Loading...
HomeMy WebLinkAboutBeach Access Study-..,.,..w...�r.w.....,,..�a.u�...«....+«..�w......��,...w�..,,. ,. ». ........wrw.......a,..�.... w..w...�.....«.....�.........�.«�.�+wa....»w.w.w.ea...«...r.«..�.ms rxna w.�nnnyx�1w:.er�anrn:n.xvu w.�r� TABLE OF CONTENTS PAGE NUMBER ` INTRODUCTION...........................................2 SURVEY OF EXISTING CONDITIONS ..........................3 Existing Policies Beach 4 • on use aBeach Ownership Patterns 5. Existing User Groups and Associated conflicts 7 aOwnership of Beach Accessways 8 Inventory of Existing Beach Accessways 10 Sample Beach Access Evaluation Form 12 Beach Access Evaluation Forms Summary 13 Beach Access Inventory Map 23 aDEVELOPMENT PLAN ...................................... 24 Future Access Needs 25 Major Accessways 26 aNeighborhood Accessways 35 Vehicular Accessways 37 aUndesirable Accessways 38 Beach Access Development Classification Summary 39 IMPLEMENTATION PLAN..................................42 Beach Access Acquisition and Preservation 43 Financing Beach Access Acquisition and Development 45 Education and Information 47 Beach Access Acquisition and Development a Implementation Policies 48 Summary 49 a a 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 R INTRODUCTION The continuing pressure for access to the shoreline from a growing leisure oriented society requires that the State and local governments take positive steps to mitigate the conflict between oceanfront property owners and those seeking access to the shore. This plan for Holden Beach is such a step and represents an initiative by the Town toward planning for both its residents and visitors. The preparation of this study vas financed in part by a grant provided by the North Carolina Coastal Management Program, through funds provided by the Coastal Zone Management Act of 1972, as amended, which is administered by the Office of Coastal Zone Management, National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration. Technical assistance was provided by the Brunswick County Planning Department Deborah E. Ryan..... Planner -in -Charge Gaile Pittman.,..... Planner Karen O'Donnel....... Planning Intern Chris Barna......... Planning Intern Wayne Bowling ........ Draftsman Lottie t1oore......... Typist Tracy Roycroft....... Typist Board. The Holden Beach Access Study was prepared for the Holden Beach Town John Tandy ........... Mayor Dr. James Mulholland John Clark Lyndon Holden, Roger Morton Spero Poulos The study was prepared by the Holden Beach Access Advisory Committee. 0 2 i SURVEY OF EXISTING CONDITIONS An increasing conflict has resulted from the growing concentration of a our nations population in coastal areas. Today, over 70 percent of the U.S. population now lives within 70 miles of the coast. This growing coastal density has resulted in an increased demand for public access to athe beach.for recreation purposes. Holden Beach is just one of the many beach communities in the area trying to provide for this increasing demand. An objective of the 1976-Holden Beach Land Use Plan was to "acquire title or permanent use of beach accessways.for all citizens to.enjoy beach recreation activities." The impetus for this objec- tive was loss of a number of public accessways over the previous five years. Many alleyways and street ends included in original subdivision plats were withdrawn from public dedication by the developers in 1972 and 1973. Alleyways were distributed among adjacent property owners to increase their lot size and many street ends were sold as building lots. If Holden is to provide adequate Beach Access, significantly more is needed than acquiring a handful of titles. The purpose of this study is not to establish ownership or acquire the titles of accessways, but rather to determine what prob- lems exist, why they have developed, and what can be done now to provide more adequate beach access. I 111 0 i I IF Existing Policies on Beach Use Town officials are becoming increasingly aware of the conflicts and problems of beach use and beach access in Holden Beach. Several ordinances have. been adopted in recent years to regulate use of the beach and require developers to provide adequate beach access. Subdivision Ordinance for the Town of Holden Beach The Ordinance was created with purpose of establishing procedures and standards that will regulate and control the subdivision of land within the municipality of Holden Beach in order to promote the public health, safety, and general welfare of the town. In addition, this Ordinance requires developers to provide beach access every one quarter mile, but because so much land was subdivided before this regulation was adopted, its affect has been minimal. a An Ordinance Regulating Vehicular Traffic on the Beach Strand Within the Town of Holden Beach The Ordinance establishes that a permit be obtained for the operation of a motor or engine driven vehicle along the beach strand extending from Lockwood Folly Inlet to Shallotte Inlet. Approved vehicles are permitted on the beach at approved accessways only. Procedures for the permit process are stated in the Ordinance, as well as restrictions regarding vehicle oper- ations on the strand. Money collected from the issue of these permits is used specifically to upgrade access points at Holden Beach. aRules and Regulation on Net Fishing The regulation suggests rules to be followed for net fishing within the Town of Holden Beach. All commercial net fishermen. must have written per- mission from the landowner and must follow the regulations stated for posts, lines, trash, shacks, vehicles, and all other laws and regulations of the Town of Holden Beach. I I I I - Beach Ownership Patterns Problems with Beach Access arise primarily bacause of the ownership patterns along beach communities. While the public owns.the beach from the high water mark seaward (actually it is held in trust by the State for its public beneficiaries), from the mean high water mark landward is privately �j owned: u Both State and Federal Regualtions endeavor to insure beach access .to the public. The Federal Coastal Zone Management Act of 1972 as amended in 1976 requires each State to define the term "beach" and provide a planning process for the protection of, and access to, public beaches and other coastal areas of environmental, recreational, historical, esthetic, ecological, or cultural value. The Federal Act further provided the impetus for the enactment of.the a North Carolina Coastal Area Management Act (CAMA). An objective of CAMA insures the public's right to enjoy the physical, cultural and recreational qualities of the State's shorelines. As required by the Federal directive, a CAMA defined the term "beach" in 1978 as the area extending from the mean low water mark landward to where the first.line of vegetation occurs, a distinct change in slope or elevation occurs, or the beach front owners have specifically and legally restricted access above the mean high water mark. Q It is expected that this definition will be revised as we learn more about the dynamic nature of the "beach". a Regardless of new information, development shall not interfere with the public's right of access where acquired through public acquisition. CAMA places the major responsibility of insuring adequate access to public trust lands and waters on local government, but to be assisted by State and Federal Governments. While the extent of State and Federal Governments assistance is unclear, it is apparent that assistance for other beach projects (such as beach renourishment) is dependent on whether adequate access is provided. Adequate access should include not only access rights, but adequate identi- fication, parking, and provisions to protect the frontal dunes. I dl 1 I LIB I PUBLIC Holden Beach Access Study Beach Ownership Patterns PRIVATE TYPICAL SECTION PUBLIC ..PRIVATE User Groups and Associated Conflicts In order to understand the problems that exist with beach access, the different groups of people using the beach must be identified. First. is the beach front property owner with obvious private access. If access is not adequately provided for the pbulic, the beach front owner will also suffer, because the public will be crossing over his private property to reach'the beach. In order to protect his property, he should be equally inter ested in beach access. Often, it is still hard to impress on him the public's aright to access to the beach when he pays highly for the private luxury. The second group which is perhaps the least provided for at Holden Beach, is the non -beach front property owners. Their problems become extremely signi- ficant when grouped together in dense subdivisions, as they are in the various finger canal developments in Holden Beach, Basically, these residents need accessways at relatively short intervals or else they will cross the beach front property wherever it is most convenient to them, regardless of whether an official access point exists. a The next group of people are those living in the adjacent unincorporated county, who most often drive a few miles to the beach for the day. This group requires more public facilities in the way of parking, trash receptacles, and bathrooms than the other groups because they are the furthest distance away from their lodgings. t4ost tourists are also included in this group. The fourth group includes those people requiring vehicular access to the beach. Although this group consists primarily of fishermen, emergency vehicles also require access at regular intervals along the beach. III I in I 0 It Ownership of Beach Accessways The best planned and designed access points will be of little use unless the public's right to use the property is adequately established. Ownership of beach accessways on Holden Beach must be determined in order to locate areas.where the public is legally guaranteed access. Because of past develop- ment patterns, this is not an easy task. Primarily, there are three types of ownership