Loading...
HomeMy WebLinkAboutLand Use Plan Update 1986-19870 0 0 0 0 e 0 0 0 0 0 u 0 0 0 0 Tow S� 'O F �4 BEACH LAND USE PLAN UPDA7,E Talbert, Cox - & Associates, Inc. Local Adoption Date August 3. 1987 CRC Certification Date: September 25.1987 j PROPERTY OF DIVISION OF COASTAL MANAGEMENT PLEASE DO NOT REMOVE - 0 0 0 0 0 C 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 Tow IJl 'o F JT�. BEACH LAND USE PLAN UPDATE Talbert, Cox - & Associates, Inc. Local Adoption Date August 3. 1987 CRC Certification Date: September ?5.1987 SUNSET BEACH, NORTH CAROLINA LAND USE PLAN: 1985 UPDATE PREPARED FOR SUNSET BEACH, NORTH CAROLINA James E. Gordon, Mayor SUNSET BEACH BOARD OF COMMISSIONERS Edward M. Gore, Mayor, Pro Tem Minnie K. Hunt Katherine Hill Mary K. Griffith Donald Safrit PREPARED BY SUNSET BEACH PLANNING BOARD Richard Good, Chairman Walter Hoff James Craig C. Schuyler Bramley Chance Scrantom Channing F. Coppage John Zivkovic AND Linda J. Fluegel, Town Administrator PLANNING ASSISTANCE PROVIDED BY Kenneth Weeden, AICP, Project Manager .Talbert, Cox & Associates, Inc. The preparation of this document was financed in part through a grant provided by the North Carolina Coastal Management Program, through funds provided by the Coastal Zone Management Act of 1972, as amended, which is administered by the Office of Ocean and Coastal Resource Management, National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration. Attachment # 1 1. Use of Package Treatment Plants (Page 41) It is the policy of. the Town of Sunset Beach that package treatment plants which comply with the applicable Environmental Regulations are allowed. All development activity which will occur, subsequent to the_ availability of a centralized sewer system, will be required to connect to the Town's Wastewater service, and all existing development within the area of availability will also be required to connect within a reasonable period of time. 2. Local commitment to Providing Services to Development (Page 45) As areas develop, it is the policy of the Town that the developer/owner share in the financial responsibility* of providing basic urban services. Within this current planning period, the Town .will be served by the Brunswick County water system. The Town will apply for grant and loan funds to construct a municipal -wastewater system. .The system, once constructed, will eventually be extended to serve the entire Town and ETA. Construction plans, which may be subject to modification, provide for :system development in three phases. Phase I: To serve the island, Sugar Sands, and Seatrail Plantation. Phase II: To serve the remainder of the mainland -(excepting portions of the ETA West). Phase III: Toservethe western portion of the ETA. It is the policy of the Town of Sunset Beach to support Hunicipal wastewater service for the Town by all means available (grants, etc). It is further the expressed desire of the Town that wastewater service.will not be used as a means by which to increase the density of development in Town or the ETA. Sunset Beach policy will remain, as previously noted, low, density and single family dwelling oriented. The Town wishes to pursue centralized sewer service as a means by which to protect the environment. The Town does not.wish to allow increased density, with the accompanying increase in impervious surfaces, to lead to water quality degradation. Therefore, the .Town will review and update its present policies, (stormwater management, buffers, etc.) relating to the mitigation of developmental impacts to ensure continued and enhanced environmental protection. P&SI 407 DIVISION OF COASTAL MANAGEMENT 127 Cardinal Drive Extension Wilmington, NC 28405 (919),395-3900 mvmnn A XMI TM TO: Planning and Special Issues mmittee FROM: Haskell S. Rhett SUBJECT: Town of Sunset -Beach Land Use Plan Amendment DATE: May 8,.1992 The Town of Sunset Beach proposes to amend the Town's Land Use Plan Update adopted locally in August, 1987, and adopted by this Commission in September, 1987. The Town proposes amending plan policy so as to allow the Town the opportunity, to apply for grant and loan funds to construct a municipal wastewater system. Previous application for grant funds was denied due to inconsistency with the local government's Land Use Plan. The denial has sparked the Town's interest in revising plan policy. Attachment # 1 is the text of the proposed plan amendment. Attachment # 2 is the text language in the adopted plan. Attachment # 3 is my opinion on consistency for the previously referenced grant application: (Attachment # 3 also illustrates the difficulty the community had in 1987 in deciding what plan policy was to be.. Both sides (pro and con) are represented in quotes from the plan text.) The local public hearing is to be held May 15. It is unknown at this writing what action the. local government may take.' If the local government approves the plan amendment as submitted, staff recommends P&SI/CRC certification of the amendment. The full text of the 1987 Sunset Beach Land Use Plan Update is available for review at my office through May 26. A copy will also be available at the May CRC meeting from me. w 0 GEi male in mines v u .l a W a &+ qWG. v 1. 0 25 50 75 100 MAP I C 0 Q c 01 SUNSET BEACH, NORTH CAROLINA LAND USE PLAN: 1985 UPDATE TABLE OF CONTENTS SECTION I: Analysis of Existing Conditions and Projected Demand A. Establishment of Information Base B. Present Conditions 1. Population 2. Economy 3. Impact of Seasonal Population 4. Existing Land Use Analysis a. Current Conditions b. Land Compatibility Problems c. Problems from Unplanned Development d. Areas Likely to Experience Changes in Predominant Land Use e. Areas of Environmental Concern 5. Current Plans, Policies, and Regulations C. Constraints: Land Suitability .1. Physical Limitations 2. Wellfields 3. Slopes 4. Fragile Areas 5. Areas of Resource Potential D. Constraints: Capacity of Community Facilities 1. Existing Water Service Areas 2. Sewer Service Area 3. Schools 4. Transportation E. Estimated Demand 1. Population Trends 2. Future Land Need 3. Community Facilities Needs 4. Summary of Trends and Facilities Demand: Policy Issues SECTION II: POLICY STATEMENTS A. Resource Protection: Estuarine System 1. Areas of Environmental Concern 2. Areas of Environmental Concern: Ocean Hazards Area ii PAGE 1 2 2 11 11 11 14 15 15 15 18 23 23 24 24 24 25 26 26 26 27 27 28 28 29 30 32 34 35 35 37 PAGE 3. Development in Areas with Constraints 39 4. Hurricane and Flood Evacuation Needs and Plans 41 5. Protection of Potable 'dater Supplies 41 6. Use of Package Treatment Plants 41 7. Stormwater Runoff 42 8. Marina and Floating Home Development 42 9. Industrial Impacts of Fragile Areas 42 10. Development of Sound and Estuarine System Islands 42 B. Resource Production and Management 43 1. Recreational Resources/Fisheries 43 2. Off -Road Vehicles 43 C. Economic and Community Development 44 1. Local Commitment to Providing Services to Development 45 2. Redevelopment of Developed Areas 45 3. Desired Urban Growth Patterns 46 4. Commitment to State and Federal Programs 47 5. Assistance to Channel Maintenance and Beach Renourishment 47 6. Tourism 48 7. Beach and Waterfront Access, and Parking 48 D. Continuing Public Participation Policies 49 E. Storm Hazard Mitigation, Post -Disaster Recovery, and Evacuation Plan 50 1. Hazard Areas at Sunset Beach 51 2. Potential for Loss During a Storm 52 3. Flood Plain Management Regulations 52 4. Storm Hazard Mitigation Policies 53 5. Hurricane Evacuation, Post -Disaster Recovery 53 SECTION III: LAND CLASSIFICATION SYSTEM 54 A. Developed 54 B. Transition 55 C. Conservation 56 D. Conservation Spoil 56 E. Other Classifications 56 iii C l PAGE SECTION IV: RELATIONSHIP OF POLICIES AND LAND CLASSIFICATIONS 58 A. Developed and Transition Classes 58 B. Conservation and Conservation Spoil Classes 58 APPENDICES 1. CAMA Permit 2. Town Zoning Map �T T. Citizens' Survey/Results 1 4. Sunset Beach Hurricane Evacuation Plan 1 2 6 p C G C 0 L' iv C G SUNSET BEACH LAND USE PLAN: 1985 UPDATE LIST OF TABLES AND MAPS TABLE.NUMBERS PAGE 1. Sunset Beach Year -Round Population: 1985 Estimate 3 2. Brunswick County Township Population Projections 4 3. Sunset Beach Population Projections: 1990-1995 5 4. Estimated Residential Units Within the Sunset Beach Town Limits: 1985 6 5. Unit Utilization by Type and Population Projection: 1985 7 6. Average Daily Traffic Volumes, 1985: Sunset Beach Bridge 8 7. Sunset Beach Area Population Summary: 1985 9 8. Sunset Beach Assessed Valuations: 1981-1985 11 9. 1985 Sunset Beach Residential Land Use by Type 12 10. Building Permits: 1981-1985 13 11. Land Development Summary: 1985 14 12. General Soils Limitations in Sunset Beach 24 13. Enrollment Levels and School Capacity: Shallotte, NC 27 14. Sunset Beach Population Projections: 1986-1995 29 MAPS 1. Location Map 2. Existing Land Use Map 3. Composite Hazards Map 4. Land Classification Map iv (a) i (Attached) (Attached) (Attached) C Li L SECTION I Analysis of Existing Conditions and Projected Demand C G - SUNSET BEACH LAND USE PLAN UPDATE 1985 A. ESTABLISHMENT OF INFORMATION BASE This 1985 Land Use Plan Update for Sunset Beach has been prepared in accordance with requirements of the North Carolina Coastal Area Management Act (CAMA). Specifically, this document complies with Subchapter 7B, "Land Use Planning Guidelines," of the North Carolina Administrative Code, as amended, July 9, 1984. The initial CAMA Land Use Plan for Sunset Beach was prepared in 1976, with the first five-year update being done in 1980 as required by the CAMA regulations. The 1980 Plan, which was adopted by the Town and later approved by the Coastal Resources Commission, must also be updated after five years. This document represents the Town's compliance with this required, and, very useful exercise. According to the Land Use Planning Guidelines, the major pur- pose of periodic updating of local land use plans is to identify and analyze newly emerging community issues and problems. An additional element which was not required in either the 1976 Plan or the 1980 Update is a "Storm Hazard Mitigation, Post -Disaster Recovery, and Hurricane Evacuation Plan," and is required to be included in the 1985 Update. This element is designed to help local governments effectively coordinate policies and actions relating to the impact of hurricanes or other severe storms. Another added emphasis in this 1985 Update is the effect of in- creasing development activity on the quality of coastal waters. As indicated in both the 1976 and 1980 Land Use Plans, population growth, which requires an increasing utilization of land and other resources, can lead to undesirable consequences if the land and community facilities are unregulated or improperly managed. Sunset Beach, through the development and subsequent updating of this foundational policy document, along with the enforcement of existing local controls, is seeking to avoid the (T negative results of Unmanaged growth. (� The guidelines further give the following objectives the update should meet: -- to further define and refine local policies and issues; -- to further examine and refine the land classification system and the land classification map; to assess the effectiveness of the existing land use plan and its implementation; l.J - 1 -- to further explore implementation procedures, and; -- to promote a better understanding of the land use plan- ning process. Both the 1976 Land Use Plan and the 1980 Update provided much of the needed information base for this most recent update. However, in some cases, new information had to be developed. A number of data sources were tapped during the preparation of this plan in order to prepare updated analyses of population, housing, the economy, and existing land uses. Most of the data came from primary and secondary sources in the form of direct contacts with Town officials, including members of the Planning Board, represen- tatives of various state and federal agencies and/or previously published documents or reports. On -site "windshield" surveys were conducted to obtain data on existing land use patterns. Efforts were made to obtain data that was as up to date and accurate as possible. A citizen's questionnaire survey was sent to a random sample of 10% of property owners, as well as a general citizens' public information meeting, several public meetings were held with the Planning Board in order to solicit citizens' input in identi- fying preliminary land development issues. B. PRESENT CONDITIONS 1. Population In the conventional land use planning process, population analysis and future growth projections are often relatively uncom- plicated procedures of collecting one set of figures from standard secondary sources, such as the U. S. Census Bureau or State agen- cies, and making estimates of future growth based on recent or existing trends. For seasonally attractive localities, particu- larly those with a high tourist orientation, population analysis and attendant forecasting is not as uncomplicated. Such is the case with Sunset Beach, North Carolina. a. Year -Round Population: Sunset Beach, like other summer resort communities, experi- ences a wide fluctuation of population according to the season. Although the year-round permanent population.has always been and remains relatively small, it has been steadily growing. The Town was incorporated in 1963 and made its first showing in the U.S. Census in 1970 with a permanent population of 108 persons.in Sunset Beach. In 1980, however, -the U. S. Census showed a year- round population of 304 persons. The Town has subsequently disagreed with this total on the basis that some residents outside of the Town's jurisdiction gave Sunset Beach as their mailing address during the 1980 U.S. Census.. The actual 1980 count.is thought to have been substantially less. The Town feels the same about the 1985 year-round estimate provided by the State of North. Carolina, which reports 415 permanent residents. Therefore, in K Oi order to establish a "base" 1985 population figure, the Town came up with its own estimate. The Town's estimate is based on analyzing and comparing the addresses of water system customers; i.e., if the billing address and permanent address are both in the Town, then it was assumed that the household was year-round. Secondly, the total year-round customer households counted (82) were multiplied times the average household size (2.0), to derive a total of 164. Thirdly, a 10% potential error factor was added to arrive at a base population estimate of 180 permanent residents. The U.S. Census 1980 official figure of 304 permanent resi- dents in Sunset Beach would represent an increase of 196 persons (180% increase) over the 1970 U.S. Census. However, the Town's estimate for 1985 (based upon an actual count of water service customers) of 180 still represents a significant increase since 1970 (67%). Population growth at Sunset Beach is somewhat consistent with the strong overall growth trends in Brunswick County, which grew by 47.71 between 1970 and 1980. From 1980 to 1984, according to State Office of Budget and Management estimates, permanent resi- dents in Brunswick County grew by 27.5% during the brief four-year period. Most of this growth occurred in the beach areas and in the mainland areas adjacent to the Intracoastal Waterway. For planning purposes, the 1985 population estimate provided by the Town, i.e., based on water customers, will be considered the "base population-" for Sunset Beach. Again, it should be noted that this is based on water service customers within the Town limits only and not those in the extraterritorial jurisdiction. This estimated total consisted of 99 residents on the mainland, and 81 on the barrier island portion of the Town. Without considering the final U.S. Census counts for the Sunset Beach jurisdiction, the 1980 Sunset Beach Land Use Plan reported the 1980 base population for the Town's jurisdiction to be 140. Notice Table 1 below: Table 1: Sunset Beach Year -Round Population: 1985 Estimate: Year Population No. Change % Change 1980 140* --- 1985 180 40 28.6% Source: 1980 Land Use Plan Update; Town of Sunset Beach *Town's estimate. Comparing the base population estimate contained in the 1980 Land Use Plan to current estimates, the Town's population grew by a total of 28.6% over the five-year period, which is an annual average growth rate of 5.7%. This is a net numerical gain of 40 more persons projected within the corporate limits, not counting residents in the extraterritorial jurisdiction. As the island community continues its growth as a family summer resort, as well as golfing resort, it is likely that more and more people will want to "come to the beach" to stay, and thereby increase the Town's year-round population. The year-round corporate population could also be easily increased through annexation, since there are several developing areas within the Town's extraterritorial jurisdiction which could be annexed. Sunset Beach and Ocean Isle Beach are both located in Brunswick County's Shallotte Township, which is projected by the County Planning Department to be the fastest growing of all the six Townships in the County. Notice Table 2 below: Table 2: Brunswick County -Township Population Projections Change 1985-95 1985* 1990 1995 Number % Lockwood Folly Northwest 10,415 7,735 13,470 9,335 16,525 10,930 6,110 3,195 58.7% 41.3% Shallotte 10,356 14,160 17,970 7,614 73.5% Smithville 8,625 10,410 12,200 3,575 41.4% Town Creek 8,946 11,015 13,080 4,134 46.2% {� Waccamaw 2,452 2,880 3,310 858 35.0% TOTALS* 48,529 61,270 74,015 25,486 52.5% *Brunswick County Planning Department Estimate Source: Brunswick County Planning Department. Over the next 10 years, Brunswick County's population is pro- jected to increase by more than 50%, with growth in the Shallotte Township comprising almost one-third of that increase. From 1985 to 1995, the Shallotte Township is projected to grow by nearly 74%, or an average of 7.4% per year. However, the Town of Sunset Beach, as depicted in Table 1, page 3, experienced a growth in permanent population from 1980 to 1985 at the rate of 5.7% per year, a little less than the growth rate of the Township overall. If Sunset Beach continues its current rate of growth over the next five years in the year-round population, then by 1990 the year- round corporate residents will total 237 persons. Notice Table 3; next page. From 1990 to 1995, however, because of a growing number of newly platted subdivisions, and additional planned golf courses, it is likely that the rate of population growth will increase. For 4 14 {� projection purposes, it will be assumed that the growth rate from L11 1990 to 1991 will equal 6%, with an additional 1% growth rate each year, up.to 10% per year by 1995. Table 3: Sunset Beach'Population Projections 1990-1995: Projection Year Estimated Year- Round Population Number Increase Number % �+ 1985 180 1990 237 57 31.7% R 1995 348 111 46.8% Source: Projections by Talbert, Cox and Associates, Inc. By 1995, the year-round population at Sunset Beach could be 93% higher than the 1985 estimate, with a total increase of 168 additional permanent residents.- Current -subdivision --platting and building permit trends appear to support the projected growth trend. This growth will have some impact upon the Town's provi- sion of services. However, these specific impacts will be addressed in later sections of this plan. Also, the year-round population in the extraterritorial area is an important.factor to be considered. Based on surveys recently conducted by the Planning Board, there are 198 dwelling units in the area contain- ing permanent residents. At the average household size of 2.0 persons, this equals 396 persons. b.. Seasonal Populations The year-round population for resort communities is just one component -of the total population, especially in terms of impacts upon local facilities and services. The "seasonal" population, i.e., those persons drawn to the area during the summer months is perhaps more significant. This is especially true in Sunset Beach, where year-round residents actually live in a very small percentage of the total units; this is also true for the extra- territorial area. In Sunset Beach the seasonal population con- sists of summer residents and "weekenders" (i.e., persons who have permanent addresses elsewhere, but who own residences in Sunset Beach in which they spend all or part of the summer months); cot- tage and motel unit renters, and day visitors. Each of these sub -components will be discussed below: (1) Summer Residents and Weekenders As in many beach or other tourist locations, some property owners take up residence only during the summer months, or just on weekends. It is difficult to estimate the number of residential units used for such purposes. However, when the estimated total !l number of units utilized by year-round residents is known, the u fl number of units used for seasonal, weekend, or short-term rental purposes can be projected. To begin with, notice Table 4, below: Table 4: Estimated Residential Units Within the Sunset Beach Town Limits, 1985: Unit Tvpe Single -Family Duplex Multi -Family Motel Units Mobile Homes Island (Beach) Mainland 706 80 32 -- 34 -- 11 -- Total Units 786 32 34 11 �J 783 80 863 Source: Sunset Beach Town Hall, Administrator's Office Based on an analysis of the addresses of water service custom- ers and assuming a 10% adjustment factor, it is estimated that 90 households (49 on the mainland and 41 on the beach) reside in the Town limits year-round. Also, contacts with the two real estate rental agencies in the Town provided an indication of the number of units used for short-term or "cottage" rentals. (Note: Although all rental units are not rented through these two agen- cies, the majority are. It is acknowledged, therefore, that some rental units are handled directly by the owners, but are not reflected as such in the following estimates.) Notice Table 5, below: 1� 0111 G Table 5: Unit Utilization by Type and Population Projection: 1985 Avg. Peak Main- Occu- Popu- % ** land Island Total pancy lation Total Popula- Total Units 80 783 863 -- -- tion - Year -Round 49 41 90 2.0 180 3.50 - "Cottage" Rentals 2 524 526 8.0 41208 81.90 - Summer Owners/ 29 207 236 3.0 708 13.80 Weekenders - Motel Units -- 11 11 4.0 44 .85 TOTAL 80 783 863 5,140 100.00 Source: Town Administrator's Office; Calculations by Talbert, Cox & Associates *Assuming maximum occupancy, this would be the peak number of "residents" in the Sunset Beach Town Limits **Not including extraterritorial area. The overwhelming majority of residential structures within the Sunset Beach Town limits are located on the island or "beach" portion of the Town, as opposed to the mainland. However, more year-round residents live on the mainland than on the island, as r� is shown in Table 5, above. At maximum projected occupancy for 1985, 5,140 persons could be "residents" within the Sunset Beach Town limits (not including those in the extraterritorial jurisdic- tion). In the extraterritorial area, surveys conducted by the Planning Board showed an estimated 377 dwellings as being used for "seasonal" residences. These units are mostly mobile homes or conventional single-family dwellings. Assuming the Town's average household size of 2.0 persons, an additional 744 residents could be in the greater Sunset Beach area during peak seasonal occu- pancy. There appears to be a substantial number of "summer -owner" and "weekender" units in Sunset Beach. It is also possible that when these weekend or summer -owner units are not being used by their owners, they also might be rented out as "cottages" and thereby may be more or less continuously occupied. Notice that i� there is only one conventional "motel" in Sunset Beach with only •!.