Loading...
HomeMy WebLinkAboutLand Use Plan Update-1997ZO kv, fj Ef e t d n E -'<4s t�1F � y t ✓ rt„ i � � i , 4 �� �p ..,.� �k 4�� hPV0 A0 10 IE- - �,: m y a1 > 'a � a 1 1 Preface 1 Participadng Local Government Officials 1 • Holden Beach Mayor and Board of Commissioners 1 • Holden Beach Planning & Zoning Board • Holden Beach Town Manager 1 Authors: 1 This plan was initially contracted for preparation to Howard T. Capps & Associates, Inc. by the local government of Holden Beach, for completion under a State of North Carolina financial grant with funds being provided by the Coastal Zone Management Act of 1972, as amended by 1 the Office of Ocean and Coastal Resource Management, National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration. The plan was delayed in completion primarily due to a change in Town Managers at Holden 1 Beach, which coincided with election of a new Board of Commissioners for the town. This loss in continuity made it necessary to extend the completion date of the contract well beyond the 1 time originally intended. A Final Draft of the Land Use Plan Update was prepared by the contractor, approved for State review by the town Board of Commissioners and then submitted to coastal management officials of the State of North Carolina for their review and comment. 1 Following receipt of comprehensive review comments from the State, and after conducting a public meeting to discuss State comments with the Division of Coastal Management person primarily responsible for approval of the final plan, it was determined by the Holden Beach ' Board of Commissioners that the Town of Holden Beach would be better served (considering time constraints) if the plan was revised (based on State comments) by the Town Manager. 1 Accordingly, the Final Draft that was prepared by Capps & Associates was rewritten by the Town Manager. That version is presented herein. It should be noted, however, that the basic template and some of the important reference materials in the plan, as well as all of the maps and 1 original public participation processes were compiled, managed and prepared by Capps & Associates. For that effort, the Town of Holden Beach is grateful. 1 Dedication: This version of the Holden Beach Land Use Plan is dedicated in memory of Crawford Hart — a spirited proponent for protection of the fragile North Carolina coastal 1 environment, including the sea creatures that live off shore. May this plan be used to guide island growth and development accordingly. 1 TABLE OF CONTENTS - HOLDEN BEACH NC LAND USE PLAN ' 4 I. EXECUTIVE SUMMARY Overview: 4 Policy Statements of Particular Emphasis 5 ' Plan Summary 7 Land Classification Map 7 ' II. INTRODUCTION 8 III. GOALS AND OBJECTIVES 8 ' IV. DATA COLLECTION AND ANALYSIS (PRESENT CONDITIONS) 8 A. Population — Economy Status and Trends 8 (1) Population Analysis and Trends: 10 ' (2) Economic Analysis and Trends: 10 (3) Summary of Population and Economy Trends: 12 ' B. Existing Land and Water Uses 12 (1) Land Use Discussion 12 (2) Location of Major Subdivisions Platted but Not Yet Fully Developed 14 (3) Number of Subdivisions Approved Since 1990 Land Use Plan 14 ' (4) Number of Building Permits Issued Since 1980 14 (5) Water Conditions/DEM Stream Classifications 15 (6) Water Quality Use Support (Identified by Division of Environmental Management) 18 ' (7) Watershed Boundaries 18 (8) Wetlands 19 (9) Primary and Secondary Nursery Areas 19 (10) Outstanding Resource Waters (ORW) 20 ' (11) Shellfish Beds 21 (12) Beds of Submerged Aquatic Vegetation 21 (13) Natural Heritage Protection Sites 21 (14) Significant Land and Water Use Compatibility Problems 22 ' (15) Major Problems Resulting from Unplanned Development 22 (16) Areas Experiencing or Likely to Experience Changes 22 ' C. Current Plans, Policies and Regulations 22 1. Transportation Plan 23 2. Community Facilities Plans 23 3. Water Supply Plans 23 ' 4. Solid Waste Plans 24 5. Utility Extension Policy 24 ' 6. Prior Land Use Plans and Policies 25 ' Holden Beach 1997 Land Use Plan Update Page 1 25 7. National Flood Insurance Program 8. Zoning 26 9. Subdivision Regulations 26 ' 10. Floodway 27 11. Building Code 27 12. Septic Tanks 27 13. Nuisance Ordinance 27 14. Dune Protection (Erosion Control and Mitigation) 27 15. Environmental Impact Ordinances 28 ' 16. 17. Storm Water Management Plan and Ordinance Mobile Home Park Ordinance 29 29 D. Constraints: Land Suitability 29 (1) Physical Limitations for Development 30 (2) Fragile Areas 34 (3) Areas with Resource Potential 38 ' E. Constraints: Community Services Capacity 38 (1) Wastewater Management 38 (2) Drinking Water Supply 39 (3) Transportation 39 (4) Other Community Facilities and Services 40 I V. ESTIMATED DEMAND (POPULATION AND ECONOMIC ESTIMATES) 43 A. Permanent Population 43 ' B. Seasonal Population 45 C. Local Objectives Concerning Growth 46 46 D. Foreseeable Social and Economic Change ' E. Future Land Needs 47 F. Community Facilities Demand 47 ' VI. POLICY STATEMENTS 48 Background 48 A. Resource Protection 51 1. Appropriate Land Use in Areas of Environmental Concern 51 ' 2. Constraints to Development in Flood Prone Areas, Soil Suitability and Septic Tank Use 52 3. Protection of a Potable Water Supply 53 4. Use of Package Treatment Plants 53 5. Stormwater Management and Control 54 ' 6. Marinas, Floating Homes, Moorings, Mooring Fields, Dry Stack Facilities 55 7. Upland Excavation for Marina Basins 55 8. Industrial Impact on Fragile Areas 56 9. Development of Sound and Estuarine System Islands 56 ' 10. Damage to Existing Marshes by Bulkhead Installation 57 11. Surface Water Quality 58 ' Holden Beach 1997 Land Use Plan Update Page 2 B. Resource Production and Management 58 1. Commercial and Recreational Fisheries 59 2. Off -Road Vehicles 60 3. Residential and Commercial Development 60 C. Economic and Community Development 61 1. Community Attitude Toward Growth 61 2. Local Commitment to Providing Services 62 3. Growth Patterns Desired 63 4. Redevelopment of Developed Areas 64 5. Commitment to State and Federal Programs 65 6. Tourism 66 8. Public Beach and Waterfront Access 67 9. Capital Improvements Plan 68 D. Continuing Public Participation 68 E. Storm Hazard Mitigation and Post Disaster Recovery and Evacuation Plans 69 1. Storm Hazard Mitigation 70 2. Evacuation Plans 71 3. Post Disaster Recovery 72 VIi. LAND CLASSIFICATION 72 A. Land Classification Definitions 73 1. Developed 73 2. Low Density Development Area 74 3. Conservation 74 B. Land Classification Map 75 VIII. INTERGOVERNMENTAL COORDINATION AND IMPLEMENTATION 76 IX. PUBLIC PARTICIPATION DURING LAND USE PLAN UPDATE 76 Holden Beach 1997 Land Use Plan Update Page 3 7 1 TOWN OF HOLDEN BEACH 1997 Land Use Plan Update I. EXECUTIVE SUMMARY Overview: The Town of Holden Beach is located along the southeastern coast of the State of North Carolina on a barrier island (the limits of the town essentially being the island proper). This Land Use Plan Update provides a comprehensive analysis of present and estimated future social, economic, and land/water resources of Holden Beach. ' The plan takes an inventory of current town resources (as they were in 1997 and early 1998), examines how they have been altered since the last Land Use Plan Update in 1990, and then looks forward in time as to what might be expected over a five to ten year ' planning period. An important part of this Land Use Plan Update is the "community vision" statement that ' was adopted by the Town's Board of Commissioners in early 1998. The statement was based on comment and recommendations received from property owners and residents of the town. It reads as follows: "By the year 2008, Holden Beach, North Carolina, will have utilized available resources to maximize its full potential (within local, state and federal guidelines), to remain a tight -knit, wholesome family community that continuously focuses its present and long-range planning, economic and developmental efforts to protect and sustain: • its recreational beach, • its residential character and natural resources, • and the supporting services of the Town (public and private) for the next generation of Town property owners and residents." Using the vision statement as a guide, the plan examines expected growth of the community, balances that growth with the need to preserve and protect the fragile natural environment in which the town is located, and then lists several important policy statements pertaining to land use planning. The policy statements are categorized as: A. Resource Protection B. Resource Production and Management C. Economic and Community Development I Holden Beach 1997 Land Use Plan Update Page 4 D. Continuing Public Participation ' E. Storm Hazard Mitigation Policy Statements of Particular Emphasis The following policy statements presented in detail in the Land Use Plan involve priority ' issues for the Town of Holden Beach during the planning period: Appropriate Land Use in Areas of Environmental Concern ' Part a: It is the policy of the Town of Holden Beach to conserve and manage estuarine ' waters, coastal wetlands, public trust areas, and shorelines, as an interrelated group of AECs, so as to safeguard and perpetuate their biological, social, economic, and aesthetic values and to ensure that development occurring within the AECs is , compatible with natural characteristics so as to minimize the likelihood of significant loss of private property and public resources. Part b: It is also thepolicy o the Town o Holden Beach (following the above ' P c1' .f .f (f g rationale) to properly and effectively manage development inside or adjacent to 404 wetlands, hazardous and other environmentally fragile areas. , Stormwater Management and Control It is the policy of the Town of Holden Beach to control Stormwater runoff resulting ' from land development. The intent of regulations and procedures in that regard is to assure that stormwater is controlled within tl:e limits of individual property under ' development so that storm runoff does not adversely affect adjacent property, and so that none directly flows into coastal waters — ocean or waterway. Surface Water Quality' It is the policy of the Town of Holden Beach to seek improved stormwater runoff and ' other development standards and management procedures which will protect and enhance the water quality of the estuarine and ocean system. , Residential and Commercial Development It is the policy of the Town of Holden Beach to continue to support primarily ' residential development on the island, while limiting any additional commercial development to the existing commercial zone. The town does not support increasing the size of the commercial zone. ' Community Attitude Toward Growth ' It is the policy of the Town of Holden Beach to manage the Town's growth and development in balance with the environment and the provision of municipal services, ' Holden Beach 1997 Land Use Plan Update Page 5 ' and consistent with the community vision statement. All new development and redevelopment will adhere to the Town's building and development regulations and to the density requirements set forth in the Zoning Ordinance. Growth Patterns Desired ' It is the policy of the Town of Holden Beach to limit building height below 35 feet. It also the policy of the town to work to lower building density on undeveloped property on ' the island, and to prevent the expansion of the commercial zone while restricting new development in those zones to architectural standards set by the Board of Commissioners. The tows: will enforce state and local regulations involving ' development in or adjacent to conservation zones, and set their preservation as a long term objective. Redevelopment of Developed Areas It is the policy of the Town of Holden Beach that homes and other structures may be redeveloped (rebuilt) on the same property as a result of coastal storms or other reasons, so long as they are not damaged beyond 50% of their value. If damages exceed 50% of value, then redevelopment on the same property must meet town and state requirements ' pertaining to hazard setback, and septic tank installation. Structures may be moved off property subject to erosion and relocated elsewhere so long as that movement meets the ' requirements of the town ordinance and building code. It is also the policy of the town that homes damaged as a result of erosion: or coastal storms may be considered a public nuisance and may be subject to removal at the property owner's expense. ' Commitment to State and Federal Proizrams It is the policy of the Tows: of Holden Beach to support state and federal programs such as coastal area management, erosion control and mitigation, public recreational access, highway and road improvements, dredging (channel maintenance and beach ' renourishment), and other similar programs that may be appropriate for the town. More specifically, the tows: strongly supports the efforts of the U.S. Army Corps of Engineers to study the effects of reorientation of the Lockwoods Folly Inlet, and to develop an ' engineering plan to renourish a large percentage of beach areas on the island. The town understands the need for Corps of Engineers maintenance dredging of adjacent waters, but seeks to control dredging so it does not directly or indirectly increase beach ' or waterway erosion on the island. In all dredging cases, resulting spoil should be located on the island so as to mitigate the effects of past erosion or to prevent additional erosion. ' Tourism It is the policy of the Town of Holden Beach to support and promote tourism as an essential economic activity having direct positive economic impact on future development. IHolden Beach 1997 Land Use Plan Update Page 6 Public Beach and Waterfront Access It is the policy of the Town of Holden Beach to support the use of CAMA access grants ' to improve beach and Intracoastal Waterway access for all residents and public visitors. In that regard, Holden Beach supports the establishment of "No Parking" ' zones along the selected road rights -of -way, and to increase public frontal dune walkways and ramps at selected points along the beach front. The Town will seek to acquire land for additional beach access locations, and to construct as many , accessways as possible in accordance with American Disabilities Act standards. The town will also seek to provide sufficient Intracoastal Waterway access. Capital Improvements Plan ' It is the policy of the Town of Holden Beach to prepare a Five -Year Capital ' Improvements Plan prior to preparing the 1999-2000 operating budget. Plan Summary ' The plan next discusses the need for continued public participation and contains a ' summary of comments and opinions received from residents and property owners during the Land Use Plan development process. Public participation is important to the plan, and the percentage of people who participated (based on the number asked) was above 50% -- which is considered excellent property owner representation. Lastly, but certainly no less important than other sections, the plan discusses storm hazard mitigation, storm preparedness and evacuation plans for the island. I Land Classification Map ' The plan contains a Land Classification Map, that was developed after summarizing all parameters presented in the plan. That map will eventually be used as a guide for , development and zoning decisions and (perhaps) to update the town's Official Zoning Map. Holden Beach 1997 Land Use Plan Update Page 7 1 7 ' II. INTRODUCTION Holden Beach is located on a narrow barrier island in the southeast portion of ' Brunswick County along the southernmost reaches of North Carolina's coastal plain. In 1974 the State of North Carolina established a cooperative program between local governments like Holden Beach and the State, to manage ' development and growth of those areas through the Coastal Resources Commission (CRC). ' The CRC determined that land use planning lies at the center of a local government's oversight and control. This gives local leaders an opportunity and responsibility to establish and enforce policies that will guide the development of their community. While regulations, land acquisition, education and other management tools will continue to play an important role, the CRC determined that land use planning offers the best chance for developing a common vision and ' goals for the future in order to appropriately balance economic development and resource protection that is necessary for maintaining an overall healthy coastal '7 L F area. Proper land use planning provides opportunities for analysis of the implications of various development alternatives; allows meaningful involvement of citizens in discussing the future of their community; and provides a chance for local elected officials to make clear public policy choices for the future that help guide public and private investments. Land use planning is an important tool for effectively addressing the many complicated issues that face areas with high growth. III. GOALS AND OBJECTIVES The primary goal and objective in preparing this update to Holden Beach's Land Use Plan is to define a realistic and achievable vision for the community and to provide a plan that can'guide efforts resulting in the attainment of that vision — over the five- to ten-year planning period. This process includes formal establishment of land use policy and strategy to implement that policy. It focuses on retaining the residential character of the island, while at the same time allowing for desired community development, growth and retention of appropriate municipal support services. IV DATA COLLECTION AND ANALYSIS (PRESENT CONDITIONS A. Population — Economy Status and Trends ' Holden Beach 1997 Land Use Plan Update Page 8 The population of Holden Beach on any given day is the sum of permanent residents living on the island year -around, seasonal visitors such as property owners who do not rent their homes and visit the island periodically, those who rent residential property (or stay at the campground) for relatively short periods of time, and those from the mainland who arrive daily for recreational and other purposes. In that regard, consider the following: • each non -rental home had (on average during the year) two residents; • peak seasonal overnight population is estimated based on the assumption that the average rental unit has four bedrooms with a capacity of two per bedroom, and; • daily visitors are constrained by the number of parking spaces on the island which is estimated to be 400, and; • each vehicle is assumed to have four occupants on average — thus, peak daily visitors are estimated at 1600, and; • the island campground has 55 spaces with an average of 4 persons per space — thus 220 people on average for peak overnight load. Exhibit 1 shows a summary of data associated with these components of Holden Beach's population from 1980 through 1997. Peak seasonal population is estimated by taking permanent population, plus people in rental units, plus daily visitors, plus campground unit visitors. . Exhibit 1 Population Component Permanent Population 1980 232 1990 626 1995 782 1997 816 Peak Seasonal Population Jul -Au 9340 12934 14114 14444 Number of Residential Units Total 1027 1624 1830 1884 Number of Residential Units on -rental 116 313 391 408 Number of Residential Units(Rental) 911 1311 1439 1476 Sources: 1996 Brunswick County Data, 1990 Census of Population 1995 and 1996, Estimate from N.C. Office of State Planning, U.S. Census of Population & Housing 1980 and 1990 NC State Office of Planning, Town of Holden Beach Building Inspections Department, 1990 Land Use Plan — Holden Beach Holden Beach Sewer Committee, 1994-1998 1 Holden Beach 1997 Land Use Plan Update Page 9 1 ' (1) Population Analysis and Trends: Examination of the demographics of the population of Holden Beach is ' more significant for planning purposes when the non -rental population is considered. For example, peak seasonal rental and daily visitors are generally much younger than are the town's non -rental residents — many ' of whom are in semi or fully retired status. Those permanent residents who are not semi or fully retired are in their 30's and 40's and are generally employed by local (within a 40 mile radius) businesses of some sort. ' Holden Beach's permanent population demographics are similar to Ocean Isle Beach and Sunset Beach who have essentially the same "residential" character. However, based on a drive -through inspection Holden Beach ' has significantly less commercial activity (on -island businesses) compared to these two nearby towns. In fact, Holden Beach in 1997 had less on - ' island business activity than it did ten years prior. Clearly, Holden Beach has developed it's "residential" character by design. population It is projected that the residential character of Holden Beach will not ' significantly change during the planning period. The growth trend in residential homes depicted above is expected to continue at a similar rate (approximately 50 new home starts per year). Based on past trends, the largest majority of these new homes will be of a rental nature, and the peak seasonal population will thus continue to grow each year based on having more available homes to rent. The permanent population, however, ' may not grow at the same rate associated with new home development. Since the island's property owners have expressed a desire for slow (limited) commercial growth, it can be expected that this may be a factor t when a property owner decides whether or not to reside permanently on the island. However, the number of permanent residents will certainly ' increase over the planning period, since the inviting nature of the community will appeal to many. ' (2) Economic Analysis and Trends: The Ad Valorem tax base of the island has grown steadily since 1980, to approximately $300 million in 1997. Most of that tax base is associated with single and multi -family homes — both rental and otherwise. Per capita income for property owners is higher than that for those who live outside town limits. Many permanent residents on Holden Beach are on fixed income retirement plans, while others who are semi -retired supplement retirement income with part-time or full-time jobs. ' A new home built on Holden Beach in 1997 averaged well over $150,000, and in many cases along the waterway or oceanfront averaged over I Holden Beach 1997 Land Use Plan Update Page 10 , $250,000. Older homes may no longer have a mortgage, but some older homes are frequently remodeled or moved to a new location with possibly a new mortgage. The latter "re -development" nature of the island is ' important to consider, because as one generation of property owners passes along their wealth to descendants, more opportunity for change exists. As older homes are remodeled or rebuilt, the tax value of the , property increases, thereby adding to the overall tax base for the community. , In 1997, the commercial activity on the island included several real estate property rental and development offices, a small marina, three variety stores, ocean front fishing pier, pizza parlor and ocean front RV camp site. , A large percentage of the island's platted land has been developed in some way. It was recently estimated in updates to the Town's Water Supply ' Plan and planning associated with development of a sewer system that the available land will be largely developed by the year 2020 (at the current rate of growth). As the population grows with the development of land, so ' will the demand to provide support services — both municipal and commercial (a wastewater collection system being of prime concern). , However, roe owners are expected to continue to resist commercial ,p property p growth but may be willing to accept some new businesses (such as restaurants and service oriented establishments). Commercial growth will be limited during the planning period to those areas presently zoned "commercial". ' Associated with the resistance to commercial growth is a strong desire by property owners to protect the fragile natural environment of the island. Much of the island's vacant land is currently zoned "conservation" and ' (unless re -zoned or changed naturally in some way) will remain undeveloped. There has been and will continue to be strong resistance on the part of property owners to reduce the amount of conservation land, and ' many will seek to increase the size of the conservation zones. Thus, as land suitable for residential construction is developed, and as property owners seek to limit commercial growth while at the same time voicing strong support for environmental protection, the economic growth of the island will be centered primarily on tourist and coastal recreational related activities. While commercial growth on the island will be limited during the planning period, examination of growth trends for Brunswick County indicates that the area between Holden Beach and Shallotte, and Holden ' Beach and Supply may see some commercial growth and certainly more residential growth. Also, a 1-mile area along the "causeway" between the Holden Beach 1997 Land Use Plan Update Page 11 1 bridge to Holden Beach and NC 130 will remain the center of commercial activity supporting a portion of the service needs of those on the island. While that area is outside the city limits, there is a desire on the part of many in the town to review the advantages and disadvantages to take Extra Territorial Jurisdiction (ETJ) over that area. Should that occur, the residential character of the island would remain; however, there would be a much greater commercial zone across the Intracoastal Waterway on the mainland. (3) Summary of Population and Economy Trends: Holden Beach has grown rapidly in terms of number of homes, population and overall economy since the last Land Use Plan Update (1990). It is anticipated that this growth will continue to the same degree during the planning period. The island will continue to orient it's planning and capital improvements to support the residential nature of the town, and will not see any significant growth in commercial activity (unless ETJ action is approved). Holden Beach's growth will be joined by similar growth throughout Brunswick County — especially that for beach communities. The region will remain highly attractive to retirees and others seeking the advantages of living along the Atlantic Ocean in North Carolina. ' Land Water Uses B. Existing and ' (1) Land Use Discussion Existing land use on Holden Beach continues to be predominantly single ' family residential in nature. A review of the current zoning map reflects seven areas along this eight -mile long beach community zoned R-2, which allows medium density residential or multi -family use. There are five ' areas zoned for commercial use, with much of that use concentrated around the bridge to the mainland. ' The western end of the beach is a private development with access gate. This area had approximately 20 lots developed since the previous land classification map was prepared in 1991, leaving relatively few lots ' remaining to be developed on both the ocean and sound side of Ocean View Boulevard West. ' Approximately 53 additional residential structures have been built between Straw Flower cul-de-sac to Sailfish Drive since the 1991 land classification map was completed. In comparison, between Sailfish Drive ' and Boyd Street, approximately 76 residential structures have been built during this time. I Holden Beach 1997 Land Use Plan Update Page 12 From Boyd Street to the eastern end of the island, approximately 83 new residential structures have been built since the 1991 survey. Significant on the island east of the bridge are three new subdivisions currently in development — Wild Dunes near the bridge, Winding River on Holden Beach near Old Ferry Road, and Dunescape at the extreme east end. Continual ocean -front erosion along the entire length of the island has caused a loss of numerous homes and structures since the last land use plan update was prepared. These losses have been especially significant from the bridge -head eastward. Much of Hillside Drive east of the bridge- head was lost; however, room for an "alleyway" remains today. The eastward -most portion of Ocean View Boulevard has been closed to vehicular traffic, and McCray Steer constructed further landward to replace that road. Homes that were "second -row" along a large stretch of that portion of the beach are today considered "first -row." Several homes were destroyed at the extreme east end of the island as a result of tropical storms in 1996. Beach erosion has significantly altered the geography and land use potential of major portions of the island, and the threat of continued erosion along the entire ocean front remains today. Water uses at Holden Beach occur primarily along the Intracoastal Waterway and consist of private piers and docks, canal access and a marina located between the bridge and Old Ferry Road east of the bridge. There is a long, private pier over the marsh to the Intracoastal Waterway at Marsh -Walk -by -the -Sea on the western end of the island. There is canal access at the end of Sand Dollar Drive and Scotch Bonnet Drive, as well as Greensboro Street and High Point Street. There are 10 private piers along waterfront lots along Sand Dune Lane at Sea Oats Acres subdivision. There is one short pier adjacent to Brunswick Avenue West at Sand Dune Lane and eight private piers north of Lois Avenue. Water use along the ocean front includes the beach, one fishing pier located near Durham Street at the western end of the beach approximately 1.5 miles from the bridge. There are 17 CAMA beach access areas available to the public along the ocean front, distributed over most of the island. Parking near CAMA access points is limited; however there is a large parking area near the bridge that can accommodate well over 150 vehicles. There is a short walk from that area to a CAMA beach access point. There are no beach access areas specifically designed for handicapped people or others with disabilities. However, the town has submitted an application for a Grant to provide State funds to construct such an access next to the large parking area under the bridge. 