on Holden Beach: Private or Individual; Semi -Public; and Public. Of the 68 accessways evaluated in this study, 25 are designated as Private. They are listed in the Brunswick County Tax Records as property owned by one particualr person. These private accessways are included in the study because they are currently in use by the public (with or without the permis- sion of the owners) or they have potential for development -into public access - ways. Two private accessways of particular interest are #1 and #2 at the eastern end of the island. Because so much of the beach has eroded away in this area, the lots are not currently suitable for building. Because of this, the owners of the ocean front property seem unconcerned with the public's use of their land. Although this situation may currently be acceptable, it would be advisable for the Town of Holden Beach to take steps in permanently securing the public's right of access in the future. Other private accessways of particular interest are those in the areas of the three finger canal developments. Specifically, accessways #44, 448, #50, #55, and #57 are all locations where the public is crossing over to the beach without permission or knowledge of the owner. Ideally, these locations would be the first considered in an access acquisition program, especially since they are used almost exclusively by the finger canal lot owners or their guests, rather than daily visitors from off the island. Accessways owned by a number of property owners rather than one individual are classified as Semi -Public. Their purpose is to provide beach access to non -beach front property owners in developments north of Ocean Boulevard. The problem with Semi -Public accessways is not in their number, but rather in their lack of facilities and maintenance. Better facilities are needed at most, but is is difficult to say who should provide them. When repairs are required, one or two individual owners must take it upon themselves to make them if they are to be done at all. Because of this, Semi -Public accessways suffer from inadequate upkeep. Of the three types of accessway ownership, Semi -Public is the least desirable, because no one person or institution is responsible for them. They are not policed to insure only co -owners use them, nor could they be, because of the large transient (tourist) summer population. In actuality, a the public at large can and does use these accessways without being challenged. Because of this, they are grouped info the public acessway category for the pur- pose of this study. It would be advisable for the Town of Holden Beach to assume the responsibility for the upkeep and maintenance of as many of the Semi -Public accessways as the Town judges suitable. In return for this service, the accessways would ideally be deeded to the Town of Holden Beach with the possible understanding that additional public use would not be further encouraged, yet no longer discouraged. Public accessways are those owned by the Town of Holden Beach. There are only a handful specifically deeded to the Town and -most, if not all of these are intended for use by day or off -island visitors. In recent years significant effort has been made to upgrade these accessways, but until the Town is willing to take on the responsibility of maintaining and developing some of the other Semi -Public and Private accessways, the public's access to the beach will be inadequate. Inventory of Existing Beach Accessways In January and May of this year, most, if not all of the access points at Holden Beach were evaluated. Sixty-eight were judged to have significance in this study. The adequacy of each access was evaluated not only in terms of physical -facilities such as trash recepticles, parking areas, and walkovers, but also for ownership, visibility, and erosion controls. k cause of time constraints, only accessways located on the southern side of Ocean Blvd, leading to the beach were evaluated. Access to the Atlantic Intercoastal Waterway (AIWW) was not evaluated although some access is provided to the public by way of public street ends. This access should be preserved and developed to include parking, pedestrian, and trash facilities.when a more sub- stantial interest is shown in the use of the AI14W as a recreational area. In terms of access to the beach, most points in use at the time of survey generally lacked many of the facilities needed by the public. Less than ten parking areas exist, some of those difficult to locate because of small or inadequate identification. Many of the pedestrian accessways without parking provisions were even more difficult to locate because they also lacked proper signage on either the land or ocean side of the access. In addition, few have trash receptacles, night lighting, or the convenience of bike racks. No handicap accommodations exist. Existing provisions for the protection of frontal sand dunes are inadequate. Less than one third of all accessways have adequate walkover structures, even fewer provide and adequate path from the road or parking area to the walkover. Almost none have properly placed sand fences along the dunes. Although each access point has been evaluated individually, there are several areas which include a number of acessways, with more significant access problems than others. 1) The East end of Holden Beach: Although the whole area is used as public access, it is privately owned. Erosion, probably worse here than anywhere else on the island, is only increased by the large number of people using the area and the lack of erosion controls. 2) The end of Jordan Blvd. (North Carolin Highway #130): Because this area, i s the entrance to Holden Beach, it should be. given special attention, Although visitors may.find.beach_access most conven, ient in this area, aesthitics and the amount of traffic make it less desirable, 3) Finger Canal Developmentsi Because these areas are so densely developed, a large number of people require access in a very small stretch_ of land; Evidence that needs are not met are the small' unofficial paths leading through private ocean front lots directly across the road from the finger canal deve.lopments., The Holden Beach Subdivision Ordinance now requires public access be required every one -quarter mile in areas developed after 1975i but the problem still remains for the residents of the earlier finger canal developments. 10 Following is a sample Beach Access Evaluation form, and brief individual summaries of the 58 locations evaluated. Only conditions or problems unique to a particular site and specific facilities provided at the time of the sur- vey are -noted in the summaries. For more detailed information on a particular site, a complete set of evaluation forms is on file at the Holden Beach Town Hall and'the Brunswick County Planning Department for public inspection. Also following is a Beach Access Inventory Map to assist in locating individual access points discussed in this.study. Other access points not evaluated or numbered should not be disregarded as unimportant. As noted earlier, the accessways discussed in this study have in the past or are cur- rently in use by the public, or are intended for public use according to County tax records. If undeveloped land becomes available for an access point at a sights other than those designated in the study, the sights should be incorpo- rated into the plan. I I 0 I t I IF e a �� ' MAP NUMBER SAMPLE BEACH ACCESS FORM LOCATION PRIVATE OR PUBLIC ACCESSWAY • a Visibility from road? c Marked with signs?. ' ® Trash cans provided? 0 Is the ;area lighted? ' ® Additional Comments WALKOVER ' Condition of path leading to walkover Non-existant Overgrown Grassed Compacted Sand Loose Sand Other g Condition of Walkover Excellent Good Acceptable Poor Dilapidated t ® Deck included? Yes No o Type of Steps ' ® Additional Comments PARKING o Parking area provided Yes No Q Paving Material o Size or app, number of cars a Additional Comments 1 17 r- DUNE o Extent of erosion c Dune height Low Average __ Large e Is ocean visible from road? 12 Q Dune vegetation Sparce - Acceptable Good ® Additional Com;�ents m GENERAL COMMENTS I Beach Access Evaluation forms Summary 1 Beach Access #1 Located at the extreme eastern end of the beach, this access is ' privately owned. It is marked by numerous "No Parking" signs and a "Vehicle acces$ by permit only" sign. Two small bright orange trash cans are provided. There is no clear path to the ocean. The entire area is visible from the road ' because the dune height is extremely low. Vegetation is sparce to non-existant. Beach Access #2 ' Although this acessway is not marked with signs, it is heavily used and very visible. It sits at the eastern end of the island and is privately owned by several people. Bright orange trash cans are provided in the center of the ' packed sand parking area that is bordered with telephone poles laid end to end. Because the entire area is used for access, no real path exists and erosion is severe. The ocean is visible because the area is so trampled there is no dune. ' Vegetation is sparce to non-existant.. Beach Access #3 ' This accessway is the publicly owned street end of Avenue "D". .Small signs mark it as a public parking area and one big trash can in need of paint is provided. The walkover with wood slats down a ramp is in acceptable condi- tion but does not extend to the ground on the ocean side becuase of erosion. The paving material of the parking area is a combination of stone and sand. The parking area extends to the crest of the dune and needs borders on both ' sides. Erosion is severe. The dune height is low and vegetation is sparce. Additional parking area is available to the left, right, and across Ocean Boulevard. ' Beach Access 114 ' This accessway is the publicly owned street end of Avenue "C". A small parking area is marked but it is overgrown with vegetation. Additional space for parking is available if the area is expanded on the oceanside of Ocean