� 11 room units. In summary, when all of the cottage rentals, sum- mer and weekend units, and the one motel are completely occupied, an additional 4,960 persons could be added to the Town's small year-round population. The next consideration in the Town's popu- lation picture is the number of "day visitors," i.e., residents from nearby inland areas who come to spend a "day at the beach," usually on weekends. 0 fi (2) Day Visitors The typical peak day for day visitors is a Saturday during the summer --especially if it is a holiday weekend. Although it is very difficult to count all such visitors, an analysis of annual Average Daily Traffic (ADT) rates provided by the State Department of Transportation, provides some indication. The most recent traffic count data for Sunset Beach were obtained from a report by the State Division of Highways, Planning and Research Branch, 111985 Summary of the Traffic Count at Drawbridges." This report contained both average weekday and annual average traffic volumes taken at the Sunset Beach bridge across the Intracoastal Waterway. Notice Table 6, below: Table 6: Average Daily Traffic Volumes, 1985: Sunset Beach Bridge . G Local I Out of I Other I Pass. State Comm. Total Average Weekday Volumes 913 355 542 1,810 Annual Average Daily Volume 1,141 405 554 2,100 Source: N.C. Division of Highways, Planning & Research Branch The annual ADT count, which provides a better basis for peak seasonal projections, was 959 vehicles per day, excluding local passenger traffic. However, DOT officials stated that for season- al areas, a "safe" projection of a 25% increase during the summer is reasonable. Therefore, the summer daily traffic volume at the bridge (again excluding local "resident" traffic) could be 1,199 vehicle trips per day. These 1,199 trips to Sunset Beach presum- ably do not include those made by persons already on the beach, i.e., year-round residents and cottage and motel unit renters. Therefore, it will be assumed that all 1,199 vehicles carry "day visitors." Again, it will be assumed that at any given point in time, 50% of these vehicles are -actually on the beach, i.e., 599. Town officials estimate that each such vehicle, on the aver- age, contains about four occupants. The total number of day visitors on a "peak" day, therefore, is projected to be 4 x 599, or 2,396 persons. c. Population Summary Table 7, below, presents a summary of the various components of the "peak" seasonal population of Sunset Beach in 1985. 11 G Table 7: Sunset Beach Area Population Summary, 1985 { Corporate Extra-Terri- 11�1 Component Limits torial Area Year -Round Residents 180 396 { Summer Residents/Weekenders 708 744 j� Cottage and Motel Renters 4,252 Subtotal "Resident" Population 5,140 1,140 Day Visitors 2,396 -- Total Peak .-7.1536 *8,676 Source: Estimates and projections based on information provided by Town officials; and N.C.D.O.T. Planning and Research Branch *Total- peak for extended area, including extraterritorial It is important to note that the 1980 Plan Update reported an estimated seasonal peak population of up to 7,500 persons for the area. The current area -wide seasonal peak, therefore, represents an increase of almost 16% more than the level reported in the previous Plan, indicating a.growth rate of approximately 3.0% per year. The composition of the population in,terms of age consists mostly of middle -age adults and retirees, which is significant -for planning purposes. The number of school-age.children residing within the Town is very small, estimated by the Town during its last hurricane evacuation to be 14. As the population increases and if more younger families choose to permanently locate in Sunset Beach, the number of school -age children would increase. Sunset Beach's permanent population does contain a few persons from racial minority groups. However, since the 1980 Census fig- ures are not considered reliable, the number of minorities will not be discussed. As the overall population continues to grow, it is feasible that it will also include members of minority groups. 2. Economy The economy of Sunset Beach has changed little since the 1980 Plan. It is still dependent upon real estate development, tour- ism, and travel. Sunset Beach lies just west of two other Brunswick County beach communities, Ocean Isle Beach and Holden Beach, and borders the Intracoastal Waterway. The Town features white, powdered sand beaches, a gentle surf, quietude, and pri- vacy. These attractions, as well as the opportunity for surf and pier fishing, offer relaxing vacations to thousands of visitors 0 9 during the summer months each year. Of increasing importance to the local tourist economy is golfing. There are currently two championship courses in the Town's jurisdiction (both are partly located within the corporate limits and partly within the extra- territorial jurisdiction). Sunset Beach's economic base consists mainly of services, such as a motel, cottage rentals, restaurants, gifts and specialty shops, and privately -owned recreational facilities, such as two golf courses partly located within the Town and in the extraterritorial area. All of these services are generally geared toward the traveling and vacationing public and, as such, are dependent upon the seasonal flow of visitors for their financial sustenance. The seasonal population influx also produces what is, by and large, a seasonal economy. Most of the businesses in the Town do not remain open all year-round. Obviously, some stores, shops, and service stations must remain open to serve the small year-round population and occasional off-season visitors. There is no commercial agricultural or farming activity in the Town; neither are there any manufacturing or industrial interests in Sunset Beach. Real estate development and sales are still the most significant factor in the resort community's economy, and since 1980, two more -real estate offices have opened in the Town. The significance of the real estate growth is illustrated by the fact that the 1980 Plan reported the total residential units to be only 455, as opposed to 863 in 1985. The continuing real estate development and sales in the Town will most likely foster a continual growth in the number of perm- anent residents. As permanent residents increase, the demand for local services also increases. As local commercial services and activities increase, the Town may witness even more expansion of its economic base. Another indication of the significant and continuing growth trend of the Town's economy is the growth in property valuations in recent years. Notice Table 8, below: EU; E' Table 8: Sunset Beach Assessed Valuations, 1981-85 0 a [I I El E C Year 1981 1982 1983 1984 1985 *1986 Assessed Valuation 32,984,286 33,750,000 36,911,668 40,500,000 45,000,000 121,000,000 Source: Town of Sunset Beach, Administrator's Office *Projected; year of re -valuation. % Change 2.32 9.37 9.72 11.10 As real estate development and population increase, the total assessed valuation will also increase, providing part of the needed local government revenues. 3. Impact of Seasonal Population: Since 1980, the seasonal peak population has increased from 7,500 to about 8,700 people. Naturally, there has been some impact upon the Town. The most significant impacts are upon the Town's economy and community facilities, such as parking, water, solid waste, and sewage disposal. Significantly increased traffic is also one of the impacts of the seasonal populations. The increase in summer -residents causes the Town's solid waste collec- tion service to increase from twice per week to four times per week. And, since Sunset Beach is considered a quiet family beach, increase in noise is also one of.the impacts of seasonal popula- tions. However, since the 1980 Plan, Sunset Beach has taken a significant step to deal with seasonal water demands. Sunset Beach, like several other smaller communities in Brunswick County, has become connected to the Brunswick County water system and is served exclusively by this system. During periods of high peak demand, however, the Town's wells are activated temporarily. Eventually, even during peak demand periods, the Town will receive all of its water from Brunswick County. Being an ecologically sensitive barrier island, with limiting soil types, disposal of effluent has always been a concern at Sunset Beach, and the Town has never developed a central sewer system. Sewage disposal is still "on -site," through septic tanks which must be approved by the County health department. 4. Existing Land Use Analysis a. Current Conditions The overall land use pattern in Sunset Beach has changed little since the preparation of the 1980 Land Use Plan Update. Within the Town's corporate limits are approximately 1,900 acres of land, water, wetlands, and beaches. Approximately 1,400 acres consist of undevelopable marsh, beaches, and waterways. 11 Nearly all of the developed and/or platted acreage is for residential use. Notice the attached Map 2, which shows the existing 1985 land use patterns. In addition to residential uses, there are some commercial areas, governmental/institutional uses, and recreation uses (golf courses) of land within Sunset Beach and its extraterritorial jurisdiction. Additional discussion on land uses follows: (1) Residential Land Use In the absence of centralized sewer and septic tank limita- tions in some areas for high -density uses, most of the residential land uses in Sunset Beach consist of single-family dwellings. There are, however, some duplexes and higher density multi -family units being developed in the Town. Notice Table 9, below, which summarizes the residential land use on both the mainland and island portions of the Town, as well as the extraterritorial jurisdiction. Table 9: 1985 Sunset Beach Residential Land Use By TvAe No. Units Extra- Total Unit/Type Island Mainland Total territorial Ping. Area Single Family 706 80 786 208 994 Duplex 32 - 32 16 48 Multi -Family 34 - 34 44 78 Mobile Home - - - 307 307 Total 772 80 852 575 1,427 Currently, as implied above, residential density is limited by the absence of centralized sewer. However, the low -density resi- dential character of the area is likely very attractive to resid- ents and visitors alike. It should be noted that a major CAMA development permit for the Town, Permit No. 36, issued December 28, 1978, has affected the density of development on the ocean front. Permit 36 restricts the size of single-family dwelling units to no more than four (4) bedrooms, on lots under 15,000 S.F., and which were platted before or by July 22, 1978. For lots over 15,000 S.F., higher density residential developments, such as duplexes, can be developed,. if septic tank permits can be obtained from the Health Department. (See Appendix 1.) Currently, according to the Town's zoning ordinance, mobile home units are allowed only in the extraterritorial area and not within the corporate limits. Multi -family units on the island consist of a condominium complex (converted from a motel), and on the mainland in the extraterritorial area some new units are being constructed. These new multi -family units include "The Colony" and "The Woods" developments. 12 0 (2) Commercial Land Uses Commercial land uses are concentrated in two areas, one each on the mainland and island portions of the Town, including a small shopping plaza on the mainland. Currently about 24 structures are utilized for commercial purposes within the entire planning juris- diction, i.e., 7 on the island, 11 on the mainland, and 6 in the extraterritorial area. This total includes an 11-unit motel on the island portion of the area, stores and shops, and real estate offices. On the mainland, commercial services are located on N.C. 179 and include two restaurants, a grocery store, a grocery store/ seafood store combination, several shops, and real estate offices. On the island area, the motel, a grocery store, small shops, and real estate offices are located on both sides of Sunset Boulevard. (See Map 2, attached.) According to the Town's official zoning Y map, there are substantial areas zoned for commercial activities within the Town's planning area. (3) Governmental/Institutional Both the Town Hall and Fire Department buildings are located on the mainland. A total of four structures are currently utilized for government purposes; i.e., Town Hall, Volunteer -Fire Department -Police Department, Town Garage and the Water Tower. (4) Recreational Land Uses The principal recreation areas, other than the beach front, are two 18-hole golf courses located partly in the Town and in the extraterritorial jurisdiction. However, the two clubhouses for the courses, and the adjacent parking areas, have been annexed into the Town limits upon petition of the owners. (5) Building Permit Trends As discussed above the predominant land use in Sunset Beach is for single-family residential structures. This is also reflected in building permits issued since the 1980 Plan, i.e., from 1981-1985. Notice Table 10, below, for both the Town and the extra -territorial areas: Table 10: Building Permits, 1981-1985 (Town and Extra -territorial) Unit/Type 1981 1982 1983 1984 1985 Total Single Family 49 99 14 104 95 361 Multi Family 4 4 8 Duplex - 4 6 16 6 32 Commercial - - 1 - 1 2 49 103 25 120 106 403 011 13 'L) Building permit density has fluctuated throughout the period, with the last two years, i.e., 1984-85, being quite active. This trend will likely continue. Permit activity has been.the slowest for commercial developments. (6) Existing Land Use Summary As Map 2 (attached) indicates, nearly all of the developable land within Sunset Beach has been subdivided into building lots -- mostly for single-family structures. A considerable portion of the extra -territorial jurisdiction remains to be subdivided. There is still a significant number of undeveloped building lots �! L� in the Town -- especially on the island. Notice Table 11 below. Table 11: Land Development Summary: 1985 Total % Platted Lots Vacant Developed Developed Island 1,577 834 743 47.1 Mainland 292 198 94 32.3 Extra -Territorial 1,413 260 1,153 81.6 Total 3,282 1,292 1,990 60.6 - Source: Sunset Beach Town Hall. ---.- -. As Table 11 shows, there are more undeveloped lots on the �. island or "beach" portion of the Town than n m the mainland o p a in terms of numbers. According to the building permit trends (shown --- in Table 10), the total number of permits issued for the entire area for the five-year period 1981-85 averaged about 80 per year. At this rate, new building permits will slightly outnumber the existing vacant platted lots. However, it should be mentioned again that there are still sizeable tracts of land which -have not yet been subdivided. b. Land Compatibility Problems In the conventional land use planning concept, a land compati- bility problem is generally identified when two or more land use types are adjacent to each other and one is somehow restricted u from expansion because of adverse conditions caused by the other use or uses, thus discouraging additional investment. Currently, there are no such land compatibility problems in Sunset Beach. Sunset Beach is completely connected to the County regional water system and no longer relies on its old system of seven deep wells. Even so, there were never any problems reported with the deep wells and septic tank compatibility. 9 14 0 C. Problems from Unplanned Development Currently, problems from unplanned development relate to the demand of a growing seasonal and year-round population on trans- portation access, via the Bridge, to the island and other commun- ity facilities, such as improved solid waste management, adequate. public parking and public estuarine access. On two notable occa- sions in recent years, the old drawbridge connecting the island to the mainland has been disabled, prompting the Town to request a new bridge. Access to and from the island, from the mainland, will be improved substantially if a new high-rise bridge (similar to the one constructed for Ocean Isle Beach in 1985) across the Intracoastal Waterway were developed. However, the improved access may well mean more cars, more people, and more of the problems related to the items discussed in the above paragraph. Planning for more extensive services is an issue which would have to be addressed by Sunset Beach. d. Areas Likely to Experience Changes in Predominant Land Use The areas within the Town's current jurisdiction likely to experience changes in predominant land use during the planning period are those areas which are presently vacant. As previously mentioned, there are still a substantial number of vacant platted lots 'and sizeable tracts of developable land within Sunset Beach corporate limits and extraterritorial jurisdiction which will likely experience varying degrees of development throughout the planning period. e. Areas of Environmental Concern (AEC): The statutorily defined Areas of Environmental Concern (AECs) in Sunset Beach were generally described in the 1980 Plan, and except for some changes in the "Ocean Hazards" category, remain essentially the same. However, these areas need to be described again for this 1985 Update. The AECs found for the Town of Sunset Beach come under the gstuarine System grouping and the Ocean Hazard Area category. The AECs under the Estuarine System group for Sunset Beach are: (1) Coastal Wetlands, which are defined as any salt marsh or other marsh subject to regular or occasional flooding by tides, including wind tides (whether or not the tide waters reach the marshland areas through natural or artificial water sources), provided this shall not include hurricane or tropical storm tides. Coastal Wetlands also contain certain marsh plant species. The Sunset Beach Coastal Wetlands occur mostly north of the island area between the Intracoastal Waterway. Additional amounts of wetlands are located on the mainland, north of the Intracoastal 15 Waterway. Some of these areas are important because the marsh maintains the high productivity of fish and shellfish and the complex food chains which are typically found in the estuaries. (2) Estuarine Waters are defined as "all the water of the Atlantic Ocean within the boundary of North Carolina and all the water of the bays, sounds, rivers, and tributaries thereto seaward to the dividing line between coastal fishing waters and inland fishing waters" (N.C.G.S. 113A-113(b)(2). The Estuarine waters are very important for a number of reasons, mainly because they serve as the birthplace and nursery areas of many species of fish and shellfish. Estuarine Waters support the valuable commer- cial and sports fisheries of the coastal area which are comprised of estuarine -dependent species such as menhaden, flounder; shrimp, crabs, and oysters. These species must spend all or some part of their life cycle within the Estuarine Waters in order to mature and reproduce. The Estuarine Waters within Sunset Beach's jurisdiction include the Intracoastal Waterway, adjoining creeks, the major inlets on either end of the island (Tubb's Inlet on the east end, and Mad Inlet on the west end), and the finger canals located near the island's center. (3) Public Trust Areas, which are sometimes partially defined as all waters of the Atlantic Ocean and the land there- under from the mean high water mark to the seaward limit of State jurisdiction; all natural bodies of water subject to measurable lunar tides and lands thereunder to the mean high mark; all navi- gable natural bodies of water and land thereunder to the mean high water level or mean water level, as the case may be. Public Trust Areas are used for both commercial and recreational purposes. Current regulations define that in Sunset Beach the Intracoastal Waterway, Tubbs Inlet, Mad Inlet, Ocean Beaches, and the Atlantic Ocean adjacent to the beaches are all Public Trust AECs. Adjacent creeks and man-made canals may also be Public Trust AECs. These areas support recreational uses such as swimming, boating, water skiing and sportsfishing and commercial fishing. (4) Estuarine Shorelines are defined as non -ocean, shorelines which are especially vulnerable to erosion, flooding, or other adverse effects of wind and water and are intimately connected to the estuary. This area extends from the mean high water level or normal water level along the estuaries, sounds, bays and brackish waters for a distance of 75 feet inland.. These areas are significant because development within the shorelines can influence the quality of estuarine life and can be subject to the damaging process of shorefront erosion and flooding. The shorelines of the Estuarine Waters described on this page and 75 feet landward are the Estuarine Shorelines in Sunset Beach. On the mainland, this includes the area north of the Intracoastal Waterway and south of the Calabash River. Areas of Environmental Concern within the Ocean Hazards Areas category are those areas considered to be natural hazard areas 16 along the Atlantic Ocean shoreline where, because of their special vulnerability to erosion or adverse effects of sand, wind and water, uncontrolled or incompatible development could be hazard- ous. Ocean hazard areas include beaches, frontal dunes, inlet lands, and other areas in which geologic, vegetative and soil conditions indicate a substantial possibility of excessive erosion or flood damage. The three major Ocean Hazard Areas are described below: a) Ocean Erodible Area: This is the area of which there exists a substantial possibility of excessive erosion and significant shoreline fluctuation. The seaward