicular
to the shoreline, 6 feet waterward of the
erosion escarpment, and no higher than 6
inches from the elevation of the existing
marsh substrate The sill will be no more than
30 feet offshore of the mean high water. Coir
fiber/jute matting will be used for the bottom
layer of the marsh toe revetment.
Figure 1 - Location Map &
Site Plan
ADolicant(s)
John Stanback
249 Polly Way Ln
rshallberg, NC 28553
Site Plan
ROLINA
ILvres
Nnn,.l RIIO.r[ Prof io..[s
PO Box 1017
Edenton, NC 27932
[phone] w .carolinasilvics.com

Project Description
The location of the proposed oyster shell bag marsh toe revetment and sill at the property
shown to the left is shown in the photograph below (yellow line). The total length of the marsh
toe revetment will be approximately 315 linear feet, with a gap every 100 feet.
The marsh toe revetment will be constructed by layering oyster shell bags perpendicular to
the shoreline, 6 feet waterward of the erosion escarpment and no higher than 6 inches from
the elevation of the existing marsh substrate. The sill will be no more than 30 feet offshore of
the mean high water. Coir fiber/jute matting will be used for the bottom layer of the marsh toe
revetment. _
Coastal
Wetlands
Mars
Escarpn
Coir or JI
Mattins
Proposed Oyster Shell Bag
Marsh Toe Revetment
Date Prepared: March 30, 2019
Mapping source: Google Earth,
03/30/2019
Maximum 6'
NHW (18 inches)
NLW (6 inches)
Example of Oyster Shell Bag
Marsh Toe Revetment
at Low Tide.
Figure 2 - Cross -Section
Applicant(s)
John Stanback
249 Polly Way Ln
Marshallberg, NC 28553
ROLINA
ILvlcs
Nafurar RrsaurcrsPr f iortals
PO Box 1017
Edenton, NC 27932
[phone] w .carolinasilvics.com

CERTIFIED MAIL • RETURN RECEIPT REQUESTED
DIVISION OF COASTAL MANAGEMENT
ADJACENT RIPARIAN PROPERTY OWNER NOTIFICATIONIWAIVER FORM
Name of Property Owner. D h n
Address of Properly. `� Po / / y (.-v:, Y / <., e , r�7 a r f (, 1 l � r
(Lot or Street #. Street or Road. City & County)
Agent's Name#: _ hFaifing Address:
Agent's phone #:
4.r 4A2 f
I hereby certify that I own property adjacent to the above referenced property. The individual
applying for this permit has described to me as shown on the attached drawing the development
they are proposing. A description or drawing, with dimensions must be provided with this letter.
I have no objkx;tions to this proposal. _ I have objections to this proposal.
tf you lave 0bf9Ctions to what is bearg proposod, you must notify the Div►slon ofCoastal MBnaganmof
MCAQ In writing within 10 days of receipt 0f this notice. Contact information for DCU offices is
avar7ableOfh :/Avw'.vnccoastifinana emen,.net/w®b1cmis.aff•Jlstlnoorbvcadlna1-888dRCOAST.
WAIVER SECTION
understand that a pier, dock, mooring Pifings, boat ramp, breakwater, boathouse, or lift must
be set back a minimum distance of 15 from my area of riparian access unless waived by me. (if
you wish to waive the setback, you must initial the appropriate blank below.)
do wish to waive the 15' setback requirement
do not wish to waive the 15 setback requirement.
(Pr rty Owner Information)
77 TF
SValu/Irr r 1
Jahx ' '-'0 4"c' LC
i�rra or Type Aleme
(Riparian Property Owner Information)
Qrature r /
FWorType N
aim
-736 9, T I S U)
Mailing Address Mailing Address
caty/state"Zip c
ryi 11-1 NI ID �CiANh�rfrWy �y�u.rcy ZS Z- S 3l'Y/ Sb dc, nyv .!fi7
Tekplwne N,.mberl EMW Address Terephane Number/ Emag Address / Y13 �S r
!U 1�1��uE a 0 1't 5- _�)-
flare Darr
(Revised Aug. 2014)