7 I 7 Holden Beach 1997 Land Use Plan Update Page 13 1 H (2) Location of Major Subdivisions Platted but Not Yet Fully Developed Heron Landing, located east of Swordfish Drive in the western section of the Beach is under development. Phase One of the development contains seven lots, while Phase Two contains 15. Winding River on Holden Beach subdivision is located west of Old Ferry Road. This development with 39 lots is under development. It will contain both a waterway private access area, and public beach access point, with private beach club. Wild Dunes Subdivision near the bridgehead has several new homes under construction between the waterway and Brunswick Avenue east. Dunescape Private Subdivision at the extreme east end of the island is being developed with 58 large lots on both the ocean front and Waterway side of the island. There is a private amenity section to the subdivision that contains tennis courts, volleyball court, basketball court and swimming pool. Two other new developments that have been constructed since the last Land Use Plan Update include Marker Fifty -Five with 16 lots and Yacht Watch with 44 lots. The former contains two tennis courts and a swimming pool. (3) Number of Subdivisions Approved Since 1990 Land Use Plan Since the 1990 Land Use Plan was prepared, six major subdivisions have been approved (see above). (4) Number of Building Permits Issued Since 1980 Exhibit 2 Building Permits for Holden Beach, North Carolina 1980 — July 1997 Source: 1980 —1994 U. S. Bureau of Census 1995 — July 1997 Holden Beach Building Inspector Three- or Five- or Sin le- Two- Four- More Demo - Family Family Family FamilE lition 1980 27 2 2 — — 1981 96 1982 59 — — — — 1983 110 6 2 — 1 1984 94 15 3 — 2 1985 86 6 3 — — 1986 30 9 — — — 1987 45 14 — — 3 1988 38 8 — — 3 Holden Beach 1997 Land Use Plan Update Page 14 1989 41 3 - - 6 1990 42 5 - - 21 1991 59 4 - - 9 1992 48 3 - - 18 1993 60 3 - - - 1994 55 1 - - - 1995 53 1 - - - 1996 54 - - - 12 1997 35 = Total 1,032 80 10 1 75 Based on census data and local building inspection information, there have been built 1,123 housing units in Holden Beach between January 1, 1980 and August 1, 1997. Of these 1,123 units, 1,032 are single-family, which represents 91.8% of all housing units built at Holden Beach since 1980. This ratio of single-family to multi -family is well within the community's desire to remain a single-family residential community. (5) Water Conditions/DEM Stream Classifications Based on the Water Quality Use Classes Map prepared by DCM and dated September 25, 1996, the Holden Beach planning area contains two water classifications. Along the Intracoastal Waterway from the Shallotte River Inlet on the west to the Lockwoods Folly Inlet on the east, the waters are classified SA. The Atlantic Ocean along the southern boundary of Holden Beach is classified SB waters. The Division of Environmental Management has established primary classifications for coastal waters with saltwater quality characteristics. SB waters have the following characteristics: Best Uses • Primary recreation activities such as swimming, which occur on a frequent or organized basis; • plus SC Best Uses (aquatic life propagation, secondary recreation such as fishing and boating) Max. F. Coli. • Not to exceed 200 (geometric mean Counts (No./100 of 5 consecutive samples in a 30 day m1.) period); and • 400 in 20% of samples Wastewater No categorical restrictions. However, Discharges DEM may prohibit discharges on a case -by -case basis for protection of water quality H Holden Beach 1997 Land Use Plan Update Page 15 1 IL SB construction and development characteristics include: Dredge and Fill Refer to Supplemental Classification, Activities and to the N.C. Division of Coastal Management, N.C. Division of Marine Fisheries, and N.C. Shellfish Sanitation Branch. Erosion and • Standard erosion protection and Sedimentation sedimentation control required for Control Rules projects greater than 1 acre. • Required to manage 10-year storm runoff. • Refer to the N. C. Division of Land Resources.* Recreational Protected for: Activities • Swimming, snorkeling, etc. • Marina development, depending on local fishery and swimming activities. • Recreational fishing and water craft. SB stormwater control (when CAMA Major Development or Sedimentation and Erosion Control Permits are required): Min. Buffer Low DensityOption Requirements 30 ft. from surface waters Min. Built -upon Low DensityOption Restrictions 30% Engineered Controls N/A Min. Residential Low DensityOption Lot Size 1/3 acre Engineered Controls N/A Engineered • Infiltration and detention ponds Control Systems allowed. • Systems must control runoff from 1.0 inch of rainfall. • Refer to Coastal Stormwater Rules for specific design information. I Holden Beach 1997 Land Use Plan Update Page 16 SA waters have the following characteristics: Best Use • Commercial shellfish harvesting; • Primary recreation involving swimming on a frequent or organized basis; • plus SC Best Uses (see above). Max. F. Coli. • Not to exceed 14; and Counts (7V6./100 • 43 in 10% of samples. ml.) Wastewater Domestic discharges are prohibited. Discharges SA construction and development characteristics include: Dredge and Fill Refer to Supplemental Classification, Activities and to the N.C. Division of Coastal Management, N.C. Division of Marine Fisheries and N.C. Shellfish Sanitation Branch. Erosion and The Sedimentation Control Commission Sedimentation has as many as five increased design Control Rules standards for projects in all HQW zones. See Sedimentation Control Rules for Design Standards in Sensitive Watersheds (15A NCAC 4B.0024).* Recreational Protected for: Activities • Swimming, snorkeling, etc. • Marina development, depending on local fisheries and swimming areas. • Recreational fishing, shellfishing and water craft. SA stormwater control (when CAMA Major Development or Sedimentation and Erosion Control Permits are required): Min. Buffer Requirements Low Density Option 30 ft. from surface waters. n Holden Beach 1997 Land Use Plan Update Page 17 1 u Min. Built -upon Restrictions Min. Residential Lot Size Low Density Option 25% Engineered Controls N/A Low Density Option 1/3 acre Engineered Controls N/A Engineered • Infiltration systems allowed. Control Systems • System must control runoff from 1.5 inches of rainfall. Refer to Coastal Stormwater Rules for specific design information. *Turbidity limited to 25 NTU's. (6) Water Quality Use Support (Identified by Division of Environmental Management) Based on the Water Quality Supplemental Classes Map by DCM (Division of Coastal Management) dated September 25, 1996, there are no high quality waters designated in the Holden Beach jurisdiction. The Water Quality Concerns map by DCM dated September 25, 1996, reflects closed shellfish waters at Saucepan Creek, which is located west of the Holden Beach watershed, and a point source discharge located on the western side of the Shallotte River, also outside the waters adjacent to Holden Beach. (7) Watershed Boundaries The Watersheds Map for Holden Beach prepared by DCM and dated September 26, 1996, shows two watershed areas for the beach. Intracoastal Waterway area 03040207020080 is located from the N.C. 130 bridge west to the Shallotte River Inlet. Intracoastal Waterway area 0304027020050 is located from the N.C. 130 bridge to the Lockwoods Folly Inlet at the eastern end of the island. ' Holden Beach 1997 Land Use, Plan Update Page 18 (8) Wetlands ' The Wetlands Map for Holden Beach dated September 26, 1996, and prepared by DCM using data from the National Wetlands Inventory reflects four types of wetlands present on Holden Beach. ' Estuarine Emergent Wetlands (EE Wetlands) are located primarily at the western end of Holden Beach adjacent to the Intracoastal ' Waterway and west of Sailfish Drive. There is also a small area located between the northern edge of Sailfish and Swordfish Drive and the Intracoastal Waterway. The next area of EE Wetlands is ' located between the northern edge of Highpoint Street and the Intracoastal Waterway and along the Intracoastal Waterway between Highpoint Street and the western side of Boyd Street. The ' last section of EE Wetlands is located at the eastern end of the island adjacent to the Intracoastal Waterway on the U.S. Army Corps of Engineers Atlantic Intracoastal Waterway right-of-way. ' Small areas of Estuarine Woody Wetlands (EW Wetlands) occur west of Sailfish Drive, between Highpoint Street and Boyd Street ' and between South Bonnet Drive and Greensboro Street. A very small area of EW Wetlands also occurs on the north side of Greensboro Street right-of-way. The last EW Wetlands are located ' at the eastern end of the island on Corps of Engineers easement area. ' The onlyFreshwater Emergent Wetlands on Holden Beach are g located just west of Sand Dollar Drive on land managed by the Army Corps Engineers. ' of Freshwater Woody Wetlands are located at the eastern end of the I island and north of Ocean View Boulevard East. (9) Primary and Secondary Nursery Areas , Fisheries nursery areas have been designated by the State of North Carolina, "to establish and protect those fragile estuarine areas which support juvenile populations of economically important ' seafood species ..." (NCAC 3N .0001). The N. C. Division of Marine Fisheries rules define nursery areas as follows: ' (a) Nursery areas are defined as those areas in which for reasons such as food, cover, bottom type, salinity, temperature and other , factors, young fin -fish and crustaceans spend the major portion of their initial growing season. Holden Beach 1997 Land Use Plan Update Page 19 1 (b) Primary nursery areas are those areas in the estuarine system ' where initial post -larval development takes place. These areas are usually located in the uppermost sections of a system where ' populations are uniformly very early juveniles. (c) Secondary nursery areas are those areas in the estuarine system ' where later juvenile development takes place. Populations are usually composed of developing sub -adults of similar size which have migrated from an upstream primary nursery area to the ' secondary nursery area located in the middle portion of the estuarine system (NCAC 3N .0002). ' Special secondary nursery areas may be opened by special proclamation by the Fisheries Director to trawl net use for shrimp or crab trawling during certain parts of the year. While the water areas surrounding Holden Beach serve these purposes, none has been specifically designated so by the state of ' North Carolina. (10) Outstanding Resource Waters (ORW) ' Outstanding Resource Waters are those estuarine waters and public trust areas classified by the N. C. Environmental Management Commission pursuant to Title 15A, Subchapter 2B .0216 of the N. C. Administrative Code as Outstanding Resource Waters (ORW) upon finding that such waters are of exceptional State or national ' recreational or ecological significance. In those estuarine waters and public trust areas classified as ORW by the Environmental Management Commission (EMC), no permit required by the ' Coastal Area Management Act shall be approved for any project which would be inconsistent with applicable use standards adopted by the CRC, EMC, or Marine Fisheries Commission (MFC) for ' estuarine waters, public trust areas, or coastal wetlands. For development activities not covered by specific use standards, no permit shall be issued if the activity would, based on site specific ' information, materially degrade the water quality or outstanding resource values unless such degradation is temporary. ' Holden Beach does not have any ORW waters in the Town's planning jurisdiction. I Holden Beach 1997 Land Use Plan Update Page 20 (12) (13) Shellfish Beds Shellfish (oysters, clams and mussels) can only be taken from waters that are designated as class "SA" by the Division of Water Quality and as "Approved" or "Conditionally Approved" for shell - fishing by the Division of Marine Fisheries. The Shellfish Sanitation Branch of the Division of Environmental Health conducts sanitary surveys of coastal waters to determine if an area is suitable for shellfish harvesting. Recommendation is made to the Division of Marine Fisheries to open or close shell -fishing waters. Information on the status of waters open for shellfish harvesting can be obtained through the Shellfish Sanitation branch (Morehead City) of the Division of Environmental Health. All of the waters along the Intracoastal Waterway within the Town of Holden Beach Town Limits are designated'SA' waters. Thus, they are open to the taking of shell -fish. At various times of the year, however, these areas may be temporarily closed by the State of North Carolina for environmental or public health reasons. Beds of Submerged Aquatic Vegetation Beds of submerged aquatic vegetation (SAV) are those habitats in public trust and estuarine waters vegetated with one or more species of submergent vegetation. These vegetation beds occur in both subtidal and intertidal zones and may occur in isolated patches or cover extensive areas. In either case, the bed is defined by the presence of above -ground leaves or the below -ground rhizomes and propagules. In defining SAV's, the CRC recognizes the Aquatic Weed Control Act of 1991 (G.S. 113A-220 et. seq.) and does not intend the SAV definition and its implementing rules to apply to or conflict with the non -development control activities authorized by that Act. There are no specifically designated SAV areas along Holden Beach. Natural Heritage Protection Sites The North Carolina Natural Heritage Program of the Division of Parks and Recreation works to identify and facilitate protection of the most ecologically significant natural areas remaining in the State. Natural areas may be identified because they provide important habitat for rare species or because they contain outstanding examples of the rich natural diversity of this State. 1 Holden Beach 1997 Land Use Plan Update Page 21 1 I Based on the Sensitive Habitats Map prepared by DCM dated ' September 25, 1996, there are no known Natural Heritage Protection Sites on Holden Beach. ' (14) Significant Land and Water Use Compatibility Problems There are no significant compatibility problems between land and ' water use on the island; however, there is obvious potential loss of tax base revenue due to continual erosion of private property along portions of the ocean front. Public property, specifically state - maintained Ocean View Boulevard, is also at risk as the high tide water mark continues its northward migration. ' (15) Major Problems Resulting from Unplanned Development The dependence upon septic tanks for sewage disposal adjacent to ' SA waters (water suitable for shellfish harvesting) has the potential to pollute canals and the Intracoastal Waterway. Pollution of these adjacent waters could have a significant negative effect on the ' estuarine water and habitat. ' (16) Areas Experiencing or Likely to Experience Changes Due to beach erosion from the 800 block east to the end of the island, some homes south of Ocean View Boulevard may require relocation during the five-year planning period. Marsh views from the south side of Ocean View Boulevard near the center of the island may be lost as lots develop on the north side of the road, and block the current views. Current Plans, Policies and Regulations The municipal staff for the Town of Holden Beach helps to develop and execute the Town's Board of Commissioners' plans, policies, procedures and ordinances that apply to the operation of the town. The full-time staff consists of a Town Manager, Town Clerk, Administrative Officer (primarily responsible for tax collection and financial operations), Building Inspections Department of three personnel, Public Works Department of five personnel, and a Police Department with six personnel. Part-time employees consist of one Auxiliary Police Officer and two Courtesy Patrol personnel working under the supervision of the Public Works Director. Under the overall direction of the Town Manager, town employees perform municipal support services, code enforcement, and law Holden Beach 1997 Land Use Plan Update Page 22 enforcement duties. There are several formal plans that guide these operations — one being the Land Use Plan. Working in conjunction and coordination with the Town's Planning & Zoning Board, Board of Adjustment and Board of Commissioners, the Town Manager and Building Inspector are most involved with actions that involve land usage. In each instance, the Town Manager and Building Inspector (assisted by the Local CAMA Permit Officer) assure compliance with local, state and federal regulations that apply to coastal area management. The current municipal staffing level is not expected to decrease during the planning period — however, there may be recommendations put forth to increase the staff to include a larger Police force, and a Budget and Planning Officer. Additional Police might be necessary, for example, if the town decided to extend ETJ per discussion in Part IV B (2) of this plan update. Town plans that may affect land use planning include: 1. Transportation Plan Holden Beach has a Thoroughfare Plan that was adopted on June 12, 1988. This plan is currently being updated by Brunswick County and DOT and should be available during 1998. 2. Community Facilities Plans Holden Beach does not presently have a Community Facilities Plan. However, the town has approved development of a Five -Year Capital Improvements Plan beginning in 1998 that will include financial planning data affecting all capital expenditures in the town. Examples include sewer infrastructure, stormwater management, water distribution, streets and sidewalks, parks and recreation, and beach strand maintenance/restoration. 3. Water Supply Plans Chapter 51 of the Holden Beach Town Code requires that all habitable dwellings located within the corporate limits of the Town have a potable public water supply. A separate meter is required for all but very few dwelling units, office or other business or commercial use. The Brunswick County water system sells water wholesale to Holden Beach which in turn charges property owners. The water distribution system is well documented and maintained by town personnel. There is currently one main waterline coming u Holden Beach 1997 Land Use Plan Update Page 23 1 Ii to the island from Brunswick County. An approved capital project is underway to add an additional line to the island on the west end of the town. During the planning period, there may be discussion and possible action by Town Commissioners to dedicate the town's water distribution system to the County. Prior to that happening, however, there is a need for detailed analysis of the advantages and disadvantages of such action. The town recently updated its State -mandated Water Supply Plan for 1998, and will do so again during the planning period. 4. Solid Waste Plans Brunswick County provides county -wide solid waste collection once weekly on Holden Beach. The town supplements that collection (at town expense) for a second pick-up from June through October. The County service was developed as a result of the closure of the County landfill site, and the need to transport solid waste to another county for disposal. Holden Beach has a small recycle collection center that accepts (year -around) recycle - able materials such as bottles, cans, and newspaper. The town is now much more integrated with the County in terms of solid waste planning as a result of these new developments. This is not expected to change during the planning period. ' 5. Utility Extension Policy The Code of Ordinances for Holden Beach, Chapter 51, contains policy for water services on Holden Beach. The code requires all habitable dwellings located within the Corporate Limits of the Town to have potable public water. Wells on Holden Beach can ' only be used for washing cars, watering lawns and gardens and similar purposes. ' For extension of water distribution lines, a "developer" must use the following procedure: (a) The developer will submit plans for reviews and approval by the Town, its engineer and the Division of Health Services. ' (b) The developer will install the lines in accordance with the approved plans. I Holden Beach 1997 Land Use Plan Update Page 24 6. 7. (c) Upon completion of the new extension including all required testing, the developer will deed the completed facility, to include all rights -of -way, easements, permits,: franchises, and authorizations or other instruments needed for the operation and maintenance of the facility, to the Town. The Town will not reimburse the developer for the extension. Prior Land Use Plans and Policies The 1990 CAMA Land Use Plan adopted by the Town of Holden Beach on March 18, 1992, will remain in effect until adoption of this latest update. The old plan contains information about Holden Beach at that time similar to that contained herein. The plan also contains land use policy and a land classification map that will remain in effect until the adoption of the 1997 Land Use Plan Update. See Appendix 1 for a summary of policies contained in the 1990 Plan. National Flood Insurance Program The Flood Insurance Maps for Holden Beach are dated April 2, 1991, and consist of Community Panel Number 375352 0010 E, 375352 0005 E and Index Map Number 37532 0005.0020. The town has recently asked that the maps be updated. Much of the western end of the beach is subject to coastal flooding with velocity hazard due to wave action. At the eastern end of the beach a substantial section of the beach is subject to flooding and velocity hazard due to wave action. At the northeastern end of the beach there is a narrow area from approximately Halstead Street to the eastern end of the island that is in the 500-year flood area only; however, in a 100-year flood storm, this area would be isolated with no land access. The island has a history of strong storm over - wash at its center — near the Holden Beach pier. Holden Beach is an active participant in the Community Rating System, and has obtained an excellent rating. Sustaining this rating helps lower flood insurance costs, and is only granted after demonstrating a commitment to public education and enforcement of flood related policies. D 1 Holden Beach 1997 Land Use Plan Update Page 25 ' 8. Zoning The Holden Beach Zoning Ordinance and Map (latest version October 1997) shows Rural Districts, Residential Districts, Commercial Districts and Conservation Areas. The R-1 Residential District is for one and two-family dwellings. The R-2 zone provides areas for multi -family dwellings. Most of Holden Beach is zoned R-1 for single-family use. Of special note, the Conservation District is established as a district in which the principal use of land is the effective long-term management and protection of significant, limited, or irreplaceable areas. Management is needed due to the natural, cultural, recreational, scenic, or natural productive values of local, regional, State, and national concern. Areas included within this district are depicted on the Zoning Map and include the following lands and waters: coastal wetlands, public trust waters, estuarine waters, ocean hazard and inlet hazard areas seaward of the first line of stable vegetation, and the Corps of Engineers A.I.W.W. right-of- way (excepting only those areas shown as Rural Special Use). Other large homogenous tracts of marshland within the Town are also classified as Conservation. Development activities within the Conservation category described above must be consistent with the regulations (15A NCAC7H) governing water dependent development. Suitable uses would include piers, docks, and gazebos, but no permanent commercial structures or habitable dwellings of any type. The intent of the Conservation class is to perpetuate the natural, productive, scenic, cultural, and recreational features of the coastal zone. ' Subdivision Regulations 9. ' The Subdivision Regulations for Holden Beach were originally written in May of 1969, and were recently totally revised and adopted by the Board of Commissioners. Significant changes from ' a land use standpoint include increasing building lot property line setback requirements and increasing the minimum platted area from 6000 to 7500 square feet. Both of these changes will lower ' the density of subdivision building on the island — a positive action in reference to land usage, and the general desires of property owners on Holden Beach. ' Holden Beach 1997 Land Use Plan Update Page 26 10. 