boundary of this area is the mean low waterline. The landward extent of this area is basically 60 feet. However, in November, 1984, a CAMA rule change resulted in the setback being doubled in size to 120 feet for "large structures." The "basic" setback requirements in the Ocean Hazards AECs for single-family or small structures must be doubled for any structure that has either a 5,000 S.F. or greater foundation for commercial buildings, or consists of more than four (4) units per residential foundation. These rule changes are applicable in the Ocean Erodible Area. Generally, however, the basic Ocean Erodible Area is determined as follows: ° a distance landward from the first line of stable natural vegetation to the recession line that would be established by multiplying the long-term annual erosion rate, as most recently determined by the Coastal Resources Commission, times 60, provided that where there has been no long=term erosion or the rate is less than two feet per year, this distance shall be set at 120 feet landward from the first line. -of stable natural vegetation; and ° a distance landward from the established recession line to the recession line that would be generated by a storm having a one percent change or being equalled or exceeded in any given year -[determined to be 320 feet in Sunset Beach]. The total Ocean Erodible Area for Sunset Beach, based on the above definition, would extend to 440 feet. For setback purposes, the rate of erosion has been set at two feet per year. In actuality, Sunset Beach has experienced significant accretion, especially on the East end. Because of this accretion, the Town's ordinances restrict development to no further than 125 feet seaward of the property lot lines which abut Main Street. b) High Hazard Flood Area: This is the area subject to high velocity waters (including, but not limited to, hurricane wave wash) in a storm having a one percent chance of being equalled or exceeded in any given year, as identified as W" zone on the flood insurance rate maps of the Federal Emergency Management Administration. The 100-year flood elevation level for Sunset Beach ranges from 13 feet above mean sea level in the "A" 17 zones, and up to 16 feet in the "V" zones. The area with the greatest flood hazard potential extends along the ocean beach. The Town does participate -in the "regular phase" of the Federal Flood Insurance Program and has "final" maps dated December 18, 1985. (See "Composite Hazards" map, attached). c) Inlet Hazard Area: The Inlet Hazard Areas are those lands identified by the State geologist to have a substan- tial possibility of excessive erosion that are located adjacent to inlets. This area extends landward from the mean low waterline to a distance sufficient to encompass the area within which the inlet will migrate, based on statistical analysis. Such factors as previous inlet territory, structurally weak areas near the inlet (such as an unusually narrow barrier island, an unusually long channel feeding the inlet, or an overwash area), as well as exter- nal influences such as jetties and channelization, shall also be considered. - Sunset Beach has two Inlet Hazard Areas, one located near the eastern and one near the western ends of the island. In both areas, however, (Mad Inlet on the West, and Tubbs Inlet on the East), significant accretion has taken place -and no severe erosion has occurred in recent years. In addition to the Ocean Erodible, Flood Hazard, and Inlet Hazard Areas, significant land forms such as ocean beaches and frontal dunes are also considered to be ocean hazards. Ocean beaches, which consists of the land area between the mean low waterline and the first line of vegetation, or where a significant change in elevation or slope alters the configuration of the land form, whichever is farther landward, occur all along Sunset Beach's southern border. There are also primary dunes within the Town's jurisdiction. However, because of height definitions, these would have to be determined on a case by case basis. All development and development -related activity within the designated AEC's within Sunset Beach, is currently regulated by the Coastal Area Management Act permit process. 5. Current Plans, Policies, and Regulations a. Transportation The most significant feature of Sunset Beach's most recent Thoroughfare Plan is the proposed construction of a new high-rise bridge across the Intracoastal Waterway. However, the bridge is not projected for completion until 1991. When it is constructed, accessibiltiy to the Island will be greatly improved. Other ele- ments of the Thoroughfare Plan, if implemented, could improve traffic flow within the Town itself. 18 C Although there are no official policies on pedestrian traffic, 1.� the Town has discussed the idea of constructing sidewalks within areas which experience heavy pedestrian traffic during the tourist season for reasons of safety. b. Community Facilities (1) Water Distribution Plan: Sunset Beach, like sev- eral other smaller communities in Brunswick County, have recently become part of the Brunswick County Water System. The Town's (T former water system consisted of seven wells (one of which was dysfunctional), a treatment plant and distribution lines. How- ever, the Brunswick County system bought out the wells, making them part of the regional system. The wells are currently used only to meet peak demands during the height of the tourist season. Otherwise, during the off season, the wells are not utilized at all. It is the Town's Policy that developers share part of the cost of extending water service into new areas. (2) Waste Treatment Plants: Sunset Beach was included in a 1978 201 Facilities Plan for southwest Brunswick County. This plan, which showed a proposed waste treatment plant using land application methods, has not been implemented for Sunset Beach. During 1985, meetings between the Town, area developers, and businessmen were held to discuss the feasibility of providing centralized sewer service to the area between Sunset Beach, Ocean Isle Beach, and Calabash. The Lower Cape Fear Water and Sewer Authority acted as lead agency in these discussions. Although a feasibility study was prepared and presented by a consulting engineering firm, no action has been taken. Sunset Beach still relies on ground absorption systems, for all sewage disposal as permitted by. the Brunswick County Health Department. c. Utilities Extension Policy The Town's policy concerning extending waterlines to newly developed areas is for the developer to pay all of the costs of extension and installation. After construction, all the lines become the Town's property. d. Recreation Policy The beaches provide most of the area's recreational opportuni- ties, and public beach access is also provided at 33 locations along the strand. Although the Town does not currently have a formal recreation policy, a committee has been appointed to discuss recreation needs and policies. Currently, the Town does not have parks or similar public recreational facilities. 19 e. Prior Land Use Plans 0 The Town of Sunset Beach had its first CAMA Land Use Plan prepared in 1976, with the first required update being done in 1980. Both of these previous plans contained description of the Town and general development policies. f. Regulations and Enforcement Provisions (1) CAMA Permits: Because of Sunset Beach's location and geographic features, most of the new development is regulated by the CAMA permit process. The Town has both a Building Inspec- tor and a CAMA Local Permit Officer. The Areas of Environmental Concern which were described in the preceding section are areas which need protection. Enforcement of the CAMA permit process is a major means of that protection. (2) Zoning Ordinance and Zoning Map: The Sunset Beach Zoning Ordinance is the major tool for regulating the use of land within the Town's corporate limits and the one mile extra- territorial area. The zoning districts are shown on map 3, Appendix 2, and are defined as follows: MR-1 Mainland residential District. Exclusively for single- family residences, and with provisions for customary and secondary uses. MR-2 Mainland Residential District. Exclusively for single- family residences, and with provisions for customary and secondary uses. MR-3 Mainland Residential District. Primarily for multi -family and single-family residential development, and with provi- sions for customary and secondary uses. MB-1 Mainland Business District. Primarily for the conduct of retail trade with provisions for retail service -type estab- lishments, and with provisions for residential uses and convenience -type retail trade establishments. BR-1 Beach Residential District. Primarily for single-family residential uses with provisions for beach cottages. BR-2 Beach Residential District. Primarily for single-family residential uses with provisions for beach cottages. 20 c BB-1 Beach Business District. Primarily for general business use, and with provisions for residential uses and convenience -type trade establishments. MH-1 Mobile Home/Conventional Home Residential. Primarily for mobile home single-family residential use with provisions for single-family, conventional houses. AF-1 Agricultural -Forestry. Primarily for production of agricul- tural, and forestry products with provisions for single-. family homes. RI-1 Recreational -Institutional. Primarily for use as schools, churches, playgrounds, parks, and other like uses. Notice that there are slightly different provisions which apply to the mainland and beach portions of the Town. On the beach, although single-family dwellings are emphasized, multi- family dwellings are allowed in all districts. The Town Administrator is also the Zoning Officer. In conjunction with the Zoning Ordinance, the Town also has both a Planning Board and a Board of Adjustment. Supplementary enforcement provisions in the ordinance include ocean set -back lines, dune protection, and a prohibition against the location of mobile homes within the corporate limits. Mobile homes are allowed in the extraterritori- al areas, however. (3) Subdivision Regulations: The Town of Sunset Beach also enforces a set of subdivision regulations, which have been utilized to guide the general design of newly developing areas within the Town's jurisdiction. The ordinance states five major purposes of these regulations: (a) To provide for economical and sufficient streets with adequate widths and with proper alignment and grade; j ( ( b ) To provide space for safe and sanitary �j dwelling accommodations within the corporate limits of the town; (c) To provide for suitable residential neighbor- hoods with adequate streets and utilities and appropriate building sites; (d) To save unnecessary expenditure of public funds by studying space and recommending from time to time the purchase of such space for public lands and buildings and by ini- tial proper construction of streets and utilities; and 0 21 (e) To provide proper land records for the con- n venience of the public and for better identification and permanent location of real estate boundaries. In addition to a standard plat review procedure prior to the approval of any "regular" subdivision, the regulations also con- tain a rather detailed set of procedures for approval of "Planned Residential Developments", or PRD. Notice the following excerpt from the Subdivision Regulations: Through PRD the town can allow development of land that has a higher degree of consideration of physical features and natural constraints to development than would be possible under general zoning or subdivision regulations. PRD is expected to promote a more efficient.use of the land, a higher level of amenities, and more creative designs than would otherwise be possible. In each case the overall density of dwelling units shall be less than that permitted by the applicable zoning requirements. (Ord. 82.1.12-4, passed 1-12-82) The PRD is a specially permitted use in the MR-1, MR-2, and BR-2 Zoning districts and has provisions for open spaces, tree cover, recreational areas, scenic vistas, and mixed residential uses such as cluster homes and townhouses. (4) Dune Protection: Sunset Beach does have specific ordinances for protecting dunes in the Building Code and general provisions of the Traffic Code. However, there are no ordinances governing pedestrian traffic through the dunes to the beach. (5) Septic Tank Regulation: Sunset Beach is served by ground absorption waste disposal systems that are permitted by the Brunswick County Health Department. Any system generating more than 3,000 gallons of waste water per day is designed by engineers and submitted to the North Carolina Department of Human Resources for approval. Building permits are not issued until a septic tank permit or an approved site plan is presented. A final inspection is not given, nor a certificate of occupancy completed, until an inspection slip from the Health Department is in the town file indicating that the system was installed as permitted.. (6) Flood Damage Prevention Ordinance: Sunset Beach adopted a Flood Damage and Prevention Ordinance and began partici- pation in the emergency phase of the Federal Flood Insurance Pro- gram in 1974. However, in 1985, with the publishing of final Flood Insurance Rate*Maps by the Federal Emergency Management Administration, the Town entered the regular phase of the program. First floor building elevation requirements vary in the Town, ranging from 13 feet in the "A" zones to 16 feet in the "V" zones, including wave height calculations. The Flood Ordinance is 0 0 n �I I Ell W11 0 0 I C 22 C enforced as part of the Town's building permit program. The Building Inspector is also the enforcement officer. f. Federal and State Regulations In addition to the local ordinances and County regulations listed and described above, there are various State and Federal regulations which could also affect land devleopment in Sunset Beach. C. CONSTRAINTS: LAND SUITABILITY As noted in the discussion of Existing Land Uses, there is a considerable amount of undeveloped land in Sunset Beach's extra- territorial area which might have future development potential. However, the Town recognizes the importance of being aware of existing physical limitations to development. Physical limita- tions are important to recognize, both from the standpoint of guiding land use decisions and in protecting the health, safety, and welfare of the general public. Below is a discussion of the jj physical limitations to development in Sunset Beach. 1. Physical Limitations: The old waterway bridge, which can be a hazard to navigation, is the only man-made hazard within the current jurisdiction of the Town: Natural hazard areas in Sunset Beach are basically the same as the AEC's described and discussed under Ocean Hazard Areas, and include the Ocean Erodible Area, Flood Hazard Area (see Map 3, attached,,"Composite Hazards," which shows the 100-year flood area), Inlet Hazard Area, Ocean Beaches, Frontal Dunes, and possibly, some Primary Dunes. These areas do (�( present physical limitations to development in Sunset Beach. Although erosion has not been a particular problem on Sunset Beach,_poor surface drainage does cause problems occasionally -- especially of ter unusually heavy rains. In the 1980 Plan Update, it was reported that there were four - different soil types in the Sunset Beach area, only one of which could present problems both for building foundations and septic tank installation. This was according to the Brunswick County Soil S-urvey which was prepared in 1977. However, since that time j� a new Soil Survey has been completed for Brunswick County, and in some cases the soil types have been reclassified. Currently, there are seven soil types instead of four classified as occurring in the Sunset Beach area. The seven types and their general suit- ability for septic tanks and building foundations are listed below: DI U 23 12: Soils Limitations in Sunset Beach Table General SEPTIC TANK STRUCTURAL* SOIL SERIES SUITABILITY FOUNDATIONS Bohicket Severe Severe Corolla Severe Severe Kureb Severe Slight Leon Severe Severe Newham Severe Severe Pactolus Severe Moderate Wando Severe Severe Source: Soil Survey of Brunswick County, N.C., USDA Soil Conservation Service, November, 1986 * Buildings without Basements (� According to Soil interpretation records, all seven types have �J some limitation for septic tank placement, and four have limita- tions for Structural foundations. However, these general declara- tions of limitations do not mean that sites within those areas are absolutely unsuitable. The Soils Survey report points out that individual on -site investigations must be conducted to determine final suitability. A sanitarian with the Brunswick County Health Deparment stated that no general areas in Sunset Beach's jurisdic- tion had presented any severe problems with septic tank placement. However, one area which has more reports of difficulties is a 11, relatively small area between 39th and 40th Streets. Other reports of septic tanks difficulties are isolated, he added. 2. Wellfields Although there are still deep wells in Sunset Beach, the Towns primary source of water is the Brunswick County water system, which generally does not utilize the Town's wells. The wells in Sunset Beach, all of which are located on the mainland, are activated only during periods of peak demands, and pose almost no physical limitations to development. 3. Slopes The only area where the slope may exceed 12 percent are some of the frontal dunes, which are also ocean hazard areas and are protected by CAMA and provisions in local ordinances. 4. Fragile Areas These are areas which could easily be damaged or destroyed by inappropriate or poorly planned development. In Sunset Beach, the fragile areas coincide with the Areas of Environmental Concern. 24 0 C 0 These areas are described in Part B, 4.(e) of this section and are summarized below: Coastal Wetlands: The marsh areas adjacent to the Intracoastal Waterway and between the island area, and some of the land around the finger canals, are considered Coastal Wetlands. ° Estuarine Waters: This includes the Intracoastal Waterway; Tubb's Inlet on the east end of the island; Mad Inlet on the west end; and the finger canals located near the center of the island. ° Public Trust Areas: According to current regulations, the two inlets on either end of the island, the Intra- coastal Waterway, adjoining creeks and possibly man- made canals, ocean beaches, and the ocean adjacent to the beaches and lands thereunder, are the Public Trust Areas of Sunset Beach. ° Estuarine Shorelines: This applies to the shorelines and 75 feet inward from the Estuarine Waters noted above. ° Ocean Beaches: The beach along the Atlantic Ocean, which extends along the entirety of the island's southern border, from the first line of vegetation or significant change in slope toward the ocean. ° Inlet Hazard Areas: The lands identified by the State geologist to have substantial possibility of excessive erosion located adjacent to inlets; Sunset Beach has two such areas, as previously described. Sunset Beach does not contain any of the following fragile areas: complex natural areas; areas that sustain remnant species; areas containing unique geologic formations; registered natural (� landmarks; wooded swamps, prime wildlife habitats; or scenic or LJ prominent high points. However, according to the N.C.. Historic Preservation Office, Sunset Beach's mainland area is considered to be an "Archaeologically Sensitive Area." Also, the State office has recorded 29 archaeologic sites within the Town's planning jurisdiction. 5. Areas with Resource Potential There are no productive or unique agricultural lands within Sunset Beach. The island also does not contain any potentially valuable mineral sites; publicly owned forests, parks, fish, and wildlife gamelands; or non -intensive outdoor recreation lands (besides the two Championship golf courses), or privately -owned �-) wildlife sanctuaries. However, the estuaries near Sunset Beach are considered to be important breeding areas for both finfish and shellfish. Also, the golf courses can be considered an area with resource potential that poses a physical limitation for those particular tracts of land. (� 25 I 0 D. CONSTRAINTS: CAPACITY OF COMMUNITY FACILITIES 1. Existing Water Service Areas The Sunset Beach water service area currently includes all of the Town's corporate limits and portions of the extraterritorial area. Most of the Sea -Trails development on the mainland (in the extraterritorial jurisdiction) is not currently served by the n Town's water system, but by private wells. Again, it should be (� noted that this area is not within the Town's corporate limits. When the Town's system was initiated in January, 1980, it started out with 296 customers. Currently, there are more than 1,100 water customers, including island and mainland portions of the Town, as well as extraterritorial area customers. Since the Town has become a customer of the Brunswick County Water System, the provision of water is no longer a constraint to development. According to the Brunswick County Water Department, 0 the County plans to double its pumping capacity to the Shallotte- Holden Beach -Ocean Isle Beach -Sunset Beach area, within the next five years. 0 It is unlikely that limited water supplies will pose a con- straint to development throughout the period covered by this plan, i.e., 1995. The Brunswick County water system is proposed to 0 eventually make centralized water available to the entire County. Presently, a little less then half of the County is served. The County's current water treatment plant can provide up to seven (7) D million gallons of water per day (MGD), whereas the current usage is only about three (3) MGD. The new water plant near Leland, when complete and operational, will give the County system the daily output potential of 24 MGD. Also, there is no "cap" or limits proposed as to how much water Sunset Beach or other com- munities can purchase from the system. If, by 1995, the daily average per capita water consumption for the "resident" population is 70 gallons per day, and about 13 gallons per day for "day visitors," the peak demand would be about .762 MGD. This should easily be available from the County system. F1 2. Sewer Service Area As discussed previously, Sunset Beach does not have a central- ized sewer system and is currently served by a ground absorption disposal system, i.e., septic tanks. All septic tanks must be approved by and permits granted from the Brunswick County Health Department. Although the most recent soils analysis reports indicate that the general soils classifications in the Sunset Beach area have limitations for septic tank placement, the existing system appears to have worked very well. The County Health Department reported one small area (between 39th and 40th Street) where general problems had been encountered as far as permitting septic tanks. 