Boulevard. ' Beach Access #5 Although it is publicly ovrned, this accessway has never been cut. Vacant ' land suitable for parking is available across Ocean Boulevard. ' Beach Access #6 "A", This accessway is the publicly owned street end of Avenue A trash can and sign are located on the crest of the dune. A parking area is ' provided but it extends too far up the dune causing substantial erosion. The parking area could be extended to the right or across Ocean Boulevard, There is a shack at the bottom, ocean side of the dune. 13 Beach Access # 7 This accessway is located off of the main road, left of 1st ' Street. It is publicly owned although it is not marked with a sign. The dirt road that leads over the dune to the ocean has caused substantial erosion. ' Beach Access # 8 This accessway is located off of the main road, left of ' 2nd Street. Although is is publicly owned, it is not marked with a sign. A walkover in acceptable conditioned is provided, but the path leading to is is so close to a neighboring house, ' it is difficult to 'determine whether it is public or private. Erosion is minimal. The dune heigth is average and vegetation is good. ' Beach Access ,#9 Located left of the Whistling Swan, this accessway is ' publicly owned although it is not marked with any signs. Erosion is minimal as a result of the walkover. ' Beach Access # 10 This access point is located beside the Surf Scooter almost hidden behind a dune. A walkover in acceptable condition is ' provided, but the path leading to it is overgrown. Erosion in the area is significant as the dune heigth is low enough to make the ocean visible. Although it looks private, it is 'publicly, owned. ' Beach Access ## 11 ' This access point is a publicly owned street end. Its visibility is poor because it is not marked from the main road. The access is lighted and a r•ow of grey trash cans are provided. A walkover is provided but it is in poor condition. A large stone parking area ' is provided but parking is allowed too far up the dune causing some erosion problems. ' Because a bulkhead has been constructed, erosion of the beach is significant. Vegetation is sparce and the dunes are so low that the ocean is visible from the road. Bath rooms are provided by the adjacent pavillion and putt -putt course. ' Beach Access # 12 ' This access point is the publicly owned street end of Ferry Drive. It is used for parking by the Surfside Pavillion. It is lighted but not marked with signs. A walkover is provided but ' it begins at the crest of the dune so the landward side is eroding. A small deck is also included in the structure. The large parking area is paved with asphalt but ballards of some kind are needed to limit parking to the paved area. Vegetation is sparce and the dune ' heigth is low enough that the ocean is visible. 1 14 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 Beach Access # 13 Al thOL!gh this access is publicly owned and marked with sticks, it is uncut. Beach Access # 14 • This publicly owned access is sufficently visible and marked with posts. A grassed path leads to a walkover in good condition. No parking is provided but a large adjacent area is vacant and could be used for parking. Erosion in minimial, except at the base of the walkover. Vegetation and dune heigth are good. Beach Access # 15 This publicly owned access point is located just right of The Dull Gulls. It is not marked or cut but a number of paths, indicate the area is substantially used. Dune heigth is average and vegetation is good. Beach Access # 16 This publicly owned accessway is located to the left of 118 Ocean Boulevard. A grass and stone driveway leads to an oceanfront house but is roped off although steps are provided down to the beach Beach Access # 17 ' Although this access point was once the street end of Quinton Street, it is now privately owned. The public is obviously using the area for access although no facilities are provided. Erosion ' is significant along the path, but the dunes still have good veg- etation and heigth. ' Beach Access # 18 This publicly owned access point is marked at the crest of the dune with a sign reading "Block, Public Access". Grey trash cans are provided as well as a walkover in acceptable condition. The area is bulkheaded, which has caused significant erosion. The dune heigth is low enough that the ocean is visible. ' Vegetation is acceptable. Beach Access # 19 This privately owned access is located just to the right of Jordon Blvd. There are several loose sand paths but no walkover is provided. Erosion is minimal and both the dune heigth and vegetation are good. ' If the area is not to be used for access, a more permanent statement is needed to relay this to the public since the area is located at the entrance to the beach, 1 1 15 Beach Access # 20 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 This public owned access is located a few lots left of Cole Street. Although a trash can holder and a walkover are provided it is not marked with any signs. Where the walkover has been con- structed, the dune is in good shape, but it is seve rly eroding one lot over. Vegetation is acceptable. Beach Access # 21 Located two lots right of Cole Street, this access is publicly owned. Although the sign is visible from the road, it is placed over the walkover at the crest of the dune reading "Private Access to Block P". A walkover in good condition is provided, as well as a grassed path leading to it. Erosion in the area is severe, although both vegetation and dune heigth are acceptable. Beach Access # 22 Located four lots right of Rothschild Street, this access is* privately owned, although it is marked with posts. A compacted sand path leads to a walkover in excellan t condition. Erosion is minimal leaving the dune heigth high and the vegetation good. Beach Access # 23 Located between 155 and 157 Ocean Blvd., this access point is publicly owned. It is marked with wood posts. Even tho«gh it is. only a loose sand path, erosion has been minimal. Dune heigth is large and vegetation is good. Beach Access # 24 ' This public owned access point is located at Briles Apartments. It is not marked and is hard to find. Grey metal trash cans and a walkover in acceptable condition are provided. A large deck is also ' included. A compacted parking area is available for approximately 10-15 cars. Dune heigth is average and vegetation is acceptable. 1 1 1 1 Beach Access # 25 Located across from Rest Haven, this access point is publicly owned. It is marked as a "Private Access" with wood posts. An overgrown path leads to a walkover in poor condition. Erosion in the area is substantial resulting from heavy use. Dune heigth is average, and the vegetation is good on either side of the path. Beach Access # 26 Located to the left of 179 Ocean Blvd., this access is owned by the public. It is marked with posts and a trash can is provided. A grassed path is included but no walkover. Dune heigth is large and vegetation is acceptable. M-1 'A ' Beach Access # 27 This access is located to the left of 185 Ocean Blvd. and is ' publicly owned. One small post marks its location. A walkover is provided but it is in dilapidated condition, and has only sand steps on the landward side of the dune. Dune heigth is average and dune vegetation is good. Beach Access # 28 ' Located to the right of 189 Ocean Blvd, this public access -point is marked with wood posts. A stone -look trash can holder is provided. A grassed path leads to a Walkover and deck in excellent ' condition except that is was started at the crest of the dune causing erosion along the landward side. Dune heigth and vegetation are good. ' Beach Access # 29 Located to the right of 7th street, this access is owned by the pub- lic, although it is marked with posts as a "Private Walk". A compacted ' sand path leads .to a walkover in acceptable condition althoughit also begins at the crest of the dune causing erosion. Although there has been substantial erosion in some places, the dune height is still high ' and vegetation good. The accessway . is lined with yuccas. Beach Access # 30 ' This privately owned access is located to the left of 211 Ocean Blvd. Although it is marked with wood posts, it is uncut.. Dune height and vege- tation are both very good. ' Beach Access # 31 ' Located just left of 215 Ocean Blvd., this publicly owned access is marked with wood posts. A grassed path leads to a walkover in good condi- tion. Very little erosion has occurred and the dune remains large and ' covered with vegetation. Beach Access # 32 Located to the right of 223 Ocean Blvd., this walkover is marked with posts as a "private walkover" although it is owned by the public. A grassed and loose sand path leads not to a walkover over the dune, but wood laid randomly on the dune in an unsightly manner. The path itself is substantially ' eroding the duen, although dune height and vegetation in the area are rela- tively good. The accessway is lined with yuccas. ' Beach Access # 33 Although this access point was once the street end of Boyd Street, it ' is presently privately owned. Old pieces of wood are strectched across the sand to provide an unsightly path to a walkover in acceptable con- dition. Erosion has been slight and the dune height and vegetation are good. 17 Beach Access # 34 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 Located to the right of 239 Ocean Blvd., this access is publicly owned although it is marked private. A loose sand path leads to a walkover in acceptable condition but because the structure was begun at the crest of the dune, the landward side is eroding. Erosion along the path is also substan- tial although dune height and vegetation remain acceptable. Beach Access # 35 Marked with a single wood post, this public access point is located to 'the left of Shorehaven. An overgrown path leads to a walkover but it is in a dilapidated condition. Dune height and vegetation are acceptable with only slight erosion. Beach Access # 36 Located left of Hickory