11. 12. 13. 14. Floodway The Floodway Boundary for Holden Beach can be found on the National Flood Insurance Program Maps 375352 0010 E and 375352 0005 E and study dated April 2, 1991. Boundaries of the floodways were computed at cross sections and interpolated between cross sections. The floodways were based on hydraulic considerations with regard to requirements of the Federal Emergency Management Agency. Building Code Section 151.01 of the Holden Beach Code of Ordinances contains the Town Building Code. The Town has adopted the North Carolina State Building Code, Volume I, General Construction, and the North Carolina Uniform Residential Building Code. Septic Tanks Currently all residential and commercial development on Holden Beach uses septic tank facilities for sewage disposal. Application for a septic tank is made through the Central Permitting Office at the Brunswick County Planning Department. In response to the permit request, and environmental health specialist from the Brunswick County Health Department conducts an on -site investigation to determine if a permit can be issued based on soil and site conditions. Nuisance Ordinance Section 92.01 of the Holden Beach Code of Ordinances contains a section on nuisances such as dead vegetation, storage of unsightly items on lots, and accumulation of trash and debris from storm or erosion damage. The Ordinance was recently revised to become better enforceable by the Town Manager. Dune Protection (Erosion Control and Mitigation) Two hurricanes in 1996 that directly affected Holden Beach have emphasized the need to have a short and long-range plan for beach preservation, restoration and storm damage mitigation. Past studies and reports including that by the Town's Erosion Committee in early 1996, and UNCW Professor Bill Cleary in December 1996 emphasize the need for Holden Beach to establish a beach erosion mitigation plan. �J 1 Holden Beach 1997 Land Use Plan Update Page 27 1 ' Accordingly, the town financed and completed a $1.2 million dollar project in 1997 and 1998 to re -build 4.5 miles of its beach ' frontal dune from the east end of the island to the 800 block of Ocean Boulevard. Beach variety vegetation was planted on the new dune which is serving its purpose as a "second line of defense" ' against storm damage. The "first line of defense" is a wide, dry beach strand at high tide. ' The town's 1997 Erosion Control and Mitigation Plan calls for a minimum of 100 feet of dry sand at high tide along the island. In that regard, the U.S. Army Corps of Engineers is working on a plan ' to renourish sections of the beach on the island. It is anticipated that the plan will be completed in early 2001. At that time, the ' town faces the need to set aside funds for the multi -million dollar project — a portion of which is hoped to be made available from federal and state resources. , In addition to the above efforts, the Corps of Engineers is also involved in addressing the flow of water from the ocean, in and out of Lockwoods Folly Inlet, and up and down Lockwoods Folly ' River. The intent of the initial portion of that study project is to determine the effects of the construction of the Intracoastal Waterway on shell -fish and other aquatic life in the Lockwoods ' Folly River basin area of Brunswick County. The study will eventually investigate the feasibility of redirecting the tidal flow at the inlet to correspond to the old "Eastern Channel" behind Long Beach (the island east of Holden Beach). Many believe that if this is done, the river basin environment will significantly improve, and ' the eastern most erosion on Holden Beach might be slowed. During the planing period, local officials will continue to monitor ' beach erosion, maintain the frontal dune as required (and as can be afforded), and will strongly support the Lockwoods Folly Inlet study effort, and any plans that may develop in that regard. 15. Environmental Impact Ordinances The North Carolina General Assembly has authorized the governing bodies of all cities, counties and towns acting individually or collectively to require any special purpose unit of ' government or private developer of a major development project to submit detailed statements reflecting the environmental impact on such projects. ' Major development project means and includes shopping centers, subdivisions, and other housing developments, industrial and I Holden Beach 1997 Land Use Plan Update Page 28 r- Q commercial projects, and projects involving dredging or filling, and any project which involves any change (by bulldozing, cutting of trees or vegetation, or otherwise) of more than 50% of the surface area of any proposed project, but shall not include any projects of less than two contiguous acres in extent. Any project significantly affecting the quality of the environment includes (without limitation) projects that may have a detrimental impact on air or water quality or on ambient noise levels for adjoining areas; that involve a possibility of contamination of a public or domestic water supply system or source; or will affect fish, wildlife, ground water, flooding, erosion, or sedimentation. 16. Storm Water Management Plan and Ordinance Holden Beach adopted in 1998 a comprehensive Stormwater Management Ordinance that was contained in a Stormwater Management Plan prepared under State DCM contract. The ordinance addresses problems associated with building and other development, especially placement of fill materials on the island. The intent of the ordinance is to control stormwater as much as is possible within property boundaries, so that stormwater runoff does not adversely affect neighboring property. The Stormwater Management Plan documents the existing stormwater system on the island, and makes recommendations as to how that system might be improved. Those recommendations are presently under review by town officials, and recommendations believed to be appropriate will be included (financed) in the Capital Improvements Plan to be developed before the end of CY 1998. 17. Mobile Home Park Ordinance Chapter 152 of the Town Code includes a Mobile Home Park Ordinance for Holden Beach. However, the Zoning Ordinance prohibits mobile homes in every building zone. This inconsistency will be addressed during the planning period. Constraints: Land Suitability (Note: Many of the constraints which apply to the 20 coastal CAMA counties in North Carolina are not found on Holden Beach. They are described in Appendix 2 of this plan. What follows here is a discussion of the specific constraints which are found on Holden Beach.) 7 1 Holden Beach 1997 Land Use Plan Update Page 29 1 d 1 d i (1) Physical Limitations for Development This section of the Land Use Plan discusses physical limitations for development, to assist in determining land classification categories. a. Natural Hazard Areas Including Ocean Hazard Areas, Flood Hazard Areas and Areas Susceptible to Sea Level Rise Ocean hazard areas are composed of those Areas of Environmental Concern that are considered natural hazard areas along the Atlantic Ocean shoreline where, because of their special vulnerability to erosion or other adverse effects of sand, wind and water, uncontrolled or incompatible development could unreasonably endanger life or property. Ocean hazard areas include beaches, frontal dunes, inlet lands and other areas in which geologic, vegetative and soil conditions indicate a substantial possibility of excessive erosion or flood damage. Since Holden Beach is located on a barrier island, a large portion of the town is susceptible to storm flood damage. The primary causes of the hazards peculiar to the Atlantic shorelirie are the constant forces exerted by waves, winds and currents upon the unstable sands that form the shore. During storms, these forces are intensified and can cause significant changes in the bordering landforms and to structures located on them. On Holden Beach, ocean hazard area property is primarily under the ownership of private individuals as well as the town (town property, streets and beach accessway areas) All (that portion of the beach between the frontal dune and the mean high water mark) is used mutually by property owners and visitors to the island. Ocean hazard areas are therefore critical, because of both the severity of the hazards and the intensity of interest by town property owners and the general public in these areas. The location and form of the various hazard area landforms, in particular the beaches, dunes and inlets, are in a permanent state of flux, responding to meteorologically induced changes in the wave climate. For this reason, the appropriate location of structures on and near these landforms must be reviewed carefully in order to avoid I Holden Beach 1997 Land Use Plan Update Page 30 their loss or damage. As a whole, the same flexible nature of these landforms which presents hazards to development situated immediately on them offers protection to the land, water and structures located landward of them. For those reasons, both the State of North Carolina and the Town of Holden Beach have established "setback" requirements to limit the location of structures inside the ocean hazard area. The ocean hazard system of Areas of Environmental Concern contains all of the following areas: (1) Ocean Erodible Areas are areas in which there exists a substantial possibility of excessive erosion and significant shoreline fluctuation. (2) Inlet Hazard Areas are natural -hazard areas that are especially vulnerable to erosion, flooding and other adverse effects of sand, wind and water because of their proximity to dynamic ocean inlets. This area shall extend landward from the mean low water line a distance sufficient to encompass that area within which the inlet will, based on statistical analysis, migrate, and shall consider such factors as previous inlet territory, structurally weak areas near the inlet (such as an unusually narrow barrier island like Holden Beach, an unusually long channel feeding the inlet, or an over -wash area). These areas shall be identified on inlet hazard area maps. In all cases, this area shall be an extension of the adjacent ocean erodible area and in no case shall the width of the inlet hazard area be less than the width of the adjacent ocean erodible area. Holden Beach contains all of the above areas — an eroding beach and waterway shoreline, and two dynamic inlets at the east end (Lockwoods Folly) and the west end (Shallotte). The physical landform of the island (See Appendix 3 Soils Map) shows a protrusion on both the east and west end, separated by a narrow portion of the island at its center. While the east end of the island has been eroding for years, the west end has shown a tendency toward accretion of sand. The center of the island is also eroding, and historically has been an area of storm over -wash. For example, at one time there was an inlet located near the center of the island adjacent to the present fishing pier. Given that fact and the current state of the beach (less 0 F Holden Beach 1997 Land Use Plan Update Page 31 1 than 50 feet of dry sand at high tide), it may not be prudent to locate new facilities there — especially large structures. Other areas of the island show similar characteristics and are generally located between the 300 and 950 block of Ocean Boulevard West. The main east -west road for the island is the state road Ocean View Boulevard. If, as a result of severe storms, a significant number of houses on the "first row" south of that road were to be lost due to storm surge flooding, then the State Department of Transportation has indicated it would consider the road being threatened, and would thus seek State Coastal Management approval to construct appropriate erosion protection devices to preserve the road. Per above, if the road were to be damaged, then the center of the ' island might be totally breached, creating a new inlet and cutting off access to the west end of the island. In addition, the bridgehead might be lost in the event of a major storm of Category 5 ' proportions and thus the entire island could be isolated, at least temporarily. ' Both Shallotte and Lockwoods Folly inlet hazard areas are equally susceptible to erosion damage from flooding. The Town engaged the services of a coastal engineer in 1996 and 1997 to record actual ' rates of erosion in these areas, and that data shows more erosion on Lockwoods Folly Inlet area — however, the area adjacent to Shallotte Inlet showed significant erosion in 1997. Canal areas along the waterway are also eroding, especially at the entrance to the canals from the waterway. Canal areas can be ' protected to a degree by the installation of bulkheads. Much of the canal areas on Holden Beach have these constructed; however, many are in need of repair or rebuilding. The areas that are in ' greatest need of repair are at the entrance to the canals from the waterway. Those areas receive wave damage from passing boat wakes as a result of heavy traffic along the waterway — especially in the early summer and late fall. ' In summary of this section, the island is significantly threatened by the effects of continuiniz erosion and much of the island could be underwater in the event of a Category 4 of 5 hurricane, at least for a short period of time. Improved building code requirements for new homes will limit damage to structures built since the code was placed in effect However, numerous older homes (especially those ' built at ground level out of concrete block materials) can be expected to suffer severe damage. Finally, erosion prone areas I Holden Beach 1997 Land Use Plan Update Page 32 throughout the island would be greatly affected, as will the main ' road on the island. The reader is directed to Part VI, Section E of this plan for more ' information concerning hazard areas on the island. b. Areas with Soil Limitations Including Non -Compacting Soils, Shallow Soils, Poorly Drained Soils and Soils Not Suitable, or Septic Tanks ' The Septic Tank Suitability. Map (from Soil Survey) prepared by the Division of Coastal Management (DCM) ' and dated October 21, 1996, shows all of Holden Beach as having severe septic tank restrictions. The Soil Survey of Brunswick County shows the following soils types on , Holden Beach (see Soils Map at Appendix 3): BO — Bohicket Silty Clay Loam ' CA — Carteret Loamy Fine Sand Co — Corolla Fine Sand Du — Duckston Fine Sand ' NeE — Newhan Fine Sand NhE — Newhan Fine Sand, Dredged ' All six soil types have severe limitations for septic tanks due to flooding, wetness or poor filtering characteristics. ' Bohicket (BO) soils are silty clay loam soils that are nearly level and poorly drained on tidal flats at elevations of 0 to 3 feet above sea level. This soil has native vegetation adapted , to tidal marsh. Carteret (CA) soils are loamy fine sand soils that are nearly ' level and very poorly drained soils on tidal flats at elevations of 1 to 3 feet above sea level. Surface runoff is very slow. Permeability is very rapid. Cart , eret soils also have native vegetation adapted to tidal marsh. Important vegetation consists of smooth cordgrass and small areas of ' black needlerush. Corolla (Co) soils are fine sand which is nearly level, ' somewhat poorly drained to moderately well drained soils on the inland side of the Outer Banks in low areas adjacent to undulating sand ridges. Surface runoff is slow with very , rapid permeability with high seepage rate. Holden Beach 1997 Land Use Plan Update Page 33 ' F 1 (2) Fragile Areas Duckston (Du) soil is a fine sand that is nearly level, poorly drained soil joining the marshes of the coastal area. Surface runoff is very slow with very rapid permeability. The water table is 1 to 2 feet below the surface and fluctuates with the tide and is subject to occasional flooding. Newhan (NeE) is a find sand that is excessively drained soil on ridges between the beach and the inland side of the coastal area. Some areas of this soil have vertical slopes joining the beach with elevations ranging from 5' to 30'. Surface runoff is slow with very rapid permeability. This soil is poorly suited to recreational and residential development due to slope, high seepage rates, caving of cutbanks and sandiness. Lawns and shrubs are difficult to establish due to leaching of plant nutrients. This soil may have slopes ranging from 2% to 30%. Newhan Dredged (NhE) is excessively drained, sandy dredge spoil. Surface runoff is slow with rapid permeability. The seasonal high water table is about 4' below the surface. This soil is poorly suited to residential or recreational use because of slope, high seepage rates, caving of cutbanks and sandiness. Slopes can range from 2% to 30%. Fragile coastal natural resource areas are generally recognized to be of educational, scientific, or cultural value because of the natural features of the particular site. These features on Holden Beach serve to distinguish the area designated from the vast majority of coastal landscape and therein establish its value. Such areas may be key components of systems unique to the coast which act to maintain the integrity of that system. Areas that contain outstanding examples of coastal processes or habitat areas of significance to the scientific or educational communities are a second type of fragile coastal natural resource area. These areas are essentially self-contained units or "closed systems" minimally dependent upon adjoining areas. Finally, fragile areas may be particularly important to a locale either in an aesthetic or cultural sense. Fragile coastal cultural resource areas are generally recognized to be of educational, associative, scientific, aesthetic or cultural value because of their special importance to our understanding of past human settlement ' Holden Beach 1997 Land Use Plan Update Page 34 of and interaction with the coastal zone. Their importance serves to ' distinguish the designated areas as significant among the historic architectural or archaeological remains in the coastal zone, and ' therein established their value. Fragile areas on Holden Beach include: a. Coastal Wetlands ' Coastal wetlands are defined as any salt marsh or other ' marsh subject to regular or occasional flooding by tides, including wind tides (whether or not the tide waters reach the marshland areas through natural or artificial ' watercourses); provided this shall not include hurricane or tropical storm tides. Coastal wetlands contain some, but not necessarily all, of the following marsh plant species: ' (1) Cord Grass (Spartina altemiflora), (2) Black Needlerush (Juncus roemerianus), ' (3) Glasswort (Salicomia spp.), (4) Salt Grass (Distichlis spicata), (5) Sea Lavender (Limonium spp.), ' (6) Bulrush (Scirpus spp.), (7) Saw Grass (Cladium jamaicense), (8) Cat -tail (Typha spp.), ' (9) Salt Meadow Grass (Spartina patens), (10) Salt Reed Grass (Spartina cynosuroides). ' The management objective for coastal wetlands is to conserve and manage coastal wetlands so as to safeguard and perpetuate their biological, social, economic and ' aesthetic values; to coordinate and establish a management system capable of conserving and utilizing coastal wetlands as a natural resource essential to the functioning of the ' entire estuarine system. ' Coastal wetlands exist along much of the northern boundary of Holden Beach and are highly valued by the town. ' b. Estuarine Waters and Estuarine Shorelines Estuarine waters are defined in G.S. 11 3A- 1 13(b)(2). The boundaries between inland and coastal fishing waters are set forth in an agreement adopted by the Wildlife Resources ' Commission and the Department of Environment and Natural Resources and in the most current revision of the Holden Beach 1997 Land Use Plan Update Page 35 1 H North Carolina Marine Fisheries Regulations for Coastal Waters, codified at 15A NCAC 3Q.0200. Estuarine waters are the dominant component and bonding element of the entire estuarine system, integrating aquatic influences from both the land and the sea. Estuaries are among the most productive natural environments of North Carolina. They support the valuable commercial and sports fisheries of the coastal area which are comprised of estuarine dependent species such as menhaden, flounder, shrimp, crabs and oysters. These species must spend all or some part of their life cycle within the estuarine waters to mature and reproduce. Of the ten leading species in the commercial catch, all but one are dependent on the estuary. Estuarine shorelines, although characterized as dry land, are considered a component of the estuarine system because of the close association with the adjacent estuarine waters. Estuarine shorelines are those non -ocean shorelines which are especially vulnerable to erosion, flooding, or other adverse effects of wind and water and are intimately connected to the estuary. This area extends from the mean high water level or normal water level along the estuaries, sounds, bays, and brackish waters as set forth in an agreement adopted by the Wildlife Resources Commission and the Department of Environment and Natural Resources for a distance of 75 feet landward. Development within estuarine shorelines influences the quality of estuarine life and is subject to the damaging processes of shore front erosion and flooding. The management objective of the estuarine shoreline is to ensure shoreline development is compatible with both the dynamic nature of estuarine shorelines and the values of the estuarine system. Estuarine waters and estuarine shorelines, like coastal wetlands, exist along much of the northern edge of Holden Beach. C. Public Trust Waters Public trust areas are all waters of the Atlantic Ocean and the lands thereunder from the mean high water mark to the seaward limit of State jurisdiction; all natural bodies of I Holden Beach 1997 Land Use Plan Update Page 36 0 ' water subject to measurable lunar tides and lands thereunder to the mean high water mark; all navigable natural bodies of water and lands thereunder to the mean high water level or mean water level as the case may be, ' except privately -owned lakes to which the public has no right of access; all water in artificially created bodies of ' water containing significant public fishing resources or other public resources which are accessible to the public by navigation from bodies of water in which the public has ' rights of navigation; and all waters in artificially created bodies of water in which the public has acquired rights by prescription, custom, usage, dedication, or any other means. ' Public trust areas in Holden Beach include the Atlantic Ocean, Intracoastal Waterway and adjacent navigational ' canals. Lands Identified Through Division of Coastal Management ' Wetland Maps The Wetlands Map for Holden Beach dated September 26, ' 1996, and prepared by DCM using data from the National Wetlands Inventory reflects four types of wetlands present ' on Holden Beach. Estuarine Emergent Wetlands (EE Wetlands) are located primarily at the western end of Holden Beach adjacent to ' the Intracoastal Waterway and west of Sailfish Drive. There is also a small area located between the northern edge of Sailfish and Swordfish Drive and the Intracoastal ' Waterway. The next area of EE Wetlands is located between the northern edge of Highpoint Street and the Intracoastal Waterway and along the Intracoastal Waterway , between Highpoint Street and the western side of Boyd Street. The last section of EE Wetlands is located at the eastern end of the island adjacent to the Intracoastal ' Waterway on the U.S. Army Corps of Engineers Atlantic Intracoastal Waterway right-of-way. ' Small areas of Estuarine Woody Wetlands (EW Wetlands) occur west of Sailfish Drive, between Highpoint Street and I Boyd Street and between Scotch Bonnet Drive and Greensboro Street. A very small area of EW Wetlands also occurs on the north side of Greensboro Street right-of-way. , The last EW Wetlands are located at the eastern end of the island on Corps of Engineers property. J Holden Beach 1997 Land Use Plan Update Page 37 1 The only Freshwater Emergent Wetlands on Holden Beach ' are located just west of Sand Dollar Drive on land owned by the Army Corps of Engineers. ' Freshwater Woody Wetlands are located at the eastern end of the island and north of Ocean View Boulevard East. These wetlands are located in an area that has been ' subdivided into residential lots and also may be subject to continued erosion. ' e. Other fragile areas are defined by the State of North Carolina, but do not exist on Holden Beach. For a summary of these areas, see ' Appendix 2. (3) Areas with Resource Potential ' State definitions in this area do not apply to Holden Beach. For a summary of the areas involved, see Appendix 2. E. Constraints: Community Services Capacity (1) Wastewater Management ' Individual on -lot treatment and disposal systems (septic tanks) are currently being used for wastewater management on Holden ' Beach. Section IV.D. Lb of this Plan includes discussion of the septic tank suitability map prepared by the Division of Coastal Management which shows all of Holden Beach having severe ' septic tank restrictions due to soil types found on the island. Because of the sensitive environment of Holden Beach, citizens have discussed setting a goal (going back to the original 1976 Land Use Plan) to construct a sewage collecting system. In early 1998, the Board of Commissioners passed a Resolution that committed ' the town to a sewage collection system serviced by a Brunswick County operated treatment facility. Town officials have since worked in close cooperation and coordination with Brunswick ' County to work toward achievement of that objective. ' The County hired the services