26 �( C ('1 The EPA, in the 1984 Environmental Impact Statement: North l-� Carolina Barrier Islands Wastewater Management stated that few cases of pollution by on -site systems on the barrier islands had ('4 been documented. It noted problems with a few isolated finger canal areas, but the report did not state how many finger canal areas were given a clean bill of health, or how extensively the movement of effluent into the shallow aquifer and surface waters had been studied. As development of the area continues, and if density increases significantly, the pollution of shallow ground water and surface waters could become a problem. However, devel- opment density is presently controlled by the Town'-s Zoning Ordinance, and by the previously mentioned CAMA permit No. 36, meetings have been held to discuss the possibility of developing centralized sewer service. However, the Town has not pursued this further. It appears that within the bounds of current regulations and restrictions (including Zoning), ground absorption systems may be generally adequate for Sunset Beach during the planning period. 3. Schools The relatively few school -age children who reside in the Town attend the -three schools in Shallotte, which is ten miles away. Two of the three,schools, West Brunswick High School and Union Primary, are currently operating near or over capacity levels. If the number of children in grades K-3 and 9-12 increases signif- icantly in Sunset Beach, then an expansion of school facilities (] may be needed. This is indicated by Table 13, below: Table 13: Enrollment Levels and School Capacity: Shallotte, N.C. 1985-86 Design Percent School Enrollment Capacity Utilization W. Brunswick High (9-12) 933 1,000 93.3 Shallotte Middle (4-8) 1,079 1,200 89.9 Union Primary (K-3) 823 750 109.7 Source: Brunswick County Board of Education However, by and large, Sunset Beach residents consist of middle - age adults and retirees, a trend likely to continue. 4. Transportation The major.traffic arteries in Sunset Beach are N.C. 179, which is the main access road to and from the mainland, including the Intercoastal Waterway bridge, (S.R. 1172, Sunset Boulevard), and Shoreline Drive on the mainland. The other streets in the Town are neighborhood streets. Both N.C. 179 and Shoreline Drive are paved and are maintained by the State Department of Transporta- 27 n tion. The design capacities of these roads, except for the old bridge across the Waterway, are currently estimated to be adequate to handle present traffic volumes. However, the State DOT has plans to construct a modern high-rise bridge across the Waterway beginning in 1991. Unlike the old single -lane bridge, the new bridge will have two lanes and a greatly increased capacity for traffic flow. However, prior to the construction of the new bridge, traffic counts will likely increase in the Sunset Beach (� area. Some other minor improvements currently planned or underway will help somewhat. The addition of a left -turn lane at the intersection of N.C. 179 and Shoreline Drive is one example of such an improvement. To summarize the discussion of Constraints, it should be pointed out that it is difficult to separate the major inhibitors {} of future development in Sunset Beach into categories of "land 11 suitability" and "capacity of facilities." Because of the physio- graphy of the island, the two areas of constraint are closely connected. All of the constraints, however, do form a basis for U discussion of issues leading to the formulation of policy alterna- tives. ry E. ESTIMATED DEMAND 1. Population Trends The demand for housing and other goods and services and the use of public facilities is a direct function of population levels. As Table 5, page 7, indicates, in summarizing the four components of Sunset Beach's population, the total 1985 "resident" population, i.e., year-round residents, summer residents, and cottage and motel renters, is estimated at 5,140 persons in the Town limits and an additional 1,140 in the extraterritorial area, while the "day visitor" population for the same period was esti- mated to be 2,396. The population growth trends and building trends indicate an. overall average annual growth rate for Sunset Beach of 5.7% per year from 1985 to 1990 (which is the estimated growth rate from 1980 to 1985) , followed by a faster rate of growth, i.e., increasing an additional 1% per year from 1990 to 1995, peaking at 10% annual growth by 1995. Assuming that the overall historical growth will continue at the same and projected rates, Table 14, below, shows the projected peak populations for Sunset Beach from 1986 through 1995 within current Town limits. Possible annexations of portions of the extraterritorial areas, of course, could increase these projections. IN If 28 (1 a a aTable 14: Sunset Beach Population Projections: 1986-1995 (� Year * Resident Day Visitors Total Peak �j 1986 5,433 2,533 7,966 1987 5,743 2,677 8,420 1988 6,070 2,830 8,900 1989 6,416 2,990 9,406 1990 6,781 3,161 9,942 1991** 7,188 3,351 10,539 1992 7,691 3,586 11,277 1993 8,306 3,872 12,178 1994 9,054 4,221 13,275 1995 9,952 4,643 14,595 Source: Talbert, Cox & Associates, Architects, Engineers, & Planners *Year-round residents, summer residents, and overnight visitors j� **These projections do not take into consideration the potential increases resulting from completion of the new bridge across the waterway. At the current and projected overall rates of growth by 1995, the "resident," i.e., persons living year-round, plus overnight rentals in.cottages.and motels, could be 9,952 persons, approach- ing double the 1985 level of 5,140. In addition, if "day visi- tors" grow at the same rates, the number will increase from 2,396 in 1985-86.to 4,643 in 1995. These projections, however, do not take into account the amount of developable land in the Town, or the increases likely because of the completion of.the new bridge across the waterway. Nevertheless, if these projections become reality, at periods of "peak" occupancy, e.g., a summer holiday weekend, Sunset Beach could have 14,595 persons in the Town at one time (not counting the current extraterritorial area). Such an increase does have implications for the provision of community facilities and services which need to be considered. These implications are discussed below. 2. Future Land Need Sunset Beach, as noted previously, has considerable amounts of undeveloped, but developable, land remaining, especially in the extraterritorial area. No detailed measures of the "developed" acreage in Sunset Beach were attempted, since building and development are ongoing. However, since the "resident" population is projected to almost double, a glance at the attached "Existing Land Use Map" shows that there are a number of vacant, platted lots, as well as vacant, currently undeveloped land. Because of the rather extensive developable land, even without centralized sewer services, the projected 1995 "resident" density should pose no difficulties from the standpoint of land availability. 29 3. Community Facilities Needs a.. Water With the growth in populations at Sunset Beach --both year- round and seasonal --will come an increased demand for water ser- vices. However, as discussed previously, Sunset Beach, through its connection with the Brunswick County regional water system, will be able to tap a relatively unlimited supply of water to meet peak demands. Currently, the County can pump up to 1 MGD to the Town, with plans to double this to 2 MGD in early 1987; 1985 peak day usage was estimated to be about 250,000.GPD. At an assumed consumption rate of 70 gallons per day for the "resident" popula- tion, and about 13 gallons per day for "day visitors," the highest peak day water demand by 1995 would be .762 million gallons per day. (See Table 14, page 28.) The County -wide water system, which is to be completed prior to 1995, is projected to have a total capacity of 30.0 MGD. The projected peak demand from Sunset Beach in 1995 is estimated to be only 38% of the County's capacity for the Town. Sufficient water supplies should not be a problem during the period covered by this plan. b. Sewer Centralized sewer service is not projected to be available to Sunset - Beach during the planning period; thus, septic tank systems (as permitted by the County Health Department) will continue to be the primary source of sewage disposal. To date, no major diffi- culties have been reported for Sunset Beach. However, during the upcoming planning period, the impact of increasing ground absorp- tion systems should be closely monitored. c. Solid Waste Disposal The Town of Sunset Beach provides its own trash collection and disposal service, utilizing a Town -employed crew and Town -owned equipment. The solid waste is disposed of in the Brunswick County Landfill after being dumped into a compaction unit, which is picked up by Brunswick County. The Brunswick County Landfill is currently projected to last about seven (7) years, i.e., through 1992. It is likely that prior to that time, the County will have developed a new landfill or some other viable solid waste disposal alternative. d. Recreation The oceanfront and adjacent waterways, and increasingly so, golf courses, provide the major recreational opportunities for residents and visitors of Sunset Beach. Although the Town does not have an officially adopted recreation policy, it has appointed a committee to study and report on the recreational needs of the permanent population. Currently, there are no public parks or 30 I other Town -provided recreational facilities. Additional recrea- tional facilities may be needed for the increasing levels of sum- mer residents, i.e., motel and cottage dwellers and "day visi- tors." Improved beach access and public parking facilities are examples of recognized needs. It is believed by the Town that the County, State and Federal agencies should share the responsibility for meeting the needs of day visitors. e. Police Protection {� The Town's police force currently consists of four full-time l.J sworn officers. Also, during the summer seasons, additional traf- fic control officers are employed. This level of police protec- tion appears to have been adequate in the past. However, since steady growth is projected to occur in both the permanent and seasonal populations, additional full-time personnel may be needed. The Town has made an effort to have all applicants for employment qualified as law enforcement officers, and preference is given to those with EMT training and fire training. The long- range program aim is to have public safety officer(s) who can handle fire, rescue, and law enforcement. f. Fire Protection The Town's Volunteer Fire Department, perhaps with the addi- tion of more volunteers, should be adequate for Sunset Beach throughout the planning period. The Sunset Beach Volunteer Fire Department provides fire protection for the Town of Sunset Beach. The department is well equipped and is housed in town on Highway 179. Recently, the area in the Sunset Beach Fire District served by a fire hydrant was upgraded from a 9 rating to a 7 rating largely due to the efforts of the local volunteer fire department, thereby reducing fire insurance rates. However, if development n densities increase, it will be imperative that all access routes +'-}I be well -planned and clear of potential obstructions, e-. g. , on - street parking during peak population periods. g. Emergency Rescue and Safety Emergency medical rescue services are provided to Sunset Beach by rescue squads in Calabash (about 5 miles away) . This -service should be adequate during the planning period. h. Parking Facilities Perhaps the most dramatic impact of the projected influx of day visitors over the next few years relates to public parking. Currently, Sunset Beach does have some, but rather limited, public parking through a lease agreement with a property owner. The estimated 1985 "peak day" parking demand by day visitors of 599 vehicles will nearly double by 1995 to 1,153 vehicles. Unless consideration is given to developing even more public parking facilities, or other alternatives, serious traffic problems (both vehicular and pedestrian) could result. 31 i. Thoroughfare Access The most important thoroughfare access need in Sunset Beach is a replacement bridge across the Intracoastal Waterway. The single -lane bridge is scheduled by the N.C. Department of Trans- portation to be replaced by the early 1990s. The replacement span is to be a high-rise, two-lane modern structure and will greatly improve access from the mainland to the island portion of the Town. The new bridge will have a maximum carrying capacity of 19,100 vehicles per day, which is substantially more than the seasonally adjusted reported traffic volume of 2,625 vehicles per day in 1985. (See Table 6, page 7: 2,100 x 25%.) A proposed project to add a left -turn lane at the intersection of N.C. 179 and Shoreline Drive on the mainland will help alle- viate traffic back-up as vehicles attempt to cross the existing single -lane bridge. There does not appear to be any other sig- nificant internal traffic flow problems --either on the mainland or in the island area. However, an internal traffic flow plan, considering pedestrian and vehicular traffic in the beach area, may need to be developed for the Town, especially with the population projected to increase significantly. j. Administrative Services Currently, most of Sunset Beach's administrative and personnel matters are coordinated by the Town Administrator. As the popula- tions increase, the administrative service load will also increase. The Town may need to consider employing additional personnel. k. Community Appearance Sunset Beach, like other communities in resort settings, appears to have a continual problem of litter and loose trash in various parts of the Town. In spite of regular pick-up of solid waste in containers, loose and unsightly litter can still be found strewn along the beach strand and along neighborhood streets and major access routes as well. Currently, the Town does not have any additional provisions_ for improving community appearance, other than regular trash pick-up (twice weekly curbside). How- ever, there are two property owners associations, which have voluntarily been involved in landscaping and litter pick-up projects. 4. Summary of Trends and Facilities Demand: Policy Issues The following statements are presented in summary of this Section I of the 1985 Land Use Plan Update, analyzing development trends and policy implications for the next 10 years. 32 I ° Both the "resident" and day visitor populations at Sunset Beach have shown increases in recent years and are projected to continue moderately increasing throughout the planning period. ° The resort -tourist based economy of Sunset Beach is strong, contributing to growing tourism revenues in Brunswick County each year. ° Residential and some commercial development in the community will continue. However, it is unlikely that all of the developable land within the Town's current Jurisdiction will be developed during the period. ° At current and projected demand rates, water and solid waste disposal capacities will need to increase during the planning period in order to adequately handle "peak" demands, particularly from day visitors. However, the issue of adequate water supply has been addressed by the Town; sewage service will continue to be handled primarily by ground absorption systems. ° Public safety, i.e., provision of adequate police and fire protection needs, will have -to be continually assessed. Internal traffic, both pedestrian and vehicular, as well as public parking provisions will also have to be addressed. All of the above issues and others, including storm hazard mitigation, and post -disaster recovery, will be addressed in more detail in Section II of this Plan, "Policy Statements." 33 SECTION 11 : Policy Statements SECTION II: POLICY STATEMENTS The formulation of specific policies regarding growth, devel- opment, and management objectives is perhaps the most important part of any land use plan prepared under the State's Coastal Area Management Act. Because of regulatory requirements, these poli- cies must often strike a delicate balance between desires and objectives of the citizens and the local government of Sunset Beach and the objectives of the CAMA program, as overseen by the Coastal Resources Commission. Land development policies, which should be based on an analysis of existing conditions and projec- ted trends, serve -as general guides for effectuating desired development patterns. The land use policies also have important ,►� interface with local regulations, such as the zoning ordinance or subdivision regulations, as well as with State and Federal regula- tions and programs. For example, development permits issued under CAMA must be consistent with the local land use plans. Also, projects supported by State and Federal funds must be consistent with the local land use plans, prior to allowing expenditures. Perhaps it is useful to review the policies contained in the last plan update. An assessment of those policies is shown in Appendix 5. Some relevant trends identified in Section I of this Plan include: the population of Sunset Beach, both resident and -day -- visitors,. -is -constantly increasing; -consistent with overall growth projections for Brunswick County; along with continued growth of residential and commercial development,- additional -demands -will be placed -on public -facilities and services, such as water, sewer, police and fire protection, and parking, as the population increases. However, it should be noted that Sunset Beach has taken steps to address water service by purchasing water from the Brunswick County Regional Water System. Water service should be adequate during the period. These are some of the issues which need to be addressed by the Town during the planning period. The Coastal Resources Commission, recognizing the diversities which exist among the coastal communities, required the Town to specify particular development policies under four rather broad topics in 1981. For the 1985 Update, however, the CRC has added a fifth issue, i.e. "Storm Hazard Mitigation." In most cases, poli- cies developed under these topics will cover most of the local development issues, but in some cases, they do not. In the latter case, the locality has the flexibility to address its own locally defined issues. The five required broad topics are: -- Resource Protection Resource Production.and Management Economic and Community Development -- Continuing Public Participation -- Storm Hazard Mitigation After an analysis of the existing conditions and trends and input from the Town's citizens through surveys and public informa- 34 0 tion meetings, the following policies were developed to provide an (j overall framework for guiding growth and development in Sunset �J Beach throughout the next planning period, i.e., through 1995. A. Resource Protection: Estuarine System. 