Nuts, this public access point is marked by a single wood post. An overgrown, partially blocked path leads to a walkover in extremely poor shape. Erosion has been minimal with an average dune height and good vegetation existing. Beach Access # 37 Marked as a "private walk" with wood posts, this publicly owned access is located just left of 263 Ocean Blvd. Trash cans are provided. A com- bination grassed and compacted sand driveway leads to an oceanfront house. A walkover is provided but it is in poor condition and was begun at the crest of the dune so the landward side has substantially eroded. Dune height and vegetation are acceptable. Beach Access # 38 Located to the right of 267 Ocean Blvd., this public access point is marked with wood posts although no path has been cut. Where a path once was, excessive erosion has occurred but otherwise dune height and vegetation are both good. Plenty of vacant land suitable for a parking area lies adja- cent to the accessway. Beach Access # 39 Privately owned, this access point is located to the left of 301 Ocean Blvd. It is not marked, although a winding loose sand path indicates some use by the Public. A walkover in acceptable condition is provided. Dune height is average and vegetation is good. Erosion is minimal. Beach Access # 40 Although once a public street end, this access located just right of Wanta Linga is presently privately owned. It is marked with a sign reading 'Private Property, No Tres assino " although loose sand paths in the immed- iate area indicate use by he public. Erosion has been substantial along the paths although the dune height and vegetation are still good. Beach Access # 41 Located four lots past access # 40, this access point is also privately owned. A sand fence has been constructed, but has an opening to permit access. Because there is no walkover, some erosion has occurred although the dune height 2tation are still good. y IBeach Access # 42 Located beside Age of the Storm, this access point is privately owned. ' A compacted sand path leads to a walkover and small deck in acceptable con- dition but because it was begun at the crest of the dune, substantial erosion has occurred. Dune height and vegetation are acceptable. Beach Access # 43 • Marked with wood posts, this public access is located left of 391 ' Ocean Blvd. A grassed path lined with yuccas leads to the beach. Because there is no walkover, substantial erosion has occurred from heavy use. Dune height is average and the vegetation is acceptable. ' Beach Access # 44 Although this access is privately owned, it is used by the public as evidenced by the loose sand paths that weave around a sand fence con- structed to prevent access. Erosion is substantial along the paths, ' although dune height and vegetation remain acceptable. Beach Access # 45 This public access point is located at the Holden Beach Fishing Pier. Although the pier is marked, the actual access point is not and hidden behind the building. Trash cans are provided. A well -lit, asphalt parking area is included capable of accommodating approximately 100 cars. ' A compacted sand path leads from the parking area to a walkover in accept- able condition. Substantial erosion has resulted from unrestricted access, ' but a sand fence has been constructed to direct the public to improved points. Although vegetation is sparce, dune height is average. Beach Access # 46 Although this group of access points, located in the campground beside the Fishing Pier, are used by the public -at -large, they are primarily for use by the campers. Walkovers and sandfences have been constructed, but ' some erosion has occurred in the area of the loose sand paths. Dune height and vegetation are acceptable. tBeach Access #47 Privately owned, this access is located_.beside:-Ri.verdale.:._Vacant area ' suitable for parking is available on either side of the access and across Ocean Blvd. Some erosion has occurred in the area leaving vegetati= sparce. Beach Access #48 Located right of 553 Ocean Blvd., this access is privately owned. Although a trailer sets on half of the lot, the other half is used for ' access by the public although it is discouraged by signs. Excessive erosion of the dune indicates heavy use. Dune height is average, although vegetation is sparce. I 19 Beach Access #49 Located right of 557 Ocean Blvd., this private access is marked with signs reading "Private Property, no access to beach". A loose sand path leads to a walkover and deck in acceptable condition although it starts. at the crest of the dune causing some erosion problems. Dune height remains acceptable although vegetation is sparce. Beach Access #50 Located left of 563 Ocean Blvd., this privately owned point is used for vehicular access. Only a loose sand path is provided, and it is severely eroding the dune. Dune height is low and vegetation is sparce. Beach Access #51 Publicly owned, this access islocated left of Gull Cottage and is marked with a rusting sign reading "access to Beach, Heritage Harbor." One grey metal trash can is provided at the entrance to the access. A compacted sand path leads to a walkvoer in acceptable condition. Although erosion has been slight, dune height is so low the ocean is visible. Vege- tation is also sparce. Beach Access #52 ` No accessway was ever laid out or cut, although publicly owned. Beach Access #53 This 30 foot public right of way is located just right of 803 Ocean ' Blvd. A small sign reading "Access for emerging vehicles only" marks the dirt road leading up over the dune. Because the road itself is roped off, pedestrian access is inconvenient . Vacant land across Ocean Blvd. is suit- able for a future parking area, although none is presently provided. Erosion has been substantial along the road, but only minimal on either side of the access. Dune height is average and vegetation is good. ' Beach Access #54 Located five lots past Beach Access #53 is a 10 foot public right of way. It has never been cut and it is not marked but it exist according to ' Brunswick County tax records. ' Beach Access #55 Although this access was formerly the public street end of Dophine Drive, it is currently privately owned. The area is not marked, although ' it is obviously used by the public. Loose boards are spread across the sand in an unsightly manner. Erosion has not been substantial although vege- tation is sparce. Dune height is large. Beach Access #56 Located left of 917 Ocean Blvd, this point is presently being used as a vehicular access by the public. A sign marks it location reading "Vehic- ' 20 'Y ' ular Access by permit only. A grassed and compacted Sand driveway is edged with bright yellow cord and rope. The road has caused significant erosion and although the ocean is not visible, the dune height is low. Vegetation is good on either side of the access. ' Beach Access #57 Although this access point was once the public street end of Sailfish 9 p Drive, it is currently privately owned. Metal and wood fences have been ' put up to discourage access but the existing loose sand path indicates sub- tantial use by the public. The extent of erosion varies in the area although dune height is generally average and vegetation is good. Beach Access #58 Publicly owned, this access is located to the left of 1023 Ocean Blvd. ' A combination gravel and compacted path wide enough for a vehicle leads to the ocean. A parking area paved with the same material is provided for 6-8 cars. Additional vacant land suitable for parking is available across Ocean Blvd. Erosion has been severe along the path but mimimal in all other areas. Dune height is average and vegetation is good. ' Beach Access #59 Located at the end of the paved portion of Ocean Blvd., this access is privately owned as indicated by a sign on the site. A wood deck walk and deck are provided, both in excellent condition. There is no erosion problem as a result of the fine facilities constructed on the site. Vegetation is almost undisturbed and dune height is acceptable. Beach Access #60 Privately owned, this access is located across from 1100 Ocean Blvd. A loose sand path and compacted sand parking area for approximately 6-8 cars are provided. Additional land is available on all sides of the access point for future parking needs. Although the path over the dune has caused substantial erosion, dune height and vegetation in the area remain very good. Beach Access #61 Located beside the campground, this public access point is not marked although it is substantially used by the public. Three to four loose sand paths lead lover the dune, each causing substantial erosion. A patched sand parking ' area is available for approximately 20 cars but it needs some physical and visual separation from the main road. Dune height and vegetation are generally accep- table. ' Beach Access #62 This access is actually a group of accessways provided for campers in,, the Sand and Sea Campground. Walkovers are provided but they are in poor condition although they have helped in preventing unnecessary erosion. Grassed Parking 21 areas are available but they primarily are for the campers use. In general, campground roads needs to be edged to prevent cars from driving up on the edges of the dunes. Dune height and vegetation are good. Beach Access #63 Located just beyond the campground, is this uncut, private access point. Dune height and vegetation in the area are very good. Beach Access #64 This public access point, located two lots beyond Beach Access #63 is also uncut. Dune height and vegetation are very good in the area. Beach Access #65 Privately owned, this access point is also uncut. Dune height and vege- tation are good. Beach Access #66 Although this was once the public street end of Schooner Drive, it is presently privately owned. A sign marks the access as private at the entrance to a wooden deck walk which leads to a walkover, both in excellent condition. Dune height and vegetation are very good. Beach Access #67 Located to the left of Shell Drive, this publicly owned access is marked with a sign reading "Private Access." A wood deck walk and walkover both in excellent condition are provided. Erosion has been minimal as a result of the excellent facilities constructed on the site. Both dune height and vegetation are acceptable. IBeach Access # 68 Located within a foot of the right wall of 899 Ocean Blvd, this publicly ' owned access point appears to be private. An 18 inch high sign reading "Private ..Access" is located at the start of a wood deck walk which leads to a walkover in good condition. Unfortunately, the deck walk and walkover were constructed after ' substantial erosion to the dune had already occurred. Dune height is so low the ocean is visible, and vegetation is accordingly sparce. 