of a contract engineering firm to study alternatives for a regional treatment facility, and the town is in the process of developing specific requirements related to the sewage collection system. It is anticipated that sufficient I Holden Beach 1997 Land Use Plan Update Page 38 ' information from which to make a engineering and funding decision will be available by the end of CY 1998. ' Because of the lack of a sewer system and more stringent requirements to obtain a septic tank permit, numerous lots on the island that cannot be approved for a septic tank under current ' regulations will remain undeveloped during the planning period. (2) Drinking Water Supply I Holden Beach receives all potable water from the Brunswick County water system. There is currently low water pressure and ' potentially low fire flow pressure at the west end of island. Water pressure overall is controlled jointly by County pumping stations, aided by a 300,000 gallon elevated tank located on the island. ' While the tank and pumping stations normally can maintain adequate pressure, there are peak usage periods during the summer (July 4"' weekend for example) when pressure drops significantly. ' To resolve the low water pressure situation, the town approved a ' $294,000 Capital Project to construct a new waterline from the island to the mainland under the Intracoastal Waterway on the west end of the island. The line will connect to a new County waterline ' being constructed on Windy Point Road across the waterway. Overall, the Brunswick County water system has sufficient ' capacity to provide Holden Beach with potable water during the five- to ten-year planning period. The town recently updated its State Water Supply Plan in that regard. ' (3) Transportation , The 1988 Brunswick County Thoroughfare Plan is currently being updated and should be available in 1998. The plan will describe the County -wide traffic network affecting Holden Beach. ' There are approximately 13 miles of roads on Holden Beach. The main road (Ocean View Boulevard) is largely State -maintained, ' while the remainder is serviced by the town or is private. Roads are mostly paved; those that are not have a marl/gravel surface that can be graded periodically for maintenance. Design capacity for all , roads is satisfactory, and will remain so during the planning period. Ocean Boulevard is the major east -west road on the island, and is ' supplemented for east -west traffic flow on Brunswick Avenue from Ferry Road to High Point Street. Numerous relatively short ' Holden Beach 1997 Land Use Plan Update Page 39 1 north -south roads are located throughout the length of the island. It is these short roads that are not all paved. Ocean Boulevard has an adjacent sidewalk along its length, for pedestrian and bicycle traffic. The majority of vehicular traffic travels along Ocean Boulevard. Daily traffic counts vary throughout the island, with the largest amount being recorded at the foot of the bridge during the summer tourist season. Peak load traffic at the bridge, for example, can be as much as 500 vehicles per hour (estimated by the Holden Beach Police Department). A surprisingly large number of island weekly visitors also routinely travel from one end of the island to the other to view homes and the marsh areas. That traffic coupled with arriving and departing visitors sometimes results in congested areas near the bridge. When that occurs, the Police Department directs traffic to relieve the problem. ' Several roads on the island have inadequate stormwater drainage structures, and many were originally constructed at grades that are ' now lower than desired. This situation causes partially flooded roads following heavy rains. However, water normally drains off the road several hours after the event. (4) Other Community Facilities and Services ' a. Design Capacity of Existing Schools Holden Beach is currently served by the following schools (1997): ' School Grades Capacity Enrollment Supply Elementary K — 5 653 820 Shallotte Middle 6-8 905 984 ' West Brunswick 9 —12 920 1,120 The capacity of schools is satisfactory for Holden Beach during the planning period. It should be noted that there are less than 150 school age children living on the island during the school year. ' That figure is not expected to change significantly during the planning period. ' b. Landfill The Brunswick County Landfill was closed at the end of ' 1997. All County residents are now serviced by a private contractor who hauls solid waste to a transfer station, for eventual deposit in a landfill in Sampson County. Tipping ' Holden Beach 1997 Land Use Plan Update Page 40 C. e. Fees are charge to deposit waste at the transfer station and at the old County landfill. This procedure will remain adequate during the planning period. Other Solid Waste Disposal Facility Holden Beach residents have the option to recycle at a collection point located behind the Town Hall. This facility includes designated containers for newspapers, plastic bottles, glass and other recyclable materials. The land area being used for recycling center is leased, and there will be a need during the planning period to locate to another site for this purpose. Police The Holden Beach Police Department currently has six full-time officers with one auxiliary officer. An additional full-time officer has been requested through the federal government's Community Oriented Policing Program. Officers have sufficient patrol vehicles and other equipment. The town recently purchased two new police cars, and has a plan to replace others. Adequate law enforcement will be available during the planning period so long as the limits of patrol are not extended through Extraterritorial Jurisdiction. If that occurs, there will be a need for additional officers. Fire Protection The Tri-Beach Volunteer Fire Department (VFD) is a non- profit organization providing fire protection to Holden Beach. The Department has a substation located at Star Fish Drive and Ocean View Boulevard that contains one 1979 Chevrolet, 250-gallon capacity, 1,000 gpm pumper truck. There is a need for a ladder truck to be located on the island; however, one is located at the Department's main station on the nearby mainland. 1 H Holden Beach 1907 Land Use Plan Update Page 41 1 LI F The main fire station has the following equipment: 1961 65' ladder truck; 1981 International 1,000-gallon capacity, 1,000 gpm pumper; 1991 International 1,000-gallon capacity, 1,250 gpm pumper. Water rescue equipment includes two boats and one Suburban truck. The beach has a "six" fire rating, which provides discounts on fire insurance. With the substation and main station, 28 volunteers are needed; and 32 to 34 volunteers are normally available. There is a desire on the part of the VFD to have more volunteers who reside on the island. Currently, there are only three. f. Public Administrative Ability The Town has a full-time staff that manages day-to-day operations, and provides short and long-range planning services. Operations are appropriately organized and are accomplished by desktop computer systems with adequate software support. The Town Manager publishes a community quarterly newsletter and maintains an Internet Web Page to facilitate communications and public education. The Town Hall was recently renovated, with significant enlargement of administrative space resulting. This has greatly improved staff morale and efficiency, and has increased customer service capability. The present staff is adequate to manage office affairs; however, there is marginally satisfactory back-up capability should any single employee be absent. The Town Manager will address this situation with the Board of Commissioners during the planning period. I Holden Beach 1997 Land Use Plan Update Page 42 E g. Hurricane Evacuation Planning. The town has an up to date comprehensive Hurricane Preparedness Plan that contains detailed information to guide preparation for a hurricane and island evacuation. It also addresses damage assessment. The Mayor recently appointed a Hurricane Preparedness Officer for the town — to work in coordination with the Board of Commissioners and the Town Manager. The town annually conducts seminars and practice sessions with more than 70 volunteers who assist with evacuation and damage assessment. The key to Hurricane Preparedness is an up-to-date plan. Therefore, Holden Beach will continue to revise it's plan each year during the planning period. V. ESTIMATED DEMAND (Population and Economic Estimates) A. , Permanent Population Projecting the growth of the island's permanent population involves several factors. For permanent population estimates, consider the following: • the increase in the number of new homes each year, • the number of non -rental homes, • the number of non -rental homes (existing and new) occupied by permanent residents, • and the desire on the part of property owners to remain a permanent resident, after a period of time in that category. Exhibit 1 in Section IV, Part "A" lists historical data that reflects approximately 400 homes in 1997 that were categorized as "non -rental". That figure is roughly 22% of the total number of homes on the island. It is logical (for planning purposes) to assume that this percentage will remain relatively constant over the next ten years. After calculating the total number of non -rental homes, one could estimate the number of those homes that will be occupied by permanent residents. Since Holden Beach is a relatively small community most of the year, it is fairly easy to determine (based on tangibles such as public meeting attendance, voter turn -out, etc.) that most non -rental homes are occupied year -around. While one could determine a fairly accurate percentage in r� Holden Beach 1997 Land Use Plan Update Page 43 ' ' that regard, it is not considered to be significant when future permanent population estimates are determined for land use planning. Therefore, for ' planning purposes, assume that the non -rental home figure equals the permanent resident home figure. ' If one assumes that two residents will occupy every non -rental home on average during the year, then the number of permanent residents can be ' estimated. For several years, the Building Inspection Department on Holden Beach ' has consistently recorded an average of 65 new homes being built each year — a figure that is expected to continue over the next ten-year period. Exhibit 1 shows a total of 1884 homes on the island in 1997. To arrive at a ' starting point for future permanent population projections, round that figure up to 1900 homes for CY 1999. Using the above figure of 1900 homes in 1997-1998, the number of rental ' and non -rental homes can be projected for the years following, adjusted annually based on the number of new homes built and each home's occupancy during the year. Since we are assuming that non -rental homes ' equal permanent resident homes, future permanent population estimates may be determined based on the total number of homes on the island. ' Exhibit 3 below summarizes the estimated number of permanent residents on Holden Beach from 1999 to 2008. ' Exhibit 3 (Source — see Exhibit 1) Estimated Number of Permanent Residents on Holden Beach NC (Note that these figures are for planning purposes only) Item " ' 2000 2001 2002II 114 2005 2006 2007.11: Total 1900 1965 2030 2095 2157 2222 2287 2352 2417 2482 Homes Non -rental 418 432 447 461 475 489 503 517 532 546 Homes Population 850 1 878 1 906 1 934 1 962 1 990 1 1018 1 1046 1 1074 1 1102 One factor that may cause either an upward or downward trend in the population data in Exhibit 3, involves the "fourth bullet" in the first paragraph of this section — the decision whether or not to remain on the island full-time. That decision can be affected by several factors such as the threat of hurricanes and other coastal storms, a relative lack of close -by commercial activities providing services found in larger communities, and an aging retired or semi -retired population. Holden Beach 1997 Land Use Plan Update Page 44 i� Intangibles like the above make it impossible to reliably determine any effect on population year -by -year. For example, a major hurricane in 2003 might cause a significant number of permanent residents to move off the island at that time, thereby lowering the permanent population to earlier levels. However, it is important that intangibles such as these be considered during land use planning. Seasonal Population As discussed in the previous section, Exhibit 1 shows historical peak seasonal population figures for Holden Beach. Part IV, Section "A" describes how that data was determined. Future projections for peak seasonal population may be estimated using the base data in Exhibit 1, and the criteria listed below. Criteria for estimating future peak seasonal population figures for Holden Beach are as follows: (Note: "peak season" is defined as July through the second week of August) the total number of people occupying homes on an average day — rental and non -rental, the number of people staying overnight on an average day at the campground, the average number of daily visitors. Exhibit 3 depicts the number of homes on the island year -by -year. To estimate peak seasonal occupancy, assume (on average) eight persons per rental unit, and four persons per all other homes. (Note: It is assumed for future projections that non -rental homes will have more occupants during peak periods than during the "off-season" e.g. four versus two per residence). Exhibit 4 below summarizes home occupancy, campground visitors, and daily visitors. The latter two variables are estimated in exactly the same way as was done at Exhibit 1. Specifically — the number of campground spaces times four, and the number of parking spaces on the island times four. In that regard, it is assumed that there will be no appreciable increase in the amount of public parking on the island over the next ten years. That assumption is based on a documented desire on the part of many Holden Beach residents to continue to limit public parking. (see Appendix 4). The campground has no additional space over which to expand, so it can be assumed it will remain stable in terms of peak seasonal occupancy. 0 C 1 l�� Holden Beach 1997 Land Use Plan Update Page 45 ' Exhibit 4 (Source — See Exhibit 1) Estimated Peak Seasonal Population on Holden Beach NC (Note: figures are for planning purposes only) Rental 1482 1533 1583 1634 1682 1733 1784 1835 1885 1936 Non -rental 418 432 447 461 475 489 503 517 532 546 Total Homes 1900 1965 2030 2095 2157 2222 2287 2352 2417 2482 In Homes* Rental 11856 12264 12664 13072 13456 13864 14272 14680 15080 15488 Non -Rental 1672 1728 1788 1844 1900 1956 2012 2068 2128 2184 Campground 220 220 220 220 220 220 220 220 220 220 Dail Visitors 1600 1600 1600 1600 1600 1600 1600 1600 1600 1600 Total Peak 15656 16194 16724 17262 17770 18308 18846 19384 19914 20452 * r„ u,,,,,Ac- u,, lipr of"nn_rantnl hnmes times fnim nccunants each_ All others (rental) have assumed occupancy of eight each. C. Local Objectives Concerning Growth Based on the Land Use Plan Update Public Participation Plan surveys and discussions (see Appendix 4) property owners on Holden Beach clearly wish to have the community remain as it is today — residential and family - oriented. The majority desire mainly single-family development with less multi- family and commercial development. The "vision" statement in the next part of this plan provides a concise statement of those objectives. ' While growth during the planning period is inevitable for the Town of Holden Beach, it is the desire of the community that such growth be ' controlled in ways that will continue to complement the "residential" nature of the town. ' D. Foreseeable Social and Economic Change Holden Beach should remain stable both sociologically and economically over the next several years economically, the town's assessed tax base will continue to grow, and the community should adapt to that growth ' with appropriate adjustments being made in funding of annual and long range capital improvement programs. 0 ' Holden Beach 1997 Land Use Plan Update Page 46 E. F. Future Land Needs A majority of developed and undeveloped land on Holden Beach is under private ownership. Only a small percentage of land is owned by the town — thereby limiting the ability of the community to provide additional public facilities such as improved public parking lots, scenic overlooks, parks, beach and waterway access. To address this situation, the town recently prepared a five-year Community Recreation and Beach Access Plan. In that document, recommendations were made for the town to acquire suitable land to place in public trust, create parks, beach/waterway access, and to improve public parking lots. The main limiting factor to implement these recommendations is annual funding that could be used to purchase land. Whether or not additional land is actually acquired during the planning period, an objective to do just that should remain a high priority in the Capital Improvements Plan. For example, acquisition of conservation areas would assure that fragile areas remain free from potential land development in the future. Community Facilities Demand Holden Beach relies on Brunswick County for its water supply, solid waste disposal and schools system. County planning efforts appear adequate to assure continued satisfaction of town future needs in that regard. The town's elected officials have been discussing the possibility of eventually dedicating the town's water distribution system to the county sometime in the future. Also, as discussed earlier in this plan, the town is actively involved in seeking to soon design, fund and construct a sewage collection system on the island — connecting to a regional treatment facility operated by Brunswick County. The Brunswick County School Board is giving consideration to a new elementary school in the Shallotte area that, if built, may serve Holden Beach. 0 r_ F F Holden Beach 1997 Land Use Plan Update Page 47 1 VI. POLICY STATEMENTS Background The most important part of any land use plan, particularly those prepared under North Carolina's Coastal Area Management Act (CAMA), is the formulation of specific policies regarding growth, development and management objectives. Because of regulatory requirements and local conditions, the policies that are developed attempt to strike a balance between desires and objectives of local citizens, the local government, and the objectives of the Coastal Area Management Program. Land development policies, which are based on analyses of existing conditions (including natural and manmade constraints) and projected trends, are to serve as general guides for future desired development at Holden Beach. Under CAMA, the overriding issue is that of managing growth while at the same time protecting unique coastal resources. The special resources and constraints within Holden'Beach in that regard were ' identified in the previous sections of this plan. The policy statements contained in this section address both growth management, protection, and maintenance of these resources. n Recognizing the diversities that exist among the coastal communities, the Coastal Resources Commission (CRC) requires each local government to outline specific development policies under five broad categories, each with its own subset of policy areas. The five required topics, addressed in order in this section (as lettered) are: F. Resource Protection G. Resource Production and Management H. Economic and Community Development I. Continuing Public Participation J. Storm Hazard Mitigation Although land use related policies developed under these topics cover most of the local development issues, in some cases they do not. Under these five policy topics, Holden Beach has chosen to address specific community issues within the scope of this plan. Prior to beginning discussion of the five topics, it is important to understand the significance of local CAMA policy statements and how they interact with day-to- day activities of Holden Beach. Three areas are affected. ' Holden Beach 1997 Land Use Plan Update Page 48 First, the policy statements will serve to guide the issuance of CAMA minor and major permitting as required by NCGS-1 13A-1 18 prior to undertaking any ' development in any Area of Environmental Concern. Holden Beach will adopt policies which are, at a minimum, equal to and consistent with the State's minimum use standards. The local government may, however, adopt minimum ' use standards which are stricter than the State's and the local government's stricter standards would become the determining factor whether a CAMA permit should be issued. ' The second area of application is that of establishing local policies and regulations which guide Holden Beach's growth and development. Under North Carolina ' legislation, land use plans are not regulatory controls. Policy statements must be consistent with and implemented through local land use ordinances such as zoning hearings to , or subdivision ordinances which require public prior any revisions. The final area of application is that of "Consistency Review." Proposals and ' applications for state and federal assistance or requests for agency approval of projects are normally reviewed against the jurisdiction's land use plan to determine if the project is consistent with local policies. Inconsistencies of a ' federal or state project with local policies will serve as grounds for denial or revision of a project. Many have said, "If you don't know where you are going, you will not know how ' to get there". This statement is certainly true where land use planning is concerned. One of the first actions accomplished during the development of this , plan update, was discussion, by community property owners and elected officials, of the question, "What do we want Holden Beach to look like in ten years?" To answer that question, a "vision statement" was prepared as follows. ' Community Vision Statement for the Five to Ten -Year Planning Period Based on the public participation process (see Appendix 4), it is clear that the majority of property owners and residents of Holden Beach want to see the following major objectives addressed by the community over the next five to ten- I year planning period: • Holden Beach should remain a residential/family-oriented beach community. • The town should sustain frontal dune protection and beach renourishment. , • Residents want to limit building height in the zoning ordinance. • Residents want to discourage expansion of the commercial zone or non-residential development. , • Residents want to protect fragile marshland areas and the waterway. Holden Beach 1997 Land Use Plan Update Page 49 ' P LJ Residents want to discourage duplex and multi -family development. Residents want a sewage collection system. Residents desire a water system with adequate water pressure. Considering the above and other similar information, the Town of Holden Beach approved the following vision statement in early 1998: "By the year 2008, Holden Beach, North Carolina, will have utilized available resources to maximize its full potential (within local, state and federal guidelines), to remain a tight -knit, wholesome family community that continuously focuses its present and long-range planning, economic and developmental efforts to protect and sustain: • its recreational beach, • its residential character and natural resources,. • and the supporting services of the Town (public and private) for the next generation of Town property owners and residents." There are four over -reaching imperatives within this vision statement that involve the town's continuous and necessary need to provide local governmental stewardship toward protecting the unique and fragile environment of this barrier island. Specifically, land use planning and development must focus on: sustaining a healthy estuarine and ocean water quality for future generations, • keeping shell and other fishing areas open, • maintaining the recreational beach and associated natural features, and • protecting the right of island property owners and the general public to safely enjoy all of the above. The vision statement with the four imperatives described above forms the basic community "attitude" toward resource protection and must be considered in balance with the expected and eventual growth of the community. The common threads linking all these actions are local, state and federal guidelines and regulations that are designed to assist (and control) the planning and developmental process. The key to success in this process is public education and involvement throughout. With the vision of the Town of Holden Beach in mind, policies to support realization of that vision have been approved. Each is discussed below according to the following standard format. Policy Format Policy Identification A brief summary of the issues, relevant findings and, where applicable, alternative policy responses. Holden Beach 1997 Land Use Plan Update Page 50 A. Policy Statement Statement(s) of local government policy are designed to achieve public objectives related to the I issue. Policy Implementation Method used by Holden Beach to implement policy. ' Policy identification is not policy, and does not carry the same importance as the actual policy statements. The "identification" portion is to provide background ' and rationale for the policy statements themselves. In most instances, the discussion serves to identify a problem or issue, and may present a summary of findings from other technical studies. ' The policy statements are, in fact, statements of local government principle. These policies should remain substantially unchanged during the five-year ' planning period, since alteration thereof may undermine their effectiveness in achieving intended goals and objectives — more importantly the vision. The ' policies are designed to maintain a consistent and predictable direction (over time) for local government decisions affecting local growth and development. Lastly, policy implementation is just that — how will the Town of Holden Beach ' execute planning and local governmental action that is consistent with its stated land use policy. ' With this in mind, the following policies are hereby adopted: Resource Protection ' This section addresses policies associated with natural and related man-made ' resources that are applicable to land use planning on Holden Beach. They are: 1. Appropriate Land Use in Areas of Environmental Concern ' The AEC's referred to below are presented in detail in Appendix 5. The reader should refer to this appendix to answer specific , questions about which natural resources are involved. Policy Identification ' In accordance with those policies set forth in Subchapter 7H of the ' North Carolina Administrative Code, Holden Beach realizes the importance of having a local policy of controlling (preventing or limiting) land disturbing activities within or adjacent to Areas of ' Environmental Concern as explained in Appendix 5. Holden Beach 1997 Land Use Plan Update Page 51 t n P Ll Policy Statement Part a: It is the policy of the Town of Holden Beach to conserve and manage estuarine waters, coastal wetlands, public trust areas, and shorelines, as an interrelated group ofAECs, so as to safeguard and perpetuate their biological, social, economic, and aesthetic values and to ensure that development occurring within the AECs is compatible with natural characteristics so as to minimize the likelihood of significant loss of private property and public resources. Part b: It is also the policy of the Town of Holder: Beach (following the above rationale) to properly and effectively manage development inside or adjacent to 404 wetlands, hazardous areas (see part VI, Section 'E'), and other environmentally fragile areas. Implementation The town will implement both parts of this policy through its CAMA Minor Permitting Program — which supports the State permitting authority as set forth in the CAMA. The local CAMA permitting officer will insure applications are filled out correctly and that appropriate local, state and federal guidelines are met. In addition, storm hazard planning and management procedures will be implemented and followed to control development within, specifically, the ocean hazard area. 2. Constraints to Development in Flood Prone Areas, Soil Suitability and Septic Tank Use Policy Identification The Composite Hazards Map reflects the ocean erodible AEC, CAMA V-Zone AEC and inlet hazard area and areas subject to flooding, which includes most of Holden Beach. All construction in these areas comes under the CAMA permitting process as well as Federal Flood Insurance program. As discussed in earlier sections, much of Holden Beach is made up of soil that is not suitable for septic tank use; and yet that is the type of system that is being used on the island. Based on the results of recent public information meetings and questionnaire results, the majority of Holden Beach property I Holden Beach 1997 Land Use Plan Update Page 52 7 owners would like to see local officials pursue the design and ' installation of a central sewer collection system to eliminate the need for continued use of septic tanks. ' Policy Statement It is the policy of the Tows: of Holden Beach to allow ' construction on subdivided lots with septic tanks if all federal, State and local permits are obtained. ' Implementation All septic tanks will be approved by Brunswick County Health Department on a lot -by -lot basis. 