1. Areas of Environmental Concern: Sunset Beach recognizes the concern of the Coastal Resources Commission, in terms of primary protecting resources, as managing Areas of Environmental Concern (AECs). The Town also shares this concern for the protection and sound management of these environmentally sensitive lands and (� waters. The AECs which occur in Sunset Beach were identified in (j Section I of this Plan on pages 14 through 17, with areas within both the Estuarine System and Ocean Hazards area. In terms of developing policies, the Estuarine System AECs, which include Coastal Wetlands, Estuarine Waters, Estuarine Shorelines, and Public Trust Areas, will be treated as one uniform grouping since they are so closely interrelated. Another reason for grouping these AECs together is the fact that the effective use of maps to detail exact on -ground location of a particular area, sometimes poses serious limitations. n (j Sunset Beach's overall policy and management objective for the Estuarine System is "to give the highest priority to the protec- tion and perpetuate their biological, social, economic, and aes- thetic values and to ensure that development occurring within these AECs is compatible with natural characteristics so as to minimize the likelihood of significant loss of private property (� and public resources." (15 NCAC 7H. 0203) In accordance with {J this overall objective, Sunset Beach will permit those land uses which conform to the general use standards of the North Carolina Administrative Code (15 NCAC 7H) for development within the Estuarine System. Specifically, each of the AECs within the Estuarine System is discussed below. a. Coastal Wetlands Coastal wetlands, which are defined as any salt marsh or other marsh subject to regular or occasional flooding by tides, inclu- 0 ding wind tides (whether or not the tide waters reach the marsh- land areas through natural or artificial water courses), provided this shall not include hurricane or tropical storm tides. Coastal 0 wetlands also contain certain marsh plant species. In Sunset Beach, coastal wetlands occur generally in the areas north of the island portion of the Town and which are adjacent to the Intracoastal Waterway. Also, smaller amounts of coastal wetlands occur on the north side of the Intracoastal Waterway on the main- land. The most substantial amount of wetlands is located to the east and west of the Sunset Beach Bridge, including the marshlands (J adjacent to the Intracoastal Waterway. These areas are important because the marsh maintains the high productivity of fish and shellfish and the complex food chains which are typically found in 35 n U the estuaries. The first priority of uses of land in these areas should consider "conservation" of the sensitive areas, with con- servation meaning the lack of imposition of irreversible damage to the wetlands. Generally, uses which require water access and uses such as utility easements, fishing piers and docks, will be allowed, but must adhere to.use standards of the Coastal Area Management Act (CAMA: 15 NCAC 7H). b. Estuarine Waters and Estuarine Shorelines The importance of the estuarine waters and adjacent estuarine shorelines in Sunset Beach was discussed in Section I of this document on pages 15-16. The Town is very much aware that protec- tion of the estuarine waters and adjacent estuarine shorelines can be important to fishing, both commercially and for recreation, and for the continued maintenance of quality development. Sunset Beach recognizes that certain actions within the estuarine shore- line, which is defined as the area extending 75 feet landward of. the mean high waterline of the estuarine waters, could possibly have a substantial effect upon the quality of these waters. The estuarine waters within Sunset Beach's jurisdiction include the Intracoastal Waterway, the major inlets on either end of the island (Tubb's Inlet on the east end, and Mad Inlet on the west {� end), and the finger canals located near the island's center. The uadjacent shorelines, up to 75 feet inland, are the estuarine shorelines. In order -to promote the quality of the estuarine waters Sunset Beach will -evaluate uses as to compatibility with both the estuarine shorelines and the protection of the estuarine system. Residential, recreational, and commercial uses may be permitted within the estuarine shoreline, after consideration has been given to the following: 1. a substantial chance of pollution occurring from the development does not exist; 2. development does not have a significant adverse impact on estuarine resources; 3. development does not significantly interfere with existing public rights or access to, or use of, navigable waters or public resources. c. Public Trust Areas Sunset Beach recognizes that the public has certain estab- lished rights to certain land and water areas. In Sunset Beach, the Intracoastal Waterway, Tubbs Inlet, Mad Inlet, ocean beaches, (� and the Atlantic Ocean adjacent to the beaches are all Public �f Trust AECs. These areas support recreational uses such as swim- ming, boating, water skiing, and sportsfishing and commercial fishing. These public areas also support tourism, and are of significant aesthetic value. Appropriate uses include those which 36 protect public rights for navigation and recreation. Projects which would directly or indirectly block or impair existing navi- gation channels, increase shoreline erosion, deposit spoils below mean high tide, cause adverse water circulation patterns, violate water quality standards, or cause degradation of shellfish waters, U shall not be allowed. Allowable uses shall be those which do not U cause detriment to the physical, chemical or biological functions of public trust areas. Such uses as navigational channels, drain- age ditches, bulkheads to prevent erosion along the AIWW and inland canals, piers or docks, shall be generally permitted, as long as they conform to State standards. d. Policy Statements: Development in AECs Sections a, b, and c, above, included a brief discussion of Sunset Beach's policy on land uses in the statutorily defined Areas of Environmental Concern (AECs). Protection of environment- ally sensitive as well as vitally important public resources is a strong ongoing concern of the Town of Sunset Beach. The overall D policy of the Town in relation to Resource Protection shall be as follows: Sunset Beach shall continue to give priority to those uses which are compatible with appropriate management of the Estuarine System. It is the intent of the Town to safeguard and perpetuate (� the system's biological, social, economic and aesthetic values and (� to insure that any development occurring within the system is compatible with natural characteristics, so as to minimize the zo likelihood of significant loss of private property and public resources. e. Policy Implementation Q Sunset Beach believes that the existing development permit system enforced by CAMA, the U. S. Army Corps of Engineers, com- bined with enforcement of the Town's Zoning Ordinance, Subdivision Regulations and Dune Maintenance and Protection Plan, represent adequate measures to protect the discussed resources. Enforcement of these provisions will continue. 0 2. Areas of Environmental Concern: Ocean Hazards Areas Ocean Hazards Areas of Environmental Concern are the second broad category of AECs occurring in Sunset Beach. These are areas along the Atlantic Ocean shoreline which have a special vulner- ability to erosion or other adverse effects of sand, wind, and water. Because of this vulnerability, improperly managed growth and development could expose life and property to unreasonable levels of danger. The Ocean Hazards in Sunset Beach, as discussed on Pages 17-18 of this document include: 1) the ocean erodible area; 2) the high hazard flood area; and 3) the inlet hazard area. n 37 0 0 0 aFor both the ocean erodible and inlet hazard areas, develop- ment of any type is prohibited or tightly controlled by existing regulations and enforcement provisions. It is the susceptibility to change from the constant forces of waves, wind, and water upon the sands that form the shore, which may cause these areas to be considered "hazardous." These forces are magnified during storms and can cause significant changes in bordering land forms (such as dunes and beaches), as well as to any structures located on them. It is the flexibility of these land forms (dunes and beaches), however, which also lends protection from the magnified energies of wind and water -as a first line of defense for development located behind them. The important, basic and essential function of the beach and dunes is their capacity for storing sand, serving to absorb and thereby dissipate the initial impact of excessive wind and waves. Thus, it is important to consider policies which are aimed both at protecting the land forms (dunes and beach) and any struc- tures which are allowed to be constructed in those areas. a. Policy Statements: Ocean Hazards Area Generally, all land uses in the areas classified under the "Ocean Hazards" category, i.e. ocean erodible, high hazard flood, and inlet hazard areas, shall be consistent with the requirements of existing State, -Federal,- and -Local regulations,- and the Sunset Beach Zoning Ordinance, Subdivision Regulations, Dune Maintenance ( and Protection Plan, and the Town's requirements for -the National Flood Insurance Program and the Town's building set -back line. (� 1. Allowable land uses shall generally be designed and con (j structed so as to maximize structural protection from wind and water and to minimize damage to the protective land forms of dunes and beaches. 2. Sunset Beach will continue to support comprehensive shore- line management such as the Corps of Engineers beach renourishment projects as a preferred control measure to combat oceanfront ero- sion. Again, it should be noted, however, Sunset Beach has experienced significant accretion instead of erosion. 3. When existing dunes are "added to," this shall be accom- plished in a manner which minimizes damage to existing vegetation. Any areas filled will be replanted immediately or stabilized temporarily until planting can be successfully completed. b. Implementation Sunset Beach will continue to enforce its local regula- tions as cited above, and continue to support the CAMA major and minor permitting, and the Corps of Engineers 404 wetlands permit- ting programs. 0 a38 3. Development in Areas with Constraints The constraints to development in Sunset Beach were discussed in Section I, pages 23-27 of this report. Elements posing con- (� straints to growth and development can relate to physical land (VJ capability constraints such as availability of developable land, man-made or natural hazards, AECs, special fragile areas, or areas with soils limitations. Also, the capacity of community facil- ities and services such as water, sewer, solid waste disposal, police and fire protection and parking can often pose constraints to development. All of these are facilities which need to be (� considered by any community in proposing land development poli- cies. There are no known man-made hazards in Sunset Beach prohibit- ing development and the natural hazards are closely linked to AECs in both the Estuarine System and Ocean Hazards category, as are also the "fragile" areas. Limitations noted were: certain soil types, which were described by the Brunswick County Soil Surveys as having limitations for septic tank suitability, and fragile areas that coincide with the Town's AECs and which were included (� in the preceding policy discussion. The only major limitation in terms of community facilities is the lack of a central sewer system. Since the barrier island comprises a.substantial portion of the Town's jurisdiction, it is not suprising that virtually all of this portion of the Town is located in the 100-year flood zone area, i.e., subject to a one percent chance of major flooding in any given year. Also, as stated previously, the Town has certain "high velocity" or "V-16" flood zones identified on recent Flood Insurance Rate Maps prepared by the Federal Emergency Management Agency (dated December 18, 1985). Both the 100- year flood area and V-Zones pose possible serious constraints to development. However, most of the V-Zones are located along the immediate oceanfront in areas where virtually any type of development is prohibited. But the 100-year flood zones include a significant portion of the Town's jurisdiction and it is not practical to prohibit development in all areas. However, within the extra- territorial jurisdiction, there are substantial amounts of land classified in Zone "C", Minimally Flooded areas, not subject to the 100-year flood. Most of the land area in Zone "C" is platted �J into building lots. As the discussion on pages 28-33 indicated, at current and projected demand rates during "peak" utilization, Sunset Beach may need expanded capacity in the provision of solid waste disposal, police protection, and fire protection services during �} the next 10 years. Also, the need for improved vehicular access, LJ and parking will increase in significance during the planning period because of present limitations on internal roadways. Sunset Beach, was developed primarily as a quiet, relaxing, U 39 I afamily -oriented beach. This appeal attracts thousands of visitors each year. It is vital, therefore, to the Town that this appeal continues to be maintained. at the highest level of quality. In consideration of all of the constraints relating to the physical capacity of the land, and the capacity of community facilities, the following policies are proposed: a. Policy Statements: Physical Constraints to Development 1. Since in many cases, conditions posing physical limitation to o growth and development in Sunset Beach are closely associated with identified areas of environmental.concern or other sensitive areas, the Town believes that these areas should generally be protected from any adverse or potentially adverse development. Also, development in certain areas which could result in unneces- sary risks to the safety and protection of life and property will be seriously evaluated. Specifically: a. Sunset Beach's policies on development in fragile areas are basically the same as those stated for Areas of Environmental Concern. b. Until such time as a central sewage collection and disposal system can be developed, growth and development will not be permitted in areas where septic tanks will not function. All septic -,tanks -must be in compliance with State Health Regulations through the Brunswick County Health Department. c. Development will be discouraged in areas where soils are not suitable for proposed construction. Development may U be constructed if corrective measures for stabilizing building foundations are incorporated into development design. 2. Allowable land uses in areas posing physical constraints should be only those approved through the CAMA and Army Corps of. Engineers "404" permitting processes and by the Town of Sunset Beach's building and development ordinances, including provisions for dune protection contained in local ordinances. 3. All uses allowed in the Town's Zoning Ordinance shall be per- missable in the 100-year flood zones, provided that all new con- struction and substantial improvements comply strictly to the Town's Flood Damage Prevention Ordinance, which has been adopted in conjunction with Sunset Beach's participation in the National Flood Insurance Program. 4. In relation to capacity of community facilities, it shall be the policy of the Town of Sunset Beach to attempt to provide (� services, such as water, police protection and fire protection �j (which is presently being provided by volunteers), solid waste, 40 collection, and traffic accessibility, to meet needs and antici- pated peak demand throughout the planning period. 5. The Planning Board should give close attention to provisions for adequate access and traffic circulation for all new developments. U U b. Policy Implementation (� 1. The existing local ordinances and building regulations in Sunset Beach shall continue to be enforced. Also, the Town will continue to comply with State and Federal regulatory programs for areas with physical constraints to development, including CAMA and the Corps of Engineers 404 program. 2. In FY 1986, the Town will request that the area Traffic Engineer, with the State Department of Transportation, consider the designing and construction of turning lanes at the inter- section of NC 179 and SR 1172 just west of the waterway bridge. Also, a reduction in the speed limit to 25 mph on Main Street will be requested. 3. The Town Planning Board will request technical assistance from the Division of Community Assistance, of the North Carolina Department of Natural Resources and Community Development, to help (� review subdivision plats and major development proposals. 1.J 4. Hurricane and Flood Evacuation�Needs and -Plans D This area will be treated in a separate section of this Land Use Plan; which will include policy statements on hurricane and flood evacuation as well as storm mitigation and post disaster o recovery policies. 5. Protection of Potable Water Supplies Since July 1984, Sunset Beach has been receiving all of its water supply from the Brunswick County water system, and the existing deep wells are no longer the principal source of water for the Town. However, during peak demand periods, the Town's old deep wells are activated by the County system (which owns the wells). But for most of the year, the wells are not utilized, and development near them does not pose any hazards to the wells. 6. Use of Package Treatment Plants ('4 The Town of Sunset Beach has no definite plans for developing �J a centralized sewer system because of the extensive costs. Currently, ground absorption systems are the main means of sewage disposal for the Town. However, the Town does allow package treatment plants which can comply with applicable environmental regulations. (� 41 I a7. Stormwater Runoff The Town of Sunset Beach shares the concern of the State Division of Environmental Management (DEM) that stormwater runoff from urbanized areas may be contributing to declining surface water quality in some areas. Maintenance of water quality is of n concern to Sunset Beach. The Town recognizes the value of water 'UI quality maintenance both in terms of protecting commercial and recreational fishing resources and providing clean water for other recreational purposes. The Town is also very much concerned about j1 the potential adverse effect on water quality from large open -area recreational developments. The Town will continue to enforce local ordinances and state building regulations relating to storm - water runoff resulting from development. 8. Marina and Floating Home Development The development of bulkheads, marinas, and private boatslips in Sunset Beach have generally been allowed and regulated by the Town's Zoning and other development ordinances, as well as CAMA. (� These uses will be continued as long as they are in compliance with State, federal and local regulations. - In recent years, Sunset Beach and other coastal communities have become increasingly concerned over the issue of "floating homes", i.e., waterborne vessels used.not only as "boats" but.as. permanent domiciles. The legal aspects of this issue have been. adebated in many areas. In Sunset Beach, the issue of floating homes has not been a significant problem and the Town has never developed any ordi- nances or regulations regarding floating homes. However, the Town is supportive of the State's policies on "floating structures" and D believes that such structures should not be allowed within Public Trust waters within its jurisdiction. Also, during the planning period, the Town will consider the adoption of local regulations nregarding floating homes. iJ 9. Industrial Impacts of Fragile Areas There are no conventional industrial impacts on fragile areas in Sunset Beach and the Town does not anticipate any industrial development.- 10. Development of Sound and Estuarine System Islands Policies related to managing growth and development in these (� environmentally sensitive areas are included in policy statements �j regarding development in Areas of Environmental Concern and in areas with physical constraints, particularly dealing with "fragile" areas. Sunset Beach's concern for these mostly "marsh" islands is reflected in the proposed Land Classification System (see Section III of this Plan). 42 B. Resource Production and Management 1. Recreational Resources/Fisheries In most coastal counties and towns, "resource production and management" usually relates to agricultural, forestry, mining, fisheries, as well as, recreational resources. In Sunset Beach, however, recreational and fisheries resources are the only rele- vant ones in the conventional sense. In resort settings such as Sunset Beach, because of the abundant water areas (which are also Estuarine and/or Public Trust Waters), recreational and fishery resources quite often overlap. The overall, major recreational resource is the "beach" and the attractiveness of the Atlantic Ocean and, increasingly so, golfing. Fishing, both as a recreational and commercial resource, is important to Sunset Beach and to all of Brunswick County. Proper utilization of water resources is of utmost concern to Sunset Beach. The Town,recog- nizes the value of water quality maintenance both in terms of protecting commercial and recreational fishing resources and pro- viding clean water for other recreational purposes. Recreational opportunities, such as boating, swimming, water skiing, surf boarding, and sports fishing, are not only viable resources for Sunset Beach, but also are important economic attractions for the Town. The seasonally.influenced economy, as noted in Section I of this plan, is dependent, to some extent, upon the continued preservation and maintenance of these resources. Projections for the 10-year planning period indicate growth both in the permanent and seasonal populations of.Sunset Beach. Both the aesthetics and recreational opportunities of the Town are important resources which need to be protected and managed. a. Policy Statements . With the above -stated concerns in mind, the Town of Sunset Beach adopts the following policy: 1. The Town supports current on -going State and federal pro- grams designed to enhance the proper utilization of water resour- ces within its jurisdiction. b. Implementation 1. The Town will continue to enforce local regulations as well as.support State and Federal initiatives, related to main- taining and enhancing proper water use. 2. Off -Road Vehicles It is important to Sunset Beach that the aesthetics of the beach strand be maintained. It is also important to the Town that the integrity of the island's sand dunes be maintained. The in- trusion of off -road vehicles onto the strand and dunes is viewed 43 I Q as being inconsistent with the management objective of maintaining the quality and character of these sensitive areas. In accordance with the general provisions of its Traffic Code, the Town of Sunset Beach does not allow off -road vehicles on dunes or on the shoreline area, with the exception of public service or emergency vehicles. These provisions shall continue to be enforced. C. Economic and Community Development The economic vitality of Sunset Beach, as stated previously, relates directly to tourism and the Town's attraction as a resort and retirement community. Second -home and building lot sales and cottage rentals, which attract thousands of visitors each summer, and to a lesser degree, day visitors from inland communities, are important elements in the island's economy. The land development pattern in Sunset Beach, as shown on the attached Land Use Map, is nearly all residential. Nearly all of the commercial development is located along N.C. 179 and Sunset Boulevard. Although both the permanent and seasonal populations are projected to increase, the overall land development pattern will likely remain the same because of the vacant but platted lots. Eventually, but not within the current planning period, all development,..including.residential, commercial, etc., will be limited in Sunset Beach because of limited availability of land and the absence of centralized sewer. Issues currently before the' Town concern the responsibility for service provisions, avail- ability of support facilities such as water, sewer, parking, beach (� access (vehicles and pedestrians) and economic impacts. U Near the beginning of the 1985 Land Use Plan updating process (February 1985), a questionnaire/survey for a 10% random sample of Sunset Beach property owners was developed with 22 specific questions. Most of these questions related to the Town's community -wide and economic.development. The survey results and pertinent issues will be summarized below, prior to presenting proposed policies and implementation measures. (Also, see Appendix 3.) -- The five most serious problems to face Sunset Beach over the next 10 years, in descending order of importance, are: 1) Planning/Development; 2) lack of sewer service; 3) roads and drainage; 4) bridge access, and 5) parking. -- Most respondents indicated that they would like to see a Qcentralized sewer system provided in the Town. -- Most appeared satisfied with the current Town -provided services. However, notable concern was expressed about street maintenance, planning & zoning, and mosquito control. n 44 U rig -- Most repondents indicated a willingness to pay higher D taxes to increase or improve existing services. -- The majority of respondents did not think public -provided recreation to all ages was an important issue for the Town. When asked what other recreational facilities other than golf courses should be developed in the Town, "Tennis D courts" and "None" received nearly equal responses. -- on improving vehicular traffic, the majority of respondents indicated that enforcement of existing laws and regulations would be adequate. -- Respondents did not look favorably on allowing parking on n Main Street. U -- Single-family dwellings, in a quiet, low -density setting, were overwhelmingly indicated as the preferred urban development type. Respondents indicated a desire to see less commercial, and less multi -family developments. The relevant policy areas to be addressed are discussed below, along with the Town's policy position. 