22 DEVELOPMENT PLAN ' As the population of Holden Beach increases, the demand for beach access becomes more and more intense. In order to more adequately provide ' for the present demand, and prepare for future access needs, a Develop- ment Plan should be initiated as soon as possible. The first steps in a Development Plan are to establish minimum ' standardsfor accessways and then decide where the access points are to be located. But as noted earlier in this study, different types of users require access to the beach and each group has its own set of needs. ' Because of this, three classifications of Beach Accessways have been de- veloped. They are Major, Neighborhood, and Vehicular. ' In the Beach Access Summary a fourth classification of Undesirable Accessways is added. These are primarily access points that have legal or physical features that make them undesirable and therefore, are not included in the Development Plan. 1 1 23 Future Access Needs The number of beach accessways on Holden Beach is barely adequate to serve the present population. If the population increases at the projected rate, the existing number of accessways will be entirely inadequate and the public will gain access wherever they please, causing irreparable damage to the dunes. Much of this damage can be avoided if future need is anticipated and planned for. The Brunswick County Planning Department developed population Projections for Holden Beach as well as Brunswick County as a portion of their respective Land Use Plan Updates. These figures can be used to help determine future Access Needs for Holden Beach. Population Projections Brunswick County Holden Beach Permanent Holden Beach Seasonal 197E 35,621 180 5,000 1980 38,100 250 6,800 1985 51,200 300 8,600 1990 - 64,300 350 10,400 Although the permanent population of Holden Beach is projected to increase by only 100 persons from 1980 to 1990, the seasonal population is expected to increase by 3,600 or 53% during the same time period. These figures indicate that substantially more accessways will be needed to adequately serve the future population of Holden Beach. In addition, the figures indicate more access is needed for day visitors. Since many people from the unincorporated areas of the County visit Holden Beach on a daily basis, population figures for the entire County should be examined to determine increased future demand. Because a 69% population increase is expected in the County within the next ten years, substantially more public accessways must be provided to avoid unnecessary damage to the dunes. The Development Plan recommends a large number of accessways be acquired and maintained by Holden Beach. Based on population projections for the Town and the surrounding region, the total number should adequately provide enough access for future demand, yet not be financially unrealistic. 24 . , Major Accessways Major Accessways should primarily provide for the needs of the day or off -island visitors. Because these accessways will be the most heavily used by 'the public, more facilities are needed, as well as substantial erosion controls. When locating sites for major accessways, it is recommended that the sites chosen meet the following general criteria prior to development. 1. Whenever possible, Major Accessways should be located near or at sites presently used by the public. 2. Major Accessways should be located only where the dune height is high and the dune vegetation is in good conditon. Barrier -free access for the handicapped should be located at lower points, but areas where the dune height is so'low that the ocean is visible from the road should be avoided. 3. Accessways should be discouraged in extremely dynamic or environ- mentally sensitive areas, such as in inlet hazard areas. 4. Accessways should be connected directly to a public area such as a public road or park. Whenever possible, they should be located directly off a major road so as to be highly visible. 5. Major Accessways should be encouraged in areas where enough un- developed land is available to locate public parking areas. 6. Major accessways should be located only on land that is permanently owned by the Town of Holden Beach. Although specific locations suitable for major accessways are spread out the entire length of the beach, there is a greater concentration of sites on the eastern end of the island. Of the 68 sites examined, 18 are suitable for this category. The number actually developed would ob- biously depend on funds available. Those locations with the criteria recommended for major accessway development are: #2 (less desirable because of low-to-non-existant dunes but acceptable until more suitable areas are developed), #3, #4, #5 (presently uncut), #6, #11, #12, #13, #14, #15, #26, #38, #45, #47, #53,#58, #60, and #61. Although some facilities are provided at a number of these access- ways,none have all the recommended facilities. Effort should be made to be consistant in upgrading major access points so as to make them more visible to the public. All signs should be consistant as well asthe type of facilities provided. The navino material'of parking areas should be s i mi 1 ar so as to make' thei7 easier to locate. The following facilities should be provided at all Major Accessways. 1. Parking: All Major Accessways should include an area for parking. Adequate parking areas could be located on either side of Ocean 25 Boulevard. At present, all public parking areas are located on oceanfront property. If this is to continue, these oceanfront parking areas sould be redeveloped in such a manner so as not to continue to damage the sand dunes. currently, parking is allowed all the way up to the crest of the dune. As illustrated on one of the following pages, it would be much better toallow parking only to the base of the dune, and replant vegetation on the dune itself. A more feasible location for additional parking would be on property located north of Ocean Boulevard. A crosswalk could be provided across the highway to visually and physically join the parking area and accessway. This would greatly decrease the cost of acquiring more land for parking and help preserve the dune struc- ture. 2. Bike racks:Bike racks should be provided at some but not all of the Major Accessways. They should be located off to one side of the parking area or protected by ties or balla.rds" 3. Trash receptacles: Trash receptacles should be provided on both the landward side of the dune at the entrance to the access and the oceanside of the dune at the bottom of the steps of the walkover. Pick-up should be a minimum of three times per week during the Summer season. 4. Signs: Consistant identification signs should be placed at the entrance of the accessway and the parking area if it is north of Ocean Boulevard. Small signs should also be placed at the bottom of the steps of the walkovers on the ocean side. Wooden signs are recommended for durability as well as aesthetics. They should be double -sided facing toward the direction of pedeatrian or vehicular traffic. Information signs (concerning parking regulations safety, surfing, litter, etc.) should be kept at a minimum and placed below or along side the main sign. 5. Bathroom facilities: Because the impact of constructing bathroom facilities is substantial, it is recommended that no additional facilities be added, but that existing bathrooms be expanded and better marked with signs. 6. Sand fences: To help direct access and lessen erosion, the construction of sand fences is recommended wherever a walkover is constructed. Where possible, 20' of fencing with posts every 10' on either side of the walkover should be placed on the dune ridge. 7. Walkovers: Many sand dunes within Holden Beach are being destroyed due to the loss of vegetation caused by unrestricted access to the beach over the dunes. As the vegetation is lost, the wind begins to erode the dune and causes a progressive deterioration of the entire system. 26 BRUN3WICK COUNTY PLANNING DEPARTMENT 19E30 1 (i s_` ((� Lj {-� � 3 a �' � 1 _ � to '.�•� "_:.'o-t'tT`� '� +. � ._- � � i -t-+ r-t-- �-�+-t _,-I !� .� .� -- ' •"_-:- '--�-`I.., i_��'��+�y,!-L,-�k_--rt;t--: _a__ _ _.t..� z—�3_ .a 4 t : 1}1! --•----- i k r I 1 'i,..� (' i; t_.\�-�.-i� i. ; .ti.:.{i- j il`.`++�� C}--. t.- 1_li._t-. _i...-i 'r--'i �, 1 ---.. -.. r...•...., -� _ i � t � I ` 4 y i 1 i .+sue - .-,t = + � Ll++•'•r _ 1 �--• - t-i , - ; • -' - - ---- -. _._-___ _ � i � � =�,_ r�-j-•--�.._r _^T : �T_} 1 ` � � 1 l � 1 t � 1 1 I.M, !�„ 1' �-- {�- k -� �-.f `'L C __ ..T r . S, :%��,-; _..:� L--•--r7."-"• � � -t- 1--� t I L---J �______.�L________ �__� 1 _.----`-_-' "- -- r�.�.-_-.-•-•-� L....._...�' :{ � �I i l -i ! I 1 1 � , � , I 1� t L:.1-+,+� .wYLaE I !r J I f' }- , n+}- ri .---. -1 S• _ _ : --'•--'.1' 1 � 1 j. , 71'_r' � _ T( ._� - .__---^-- - - �-'-.. "t--* r- • -- I '...:1_.a.:..I.. .... - 1 I-�-+.?•-•`J � M�B� - �� 1 r :.5�. _ - r.j --�t j i 1 i I f � I777 • _' t:-'1 - - - i . 1 J _-� _ - rT. - t:l . � � - S� I _/ ,�_ � ----•- _ F-" 1 - -r - 1 l�•+r- 1 1 t! _ - ! r' 'r F � - r-. I- -_� -�. � .. - 1 - -J. "S t,•-. _ ._, _ - . � 1..-} . � Iy ..r� f 1 F-= - •, Sr _._a-✓+.— 1 ) 1 I 1 , ! � ' � :.