3. Protection of a Potable Water Supply ' Policy Identification I Holden Beach obtains all of its potable water from the Brunswick County Water System. ' Policy Statement ' Although the water source for the Brunswick County water system is outside the Holden Beach planning jurisdiction, Holden Beach policy is to support and encourage the protection ' of the potable water supply well sites and river in flow area through land use regulations and zoning regulations of Brunswick County and the State of North Carolina. ' Implementation I Holden Beach will continue to support the Brunswick County Health Department and County Planning Department in protection of the sources of County. I 4. Use of Package Treatment Plants ' Policy Identification In June of 1997, Holden Beach joined other Brunswick County ' beach communities by adopting a resolution asking Brunswick County Commissioners to set up a board to address the need for a ' regional sewage treatment system. Such a system would make consideration of package treatment plants unnecessary. Holden Beach 1997 Land Use Plan Update Page 53 , 1 Policy Statement Package treatment plants are not permitted, but State -approved alternative systems will be considered for individual housing units on an individual design basis. Implementation Application for these treatment systems will be made to Building Inspector and then forwarded to Planning and Zoning Board for approval. 5. Stormwater Management and Control Policy Identification Uncontrolled surface water runoff into adjacent estuarine or ocean waters can be a serious problem. In addition, flow of stormwater onto adjacent property from improperly filled or drained lots under (or following) construction of buildings creates a public nuisance and can seriously damage public and private property. The Town of Holden Beach recently adopted a comprehensive Stormwater Management Control Plan which contains a Stormwater Control Ordinance. ' Policy Statement r n H It is the policy of the Town of Holden Beach to control Stormwater runoff resulting from land development. The intent of regulations and procedures in that regard is to assure that stormwater is controlled within the limits of individual property under development so that storm runoff does not adversely affect adjacent property, and so that none directly flows into coastal waters — ocean or waterway. Implementation The Town of Holden Beach will execute procedures contained in the Stormwater Control Ordinance, and review recommendations for improved stormwater management systems contained in the recently completed Stormwater Management Control Plan. Holden Beach 1997 Land Use Plan Update Page 54 6. Marinas, Floating Homes, Moorings, Mooring Fields, Dry Stack Facilities Policy Identification I Marinas are defined as any publicly or privately owned dock, basin ' or wet boat storage facility constructed to accommodate more than 10 boats and providing any of the following services: permanent or transient docking spaces, dry storage, fueling facilities, haul -out , facilities and repair service. Floating structures are any structure, not a boat, supported by a means of flotation, designed to be used without a permanent foundation, which is intended for human ' habitation or commerce. Moorings and mooring fields are areas where boats may be tethered individually or in groups. A dry stack facility is a structure designed for temporary storage of boats, ' stacked vertically and horizontally in layers, elevated off the ground. ' Holden Beach has a single marina, but other than a few waterway moorings near the bridge, and on privately owner docks in canal areas, none of the other facilities. ' Policy Statement ' It is thepolicy o the Town of Holden Beach to prohibit the P c1' .f development of any additional marinas on the island. Dry stack storage of boats and floating home development will not be ' approved for the island. Commercial seafood vessel dockage along the Intracoastal Waterway is deemed acceptable. All moorings in that regard must conform to CAMA and State ' regulations. Implementation ' This policy will be enforced by CAMA minor and major I permitting process and the zoning ordinance. 7. Upland Excavation for Marina Basins ' Policy Identification Upland excavation of marinas is a method of creating a marina , basin within upland areas along public waterways. r Holden Beach 1997 Land Use Plan Update Page 55 , Policy Statement It is the policy of the Town of Holden Beach not to allow upland excavation for marina basins. ' Implementation ' This policy will be enforced through the town Zoning Ordinance. 8. Industrial Impact on Fragile Areas ' Policy_ Identification ' There are no industries, other than businesses associated with the "tourist" industry, located in Holden Beach, and "industrial use" is not a permitted use in the Town's zoning ordinance. Policy Statement ' It is the policy of the Town of Holden Beach to prohibit any form of industry other than that associated with tourism. The meaning ' of the word "industry" as it applies to tourism related business activities simply provides a common category reference for tourist activities. ' Policy Implementation This policy will be enforced through the town Zoning Ordinance. 9. Development of Sound and Estuarine System Islands ' Policy Identification Estuarine and spoil islands currently exist and will continue to exist at various locations on Holden Beach, primarily near the center of the island. These areas were created and are often enlarged by periodic dredging by the U.S. Army Corps of Engineers along adjacent waterways. While development in these areas may be allowed by the Zoning Ordinance, it will be carefully controlled and limited in terms of density. Policy Statement It is the policy of the Town of Holden Beach to carefully and thoroughly review proposals for development on estuarine and Holden Beach 1997 Land Use Plan Update Page 56 spoil "islands" only for residential development at low densities ' consistent with the Town's Zoning Ordinance and Subdivision Regulations. The development of these areas will be given ' preliminary approval by the Town, then the property owner must obtain all State and federal permits before seeking final review and approval for development by the Town. I Implementation The Holden Beach Zoning Ordinance, and CAMA major and ' minor permitting process will be used to enforce this policy. 10. Damage to Existing Marshes by Bulkhead Installation ' Policy Identification ' Holden Beach supports State standards and regulations for bulkheads as identified in the State's general permit for the , construction of such structures in estuarine and public trust areas. To meet the requirements for the general permit, bulkheads can be placed only along (non -ocean) shorelines void of wetland , vegetation including marsh grass and wooded swamp or where all construction will be accomplished landward of such vegetation. ' On Holden Beach, approved bulkheads have been constructed along canal lots and the waterway to prevent erosion of the shoreline due to tidal influences, boat wakes and coastal storms. , Policy Statement I It is the policy of the Town of Holden Beach to prevent damage to existing coastal and freshwater marshes as a result of , bulkhead installation. Maintenance and replacement of existing bulkheads will be permitted. Ocean front bulkheads, groins, seawalls or other shoreline , hardening erosion control structures are not permitted by the State of North Carolina and will not be allowed on Holden ' Beach. Implementation I The policy will be implemented through the CAMA major and minor permitting process, as well as adherence to U.S. Army Corps I of Engineers regulations (for freshwater wetlands). Holden Beach 1997 Land Use Plan Update Page 57 ' I� 11. Surface Water Quality Policy Identification All waters adjacent to Holden Beach along the Intracoastal Waterway are classified as "SA" waters. The Atlantic Ocean region near Holden Beach is classified as "SB" waters. Surface and subsurface water control systems are designed to curtail or halt further degradation of water quality of sound and beach waters. Provision of wastewater collection systems and an off -island treatment facility instead of the reliance upon septic tanks is regarded as a means to protect water quality. Policy Statement It is the policy of the Town of Holden Beach to seek improved stormwater runoff and other development standards and management procedures which will protect and enhance the water quality of the estuarine and ocean system. IImplementation The town will work with Brunswick County and others to design, ' fund and construct a sewage collection system on the island, and to encourage the County to provide a wastewater treatment facility ' outside the Town limits. In addition, the town will work to implement appropriate recommendations contained in the Stormwater Management Control Plan. B. Resource Production and Management This section addresses additional resources, man -related and otherwise, that affect land use planning on Holden Beach. These resources play a role in the economy of the Town, southeastern Brunswick County and North ' Carolina. For example, the beaches, marshlands and surrounding waters of Holden Beach are utilized for swimming, sunbathing, fishing, walking, exploring and boating by people from all over the world. The area is ' unique along the east coast due to the "south -facing" nature of the shoreline, and the species of plants, birds, mammals and fish located ' nearby. As such, these resources are highly valued by the Town of Holden Beach. In many coastal counties and towns, "resource production and ' management" relates to agriculture, forestry and mining activities as well as recreational and fisheries resources. For Holden Beach, onl ' Holden Beach 1997 Land Use Plan Update Page 58 recreational and fisheries resources apply, since the other categories do not , exist. The following polices are adopted: 1. Commercial and Recreational Fisheries ' Policy Identification I The abundant water, beach and marsh areas of Holden Beach are the predominant resource supporting recreational and fishing ' activities. Holden Beach recognizes the value of water quality maintenance in terms of protecting commercial and recreational fishing resources and providing clean water for other recreational ' purposes such as swimming, water skiing and boating. The water systems, beaches and marshes are also classified as Areas of Environmental Concern previously discussed. For these reasons, , Holden Beach recognizes that by protecting the water quality within its jurisdiction it is also protecting its economic base and quality of life. ' Policy Statement , It is the policy of the Town of Holder: Beach to work toward the protection and enhancement of North Carolina's sport and commercial fisheries industry. Development or any activity which ' will adversely affect coastal and estuarine waters will be prohibited. Those structures which support commercial and recreational fisheries will be allowed to be placed adjacent to , coastal and estuarine waters if all required permits are obtained. In the design, construction and operation of water dependent structures, efforts will be made to mitigate negative effects on , water quality and fish habitat, as determined by 15A NCAC 7H, the Division of Environmental Management and the Coastal Resources Commission. The developer and/or owner will bear , the cost of any such mitigation. Holder: Beach supports the N. C. Division of Marine Fisheries' ' efforts to develop regulations and policies that help protect ocean and estuarine water quality. , Holden Beach also supports the efforts of many coastal communities to restrict operation of Menhaden fishing activities to an area outside a one -mile limit of the island. , In order to expand Holden Beach's sport and commercial ' fishing, Holden Beach will permit private and public dredging activities which will positively affect those industries when all Holden Beach 1997 Land Use Plan Update Page 59 ' F federal, State and local permits are obtained. It is recognized that in dredging and stabilization activities, some fish habitat damage may occur. Only those projects which have a reasonable likelihood of providing greater benefits than damage for marine life will be supported. All dredging and stabilization projects must be performed in a manner which will do minimal damage to fish habitats. Implementation This policy will be implemented through continued enforcement of state regulations, and the CAMA major and minor permitting process. The town will continue close coordination with other North Carolina coastal communities and will work with them in concert toward common objectives. 2. Off -Road Vehicles Policy Identification .Holden Beach is concerned that the aesthetics of the beach strand and the stability of the sand dunes be maintained. The intrusion of off -road vehicles onto the strand and dunes is inconsistent with these management objectives. Holden Beach Code does not allow vehicles in the shoreline area, with the exception of public service or emergency vehicles. Policy Statement It is the policy of the Town of Holden not to allow off -road vehicles on the dunes or on the shoreline area, with the exception of public service or emergency vehicles and inherited commercial fishing right access. Implementation The Town of Holden Beach will implement this policy through enforcement of Town ordinances. 3. Residential and Commercial Development Policy Identification Holden Beach property owners have expressed a desire to see Holden Beach remain primarily a residential family -oriented community. ' Holden Beach 1997 Land Use Plan Update Page 60 C. To met that objective, the majority of property owners favor primarily residential development, with little or no increases in commercial development. However, property owners are not necessarily opposed to construction of commercial buildings — within existiniz commercial zones — so long as they are designed and built to standards compatible with other Holden Beach ' architecture. Policy Statement I It is the policy of the Town of Holden Beach to continue to support primarily residential development on the island, while , limiting any additional commercial development to the existing commercial zone. The town does not support increasing the size of the commercial zone. i Implementation The Planningand Zoning Board will be directed b Town officials g Y to carefully review applications for new commercial activity within ' the commercial zone, so as to assure that buildings are constructed along comparable architectural lines as other buildings within the community. The board will also be instructed to accept no applications that would, if approved, increase the size of any C-1 zoning district. Economic and Community Development I This section presents policy associated with the town's economy and t community development. The intent is to provide policy to guide the future growth of the community in ways that support realization of the community vision. ' 1. Community Attitude Toward Growth Policy Identification , The Town of Holden Beach experienced rapid growth since the ' 1980's. As discussed earlier in this plan, the community adopted a vision statement that is intended to guide future development. ' While growth is inevitable, property owners and elected officials seek to properly control and limit that expansion within accepted parameters. ' There are two patterns of growth on Holden Beach. "New development" and "redevelopment". Newly designed and I Holden Beach 1997 Land Use Plan Update Page 61 ' 7 constructed homes are sited on vacant lots at a rate of near sixty per year. Holden Beach has no "neighborhoods" that might be considered for redevelopment, such as might be the case in larger cities and towns — redevelopment on Holden Beach applies simply to older, single-family and multi -family homes interspersed throughout the island. For example, many older homes are often remodeled, relocated or rebuilt annually on the island for various reasons. Together, these two types of development add to the assessed tax value for the community. This increases the economic well being of the town, and allows for potential placement of funds into capital reserve to meet future contingency needs and public service growth opportunities. Policy Statement It is the policy of the Town of Holden Beach to manage the Town's growth and development in balance with the environment and the provision of municipal services, and consistent with the community vision statement. ' All new development and redevelopment will adhere to the Town Is building and development regulations and to the density requirements set forth in the Zoning Ordinance. ' Implementation ' To accomplish this goal, the Town Board of Commissioners will direct the Planning and Zoning Board to review current uses now permitted to determine if they are consistent with the desires of t Holden Beach property owners; and, if necessary, revise the Zoning Ordinance following required public hearings. 0 All applications for property redevelopment will be reviewed according to town and state regulations. 2. Local Commitment to Providing Services Policy Identification Holden Beach chooses to provide services such as volunteer fire protection, police protection, water distribution service and solid waste removal. ' Holden Beach 1997 Land Use Plan Update Page 62 3. Policy Statement It is the policy of the Town of Holden Beach to provide services such as fire protection through a volunteer fire department, police protection, water distribution service and solid waste removal. However, the town recognizes that is may be necessary to examine, during the planning period, the feasibility of eventually transferring the town -owned water distribution system to Brunswick County. Implementation The Town of Holden Beach will continue to annually fund adequate volunteer fire protection, police protection, water distribution and solid waste removal. Growth Patterns Desired Policy Identification Property owners of Holden Beach desire to see planning emphasis on growth that adheres to the community vision statement — e.g. a family -oriented residential community. In summary, the following growth principles are desired: • Control building height. • Lower building density. • Increase minimum lot size in subdivisions. • Limit development primarily to single-family homes. • Control commercial development within set architectural guidelines and within existing zones. • Protect conservation areas. Policy Statement It is the policy of the Town of Holden Beach to limit building height below 35 feet. It also the policy of the town to work to lower building density on undeveloped property on the island, and to prevent the expansion of the commercial zone while restricting new development in those zones to architectural standards set by the Board of Commissioners. The town will enforce state and local regulations involving development in or adjacent to conservation zones, and set their preservation as a long term objective. 7 0 Holden Beach 1997 Land Use Plan Update Page 63 t J Implementation The Planning and Zoning Board, Town Manager and Board of Commissioners will review existing town policy and regulations and make appropriate recommendations for changes that adhere to the above policy. The Town Manager will also work with the Planning & Zoning Board to create a standard criteria for architectural design in the commercial zone. The local government will examine the feasibility and affordability of placing land within the conservation zone under town ownership or control such that it may always remain preserved and undeveloped. 4. Redevelopment of Developed Areas Policy Identification Sometimes, redevelopment is caused by coastal storms and associated beach erosion. When a home is damaged (for whatever reason) beyond 50% of its value, it may not be possible for the property owner to rebuild if the property does not meet town and CAMA hazard setback requirements. In this case, the home/structure may be moved to another location that meets this criteria, or be subject to demolition as a public nuisance. Policy Statement It is the policy of the Town of Holder: Beach that homes and other structures may be redeveloped (rebuilt) on the same property as a result of coastal storms or other reasons, so long as they are not damaged beyond 50% of their value. If damages exceed 50% of value, then redevelopment on the same property must meet town and state requirements pertaining to hazard setback, and septic tank installation. ' Structures may be moved off property subject to erosion and relocated elsewhere so long as that movement meets the requirements of the town ordinance and building code. It is also the policy of the town that homes damaged as a result of erosion or coastal storms may be considered a public nuisance and may be subject to removal at property owner expense. ' Holden Beach 1997 Land Use Plan Update Page 64 Implementation The town will enforce its zoning and other land use ordinance to manage and control property/structure redevelopment. 5. Commitment to State and Federal Programs Policy Identification There is a need for Holden Beach to support state and federal programs which directly or indirectly enhance or improve the Town's public and private facilities. Specifically important are programs to: • assist in controlling oceanfront and waterway erosion, • provide public access facilities to recreational areas, • maintain highways and roads, • and provide dredging of adjacent waters. The above programs may, when executed, significantly complement town efforts to realize the community vision. As such, they must be supported as much as is possible and applicable. Policy Statement It is the policy of the Town of Holden Beach to support state and federal programs such as coastal area management, erosion control and mitigation, public recreational access, highway and road improvements, dredging (channel maintenance and beach renourishment), and other similar programs that may be appropriate for the town. More specifically, the town strongly supports the efforts of the U.S. Army Corps of Engineers to study the effects of reorientation of the Lockwoods Folly Inlet, and to develop an engineering plan to renourish a large percentage of beach areas on the island. The town understands the need for Corps of Engineers, maintenance dredging of adjacent waters, but seeks to control dredging so it does not directly or indirectly increase beach or waterway erosion: on the island. In all dredging cases, spoil resulting should be located on the island so as to mitigate the effects of past erosion: or to prevent additional erosion. J 7 r Holden Beach 1997 Land Use Plan Update Page 65 , i� n Implementation The Town Manager and elected officials will remain cognizant of information and planning associated with appropriate state and federal programs that may provide support in the above areas. The town will continue to execute a public information program to fully advise property owners of the basic intent and purpose of these programs, and will seek their support in that regard. 