1. Local Commitment to Providing Services to Development As areas develop, it is the policy of the Town that the developer/owner share in the financial responsibility of providing basic urban services. Within this current planning period, the Town will be served by the Brunswick County water system but does not expect to have a central sewer system. -The Town will remain committed -to providing water service to new areas as they develop. Since there is no evidence at this time that the current growth absorption system is problematic, or projected to be during the planning period, and because the citizens of Sunset Beach have expressed a desire to maintain a low -density, single-family environment, the Town will not pursue development of a centralized sewer system at this time. 2. Redevelopment of Developed Areas: Most of Sunset Beach has no need for consideration for rede- velopment. .However, in some sections of the Town, older struc- tures, including houses and motels, have been or may be torn down to allow for the construction of new similar uses -on the same site. In keeping with the dynamic character of the community, Sunset Beach supports such activity as a positive re -use of land resources, enhancing the Town as a whole. Such redevelopment shall be permitted as long as the activity complies with the spirit and intent of existing regulatory requirements. It is the Town's policy that density allowances for redevelopment areas conform to existing Town building and zoning regulations and the Special CAMA Permit No. 36. (See Appendix 1.) 45 0 3. Desired Urban Growth Patterns As it is very important that the atmosphere and character of a quiet, relaxing family beach be maintained, Sunset Beach is not interested in developing any manufacturing industries within the Town. Also, intense commercial developments, beyond that neces- sary to serve tourists, will not be encouraged. Commercial accom- modations and similar residential development are desirable in the Town. Residential development•is regarded as desirable for the a Town, as long as no major or irreversible damage threatens any environmentally sensitive area. Single-family detached dwellings are overwhelmingly the predominant residential -type in Sunset Beach, although recently more.multi-family units have been devel- oped and others are proposed. Currently, no mobile homes are allowed within the Town's limits proper. However, mobile homes are allowed in the extra- territorial jurisdiction and many units are currently located in this area. This is especially true in the Sea Trails area. a It is the Town's intentions, as reflected in its zoning ordinance and zoning map, to allow a mixture of residential -type accommoda- tions in a balanced manner. 11 0 I I 0 Should Sunset Beach choose to annex this portion of its extra- territorial jurisdiction, then both the Zoning Ordinance and Zoning Map may -need to be modified, since then mobile homes would be considered for allowable use within the Town limits. However, a detailed annexation feasibility analysis needs to be done prior to any consideration of annexation. A matter which relates indirectly to urban qrowth patterns, but one.of much concern to Sunset Beach, is community appearance. The Town would like to see some actions taken to encourage more responsive actions on the part of citizens. a. Policy (1) Since it is the desire of Sunset Beach to avoid incompat- ible land uses, the Town will continue to enforce its current ordinances and local building permit program to help achieve a desired balance between commercial and residential development. The Town will also continue to enforce the State CAMA permit process and State Health Regulations regarding septic tank place- ment (until such time as a central sewer system may serve the entire Town). (2) It is the belief of the Town of Sunset Beach that residents of developed areas in the extra -territorial area make substantial use of the Town's facilities; enjoy the benefits of access to the Town's beach front; and share the community's interests, but do not share the responsibility for the support, maintenance, and future orderly development of the Town. It shall be the policy of the Town of Sunset Beach, therefore, that such areas be considered for annexation, if economically feasible. 46 b. Implementation (1) The Town will continue to enforce its current land use regulations to encourage development of the Town primarily as a low density, quiet residential resort area with appropriate and limited supporting retail and tourist -oriented services. (2) In FY 86-87, the Town will seek planning grant assistance from the Division of Coastal Management to prepare an Annexation Feasibility Study for -selected areas in the current extra- territorial jurisdiction. ( 3 ) In FY 87, the Town will seek assistance in developing, and consider adopting, a'Community Appearance ordinance. 4. Commitment to State and Federal Programs Sunset Beach is generally receptive to State and Federal pro- grams, particularly those which either enhance or improve the Town's facilities. The Town will continue to cooperate with such programs, including CAMA. The North Carolina Department of Transportation road and bridge improvement programs are very important to Sunset Beach because of increasing traffic volumes and resultant access problems during peak seasons. The Town looks forward to the construction of a new high-rise bridge in the early 1990s by the N.C. DOT. Examples of other State and Federal programs which are import- ant to and supported by Sunset Beach include: dredging and channel maintenance, as well as beach renourishment and restora- tion (when needed), by the U. S. Army Corps of Engineers; the NRCD Beach Access Program; and Federal and State projects which provide efficient and safe boat access for sports fishing. 5. Assistance to Channel Maintenance and Beach Renourishment Proper maintenance of channels, particularly the Atlantic Intra-Coastal Waterway, is very important to Sunset Beach because of the impact of commercial and recreational fisheries and general boating. Sunset Beach is supportive of the Corps of Engineers' maintenance of the Intracoastal Waterway. Although erosion has not been a problem at Sunset Beach, beach nourishment is still an important concern. The Town recognizes that beach erosion could, at some time, become threatening. Sunset Beach is supportive of beach nourishment projects in the area. Also, in 1985, the Town was directly involved in a local renourishment project which included the planting of American Beach grass and trees to stabilize the dunes. These plantings have helped to maintain the stability of the sands. Assistance for these plantings came from the County Agricultural Extension Office. 47 I I I I I In the future, the Town will continue to encourage local efforts, and if necessary, seek Federal and State assistance in support of beach nourishment projects. 6. Tourism The importance of tourism to Sunset Beach is obvious, as has been discussed in other parts of this plan. The natural resources of the beach along the Atlantic Ocean and inland waterways which continue to attract thousands to this island community each summer as well as newly developing golf courses, are vital generators of income through real estate sales and rentals. The tourist season also provides employment for some Town residents and for some residents of other parts of Brunswick County as well. According to the Travel and Tourism Division, North Carolina Department of Commerce, in 1984, travel and tourism accounted for $98,429,000 in expenditures in Brunswick County compared -to $16.7 million in 1979. Although detailed figures are not available for Sunset Beach, relative to its size, the island community probably gene- rated a respectable percentage of this total. To simply say that tourism is important in Sunset Beach would be a severe understate- ment. Policy alternatives concerning support of tourism are few in an area where it essentially forms the economic base. In fact, all of the other policy statements under Economic and Community Development relate to tourism. Therefore, Sunset Beach will con- tinue to support and promote tourism as its main economic base. The development of non -intensive recreational and commercial land uses will be encouraged in order to enhance services for.the- publ ic. 7. Beach and Waterfront Access, and Parking Relatively free and open access to the ocean front and other waterways is an important consideration for any beach community. This is a fact which Sunset Beach recognized in the initial stages of its development. There are 33 dedicated paths, located at the end of most streets, providing public access to the beach. The seven paths on the easternmost portion of the beach are 5-feet in width and are marked with CAMA beach access signs. The remaining 26 paths are 10 feet in width, and are marked with white posts with the word "Walkway." These paths provide pedestrian access only. Town ordinances prohibit vehicular traffic on the beach. There are also 10 dedicated paths providing public access to estu- arine waters. The three on the western portion of the island are 30 feet wide. They are currently overgrown and not marked. The seven on the eastern end of the island are 5 feet wide and are marked by low yellow concrete markers. Access to other water areas mainly for sports fishing is also open to the public. There is one private pier on the island, which has allowed parking and access for pier fishing and for the beach. Also, the Town leases three (3) tracts of land for free public parking and there is some paid commercial parking in the beach area as well. As the Town continues to grow, the easement access ways may need to be improved in order to provide the dunes protection from pedestrian traffic. Further, this is especially true for the three estuarine access ways on the west end which are currently overgrown. The Town will consider developing and adopting a detailed beach and estuarine access plan. As a general policy, the Town will continue in its attempts to provide adequate access to the public, as well as seek means to provide boat launching facilities on both the mainland and the island. Beginning in FY87, the Town will apply for grant assistance to federal and state agencies, as well as commit some local resources to helping improve both beach access and parking. D. Continuing Public Participation Policies Sunset Beach recognizes that an important element in develop- ing and implementing any local policies or plans regarding the use of land in the Town, is involvement of the Town's citizenry. From the initial stages of development of this 1985 update of the Town's CAMA Land Use Plan, Sunset Beach has sought to provide open opportunities for citizen input. Although public involvement was generated through the Town Planning Board and through "public information" meetings, advertised in local newspapers and open to the general public, the principal vehicle for citizen input was through a survey questionnaire. Beginning in September 1984, the Sunset Beach Planning Board received and developed suggestions on various topics which had been presented before them and ideas related to growth and manage- ment. From these discussions, this questionnaire was generated. This questionnaire was received by the Town Council, and an addi- tional inquiry was added as suggested by one member of that body. Seventy-nine percent responded, and it appeared that the concerns and viewpoints on issues had not significantly changed since the 1980 survey. In February, 1985, a "Property Owner's Participation Question- naire" was mailed, along with a letter of explanation, to 100 randomly selected owners of property in Sunset Beach (See Appendix 3). The questionnaire consisted of 22 questions, addressing issues such as provision of public services (especially sewer), beach access, recreational facilities, and the desired types of urban growth and development patterns. Generally, the response rates were good and the information was useful in developing poli- cies (especially those dealing with economic and community devel- opment, as discussed in the previous section). Three public hearings were held during this Land Use Plan update. Conversations were also held with individuals who came to Town Hall during the planning period to ask questions or to ex- press their concerns. These visits were usually related to issues of continuing growth, such as parking, noise, traffic, garbage, and building heights and sizes. 49 The preliminary draft plan, prior to submission to the CRC, a was presented to the Town Board of Commissioners on December 15, 1986. aIn addition to direct citizens' input through the public meetings, information was received from representatives of various agencies in the Sunset Beach -Brunswick County area. These included the County Planning Department, Emergency Management Office, County Health Department, and the.North Carolina Depart- ment of Transportation. aCurrently, the Planning Board is composed of five residents living within the Town's jurisdiction. Throughout the plan updating process, Sunset Beach has demonstrated its desire to keep citizens informed of the planning process by giving them oppor- tunities to provide input and thereby participate in the decision - making process. Policy choices are: a. Sunset Beach believes that its Planning Board; which has regu- larly scheduled meetings, all of which are open to the public, provides opportunities for citizens to air their views and concerns related to planning matters. The Board will continue to be the primary vehicle for citizens' input. b. The Town will continue to use published public notices to inform citizens of pending decisions involving land use plan- ning matters in order to provide opportunities for input. D E. Sunset Beach Storm -Hazard Mitigation, Post -Disaster Recovery, and Evacuation Plan Sunset Beach's incorporated area consists of an elongated Q island between Madd Inlet on the west and Tubb Inlet on the east. On the mainland the Town limits run parallel to the Intracoastal Waterway. It is best characterized as a family oriented vacation o and second home community with seasonal populations reaching nearly 8,700 persons during peak periods, in contrast with a year-round population of no more than 200 (about 180 in 1985). Existing commercial development consists of a fishing pier, pavilion (with an arcade and shops), three grocery stores, three real estate offices, two motels, an ABC store, two restaurants, (� and a series of shops in a development on the mainland. In 1.1 addition, two golf course club houses have been incorporated into the Town's boundaries. 0 50 !II a 1. Hazard Areas at Sunset Beach The Areas of Environmental Concern (AEC's) located at Sunset Beach are divided into the following categories: (1) Inlet a Hazard, (2) Ocean Erodible, and (3) Estuarine Shoreline. The 100-year flood plain is also a hazard area that should be addressed in a mitigation discussion. (See Map 3, attached.) a. Inlet Hazard AECs At the ends of the island of Sunset Beach is a natural hazard area that is especially vulnerable to flooding, erosion, and other adverse effects of sand, wind, and tides because of the proximity to migrating ocean inlets. The sections adjacent to Tubbs Inlet and Madd Inlet are designated hazard areas and require the same set backs that are required for the Ocean Erodible AEC's. D Setback measurements begin at the first line of stable vegetation and continue inland to a depth of 60 times the average annual rate of erosion of two feet per year, or 120 feet. n u b. Ocean Erodible AEC's The Ocean Erodible Area is along the ocean front where a substantial possibility of excessive erosion and fluctuating shoreline exists. This AEC is based on a setback from the first line of stable natural vegetation, plus an additional area where a erosion can be expected from wave action and storm surges. The total AEC for the Ocean Erodible Area in Sunset Beach is basically- 60 times the average erosion rate of two feet per year (or 120 feet for large structures), plus a 100-year storm recession a average of 320 feet. c. Estuarine Shoreline AEC's Estuarine shorelines are the non -ocean shorelines which are vulnerable to flooding or high winds where the shoreline AEC extends 75 feet from the mean high water landward along the entire northern edge of the island. d. Flood Hazard AEC's The National Flood Insurance Rating Maps refer to V-Zones which correspond to the flood -prone areas that are susceptible to high velocity wave surges. These are the "high hazard" flood areas. Sunset Beach entered into the Regular Phase of the National Flood Program in December 1985, with the publication of (� new Flood Insurance Rate Maps showing flood -prone areas. The u maps, prepared by the Federal Emergency Management Administration, also shows substantial areas in the "minimally flooded" areas. 51 0 aThe remainder of the 100-year flood plain not included within V-Zones are designated as "A" Zones. The 1985 map shows most of Sunset Beach to be in an "A" Zone. Sunset Beach does not D have a central sewage system, but one package system has been installed within the extra -territorial jurisdiction. Individual ground disposal septic tank systems are used to handle sewage. Loss of a water source is not likely during a major storm. 2. Potential for Loss During a Storm a The Town of Sunset Beach has an estimaed tax base of about $121,000,000 (1986 tax year estimate). The increase has been at the rate of 10% per year for the past six years due to new construction. The average cost of the new single-family residence is about $70,000, and no lots on the island are selling for less than $35,000 with ocean front lots at $175,000. a3. Flood Plain Management Regulations The Town's National Flood Insurance Program includes u provisions to minimize flood damage while a building is under L! construction. D (1) All new residential construction or substantial improvements must be elevated to or above the base flood level in "A" and "V" Zones (14 feet above MSL in "A" zone and 16.1 feet in "V" zones). This elevation is measured at the lowest supporting member in a "V" zone and at floor level in an "A" zone. (2) Commercial buildings located in the "A" zone must be D elevated to the base flood level and attached to pilings even if the average elevation is above 14 feet, (none of the commercial district is in a "V" zone) under the new FIRM. (3) Open space of breakaway walls must be used below base flood elevation in both "V" and "A" zones. a (4) The design and installation of anchoring and pilings must be certified by a registered engineer or architect when built in a "V" zone and must be constructed in full compliance with the North Carolina State Building Code, including the design -wind requirements therein at any location in the Town. a (5) No use of fill for structural support or to raise the lot above the average elevation of the surrounding area is permitted. Sunset Beach has not to -date permitted mobile homes or modular units within the Town limits. Some mobile homes iri the extra -territorial jurisdiction are located outside of the flood (� plain, and all are tied down and blocked to meet North Carolina (j design -wind requirements for this area. I 52 4. Storm Hazard Mitigation Policies The island portion of the Town of Sunset Beach is susceptible to significant damage from a hurricane or a storm of similar magnitude. All of the island development is located in areas that would be flooded with a 100-year storm. The entire Town is subject to wind damage which accompanies storms of any magnitude. In general, the Town's existing mitigation policies follow the requirements of hazard mitigation planning as discussed in "Before the Storm." (1) All new development must meet as a minimum the provisions of the North Carolina Building Code. (2) The Town's zoning ordinance sets out requirements for low density residential development by setting standards for lot sizes, building heights, and building setbacks. The lack of a central sewage treatment system has kept high rise developments, which are permitted only in the business districts, from coming to Sunset Beach. The tallest structure in Town is 35 feet. (3) The Town's policies are in support of and are consistent with State policies and regulations for development in Areas of Environmental Concern. (4) The Town's flood plain development policies conform with all Federal and State requirements and are vigorously enforced. The Town of Sunset Beach enforces these stated policies through its zoning ordinance, the Flood Ordinance, North Carolina Building Code, and CAMA minor development process. Through these policies and equipped with these tools for enforcement, Sunset Beach is dedicated to the mitigation of future storm damage. 5. Hurricane Evacuation, Post -Disaster Recover Note: The Town of Sunset Beach had previously developed policies on hurricane evacuation and post -disaster recovery prior to the submission of this 1985 Land Use Plan Update. The hurricane evacuation plan and related policies are incorporated into this plan as an Appendix. (See Appendix 4.)