� 1 I 1 1 . - _ _: __ ._ _. _-::7 -- r-- ._ �''''�` _ .:..:..r - .. -. �f } { j J ' i _r-" •,.....:.:. �--.._lam-, L CAST r--t'r._. 1 � - .. _- _. _ l �' '4- _ _- --- :•T•'. ' � .fr .-+*+ 1 •��-t-- � •, _.. EAR ,��• Y , ..__ - - _t t- -i� -- -.�t 1 t.{}--'i �-t-' } .--i•T-j-?T�{� .tom •-,.,�.f'.'i t r j ..� r-r- _ -< - -- - V� • t:� - - - _r - t..r._ +-t-- - .cl''�'.�.. - , . 1 �" T L •E- _ 'T i : 4 I I�� F:. � H ♦ y f.. `'-. 1 i•.^/ �- I i I I 1 1 1 1 I I I a i 1 A ♦ 1 ,l . • C J 1 , Y- . --, 1 - t � .t- _'• �q - t .- �- ...: ;---�{ : `- 1 . F"''_. i .-t _.-. . • -a...v,-.-�•r .. i i.-. } ' ' 1 1 I y..:,l_%-- �- 1 ^ i . t t-1�I-F'G'<-i � , — — r L= i — i - ! "-G F t : .._.r }{_._ - It -- =i '1 - ['. i t,?.� 1 1 `�i.:. '. .---•r- I { i. _ �_ _ - 1 _ - - - --� - 1 - cw i � • ,>_„_,.; �._.__- , 1 J ' 1 , 1 J I l 1 j �� .,. '.Z P'y 17 {6 15 29 C� j 10 't - �i "^-`"!� t i S I y! �_,.-. _ ---+ t.�.L� ._._J �r r _ !� 1 ;n N - .,•. W . --� -. r3 .F -. r'-. -- - r 1 I- r , 1 _. 1..1.�1.--J•"-' .r.-r _ 1 -" _ _- _ _ _ - -tam - .--.+. 1- :.._+--•_- - .._.-ri. �_'�.-.-. - ♦- r r- $r' _ i f -�--• � ,.. ' i Lam.--...-.-_- __.. . _.� - �j y . r r---� -+-� -.,,.. #.. t1 __. :'.+' _. - ....., �:, ;_yi.l�..-+-.•-.. - .T,.'^ 'i` -=� I` V6 v.',- 1 MA t t .'t,*`y.'_. s..•.r .-t} - t� .... - _,..-_�j _"ram --. - _ - r _ -tf '4 1 1 '1 .1.1 .._. _--.. _ r a i . 50 • - 1 IJOLDEN 1 � Gc_o I MA. �. ACCESS INVENTORY 52, t ;4 , }. ,,, �� 65 54 b^ +2-�� , t 1 I 67 5 53 - .>--.._._,.=.;,._ .,ate _ .._-A,•..-T <,_... _- - _ _ -- Parking should not extend beyond this point Holden Beach Access Study Oceanfront Parking Patterns Typical Sections In areas of high human traffic, such as a Major Accessway, a beach walkover structure is needed to protect the dunes from deteriorating. The following drawing illustrate a general, recommended design for a public walkover structure. The drawings are basic enough that various alternatives can be added to the design without altering the structures extensively. The walkover should be placed along the center line of the accessway. Ducks are not recommended as part of the Walkover design unless the access point is unusually wide. The addition of properly spaced skid resistant materials to the decking of the ramp section of the walkover would male the'deck accessible to wheel- chair users. All wood used in the construction of a walkover should be pressure treated with a waterborne preservative. Types of wood acceptable varies, depending on the quality of construction desired. A suitable, inexpensive wood is Southern Pine. Higher grade and more expensive woods are the Heart- wood of Bald Cypress, Redwood, or Eastern Red Cedar. Very expensive, but extremely durable and decay resistant woods such as Greenheart of Basra Louis are also acceptable. `Rough Cut" lumber can be used in the substruc- ture while "dressed" lumber should be used on the flooring and handrails. Further information on wood specifications can be found in the tfood Handbook: Wood as an Engineering Material, USDA, Forest products Laboratory, 1974, All bolts, nails, and other hardware should be hot dipped galvanized to prevent rust. Bolts in the handrails should be countersunk so that they do not project beyond the posts. After fastening, the excess from projecting bolts should be trimmed, Posts should be placed directly into the ground to at least the minimum depths illustrated on the following drawings. The bottom of the piling should not be encased in concrete. 8. Handicapped Modifications: There should be at least one access point developed with iandicapped modifications. Beach Accessway #2 is recommended because of its available parking area and low-to-non-existant dunes. Two percent of the parking spaces in the area should be reserved for the handicapped. The parking spaces should be marked with the international symbol for handicapped and located immediately adjacent to a hardsurfaced walkway. They should be a minimum of 12' X G'. Dune walkovers should be ramped with a maximum slope of 1:8. The transi- tion from the walkway to the walkover should be smooth and continuous. Ballards, Posts, or other barriers to wheelchairs of persons with walking aids should be removed. In terms of Beach Accessway #2, one or more walkways are needed to direct present foot traffic, rather than permit access to occur anywhere and everywhere in the area. When these individual paths are developed, they should be constructed ►•:ide and smooth enough to be capable of being used aby wheelchair users. To further direct people requiring barrier free access, a sign should be placed at the entrance of Holden Beach and at the entrance to the accessway indicating its location. 28 r Typieal Beoch Profile 8 -bdoiv existing profile �"9e Och Storm Profile — _ -- EXISTING DUNE Expected during a storm CREST LINE " R/W Varies Varies Varies o as Required as Required as Require U C t t eRa 1-A SecD on l-B Sect��n a o _ > o m m J Fedestrion o Bcrrier v� (Fence) 0 • a R/W — — Note: Sections of Dune ' Walkover structure should be planned to the specific profile of the area for which it is desired. f"ig.I TYPICAL PLAN and ELEVATION VIES' Scale: I" =2d Section I -- A - L andside Section l -D - Deck Section l - C - Se aside This Dimension Vries Depending on This Dimension Varies ' This Dimension Varies Dropoff Beh�nd Dune Depending on Width Depending on •Dropoff in of Dune Front of Dune Crest s t � O •-- -,r - „ r/Re o ZBSteDS tens eps Detcl n No tQ : Place steps on beach side to level of- mwrirnum beach recession during a severe storm or tropical hurricane C Fig.2 TYPICAL SECTION No. I Scale : I" = 5' ftL Beach Storn Profile <Maxlmum Expected Recessior� O' MSL O Q. th o- W 6�-0�� 2 x 8 1/2"X 12 Hex. bolts w1th Nuts Q Ivashors 5 , - O„ (hood countorsunk) i2 x 10 x 7� Jost 2 x 6 x 61 Dockin 2 x 10 Spl/co Board 2 Ea. 1/2" x 12" Connoctlon = Hox B to l r ' j ' c ' o . o swth 7` Nuts a Ilashor• MR 1 2 x 10 x 7' Str/noor 2 x 10 Spllco So arch 2 x 10 x 6' Bents Fig-3 TYPICAL SECTION I-B DECK I Scale-." I - I 0 1 31 1 ' 0 D. Pile 'SO 7= 0" 2X �" Dec Stringer Notch Strin j0�� q ers in Fieldtoo Rest on ts w --- //2 x /2 Hex Head Bolts 2"x/0"Bent. w Nuts B V✓ushers ' 2 "x l0"Bents Fig.4 TYPICAL RAMP DETAIL 1 Scale: 1 . ' 32.. - 0 Varies 7'- 0" Varies 7 f - 0 Varies I 71 1[ — -- �I ---� Strip or Dimensions B �A-Q - C _2_x o z ' „ 2_x 10 3" F _x_7- _2 x I4_x_9'-0" notchod for-9toos_ 2 x- 14 .x _8'- 6" no!ch_od for �t©off 2 x 14 x 8'- 9" notched for sPoas - G H l�on�._ Dimension 3pllco Dimenslon ✓ t-�r- 2xtQx�Q_ K Note: Bill of Materials based on ramp length of 21; dock len th of 28' and 2 star sections of 6'- 8aeach. Fig.6 TYPICAL STRINGER LAYOUT DETAIL Scale: I = 5' 0" w Steps ' Note : All splice blocks to be nailed to stringers to provide both lateral support at joints and bearing support All pile bolted connections to be 112" x12 "hex. bolt with nut and rashers. Quan. Ytom - Doscri tion 44 2 x 6 x 20' 2 x 8 x 20, dr_ossod dressed 9 5 2 x 10 x 20' 2 x 10x 20' dressed rough 19 3 2 14 x 20' rough - 100 V2'Sc 12" hex. bolt cylth nut and crashers L Neighborhood Accessways Neighborhood Accessways are similar to Major Accessways in that they serve a .large number of users. The difference is the majority of these users own or rent homes in the immediate area rather than come from off the island. The facilities needed differ slightly from those needed for Major Access - ways primarily in that parking areas are not required and signage should be less obtrusive. Neighborhood Accessways are recommended in areas with a high residential density, as in the area of the finger canals. Consideration should also be given to locating accessways in areas likely to be more fully developed in the near future. Using the earlier criteria as a guide in locating accessways for development, it would be advisable to seek to obtain rights to the sites already used by the public for access. As evidenced by the paths cut through the sand dunes, the best location for Nei.ghborhood accessways is at street ends. Of the 68 access points evaluated, 33 are designated Neighborhood Accessways. Because their number is so large, this access type is divided into two sub -classifications to make it more manageable. The subclassifications are Neighborhood/Maintained and Neighborhood/Developed. There are 19 of the total 33 Neighborhood Accessways designated as Neighborhood/Maintained. A minimum of public expenditure would be necessary to bring these access points up to an acceptable level bacause most presently have a good number of facilities. Primarily, they lack proper maintenance and upkeep because of their group ownership. The Town of Holden Beach should strive to obtain as many of the titles to these sites as feasible and make whatever improvements needed. The following accessways are classi- fied Neighborhood/Maintained: #8, #9, #10, #18, #20, #21, #24, #25, #28, #29, #31, #34, #35, #42, #46, #,49, #51,#52;' and #68. Accessways classified Neighborhood/Developed differ from Neighborhood/ Maintained in their lack of facilities. Few have walkovers, although some are marked with varying types of signs. Although some of the sites are privately owned, they are classified Neighborhood/Developed because they are currently in use by the public. To bring these sites up to an accep- table level would involve significant expenditures for both land acquisi- tion and construction or purchase of facilities. Those accessways classi- fied Neighborhood/Developed are: #17,#23, #27, #32, #36, #40, #43, #44, #48, #55, #57, #64, #65, and #67. In general, both subclassifications of Neighborhood Accessways should have the following facilities: 1. Walkovers: In order to protect the frontal sand dunes and deter erosion, walkovers are recommended at all Neighborhood Access points. Design specifications should be similar to those described for walkovers at Major Access points. A walkway should also be provided from Ocean Boulevard to the walkover itself. Ideally, this could be constructed out of wood in the manner of a deck walk. That being perhaps cost prohibitive, a compacted sand or grassed path would suffice. 