6. Tourism Policy Identification In a sense, "tourism" is at the economic heart of Holden Beach. The difference between the town's seasonal and permanent population is proof alone that "residents" are composed of people living on the island year around, and "tourists" are those who visit daily and weekly for recreational and vacation purposes. For example, compare approximately 750 permanent "residents" in January, to over 15,000 in July. This tremendous increase is due primarily because of tourism. Most new home construction on the island is devoted, in part, to rental business — for tourists. Also, the island commercial businesses receive much of their annual income from tourists, and so do those merchants and service providers located nearby Holden Beach. It is therefore essential that the town consider the impact of this "industry" upon the future of the community. In that regard, the town has enacted a 6% Occupancy Tax on gross monthly receipts from rental property. Of that amount, 1% is required to be given to Brunswick County to support tourism, 3% is used to support town tourist -related support activities, and 2% is designated as "Capital Reserves - Beach" to sustain and preserve the recreational beach — for use by tourists, the general public and property owners. Policy Statement It is the policy of the Town of Holden Beach to support and promote tourism as an essential economic activity having direct positive economic impact of future development.. ' Holden Beach 1997 Land Use Plan Update Page 66 Implementation The town will continue to collect a room occupancy tax to provide partial funding for tourist -related activities and support. The town will also work with other coastal communities in Brunswick County, through local Chambers of Commerce, to publicize and promote the unique nature of Holden Beach for family vacations. 8. Public Beach and Waterfront Access Policy Identification The Town of Holden Beach is sensitive to the need to provide appropriate public beach and waterfront access, as well as the need to maximize effective use of existing access areas. In some areas of the community, public beach access appears to be adequate, while other areas lack sufficient public access — especially that for handicapped individuals. Policy Statement It is the policy of the Tows: of Holden Beach to support the use of CAMA access grants to improve beach and Intracoastal Waterway access for all residents and public visitors. In that regard, Holden Beach supports the establishment of "No Parking" zones along the selected road rights -of -way, and public frontal dune walkways and ramps at selected points along the beach front. The Town will seek to acquire land for additional beach access locations, and to construct as many accessways as possible to American Disabilities Act standards. The town will also seek to provide sufficient Intracoastal Waterway access. Implementation Holden Beach will consider the use of CAMA planning and access grant funds and all other resources to execute projects where additional public access is needed. The town will work with property owners, through public meetings and other forums to seek consensus on where public access points should be located. Finally, the town will inform all property owners of the tax advantages of donating ocean front property to the town — property I H �I Holden Beach 1997 Land Use Plan Update Page 67 ' L 11 no longer meeting building ocean hazard area setback requirements. 9. Capital Improvements Plan Policy Identification A responsible town government should develop a long range (five- year) capital improvements plan so that projected future revenues and expenses can be analyzed to provide funds to finance capital improvement projects. Examples on Holden Beach are water distribution system additions or replacement, sewage collection systems, street and roadway improvements, parks and recreation improvements, stormwater management projects, and beach renourishment. ' Currently, the town has no capital improvements plan; however, the Board of Commissioners has directed the Town Manager to prepare one prior to the end of CY 1998. When this necessary ' document is approved, the town will have a valuable planning document future financial to guide allocation of resources. Policy Statement It is the policy of the Town of Holden Beach to prepare a Five - Year Capital Improvements Plan prior to preparing the 1999- 2000 operating budget. ' Implementation The Town Manager will prepare the Capital Improvements Plan for official town review before the end of CY 1998. D. Continuing Public Participation The of this section is to discuss the involvement of property purpose P owners from Holden Beach in the development of this land use plan ' update. Unlike prior sections, there is only one policy statement contained herein. IPolicy Identification ' Communications and public education about land use planning on Holden Beach is key to the successful development of a plan that has credibility with those it is designed to support. To meet that objective, several public Holden Beach 1997 Land Use Plan Update Page 68 meetings for property owners were conducted to obtain public comment, and to answer questions concerning the desired future of Holden Beach. ' In addition, the town sent two lengthy questionnaires to property owners during the land use plan update process and asked them to answer a series of questions designed to gain public opinion on important land use topics , and issues. Response rates from both questionnaires were excellent — the second questionnaire was mailed to approximately 1500 property owners, with more than half responding. Appendix 4 contains the survey data. , In addition to the public information meetings and the two planning questionnaires, the Planning and Zoning Board and Board of ' Commissioners were involved to discuss the results of the public participation process and to obtain guidance on how that data was to be used. ' In summary, the results of public participation meetings and questionnaires helped establish issues, goals and objectives and, as a ' result, policy to develop land use goals and objectives as they apply to Holden Beach. , The public participation process must continue after formal adoption of the Land Use Plan Update, so as to assure that property owners remain involved in helping its ' guide the town toward realization of vision. Policy Statement I It is the policy of the Town of Holden Beach to continue to include Holden Beach property owners in the land use planning process, so they , may express their views and concerns, and to broaden their knowledge of planning issues. It shall also be Holden Beach policy to review the policy and implementation section of this Land Use Plan, once adopted, ' on an annual basis to review how policy implementation is taking place. Implementation I The Town Manager will review policy implementation with the Board of Commissioners at the first meeting in January each year prior to the next I land use plan update. E. Storm Hazard Mitigation and Post Disaster Recovery and Evacuation ' Plans Perhaps nothing in the way of planning is more important on a barrier ' island off the coast of North Carolina than is coastal storm preparedness Holden Beach 1997 Land Use Plan Update Page 69 ' I and damage control/n1itigation. This section addresses these two topics in reverse order. 1. Storm Hazard Mitigation Policy Identification During coastal storms, Holden Beach is potentially subject to severe island flooding, beach erosion, storm surge wave action, and high winds. Due to Holden Beach's east -west orientation along the coast line, northeast storms will not have a pronounced effect on the beach in terms of heavy wave action, as the prevailing winds will pass over the beach from the mainland, thereby somewhat attenuating the wind effects of the storm on water surge. Southeast arriving storms have the opposite and more damaging effect. Flooding and beach erosion due to high tides are possible regardless of storm direction. Moreover the entire Town of Holden Beach is susceptible to significant storm damage from a hurricane. Currently, all of the island is located in Areas of Environmental Concern and/or in areas susceptible to flooding associated with the 100-year storm. ' The Town of Holden Beach annually updates its Storm Hazard Mitigation, Evacuation and Post Disaster Recovery Plan. The plan addresses the need to minimize potential dangers, ensures effective ' evacuation when necessary, and allows for a safe and orderly island re-entry by property owners following a storm. ' Composite Hazards Map and Land Use Affected The Composite Hazards Map consists of the CAMA (V-Zone) ' AEC, Inlet Hazard Areas and Ocean Erodible Areas of Environmental Concern. The latter are discussed in Appendix 5. F_ L Policy Statement In the following categories, it is the policy of the Town of Holden Beach to plan accordingly for: High Winds — Holden Beach supports enforcement of tl:e N. C. State Building Code. The Town will continue to enforce the State Building Code on wind resistant construction with design standards of from 120 to 150 mph wind loads. Flooding and Storm Surge — Holden Beach is an active participant in the National Flood Insurance Program and is supportive of hazard mitigation elements. Holden Beach is participating in the regular phase of the insurance program. ' Holden Beach 1997 Land Use Plan Update Page 70 Holden Beach also supports continued enforcement of the CAMA and 404 wetlands development permit processes in areas potentially susceptible to flooding. Wave Action and Shoreline Erosion — Holden Beach is supportive of the CAMA development permit process for estuarine shoreline areas and the requisite development standards which encourage both shoreline stabilization and facilitation of proper drainage. Development in Hazardous Areas — The Town of Holden Beach shalt continue to discourage high -intensity uses and large structures being constructed within the 100 year floodplain, erosion prone areas, and other locations susceptible to hurricane and flooding hazards. Public Acquisition of Hazardous Areas — The Town of Holden Beach shall consider purchasing parcels located in hazard areas or rendered unbuildable by storms or other events, for the purpose of public water access and conservation of open: space if funding, including State or federal funding, is available. Implementation These policies will be implementation through applicable codes, ordinances, regulations and forms of available funding. 2. Evacuation Plans Policy Identification The purpose of the Hurricane Evacuation Plan is to identify actions taken by the public during a hurricane emergency to minimize danger, to ensure orderly and coordinated evacuation of the island, to identify the basic actions and procedures to be followed by the Town officials, and to assist in an orderly recovery following the emergency. Policy Statement It is the policy of the Town of Holden Beach to provide for an orderly and timely evacuation: of Tows: property owners and visitors during a declared emergency by following established procedures set forth by the Holden Beach Evacuation Plan and by the Brunswick County Emergency Management Agency. 1 Holden Beach 1997 Land Use Plan Update Page 71 ' I� U IJ 7- L Implementation The town will follow its storm preparedness plan 3. Post Disaster Recovery Policy Identification Holden Beach's Hurricane Evacuation Plan states the Town's recovery and reconstruction policies. This plan also outlines the sequence of procedures to be followed to meet State and federal disaster relief regulations including the organization of a Damage Assessment Team, criteria for assessing the damage, and the organization of recovery operations. The reconstruction policies outline the procedures for allowing residents to return to their properties, the issuance of building permits and the restoration of public facilities. Policy Statement It is the policy of the Town of Holden Beach to follow the Hurricane Preparedness Plan for Holden Beach in coordination with the Brunswick County Emergency Services Agency. Implementation The Town of Holden Beach shall continue to improve on its present plans for evacuation, recovery and reconstruction as well as support planning efforts by the Brunswick County Emergency Services Agency. VII. LAND CLASSIFICATION A land classification system has been devised as a means of assisting in the implementation of the local policies adopted pursuant to Rule .0212 of Section T15A: 07B .0200 of the North Carolina Administrative Code. By delineating land classes on a map, local government and its citizens can specify those areas where certain policies (local, state and federal) will apply. The land classification system should be supported by and be consistent with zoning, subdivision and other local growth management tools. Although specific areas are outlined on a land classification map, land classification is merely a tool to help implement policies and not, in the strict sense of the term, a regulatory mechanism. (See note on Land Classification Map.) ' Holden Beach 1997 Land Use Plan Update Page 72 A. 1. Land Classification Definitions The land classification system set forth by the CAMA Guidelines includes seven major categories: Developed, Urban Transition, Limited Transition, Community, Rural, Rural with Services, and Conservation. In preparing the Land Classification Map for Holden Beach, two of the seven land classifications have been used, specifically Developed and Conservation; with a third classification identified by Holden Beach officials, specifically Low Density Development Area; all of which are defined below. The definitions below are derived, in part, from CAMA guidelines. Developed a. Policy and Planning Emphasis. On Holden Beach, the Developed classification applies to areas where minimal undeveloped land remains and where redevelopment and controlled growth continues. The area has utility and other municipal services available and includes mixed land uses such as single-family residential, multi -family residential and commercial uses. Population densities within this area are seasonal, with the highest density occurring from June through October. The planning emphasis within this classification area is to allow for controlled growth and development according to policy guidance and regulations contained in applicable Town Code. b. Purpose. The purpose of the Developed class is to provide for continued development and redevelopment of existing cities, towns and their urban environs. C. Description and characteristics. Areas meeting the intent of the Developed classification are currently urban in character where minimal undeveloped land remains and have in place, or are scheduled for the timely provision of, the usual municipal or public services. Urban in character includes mixed land uses such as residential, commercial, industrial, institutional and other uses at high to moderate densities. Services include water, sewer, recreational facilities, streets and roads, police and fire protection. In some instances an area may not have all the traditional urban services in place, but if it otherwise has a developed character and is scheduled for the timely provision of these services, it still meets the intent of this classification if they contain a density of three or more dwelling units per acre; a u Holden Beach 1997 Land Use Plan Update Page 73 , majority of lots of 15,000 square feet or less, which are provided or scheduled to be provided with the traditional urban services; or have permanent population densities that are high and seasonal populations that may swell significantly. 2. Low Density Development Area a. Policy and Planning Emphasis. On Holden Beach, the Low Density Development Area classification applies to those land areas upon which spoil dredged from the Intracoastal Waterway by the Corps of Engineers is placed (Rural Special Use - RS, on Holden Beach Zoning Map, or Rural District - R, for single-family dwellings at 2.5 units per acre).The area may be adjacent to the Corps of Engineers right-of-way along the waterway. The planning emphasis within this classification is to identify a segment of land on the island that is used to place dredge spoil, or land that may be suitable for low density single-family development. If land within the RS zoned area of the classification contains sufficient dredge spoil that it might be considered appropriate for future development (assuming local, state and federal permits could be obtained), then these land areas could be considered for single-family development according to applicable Town Code and density limit of 2.5 units per acre. b. Purpose. The Low Density Development Area classification includes land areas established primarily for use by Corps of Engineers spoil activities or for single family development at a maximum of 2.5 units per acre over areas suitable for building per state and local regulations — buildings must be sited according to low building density policy discussed earlier in this plan ( Part VI, C, 3). Single family development shall not be located in areas defined as Coastal Wetlands AEC. Any proposed development in this classification must be consistent with all local zoning ordinance and must obtain all local, state and federal permits including road and utility extension. 3. Conservation a. Policy and Planning Emphasis. On Holden Beach, the Conservation classification applies to all land areas that contain coastal and other wetlands, marshlands and beach Holden Beach 1997 Land Use Plan Update Page 74 and Intracoastal Waterway shoreline areas of environmental concern. The planning emphasis within this classification is to protect and preserve the natural integrity of a fragile, irreplaceable and unique barrier island environment, while at the same time providing open space with scenic views afforded to adjacent property owners and others who visit the island. b. Purpose. The purpose of the Conservation class is to provide for the effective long-term management and protection of significant, limited or irreplaceable areas. Management is needed due to the natural, cultural, recreational, scenic or natural productive values of both local and more than local concern. The primary intent of the Conservation class is to provide protection for the fragile resources that involve, in part AECs. Land Classification Map The Land Classification Map is divided into three classifications which are Developed, Low Density Development Areas and Conservation. The Developed classification includes land area at Holden Beach that is either currently developed or where minimal undeveloped land remains. There are 12 Low Density Development Areas shown on the Land Classification Map, which all occur on the northern side of the island adjacent to the Intracoastal Waterway. The land in this classification includes areas used for dredge spoil or areas zoned Rural District on the Holden Beach Zoning Map. The Conservation classification is made up of coastal wetlands, estuarine waters or inlet hazard AEC areas found at the western and eastern end of the island. The Land Classification Map is for general use only. Final determination of location for Conservation or Low Density Development Area Classification shall be made by the responsible federal, state or local official having regulatory authority and such determination shall be made based on a field investigation of any area in question. U I E Holden Beach 1997 Land Use Plan Update Page 75 , VIII. INTERGOVERNMENTAL COORDINATION AND IMPLEMENTATION • To prepare the 1997 Land Use Plan Update, there has been discussion with County Planning staff about issues such as a possible ETJ or annexation of the NC 130 commercial corridor on the north side of the Holden Beach bridge. • To address the need for a central sewage system and storm drainage system, Holden Beach officials are coordinating with Brunswick County in their efforts to investigate a regional central sewer system and storm drainage plan. If a regional sewer system is found to be feasible, there will be a great deal of coordination required between local governments to implement such a system. • Holden Beach officials are also working with other Brunswick County beach communities in a coordinated effort to receive grant funds for renourishment of the beach front and frontal dunes. IX. PUBLIC PARTICIPATION DURING LAND USE PLAN UPDATE (See Appendix 4) Holden Beach 1997 Land Use Plan Update Page 76 1 APPENDIX] 1990 HOLDEN BEACH LAND USE PLAN Summary of the Policy Section This is a summary of some of the major points in the 1990 Land Use Plan. 6.1 Resource Protection 6.1.1 Areas of Environmental Concern Holden Beach will support and enforce through its delegated CAMA permitting authority the State policies and permitted uses in the Areas of Environmental Concern (AEC's). 6.1.2 The Estuarine System Holden Beach will promote conservation and management of the estuarine system. The management objective for the system shall be to give highest priority to the protection and coordinated management of all the elements as an interrelated group of AEC's in order to safeguard and perpetuate the above states values. Permitted land uses in these areas shall be those which are water dependent • Coastal Wetlands: Acceptable land uses may include utility easements, fishing piers, and docks. Unacceptable uses may include, but would not be limited to, restaurants, businesses, residences, apartments, motels, hotels, floating homes, parking lots, private roads, and highways. • Estuarine Waters: Holden Beach shall promote the conservation and quality of this resource. Appropriate uses may include simple access channels, structures which prevent erosion, navigational channels, boat docks, piers, and mooring pilings. Holden Beach supports projects in estuarine water areas which aim to increase the productivity of these waters. • Public Trust Areas: In the absence of overriding public benefit, any use which significantly interferes with the public right of navigation or other public trust rights which apply in the area shall not be allowed. • Estuarine Shoreline: Holden Beach supports the Division of Coastal Management and the U. S. Army Corps of Engineers in their efforts to " I I 1 L Holden Beach 1997 Land Use Plan Update Page 77 7 preserve the Estuarine Shoreline AEC, their dredging operations, and their efforts to find suitable locations for spoil material. Residential and recreational land uses are all appropriate types of use along the estuarine shoreline, provided that all standards of NCAC 15 Subchapter 7H relevant to estuarine shoreline AEC's are met. • Ocean Hazard Areas: Holden Beach supports the State policies for ocean hazard areas in Subchapter 7H of the State CAMA regulations. The ocean hazard area designation for Holden Beach includes the AEC's of ocean erodible areas, high hazard flood areas, and inlet hazard areas. Residential, commercial, and recreational land uses are also acceptable types of use in ocean hazard areas provided that: (1) for small structures such as residences, setback measurements begin at the first line of stable vegetation and continue inland to a depth 30 times the average annual rate of erosion. • Natural Cultural, and Historic Resource Areas: Holden Beach will support and protect natural, cultural, and historic resources found in the Town. These resources will be protected for their scientific, educational, or associative values, and for any aesthetic qualities. The Town of Holden Beach does not currently have any identified or listed natural, cultural, or historic resources of State or federal significance. • Industrial Impacts on Fragile Areas: Holden Beach supports protective ' measures and use standards which would prevent industrial development impacts to fragile areas, including appropriate planning and zoning ordinances governing such industrial development. • Water Supply Areas: Holden Beach recognizes that future demand for water supply may require consideration of using additional existing areas within ' Holden Beach to meet potential water supply needs. • Waters With Special Values: Currently there are no waters specifically ' designated as Outstanding Resource Waters (ORW) within the Town of Holden Beach. Holden Beach supports protective measures and use standards to prevent adverse impacts to waters identified as having special values. ' • Man -Made Hazards: There have been no man-made hazards identified during the planning process for Holden Beach. ' Holden Beach 1997 Land Use Plan Update Page 78 6.1.3 Stormwater Runoff The Town of Holden Beach supports North Carolina Stormwater Control ' Regulations. 6.1.4 Development of Sound and Estuarine System Islands ' It is the policy of Holden Beach to review proposals for development on nearby ' estuarine "islands" only for residential development at densities consistent with the Town's zoning ordinance and the policies of this land use plan. 6.1.5 Marinas ' The Town of Holden Beach discourages the development of any marinas, including upland marinas in excavated basins, on the barrier island. Dry storage of boats by individual owners is encouraged. Commercial seafood vessel dockage ' along the AIWW is deemed acceptable. The Town will carefully review all marine related use development proposals for consistency with this policy. 6.1.6 Floating Homes I The Town of Holden Beach does not allow floating home development of any ' type. 6.1.7 Rising Sea Level ' The Town will consider any State and federal policies formulated prior to formulating specific policies regarding sea level rise. ' 6.1.8 Bulkheads, Groins. Jetties and Seawalls , New bulkheads, groins, seawalls, or other shoreline hardening erosion control structures are not permitted on the oceanfront according to NC CAMA regulations. Holden Beach will fully comply with State regulations. ' 6.1.9 Potable Water Supply Holden Beach's potable water is supplied by the Brunswick County water system described herein before. The Town encourages and supports water conservation practices. Holden Beach requires all new development to tie into its system for ' potable water supply and prohibits individual wells for potable use. 0 Holden Beach 1997 Land Use Plan Update Page 79 , I H d 6.1.10 Wastewater Treatment and Disposal The Town of Holden Beach supports safe and adequate wastewater treatment and disposal without pollution of groundwater or surrounding waters. It is the policy of Holden Beach to discourage the use of package sewage treatment plants largely due to problems commonly related to long term operation and maintenance by private entities. 6.1.11 Solid Waste Disposal It is the policy of Holden Beach to have this service provided in an efficient, safe and sanitary manner. Holden Beach presently uses the County landfill for solid waste disposal. 6.1.12 Storm Drainage Growth and development will not be allowed where poor drainage exists unless appropriate corrective improvements are to be completed as part of the project. The Town will work towards developing a master plan for improving stormwater drainage on the island. 6.1.13 Bearing Capacity Growth and development will be discouraged in areas where soils will not adequately support buildings. 