* 53 I 11 I I 0 III 0 u ��I SECTION LAND CLASSIFICATION SYSTEM I SECTION III: LAND CLASSIFICATION SYSTEM The land classification system provides a uniform way of look- ing at how the use of land interacts with environmentally sensi- tive areas and with the development needs -of a particular locali- ty. It is not a strict regulatory device in the sense of a zoning ordinance or zoning map. It represents more of a tool to aid in understanding the relationships between various land use categor- ies and how these relationships help shape local policy. Particu- lar attention is focused on the intensity at which land is used and the level of services needed to support that intensity. The regulations for the Coastal Area Management Act state: "The land classification system provides a framework to be used by local government to identify the future use of all lands in each county. The designation of land classes allows the local government to illustrate their policy statements as to where and to what density they want growth to occur, and where they want to conserve natural and cultural resources by guiding growth." (7B.0204) (a) The five land classifications, along with a land classifica- tion map, are therefore intended to serve as a visual representa- tion of the policies stated in Section II of this plan. The map depicting these classifications must be as flexible as the poli- cies that guide them. (See the attached Land Classification Map, Map 4.) Only three of the Coastal Resources Commissions' five -land classifications are relevant to the land development policies of Sunset Beach. They are identified and described below. QA. DEVELOPED The developed class of land use provides for continued inten- sive development and redevelopment of existing cities. Areas to be classified as "developed" include lands currently developed for urban purposes or approaching a density of 500 dwellings per square mile that are provided with usual municipal or public ser- vices, including at least public water, sewer, recreational facil- ities, police and fire protection. Areas which exceed the minimum density but which do not have public sewer service may best be a divided into a separate class to indicate that although they have a developed character, they will need sewers in the future. Within Sunset Beach, the areas complying with the above definition, except for the provision of central sewage service, include: the existing residential and commercial areas on both the mainland and island, including portions of the extra- territorial area. Lots in these areas are nearly completely developed, and the undeveloped acreage could be developed by or before 1995. 54 a 9 B. TRANSITION 0 Transition land is classified as those lands providing for future intensive urban development within the ensuing ten years on a lands that are most suitable and that will be scheduled for provi- sion of necessary public utilities and services. They may also provide for additional growth when additional lands in the devel- oped class are not available or when they are severely limited for i! development. Lands classified "transition" may include: a 1. lands currently having urban services, and 2. other lands necessary to accommodate the urban population and economic growth anticipated within the planning juris- diction over the next ten years. Lands classified for the latter reason must: a. be served or be readily served by water, sewer, and other urban services, including streets, and b. be generally free of severe physical limitations for urban development. The "transition" class should not include: a. lands of high potential for agriculture, forestry, or mineral extraction, or land falling within extensive rural areas being managed commercially for these uses, D when other lands are available; b. lands where urban development might result in major or irreversible damage to important environmental, cultural, scientific, or scenic values; or c. land where urban development might result in damage to natural systems or processes of more than local Q ,concern; LJ and d. lands where development will result in undue risk to life or property from natural hazards or existing land uses, e.g., frequently flooded areas. The lands in Sunset Beach that will be classified "transi- tional" are those areas adjacent to the currently developed areas on the mainland (including the extraterritorial area), and island area. This includes some areas where lots have recently been platted, as well as some of the unsubdivided land on the mainland. The relationship between the "developed and transition" clas- sification is usually an important one. The first class is meant to define the already intensively developed areas and/or those areas where intensive urban -type development is likely to occur. Transitional lands are those areas where public investment deci- sions will be required to provide the necessary urban services. 55 I I it I 0 I �I I I it These become important areas to closely monitor. The Coastal Resources Commission has further clarified this relationship as described below. The Developed and Transition classes'should be the only lands under active consideration by a county or municipality for inten- sive urban development requiring urban services. The area within these classes is where detailed local land use and public invest- ment planning will occur. State and federal expenditures on proj- ects associated with urban development (water, sewer, urban street systems, etc.) will be guided to these areas. Most of the "trans- itional" lands on Sunset Beach already have access to the Town's water system (including the extraterritorial area) and are included in the municipal service area, i.e., police and fire protection (exept the extraterritorial area). C. CONSERVATION The "conservation" class provides for effective long-term management of significant limited or irreplaceable areas. This management may be needed because of its natural, cultural, recre- ational, productive, or scenic values. This class should be limited to lands that contain: major wetlands; essentially undeveloped shorelands that are unique, fragile, or hazardous for development; necessary wildlife habitat or areas that have a high probability for providing necessary. habitat conditions; publicly - owned water supply watersheds and aquifers; and forestlands that are undeveloped and will remain undeveloped for commercial pur- poses. In Sunset Beach, the lands described as the following Areas of Environmental Concern are listed in this classification: Coastal Wetlands; Estuarine Shorelines (excluding areas adjacent to already -developed lots); Inlet Hazard Areas; and the Ocean Erodible Area. D. CONSERVATION SPOIL This is a subclass of conservation and will be used to classi- fy lands which would generally be suited for use as spoil areas for the maintenance of major waterways, but not for other uses. This would include areas used, or to be used, by the U.S. Army Corps of Engineers. E. OTHER CLASSIFICATIONS According to planning guidelines, there are two other land use classifications, neither of which are applicable in Sunset Beach. They are described below:. 56 1. Community 0 The "community" classification provides for clustered land uses to meet housing, shopping, employment, and public service a needs within the rural areas of'a county. It is usually charact- erized by a small grouping of mixed land uses which are suitable and appropriate for small clusters of rural development not requiring municipal sewer service. (� 2. Rural The "rural" class provides for agriculture, forest management, mineral extraction, and other low -intensity uses on large sites, including residences where urban services are not required and where natural resources will not be unduly impaired. These are lands identified as appropriate locations for resources management and allied uses: land with high potential for agriculture, forestry, or mineral extraction; lands with one or more limita- tions that would make development costly and hazardous; and lands containing irreplaceable, limited, or significant natural, recrea- tional, or scenic resources not otherwise classified. I I I ill I 57 n I SECTION IV RELATIONSHIP BETWEEN POLICIES AND LAND CLASSIFICATION 0 0 I� I 11 L I I I L, I r� a SECTION IV: RELATIONSHIP OF POLICIES AND LAND CLASSIFICATIONS After the Land Classification System is developed, the Coastal Resources Commission requires each land use plan to relate the Policy Section to the land classification map and to provide some indication as to which land uses are appropriate in each class. A. DEVELOPED AND TRANSITION CLASSES As discussed in Section I, Analysis of Existing Conditions, the development of primarily single-family structures is likely to continue in Sunset Beach and in its extraterritorial area. The developed and transition classes were specifically designed to accommodate these projected more intensive developments and land uses. This may include commercial uses, parks and open space, community facilities, and transportation facilities. Hazardous or offensive uses, such as power plants, airports, and storage facilities, will not be in these classes. Where identified con- straints, such as poor soils, AIWW easements, or other fragile areas occur within these classes, the areas will not be considered as Developed or Transition. B. CONSERVATION AND CONSERVATION SPOIL CLASSES . The Conservation Class is designated to provide for effective long-term management of significant limited or irreplaceable areas which include wetlands; undeveloped shorelines that are unique, fragile, or hazardous for development; wildlife habitat areas; publicly -owned watersheds and aquifers; undeveloped forestlands; and cultural and historical sites. Policy Statements under Resource Protection and Resource Production and Management issues, address the Town's intentions concerning the Conservation Class. The Conservation Spoil Class will apply to lands which must be managed on a long-term basis, but are suitable as spoil sites for the maintenance of major waterways, including the Atlantic Intracoastal Waterway, by the Corps of Engineers. 58 I APPENDIX 1 I 0 �I L' E L Coastal Resources Commission PERMIT For Major Development In An Area Of Environmental Concern (Re: N.C.C.S.113A•118) Permit No. 36 Permit Class Issued to:Town of Sunset Beach Modified P.O. Box 221, Sunset Beach, N.C. 28459 This permit authorizes major development in Brunswick County, N.C. At AIWW at Sunset Beach SR 1172 Bridge as requested in the permittee's application dated 417178 subject to the conditions set forth below. #1 That the town of Sunset Beach not permit any development within city limits Including an on site disposal on lots less than 15,000 square feet until such a time that a central sewage treatment facility can be utilized. This condition shall not apply to the installation of a single septic tank system serving a single family residence not to exceed four (4) bedrooms on a lot or tract of land which on the effective date of the original permit issued July 27.1978, is specifically described in deed, contract, or other instrument conveying fee title or which is specifically described in a recorded plat. Signed by the authority of This permit terminates on: December 31, 1981 the Chairman of the Coastal Resources Commission Issuing Date: December 28, 1978 Kenneth Stewart NORTH CAROLINA DEPARTMENT OF NATURAL RESOURCES & COMMUNITY DEVELOPMENT Mr. Wallace Martin CAMA Officer Town of Sunset Beach P. O. Box 221 Sunset Beach, N.0 28459 Dear Mr. Martin: I am responding to your request fora clarification of Condition No.1 CAMA Major Development Permit No.36, issued to the Town of Sunset Beach on December 28, 1978 as a modification to the original permit Issued by the Coastal Resources Commission on July 27, 1978. A copy of this con- dition is enclosed. For Lots larger than 15,000 square feet, no specific conditions apply other than existing local, state or federal rules. No development is allowed on lots smaller than 15,000 square feet until a central sewage system is operative. There Is one and only one exception to this condition. Development may be allowed on lots smaller than 15,000 square feet where all of the following conditions are met: (a)a single septic tank system is involved; (b) a single family residence is being serviced; (c) no more than four bedrooms are allowed, and; (d) each of the above occurs on lots recorded as of July 27, 1978. This rule excludes duplexes and multifamily uses on lots smaller than 15,000 square feet, multi- ple septic tank systems. and single family residences with more than four bedrooms.) can also ad- vise you that although the permit on which these condition is based expires on December 31, 1981, the permit conditions, in particular Condition No.1, will remain effective until the Town Is served by a central sewage treatment facility. If 1 can make any of these points clearer, please contact me. Sincerely, Kenneth D. Stewart 1 =7 L' �` APPENDIX 2 SUNSET BEACH (See pg;. 20 for-explanati on) Inz .- ZONING MAP ov 2 .00 ev c lz LA" tA AMA AC40V RE390MAC RC40V ^MAC" AW-1 al. �� 7 CYX '.lD INLET MIZ-3 IN '44-COASTA, _ WATER WAV IUBBS INLET ATLANTIC OCEAN ilk APPENDIX 3 0 TOWN OF SUNSET BEACH 220 Shoreline Drive W. Sunset Beach, N.C. 28459 -Phone 919-579-6297 - February 8, 1985 DDear Pronert_v Owner.: r( In 1980, the Town of Sunset Beach undated its second Land Use Plan as a guideline for Town development. The time has come under state statu;.e to update the 1980 plan, so we are currently n _gathering information by sending a questionnaire to selected U property owners. There are a number of important issues to be considered. For instance: how will the Town _prepare for population growth in the future; what about roads, bridges, housincj, zoning, environment, and access to the beach? Before deciding these issues, we would like to hear the opinions of the Sunset Beach residents and property owners. As a result, you, alone with other Sunset Beach taxpayers and residents, are being asked to dive your opinions on land use. Your name was chosen from an official listing of taxpayers by the use of a random numbers table. Since you were chosen in this (� sample for public participation, it is very important that each L,1 questionnaire be completed and returned. Your name will never be placed on the questionnaire, and as a result, your answers will �j be strictly confidential. U . Enclosed is a stamped envelope for your convenience in returning this inruiry. Our closing date for receiving this information is March 31, 1985. If you have any questions, please call the Town Hall at 919- (1 579-6297. ..Sincerely y urs a//,ter �.• ,.✓/// Wallace M tin. Town r.ana -r 11M/ob Enclosures: 2 U 3 Appendix 3, Cont'd. PROPERTY OWNER'S PARTICIPATION QUESTIONAIRE 1. Do you live in Sunset Beach as a full time resident? (Yes) (No) Check answer a 2. Rate the services provided by the town on a scale from 1 to 5,with 1 as the lowest or worst rating and 5 as the highest or best rating. Comment on ways to improve. 4 Street Maintenances 1 2 3 4 5 194 15 Yes = 31 6 17 24 13 6 3 Plann�ng and Zoning: 1 2 3 4 5 191 4 Police `protection: 1 2 3 4 5 272 3 7 5 Garbage Collection: 1 2 3 4 5 267 2 1 Building Inspection: 1 2 3 4 5 174 4 6 Water Service: 1 2 3 4 5 270 3 2 Mosquito Control: 1 2 3 4 5 182 10 3. Would you support an increase in taxes to improve those services rated 1 or 2 ? (Yes) Yes = 31 No = 24 4. What services or facilities do you feel that Sunset Beach should be providing that are not provided now? Sewage = 12 None = 11 Parking = 5 n S. Why -did you choose Sunset Beach as a place to live or invest in property? jU} (a) Pleasant surrondings 41 (e) Low taxes 13 (b) Mild climate 24 (f) Quiet community 47 (c) Family beach 59 (g) Other Lack of. Condos/Low Density - 7 (d) Pontential growth 15 6. Do you think that publicaccess to the foreshore (area between the high water mark and the low water mark) at Sunset Beach is adequate? (Yes) (No) 59 10 7. Would you support a taxincreaseto improve beach access in the form of increased n public parking on the island?' (Yes) (No) When you consider parking for Sunset u Beach citizens only would your responselbe the same to question 0 77 (yes) (No) - 6 60 8. Do you believe that there is adequate participation by the public in town decision making? (Yes) (No) Have you ever attended a meeting of the Town Council? (Yes) (No) Yes=4 Yes-12 17 49 No=13 No=17 9. Do you know the name of the mayor 53 .a council member 45,the chairman of the planning board 19 ,or the chief of police 24 ? 10. Looking forward to the fiscal year 1986 when a county wide revaluation of property will take place would you support a program of keeping the existing tax rate and appropriating the excess revenue for the purpose of paving roads on an established priority basis within the town? (Y s) (N ll. Does the lack of a sewage system in the face of tremendous growth in single family houses create a concern for you? (Yes) (No) How serious could this problem become 40 28 over the next five years in your opinion? Appendix 3, Cont'd. 12. Knowing that there are growth pressures on the entire coastal region,what type of growth would you prefer if you could control the construction? 13. No Condo = 13 Single Family = 46 Do you feel that a high level bridge to allow a flow of vehicular traffic uninterrupted would be justified in the interest of public health and safety at Sunset Beach? (Yes) (No) (N/A) 32 35 4 14. Do, you feel that the lack of recreational facilities for all ages is a problem that should be addressed in a town that depends mainly on tourism to generate business? (Yes) (No) Upon completion of the second regulation 16 48 golf course touching the town limits of Sunset Beach at the western and (� ! Lj northern entrance to the town,what other recreational facilities would you suggest? . Tennis = 29 None = 21 15, Sunset Beach is one of the very few accreting islands on the N.C. coast. If serious erosion threatened the island would you be willing to support erosion control projects with tax funds? (Yes) (No) 52 16 Q.16. In what ways do you think vehicular traffic can be better controlled in the town of Sunset Beach? Enforce Laws = 11: OK as is = 11 j 17. Poor drainage is a problem on some of the streets in town,would you support �j the use of tax dollars to solve these problems on a budgeted basis with the most needed being addressed first? (Yes) (No) Il 60 9 }� le. Do you feel that construction work should be allowed on Sundays? (Yes) (No) 15 53 19. Do you feel that itinerant merchants should be allowed td operate within the u Sunset Beach town limits? (Yes) (No) 14 52 20. List five problem areas that you anticipate being the most serious for the Town of Sunset..Beach over the next five years in order of their seriousness. 1. Development $ Planning = 43 2. Sewage = 30 s 3. Roads/Drainage = 24 4. Water = 20 {-( gParking = 16 21.- Do you feel that parking should be permitted along main street with all of the pedestrian traffic in that area? Yes 9 No 57 22. Which of the following types of development would you like to see more or less of: Single family detached units More 64 Less 5 QSingle family multi -unit (condominium) More 5 Less 60 Multi -Family rental: {{{---►►► 1 ( Duplex More 12 Less 50 LApartments More 2 Less 60 Commercial: . Hotels More 6 Less 56 Restaurants More 25 Less 35 r-� Retail More 21 Less 41 i1 Lounges More 8 Less 54 APPENDIX 4 IV. SUNSET BEACH HURRICANE EVACUATION PLAN A. Purposes (1) To be, organized to minimize the danger to the public and the destruction of property, after --a storm warning. (2) To identify and assign basic responsibility and out- line procedures to be followed by Town officials, personnel, and the Brunswick County Emergency Management Agency during a declared hurricane emergency. (3) To provide for an orderly and timely evacuation of Sun- set Beach by residents and visitors during a declared emer- gency requiring this action. B. Phases During A Hurricane Emergency (1) Hurricane Watch - A storm is developing and a possible threat to the area exists. Lead time of 24 hours is generally given before any threat is recognized. The path of the storm and its intensity are observed during this period. (2) Hurricane Warning - A warning is issued if it appears that in tracking the storm and measuring its speed and direct- ion that it will reach a specific coastal area within 24 hours or less. (3) Evacuation Ordered - The mayor or Town Administrator will review all the reports and order evacuation during or after the Hurrican Warning. (4) Complete Evacuation and return to Emergency Operation Center. (S) After the Storm - The threat has passed and the time has come to assess the damage and begin re-entry to the Island if it is declared safe. �j C. Procedures r (1) The Emergency Operations Center will be on the mainland at the office of the Sunset Beach Police. s (2) The Brunswick County Emergency Management Agency will be 0 . - used for weather advice. (3) The beach section of the town will be divided into five sections for notification and planning with at least one unit responsible for each section. D. Duties and Responsibilities Hurricane Watch Response: Assignment: Town personnel and volunteers Administrator on standby Advise residents and visitors Mayor or to begin preparation for hurri- Administrator cane emergency, through notifi- cation by sections as outlined;. rescue squad and volunteer fire department maybe asked to help communicate with affected persons Advise contractors to tie down Inspection all materials at the construct- Department ion site Fill all town vehicles and equip- Police Chief ment with fuel Check all communications equip- Police Chief ment Schedule with Brunswick County Mayor or Emergency Management Communica- Administrator tions intervals for.the Emerg- ency Operations Center to re- ceive reports and activate the Center for constant contact Staff Town Hall for information Administrator flow Check emergency power generator Police Chief at the Operations Center for readiness Keep elevated water tank full Water System Operator Establish evacuation route and traffic control points in keep- Police Chief ing with county plan 7 Hurricane Warning Response: Assignment: Final check on fuel in storage Police Chief tank and town vehicles Check status of designated Police Chief center for evacuees Communicate with County Emerg- Police Chief ency Management Agency Evacuate invalids, and any Rescue Squad person needing help Police Chief Volunteer Fire Department Evacuation Response: Assignment: State of Emergency exists Mayor or Administrator Traffic control established at critical points - Inter- Police Chief section of 179 and Sunset Boulevard Inform residents and visitors Police Chief that an evacuation order has Rescue Squad been issued and tell them the Volunteer Fire hour that the bridge will be Department closed and tied down Cut off water line supply to Water system the Island Operator Check to be sure final evac- Police Chief uation of residents has been and completed Assistants Ask Brunswick Electric Member- ship Corporation to turn off Administrator electric power to area Establish security road block Police Chief at the bridge Evacuation Complete - Hurricane impact imminent Rl After the Storm Response: Assignment: A team, appointed by the Building Inspect - Mayor or Administrator or, Water operat- inspect the island for ions Manager, Police health and safety and Chief, Mayor makes a decision to allow re-entry if safe Coordinate the re-estab- Administrator lishment of critical town services Implement a system to allow Police Chief property owners and perma- nent residents back on the island Initiate damage assessment Administrator process for State and Federal disaster Declaration and report"to