35 1 ' 2. Signs: Signs should be placed at the entrance of the access point along Ocean Boulevard or other appropriate streets and also at the bottom of the steps of the walkover on the ocean side. Signs should be ' relatively unobtrusive so as not to further attract additional users not residing in the area but more visible than the posts currently placed at many of the accessways. Signs should be constructed of wood for durability and aesthetics, and have a consistant design. ' A one-sided sign would be adequately visible for pedestrains. 3. Trash Receptacles: Recommendation for trash receptacles at Neighbor- hood Access sites are the same as those for Major Access Sites. 4. Sand Fences: Recommendation for sand fences at Neighborhood Access points are the same as those for Major Access points. L 1 1 36 Vehicular Accessways ' As long as the Town of Holden Beach permits vehicles along its beaches, adequate access must be provided. In general, it is best to provide vehicular access in areas where the dune heigth is relatively low, ' development is not extremely dense, and in areas away from major pedes- trian -access points. Six sites have been designated as sites for vehi- cular access: #1, #7, #37, #50, #54, and #56. ' Because the impact of vehicles crossing the dunes is substantial, the number of Vehicular Accessways should be kept at a minimum. The foremen- ' tioned sites should be an adequate number to provide for the needs of fishermen, emergency vehicles, and occassional jeep owners. In terms of facilities, Vehicular Accessways should be marked at the ' entrance from Ocean Boulevard and on the ocean side of the dune. The paving material of the access should be nothing more substantial than loose gravel or packed sand. t I 1 1 37 Undesirable Accessways Acc ws points classified as Undesirable Accessways are not necessarily inappropriate sites for beach access, but rather sites that could not feasibly be acquired, developed, or maintained by the Town of Holden Beach. Specific problems anticipated included privately owned and developed sites not likely to sold, poor location, or extremely sensitive features. W, Beach Access Development Classification Summary Access Number Development Classification 1 Vehicular 2 Major/Barrier Free 3 Major 4 Major 5 Major 6 Major 7 Vehicular 8 Neighborhood/Maintained 9 Neighborhood/Maintained 10 Neighborhood/Maintained 11 Major 12 Major 13 Major 14 Major 15 Major 16 Undesirable 17 Neighborhood/Developed 18 Neighborhood/Maintained 19 Undesirable 20 Neighborhood/Maintained 21 Neighborhood/Maintained 22 Undesirable 39 Access Number Development Classification 23 Neighborhood/Developed 24 Neighborhood/Maintained .25 Neighborhood/Maintained 26 Major 27 Neighborhood/Developed 28 Neighborhood/Maintained 29 Neighborhood/Maintained 30 Undesirable 31 Neighborhood/Maintained 32 Neighborhood/Developed 33 Undesirable 34 Neighborhoodfliaintained 35 Neigborhood/Maintained 36 Neighborhood/Developed 37 Vehicular 38 Major 39 Undesirable 40 Neighborhood/Developed 41 Undesirable 42 Neighborhood/Maintained 43 Neighborhood/Developed 44 Neighborhood/Developed 45 Major 46 Neighborhood/Maintained 47 Major 48 Neighborhood/Developed 40 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 Access Number Development Classification 49 Neighborhood/Maintained •50 Vehicular ' 51 Neighborhood/Maintained 52 Undesirable 53 Major 54 Vehicular 55 Neighborhood/Developed 56 Vehicular 57 Neighborhood/Developed 58 Major 59 Undesirable 60 Major 61 Major 62 Neighborhood/Maintained 63 Undesirable 64 Neighborhood/Developed 65 Neighborhood/Developed 66 Undesirable 67 Neighborhood/Developed 68 Neighborhood/Maintained 41 IMPLEMENTATION PLAN The recent efforts of the Holden Beach Access Advisory Committee re- presents, a promising beginning, but considerable improvements are needed to assure continued adequate access. Because problems are apparent in both the quality and quanity of existing access, steps should be taken in not only acquiring titles to accessways, but also in upgrading facilities at existing access points. The Implementation Plan suggests ways of acquiring additional land for access, as well as financing methods available for the purchase of land and funding of improvements. 1 1 r 42 1 1 1 LEI u 1 1 0 1 Beach Access Acquisition and Preservation There are a number of legal tools available for acquiring or preserving land for beach accessways. Options range from purchase in fee simple to condemnation of access easements. The following are just a few more viable methods that Holden Beach should consider. 'Acquisition of fee simple interest: Purchase of fee simple title is the most direct means of acquiring access but may also be the most expensive method depending on the location and amount of land sought. North Carolina governments are granted the authority to acquire real property in General Statutes 153-A-158 and 160-11, as well as to purchase property for parks and recreation purposes in N.C. General Statutes 15A-444 and 160-353. Purchase of a fee interest would be most appropriate for purchasing narrow strips for access to the beach or small parking areas preferrably on th^ northern side of Ocean Boulevard. Questions have been raised as to what affect the purchase of addi- tional easements would have on the status of those previously given to the Town of Holden Beach. The legality of some of the financial restrictions placed on accessways given in the past to Holden Beach is questionable. Because of this, before any purchase is made for an additional accessway, any restrictions on the deeds in question should be clarified and their legality tested. If the population of Holden Beach increases at its present rate, then more beach access will be necessary in the future. It is only realistic to assume the Town will have to purchase land at some point to provide for this additional beach access demand. It is therefore advisable to determine the repercussions of purchasing accessways now, rather than to guess at what if any they might be in the future. Easements: Easements, or the right to use someone's land in some specifically designated manner, may generally be acquired by either pur- chase or prescription. Easements are most appropriate in acquiring walk- ways from a public area, across a landowner's property to the beach. Pur- chase of easements may be expensive or unavailable but landowners may be persuaded to sell if they are allowed a reduction in property taxes because of a decrease in value. Another type of easement is the prescriptive easement. It is acquired because of the continued use of the landowner's property by some other party and the law will recognize that party's right to continue that use. In the case of beach access the "other party" is the public. In many beachfront communities and possibly Holden Beach, the public has continually used certain areas to reach the J3each. If such public use satisfies the requirements, primarily as to duration of the use and prescription, then the public has acquired the right to use that particular accessway irrespective of the desires of the land titleholder. It should be noted, that a prescriptive easement can be acquired only when it can be shown that the use has been made by the public at large and to be legally recognized must be established by litigation, followed by recordation of the encumbrance upon the title. 43 Land Use Controls: There are two basic tools that fall under the police power heading available to local governments to acquire pedestrain access for the general public. They are Zoning Ordinances and Subdivision Regula- tions. T, e Holden Beach Subdivision Regulations currently requires 5 foot wide public access be provided every 1/4 mile in areas developed after 1975. Unfor- tunately, so much of Holden Beach was developed before this time that this indi- vidual regulation has had little affect in improving beach access. Where it might possibly have a greater affect, is if it is applied to the northern side ' of the island along AIVA-1 where development is not yet so dense. An additional subdivision regulation that might be applicable to Holden Beach would be the required dedication of new roads for the purpose of access. Public access to beaches is afforded by requiring the extension of rights -of - way to the fore shore and dedication to the public. In application two require- ments are necessary. First. all roads and rights of way of streets not parallel ' to the ocean should be extended down to the fore shore. Secondly, all such roads should be dedicated to the public. The authority for requiring such a dedication is contained in N.C. Statutes 153-A-331 which states " a subdivision control ordinance may provide for.... the dedication or reservation of recrea- tion areas... and of rights -of -way or easements for streets". Still another method of acquiring access through the Subdivision Ordinance could be the requirement of water access lots. Here again, this regulation would have little affect on the beachfront, but it could help to insure access to the waterway. Any subdivisions containing interior lots should provide a ' water access lot for residents of the entire Subdivision not necessarily the public. Later the Town of Holden Beach could acquire the lot through eminent domain and insure its upkeep as suggested earlier in the discussion of semi- public accessways. Using the "before and after" valuation method required in condemnation proceedings, the cost of acquisition would probably be relatively love due to the difficulty of transfer cause by the many owners of the lot. The Holden Beach Subdivision Ordinance requires a residential minimum lot width of 50 feet. In order to encourage the development of additional beach access, the Board of adjustment should grant variances -to beach front property owners allowing 5 foot access strips as part of the 50 foot requirement. In addition, more zoning regulations could be implemented. One