6.2 Resource Production and Management 6.2.1. Commercial and Recreational Fisheries Holden Beach will encourage the preservation and expansion of its fisheries industry, both sport and commercial. Holden Beach respects inherited rights of access for commercial fisherman to retrieve their catch from the beach. Any development which will profoundly and/or adversely affect coastal and estuarine waters will be discouraged. Holden Beach will support private and public projects which will positively affect sport and commercial fisheries industries. Holden Beach supports State and federal channel and inlet dredging projects which will increase the water access for fishing boats. ' Holden Beach 1997 Land Use Plan Update Page 80 6.2.2 Productivity I Holden Beach supports projects and activities which increase productivity of ' coastal and estuarine waters. Holden Beach supports the Brunswick County Shellfish Action Plan. Holden Beach will support and assist the Division of Marine Fisheries in its ' Fisheries Management Enforced Activities. 6.2.3 OfRoad Vehicles and Vehicles on Beach Areas , Holden Beach discourages the operation of off road vehicles in the island's ' undeveloped, natural areas. All such vehicles are prohibited from the beach and dune areas year round. 6.3 Economic Growth and Community Development The Town of Holden Beach supports the development of single family residences ' with low to medium density, providing there are no negative impacts to neighboring land uses or the natural environment. Any commercial development , will be limited and intended to accommodate the needs of island residents. 6.3.1 Industry ' Holden Beach will encourage industrial development in the area of Brunswick County, but only outside its town limits. 6.3.2 Transportation Holden Beach supports any transportation improvement or program that will benefit the people of Holden Beach. 6.3.3 Tourism , The Town of Holden Beach recognizes the importance and necessity of , summer/seasonal residential tourists in houses (rental) and properly managed camping facilities. However, it is the policy of the Town to not promote or encourage commercial/hotel development to accommodate tourists. Holden ' Beach does not want to promote "high intensity" tourism. 6.3.4 Beach and Water Access ' Holden Beach supports the spending of tax money to improve beach access for all residents and visitors. The Town will continue to improve and maintain its existing beach access facilities. Holden Beach 1997 Land Use Plan Update Page 81 ' Holden Beach supports the establishment of additional official beach access points with designated parking lots when and where the need is demonstrated. 6.3.5 Commitment to Federal and State Programs The Town of Holden Beach supports the U. S. Army Corps of Engineers in the maintenance dredging of the Atlantic Intracoastal Waterway, the Lockwoods Folly and Shallotte Inlets, and in the renourishment of the region's beaches. 6.3.6 Channel Maintenance and Beach Erosion Control The Town supports the development of a special tax district to finance the maintenance dredging of its canals, and will work to establish such a district in the coming fiscal year. Holden Beach supports the continuation of the dune restoration and planting program. Funds for dune restoration/shoreline protection will be allocated in the Town's annual budget. The Town also supports and encourages the deposition of suitable spoil from dredging projects onto nearby shorelines for beach renourishment and erosion control. 6.3.7 Growth Patterns ' Holden Beach's policy is to discourage large incremental amounts of growth and development and large increases in population. Low to medium density residential growth is preferred. ' It is the policy of the Town to consider exercising extraterritorial jurisdiction on the mainland adjacent to Holden Beach only as future circumstances warrant. ' 6.3.8 Housing and Property ' Holden Beach will encourage seasonal and permanent single family residences at low to medium densities. Holden Beach will encourage the development of any individual residential projects over three acres as planned unit developments. The Town will maintain its 35-foot building height limitation. Reconstruction or relocation of structures threatened, damaged or destroyed by ' coastal storms will proceed according to State CAMA requirements and the Storm Hazard Mitigation - Post Disaster Recovery and Evacuation Plans. ' Holden Beach 1997 Land Use Plan Update Page 82 6.3.9 Energy Facility Siting and Development The Town of Holden Beach supports the State policies on offshore continental shelf drilling for oil and gas. The location of any shoreside OCS facilities at Holden Beach would be inappropriate and is strongly discouraged. 6.3.10 Government Agency Planning and Development Holden Beach has an interest in any planning and development by other government agencies. Prior to any decisions by the U. S. Army Corps of Engineers that impact the location of the Atlantic Intracoastal Waterway right-of- way line, the Town of Holden Beach shall be notified in writing. 6.4. Storm Hazard Mitigation -- Post Disaster Recovery and Evacuation Plan 6.4.1 Storm Hazard Mitigation Policies These policies meet the requirements for storm hazard mitigation planning outlined in the publication Before the Storm.2./ 6.4.3 Post Disaster Recovery PUSHING SAND TO RESTORE DUNE - - Before any sand can be pushed on the strand to restore the dune, a dune line must be established by CAMA. Holden Beach 1997 Land Use Plan Update Page 83 ' APPENDIX 2 (Note: This Appendix contains items required by State Guidelines for preparation: of ' Land Use Plans. Items contained herein are not applicable to Holden Beach, but are listed for information purposes.) ' Land Suitability Constraints Not Applicable to Holden Beach As Required by Guidelines for Preparation of Land Use Plans in the State of North Carolina a. Man-made Hazard Areas Including Airports, Tank Farms, and Nuclear Power Plants ' Holden Beach does not contain an airport, tank farms or nuclear power plant. ' b. Water Supply Including Groundwater Recharge Areas, Public Water Supply Watershed and Well Fields Small surface water supply watersheds are catchment areas situated entirely within the coastal area which contain a water body classified as A -II by the Environmental Management Commission. The maximum beneficial use of these ' bodies of water is to serve as public water supply areas. Public water supply well fields are areas of well -drained sands that extend ' downward from the surface into the shallow ground water table which supplies the public with potable water. These surface well fields are confined to a readily definable geographic area as identified by the North Carolina Department of Environment and Natural Resources with assistance and support from affected local governments. ' The Water Supply Protection Rules adopted in 1992 required that all local governments having land use jurisdiction within water supply watersheds adopt and implement water supply watershed protection ordinances, maps and a ' management plan. Municipalities with populations less than 5,000 were to submit their ordinances by October 1, 1993. Holden Beach does not have a water supply watershed or well fields within its municipal boundary; therefore, ' a Watershed Protection Ordinance is not applicable to Holden Beach. ' Fragile Area Definitions Not on Holden Beach As Required by Guidelines for Preparation of Land Use Plans in the State of North Carolina ' Complex Natural Areas ' Coastal complex natural areas are defined as lands that support native plant and animal communities and provide habitat qualities which have remained essentially unchanged by human activity. Such areas may be Holden Beach 1997 Land Use Plan Update Page 84 either significant components of coastal systems or especially notable habitat areas of scientific, educational, or aesthetic value. They may be surrounded by landscape that has been modified but does not drastically alter conditions within the natural area. Such areas may have been altered by human activity and/or subject to limited future modifications, e.g. the placement of dredge spoil, if the CRC determines that the modifications benefit the plant or animal habitat or enhance the biological, scientific or educational values which will be protected by designation as an AEC. There are no known complex natural areas on Holden Beach. e. Areas that Sustain Remnant Species Coastal areas that sustain remnant species are those areas that support native plants and animals which are threatened to be rare or endangered. There are no known areas on Holden Beach that sustain remnant species. f. Areas Containing Unique Geologic Formations Unique coastal geologic formations are defined as sites that contain geologic formations that are unique or otherwise significant components of coastal systems, or that are especially notable examples of geologic formations or processes in the coastal area. There are no known unique coastal geologic formations on Holden Beach. g. Scenic and Prominent High Points There are three scenic points on the northern side of Ocean View Boulevard with beautiful vistas of extensive marsh areas. There are no known designated prominent high points on Holden Beach. h. Historic and Archaeoloizical Sites Significant coastal historic architectural resources are defined as districts, structures, buildings, sites or objects that have more than local significance to history or architecture. Such areas will be evaluated by the North Carolina Historical Commission in consultation with the CRC. There are no known historic sites on Holden Beach. Significant coastal archaeological resources are defined as areas that contain archaeological remains (objects, features and/or sites) that have more than local significance to history or prehistory. Such areas will be I I r Holden Beach 1997 Land Use Plan Update Page 85 , ' evaluated by the North Carolina Historical Commission in consultation with the CRC. ' There are no known archaeological sites on Holden Beach. ' Areas Identified Throz«h DEHR'S Natural Heritage Program The North Carolina Natural Heritage Program of the Division of Parks and ' Recreation works to identify and facilitate protection of the most ecologically significant natural areas remaining in the State. Natural areas may be identified because they provide important habitat for rare species ' or because they contain outstanding examples of the rich natural diversity of this State. ' The North Carolina Department of Environment and Natural Resources, Division of Parks and Recreation, Natural Heritage Program in cooperation with the N.C. Center for Geographic Information and ' Analysis, developed the Natural Areas digital data to determine the areas containing ecologically significant natural communities or rare species. This data was created to assist governmental agencies and others in ' making resource management decisions through use of a Geographic Information System (GIS). ' The Natural Heritage GIS map has no natural heritage areas identified on Holden Beach; however, three areas have been identified on the mainland ' north of Holden Beach and outside the Town Limits. Areas with Resource Potential Not Found on Holden Beach As Required by Guidelines for Preparation of ' Land Use Plans in the State of North Carolina ' a. Productive and Unique Agricultural Lands Based on the Prime Farmland Map prepared by the Division of Coastal ' Management dated October 21, 1996, there are no productive, unique or prime farmlands on Holden Beach. b. Potentially Valuable Mineral Sites There are no known mineral sites on Holden Beach. C. Publicly Owned Forests There are no known publicly owned forest areas on Holden Beach. d. Parks There are no State park sites on Holden Beach. There is one regional CAMA access area located under the Holden Beach access bridge. ' Holden Beach 1997 Land Use Plan Update Page 86 e. Fish and Game Lands Holden Beach does not contain any game lands. The Atlantic Ocean is suitable for fishing with an SB water classification. The Intracoastal Waterway has an SA water classification and is suitable for recreational fishing and shell -fishing. f. Non -Intensive Outdoor Recreation Lands The only non -intensive outdoor recreation areas at Holden Beach include the beachfront, with CAMA access points and the regional access area on the Intracoastal Waterway. g. Privately Owned Wildlife Sanctuaries There are no known privately owned wildlife sanctuaries on Holden Beach. Holden Beach is considered a bird sanctuary. h. Prime Farm Land (Consistent with Governor's Executive Order Number 96) There are no prime farm lands on Holden Beach based on the Prime Farmland Map prepared by DCM and dated October 21, 1996. Holden Beach 1997 Land Use Plan Update Page 87 ' APPENDIX 3 Soils Map 1 1 1 ' Holden Beach 1997 Land Use Plan Update Page 88 APPENDIX 4 Land Use Plan Update Survey Information Background: A Public Participation Plan for the Holden Beach land use planning process was presented and adopted by the Holden Beach Board of Commissioners during a regular meeting held on November 19, 1996. Prior to the adoption of the Plan, the first Public Information Meeting was advertised and held on October 21, 1996. Approximately 47 residents or property owners from Holden Beach were present. A private consultant opened the meeting by briefly discussing the purpose of the Land Use Plan Update. He then asked those present the question, "What would you like to see happen at Holden Beach during the next five- to ten-year planning period to make it a better place in which to live?" Using a flip chart, each response was written down and posted around the room on the wall. Following this process, each person was given five stickers and asked to place their stickers next to the five items or issues that are of the greatest importance to them. Based on that process, of those present at the meeting the following emerged as the top ten priorities. Priority Order Issue Number of Votes 1 Addressing (site specific) erosion concerns 47 2 Immediate plan for sewer system and stormwater 40 3 Density restrictions/building height restrictions 17 4 Define what Town will permit regarding reconstruction of dunes and buildings, etc., after disaster (hurricane) 16 5 Adequate water distribution and pressure 14 6 Limit commercial development 12 7 Playground/Park 11 8 Marshland preservation 10 9 Availability of insurance 8 10 Annexation of causeway and adjacent 4 areas It was apparent from comments made at the meeting and the priorities shown above that the main concerns of those present were erosion of the beach from two recent hurricanes, need for immediate plans to address sewer system and storm drainage, density of development, reconstruction of dunes and buildings damaged by hurricanes, and water distribution and pressure. J 1 L J 1 1 Holden Beach 1997 Land Use Plan Update Page 89 , Other items of concern that ranked six through ten included placing limits on ' commercial development, need for playground/park, protection of marshlands, availability of insurance, and annexation of causeway and adjacent areas. ' Because many of the property owners at Holden Beach are not permanent residents, a special meeting was held on Saturday, November 30, 1996, during the Thanksgiving weekend, to give out-of-town property owners the opportunity to ' participate in the planning process. Approximately 78 people attended this public information meeting. ' The Consultant briefly outlined the purpose of the Land Use Plan and then asked what those present like about Holden Beach and what they would like to see ' changed during the five- to ten-year planning period. Mr. Robert Lineberger, a member of the Board of Directors of the Holden Beach ' Property Owners Association, Inc., read a statement from there organization of over 500 property owners that included the following concerns. Concern about environment and quality of life. ' • Most concerns are caused by growth. • Searching for ways to assure less growth, or quality growth, as opposed to quantity growth. ' Property values have skyrocketed. Concern that local, State and federal authorities are doing a ' responsible job of protecting and preserving the marshlands, wetlands and beach environment. Instead of spending millions of dollars for a sewer system for Holden ' Beach, that money be used to enforce septic tank regulations and to purchase empty marshlands and other property. They fear increased density, more growth, high rises, more ' commercial activity and more building lots. Following the reading of a statement, those present raised issues that ranged from ' retaining the beach (erosion), erosion at east end of beach, need to retain area as family beach, need for public access along Intracoastal Waterway, to need for landscape beautification. ' As a follow-up to the November 30, 1996, meeting, the Holden Beach Property Owners Association, Inc., sent out a Public Participation Survey to all members ' asking them to check five items of greatest importance to them. These issues were based on the comments made by those in attendance at the November 30 meeting. There were 211 Public Participation Surveys mailed back in response to the ' February 1997 newsletter from Holden Beach Property Owners Association, Inc. The "number one" concern is that Holden Beach remain a residential/family beach, with 159 out of 211 responses, or 75%, expressing a concern about this ' Holden Beach 1997 Land Use Plan Update Page 90 issue. The second highest response was that Town officials should retain existing height requirements for buildings. Out of 211 surveys returned, 106, or 50%, expressed this concern. The top concerns expressed are listed -below, ranked one through ten: 1 Holden Beach should remain a residential/family beach. (159) 2. Town authorities should retain existing height requirements for buildings. (106) 3. Searching for ways to assure less growth, or quality growth, as opposed to quantity growth. (67) 4. Concern that local, State and federal authorities are not doing a responsible job of protecting and preserving the marshlands, wetlands and beach environment. (60) 4. (Tie) Do not expand commercial development. (60) 5. Concern about retaining the beach. (57) 6. Instead of spending millions of dollars for a sewer system for Holden Beach, that money be used to enforce septic tank regulations and to purchase empty marshlands and other property. (48) 7. Maintain marsh and wildlife. (46) 7. (Tie) We should spend money to renourish the beach. If you wish to be at Holden Beach, you must be willing to pay for renourishment of dunes. (46) 8. Rental property should be restricted to two persons per bedroom. Frequently rental property has more than two persons per bedroom, which may be part of septic tank problems on beach. (44) 9. Lockwoods Inlet dredging may be causing erosion at Holden Beach. (39) 10. Concern about environment and quality of life. (32) NOTE. Number in parentheses indicates number of responses out of 211 survey forms returned. Other issues included east and west end of island for access (23 responses), work to place power lines underground (26 responses), and concern that marsh is being filled (30 responses). C 1 Holden Beach 1997 Land Use Plan Update Page 91 Following a review of the Holden Beach Property Owners Association, Inc., survey, the Holden Beach Planning and Zoning Board wanted to give all property owners the opportunity to participate in the planning process. A two -page planning questionnaire with questions gleaned from issues raised at the October 21 and November 30 public meetings was prepared. Due to changes in Town administration, the questionnaire did not go out to citizens until June, with a return date of July 11, 1997.One thousand five hundred questionnaires were mailed to all Holden Beach property owners, with over one-half being returned, which is an excellent response rate. Of the questionnaires returned, 76%, or 516, were from non -permanent resident ' property owners. Twenty-four percent, or 242, were from permanent resident property owners. Some of the major issues of concern follow. ' Issue — Central Sewer System (Ouestion 2) When asked abut developing a central sewer system for Holden Beach, 79% of non -permanent and 72% of permanent residents favor development of a central sewer system. This was the number two priority at the October 21, 1996, public information meeting. Issue — Beach Erosion (Ouestion 6) Four hundred non permanent property owners, or 78%, indicated that they would favor Town officials establishing a program to provide on -going beach renourishment. One hundred fourteen, or 83%, of the permanent residents responding to the question favored such a program. Renourishment of beach was also a high priority based on results of responses to the Holden Beach Property Owners Association, Inc. survey, with 46 responses out of 211. Issue — Extraterritorial Planning Jurisdiction (ETJ) for Commercial Area on Mainland (Question 7) Ninety-three, or 69%, of the permanent residents answering this question favor an ETJ area being established along the mainland commercial corridor leading to Holden Beach. Of the non -permanent residents responding to this question, 395, or 78%, agree. Issue —Annexation of Commercial Corridor on Mainland Side o Bridge (Question 8) Seventy-eight percent, or 395 non -permanent property owners responding to question 8 favored annexation of mainland commercial corridor to increase Holden Beach tax base. Fifty-seven percent, or 79 permanent residents also favored annexation of this area. ' , Holden Beach 1997 Land Use Plan Update Page 92 ' At the October 21, 1996, public information meeting, the annexation of this commercial corridor was the number ten priority item, with four votes out of the approximately 47 residents present at the'meeting. , Issue — Public Access (Question 9) ' When asked about adequacy of public access to the beach and Intracoastal Waterway, 61%, or 90 permanent residents, and 63%, or 326 non -permanent resident property owners answering the question indicated that they think there is ' adequate access. One hundred ninety, or 37% of the non -permanent, and 58, or 39% of the ' permanent residents, indicated that there was not adequate access. In addition, 180, or 96% of the non -permanent resident property owners and 56, , or 69% of the permanent resident property owners who answered "no" to question 8 indicated in response to question 10 that they would like to see Town officials pursue grants to fund purchase and development of additional public access to ' beach and Intracoastal Waterway. Issue — Town -Owned Open Space and Recreational Facilities (Question 11) , Eighty, or 59% of permanent residents responding to question, and 321, or 66% of non -permanent residents think the Town of Holden Beach has adequate Town - ' owned open space and recreational facilities. When asked about paying additional taxes to see Town -owned open space and ' recreational facilities developed (question 13), 348, or 74% of non -permanent residents said "no" and 95, or 70% of permanent residents responding to the question agreed that they would not be willing to pay additional taxes for ' additional open space and recreational facilities. Issue — Capital Improvements Plan (Question 14) ' Seventy-three percent, or 339 of the non -permanent resident property owners and , 94, or 70% of permanent residents responding to question favored Town of Holden Beach officials budgeting funds to prepare a Capital Improvements Plan to set priorities and cost for such facilities as sewer, water, streets, sidewalks, , parks, community beautification and public beach access. Issue — Most Important Problems Facing Holden Beach (Question 1 S) , This question gave Holden Beach property owners the opportunity to rank the most important problems currently facing Holden Beach. Based on the results of ' the questionnaire, they are as follows: Holden Beach 1997 Land Use Plan Update Page 93 , 1 IPriori Non -Permanent Residents Permanent Residents ' 1 Protection from erosion (346) Protection from erosion (92) 2 Lack of public wastewater Lack of public wastewater disposal system (237) disposal system (67) ' 3 Overloading of septic tanks Overloading of septic tanks (55) (219) 4 Growth management (205) Growth management (50) ' 5 Environmental protection (151) Environmental protection (31) 6 Stormwater runoff (drainage) Stormwater runoff (drainage) (72) (31) ' 7 Parking for "day trippers" (58) Enforcement of town laws (25) 8 Enforcement of town laws (41) Parking for "day trippers" (16) ' Note: Number in parentheses represents number of responses. Issue — Current Rate of Growth and Development for Holden Beach (Question 16) This question gives property owners the opportunity to indicate how they feel ' about current rate of growth at Holden Beach Non -Permanent Permanent Residents About right 299 (63%) 84 (63%) Too slow 7 (01%) 3 (02%) Too fast 172 (36%) 47 (35%) Total Responses 478 (100%) 104 (100%) ' Based on the results of this question, the majority of both permanent (63%) and non -permanent (63%) resident property owners answering the question feel that ' the current rate of growth for Holden Beach is about right. Issue —Type of Development to Encourage and Discourage (Question17) This question gave property owners the opportunity to indicate what type of growth and development they would like to see encouraged or discouraged during the five- to ten-year planning period. The number one response was to encourage single-family residential ' development, with 457 non -permanent resident property owners and 126 permanent resident property owners responding favorably to this type of development. That response is consistent with the 159 out of 211 responses to the ' Holden Beach Property Owners Association, Inc., survey which showed Holden Beach remaining as a residential/family beach as the highest priority. ' Holden Beach 1997 Land Use Plan Update Page 94 Two hundred twenty-six non -permanent and 57 permanent residents would like to ' see Town officials discourage duplex residential development. Four hundred sixteen non -permanent and 102 permanent residents want to see multi -family '. residential development discouraged. Three hundred forty-seven non -permanent and 150 permanent residents would , like to see motel development discouraged; and 282 non -permanent and 82 permanent residents would like to see restaurants on Holden Beach discouraged. It is worth noting that 167 non -permanent residents and 41 permanent residents would like to see restaurants encouraged; however, the clear majority responding to the question prefer that restaurants be discouraged. ' Three hundred three non -permanent and 87 permanent residents would like to see service -type businesses discouraged. When asked about retail business on Holden Beach, 336 non -permanent and 89 permanent residents would like to discourage retail business. Three hundred three non -permanent and 104 permanent residents would like to , encourage land and resource preservation. Scrmntary to Question 17 , Type of Development to Encourage Type ofDevelopment to Discourage Single -Family Residential Duplex Residential Land and Resource Preservation Multi -Family Residential , Motels Restaurants Service -Type Businesses ' Retail Businesses Issue — Parking and Sanitation Facilities for Day Visitors at No Cost to ' Visitors (Question 19) Both non -permanent (370 or 79%) and permanent (104 or 78%) resident property , owners disagree with providing facilities for day visitors at no cost to day visitors. Issue — Special Tax District for Dredging and Maintenance of Canals (Question 20) One hundred twenty-eight, or 74% of non -permanent, and 54, or 77% of , permanent residents would favor a special tax district to cover cost of dredging and maintenance of canals. In summary, the results of the public participation meetings and subsequent questionnaires help establish issues, goals and objectives and, as a result, policy to Holden Beach 1997 Land Use Plan Update Page 95 ' accomplish goals and objectives to address issues of concern to Holden Beach residents. As the Plan takes draft form and is discussed by local officials, citizens will continue to have an opportunity to review proposed policy and implementation strategy to accomplish these goals and objectives during the five- year planning period prior to the next land use plan update in 2,002. Holden Beach 1997 Land Use Plan Update Page 96 APPENDIX 5 Areas of Environmental Concern (AEC) Within the State of North Carolina The following AEC's are defined and discussed in terms of their applicability to land use planning in North Carolina. Estuarine System — The first Areas of Environmental Concern discussed collectively are those water and land areas of the coast that contribute enormous economic, social, and biological values to North Carolina as components of the estuarine system. Included within the estuarine system are the following AEC categories: estuarine waters, coastal wetlands, public trust areas, and estuarine shorelines. Each of the Areas of Environmental Concern is either geographically within the estuary or, because of its location and nature, may significantly affect the estuary. It is the objective of the Coastal Resources Commission to conserve and manage estuarine waters, coastal wetlands, public trust areas, and estuarine shorelines, as an interrelated group of Areas of Environmental Concern so as to safeguard and perpetuate their biological, social, economic, and aesthetic values and to ensure that development occurring within these Areas of Environmental Concern is compatible with natural characteristics so as to minimize the likelihood of significant loss of private property and public resources. Furthermore, it is the objective of the Coastal Resources Commission to protect present common-law and statutory public rights of access to the lands and waters of the coastal area. a. Coastal Wetlands AEC Coastal wetlands are defined as any salt marsh or other marsh subject to regular or occasional flooding by tides, including wind tides (whether or not the tide waters reach the marshland areas through natural or artificial watercourses), provided this shall not include hurricane or tropical storm tides. Coastal wetlands contain some, but not necessarily all, of the following marsh plant species: (1) Cord Grass (Spartina altemiflora), (2) Black Needlerush (Juncus roemerianus), (3) Glasswort (Salicornia spp.), (4) Salt Grass (Distichlis spicata), (5) Sea Lavender (Limonium spp.), (6) Bulrush (Scirpus spp.), (7) Saw Grass (Cladium jamaicense), (8) Cat -tail (Typha spp.), (9) Salt Meadow Grass (Spartina patens), (10) Salt Reed Grass (Spartina cynosuroides). Holden Beach 1997 Land Use Plan Update Page 97 The management objective for coastal wetlands is to conserve and manage coastal wetlands so as to safeguard and perpetuate their biological, social, economic and aesthetic values; to coordinate and establish a management system capable of conserving and utilizing coastal wetlands as a natural resource essential to the functioning of the entire estuarine system. Use Standards: Suitable lands uses shall be those consistent with the management objective in Rule .0208 (see Attachment H for use standards). Highest priority of use shall be allocated to the conservation of existing coastal wetlands. Second priority of coastal wetland use shall be given to those types of development activities that require water access and cannot function elsewhere. Unacceptable land uses may include, but would not be limited to, the following examples: restaurants and businesses; residences, apartments, motels, hotels, and trailer parks; parking lots and private roads and highways; and factories. Examples of acceptable land uses may include utility easements, fishing piers, docks, and agricultural uses, such as farming and forestry drainage, as permitted under North Carolina's Dredge and Fill Act or other applicable laws. In every instance, the particular location, use, and design characteristics shall be in accord with the general use standards for coastal wetlands, estuarine waters, and public trust areas described in Rule .0208 (see Attachment H). ' b. Estuarine Waters AEC Estuarine waters are defined in G.S. 113A-113(b)(2). The ' boundaries between inland and coastal fishing waters are set forth in an agreement adopted by the Wildlife Resources Commission and the Department of Environment and ' Natural Resources and in the most current revision of the North Carolina Marine Fisheries Regulations for Coastal Waters, codified at 15A NCAC 3Q.0200. Estuarine waters are the dominant component and bonding element of the entire estuarine system, integrating aquatic influences from both the land and the sea. Estuaries are among the most productive natural environments of North Carolina. They support the valuable commercial and sports fisheries of the coastal area which are comprised of estuarine dependent species such as menhaden, flounder, shrimp, crabs. -and oysters. These species must spend all or ' Holden Beach 1997 Land Use Plan Update Page 98 some part of their life cycle within the estuarine waters to mature and reproduce. Of the ten leading species in the commercial catch, all but one are dependent on the estuary. This high productivity associated with the estuary results from its unique circulation patterns caused by tidal energy, fresh water flow, and shallow depth; nutrient trapping mechanisms; and protection to the many organisms. The circulation of estuarine waters transports nutrients, propels plankton, spreads seed stages of fish and shellfish, flushes wastes from animal and plant life, cleanses the system of pollutants, controls salinity, shifts sediments, and mixes the water to create a multitude of habitats. Some important features of the estuary include mud and sand flats, eel grass beds, salt marshes, submerged vegetation flats, clam and oyster beds, and important nursery areas. Secondary benefits include the stimulation of the coastal economy from the spin-off operations required to service commercial and sports fisheries, waterfowl hunting, marinas, boatyards, repairs and supplies, processing operations, and tourist related industries. In addition, there is considerable nonmonetary value associated with aesthetics, recreation and education. The management objective for estuarine waters is to conserve and manage the important features of estuarine waters so as to safeguard and perpetuate their biological, social, aesthetic, and economic values; to coordinate and establish a management system capable of conserving and utilizing estuarine waters so as to maximize their benefits to man and the estuarine system. Use Standards: Suitable land/water uses shall be those consistent with the management objectives in Rule .0208 (see Attachment H). Highest priority of use shall be allocated to the conservation of estuarine waters and its vital components. Second priority of estuarine waters use shall be given to those types of development activities that require water access and use which cannot function elsewhere such as simple access channels; structures to prevent erosion; navigation channels; boat docks, marinas, piers, wharfs, and mooring pilings. In every instance, the particular location, use and design characteristics shall be in accord with the general use standards for coastal wetlands, I I I 1 1 1 Holden Beach 1997 Land Use Plan Update Page 99 ' 7 estuarine waters, and public trust areas described in Rule .0208 (Attachment H). C. Public Trust Areas AEC Public trust areas are all waters of the Atlantic Ocean and the lands thereunder from the mean high water mark to the seaward limit of State jurisdiction; all natural bodies of water subject to measurable lunar tides and lands thereunder to the mean high water mark; all navigable natural bodies of water and lands thereunder to the mean high water level or mean water level as the case may be, except privately -owned lakes to which the public has no right of access; all water in artificially created bodies of water containing significant public fishing resources or other public resources which are accessible to the public by navigation from bodies of water in which the public has rights of navigation; and all waters in artificially created bodies of water in which the public has acquired rights by prescription, custom, usage, dedication, or any other means. In determining whether the public has acquired rights in artificially created bodies of water, the following factors shall be considered: (1) the use of the body of water by the public, (2) the length of time the public has used the area, (3) the value of public resources in the body of water, (4) whether the public resources in the body of water are mobile to the extent that they can move into natural bodies of water, (5) whether the creation of the artificial body of water required permission from the State, and (6) the value of the body of water to the public for navigation from one public area to another public area. The public has rights in these areas, including navigation and recreation. In addition, these areas support valuable commercial and sports fisheries, have aesthetic value, and are important resources for economic development. The management objective for public trust areas is to protect public rights for navigation and recreation and to conserve and manage the public trust areas so as to safeguard and perpetuate their biological, economic and aesthetic value. ' Holden Beach 1997 Land Use Plan Update Page 100 Use Standards: Acceptable uses shall be those consistent with the management objectives. In the absence of overriding public benefit, any use which significantly interferes with the public right of navigation or other public trust rights which the public may be found to have in these areas shall not be allowed. The development of navigational channels or drainage ditches, the use of bulkheads to prevent erosion, and the building of piers, wharfs, or marinas are examples of uses that may be acceptable within public trust areas, provided that such uses will not be detrimental to the public trust rights and the biological and physical functions of the estuary. Projects which would directly or indirectly block or impair existing navigation channels, increase shoreline erosion, deposit spoils below mean high tide, cause adverse water circulation patterns, violate water quality standards, or cause degradation of shellfish waters are generally considered incompatible with the management policies of public trust areas. In every instance, the particular location, use, and design characteristics shall be in accord with the general use standards for coastal wetlands, estuarine waters, and public trust areas. Uses which are not water dependent shall not be permitted in coastal wetlands, estuarine waters, and public trust areas. Restaurants, residences, apartments, motels, hotels, trailer parks, private roads, factories and parking lots are examples of uses that are not water dependent. Uses that are water dependent may include utility easements, docks, wharves, boat ramps, dredging, bridges and bridge approaches, revetments, bulkheads, culverts, groins, navigational aids, mooring pilings, navigational channels, simple access channels and drainage ditches. Estuarine Shoreline AEC Estuarine shorelines, although characterized as dry land, are considered a component of the estuarine system because of the close association with the adjacent estuarine waters. Estuarine shorelines are those non -ocean shorelines which are especially vulnerable to erosion, flooding, or other adverse effects of wind and water and are intimately connected to the estuary. This area extends from the mean high water level or normal water level along the estuaries, sounds, bays, and brackish waters as set forth in an agreement adopted by the Wildlife Resources Commission P u I Holden Beach 1997 Land Use Plan Update Page 101 ' ' and the Department of Environment and Natural Resources » for a distance of 75 feet landward. Development within estuarine shorelines influences the quality of estuarine life and is subject to the damaging ' processes of shore front erosion and flooding. The management objective of the estuarine shoreline is to ' ensure shoreline development is compatible with both the dynamic nature of estuarine shorelines and the values of the estuarine system. ' Use Standards: (1) All development projects, proposals and designs shall substantially preserve and not weaken or eliminate natural barriers to erosion, including, but ' not limited to, peat marshland, resistant clay shorelines, and cypress -gum protective fringe areas ' adjacent to vulnerable shorelines. 2 All development projects, proposals and designs () p ' shall limit the construction of impervious surfaces and areas not allowing natural drainage to only so much as is necessary to adequately service the ' major purpose or use for which the lot is being developed. Impervious surfaces shall not exceed 30 percent of the AEC area of the lot, unless the applicant can effectively demonstrate, through ' innovative design, that the protection provided by the design would be equal to or exceed the protection by the 30 percent limitation. ' Redevelopment of areas exceeding the 30 percent impervious surface limitation can be permitted if impervious areas are not increased and the applicant ' designs the project to comply with the intent of the rule to the maximum extent practical. ' (3) All development projects, proposals, and designs shall comply with the following mandatory standards of the North Carolina Sedimentation ' Pollution Control Act of 1973: ' (A) All development projects, proposals and designs shall provide for a buffer zone along the margin of the estuarine water which is ' Holden Beach 1997 Land Use Plan Update Page 102 sufficient to confine visible siltation within 25 percent of the buffer zone nearest the land disturbing development. (B) No development project, proposal or design shall permit an angle for graded slopes or fill which is greater than an angle which can be retained by vegetative cover or other adequate erosion -control devices or structures. (C) All development projects, proposals and designs which involve uncovering more than one acre of land shall plant a ground cover sufficient to restrain erosion within 30 working days of completion of the grading; provided that this shall not apply to clearing land for the purpose of forming a reservoir later to be inundated. (4) Development shall not have a significant adverse impact on estuarine resources. (5) Development shall not significantly interfere with existing public rights of access to, or use of, navigable waters or public resources. (6) No major public facility shall be permitted if such facility is likely to require extraordinary public expenditures for maintenance and continued use, unless it can be shown that the public purpose served by the facility outweighs the required public expenditures for construction, maintenance and continued use. For the purpose of this standard, "public facility" shall mean a project which is paid for in any part by public funds. (7) Development shall not cause major or irreversible damage to valuable, documented historic architectural or archaeological resources. (8) Established common-law and statutory public rights of access to the public trust lands and waters in estuarine areas shall not be eliminated or restricted. Development shall not encroach upon public Holden Beach 1997 Land Use Plan Update Page 103 it limit intended the accessways nor shall the use of accessways. ' Ocean Hazard Area — The next broad grouping is composed of those Areas of Environmental Concern that are considered natural hazard areas along the Atlantic Ocean shoreline where, because of their special vulnerability to erosion or other adverse effects of sand, wind, and water, uncontrolled or incompatible development ' could unreasonably endanger life or property. Ocean hazard areas include beaches, frontal dunes, inlet lands, and other areas in which geologic, vegetative and soil conditions indicate a substantial ' possibility of excessive erosion or flood damage. The CRC recognizes that absolute safety from the destructive ' forces indigenous to the Atlantic shoreline is an impossibility for development located adjacent to the coast. The loss of life and property to these forces, however, can be greatly reduced by the ' proper location and design of structures and by care taken in prevention of damage to natural protective features, particularly primary and frontal dunes. Therefore, it is the CRC's objective to ' provide management policies and standards for ocean hazard areas that serve to eliminate unreasonable danger to life and property and ' achieve a balance between the financial, safety, and social factors that are involved in hazard area development. The purpose of these Rules shall be to further the goals set out in ' G.S. 113A-102(b), with particular attention to minimizing losses to life and property resulting from storms and long-term erosion, preventing encroachment of permanent structures on public beach ' areas, preserving the natural ecological conditions of the barrier dune and beach systems, and reducing the public costs of inappropriately sited development. Furthermore, it is the objective ' of the Coastal Resources Commission to protect present common- law and statutory public rights of access to and use of the lands and waters of the coastal area. The ocean hazard system of Areas of ' Environmental Concern contains the following areas: ' e. Ocean Erodible Area AEC This is the area in which there exists a substantial ' possibility of excessive erosion and significant shoreline fluctuation. The seaward boundary of this area is the mean low water line. The landward extent of this area is ' determined as follows: ' Holden Beach 1997 Land Use Plan Update Page 104 (1) a distance landward from the first line of stable natural vegetation to the recession line that would be established by multiplying the long-term annual erosion rate times 60, provided that, where there has been no long-term erosion or the rate is less than two feet per year, this distance shall be set at 120 feet landward from the first line of stable natural vegetation. For the purposes of this Rule, the erosion rates shall be those set forth in tables entitled "Long Term Annual Erosion Rates updated through 1986" and approved by the Coastal Resources Commission on July 29, 1988 (except as such rates may be varied in individual contested cases, declaratory or interpretive rulings). The tables are available without cost from any local permit officer or the Division of Coastal Management; and (2) a distance landward from the recession line established in item (1) above to the recession line that would be generated by a storm having a one percent chance of being equaled or exceeded in any given year. f. gh Hazard Flood Area AEC This is the area subject to high velocity waters (including, but not limited to, hurricane wave wash) in a storm having a one percent chance of being equaled or exceeded in any given year, as identified as zone V1-30 on the flood insurance rate maps of the Federal Insurance Administration, U.S. Department of Housing and Urban Development. In the absence of these rate maps, other available base flood elevation data prepared by a federal, State, or other source may be used, provided said data source is approved by the CRC. g. Inlet Hazard Area AEC The inlet hazard areas are natural -hazard areas that are especially vulnerable to erosion, flooding and other adverse effects of sand, wind, and water because of their proximity to dynamic ocean inlets. This area shall extend landward from the mean low water line a distance sufficient to encompass that area within which the inlet will, based on statistical analysis, migrate, and shall consider such factors as previous inlet territory, structurally weak. areas near the J H 1 1 u 1 Holden Beach 1997 Land Use Plan Update Page 105 inlet (such as an unusually narrow barrier island, an unusually long channel feeding the inlet, or an overwash area), and external influences such as jetties and channelization. The areas identified as suggested Inlet Hazard Areas included in the report entitled INLET HAZARD AREAS, The Final Report and Recommendations to the Coastal Resources Commission, 1978, by Loie J. Priddy and Rick Carraway are hereby designated as Inlet Hazard Areas. In all cases, this area shall be an extension of the adjacent ocean erodible area and in no case shall the width of the inlet hazard area be less than the width of the adjacent ocean erodible area. Use Standards: General Use Standards for Ocean Hazard Areas permitted under T15A:07H.0300 Subsection .0306 and .0308 and Subsection .0310 Use Standards for Inlet Hazard Areas are adopted by Holden Beach by reference. (See copy of these subsections in Land Use Appendix Attachment I.) Holden Beach 1997 Land Use Plan Update Page 106 r, WHIM a>, � awl °r•r _ eg s _ .� ra aw-. aa, arc ,y��y = _ '°" _ ars ,•� sa ._ __ +w aY 'arer acr all a. �{ ,pa■p ip■a a �• ` :J� e+4.a_ci •A xa M. �1tlI8,AAfl6�aV11711�i1!—�:•Ir, .s _ sat=°'a':: ��'•- � 4 � � �� erc � �- i -� +s «: +or . 1�-^" � �' ��rt.s .a,.�l`-1—ax A.s_ s..aa-__ __ _ran \� .-'.. •ra: .— w stir —I -r.r 0.N ax i'�' 'ffir _ �► ®�m�-s __ex'ay.—_.asx•.;—_ a.r_ _.—m_r���__ r— oo +we.a ■ ■ =sr �M-cwr _Ja�� R_, aw_nes ,�.� .i �== � •" :.'r r 1— „� ® �a� �— _ __ a" .a .rw� rr r �"x atr ra� `a>�—s-S�feE�tiWartsa_-satyr-Eal6 a!_-sw-aa_-_—-•�x'r���,e..o,� "Ira ,,,,,,t, 1 / ) $ .+fit — � �-i � 'wy%r � ner -- � �ea:� __ -�p� sI q[mt. _ a. � ws _ �_�-1 � r _ } t ��,"",a""�„�'t'���I�„�'1", wL�_ wi-_ .'�.:k+a: a-rL� t .� wl �r-- i y. >W' '_. _.�: _ ar► m.:r. .—[_ .. — — _ ®.-� 'wal- Ir� l _ - �lll`=111k; 5t1=tiSts�"/gt 1/t a lli:t� - _•}=NM,-,,$��ttt/._ - r_fif�iUl�l��'l.i'$amsal'$itttt��1� 0CEAN A T L A ail C—t��y.Crr�r Gnu Atcen CAW Accm ATLAM TIC 0 C E � a�"� � �-•�_ Gn4A Acmt CA14A Accen Ome tier 10 rrira4 tiers Gnu Area. I GMA Acem G1NA Aeem New De►da/eeat Yacht Watch (44 lob) -'� ` S A wean_' • ~` � �. LWEND Residential (Developed as of December 31,1997) Commercial ® Public Semi —Public Vacant (Undeveloped residential) Existing Land Water Use Map HOLDEN BEACH. N.C. ® o _ taoo taco moo Scale Prepared by Howard T. Capps Je,, Associates, Inc. Land Planning a Landscape Architecture 201 N. Front Street, Suite 402 Wilmington, North Carolina 28401 -a�t '�I,IU/1111t1Ipt�t ■i. qba� agar -Anal_ I •_ ��-_ate' � _=ate , —l-_ate am Ma'-11111 No an ttt t�s�t air mutt �[iutlrirst �uunu u ` ro It ,-'••� all' �ia at�aa� a as:iun� t►t111 off. I a �! ' aaf /1lII r■err �� �� 11IIutl�� [ IR Lk ITS - s r ftty D The preparation of this document was financed in part though a grant provided by the North Carolina Coastal Management program, through tbnds provided by the Coastal Zone Management Act of 1972, as amended, which is administered by the Office of Ocean and Coastal Resource Management, National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration. l • S A W esters �- `f f it to Oc• � 1 � LAMA (V-Zose) CAMA Access tine to Ocean j LAMA (V-Zone) Canal Access LAMA Access New D-eloP^'eal Canal Access Heron Landing New DeveMpmeat (71ets) Canal Alms Marker Fitly Five (16 Lets) L1I. ITS����++•--»�-- ��—� _ SAWaters 10 Yrirste riers New llevebpmest Yacht Watch (44 Lots) �� SA Waters ��-�"---� $e ' Composite Hazards Map 0 D N B ACH, N.C. low 1500 Scale Pnpind by Howard T. Capps C Associates, Inc. Land Planning s Landreape Architectwe 201 N. Front Street, Suite 402 'Wilmington, North Carolina 28401 LEGEND ;.; Ocean Erodible AEC ® Inlet Hazard AEC CAMA (V—Zone) AEC 211WRIVIRil 91111 � l� ill, �eTC^.CES?��:GIIg±iLhiC4gY�RlY9i><R>ITPC.E@33Y1<SYiYlh�S I Ea7a3394tG pR� »ILLS GaaCt L1 �tC.'f K;3�aabSxSk�Z[Z1 �1R � t)ma Fier The risks associated with these hazards are described throughout the text of the Land Use Plan. Potential storm surge information (CAMA V-Zone) is discussed in Policy Section V1, Part E of the Plan. 1 . lll�tl� 11�1� '• nmm o. M --_ nomsSIR =asr W an ` ae.ta�■e.�': gu- War 1E1j#I, `'111p1l/ /111111111 nu�11 ilia II1In1I1I 1l�lt�l ( l�iIng .... i1j bflt €l uau l .-;.' I!■ ,a It'J• al1IIII. � - _ EliilEp- 611�L'C S1Jllsy _ f. WO flol.i.j.101 .,1 _I . 1 • i _ r A T L A N T I C SAWaterS 0C1AN M /� _111ttt[I CADu Aeeo CAAu Aetat slew Dwodepatot )darer Loading (7lab) ATLAN TIC Caul Access leer!�lllllllllllllllltllllllllllillllllllllllllll 111111�'■I���I�It,�1�t1I�i�1111111I�t11�1��1I� Caad AC.M h(New *,eleat aeMarkerr FifgR� Five (16 Lao) 11111p1Ii1�111111111■1111I1/r .I�IlII/IIII�p111111 0 - tler 10 re..te rim New De dop.eot Yacht Wateb (at LAO) OR a filttall■■ " Illllilllll�'i �--� 11111111111 t t•1� � Ili Acme CAM Ass � M. I a a 02 2 11 R �—,M' Land Classification Map HOLDEN BEACH, N.C. Vim\ 0 — ,000 ,f00 — �`\V`i(/j•/�/v) Scale Prepared by Howard T. Capps &i Associates, Inc. !arid Planning - Landscape Amhitcchwe 201 N. Front Street, Suite 402 Wilmington. North Carolina 28401 hew Do t Seaside at Winding River / (» L—) /--mrte•s !Hansa S A waters a.s;AarT t0�+ a1 New Dc.elepawat Drarascape CM leay 11111■in � e 111/f1 11 IIIIl1fill ,.•.-----a.aauu/1>•IUfU11111 IIQLIIIII llllq /U Selig —aa� a ��-f,►i► 1 ifs lIL1U�/1 /I)Ita: ��upt J / t�ttt .es L•tt CAMA Accos I I Aftat Access SWA aManagem� Developed Loiad beases In tad area ttent CmsW program, through funds provided The Land Classification Map is for general use only. 10" loss "'"b """ the CDasW zDoe by Mtlnagealerlt Act or 1972, as Final determination of location for Conservation •-.'�-��'-.'-. Low Density Development Area Holden Beach N.C. Township: Lockwood Folly, Count • Brunswick. General � P� y� y o �w x � National or Low Density Development areas shall be made location: 78.2 Degrees West Longitude, 33.9 Degrees North Latitude. Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration. through field investigation by a responsible federal, ® Conservation state or local official having regulatory authority.