Brunswick County Following the Brunswick Police Chief County Plan coordinate patrol functions with National Guard and County Sheriff's Department Allow re-entry of property Mayor or owners and permanent resid- Administrator ents as soon as practical Request Brunswick Electric Administrator Membership to check and restore electrical power to the island Restore water service to Water system the island Operator Start post -disaster plan Mayor/Administrator E 0 ci Police Department Hurricane Procedure Condition: Action: Hurricane Watch Gas all town vehicles and equipment; notify any aux- iliaries of impending emer- gency Hurricane Warning Meet with Administrator and Mayor for final briefing at the Emergency Operations Center; file request with Brunswick County and North Carolina Highway Patrol for assistance if evacuation becomes necessary Evacuation After ordered, start house to house notification by sections; assign someone to each section to work on notification; report anyone refusing to evacuate to Mayor or Town Administrator; - hand out maps to evacuation center; continue to coordinate with Brunswick County Emergen- cy Management; determine from Coast Guard and North Carolina Fisheries whether or not patrols of the waterway and sounds has been established by the County During the Storm Stand by at Emergency Operations Center After the Storm Establish checkpoints and road- blocks; assist in patrolling sound and waterways as necess- ary; Police Chief assist in post - storm damage assessment team; start re-entry when authorized for official residents and property owners only; patrol to avoid looting, and coordinate with National Guard unit if they have been called to the scene 10 f E. Sunset Beach Evacuation Route Sunset Beach is served by one major route, NC Highway 179. This is a two-lane facility that would be fed during evacuation by single lane barge bridge over the Intracoastal Waterway. The evacuation route is North along Highway 179, then North on High- way 904 to Highway 17 at Grissettown; then North on Highway 17 to the first traffic light in Shallotte, then West on Highway 130 to the West Brunswick High School. (see map, exhibit #3) The capacity of a two-lane roadway under ideal conditions is 2,000 passenger vehicles per hour counting both directions. The highest flow that can be maintained for short periods of time without a breakdown in flow is about 70% of this ideal figure, or 1,400 cars per hour. The ability of the floating bridge to hand- le the evacuating traffic forms a part of a barrier to traffic flow process, and consequently, is a constraint to traffic flow. Futhermore, if gale winds reach 45 to 55 mph the bridge tender closes the bridge to vehicular traffic, and if the tide rises to three feet above normal high tide, the aprons of the bridge do not rest on the fixed portion of the bridge. If traffic is allowed to flow, it is estimated that no more than 500 vehicles per hour could safely cross the bridge in an evacuation movement. On a peak day with all rental units occupied, it is estimated that 10,800 people could be on the island. This figure includes 7,000 day visitors. Using a norm of 2.5 persons per car, the total number of cars to be evacuated would be 4,320 vehicles. The large proportion of day visitors would evacuate at the Hurricane Warning stage. Only those who are endlessly curious would remain, and approximately 80% of those living nearby would leave the beach because of the impending storm. Departure on the part of the day visitors would leave approximately 5,200 people to be evacuated. Of those vacationers renting on the beach it is estimated that ( 15% of those would leave immediately upon hearing the Hurricane Warning. This would reduce the number to 4,775, or 1,910 vehicles to be evacuated. 11 s C•: itA 0 0 EVACUATION ROUTE WEST BRUNSWICK HIGH SCHOOL EXHIBIT #3 Page 18 A N r-I Since the bridge will safely carry about 500 cars per hour, it will take about four hours to evacuate the island during a peak period after the announcement has been made. Should the tide pattern be one of excessively high tides or gale force winds accompanying the land fall of the storm make the bridge inoperable, more advance notice of the intention to evacuate would be given. F. After the Storm Sunset Beach plans for rebuilding a community after a destructive storm in three distinct phases. (1) Emergency Period - Immediately following the n storm, the principal focus should be on restoring u public health and safety as quickly as possible and studying the nature and extent of damage for which federal and state aid might be available. (2) Restoration Period - [leeks and months after a hurricane disaster the town should concentrate on D procedures for restoring community facilities, such as roads, utilities such as water and electricity, along with essential businesses to return the area to normal. a(3) Replacement Period - Depending on the extent of damage incurred, this period could last for a long time. This phase involves rebuilding a community. It is essential that the local officials understand the U federal -state -local procedures for providing assistance so that local damage assessment and reconstructin efforts are eligible for aid. The Disaster Relief Act of 1974 authorizes support for reconstruction activities provided certain guide- lines are followed. (1) The local damage assessment team survey the damage and report to the Brunswick County Emergency Management Co- ordinator. 13 (2) The County in turn compiles and summarizes the na- ture and extent of damage and reports to the North Caro- lina Division of Emergency Management. (3) DEM gathers all local -data and makes recommendations to the Governor for State action. (4) The Governor may request an "emergency" or "disaster" status be declared by the President. This declaration makes various federal resources available. (5) Federal Relief programs operate on time frames for application and completion, and must be met to receive aid. It has been learned that earlier disaster assistance pro- grams provided aid to rebuild in the same way as existed before the disaster occurred. By so doing this policy tended to foster recurring errors that encouraged the same mistakes. Consequently, executive order #1198 (Flood Plain Management) directs all federal agencies to avoid either directly or indirect- ly funding future unwise development in flood plains. Under the Disaster Relief Act communities can be required to take specific actions to mitigate future flood losses before granting relief assistance. The following procedures should be followed in order to meet all federal and state requirements for assistance. Damage Assessment Team This group should be composed of individuals who are quali- fied to give reliable estimates of the original value of the buildings and an estimated cost of repairs for the su - stained damage. The damage assessment team shold include the building ins- pector, a local property appraiser or broker, a building contractor, and an architect or engineer. All of these team members should be community volunteers except for the town employee. 14 0 These individuals should be contacted prior to the emer- gency, because the services of these g y, qualified individuals n ILII will be in great demand after the disaster. Damage Assessment Requirement A realistic estimate of the amount of damage could be ex- pressed in terms of (a) number of buildings damaged, (b) amount of damage by building type, (c) estimated total dollar loss, and (d) loss by insurance. estimated covered Since this will take considerable time, the initial damage be assessment should a visual survey of damaged structures. The extent of damage incurred should be identified with the Dprobable cause (wind, flooding, wave action, etc.) of this damage. Damage can be classified in the following manner: Destroyed - (repairs would exceed 80% of the value) Major Repairs - (work would cost more than 30% of the value) Minor Repairs - (uninhabitable, but work would cost less than 30% of the value) UHabitable - (water, electricity available and sanitary system functional with minor structural n �J damage less than 15% of the value to repair) Damages should be recorded on a map showing location and class- ifidation of damage by some coding mechanism. (1) The commercial buildings and residential structures Dshould be summarized by category. (2) The value of each damaged structure should be multi- plied by the following percentage for each category. Destroyed - 100% Major Repairs - 50% Minor Repairs - 25% Habitable (Damaged) - 10% (3) The total of all damages should be reported to the Brunswick County Emergency Management Coordinator. (4) The estimated value loss covered by hazard insurance i should be determined by a system of averages using esti- mates of coverage furnished by the County. 15 Organization of Recovery Operations ZFollowing the emergency operations to restore public health and safety, and the initial damage assessments are completed, the restoration and reconstruction phase should begin. The Town Council should establish some policy guidance on the following matters. 1 - Establishing re-entry procedures 2 - Overall restoration schedule 3 - Information to the public and owners 4 - Commencing cleanup, debris removal and utility restoration S - Undertaking repair and restoration of essential public facilities and services in accordance with develop- ed priorities 16 Reconstruction Policies Returning to the Beach: 1 - Re-entry of residents and property owners should not be allowed until initial damage assessment is completed, and the beach section of the town is safe to re-enter. 2 - An identification system will be implement- ed for re-entry to the beach for property owners until the emergency period is officially lifted. Permits: 1 - All buildings suffering major damage as de- fined shall be repaired to conform with the North D Carolina Building Code, Sunset Beach Zoning Ordi- nance, and Sunset Beach Flood Plain Management Regulations. 2 - Building permits will be automatically issued to conforming structures not located in the AEC's. 3 - All structures with minor damage shall be per- mitted to repair to the original state before the storm. 4 - For areas where the construction and use require- ments appear adequate, permits shall be issued in accordance with permit policies 1, 2, and 3, above for lands located in the AEC's. If it appears that conditions and -requirements have not been met, no permit will be issued for repair of non -conforming structures located in the AEC while the town is given time to assess the damages. Restoration of Public Facilities 1- Broken water lines should be repaired as soon as possible and disinfected to assure a potable water supply. 17 2 - Electric power lines should be repaired and all lines and utility poles that are down should be re- placed before any re-entry to the island is permitted. If overhead power lines along Main Street are seriously damaged, the Town should negotiate with Brunswick Elec- tric Membership Company to place these lines underground in the restoration of power. 3 - In the event of a severe storm that could possibly wash our or place sand and debris over the causeway and Main Street, the Town should have a letter of agree- ment with the North Carolina Department of Transportation providing cost reimbursement to the Town for doing these emergency repairs on these state roads in a timely manner. I APPENDIX 5 I I III 0 0 0 SUNSET BEACH LAND USE PLAN UPDATE, 1985 Analysis of 1980 Policy Statements/Implementation Actions The CAMA Land Use Plan for coastal communities is essentially a policy document aimed at guiding localities toward sound growth management. Because circumstances, conditions, and issues change over time, the Coastal Resources Commission, under State law, requires the local land use plans to be updated every five years in order to "take a second look" at old policies for their relevance as well as examine newly emerging trends and concerns. The Commission requires for all updates an assessment of the previous policy state- ments and implementation steps taken to effectuate them. The 1980 Plan Update was prepared in a different format and included only one direct policy statement, two implementation statements, and three expressions of policy objectives. DEVELOPMENT ISSUES Policy/Implementation 1. Policy Objective: To give the highest priority to the preservation of the low tidal marshland. 2. Policy Objective: To give a high priority to the preservation and management of the high tidal marshland so as to safeguard and perpetuate their biological, economic, and aesthetic values. Status/Relevancy Actions 1. Ongoing concern. 2. Ongoing concern. 3. Policy Statement: To preserve 3. Ongoing concern. and manage estuarine waters so as .to safeguard and perpetuate their bio logical, economic, and aesthetic values. 4. Policy Objective: To protect public rights for navigation and recreation, and to preserve and manage the public trust waters so as to safeguard and perpetuate their biological, economic, and aesthetic value. 4. Ongoing concern. 0 19 Status/Relevancy Policy/Implementation Actions 5. Implementation Strategy: During 5. Not implemented. the year left with the nearby land- fill, join in a regional planning concept -through the central organi- zation of governments and apply for grants and participate with the other governmental units in studying better ways to handle solid waste. 6. Implementation Strategy: At a 6. Not implemented. time when erosion threatens an area and an equitable plan can be devised to disburse funds to all affected property owners on the same basis, the town will probably appropriate funds for assistance, provided they are convinced that their investment will help. 20 dft L --j - 4" OR 4% Its lob _T L -77 41, �_/ Ir J (`may/ A WESTERN LAKE EAS TERN LAKE rv�f . . .............. TOWN, HALL /Al-rF?4 7T7-1f-b =I- -COAS-rAL . . . .............. -Ai ERWAY .... ....... . ............ ............. . ......... SUNSET BEACH NORTH CAROLINA 94 , " __.' 0 -N SOS TRAIL C11.0, House 77� I L 7 7' 7 won- tomass wa 0 800 2000 FT. SCALE-' ["=800! -------------- — LEGEND ........... TOWN LIMITS ---EXTRATERRITORIAL LIMITS INSTITUTIONAL COMMERCIAL V':­ 1COMMERCIAL E2]RESIDENTIAL IYA I /22/96 TUBBS INLET S...8 EXISTING LAND USE MAP-1985 1 � -- LEN K* SUNSET BEACH ATLANTIC OCEAN Talbert;: Co„ & Associates, Inc- I I I — r II I r •' Y '. .Q 1 11I j 1 �1 aY � V 17 w R! l d I I N r{ I Y V ' i "• Y) M ee M N 131 +I II II I" I I • I III I y, I P II I , 1 1'I'I II 'll �l I II i tl Ir e O S II II Y I I M "i0 I {Y' 7Y I II M AN I, L N 11111.6 I ' I I I I 4 1 I , i I I ly � I qI , I I I i' u l 1 i' I ✓.. I I I I I 1 +`~7 � a A u I�' d r 'I 1 I rl I I I II V .YI 'I I�i, JJ ' � �P ►/. O I •� ,� iJ "w/ �Y 1� 42 � O ,O I I ' II I' I�I ^I I''I p I I ', ' l ' II I y' ' I II ' y 'I +' I. I I ' 1 •' I II I I V��III �, I I I I w Bs! w n I I I I 11 I I N • 11 I I I I I I 1 i I I I 4 ,q u W rp I n YMIM I a w ' ',' I / J I • � I I 4A 110L•••+$4 art' SO O ►lw Ilu 0 o ' ,.'.....-'•• n ' r r 1 I r , II �`"`� M r Q 0. O N' .J 1 , •" I nl J r i` Y I I, I I �\ 1 1 3a WOlttniutj ..6JiF� y • '� .� 'll i YI II ' ,u I I I IM I 111 'I Y d I I I II \ I Q" kill �I :Ts04 N��� C YM III II I I 7•-. i I dl r 1, II l � � I Y� Z w u R1 M A " r ,rfl II .I I �-�Yla'Yalnlrr..,r1Y I I I H. I I I '' w1 I � ,II I 1 , I I YI I /� I ,� I ,I � +u V�`� � IV 1 I I a I .. I I z I I I' I I / � I I R11 � •� w-'ani,tralll•,Yr,�l rY1rR �, I I +, + r, l � I .. I. !✓ I � I Y •d G 1 n q Co u I I sa Ir rl y I 8 7 Ir /"p1 W N ,11 '�I ''I Y Y r 1 'p yl •�r. ..,,�,�,�„ RIr1. rr�Yulrirr r- rrr III I,'I II 'll�l I, ..�•�I 1',u H W �Ill U +FI L' i O X A I I . r r l I I �` �•••'� ♦` V 1 YI LY '� 'Y r ilr I'° " I� r l , I + V I •5, �♦ II 4I ' I II I I I ♦ 1 I I+ n f I 1 IL11 z { I ( r _ , I I 3 I I / r , • . F•' 1 �' ..II I I � _ I ' I I I13 1 I I 'rY I VI I I 1 IYI Y. I r' I' I 1 I I I I I _ I I I vy I' h I I I i 1 I I I 1 I r Y I I\ I _ I 1 I 1 I -'9• I I I I. •1• 1 d I • , Y p, I .I I I 4 \ I I l cc II Y r. Ywf,- T I L � I i I I I I I + I I I III / Y C ,Ilk � I ' � 'ra'.,. .. � iY;:; 1 t'i � I lY • I ' I I I I 9 .,.,.% I" I' I I G III I , , ' 'I I ,♦ II <a `•, . �ii.r + 1 1 V ` / + +^ I I I J 1 r I 1 � Y. I y 'Va I `III I ' n . I I 1 ' Iti' �+ .��.' � �u`.. 'J Vrj'il'. >♦. f y�'r �..r. C I • I I ' I i / "I i 1 I • I , I I •� I I I I 0 1( I sa YI Yi '�: } I n+ r, i 1d :/ 1 y II �•' I II I el + I II Ilk Y I I I 1 w' '• 1' , I al I + II. � II I I •M, ..' . _'_ .., "' II +. a •,.YI LI i r ,w Y: I °� .. � M L '•IYI,r li ' J Y..Jr I• •1 I i I i I I I ', I I I 'I .I � � I I. • Y 1 I� •r �' ` I I I I I .....'' ... 1 ,rr�•.f.ruY)• `', I I I ,� � I I Q I• V I � � •J Y.,..•y I I I it I Y I I I � :,r" "F*,�IIi '� � I ... .i.. Yr. +. .p' I' I}I} ".I •\ f I 111 � ', ,� I I ' II ' � I �,Y,YI�. ih('�.✓ _ _ w.o I .+.I. ,Y..1.�....I � I•. I I I I .. ... ' � ' I ' i I ' ' Wiwi FYI•. t.11.l ,• . r INN LLSJ I „i y .;;" .I. �I'II � n"•` r � • . Y I I I I I Y m I i I i Jr.y, 'R', "l �' I I • . i ,. I I I I I I I �, i I ",) Y , I I � I I s,,,, 'y I 1 Y YY:L,. I � • . I I•' I I IY ` I I ++ ' :':h 1. ds. "I' a.. I ( I, ` I I • , ` + ' � I I � I J I i Y .►'•�, � CIDU 1 I ''++ dr: y .aI 1 + r+.y- • 1 • I. ( I ,I 'I , �� II I I I �I . r u'; +I u I I I � y • •Tr I II i 1 • • I I , I I r P;i`' �" w r: (iI 1 \ � { ` 1 • , . I I I 1.. 1^'�'y.. ' I � `0 :µ�; s" I Y Y • • •• I I I I r � rrrC"I ' IY �'.'i 1 ' l ��� ; r 1 0l h� �.�,*. N�pl'' *I Y K'',r„{,:" I ' ' •r Y • • + r I 1.1 I ..,. .., y,.... `I II Ay � , 1 I I Y' Y I I '• I ' � ' I I I ' 1"I o I � h'i0 � •� I'IYIIY rW llr F ;w'�. ( I ` Y • Y 1 r I ++`� I • � ;{ ,'� , +m-1 I I / + • { ' • Y' I+ I Ili "' !i � Iiir,,,,, ' � �' � I + • • � •. • rl • '` I I TY II I ' .w.d y �'WIYr I u I I , I / I + "'Y.,,' •�`,.' Y 1 I 1 I I I 11 �. - '��"'I+V.' / ; ..,�, � � ( ' . I 1 III I I I( y' I r J1� ' ;,YL• I I I I , „" � ilia ��, ,. 1 � . ' • • I � I I ,r ,� .�:: l.. , a41 1 • , r. r , I I I I ' 1 ' 1 � 1 � ,.rl '�I. .,I:' L,,I J'° � 1 ' . 1'' • r / I l��r� I o.. •rw.. ✓ II• . i I I I 1 '� .� 4Wr 'p. I -•J' I I y , I I I .1j ..a I �. ♦ J s. / I I II .q:w r •y • r J w r I I I I' wY,., I Z� 1 I ' f y` a' w� .. +.r_ iS:: III IY � ` ;•,1 - ...% ' , , , / (1/ , r I I I % I I I 11 ., .,� �I, , ., I 'I I � � I 1 ,.., l• Y Y y I I I I I - I O 1 ,i. ', LI ;1 ,� ,• Y I I I I I I' '��A I ' ssi I Y II � I ori. Y•s , IYY { r / I I � � 1 I I T rr '' p I I ,� y" � 'syin ll_ 1 '. I 1 r I, ++ r Y • 1 I I 1 I I I I � II I I ': I Mr a 7. O 1 I 1 T,•_ t \I `�, ', I I I I I I I r I` .ir•r I Yl �, + mI � I i+" a 'lll�.' ' •1 '` I • Y ' • I U + I I N I w l'•--•I ' ' 1 r . + 1• Y r ,,.'` I I I j I � F" � j WI ` is '•__ r• `r • +1 •I , , r," I 1 I � I � I � �:��1 i � •Q 4 `• • 1 r Y + . I 1 r I _ I I 1 )I IJco r I. O ...I z y' \ 'I+, '"" V IL.. I I I I I I I I I r i .. '. L� I R•� i I I 1 Ill�rlrr o I U Q L z �.... ..�•' I 'u•I.• �YZ'.u...'Wdwwr.. Y I I • Y I I I I I l.i. 1—' � ,r. ' I I I I I 11 T 7 �'� cr '• I I 11 i O •ri'piin'o• Q .J W It F) w z En I fI Z 4 ul • • • • • Y '•� • \} I r..„�„` I...�_, .I I•� L4..i 1 �•1Y •Q d,�.. ._ z z 1 Mw... • • . • + , , ''AJ I I I 1 I I a W I� U (•' 1 I1 r LI, •' Y ', r I I 1 1 1 � ''+ I I I 110f Ilk I I 1 r " i :asod� I • •' ' I I � � I I.I,I lll.���. � f.l I ( 14. F- y 1 � �� � , Ic . f ,.l /'Ilr ,� `,; �• �• �; , ` I � + + .+ .. Y � ' � I,� I I � I � ""ll �I I+J � I I I M �': P'� I I w z � I ,I V 1 !� 1• I I I r I ., r r IJJ I_- I l „�' +' Ll/L * rl I!. I Y Y • /� �I I I I I II I (� I l IM z d, ,, 3 � w � y� l ' `�' I ,' z • ` • � I ...�, � I � � �' � � I I I �1 I "' .I, � I 0 o ••. Y I I r. Z ' i!iMl ` I L., W,I_ :IL II I I '� , 1 ( � �� { ,.. r r•w � �h � , .,n,� IY ;.I ?� ..1 l � � I I I � ! . � � I I , I ? ... Y • ' I I , I �I � I -�I .�w .t , �.�.�.. I �,,�;�.. I I �- � � ,. � II_,� �I � I I � I � I I, I 1 'r I • , • . � .: ' I I l � W ' � IL T"� . I I ''•• I I llll, �z, I I , 1 I • � �� '^ol�,r, .. I� y � / � � I • Y• '.�' ' • `r Y • 10 , I � f � /'r�T. I ; 1 Y .y+, r • • y � I � II ,1 .,1' � I. .�. - � .:,J I I ` I ,y I I I 'I � I , •: • . • I� � �� I I I 1�,.,:. `roc �, 1 — • 1 I � 4 �• Y., I I I' I • �,,. I Y • .. 1 I � ' � NIA - ,I •. ` '. ' ./ JjjII � r•rl'' d (,,.r' 1 I IT, •, • ' • • 'll I I Ina r.•r..ri I I I I rq I I � I W I j -+A'L I I �` • Y • '•' �'. I I f• ►' I "�. 1� - I • . I I kill .i I ���:J1 �'r8f,'S.I• �'t' v�' r'y � �� I I 1 I •�,•Y '+ '' I � I I '� I •��r'^ I II: I I I I I '\I ,. II cal y niY•;' � .. , + , r', IT '` I , • I I I I � I ly I � .` ... � 1 r I �. \Y�. I W�'N.•. ',� . '^7e,�1$.m+*•,,. ! r 1 ` Y , , . • Y I r � I I I I I / \ "�` Y/ l 1 qA�tdi;'t'ha ' I Y Y r • , 1, +` I I I I i I I ' � Are f'� '`� +•1{ YI � / I � ' II Y ,' r• r ' , . , I I I 1 + I I I I 1 ",� 'I'. ,I ' Y � •' Y Y• r' I I I , �'1 I I I I ,y. 11 INrI ,, , r Y • .. •. I I I I, 1 1 I I I I I I 1 � I ,/. � �I I',J�II I� I J 1, Y Y.• 1 I 'I � I I I I I i7✓ I I I F I I I I I • `' ' I I I r I I • r � I I I •` w!�'•, . I 13 � I ,l Yy I I � ' r Y ', / • „ + I I I I I I �� I I I I L, I 1.•Y ' •' . I I I I III I �- �� � s �'� 111� 1• — _ I� I I I I I I I I I Ir 'I �11 f • ''y'nl ' `,II • �:`'i I 1 , •, + •r Y,' I I I I I I I I I �,/ I I I� I ( �' I ,• • ` r1', , •• • • I � I � I I I I 111� ,, IIIIII , I I ir�u I � I � .•• I I I I � I� , I I YY, I � 1 r.. • ' • ,�/-• � r, _ I I !' �• `• r,' •..••+• III I I I I I I I I I , I I I I I Y � I r � I ,,, � W 1 • Y r r• I I I I I 'hl I I I 1 I I _•I. ./ � I ... ... I I r l I I I I I I I �, Y I EI • ' • I I � I 'I v •.. Ij I I i J •• r •' Y' r I I I I I I I I I I � 1 l� Y,• I I II II II I •• �, ,.`r rr Y �,n(: I : � � +�' `• , ' • •, z I I I I I I kill r • r y�Y I 7 I I I I Al 'L ° y I � + 1 •Y r Y I I I I I I I I I � + I I J 1 I r. I I � '•Y . / '� I I I I I I� I I Y•` II IIII / �� I I I ► , I III ,.: ... YY I, I r. .' ,u/ 1?'"N '7!,., • , r Y I I I I I ,1I I I +'Y�'111I1 I I .��'1tI i'YI':r i I yy • • Y , �,y(,t1I ` I 1 1 I T ► `'- \I. i'N'n hY,�/r.�:. \ 1 .1 • 1 . I I I I �.t I I lii ` I III I I I I I I I I I I �_ a• -r I � ti ! ' I, - � �- ; 1 rrrrr r rrrrrrrrl rrrli•�IrrrrY rrrrr Irr rri r�i—r `•`' � 1� •-.w,._ -ail. _ I ,r.. it ;., 'I goop dp •I I I r. oo I y - r r I I I I I , i III' I I I Y J I I I I I I Y � 1 I , o }' , IIII I I I I ! ' Y 1 I I I , I. I• , I I 111 I I 6 I I I 1 I I I I I I I I I •1 � I II I I I I II ' I Yt.l• Il+l I L� 141 II' l II 'I'.,, I I.I I h, II ,III,I ■I rrl IIII Ilrlllr ll IIII Il rllllll111 III III IIIIr1 Ir�rrII1 rIY IrYI II IIII IIIIIIIY � �IWrIII IIYYr �lllllllll�l�ll IIII III YIr Y�'II� WI�II II�YI11Y IYI IY Y III IIIII IYI II III 11 11111111 II 1 111 h11111110111 11 11 II IIYI II IIII 1611II II ill IN I 1 11 III 1 I 1 I Y I Y,I i r� I II all l u Inl I n tl II II I 11 C