approach which has been well utilized in Currituck County since 1971 is the creation of a Recreational Residential zone with access provisions being one of the require- ments of the zone. 1 44 Financing Beach Access Acquisition And Development 1 Funds for improvements must come from either local or non -local ' sources. While the Town of Holden Beach should pursue all sources of Federal -or State grants to assist in financing, providing beach access ' should not be delayed if grants are not available. There are three basic methods that North Carolina county governments may use to generate funds at the local level for beach improvement projects--advalorem taxes, special assessments, and county service districts. Advalorem or property taxes ' may be used under a town's general taxing authority to make improvements or construct beach erosion control and hurricane protection projects. Since the provision and maintenance of accessways aids in the protection of the frontal dunes which are the first line of defense against hurricanes, ' this type of project would be eligible for advalorem tax expenditures. Special assessments permit towns to assess property owners for projects on ' a front foot, valuation, or area basis; however, if valuation is used as the assessment method only the value of the land, without improvements, can be assessed. Further, no assessments can be levied until the project is completed. Service districts permit the establishment of special taxing ' districts in which a tax in addition to the ordinary property tax is levied for the purpose of providing services or facilities to a greater extent: than provided throughout the remainder of the county. Among the types of services and facilities that may be provided under this legislation are beach erosion control and hurricane protection projects. drainage projects, and off-street parking. However, services must be provided within a reason- able time after definition of the district, not to exceed one year. The 1980 Holden Beach Land Use Update Survey questioned Town residents and landowners concerning their feelings on financing beach access. ' Sixty-four percent favored tax money being spent on improving beach access for non -beach front property owners and seventy-seven percent of the non - beach front owners indicated willingness to personally help finance their own access. While a majority of Holden Beach's residents seem unapposed to spending tax money to help their fellow citizens, the general feeling at recent public meetings seems to indicate they feel less generous in providing access for day or off -island beach goers. Visitors from off the island do require more facilities than those staying in Holden Beach. The major expense is primarily in providing adequate amounts of parking for them. Currently, small, often inadequate areas are used by these daily visitors. It might be advisable to find some way in implementing a program that shares the expense of providing facili- ties with the users themselves. One viable program could be accessing a small parking fee of perhaps $20.00 for the summer for nearby County residents and lesser daily amounts for the occassional visitor. The Town Hall could issue parking permits much the same way they issue permits for vehicles on the beach. Those visitors not willing to pay a small parking fee would be ticketed by the Holden Beach Police Department. The money collected could then be used to finance improvements and acquire addi- tional land for better beach access. n 1 45 ' In terms of -1 d c non -local funds for beach access improvements, the most ' viable source presently appears to be the U.S. Department of Interior's Land and Water Conservation Fund. This fund is administered by the Heritage Conservation and Recreation Service and the N.C. Department of Natural Resources and Community Development. Under this program grants are ' available to local governments to pay for up to 50 percent of the total cost of recreation related projects. Under current guidelines the provision and improvement of beach access is an eligible project. Under Section 315(2) of the Federal Coastal Zone Management Act, 50 percent grants are available ' to local governments for the purpose of acquiring public access to beaches and other coastal areas. Although funding was authorized for $25 million ' dollars per fiscal year through 1980, no funds have ever been appropriated. Even though no appropriations have been made this program has promise and should be closely watched for future appropriations. 46 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 s Education and Information Fron the standpoint of dune protection and utilization, this is the most important implementation method. In addition to adequate directional signs at appropriate points (land and oceanside of walkover, and at the entrahce to Holden Beach) information can be disseminated through such media as radio, television, and brochures. If the significance and features of the Development Plan are explained to the public, than the Plan has a greater chance of success. 47 BEACH ACCESS ACQUISITION! AND DEVELOPMENT IMPLEMENTATION POLICIES 1. Beach Access Acquisition: The town of Holden Reach will work to acquire ' title or permanent use (by easement) of beach accessways for all citizens to enjoy beach recreation activities. ' A. The ownership of accessways in the study and any other accessways deemed of significance to the Town will be determined. ' B. The legality of any questionable deed restrictions on existing access ways shall be determined. C. The Town will seek to obtain titles to semi-public access points (those ' owned by a large number of non -beach front property owners). In exchange for regular maintenance and upkeep. ' D. The Town of Holden Beach will encourage the development of additional beach access by encouraging the Holden Beach Board of Adjustment to grant variances to beach front property owners allowing 5 foot access ' strips as part of the 50 foot minimum residential lot width requirement. 2. Provision of Facilities: The Town of Holden Beach will provide the minimum ' facilities as outlined in the Development Plan of this study for major neighborhood, and vehicular accessways at as many access points as funds allow and the Access Advisory Committee deems necessary. ' A. No public expenditure shall be made on any access point unless it is owned or an easement is held for the property by the Town of Holden Beach. ' B. Uniform facilities and materials (trash receptacles, signs, Paving material) shall be developed and used consistantly at each improved ' access point. C. At least one access point shall be developed to accommodate the Nandi - capped. 3. Financing Deach Access: Local, State, and Federal funds shall be agres•• sively sought to finance improving beach access. A. Money received from the.issue of permits for vehicles on the beach and public parking shall be used to finance the acquisition and develop- ment of beach access points. B. Local tax money may be used to imprvoe beach access if other funds are not sufficient. 1 ' 48 SUMMARY 1. A growing coastal population has increased demand for public access to the beach. 2. Problems arise in providing beach access because of ownership patterns along beach communities. While the public owns the beach from the high water mark seaward, from the mean high water mark landward is privately owned. 3. Four types of users demand access to the beach. They are beach front property a-mers, non -beach front property owners, daily visitors from off the island, and people requiring vehicular access. 4. There are three types of acessway ownership at Holden Beach. Privately owned accessways are owned by an individual, included in the study because they are currently being used by the public with or without the permission of the owner. Semi-public accessways are owned by a group of non -beach front property owners rather than an indivudual. Public accessways are owned by the Town of Holden Beach. 5. Sixty-eight existing beach access points were evaluated in terms of physical facilities, ownweship, visibility, and erosion controls, Most lacked some if not all of the facilities needed by the public.. ' 6. To provide for the different types of users requiring access to the beach, three classifications of accessways have.been designated: Major, Niegh- borhood, and vehicular. ' 7. Major accessways should provide for the needs of the day or off -island visi- tors. They should be easily identified and included at the minimum, a parking area, trash receptacles, sandfences, and a wolkover. A fete major ' accessways should also include bike racks and bathroom facilities and at least one major access point should be modified for the handicapped. . ' 8. Neighborhood accessways should primarily accomodate non -beach front property owners. They should be unobtrusively identified and include ..at_a_min.inum:._..., a walkover, trash receptacles and sand fences, ' 9. Vehicular Access! -rays provide access for emergency vehicles, jeeps, and fioherman at various points along the beach. They should be located in relatively lot; areas and paved with nothing more substantial than loose ' gravel. v 10. There are several methods available for gcquiring land for beach accessways. Options include purchase in fee simple interest and acquisition of various types of easements. The Holden Beach Subdivision and Zoning. Ordinance can also be amended to encourage the development of additional beach access. 1 49 11. State and Federal funds should be agressively sought to finance beach access qcquisition and development, although local revenue sources currently appear more promising. A mojority of Holden Beach residents favor tax money to be spent to improve neighborhood beach access. Major access points could be financed by assessing a parking fee in much the _same manner that permits are issued for vehicles on the beach. 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 50